Skip to main content

Full text of "Proceedings of the annual convention"

See other formats


PROCEEDINGS 


THIRTEENTH  ANNUAL  CONVENTION 


American  Railway  Engineering 
Association 


HELD  AT  THE 


CONGRESS  HOTEL,  CHICAGO,  ILLINOIS 
March  19,  20  and  21,  1912 


VOLUME  13 


PUBLISHED   UNDER    DIRECTION    OF   THE  COMMITTEE 

ON  PUBLICATIONS 

1912 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS. 


PAGE. 

TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 7-20 

CONSTITUTION. 

CONSTITUTION    23-31 

Name,  Object  and  Location 23 

Membership    '. . . 23,  24 

Admissions  and  Expulsions   24, 25 

Dues   26 

Officers 26.  27 

Nomination  and  Election  of  Officers   27-29 

Management    29, 30 

Meetings    30,  3 1 

Amendments 31 


GENERAL  INFORMATION. 

GENERAL  INFORMATION   32-36 

Appointment  of  Committees  and  Outline  of  Work 32 

Preparation  of  Committee  Reports 32-34 

Publication  of  Committee  Reports 34 

Consideration   of  Committee  Reports 34.  35 

General  Rules  for  the  Publication  of  the  Manual 36 

BUSINESS  SESSION. 

BUSINESS    SESSION    39-62 

Introductory  Remarks  by  the   President 39 

President's    Address    40-48 

Association  Affairs 40-44 

Progress  in  Engineering  Works 44-47 

The  Complete  Engineer  of  300  Years  Ago 47,  48 

7 


8  TABLE   OF    CONTENTS. 

BUSINESS  SESSION— Continued. 

PAGE. 

Report  of  Secretary   49-52 

r>          Membership 4Q.  50 

Geographical  Distribution  of  Membership  .  ; 50 

Classification  of  Members   50 

Publications    51 

Financial    Statement    5 1.,  52 

Expenditures  in  Detail  52 

Report  of  Treasurer  . .. , 53 

Condensed  Report  of  Convention  54-62 

Resolutions  Adopted  59-62 

Report  of  Tellers   59,  60 

Election  and  Installation  of  Officers  61 

COMMITTEE  REPORTS. 

RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION    65-68 

Introductory ;. ......   •       65 

Instructions  as  to  Conduct  of  Work 66-68 

Cross-Sections    '         66 

Drainage    66 

Ballasting    66 

TlCS     '• ■■■-. 66'67 

Rail    67 

Surfacing    68 

SIGNALS  AND  INTERLOCKING  .:...: 69-74 

Introductory    69 

Conclusions 69,  70 

Table  of  Insulation  Resistances 70 

Uniform  Signaling  7°'74 

Essentials  of  Signaling 70,  71 

Minority    Report    '. .v 75,76 

WOODEN  BRIDGES  AND  TRESTLES  77-8o 

Introductory    77, 78 

Sheet  Piling — Progress  Report 78,  79 

1   Pile  Formulas — Progress  Report '. 79 

Guard  Rails — Progress  Report 79 

Fii  s  Protection — Progress  Report 79,  80 


TABLE   OF    CONTENTS.  9 

PAGE. 

IRON  AND  STEEL  STRUCTURES   81-88 

Introductory     81, 82 

Conclusions 82 

Specifications  for  the  Erection  of  Railroad  Bridges  . . .  . 83-87 

Work  to  Be  Done 83 

Falsework ' 83 

Conduct  of  Work 83,  84 

Engine  Service    84 

Transportation 84 

Masonry    84 

Handling  and  Storing  Materials  84 

Maintenance  of  Traffic .' 85 

Removal  of  Old  Structure 85 

Metal  Work 85 

Misfits    85, 86 

Anchor  Bolts    '       86 

Bed  Plates   86 

Decks 86 

Painting    86 

Clearing  the  Site 86 

Superintendence  and  Workmen    86, 87 

Inspection    87 

Responsibility     87 

Insurance  and  Bond 87 

Engineer  Defined  87 

Secondary  Stresses   88 

YARDS  AND  TERMINALS   89-93 

Introductory    89 

Typical  Situation  Plans  of  Passenger  Stations 90 

Handling  of  Freight  by  Al'echanical  Means   90, 91 

Typical  Situation  Plans  for  Division  Engine  Terminal 91,92 

Conclusions     93 

BALLAST    95-300 

Introductory 95 

Proper  Depth  of  Ballast  to  Insure  Uniform  Distribution  of  the 

Loads  on  the  Roadbed 95-97 


10  TABLE   OF    CONTENTS. 

BALLAST — Continued. 

pagf. 

Physical  Tests  of  Stone  for  Ballast 97-99 

Review  of  Gravel  Ballast  and  Methods  for  Grading  the  Differ- 
ent   Qualities    99-102 

Gravel    Washing    Plant    of    the    Richmond,    Fredericksburg   & 

Potomac   Railroad    10.3- 1 10 

Experiment    to    Determine    the    Necessary     Depth    of    Stone 

Ballast    113-265 

Description  of  Test  Track   1 14-121 

Methods   of   Tests    122-127 

Conclusions   126,  127 

Detail  of  Tests   128-265 

Gravel    as    Ballast    266-289 

Ballast  (Monograph  by  G.  W.  Vaughan)    290-300 

TIES    301-370 

Introductory     3°[ 

Size  of  Cross-Ties  Required  for  the  Stresses  to  Which  They 

Are  Subjected   301-331 

Bearing  Strength  of  Ties  Under  the  Rail  Tests 303 

Bibliography  on  Size  of  Cross-Ties  307-311 

Summary    of    Answers    to    Circular    Regarding    Size    of 
Cross-Ties  Required  for  the  Stresses  to  Which  They  Are 

Subjected    312-329 

Arrangement  of  Ties  Under  Joints   330 

Conclusions     Mi 

Tie  Renewals  in  Continuous  Stretches  Versus  Single-Tie  Re- 
newals      332-34-' 

Co  .elusion    342 

Metal,  Composite  and  Concrete  Ties  343"370 

Conclusions     37c' 

TRACK  371-386 

Introductory     371 

Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches   37I_374 

Tie-Plates  and  Track  Fastenings  374 

Designs  of  Main  Line  Turnouts 374 

Vertical  Curves   374 

Conclusions    37  4 


TABLE   OF    CONTENTS.  11 

TRACK — Continued. 

page. 
General   Specifications   for   Frogs,   Crossings  and   Switches.  ..  .375-386 

General  Instructions 375 

Inspection    375)  3?6 

Material    ^76,  377 

Workmanship    377 

Fr°gs    377,37* 

Switches     381-386 

ROADWAY    387-400 

Introductory     387 

Waterway  Formulas   387,  388 

Unit  Pressures  Allowable  on  Roadbeds  of  Different  Materials.  .388-396 

Tunnel  Construction  and  Ventilation   306 

Agricultural  Drainage  as  It  Affects  Railways   396,  397 

Record  of  Tunnel  Ventilation   398-400 

WATER  SERVICE  401-428 

Introductory    401 

Use  of  Reinforced  Concrete  for  Water  Tanks  and  Supports.  .402-417 
General    Specifications    for    a    Reinforced    Concrete    Standpipe 

Water  Tank  for  Railways 413-417 

General    Specifications     for    Ordinary    Steel    Water    and    Oil 

Tanks    417-419 

Conclusion    419 

Locomotive  Boiler  Corrosion  and  Treated  Water  420-428 

CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES   429-457 

Introductory     429 

Tree  Planting  and  General  Reforestation    (United  States)  ...  .430-437 

Bibliography  of  Timber  Resources    435-437 

Coal  and  Fuel  Oil  Resources   437-454 

Advantages  of  Oil  as  Fuel  Compared  to  Coal 437,  438 

Petroleum  as  a  Locomotive  Fuel   438,  439 

Evaporative   Tests — Oil  as  Fuel    439-441 

Inspection  and  Tests  of  Fuel  Oil 441-443 

Government  Fuel   Oil  Specifications    443,  444 

Methods  of  Preventing  or  Lessening  Waste   444-449 


12  TABLE   OF    CONTENTS. 

CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES— Continued. 

PAGE. 

Coal  Fields  of  the  United  States 449-452 

Duration  of   Supply    : 453.  454 

Tree  Planting  and  Reforestation  in  Canada ....455,456 

Annual  Fire  Loss  456 

Coal  and  Fuel  Oil  Resources  456,  457 

Peat  Deposits  in  Canada 457 

Crude  Petroleum  ■  •         457 

Natural  Gas  in  Canada 457 

MASONRY 459-504 

Introductory    459 

Waterproofing  of  Masonry  459-474 

Methods    of    Patching    and    Repairing    Plain    and    Reinforced 

Concrete    474"4§7 

Methods  of  Depositing  Concrete  Under   Water    487-502 

Conclusions    4S8 

Report  on  Work  of  Joint  Committee  on  Concrete  and  Rein- 
forced Concrete    502 

Unification    of    Portland    Cement    Specifications    502-504 

Conclusions 504 

RECORDS  AND  ACCOUNTS   i 505-507 

Introductory     ■  505.  506 

Reasons  for  Maintaining  a  Storehouse   506,  507 

Conclusions    5°°.  5°7 

ELECTRICITY    509-558 

Introductory 5°9 

Clearances    • 510 

.    Transmission  Lines  and  Crossings   510,  511 

Recommendations ,, 511 

Specifications   for   Overhead   Crossings   of   Electric  Light   and 

Power    Lines    512-521 

General  Requirements 5r2-5i4 

Loads    514.  515 

Factors  of  Safety    . . .  .• ■ 515,  516 


TABLE   OF    CONTENTS.  13 

ELECTRICITY— Continued. 

PAGE. 

Material    516-518 

Protective  Coatings 518 

Foundations ! '  518 

Working  Unit   Stresses    '. 518,  519 

Specification  for  Galvanizing  for  Iron  or  Steel  519-521 

Data  Regarding  Third  Rail  Clearances 524 

Diagrams  Showing  Equipment  Lines  of  Various  Railways 526-534 

Diagrams  Showing  Third  Rail  Structure  of  Various  Railways'. 535-558 

RAIL    559-872 

Introductory    559-564 

Specifications  for  Carbon  Steel  Rails . .  . .  .565-571 

Inspection 565 

Material 565 

Chemical   Requirements ■ 565,  566 

-   Physical  Requirements 566-569 

Details  of  Mann  f acture ( 569-571 

A  Study  of  Seventeen  Good  Service  Rails 1 ^.  .573-612 

Rail  Failure  Statistics  for  Year  Ending  October  31,  1910 613-633 

Thoughts  Resulting  from  the  Study .        633 

Comparative  Wear  of  Bessemer,  Open-hearth  and  Nickel  Steei 

Rail  on  Pennsylvania  Railroad .635-654 

Segregation  and  Other  Rail  Properties  as  Influenced  by  Si?e 

of  Ingot  .  . . .655-751 

Tests   of   Rail   Steel   Ingots   and   Derivative    Shapes   Made   at 

Watertown  Arsenal , 753 

Influence  of  Rolling  Temperature  on  the   Properties   of  Bes- 
semer Rails   ,.,-..! 797-839 

•Hearing  Before  Indiana  Railroad   Commission 841-862 

The  History  and  Development  and  Use  of  Rails  by  Rail- 
road   Companies    of    the    United    States    from    1830  .  to 

Date .843-850 

Investigations  Made  by  the  American  Society  of  Civil  En- 
gineers on  Steel  Rails 851,852 

The    Question   of  the   Improvement   of   Rail    Design    and 

-    Specifications  from  1830  to  the  Present  Time ^853-862 


14  TABLE   OF    CONTENTS. 

PAGF. 

WOOD  PRESERVATION  863-872 

Grouping  of  Timbers  for  Antiseptic  Treatment 863,  864,  868-872 

Reco.  ds  from  Service  Tests   864 

Merits  of  Various  Preservatives  864 

Revision  of  the  Adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote  Oil 865,  866 

Forms  for  Reporting  Inspection    866 

Specification  for  Impregnation  with  Creosote  Oil 866 

Value  of  Brush  Coating  and  Dipping 867 

Value  of  Impregnation  with  Crude  Oil 867 

Conclusions     867 


GRADING  OF  LUMBER   873-884 

Introductory    873 

Recommendations    873,  874 

Classification    and    Grading    Rules    for    Cypress    Lumber    and 

Shingles    875-884 

General  Instructions 875 

Standard  Defects 875-877 

Standard  Lengths 878 

Standard  Finished   Sizes  of  Cypress   878,  879 

Tank  Stock  879 

First  and   Second   Clear 879,  880 

Selects    880 

Selected  Common  Tank  Stock  880 

No.  1  Barn  or  Dimension   S80 

No.  2  Barn  or  Dimension 880,  881 

Cull  or  Peck 881 

Finishing    88i,  882 

Siding    882 

Flooring  and  Ceiling 882 

Partition    882 

Pickets  883 

Battens    883 

Car  Roofing  and  Siding   883 

Car  Lining  883 

Shingles    883,  884 


TABLE   OF   CONTENTS.  15 

PAGE. 

BUILDINGS    885-890 

Introductory    885 

Roof    Coverings    885-800 

Gutters    88&-88o 

Flashings    889,  890 

Details    of    Flashing    and    Counter    Flashing    for    Roofs    and 

Walls    891-806 

American  Method  of  Laying  Asbestos  Shingles 897,  898 

Diagonal  Method  of  Laying  Asbestos  Shingles 899 

SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS  900-904 

Intro  luctory    900 

Quality  of  Fence  Wire  to  Resist  Corrosion  and  Secure  Dura- 
bility     900-002 

Concrete  Fence  Posts  902 

Track   Construction    and    Flangeways    at    Street    Crossings    in 

Paved   Streets    902,  903 

Signs  for  Railroad  Purposes   903,  904 

Recommendations    904 

ECONOMICS    OF   RAILWAY    LOCATION    905,906 

UNIFORM  GENERAL  CONTRACT  FORMS   907-916 

Introductory 907,  90S 

Construction  Contract — Agreement    909,  910 

Construction  Contract — General  Conditions 911-916 

Bond    Oil 

Contractor's  Understanding  91 1 

Intent  of  Plans  and  Specifications 911 

Permits    91 1 

Protection     911 

Rights   of  Various   Interests    911 

Consent  to  Transfer  912 

Superintendence 912 

Timely  Demand  for  Points  and  Instructions 912 

Report  Errors  and  Discrepancies  912 

Preservation  of  Stakes 912 

Inspection     912 


16  TABLE   OF    CONTENTS. 

UNIFORM  GENERAL  CONTRACT  FORMS— Continued. 

PAGE. 

Defective  Work  or  Material   912 

Insurance 912 

Indemnity '912 

•-     Settlement  for  Wages ■  913 

Liens 913 

Work  Adjacent  to  Railroad 913 

Risk 913 

Order  and  Discipline 913 

Contractor  Not  to  Hire  Company's  Employes 913 

Intoxicating  Liquors  Prohibited  913 

Cleaning  Up , 913 

Engineer   and    Chief   Engineer    Defined    913,914 

Power  of  Engineer 914 

Adjustment  of  Dispute 914 

Order  of  Completion  ;  Use  of  Completed  Portion . .  .  914 

Changes '■  ■  '■ 9J4 

Extra  Work  .. ' .  .914.915 

Property  and  Right  of  Entry 915 

Unavoidable  Delays;  Extension  of  Time  on  Parts  of  Work  915 

Suspension  of  Work 915 

Monthly  Estimate   916 


DISCUSSIONS. 

RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION I  . . .  '9*0-931 

SIGNALS  AND  INTERLOCKING 932,  933 

IRON  AND  STEEL  STRUCTURES 934-945 

WOODEN  BRIDGES  AND  TRESTLES  ...... . 946 

YARDS  AND  TERMINALS 947,  948 

BALLAST ....i  .049,950 

ties .....:..:.. .:.    951-964 

TRACK ;■■••••: r     965-980 

ROADWAY 981,982 

WATER  SERVICE !;".'......... '."  983-988 



CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 989 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS.  17 

DISCUSSIONS— Continued. 

PAGE. 

MASONRY    990-995 

RECORDS   AND   ACCOUNTS 996,  997 

ELECTRICITY    998-1016 

RAIL 1017-1038 

WOOD    PRESERVATION    1039-1051 

GRADING  OF  LUMBER 1052,  1053 

BUILDINGS    1054 

SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS 1055-105/ 

ECONOMICS  OF  RAILWAY  LOCATION 105S 

UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS 1059-1076 

AMENDMENTS. 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Uniform   Rules   and   Organization...  1079 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Iron   and    Steel   Structures 1080 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Ballast     1080 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Track    1080 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Water    Service    1080 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Electricity     1080,  108 1 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Rail    io8t 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Wood    Preservation 1081,  1082 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Buildings    1082 

Amendments  to  Report  on  Uniform  General  Contract  Forms...  1082 

MONOGRAPHS. 

THE    DESIGN     OF    RAILWAY     BRIDGE    ABUTMENTS, 

by  J.    H.    Prior 1085-1 150 

Introductory    1085,  1086 

Abutments  Built  of  Stone  Masonry 1087-1090 

Abutments   of   Concrete,   Plain   and   Reinforced 1091-H25 

Memorandum  of  Total  Cost  of  Various  Types 1125-1141 

Conclusion    1 142,  1 143 

Discussion    and    Closure 1 149,  1 150 


18  TABLE  OF  CONTENTS. 

p 
EQUATED    TONNAGE    RATING    FOR    LOCOMOTIVES, 

by  M.  H.  Wickhorst 1 151- 

Introductory    „ 

Tonnage  Rating  of  Locomotives,  C.  B.  &  Q.  R.  R 1152- 

Tractive   Force   1 153, 

Train   Resistance    1 155- 

Equated  Tonnage  Tables 1 158, 

Explanation    of    Method 

Table  of  Tractive  Force,  Weights  and  Heating  Surface.... 

Curves  of  Train  Resistance,  Frictional  and  Grade 

Curves  of  Negative   Train   Resistance 

Curves  of  Tractive  Force  of  Engines 

Curve  of  Engine  Resistance 

Method  of  Calculating  Equated  Train    Resistances  in  Tons  of 

Train    

Sample  Tonnage  Rates,  Aurora  Division,  C.  B.  &  Q.  R.  R..  . 
Equated  Tonnage  for  0.3  to  1.5  Per  cent  Grades 1167- 

THE     STORAGE     BATTERY     IN     RAILWAY     SERVICE, 

by  L.   C.  Fritch 1181- 

Introductory    

History    1 181- 

The  Lead-Sulphuric  Acid  Storage  Battery 1183- 

Principles   of  the   Storage   Battery 1 183, 

The  Lead   Cell 

Characteristics  of  the  Lead  Cell 1184- 

Lead   Battery   Characteristics 1188, 

Types   of   Plates 1 189- 

Contaiuing   Vessels    1 I93_ 

Method  of  Control  and  Controlling  Apparatus 

Definitions  of  Component  Parts.  . . . . 1198- 

Special  Instructions  Regarding  Lead  Storage  Batteries.  . 

The    Edison    Storage    Battery 1206- 

Theory   of   Chemical    Reaction 

Positive  Plate   

Negative  Plate   

Electrolyte 

Insulation    


180 

180 

154 
158 
159 
159 
160 
161 
162 
163 
164 

165 
166 
180 


221 

181 

183 
205 
184 
iS-i 
188 
i8q 
192 

197 
198 
205 

205 

2IT 
206 
207 

207 

207 
208 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS.  19 

THE  STORAGE  BATTERY— Continued. 

PAGE. 

Container  or  Jar 1208 

Trays  or  Boxes 1209 

Connectors    1209 

Voltage    1209 

Efficiency     1209,  1210 

Applications   in    Railway   Service 1211-1220 

Train  Lighting    1211-1214 

Signaling    1214,  1215 

Drawbridge  Operation  1215 

Station  Lighting  1215 

Storage  Battery  Traction    1218 

Storage  Battery  Charging  Apparatus   1218-1220 

List  of  Illustrations 1221 

INDEX     1223-1236 


CONSTITUTION 


CONSTITUTION. 

REVISED    Al     THE    FIFTH,    EIGHTH     AND    TWELFTH    ANNUAL    CONVENTIONS. 

ARTICLE    I. 


NAME,  OBJECT  AND  LOCATION. 

i.  The  name  of  this  Association  is  the  American  Railway  Engi- 
neering Association. 

2.  Its  object  is  the  advancement  of  knowledge  pertaining  to  the 
scientific  and  economic  location,  construction,  operation  and  maintenance 
of  railways. 

3.  The  means  to  be  used  for  this  purpose  shall  be  as  follows : 

(a)  Meetings  for  the  reading  and  discussion  of  reports  and  papers 
and  for  social  intercourse. 

(b)  The  investigation  of  matters  pertaining  to  the  objects  of  this 
Association  through  Standing  and  Special  Committees. 

(c)  The  publication  of  papers,  reports  and  discussions. 

(d)  The  maintenance  of   a  library. 

4.  Its  action  shall  be  recommendatory,  and  not  binding  upon  its 
members. 

5.  Its  permanent  office  shall  be  located  in  Chicago,  111.,  and  the 
annual  convention  shall  be  held  in  that  city. 


Name. 
Object. 


Means  to 
be  Used. 


Responsibil- 
ity. 


Location  of 
Office. 


ARTICLE    II. 


MEMBERSHIP. 

i.    The  membership  of  this   Association  shall   be  divided  into  three    Membership 
classes,  viz. :    Members,  Honorary  Members  and  Associates. 


(2)     A  Member  shall  be: 

(a)  Either  a  Civil  Engineer,  a  Mechanical  Engineer,  an  Electrical 
Engineer,  or  an  official  of  a  railway  corporation,  who  has  had  not  less  than 
five  (5)  years'  experience  in  the  location,  construction,  maintenance  or  op- 
eration of  railways,  and  who,  at  the  time  of  application  for  membership,  is 
engaged  in  railway  service  in  a  responsible  position  in  charge  of  work  con 
nected  with  the  Location,  Construction,  Operation  or  Maintenance  of  a 
Railway;  provided,  that  all  persons  who  were  Active  Members  prior  to 
March  20,  1907,  shall  remain  Members  except  as  modified  by  Article  II, 
Clause  9. 

(b)  A  Professor  of  Engineering  in  a  college  of  recognized  standing. 

23 


Membership 
Qualifica- 
tions. 


24 


CONSTITUTION. 


Honorary 
Membership 
Qualifica- 
tions. 

Associate 
Membership 
Qualifica- 
tions. 


Membership 
Rights. 


Age  Require- 
ment. 


"Railway" 
Defined. 


Changes  in 
Classes. 


Supply 
Men. 


Transfers. 


3.  An  Honorary  Member  shall  be  a  person  of  acknowledged  emi- 
nence in  railway  engineering  or  management.  The  number  of  Honorary 
Members  shall  be  limited  to  ten. 

4.  An  Associate  shall  be  a  person  not  eligible  as  a  Member,  but 
whose  pursuits,  scientific  acquirements  or  practical  experience  qualify 
him  to  co-operate  with  Members  in  the  advancement  of  professional 
knowledge,  such  as  Consulting,  Inspecting,  Contracting,  Government  or 
other  Engineers,  Instructors  of  Engineering  in  Colleges  of  recognized 
standing,  and  Engineers  of  Industrial  Corporations  when  their  duties- are 
purely  technical. 

5.  (a)  Members  shall  have  all  the  rights  and  privileges  of  the 
Association. 

(b)  Honorary  Members  shall  have  all  the  rights  of  Members,  except 
that  of  holding  office,  and  shall  be  exempt  from  the  payment  of  dues. 

(c)  Associates  shall  have  all  the  rights  of  Members,'  except  those 
of  voting  and  holding  office. 

6.  An  applicant  to  be  eligible  for  membership  in  any  class  shall  not 
be  less  than  twenty-five  (25)   years  of  age. 

7.  The  word  "railway"  in  this  Constitution  means  one  operated 
by  steam  or  electricity  as  a  common  carrier,  dependent  upon  transpor- 
tation for  its  revenue.  Engineers  of  street  railway  systems  and  of  rail- 
ways which  are  used  primarily  to  transport  the  material  or  product  of 
an  industry  or  industries  to  and  from  a  point  on  a  railway  which  is  a 
common  carrier,  or  those  which  are  merely  adjuncts  to  such  industries, 
are  eligible  only  as  Associates. 

8.  A  Member,  elected  after  March  20,  1007,  who  shall  leave  the 
railway  service,  shall  cease  to  be  a  Member,  but  may  retain  membership 
in  the  Association  as  an  Associate,  subject  to  the  provisions  of  Article  II, 
Clause  9;  provided,  however,  if  he  re-enters  the  railway  service,  he  shall 
be  restored  to  the  class  of  Members.  . 

9.  Persons  whose  principal  duties  require  them  to  be  engaged  in 
the  sale  or  promotion  of  railway  patents,  appliances  or  supplies,  shall 
not  be  eligible  for,  nor  retain  membership  in  any  class  in  this  Association, 
except  that  those  who  were  Active  Members  prior  to  March  20,  1907, 
may  retain  membership  as  Associates ;  provided,  however,  that  anyone 
having  held  membership  in  the  Association  and  subsequently  having  be- 
come subject  to  the  operation  of  this  clause,  shall,  if  he  again  becomes 
eligible,  be  permitted  to  re-enter  the  Association,  without  the  payment  of 
a  second  entrance  fee. 

10.  The  Board  of  Direction  shall  transfer  members  from  one  class 
to  another,  or  •  remove  a  member  from  the  membership  list,  under  the 
provisions  of  this  Article. 

ARTICLE    III. 


Charter 
Membership. 


!  ADMISSIONS  AND   EXPULSIONS.  ,. 

i'.     The  Charter  Membership  consists  of  all  persons  who  were  elected 
before  March  15,  1900. 


CONSTITUTION. 


2.  The  Charter  Membership  having  been  completed,  any  person 
desirous  of  becoming  a  member  shall  make  application  upon  the  form 
prescribed  by  the  Board  of  Direction,  setting  forth  in  a  concise  statement 
his  name,  age,  residence,  technical  education  and  practical  experience. 
He  shall  refer  to  at  least  three  members  to  whom  he  is  personally  known, 
each  of  whom  shall  be  requested  by  the  Secretary  to  certify  to  a  personal 
knowledge  of  the  candidate  and  his  fitness  for  membership, 

.  3.  Upon  receipt  of  an  application  properly  endorsed,  the  Board  of 
Direction,  through  its  Secretary,  or  a  Membership  Committee  selected 
from  its  own  members,  shall  make  such  investigation  of  the  candidate's 
fitness  as  may  be  deemed  necessary.  The  Secretary  will  furnish  copies 
of  t,he  information  obtained  and  of  the  application  to  each  member  of  the 
Board  of  Direction.  At.  any  time,  not  less  than  thirty  days  after  the 
filing  of  the  application,  the  admission  of  the  applicant  shall  be.  canvassed 
by  letter-ballot  among  the  members  of  the  Board,  and  affirmative  votes 
by  two-thirds  of  its  members  shall  elect  the  candidate;  provided,  how- 
ever, that  should  an  applicant  for  membership  be  personally  unknown  to 
three  members  of  the  Association,  due  to  residence  in  a  foreign  country, 
or  in  such  a  portion  of  the  United  States  as  precludes  him  from  a  sufficient 
acquaintance  with  its  members,  he  may  refer  to  well-known  men  engaged 
in  railway  or  allied  professional  work,  upon  the  form  above  described, 
and  such  application  shall  be  considered  by  the  Board  of  Direction  in  the 
manner  above  set  forth,' and  the  applicant  may  be  elected  to  membership 
by  a  unanimous  vote  of  the  Board. 

4.  All  persons,  after  due  notice  from  the  Secretary  of  their  elec- 
tion, shall  subscribe  to  the  Constitution  on  the  form  prescribed  by  the 
Board  of  Direction.  If  this  provision  be  not  complied  with  within  six 
months  of  said  notice,  the  election  shall  be  considered  null  and  void. 

5.  Any  person  having  been  a  member  of  this  Association,  and  hav- 
ing, while  in  good  standing,  resigned  such  membership,  may  be  reinstated 
without  the  payment  of  a  second  entrance  fee;  provided  his  application 
for  reinstatement  is  signed  by  five  members  certifying  to  his  fitness  for 
same,  and  such  application  is  passed  by  a  tv/o-thirds  majority  of  the 
Board  of  Direction. 

6.  Proposals  for  Honorary  Membership  shall  be  submitted  by  ten  or 
more  Members.  Each  Member  of  the  Board  of  Direction  shall  be  fur- 
nished with  a  copy  cf  the  proposal,  and  if,  after  thirty  days,  the  nominee 
shall  receive  the  unanimous  vote  of  said  Board,  he  shall  be  declared  an 
Honorary  Member. 

7.  When  charges  are  preferred  against  a  Member  in  writing  by  ten 
or  more  Members,  the  Member  complained  of  shall  be  served  with  a  copy 
of  such  charges,  and  he  shall  be  called  upon  to  show  cause  to  the  Board 
of  Direction  why  he  should  not  be  expelled  from  the  Association.  Not 
less  than  thirty  days  thereafter  a  vote  shall  be  taken  on  his  expulsion, 
and  he  shall  be  expelled  upon  a  two-thirds  vote  of  the  Board  of  Direction. 

8.  The  Board  of  Direction  shall  accept  the  resignation,  tendered  in 
writing,  of  any  Member  whose  dues  are  fully  paid  up. 


Application 
for  Member- 
ship. 


Election  to 
Membership. 


Subscription 
to  Constitu- 
tion. 


Reinstate- 
ment. 


Honorary 
Membership. 


Expulsions. 


Resignations. 


26 


CONSTITUTION. 


ARTICLE    IV. 


i.  An  entrance  fee  of  $10.00  shall  be  payable  to  the  Association 
through  its  Secretary  with  each  application  for  membership;  and  this 
sum  shall  be  returned  to  the  applicant  if  not  elected. 

2.  The  annual  dues  are  $10.00,  payable  during  the  first  three  months 
of  the  calendar  year. 

3.  Any  person  whose  dues  are  not  paid  before  April  1st  of  the  cur- 
rent year  shall  be  notified  of  same  by  the  Secretary.  Should  the  dues 
not  be  paid  prior  to  July  1st,  the  delinquent  Member  shall  lose  his  right 
to  vote.  Should  the  dues  remain  unpaid  October  1st,  he  shall  be  notified 
on  the  form  prescribed  by  the  Board  of  Direction,  and  he  shall  no  longer 
receive  the  publications  of  the  Association.  If  the  dues  are  not  paid  by 
December  31st,  he  shall  forfeit  his  membership  without  further  action 
or  notice,  except  as  provided  for  in  Clause  4  of  this  Article. 

4.  The  Board  of  Direction  may  extend  the  time  of  payment  of  dues, 
and  may  remit  the  dues  of  any  Member,  who,  from  ill-health,  advanced 
age  or  other  good  reasons,  is  unable  to  pay  them. 


ARTICLE   V. 

OFFICERS. 

i.     The  officers  of  the  Association  shall  be  Members  and  shall  con- 
sist of: 

A  President, 

A  First  Vice-President, 

A  Second  Vice-President, 

A  Treasurer, 

A  Secretary, 

Nine  Directors, 
who,  together  with  the  five  latest  living  Past-Presidents  who  are  Members, 
shall  constitute  tbe  Board  of  Direction  in  which  the  government  of  the 
Association  shall  be  vested,  and  who  shall  act  as  Trustees,  and  have  the 
custody  of  all  property  belonging  to  the  Association. 

2.  The   offices   of  First  and  Second  Vice-Presidents   shall  be  deter- 
mined by  the  priority  of  their  respective  dates  of  election. 

3.  The  terms  of  office  of  the  several  officers  shall  be  as  follows : 

President,  one  year. 
Vice-Presidents,  two  years. 
Treasurer,  one  year. 
Secretary,  one  year. 
Directors,  three  years. 

4.  (a)     There  shall  be  elected  at  each  Annual  Convention: 

A  President, 
One  Vice-President, 
A  Treasurer, 
A  Secretary, 
Three  Directors. 


CONSTITUTION. 


27 


(b)  The  candidates  for  President  and  for  Vice-President  shall  be 
selected  from  the  members  of  the  Board  of  Direction. 

5.  The  office  of  President  shall  not  be  held  twice  by  the  same  per-    conditions  of 

son.      A   person    who    shall    have    held    the    office   of    Vice-President    or    R,e"®l.ection 
.  „,  .  of  Officers. 

Director  shall  not  be  eligible  for  re-election   to  the  same   office  until  at 

least  one  full  term  shall  have  elapsed  after  the  expiration  of  his  previous 

term  of  office. 

6.  The  term  of   each  officer   shall   begin  with  his  election  and  con-    Term  of 

.,  ,  .  .  Officers, 

tinue  until  his  successor  is  elected. 

7.  (a)  A  vacancy  in  the  office  of  President  shall  be  filled  by  the  Vacancies 
ir-  *  ir  t>  -a  I  m  Offices, 
rirst  Vice-President. 

(b)  A  vacancy  in  the  office  of  either  of  the  Vice-Presidents  shall 
be  filled  by  the  Board  of  Direction  by  election  from  the  Directors.  A 
Vice-Presidency  shall  not  be  considered  vacant  when  one  of  the  Vice- 
Presidents  is  filling  a  vacancy  in  the  Presidency. 

(c)  Any  other  vacancies  for  the  unexpired  term  in  the  membership 
of  the  Board  of  Direction  shall  be  filled  by  the  Board. 

(d)  An  incumbent  in  any  office  for  an  unexpired  term  shall  be 
eligible  for  re-election  to  the  office  he  is  holding;  provided,  however, 
that  anyone  appointed  to  fill  a  vacancy  as  Director  within  six  months 
after  the  term  commences  shall  be  considered  as  coming  within  the  pro- 
vision of  Article  V,  Clause  5. 

8.  When   an  officer  ceases  to  be  a  Member  of  the   Association,  as    Vacation  of 

.  Office 

provided  in  Article  II,  his  office  shall  be  vacated,  and  be  filled  as  provided 

in  Article  V,  Clause  7. 

9.  In  case  of  the  disability  or  neglect  in  the  performance  of  his  duty,  ^  Neg/ect 
of  an  officer,  the  Board  of  Direction,  by  a  two-thirds  majority  vote  of  the 

entire  Board,  shall  have  power  to  declare  the  office  vacant,  and  fill  it  as 
provided  in  Article  V,  Clause  7. 

ARTICLE   VI. 

NOMINATION    AND   ELECTION    OF  OFFICERS. 

1.  (a)  There  shall  be  a  Nominating  Committee  composed  of  the  Nominating 
five  latest  living  Past-Presidents  of  the  Association,  who  are  Members,  Committee, 
and  five  Members  not  officers. 

(b)  The  five  Members  shall  be  elected  annually  when  the  officers  of 
the  Association  are  elected. 

2.  It  shall  be  the  dutv  of  this  committee  to  nominate  candidates  to    £un\ber  of 

P3.ndlQ3.t6S 

fill  the  offices  named  in  Article  V,  and  vacancies  in  the  Nominating  Com- 
mittee caused  by  expiration  of  term  of  service,   for  the  ensuing  year,  as 

follows  :                                                                 Number  of  Candi-  Number  of  Candi- 
dates to  be  named  dates  to  be  elected 
Office  to  be  Filled.                               by  Nominating  at  Annual  Election 

Committee.  of  Officers. 

President  1  1 

Vice-President   1  1 

Treasurer    1  1 

Secretary    1  1 

Directors    9  3 

Nominating   Committee    10  5 


28 


CONSTITUTION. 


Chairman. 


Meeting  of 
Committee. 


Announce- 
ment of 
Names  of 
Nominees. 


Additional 
Nominations 
by  Members. 


Vacancies 
in  List  of 
Nominees. 


Ballots 
Issued. 


Substitution 
of  Names. 


Ballots. 


Invalid 
Ballots. 


Closure 
of  Polls. 


Requirements 
for  Election. 


Tie  Vote. 


3.  The  Senior  Past-President  shall  act  as  permanent  chairman  of 
the  committee,  and  will  issue  the  call  for  meetings.  In  his  absence  from 
meetings,  the  Past-President  next  in  age  of  service  shall  act  as  Chairman 
pro  tern,  at  the  meeting. 

4.:  Prior  to  December  1st,  each  year,  the  Chairman  shall  call  a  meet- 
ing of  the  committee  at  a  convenient  place  and,  at  this  meeting,  nominees 
for  office  shall  be  agreed  upon. 

5.  The  names  of  the  nominees  shall  be  announced  by  the  permanent 
Chairman  to  the  President  and  Secretary  not  later  than  December  15th  of 
the  same  year,  and  the  Secretary  shall  report  them  to  the  Members  of  the 
Association  on  a  printed  slip  not  later  than  January  1st  following. 

6.  At  any  time  between  January  1st  and  February  1st,  any  ten  or 
more  Members  may  send  to  the  Secretary  additional  nominations  for  the 
ensuing  year  signed  by  such  Members. 

7.  If  any  person  so  nominated  shall  be  found  by  the  Board  of  Direc- 
tion to  be  ineligible  for  the  office  for  which  he  is  nominated,  or  should 
a  nominee  decline  such  nomination,  his  name  shall  be  removed  and  the 
Board  may  substitute  another  one  therefor ;  and  may  also  fill  any 
vacancies  that  may  occur  in  this  list  of  nominees  up  to  the  time  the  bal- 
lots are  sent  out. 

8.  Not  less  than  thirty  days  prior  to  each  Annual  Convention,  the 
Secretary  shall  issue  ballots  to  each  voting  member  of  record  in  ,good 
standing,  with  a  list  of  the  several  candidates  to  be  voted  upon,  with  the 
names  arranged  in  alphabetical  order  when  there  is  more  than  one  name 
for  any  office. 

9.  Members  may  erase  names  from  the  printed  ballot  list  and  may 
substitute  the  name  or  names  of  any  other  person  or  persons  eligible  for 
any  office,  but  the  number  of  names  voted  for  each  office  on  the  ballot 
must  not  exceed  the  number  to  be  elected  at  that  time  to  such  office. 

10.  (a)  Ballots  shall  be  placed  in  an  envelope,  sealed  and  endorsed 
with  the  name  of  the  voter,  and  mailed  or  deposited  with  the  Secretary 
at  any  time  previous  to  the  closure  of  the  polls. 

(b)  A  voter  may  withdraw  his  ballot,  and  may  substitute  another, 
at  any  time  before  the  polls  close. 

11.  Ballots  not  endorsed  or  from  persons  not  qualified  to  vote  shall 
not  be  opened;  and  any  others  not  complying  with  the  above  provisions 
shall  not  be  counted. 

12.  The  polls  shall  be  closed  at  twelve  o'clock  noon  on  the  second 
day  of  the  Annual  Convention,  and  the  ballots  shall  be  counted  by  three 
tellers  appointed  by  the  Presiding  Officer.  The  ballots  and  envelopes  shall 
be  preserved  for  not  less  than  ten  days  after  the  vote  is  canvassed. 

13.  The  persons  who  shall  receive  the  highest  number  of  votes  for 
the  offices  for  which  they  are  candidates  shall  be  declared  elected. 

14.  In  case  of  a  tie  between  two  or  more  candidates  for  the  same 
office,  the  members  present  at  the  Annual  Convention  shall  elect  the  officer 
by  ballot  from  the  candidates  so  tied. 


CONSTITUTION.  29 

15.  The  Presiding  Officer  shall  announce  at  the  convention  the  names  Announce- 
of  the  officers  elected  in  accordance  with  this  Article.  men  " 

16.  Except    as   to   the    Past-Presidents,    the    first   Nominating    Com-  First 
mittee  and  the  three  additional  Directors  provided  for  shall  be  appointed  committee? 
by  the  Board  of  Direction,   one  of  the  Directors   for  one  year    one   for 

two  years,  and  one  for  three  years. 


ARTICLE   VII. 


MANAGEMENT. 


R?  (a)  The  President  shall  have  general  supervision  of  the  affairs 
of  the  Association,  shall  preside  at  meetings  of  the  Association  and  of 
the  Board  of  Direction,  and  shall  be  ex-officio  member  of  all  Committees, 
except  the  Nominating  Committee. 

(b)  The  Vice-Presidents,  in  order  of  seniority,  shall  preside  at  meet- 
ings in  the  absence  of  the  President  and  discharge  his  duties  in  case  of  a 
vacancy  in  his  office. 

2.'  The  Treasurer  shall  receive  all  moneys  and  deposit  same  in  the 
name  of  the  Association,  and  shall  receipt  to  the  Secretary  therefor.  He 
shall  invest  all  funds  not  needed  for  current  disbursements  as  shall  be 
ordered  by  the  Board  of  Direction.  He  shall  pay  all  bills,  when  properly 
certified  and  audited  by  the  Finance  Committee,  and  make  such  reports 
as  may  be  called  for  by  the  Board  of  Direction. 

3.  The  Secretary  shall  be,  under  the  direction  of  the  President  and 
Board  of  Direction,  the  Executive  Officer  of  the  Association.  He  shall 
attend  the  meetings  of  the  Association  and  of  the  Board  of  Direction, 
prepare  the  business  therefor,  and  duly  record  the  proceedings  thereof. 
He  shall  see  that  the  moneys  due  the  Association  are  collected  and  with- 
out loss  transferred  to  the  custody  of  the  Treasurer.  He  shall  personally 
certify  to  the  accuracy  of  all  bills  or  vouchers  on  which  money  is  to  be 
paid.  He  is  to  conduct  the  correspondence  of  the  Association  and  keep 
proper  record  thereof,  and  perform  such  other  duties  as  the  Board  of 
Direction   may  prescribe. 

4.  The  accounts  of  the  Treasurer  and  Secretary  shall  be  audited 
annually  by  a  public  accountant,  under  the  direction  of  the  Finance  Com- 
mittee of  the  Board. 

5.  The  Board  of  Direction  shall  manage  the  affairs  of  the  Associa- 
tion, and  shall  have  full  power  to  control  and  regulate  all  matters  not 
otherwise  provided  in  the  Constitution. 

6.  The  Board  of  Direction  shall  meet  within  thirty  days  after  each 
Annual  Convention,  and  at  such  other  times  as  the  President  may  direct. 
Special  meetings  shall  be  called  on  request,  in  writing,  of  five  members 
of  the  Board. 

7.  Seven  members  of  the  Board  shall  constitute  a  quorum. 

8.  At  the  first  meeting  of  the  Board  after  the  Annual  Convention, 
the  following  committees  from  its  members  shall  be  appointed  by  the 
President,  and  shall  report  to  and:  perform  their  duties  under  the  super- 
vision of  the  Board  of  Direction : 


Duties  of 
President. 


Duties  of 
Treasurer. 


Duties  of 
Secretary. 


Auditing  of 
Accounts. 


Duties  of 
Board. 


Board 

Meetings. 


Board       l 
Quorum. 

Board 

Committees 


30 


CONSTITUTION. 


Duties  of 

Finance 

Committee. 


Duties  of 

Publication 

Committee. 

Duties  of 

Library 

Committee. 


Duties  of 
Committee  or 
Outline  of 
Work  of 
Standing 
Committees. 

Standing 
Committees. 


Special 
Committees. 


Discussion 
by  Non- 
Memteers. 
Sanction  of 
Acts  of 
Board. 


a.  Finance  Committee  of  three  members. 

b.  Publication   Committee  of  three  members. 

c.  Library  Committee  of  three  members. 

d.  Outline  of  Work  of  Standing  Committees  of  five  members. 

9.  The  Finance  Committee  shall  have  immediate  supervision  of  the 
accounts  and  financial  affairs  of  the  Association;  shall  approve  all  bills 
before  payment,  and  shall  make  recommendations  to  the  Board  of  Direc- 
tion as  to  the  investment  of  moneys  and  as  to  other  financial  matters.  The 
Finance  Committee  shall  not  have  the  power  to  incur  debts  or  other  obli- 
gations binding  the  Association,  nor  authorize  the  payment  of  money 
other1  than  the  amounts  necessary  to  meet  ordinary  current  expenses  of 
the  Association,  except  by  previous  action  and  authority  of  the  Board  of 
Direction. 

10.  The  Publication  Committee  shall  have  general  supervision  of 
the  publications  of  the  Association. 

11.  The  Library  Committee  shall  have  general  supervision  of  the 
Library,  the  property  therein,  and  the  quarters  occupied  by  the  Secretary; 
shall  make  recommendations  to  the  Board  with  reference  thereto,  and 
shall  direct  the  expenditure  for  books  and  other  articles  of  permanent 
value,  from  such  sums  as  may  be  appropriated  for  these  purposes. 

12.  The  Committee  on  Outline  of  Work  of  Standing  Committees 
shall  present  a  list  of  subjects  for  committee  work  during  the  ensuing 
year  at  the  first  meeting  of  the  Board  of  Direction  after  the  Annual  Con- 
vention. 

13.  The  Board  of  Direction  may  appoint  such  Standing  Committees 
as  it  may  deem  best,  to  investigate,  consider  and  report  upon  questions 
pertaining  to  railway  location,  construction  or  maintenance. 

14.  Special  Committees  to  examine  into  and  report  upon  any  subject 
connected  with  the  objects  of  this  Association  may  be  appointed  from 
time  to  time  by  the  Board  of  Direction. 

15.  The  Board  of  Direction  may  invite  discussions  of  reports  from 
persons  not  members  of  the  Association. 

16.  An  act  of  the  Board  of  Direction  which  shall  have  received  the 
expressed  or  implied  sanction  of  the  membership  at  the  next  Annual  Con- 
vention of  the  Association  shall  be  deemed  to  be  the  act  of  the  Associa- 
tion, and  shall  not  afterwards  be  impeached  by  any  Member. 


Annual 
Convention. 


Special 
Meetings. 


ARTICLE  VIII. 

MEETINGS. 

1.  The  Annual  Convention  shall  begin  upon  the  third  Tuesday  in 
March  of  each  year,  and  shall  be  held  at  such  place  in  the  City  of  Chicago 
as  the  Board  of  Direction  may  select. 

2.  Special  meetings  of  the  Association  may  be  called  by  the  Board 
of  Direction,  and  special  meetings  shall  be  so  called  by  the  Board  upon 
request  of  thirty  Members,  which  request  shall  state  the  purpose  of  such 
meeting.  The  call  for  such  meeting  shall  be  issued  not  less  than  ten 
days  in  advance,  and  shall  state  the  purpose  and  place  thereof,  and  no 
other  business  shall  be  taken  up  at  such  meeting. 


CONSTITUTION. 


31 


3.  The  Secretary  shall  notify  all  members  of  the  time  and  place  of 
the  Annual  Convention  of  the  Association  at  least  thirty  days  in  advance 
thereof. 

4.  Twenty-five  Members  shall  constitute  a  quorum  at  all  meetings 
of  the  Association. 

5.  (a)  The  order  of  business  at  annual  conventions  of  the  Associa- 
tion shall  be  as  follows : 

Reading  of  minutes  of  last  meeting. 
Address  of  the  President. 
Reports  of  the  Secretary  and  Treasurer. 
Reports  of  Standing  Committees. 
Reports  of  Special  Committees. 
Unfinished  business. 
New  business. 
Election  of  officers. 
Adjournment. 

(b)  This  order  of  business,  however,  may  be  changed  by  a  majority 
vote  of  members  present. 

6.  The  proceedings  shall  be  governed  by  "Robert's  Rules  of  Order," 
except  as  otherwise  herein  provided. 

7.  Discussion  shall  be  limited  to  members  and  to  those  invited  by 
the  presiding  officer  to  speak. 


Notification 
of  Annual 
Convention. 


Association 
Quorum. 


Order  of 
Business. 


Rules  of 
Order. 


Discussion. 


ARTICLE   IX. 


AMENDMENTS. 

I.     Proposed  amendments  to  this  Constitution  shall  be  made  in  writ-    Amendments 
ing  and  signed  by  not  less  than  ten  Members,  and  shall  be  acted   upon 
in  the  following  manner: 

The  amendments  shall  be  presented  to  the  Secretary,  who  shall  send 
a  copy  of  same  to  each  member  of  the  Board  of  Direction  as  soon  as 
received.  If  at  the  next  meeting  of  the  Board  of  Direction  a  majority 
of  the  entire  Board  are  in  favor  of  considering  the  proposed  amend- 
ments, the  matter  shall  then  be  submitted  to  the  Association  for  letter- 
ballot,  and  the  result  announced  by  the  Secretary  at  the  next  Annual 
Convention.  In  case  two-thirds  of  the  votes  received  are  affirmative, 
the  amendments  shall  be  declared  adopted  and  become  immediately 
effective. 


Standing 
Commit- 
ters. 


Special 
Commit- 
tees. 


Personnel 
of  Com- 
mittees. 

Outline  of 
Work. 


General. 


GENERAL  INFORMATION. 

(Subject  to  change  from  time  to  time  by  Board  of  Direction.) 

GENERAL    RULES    FOR   THE    PREPARATION,    PUBLICATION 
AND   CONSIDERATION    OF   COMMITTEE    REPORTS. 

(a)     appointment  of  committees  and  outline  of  work. 

i.     The  following  are  standing  committees: 
I.    Roadway. 
II.    Ballast. 

III.  Ties. 

IV.  Rail. 
V.    Track. 

VI.  Buildings. 

VII.  Wooden  Bridges  and  Trestles. 

VIII.  Masonry. 

IX.  Signs,  Fences  and  Crossings.  , 

X.  Signals  and  Interlocking. 

XL  Records  and  Accounts 

XII.  Rules  and  Organization. 

XIII.  Water  Service. 

XIV.  Yards  and  Terminals. 
XV.  Iron  and  Steel  Structures. 

XVI.    Economics  of  Railway  Location. 
XVII.    Wood  Preservation. 
XVIII.    Electricity.     . 
XIX.     Conservation  of  Natural  Resources.  ■•-,-.. 

2.  Special  Committees  will  be  appointed  from  time  to  time,,  as  may 
be  deemed  expedient,  in  the  manner  prescribed  by  Article. ;VII,  Clause 
14,  of  the  Constitution. 

3.  The  personnel  of  all  Committees  will  continue  from  year  to 
year,  except  when  changes  are  announced  by  the  Board  of  Direction. . , 

4.  As  soon  as  practicable  after  each  annual  convention  the^Boarql 
of  Direction  will  assign  to  each  Committee  the  important  questions 
which,  in  its  judgment,  should  preferably  be  considered  during  the  cur- 
rent year.  Committees  are  privileged  to  present  the  results  of  any  spe- 
cial study  or  investigation  they  may  be  engaged  upon  or  that  may  be 
considered  of  sufficient  importance  to  warrant  presentation. 

(b)     preparation  of  committee  reports. 

5.  The  collection  and  compilation  of  data  and  subsequent  analysis 
in  the  form  of  arguments  and  criticism  is  a  necessary  and  valuable  pre- 
liminary element  of  committee  work. 

32 


GENERAL   INFORMATION. 


'63 


6.  Committees  are  privileged  to  obtain  data  or  information  in  any- 
proper  way.  If  desired,  the  Secretary  will  issue  circulars  of  inquiry, 
which  should  be  brief  and  concise.  The  questions  asked  should  be  specific 
and  pertinent,  and  not  of  such  general  or  involved  character  as  to  pre- 
clude the  possibility  of  obtaining  satisfactory  and  prompt  responses. 
They  should  specify  to  whom  answers  are  to  be  sent,  and  should  be  in 
such  form  that  copies  can  be  retained  by  persons  replying  either  by 
typewriter  or  blue-print. 

7.  Committee  reports  should  be  prepared  as  far  as  practicable  to 
conform  to  the   following  general  plan: 

(a)  It  is  extremely  important  that  every  Committee  should  ex- 
amine its  own  subject-matter  in  the  "Manual"  prior  to  each  annual  con- 
vention, and  revise  and  supplement  it,  if  deemed  desirable,  giving  the 
necessary  notice  of  any  recommended  changes  in  accordance  with  Clause 
6  (a)  of  the  General  Rules  for  the  Publication  of  the  "Manual."  If  no 
changes   are   recommended,  statement   should  be  made   accordingly. 

(b)  When  deemed  necessary,  the  previous  report  should  be  reviewed. 

(c)  Subjects  presented  in  previous  reports  on  which  no  action 
was  taken  should  be  resubmitted,  stating  concisely  the  action  desired.  It 
may  not  be  necessary  to  repeat  the  original  text  in  the  report,  reference 
to  former  publication  being  sufficient,  unless  changes  in  the  previously 
published  version  are  extensive.  Minor  changes  can  be  explained  in  the 
text  of  the  report. 

(d)  Technical  terms  used  in  the  report,  the  meaning  of  which  is 
not  clearly  established,  should  be  defined,  but  defined  only  from  the 
standpoint   of   railway   engineering. 

(e)  If  necessary,  a  brief  history  of  the  subject-matter  under  dis- 
cussion, with  an  outline  of  its  origin  and  development,  should  be  given. 

(f)  An  analysis  of  the  most  important  elements  of  the  subject-matter 
should  be  given. 

(g)  The  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  the  present  and  recom- 
mended practices  should  be  set  forth. 

(h)  Illustrations  accompanying  reports  should  be  prepared  so  that 
they  can  be  reproduced  on  one  page.  The  use  of  folders  should  be  avoided 
as  much  as  possible,  on  account  of  the  increased  expense  and  inconvenience 
in  referring  to  them.  Plans  showing  current  practice,  or  necessary  for 
illustration,  are  admissible,  but  those  showing  proposed  definite  design 
or  practice  should  be  excluded.  Recommendatoins  should  be  confined  to 
governing  principles. 

Illustrations  should  be  made  on  tracing  cloth  with  heavy  black  lines 
and  figures,  so  as  to  stand  a  two-thirds  reduction ;  for  example :  To  come 
within  a  type  page  (4  inches  by  7  inches),  the  illustration  should  be 
made  three  times  the  above  size. 

To  insure  uniformity,  the  one-stroke,  inclined  Gothic  lettering  is 
recommended. 

Photographs  should  be  clear  and  distinct  silver  prints. 


Collection 
of  Data. 


Plan  of 

Reports 


Definitions. 

History. 
Analysis. 
Argument. 
Illustrations 


34 


GENERAL   INFORMATION. 


Conclusions. 


Reports 
Required. 


Date  of 

Filing 

Reports. 


Publication 
of  Reports. 


Written 
Discussions. 


Verbal 
Discussions. 


Sequence. 


Plans  showing  current  practice,  or  necessary  for  illustration,  are 
admissible,  but  those  showing  proposed  definite  design  or  practice  should 
be  excluded.    Recommendations  should  be  confined  to  governing  principles. 

(i)  The  conclusions  of  the  Committee  which  are  recommended  for 
publication  in  the  Manual  should  be  stated  in  concise  language,  logical 
sequence,  and  grouped  together,  setting  forth  the  principles,  specifications, 
definitions,  forms,  tables  and  formulas  included  in  the  recommendation. 
Portions  of  the  text  of  the  report  which  are  essential  to  a  clear  interpre- 
tation and  understanding  of  the  conclusions,  should  be  included  as  an 
integral  part  thereof. 

(C)       PUBLICATION    OF  COMMITTEE  REPORTS. 

8.  (a)  Reports  will  be  required  from  each  of  the  Standing  and 
Special  Committees  each  year. 

(b)  Although  several  subjects  may  be  assigned  to  each  Committee 
by  the  Board  of  Direction,  a  full  report  on  only  one  subject  is  expected 
at  each  annual  convention,  but  the  preliminary  work,  on  some  of  the 
remaining  subjects  should  be  in  progress,  and,  when  deemed  advisable, 
partial  reports  of  progress  should  also  be  presented.  This  method  allows 
time  for  their  proper  preparation  and  consideration. 

g.  Committee  reports  to  come  before  the  succeeding  convention  for 
discussion  should  be  filed  with  the  Secretary  not  later  than  November, 
30  of  each  year. 

10.  Committees  engaged  upon  subjects  involving  an  extended  investi- 
gation and  study  are  privileged  to  present  progress  reports,  giving  a 
brief  statement  of  the  work  accomplished,  and,  if  deemed  expedient,  a 
forecast  of  the  final  report  to  be  presented. 

11.  Committee  reports  will  be  published  in  the  Bulletin  in  such 
sequence  as  the  Board  of  Direction  may  determine,  for  consideration  at 
the  succeeding  convention.  Reports  will  be  published  in  the  form  pre- 
sented by  the  respective  Committees.  Alterations  ordered  by  the  conven- 
tion will  be  printed  as  an  appendix  to  the  report. 

12.  Committees  should  endeavor  to  secure  written  discussions  of 
published  reports.  Written  discussions  will  be  transmitted  to  the 
respective  Committees,  and  if  deemed  desirable  by  the  Committee,  the 
discussions  will  be  published  prior  to  the  convention  and  be  considered 
in  connection  with  the  report. 

13.  Each  speaker's  remarks  will  be  submitted  to  him  in  writing  be- 
fore publication  in  the  Proceedings,  for  the  correction  of  diction  and 
errors  of  reporting,  but  not  for  the  elimination  of  remarks. 

(d)     consideration  of  committee  reports. 

14.  The  sequence  in  which  Committee  reports  will  be  considered  by 
the  convention  will  be  determined  by  the   Board  of  Direction. 


GENERAL    INFORMATION. 


35 


15.  The  method   of  consideration  of  Committee   reports  will  be  one    Method, 
of  the  following: 

(a)  Reading  by  title. 

(b)  Reading,   discussing   and   acting  upon  each  conclusion  sep- 

arately. 

(c)  By   majority   vote,    discussion    will    be   had    on    each    item. 

Clauses    not   objected   to   when    read    will   be   considered 
as  voted  upon  and  adopted. 

16.  Action  by   the  convention  on  Committee   reports   will   be  one   of    Final 
the   following,  after  discussion  is  closed : 

(a)  Receiving  as  information. 

(b)  Receiving  as  a  progress  report. 

(c)  Adoption    of    a    part    complete    in    itself    and    referring    re- 

mainder back  to  Committee. 

(d)  Adoption  as  a  whole. 

(e)  Recommittal  with  or  without  instructions. 
(1)     Adoption  as  a  whole. 
(g)     Recommendation  to  publish  in  the  Manual. 


Action. 


Note. — An  amendment  which  affects  underlying  principles,  if  adopted, 
shall  of  itself  constitute  a  recommittal  of  such  part  of  the  report  as  the 
Committee  considers  affected. 

The  Chair  will  decline  to  entertain  amendments  which  in  his  opinion 
lie   entirely   within  the   duties  of  the   Editor. 


GENERAL  RULES  FOR  THE  PUBLICATION  OF  THE  "MANUAL." 

i.  The  title  of  the  volume  will  be  "Manual  of  the  American  Railway 
Engineering  Association." 

2.  The  Board  of  Direction  shall  edit  the  Manual  and  shall  have 
authortiy  to  withhold  from  publication  any  matter  which  it  shall  consider  as 
not  desirable  to  publish,  or  as  not  being  in  proper  shape,  or  as  not  having 
received  proper  study  and  consideration. 

3.  Matters  adopted  by  the  Association  and  subsequently  published 
in  the  Manual  shall  be  considered  in  the  direction  of  good  practice,  but 
shall  not  be  binding  on  the  members. 

4.  The  Manual  will  only  include  conclusions  relating  to  definitions, 
specifications  and  principles  of  practice  as  have  been  made  the  subject  of  a 
special  study  by  a  Standing  or  Special  Committee  and  embodied  in  a  com- 
mittee report,  published  not  less  than  thirty  days  prior  to  the  annual  con- 
A'ention,  and  submitted  by  the  Committee  to  the  annual  convention,  and 
which,  after  due  consideration  and  discussion,  shall  have  been  voted 
on  and  formally  adopted  by  the  Association.  Subjects  which,  in  the  opinion 
of  the  Board  of  Direction,  should  be  reviewed  by  the  American  Rail- 
way Association,  may  be  referred  to  that  Association  before  being  pub- 
lished in  the  Manual. 

5.  All  conclusions  included  in  the  Manual  must  be  in  concise  and 
proper  shape  for  publication,  as  the  Manual  will  consist  only  of  a  summary 
record  of  the  definitions,  specifications  and  principles  of  practice  adopted 
by  the  Association,  with  a  brief  reference  to  the  published  Proceedings 
of  the  Association  for  the  context  of  the  Committee  report  and  subsequent 
discussion  and  the  final  action  of  the  Association. 

6.  Any  matter  published  in  the  Manual  may  be  amended  or  with- 
drawn by  vote  at  any  subsequent  annual  convention,  provided  such 
changes  are  proposed  in  time  for  publication  not  less  than  thirty  days 
prior  to  the  annual  convention,  and  in  the  following  manner :  (a)  Upon 
recommendation  of  the  Committee  in  charge  of  the  subject;  (b)  upon 
recommendation  of  the  Board  of  Direction;  (c)  upon  request  of  five 
members,   made   to   the    Board    of   Direction. 

7.  The  Manual  will  be  revised  either  by  publishing  a  new  edition  or 
a  supplemental  pamphlet  as  promptly  as  possible  after  each  annual  con- 
vention. 


36 


BUSINESS  SESSION 


PROCEEDINGS. 


The    object   of  this    Association   is   the   advancement   of    knowledge    pertaining    to   the 

scientific  and  economic  location,  construction,  operation  and  maintenance 

of  railways.     Its  actios  is  not  binding  upon  its  members. 


TUESDAY,  MARCH  19,  1912. 

MORNING   SESSION. 

The  Convention  was  called  to  order  by  Mr.  W.  C.  Cashing.  Chief 
Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Pennsylvania  Lines  West  of  Pittsburgh, 
at  9:20  o'clock. 

The  President : — Gentlemen,  please  come  to  order. 

The  Thirteenth  Annual  Convention  of  our  Association,  now  known 
for  its  first  year  under  its  new  name,  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association,  ought  to  be  an  auspicious  one,  for  was  not  "13"  the  number 
of  the  original  States  of  our  glorious  Republic  and  "13"  the  number  of 
letters  in  the  motto  of  our  State  coat  of  arms,  ''E  Pluribus  Unum,"  while, 
in  one  claw,  the  eagle  holds  thirteen  sharp-pointed  arrows,  and  in  the 
other  an  olive  branch  with  thirteen  leaves?  Moreover,  the  words  "City 
of  Chicago,"  which  lends  its  hospitality  for  our  meeting,  contain  thirteen 
letters. 

The  Committee  on  Arrangements  has  been  untiring  in  its  zeal,  and 
we  are  certain  that  our  program  has  been  well-prepared,  and  that  we 
will  have  an  enjoyable  time. 

The  Railway  Age-Gazette  and  the  Railway  and  Engineering  Review 
will  prepare  Daily  Editions,  thus  helping  to  keep  up  our  interest  and  in- 
form us  of  the  current  events  during  the  Convention.  They  are  entitled 
to  the  gratitude  and  thanks  of  the  members. 

The  privileges  of  the  floor  are  extended  to  railway  officials,  engineers, 
and  others  not  members  of  the  Association,  and  they  are  cordially  invited 
to  participate  in  the  discussions. 

For  the  benefit  of  your  fellow-members  and  the  reporters,  each 
speaker  is  requested,  upon  arising  for  recognition  by  the  Chair,  to  state 
his  name  and  the  Company  or  College  with  which  he  is  associated. 

The  first  business  to  be  attended  to  is  the  reading  of  the  Minutes 
of  the  last  Convention,  but,  as  they  have  already  been  in  print  for  some 
time,  the  reading  will  be  dispensed  with  and  the  approval  of  the  members 
considered  as  given,  unless  there  is  some  objection. 

There  being  no  objection,  the  Minutes  stand  approved  as  printed. 

Next  in  order  is  the  report  of  the  President. 

39 


40 


BUSINESS    SESSION. 


PRESIDENT'S   ADDRESS. 


ASSOCIATION  AFFAIRS. 

To   the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

At  the  last  Annual  Convention  we  numbered  967  Members,  Honorary 
Members  and  Associates.  During  the  year  we  have  passed  the  1,000  mark, 
although,  naturally,  our  rate  of  growth  has  not  been  quite  so  rapid  as  in 
former  years.  As  the  date  of  our  fiscal  year  has  been  changed  from 
March  to  December  31st,  it  is  difficult  to  make  exact  comparisons.  The 
largest  number  of  accretions  in  any  one  year  was  124,  in  1901,  while  in 
1904  we  had  104,  and  in  191 1,  98  new  members.  From  last  March  to 
December  31,  191 1,  only  part  of  a  year,  37  new  members  have  joined. 

During  the  first  few  years  of  the  existence  of  the  Association  a  com- 
fortable cash  surplus  was  accumulated,  but  in  the  last  three  years  the 
amount  of  printed  matter  issued  has  grown  to  such  an  extent  that  our  ex- 
penditures have  been  in  excess  of  our  receipts,  and  the  surplus  has  been 
drawn  upon.  The  following  table  gives  approximately  the  number  of 
printed  pages  issued  in  each  year  since  the  beginning : 


1899 

1900 

1901 

1902|l903 

1904 

1905 

1906 

1907 

1908  1909 

1910  1911 

Totals 

54 

54 

172 

513 

430 

1124 

794 

1028 

1074 

848 

1302  2234 

1990 

1470 

12979 

244 

825 

598 

602 

1000 

9S0 

942 

768 

970  1778 

1412 

19S2 

12101 

210 

316 

522 

1048 

44 

36 

36 

44 

48 

48 

80 

78 

62 

82 

558 

24 

8 

26 

34 

34 

32 

158 

Totals 

54 

4161338 

1072 

1786 

1838 

2262 

2064 

1980 

2378  4184 

3498 

4330 

27140 

You  will  observe  from  this  that  during  the  last  four  years  14,330 
pages,  or  more  than  half  the  total,  have  been  printed,  exceeding  the  num- 
ber issued  in  the  preceding  nine  years. 

It  was  clear  to  your  Board,  therefore,  that  either  the  printing  bill 
must  be  reduced,  or  the  revenue  increased,  or  both. 

So  far  as  increasing  the  revenues  are  concerned,  your  Board  has 
been  unwilling  as  yet  to  recommend  an  increase  in  annual  membership 
dues,  but  is  arranging  for  the  present  to  obtain  additional  revenue  by  em- 
ploying an  advertising  agent  to  secure  advertisements  for  the  Bulletins 
and  Program.  It  is  estimated  that  this  arrangement  will  net  about  $4,000 
annually.  The  advertisements,  and  methods  of  obtaining  them,  will  be 
closely  supervised,  but,  nevertheless,  the  members  of  the  Board  are  op- 
posed to  the  principle,  and  would  not  resort  to  it  except  in  a  case  of 
emergency.  It  is  hoped  that  the  plan  can  be  abolished  at  a  future  date, 
as  in  the  case  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers. 

With  reference  to  reducing  the  expenditures,  the  Board  has  given  a 
great  deal  of  study  to  the  question  during  the  past  year,  and  has  made 


BUSINESS    SESSION.  41 

some  changes  through  the  careful  and  energetic  investigation  of  the 
Publication   Committee  and  the  Secretary. 

First  in  importance  is  the  Secretary's  plan  to  avoid  a  reprinting  of 
the  reports  for  the  Proceedings,  after  the  Convention,  by  having  a  suffi- 
cient number  of  pages  for  the  Proceedings  printed  at  the  same  time  as 
the  Bulletins.  The  only  disadvantage  is  that  the  discussions  will  be  col- 
lected together  at  the  end  of  the  volume,  instead  of  appearing  at  the  end 
of  the  reports  to  which  they  refer,  as  in  the  past.  This  objection,  how- 
ever, was  not  considered  of  sufficient  importance  in  comparison  with  the 
saving  in  printing,  which  is  estimated  to  be  about  $1,000. 

In  addition  to  the  above,  but  10  Bulletins  a  year  instead  of  12  will 
be  issued,  the  May  and  June  numbers  being  omitted.  This  is  done  be- 
cause it  is  usually  difficult  to  obtain  articles  for  them,  and  the  Secre- 
tary is  very  busy  during  those  months  in  preparing  for  the  publication 
of  the  Proceedings.  It  is  hoped  that  it  will  result  in  their  earlier  ap- 
pearance. Moreover,  a  reduction  in  the  number  of  Bulletins  to  be  printed 
will  be  made,  so  that  it  will  be  necessary  for  members  to  bring  their 
copies  with  them  to  the  Convention.  Some  extra  ones  will  be  provided 
for  those  who  prefer  to  purchase  them  at  cost. 

Further  economy  is  expected  in  postal  rates  by  obtaining  the  second- 
class  mail  privilege,  •  application  for  which  has  been  made  to  the  Post- 
master-General. All  the  prescribed  details  have  been  complied  with, 
among  which  is  the  altered  appearance  of  the  cover  of  the  Bulletins.  In 
this  connection  it  was  necessary  to  establish  regular  subscription  rates  for 
our  Bulletins,  and  we  are  also  now  advertising  in  them  the  established 
prices  for  all  of  our  publications.  The  estimated  reduction  of  expense  for 
postage  by  this  arrangement  is  about  $500.  It  is  of  interest  to  know 
that  we  could  not  come  under  the  regulations  for  this  privilege  till  our 
Association  numbered  1,000  persons. 

The  question  of  the  use  of  a  thinner  and  lighter  weight  paper  for 
our  publications  is  now  before  the  Board,  and  its  adoption  will  probably 
result  in  some  economy  of  postage  expense.  The  transactions  of  the 
American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  are  hereafter  to  be  issued  in  one 
volume  printed  on  India  paper,  but  its  use  would  not  be  economical  for 
this  Association,  because  a  special  paper  is  required  for  the  illustrations. 

For  a  good  while  the  Board  of  Direction  realized  that  the  number  of 
subjects  reported  on  by  committees  was  apt  to  be  too  many  for  thorough 
discussion  on  the  floor,  considering  the  large  number  of  standing  com- 
mittees, and  introduced  Rule  8-b  for  the  preparation  of  committee  reports, 
which  limited  the  number  to  two  for  action  by  the  Convention.  A  large 
number  of  subjects  has  always  been  assigned  each  year,  so  that  the  com- 
mittees could  be  collecting  subject  matter  for  other  reports  to  be  presented 
a  year  or  more  hence.  When  the  increase  in  expenses  became  alarm- 
ing the  Board  found  it  necessary  to  have  the  President  issue  a  special 
circular  to  committee  chairmen,  calling  attention  to  the  necessity  for  en- 
forcing the   rule    strictly   this   year.     The   several    committees     have     re- 


42  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

sponded  heartily  to  the  request,  and  the  results  of  their  conscientious  and 
painstaking  work  is  apparent  in  the  valuable  reports  presented. 

The  ideal  method  of  increasing  our  revenues  (without  resorting  either 
to  the  augmentation  of  the  annual  dues  or  to  advertising)  would  be  to 
secure  a  larger  membership,  approximately  double  the  present  number, 
as  the  expense  involved  in  issuing  the  Bulletins  and  Proceedings  is  not 
much  more  for  a  membership  of  2,coo  than  for  one  of  1,000,  while  the 
revenue  would  be  doubled.  While  we  are  pleased  with  the  present  num- 
ber of  members,  yet  it  is  evident  that  many  who  are  eligible  and  who 
would  be  most  desirable  confreres  have  not  yet  identified  themselves  with 
the  Association. 

In  view  of  the  unauthorized  use  of  extracts  from  our  Proceedings 
for  advertising  purposes  by  commercial  agencies,  your  Board  arranged  for 
copyrighting  all  of  our  publications  in  the  United  States.  It  was  not  ex- 
pedient to  do  so  in  Canada. 

At  the  last  Convention  important  changes  in  our  Constitution  were 
adopted,  among  which  were  the  shortening  of  the  name,  the  establish- 
ment of  a  Nominating  Committee,  in  order  to  place  a  larger  share  of  the 
management  in  the  hands  of  the  members,  and  the  addition  of  three 
members  to  the  Board  of  Direction.  During  the  past  year  it  has  been  found 
desirable  to  make  some  changes  in  the  "General  Rules  for  the  Prepara- 
tion, Publication  and  Consideration  of  Committee  Reports,"  and  the 
"General  Rules  for  the  Publication  of  the  Manual,"  in  order  to  make  the 
work  of  the  Association  more  expeditious  and  the  papers  and  reports 
more  valuable. 

An  invitation  to  send  five  delegates  to  the  Third  National  Conserva- 
tion Congress  at  Kansas  City  on  September  25,  26  and  27,  191 1,  was  ex- 
tended to  the  Association,  and  Messrs.  W.  S.  Kinnear,  John  V.  Hanna, 
John  R.  Leighty,  H.  S.  Moore  and  J.  A.  L.  Waddell  were  named. 

An  invitation  was  issued  to  your  Association  through  the  sub- 
department  Secretaries  of  the  Department  of  Commerce  and  Labor  to 
participate  with  them,  the  Government  engineers,  and  other  engineering 
societies,  in  a  conference  for  the  purpose  of  unifying  specifications  for 
Portland  Cement,  and  the  invitation  was  accepted,  the  matter  being  put 
in  the  hands  of  Committee  VIII — Masonry.  We  were  advised  by  the 
Special  Committee  of  the  Departmental  Conference  that,  on  January  8, 
1912,  all  parties  had  agreed  to  the  preliminary  specifications,  except  there 
was  a  difference  of  opinion  as  to  whether  the  Vicat  or  Gilmore  needles 
should  be  used  for  determining  the  time  of  setting.  On  January  17,  the 
Committee  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  presented  its  final 
report,  recommending  the  continued  use  of  the  Vicat  needle  for  deter- 
mining consistency  and  time  of  setting,  which  was  accepted. 

The  Assistant  Purchasing  Agent  of  the  Isthmian  Canal  Commission 
has  written  our  Secretary  for  our  rules  covering  creosote  treatment  of 
lumber  and  piling. 

An  invitation  was  also  sent  to  this  Association  to  send  a  representa- 
tive to  the  convention  of  the  International  Association  for  Testing  Ma- 
terials to  be  held  in  September,  1912,  and  we  will  accept  it. 


BUSINESS    SESSION.  43 

The  Association  has  received  from  Mr.  Willard  A.  Smith,  President 
of  the  Railway  and  Engineering  Review,  a  valuable  contribution  of  photo- 
graphic views  of  the  St.  Gothard  Railway  in  Switzerland,  and  another 
valuable  contribution  of  a  bound  volume  entitled  "Railroad  Transportation 
at  the  St.  Louis  World's  Fair"  from  Mr.  W.  M.  Camp,  Editor  of  the 
same  journal,  both  of  which  are  in  the  Library. 

Prof.  W.  F.  M.  Goss,  Dean  and  Director  of  the  University  of  Illi- 
nois, has  tendered  the  use  of  data  collected  by  the  University,  and  the 
assistance  of  its  staff,  in  the  work  of  Committee  XVI — Economics  of 
Railway  Location. 

In  1910  the  amount  of  money  contributed  by  the  American  Railway 
Association  for  experiments  and  other  work  in  connection  with  the  study 
of  the  rail  problem  was  $6,213.57,  while  the  amount  authorized  by  that 
Association  for  191 1  is  $10,000.  The  results  of  the  study  are  published  in 
the  Bulletins  as  fast  as  completed.  In  this  connection  you  are  informed 
that  the  following  letter  has  been  received  by  your  President  from  Judge 
Wm.  J.  Wood,  Chairman,  Railroad  Commission  of  Indiana : 

"The  Railroad  Commission  of  Indiana  has  about  decided  to  commence 
a  formal  inquiry  into  the  condition  of  steel  now  being  put  into  the  rail- 
road tracks  of  this  State,  involving,  of  course,  a  comparison  of  the  steel 
now  being  constructed  and  that  formerly  used  on  the  railroads  of  this 
State. 

"I  understand  that  your  Association  has  had  this  matter  up  more  than 
once,  and  I  wish  to  have  a  conference  with  you  about  it  in  order,  among 
other  things,  to  have  a  suggestion  from  you,  as  to  some  person  who  could 
address  a  conference  of  Railroad  Managers  and  Engineers,  and  other 
persons  interested,  held  at  Indianapolis  under  the  direction  of  this  Com- 
mission. Will  you  be  in  Chicago  this  week?  I  will  thank  you  to  advise 
me  in  reference  to  this  subject,  and  whether  or  not  I  could  meet  you  if  I 
shall  come  there  for  that  purpose. 

"Yours  very  truly, 

(Signed)     "W.  J.  Wood,  Chairman." 

Your  President  called  upon  Judge  Wood,  and  explained  to  him  the 
work  which   Committee   IV — Rail,   has  been  doing. 

At  the  meeting  subsequently  held  on  February  20,  1912,  papers  con- 
cerning the  question  of  improvement  of  rail  design  and  specifications  were 
read  by  Messrs.  P.  H.  Dudley  (by  representative),  Thos.  H.  Johnson  and 
W.  C.  Cushing,  and,  in  addition,  addresses  were  made  by  Messrs.  F.  A. 
Delano,  E.  J.  Buffington,  R.  Montfort  and  Dr.  Benjamin. 

Your  attention  is  called  to  the  kindly  expression  of  appreciation  of 
our  work  in  the  editorial  of  the  Railway  and  Engineering  Review  of 
October  28,  191 1,  page  940,  and  the  statement  on  "Railway  and  Engineer- 
ing Literature,"  page  944.  These  words  should  be  a  stimulus  to  further 
effort. 

In  the  "Regulations  adopted  on  December  28,  191 1,  by  the  Superin- 
tendents of  Buildings  of  all  Five  Boroughs  of  the  City  of  New  York," 
relative  to  reinforced  concrete,  clause  No.  9,  says  that  "Steel  for  rein- 
forcement of  concrete  shall  meet  the  requirements  of  the  standard  speci- 
fications for  steel  reinforcement  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association." 


44  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

In  addition  to  the  above  three  authors  of  new  books  to  be  published 
have  asked  the  authority  of  your  Board  of  Direction  to  embody  informa- 
tion contained  in  our  Proceedings  in  their  books. 

From  these  instances  it  will  be  apparent  that  your  work  has  attained 
such  a  value  that  information  from  it  is  now  sought.  The  knowledge, 
ought  to  spur  us  on  to  constant  improvement. 

During  the  past  year  the  third  edition  of  the  Manual  has  been  issued. 
The  comments  on  this  volume  by  members  and  others  have  been  quite 
complimentary.  These  compliments  are  deserved  by  the  committees, 
Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt,  the  Reviewer,  Prof.  Pence,  the  Editor,  and  your 
Secretary,  Mr.  E.  H.  Fritch. 

It  is  our  sad  task  to  announce  that  we  have  lost  several  of  our 
fellow-members  by  death  during  the  past  year : 

Benjamin  Douglas,  late  Tunnel  Engineer,  Detroit  River  Tunnel  Com- 
pany, a  charter  member  and  an  active  worker  on  committees,  was  acci- 
dentally killed  while  inspecting  a  bridge  in  Brazil,  South  America. 

W.  D.  Taylor,  late  Chief  Engineer,  Chicago  &  Alton  Railroad,  a  brief 
sketch  of  whom  was  given  in  Bulletin  138. 

Frank  E.  Simar,  late  Division  Engineer,  Canadian  Northern  Railway, 
at  Duluth,  Minn. 

N.   P.   Curtis,  late  Instructor,  University  of  Wisconsin,  at  Madison. 

N.  J.  Gibbs,  until  recently  engaged  in  construction  work  on  the  Pan- 
ama Canal.     He  was  accidentally  killed  at  Tomkins  Cove,  N.  Y. 

H.  Pierce,  late  Engineer  of  Construction  of  the  Chesapeake  &  Ohio 
Railway. 

Lewis  Kingman,  late  Office  Engineer  of  the  National  Railways  of 
Mexico. 

John  S.  Metcalf,  President  of  John  S.  Metcalf  Co.,  Chicago. 

PROGRESS    IN    ENGINEERING    WORKS. 

The  year  191 1  has  witnessed  the  continued  progress,  and  in  some 
cases  the  completion,  of  vast  works  of  engineers.  Governments,  whether 
Federal,  State  or  Municipal,  continue  their  works  in  times  of  depressed 
business  as  well  as  in  prosperous  times,  and,  therefore,  the  three  greatest 
government  undertakings,  the  Panama  Canal,  the  Catskill  Aqueduct  and 
the  Erie  Canal,  have  been  pushed  steadily  forward. 

Of  these  the  Catskill  Aqueduct,  estimated  to  cost  $162,000,000,  is  of 
high  importance,  for  it  is  expected  to  carry  ultimately  the  water  supply 
for  20,000,000  people.  It  is  a  stupendous  undertaking,  measuring  92  miles 
in  length,  from  the  Ashokan  Reservoir  in  the  Catskill  Mountains  to  New 
York  City,  and,  in  time,  to  be  extended  into  Brooklyn  and  Staten  Island. 
The  daily  delivery  of  water  is  to  reach  500,000,000  gallons.  In  addition 
to  the  55  miles  of  cut  and  cover,  there  will  be  24  grade  tunnels,  aggre- 
gating 14  miles,  6  miles  of  steel  pipe  siphons  and  17  miles  of  pressure 
tunnels,  7  in  number.  The  pressure  tunnels  are  circular,  about  14  ft. 
diameter,  and  the  one  of  greatest  magnitude  and  difficulty  is  that  under 
the  Hudson  at  Storm  King  Mountain,  1,150  feet  below  the  surface  of  the 


BUSINESS    SESSION.  45 

ground.  It  was  holed  through  last  month  in  the  presence  of  the  Mayor 
of  New  York  City  and  many  others. 

Another  important  government  enterprise,  which  was  brought  to  suc- 
cessful completion  last  March,  is  the  Roosevelt  Dam,  in  the  canyon  of 
the  Salt  River,  about  70  miles  east  of  Phoenix,  Ariz.,  as  it  is  for  the 
purpose  of  impounding  418,000,000,000  gallons  of  water  for  irrigation.  It 
is  276  feet  high,  with  a  crest  length  of  1,080  ft.  It  was  begun  in  Septem- 
ber, 1906,  and  was  estimated  to  cost  about  $3,850,000.  Owing  to  its  iso- 
lation, the  cement  used  was  manufactured  at  the  site  in  a  mill  especially 
constructed  for  the  work.  The  cost  per  barrel  was  $1.96,  whereas,  if 
shipped  in,  it  would  have  been  $9  per  barrel. 

Notwithstanding  the  depression  in  business,  the  year  witnessed  the 
continued  progress,  and  also  the  completion,  of  some  magnificent  engi- 
neering works  in  the  railway  world. 

The  erection  of  the  enormous  and  palatial  station  of  the  New  York 
Central  Lines  in  New  York  City  has  been  finally  started,  after  carrying 
on  since  1903  a  large  amount  of  preliminary  work  of  excavation,  track 
laying  and  office  building.  This  work  has  embraced  about  3,000,000  cu. 
yds.  of  rock  excavation,  carried  on  under  great  difficulties,  about  250,000 
cu.  yds.  of  concrete  and  about  60,000  tons  of  steel. 

The  tracks  are  on  two  levels,  the  suburban,  20  in  number,  about  49 
ft.  below  the  street  level,  and  the  express  or  through  tracks,  22  in  number, 
20  to  25  feet  above  them. 

On  June  4,  191 1,  the  large  new  passenger  station  of  the  Chicago  & 
Northwestern  Railway  in  Chicago,  costing  about  $24,000,000,  was  opened 
for  service.  Its  style  is  Italian  Renaissance,  and  it  is  built  of  gray  Maine 
granite.  The  train  shed  has  16  tracks,  and  belt  conveyors  are  used  for 
conveying  some  of  the  incoming  mail. 

Identified  with  the  name  of  one  man,  Henry  M.  Flagler,  an  enterprise 
entirely  different  from  any  other  was  brought  to  successful  completion  in 
the  last  week  of  December,  191 1,  so  far  as  the  placing  of  the  last  batch 
of  concrete  was  concerned.  This  is  the  famous  ocean  railway  from 
Miami  to  Key  West  in  Florida,  154  miles,  of  which  74  miles  are  on  land, 
25  miles  on  swamps  and  55  miles  over  water  or  on  the  long  line  of 
islands  that  make  up  the  Florida  Keys.  There  are  about  500  reinforced 
concrete  segmental  and  semi-circular  arches  from  45  to  60  ft.  span.  The 
longest  viaduct  is  10,500  ft.,  between  Long  Key  and  Conch  Key.  It  is  a 
wonderful  piece  of  work  and  several  disasters  from  storms  during  the 
construction  have  been  experienced.  It  was  opened  for  public  service 
January  22,  1912. 

Another  great  railroad  enterprise,  estimated  to  cost  $9,500,000,  is  the 
line  and  grade  improvement  of  the  Delaware,  Lackawanna  &  Western 
Railroad,  between  Slateford,  Pa.,  and  Hopatcong,  N.  J.,  which  was  opened 
for  traffic  Christmas,  191 1.  The  old  line  was  shortened  from  39.57  miles  to 
28.45  miles,  the  grade  reduced  from  1.14  per  cent,  to  .55  per  cent.,  and 
the  curvature  from  6°  54'  to  2°,  except  in  the  case  of  one  of  3^2°,  saving 
1,560°  of  central  angle.     It  was  an  unusually  bold  piece  of  work,  and  of 


46  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

great  magnitude.  The  grading  consisted  of  7,890,000  cu.  yds.  of  earth  ex- 
cavation, 6,502,000  cu.  yds.  of  rock  excavation  and  16,000,000  cu.  yds.  of 
embankment.  The  Pequest  fill,  containing  6,625,650  cu.  yds.  of  material, 
is  probably  the  largest  railroad  embankment  ever  constructed,  being  3 
miles  long  and  from  75  ft.  to  no  ft.  high.  The  total  quantity  of  concrete 
is  266,900  cu.  yds.,  and  two  of  the  bridges  are  magnificent  reinforced  con- 
crete arch  viaducts,  one  over  the  Delaware  River,  and  the  other  over  the 
Paulins  Kill.  The  first  is  1,540  ft.  long  and  64  ft.  high,  and  consists  of 
five  spans  of  150  ft.,  two  of  120,  one  of  53  and  one  of  50J/2  ft.  The 
Paulins  Kill  viaduct  is  1,100  ft.  long  and  117  ft.  high,  and  has  five  spans 
of  120  ft.  and  two  of  100  ft. 

The  Southern  Pacific  Railway  also  completed  a  line  and  grade  change 
up  the  western  slope  of  the  Sierras  from  Rocklin,  Cal.,  to  Colfax,  30.8 
miles  on  a  1.5  per  cent,  grade.    There  are  17  tunnels  on  the  line 

The  Galveston  Causeway,  estimated  to  cost  $1,615,000,  was  be^un  in 
1909,  and  is  a  structure  a  little  more  than  2  miles  long,  connecting  Gal- 
veston Island,  on  which  the  city  of  that  name  stands,  with  the  mainland, 
its  main  feature  being  a  reinforced  concrete  viaduct  2,455  ft.  long,  consist- 
ing of  twenty-eight  70  ft.  arch  spans  and  a  lift  span  with  a  clear  water- 
way of  109  ft.  The  viaduct  portion  is  66  ft.  wide,  and  carries  2  railroad 
tracks,  one  electric  railway  track  and  a  roadway  of  19  ft.  clear  width.  On 
the  causeway  embankment  approaches  there  are  more  tracks,  and  the 
roadway  widens  to  40  ft.  About  9,808  concrete  sheet  piles,  making  a  con- 
tinuous strip  35  miles  long,  were  required. 

The  work  of  introducing  electric  power  on  steam  railroads  was  con- 
tinued, although  in  this  case,  the  Hoosac  Tunnel,  it  was  of  but  limited 
extent.  The  work  was  begun  October  3,  1910,  and  finished  May  18,  191 1, 
at  a  cost  of  1^4  millions.  The  electric  system  is  the  same  as  used  by  the 
New  York,  New  Haven  &  Hartford,  and  the  zone  extends  from  a  small 
tunnel  just  west  of  the  North  Adams  Station  to  a  point  just  east  of  the 
Hoosac  Tunnel  station,  21  miles  of  track  being  electrically  operated.  The 
tunnel  is  4.75  miles  long,  and  was  opened  in  1875.  But  lately  the  New 
Haven  Company  has  made  known  its  plan  to  change  the  main  line  from 
Stamford  to  New  Haven  to  electric  traction  at  an  early  date,  at  an  esti- 
mated cost  of  $7,000,000. 

Last  April  it  was  announced  that  a  beginning  had  been  made  on  the 
last  of  the  $160,000,000  worth  of  improvements  started  in  1903  by  the 
Pennsylvania  Railroad  Company,  viz :  the  New  York  Connecting  Rail- 
road, which  will  link  the  Pennsylvania  and  New  Haven  roads  together. 
This  link  will  be  12  miles  long,  the  principal  feature  of  which  will  be  the 
four-track  bridge  from  Astoria  on  Long  Island  over  Hell  Gate,  Ward's 
and  Randall's  Islands  to  Mott  Haven  or  Port  Morris.  The  bridge  over 
Hell  Gate  and  its  approaches  will  be  about  3  miles  long,  and  will  be  of 
most  massive  construction,  costing  about  $20,000,000.  The  main  span  is  a 
steel  arch  1,020  ft.  long  and  140  ft.  above  mean  water  level,  making  an 
imposing  gateway  for  the  East  River  entrance  to  New  York  Harbor. 

Great  engineering  works  are  not  confined  to  this  country.     The  Swiss 


:'.  BUSINESS    SESSION.  47 

railway  engineers  have  been  obliged,  by  the  rugged  nature  of  their  coun- 
try, to  resort  to  long  and  ingenious  tunnel  building,  in  order  to  prevent 
their  land  from  becoming  a  barrier  to  international  transportation.  The 
world's  longest  tunnels  have  been  built  there,  the  Simplon,  12.4  miles  long; 
the  St.  Gothard,  9.5  miles  long,  and  the  past  year  witnessed  the  piercing 
of  the  third  longest,  the  Loetschberg,  9  miles  long.  They  also  have  the 
first,  Mont  Cenis,  7.5  miles  long,  begun  in  1857,  and  the  Arlberg,  6.5  milet 
long.  In  the  case  of  many  of  these  tunnels,  gain  in  elevation  in  short  ins- 
tances has  been  obtained  by  the  use  of  the  spiral,  making  the  journey  over 
the  railway  most  fascinating,  interesting  and  beautiful. 

The  Loetschberg  Tunnel  is  built  to  put  the  capital,  Bern,  on  the  main 
line  from  Milan,  Italy,  to  Paris  and  Calais  in  France,  while  at  the  same 
time  the  distance  is  shortened  by  80  miles  to  675  miles.  It  was  originally 
planned  to  be  straight,  but  a  disastrous  inrush  of  water  from  the  Kander 
River,  burying  25  men,  compelled  the  contractors  to  wall  it  up  and  build 
a  detour  with  two  short  curves.  The  record  of  tunnel  driving  has  been 
made  in  this  work,  a  start  being  made  November  1,  1906,  while  the  head- 
ings met  March  31,  191 1. 

The  increased  daily  rate  of  tunnel  driving  due  to  improved  methods 
and  machinery  is  well  illustrated  in  these  Swiss  tunnels. 

The  rate  at  the  M'ont  Cenis,  begun  in  1857,  was  7.75  ft.  per  day,  two 
headings. 

The  rate  at  the  St.  Gothard,  begun  in  1872,  was  18  ft.  per  day,  two 
headings. 

The  rate  at  the  Arlberg,  begun  in  1880,  was  27.25  ft.  per  day,  two 
headings. 

The  rate  at  the  Simplon,  begun  in  1893,  was  36  ft.  per  day,  two  head- 
ings. 

The  rate  at  the  Loetschberg,  begun  in  1906,  was  29.5  ft.  per  day,  one 
heading,  while  a  maximum  for  one  day  with  one  heading  was  36  ft. 

The  Panama  Canal  continues  to>  be  the  most  costly  and  most  stupen- 
dous enterprise  now  in  progress,  and  its  engineers  are  earning  a  monu- 
ment of  fame  for  themselves.  The  Special  Commissioner  to  "The  Engi- 
neer" of  London,  Mr.  Percy  F.  Martin,  F.R.G.S.,  who  visited  the  Canal  in 
1910,  makes  this  statement  in  the  issue  of  June  9,  191 1:  "When  the 
Canal  shall  be  pronounced  completed,  and  the  huge  lock  gates  swing  open 
for  the  first  time  to  receive  the  earliest  vessel,  a  chorus  of  acclamation 
and  congratulation  will  ascend  such  as  probably  no  human  achievement 
has  ever  yet  called  forth.     And  justifiably  so." 

In  Engineering  News  for  February  17,  1910,  the  following  appeared: 

THE  COMPLETE  ENGINEER  OF   30O  YEARS  AGO. 

"Wrapped  in  the  stoutest  of  manila  paper  and  deposited  on  the  shelves 
of  the  library  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  is  a  book,  the 
gift  of  Mr.  W.  A.  Haven,  M.  Am.  Soc.  C.  E.,  which  is  probably  one  of 
the  earliest  of  printed  books  in  the  English  language  treating  of  the  art 
of  science  of  engineering.  On  a  curiously  embellished  title  page  is  the 
following  caption : 


48  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

"  'A   Practical    Abstract  of  the   Arts   of   Fortification    and    Assailing 

*     *     *     Written  for  the  benefit  of  such  as  delight  in  the  Practice  of 

those  Noble  Arts.     By  David   Papillon   Gent :     *     *     *     London  Printed 

by  R :  Austin  and  are  to  be  sould  at  the  south  side  of  the  Exchange  & 

in  Popes  head  Alley  1645.' 

"Engineering  in  that  day,  and  for  a  century  or  so  after,  was  entirely 
a  military  accomplishment,  and  so  the  science  discussed  by  the  author 
did  not  embrace  any  of  the  civil  arts  which  were  later  a  part  of  the  en- 
gineer's knowledge,  but  prefacing  the  more  serious  work  there  is  a  chap- 
ter on  (The  True  Character  of  a  Complete  Engineer)  which  will  appeal 
even  to  the  modern  engineer.  Especially  will  the  last  paragraph  of  this 
chapter  touch  a  tender  spot  in  the  heart  of  every  engineer  who  has  had 
to  argue  against  all  reason  with  the  lawyer,  director  or  business  man 
who  can  see  in  engineering  only  a  superior  sort  of  craftsmanship  which,  in 
its  fundamentals,  should  be  knowledge  easily  deduced  by  themselves.  The 
major  portion  of  this  first  chapter   follow: 

"  'of  the  true  character  of  a  complete  engineer. 

"  '(1)  He  is  to  be  religious  for  the  fear  of  the  Lord  is  the  beginning 
of  wisdom. 

"'(2)  He  is  to  be  a  souldier  for  none  can  better  judge  of  the  suffi- 
diency    or    insufficiency    of    fortification.     *     *     * 

"'(3)  He  is  to  be  a  traveller;  for  he  that  hath  not  seen  variety  of 
works,  and  the  excellency  of  foreign  Fortifications,  cannot  perceive  the 
defects  of  ours,  nor  give  directions  to  rectify  them. 

"'(4)  He  is  to  be  well  versed  in  the  Arithmetike  for  his  calcula- 
tions; in  the  Geometry,  for  the  setting  out  of  all  superficies;  in  the 
Architecture,  for  to  direct  all  manner  of  artificers ;  and  in  the  other  parts 
of  the  Mathematikes,  for  the  taking  of  distances,  depths  and  elevations, 
and  for  the  inventing  and  contriving  of  all  manner  of  Engines  and  ma- 
chines. 

"  '(5)  He  is  to  be  wise  in  all  his  proceedings,  punctual  in  all  his 
promises,  careful  and  diligent  in  his  calling,  and  rather  inclined  to  aus- 
terity with  lenity,  or  otherwise  he  will  never  be  respected,  served  or 
obeyed. 

"'(6)  He  is  to  be  of  solid  judgment  and  quick  of  apprehension  to 
judge  aright  of  the  defects  and  advantages  of  places.  *  *  *  He  is  not 
to  give  account  of  his  actions  to  any,- but  to  the  Generall,  or  to  the  lieu- 
tenant Generall  of  the  Ordnance  if  he  be  in  an  Army,  or  in  a  Garison, 
only  to  the  grand  Committee,  and  to  the  Governour;  and  as  for  all  other 
kinds  of  men,  inhabitants,  souldiers  or  officers;  he  is  not  bound  to  ex- 
postulate the  case,  if  they  demand  of  him  reasons  for  any  thing  he  directs 
or  commands  to  be  done;  neither  ought  he  if  he  regards  his  reputation, 
and  makes  conscience  of  his  ways,  to  comply  *  *  *  with  the  humour 
of  the  greatest  in  authority,  or  be  led  to  assent  to  any  resolution,  that  is 
against  the  maxims  of  his  Art,  by  the  Logical  and  Sophisticall  reasons 
and  arguments  of  Scholars  or  Church-men ;  for  some  of  them  are  now 
a  days  overbusie  in  things  that  go  beyond  their  element,  and  endeavor  to 
over-sway  Artists  by  rhetorike,  considering  not  that  their  reasons  are  no 
reasons  at  all  to  the  reasons  of  Art.  And  this  last  quality  is  the  essen- 
tiall  part  of  a  good  Engineer ;  for  all  the  other  are  but  to  small  purpose 
without  this.'  " 

Fellow  members :  Many  of  the  engineers  engaged  in  the  huge  enter- 
prises briefly  outlined  in  the  foregoing  pages,  and  in  other  work,  too,  not 
mentioned,  will  measure  up  with  "The  Complete  Engineer  of  300  Years 
Ago."    (Applause.) 


BUSINESS    SESSION.  49 

The  President  :■ — I  desire  to  read  the  following  extract  from  a  letter 
from  Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt,  Chairman  of  the  Publication  Committee,  as 
it  gives  additional  information  to  that  which  I  have  given  in  the  report: 

"The  work  of  the  Publication  Committee  for  the  year  may  be  con- 
sidered as  finished. 

"The  Secretary  reports  that  the  paper  stock  for  Proceedings  has  been 
imported  from  Europe  and  is  now  in  Chicago.  The  results  from  the 
use  of  this  paper  have  been  very  satisfactory  and  the  Secretary  reports 
that  all  experience  with  this  paper  so  far  demonstrates  the  wisdom  of  its 
selection.  It  is  particularly  gratifying  to  know  that  it  will  be  feasible 
and  practical  to  bind  the  1,600  pages  of  our  Proceedings  into  one  vol- 
ume, winch  will  be  No.  13.    The  advantages  of  this  practice  will  be: 

"A  saving  in  shelf  room  in  libraries. 

"The   elimination   of  one   volume   of  our   Proceedings. 

"A  reduction  in  costs  of  binding. 

"It  is  probable  that  the  1912  Proceedings  will  be  available  in  paper 
binding  by  May  1.  Cloth  bound  copies  will  likely  be  ready  June  1.  When 
our  next  Proceedings  have  been  issued  and  all  of  our  printing  bills  have 
been  paid,  the  Board  of  Direction  will  have  reason  to  congratulate  itself 
by  reason  of  the  reduction  in  expenses  of  printing,  binding  and  mailing. 
The  Secretary,  as  usual,  has  followed  this  work  in  detail  with  the  great- 
est care  and  we  are  fortunate  in  having  as  Secretary  a  man  who  is 
capable,  energetic  and  loyal  in  the  highest  degree. 

"Another  subject  needs  some  comment  at  this  time.  Our  Advertising 
Representative  has  not  been  successful  in  making  contracts  for  advertis- 
ing, either  for  the  Bulletins  or  the  Official  Program  of  the  Convention. 
This  is  a  matter  for  regret  as  we  had  confidently  calculated  upon  a  net 
return  from  the  Program,  especially.  After  a  conference  between  the 
Advertising  Representative  ana  Mr.  Fritch,  it  was  decided  by  the  Secretary 
and  myself  that  it  would  be  proper,  and  even  satisfactory  to  the  Adver- 
tising Representative,  for  the  Secretary  to  make  his  usual  effort  to  obtain 
advertising  for  the  Program  which  will  be  issued  this  week  before  the 
Convention." 

The  President: — The  next  order  of  business  is  the  Secretary's  and 
Treasurer's  reports. 

(Secretary  E.  H.  Fritch  then  read  the  following  reports:) 


50  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

SECRETARY'S  REPORT. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

I  have  the  honor  to  present  the  following  report  for  the  period  ending 
December  31,  1911,  and  from  January  1,  1912,  to  March  15,  1912: 

MEMBERSHIP. 

Total  Membership  at  last  annual  convention,  March  15,  1911 967 

Additions  during  the  year,  95 95 

1,062 

Deceased  Members 7 

Withdrawals    during   the   year 13 

Dropped  for  non-payment  of  dues 12 

32  32 

Total  membership   March    15,    1912 1,030 

Consisting  of: 

Members 939 

Honorary  Members 4 

Associates    87 

1,030 

GEOGRAPHICAL   DISTRIBUTION. 

The  geographical  distribution  of  the  membership  is  indicated  in  the 
following  table : 

United  States  899      Korea   1 

Dominion   of   Canada 83      Panama    1 

Mexico  9      Australia    1 

Cuba    5      Great    Britain    1 

China    6      Peru    2 

New  Zealand    4      Russia    1 

Philippine  Islands 3      Central  America 2 

India  2      Porto  Rico  1 

Bolivia    1                                                         

Japan    3             Total    1,030 


BUSINESS    SESSION. 


Si 


CLASSIFICATION    OF    MEMBERS. 


Presidents   zz 

Assistant  to   President 2 

Vice-Presidents   z"j 

General    Managers 20 

Dir.  Maint.  and  Operation....  1 

Asst.   General    Managers 8 

General   Superintendents    16 

Asst.    General   Superintendent.  1 

Division  Superintendents 38 

Chief   Engineers 121 

Asst.   Chief  Engineers 16 

Principal  Asst.  Engineers [4 

Chief  Eng.  Maint.  of  Way....  5 

Asst.  Chief  Eng.  M.  of  Way.  5 

Engineers  of  Construction....  14 

Engineers  Maint.  of  Way 86 

Bridge   Engineers Z/ 

Engineers    Surveys 1 

Division    Engineers 86 

Assistant  Engineers 1 1 1 

District    Engineers 13 

Electrical    Engineers 2 

Inspecting  Engineers   14 

Supervising  Engineers    1 

Architects    4 

Locating  Engineers   3 

Engineers  Track  Economics. .  .  1 

Engineers  Track  and  Roadway  4 

Maintenance  of  Way  Acct.  ...  1 

Engineers   Bridges   and   Bldgs.  7 

Office  Engineers 5 

Chief  Draftsmen 4 

General    Roadmasters 2 

Roadmasters  16 


Master  Carpenters 2 

Rail  Expert 1 

Supt.    Bridges   and    Buildings..  9 

Supervisors    2 

Resident  Engineers 36 

Signal  Engineers 18 

Assistant  Signal  Engineer 1 

Managers    Timber    Dept 6 

Chief  Timber  Inspector 1 

Forester  3 

Contracting  Engineers    13 

Supervisor    Materials 1 

Chemists  and  Engineers  Tests.  4 

Metallurgical    Engineers 4 

Professors  in  Colleges 19 

Associate  Professors 16 

Civil  Engineers 50 

Consulting   Engineers 89 

General  Foreman  Water  Works  1 

Engineer   Grade    Elimination.  .  4 

Purchasing    Agent 1 

Receivers  3 

Editors     3 

Inspector   Maintenance 3 

Masonry  Engineer 

Asst.   Superintendents 

Engineers   Valuation 

Drainage  Engineer  

General  Agent 

Engineer   Water   Service... 


Municipal    Engineers 6 

Commercial  Engineer    1 

Miscellaneous     26 


Totals   1,030 


PUBLICATIONS. 

During  the  year  the  following  publications  have  been  issued  by  the 
Association : 
12  Bulletins. 

Proceedings  for  191 1    (Parts  1  and  2). 

1  Edition  of  the  Manual. 

2  Editions  of  Specifications  for   Plain  and  Reinforced  Concrete  and 

Steel  Reinforcement. 
1  Edition  of  Conventional  Signs. 

Program  for  the  Thirteenth  Annual  Convention. 


52  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

The  table  below  indicates  the  number  of  pages,  illustrations,  etc.,  of 
the  publications  issued : 

No.  Half-        Folding    Dia- 

Pages.  Tones.         Plates     grams.     Tables.  Forms. 

Bulletins    1740  440              20 

Proceedings    135.2  82                8 

Manual 525  55               5            264 

Steel  Specifications.  34 

Concrete   Specific.  15 

Conventional   Signs             15  30 

Program    56 


240 

35i 

306 

219 

264 

44 

3 

2 

1 

1 

no 

3737  607  33  924  61; 


FINANCIAL    STATEMENT. 

Balance  cash  on  hand  March   15,   191 1 $13,216.6^ 

Consisting  of: 

Ten  Railroad  Bonds,  as  follows :  Four  St. 
Louis  Southwestern  Railway  Company 
Bonds,  par  value  $1,000  each,  at  cost $  3,319.31 

Six  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern  Rail- 
way Company  Bonds,  par  value  $1,000  each, 

at  cost    5,660.25 

Cash    in    bank 4,237.06 


$13,216.62 

Receipts  during  the  year : 

March  16,      Jan.  1,  1912,        Totals 
1911,  to  to  for  One 

Dec.  31,  1911.  Mar.  15,  1912.       Year. 

From  Members,  dues,  etc $  5,274.48        $  8,567.35        $13,841.83 

From    Others,    sales    of    publications, 

advertising,   etc 6,853.59  1,394.91  8,248.50 

From  American  Railway  Association, 

account  Rail  Committee  Expense.     6,495.57 

From  Interest  295.72 

From   Loan    1,000.00 

From  Proceeds  of  Sale  of  Bonds....     3,797-33 


508.56 

7,004.13 

67.62 

363-34 

1,000.00 

3,797-33 

Totals   $23,716.69        $10,538.44        $34,255.13 

Expenditures  during  the  year: 

March  16,  191 1,  to  Dec.  31,  191 1 $26,650.64 

January  1,  1912,  to  March  15,  1912 2,719.02 


Total  Expenditures   $29,369.66 


BUSINESS    SESSION.  53 

Summary. 

March  16,  Jan.  i,  1912, 

191 1,  to  to 

Dec.  31,  1911.  Mar.  15,  1912. 

Receipts  $23,716.69  $10,538.44        $34,255.13 

Expenditures    26,650.64  2,719.02          29,369.66 


Total $  4,885.47 

Less  amount  of  proceeds  from  sale  of  bonds 3,797-33 


Net  Excess  of  Receipts  over  Expenditures $  1,088.14 

EXPENDITURES    IN   DETAIL. 

March  16,      Jan.  1,  1912,  Totals 

Items.                                            1911,  to  to  for  One 

Dec.  31,  191 1.  Mar.  15,  1912,  Year. 

Stationery   and    Printing $    298.20  $  66.66  $    364.86 

Proceedings    4,842.18  .25  4,842.43 

Bulletins    4,i5i-6i  366.54  4,518.15 

Manual  2,187.79  2,187.79 

Postage 784.20  189.87  974-07 

Salaries    3,593-30  746.66  4-339-90 

Officers  Expenses  19.00  16.50  35-50 

Annual  Meeting   1,220.93  1,220.93 

Telephone   and    Telegrams 67.41  20.24  87.65 

Rents    600.00  120.00  720.00 

Expressage   524.46  28.53  552-99 

Exchange    23.20  2.40  25.60 

Supplies    220.06  36.18  256.24 

Light  12.79  6.15  18.94 

Miscellaneous     75.91  9.85  85.76 

Badges   80.00  80.00 

Commission    on    Advertising 76.25  76.25 

Impact    1,048.96  1,048.96 

Rail   Committee    5,850.70  936.26  6,786.96 

Committee  Expenses  H7-44  16.68  I34-T2 

Repayment  of  Loan 1,000.00  1,000.00 

Interest  on  Loan 12.50  ,  12.50 


Total   $26,650.64  $2,719.02        $29,369.66 

Respectfully  submitted, 

E.  H.  Fritch,  Secretary. 


54  BUSINESS    SESSION. 

TREASURER'S  REPORT. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Raikvay  Engineering  Association: 
I  have  the  honor  of  presenting  the  following  report : 

Balance  Cash  on  hand,  March  15,  191 1 $13,216.62 

Consisting  of: 

Ten    railroad   bonds,    as    follows :      Four    St. 
Louis    Southwestern    bonds,    par    value, 

$1,000  each,  at  cost. $  3,319.31 

Six    L.    S.    &    M.    S.    Ry.    bonds,    par    value, 

$1,000  each,  at  cost 5,660.25 

Cash  in   Bank 4,237.06 


Total  $13,216.62 

Receipts  from  all  sources,  March  16,  1911,  to  Dec.  31,  1911 $23,716.69 

Receipts  from  all  sources,  Jan.  1,  1912,  to  March  15,  1912 10,538.44 


Total  Receipts  for  the  year $34,255.13 

Expenditures : 

March  16,      Jan.  1,  1912, 
1911,10  to 

Dec.  31,  1911.  Mar.  15,  1912. 
Paid  on  audited  vouchers $25,602.96        $  3,766.70        $29,369.66 


Balance  to  credit $  4,885.47 

Less  proceeds  from  sale  of  four  L.  S.  &  M.  S.  bonds 3,797-33 


Net  Excess  of  Receipts  over  Expenditures $  1,088.14 

Composition  of  Balance,  March  15,  1912: 

Cash  in  bank $  8,836.43 

Cash  on  hand,  checks,  etc 286.10 

Four  St.  Louis  Southwestern  bonds,  at  cost 3,319-31 

Two  L.  S.  &  M.  S.  bonds,  at  cost 1,886.75 


Total  Cash  Assets,  March  15,  1912 $14,328.59 

The  bonds  above  listed  are  registered  in  the  name  of  the  Association 
and  have  been  placed  in  a  safety  deposit  box  in  the  Merchants'  Loan  and 
Trust  Company's  vaults,  Chicago. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

Geo.  H.  Bremner,  Treasurer. 

The  President : — What  is  your  pleasure  in  regard  to  the  reports  of 
the  Secretary  and  the  Treasurer? 

Mr.  W.  H.  Elliott : — I  move  the  acceptance  of  the  reports. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President : — There  has  been  prepared  for  our  benefit  by  the 
National  Railway   Appliances  Association  an  unparalleled  exhibit  of  rail- 


BUSINESS  SESSION.  55 

way  appliances  in  the  Coliseum,  on  Wabash  Avenue,  and  in  order  to  allow 
the  members  time  to  visit  it,  it  has  been  decided  to  adjourn   at  4  p.  m. 
to-day.     The   exhibit  is   more   complete   and   larger  than   ever,   so   that   it 
has  been  necessary  to  use  the  adjacent  armory  building  this  year. 
There  will  be  no  evening  session. 

The  members  are  requested,  as  usual,  to  be  early  in  the  purchase  of 
dinner  tickets,  which  will  be  on  sale  this  afternoon  in  the  lobby  outside 
of  this  room.  You  all  know,  from  what  has  been  said  in  previous  years, 
that  we  have  to  give  the  necessary  information  to  the  hotel  people  in 
order  that  they  may  make  the  necessary  preparations. 

The  next  order  of  business  is  the  presentation  of  the  reports  of  the 
Standing  and  Special  Committees.  The  members  of  committees  will 
please  take  their  places  on  the  platform  when  their  names  are  called  by 
the  Secretary.  If  all  the  reports  assigned  for  any  one  day  are  finished 
before  the  time  of  adjournment,  the  first  report  assigned  for  the  following 
day  may  be  brought  before  the  Association  in  order  to  advance  the  work 
of  the  convention. 

We  will  now  take  up  the  report  of  the  Committee  on  Rules  and  Or- 
ganization. Mr.  Jos.  O.  Osgood,  the  Chairman  of  the  Committee,  at  the 
last  minute  was  prevented  from  coming  here,  so  that  he  has  not  had  an 
opportunity  to  fully  instruct  the  other  members  of  his  Committee  as  to 
the  preliminary  announcement.  Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony  will  be  kind  enough 
to  state  the  general  work  of  the  Committee  in  order  that  the  report  of  the 
Committee  may  be  discussed. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Rules  and  Organization  was  pre- 
sented by  Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony,  a  member  of  the  Committee.  See  report, 
pp.  65-68;  discussion,  pp.  919-931.) 

The  President :  The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Signals 
and  Interlocking,  of  which  Mr.  A.  H.  Rudd  is  Chairman.  In  the  absence 
of  the  Chairman,  Mr.  L.  R.  Clausen,  the  Vice-Chairman,  will  present  the 
report. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Signals  and  Interlocking  was  pre- 
sented by  Mr.  L.  R.  Clausen,  the  Vice-Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  69-76 ; 
discussion,  pp.  932,  933.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Iron 
and  Steel  Structures,  of  which  Mr.  C.  H.  Cartlidge  is  Chairman.  We 
will  ask  the  Chairman  of  the  Committee  to  make  the  opening  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Iron  and  Steel  Structures  was  pre- 
sented by  Mr.  C.  H.  Cartlidge,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  81-88;.  dis- 
cussion,  pp.   934-945.) 

AFTERNOON  SESSION. 

The  President : — The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Wooden  Bridges 
and  Trestles  will  next  be  disposed  of.  Mr.  C.  C.  Went  worth,  the  Chair- 
man, will  make  the  opening  statement. 


56  BUSINESS  SESSION. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Wooden  Bridges  and  Trestles  was 
presented  by  Mr.  C.  C.  Wentworth,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  71-80 ; 
discussion,  page  946.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Ballast, 
of  which  Mr.  H.  E.  Hale  is  Chairman.     The  Chair  will  ask  Mr.  Hale  to- 
make  the  opening  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Ballast  was  presented  by  Mr.  H.  E. 
Hale,  the  Chairman.     See  report,  pp.  95-300;  discussion,  pp.  949,  950.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Ties, 
of  which  Mr.  L.  A.  Downs  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Downs  will  make  the 
opening  statement  for  the  Committee. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Ties  was  presented  by  Mr.  L.  A. 
Downs,  the  Chairman.     See  report,  pp.  301-370;  discussion,  pp.  951-964.) 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Track, 
of  which  Mr.  J.  B.  Jenkins  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Jenkins  will  make  the  pre- 
liminary statement  for  the  Committee. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Track  was  presented  by  Mr.  J.  B. 
Jenkins,  the  Chairman.     See  report,  pp.  371-386;  discussion,  pp.  965-980.) 

The  President: — We  will  now  adjourn,  and  the  remaining  questions 
will  be  taken  up  in  the  morning  on  the  length  of  switches  and  also  the 
specifications. 

(Adjourned  until  9  o'clock  a.  m.,  Wednesday.) 

WEDNESDAY,  MARCH  20,  1912. 

MORNING  SESSION. 

The  President: — Before  taking  up  the  regular  order  of  business,  the 
Chair  would  ask  the  unanimous  consent  of  the  Association  to  vary 
slightly  from  the  program  in  order  to  be  able  to  announce  the  results 
of  the  election  of  officers  at  the  close  of  the  afternoon  session.  The 
Chair  will  appoint  as  Tellers  the  following  members :  C.  H.  Spencer, 
C.  H.  Fisk  and  W.  J.  Bergen.  The  Secretary  will  turn  over  the  ballots 
to  the  Tellers  after  the  noon  adjournment.  The  Tellers  will  retire  to  the 
anteroom  and  prepare  their  report.  The  polls  will  close  at  twelve  o'clock 
to-day.  This  room  has  been  engaged  for  some  banquet  this  evening,  and 
as  an  accommodation  to  the  hotel  they  would  like  to  have  us  adjourn 
between  four-thirty  and  five  o'clock  if  we  can  possibly  do  so,  in  order 
that  they  may  have  the  room  so  as  to  prepare  for  the  banquet. 

This  evening  our  annual  dinner  is  to  commence  promptly  at  seven 
o'clock,  and  the  members  are  urgently  requested  to  be  at  the  banquet  hall 
before  seven  o'clock,  so  that  we  can  begin  promptly  at  seven. 

The  further  consideration  of  the  report  of  the  Committee  on  Track 
will  now  be  taken  up.  The  consideration  of  the  report  was  suspended  last 
evening  while  we  were  discussing  conclusion  3  on  page  374,  with  reference 
to  the  lengths  of  switches  and  number  of  frogs,  and  this  question  is  now 


BUSINESS  SESSION.  57 

open  for  discussion.  Mr.  Jenkins,  the  Chairman  of  the  Committee,  will 
continue  the  presentation  of  the  report. 

The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Yards  and  Terminals,  of 
which  Mr.  C.  H.  Spencer  is  Chairman.  The  Chairman  will  make  the  pre- 
liminary  announcement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Yards  and  Terminals  was  presented 
by  Mr.  C.  H.  Spencer,  the  Chairman.     See  report,  pp.  89-92;  discussion, 

PP.  947,  948.) 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Rail, 
Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill,  Chairman.  The  Chairman  is  requested  to  make 
the  preliminary  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Rail  was  presented  by  Mr.  Chas.  S. 
Churchill,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  559-862;  discussion,  pp. 
1017-1038.) 

The  President  :^The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Road- 
way. In  the  absence  of  the  Chairman,  Mr.  W.  M.  Dawley,  the  Vice-Chair- 
man, will  make  the  preliminary  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Roadway  was  presented  by  Mr. 
W.  M.  Dawley,  the  Vice-Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  387-400;  discussion, 
pp.  981,  982.) 

The  President : — The  next  Committee  is  that  on  Water  Service,  Mr. 
Robert  Ferriday,  Chairman.  The  Chairman  will  make  the  opening  re- 
marks in  regard  to  the  report. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Water  Service  was  presented  by  Mr. 
Robert  Ferriday,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  421-428;  discussion,  pp 
983-988.) 

AFTERNOON  SESSION. 

The  President :— The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Masonry, 
of  which  Mr.  Geo.  PI.  Tinker  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Tinker  will  make  the 
opening  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Masonry  was  presented  by  Mr.  Geo. 
H.  Tinker,  the  Chairman.     See  report,  pp.  459-504;  discussion,  pp.  990-995O 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Records 
and  Accounts,  of  which  Mr.  H.  J.  Pfeifer  is  Chairman.  The  Chairman 
will  make  the  preliminary  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Records  and  Accounts  was  pre- 
sented by  Mr.  H.  J.  Pfeifer,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  505-507;  dis- 
cussion, pp.  946,  947.) 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Elec- 
tricity, of  which  Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Kittredge 
will  make  the  preliminary  statement  for  the  Committee. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Electricity  was  presented  by  Mr. 
George  W.  Kittredge,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  509-558 ;  discussion, 
pp.  998-1016.) 


58  BUSINESS  SESSION. 

The  Chair  expected  to  announce  the  result  of  the  election  to-night, 
but  the  Committee  is  still  counting  the  ballots  and  he  will,  therefore, 
be  unable  to  do  so   until  to-morrow. 

Some  members  have  expressed  a  desire  to  visit  the  cement  plants  at 
Buffington  and  the  steel  plants  at  Gary,  Indiana.  Arrangements  have 
been  made  for  a  trip  of  inspection  Friday  morning. 

No  more  reports  will  be  taken  up  this  evening,  and  a  motion  to  ad- 
journ is  in  order. 

(On  motion  the  meeting  was  adjourned  until  9  a.  m.,  Thursday.) 

THURSDAY,  MARCH  21,  1912. 

.MORNING  SESSION. 

The  President : — The  first  business  this  morning  will  be  the  report  of 
the  Committee  on  Conservation  of  Natural  Resources,  Mr.  E.  O.  Faulkner, 
Chairman.  In  the  absence  of  Mr.  Faulkner,  the  report  will  be  presented 
by  Mr.  William  McNab,  the  Vice-Chairman. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Conservation  of  Natural  Resources 
was  presented  by  Mr.  William  McNab,  the  Vice-Chairman.  See  report,  pp. 
429-458;  discussion,  page  989.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Signs, 
Fences  and  Crossings,  Mr.  C.  H.  Stein,  Chairman. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Signs,  Fences  and  Crossings  was 
presented  by  Mr.  C.  H.  Stein,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  900-904;  dis- 
cussion, pp.  1055-1057.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Build- 
ings, of  which  Mr.  Maurice  Coburn  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Coburn  will  make 
the  opening  statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Buildings  was  presented  by  Mr. 
Maurice  Coburn,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  885-889;  discussion,  page 
1054.) 

The  President : — The  Committee  on  Uniform  General  Contract  Forms 
will  please  come  forward.  Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood,  the  Vice-Chairman,  will 
make  the  statement  of  the  work  of  this  Committee. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Uniform  General  Contract  Forms 
was  presented  by  Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood,  the  Vice-Chairman.  See  report,  pp. 
907-916;  discussion,  pp.   1 059-1076.) 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Economics  of  Railway  Location),  of  which  Mr.  A.  K.  Shurtleff  is  Chair- 
man.    Mr.    Shurtleff  will   make  the   opening   statement. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Economics  of  Railway  Location  was 
presented  by  Mr.  A.  K.  Shurtleff,  the  Chairman.  See  report  pp.  905,  906: 
discussion,   page  958.) 

.  The  President : — The  next  Committee  is  the  Special  Committee  on 
Grading  of  Lumber,  Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk,  Chairman.  We  will  hear 
from   Dr.   von   Schrenk. 


BUSINESS  SESSION.  59 

(The  report  of  the  Special  Committee  on  Grading  of  Lumber  was  pre- 
sented by  Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  873- 
884:    discussion,   pp.    1052,    1053.) 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  the  Committee  on  Wood  Preser- 
vation. Mr.  Earl  Stimson  is  the  Chairman.  We  will  have  the  opening 
statement  by  Mr.  Stimson. 

(The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Wood  Preservation  was  presented  by 
Mr.  Earl  Stimson,  the  Chairman.  See  report,  pp.  863-872;  discussion,  pp. 
1030- 105 1.) 

The  President: — We  have  finished  the  business  in  connection  with  the 
reports  of  Special  and  Standing  Committees,  and  under  the  heading  of 
"New  Business"  there  are  some  resolutions  to  be  offered. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Berry  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific)  : — I  would  suggest 
action  by  the  members  of  this  Association  on  the  following  resolutions  : 

'"Resolved,  by  the  members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association  in  convention  assembled,  that  we  desire  to  place  on  record 
our  hearty  appreciation  of  the  efforts  made  and  the  admirable  results  ob- 
tained by  the  Railway  Age  Gazette  in  its  daily  issue  during  this  conven- 
tion. 

"Resolved,  that  the  cordial  thanks  of  the  Association  be  extended  to 
its  managing  officers  and  editorial  staff. 

"Resolved,  that  a  copy  of  these  resolutions  be  spread  upon  the  Minutes 
of  this  convention  and  a  copy  transmitted  to  the  Railway  Age  Gazette." 

I   submit  the   foregoing  resolutions   for  adoption  by  the   Association. 
(The  resolution  was  unanimously  adopted.) 
Mr.  Berry: — I  offer  the  following  resolutions: 

"Resolved,  by  the  members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association  in  convention  assembled,  that  we  desire  to  place  on  record 
cur  hearty  appreciation  of  the  efforts  made  and  the  admirable  results  ob- 
tained by  the  Railway  and  Engineering  Review  in  its  daily  issue  during 
this  convention. 

"Resolved,  that  the  cordial  thanks  of  the  Association  be  extended  to 
its  managing  officers  and  editorial  staff. 

"Resolved,  that  a  copy  of  these  resolutions  be  spread  upon  the  Min- 
utes of  this  convention  and  a  copy  transmitted  to  the  Railway  and  En- 
gineering Review." 

(The  resolution  was  unanimously  adopted.) 

Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill  (Norfolk  &  Western)  : — I  offer  the  following 
resolutions  : 

"Resolved,  by  the  members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association,  in  convention  assembled,  that  we  desire  to  place  on  record 
our  appreciation  of  the  efforts  made  by  the  National  Railway  Appliances 
Association  in  making  possible  the  most  admirable  and  instructive  exhibit 
of  devices  and  materials  used  in  the  construction,  operation  and  mainten- 
ance of  railways,  and  of  the  educational  value  of  the  exhibition. 

"Resolved,  that  the  thanks  of  the  members  of  this  Association  be  ex- 
tended to  the  officers  and  members  of  the  National  Railway  Appliances 
Association  for  courtesies  and  facilities  placed  at  our  disposal  during 
the  convention. 


60  BUSINESS  SESSION. 

"Resolved,  that  a  copy  of  these  resolutions  be  forwarded  to  the  offi- 
cers of  the  National  Railway  Appliances  Association,  and  that  they  be 
spread  upon  the  Minutes  of  this  convention." 

(The  resolutions  were  unanimously  adopted.) 

Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt  (Pittsburgh  &  Lake  Erie)  :— I  offer  the  follow-, 
ing  resolution : 

"Resolved,  that  the  hearty  thanks  of  the  members  of  the  American 
Railway  Engineering  Association  in  convention  assembled  lie  tendered 
to  the  Official  Reporters,  Messrs.  T.  E.  Crossman  and  G.  W.  Burgoyne, 
for  their  efficient  and  accurate  report  of  the  Proceedings  of  this  conven- 
tion, and  that  a  copy  of  this  resolution  be  spread  upon  the  Minutes  and 
a  copy  transmitted  to  them." 

(The  resolution  was  unanimously  adopted.) 

Mr.  C.  H.  Stein  (Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey)  : — I  offer  the  fol- 
lowing resolution  for  adoption : 

"Resolved,  that  the  hearty  thanks  of  the  members  of  the  American 
Railway  Engineering  Association  in  convention  assembled  be  tendered  the 
Tellers,  Messrs.  C.  H.  Spencer,  C.  H.  Fisk  and  W.  J.  Bergen,  for  their 
arduous  labor  and  for  the  efficient  manner  in  which  the  work  has  been 
performed." 

(The  resolution  was  unanimously  adopted.) 

Mr.  A.  F.  Robinson  (Santa  Fe)  : — I  offer  the  following  resolution: 

"Resolved,  that  the  hearty  thanks  of  the  members  of  the  American 
Railway  Engineering  Association  in  convention  assembled  be  extended 
and  are  hereby  tendered  the  Committee  on  Arrangements  for  the  efficient 
manner  in  which  all  details  for  this  convention  have  been  carried  out. 

"Resolved,  that  the  Committee  be  'continued  at  the  same  salary.'  " 

(The  resolution  was  unanimously  adopted.) 

The  President : — I  will  ask  the  Secretary  to  announce  the  election 
of  officers  for  the  ensuing  year,  and  I  desire  to  say  that  we  have  imposed 
on  the  Tellers  this  time.  They  were  all  afternoon  yesterday  and  long 
into  the  evening  counting  the  votes,  and  we  are,  therefore,  under  obliga- 
tions to  the  Committee  at  this  time  for  the  care  and  labor  used  in  the 
preparation  of  their  report. 

The  Secretary: — The  report  of  the  Tellers  is  as  follows: 

REPORT  OF  TELLERS. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

We,  the  undersigned,  appointed  Tellers  to  canvass  the  votes  cast  for 
the  election  of  officers,  Board  of  Direction  and  Nominating  Committee 
for  the  year  1912,  beg  leave  to  advise  that  after  careful  examination  and 
canvass  of  each  ballot  the  results  are  as  follows : 

Total  vote  cast 517 

Unsigned   ballots    12 

Associate  members  not  counted 20        32 

Total  vote  counted 485 


BUSINESS  SESSION.  61 

President : 

C.  S.  Churchill 483 

A.  W.  Thompson 1 

Blank   1 

Vice-President : 

W.  B.  Storey,  Jr 482 

J.    B.    Berry 1 

A.  S.  Baldwin 1 

Robert   Trimble    1 

Treasurer : 

Geo.  H.  Bremner 485 

Secretary: 

E.  H.  Fritch 485 

Directors  for  3  Years  : 

F.  A.    Delano 238 

W.   L.   Darling 236 

W.  B.  Scott 188 

C.  H.  Cartlidge 182 

C.  C.  Anthony 141 

S.  B.  Fisher 131 

W.   S.   Kinnear 117 

C.  H.  Ewing 109 

J.  M.  R.  Fairbairn 88 

J.  G.  Sullivan 1 

Nominating  Committee : 

F.  L.  Stuart 330 

C.  F  W.  Felt 307 

J.    O.    Osgood 267 

G.  J.  Ray 249 

F.    H.    Alfred 241 

A.  K.  Shurtleff 224 

C.  E.  Lindsay 216 

W.  Beahan  203 

A.  W.  Newton 148 

C.  L.  Ransom 125 

A.   O.   Cunningham'. 1 

J.  F  Coleman 1 

J.  G.   Sullivan 1 

Respectfully  submitted, 

C.  H.  Spencer, 
C.  H.  Fisk, 
W.  J.  Bergen, 

Tellers. 

The  Secretary — The  result  of  the  ballot  for  officers  is  as  follows  : 

President — Chas.  S.  Churchill. 

Vice-President — W.  B.  Storey,  Jr. 

Treasurer — Geo.  H.  Bremner. 

Secretary— E.  H.  Fritch. 

Three  Directors  (three  years  each)— W.  L.  Darling,  F.  A.  Delano, 
W.  B.  Scott. 

Five  Members  of  Nominating  Committee — 'Francis  Lee  Stuart,  C.  F. 
W.  Felt,  Jos.  O.  Osgood,  G.  J.  Ray,  F.  H.  Alfred. 


62  BUSINESS  SESSION. 

The  President : — Gentlemen,  in  relinquishing  the  office  of  President, 
I  desire  to  express  my  profound  appreciation  of  the  honor  and  favor 
you  have  done  me  in  electing  me  to  that  office  for  the  past  year.  I  now 
take  pleasure  in  asking  Mr.  McDonald  and  Mr.  Wendt  to  escort  the 
newly-elected  President  to  the  platform. 

President-Elect  Churchill : — Gentlemen,  I  have  always  considered  a 
membership  on  any  Committee  of  this  working  association  to  be  a  posi- 
tion of  distinct  trust  and  prestige,  and  any  official  position  as  an  honor. 
I,  therefore,  am  very  grateful  for  this  highest  honor  that  you  have  con- 
ferred upon  me  in  making  me  the  President  of  this  Association,  which 
now  stands  so  high  in  the  railway  matters  of  the  world. 

I  thank  you.  I  appreciate  the  fact  that  in  taking  this  office  after 
such  brilliant  stars  who  have  preceded  me  that  I  need  all  the  help  that 
the  committees  and  members  can  give,  and  I  am  sure  that  I  will  have  it, 
and  you  shall  have  my  best  efforts  in  everything  that  we  are  called  upon 
to  carry  out. 

In  my  last  word  I  want  to  call  attention  to  the  recommendation  of  the 
outgoing  President : — that  we  try  to  increase  the  membership  for  the 
specific  object  at  this  time  of  increasing  the  revenues  of  the  Association. 
There  are  many  matters  before  this  Association  that  could  be  looked 
into  further  than  we  are  now  able  to  look  into  them,  and  experiments 
which  could  be  carried  on  which  we  are  now  unable  to  make,  because  of  a 
lack  of  sufficient  funds.  If  each  member  of  this  Association  will  leave 
this  assembly  with  the  idea  that  he  will  try  to  bring  into  the  Association 
during  this  year  more  new  members,  we  will  in  the  course  of  a  year  or 
so  have  the  revenue  from  the  membership  dues  which  we  require. 

This,  I  believe,  is  all  the  business  before  this  convention. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — Mr.  President.  I  wish 
to  offer  the  following  resolution : 

"Resolved,  by  the  members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
Association  in  convention  assembled,  that  we  desire  to  place  on  record 
our  hearty  appreciation  of  the  well-directed  and  untiring  efforts  and 
eminently  efficient  administration  of  the  retiring  President,  Mr.  W.  C. 
dishing,  and  that  this  resolution  be  spread  upon  the  Minutes  of  the 
meeting  and  a  copy  transmitted  to  Mr.  Cushing." 

(The  question  on  the  adoption  of  the  resolution  was  put  by  Mr. 
J.  B.  Berry,  and  was  unanimously  adopted.) 

Past-President  Cushing:— I  thank  you. 

The  President : — I  wish  to  announce  a  meeting  of  the  Board  of  Di- 
rection in  Room  1166,  at  two  o'clock. 

The  convention  is  adjourned  to  March,  1913. 

E.  H.  Fritch,  Secretary. 


COMMITTEE  REPORTS 


REPORT   OF   COMMITTEE  XII— ON  RULES   AND 
ORGANIZATION. 

Jos.  O.  Osgood,  Chairman;  G.  D.  Brooke,  Vice-Chairman; 

F.  D.  Anthony.  F.  P.  Gutelius. 

J.  B.  Carothers.  Kenneth  Hanger. 

S.  E.  Coombs.  Jos.  Mullen. 

J.  B.  Dickson.  F.  L.  Nicholson. 

C.  Dougherty.  W.  C.  Smith. 

J.  A.  Gordon.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Raihvay  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Rules  and  Organization  respectfully  submits  here- 
with its  report,  as  follows : 

Meetings  of  the  Committee,  Sub-Committees  and  Chairmen  of  the 
Sub-Committees  were  held  as  follows :  A  meeting  of  the  Committee  was 
held  in  New  York,  June  9,  191 1;  Sub-Committee  meetings  were  held  in 
New  York  and  Chicago  on  July  21,  and  in  Montreal  on  July  31,  191 1  ; 
three  Chairmen  of  Sub-Committees  held  a  meeting  in  New  York  on  Sep- 
tember 8,  191 1. 

Last  year's  report  of  this  Committee  embodied  revisions  of  the  rules 
as  then  published  in  the  Manual  and  additional  rules  of  the  same  general 
character,  all  relating  to  the  government  of  employes  of  the  Maintenance 
of  Way  Department. 

For  this  year's  work  your  Committee  was  instructed  by  the  Board  of 
Direction  to : 

(1)  Continue  the  compilation  of  rules  for  the  government  of  Main- 
tenance of  Way  employes. 

(2)  Formulate  rules  in  the  nature  of  specifications  or  instructions 
regarding  the  conduct  of  work,  making  use  of  the  recommendations  of  the 
various  Committees  dealing  with  these  subjects  and  of  the  best  practice 
of  railway  companies,  as  embodied  in  their  books  of  rules. 

Some  progress  has  been  made  with  rules  falling  under  the  first  of  the 
instructions,  but  this  year's  report  deals  only  with  the  work  falling  under 
the  second  of  the  instructions. 

Your  Committee  recommends : 

(1)  That  no  change  be  made  in  the  General  Rules  for  the  Govern- 
ment of  Employes  of  the  Maintenance  of  Way  Department  heretofore 
adopted  by  the  Association. 

(2)  That  to  the  rules  heretofore  adopted  by  the  Association  be 
added  instructions,  as  follows : 

65 


66  RULES    AND    ORGANIZATION. 

♦INSTRUCTIONS. 
Cross-Sections. 

(i)  The  roadbed,  ballast  and  track  shall  conform  to  the  standard 
plans.  No  changes  in  the  sections  shown  shall  be  made  without  proper 
authority.  ^ 

(Note:  It  is  understood  that  cross-sections  for  wet  cuts  will  be  in- 
cluded in  the  standard  plans.) 

Drainage. 

(2)  All  ditches,  including  intercepting  ditches  on  the  upper  side  of 
cuts,  must  be  kept  clean. 

(3)  Where  heaving  or  wet  spots  develop,  special  drainage  shall  be 
provided. 

Ballasting. 

(4)  Before  re-ballasting  track,  line  and  grade  stakes  shall  be  set 
by  the  Engineer.  All  unsuitable  material  shall  be  removed  and  the  road- 
bed widened  to  proper  section,  the  waste  material  being  used  to  widen 
banks,  or  otherwise,  as  may  be  directed. 

(5)  Track  must  be  kept  in  good  line  and  surface  while  ballasting, 
open  track  avoided  as  far  as  practicable,  and  such  track  carefully  watched. 

(6)  After  ballast  is  distributed  it  shall  be  trimmed,  and  the  track 
lined  and  surfaced  to  conform  to  the  standard  plans. 

(7)  Where  track  is  bonded,  ballast  must  be  kept  at  least  one  inch 
below  the  base  of  rail.  At  road  crossings,  platforms,  etc.,  where  this  is 
not  practicable,  only  clean  gravel  or  rock  ballast  shall  be  used. 

Ties. 

(8)  Ties  stored  along  right-of-way  shall  be  piled  to  conform  to  the 
standard  plan. 

(Note:  The  standard  plan  should  show  the  minimum  distance  to  the 
nearest  rail.) 

(9)  The  ties  in  track  must  be  inspected  at  stated  times  each  year 
and  those  which  will  not  last  until  the  next  inspection  marked  for  renewal. 

(10)  The  renewal  of  ties  shall  be  started  when  directed  by  the 
\ .1.t... When  ties  are  being  renewed,  the  line  and  sur- 
face shall  be  corrected  and  ballast  trimmed. 

(11)  All  defective  ties  removed  from  track  shall  each  day  be  placed 
for  burning  or  loading  on  cars. 

(12)  The *:.}.... shall  frequently  inspect  ties  removed 

from  track  to  see  if  any  have  been  removed  which  might  have  remained 
in  the  track  with  safety  until  the  next  inspection. 

(13)  Ties  shall  be  spaced  according  to  the  standard  plans.  All  ties 
shall  be  placed  square  to  the  line  of  rails.  The  outside  ends  on  double 
tracks,  and  the  ends  on  one  side  throughout  on  single  track,  must  be  lined 
parallel  with  the  rail. 

(14)  The  heart  side  of  ties  must  be  turned  down.     The  largest  and 


*For  amendments  to  Clauses  6.   7.    10.   12   and   14,  see  Index. 


RULES    AND    ORGANIZATION.  67 

best  ties  shall  be  selected  for  use  at  joints.     Twisted  or  badly  hewn  ties 
must  not  be  notched,  but  the  bearings  must  be  made  true  with  the  adze. 

(15)  Whenever  spikes  are  drawn  from  ties,  wooden  tie  plugs  must 
be  driven  into  all  holes  except  in  ties  which  are  to  be  renewed  that  season. 
In  replacing  spikes  they  should  be  driven  into  the  plugs. 

Rail. 

(16)  In  unloading  rails  from  cars  they  should  be  skidded  or  other- 
wise carefully  lowered  to  avoid  injury.  Where  it  is  necessary  to  drop 
them,  both  ends  must  be  dropped  together  and  the  greatest  care  taken 
to  avoid  their  falling  on  hard  and  uneven  surfaces. 

(17)  The  bottom  of  the  new  rail  and  the  bearing  surface  of  the  tie 
shall  be  cleaned  before  the  new  rail  is  laid. 

(18)  When  replacing  rail  with  rail  of  the  same  section,  only  two 
rows  of  spikes  shall  be  drawn ;  in  replacing  with  rail  of  a  different  section, 
three  rows  of  spikes  shall  be  drawn. 

(19)  In  laying  new  rail,  standard  expansion  shims  shall  be  used. 
The  temperature  of  the  rail  shall  be  taken  by  placing  the  thermometer  on 
the  rail.    The  openings  between  33  ft.  rails  shall  be  as  follows: 

Temperature   (Fahrenheit).  Amount  of  Opening. 

— 200  to      o°  fe  in. 

0°  to    25°  Vi,  in. 

250  to     50°  -h  in. 

50°  to     75°  V*  in- 

750  to  ioo0  tV  in. 

Over  ioo°  to  be  laid  close. 

The  rail  should  be  laid  without  bumping  and  when  practicable,  laid 
rail  by  rail. 

(20)  The  rails  shall  be  brought  squarely  into  line  and  at  least  two 
bolts  tightened  before  spiking.  All  joint  bars  shall  be  securely  fastened 
with  the  full  number  of  bolts,  tightening  those  at  the  center  first.  At 
permanent  connections  of  rails  of  different  sections  step  chairs  and  off-set 
splices  must  be  used. 

(21)  All  spikes  must  be  driven  vertically  with  the  face  in  contact 
with  the  base  of  the  rail.  They  should  not  be  straightened  while  being 
driven.  The  rail  must  be  full  spiked  and  the  spikes  staggered  so  that 
the  outside  spikes  shall  be  on  the  same  side  of  the  tie  and  the  inside 
spikes  on  the  opposite  side. 

(22)  In  making  temporary  connections  in  main  tracks  an  old  rail 
should  be  cut  and  fastened  to  the  new  rail,  using  compromise  joints  when 
necessary.  Switch  points  shall  be  used  for  this  purpose  only  during  the 
presence  of  the  Track  Foreman. 

(23)  After  new  rail  is  laid  the  track  must  be  lined  and  surfaced. 

(24)  All  kinked  or  crooked  rails  must  be  straightened  before  being 
laid ;  if  bent  in  service  they  must  either  be  removed  or  straightened. 

(25)  Rails  for  curves  of  2  degrees  and  over  should  be  curved  before 
being  laid.   In  curving  or  straightening  rails,  the  rail  bender  must  be  used. 

*For  amendments  to  Clauses  17,  18,  20  and  25,  see  Index. 


68  RULES    AND    ORGANIZATION. 

Surfacing. 

*(26)     When  surfacing  (picking  up  low  points  or  other  low  places), 
the  general  level  of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed. 

NEXT  YEAR'S  WORK. 

(3)     For  next  year  it  is  recommended  that  the  Committee  continue 
this  year's  work. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION. 


*For  amendment    to    Clause    26,    see    Index. 


REPORT    OF    COMMITTEE   X— ON    SIGNALS   AND 
INTERLOCKING. 

A.  H.  Rudd,  Chairman;  L.  R.  Clausen,  Vice-Chairman; 

Azel  Ames.  A.  S.  Ingalls. 

C.  C.  Anthony.  J.  C.  Mock. 

H.  Baker.  F.  P.  Patenall. 

H.  S.  Balliet.  J.  A.  Peabody. 

W.  B.  Causey.  Frank  Rhea. 

C.  A.  Christofferson.  W.  B.  Scott. 

C.  E.  Denney.  A.  G.  Shaver. 

W.  J.  Eck.  T.  S.  Stevens. 

W.  H.  Elliott.  H.  H.  Temple. 

G.  E.  Ellis.  Edwin  F.  Wendt. 

W.  J.  Harahan.  J.  C.  Young. 

M'.  H.  Hovey.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

During  the  past  year  your  Committee  has  met  as  follows :  At  Buffalo, 
May  25;   Buffalo,  June  29;   Buffalo,  July  27. 

The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  four  subjects  for  consideration: 

(1)  Continue  investigation  of  outline  and  description  of  a  com- 
prehensive and  uniform  signal  system,  suitable  for  general  adoption,  con- 
ferring with  proper  committee  of  the  American  Railway  Association. 

(2)  Revise  mechanical  interlocking  specifications,  and  include 
wrought-iron  pipe  as  well  as  steel. 

(3)  Revise  electric  interlocking  specifications  and  submit  statement  of 
the  results  from  experience. 

(4)  Report  on  the  effect  of  treated  and  metal  ties  on  track  circuits. 
Last  year  your  Committee  presented  revised  specifications  for  various 

kinds  of  insulated  wire,  which  the  Association  adopted.  In  order  to 
bring  these  specifications  into  conformity  with  those  adopted  by  the  Rail- 
way Signal  Association,  a  new  insulation  resistance  table  is  herewith 
submitted  with  the  following: 

CONCLUSION. 

(1)  The  following  table  of  insulation  resistances  in  megohms  per 
mile  at  sixty  (60)  degrees  Fahrenheit  for  the  various  thicknesses  of  in- 
sulation in  fractions  of  an  inch  and  the  various  sizes  of  wire  is  made  a 
part  of  the  specifications  for  mineral  matter,  rubber  compound,  insulated 
signal  wire  for  current  of  660  volts  or  less,  appearing  in  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 

69 


70  SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING. 

pp.   101   to   104,   inclusive,   and  the  insulation    resistance   in    megohms  per 
mile,  shown  on  page  108,  is  revised  to  conform  with  this  table. 

i      i      L      L     L      i       !L      *L      L      _! 

B.  &  S.  G.     64  32  64  32  64  32  32  32  32         32 

0 900  1100  1200  1300  1500  1800  2000  2200 

1 1000  1200  1400  1500  1800  1900  2200  2400 

2 1000  1100  1400  1500  1600  1900  2200  2300  2600 

3 1100  1200  1500  1600  1800  2000  2300  2600  2700 

4 1200  1400  1600  1800  1900  2200  2400  2700  2800 

5 1300  1500  1700  1900  2000  2300  2600  2800  3100 

6 1400  1600  1800  2000  2200  2600  2800  3100  3400 

8 1400  1600  1900  2200  2300  2600  2800  3200  3500  3800 

9 1500  1800  2000  2300  2600  2700  3100  3400  3600  3900 

10 1600  1900  2200  2400  2700  3000  3200  3600  3900  4200 

12 1800  2200  2500  2800  3100  3200  3600  4000  4300  4600 

14 2200  2600  2800  3200  3500  3600  4200  4400  4800  5100 

(2)  The  above  table  of  insulation  resistances  in  megohms  per  mile  at 
sixty  (60)  degrees  Fahrenheit  for  the  various  thicknesses  of  insulation 
in  fractions  of  an  inch  and  the  various  sizes  of  wire  is  made  a  part  of 
the  specifications  for  mineral  matter,  rubber  compound,  insulated  aerial 
braided  cables  for  current  of  660  volts  or  less,  shown  on  pp.  105  to  109, 
inclusive,  of  the  same  Volume,  and  the  insulation  resistance  megohms  per 
mile,  shown  on  page  108,  is  revised  to  conform  thereto. 

(3)  The  above  table  of  insulation  resistances  in  megohms  per  mile  at 
sixty  (60)  degrees  Fahrenheit  for  the  various  thicknesses  of  insulation  in 
fractions  of  an  inch  and  the  various  sizes  of  wire  is  made  a  part  of  the 
specifications  for  mineral  matter,  rubber  compound,  insulated,  lead-covered, 
armored  submarine  cables  for  600  or  lower  voltage  service,  shown  on  pp. 
no  to  114,  inclusive,  of  the  same  Volume,  and  the  insulation  resistance 
megohms  per  mile,  shown  on  page  113,  is  revised  to  conform  thereto. 

Your  Committee  does  not  report  this  year  on  subjects  Nos.  2,  3  or  4, 
assigned  by  the  Board  of  Direction.    It  reports  on  Subject  No.  1  as  follows: 

UNIFORM  SIGNALING. 

This  subject  was  referred  to  the  Committee  on  Transportation  of  the 
American  Railway  Association  by  the  1910  convention.  In  191 1,  progress 
was  reported. 

The  amended  report  of  the  Committee  on  Transportation,  accepted 
by  the  American  Railway  Association,  as  information,  May,  191 1,  and 
transmitted  to  your  Committee  X  through  Secretary  Fritch,  is  as  follows : 

MEMORANDUM    ON    THE   ESSENTIALS    OF    SIGNALING. 

Incorporated  in  the  Report  of  the  Committee  on  Transportation  of  the 
American  Railway  Association,  May,  1911. 

The  reports  of_  various  Committees  of  the  Railway  Signal  Association 
and  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way 
Association  on  the  subject  of  signaling  have  been  submitted  to  this  Com- 
mittee, with  the  request  that  the  essentials  of  signaling  be  outlined  or 
defined  for  the  future  guidance  of  their  Committees. 

The  subject  has  been  carefully  analyzed  and  considered.  There  are 
three  signals  that  are  essential  in  operation  and  therefore  fundamental,  viz. : 

(1)  Stop. 

(2)  Proceed  with  caution. 

(3)  Proceed. 


SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING.  71 

The  fundamental,  "Proceed  with  caution,"  may  be  used  with  the 
same  aspect  to  govern  any  cautionary  movement,  for  example,  when 

(a)  Next  signal  is  "stop." 

(b)  Next  signal  is  "proceed  at  low  speed." 

(c)  Next  signal  is  "proceed  at  medium  speed." 

(d)  A  train  is  in  the  block. 

(e)  There  may  be  an  obstruction  ahead. 

There  are  two  additional  indications  which  may  be  used  where  move- 
ments are  to  be  made  at  a  restricted  speed,  viz. : 

(4)  Proceed  at  low  speed. 

(5)  Proceed  at  medium  speed. 

Where  automatic  block  system  rules  are  in  effect,  a  special  mark  of 
some  distinctive  character  should  be  applied  at  the  stop  signal. 
The  Committee  therefore  recommends : 

SIGNAL  FUNDAMENTALS. 

(1)  Stop. 

(2)  Proceed  with  caution. 

(3)  Proceed. 

SUPPLEMENTARY   INDICATIONS    TO   BE   USED   WHERE   REQUIRED. 

(4)  Proceed  at  low  speed. 

(5)  Proceed  at  medium  speed. 

Stop  signals  operated  under  automatic  block  system  rules  should  be 
designated  by  some  distinctive  mark,  to  be  determined  by  each  road  in 
accordance  with  local  requirements. 

RECOMMENDATIONS   OF   COMMITTEE   X. 

The  simplest  aspects  for  the  three  fundamental  indications  are :  [Z3 
1.     Stop  


2.     Proceed  with  caution. 


O 

J] 


3.     Proceed 


Having  in  view,  and  not  desiring  to  depart  from,  the  established 
practice  of  indicating  diverging  routes  and  incidentally  low  and  medium 
speeds,  your  Committee  recommends  that  the  medium  and  low  speed  in- 
dications be  given  by  an  additional  arm  or  arms.  The  simplest  method 
(although  incapable  of  expansion  to  provide  additional  aspects  or  even 
combinations  of  the  fundamentals  and  supplementaries)  is  to  use  a 
second  arm  for  both  of  these  indications.  The  Committee  on  Transporta- 
tion rules  that  the  fundamental,  "Proceed  with  caution,"  may  be  used  to 
govern  any  cautionary  movement.  Therefore,  for  those  roads  which  de- 
sire to  operate  under  this  plan  and  deem  the  five  indications  entirely 
sufficient,  two  additional  aspects  are  necessary: 


72 


SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING. 


4.     Proceed    at    low    speed. 


o 


p 


5.     Proceed  at  medium  speed. 


D 


At  interlocking  plants  which  are  also  block  stations  it  may  be  desirable, 
even  on  such  roads,  to  give  passenger  trains  caution  signals  for  diverging 
movements,  but  not  for  entering  occupied  block  sections ;  this  would, 
with  the  system  outlined  above,  require  a  separate  signal  beyond  the 
interlocked  switches.  It  may  frequently  also  be  desirable  to  display  the 
fundamental,  "Proceed  with  caution,"  on  the  medium-speed  route,  and  to 
logically  and  consistently  apply  the  fundamental  aspects  for  "Proceed  with 
caution"  and  "proceed"  to  those  signals  indicating  medium  speed  and  low 
speed,  the  45-degree  position  should  be  used  for  caution  and  the  vertical 
for  proceed. 

Again,  as  the  Committee  on  Transportation  merely  makes  optional  the 
combination  of  various  indications  under  caution  and  as  several  roads  have 
found  it  desirable  to  differentiate  between  such  indications,  the  Committee 
recommends  for  such  roads  a  low  arm  as  a  low-speed  arm  and  a  middle 
arm  where  the  indication  of  medium  speed  is  desired. 

The  Committee  on  Transportation  states  that  "stop  signals  operated 
under  automatic  block  system  rules  should  be  designated  by  some  dis- 
tinctive mark  to  be  determined  by  each  road  in  accordance  with  local  re- 
quirements." The  instructions  to  this  Committee  are  to  design  a  uniform 
system,  which  end  is  defeated  if  each  road  uses  a  different  method  of 
designating  the  automatic  home  signal.  Therefore,  the  Committee  recom- 
mends as  follows : 

Conclusion  No.  1. 

On  roads  desiring  to  operate  with  the  three  fundamentals  and  the 
two  additional  indications  without  expansion  or  combination  of  these  in- 
dications, the  following  aspects  may  be  used : 


Scheme  No.  1. 

FUNDAMENTALS. 


i.     Stop. 


\0   \0 


2.     Proceed  with  caution. 


p 


3.     Proceed . 


H    U 


SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING. 

SUPPLEMENTARY    INDICATIONS. 

4.     Proceed  at  low  speed 


73 


<? 


F 


5.     Proceed  at  medium  speed. 


D 


Conclusion  No  2. 

On  those  roads  desiring  combinations  of  the  fundamentals  and  supple- 
mentary indications  and  different  aspects  for  the  various  caution  indica- 
tions permissible  under  the  ruling  of  the  Committee  on  Transportation, 
the  following  aspects  should  be  used: 

Scheme  No.  2. 

FUNDAMENTALS. 


i.     Stop. 


2.     Proceed,  prepare  to  stop  at  next  signal. 


3.     Proceed. 


SUPPLEMENTARY    INDICATIONS. 


=1 

=1 

=1 

or 

or 

Z] 

3    or  p 

f 

f 

f 

or 

or 

=1 

D 

3 

n 

a 

J] 

or 

or 

=1 

I] 

■3 

4.     Proceed  at  low  speed,  prepare  to  stop. 


O         O 


F 


5.     Proceed  at  medium  speed. 


D 


Conclusion  No.  3. 
When  it  is  desired  to  indicate  "Proceed  at 
medium  speed,  prepare  to  stop  at  next 
signal,"    aspect 


o 


should  be 
used. 


74 


SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING. 


Conclusion  No.  4. 
When  it  is  desired  to  indicate,  "Proceed  at 
low  speed,"  aspect 


iD 


should  be 
used. 


Conclusion  No.  5. 
When    it   is    desired    to   indicate,    "Proceed, 
prepare  to  pass  next  signal  at  medium 
speed,"  aspect 


D 


should  be 
used. 


Conclusion  No.  6. 
Where  in  manual  block  territory,  it  is  de- 
sired to  indicate  "Proceed  with  caution, 
block  occupied,"  aspect 


should  be 
used. 


Conclusion  No.  7. 

That  the  arms  of  automatic  signals  be  pointed  and  the  arms  of  other 
signals  giving  the  stop  indication  have  square  ends ;  that,  on  roads  using 
Scheme  No.  1,  a  number  plate  be  added  on  the  automatic  signal  and,  on 
roads  using  Scheme  No.  2,  a  red  marker  light  below  and  to  the  left  of 
the  active  light  be  provided. 

Note. — Messrs.  Baker,  Clausen,  Scott,  Stevens  and  Young  do  not  ap- 
prove the  report  on  Subject  No.  1. 

Respectfully    submitted, 
COMMITTEE  ON  SIGNALS  AND  INTERLOCKING. 


MINORITY  REPORT   OF  COMMITEE  X— AMERICAN 
RAILWAY  ENGINEERING  ASSOCIATION. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

The  undersigned  believe  that  the  indications  provided  by  the  Ameri- 
can Railway  Association  are  sufficient  for  the  operation  of  any  railroad 
and  are  all  for  which  this  Association  should  provide  aspects. 

We,  therefore,  recommend  that  the  following  indications  specified  by 
the  Committee  on  Transportation  of  the  American  Railway  Association 
and  the  aspects  used  to  represent  them  be  accepted  and  approved  as  rec- 
ommended practice : 


FUNDAMENTAL 


SUPPLEMENTAL 


i.    Stop. 


2.     Proceed  with  caution. 


3.     Proceed. 


O 


1.    Stop. 


2.     Proceed  with  caution ^ 


D 


3.     Proceed. 


4.     Proceed  at  low  speed /y 


5.     Proceed  at  medium  speed 


D 


(Stop  signals  operated  under  automatic  block  system  rules  shall  be 
designated  by  a  number  plate.) 

The  specific  objections  to  the  additional  indications  and  aspects  pro- 
vided by  the  Majority  are  the  same  as  previously  presented  to  this  Asso- 
ciation and  are  in  accordance  with  the  arguments  presented  before  the 
Transportation  Committee  of  the  American  Railway  Association  at 
Niagara  Falls  in  June,  1010. 

75 


76  SIGNALS    AND    INTERLOCKING. 

They  are  as  follows  : 

i.  It  is  impracticable  to  provide  a  separate  signal  for  each  of  the 
conditions  on  a  railroad  requiring  cautious  running  and  to  maintain  the 
fine-haired  distinctions  necessary  to  their  interpretation. 

2.  It  is  unnecessary,  and,  in  fact,  dangerous,  to  tell  the  engineman 
by  fixed  signal  how  he  shall  control  his  train  at  some  point  in  advance. 

3.  Advance  information  so  given  is  misleading  and  unreliable,  as  it 
is  subject  to  change  without  notice,  and  therefore  the  engineman  cannot 
safely  use  it.    If  he  does  so  use  it,  it  is  done  at  the  expense  of  safety. 

4.  The  conditions  of  modern  railway  operation  do  not  require  trains 
to  be  run  at  full  speed  past  Caution  signals,  and  any  time  gained  by  this 
practice  is  at  the  expense  of  safety. 

5.  Each  signal  should  indicate  Stop  or  Caution  or  Proceed,  and 
have  no  relation  to  signals  in  advance  or  in  the  rear. 

6.  Each  signal  should  be  observed  in  turn  as  the  train  comes  to  it, 
and  not  at  some  point  in  advance  at  the  option  of  the  engineman. 

7.  With  signals  properly  located,  it  is  time  a  train  should  be  run  with 
caution  if  it  has  reached  a  point  so  close  to  preceding  trains  or  Stop 
signals  in  advance  that  a  Caution  signal  is  received. 

8.  No  Proceed  or  Caution  indication  should  "imply  or  assure  clear 
track  to  a  point  in  advance."  Railway  signaling  devices  and  our  methods 
of  communication  have  not  reached  the  perfection  that  will  admit  of 
this  being  done.  We  cannot  know  positively  if  the  track  is  clear,  and 
further,  it  may  not  stay  clear.  We  are  under  a  moral  obligation  not 
to  give  such  misleading  information. 

9.  The  giving  of  information  by  signal  indications  about  conditions 
in  advance,  whether  it  be  regarding  the  next  signal  or  the  next  station, 
or  any  other  object  or  condition,  is  wrong  practice,  productive  of  laxity 
and  a  fruitful  source  of  danger  and  accident. 

10.  It  wilj  be  difficult,  if  not  impossible,  to  maintain  discipline  and 
proper  observance  of  the  great  variety  of  Caution  indications  proposed 
by  the  Majority,  because  of  the  fine  distinctions  involved. 

A  number  of  serious  and  fatal  accidents  in  the  past  few  years, 
wherein  the  engineman  failed  to  properly  observe  the  Caution  signal,  but 
fully  intended  to  stop  at  the  next  signal,  testify  most  conclusively  to 
the  correctness  of  our  position  in  this  matter. 

Respectfully   submitted, 

H.  S.  Baker, 
W.  B.  Scott, 
T.  S.  Stevens, 
J.  C.  Young, 
L.   R.    Clausen. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  VII— ON  WOODEN  BRIDGES 
AND  TRESTLES. 

C.  C.  Wentworth,  Chairman;  W.  F.  Steffens,  V  ice -Chairman  ; 

F.  H.  Bainbridge.  Hans  Ibsen. 

F.  E.  Bissell.  Henry  S.  Jacoby. 

W.  S.  Bouton.  J.  A.  Lahmer. 

R.  D.  Coombs.  H.  Rettinghouse. 

E.  A.  Hadley.  I.  L.  Simmons. 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

COMMITTEE   MEETINGS. 

One  meeting  of  the  Committee  was  held  in  Chicago  at  the  offices  of  the 
Association  on  October  2,  191 1.  Those  in  attendance  were  H.  Ibsen,  H. 
Rettinghouse,  I.  L.  Simmons  and  C.  C.  Wentworth. 

REVIEW   OF   THE   REPORT   OF    19H. 

A  pile  record  form  was  recommended  and  adopted.  See  Proceedings, 
Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  307;  also  Manual,  Edition  of  191 1,  page  154. 

Principles  of  practice  for  pile  driving  were  recommended,  and,  after 
some  amendment  by  the  convention,  adopted.  See  Proceedings,  Vol.  12, 
Part  1,  pp.  307  to  320,  inclusive;  also  Manual,  Edition  of  191 1,  pp.  150  to 
152,  inclusive. 

The  remainder  of  the  report  on  piles  and  pile  driving  was  accepted  as 
information,  so  also  was  the  conclusion  as  to  a  means  of  protecting  piling 
against  marine  borers  by  surrounding  each  pile  with  a  vitrified  clay  pipe 
and  filling  the  space  between  the  pile  and  the  pipe  with  sand.  See  Pro- 
ceedings, Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  322. 

The  work  assigned  by  the  Board  of  Direction  for  the  year  191 1  was  as 
follows : 

(1)  Report  on  the  formulas  for  use  in  determining  the  strength  of 
sheet  piling. 

(2)  Report  on  equipment  required  for  pile  driving. 

(3)  Collect  information  on  special  methods  of  driving  sheet  piles 
in  cofferdams  where  conditions  do  not  permit  the  use  of  ordinary  equip- 
ment. 

(4)  Collect  information  on  actual  experience  on  the  bearing  power 
of  piles  and  on  the  practical  results  of  the  use  of  formulas. 

(5)  Report  on  the  use  of  guard  rails  for  wooden  bridges  and 
trestles. 

(6)  Report  on  fire  protection  of  wooden  bridges  and  trestles. 

77 


78  WOODEN    BRIDGES    AND    TRESTLES. 

In  accordance  with  the  general  rules  as  to  Committee  reports  given 
on  page  14  of  Bulletin  134,  the  following  subjects  were  finally  selected 
for  consideration  this  year :  Nos.  1,  4,  5  and  6  of  the  foregoing  list.  The 
Committee  reports  its  progress  thereon  as  follows : 

(1)  Sheet  Piling — .Prof.  H.  S.  Jacoby,  Chairman;  and  H.  Ibsen,  Sub- 
Committee  : 

This  subject  Committee  VII  did  not  think  could  be  reported  on  this 
year,  as  an  experimental  investigation,  which  it  was  hoped  Cornell  Uni- 
versity would  make,  could  not  be  completed  in  time  for  report  if  under- 
taken; and  it  was  thought  that  the  result  of  these  experiments  would 
be  of  much  service  in  making  up  its  final  report  to  the  Association.  The 
Committee  has  since  been  advised  that  Cornell  could  not  undertake  these 
experiments,  but  the  Committee  hopes  that  some  other  Institution  may 
find  it  desirable  that  they  be  carried  out  by  it. 

The  procedure  suggested  for  these  experiments  was  that  a  strong 
concrete  open  top  box  be  made,  across  which  at  its  middle  a  vertical 
plate  diaphragm  of  tempered  spring  steel  could  be  set;  this  diaphragm 
being  held  in  place  against  horizontal  motion  at  its  top  and  bottom.  On 
both  sides  of  this  diaphragm  the  box  would  be  simultaneously  filled  with 
the  material  to  be  tested,  as  sand ;  thus,  when  the  box  is  full,  represent- 
ing sheet  piling  driven  in  sand. 

The  sand  was  then  to  be  removed  from  one  side  of  the  diaphragm, 
as  would  occur  when  a  trench  is  excavated  protected  by  sheet  piling.  After 
the  diaphragm  had  assumed  the  curve  due  to  the  pressure  of  the  sand  its 
curved  shape  was  to  be  accurately  determined  and  a  closely  fitting  tem- 
plate made  to  record  its  curvature. 

In  order  to  determine  the  amount  and  distribution  of  the  sand  pres- 
sure, the  diaphragm  would  then  be  removed  from  the  box  and  placed 
horizontally,  supported  at  its  ends  at  the  same  points  it  was  supported 
by  when  vertical  in  the  box.  A  number  of  metal  strips  should  be 
provided,  each  long  enough  to  reach  across  the  diaphragm,  but  of  vary- 
ing thickness  to  make  up  any  required  weight,  and  of  equal  width.  These 
would  be  piled  at  equal  intervals  on  the  diaphragm  until  the  curve  of  flex- 
ure is  again  exactly  reached  by  it  which  was  given  it  by  the  sand  and 
recorded  by  the  template;  bearing  in  mind  that  the  tops  of  the  succes- 
sive piles  of  metal  strips  must  be  on  a  curve  of  some  uniformity,  which 
may  be  called  the  curve  of  load,  without  such  irregular  outline  as  that 
of  a  battlement,  and  carried  over  the  supports  on  the  line  indicated  by 
the  curve  approaching  them.  The  total  pressure,  and  the  center  of  pres- 
sure, would  thus  be  determined,  it  is  thought,  with  considerable  accur- 
acy. 

As  a  check,  the  flexure  curve  of  the  diaphragm  already  found  could 
be  plotted  to  a  convenient  scale,  and  successive  differentials  taken  thereof 
up  to  and  including  the  fourth.  As  the  equation  of  this  flexure  curve  is 
unknown,  the  differentiation  would  be  done  graphically,  remembering 
that  the  first  differentiation  gives  the  curve  of  tangents  to  the  flexure 
curve ;  the  second  the  curve  of  moments ;  the  third  the  curve  of  shear, 


WOODEN    BRIDGES    AND    TRESTLES.  79 

and  the  fourth  the  curve  of  load,  which  should  agree  with  the  curve  of 
load  determined  by  the  first  method — that  of  weights  superimposed  on  the 
horizontal  plate. 

Other  materials  than  sand  need  testing,  such  as  a  heavy  semi-fluid 
mud,  and  ballast.  In  each  case  the  angle  of  repose  would  be  noted  of  the 
unretained  material,  and  its  weight  per  cubic  foot. 

In  order  to  obtain  definite  conclusions  the  concrete  box  and  steel 
diaphragm  should  be  of  rather  large  size;  and  to  prevent  the  friction  of 
the  retained  material  on  the  sides  of  the  box  from  affecting  the  result  ma- 
terially, narrower  steel  plates  could  be  placed  on  each  side  of  the  main 
diaphragm,  observations  being  taken  on  the  main  plate  only. 

The  investigation  could  be  extended  to  determine  the  pressure  on 
abutments,  which  are  generally  filled  against  gradually  on  one  side  only, 
though  this  is  not  part  of  the  work  of  this  Committee.  It  seems  prob- 
able that  under  such  mode  of  filling,  the  total  pressure  would  be  greater, 
and  its  center  lower,  than  in  the  case  of  sheet  piling. 

(4)  Pile  Formulas — F.  E.  Bissell,   Chairman;  F.  H.  Bainbridge,  R. 

D.  Coombs  and  W.  F.  Steffens,  Sub-Committee : 

A  large  number  of  requests  for  information  were  sent  out,  but  the 
chief  matter  to  be  noted  from  the  replies  received  was  the  very  small 
number  of  roads  keeping  record  of  their  pile  driving  in  form  for  use  in 
this  investigation. 

It  seems  to  the  Committee  that  while  a  pile  driving  formula  should 
be  based  on  theoretical  considerations,  there  are  so  many  modifying  con- 
ditions to  be  allowed  for  that  the  result  is  a  formula  more  or  less  em- 
pirical in  its  final  make-up. 

These  modifying  conditions  can  best  be  noted  from  actual  experience 
in  pile  driving ;  and  members  are  urged,  for  the  advancement  of  the  art. 
to  keep  record  of  the  behavior  of  piles  during  driving  and  after  loading. 
Especially  is  this  record  valuable  in  the  case  of  test  piles  loaded  to  failure. 

(5)  Guard  Rails — H.  Ibsen,  Chairman:  Prof.  H.  S.  Jacoby,  I.  L. 
Simmons  and  H.  Rettinghouse,   Sub-Committee : 

A  large  amount  of  work  was  done  on  this  subject,  replies  having  been 
received  from  members  and  others  representing  a  mileage  of  119,314. 
These  replies  were  tabulated  and  considered,  but  recommendations  were 
not  reached  for  presentation  to  the  Association. 

It  seems  that  there  are  two  types  of  guard  rail  in  use ;  a  guard  rail 
being  a  member  as  defined  on  page  130  of  the  Manual,  Edition  of  191 1.  In 
one  type  the  two  rails  are  brought  together  at  their  ends  at  the  middle  of 
the  track ;  in  the  other,  two  similar  rails  are  not  brought  together  at  their 
ends,  but  remain  parallel  to  the  stock  rail,  and  a  third  rail,  also  straight, 
is  put  in  the  middle  of  the  track ;  all  three  rails  in  the  latter  case  being 
deflected  at  their  ends  below  base  of  rail. 

(6)  Fire  Protection — I.  L.  Simmons,  Chairman ;  F.  H.  Bainbridge,  F. 

E.  Bissell,  H.  Isben  and  J.  A.  Lahmer,  Sub-Committee: 

Replies  to  a  circular  letter  of  inquiry  were  received  from  members 
and  others  representing  110,214  miles  of  railway.     Of  this  mileage  62  per 


80  WOODEN    BRIDGES    AND    TRESTLES. 

cent,  when  using  fire  protection  adopted  either  full  ballast  decks,  floors 
protected  by  a  thin  covering  of  ballast  or  other  like  material,  or  by  sheet 
metal. 

NEXT  YEAR'S    WORK. 

The  Committee  recommends  that  the  same  subjects  be  assigned  it 
for  the  year  1912  as  were  assigned  for  the  year  191 1,  and  given  in  full  at 
the  beginning  of  this  report. 

Respectfully  submitted, 
COMMITTEE  ON  WOODEN  BRIDGES  AND  TRESTLES. 


REPORT   OF  COMMITTEE   XV— ON   IRON  AND   STEEL 
STRUCTURES. 

C.  H.  CartlidgE;  Chairman;  A.  J.  Himes,  y  ice-Chair  man; 

J.  A.  Bohland.  Albert  Reich mann. 

Charles  Chandler.  A.  F.  Robinson. 

C.  L.  Crandall.  C.  C.  Schneider. 

J.  E.  Crawford.  O.  E.  Selby. 

J.  E.   Greiner.  C.  E.   Smith. 

J.  M.  Johnson.  I.  F.  Stern. 

C.    N.   MONSARRAT.  F.    E.    TURNEAURE. 

W.  H.  Moore.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  held  two  meetings  during  the  year  191 1 — one  at 
Niagara  Falls  on  June  27  and  the  other  at  Chicago  on  October  24th. 

We  have  to  report  as  follows : 

Subject  No.  1 — Investigation  on  Impact  and  Secondary  Stresses : 
Appendix  B  contains  a  report  from  Prof.  F.  E.  Turneaure,  Chairman 
of  Sub-Committee  on  Impact,  giving  an  outline  of  the  work  done  by  the 
Committee  during  the  past  year. 

Subject  No.  2 — Influence  of  Theory,  Experiment  and  Experience  on 
Bridge  Design :  It  was  unanimously  decided  by  the  Committee  that  it  was 
unable  to  report  adequately  on  this  subject,  and  the  request  is  therefore 
made  that  the  subject  be  dropped. 

Subject  No.  3 — Rules  for  Instruction  and  Guidance  of  Inspectors  in 
Mills,  Shop  and  Field:  The  Committee  reports  progress.  The  Chairman  of 
the  Sub-Committee  has  received  discussion  from  two  of  the  members  of 
his  Sub-Committee,  and  will  probably  be  able  to  submit  a  paper  giving 
the  results  of  their  findings  during  the  next  few  months. 

Subject  No.  4 — Design  of  Built-up  Columns :  The  tender  of  the  serv- 
ices of  this  Committee  to  collaborate  with  the  Joint  Committee  of  the 
American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  was  made  and  very  promptly  ac- 
cepted. Sufficient  time  has  not  yet  elapsed  to  permit  the  organization 
of  any  actual  work  on  this  subject.  The  program  proposed  by  the 
A.  S.  C.  E.  Committee  is  very  elaborate  and  comprehensive  and 
when  carried  out  will  immensely  increase  our  knowledge  of  the  subject. 
In  order  that  this  Committee  do  any  practical  work  on  this  subject,  it 
will  be  necessary  to  have  funds.  Your  Committee  understands,  of  course, 
that  none  of  the  funds  of  the  Association  are  available  for  this  purpose. 
We  feel  warranted,  however,  in  recommending  that  individual  roads  be 
asked  to  contribute  for  the  purpose  of  making  these  tests.     This  work 

81 


82  IRON    AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

and  that  of  the  Impact  Committee  are  original  research  work  and  it  is 
hardly  necessary  for  us  to  point  out  the  ultimate  value  of  the  work  done 
in  the  manner  in  which  it  has  been  done.  It  will  probably  be  necessary 
in  the  near  future  to  take  cognizance  of  these  experiments  in  our  speci- 
fications for  design,  but  the  Committee  does  not  recommend  that  any 
change  be  made  at  present,  nor  until  further  experiments  on  secondary 
stresses  have  been  made,  and  if  possible,  considerable  work  on  columns. 
The  Committee  will  present  later  a  more  definite  report  of  the  probable 
amount  of  money  needed  for  the  first  year's  work.  It  is  expected  that  this 
will  be  very  small  and  that  it  can  easily  be  raised. 

Subject  No.  5 — (Specifications  for  Erection  of  Steel  Bridges:  In 
Appendix  A  the  Committee  presents  for  the  consideration  of  the  Asso- 
ciation a  set  of  specifications,  revised  in  accordance  with  the  discussion 
at  the  last  convention  and  with  the  written  discussions  from  members  and 
others  received  since  the  convention. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

The  recommendations  of  the  Committee  are  as  follows : 
(i)     That   the    specifications    for    Bridge    Erection   be   adopted   and 
printed  in  the  Manual. 

(2)  That  the  report  of  the  Impact  Committee  be  received  as  in- 
formation. 

(3)  That  no  change  be  made  at  present  in  the  specifications  printed 
in  the  Manual. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  IRON  AND   STEEL  STRUCTURES. 


Appendix  A. 

SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  THE  ERECTION  OF  RAILROAD 
BRIDGES. 
Work  to  Be  Done. 

i.  The  Contractor  shall  erect,  rivet  and  adjust  all  metal  work  in 
place  complete,  and  perform  all  other  work  hereinafter  specified. 

Plant. 

2.  The  Contractor  shall  provide  all  tools,  machinery  and  appliances 
necessary  for  the  expeditious  handling  of  the  work,  including  drift  pins 
and  fitting  up  bolts. 

Falsework. 

3.  The  method  of  erection  and  plans  for  falsework  and  erection 
equipment  shall  be  subject  to  approval  by  the  Engineer,  but  such 
approval  shall  not  relieve  the  Contractor  from  any  responsibility.  False- 
work will  be  built  by  * Falsework  material  of 

every  character  will  be  provided  by  the  * 

The  temporary  structure  for  use  during  erection  and  for  maintaining 
the  traffic  shall  be  properly  designed  and  substantially  constructed  for 
the  loads  which  will  come  upon  it.  All  bents  shall  be  thoroughly  secured 
against  movement,  both  transversely  and  longitudinally.  The  bents  shall 
be  well  secured  against  settling,  and  piles  used  wherever  firm  bottom 
cannot  be  obtained.  Upon  completion  of  the  erection,  the  temporary 
structure,  if  the  property  of  the  Railway  Company,  shall  be  removed 
without  unnecessary  damage,  and  neatly  piled  near  the  site  or  loaded  on 
cars,  as  may  be  directed.  If  the  property  of  the  Contractor,  it  shall  be  re- 
moved in  a  manner  subject  to  the  approval  of  the  Engineer. 

Falsework  placed  by  the  Railway  Company  under  an  old  structure  or 
for  carrying  traffic,  may  be  used  as  far  as  practicable  by  the  Contractor 
during  erection,  but  it  shall  not  be  unnecessarily  cut  or  wasted. 

Conduct  of  Work. 

4.  The  work  shall  be  prosecuted  with  sufficient  force,  plant  and  equip- 
ment to  expedite  its  completion  to  the  utmost  extent  and  in  such  a  man- 
ner as  to  be  at  all  times  subordinate  to  the  use  of  the  tracks  by  the 
Railway  Company,  and  so  as  not  to  interfere  with  the  work  of  other 
contractors  or  to  close  or  obstruct  any  thoroughfare  by  land  or  water, 
except  under  proper  authority. 

Reasonable  reduction  of  speed  will  be  allowed  upon  request  of  the 
Contractor. 


*Insert  "Railway   Company"   or    "Contractor,"   as   the   case   may   be. 

83 


84  IRON    AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

Tracks  shall  not  be  cut  nor  shall  trains  be  subjected  to  any  stoppage 
except  when  specifically  authorized  by  the  Engineer. 

The  Contractor  shall  protect  traffic  and  his  work  by  flagman  furnished 
by  and  at  the  expense  of  the  Railway  Company.  The  Contractor  shall 
provide  competent  watchmen  to  guard  the  work  and  material  against 
injury. 

Engine  Service. 

5.  If  under  the  contract,  work  train  or  engine  service  is  furnished 
the  Contractor  free  of  charge,  such  service  shall  consist  only  in  unloading 
materials  and  in  transferring  the  same  from  a  convenient  siding  to  the 
bridge  site.     Other  engine  service  shall  be  paid  for  by  the  Contractor  at 

the  rate  of  $ per  day  per  engine,  the  time  to  include  the 

time  necessary  for  the  engine  to  come  from  and  return  to  its  terminal. 
When  engine  service  is  desired  the  Contractor  shall  give  the  proper  railway 
officials  at  least  24  hours'  advance  notice  and  the  Railway  Company  will 
furnish  the  service  as  promptly  as  possible,  consistent  with  railroad 
operations. 

When  derrick  cars  are  used  on  main  tracks,  their  movements  shall 
be  in  charge  of  a  train  crew,  and  the  expense  of  the  crew  and  any  engine 
service  other  than  as  noted  above  shall  be  charged  to  the  Contractor. 

Transportation. 

6.  When  transportation  of  equipment,  materials  and  men  is  fur- 
nished free  over  the  Railway  Company's  line,  it  shall  be  subject  to  such 
conditions  as  may  be  stated  in  the  contract. 

Masonry. 

7.  The  Railway  Company  will  furnish  all  masonry  to  correct  lines 
and  elevations,  and  unless  otherwise  stated  in  the  contract,  will  make 
all  changes  in  old  masonry  without  unnecessarily  impeding  the  operations 
of  the  Contractor.  The  Railway  Company's  engineers  will  establish  lines 
and  elevations  and  assume  responsibility  therefor,  but  the  Contractor  shall 
compare  the  elevations,  distances,  etc.,  shown  on  plans,  with  the  masonry 
as  actually  constructed  as  far  as  practicable,  before  he  assembles  the  steel. 
In  case  of  discrepancy,  he  shall  immediately  notify  the  Engineer. 

Handling  and  Storing  Materials. 

8.  Cars  containing  materials  or  plant  shall  be  promptly  unloaded 
upon  delivery  therefor,  and  in  case  of  failure  to  do  so  the  Contractor 
shall  be  liable  for  demurrage  charges.  Material  shall  be  placed  on  skids 
above  the  ground,  laid  so  as  not  to  hold  water,  and  stored  and  handled  in 
such  a  manner  as  not  to  be  injured  or  to  interfere  with  railroad  operations. 
The  expense  of  repairing  or  replacing  material  damaged  by  rough  handling 
shall  be  charged  to  the  Contractor.  The  Contractor,  while  unloading  and 
storing  material,  shall  compare  each  piece  with  the  shipping  list  and 
promptly  report  any  shortage  or  injury  discovered. 


IRON    AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES.  85 

Maintenance  of  Traffic. 

9.  When  traffic  is  to  be  maintained  it  will  be  carried  on  in  such  a 
manner  as  to  interfere  as  little  as  practicable  with  the  work  of  the 
Contractor. 

Changes  in  the  supporting  structure  or  tracks  required  during  erection 
shall  be  at  all  times  under  the  direct  control  and  supervision  of  the  Rail- 
way Company. 
Removal  of  Old  Structure. 

10.  Unless  otherwise  specified,  metal  work  in  the  old  structure  shall 
be  dismantled  without  unnecessary  damage  and  loaded  on  cars  or  neatly 
piled  at  a  site  immediately  adjacent  to  the  tracks,  and  at  a  convenient 
grade  for  future  handling,  as  may  be  directed.  When  the  structure  is 
to  be  used  elsewhere  all  parts  will  be  matchmarked  by  the  Railway  Com- 
pany; when  the  old  bridge  is  composed  of  several  spans  the  parts  of  each 
shall  be  kept  separate. 

Metal  Work. 

11.  Material  shall  be  handled  without  damage.  Threads  of  all 
pins  shall  be  protected  by  pilot  and  driving  nuts  while  being  driven  in 
place. 

Light  drifting  will  be  permitted  in  order  to  draw  the  parts  together, 
but  drifting  for  the  purpose  of  matching  unfair  holes  will  not  be  per- 
mitted.   Unfair  holes  shall  be  reamed  or  drilled. 

Nuts  on  pins  and  on  bolts  remaining  in  the  structure  shall  be  effectively 
locked  by  checking  the  threads. 

All  splices  and  field  connections  shall  be  securely  bolted  prior  to 
riveting.  When  the  parts  are  required  to  carry  traffic,  important  connec- 
tions, such  as  attachments  of  stringers  and  floor  beams,  shall  have  at  least 
fifty  (50)  per  cent,  of  the  holes  filled  with  bolts  and  twenty-five  (25)  per 
cent,  with  drift  pins.  All  tension  splices  shall  be  riveted  up  complete 
before  blocking  is  removed.  When  not  carrying  traffic,  at  least  thirty-three 
and  one-third  (33}<3)  per  cent,  of  the  holes  shall  have  bolts. 

Rivets  in  splices  of  compression  members  shall  not  be  driven  until  the 
members  shall  have  been  subjected  to  full  dead  load  stresses.  Rivets 
shall  be  driven  tight.  No  recupping  or  calking  will  be  permitted.  The 
heads  shall  be  full  and  uniform  in  size  and  free  from  fins,  concentric  and 
in  full  contact  with  the  metal.  Heads  shall  be  painted  immediately  after 
acceptance. 

Rivets  shall  be  uniformly  and  thoroughly  heated  and  no  burnt  rivetj 
shall  be  driven.     All  defective  rivets  shall  be  promptly  cut  out  and  re- 
driven.     In  removing  rivets  the  surrounding  metal  shall  not  be  injured ; 
if  necessary,  the  rivets  shall  be  drilled  out. 
Misfits. 

12.  Correction  of  minor  misfits  and  a  reasonable  amount  of  reaming 
shall  be  considered  as  a  legitimate  part  of  the  erection. 

Any  error  in  shop  work  which  prevents  the  proper  assembling  and 
fitting  up  of  parts  by  the  moderate  use  of  drift  pins,  and  a  moderate  amount 


86  IRON    AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

of  reaming  and  slight  chipping  or  cutting,  shall  be  immediately  reported 
to  the  Engineer  and  the  work  of  correction  done  in  the  presence  of  the 
Engineer,  who  shall  check  the  time  expended. 

The  Contractor  shall  render  an  itemized  bill  for  such  work  of  correc- 
tion for  the  approval  of  the  Engineer. 

Anchor  Bolts. 

13.  Holes  for  all  anchor  bolts,  except  where  bolts  are  built  up  with 
the  masonry,  shall  be  drilled  by  the  Contractor  after  the  metal  is  in  place 
and  the  bolts  shall  be  set  in  Portland  cement  grout. 

Bed  Plates. 

14.  Bed  plates  resting  on  masonry  shall  be  set  level  and  have  a 
full  even  bearing  over  their  entire  surface ;  this  shall  be  attained  by  either 
the  use  of  Portland  cement  grout  or  mortar,  or  by  tightly  ramming  in 
rust  cement  under  the  bed  plates  after  blocking  them  accurately  in  position. 
Decks. 

15.  The  * will  frame  and  place  the  per- 
manent timber  deck. 

Painting. 

16.  The  paint  will  be  furnished  by  * and 

shall  be  of  such  color,  quality  and  manufacture  as  may  be  specified. 

Surfaces  inaccessible  after  erection,  such  as  bottoms  of  base  plates, 
tops  of  stringers,  etc.,  shall  receive  two  coats  of  paint  before  assembling 
in  place.  After  erection,  the  entire  structure  shall  receive  two  coats  of 
paint,  allowing  enough  time  between  coats  for  the  first  coat  to  dry 
before  applying  the  second.  No  paint  shall  be  applied  in  wet  or  freezing 
weather,  nor  when  the  surface  of  the  metal  is  damp.  Painting  shall  be 
done  in  good  and  workmanlike  manner,  subject  to  strict  inspection  during 
progress  and  after  completion,  and  in  accordance  with  special  instructions 
which  shall  be  given  by  the  Engineer.  All  metal  shall  be  thoroughly 
cieaned  of  dirt,  rust,  loose  scale,  etc.,  before  the  paint  is  applied. 
Clearing  the  Site. 

17.  The  Contractor,  after  completion  of  the  work  of  erection,  shall 
remove  all  old  material  and  debris  resulting  from  his  operations  and  place 
the  premises  in  a  neat  condition. 

Superintendence  and  Workmen. 

18.  During  the  entire  progress  of  the  work  the  Contractor  shall  have 
a  competent  superintendent  in  personal  charge  and  shall  employ  only 
skilled  and  competent  workmen.  Instructions  given  by  the  Engineer  to 
the  superintendent  shall  be  carried  out  the  same  as  if  given  to  the  Con- 
tractor. If  any  of  the  Contractor's  employes  by  unseemly  or  boisterous 
conduct,  or  by  incompetency  or  dishonesty,  show  unfitness  for  employment 
on  the  work,  they  shall,  upon  instructions  from  the  Engineer,  be  discharged 


♦Insert  "Railway   Company"   or    "Contractor,"   as   the   case   may   be. 


IRON    AND    STEEL    STRUCTURES.  87 

from  the  work,  nor  thereafter  be  employed  upon  it  without  the  Engineer's 
consent. 

Inspection. 

19.  The  work  of  erection  shall  at  all  times  be  subject  to  the  inspec- 
tion and  acceptance  of  the  Engineer. 

Responsibility. 

20.  The  Contractor  shall  assume  all  responsibility  for  loss  or  damage 
to  his  own  work,  materials  or  plant,  due  to  any  cause;  also,  for  all  loss 
or  damage  to  the  Railway  Company's  materials  or  property,  and  to  other 
property  adjacent  to  the  railroad,  due  to  causes  within  his  reasonable 
control. 

The  Contractor  shall  assume  all  responsibility  for  injury  to  the  work- 
men and  the  public,  or  to  any  individual ;  and  in  case  of  accident  or  suit 
he  shall  defend  the  suit  in  person  and  relieve  the  Railway  Company 
from  all  costs  and  expenses,  and  pay  any  judgments  that  may  be  recovered 
thereon. 

The  Contractor  shall  comply  with  the  laws  and  ordinances  affecting 
the  manner  of  doing  work;  shall  take  out  all  necessary  permits  and  com- 
ply with  their  requirements,  and  shall  take  such  precaution  as  may  be 
necessary  to  protect  life  and  property. 

Insurance  and  Bond. 

21.  The  Contractor  shall  carry  such  liability  insurance  as  is  necessary 
to  protect  himself  and  the  Railway  Company  against  loss  or  damage  caused 
by  injuries  to  his  men,  and  shall  furnish  the  Railway  Company  a  bond  in 
form  and  of  a  surety  acceptable  to  the  Railway  Company,  providing  for 
the  faithful  performance  of  the  work  and  all  matters  pertaining  thereto, 
in  such  sum  as  shall  be  specified  in  the  contract. 

Engineer. 

22.  The  term  "Engineer,"  as  used  herein,  shall  be  understood  to  mean 
the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Railway  Company,  or  his  accredited  repre- 
sentative. 


Clauses   20  and   21   to  be   eliminated;   Clause   22   to  be   renumbered.      See 
Index. 


Appendix  B. 
SECONDARY   STRESSES. 

We  herewith  submit  a  brief  report  of  progress  relative  to  tests  of 
secondary  stresses,  which  were  carried  out  during  the  past  summer  by 
your  Sub-Committee  on  Impact  and  Secondary  Stresses. 

Through  the  assistance  of  the  mechanician's  shop  at  the  University 
of  Wisconsin,  we  were  able  to  develop  and  manufacture  a  special  form 
of  extensometer  for  use  in  measuring  secondary  stresses.  An  important 
requirement  of  such  an  instrument  is  freedom  from  friction  of  all  moving 
parts  and,  in  general,  a  high  degree  of  sensitiveness,  combined  with  sta- 
bility and  strength  of  framework,  convenience  of  adjustment  and  ma- 
nipulation. An  instrument  was  developed  along  the  line  of  the  ex- 
tensometers  used  for  impact  tests,  but  to  secure  sensitiveness  the  principal 
bearings  were  made  of  knife  edges,  and  instead  of  using  a  pencil  for  se- 
curing a  continuous  record,  a  ray  of  light  is  allowed  to  pass  through  a 
minute  perforation  in  a  disc  at  the  end  of  the  long  lever,  and  a  path  of 
this  ray  of  light  is  photographed  on  a  moving  slip  of  sensitized  paper. 

The  apparatus  proved  satisfactory  in  practical  operation,  and  the 
method  of  obtaining  the  record  was  found  to  be  very  good  indeed.  The 
sensitized  paper  was  developed  in  the  field  so  that  results  could  quickly 
he  obtained. 

Four  of  these  extensometers  were  made  by  the  University  of  Wiscon- 
sin and  were  used  by  the  Committee  on  its  tests. 

About  three  weeks  were  spent  in  the  field  and  tests  were  made  on  the 
following  bridges  : 

On  the  Chicago,  Milwaukee  &  St.  Paul  Railway,  a  160-ft.  riveted 
span  and  a  176-ft.  pin-connected  span  at  Byron,  111.,  a  104-ft.  pony  truss 
span  at  Rockton,  111.,  in  which  eye-bars  were  used  for  the  diagonal  mem- 
bers, and  a  span  of  the  same  length  at  Brodhead,  Wis.,  in  whicfh  all 
members  were  riveted. 

On  the  Chicago  &  North- Western  Railway,  a  182-ft.  riveted  truss, 
a  75-ft.  deck-plate  girder,  and  a  through  riveted  lattice  truss,  all  on  the 
new  Belt  Line  at  Milwaukee. 

At  the  present  time  preliminary  results  only  are  available,  which  are 
not  in  form  for  publication.  It  is  expected  that  before  the  meeting  in 
March  it  will  be  possible  to  present  all  important  results,  together  with 
comparative  results  determined  from  a  theoretical  analysis. 

In  all  of  these  tests  the  Railroad  Company  furnished  a  special  train, 
and  such  other  facilities  in  the  way  of  mechanics  as  were  needed ;  and 
your  Sub-Committee  desires  here  to  express  its  great  appreciation  for  the 
assistance  thereby  rendered. 

The  field  work  was  carried  out  by  Professors  C.  L.  Crandall  and  F. 
E.  Turneaure,  members  of  the  Sub-Committee,  assisted  by  Messrs.  W.  L. 
Conwell  and  W.  A.  Axtell,  of  Cornell  University,  and  Messrs.  W.  S. 
Kinne,  0.  L.  Kowalke  and  J.  B.  Kommers,  of  the  University  of  Wisconsin. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

C.    L.    CRANDALL, 
F.    E.    TURNEAURE, 
Sub-Committee  on  Impact. 
88 


REPORT    OF    COMMITTEE   XIV— ON   YARDS   AND 
TERMINALS. 

C.  H.    Spencer,   Chairman;  E.  B.  Temple,   V ice-Chairman; 
Hadley  Baldwin.  L.  J.   McIntyre. 

W.  C.  Barrett.  B.  H.  Mann. 

M.  S.  Blaiklock.  A.  Montzheimer. 

G.  H.  Burgess.  W.  L.  Seddon. 

A.  E.  Clift.  A.   Swartz. 

A.  L.  Davis.  J.  E.  Taussig. 

H.  T.  Douglas,  Jr.  E.  E.  R.  Tratman. 

A.  C.  Everham.  W.  L.  Webb. 

D.  B.  Johnston.  J.  G.  Wishart. 

H.  A.  Lane.  Committee. 

To   the  Members   of   the  American   Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Yards  and  Terminals  submits  herewith  its 
Twelfth  Annual  Report. 

The  Board  of  Direction  has  assigned  the  following  subjects  to  your 
Committee : 

(i)  Report  on  typical  situation  plans  of  passenger  stations,  of  both 
through  and  stub  types,  with  critical  analyses  of  working  capacity,  and 
include  a   review  of  the   different  methods   of  estimating  their  capacity. 

(2)  Report  on  developments  in  the  handling  of  freight  by  mechanical 
means. 

(3)  Report  on  developments  in  the  design  and  operation  of  hump 
yards. 

(4)  Report  on  typical'  situation  plans  for  a  division  engine  terminal. 

(5)  Report  on  methods  of  handling  baggage,  express  and  mail,  at 
passenger  terminals. 

The  Committee  was  also  instructed  to  consider  revision  of  Manual ; 
if  no  changes  were  recommended,  to  make  statement  accordingly,  and 
to  make  concise  recommendations   for   next  year's   work. 

The  Committee  held  two  meetings  during  the  year,  in  addition  to 
the    meetings    of   the   various    Sub-Committees,    as    follows : 

St.  Louis,  Mo.,  June  26  and  27;  Washington,  D.  C,  October  6 
and  7. 

A  large  amount  of  work  has  been  done  by  all  of  the  Sub-Committees 
on  topics  assigned  to  them. 

REVISION    OF    MANUAL. 

After  careful  consideration  of  the  present  Manual,  the  Committee 
has  no  recommendation  for  further  changes  at  the  present  time. 

89 


90  YARDS    AND    TERMINALS. 

(i)     TYPICAL  SITUATION  PLANS  OF  PASSENGER  STATIONS. 

The  Sub-Committee  has  accumulated  a  large  amount  of  data  with 
respect  to  existing  terminals.  The  subject  assigned,  however,  is  so  broad 
and  important  that  it  is  desirable  to  continue  work  on  it  through  another 
year.  In  view,  therefore,  of  the  expressed  desire  of  the  Board  of  Direc- 
tion that  the  reports  be  limited  as  far  as  possible,  it  was  decided  to  reserve 
report  on  this  subject  until  next  year. 

(2)     HANDLING   OF   FREIGHT   BY   MECHANICAL  MEANS. 

Considerable  progress  has  been  made  at  different  points  in  the  de- 
velopment of  freight  handling  by  mechanical  means  since  the  Committee's 
last  report,  and  during  the  past  year  inspection  was  made  of  the  new 
Missouri,  Kansas  &  Texas  Railway  freight  handling  plant  at  Broadway 
Station,  St.  Louis,  Mo.,  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad  telpher  system  at 
Pier  No.  8,  Locust  Point,  Baltimore,  Md.,  the  power  conveyor  system 
in  one  of  the  new  warehouses  of  the  Texas  City  Transportation  Com- 
pany, at  Galveston,  Texas,  and  of  the  electric  truck  system  at  Dock 
No.  6,  Jersey  City,  N.  J.  As  nearly  all  of  these  systems  are  practically 
new  and  sufficient  time  has  not  elapsed  since  installation  to  enable  all 
points  as  to  their  utility  to  be  definitely  determined,  both  as  to  economy 
of  operation  and  practical  utility,  full  report  on  these  systems  is  held 
over  for  future  publication. 

The  attention  of  the  Association  is  called  to  certain  published 
articles  noted  below  in  relation  to  this  subject: 

1.  Freight  House  at  St.  Louis,  with  Mechanical  Freight-Handling 
Equipment ;  Engineering  News,  June  29 ;  Railway  Age  Gazette,  June  23 ; 
Railway  and  Engineering  Review,  November  11. 

2.  Electric  Truck  System  at  Dock  No.  6,  Jersey  City,  N.  J.;  Rail- 
way and  Engineering  Review,  July  29. 

3.  Mechanical  Handling  of  Freight  (by  S.  B.  Fowler)  ;  Proceedings 
of  the  American  Society  of  Mechanical  Engineers;  Railway  and  Engi- 
neering Review,  February  11. 

4.  Motor  Trucks  for  Freight  Transportation ;  Engineering  News, 
June  22. 

5.  Freight  Handling  Installations  at  River  Ports ;  Engineering  News, 
May  4. 

6.  Mechanical  Handling  of  Package  Freight;  Engineering  News, 
May  11. 

7.  A  Freight  Station  for  the  Use  of  Storage  Battery  Trucks ;  En- 
gineering Record,  January  28. 

8.  Electric  Trucks  for  Handling  Freight  and  Baggage ;  Engineer- 
ing News,  May  11,  June  22,  December  7. 

9.  Telfer  System  for  Handling  Baggage  at  an  English  Passenger 
Terminal  Station;  Engineering  News,  August  17. 

10.  Terminals,  Yards  and  Mechanical  Handling  of  Baggpge  at  Sta- 
tions; Bulletin  of  the  International  Railway  Congress,  November,  191 1. 


YARDS    AND    TERMINALS.  91 

ii.  Cargo  Transference  at  Steamship  Terminals  (H.  McL.  Hard- 
ing) ;  Proceedings  of  the  Society  of  Naval  Architects  and  Marine  Engi- 
neers, 191 1. 

12.  Terminals  and  Freight  Piers  at  Boston;  Engineering  News, 
November  2,  191 1. 

13.  Freight  Piers  and  Freight  Handling  Machinery  at  Boston,  Engi- 
neering News,  November  9,  1911. 

(3)     DESIGN    AND   OPERATION   OF  HUMP   YARDS. 

Additional  data  on  existing  hump  yards  has  been  secured  by  Sub- 
Committee,  and  is  held  for  future  report. 

(4)     TYPICAL    SITUATION    PLANS    FOR    DIVISION    ENGINE 

TERMINAL. 

In  treating  this  subject,  the  Committee  understands  its  work  to  be 
the  making  of  recommendations  as  to  the  best  arrangement  of  facilities 
for  the  handling  of  locomotives  at  terminals  rather  than  as  to  specifica- 
tions for  exact  designs  of  the  various  structures  involved,  excepting 
as  in  a  general  way  the  characteristics  of  such  structures  seem  to  be 
more  or  less  suited  to  the  arrangement  recommended. 

It  is  also  understood  that  the  scope  of  the  Committee's  work  does 
not  include  the  consideration  of  shop  or  repair  yard  locations. 

We  submit  herewith  a  typical  plan  or  layout  for  an  engine  terminal 
whose  characteristics  permit  of  application  equally  well  to  larger  or 
smaller  demands  practically  without  limit  and  without  respect  to  whether 
the  locomotives  cared  for  are  all  freight  or  passenger,  or  in  both  kinds 
of  service. 

We  have  examined  a  number  of  plans  of  recently  constructed  engine 
terminals,  and  think  we  have  adopted  in  our  plan  the  best  ideas  of 
all,  and  that  we  have  avoided  the  manifest  errors  of  some  at  least  of 
these  plans.  It  must,  of  course,  be  recognized  that  in  any  case  of  actual 
construction,  physical  limitations  as  to  space  and  shape  of  the  ground 
site  will  impose  more  or  less  modification  of  the  plan  we  recommend,  but 
we  think  it  will  come  more  generally  within  the  possibility  of  any  given 
set  of  conditions  than  any  other  typical  plan  that  could  be  suggested. 

In  locating  an  engine  terminal,  the  facilities  should  be  placed  with 
reference  to  the  yards  and  main  line  in  the  most  advantageous  position 
possible,  that  is,  so  that  the  distance  between  the  engine  terminal  and 
the  points  where  engines  begin  and  end  their  service  shall  be  a  minimum, 
and  so  that  reverse  or  conflicting  movements  shall  be  avoided  as  much 
as  practicable. 

The  idea  to  be  kept  in  mind  is  the  most  direct  and  convenient,  that 
is,  rapid  and  economical  performance  of  those  things  required  for  an 
engine  in  its  terminal  in  that  sequence  which  answers  all  requirements 
in  the  order  of  their  urgency.  It  appears  to  us  that  on  the  arrival  of 
a  locomotive  at  its  terminal,  the  first  imperative  demand  is  likely  to  be 


92  YARDS    AND    TERMINALS. 

for  water,  and  that  this  demand  is  likely  to  be  the  last  when  leaving 
the  terminal  for  service,  and  for  this  reason  our  typical  plan  provides 
for  the  location  of  watering  facilities  accordingly. 

After  an  incoming  engine  has  been  protected  by  receiving  water, 
the  next  step  appears  logically  to  clean  its  fires  or  remove  it  entirety, 
according  to  need,  and  place  the  engine  as  quickly  as  possible  in  the 
engine  house  where  the  repairs  necessary  to  prepare  it  for  new  service 
may  be  made,  engine  cleaned,  etc.  The  cinder  pit  should  be  located  as 
close  as  practicable  to  the  engine  house  and  permit  at  the  same  time  of  en- 
gines moving  off  cinder  pit  in  normal  direction,  being  switched  direct  to  an 
outbound  track  without  using  or  fouling  turntable,  as  may  often  be 
desired. 

It  appears  logical  that  the  process  of  coaling  should  be  reserved, 
if  practicable,  until  just  before  the  engine  re-enters  service  in  order  that 
it  may  do  so  with  a  maximum  supply  of  fuel,  and  also  because  the 
cleaning  or  removal  of  fire  on  cinder  pit,  as  well  as  repairs  of  engine 
tank  or  other  repairs,  can  be  accomplished  without  that  interference 
that  might  result  from  having  tender  filled  with  coal,  and  this  reasoning 
dictates  that  the  location  of  the  coaling  station  should  be  primarily  to 
serve  the  outbound  tracks.  Inasmuch,  however,  as  it  may  often  occur 
that  incoming  engines  will  require  coal,  the  coaling  station  should  be 
located  as  indicated  on  our  typical  plan,  so  that  coal  may  also  be  taken 
by  an  engine  on  an  inbound  track. 

The  trestle  type  of  coal  dock  may  be  used  if  desired,  if  only  two 
coaling  tracks  are  required,  and  can  be  located  between  the  inbound 
and  outbound  tracks  in  same  relative  position  as  shown  in  typical 
plan. 

The  most  convenient  and  economical  arrangement  for  storing  and 
drying  sand  is  at  the  coal  station,  where  it  may  be  handled  by  the  same 
attendants.  Sand  should  ordinarily  be  delivered  to  engines  passing  on  the 
inbound  tracks. 

It  will  be  observed  that  the  arrangement  of  facilities  permits  of 
large  increase  in  capacity  of  cinder  pit,  coaling  station,  etc.,-  and  in  this 
connection  the  idea  of  having  the  coaling  station  at  a  busy  terminal 
comprising  two  independent  units  makes  a  strong  appeal  for  approval 
in  view  of  the  possibility  of  one  of  the  hoisting  plants  suffering  tem- 
porary disability  from  breakdown,  or  other  cause. 

The  location  of  storehouse,  oil  house,  enginemen's  tool  and  locker 
rooms  need  not  be  arbitrarily  prescribed,  but  should  be  as  close  as  prac- 
ticable to  the  engine  house  and  the  cinder  pit.  However,  where  any  of 
these  buildings  are  served  by  their  own  tracks,  those  tracks  should  be 
so  located  and  connected  as  not  to  interfere  with  the  uninterrupted  free 
use  of  the  engine  tracks. 

A  system  of  ample  lighting  facilities  is  important,  with  lights  dis- 
tributed so  as  to  avoid,  as  far  as  practicable,  darkness  or  shadow  where 
men  are  engaged  in  work  upon  engines. 


TYPICAL   PLAN   OF   RNGINE  TERMINAL. 


93 


sy 

se 

le 
er 


TrfitC  *L   &L  **/V  QT  fA/GtMC  7f 

Ptoooosco  mv  Sum  Co*****  Tree  A/o£ 


YARDS    AND    TERMINALS.  93 

CONCLUSIONS. 

(i)  The  engine  terminal  should  be  so  located  as  to  afford  easy 
access  to  both  Main  Line  and  Yards,  with  the  fewest  possible  reverse 
or  conflicting  movements. 

(2)  The  facilities  provided  should  be  arranged  to  permit  of  the 
most  direct  and  rapid  handling  of  an  engine  in  its  terminal  in  the  order 
of  its  needs. 

The  Committee  recommends  for  next  year's  work  a  continuation 
of  Subjects  Nos.   1,  2  and  3,  enumerated  above. 

Respectfully  submitted, 
COMMITTEE  ON  YARDS  AND  TERMINALS. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  II -ON  BALLAST. 


H.  E.  Hale,  Chairman; 
W.  J.  Bergen. 
A.  F.  Blaess. 
T.  C.  Burpee. 

F.  T.  Darrow. 
J.  M.  Egan. 

T.  W.  Fatherson. 
H.  L.  Gordon. 

G.  H.  Harris. 


J.  M.  Meade,  Vice-Chair  man; 

C.  C.  Hill. 

S.  A.  Jordan. 

A.  S.  More. 

J.  V.  Neubert. 

S.  B.  Rice. 

E.  V.  Smith. 

F.  J.  Stimson. 
S.  N.  Williams. 

Committee. 


To  the  Members  of  the  American  Raihvay  Engineering  Association: 

Two  meetings  of  the  Committee  were  held  in  Chicago,  one  on  July 
27,  and  one  on  November  13,  191 1. 

Five  meetings  of  Sub-Committees  were  held  during  the  year,  as  fol- 
lows:  June  26,  at  Washington,  D.  C. ;  June  30,  at  St.  Louis;  July  27,  at 
Chicago ;  October  7,  at  Chicago ;  November  1,  at  Washington,  D.  C. 

REPORT  ON  THE  PROPER  DEPTH  OF  BALLAST  TO  INSURE 

UNIFORM  DISTRIBUTION  OF  THE  LOADS  ON 

THE   ROADBED. 

REVIEW   OF   PREVIOUS   REPORT. 

The  report  of  the  Committee  on  the  proper  depth  of  ballast  submitted 
during  the  year  1910  was  in  the  form  of  a  progress  report,  accompanied 
by  a  table  showing  the  approved  depth  of  ballast  on  various  railroads, 
as  printed  in  the  Proceedings,  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  345,  but  on  account 
of  lack  of  sufficient  information  on  which  to  base  definite  recommenda- 
tions, no  action  was  taken  on  this  subject  by  the  Association. 


DEFINITIONS. 

Depth  of  Ballast. — The  distance  from  the  bottom  of  the  tie  to  the 
top  of  the  subgrade.  (For  definition  of  "subgrade,"  see  Manual,  191 1, 
page  16.) 

historical. 

Various  experiments  and  investigations  have  been  made  to  deter- 
mine the  proper  depth  of  ballast,  and  a  list  of  some  of  the  most  im- 
portant ones  follows : 

(A)     Experiments  by  Railroad  Director  Schubert,  in  Germany,  given 

95 


96  BALLAST. 

in  Proceedings,  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way 
Association,  Vol.  7  (1906),  page  102. 

(B)  Report  on  the  "Question  of  Strengthening  the  Track  and 
Bridges,  with  a  View  to  Increasing  the  Speed  of  Trains,"  made  to  the 
International  Railway  Congress  by  the  Reporter  for  America,  Mr.  M.  L. 
Byers,  and  later  published  in  the  Engineering  News,  of  February  3,  191a 

(C)  An  article  entitled  "Gravel  as  Ballast,"  by  Mr.  C.  Brauning, 
translated  from  "Zeitschrift  fur  Bauwesen,"  Vol.  LIV,  Berlin,  1904,  being 
Appendix  "C"  (Bulletin  136,  pp.  157-179). 

(D)  An  article  on  "Ballast,"  by  Mr.  George  W.  Vaughan,  Engineer 
Maintenance  of  Way,  New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River  Railroad, 
printed  in  this  report  at  Appendix  "D"   (Bulletin  136,  pp.  180-190). 

(E)  Report  of  Pennsylvania  Railroad  General  Manager's  Committee 
appointed  "To  Determine  by  Experiment  the  Necessary  Depth  of  Stone 
Ballast,"    dated    March   5,    191 1,   being  Appendix   "B"    (Bulletin    136,   pp. 

3-155)- 

(F)  "A  Study  of  the  Stresses  Existing  in  Track  Superstructure  and 
Rational  Design  Based  Thereon,"  by  Mr.  O.  E.  Selby,  Bridge  Engineer, 
Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis  Railway,  published  in  Pro- 
ceedings, American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Asso- 
ciation, Vol.  8,  1907,  pp.  52-59. 

ANALYTICAL. 

Your  Committee  feels  that  very  valuable  information  was  given  to 
the  Association  in  the  report  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  Committee 
on  the  necessary  depth  of  stone  ballast,  published  in  Bulletin  136,  through 
the  kindness  of  Mr.  W.  C.  Cushing,  President  of  the  American  Railway 
Engineering  Association,  and  Mr.  L.  R.  Zollinger,  Chairman  of  the  Com- 
mittee, appointed  by  the  General  Manager  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad. 

The  details  of  the  test,  which  are  very  complete,  are  given  in  Ap- 
pendix "D"  of  this  report,  and  the  conclusions,  in  so  far  as  the  proper 
depth  of  ballast  which  will  insure  uniform  pressure  on  the  subgrade,  are 
as  follows : 

The  tests  made  by  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  at  Altoona  indicate  that 
with  approximately  320,000  to  440,000-lb.  axle  loads,  or  75,000  lbs.  each,  pass- 
ing over  test  ties  on  the  test  ballast,  at  five  miles  per  hour,  the  subgrade 
practically  reached  a  permanent  settlement,  and  that  where  the  ballast  was 
materially  less  than  24  in.,  the  settlement  of  the  subgrade  (loam)  und«? 
the  ballast  was  not  uniform,  but  showed  a  greater  settlement  under  tbk. 
ties  than  between  the  ties. 

These  experiments  further  indicated  that  when  stone  ballast  was 
placed  24  in.  deep  under  the  ties,  the  settlement  of  the  subgrade  (loam) 
under  the  ballast  was  practically  uniform,  and  therefore  the  pressure  must 
have  been  approximately  uniform. 

It  was  also  found  that  a  combination  of  stone  and  cinder  ballast  24 
in.  deep  under  the  ties  (lower  layer  of  cinders  18  in.  to  14  in.  deep,  upper 
layer  of  stone  6  in.  to  10  in.  deep)  gave  nearly  as  gooil  results,  although 


BALLAST.  97 

the  deformation  of  the  subgrade  was  greater  than  with  24  in.  of  stone 
ballast. 

The  result  of  this  series  of  tests,  which  indicated  that  approximately 
24  in.  of  stone  ballast  is  required  to  produce  a  uniform  pressure  on  the 
subgrade,  with  the  ties  spaced  24  in.  to  25.5  in.,  center  to  center,  agrees 
very  closely  with  the  formula  given  by  Mr.  Thos.  H.  Johnson,  in  the 
Proceedings  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of 
Way  Association,  Vol.  7  (1006),  which  was  derived  from  the  experiments 
of  Director  Schubert,  namely,  that  with  ties  spaced  23  in.  apart,  center 
to  center,  stone  ballast  should  be  22  2-3  in.  deep  to  produce  uniform 
pressure  on  the  subgrade. 

CONCLUSION. 

With  the  data  available,  your  Committee  finds  that  with  the  ties 
(7  in.  by  9  in.  by  SZA  ft.)  spaced  approximately  24  in.  to  25.5  in.,  center 
to  center,  a  depth  of  24  in.  of  stone  ballast  is  necessary  to  produce  uni- 
form pressure  on  the  subgrade,  and  a  combination  of  a  lower  layer  of 
cinder  ballast  (18  in.  to  14  in.)  and  an  upper  layer  of  stone  ballast 
(6  in.  to  10  in.),  approximately  24  in.  deep  in  the  aggregate,  with  the 
same  spacing  of  the  ties  will  produce  nearly  the  same  results. 

REPORT  ON  PHYSICAL  TESTS  OF  STONE  FOR  BALLAST. 

REVIEW    OF    PREVIOUS    REPORTS. 

The  Physical  Tests  of  Stone  for  Ballast  adopted  by  the  Association 
and  described  in  Vol.  11  (1910),  Part  2,  pp.  910-914,  were  the  first  tests 
of  this  character  adopted  by  the  Association,  and  the  question  of  re- 
vising the  tests,  if  necessary,  or  adding  other  tests  to  those  adopted, 
was  again  referred  to  the  Ballast  Committee  for  furher  investigation 
and  consideration. 

HISTORICAL. 

Your  Committee  ascertained  that  the  railroads  as  a  rule  had  no  uni- 
form practice  in  making  physical  tests  of  stone  for  ballast.  Some  of  the 
roads  selected  their  stone  for  ballast  by  simply  observing  the  character 
of  the  stone,  and  then  ascertaining  its  durability  and  fitness  for  ballast  by 
the  actual  results  obtained  in  track.  Some  roads  required  a  compression 
test  in  their  specifications,  but  only  one  railroad  was  found  to  have 
used  the  physical  tests  made  by  the  United  States  Government,  previous 
to  their  adoption  by  the  Association,  as  above  referred  to. 

ANALYTICAL. 

Your  Committee  does  not  recommend  any  changes  in  the  physical  tests 
already  adopted,  but  feels  that  the  tests  would  be  more  complete  if  the 
compression  test  were  added. 

With  this  in  view,  the  question  was  taken  up  with  the  Department  of 
Agriculture    of   the    United    States    Government    at    Washington,    D.    C, 


*For  amendment   to   Conclusion,    see  Index. 


98  BALLAST. 

and  they  have  agreed  to  add  the  compression  test  to  those  adopted  by  the 
Association,  which  were  described  in  Vol.  n  (1910),  Part  2,  pp.  910-914. 
of  the  Association  Proceedings. 

The  description  of  the  compression  test,  which  the  Government  will 
make,  is  as  follows : 

A  cylinder  two  (2)  in.  in  diameter  and  more  than  two  (2)  in.  long 
is  drilled  from  the  specimen  of  stone  to  be  tested,  by  means  of  a  diamond 
core  drill,  and  sawed  to  a  length  of  two  (2)  in.  by  a  band  saw  fed  with 
emery.  The  specimen  is  finally  faced  off  on  each  end  by  means  of  a 
power-driven  grinding  lap,  on  which  water  and  emery  are  continuously  fed. 

The  cylinder  then  has  both  ends  embedded  in  plaster  of  paris,  the 
bed  being  made  as  thin  as  possible  and  both  ends  being  made  parallel. 
The  cylinder  is  next  mounted  on  an  Olsen  test  machine  on  a  special  bear- 
ing block  between  blotting  papers,  three  thicknesses  being  placed  at  each 
end,  between  the  cylinder  and  the  steel-bearing  faces  of  the  machine. 
The  load  is  then  applied  at  a  speed  of  0.152  in.  per  minute,  the  machine 
being  kept  balanced  during  the  application  of  the  load. 

Your  Committee  believes  that  with  the  physical  tests  of  stone  for 
Ballast,  which  the  Association  adopted,  and  the  compression  test  above 
described,  sufficient  information  will  be  given  by  which  to  compare  the 
character  of  stone  from  the  various  quarries  from  which  it  is  proposed 
to  obtain  ballast. 

As  a  matter  of  information  your  Committee  has,  during  the  past  year, 
requested  a  number  of  railroads  to  send  samples  of  their  stone  ballast 
to  the  Government  for  test,  and  through  the  assistance  and  courtesy  of 
these  railroads  we  are  enabled  to  present  a  tabulated  statement  of  the  re- 
sults of  these  tests,  and  while  this  statement  is  not  as  complete  as  was 
desired,  yet  we  feel  it  will  be  of  considerable  value  in  studying  this 
question. 

ADVANTAGES    AND    DISADVANTAGES. 

The  advantage  of  using  approved  physical  tests  of  stone  for  ballast 
is  to  determine  the  character  of  the  stone  and  its  fitness  for  ballast  without 
the  expense  of  opening  quarries  and  using  the  stone,  before  it  is  known 
whether  it  will  be  suitable  for  ballast  or  not,  and  without  some  method 
of  determining  this  by  physical  tests,  railroads  will  undoubtedly  be  put 
to  considerable  expense  by  opening  quarries  and  applying  stone  ballast, 
which  in  some  cases  will  have  to  be  replaced  with  better  ballast  from  other 
quarries. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

Your  Committee  recommends  that  in  addition  to  the  Physical  Tests 
of  Stone  for  Ballast,  which  have  been  adopted  by  the  Association,  that 
the  "Compression  Test,"  above  described,  be  adopted  and  included  in 
the  Manual. 

Your  Committee  also  recommends  that  the  following  reference  be 
made  in  the  Manual  to  the  description  of  the  tests  and  the  action  nec- 
essary to  have  tests  made: 


BALLAST.  99 

"For  the  description  of  the  physical  tests  of  stone  for  ballast  as 
recommended  by  the  Association  and  full  instructions  as  to  how  the  sam- 
ples should  be  obtained  and  shipped  to  the  Government,  see  Proceedings 
of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Associa- 
tion, Vol.  ii,  Part  2,  pp.  910-914,  and  report  of  Ballast  Committee  of  1912. 
If  blueprints  of  the  machines  used  in  making  the  tests  are  desired,  they 
can  be  obtained  from  the  Department  of  Agriculture,  United  States  Govern- 
ment, Washington,  D.  C." 

COMPLETE    REVIEW    OF    GRAVEL    BALLAST    AND    RECOM- 
MENDED  METHODS    FOR   GRADING   THE 
DIFFERENT  QUALITIES. 

REVIEW    OF    PREVIOUS    REPORT. 

In  the  Proceedings  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Main- 
tenance of  Way  Association,  of  1910,  Vol.  11,  pp.  909-932,  a  classifi- 
cation of  gravel  ballast  was  adopted  by  the  Association,  which  depended 
on  the  amount  of  sand  and  dust  found  in  the  gravel,  the  size  of  the  sand, 
and  the  size  of  the  gravel,  being  determined  in  accordance  with  the  defini- 
tions of  "Sand  and  Gravel"  given  in  the  Manual,  and  this  subject  was 
again  referred  to  the  Ballast  Committee  for  a  complete  review. 

ANALYTICAL. 

Your  Committee,  during  the  year,  requested  a  number  of  railroads 
to  test  their  gravel  ballast  and  determine  the  percentage  of  sand,  gravel 
(following  the  definitions  of  sand  and  gravel,  given  in  the  Manual),  dust 
etc.,  in  the  ballast,  and  we  present  herewith  a  statement  showing  the 
percentages  as  found  in  ballast  now  in  use,  and  a  brief  of  the  reports 
obtained  from  the  railroads  in  regard  to  the  use  of  these  deposits  of 
gravel  for  ballast  is  as  follows : 

The  Santa  Fe  Railway  reports  that  it  is  using  the  Chillicothe  gravel 
almost  entirely  and  finds  it  to  be  very  satisfactory,  giving  good  results 
on  the  roadbed,  as  it  comes  from  the  pit,  using  12  in.  under  the  ties. 

The  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy  Railroad  reports  show  gravel 
being  taken  from  four  different  places,  and  put  under  the  tracks  as  it  is 
loaded  from  the  pits,  which  makes  excellent  track,  binds  well  and  is 
easily  worked. 

The  Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific  Railway  reports  gravel  taken 
from  five  different  places,  the  best  being  from  Benton,  Ark.,  on  their 
Southern  lines,  but  not  equal  to  the  glacial  gravel  of  Iowa  and  Illinois. 
The  gravel  was  used  on  the  track  as  it  came  from  the  pits,  and  not  washed. 

Twelve  tests  of  pits  on  the  Grand  Rapids  &  Indiana  Railroad  are 
shown  in  the  tabulated  statement.  The  ballast  is  not  washed,  but  is  put 
in  the  track  as  it  comes  from  the  pit. 

In  the  case  of  the  Illinois  Central  Railroad,  the  tabulated  statement 
shows  tests  from  four  different  places,  and  the  ballast  from  each  is  used 


100 

STATEMENT 


BALLAST. 

SHOWING  PERCENTAGES  OF  SAND,  CLAY,  ETC.,  IN  GRAVEL 
BALLAST 


Name  of 

Location  of 
Gravel  Pit 

PERCENTAGES 

Railway 

Dust 
and 
Clay 

Sand 

Grav- 
el 

Rock  Voids 

Remarks 

C.  B.  &Q 

Atchison,  Kansas.. . . 

10.0 

12.7 

77.3 

0.0      No 
Data 

Per  cent,  by  weight. 
Main  track. 

C.  B.  &Q 

O'Neill,  Neb 

8.5 

57.5 

34.0 

0.0    No 
Data 

Per  cent,  by  weight . 
Branch  line. 

C.  B.  &Q 

Ballantine,  Montana. 

7.0 

4.9 

52.5 

35.6  !    No 
Data 

Per  cent,  by  weight. 
Main  line. 

C.B.&Q 

Peetz,  Colorado 

4.8 

51.5 

42.5 

1.2  1    No 
Data 

Per  cent,  by  weight. 
Main  line. 

C.  R.  I.  &  P 

Chillicothe,  Illinois.. 

6.0 

60.0 

40.0 

0.0      No 
Data 

Per  centege  arrived 
at  by  volume. 

C.  R.  I.  &  P 

Grattinger,  Iowa .... 

16.4 

41.4 

53.7 

No       No 
Data   Data 

Percentage  arrived 
at  by  volume. 

C.  R.  I.  &  P 

Benton,  Arkansas 

23.3 

20.8 

79.2 

No       No 
Data    Data 

C.  R.  I.  &  P 

On  St.  Louis  Division 

5.8 

22.0 

80.0 

No       No 
Data   Data 

C.  R.I.&P 

16.3 

11.8 

90.9 

No       No 
Data   Data 

G.  R.&I 

Big  Rapids,  Michigan 

6.0 

32.0 

78.0 

No       No 
Data   Data 

Shown  as  good  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

G.R.&I 

Sand  Lake,  Michigan 

18.0 

44.0 

63.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Date 

Shown  as  fair  quality 
of  ballast. 

G.  R.&I 

5.0 

30.0 

80.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

G.  R.&I 

Belmont  Pit 

0.5 

15.0 

91.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Date 

ity  of  ballast. 

G.R.&I 

M..G  R.&I 

0.0 

40.0 

75.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  fair  quality 
of  ballast. 

G.  R.  &  I 

Paris  Pit 

15.0 

40.0 

70.0 

No 
Date 

No 
Data 

ity  of  ballast. 

G.  R.  &I 

11.0 

36.0 

72.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

ity  of  ballast. 

G.  R.  &I 

5.0 

40.0 

72.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

ity  of  ballast. 

G.  R.  &  I 

Tustin 

8.0 

42.0 

72.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

ity  of  ballast. 

G.R.&I 

K.  S.  Tower  Pit, 
Oden 

13.0 

60.0 

48.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 

G.R.&I 

K.  S.  Tower  Pit, 
T.  C.  Sect.  2 

18.0 

49.0 

55.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

G.R.&I 

K.  S.  Tower  Pit, 
T.C.  Sect.  3 

15.0 

56.0 

50.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

G.  R.&I 

K.  S.  Tower  Pit, 
T.C.  Sect.  4 

16.0 

55.0 

50.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

BALLAST. 


101 


STATEMENT  SHOWING  PERCENTAGES  OF  SAND,  CLAY,  ETC.,  IN  GRAVEL 

BALLAST. 


Location  of 
Gravel  Pit 

PERCENTAGES 

Name  of 
Railway 

Dust 
and 
Clay 

Sand 

Grav- 
el 

Rock 

Voids 

Remarks 

G.R.&I 

Suttons  Bay  Pit 

15.0 

36.0 

67.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Shown  as  poor  qual- 
ity of  ballast. 

I.  C 

Forreston,  Illinois 

4.8 

17.2 

72.0 

6.0 

20.0 

I.  C 

Riverton,  Indiana.  .  . 

7.9 

23.5 

68.6 

0.0 

13.4 

I.  C 

Gravel  Switch, 

7.0 

6.2 

85.0 

1.8 

18.8 

I.  C 

Memphis,  Tennessee. 

3.3 

17.8 

77.7 

1.2 

17.3 

Fowler,  Colorado 

2.0 

65.0 

33.0 

0.0 

No 

Data 

Fair  results. 

Ft.  Gibson, 

5.0 

4.0 

94.0 

0.006 

No 
Data 

Clay  included  in  per- 

Bethel,  Arkansas. . . . 

4.0 

34.0 

76.0 

0.0 

No 
Data 

N.  Y.  C.&H.  R. 

18.0 

55.0 

27.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Sample  No.  16. 

N.  Y.  C.  &  H.  R. 

5.0 

20.0 

75.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Sample  No.  17,  first 

quality. 

N.  Y.  C.  &  H.  R. 

Glenfield 

18.0 

57.0 

25.0 

No 
Data 

No 

Data 

Sample  No.  19,  coarse 

sand,  very  good  but 
dusty. 

N.  Y.  C.  &  H.  R. 

Todds 

10.0 

35.0 

55.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Sample  No.  18. 

N.  Y.  C.  &  H.  R. 

8.0 

27.0 

65.0 

No 
Data 

No 
Data 

Sample  No.  21. 

Note. — The  sand  and  gravel  in  the  ballast  given  in  the  above  table  was 
determined  in  accordance  with  the  definition  of  sand  and  gravel  in  the 
Manual,    edition   of  1911. 


102  BALLAST. 

in  the  track  as  it  comes  from  the  pits,  except  in  the  case  of  the  Memphis 
gravel,  which  is  taken  from  the  bed  of  the  Mississippi  River  and  washed. 

The  Missouri  Pacific  Railway  reports  tests  from  three  different  places, 
and  like  the  other  roads  the  ballast  was  used  on  the  track  as  it  came 
from  the  pits. 

It  will  be  seen  from  the  reports  of  the  six  different  roads  that  no 
expense  was  incurred  in  washing  or  screening  the  gravel,  which  was  used 
upon  the  tracks  as  it  came  from  the  pits,  except  in  the  case  of  the  Illinois 
Central  Railroad,  for  gravel  secured  at  Memphis. 

A  report  from  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Intercolonial  Railroad  of 
Canada  states  that  he  is  of  the  impression  that  if  they  screened  their 
gravel  they  would  not  get  as  good  results  as  where  they  took  the  sand 
with  a  coarser  material  combined. 

A  report  from  the  Engineering  Department  of  the  Canadian  Pacific 
Railway  states  that  they  are  ballasting  with  gravel  taken  direct  from 
the  pit,  without  any  cost  of  treatment. 

Your  Committee  further  endeavored  to  determine  the  maximum 
amount  of  clay  which  would  be  permissible  in  good  cementing  ballast, 
and  by  reference  to  the  data  we  have  on  this  subject  we  find  that  most 
of  the  tests  that  have  been  made  of  gravel  ballast  give  very  meager  in- 
formation as  to  the  amount  of  clay  in  cementing  ballast,  but  from  the  best 
information  we  have  at  hand  we  are  of  the  opinion  that  where  the  clay 
amounts  to  over  10  per  cent,  it  would  be  quite  objectionable. 

Your  Committee  wishes  to  give  a  high  endorsement  of  the  report 
on  "Gravel  as  Ballast,"  by  Mr.  C.  Brauning,  which  Mr.  W.  M.  Dawley 
had  translated  from  "Zeitschrift  fiir  Bauwesen,"  Vol.  LIV,  Berlin,  1904. 
We  also  present  to  the  Association,  under  Appendix  "A,"  a  description 
and  photographs  of  a  gravel  washing  plant  on  the  Richmond,  Fredericks- 
burg &  Potomac  Railroad,  at  Massaponax,  midway  between  Richmond, 
Va.,  and  Washington,  D.  C,  which  plant  is  under  the  charge  of  Mr.  S.  B. 
Rice,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  to  whom  we  are  indebted  for  that 
report.  The  results  obtained  from  this  washed  gravel  ballast,  as  can 
be  seen  from  this  report,  are  far  superior  to  the  results  obtained  from 
the  use  of  gravel  for  ballast  without  washing. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

Your  Committee  recommends  further  investigation  of  the  amount  of 
sand,  dust  and  clay,  permissible  in  good  gravel  ballast,  since  reports  ob- 
tained this  year  from  various  railways,  and  attached  hereto  in  a  tabulated 
statement,  indicate  wide  variations  in  the  amount  of  these  materials  found 
in  gravel  ballast  in  actual  use,  yet  reported  as  giving  good  results. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON   BALLAST. 


Appendix  A. 

GRAVEL  WASHING  PLANT  OF  THE  RICHMOND,  FREDERICKS- 
BURG &  POTOMAC  AND  WASHINGTON   SOUTHERN 
RAILWAYS. 

By.  S.  B.  Rice,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way. 

The  latter  part  of  July,  1907,  or  about  the  time  the  double  tracking  of 
the  Richmond,  Fredericksburg  &  Potomac  Railroad  and  Washington 
Southern  Railway  had  been  completed,  the  officials  were  discussing  the 
matter  of  using  stone  ballast  to  make  the  line  first-class  in  every  respect, 
it  being  a  through  trunk  line  between  Richmond,  Va.,  and  Washington, 
D.  C,  with  a  traffic  that  is  very  heavy.  We  have  an  average  of  24 
through  passenger  and  10  local  trains  daily  during  the  heavy  season  and 
an  average  of  20  through  passenger  and  10  local  trains  daily  during 
the  light  season,  the  through  trains  consisting  of  from  six  to  twelve 
cars  and  the  local  trains  of  from  four  to  five  cars.  We  have 
an  average  of  20  freight  trains  daily  throughout  the  year.  Weight  of 
heaviest  engine,  156,730  lbs.  on  drivers;  total  weight,  373,200  lbs. 

About  this  time  we  had  discovered  a  heavy  deposit  of  very  excellent 
gravel  at  Massaponax,  Va.,  57  miles  from  Richmond,  midway  between 
that  point  and  Washington,  and  thought  it  possible  that  we  could  make  a 
first-class  road  from  this  material.  The  gravel  lies  in  a  bed  from  ten  to 
twenty  feet  in  depth,  about  800  ft.  wide  and  4,000  ft.  in  length.  The 
pit  we  estimated  to  contain  about  1,000,000  cu.  yds.  of  serviceable  mate- 
rial.    The  pit  was  opened  on  August  22,  1007. 

The  pit-run  gravel  from  this  pit  was  used  on  portions  of  our  track  and 
made  an  excellent  track,  but  in  long,  dry  seasons  it  was  found  to  be  very 
dusty,  and  in  long  wet  spells  we  found  that  track  became  sloppy.  In  the 
latter  part  of  1907  we  conceived  the  idea  of  washing  and  screening  this 
material,  as  was  done  by  the  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern  Railway 
at  Roupel  and  Pleasant  Lake.  In  July,  1908,  W.  D.  Duke,  Assistant  to 
President;  S.  B.  Rice,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  and  E.  M'.  Hastings, 
Resident  Engineer,  made  a  trip  to  the  Roupel  plant  with  a  view  of  looking 
into  the  advisability  of  duplicating  this  plant,  also  to  have  the  opportunity 
of  inspecting  track  that  had  been  ballasted  with  washed  gravel.  Mr.  Duke 
was  so  much  pleased  with  the  condition  of  the  track  and  plant  that  he  at 
once  recommended  the  installation  of  the  washing  plant  at  Massaponax  at 
the  earliest  possible  time.  The  authority  for  this  work  was  given  in  the 
latter  part  of  July,  1908.  Work  was  at  once  started  on  this  plant  and 
pushed  as  rapidly  as  possible  to  have  it  completed  before  bad  weather  set 
in.  The  first  shipment  of  washed  gravel  was  on  November  20,  1908,  start- 
ing at  the  Richmond  end. 

103 


104  BALLAST. 

The  plant  consists  of  a  large  concrete  hopper  into  which  the  pit-run 
gravel  is  dumped,  from  which  it  is  carried  by  a  pan  conveyor  having  a 
speed  of  30  ft.  per  minute,  or  120  to  150  cu.  yds.  per  hour,  on  an  incline  of 
30  degrees,  to  the  top  of  the  trestle  some  45  ft.  high,  where  it  is  discharged 
into  a  steel-lined  box,  6x3  ft.  in  plan  and  one  foot  deep  in  front,  or  at  the 
chute.  The  water,  discharged  from  a  flat  nozzle,  one  inch  wide  and  24 
in.  long,  connected  to  a  6-in.  discharge  pipe,  strikes  the  gravel  as  it  falls 
into  the  box,  washing  it  down  over  a  steel-lined  chute,  six  ft.  wide  and 
eight  ft.  long,  with  a  slope  of  3  in.  to  the  foot. 

It  was  found  necessary,  in  order  to  more  completely  wash  the  gravel, 
to  place  a  series  of  rods  across  the  chute,  making  the  gravel  tumble  over 
them,  thereby  retarding  its  progress  and  obtaining  a  more  complete 
washing. 

At  the  end  of  the  chute  there  is  a  double  screen  placed  at  an  angle 
of  about  45  degrees  with  the  chute.  The  screens  are  about  9  in.  apart,  and 
are  of  double-crimped  tool  steel  wire.  The  first  of  No.  6  wire,  one  mesh 
to  the  inch ;  the  second  of  No.  10  wire,  two  meshes  to  the  inch.  All  gravel 
that  does  not  pass  these  two  screens  falls  into  the  ballast  bin,  which  is  36 
ft.  long  and  12  ft.  wide  and  about  12  ft.  deep.  The  lower  six  ft.  of  this 
bin  is  sloped  toward  the  center,  so  that  the  gravel  will  fall  by  gravity 
through  the  openings  in  the  bottom.     (Fig.  4.) 

All  of  the  material  which  passes  these  two  screens  along  with  the 
water  falls  upon  a  second  steel-lined  chute  which  is  eight  ft.  wide,  nine 
ft.  long,  and  a  slope  of  two  in.  to  the  foot.  From  this  chute  the  material 
is  discharged  against  another  screen,  of  double  crimped  tool  steel  wire 
No.  12,  four  meshes  to  the  inch.  This  screen  takes  out  practically  every- 
thing larger  than  y$-in.  in  diameter.  All  material  which  does  not  pass 
this  screen  falls  into  the  ballast  bin  also. 

The  material  passing  the  screen  is  carried  over  another  steel-lined 
chute  about  ten  ft.  wide  and  seven  ft.  long,  where  it  is  discharged  as  sand 
into  a  settling  tank  about  12x13  ft.  and  three  ft.  deep.  On  the  side  of  the 
tank  opposite  this  chute  is  the  waste  flume  where  the  muddy  water  is  car- 
ried off  and  discharged  on  the  bed  of  gravel  where  the  gravel  had  been 
previously  excavated. 

The  settling  tank  is  water-tight  and  is  fitted  at  the  bottom  with  two 
conical  steel  hoppers,  six  ft.  in  diameter  at  the  top  and  ten  in.  in  diameter 
at  the  base,  five  ft.  deep.  The  bottoms  of  the  steel  cones  are  fitted  with  a 
steel  cone  plug  which  makes  them  nearly  water-tight.  The  plugs  or  cones 
are  operated  from  the  top.  The  idea  of  having  two  of  the  conical  hoppers 
was  to  grade  the  sand,  the  coarse  sand  settling  in  the  first  hopper  and  the 
fine  sand  in  the  farther  one,  there  being  a  distinct  difference  in  the  two 
grades  of  sand.  For  this  sand  we  have  found  ready  sale,  as  it  is  of  ex- 
cellent quality  for  building  purposes  and  concrete  work,  the  finer  sand 
making  excellent  engine  sand. 

The  ballast  bin  is  steel-lined  throughout  and  has  three  openings  at 
the  bottom,  fitted  with  20x20  in.  rack  and  pinion  valves,  spaced  so  as  to 
empty  into  the  center  and  two  ends  of  the  ballast  car,  giving  a  uniform 


BALLAST.  105 

loading  without  necessitating  the  moving  of  car.  The  material  is  dis- 
tributed in  the  ballast  bin  about  equally  over  the  three  openings. 

The  water  is  brought  from  Massaponax  Creek  through  a  gravity  canal, 
900  ft.  long  (Fig.  1),  to  a  concrete  lined  well,  7x5  ft.  and  11  ft.  deep;  the 
bottom  of  the  well  being  four  ft.  lower  than  the  creek  at  the  intake.  This 
canal  is  a  20x20-in.  open  wood  flume  for  500  ft.  where  it  runs  into  a 
20x20-in.  wood  box,  covered  by  some  eight  ft.  of  earth.  This  box  is  about 
370  ft.  long,  where  connection  is  made  with  an  18-in.  terra  cotta  pipe, 
which  runs  under  the  engine  foundation  and  pull-out  track  into  the  well, 
which  is  located  close  to  the  engine ;  this  flume  is  always  submerged. 
The  pump  is  an  Emerson  pump  No.  4  with  a  6-in.  suction,  rated  for  a  5-in. 
discharge.  The  rated  capacity  is  from  800  to  1,200  gallons  per  minute. 
To  overcome  friction  it  was  fitted  with  a  6-in.  discharge.  The  steam  is 
furnished  by  a  go  H.P.  return  tubular  boiler,  which  is  under  same  roof  as 
engine  and  pump.  We  also  have  a  No.  5  pulling  pump,  rated  at  350  gal- 
lons per  minute,  for  the  purpose  of  pumping  water  into  a  25,000  gallon 
tank  about  1,400  ft.  distant,  which  is  used  by  ballast  and  spotting  engines. 
This  tank  is  located  on  the  pull-out  track,  just  north  of  the  coal  bin. 

At  this  point  we  have  the  office  and  bunk  houses  for  both  white  ana 
colored  help.  These  bunk  houses  are  separated.  The  Superintendent  of 
the  plant  is  on  the  ground  at  all  times.  Steam  shovel  and  spotting  engine 
crews  are  provided  with  both  lodging  and  board. 

The  concrete  hopper  (Fig.  4),  into  which  the  pit  gravel  is  dumped 
preparatory  to  washing,  is  18  ft.  above  the  foundation,  36  ft.  long  and  12 
ft.  wide  inside,  the  outside  walls  are  two  ft.  thick.  The  inside  of  the 
hopper  slopes  from  the  top  all  ways  toward  the  center  opening,  which  is 
18x20  in.,  and  provided  with  a  steel  sliding  door  which  governs  the  feed 
on  the  conveyor.  The  slant  sides  of  the  hopper  are  six  in.  thick,  rein- 
forced with  from  l/2  to  i^-in.  iron  rods,  spaced  18  in.  in  centers  and  bent 
over  into  the  two  ft.  outside  walls.  They  are  fastened  together  with  y2-'m. 
rods  spaced  about  12  in.  apart.  The  track  on  the  hopper  is  carried  on 
12x14  in.  wood  stringers,  one  of  which  is  immediately  over  the  outside 
wall,  the  other  carried  on  I2xi4-in.  cross  stringers,  spaced  six  ft.  c.  to  c, 
and  imbedded  in  the  outside  walls.  The  track  over  the  hopper  is  fitted 
with  a  bar  screen,  bars  spaced  4^  in.  apart,  so  as  to  prevent  roots,  stumps, 
boulders,  or  large  lumps  of  clay  from  being  carried  to  the  washing  plant. 

The  approach  to  the  hopper  (Fig.  1)  is  on  a  2  per  cent,  grade  as- 
cending, which  terminates  at  a  point  150  ft.  from  the  end  of  the  hopper, 
thence  by  a  1  per  cent,  descending  grade,  which  continues  over  the  hopper, 
where  it  breaks  into  a  2.5  per  cent,  descending,  then  to  a  5  per  cent, 
descending  grade  for  about  150  ft.,  then  to  an  18  per  cent,  ascending  grade. 
At  the  junction  of  the  5  per  cent,  and  18  per  cent,  grades  there  is  located  a 
spring  switch,  the  track  leading  away  from  the  switch  being  on  a  descend- 
ing grade  to  the  pit  level,  the  idea  being  to  do  most  of  the  shifting  by 
gravity.  The  loaded  cars  after  being  pushed  up  the  2  per  cent,  approach  to 
the  hopper  are  unloaded,  dropped  from  the  5  per  cent,  grade  by  gravity, 
and  up  on  the  18  per  cent,  grade,  which  gives  them  a  kick  back  through 


106  BALLAST. 

the  spring  switch  and  down  to  the  pit  level,  where  they  are  taken  by  the 
engine  to  be  reloaded. 

It  is  intended  to  cover  the  112  miles  of  double  track  with  washed 
gravel,  thereby  securing  a  dustless  roadbed.  In  order  to  accomplish  this 
we  had  new  grades  given,  making  a  lift  in  track  from  3  to  16  in.,  taking 
out  some  slight  sags  that  were  in  tracks.  Of  course,  where  the  track  was 
lifted  as  much  as  6  inches  the  old  ballast  could  be  worked  under  the  ties, 
but  at  the  other  points  the  old  sand  and  gravel  ballast  was  thrown  out  to 
make  roadbed.  Ballast  was  loaded  into  the  Rodgers  drop  bottom  ballast 
cars  and  delivered  in  track,  using  a  Rodgers  plow  for  levelling  down. 
This  work  was  carried  on  by  an  extra  force,  renewing  all  ties  that 
were  not  good  for  two  years,  regaging  track  and  properly  spacing  ties 
ahead  of  new  ballast.  The  renewal  of  ties  and  regaging  was  charged  to 
maintenance ;  surfacing  track  was  charged  to  reballasting.  It  required 
from  3,200  to  3,800  cu.  yds.  to  the  double  track  mile.  The  force  em- 
ployed at  the  pit  consists  of  the  following :  One  general  foreman,  one 
clerk,  one  shovel  engineer,  one  craneman,  one  shovel  fireman,  four  men  at 
shovel,  one  engineer  in  charge  of  plant,  one  towerman  who  operates  the 
machinery  at  top  of  plant,  also  looking  after  the  screens,  one  foreman  on 
hopper,  one  hopper  and  two  helpers,  one  sand  loader,  one  gravel  loader 
and  two  droppers  of  cars.  In  addition  to  this  there  are  three  men  on 
cars  closing  them  up  and  calking  and  getting  them  ready  for  sand.  Shift- 
ing track  is  generally  done  by  section  force  and  is,  of  course,  charged  to 
pit  expense. 

Since  the  starting  of  the  washing  plant  there  have  been  371,877  cu. 
yds.  of  washed  gravel  shipped,  of  which  354,439  cubic  yards  were  used  for 
ballast  and  17,438  cu.  yds.  for  concrete  and  other  purposes.  From  this 
total  amount  of  gravel  we  have  taken  78,232  cu.  yds.  of  sand,  most  of 
which  has  been  sold  for  building  purposes.  Of  course,  the  hauling  of  this 
has  been  revenue  to  the  Company.  Cost  per  cubic  yard  of  loading  rough 
gravel,  8.95  cents;  cost  per  cubic  yard  of  washing  gravel,  11.34  cents;  cost 
per  cubic  yard  for  hauling,  il.ll  cents;  cost  per  cubic  yard  for  placing 
in  track,  26.15  cents;  or  a  total  cost  of  57.55  cents  per  cubic  yard  of  fin- 
ished track.  This  cost  includes  hire  of  all  engines,  train  crews,  coal  and 
supplies ;  rental  of  shovel,  coal,  supplies  and  repairs ;  one  cent  per  cubic 
yard  to  cover  cost  of  gravel  in  pit  and  10  per  cent,  depreciation  on  plant 
and  tracks ;  but  no  credit  is  taken  in  these  figures  for  sand  sold. 

We  have  found  by  actual  test  that  the  washed  gravel  is  nearly  self- 
draining;  it  will  not  retain  over  nTA  per  cent,  of  water,  while  the  pit-run 
gravel  will  retain  55  per  cent.  It  has  been  demonstrated  that  the  washed 
gravel  will  withstand  any  amount  of  continued  rain  and  not  slop,  while  the 
pit-run  would,  causing  rough  track  in  continued  wet  spells.  Aside  from 
the  better  condition  of  track  we  estimate  to  add  at  least  two  years  to  life 
of  the  ties.  It  makes  a  dustless  roadbed  and  reduces  the  cost  of  main- 
tenance. 


BALLAST. 


107 


O 


> 


fe 


1LS 


5ALLAST. 


BALLAST 


109 


K 


pq 


O 


> 


[x, 


110 


BALLAST. 


Fig.   4— View    Showing   Where  Gravel  is   Emptied  from    Carrier   and 

Where  Water  First  Strikes  It,  Also  Showing  Action  the 

Ballast  and  Water  Take  in  Passing  Over  the  Bars 

into  the  First  Flume. 


RESULTS  OF  GOVERNMENT  TESTS  ON  STONE  FOR 
BALLAST,  RESULTS  IN  TRACK,  AND  RAILWAY 
BALLAST  SPECIFICATIONS. 


•  IN  TIUOK   IND  riAII.WAI  rill       II  II   Ml..'.!, 


.>»...«. 


'.l   (lOVl  IINM1  N  i 
llhnuai    ir,..„i„^ 


>  *  lifr.i.1  8ta»  Co,  Pataoa  C».  lad. 


inhhtlV  ID  . 
Co-3w.::  Co,  K> 


:=: 
Co    Otto 
■»Go.O»*> 
v<  W«t  Co,  Oa, 
WlnjiiniKi       Co,OMa 
WatVo.  Uor»aCo,Pa  . 

*  -a-  Ma  at  Blraan.  Barb  Co.  Pa  '.. 


PlaBaT  JaAraa  Co.  T «.  . 
Bcraw  Plana,  UMmmm  Co .  T«a  . 
■m  Float,  Jafaaaa  Co,  T« 


oa 
en 

US 

ia 

1  M 

1M 

oa 

IB 

IS 

i  a 

m 

ea 

m 

OM 

in 

i  a 

■  a 

1  14 

id 

>  u 

ia 

o  to 

IU 

i  n 

IB 

i  a 

in 

on 

ia 

ia 

oa 

ia 

Oil 

1M 

IH 

ia 

ian 

m 

ia 

ia 

0  10 

ia 

m 

in 

0  II 

in 

on 

in 

m 

. 

bota  iaa  a 

1*  urn  only  .).. 
In  u*n  ..nl,  .,„ 


:       ■ 


M-ilmon. 


Ib  aarvioa  only  3  y*a>ra 
I*  aarrioa  only  3  yv» 
la  mtvIm  only  2  y«*n 


only  Syaara. 
Ii  MrriM  otlr  lytan 
Ia  a-rnoaoaly  3  >«*/* 
Ia  aai-Tioa  oily  2  yrara 
Uaad  I  yarn/*,  doaa 


Bt/»n*  Ui  ba  bard.  darmMa,  aad  U  qaaL 
HvaeetpUfa 

Hhall    ..r-..    in   ■«(. 
'      fnii,»i|     aad     •  r.*ll     ba    taor>va«hry 
I     aeraaaad  <A  all  dart,  dirt,  aad  brvca 


I  InvavM)  avtaawd  --I-)  Em  boa  dUai 


Good  aarrioa;  wmn  roua-1  la  3  or  1  ya*ra.   , 

Oood  aarrlea,  mm  roun-J  la  3  or  I  yamra. 

-'»;  wmr*  round  ia  3  or  3  yaavra. 

Uood  aarrioa.  waara  roaad  la  3  or  3  yamra. . 


n 


Liaaa 


Uaad  ID  yaavra;  vary  aataafartory  r 

rtaUriariory:  rtnad  lampuat  wall 
I  ■■    BtaB  MM  •  -«.-> i ■- .  ana  c-i 
Vary  mod 
Poor:  oramka  ia  tarn  pi  a< . 


Good:  Mill  l**l  10  >**ra.  rUaui  martin 
•  .|n.liim-      r'agarva  abo 


ia  tba  ubla  aboar  tba  partawrtaar* 


Fraa  from  doat,  aartb  mad  traab 
Fitaaaa  radxad  by  aa*  ta  track. 

Limartona  o.  approrad  a oaLiy .  Grads 
atad  ia  «u*.  Sunaid  of  all  dirt  aad 
rubbiab  aad  rtooa  amailar  tbaa  1  aatb- 
riiaba  pBaauac  34-ttch  n*  awl  ka-ter 
thaa  I  vacb.  mart  ba  brokaa  by  nauad 
at  plara  of  loadiac. 
Lux*  Eart  — Craabiaa:  Stna«U: 

UmeatoM,  10.000  tba.  par  aq   La. 

Trap.  13.000  Iba.  par  aq.  aa. 


by  aratgbt  of  dart  ot   drtntaa  arora  oS  apaea- 
loar;  troot  13  to  19  tnaduim,  aad  nbora  10  biftb. 


Appendix    B. 


(Bulletin    136.) 


EXPERIMENT  TO  DETERMINE  THE  NECESSARY  DEPTH  OF 
STONE  BALLAST. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

In  the  Proceedings  of  the  Association,  Vol.  7  (1906),  page  102,  the 
writer  called  attention  to  the  experiments  of  Railroad  Director  Schubert 
of  Germany  to  determine  the  depth  of  ballast  necessary  to  distribute  the 
superimposed  loads  arising  from  the  traffic  to  the  best  advantage  over  the 
roadbed,  and  these  experiments  of  Director  Schubert  have  inspired  the 
Pennsylvania  Railroad  Company  to  supplement  the  data  obtained  at  that 
time  by  a  series  of  experiments,  or  tests,  on  a  larger  scale  and  more  in 
accordance  with  the  conditions  to  be  met  with  in  the  United  States. 

Through  the  kindness  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  Company  and  Mr. 
L.  R.  Zollinger,  Engineer  of  Maintenance  of  Way,  the  Chairman  of  the 
Committee  appointed  to  conduct  the  tests,  the  writer  is  enabled  to  pre- 
sent the  information  in  full  to  the  members  of  our  Association. 

These  tests  are  the  most  extensive  of  the  kind  ever  conducted  in  this 
country,  and  will  be  found  of  great  interest  and  value  to  railway  engineers. 

It  is  worthy  of  note  how  closely  the  depth  of  stone  ballast,  deter- 
mined by  these  experiments  as  necessary  for  the  best  distribution  of  the 
superimposed  loads,  24  in.,  agrees  with  the  depth  for  the  same  material  as 
given  by  Mr.  Thos.  H.  Johnson's  formula,  which  he  derived  from 
Director  Schubert's  experiments,  viz.,  225-3  in. 

W.  C.  Cushing, 
Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way, 

June  5,  191T.  Pennsylvania  Lines  West  of  Pittsburg. 


113 


THE  PENNSYLVANIA    RAILROAD    COMPANY. 

REPORT   OF   THE    GENERAL  MANAGER'S  COMMITTEE  AP- 
POINTED  TO  DETERMINE,  BY  EXPERIMENT,  THE 
NECESSARY  DEPTH  OF  STONE  BALLAST. 

COMMITTEE. 

L.  R.  Zollinger,  Chairman; 
E.  D.  Nelson, 
Allen  B.  Cuthbert, 
G.  W.  Snyder. 

Philadelphia,  March  5,  191 1. 
Mr.  S.  C.  Long, 
General  Manager. 

Dear  Sir: — Your  Committee,  appointed  to  determine,  by  experiments, 
the  proper  depth  of  ballast  under  track  necessary  to  equally  distribute 
the  pressure,  due  to  moving  loads  on  the  surface  of  the  underlying  mate- 
rial, submits  the  following  report : 

During  the  years  1887  to  1890,  inclusive,  Railroad  Director  Schubert 
of  Germany  conducted  a  series  of  experiments  to  demonstrate,  "Which 
ballast  material  affords  the  best  distribution  of  force  upon  the  subgrade 
or  roadbed."  These  experiments  were  conducted  by  filling  boxes  with 
layers  of  different  kinds  of  ballast  and  other  material  upon  which  a 
section  of  a  tie  was  laid.  This  tie  was  then  tamped  in  the  ordinary  way 
and  subjected,  by  means  of  an  eccentric,  to  a  load  which  was  alternately 
imposed  upon  and  lifted  from  the  tie — thus  imitating  the  process  of 
passing  a  loaded  wheel  over  the  track.  After  repeated  tampings  and 
applications  of  the  load  the  ends  of  the  box  were  removed  and  the  con- 
ditions beneath  the  tie  investigated.  One  of  the  conclusions  drawn  from 
the  experiment  was,  as  the  depth  of  stone  ballast  under  the  tie  increased, 
that  the  distribution  of  pressure  on  the  underlying  material  became  more 
uniform. 

The  data  obtained  by  Mr.  Schubert  were  very  instructive,  yet  your 
Committee  felt  that  more  valuable  data  could  be  obtained  from  a  series 
of  experiments  if  made  in  a  manner  approaching  more  nearly  actual  track 
conditions. 

Accordingly,  at  South  Altoona  Foundries,  a  piece  of  single  track  was 
constructed,  under  which  were  placed  three  strong  boxes  open  at  the  top 
and  having  removable  ends,  each  box  sufficiently  large  to  contain  two 
standard  ties  spaced  the  standard  distance  apart;  the  boxes  were  filled 
with  various  kinds  of  ballast  and  roadbed  material. 

A  heavily  loaded  truck  was  designed  to  run  back  and  forth  on  the 
track  so  that  the  effect  of  its  load  acting  through  the  ties  upon  the  ballast 
and  roadbed  could  be  studied  by  the  removal  of  the  ends  of  the  boxes, 
when  measurements  and  photographs  could  be  taken.  The  general 
arrangement  of  the  plant  is  shown  by  the  photographs,  Figs.  1,  2,  3.  The 
track  was  109  ft.  in  length,  built  of  new  P.  R.  R.  standard  85-lb.  rail, 

114 


depth  of  stoke  ballast. 


115 


h 


116 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


117 


u. 


118  DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 

spiked  to  standard  white  oak  ties  7  in.  by  9  in.  by  8J/.2  ft.  long,  no  tieplates 
being  used.  The  rail  fastenings  were  standard  spikes,  and  the  rail  joints 
were  so  arranged  as  not  to  fall  within  the  limits  of  the  boxes.  Eighty- 
five-pound  rail  was  selected  in  preference  to  100-lb.  rail  in  order  that 
the  track  might  be  sufficiently  flexible  to  subject  the  ties  to  as  much  weight 
as  possible.  The  ends  of  the  track  were  elevated  to  facilitate  the  stop- 
ping and  starting  of  the  car,  but  the  part  over  the  boxes  was  level.  The 
boxes  were  built  of  yellow  pine  planking  4^2  in.  thick  by  8  in.  wide  and 
had  floors  of  the  same  material  resting  on  sand  several  inches  deep, 
which,  in  turn,  rested  on  an  undisturbed  shale  formation.  The  site  was 
selected  to  provide  a  solid  bottom  to  prevent  any  appreciable  settlement 
taking  place  in  the  boxes.  The  joints  between  the  planks  were  not 
tongued  and  grooved  nor  sufficiently  tight  to  prevent  the  passage  of  water. 
The  boxes  were  strengthened  by  an  arrangement  of  heavy  posts  and  tie 
rods,  as  the  photographs  show. 

The  boxes  under  the  track  were  12  ft.  apart,  center  to  center.  They 
were  alike,  and  their  inside  dimensions  were  as  follows :  4  ft.  8J4  in. 
wide,  9  ft.  long  and  3  ft.  4  in.  high,  being  set  so  that  their  tops  were  2  in. 
below  the  base  of  the  rail. 

The  testing  plant  was  roofed  over  to  prevent  rain  from  falling  on 
the  boxes  so  that  the  amount  of  water  applied  to  the  boxes  could  be 
accurately  determined. 

The  car  or  truck  having  two  axles  (as  shown  by  the  photographs) 
was  designed  to  run  back  and  forth  upon  the  track  at  a  speed  of  about 
five  miles  per  hour.  The  car  had  a  wheel  base  of  9  ft.  and  was  loaded 
with  pig  iron,  so  that  the  gross  weight  amounted  to  150,000  lbs.,  or  75,000 
lbs.  per  axle.  There  was  no  spring  intervention  between  the  weight  and 
the  axle,  the  journal  boxes  being  fastened  directly  to  the  body  of  the  car. 

The  car  was  kept  moving  by  an  electric  motor  geared  to  one  axle, 
the  current  being  supplied  through  an  overhead  shoe  bearing  against  a 
conductor.  At  the  elevated  ends  of  the  track  a  device  automatically  shut 
off  the  current  and  reversed  the  motor ;  the  car  needed  very  little  power  or 
attention  to  keep  it  in  motion.  A  counter  on  the  car  registered  the  num- 
ber of  trips  made. 

It  being  impracticable  to  run  the  car  faster  than  about  five  miles  per 
hour,  at  which  speed  any  effect  upon  the  track,  due  to  impact  alone,  would 
be  negligible,  a  weight  of  75,000  lbs.  per  axle  was  chosen  for  the  experi- 
mental truck,  so  as  to  obtain  about  the  same  effect  on  the  track  as  an 
"H8b"  locomotive  running  at  the  usual  speed.  The  weight  per  axle  for 
this  class  of  locomotive  is  58,100  lbs.  It  was  assumed  that  the  effect  on 
the  track  of  the  experimental  truck,  running  at  about  five  miles  per  hour, 
was  about  as  great  as  that  of  an  "H8b"  locomotive  running  at  the  usual 
rate  of  speed.  Even  if  the  assumption  is  open  to  question,  the  results 
obtained  with  the  use  of  different  combinations  of  material  supporting  the 
tie  can  be,  at  least,  considered  comparative. 

In  order  to  conduct  the  experiments  as  rapidly  as  possible,  the  car, 
during  the  tests,  was  kept  running  night  and  day. 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST.  119 

The  running  back  and  forth  of  the  loaded  truck  over  the  track 
resulted  in  a  settlement  of  the  ballast  and  roadbed  materials  contained  in 
the  boxes.  After  a  settlement  was  noticed,  aggregating  about  an  inch, 
the  car  was  stopped  and  the  track  raised  to  its  original  elevation  and  sur- 
faced by  tamping  the  stone  ballast  with  tamping  picks  according  to  the 
usual  service  methods,  the  proper  elevation  and  levels  of  the  track  being 
determined  by  the  use  of  a  "Y"  level.  The  truck  was  then  started  and  the 
above  operation  repeated  from  time  to  time,  additional  ballast  being 
added,  when  necessary,  to  supply  the  loss  due  to  tamping  and  settlement. 

In  filling  the  boxes  in  each  test,  the  loam,  clay,  engine  cinder  or 
other  material,  except  the  stone  ballast,  was  compacted  by  a  rammer, 
care  being  taken  to  ram  each  box  and  each  kind  of  material  as  nearly  alike 
as  possible. 

The  truck  was  kept  running  and  the  accumulated  results  of  settle- 
ment were  noted  until  the  decrease  in  the  daily  settlement  was  so  marked 
that  it  was  considered  time  to  close  the  test,  when  the  boxes  were  opened 
and  at  each  end  three  vertical  sections  parallel  with  the  rail  were  cut  in 
the  ballast  and  roadbed  materials ;  the  first  was  taken  at  the  end  of  the 
tie ;  the  second  half-way  between  the  tie  and  the  end  of  the  rail ;  and  the 
third  beneath  the  rail.  Each  section  was  photographed,  also  carefully 
measured  by  the  use  of  the  "Y"  level,  to  show  the  curve  or  line  between 
the  ballast  and  the  various  materials  with  which  each  box  was  filled.  In 
addition,  measurements  were  made  in  the  same  manner  of  vertical  cross- 
sections  at  right  angles  to  the  track ;  first,  under  the  middle  of  the  north 
tie;  second,  under  the  middle  of  the  south  tie;  and  third,  midway  between 
the  two  ties.  The  data  thus  obtained  were  plotted  for  each  box,  in  each 
test,  and  appear  in  the  appendix. 

In  addition  to  this,  other  data  were  collected  showing  the  amount  of 
daily  settlement  of  the  rail  over  each  box ;  also,  the  amount  the  track  was 
raised  each  time  it  was  tamped.  The  total  number  of  trips  of  the  car 
was  recorded,  as  well  as  all  other  data  that  would  influence  the  results 
obtained. 

In  order  to  simulate  natural  conditions  as  to  rainfall,  water  in  known 
quantities  was  sprinkled  over  each  box  for  the  purpose  of  wetting  the 
ballast  and  roadbed  materials,  to  induce  settlement  and  possibly  to  pro- 
duce pumping  track,  but  the  latter  never  developed.  A  careful  record 
was  kept  showing  when  the  water  was  applied  and  of  the  amount  in  its 
equivalent  in  inches  of  rainfall. 

While  the  various  tests  were  being  conducted  the  ties  adjacent  to 
and  between  the  boxes  were  kept  slightly  loose,  as  far  as  tamping  was 
concerned,  in  order  that  the  full  weight  of  the  car,  in  passing,  would 
come  upon  the  two  ties  in  each  of  the  three  boxes. 

A  series  of  five  tests  has  been  completed;  the  first  one  beginning  on 
September  2,  1908,  and  the  last  one  ending  on  August  2,  1910. 

The  attached  diagram,  Fig.  4,  shows  the  relative  position  of  the 
various  kinds  of  material  used  in  each  box  and  for  each  of  the  five 
tests. 


120 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


&H 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


121 


'— 


122  DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 

TEST  NO.    I. 

In  filling  the  boxes  for  the  first  test  it  was  determined  to  use  8  in. 
of  standard  trap  rock  ballast  beneath  each  tie,  8  in.  of  ballast  being 
standard  for  single  track.  Beneath  the  ballast  in  one  box  were  27  in. 
of  yellow  clay  from  Neff s  Cut  on  the  Middle  Division,  which  had  proved 
itself  a  very  bad  and  unstable  material  for  roadbed  purposes.  In  the  sec- 
ond box,  beneath  the  8  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast,  were  placed  27  in.  of 
good  sandy  loam,  and  in  the  third  box,  beneath  the  8  in.  of  trap  rock 
ballast,  were  placed  12  in.  of  engine  cinder,  and  below  that  15  in.  of 
yellow  clay,  the  same  as  in  the  first  box.  The  track  was  then  surfaced 
by  the  use  of  tamping  picks,  brought  up  to  grade  and  the  boxes  filled  with 
standard  trap  rock  ballast  to  the  top  of  the  tie.  The  car  was  started  and 
elevations  taken  from  time  to  time  to  note  the  settlement  and  the  track 
was  raised,  by  tamping,  when  required,  as  before  described. 

After  the  car  had  made  about  4,000  round  trips,  water  was  applied  by 
sprinkling  it  equally  over  each  box,  first  applying  each  day  an  amount 
equivalent  to  one-half  inch  rainfall. 

After  a  few  days  this  amount  was  increased  to  2  in.  each  day  and 
continued  daily  for  quite  a  period,  when  the  amount  was  increased  to  4  in. 
per  day  for  about  a  week,  then  8  in.  per  day  applied  for  two  days,  in  the 
hope  of  producing  pumping  track,  but  this  was  not  accomplished  for  the 
reason  that  the  water  found  its  way  out  between  the  cracks  of  the  plank- 
ing about  as  fast  as  it  was  put  in. 

The  car  having  made  81,600  round  trips  and  the  track  over  the  boxes 
being  nearly  stationary,  that  is,  settling  very  slowly,  it  was  decided  to 
close  the  test. 

The  track  over  box  No.  1  had  settled  a  total  of  10&  in. ;  over  box 
No.  2,  a  total  of  14^5  in.,  and  over  box  No.  3,  a  total  of  io^i  in.  Water 
equivalent  to  a  rainfall  of  98^4  m-  had  been  sprinkled  over  each  box  dur- 
ing the  test.  After  the  ends  of  the  boxes  were  removed,  sections  and 
photographs  were  taken,  which  are  fully  shown  in  the  account  of  test  No.  1 
in  the  appendix. 

An  inspection  of  the  boxes  showed  that  in  every  case  the  depth  of 
the  ballast  beneath  the  bottom  of  the  tie  had  been  materially  increased, 
due  to  the  compression  of  the  roadbed  material  and  the  sinking  of  the 
ballast  into  the  material  beneath  it. 

Further,  the  line  of  demarkation  between  the  bottom  of  the  ballast  and 
the  roadbed  material  was  not  straight,  the  ballast  having  formed  a  saucer- 
like depression  in  the  roadbed  material  beneath  each  tie  under  each  rail. 

In  box  No.  3  the  original  12  in.  of  engine  cinder,  between  the  bottom 
of  the  ballast  and  the  top  of  the  clay,  were  very  considerably  compressed, 
the  bottom  of  the  ballast  immediately  under  the  rail  being  forced  about 
half  way  through  the  cinder.  On  the  other  hand,  the  clay  beneath  the 
cinder  showed  very  little  compression  and  the  line  of  demarkation  between 
the  bottom  of  the  cinder  and  the  clay  was  quite  straight,  while  the  line 
between  the  bottom  of  the  ballast  and  the  top  of  the  cinder  was  very  much 
depressed  under  each  tie. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST.  123 

The  test  showed  conclusively  that  a  depth  of  8  in.  of  standard  trap 
rock  ballast,  when  laid  on  the  usual  roadbed  material,  was  not  sufficient 
to  distribute  the  weight  carried  by  the  ties  uniformly  over  the  roadbed. 

The  results  in  the  third  box  showed,  however,  that  if  12  in.  of  per- 
meable material,  such  as  soft  coal  engine  cinder,  were  used  beneath  the 
8  in.  of  ballast,  the  distribution  of  the  weight  over  the  roadbed  material 
was  much  better,  as  is  shown  by  the  cross-sections  and  photographs. 

The  results  of  the  first  test  led  to  the  conclusion  that  a  second  test 
should  be  conducted  to  determine  how  a  depth  of  12  in.,  18  in.  and  24  in. 
of  trap  rock  ballast  under  the  ties  would  behave. 

The  experience  gained  from  the  first  test  suggested  that  better  results 
would  be  obtained  by  using  sandy  loam  beneath  the  ballast  rather  than 
yellow  clay,  because  the  first  test  showed  that  the  sandy  loam  was  more 
compressible  than  the  yellow  clay  and  that  the  line  dividing  the  ballast  and 
the  loam  was  easier  to  study  than  the  line  dividing  the  ballast  and  the  clay. 

test  no.  2. 

The  boxes  were  again  filled,  No.  1  box  having  12  in.  of  trap  rock 
ballast  beneath  the  tie,  with  26  in.  of  loam  underneath  it ;  box  No.  2  hav- 
ing 18  in.  of  ballast  under  the  tie,  with  19  in.  of  loam  beneath  it ;  and  box 
No.  3  having  24  in.  of  ballast  under  the  tie,  with  14  in.  of  loam  be- 
neath it. 

The  car  was  started  running  on  April  18,  1909,  and  practically  the 
same  method  was  pursued  as  in  test  No.  1,  already  described.  During 
the  test,  water  equivalent  to  nj4  in.  of  rainfall  was  applied.  After  the 
car  had  made  49,932  round  trips,  it  was  stopped  on  June  15,  1909,  because 
the  track  over  the  boxes  settled  very  slowly.  The  boxes  were  opened  and 
photographs  and  measurements  made,  as  are  shown  in  the  report  of  test 
No.  2,  in  the  appendix. 

An  inspection  of  the  boxes  clearly  showed  that  in  box  No.  1,  having 
12  in.  of  ballast  beneath  the  tie,  the  lower  surface  of  the  ballast  had  been 
compressed  a  considerable  distance  into  the  loam,  and  that  the  line  dividing 
the  two  was  far  from  straight,  there  being  a  considerable  depression  in  the 
line  beneath  each  tie,  especially  under  the  rail. 

In  box  No.  2,  where  there  were  18  in.  of  ballast  originally  under  the 
tie,  the  ballast  had  not  been  driven  so  far  down  into  the  loam  and  the 
dividing  line  was  much  straighter. 

In  box  No.  3,  having  24  in.  of  standard  trap  rock  ballast  beneath  the 
tie,  the  amount  of  ballast  settlement  was  still  less  and  the  line  between  it 
and  the  loam  quite  straight. 

In  test  No.  2,  measurements  were  taken  to  show  cross-sections  at 
right  angles  to  the  rail,  one  through  the  middle  of  each  tie  and  one  through 
the  center  between  the  two  ties. 

An  inspection  of  these  sections  will  confirm  the  conclusion  already 
reached,  as  it  will  be  noticed  the  deeper  the  ballast,  the  straighter  the  line 
between  it  and  the  loam. 

After  a  careful  consideration  of  the  data  presented  by  the  second  test, 


124  DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 

the  conclusion  seems  inevitable  that  with  standard  stone  ballast  nothing 
less  than  24  in.  beneath  the  tie  will  distribute  the  weight  of  the  load  uni- 
formly over  the  sub-grade  or  roadbed.  On  the  other  hand,  test  No.  1  had 
shown  that  a  depth  of  8  in.  of  stone  and  12  in.  of  cinder  gave  apparently 
fair  results  in  distributing  the  weight  upon  the  sub-grade. 

TEST    NO.    3. 

It  was  therefore  decided  to  fill  No.  1  box  with  24  in.  of  cinder  beneath 
the  ties  and  12  in.  of  loam  below  that ;  No.  2  box  and  No.  3  box  the  same ; 
to  run  a  number  of  trips  over  each  box  and  then  remove  from  No.  1  box 
8  in.  of  cinder  beneath  the  tie  tnd  substitute  for  it  8  in.  of  standard  trap 
rock  ballast;  in  No.  2  box  to  remove  12  in.  of  cinder  and  substitute  for  it 
12  in.  of  ballast  and  allow  No.  3  box  to  remain  without  any  change  in 
the  materials  and  then  run  a  number  of  trips  over  each  box.  The  object 
in  running  on  the  engine  cinder  before  putting  in  the  stone  ballast  was  to 
compact  it  in  a  similar  manner  to  actual  service  conditions  when  the 
track  is  first  ballasted  with  engine  cinder  and  later  raised  out  of  the  cinder 
upon  standard  stone  ballast. 

No.  3  test  was  started  on  June  28,  1909,  and  when  the  car  had  made 
45,500  round  trips  it  was  stopped  and  the  cinder  removed  and  stone  ballast 
put  in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2,  as  described  above. 

The  car  was  then  started  and  40,100  round  trips  were  made,  water 
being  applied  at  a  rate  equivalent  to  about  one-half  inch  of  rainfall  per 
day  until  a  total  of  15^4  'n-  had  been  sprinkled  over  each  box. 

In  the  previous  tests  it  had  been  noted  that  the  water  found  its  way 
through  the  stone  ballast  to  the  top  of  the  clay  or  loam  beneath  it  and 
there  collected  and  ran  through  the  cracks  between  the  planks. 

In  making  the  third  test  a  new  feature  was  introduced  in  one  of  the 
boxes  by  placing  therein,  on  top  of  the  loam,  beneath  the  24  in.  of  cinder, 
two  pieces  of  iron  pipe  perforated  with  many  holes.  Each  piece  of  pipe 
sloped  from  the  center  of  the  box  outward  to  the  ends  of  the  box,  a  slot 
being  made  in  each  end  of  the  box  opposite  the  end  of  the  pipe,  so  that  it 
could  be  watched. 

When  the  test  was  started,  on  June  28,  IQC.9,  water  equivalent  to  one- 
half  inch  of  rainfall  was  applied  daily.  This  was  in  progress  for  nine 
rlays,  until  water  equivalent  to  a  total  rainfall  of  4^4  in.  had  been  sprinkled 
on  box  No.  3  before  any  moisture  appeared  at  the  ends  of  the  iron  pipe, 
and  then  only  a  very  small  quantity  of  slime  began  to  ooze  out  at  the  ends. 
At  no  time  during  the  test  did  water  run  freely  from  the  ends  of  these 
pipes.  This  was  considered  a  very  significant  fact,  inasmuch  as  it  showed 
the  ability  of  engine  cinders  to  absorb  and  dissipate  a  large  amount  of 
water  falling  upon  it  before  the  water  was  able  to  reach  the  sub-grade  in 
sufficient  quantities  to  do  much  damage  by  saturating  it.  During  the 
experiments  the  pipes  were  carefully  watched  and  kept  clean  from  the 
inside,  so  that  any  water  reaching  them  could  be  observed. 

On  August  6,  1909,  after  85,600  round  trips  had  been  made  and  water 
equivalent  to  isYa  ™.  of  rainfall  had  been  sprinkled  on  each  of  the  boxes, 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST.  125 

they  were  opened,  sections  measured  and  photographs  taken,  as  shown  in 
report  of  test  No.  3,  in  the  appendix. 

A  study  of  the  sections  and  photographs  as  to  the  line  separating  the 
engine  cinder  and  the  loam,  showed  that  in  box  No.  3,  where  cinder  was 
continued  through  the  entire  test  and  no  stone  ballast  substituted,  the  line 
between  the  cinder  and  the  loam  was  the  straighiest  or  best,  showing  the 
least  amount  of  cupping,  and  that  the  line  between  the  cinder  and  the  loam 
in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2  left  very  little  to  choose  between  them,  with  a 
difference,  we  think,  slightly  in  favor  of  box  No.  2.  At  the  same  time  it 
should  be  clearly  noted  that  the  sections  taken  at  right  angles  to  the  track 
show  the  ties  bent  more  in  box  No.  3  than  they  did  in  either  boxes  No.  I 
or  No.  2,  due  to  the  fact  that  engine  cinder  is  more  compressible  than 
broken  trap  rock. 

A  study  of  the  lines  of  demarkation,  between  the  trap  rock  ballast 
and  engine  cinder  in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2,  develops  that  there  was  less 
deformation  or  cupping  of  the  cinder  beneath  the  ties  where  the  depth  of 
stone  ballast  had  originally  been  12  in.  in  box  No.  2  than  where  8  in.  in 
box  No.  1. 

test  no.  4. 

It  was  determined  upon  the  conclusion  of  test  No.  3  that  it  would  be 
well  to  test  two  other  materials  available  for  use  as  sub-ballast,  namely, 
granulated  slag  and  gravel,  to  see  how  they  would  compare  with  engine 
cinder  under  similar  conditions.  Therefore  test  No.  4  was  started,  boxes 
Nos.  1  and  2  having  24  in.  of  granulated  slag  under  the  ties  and  12  in. 
of  loam  beneath,  that ;  box  No.  3  having  24  in.  of  a  sandy  New  Jersey 
gravel  procured  along  the  Bonhampton  Branch  of  the  New  York  Division. 
After  the  boxes  were  filled  practically  the  same  method  was  pursued  as  in 
test  No.  3.  It  was  noted  that  the  compressibility  of  gravel  was  about  equal 
to  that  of  engine  cinder,  while  that  of  granulated  slag  was  much  greater. 

After  45.561  round  trips  had  been  made  by  the  car,  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2, 
respectively,  had  8  in.  and  12  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  put  in  beneath  the  ties 
and  on  top  of  the  granulated  slag,  while  box  No.  3  had  12  in.  of  standard 
trap  rock  ballast  put  in  on  top  of  the  gravel.  The  car  was  again  started 
and  run  for  40.060  round  trips. 

After  a  total  of  85.621  round  trips  had  been  made  and  water  equivalent 
to  14  in.  of  rainfall  had  been  sprinkled  over  each  box.  the  car  was  stopped 
on  December  3,  1909,  the  boxes  opened,  sections  measured  and  photographs 
taken,  as  before  described. 

This  test  developed  the  superiority  of  gravel  when  used  for  sub- 
ballast,  as  compared  with  granulated  slag,  the  granulated  slag  being  much 
more  compressible  and  unstable  than  the  gravel.  There  was  little  differ- 
ence, however,  in  the  line  dividing  the  slag  and  the  loam,  and  the  gravel 
and  the  lo?m.  This  would  seem  to  indicate  that  neither  material  had 
much  advantage  over  the  other  in  distributing  the  pressure  upon  the  loam. 
A  further  study  of  this  line  showed  that  in  box  No.  2,  where,  during  the 
latter  half  of  the  test,  there  were  12  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  beneath  the  tie, 


126  DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST. 

the  line  between  the  slag  and  the  loam  was  a  trifle  better  than  where  there 
were  only  8  in.  beneath  the  tie  in  box  No.  i. 

An  inspection  of  the  line,  dividing  the  trap  rock  ballast  and  slag  in 
boxes  Nos.  i  and  2,  and  the  ballast  and  the  gravel  in  box  No.  3,  showed 
that  there  was  more  cupping  or  deformation  where  the  ballast  was  only 
8  in.  deep  beneath  the  tie  on  top  of  the  slag  than  where  it  was  12  in.  deep 
beneath  the  tie  on  top  of  the  slag  or  gravel. 

Further,  the  line  in  box  No.  3,  between  the  trap  rock  ballast  and  the 
gravel,  was  still  better  than  between  the  stone  ballast  and  the  slag  in  box 
No.  2.  This  is  also  confirmed  by  an  inspection  of  the  sections  taken  at 
right  angles  to  the  track. 

test  no.  5. 

The  data  obtained  from  all  of  the  tests  up  to  this  point  indicate  that 
the  greater  the  depth  of  trap  rock  ballast,  beneath  the  tie,  at  least  to  a 
depth  of  24  in.,  the  less  deformation  there  is  in  the  line  dividing  the  trap 
rock  ballast  and  the  material  directly  beneath  it,  the  best  results  in  this 
respect  having  been  shown  with  a  depth  of  24  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast 
beneath  the  tie  in  box  No.  3  of  the  second  test.  This  brought  forward 
the  proposition  whether  it  would  be  possible,  by  a  combination  of  trap  rock 
ballast  and  engine  cinder,  having  a  total  depth  of  24  in.,  to  get  as  good  a 
distribution  of  weight  or  pressure  on  the  loam  as  was  obtained  by  a  depth 
of  24  in.  of  standard  trap  rock  ballast  alone.  And,  further,  would  such  a 
combination  of  standard  trap  rock  ballast  and  engine  cinder  show  too  much 
deformation  of  the  line  separating  the  stone  and  the  engine  cinder? 

To  determine  this,  if  possible,  test  No.  5  was  started  with  24  in.  of 
engine  cinder  beneath  the  ties  on  top  of  13  in.  of  loam  in  each  box.  The 
car  was  started  running  on  May  19,  1910,  and  19,210  round  trips  made  to 
compact  the  engine  cinder  until  the  daily  settlement  of  the  cinder  amounted 
to  very  little. 

On  June  24,  1910,  the  car  was  stopped  and  6  in.  of  standard  trap  rock 
ballast  were  placed  beneath  the  ties  in  box  No.  1 ;  8  in.  beneath  the  ties  in 
box  No.  2,  and  10  in.  beneath  the  ties  in  box  No.  3.  The  ballast  was 
tamped  with  tamping  picks  as  in  all  the  previous  tests.  The  car  was  run 
until  a  total  of  112,304  round  trips  had  been  made  and  water  equivalent 
to  a  rainfall  of  i&A  in.  had  been  sprinkled  over  each  box.  On  August  2, 
1910,  the  car  was  stopped,  the  track  having,  for  several  days  prior,  shown 
very  little  settlement.  The  boxes  were  opened,  and  the  usual  measure- 
ments made  and  photographs  taken. 

The  fifth  test  showed  that  there  was  less  total  settlement  in  box  No.  3, 
where  the  depth  of  the  stone  ballast  was  the  greatest,  namely,  10  in. 
beneath  the  tie.  Also,  that  there  was  less  deformation  or  cupping  between 
the  line  of  engine  cinder  and  the  loam,  and  between  the  line  of  ballast  and 
the  engine  cinder,  but  the  line  between  the  engine  cinder  and  the  loam  in 
box  No.  3  was  not  as  good  as  the  line  between  the  ballast  and  the  loam 
in  box  No.  3  of  test  No.  2,  where  there  were  24  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast 
beneath  the  tie  and  on  top  of  the  loam.  This  indicates  that  24  in.  of  trap 
rock  ballast  beneath  the  tie  will  distribute  the  pressure  upon  the  sub-grade 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST.  127 

more  uniformly  than  a  like  depth  of  trap  rock  ballast  and  compressed 
engine  cinder  combined,  up  to  the  point  where  the  layer  of  engine  cinder 
has  a  thickness  of  not  less  than  14  in.,  and  it  is  our  opinion  that  any  layer 
of  engine  cinder,  having  a  less  depth  than  14  in.,  would  be  sufficient  to 
produce  the  results  desired  by  the  use  of  engine  cinder,  viz.,  a  layer  of 
material  beneath  the  stone  ballast  which  will  absorb,  lead  off  and  dissipate 
water  falling  upon  the  track  before  it  can  reach  the  roadbed  proper  in 
sufficient  quantities  to  be  injurious. 

A  depth  of  24  in.  of  standard  trap  rock  ballast,  beneath  which  is  an 
additional  layer  or  mat,  24  in.  thick,  of  good  permeable  material,  will  place 
our  sub-grade  at  a  depth  below  the  average  frost  line  obtaining  in  the 
latitude  in  which  the  greater  part  of  our  system  is  located,  thereby  elim- 
inating the  trouble  due  to  the  action  of  the  frost  upon  the  roadbed  and 
track. 

Since  the  amount  of  wear  and  tear  imposed  on  the  experimental  track 
and  sub-soil  during  the  various  tests  was  very  small  compared  with  that 
to  which  our  main  line  tracks  are  subjected  under  service  conditions,  your 
Committee  recommends  the  use  of  24  in.  of  stone  ballast  underneath  the 
ties  to  meet  satisfactorily  the  conditions  that  exist  to-day  and  which  will 
probably  become  more  severe  as  time  goes  on,  and  that  in  addition  to  the 
24  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  beneath  the  ties,  there  should  be  provided  a 
layer  of  engine  cinder,  gravel  or  an  equivalent,  to  act  as  an  absorbent  mat 
to  promptly  and  properly  dispose  of  the  water  falling  on  the  track  in  such 
a  manner  as  to  prevent  its  softening  the  roadbed  material.  Where  the 
material  forming  the  roadbed  is  of  poor  quality,  the  mat  of  engine  cinder 
or  gravel  will  also  prove  advantageous  to  prevent  its  working  up  into  the 
ballast,  thus  shutting  off  drainage. 


APPENDIX. 


TEST  NO.  i. 
September  2,  1908,  to  January  5,  1905. 

MATERIAL  IN   BOXES. 

Box  No.  1 — 8  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  under  the  ties  and  27  in.  of  bad 
yellow  clay  below. 

Box  No.  2 — 8  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  under  t:es  and  27  in.  of  sandy 
loam  below. 

Box  No.  3 — 8  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  under  ties ;  12  in.  of  engine  cinder 
under  ballast  and  15  in.  of  bad  yellow  clay  below  cinder. 

The  car  was  started  on  September  2,  1908,  and  was  run  at  various 
intervals,  making  approximately  500  round  trips  to  October  2,  when  a 
register  was  pl?ced  on  the  car  for  recording  the  number  of  trips  made. 

The  total  settlement  for  the  81,600  round  trips  was  as  follows: 

Box  No.  1 — iofs  in. 
Box  No.  2 — I4tW  in. 
Box  No.  3 — io$4,  in. 

After  4,000  round  trips,  water  in  definite  quantities  v/as  sprayed  equally 
on  each  box  daily.  A  total  amount  of  water  equivalent  to  98^  hi.  of  rain- 
fall was  used. 

On  January  5,  1909,  freezing  weather  made  it  impracticable  to  obta'.n 
any  further  results,  and  as  the  settlement  curves  showed  a  tendency  to  run 
horizontally,  the  first  test  was  closed. 


128 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


129 


130 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST. 


131 


132 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


133 


■t  , 


134 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


135 


136 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


137 


138 


DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


139 


—+-$ 


140 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


I  BM 


aUV*SS 


Ni'iS 

t  Q 

Ji 


~~l* 

^ 


X 

o 

*     s 


d3 


o     -^ 


DEPTH    OF   STONE    BALLAST. 


141 


142 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


143 


144 


DEPTH  OF   STONE  BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF   STONE    BALLAST. 


145 


f) 


o 

* 

5 
■i 


\  5 
<  8' 

0  0 

* 
8 

(0 


ui 


U__L 


■'*• 


146 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


147 


m 

B 

— *,»  p»*'»a 

i<i  p»»!»,3 

■it  p-»»:»^j. 

■".3 

.11    p»»ITJ 

»»i  p»«'<a 
•<  i»«ria 
.» ♦••>»<a 
**  **«t«ai' 

.«    po«%a 

.i  »»»>ia 
••*  ^wa 


'«^!-i  P^"»«Q  O09IQ 


in 


TO 


5e  i<j< 


i  ?  s  n  i,i  1 1  *•*  »,* 


Lftr*  i 

0  : 

Hr'         5 
SpJI\  ■  u.'*. 

11 1  '  • 

1 

1 

r      *      i 

tt5   ItltlSHSt}  }  I  HHtiliH? 


148  DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


TEST  NO.  2. 
April  18  to  June  15,  1009. 

MATERIAL   IN    BOXES. 

Box  No.  1 — 12  in.  trap  rock  ballast  under  ties  and  26  in.  of  loam 
below. 

Box  No.  2 — 18  in.  trap  rock  ballast  under  ties  and  19  in.  of  loam 
below. 

Box  No.  3 — 24  in.  trap  rock  ballast  under  ties  and  14  in.  of  loam 
below. 

The  car  was  started  on  the  18th  of  April,  1909,  and  continued  to  June 
15,  making  49,932  trips,  running  in  the  daytime  only. 

Water  was  put  on  each  box  during  the  test  to  an  amount  equivalent 
to  11^4  m-  rainfall. 

The  total  settlement  for  box  No.  1  was  8^  in. ;  for  box  No.  2,  g*/&  in., 
and  for  box  No.  3,  g%  in. 

Upon  opening  the  boxes  on  June  15  it  was  found  that  the  loam  in 
each  box  had  been  compressed  an  average  of  8  in.  in  box  No.  1,  6  in.  in 
box  No.  2,  and  2>Va  m-  in  box  No.  3. 

Photographs  and  elevations  taken  at  the  time  of  opening  the  boxes 
show  that  the  loam  in  box  No.  1  received  the  greatest  pressure  directly 
under  the  ties,  thereby  causing  unequal  settlement  of  the  loam  and  the 
formation  of  hollows  under  the  ties.  This  effect  was  noticeable  in  box 
No.  2,  but  to  a  less  degree,  and  in  box  No.  3,  with  24  in.  of  stone  ballast, 
the  pressure  was  so  evenly  distributed  over  the  loam  that  only  a  very  slight 
cupping  effect  was  noticed. 

By  taking  elevations  through  the  boxes  at  right  angles  to  the  track 
it  was  found  that  the  greatest  elevation  existed  along  a  line  parallel  to  and 
equidistant  from  the  rails.  From  this  line  the  surface  of  the  loam  inclined 
towards  the  ends  of  the  ties,  with  a  cupping  directly  under  the  rails.  Box 
No.  3  showed  the  most  uniform  surface  of  sub-grade. 

It  was  found  that  the  water  had  not  penetrated  the  loam  to  a  greater 
depth  than  three  or  four  inches  and  at  the  time  of  investigation  trickled 
out  over  the  sub-grade  in  small  streams. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


149 


150 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


151 


152 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


153 


154 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST. 


165 


156 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


157 


in 


OK 
A3  o 


$1 


<0 


■  *  u  * 

i  If 


D  * 

r  o 
*>1 


158 


DEPTH  OF  STONE  BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


159 


160 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


0 

p* 

J*. 

<j 

! 

P 

0 

w» 

id 

0 

0 

E 

0 

1 

L- 

cJ 

w+- 

d 

h 

DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


161 


162 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


163 


164 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


165 


166 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


ft 
It 


w 


ft 

Qtr: 

I  0 

sl 

^< 

0  0 


<0 


F> 


0  0* 

o  *  ^ 

z  S  -  y 

15   >  » 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


167 


168 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


169 


170 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


171 


172 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


173 


174 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


175 


176 


DEPTH   OF  STONE   BALLAST. 


H 

A 

•    w 

.«- 

"    ,f6  -4*?©" 

»  :  i .     •-'_,      '  '      ''.-.-■     ':■ 

•      ,!l    ' 

w^wjgB-iJfog?.        y 

. 

xiwwniu-j.aC?  -iv±oj_        '  j 

•£     c 

'        1 

- 

1 

I 

•  ■■■':;  .  r 

i'    ';■■'             ■  ""V    <f)'"=-'       '    ■ 

':!.'■■         .,•    ;|t      •  ■■.'■: 

.  -   our 

.       p=>c.?3 

/■ 

'       ■'    -       •■'            !-r  8'7 »,    ' 

OS 

• 

.  2  n    3    a. 

........                               «j  <  to           ,i 

•••  ■         •    '       -  P       •   K 

1 

L  Of'             »S 

,  -  .    •    ..       fr  •  •    •■*•    . 

■■        '      '.  ■  ■  ■  .      trj  "      '  '    ■•** 

i?                 ■":.'•'•  i 

•  ■  Jfs.. 

.p? 

s                         ;                    -        . 

■      " '      -? 

,  I  ■ 

<                  -i 

6 

»~!tt 

■  :   •         .  ' 

'       V     '."'                             <0. 

V* 


KM? 

'  s 

»* 

1 

SB  *  ! 

K> 

•Hrf 

B' '  - 

5 1 

85.  >•  i 

pj 

UJ  m| 

-*i 


St    9 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST.  177 

TEST  NO.  3. 
June  28  to  August  6,  1909. 

MATERIAL    IN    BOXES. 

Each  box  had  directly  under  ties  24  in.  of  engine  cinder  free  from 
clinkers,  below  which  was  12  in.  of  rich  loam.  The  loam  was  put 
into  the  boxes  in  layers  of  6  in.  in  depth,  firmly  compacted,  but  not 
stamped  hard.  The  cinder  was  filled  in  and  forced  under  ties  by  using  a 
short  piece  of  plank  as  a  stamper.  The  car  was  started  June  28  and  con- 
tinued running  until  July  20,  when  45,500  trips  had  been  completed.  Water 
was  put  on  from  the  first  in  such  quantity  to  correspond  to  one-half  inch 
rainfall  per  day.    By  July  20  there  had  been  added  8^4  in-  of  water. 

The  total  settlement  for  45,500  trips  was  as  follows :  Box  No.  1,  V/2 
in. ;  box  No.  2,  S}i  in.,  and  box  No.  3,  724  in. 

For  the  first  few  days  it  was  found  necessary  to  raise  and  tamp  the 
track  twice  a  day.  The  total  settlement  for  the  first  five  days  was  as  fol- 
lows :  Box  No.  1,  4  in. ;  box  No.  2,  4^  in.,  and  box  No.  3,  3^  in.  The 
thirteen  days  following,  in  which  time  more  than  five  times  as  many  trips 
were  completed,  show  settlement  for  box  No.  1  of  4J/2  in.;  box  No.  2,  of 
zYa  in.,  and  box  No.  3,  of  454  in. 

On  July  20,  after  the  completion  of  45,500  trips,  it  was  thought  ad- 
visable to  begin  the  second  part  of  test  No.  3,  to  cut  off  8  in.  of  cinder  from 
the  top  of  box  No.  1,  and  12  in.  from  the  top  of  box  No.  2,  and  fill  in  with 
clean  trap  rock  ballast.  The  chief  factor  in  determining  the  time  at  which 
to  introduce  stone  ballast  was  the  form  of  the  settlement  curve  just  pre- 
vious to  July  20.  This  curve  at  first  fell  off  rapidly,  gradually  becoming 
less  and  less  steep  until  the  time  of  change,  when  it  began  to  show  signs 
of  running  nearly  horizontally. 

Box  No.  3  was  left  as  at  first  filled,  and,  with  the  changes  in  boxes 
Nos.  1  and  2  as  indicated,  the  car  began  running  on  July  21  and  continued 
until  August  6,  having  made  40,100  additional  trips. 

Statement  of  Conditions. 
First  part,  Second  part, 

45,500  trips.  40,100  trips. 


Each  box  contained 
12  in.  of  loam  and 
24  in.  of  cinder. 


8  in.  cinder  removed  and 
Box  No.  1  J    g  in    trap  rock  balJast  added 

>  j  12  in.  cinder  removed  and 

Box  No.  2  j>  I2  ;n   trap  rQck  ballast  added 

Box  No.  3      Remained  as  in  first  part  of  test. 


The  settlement  for  the  second  part  of  the  test  from  July  21  to  August 
6,  was  as  follows:  Box  No.  1,  2^4  in. ',  box  No.  2,  2%  in.,  and  box  No. 
3,  2H  in. 

The  total  amount  of  water  on  each  box  during  the  entire  run  of 
85,600  trips  was  1534  in.,  extending  over  a  period  of  32  days,  or  an  average 
of  about  one-half  inch  per  day. 


178 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


179 


'{.'• .   .-  ,  ;•    "   , 


180 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


181 


182 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


183 


184 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


185 


186 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


- 

PF-v" 

'  V- 

l                                  V 

fO 

or     ! 

,-        ! 

i 

*       1 

to 

i 

i  i 

h 

IT. 

.. 

<  J 

h 

j         •                                                                   S         J                                          i^ 

X  < 

lii 

flj            s 

£* 

F 

ojij                         ~                        •''•  ' 

•     ? 

0  o 

o 

ul    . 

< 
O 

10 
< 

o 

-.1.  5    ":  i 

o  z         S                 <= 
t  -.'       ?               < 

j 

li 

§1 

0") 

o 

0) 

E* 

6 

ui    . 

0) 

1 

n                     *     | 

1 

i 

1 

. 

s 

in 

DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


187 


188 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


189 


190 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


191 


15 
L 


-t- 


192 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPfrt-OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


193 


191 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


195 


ft 


CDr, 


z  I 

0  o 

w 

0) 


< 

c 

01 

ui     I 

F  ! 

0 

til, 

a: 

< 

D 

0 

10 

0 

kJ         1 

T           j 

*H 

t 

< 

a: 

1 

F*Z 


'2<0  £ 


196 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


197 


198 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


199 


3 

•+-  ~z 
i    0 

4-4- 


200 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


201 


202 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


203 


204 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


205 


01 
OP 


t.    0     _i 
?     o    ~ 


m  o 

«? 
ni 

CO 


flav/»  o/*  Ctn&*r 


[J  CD  CO 

0    0    0 


epkjccd  by  J5/or?e  QaUaat-  A****  Zo 


CB  CD  CDOI 


?$? 


206  DEPTH  OF  STONE  BALLAST. 

TEST  NO.  4. 

October  19  to  December  3,  1909. 

First  Part. 

MATERIAL  IN    BOXES. 

Box  No.  1 — 24  in.  of  granulated  furnace  slag  under  ties  and  12  in. 
of  sandy  loam  below. 

Box  No.  2 — Same  as  box  No.  1. 

Box  No.  3 — 24  in.  of  sandy  gravel  from  Bonhampton  Branch,  New 
York  Division,  under  ties,  and  12  in.  of  sandy  loam  below. 

Water  was  sprinkled  on  the  boxes  during  the  run  to  the  amount 
of  one-half  inch  per  day,  a  total  of  8  in.  being  applied  in  the  first  part 
and  6  in.  in  the  second  part  of  test,  or  a  grand  total  of  14  in. 

The  loam  was  well  forked  and  all  lumps  broken,  spread  evenly  to 
a  depth  of  6  in.,  then  compacted  with  a  tamper  weighing  about  20  lbs. 
Each  layer  was  treated  in  a  similar  manner  and  tamped  hard  enough 
to  support  a  man's  weight  without  leaving  undue  depressions.  The 
degree  of  compactness  was  also  tested  by  prodding  with  the  unsharpened 
end  of  a  lead  pencil. 

The  slag  in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2  was  placed  carefully  upon  the  loam 
sub-grade  in  layers   of  6  in.,   each  being  tamped  as   above  mentioned. 

Box  No.  3,  in  which  gravel  was  placed  upon  the  loam,  was  treated 
in  a  similar  manner. 

On  the  morning  of  October  16  the  car  completed  12  trial  trips,  when 
it  was  found  necessary  to  shut  down  on  account  of  the  excessive  settle- 
ment of  slag  in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2.  The  gravel  held  much  better,  but 
showed  considerable  settlement. 

Track  was  raised  on  October  18,  and  well  tamped ;  the  necessary 
slag  and  gravel  «dded,  and  the  car  made  ten  trial  trips,  when  it  became 
necessary  to  shut  down  again  and  retamp  boxes  on  account  of  settle- 
ment, when  the  car  made  fifty  round  trips  before  it  again  became  neces- 
sary to  shut  down  since  the  slag  showed  little  supporting  power. 

The  roadbed  external  to  the  boxes  was  very  solid,  being  made  of 
limestone  screenings,  which  was  subjected  to  constant  wetting  and  load 
and  had  become  very  hard. 

In  order  to  allow  the  track  to  settle  uniformly,  water  was  constantly 
run  upon  the  roadbed  outside  of  the  boxes  from  a  three-fourths  inch 
hose,  and  the  ties  kept  pumping.  As  the  slag  in  boxes  Nos.  1  and  2 
compacted  under  the  ties,  more  slag  was  worked  under  from  time  to 
time.  The  gravel  in  box  No.  3  held  well — even  better  than  the  cinder 
similarly  used  in  Test  No.  3.  On  this  day,  October  19,  the  car  had 
completed  735  round  trips. 

On  October  21,  the  track  was  raised  and  the  sprinkling  of  water  on 
the  boxes  commenced,  by  means  of  a  three-fourths  inch  garden  hose 
attached  to  a  graduated  oil  barrel. 

The  quantity  of  water  put  on  each  box  per  day  was  one-half  inch, 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST.  207 

one-fourth  inch  the  first  thing  in  the  morning  and  another  one-fourth 
inch  at  noon. 

On  October  23  the  slag  was  developing  supporting  power,  and  on 
the  25th  the  track  was  secure  enough  to  allow  the  continual  running  of 
the  car  day  and  night. 

With  a  few  interruptions  it  ran  until  November  17,  when  45,561 
round  trips  had  been  completed,  the  same  number  of  round  trips  as 
were  made  in  the  first  part  of  Test  No.  3. 

The  settlement  for  the  first  part  of  the  test  up  to  November  17 
was  as  follows :     Box  No.  1,  12J/2  in. ;  box  No.  2,  1^/2  in.,  and  box  No. 

3.  &/s  in- 

The  following  table  gives  some  idea  of  the  relative  compressibility 
of  the  slag  and  gravel : 

Amount  of  Material. 

Put  in  at  Added  to 

Beginning.  November  16.      Per  Cent.  Added. 

Box  No.  1 — Slag....  156  cu.  ft.  105  cu.  ft.                  67.3 

Box  No.  2— Slag 147  cu.  ft.  126  cu.  ft.                  85.7 

Box  No.  3 — Gravel.. 108  cu.  ft.  39  cu.  ft.                   36.1 

Note. — Measurements  were  made  of  material  in  small  quantities  and 
when  material  was  loose,  before  being  placed  and  packed  in  boxes. 

Second  Part. 

On  November  17  some  of  the  slag  and  part  of  the  gravel  was  replaced 
by  trap  rock  ballast,  as  follows : 

Statement  of  Conditions. 

First  part,  Second  part, 

45,561  trips.  40,060  trips. 

12  in.   of  loam  '1  J    8  in.  of  slag  removed  and 

24   in.   of  slag  J  Box  No>  *  \   8  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  added. 

(  12  in.  of  slag  removed  and 
Same  as  Box  No.  1  Box.  No.  2  |  J2  jn    of  trap  rQck  baUast  added 

24  in.  of  loam  1  (  12  in.  of  gravel  removed  and 

24  in.  of  gravel  J  Box  No"  3  \  12  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  added. 

The  stone  was  carefully  added  to  the  boxes  so  that  the  surface  of 
the  sub-ballast  should  not  be  disturbed.  The  slag  and  gravel  under 
the  ties  broke  off  in  pieces  as  large  as  one's  head,  and  did  not  crumble 
on  being  dropped  upon  the  ground.  Picks  were  used  to  loosen  both 
slag  and  gravel   for  removal   by   shovels. 

Nothing  unusual  was  remarked  during  the  second  part  of  Test  No. 

4,  which  was  finished  on  December  3,  after  a  total  of  85,621  round  trips 
had  been  made  for  the  entire  test.  The  curve  shows  greater  settlement 
than  for  Test  No.  3,  probably  due  to  greater  compressibility  of  sub- 
ballast,  except  in  the  gravel. 


208 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


209 


210 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


211 


212 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


213 


214 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


215 


216 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


217 


218 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


1 

Am 

: 

\       ..'{- 

DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


219 


220 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


221 


222 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


223 


224 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


H 


-D 


X 
0 

(D 

I 

0 

D 

o 

&: 

z 

o 
0 

-J 

<n 
2 
0 

F 

u 
m 

<0 


ir>s 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


225 


226 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


227 


228 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


229 


230 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


231 


232 


DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


233 


234 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


n 


2 


It 

Li  o 

xr  n 


2w 

Uj  Ul 


1 

6 


F 
p 

id 

< 

j 
0 

6 

uJ 


.. 

i 

-; 

< 

mi 

•i 

r 

J  1 

;  o 

j 

?i  1 

V 

** 

I 

Q     i 

i  ■ 

0: 

>| 

D; 

! 

>j 

.6 

DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


235 


WfTff 


ul 

U  >»*  £  8 

Hi  W      h   K 

2  to  36 

«i  a  io 

r  n 


K 


fl 


236  DEPTH    OF   STONE   BALLAST. 

TEST  NO.  5. 

May  19  to  August  2,  1910. 

First  Part. 

MATERIAL  IN   BOXES. 

Each  box  contained  exactly  24  in.  of  engine  cinder  below  bottom 
of  ties,  with  about  13  in.  of  loam  below  the  cinder.  The  loam  had  been 
well  forked,  all  lumps  broken  and  all  small  stone  eliminated.  It  was 
spread  evenly  in  4-in.  layers,  each  layer  being  compacted  by  tamping 
with  a  tamper  weighing  about  20  lbs.  The  degree  of  compactness  was 
tested  by  prodding  with  the  unsharpened  end  of  a  lead  pencil.  When 
the  last  layer  of  loam  was  properly  tamped,  the  high  places  were  cut 
off  to  make  the  surface  level  to  the  desired  elevation. 

The  cinder  was  spread  carefully  upon  the  loam  sub-grade  in  4-in. 
layers,  each  layer  being  thoroughly  tamped  as  above.  The  cross-ties 
were  well  rammed  with  cinder,  so  that  the  bottom  of  each  tie  was  at 
the  proper  elevation  with  24  in.  of  cinder  under  it. 

The  car  was  started  on  May  19,  and  ran  at  intervals  until  June 
24,  when  19,210  round  trips  had  been  completed.  Prior  to  June  1,  water 
was  sprinkled  on  the  boxes  in  such  quantity  as  to  correspond  to  a  total 
of  one-inch  rainfall,  and  thereafter  on  each  day  that  the  car  ran,  one- 
half  inch  of  water  was  thus  applied,  until  on  June  24  there  had  been  a 
total  of  4V2  in.  of  water  applied  to  each  box. 

The  settlement  for  the  first  part  of  the  test  was  as  follows :  Box 
No.  1,  2^4  >n- ;  box  No.  2,  2]/%  in.,  and  box  No.  3,  2V2  in. 

Second  Part. 

On  June  24,  it  was  thought  advisable  to  begin  the  second  part  of 
Test  No.  5,  by  substituting  certain  depth  of  clean  trap  rock  ballast 
instead  of  engine  cinder.  As  in  previous  tests,  the  chief  factor  in  deter- 
mining the  time  for  introducing  stone  ballast  was  the  form  of  the 
settlement  curves  just  previous  to  June  24,  when  the  settlement  was 
becoming  less  daily,  as  compared  with  the  first  few  days  of  the  test. 
The  decrease  in  settlement  just  prior  to  June  24,  indicated  that  the 
materials  in  the  boxes  had  become  well  compacted,  and  in  all  probability 
would  not  show  much  more  settlement. 

The  statement  of  conditions  below  shows  the  changes  in  the  ma- 
terials in  the  boxes  when  the  car  was  again  started  on  June  24,  con- 
tinuing until  August  2,  making  93,094  additional  round  trips,  or  a  total 
of  112,304  round  trips. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST.  237 

Statement  of  Conditions. 
First  part,  Second  part, 

19,210  trips.  93,094  trips. 


Each  box  contained 
about  13  in.  of  loam  < 
and  24  in.  of  cinder. 


/  6  in.  cinder  removed  and 

^  6  in.  trap  rock  ballast  added. 

/  8  in.  cinder  removed  and 

I  8  in.  trap  rock  ballast  added. 


10  in.  cinder  removed  and 
'    3 1   10  in.  trap  rock  ballast  added. 
The  settlement  for  the  second  part  of  the  test,   June  24  to  August 

2,  was  as  follows:     Box  No.  1,  ^A  in- J  box  No.  2,  5 -is-  in.,  and  box  No. 

3,  AV2  in. 

The  total  amount  of  water  sprinkled  on  each  box  during  the  entire 
run  of  112,304  round  trips  was  equivalent  to  i%V2  in.  of  rainfall,  extend- 
ing over  a  period  of  46  running  days,  or  an  average  of  almost  one-half 
inch  per  running  day,  after  June  1. 

For  several  days  prior  to  August  2,  the  curves  showed  little  ma- 
terial settlement,  and  having  made  even  more  trips  than  was  made  in 
Test  No.  3,  namely,  85,600,  the  car  was  stopped  and  the  boxes  opened 
on  that  date. 


238 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


239 


240 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


241 


242 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


243 


244 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


245 


246 


DEPTH   OF   STONE  BALLAST. 


x  ± 

°% 
a  « 

lO 
**  u  *~ 

2«g 

QOTH 

03  $  I 

0(5 

o 


(0*0 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


247 


248 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


*"K}£ar   *^^'-^^^:~    ".;  ,, 


>'\ 


.m^mjw: 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


249 


250 


DEPTH   OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


251 


252 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


253 


a: 

■  ■■ 


K 

0 

03 
X 

O 
tx. 
I 
K 

O 

z 
o 


Z 

o 
h 

w 
UJ 


i 

~i 

M 

t  it 

;  i 
:  1 

254 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


10 


O 

ffi 

x 
o 

3 
O 

I 
h 

O 
Z 

o 
o 

-J 

(A 

z 
o 

O 
u 


<0» 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


255 


c  < 

CD  - 
lO 

'-   X  2 
X 

O  st 

CD  %  '■ 


1.5 


256 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


257 


258 


DEPTH    OF    STONE    BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


259 


260 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


261 


262 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


O 

.a 

I 

u 

3 
0 

K 

I 
h 

z 

0 

0 

■J 

0 

V 

o 

u 


^H 


fL^L 


SIS 


|g§ra~^^^ 


K8H 


CO. 

0 

z 

X 

O 

CD 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


263 


X 

0 

01 

X 

13 

3 
0 
K 

I. 
h 

Z 

;2 
0 
0 


z 

r-. 

h 
O 

UJ 

-n 


<  ! 

ac  j 

K 
ft 


hip 


o 

x     j 
I     O 

CD 


UJ 
D 
Z 

u 


7  \ 

A 


kU 


IIS 


264 


DEPTH   OF   STONE   BALLAST. 


DEPTH    OF    STONE   BALLAST. 


265 


2  ■  B    a 

o     o     b     o     o 


3.     (i 

ij 


-■. 


(0     «     H     *.C 


M 


«?     .- 

. 

•)/      F*-"T. 

ff? 

uo 

H 

: 

^ 

SI 

I? 

I 

r  5  i 

i? 

ri 

^ 

•1 

:  i 

* 

0   V 

, 

~ 

.  9 

M> 

•-£* 

b  u 

1  at-n,* 

■i 
i 

*     j  . 

1          V  V 

"3 

? 

h 
Z 

1 

* 

M 
t 

iij 

9- 

oS"^ 

.     Si 

ai    ■ 

•  7v4 

I       ,  5  V 

V 

i 

3 

X 

1 

5       T  -;  ' 

'  g  2 

|J        J~"B 

/. 

8    8 

e    S    8    a    8    13 

0       0       o       <j       0       0 

i    8    8 

■a   8  a 

*  p  » 

'« 

1 

0      0 

6     0      0 

0       o      s 

o-oo 

0 

GRAVEL   AS    BALLAST. 

In  connection  with  their  work  for  1910,  Committee  I — Roadway,  had 
a  sub-committee  at  work  on  the  question  of  "Unit  Pressure  on  Road- 
bed," and  Committee  II — Ballast,  one  on  the  correlated  question  of 
"Necessary  Depth  of  Ballast,"  and  at  a  joint  meeting  of  these  sub- 
committees a  paper  on  "Gravel  as  Ballast,"  by  C.  Brauning,  which  Mr. 
W.  M.  Dawley  had  translated  from  "Zeitschrift  fur  Bauwesen,"  Vol. 
LIV,  Berlin,  1904,  was  discussed,  and  accepted  as  valuable  information 
for  the  members  of  the  Association. 

It  was  considered  that  the  paper  should  be  published  in  a  Bulletin 
of  the  Association  as  a  progress  report  of  the  work  of  the  committees, 
rather  than  hold  it  for  a  final  report,  and  accordingly  it  is  presented 
herewith. 


266 


Appendix   C. 

(Bulletin   136.) 
GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 

By  C   Brauning. 

Translated  from   "Zeitschrift  fur  Bauwesen,"  Vol.   LIV,   Berlin,   1904,   under 
direction  of  Committee  I — Roadway,  and  Committee  II— Ballast. 

Owing  to  its  high  cost,  hard  stone,  crushed,  can  only  be  afforded 
for  ballast  in  roadbeds  which  are  heavily  taxed  with  traffic,  while 
stretches  taxed  to  a  less  extent  must  resort,  at  least  for  some  time  to 
come,  to  material  near  at  hand,  mostly  river  or  mountain  gravel.  Still, 
increasing  speed  and  weight  of  rolling  stock  on  these  less  severely  taxed 
stretches  are  making  heavier  demands  upon  the  ballast,  principally  in  the 
direction  of  greater  resistance  to  change  of  position  of  the  rails.  The 
greater  carrying  capacity  of  crushed  stone  is  principally  due  to  the  many 
sharp  edges  of  the  individual  pieces.  This  gives  it  the  high  resistance 
when  used  as  ballast,  which  is  not  greatly  reduced  under  shock.  On  the 
other  hand,  the  gravel  pieces  give  way  easily  under  pressure  and  lose 
still  further  in  resistance  when  subjected  to  shock.  These  different  char- 
acteristics of  crushed  stone  and  gravel  affect  the  roadbed,  first,  in  that 
they  determine  the  cross-sectional  shape  of  the  ballast;  secondly,  the 
support  to  be  given  the  track,  and,  thirdly,  the  shape  and  spacing  of  the 
cross-ties.  While  there  is  ample  data  at  hand  regarding  the  properties 
of  crushed  stone  as  ballast,  available  through  Schubert's  investigations, 
the  object  of  this  article  is  to  determine  to  what  extent  gravel  makes 
possible  a   uniform  and   permanent  roadbed. 

The  observations,  therefore,  direct  themselves  first  to  the  conditions 
to  be  met.  It  was  desirable  to  follow  out  the  changes  in  different  indi- 
vidual roadbed  stretches  and  note  their  greater  or  lesser  durability  in 
comparison  with  the  peculiar  characteristics  of  the  ballast  of  each  stretch. 
Previous  observations  in  this  direction  were  not  complete  (Zeitschrift  fur 
Bauwesen,  1896,  page  546).  Hence,  they  were  extended,  new  trial  stretches 
under  more  varying  conditions  selected,  and  the  measurements  themselves 
perfected,  namely,  by  more  securely  anchoring  the  bench  marks  outside  of 
the  roadbed.  The  ballast  of  the  observed  stretches  consisted  of  a  mix- 
ture of  coarse  and  fine  gravel  with  a  sand  content  of  25  to  33  per  cent., 
consisting  of  grains  under  1  mm.  greatest  diameter.  The  cross-ties  were 
spaced  750  to  840  mm.  The  traffic  over  the  roadbed  yearly  amounted 
to  about  1.2  million  tons.  Among  the  daily  trains  which  covered  these 
stretches  were  several  which  had  a  velocity  of  75  kilometers  per  hour  and 
more.  The  observations  were  continued  two  years,  the  elevation  of  the 
rails  was  taken  every  two  months,  and  during  affecting  weather  condi- 
tions more  often.  It  was  determined  that  the  most  important  observa- 
tions came  just  previous  to  the  occurrence  of,  during  the  time  of  the 
heaviest,  and  just  after  the  complete  disappearance  of  frost  The  rail 
elevations  at  the  above  mentioned  times  are  shown  in  Figs.  1  to  4,  Plate  I. 

267 


268  GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 

The  horizontal  base  line  indicates  the  first  observed  condition  during  the 
autumn,  the  lines  II,  III  and  IV  the  altered  elevations  during  the  severest 
time  of  winter,  of  spring,  and  of  the  following  fall,  respectively.  The 
elevations  are  to  the  scale  1=1.166,  while  the  lengths  are  greatly  con- 
tracted. .3 

Under  each  group  of  observations  is  a  longitudinal  section  through 
the  track  which  illustrates  the  composition  of  the  ballast  and  sub-soil 
and  the  depth  of  the  frost  line.  The  changes  observed  for  the  first  year 
and  for  the  second  were  so  similar  that  the  observations  for  one  year 
only  are  given. 

It  is  to  be  noted  from  the  illustrations  that  close  relations  exist 
between  the  different  elevations  of  the  rails  and  the  nature  of  the  soil 
upon  which  the  roadbed  rests.  Every  clay  and  clay-bearing  soil  drove 
the  track  upward,  and  as  other  observations  indicated,  also  towards  the 
sides.  The  more  uniform  such  soil  is,  and  the  more  uniformly  it  is  dis- 
tributed, the  more  uniform  the  tendency  to  lift  the  track  seems  to  be, 
and  to  lower  it  again  after  the  disappearance  of  frost.  Fig.  2,  Plate  I, 
in  its  first  half,  and  illustration  1  in  its  second  half  give  a  clear  repre- 
sentation of  this  effect.  Irregular  mixtures  of  sand  and  clay,  as  occur 
in  earthen  embankments  such  as  are  formed  by  dumping  led  to  very 
unfavorable  action  in  spots,  owing  to  the  fact  that  the  earth,  due  to  the 
action  of  the  frost,  was  unevenly  forced  upward  and  outward  and  did 
not  by  far  regain  its  original  position  after  frost  had  disappeared  (Fig. 
4,  Plate  I).  Clean  and  evenly  fine  grained  sand  proved  to  be  quite  con- 
stant under  the  action  of  frost,  and  a  similar  absence  of  the  expansive 
force  of  frost  was  noted  in  the  gravel  ballast  itself,  though  it  was  not 
entirely  free  from  earthy  constituents. 

During  the  seasons  of  no  frost  such  apparent  influences  of  the  soil 
underneath  the  ballast  were  not  noted.  The  effect  of  the  deposits,  which 
came  principally  into  consideration  here,  changed  itself  according  to  the 
water-absorbing  capacity  of  the  clay-bearing  sub-soil,  but  the  contour  of 
the  sub-grade  varied  within  such  narrow  limits  that  it  was  impossible  to 
observe  individual  changes.  In  the  summer  time  the  sinking  of  the  rails 
was  generally  very  small  and  hardly  measureable.  Several  times  notice 
was  taken  of  the  rising  of  the  rails  up  to  2  mm. — however,  only  at  the 
hottest  time  of  the  year. 

In  order  to  illustrate  more  clearly  the  changes  taking  place  in  the 
rail  surfaces  in  relation  to  the  seasons  and  the  condition  of  the  sub-soils, 
cross-sectional  views  illustrating  the  sinking  and  rising  of  distinct  groups 
of  the  stretches  under  observation  in  continuous  line  for  two  years  are 
given  in  Figs,  ia  to  4b,  Plate  I. 

Of  all  the  changing  lines,  those  of  Figs.  2  and  2b,  Plate  I,  between 
the  points  13  to  18,  are  of  particular  importance.  The  rail  and  cross-ties 
here  rest  on  a  strong  gravel  bed,  under  which  clean  sharp  sand  extends 
to  a  level  lower  than  the  frost  line.  The  ties  are  spaced  750  mm.  and 
the  rails  are  fastened  to  them  with  screw-spikes.  The  extraordinary  per- 
manence and  uniform  position  of  this  piece  of  track  indicates  that  gravel 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST.  269 

with  a  large  quantity  of  sand,  under  proper  condition  of  the  sub-soil  and 
construction  of  the  roadbed,  will  act  as  very  serviceable  ballast 

A  comparison  of  wooden  cross-tie  construction  was  also  made  with 
longitudinal  stringer  construction  made  up  of  Haarmann's  stringer  rails, 
which,  owing  to  their  unfavorable  position  in  the  roadbed,  are  more 
sensitive  to  the  changes  in  the  ballast  and  sub-soil  than  the  wooden 
cross-ties.  The  results  are  shown  in  Figs.  5  to  7,  Plate  2.  Rail  section, 
as  pictured  in  Fig.  5,  stood  up  comparatively  well.  The  gravel  ballast 
in  this  case  was  mixed  with  broken  stone  which  had  formerly  been 
tamped  underneath  the  previously  existing  longitudinal  stringer  of  the 
old  roadbed.  The  sub-soil  is  clean  fine  grained  sand,  which  in  several 
spots  was  permeated  with  clay,  whose  effect  on  the  roadbed  became  dis- 
tinctly noticeable.  The  section  of  track  illustrated  in  Fig.  6  seems  to  be 
considerably  more  mobile ;  in  spite  of  the  fact  that  the  roadbed  rested  on 
strong  broken  stone_  bed  of  300  mm.  thickness,  the  influences  of  the  un- 
even clay-bearing  sub-soil  made  themselves  felt  the  same  as  with  gravel 
ballast.  The  most  distinct  and  irregular  movements  occurred  with  the 
track  section  shown  in  the  second  half  of  Fig.  7,  Plate  2,  which  rested 
on  an  ordinary  gravel  bed,  resting  in  turn  on  a  heterogeneous  mixture 
of  clay  and  sand.  The  rails  were  so  considerably  bent,  due  to  the 
heaving  through  frost,  that  they  had  to  be  replaced.  (Compare,  also, 
Fig.  7a,  Plate  2.) 

The  harmful  influence  of  frost  on  the  roadbed  is  increased,  due  to 
the  fact  that  the  damage  resulting  therefrom  occurs  very  suddenly,  and 
as  long  as  the  frost  continues  can  be  remedied  only  with  great  difficulty 
and  incompleteness.  In  connection  with  this,  it  is  not  sufficient  to  take 
into  consideration  only  the  apparent  defects  which  become  noticeable 
when  riding,  but  also  the  small,  quickly  changing,  bulging  effects  which 
the  hard-frozen  roadbed  is  obliged  to  suffer,  due  to  the  minor  expansions 
in  the  sub-soil,  and  which  defects  do  not  become  noticeable  when  riding 
over  these  stretches.  For  minor  localized  heavings  cause  very  consider- 
able stresses  in  the  rails,  which  stresses  increase  with  stiffness  of  the  rail 
and  the  rigidity  with  which  it  is  frozen  in  the  roadbed.  High  rails  which 
are  securely  fastened  to  the  cross-ties,  which  are  comparatively  closely 
spaced,  are  more  endangered  than  weaker  rails  which  rest  loosely  on  the 
roadbed.  The  recent  construction  of  heavy  rails  and  narrow  tie  spacing 
are  well  adapted  to  distribute  the  load  over  a  greater  portion  of  the 
ballast,  and  thereby  decrease  the  demands  made  on  the  ballast;  but,  on  the 
other  hand,  make  increased  demands  for  more  regular  construction  and 
the  prevention  of  all  forceful  local  disturbances  of  the  form  of  the  road- 
bed. The  nature  of  the  ballast,  whether  crushed  stone  or  gravel,  does  not 
assist  in  remedying  the  influences  of  the  soil  upon  which  the  ballast  rests. 
In  order,  therefore,  that  the  sub-soil  have  no  influence  on  the  roadbed, 
it  is  necessary  that  it  consist  of  a  material  which  is  constant  under  the 
action  of  frost,  and  extends  below  the  frost  line.  In  North  Germany 
frost  extending  to  a  depth  of  70  cm.  in  loose  sand  and  gravel,  or  a  depth 
of  approximately  55  cm.  underneath  the  wooden  ties,  should  be  taken  into 


270  GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 

consideration.  Any  bed  of  clean  sand  will  serve  as  a  frostproof  sub-soil, 
even  when  the  sand  is  of  fine  grains. 

When  the  transforming  influences  of  the  sub-soil  and  the  weather 
are  removed,  the  characteristics  of  the  ballast  itself  come  into  play.  The 
investigations  were  continued  along  the  line  of  determining  the  effects 
of  these  different  properties.  In  purely  scientific  treatment  of  the  roadbed 
it  is  commonly  taken  that  the  ballast  is  uniformly  elastic,  and  this  feature 
only  is  taken  into  consideration.  As  a  matter  of  fact,  the  different  por- 
tions of  the  ballast  which  act  as  individual  supports  are  not  uniformly 
elastic.  Each  load  occurring  in  the  operation  over  the  roadbed  causes, 
with  the  temporary  depression,  also  a  permanent  change,  however  slight. 
This  permanent  set  has  a  definite  relation  to  the  unit  pressure  imposed. 
If,  therefore,  the  loads  are  unequal  which  are  transmitted  to  the  ballast 
through  the  ties,  then  the  set  underneath  the  more  heavily  loaded  ties  is 
more  serious  than  in  the  case  of  the  others.  Consequently,  owing  to 
this  tendency,  the  original  conditions  of  loading  of  the  ballast  are  grad- 
ually changed,  principally  in  that  the  pressures  under  the  more  heavily 
loaded  ties  gradually  diminish  and  the  pressures  under  the  lightly  loaded 
ties  gradually  increase,  until  the  condition  of  loading  becomes  quite  uni- 
form. In  order  to  observe  these  phenomena,  a  section  of  roadbed  was 
purposely  unevenly  tamped  so  that  a  portion  of  the  ties  rested  solidly  on 
the  ballast,  while  the  other  portion  was  without  any  support.  By  repeated 
observations  it  was  found  that  the  spaces  between  the  ballast  and  the 
ties  gradually  diminished,  and  after  six  months  disappeared  entirely. 
This  is  shown  in  Fig.  8,  Plate  2,  in  which  the  spaces  measured  at  dif- 
ferent times  between  the  tie  and  ballast  (scale  1=1.166)  are  indicated 
by  cross-hatching.  Hence,  ballast  supporting  cross-ties  not  uniformly 
loaded  tends  to  change  itself  into  a  uniformly  loaded  mass.  Of  course, 
this  equalization  of  the  loading  does  not  occur  through  a  uniform  sinking 
of  the  rail  and  ties,  but  is  due  rather  to  more  or  less  prominent  local 
depressing,  and  thus  amounts  to  a  deterioration  of  the  condition  of  the 
roadbed. 

An  equal  change  is  experienced  by  the  ballast  underneath  each  tie. 
And  here,  too,  the  tendency  is  for  the  tie  to  take  such  a  form  that  the 
unit  pressures  of  it  in  the  ballast  are  equal  in  all  places.  Hence,  the  tie 
itself  becomes  a  beam  with  uniform  loading,  and  the  surface  of  the 
ballast  underneath  the  tie  assumes,  therefore,  the  shape  of  the  elastic 
curve  of  the  tie  under  this  particular  condition  of  loading.  This  shape 
of  the  surface  is  present  whether  the  tie  is  loaded  or  not  (Fig.  1).  But 
since  the  passing  loads  are  not  uniform,  and  hence  the  unit  loads  on  the 
ballast  vary,  the  shape  of  the  surface  of  the  ballast  becomes  the  average 
of  the  elastic  curves  of  the  tie  due  to  the  different  loadings.  In  making 
this  statement  it  is  assumed  that  the  resistance  of  the  ballast  is  equal  at 
all  places.  If  this  is  not  the  case,  then  those  placed  where  the  resistance 
is  not  so  great  as  in  others  will  give  way  until  all  places  are  loaded  in 
accordance    with   their   resistance.     This   appears   regularly    as   the   case 


GRAVEL   AS    BALLAST. 


271 


underneath   the   ends  of  the  cross-ties,  of  which   mention   will  be   made 
later  on. 

The  continual  changing  of  the  form  of  the  roadbed  is  a  result  partly 
of  the  compression  of  the  ballast,   and  also,  perhaps  to  a  larger  extent. 


z~-><--^ 


>(.  — 


TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTrrrriTT^ 


Fig. I. 

the  result  of  a  sidewise  spreading.  The  loading  of  the  bed  under  and  next 
to  the  ties  is  so  continually  at  variance  that  an  equalization  of  the  pres- 
sure cannot  take  place  and  the  lightly  loaded  part  between  the  ties  is 
continually  being  displaced  by  the  heavily  loaded  part  underneath  the  ties. 
The  possible  shapes  of  these  sidewise  spreadings  are  treated  theoretically 
in  Dr.  H.  Zimmermann's  "Berechnung  des  Eisenbahnoberbaues,"  page  108. 
Thus  it  became  desirable,  by  means  of  experiments,  to  get  an  idea  of  the 
actions  as  they  really  took  place.  For  this  purpose,  therefore,  dry  sand 
of  different  colored  layers  was  poured  behind  a  pane  of  glass,  and  after 
a  picture  of  the  sand  was  transmitted  to  the  glass,  it  was  loaded  down 
with  ties  30x60  mm.,  so  that  distinct  displacements  occurred  in  the  sand 
bed.  By  comparison  with  the  original  position  of  the  different  layers,  the 
paths  of  the  sand  grains  under  increasing  loads  could  clearly  be  traced. 
The  occurrences  which  took  place  in  this  experiment,  and  which  were 
repeated  several  times,  were  as  follows :  After  the  sandbed  was  entirely 
compressed    by   the    imposed    load,    a   sidewise    displacement    of   the    sand 


began,  first  in  lines  which  were  not  distinct,  then  becoming  more  distinct, 
until  eventually  very  pronounced  lines  of  separation  appeared.  Several 
of  these  lines  are  shown  in  Fig.  2.    Although  they  diverge  considerably  in 


272 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


their  longitudinal  relation  to  one  another,  due  to  the  variation  of  the 
internal  friction,  nevertheless  the  theoretical  basic  shape  of  the  logarith- 
mic spiral  is  recognizable  in  their  curvature.  The  shape  of  the  lines  of 
separation  is  not  changed  when  the  ballast  is  piled  up  higher  than  the 
ties ;  in  fact,  they  continue  right  on  up  to  the  surface. 

The  body   of  sand,  which  separates  itself,  tends  to  retain  its  original 
shape,  and  also  seeks  to  regain  the  original  lines  of  separation  when  the 
tie  is  forced  deeper  into  the  sand,  since  when  this  is  the  case  resultant 
resistances  of  the  sand  particles  sliding  over  one  another  are  at  a  min 
imum    (Fig.   3). 


_  Onq  1  n  ol    surface 
of   ballast 


Underneath  the  tie  the  separation  of  the  sand  layers  did  not  appear 
as  uniformly  and  distinctly  as  above.  At  the  start  of  the  experiment,  a 
slender  wedge  would  usually  form,  with  its  apex  pointing  downward. 
This  wedge  would  become  more  blunt  as  the  tie  sank  deeper  into  the 
sand,  and  the  location  of  the  apex  remained  comparatively  firmly  fixed, 
so  that  the  lines  of  separation,  extending  from  the  sides,  retained  their 
original  position,  as  is  pictured  in  Fig.  4.     On  the  other  hand,  however, 


Fig.4.  Fig.  5. 

and  more  particularly  where  the  sandbeds  were  deep  and  the  resistances 
to  the  sidewise  displacements  were  greater,  there  appeared  another  wedge, 
firmly  fixed,  with  its  apex  pointing  upward,  from  whose  sides  the  sand 
particles  would  glide  (Fig.  5).  This  tendency  of  the  particles  to  glide 
from  the  sides  of  the  upturned  wedge  continues  so  long  as  the  angle  "A" 
(Fig.  s)  stays  larger  than  the  angle  of  repose  of  the  material  under  experi- 
ment,  for  as   long  as  this  condition  continues   the  particles  of  material 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


273 


which  are  being  forced  seek  the  path  of  least  resistance  and  adopt  the 
next  and  steepest  path  to  the  surface. 

Hence,  it  is  not  a  case  of  dealing  with  a  distinct  shape  of  separation, 
but  rather  with  the  nature  of  the  external  resistances  to  these  shapes, 
which  oppose  internally  the  motion  of  the  material.  The  free  develop- 
ment of  the  bodies  of  separation  is  hindered  in  the  roadbed  by  the  close 
spacing  of  the  cross-ties.  The  integral  parts  of  the  bedding  which  move 
grow  less,  but  the  internal  resistance  becomes  greater.  When  the  sandbed 
is  gradually  narrowed,  a  point  is  reached  where  the  escape  of  the  particles 
no  longer  is  possible,  which  is  due  to  the  equalization  of  the  internal 
surface-rubbing  resistances  and  the  imposed  load.  At  this  point  these 
internal  resistances  vary  in  amounts  equal  to  the  variations  of  the  imposed 
load.  The  line  of  separation  in  the  case  of  the  limited  bed  approaches 
the  semi-circle,  as  observed  several  times  and  as  its  limiting  shape  as- 
sumes the  form  as  shown  in  Fig.  6.  Such  a  shape,  as  determined  mathe- 
matically with  the  coefficient  of  friction  of  sand,  is  then  only  possible 
when  the  unit  pressures  grow  from  the  edges  towards  the  center  of  the 
tie.  As  a  matter  of  fact,  it  is  readily  observable  that  the  center  of  the 
tie  will  seat  more  firmly  than  its  edges  when  driven  into  narrowly  con- 
fined sandbeds. 


Fig.  6. 

Now,  if  the  bed  upon  which  the  tie  is  imposed  is  confined  between 
two  rigid  walls,  the  resistance  of  the  bed  with  these  walls  strongly  opposes 
the  tendency  of  the  bed  material  to  become  displaced  upwards.  But  if  the 
confinement  of  the  bed  arises  from  the  neighboring  ties,  simultaneously 
loaded,  as  is  the  case  in  track,  moving  particles  which  meet  between  the 
ties  oppose  one  another,  and,  not  finding  any  confining  resistances,  drive 
themselves  upward.  Fig.  7  illustrates  an  experiment  with  two  equally 
loaded  ties  on  a  confined  bed.  The  distances  between  the  ties  chosen  were 
such  that  the  amounts  of  material  between  the  ties  and  between  the  walls 
and  the  ties  were  equal,  and  thus  also  making  the  resistance  in  the  two 
directions  equal.  This  was  approximately  the  case  when  a/2  :c=  1:1.3. 
(Fig.  7.)  The  distance  between  ties  when  the  bed  material  ceased  to 
rise  up  between  them  appeared  to  be  when  a=i.sb.    Even  with  a  pressure 


274 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


as  great  as  40  kilograms  per  square  centimeter  no  rising  of  the  bed 
material  was  noted  when  the  ties  were  brought  closer  together  than 
a=i.5b. 

a    


Fiq.7. 


After  these  observations  of  the  nature  of  the  movements  taking 
place  in  a  gravel  bed,  it  became  desirable  to  learn  more  about  the  re- 
sistances which  the  gravel  opposes  to  these  movements.  The  heavy 
pressures  required  in  these  experiments  do  not  occur  in  the  ordinary 
roadbed,  so  it  became  necessary  to  depend  upon  special  arrangements 
on  a  smaller  scale.  The  results  herefrom  cannot  be  applied  directly  to 
ordinary  roadbed  practices,  since  enlarged  conditions,  such  as  occur  in 
practice,  would  alter  the  shapes  of  the  material  under  load;  and,  further, 
since  the  varying  nature  of  ballast  material  itself  and  peculiarities  of  the 
loading  in  actual  roadbed  practice  cannot  be  taken  into  consideration 
sufficiently.  Hence  the  object  of  these  particular  experiments  was  to 
determine  certain  relations  of  the  different  properties  of  the  ballast  mate- 
rial which  it  is  assumed  would  obtain  in  actual  practice.  More  particu- 
larly speaking,  it  was  the  object  of  these  investigations  to  determine 
the  influence  of  tie-spacing,  the  width  of  ties,  the  height  to  which  mate- 
rial was  packed  between  the  ties,  and  of  the  nature  of  the  ballast  itself. 
For  the  purpose  of  these  experiments  iron  cases  with  adjustable  walls 
were  used.  They  were  of  such  a  depth  that  the  movements  of  the  mate- 
rials in  the  bed  would  not  extend  to  the  bottom.  A  press  consisting  of  a 
screw  and  a  heavy  spiral  spring,  which  transmitted  the  pressure  imposed 
upon  the  spring  to  an  indicating  pointer,  was  used  to  load  the  tie  (Fig.  8). 
The  scale  of  the  indicating  device  was  determined  by  means  of  actual 
weights.  The  press  was  arranged  for  a  pressure  as  high  as  300  kilograms, 
but  by  means  of  a  lever,  which  could  be  coupled  in,  it  was  possible  to 
raise  the  pressures  up  to  500  kilograms.  The  ties  which  were  used  had  a 
width  ranging  from  10  cm.  to  80  mm.  The  bed  consists  of  dry  pit  gravel, 
made  up  of  rounded  grains,  up  to  5  mm.  in  diameter.  No  larger  particles 
were  used,  since  it  was  desirable  to  prevent  hollow  formations  in  the 
gravel  bed,  owing  to  the  diminished  scale  which  was  being  used. 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


275 


The  first  experiments  were  made  on  single  ties  ranging  in  width 
from  20  to  60  mm.,  resting  on  a  bed  of  fine  grained  sand,  no  particles  of 
which  exceeded  1  mm.  in  diameter.  The  pressure  was  increased  until 
clearly  defined  movements  were  discernible  in  the  bed.  As  a  rule,  a  sud- 
den collapsing  or  release  occurred  when  the  pressure  reached  a  certain 
point  temporarily  relieving  the  pressure  imposed.  The  resistance  of  the  bed 
depends  upon  its  width  "a"  (Fig.  9),  the  width  of  the  tie  "b,"  and  the  height 
to  which  the  bed  material  rises  along  the  side  of  the  tie  '"h."  The  influ- 
ence of  the  width  of  the  bed  "a"  bears  a  particular  relation  to  the  width 
of  the  tie  "b."  Hence,  this  influence  may  be  designated  by  the  relation 
a/b,  through  which  may  be  determined  the  proper  tie  spacing.  The  results 
of  the  experiments  are  demonstrated  in  Figs.  9a  to  9c.  In  Fig.  9b  the 
distances  between  ties  are  plotted  along  the  abscissa,  while  the  carrying 


capacities  of  the  bed  in  kg.  per  sq.  cm.  are  plotted  along  the  correspond- 
ing ordinates,  giving  curves  for  different  heights  of  "h"  ranging  from  o 
to  30  mm.  When  h  was  o  and  the  relation  between  a/b  was  greater 
than  7,  the  carrying  capacity  remained  practically  constant.  As  the  dis- 
tance between  ties  decreased  the  carrying  capacity  increased,  first  slowly 
and  then  more  rapidly,  so  that  when  a/b=2  it  was  twice  as  great  as 
when  a/b=3. 

The  carrying  capacity  was  further  increased  as  gravel  was  piled  up 
between  the  ties.  The  influence  of  the  spacing  was  partially  compen- 
sated by  the  increasing  height  of  the  material  between  them  to  the  extent 
that  the  carrying  capacity  was  equal  in  ties  spaced  narrowly  without  mate- 


276 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


o 
iZ 


__  \ -____ 

\___~ 

--A--- 

'-  AV- 

UiL 

:~-4V- 

*— m 

L--  :  L 

0) 


<7> 


£__       <2                «0   _  .  .  .  Q 

"s».- 

1      S__  _ 

f-VU 

2-  \       \    \    \ 

f-4-^t 

\tt 

\  it 

ut 

ilt 

ii 

jjj 

00 
o 

t- 
o 

o 

i0 
o 

E 
E 

•i 

'N 
$ 

? 

u 

3 

«» 

a 

9 

CO 

o 

o 

ii 

j 

\ 

\ 

(VJ 

o 

r$ 

% 

c>- 

\ 

, 

-  fc 

o 

9 

<5 

\ 

\ 

c 

> 

i 

■» 

o 

m 

o 

ir 

1 

O 

o 

en 

iZ 


*-~c-> 


_t- 


E#»j    i 


OP 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


277 


rial  between  them  to  ties  spaced  widely  with  material  packed  between 
them.  The  effect  of  the  height  to  which  material  is  packed  between  the 
ties  is  particularly  demonstrated  in  Fig.  p-c.  The  several  lines  are  for  tie 
separations  ranging  for  a/b  from  2.6  to  20,  while  the  height  to  which 
material  was  piled  between  ties,  ranging  from  o  to  80  mm.,  are  the  ab- 
scissae, and  the  carrying  capacities  are  the  ordinates. 

Positive  determinations  of  the  action  of  the  widths  of  the  ties  could 
not  be  made  from  the  above  results.  So  in  order  to  get  at  the  actual 
conditions  prevailing  in  a  roadbed,  where  ties  are  equally  and  simul- 
taneously loaded,  two  ties  were  rigidly  bonded  together  and  placed  into 
an  iron  box,  so  that  each  came  very  close  to  the  sides  of  the  box  (Fig.  n). 
In  order  to  reduce  the  friction  of  the  bed  material  on  the  walls  of  the 
box,  they  were  lined  with  glass.  Since  the  ties  fitted  into  the  box  so  that 
three  sides  of  each  tie  were  contiguous  to  the  sides  of  the  box,  the  only 
possible  escape  for  the  bed  material  was  between  the  two  ties.  The 
width  of  the  ties  in  reality,  therefore,  corresponds  to  Yz  the  width  of  a  tie 
in  actual  practice,  and,  consequently,  is  indicated  by  b/2.  At  this  time  it 
was  observed  that  a  wedge  with  its  apex  pointing  upward  appeared 
underneath  each  tie  when  the  material  between  the  ties  had  reached  a 
certain  height  and  the  material  of  the  bed  tended  to  glide  off  the  sides  of 
this  wedge,  exercising  a  heavy  pressure  sidewise  on  the  tie.  The  size  of 
the  gravel  particles  ranged  from  1  to  2  mm.,  the  width  of  the  ties  b/2=io 
to  50  mm.,  the  height  to  which  the  material  was  piled  between  the  ties 
extended  up  to  130  mm. 


o  o  o  00  ° 


Glass 


> 


Fig.  II. 


w 

If, 


^^^^^ 


The  results  illustrated  in  Fig.  10-a  to  10-d  are  similar  to  the  ones 
reached  in  previous  experiments;  however,  the  effect  of  tie  spacing  was 
felt  at  lower  values  of  a/b,  approximately  when  same  equaled  4  (Fig. 
10-c).  As  this  ratio  decreased  its  influence  was  still  greater  than  in  the 
previous  case,  so  that  the  carrying  capacity  with  a  ratio  of  a/b=2  was 
four  times  as  great  as  when  a/b=3.  The  limit  was  reached  for  a  sidewise 
displacement  of  the  bed  material  when  a/b=i.5  and  h=io  mm.  As  the 
height  h  increased,  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  bed,  it  seems,  grew  at  an 
increasing  rate  (Fig.  10-d).  These  relations  were  the  more  apparent  and 
more  effective  as  the  distance  between  ties  decreased.  Here,  also,  a  dis- 
tinct influence   of  the  width  of  the  ties   was  noticeable   on  the   carrying 


278  GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 

capacity  of  the  bed,  as  is  demonstrated  in  Fig.  io-b  for  different  values  of 
h,  height  of  material  between  ties.  As  the  widths  of  ties  increased  the 
unit  pressure  increased  according  to  the  laws  of  a  straight  line,  main- 
taining a  relation  quite  constant.  An  increase  in  carrying  capacity  is  also 
proven  for  this  case  in  Dr.  H.  Zimmermann's  "Berechnung  des  OberbaueS," 
page  115. 

The  experiments  thus  far  did  not  attempt  to  deal  with  any  different 
loading  except  those  free  from  shock.  Hence,  the  effect  of  a  load  in 
connection  with  shocks  still  remained  to  be  investigated.  When  ballast  is 
subjected  to  impact  the  friction  of  the  gravel  particles  rubbing  against 
one  another  is  temporarily  diminished.  Gravel  ballast,  therefore,  when 
subjected  to  this  condition,  behaves  as  a  bed  which  is  loaded  fixedly  and 
whose  angle  at  repose  is  more  flat.  In  order  to  approach  conditions  as 
(hey  occur  in  an  actual  roadbed,  the  ballast  was  subjected,  by  means  of 
a  loaded  lever,  to  a  uniform  pressure  of  1.5  kg.  per  sq.  cm.  The  case  con- 
taining the  bed  was  subjected  to  vibration  or  impact  through  a  weight 
which  dropped  each  time  from  the  same  height.  The  number  of  impacts 
in  the  time  that  Ihe  tie  sank  10  mm.  into  the  bed  was  taken  as  the  meas- 
ure of  resistance  of  the  material.  As  a  rule,  the  tie  started  in  to  sink 
faster  at  the  start  of  the  experiments,  but  its  rate  of  entering  soon  be- 
came uniform.  The  width  of  the  ties  was  from  39  to  87  mm.,  and  the 
height  to  which  the  bed  material  was  piled  extended  in  some  instances 
to  300  mm.  The  illustration  indicated  in  Figs.  12a  and  12b  again  reveal  a 
distinct  relation  with  previous  results.  The  effect  of  the  spacing  again 
became  noticeable  when  a/b=io,  and  became  more  apparent  when  a/b=4 
and  less  (Fig.  12c).  The  height  to  which  the  material  was  piled  along 
the  side  of  the  tie  also  affected  the  resistance  in  a  similar  way  (Fig.  i2f). 
The  meaning  of  the  width  of  the  ties  was  also  made  very  apparent,  as  is 
demonstrated  in  Figs.  12-b  to  12-d  for  different  tie  spacing.  The  re- 
sistance of  the  ballast  increased  rather  a  trifle  faster  than  would  be 
indicated  by  the  law  of  a  straight  line,  under  equal  pressure,  as  the  dis- 
tance between  ties  decreased.  The  closer  the  ties  were  spaced,  and  the 
higher  the  material  was  piled  between  the  ties,  the  more  rapid  this 
increase  became. 

The  ballast,  however,  behaved  differently  under  the  ends  of  the  ties 
than  elsewhere.  Similarly,  as  demonstrated  above,  a  body  of  material 
tends  to  separate  itself  underneath  the  end  of  the  tie.  But  since  there 
is  no  other  tie  to  oppose  this  displacement,  the  ballast  terminating  on  a 
slope,  the  opposition  of  this  sideward  tendency  of  the  gravel  underneath 
the  end  of  the  tie  is  comparatively  small.  Hence,  the  carrying  capacity 
of  the  tie  at  its  ends  is  less  than  at  its  center,  but  it  increases  from  the 
ends  toward  the  center  of  the  tie  until  it  reaches  those  points  from  each 
end  where  the  resistances  sidewise  and  outward  towards  the  ends  are 
equal.  Between  these  points  the  carrying  capacity  is  uniform.  Since  the 
support  given  the  tie  bears  a  direct  relation  to  its  carrying  capacity,  the 
pressure  underneath  the  tie  on  the  ballast  diminishes  outward  from  the 
two  points  described  above.     The  closer  the  ties  are  spaced,  the  greater 


e 

J*^**~ VJ 

V 

If 

r& 

*-3 

■  W 

f 


T3 
0) 

s_ 

O 

o-S 
2!  E 

tO  o 
o  5 

E  _* 

c 
c*-.  — 
o  «o 

^° 

JO 

£ 
o 
2 


o 

o 


CM 


°< 

^N 

sX 

^> 

^ 

<T> 

II 

^\ 

\ 

cO 

H 
op 

V 

\ 

0) 
m    CD 

iZ 


N 

II 
0\fi 


S<\| 

en 


280 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


the  carrying  capacity  of  the  roadbed  becomes,  and  the  nearer  to  the  ends 
the  ties  are,  the  points  from  which  the  pressure  on  the  ballast  decreases. 

By  an  experiment  with  a  tie  50  mm.  wide,  with  material  piled  to  a 
width  of  60  mm.  from  the  end  of  the  tie  outward,  it  was  determined, 
when  the  space  relation  was  a/b=3,  that  the  carrying  capacity  under- 
neath the  extreme  end  of  the  tie  was  0.4  kg.  per  sq.  cm.,  increasing  uni- 
formly towards  the  center  until  a  distance  of  45  mm.  in  from  the  end 
of  the  tie  was  reached,  thence  becoming  uniform  at  a  pressure  of  4  kg. 
per  sq.  cm.  If  these  relative  dimensions  are  applied  on  a  larger  scale  to 
a  tie  of  260  mm.  width,  spaced  780  mm.  from  center  to  center,  the  pro- 
portions which  will  result  are  illustrated  in  Fig.  13.  If  the  width  of  the 
ballast  extending;  outward  from  the  end  of  the  tie  is  unlimited,  then  C, 
the  length  of  the  territory  of  decreasing  pressure,  diminishes  to  180  mm., 
but  increases  to  400  mm.  in  the  absence  of  any  ballast  outward  from  the 
end. 


i6o  1 


A   A  A.   'A    1    A    AAA 


r«=330- 


13. 


The  length  of  the  tie  has  no  influence  on  the  relation  of  the  pressure 
at  the  ends  of  the  tie,  but  it  does  affect  the  load  intensity  and  the  length 
of  the  uniformly  loaded  territory  under  the  middle  of  the  tie.  When 
determining  the  length  of  the  ties,  consideration  should  be  taken,  on  the 
one  hand,  that  the  bending  moments  do  not  become  too  great,  and,  on  the 
other,  that  lightly  loaded  portion,  or  portion  carrying  no  load,  is  properly 
supported  by  the  ballast.  Since  the  surface  of  the  ballast  adapts  itself  to 
the  elastic  line  of  the  tie,  a  short  tie,  when  not  loaded,  will  be  supported 
at  its  middle,  while  a  long  tie,  not  loaded,  will  be  supported  at  its  ends. 
And,  furthermore,  the  bending  moment  of  a  long  tie  under  the  rail 
increases  considerably  with  its  length,  which  should  be  taken  into  con- 
sideration with  wooden  ties,  especially  when  wooden  dowels  are  screwed 
in  at  the  place  of  the  greatest  bending  moment,  which  would  consider- 
ably diminish  the  carrying  capacity.  Consideration  of  all  those  limiting 
features  seems  to  determine  a  tie  length  of  2.8  meter. 

The  question  of  the  smallest  size  of  gravel  particles  and  the  largest 
admixture  of  foreign  material  permissible  in  gravel  ballast  is  of  consider- 
able significance,  from  a  practical  and  economical  point  of  view,  to  those 
railroads  depending  upon  gravel  for  ballast.  The  carrying  capacity  of 
gravel  depends  primarily  on  its  internal  resistances,  which  are  indicated 


Angle  of  Repose. 

31° 

ii' 

33° 

45' 

36° 

9' 

37° 

io' 

40° 

15' 

39° 

48' 

34° 

35' 

36° 

52' 

GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST.  281 

by  the  angle  of  repose  of  material.     For  ordinary  dry  gravel,  the  follow- 
ing values    are  determined: 

Number.  Size  of  Grains. 

I  Less  than       1       mm. 

II  1       mm.  to  2      mm. 

III  2      mm.  to  3.1  mm. 

IV  3.1  mm.   to  4.2  mm. 
V  4.2  mm.  to  5.6  mm. 

VI  5.6  mm.  to  9.2  mm. 

Mixture  of  I,  II,  VI=i  :i  :S 

Mixture  of  II,  IV=i  :i 
Hence,  the  angle  of  repose  increases  from  30  to  40  degrees,  with  increase  in 
size  of  the  grains.  According  to  the  theoretical  investigation  of  Dr.  H. 
Zimmermann's  "Berechnung  des  Oberbanes,"  page  116,  the  carrying  capac- 
ity of  the  bed  increases  very  rapidly  as  the  angle  of  repose  of  the  bed 
material  increases  from  30  to  40  degrees,  and  at  40  degrees  it  should  be 
three  to  five  times  as  great  as  at  30  degrees.  Now,  if  experience  does  not 
substantiate  such  a  great  variation  in  carrying  capacity,  consideration  must 
be  taken  of  the  fact  that  the  internal  friction  decreases  when  the  materials 
are  subjected  to  shock,  and  that  the  presence  of  foreign  material  is  apt  to 
increase  it.  Experiments  to  determine  if  coarse  gravel  subjected  to  heavy 
impact  was  superior  to  fine  grained  gravel  were  not  conclusive  in  results 
The  size  of  the  gravel  particles  are  not  alone  in  determining  the  carry- 
ing capacity  of  the  material,  but  the  effect  of  the  moisture  present  and  the 
condition  of  material  also  influence  it  considerably.  Light  moisture,  as  is 
usually  present  at  the  base  of  the  roadbed,  tends  to  increase  the  adhesion 
between  the  particles,  and,  hence,  enhances  the  carrying  capacity  of  the 
finer  grained  gravel.  It  was  found  that  fine  grained  gravel  in  a  moist 
condition  had  twice  to  four  times  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  same 
gravel  in  a  perfectly  dry  state;  on  the  other  hand,  coarse  grained  gravel 
revealed  no  striking  difference  between  the  dry  and  the  moist  stage.  A 
surplus  of  water,  however,  loosened  up  the  adhesion  of  the  finer  grains 
when  subjected  to  quick  change  in  loading.  If  proper  drainage  is  pro- 
vided, then  coarse  grained  gravel  can  hardly  be  saturated  with  water; 
while,  on  the  other  hand,  fine  grained  gravel  may  easily  be  saturated,  since 
it  retained  the  water  up  to  its  point  of  saturation.  In  order  to  determine 
the  rate  at  which  water  is  absorbed  and  again  released  by  gravel,  the  fol- 
lowing experiments  were  made : 

In  a  watertight  box,  500  mm.  high,  dry  sand  was  piled  of  a  size  not 
exceeding  1  mm.  Water  was  then  poured  in  until  it  reappeared  on  the 
surface.  The  absorption  of  water  amounted  to  29  per  cent,  of  the  volume 
of  the  sand.  The  surface  water  was  then  drained  from  the  sand  through 
a  series  of  tap  holes,  spaced  50  mm.  apart,  and  measured.  It  was  deter- 
mined that  the  amount  of  water  drained  at  the  top  was  comparatively 
small,  it  was  increased  as  the  depth  became  greater,  and  became  fairly 
constant  after  a  depth  of  400  mm.  had  been  reached.  The  reason  for  this 
phenomenon  appears  to  be  that  the  capillary  attraction  in  the  upper  layers 


282 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 


when  the  water  level  is  high  preponderates,  but  as  the  same  sinks  the 
attraction  decreases.  Furthermore,  the  fine  streams  of  water,  as  they  flow 
downward  by  their  own  weight,  draw  water  from  the  upper  layers  as 
long  as  they  will  release  it.  When  the  highest  layers  have  become  dry, 
this  phenomenon  continues  downward,  as  each  tap  is  opened. 

The  diagram,  Fig.  14,  represents,  by  the  area  bounded  by  line  I  and 
the  X  and  Y  axes,  how  the  water  content  varied  from  the  top  to  the 
bottom  of  a  bed  i;oo  mm.  deep.  The  original  water  content  of  29  per  cent, 
decreased  from  the  bottom  towards  the  top  to  4  per  cent.  Similarly,  lines 
II,  III  and  IV  of  this  same  Fig.  14  illustrate  the  variation  of  the  water 
content  of  different  gravels  made  up  of  coarser  grains  as  designated  under 
the  diagram.  The  water-absorbing  capacity  of  the  coarser  gravel  was 
greater  than  that  of  the  finer  gravel,  but  the  release  of  water,  as  the 
level  sank,  was  more  rapid.  In  fact,  gravel  of  greater  than  2  mm.  was 
practically  free  from  moisture  at  a  height  of  130  mm.  above  the  level  of 
the  water.  The  moisture  finally  retained  after  the  gravel  had  been  drained 
ranged  with  the  different  sizes  between  the  narrow  limits  of  2.5  to  4  per 
cent. 


500 


400 


300 


ZOO 


mm  Height  of  Sand  Bed 


i 

■i 

I 

i 

P 

,_ — 

\ 

30  40^,  Water  Content 


I     Size  of  grains  less  than    1  mm. 
II     Pit  Gravel   with  2b  %  of  gra  ins  less  than  1  mm. 
EI     Size  of  grains   1  to  2  mm. 
IV   Size  of  grains  2  to  4  mm. 

Fig.  14. 


Hence,  it  becomes  apparent  that  coarse  gravel,  though  of  compara- 
tively shallow  depth,  readily  drains  itself  and  becomes  dry;  but,  on  the 
other  hand,  the  retained  water  is  practically  the  same  for  fine  and  coarse 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST.  283 

gravel,  provided  there  is  sufficient  depth.  The  disadvantages  of  fine  gravel 
in  this  respect  may  be  mitigated  by  deepening  the  roadbed.  Considera- 
tion must  always  be  taken  of  the  possibility  of  supersaturation  of  fine 
gravel,  owing  to  slower  draining  capacity  under  continued  rainfall.  This 
may  also  occur  when  the  roadbed  begins  to  thaw,  and  the  surface  water, 
which  is  released  first,  can  find  no  outlet  into  the  lower  layer,  owing  to 
their  continuing  in  a  frozen  condition.  On  the  other  hand,  the  tendency 
of  the  ballast  to  remain  frozen  under  the  ties,  and  so  form  a  solid  bed 
for  them  until  sufficient  time  has  elapsed  for  the  portion  of  the  ballast 
between  the  ties  to  thaw,  drain  to  a  considerable  depth  and  become  dry, 
is   an  advantage. 

The  principal  requirements  for  a  permanent  and  uniform  roadbed 
with   gravel  ballast  may,  therefore,  be   summed   up  as   follows : 

The  sub-soii  upon  which  the  roadbed  rests  should  consist,  to  a  depth 
cf  the  frost  line,  of  a  material  which  is  not  affected  by  weather  condi- 
tions, nor,   when  frozen,  heaves   upward,  thus  disturbing  the  ballast. 

The  continued  settling  of  the  rail  bears  a  distinct  relation  to  the 
internal  resistances  of  the  ballast.  Hence,  ballast,  as  far  as  it  is  subjected 
to  such  forces,  should  consist  of  material  which  is  uniform  in  its  carry- 
ing capacity.  When  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  sub-soil,  therefore,  is  not 
high  or  varies  greatly,  as  is  the  case  with  all  earthy  soils,  the  roadbed 
j-hould  be  of  such  strength  that  the  individual  loads  on  the  ties  are  evenly 
distributed  throughout  the  ballast  and  uniformly  distributed  over  the  sub- 
soil. Furthermore,  all  sidewise  and  circulating  movements  should  be 
confined  within  the  ballast. 

In  order  to  meet  these  requirements,  a  depth  of  bed  of  about  550  mm. 
underneath  the  ties  would  be  sufficient,  provided  some  particularly  un- 
favorable conditions  of  the  sub-soil  did  not  make  a  greater  depth  neces- 
sary. A  clean  sand,  readily  permitting  water  to  pass  through  it,  would 
act  well  at  the  bottom  of  this  bed.  The  actual  depth  of  the  ballast  should 
not  exceed  300  mm.  underneath  the  ties  in  order  to  prevent  mixing  with 
the  bottom  layer  of  sand.  Regarding  the  size  of  the  gravel  grains,  it  is 
desirable,  in  order  to  secure  a  ballast  which  drains  readily  in  its  upper 
layers,  and  in  order  to  prevent  the  undue  formation  of  dust  underneath 
and  following  trains,  and  in  consideration  of  the  future  increase  of  fine 
grain  content  due  to  tamping,  to  prevent  as  much  as  possible  the  admis- 
sion of  fine  grained  particles  in  the  ballast.  This,  however,  only  means 
particles  less  than  2  mm.  in  size.  As  a  matter  of  fact,  a  mixture  of  fine 
and  coarse  grains  is  desirable,  since  it  permits  of  a  more  solid  packing  of 
the  gravel  underneath  the  ties  than  when  only  coarse  gravel  is  used.  But, 
due  to  the  moist  condition  of  gravel,  it  is  not  very  convenient  to  segregate 
the  fine  particles  from  the  coarser.  In  order  to  accomplish  this  separation, 
large  coarse  screens  must  be  used.  This  results  in  a  loss  of  a  large  and 
useful  portion  of  the  gravel,  and  the  part  remaining  is  often  so  little  that 
the  advantage  gained  by  sifting  is  not  warranted,  due  to  the  great  expense 
involved.  Under  these  conditions,  therefore,  gravel  with  a  25  per  cent, 
content  of  grains  1  mm.  or  less  in  size  becomes  practicable,  as  long  as  the 


284  GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST. 

conditions  are  not  extraordinary  and  require  an  especially  strong  roadbed. 

The  width  of  roadbed  bears  a  certain  relation  to  the  length  of  ties 
and  the  spacing  of  the  ties.  It  is  considered  that  an  extension  of  the 
ballast  outwards  from  the  ends  of  the  tie,  with  their  usual  length  of  2.7 
to  28  m.,  amounting  to  300  mm.,  is  sufficient. 

As  the  height  to  which  the  ballast  is  packed  increases,  the  carrying 
capacity  of  the  roadbed  increases.  Hence,  material  should  be  piled  be- 
tween the  ties  as  high  as  operating  conditions  will  permit. 

The  width  of  the  tie  is  also  of  considerable  importance,  since  with 
constant  load  the  unit  pressures  on  the  bed  are  reduced  as  the  area  of  the 
tie  increases,  and  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  tie  increases  directly  as  its 
area.  A  general  use  of  larger  wood  ties  is  not  permissible,  owing  to  the 
high  purchase  price  and  the  greater  difficulty  of  obtaining  the  same.  It 
is  desirable  to  have  the  ties  2.8  m.  in  length.  Strict  consideration  should 
always  be  given  the  proper  and  uniform  spacing  of  ties  and  shaping  of 
the  roadbed  in  order  to  utilize  to  the  limit  the  resistance  of  the  roadbed. 

Of  greater  importance  than  the  width  of  the  ties  is  the  spacing  of  the 
ties.  As  the  spacing  is  decreased  two  advantages  are  derived:  first,  the 
unit  pressure  decreases;  secondly,  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  roadbed  is 
increased.  It  is  just  within  the  limits  of  tie  spacing  usually  considered 
that  the  relation  a/b,  ranging  from  3^2  to  2  (spacing  900  mm.  to  500  mmj, 
that  the  carrying  capacity  increases  at  a  high  rate.  (Figs,  gd,  10c,  and 
12c)  The  limiting  feature  of  decreasing  tie-spacing  is  the  ability  to 
tamp  the  ties  properly.  Ties  160  mm.  in  height  can  still  be  tamped  with 
convenience  when  separated  350  mm.  But  this  (the  relation  being  2.3), 
600  mm.  from  center  to  center,  is  the  lowest  limit.  This  is  the  one  most 
effective  and  simplest  means  of  increasing  the  strength  of  the  roadbed, 
and  to  utilize  it  to  the  fullest  advantage,  especially  on  roadbeds  which  are 
fully  loaded,  is  urgently  recommended. 

The  portion  of  the  ballast  under  the  joints  requires  special  considera- 
tion, since  the  impact  at  these  points  makes  extraordinary  demands  on 
the  roadbed.  It  has  been  attempted  several  times  to  strengthen  this  part 
of  the  ballast  by  packing  crushed  stone  underneath  the  ties  supporting  the 
joint,  however  without  success. 

Another  way,  and  the  one  usually  resorted  to  in  order  to  accomplish 
the  above,  is  to  bring  the  two  ties  supporting  the  joint  as  close  together 
as  possible,  500  mm.  from  center  to  center.  The  closer  the  ties  are 
spaced  outside  of  this  particular  territory  supporting  the  joints  the  less 
the  difference  is  between  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  roadbed  underneath 
the  joints  and  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  rest  of  the  bed.  In  order  to 
further  strengtiien  the  roadbed  underneath  a  joint,  it  would  be  effective 
to  increase  the  width  of  the  ties  supporting  the  joint.  For  instance,  if  the 
width  of  the  ties  used  is  300  mm.,  and  the  distance  between  them  from 
edge  to  edge  is  250  mm.,  then  the  relation  between  them  is  550 — 300=1.83, 
as  compared  with  a  relation  of  600 — 260=2.31  for  the  ties  not  underneath 
the  joints.  By  means  of  this  decrease  in  the  distance  between  the  ties  at 
the  joints,  combined  with  the  increased  width,  as  well  as  the  distribution 


GRAVEL  AS  BALLAST.  285 

cf  the  load  ove>-  greater  surfaces,  the  carrying  capacity  of  the  roadbed 
underneath  the  joints  is  increased  approximately  75  per  cent.  Since,  as 
ties  are  ordinarily  furnished,  there  is  considerable  variation  in  sizes,  and 
hence  there  should  be  no  difficulty  in  selecting  a  sufficient  number,  approx- 
imately 10  per  cent,  of  the  proper  width,  to  arrange  underneath  the  joints 
for  the  above  purpose. 

As  a  further  means  of  distributing  the  shock  at  the  rail  joints,  methods 
of  combining  the  two  ties  underneath  each  joint  by  the  use  of  a  framework 
are  being  tried  out. 

All  means  to  increase  the  resistance  of  the  ballast  to  impact  will  not 
be  complete  and  sufficient  to  properly  maintain  the  necessary  support  and 
steadiness  of  the  whole  roadbed  as  long  as  impacts,  due  to  the  passing 
traffic,  at  the  rail  joints  continue  to  vary  on  account  of  the  varying  dis- 
tance between  rail  ends,  variation  in  the  surface  elevation  of  two  abutting 
rails,  wear  of  the  rails  and  wheel  flanges,  and  other  changes  in  shapes 
which  result  in  varying  shocks.  Hence,  the  question  of  a  proper  support 
for  the  rail  joints  is  primarily  a  question  of  the  proper  joining  of  rails 
with  the  object  of  preventing  low  and  loose  joints. 


CD 


c 
o 

o 
> 

id 


gSmou)55^<\^ 

in 

III  llll             will  1 

[ij'l 

4 

O 

5 

1 1|  J|lj  1 1||  it  1    II! 

■ 

5* 

1 

-5* 

ttf 

ulli 

\\\f 

&. 
^ 

JlirnTntmlT 

1/ 

-6 

UlfTMlllfl 

lUfH 

'  * 

lllllfflljj] 

\:/\ 

-■Ci 

1    MTTTmtH 

'  fml 

^ 

IftJItiiflil  J 

n  m 

■^ 

q 

o 
^ 

Jll 

!::■/   i 

i* 
^ 

Hi 

K 

^S 

iff 

in 

Hi 

In 

iff 

,  mil 

Ww\\ 

/! 

lifll  III 

irm 

t 

N  HI    ki 

4 

|    Lw^tj  jj/    j 

JJlllli^tlll 

[fflim] 

-<5 

ililrmlll 

Mil 

^ 

itmlll 

In 

•1 

||t|j\l  ji 

'ill 

=§ 

0% 
"0 

||  ||]||| 

lilli 

^ 

["* 


CD  E 


o 

c 

X 

uJ 


.V'i'-': 


3> 

I 


r 

1 
I 


289 


Appendix    D. 

BALLAST. 

By  George  W.  Vaughan,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  New  York  Cen- 
tral &  Hudson  River  Railroad. 

Ballast  is  that  portion  of  the  permanent  way  of  a  railway  which  forms 
the  firm  and  dry  foundation  for  the  ties  and  rails,  which  they  support. 
It  is  sometimes  distinguished  as  sub-ballast,  ballast  proper,  and  top-bal- 
last. Sub-ballast  is  that  portion  used  as  a  foundation  for  the  ballast 
proper,  or  as  a  mat  between  the  ballast  proper  and  sub-grade,  made 
necessary  on  account  of  the  poor  material  forming  the  sub-grade.  Ballast 
proper,  or  under-ballast,  is  that  which  lies  wholly  below  the  ties  and  above 
the  sub-ballast.  Top-ballast  is  that  which  is  filled  in  around  from  the 
bottom  to  the  top  of  the  ties. 

Ballast  is  necessary  for  the  following  reasons : 

(a)  To  drain  water  from  the  ties. 

(b)  To  provide  a  firm  and  even  bearing  for  the  ties  and  to  dis- 
tribute the  pressure  from  the  ties  over  the  roadbed. 

(c)  To  provide  drainage,  so  as  to  avoid  heaving  by  frost. 

(d)  To  supply  filling  material  between  the  ties  and  to  hold  them  in 
place. 

(e)  To  prevent  the  growth  of  grass  and  weeds  in  the  track. 

(f)  To  allow  surfacing  and  raising  of  track  without  disturbing  the 
roadbed. 

Ballast  is  a  most  important  item  and  upon  its  quality  depends  the 
condition  of  the  track,  also  the  economy  in  maintenance  and  operation. 

Ballast  material  should  be  carefully  selected.  A  dusty  ballast  will 
cause  greatly  increased  wear  on  the  equipment  and  on  roads  with  exten- 
sive passenger  traffic  an  innumerable  number  of  complaints  from  the 
traveling  public,  and  it  is  as  important  to  avoid  dust  and  dirt  by  the  use 
cf  clean  ballast  as  it  is  to  avoid  smoke  and  dirt  by  the  use  of  hard  coal 
for  fuel. 

The  best  ballast  is  that  which  will  best  form  a  durable  support  to  the 
lies,  will  not  change  its  consistency  when  wet,  will  not  disintegrate  upon 
exposure  to  the  elements,  retains  its  solidity  and  position  under  the  effects 
of  traffic,  gives  good  drainage,  be  free  from  dust  and  make  an  easy-riding 
track. 

Broken  stone  and  furnace  slag  drain  readily,  but  burnt  clay,  sand,  etc., 
will  retain  water  more  or  less  and  will  heave  in  frosty  weather.  With 
earth  or  mud  ballast  good  drainage  is  absolutely  essential  to  enable  the 
track  to  be  kept  in  safe  and  fairly  good  condition,  as  water-soaked  earth 
becomes  pasty  and  squashes  up  between  the  ties  and  over  the  right-of-way, 
and  when  in  such  condition  it  is  impossible  to  tamp,  so  as  to  keep  the 
track  in  surface. 

A  good  depth  of  ballast  will  cheapen  the  maintenance  by  keeping  the 

290 


BALLAST.  291 

beds  of  the  ties  well  drained,  and  it  is  not  economy  to  economize  too  much 
on  ballast. 

The  depth  of  ballast  varies  on  different  lines  and  according  to  the 
practice  of  different  engineers,  the  following  may  be  taken  as  ordinary 
limits: 

Sub-ballast   10  in.  to  18  in. 

Lower-ballast    9  in.  to  18  in. 

Upper-ballast    6  in.  to    8  in. 

Totals    25  in.  to  44  in. 

The  materials  most  generally  used  are  Broken  Stone,  Furnace  Slag, 
Gravel,  Burnt  Clay,  Sand,  Cinders  and  Earth. 

DEFINITIONS. 

Broken  or  Crushed  Stone. — Stone  broken  by  mechanical  means  into 
small  fragments  of  specified  size. 

Gravel. — Small  worn  fragments  of  rock,  coarser  than  sand,  from  nat- 
ural deposits. 

Sand. — Any  hard  granular  rock  material,  finer  than  gravel  or  coarser 
than  dust. 

Cinders. — The  ashes  or  residue  from  coal  used  in  locomotives  and 
other  furnaces,  including  the  sparks  from  the  front  end  of  locomotives. 

Slag. — Waste  product.  A  more  or  less  vitrified  form  of  furnace  re- 
duction of  ore.  This  to  include  the  granulated  slag  formed  by  dumping 
hot  slag  into  water  or  any  other  product  of  a  blast  furnace,  iron,  copper 
or  lead. 

Burnt  Clay. — Clay  or  gumbo,  which  has  been  treated  with  fire. 

Mud  Ballast. — Any  natural  material  used  as  ballast,  if,  when  well 
drained,  will  not  churn  under  the  ties. 

description. 

Broken  Stone. — This  in  general  is  considered  the  best  material  for 
ballast,  as  it  meets  the  requirements ;  does  not  freeze  nor  heave  in  cold 
weather,  and  can  be  worked  in  wet  and  dry  weather  alike.  Almost  any 
hard  building  stone  may  be  used,  provided  it  breaks  with  an  angular  frac- 
ture and  not  into  thin,  flat  pieces.  Granite,  trap,  limestone  and  flint  are 
mostly  used. 

Gravel. — This  material  is  more  used  than  any  other  and  is  a  varying 
quality.  It  may  he  sandy,  dusty  or  loamy,  or  else  full  of  large  stone,  which, 
unless  removed,  will  make  an  irregular  and  rough  riding  track.  The  best 
gravel  should  be  clean  and  coarse,  and  as  far  as  possible  of  uniform  size 
and  quality.  It  does  not  give  as  good  drainage  as  stone,  but  a  fairly 
coarse  and  clean  gravel  generally  proves  satisfactory,  provided  plenty  of 
it  is  used. 

Sand. — This,  when  clean,  sharp  and  granulated,  makes  fairly  good  bal- 
last under  light  traffic,  but  unless  it  is  very  coarse  requires  constant  atten- 


292  BALLAST. 

tion  and  renewa':.  involving  a  great  deal  of  maintenance  work,  as  it  runs 
out  from  under  the  ties  and  is  gradually  weathered  away  by  the  action  of 
the  elements.  Where  gravel  or  sand  ballast  is  full  of  dust  it  should  be 
provided  by  a  top  dressing  of  coarse  cinders  or  coarse  stone  screenings,  so 
as  to  avoid  dusty  track. 

Slag. — Furnace  slag  or  cinder  is  commonly  used  on  roads  in  the  vicin- 
ity of  blast  furnaces  and  iron  works.  Coarse  slag  is  about  as  durable  as 
broken  stone  and  in  some  ways  almost  as  good,  except  that  the  ties  decay 
more  rapidly  from  dry  rot  than  in  stone  ballast.  At  the  present  time  slag 
from  blast  furnaces  and  iron  works  is  being  furnished  in  granulated  shape. 
This  is  done  by  dumping  the  slag  into  water,  the  product  of  which,  when 
taken  out,  is  similar  to  and  about  the  same  quality  as  sand  ballast.  When 
first  placed  in  the  track  it  is  very  dusty,  but  the  repeated  rains  relieve  this 
condition.  Its  drainage  qualities  are  much  better  than  that  furnished  by 
sand  ballast. 

Burnt  Clay. — This  is  being  used  in  England  and  other  foreign  coun- 
tries; has  extended  to  this  country  and  is  being  used  extensively  in  the 
West.  The  most  suitable  is  brick  clay,  or  almost  any  clay  that  has  not  too 
much  sand,  gumbo  or  clayey  earth.  Burnt  clay  is  very  light  and  is  about 
equal  to  screened  locomotive  cinders. 

Mud  Ballast. — Dirt,  earth  and  mud  are  used,  the  ballast  being  com- 
posed of  natural  soil  along  the  road.  This  is  the  cheapest  material  to  be 
used  and  generally  the  most  troublesome  to  maintain.  It  is  of  a  variable 
quality,  from  sandy  to  clayey.  Unless  very  sandy,  cakes  in  hot  weather 
and  when  any  work  is  done  it  becomes  intolerably  dusty.  In  the  winter  it 
heaves  badly  by  frost  and  in  rainy  weather  it  washes  out  and  in  continued 
wet  seasons,  or  :n  the  spring,  when  the  frost  is  coming  out  of  the  ground, 
it  becomes  so  solt  that  it  is  almost  impossible  to  keep  track  in  safe  con- 
dition, as  the  ties  churn  the  saturated  roadbed  into  mud.  In  other  words, 
good  mud  ballast  is  a  continuous  performance,  every  day  in  the  year,  Sun- 
days included. 

SPECIFICATIONS. 

BROKEN    STONE. 

Broken  stone  ballast  shall  be  made  from  stone  hard  enough  to  prevent 
pulverizing  under  the  treatment  to  which  it  is  subjected,  also  durable  and 
tough  enough  to  resist  the  disintegrating  action  of  the  elements  where  it  is 
used,  or  from  other  stone,  acceptable  to  the  Engineer. 

When  crushed  it  shall  break  into  angular  pieces  and  the  maximum  size 
shall  not  exceed  pieces  which  will  pass  through  a  revolving  screen  having 
two  (2)  in.  holes,  and  the  minimum  size  shall  lie  on  a  revolving  screen  hav- 
ing three-quarter  (24)  in.  holes. 

Stone  shall  be  crushed  in  suitable  crushers ;  be  clean  and  free  from  all 
dust,  rubbish,  dirt  and  particles  three-quarter  (%)  in.  in  diameter  and 
under.  If  crushed  by  hand,  the  stone  should  be  broken  in  clean  places 
especially  selected  for  the  purpose. 


BALLAST.  293 

STONE    SCREENINGS. 

Stone  screenings  shall  be  made  from  the  same  quality  of  stone  as  stone 
ballast,  as  it  is  a  by-product  of  the  crusher.  The  maximum  size  shall  not 
exceed  pieces  which  will  pass  through  a  revolving  screen  having  three- 
quarter  (54)  in.  holes  and  the  minimum  size  shall  lie  on  a  revolving  screen 
having  one-quarter  {%)  in.  holes.  The  product  shall  be  free  from  all  dust, 
dirt,  rubbish  and  particles  that  will  pass  through  a  one-quarter  (%)  in. 
ring  and  under. 

CINDERS. 

Cinder  ballast  shall  be  free  from  ashes,  dirt  and  rubbish. 

SLAG. 

Slag  ballast  shall  be  free  from  lime,  dirt  and  rubbish,  and  the  product 
from  the  mill,  if  not  quenched  in  water,  should  be  broken  into  pieces  which 
will  pass  through  a  revolving  screen  having  two  (2)  in.  holes,  and  the  mini- 
mum size  shall  lie  on  a  revolving  screen  having  three-quarter  (54)  in. 
holes.  If  slag  is  quenched  in  water  to  form  granulated  slag,  this  product 
shall  be  free  from  dirt,  lime  and  rubbish,  or  any  material  that  will  not 
pass  through  a  two  (2)  in.  ring. 

GRAVEL. 

The  best  should  be  clean  and  coarse,  free  from  dirt,  dust,  marl  lime,  and 
stone  that  will  disintegrate  under  the  action  of  the  elements,  and  should 
range  in  size  from  two  (2)  in.  in  diameter  to  coarse  sand.  Gravel  should 
be  screened  or  washed  where  prevention  of  dust  is  an  object,  but  this  need 
not  be  done  when  the  traffic  is  such  that  it  is  not  objectionable. 

SAND. 

Fine  gravel  or  sand  ballast  should  be  free  from  dirt,  rubbish,  marl  lime 
and  pebbles  that  will  disintegrate  under  the  action  of  the  elements,  and 
should  range  in  size  from  two  (2)  in.  in  diameter  to  fine  sand,  a  portion 
of  about  75  and  8c  per  cent,  to  20  and  25  per  cent,  of  coarser  material. 

BURNT   CLAY. 

This  ballast  should  be  made  of  clay  free  from  sand  or  silt.  The  clay 
should  be  burnt  Lard  and  thoroughly.  The  fuel  used  should  be  fresh  and 
clean  enough  to  burn  with  a  clean  fire.  Ballast  should  be  allowed  to  cool 
before  loading.  Absorption  of  water  should  not  exceed  fifteen  (15)  per 
cent,  by  weight.  Ballast  must  be  free  from  all  worthless  material,  dirt, 
dust  and  rubbish. 

EARTH    OR    MUD    BALLAST. 

Ballast  should  be  taken  from  sub-soil  and  be  of  such  material  that 
when  placed  in  the  track  water  will  drain  off  readily  from  the  top. 

TOP-BALLAST. 

This  should  consist  of  the  same  material  as  ballast  proper,  except 
when  a  dustless  roadbed  is  required  the  upper  two  or  three   (2  or  3)  in. 


294 


BALLAST. 


should  consist  of  two  or  three-quarter  (2  or  tf )  in.  stone,  slag,  screened 
gravel  or  cinders. 

SUB-BALLAST. 

This  should  be  sand,  stone  screenings,  stone  dust,  ^»ulated  8^ 
any  material  that  will  form  a  cushion  and  dram  readily.  Sub-ballast 
should  be  clean  in*  free  from  dirt  and  rubbish. 

RECOMMENDED    PRACTICE. 

STONE,  SLAG  AND  GRAVEL. 

Coarse  stone  coarse  slag  or  coarse  gravel  should  be  used ,  if  obtain- 
-Me  on  aH  h  gh  peed  and  heavy  freight  tracks.  When  not  obtainable,  *e 
ht^vnaitbLgmaterial  should  be  used,  and  if  a  dust  less  trac *u ,  de««d 
top  dress  with  crushed  stone,  screenings,  crushed  slag,  washed  erave 
or  cinders.  „,-kT™ 

CINDERS,   STONE    SCREENINGS    AND    SAND. 

The  use  of  cinders,  stone  screenings  and  sand   as    ballast    ^gtm 
meiJed  for  the  following  situations  on  Main  and  Branch  Lines  with  light 

tl'affiOn  sidings  and  in  yard  tracks;  as  sub-ballast  *£JJ^J^ 
cuts  on  fills,  and  through  clay  bottoms;  as  sub-ballast  on  new  work 
where  fills  are  settling  and  at  places  where  track  heaves  from  frost. 

BURNT  CLAY. 

The  use  of  burnt  clay  as  a  ballast  is  recommended  for  the  following 

SitUaOnnMain  and  Branch  Lines  with  medium  traffic.  On  sidings  as  a 
top  dressing  to  secure  a  dustless  track. 

EARTH    AND  MUD. 

The  use  of  earth  or  mud  is  recommended  only  when  more  suitable 
material  Ho.  obtainable.    If  used  it  should  be  rounded  up  ,„  the  cente, 

of  the  track,  so  that  water  will  drain  off  readily. 

RECOMMENDED   DEPTH    OF   BALLAST. 

Kind  of  Ballast.  Sub-Ballast.    Ballast-Proper.  ToP-Ballast^ 

12  in.  to  18  m.  o  m.  to    e  m. 

Crushed  stone   • .  6  in.  to    8  in. 

Crushed  stone  screenings io  m.         -  in.  to  la  in.  *  ^  .  ^ 

Crushed  slag       I0  in.  to  12  in.        6  in.  to    Sin. 

Granulated   slag   »  £        ^  ^   ^  jg  ^        fi  ^  tQ    g  •„. 

^raV/   I2in.  io  in.  to  12  in.        6  in.  to    8  in. 

^an,d  I2in.  io  in.  to  12  in.        6  in.  to    8  m. 

Cinderl, I2in.  toiSin.        6  in.  to    8  in. 

Burnt  Clay  q  in.  to  n  in. 

Earth  or  Mud 2  in    to     3  in. 

Dust  Guard  :  All  kinds  of  ballast 


BALLAST.  295 

RECOMMENDATIONS  AS  TO  THE  USE  OF  OIL  TO  SECURE  A 
DUSTLESS  ROADBED. 

Approximately  2,000  gallons  of  oil  are  required  for  each  mile  of  single 
track  and  the  first  cost  is  about  $80.00  per  mile.  Oil  is  usually  applied  in 
June  and  the  one  application  is  sufficient  for  the  year,  except  where  road- 
bed is  disturbed,  when  a  local  application  is  necessary,  which  can  be  made 
with  a  sprinkling  pot.  The  application  of  subsequent  years  is  thinner  and 
is  sometimes  postponed  until  dust  develops,  when  the  cost  of  applying,  per 
mile  of  single  track,  where  the  company  owns  its  own  oil  car,  exclusive 
of  the  royalty,  is  approximately  $38.00. 

The  oil  is  generally  furnished  by  the  Standard  Oil  Company  for  this 
purpose  and  appears  to  be  unrefined,  from  which  the  more  volatile  parts 
have  been  removed. 

The  ballast  on  which  oil  is  generally  used  is  either  cinder,  a  mixture 
of  sand  and  gravel  or  sand.  The  oil  has  no  appreciable  effect  on  the  effort 
to  keep  good  line  and  surface,  except  where  the  ballast  is  largely  sand. 
The  oil  makes  the  sand  incohesive,  causing  the  line  and  surface  to  deterio- 
ate  very  rapidly.  The  oil  helps  to  shed  rainwater,  but  has  no  apparent 
effect  on  the  durability  of  ballast,  except  as  stated  above,  in  regard  to  sand 
ballast.  The  oil  penetrates  usually  about  one  (1)  in.  on  cinder.  On  sand 
it  appears  to  soak  down  indefinitely. 

If  clean  washed  gravel  can  be  obtained  or  if  gravel  is  only  dusty  a 
short  time  after  being  disturbed,  the  use  of  oil  is  not  recommended,  as 
even  after  the  oil  is  applied,  the  high-speed  trains  raise  a  fine  oily  dust 
which  is  worse  than  the  clean  dust,  so  that  if  a  dustless  roadbed  is  re- 
quired, the  recommendations  are  the  use  of  a  top  dressing  of  coarse  stone 
screenings,  crushed  slag,  burnt  clay,  screened  or  washed  gravel  or  screened 
cinders. 

DESCRIPTION  OF  BALLAST   AS   SHOWN   BY   PHOTOGRAPHS 
ACCOMPANYING  THIS  REPORT: 

No.  1.    "Trap  Rock"  from  Westfield,  Mass. 

No.  2.    "Limestone"  from  Clinton  Point,  N.  Y. 

No.  3.  "Gneiss,"  "Granite,"  "Hornblende"  and  other  refuse  from  an 
iron  mine  at  Tilly  Foster,  N.  Y. 

No.  4.     "Limestone"  from  South  Bethlehem,  N.  Y. 

No.  5.  "Marble"  from  Gouverneur,  N.  Y.  Note  the  difference  in  color. 
Light  portion  is  direct  from  the  crusher,  while  the  dark  portion  has  been 
in  track  two  years. 

No.  6.     "Flint"  and  "Limestone"  from  Akron,  N.  Y. 

No.  7.    "Burnt  Clay." 

No.  8.    "Furnace  Slag." 

No.  9.    "Trap  Rock"  from  Little  Falls,  N.  Y. 

No.  11.     "Sandstone"  from  Medina. 

No.  12.     "Limestone"  from  Pennsylvania. 

No.  13.    "Limestone"  from  Bellefonte,  Pa. 


296  BALLAST. 

No.  14.    "Screenings"  from  Akron,  N.  Y. 

No.  15.     "Crystalized  Sandstone"  from  Niagara  Falls. 

No.  16.  "Gravel"  from  Beaver  River.  This  is  such  gravel  as  is  used 
on  the  Adirondack  Division  of  the  New  York  Central. 

No.  17.  "Gravel"  from  Yosts  on  the  Mohawk  Division  of  the  New 
York  Central  and  is  of  first  quality. 

No.  18.    "Gravel"  from  Todd's  Pit  on  the  M.  &  M. 

No.  19.  "Gravel"  from  Glenfield  Pit  on  the  R.  W.  &  O.  Division. 
This  material  is  coarse  sand  and  makes  very  good  ballast,  though  some- 
what dusty  when  put  in  track. 

No.  20.  "Granulated  Slag"  from  blast  furnace.  Sample  here  shown 
is  quite  coarse  and  full  of  black  cinders. 

No.  21.     "Gravel"  from  Fisher's  Pit,  Western  Division. 

No.  22.     "Medium  Coarse  Gravel"  from  Fisher's  Pit,  Western  Division. 

No.  23.     "Locomotive  Cinder." 


BALLAST. 


297 


298 


BALLAST. 


BALLAST. 


299 


300 


BALLAST. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  III— ON  TIES. 


L.  A.  Downs,  Chairman; 
H.  W.  Brown. 
W.  J.  Burton. 
L.  C.  Hartley. 

E.  D.  Jackson. 

F.  G.  Jonah. 
H.  C.  Landon. 
F.  R.  Layng. 
D.  O.  Lewis. 


G.  W.  Merrell,  V  ice -Chair  man ; 
Duncan  MacPherson. 
L.  M.  Perkins. 
J.  G.  Shillinger. 

G.   D.   SWINGLY. 

D.  W.  Thrower. 
H.  K.  Wicksteed. 
H.  S.  Wilgus. 

Committee. 


To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Ties  has  had  under  investigation  during  the  past 
year  three  of  the  subjects  assigned  by  the  Board  of  Direction,  and  here- 
with respectfully  submits  its  report: 


(i)     SIZE    OF    CROSS-TIES    REQUIRED    FOR    THE    STRESSES 
TO  WHICH  THEY  ARE  SUBJECTED. 

The  stresses  to  which  ties  are  subjected  cannot  be  considered  as  hav- 
ing no  interrelation  to  the  other  parts  of  a  roadway.  On  the  contrary, 
the  size  of  rail,  the  load  above  and  the  bearing  beneath  the  tie,  the  subsoil, 
the  character  of  the  material  between  ties,  the  presence  or  absence  of  tie- 
plates,  screw  versus  common  spikes,  and  many  other  conditions,  actual 
and  theoretical,  must  be  considered.  It  was  thought  best  to  obtain  from 
various  members  opinions  along  certain  lines  and  for  that  purpose  a  set 
of  questions  was  prepared  (see  Exhibit  A)  by  the  Sub-Chairman  and  sent 
out  by  the  Secretary  to  all  members.  Forty  replies,  representing  about 
4  per  cent,  of  membership,  or  32  per  cent,  of  the  mileage  represented  in 
the  Association,  were  received.  These  replies  have  been  tabulated  (see 
Exhibit  F  and  F-i).  The  preparation  of  the  questions  and  the  tabula- 
tion of  the  answers  have  required  considerable  time  and  patience.  The 
tabulation  is  worthy  of  careful  study,  for  it  contains  information  and 
data  of  much  value.  Indeed,  it  is  an  epitome  ot  much  that  is  not  ger- 
mane to  but  which  is  closely  allied  to  the  topic.  The  size  of  Table  F  is 
regrettable,  but  it  is  considered  that  the  information  in  that  form  is  most 
readily  comparable. 

The  various  sizes  of  ties  already  in  common  use,  as  prepared  by  the 

301 


302  TIES. 

Tie  Committee,  are  tabulated  on  pp.  771-774,  Proceedings  for  1905,  Amer- 
ican Railway  Engineering  Association.  This  table  has  been  rearranged 
in  order  to  tabulate  information  under  the  following  heads,  viz. : 

(1)  Different  number  of  ties  per  30- ft.   rail.     (See  Exhibit  B.) 

(2)  Is  a  6x8x8  tie  too  small;  is  a  larger  tie  than  6x8x8  undesirable? 
(See  Exhibit  C.) 

(3)  Different  sizes  of  cross-ties  in  current  use.  (See  Exhibit  D.) 
A  study  of  Exhibit  B  shows  a  preponderance  of  mileage  and  mem- 
bership (42.7  and  38  per  cent.,  respectively)  in  favor  of  16  ties  to  the 
30- ft.  rail  (2,816  per  mile),  main  track.  During  the  six  years  interven- 
ing the  railroads  seem  to  have  increased  the  number,  for  the  general 
average  of  a  rail-bearing  area,  as  per  Exhibit  F,  is  about  40  per  cent., 
whereas  in  1905  it  ran  about  35^4  per  cent.  Exhibit  B,  however,  indi- 
cates that  in  1905  17  (2,992  per  mile)  and  18  (3,168  per  mile)  ties  per 
30-ft.  rail  (bearing  area  of  38  per  cent,  and  40  per  cent.,  respectively, 
based  on  8-in.  ties)  were  in  strong  favor. 

Exhibit  C  was  prepared  in  order  to  ascertain  the  feeling  as  to  proper 
size  of  cross-ties.  It  would  appear  that  59  per  cent,  of  the  mileage  voting 
believed  a  6x8x8  ft.  too  small,  whereas  96  per  cent,  thought  a  larger 
tie  not  undesirable. 

Exhibit  D  indicates  22  sizes  of  cross-ties  in  current  use,  with  47  per 
cent,  of  the  mileage  and  48  per  cent,  of  the  membership  reported  as  using 
6x8x8,  whereas  that  tie  is  believed  unsatisfactory  by  59  per  cent.  (Exhibit 
C)  of  the  voting  mileage,  and  96  per  cent,  Exhibit  C,  believe  a  larger 
tie  desirable.  These  tables  all  show  an  inconsistency  among  the  rail- 
roads as  to  what  they  really  do  desire.  There  is  no  doubt  that  the  senti- 
ment is  in  favor  of  a  larger  tie,  but  the  sentiment  stage  is  not  overcome. 

The  length  of  tie  apparently  has  not  been  considered  so  much  as 
width  and  depth.  Exhibit  D  shows  that  of  139,029  miles  represented,  25,- 
112  miles  or  18  per  cent,  reported  ties  8  ft.  6  in.  in  length.  The  length 
of  a  tie  between  recognized  limits  has  a  great  influence  on  the  distribu- 
tion of  its  superimposed  load  over  the  ballast  and  consequent  tie  crush- 
ing as  well  as  the  amount  of  maintenance  work  required  with  poor  bal- 
last, poor  subgrade,  or  both.  Ten  and  three-tenths  (10.3)  per  cent,  re- 
ported in  favor  of  a  7x9x8  ft.  6  in.  and  none  in  favor  of  a  6x8x8  ft.  6  in. 
(6x8x8  ft.  is  the  most  popular). 

A.  M.  Wellington,  in  his  incomparable  treatise  on  "The  Economic 
Theory  of  Railway  Location,"  touches  admirably  on  the  topic  of  this 
Committee  in  paragraphs  1044  to  1050,  inclusive.  The  extracts  from  these 
paragraphs  as  follows  are  most  apropos : 

"1044.  The  number  of  these  (ties)  cannot  be  too  great  for  economy, 
until  they  become  so  close  as  to  impede  tamping,  which  is  when  about  40 
per  cent,  of  the  length  of  the  rail  rests  upon  ties. 

"1046 In  endeavoring  to  get  the  utmost  stability  at  the 

least  cost  the  first  essential  is  to  use  ties  as  freely  as  is  possible,  and  the 
next  essential  is  to  decide  between  a  heavier  rail  and  more  tamping  to 
supply  the  deficit. 


TIES. 


303 


"1051 The  best  dimensions   for  a  tie   are  about.  7   in. 

thick,  8  ft.  6  in.  long  and  7  in.  to  9  in.  face." 

The  Committee  has  been  unable  to  find  any  data  in  the  publications 
of  the  Association  bearing  on  the  crushing  strength  across  the  grain  of 
the  various  woods  used  for  tie  purposes,  except  on  pp.  853-4,  Volume 
11,  Part  2,  Proceedings,  1910,  American  Railway  Engineering  Association. 
That  table  is  intended  partially  to  show  the  effect  of  preservative  treat- 
ment on  crushing  strength  at  elastic  limit  and  the  average  of  tests  for 
various  woods  is  as  follows  : 

Table   I. 

BEARING  STRENGTH   OF  TIES  UNDER  THE  RAIL  TESTS. 

(See  Proceedings,  Vol.  n.  Part  2,  pp.  853-4.) 


Natural 

Treated 

No. 
of  Teats 

Crushing  at 
E.  L. 

No. 
of  Tests 

Crushing  at 
E.  L. 

Remarks 

Red  Oak..   . 

100 
70 
30 
20 
29 

249 

1090 
612 
640 
688 
830 

100 
70 
30 
20 
29 

249 

1080 
591 
618 
725 
791 

1.    Crude  oil,  529. 

1.    Crude  oil,  373. 

1.    Crude  oil,  655. 

The  natural  crushing  strength  at  elastic  limit  herein  given  does  not 
compare  favorably  with  simlar  results  obtained  by  the  United  States 
Government  (see  Exhibit  G),  because  of  the  difference  in  character  of 
material  and  moisture  content.  The  Forestry  Service  Circular  189  (see 
footnote  page  311  states,  "...  it  is  not  safe  to  base  working  stresses 
on  results  secured  from  any  but  green  material." 

The  Director  of  the  Forest  Products  Laboratory,  Forestry  Service, 
Madison,  Wis.,  furnished  the  Sub-Committee  blueprints  of  crushing 
strength  at  elastic  limit  of  timber — air  dry  and  green  and  from  which 
prints  Exhibit  G  is  extracted.  This  table  well  illustrates  why  green 
timber  for  ties  should  be  shunned. 

Exhibit  E  is  a  list  of  articles  on  the  relation  of  the  size  of  cross-ties 
to  the  stresses  to  which  they  are  subjected,  from  search  made  at  the 
Library  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers,  June  12,  1911. 

This  list  is  supplemented  as  follows : 

(1)  "Discussion  of  Committee  Report  on  Ballasting,"  by  W.  C. 
Cushing;  Bulletin  76,  June,  1906,  American  Railway  Engineering  Asso- 
ciation. 

(2)  "A  Study  of  Stresses  Existing  in  Track  Superstructure  and 
Rational  Design  Based  Thereon,"  by  O.  E.  Selby;  Bulletin  80,  October, 
1906,  American  Railway  Engineering  Association. 

(3)  "Stresses  in  Track  Fastenings,"  by  W.  C.  Cushing;  Bulletin 
104,  October,  1908. 

(4)  1.  "Experiment  to  Determine  the  Necessary  Depth  of  Stone 
Ballast,"  being  a  report  of  General  Manager's  Committee,  Pennsylvania 
Railroad.  2.  "Gravel  as  Ballast,"  by  C.  Brauning.  (Translated  from  the 
German.)      Bulletin   136,  June,   191 1. 


304  TIES. 

(5)  Volume  7,  Proceedings,  1906  (out  of  print),  American  Railway 
Engineering  Association. 

(6)  Wellington,  A.  M.,  paragraphs  1044  to  1050. 

(7)  International  Railway  Congress,  Proceedings,  1910,  Volume  1, 
Question  2,  Report  No.  1.  Strengthening  of  Track,  by  J.  W.  Jacomb- 
Hood,  Engineer  London  &  Southwestern  Railway. 

Bulletin  136,  June,  191 1,  contains  an  article  entitled  "Experiment  to 
Determine  the  Necessary  Depth  of  Stone  Ballast,"  being  a  report  of  the 
General  Manager's  Committee  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad.  This  re- 
port is  based  on  spacing  of  white  oak  ties  16I/2  in.  face  to  face  for  a  7x9x8 
ft.  6  in.  tie,  which  tie  spacing  is  equivalent  to  25^  in.  center  to  center, 
or  14  ties  per  30  ft.  rail,  which  is  equivalent  to  35  per  cent,  bearing.  That 
Committee  recommended  (page  17)  "the  use  of  24  in.  of  stone  ballast 
underneath  the  ties  to  meet  satisfactorily  the  conditions  that  exist  to-day 
and  which  will  become  probably  more  severe  as  time  goes  on,  and  in 
addition  to  the  24  in.  of  trap  rock  ballast  beneath  the  ties,  there  should  be 
provided  a  layer  of  engine  cinders,  gravel  or  an  equivalent  to  act  as  an 
absorbent  mat  to  promptly  and  properly  dispose  of  the  water  falling  on 
the  track  in  such  a  manner  as  to  prevent  its  softening  the  roadbed  ma- 
terial." 

Your  Committee  is  of  the  opinion  that  further  investigation  should 
be  made  upon  these  lines  to  ascertain  relation  of  tie  spacing  to  different 
depths  of  ballast. 

O.  E.  Selby,  in  Bulletin  80,  October,  1906,  American  Railway  Engi- 
neering Association,  treats  of  the  stresses  in  ties.  His  recommendation  is 
12  in.  stone  ballast  directly  under  tie,  superimposed  on  12  in.  gravel,  with 
ties  spaced  20  in.  center  to  center   (45  per  cent.). 

Thos.  H.  Johnson's  formulae  for  depth  of  ballast  and  tie-spacing  for 
gravel  and  stone  ballast  appear  in  Bulletin  76,  June,  1906. 

It  came  to  the  notice  of  the  Sub-Committee  that  the  Erie  Division  of 
the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  was  experiencing  trouble  with  yellow  pine  tie 
splitting;  it  therefore  wrote  to  R.  L.  Roe,  Division  Engineer,  and  replies 
from  his  Supervisors,  W.  E.  Brown,  J.  S.  Considine,  W.  S.  Wilson,  are 
given,  as  follows : 

"In  reply  to  your  circular  of  the  10th  inst,  concerning  effect  of  heavy 
engines  on  yellow  pine  ties,  would  advise  that,  on  that  part  of  the  Mary- 
land Division  between  Baltimore  and  Perryville,  where  no  engines  heav- 
ier than  Di6d  were  used,  yellow  pine  ties  were  found  equal  to  oak  as  far 
as  the  wearing  qualities  were  concerned  under  the  100-lb.  rail  without 
tie-plates.     This  was  prior  to  1905. 

"When  I  came  to  this  division  in  July,  1905,  I  found  that  a  fair 
percentage  of  yellow  pine  ties  were  used  in  the  main  track,  some  of  which 
had  been  in  service  about  three  years  and  were  all  in  fair  condition.  At 
that  time  only  one  class  E  engine  was  in  service.  During  the  next  two 
years  more  of  this  heavier  class  of  engines  were  used,  and  in  the  spring 
of  1907  we  noticed  that  some  of  the  yellow  pine  ties  which  had  been  in 
service  less  than  a  year  were  beginning  to  show  signs  of  crushing.  With 
the  increased  use  of  the  class  E  engines  the  tendency  to  split  seems  to 
grow  more  pronounced  yearly. 


TIES.  305 

"The  R.  &  C.  (a  light  traffic  line)  has  a  large  percentage  of  yellow 
pine  ties  in  track,  but  fail  to  notice  so  marked  a  tendency  in  the  pine 
ties  to  split  as  on  the  Renovo  Division,  in  spite  of  the  fact  that  very  few 
of  the  branch  ties  are  tie-plated. 

"Perhaps  this  difference  may  be  due  to  the  increased  tonnage  on  the 
Renovo  Division,  but  the  fact  that  tie-plates  are  more  generally  used  be- 
tween West  Creek  and  Strebor  should  counteract  to  some  extent  the 
heavier  traffic  and  we  are  inclined  to  attribute  the  failure  of  the  yellow 
pine  ties  more  to  excessive  axle  load  on  class  E  engine  drivers  than  to 
the  number  of  axles  which  may  be  hauled  over  the  division." 

"Replying  to  yours  of  the  ioth,  regarding  effect  of  heavy  engines  on 
pine  ties,  we  find  that  pine  ties  without  tie-plates  become  crushed  and 
checked  badly  under  the  rail  long  before  they  are  decayed  or  otherwise 
unfitted  for  service. 

"The  application  of  a  tie-plate  when  tie  is  in  this  condition  will,  of 
course,   prolong  the   life  to   some   extent. 

"It  is  the  practice  at  the  present  time  to  use  plates  on  all  pine  ties 
when  first  put  in  track,  and  while  the  greatest  amount  of  service  is  ob- 
tained from  the  tie  by  this  method,  our  experience  has  not  been  sufficient 
in  this  line  to  say  definitely  that  they  will  not  crush  under  the  heavy  con- 
centrated wheel  loads  where  plates  are  so  applied." 

"In  reply  to  Mr.  H.  S.  Wilgus'  letter  of  the  8th  inst,  relative  to 
crushing  our  yellow  pine  ties  due  to  the  heavy  concentrated  wheel  loads 
of  our  heavy  engines,  it  has  always  been  my  opinion  that  if  we  get  good 
sound  yellow  pine  ties  and  use  tie-plates  with  them,  we  will  get  prac- 
tically the  same  life  out  of  them  as  we  get  out  of  the  white  oak  ties. 

"Some  years  ago  when  track  elevation  work  was  done  on  the  P.  B.  & 
W.  through  Chester  and  Wilmington,  one  of  the  main  tracks  was  laid  in 
white  oak  ties  and  the  other  in  yellow  pine  ties.  I  have  been  told  that  a 
great  many  of  these  pine  ties  are  still  in  track,  while  a  majority  of  the 
oak  ties  have  been  removed.  Pine  ties  without  tie-plates  soon  split  and 
crush  and  wear  out  rather  than  rot  out.  We  have,  however,  a  great  many 
now  in  track  on  this  division  that  were  installed  about  eleven  years  ago 
with  tie-plates  and  they  are  in  fair  condition  considering  the  service  they 
are  giving." 


EXHIBIT  A. 

COPY   OF  CIRCULAR. 

(i)  What  percentage  of  a  rail  length  should  have  a  bearing  on  the 
ties?  Does  the  per  cent,  mean  per  cent,  of  linear  distance  or  bearing 
area? 

(2)  Has  this  percentage  any  relation  to,  (a)  Kind  of  timber  used  for 
ties?  (b)  Kind  of  ballast?  (c)  Character  of  sub-grade?  (d)  Tangent  vs. 
curve?     (e)    Minimum  distance  between  face  of  ties? 

(3)  If  the  percentage  is  capable  of  mathematical  deduction,  please 
give  the  method,  etc. 

(4)  Is  crushing  hastened  by  natural  checking  of  ties? 

(5)  Which  class  of  wood  checks  most? 

(6)  Does  preservative  treatment  tend  to  increase  the  tendency  to 
check  ? 


306 


TIES. 


(7)  Does  preservative  treatment  affect  the  natural  crushing  untt 
stresses? 

(8)  (a)  With  the  increased  tie  consumption  and  the  decreased 
available  tie  supply,  can  the  demand  for  larger  sectional  area  of  ties  be 
met?  (b)  If  a  larger  sectional  area  of  the  tie  is  not  available,  what 
would  you  recommend  as  next  best  thing  to  do — use  steel  or  composite 
or  what  not? 

(9)  Has  the  application  of  screw  or  square  spikes  any  effect  on 
crushing? 

(10)  Relation  of  kinds  of  ballast  to  tie  crushing? 

(11)  Relation  of  character  of  sub-grade  to  tie  crushing? 

(12)  Relation  of  axle  load  to  tie  crushing. 

(13)  Relation  of  frequency  of  maximum  axle  load  as  applied  to  a 
tie  to  tie  crushing? 

(14)  Relation  of  maximum  axle  load  to  weight  of  rail  and  conse- 
quent tie  crushing? 

(15)  Relation  of  impact  at  joints  to  tie  crushing? 

(16)  Relation  of  size  of  tie-plates  to  crushing  of  ties? 


EXHIBIT  B. 


DIFFERENT    NUMBER    OF    TIES    PER    30-FT.    RAIL    AND    NUMBER    OF 
MILES  OF  TRACK  REPRESENTED  UNDER  EACH  SUCH  NUMBER. 
Based    on    Table    published    on    pp.    771-774,    Vol.    6,    Proceedings,    1905, 
American    Railway   Engineering-  Association. 


Roads  Voting 

Number  of  Miles 

Percentage  of 
Total  Mileage 

Voting 

No.  of  Ties  to 
30-ft.  Rail,  M.  T. 

Number 

Per  cent  of 
those  Voting 

15 

1,834 

1.4 

12 

9.4 

16 

55,380 

42.7 

48 

38.0 

17 

17,805 

13.8 

21 

16.7 

18 

24,190 

18.7 

21 

16.7 

19 

4,589 

3.5 

3 

2.4 

20 

3,249 

2.5 

3 

2.4 

14-16 

7,180 

5.5 

2 

1.6 

15-16 

83 

— 

1 

0.8 

15-17 

154 

0.1 

1 

0.8 

15-18 

5,984 

4.5 

1 

0.8 

15-19 

1,416 

1.0 

1 

0.8 

16-17 

110 

0.1 

1 

0.8 

16-18 

3,565 

2.7 

3 

2.4 

16-19 

161 

0.1 

1 

0.8 

17-18 

3,016 

3.0 

3 

2.4 

17-20 

153 

0.1 

1 

0.8 

18-19 

49 

0.0 

1 

0.8 

18-21 

404 

0.3 

2 

1.6 

129,322 

100.0 

126 

100.0 

Total  in  Member- 

ship  

259,384 

990 

Per  cent  of  Total 

50 

13 

TIES. 


307 


EXHIBIT  C. 

IS   A  6x8x8  FT.    TIE   TOO   SMALL?      IS  A  LARGER  TIE   THAN  6x8x8 
FT.    UNDESIRABLE? 

Based  on  Table  published  on  page  771,  Vol.  6,  Proceedings,   1905,  Ameri- 
can  Railway   Engineering   Association. 


Yes 

No 

Total  Miles 
appearing 
in  table 

Total  voting  on 
this  point 

Miles 

Per  cent 
of  Total 

Miles 

Per  cent 

Miles 

Per  cent 

Is  6x8x8  ft.  too  small 

33,936 
2,220 

59 
4 

23,678 
51,755 

41 
96 

129,322 
129,322 

59,614 
51,755 

45 

Is  a  larger  tie  than  6x8x8  ft. 
undesirable 

40 

EXHIBIT   D. 

DIFFERENT    SIZES    OF   CROSS-TIES   IN    CURRENT    USE. 

Based  on  Table  published  on  page  771,  Vol.  6,  Proceedings,   1906,  Ameri- 
can   Railway   Engineering   Association. 


Miles  of  Road  Using  Same 

Roads  Voting 

Miles 

Per  cent 

Number 

Per  cent 

6        x    7  x  8 

6        x    8x8 

222 
65,432 

830 

191 
6,506 
13,999 
2,498 
5,184 
14,448 
8,100 
4,182 
1,857 

336 
5,459 
1,440 

952 
1,869 

708 
3,024 

163 

161 
1,468 

0.2 
47.3 
0.6 
0.1 
4.7 
10.1 
1.8 
3.7 
10.3 
5.8 
3.0 
1.4 
0.2 
3.9 
1.0 
0.7 
1.3 
0.5 
2.2 
0.1 
0.1 
1.0 

2 

67 

4 

1 

6 

16 

2 

6 

13 

10 

1 

2 

1 
2 
1 
1 
1 
1 
1 
1 
1 
1 

1.4 

48.0 

6        x    9x8 

2.8 

7        x    7x8 

0.7 

7        x    7x8'6" 

7        x    8x8 

4.2 
11.2 

7        x    8  x  8 '6" 

7        x    9x8 

1.4 
4.3 

7        x    9  x  8 '6" 

9.2 

7        x    9x9 

7.0 

6        x8-10x  8 

0.7 

6-7    x6-12x  8 

1.4 

6J— 8x7-llx  8 

0.7 

7        x  7-9x  8 

1.4 

7  x9-10x  8 

8  x    9  x  8'6" 

0.7 
0.7 

7        x  10  x  8 

0.7 

7        x  10  x  8 '6" 

0.7 

8        x    8x8 

0.7 

7        x7-12x  8 

0.7 

7        x7-10x  8 , ... 

0.7 

7        x7-14x8'6" 

0.7 

139,029 

100.0 

141 

100.0 

EXHIBIT  E. 

BIBLIOGRAPHY   ON   SIZE  OF  CROSS-TIES   IN   RELATION   TO 
THE  STRESSES  TO  WHICH  THEY  ARE  SUBJECTED. 

LIBRARY    OF    THE    AMERICAN    SOCIETY    OF    CIVIL    ENGINEERS. 

Note:     This  is  not  a  complete  search. 

"Loadings    for    Railroad    Bridges,"    Informal    Discussion.      Transac- 
tions,  American   Society  of  Civil   Engineers,   v.   51,   p.   106.      (Contains   a 


308  TIES. 

brief  reference  as  to  the  advisability  of  increasing  the  size  of  ties  for 
heavier  railroad  traffic.) 

"Metal  and  Reinforced  Concrete  Ties."  (Editorial.)  Railroad  Age 
Gazette,  v.  44,  p.  593   (May  1,  1908).     (On  the  durability  of  metal  ties.) 

"Steel  Ties  on  the  Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad."  Railway  and 
Engineering  Review,  v.  48,  p.  443  (June  6,  1908).  (Give  size  of  stand- 
ard steel  tie  and  experience  in  using  it.) 

"The  Life  of  Steel  Ties,"  by  W.  C.  Cushing.  (Railroad  Age  Gazette, 
v.  45,  p.  24  (June  5,  1908).  (Gives  weight  and  size  of  ties  used  in  various 
European  countries,  under  heavy  traffic.) 

"Die  Eisenschwelle,"  by  A.  Haarmann.  Stahl  und  Eisen,  v.  28,  p. 
177  (February  5,  1908).  (History  of  the  use  of  cross-ties  and  profiles 
showing  development  in  size  and  weight.) 

Translation  of  the  same.  "The  Iron  Sleeper,"  by  A.  Haarmann.  The 
Engineer,  v.  105,  p.  189,  216  (February  21,  28,  1908). 

"A  Combination  Steel  and  Concrete  Tie  on  the  Pittsburg,  Fort 
Wayne  &  Chicago  Railway."  Engineering  News,  v.  62,  p.  205  (February 
17,  1910).  (The  weight  of  the  tie  is  800  to  850  lbs.,  there  are  fifteen  of 
these  ties  in  use,  carrying  a  33-ft.  rail  length  of  track.) 

"Report  No.  8  (Austria,  Hungary,  Bulgaria,  Roumania,  Servia  and 
Turkey)  on  the  Question  of  Strengthening  the  Track  with  a  View  of 
Increasing  the  Weight  of  Locomotives  and  the  Speed  of  Trains  (Sub- 
ject II,  Littera  A,  for  discussion  at  the  Eighth  Session  of  the  Railway 
Congress),"  by  Hermann  Rosche.  Bulletin  International  Railway  Con- 
gress, v.  24,  p.  1904,  1950  (May,  1910).  (Gives  speed  of  trains,  wheel 
loads  of  locomotives  and  rolling  stock  and  dimensions  of  sleepers.) 

"Report  No.  9  (all  countries,  except  Austria,  Hungary,  Bulgaria, 
Roumania,  Servia,  Turkey,  America  and  Great  Britain)  on  the  Question 
of  Strengthening  the  Track  with  a  View  to  Increasing  the  Weight  of 
Locomotives  and  the  Speed  of  Trains  (Subject  II,  Littera  A,  for  dis- 
cussion at  the  Eighth  Session  of  the  Railway  Congress),"  by  Blum.  Bui. 
Inter.  Ry.  Cong.,  v.  24,  p.  2497  (June,  1910).  (Tables  1,  2  and  4  con- 
tain data  on  the  length,  weight,  composition  and  speed  of  trains  and  di- 
mensions and  spacing  of  sleepers  on  twenty-one  railroads.) 

"Report  No.  2  (Austria-Hungary,  Roumania,  Holland,  Luxemburg, 
Germany  and  Switzerland)  on  the  Question  of  Maintenance  of  Way  on 
Lines  with  Heavy  Traffic."  (Subject  IV  for  discussion  at  the  Sixth  Session 
of  the  Railway  Congress),"  by  J.  W.  Post.  Bui.  Int.  Ry.  Congress,  v.  14, 
p.  21  (March,  1900). 

"Report  No.  1  (Great  Britain)  on  the  Question  of  Strengthening 
the  Track  and  the  Bridges,  with  a  View  to  Increasing  the  Speed  of 
Trains"  (Subject  for  discussion  at  the  Eighth  Session  of  the  Railway 
Congress),  by  J.  W.  Jacomb-Hood.  Bui.  Inter.  Ry.  Cong.,  v.  23,  p.  571 
(July,    1909).      (Contains  two   pages   on    cross-ties.) 

"Report  No.  4  (America)  on  the  Question  of  Strengthening  the 
Track  and  the  Bridges,  with  a  View  of  Increasing  the  Speed  of  Trains 
(Subject  II   for   discussion  at  the   Eighth  Session   of  the   Railway   Con- 


TIES.  309 

gress),"  by  M.  L.  Byers.     Bui.  Int.  Ry.  Cong.,  v.  23,  p.  879   (September, 
1909). 

"Compound  Sleepers  on  the  Michel  System,"  by  Hector  Michel. 
Bulletin  International  Railway  Congress,  v.  23,  p.  1506  (November,  1909). 
(Contains  results  of  experiments  made  on  the  Paris-Lyons-Mediterra- 
nean Railway,  giving  curves  of  deformation  of  various  cross-ties,  and  de- 
termination of  what  length  they  should  be.) 

"La  Superstructure  des  Voies  des  Chemins  de  Fer  Allemands,"  by 
M.  Blum.  Revue  Generale  des  Chemins  de  Fer  et  des  Tramways,  v.  31, 
Pt.  2,  p.  277  (November,  1908).  (Gives  weight,  size,  material,  etc.,  of 
cross-ties  employed  on  railroads  in  Germany.) 

"La  Voie  Courante  des  Chemins  de  Fer  de  L'Etat  Beige,"  by  Pierre 
Decamps.  Revue  Generale  des  Chemins  de  Fer  et  des  Tramways,  v.  32, 
Pt.  2,  p.  251  (October,  1009).  (Gives  dimension  of  ties  used  by  the  Bel- 
gian State  Railway  in  track  for  heavy  and  fast  trains.) 

"Two  Foreign  Developments  in  Railway  Ties,"  Engineering  News,  v. 
53,  p.  204  (February  17,  19 10). 

"Railroad  Track  Superstructure  (Editorial)",  Railroad  Gazette,  v.  42, 
p.  326   (March   15,   1907).      (A   discussion  of  M.   Cuenot's  experiments.) 

"Track  Deformations  and  Their  Prevention,"  by  G.  Cuenot.  Rail- 
road Gazette,  v.  42,  p.  363,  416,  453,  485,  5*7,  55o,  588,  618,  654,  681,  713, 
746,  801  (March  15,  22,  29;  April  5,  12,  19,  26;  May  3,  10,  17,  24,  31  i  June 
7,  1907).  (Describes  experiments  and  gives  conclusions  deduced  from 
them.) 

"Note  sur  les  Deformation  Permanentes  de  la  Voie,"  by  M.  Couard. 
Revue  Generale  des  Chemins  de  Fer  et  des  Tramways,  v.  20,  Pt.  2,  p.  29 
(July,  1897).  (Contains  a  page  on  the  influence  of  cross-ties  on  the  de- 
formation of  railway  track.) 

"On  Best  Method  of  Maintaining  the  Track  for  the  Tonnage  and 
Speed  of  To-day."  Proceedings  of  the  Twenty-fourth  Annual  Conven- 
tion of  the  Roadmasters  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association  of  Amer- 
ica," igo6,  p.  15,  40.  (Report  of  the  Committee  with  discussion.)  Ab- 
stract of  same.    Railroad  Gazette,  v.  41,  p.  459  (November  23,  1906). 

"Steel  Ties  on  the  Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad,"  by  W.  M. 
Camp.  Proceedings  of  the  Twenty-sixth  Annual  Convention  of  the  Road- 
masters'  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association  of  America,  1908,  p.  59. 
(Discusses  the  size  and  weight  of  ties.) 

"Kimball  Concrete-Steel  Ties."  Railway  Age,  v.  44,  p.  386  (Septem- 
ber 20,  1907).  (A  type  of  concrete-steel  tie  subjected  to  the  test  of 
heavy  traffic.) 

"Versuche  mit  flusseisern  Querschwellen  in  den  Vereinigten  Staaten 
von  Nordamerika,"  by  K.  A.  Mullenhoff.  Zeitschrift  des  Vereines 
deutscher  Ingenieure,  v.  51,  Pt.  1,  p.  259  (February  16,  1907).  (Describ- 
ing and  comparing  ties  and  fastenings.) 

"The  Tie  Problem  with  Special  Reference  to  Concrete  Ties,"  by  G. 
H.  Kimball,  Journal  Western  Society  of  Engineers,  v.  8,  p,  561  (October, 
1903).     (Thirty-six  pages.) 


310  TIES. 

"Evolution  des  Voies  de  Chemins  de  Fer  en  Vue  des  Grandes 
Vitesees,"  by  Mesanger.  Genie  Civil,  v.  48,  p.  93  (December  9,  1905). 
(Two  pages.) 

"Steel  and  Concrete-Steel  Ties  on  the  L.  S.  &  M.  S.  Ry."  Railway 
and  Engineering  Review,  v.  46,  p.  627  (August  18,  1906.)  (Results  of 
experiments  and  conclusions.) 

"A  Review  of  the  Railway  Tie  Situation"  (Editor  il).  Engineering 
News,  v.  55,  p.  500  (May  3,  1506).  (Contains  a  brief  reference  to  the 
size  of  ties.) 

"Report  of  Committee  on  Ties."  Proceedings  American  Railway 
Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association,  p.  29,  35,  62,  68,  70, 
72  (508-523),  Chicago,  111.,  1906.  (Contains  report  and  discussion  on 
the  dimensions  of  ties.) 

Extract  of  same.    Railway  Age,  v.  41,  p.  464  (March  23,  1906). 

"The  Carnegie  Steel  Tie."  Railroad  Gazette,  v.  41,  p.  64  (July  20. 
1906).     (Two  pages,  illustrated.) 

"Concrete  Railroad  Ties,"  by  G.  H.  Kimball.  Cement  Age,  v.  2,  p. 
763   (April,  1906). 

"Steel  Cross-Ties,"  by  W.  F.  Miller.  Proceedings,  Engineers'  Society 
of  Western  Pennsylvania,  v.  22,  p.  69  CMarch,  1906).  (Description  of 
ties,  giving  size  and  examples  of  their  use.) 

"The  Problem  of  Track  Support,"  by  Samuel  E.  Duff.  Industrial 
World,  v.  40,  p.  301  (August  25,  1906).  (Discusses  cross-tie  system  of 
track  support.) 

"Note  on  the  Economic  Renewal  and  Maintenance  of  Railway  Tracks 
for  High  Speed  Traffic,  Examination  of  a  Vignoles  Track,  with  Cramps, 
Wedges    and    Shock-Absorbers    or    Deadener    Blocks,"    by    L.    Schlussel 
Bulletin    International    Railway    Cong-ess,    v.    21,    p.    379    (April,    1907) 
(Discusses  the  effect  of  traffic  on  ties,  etc.) 

"Experiments  with  Reinforced  Concrete  Ties  in  America,"  by  W.  M. 
Camp.  Bulletin  International  Railway  Congress,  v.  21,  p.  861  (September, 
1907).     (Experience  with  ties  for  high-speed  traffic.) 

"What  will  be  the  Future  Railway  Track  for  Heavy  Traffic?" 
(Editorial.)  Engineering  News,  v.  53,  p.  601  ("June  8.  1905).  (On  the 
substitution  of  concrete  longitudinals  in  place  of  cross-ties  on  tracks  used 
for  heavy  traffic.) 

"New  Concrete  Ties  and  Steel  Ties."  Engineering  News,  v.  54,  p. 
349  (October  5,  1905).  (Tests  under  heavy  traffic  of  concrete  ties  and 
steel  ties;  size  is,  given.) 

"Metal  Ties  in  Germany,"  by  A.  Haarmann.  Railroad  Gazette,  v. 
35.  P-  349  (May  15,  1903).  (Description  of  ties  used  on  an  experi- 
mental road  on  the  George-Marien-Hutten  Railroad.) 

"Steel  Railroad  Ties  in  Europe,"  by  Foster  Crowell.  Railroad 
Gazette,  v.  33.  p.  600  (August  30,  1901). 

"The  Railroad  Cross-Tie  Problem,"  by  S.  Whinery.  Railroad  Ga- 
zette, v.  37,  p.  526,  536  (November  4,  it,  1904). 


TIES. 


311 


"The  Railway  Tie  Question.' 
vember  19,  1903). 

"Further  Use  of  Steel  and  Reinforced  Concrete  Ties 
Engineering  Review,  v.  44,  p.  652  (September  10,  1904). 

"Experiments   with    Steel   and   Reinforced   Concrete   Ties 
and  Engineering  Review,  v.  43,  p.  580  (August  1,  1903). 

"The  Effect  on  Track  of  Modern  Equipment  and  High  Speeds,"  by 
P.  H.  Dudley.  Railway  Age,  v.  35,  p.  409  (March  20,  1903).  (Contains 
references  to  the  effect  of  traffic  on  ties.) 


Engineering  News,  v.  50,  p.  463   (No- 
Railway  and 
Railway 


EXHIBIT  G.t 


Air  Dry 

fife  *                Green 

Species 

Compression  Vertical  to  Grain 

Compression  Vertical  to  Grain 

Stress 

Area, 

In. 

Height 
In. 

No.  of 
Tests 

Per  cen 
Moist. 

Cr.  Str 
atE.L. 
lbs.  per 
sq.  in. 

Stress 

Area, 

In. 

Height 
In. 

No.  of 

Tests 

Per  cent 
Moist. 

Cr.  Str. 

atE.L. 
lbs.  per 
sq.  in. 

1.  Longleaf  Pine... . 

2.  Douglas  Fir 

4x5 
4x8 
4x8 
4x4 
4x4 

4x4 
8x5 
8x5 
8x5 
5x5 
2x2 

4 
16 
10 
8 
6 

4 
16 
14 
12 

8 
2 

22 
44 
32 

51 

49 

29 
4 
3 
5 
6 

57 

25.1 
20.8 
18.1 
20.2 
24.0 

24.8 

17.8 
16.3 
15.1 
13.0 
13.9 

572 
732 
584 
638 
613 

603 
725 
757 
730 
918 
926 

4x4 

4x8 

4 
16 

22 
259 

25.3 
30.3 

568* 
570 

3.     Shortleaf  Pine... 

6x8 
5x8 
5x8 
5x8 
5x5 
5x2 
6x8 
6x8 
4x6 
4x4 
8x4 
4x4 

(Fire 
16 
16 
14 
12 

8 

2 
16 
12 

6 

4 

8 

8 

killed) 
24 
12 
12 
24 
24 
277 
22 
20 
53 
30 
16 
38 

33.7 
37.7 
42.8 
53.0 
47.0 
48.5 
43.6 
40.2 
52.8 
50.4 
67  2 
44.6 

368 
361 
366 
325 
344 
400 
417 

416 

478 
472 

5      Loblolly  Pine.  .  . 

8x5 
8x5 
4x5 
2x2 
7x6 
6x6 
4x4 

16 
8 
8 
2 

15 
6 
4 

12 
7 
8 
57 
25 
26 
6 

19.8 

22.9 
19.5 
16.2 
18.2 
16.8 
15.9 

602 
679 
715 
697 
514 
431 
488 

392 
546 

7 .    Western  Hemlock 

6x4 

6 

30 

48.7 

434 

6x8 
6x6 
6x7 
6x3 
6x2 
6x2 
6x2 
2x2 

16 
12 
9 

14 
12 
10 
8 
2 

13 
14 
13 
13 
12 
11 
12 
186 

86.7 
83.0 
74.7 
75.6 
66.5 
55.0 
56.7 
75.5 

473 

424 

477 

411 

430 

423 

396 

569 

2x2 

2 

36 

10 

924 

2x2 
2x2 

2 

2 

43 
46 

31.8 
50.4 

310 

11.     White  Spruce... 

270 

1 

1 

*  Partially  air  dry. 

t  See  United  States  Department  of  Agriculture,  Forestry  Service  Circular  189,  Forestry  Products 
Laboratory,  Series  issued  January  25,  1912,  "Strength  for  Structural  Timbers." 


EXHIBIT   F. 

SUMMARY  OF  REPLIES  RECEIVED  IN  ANSWER  TO   CIRCULAR  REGARDING   SIZE  OF  CROSS 
TIES    REQUIRED    FOR    THE    STRESSES  TO    WHICH    THEY    ARE    SUBJECTED. 


Name  of  Railroad. 


American  Creosoting  Co 

A.T.&S.F 

B.&O 

B.  AO 

B.&  A 

C.&E.I 

C.  &N.  W 

C.  B.  &Q 

C.  R.  I.  &P 

C.R.I.&P 

C.  R.  R.  of  N.J 

D.  &R.  G 

E.P.&S.  W 

G.T 

I.C 

K.&M 

L.S.&M.S 

L.V 


Officer  and  Title. 


A.  L.  Kuehn, 
General  Superintendent 


R.  J.  Arey, 
Engineer     Grand     Di- 
vision. 

E.  Stimson, 

Chief  Engineer  Mainte- 
nance of  Way. 

A.  W.  Thompson, 
General  Manager. 

Moses  Burpee, 
Chief  Engineer. 


L.  C.  Hartley, 
Chief  Engineer. 

C.  L.  Ransom, 
Res.  Engineer. 

G.  H.  Bremner, 
District  Engineer. 


J.  M.  Brown, 
Engineer     Maintenance 
of  Way. 


Garrett  Davis, 
Superintendent. 

Jos.  O.  Osgood, 
Chief  Engineer. 


A.  O.  Ridgway, 
Asst.  Ch.  Eng. 


J.  L.  Campbell, 
Engineer     Maintenance 
of  Way, 

M.  S.  Blaiklock, 
Eng.  M.  Way. 

D.  W.  Thrower, 
Roadmaster. 

R.  P.  Black, 
Engineer    Maintenance 
of  Way. 

Sam'l  Rockwell, 
Chief  Engineer. 

E.  B.  Ashby, 
Chief  Engineer. 


Mile- 
age. 


10208 


4724 


628 


966 


8020 


670 

2778 

902 

4757 

2245 

175 

1663 
1432 


1 

What  percentage  of  a 
rail  length  should  have  a 
bearing  on  the  ties? 

It  is  not  proper  to  state 
rail  length  should  ha 
This  depends  on  sub-soil 
and  weight  of  rail. 

40  per  cent 

36  per  cent,  for  oak  and 
other  ties  of  similar 
crushing  strength. 

Same  all  through,  as 
No.  2. 

About  30  per  cent 

40  per  cent 

No  data. 

40  per  cent 

40  per  cent.  The  reason 
I  think  it  is  40  per  cent, 
is  that  is  about  as 
many  ties  as  can  be 
reasonably  put  under  the 
rail. 

40  per  cent 

41  per  cent.  This  is 
based  on  the  use  of  18 
ties  per  33-ft.  rail.  Face 
of  ties  9  in. 

Probably  40  to  45  per 
cent. 

We  have  40  per  cent. . . 

45  per  cent 

35  per  cent,  to  40  per 
cent. 

50  per  cent 

45  per  cent 

40  per  cent,  at  least.. . . 


la 

Does  per  cent,  meai 
per  cent,  of  linear  dis 
tance  or  bearing  area? 


that  a  fixed  per  cent,  t 
ve  a  bearing  on  tiet 
,  ballast,   kind  of  woo 


Linear  distance . 


Per  cent,  of  linear  dii 
tance. 


Linear  distance  beat 
ing  area  increased  by  us 
of  tie-plates. 

Linear  distance 


Of  the  linear  distanc 
or  total  area  of  base  c 
rail. 

Linear  distance 


Linear  distance . 


Linear  distance . 


Per    cent,    linear    dis 
tance. 


Linear  distance. .     .. 

Linear  distance 

Bearing  area 

Bearing  area 

Per  cent,  of  linear  diet 
ance 

Linear  distance 


312 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


Name  of  Railroad. 


L.&  A 

L.&N 

M.C 

M.  R.  &B.  T 

M.P 

N.  Y.C.&H.  R 

N.  Y.C.&H.  R 

N.  Y.C.&H.  R 

N.  Y.,  N.  H.  4  H 

N.&W 

N.4W 

Penna.  Lines,  S.  W.  System  . 

Penna.  Lines,  N.  W.  System. 

P.  &  R  

P.&R 

P.  &L.E 

P.&L.E 


Officer  and  Title. 


F.  W.  Green, 
General  Manager. 

T.  Maney. 
General  Roadmaster 

G.  F.  Black, 
Engineer     Maintenance 

of  Way. 

C.  H.  Fake, 
Chief  Engineer. 


J.  R.  Leighty, 
Engineer      Maintenance 
of  Way. 

J.  V.  Neubert, 

Engineer  Track. 
Geo.  W.  Vaughan, 

Engineer     Maintenance 
of  Way. 


Geo.  W.  Kittredge, 
Chief  Engineer. 

H.  L.  Ripley, 
Engineer   of   Construc- 
tion. 


C.  S.  Churchill, 
Chief  Engineer. 

G.  W.  Merrell, 
Assistant  to  General 
Manager. 

W.  C.  Cushing, 
Chief  Engineer  Mainte- 
nance of  Way. 

R.  Trimble, 
Chief  Engineer  Mainte- 
nance of  Way. 

R.  B.  Abbott, 
Division  Engineer. 

F.  S.  Stevens, 
Engineer   Maintenance 

of  Way. 
J.  A.  Atwood, 
Chief  Engineer. 

Edwin  F.  Wendt, 
Assistant  Engineer. 


Mile- 
age. 


260 

4590 

932 

46 


•2829 


2047 


1951 


2889 


1509 


215 


1 

What  percentage  of  a 
rail  length  should  have  a 
bearing  on  the  ties  ? 

About  40  per  cent. . 

40  per  cent 

33§  per  cent 


Most  of  my  experien 
one  kind  of  timber  and 
used,  and  a  class  of  bal 
roads,  therefore  what  o 
made  would  not  be  of 

Cannot  answer  this 
question  definitely.  See 
below. 


From  J  to  i 

The  answers  to  No.  1 
bit  on  the  spacing  of  the 
trains,  and  whether  or 
course  it  is  assumed  that 
as  loblolly,  cypress, 
plated     in      all     main 

45  per  cent 


It  seems  to  me  the 
questions  is  almost  a  ma 
ment  or  experiment  on  a 
piece  of  track  under  the 
tory  expert. 

36.4  per  cent 


40  per  cent,  without 
tie-plates:  30  per  cent 
on  plates. 

41  per  cent.... 


See  No.  3. 


About  40  per  cent. 


30  per  cent,  to  35  per 
cent. 

45  percent 


Some  time  ago  the 
New  York  Central  Lines 
Maintenance  of  Way 
Committee  recommend- 
ed that  45  per  cent,  of  the 
length  of  the  rail  should 
be  supported  by  cross- 
ties.  This  means  45  per 
cent,  of  the  linear  dis- 
tance. 


la 

Does  per  cent,  mean 
per  cent,  of  linear  dis- 
tance or  bearing  area  ? 

Linear  distance 

Linear  distance 

Linear  distance 


ce  has  been  where  but 
one  size  of  tie  has  been 
last  used  on  but  few 
bservations  I  may  have 
general  value. 


Linear  distance . 


Bearing  area . 


and  No.  la  depend  a  good 
tie,  axle  load,  speed  of 
not  ties  are  tie-plated.  Of 
all  soft  wood  ties,  such 
cedar,  etc.,  will  be  tie- 
tracks. 

Per  cent,  of  length  of 
rail. 

answer  to  most  of  your 
tter  of  laboratory  experi- 
n  especially  prepared 
observation  of  a  labora- 


L  in  ear  distance. 


Linear  distance . 


Linear  distance . 


There  is  no  difference. 

Linear  distance 

Linear  distance 

Linear  distance 


313 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


d 

a 

Name  of  Railroad. 

Officer  and  Title. 

Mile- 
age. 

1 

What  percentage  of  a 
rail  length  should  have  a 
bearing  on  the  ties? 

la 

Does    per  cent,  meat 
per  cent,  of  linear  dia 
tance  or  bearing  area? 

IS 

Q.,  M.  &  S 

F.  D.  Anthony, 
Chief  Engineer. 

S.  B.  Rice, 
Engineer     Maintenance 
of  Way. 

R.  Budd, 
Chief  Engineer. 

W.  F.  Purdy, 
Chief  Engineer. 

J.  Carmichael, 
Engineer     Maintenance 
of  Way. 

192 
89 

433 
64 

548 

43  percent 

Ifi 

R.,  F.  &P     

Not  less  than  34    per 
cent. 

Approximately  40  per 
cent. 

36  per  cent,  to  40  per 
cent. 

35  per  cent 

Linear  distance. . . ..i 

w 

8.,  P.&S 

Linear  distance 1 

38 

W.-P.  T 

W.  M 

Bearing  area,  but  witl 
full  face  ties  should  b 
same  for  both. 

Linear  distance,  90-lb 

rail  A.  S.  C,  E,  section. 

Total  replies  received,  40.    Per  cent,  of 
membership,  4  per  cent. 

Per  cent,  of  mileage,  32. 

83644 

Has  this  percentage  any  relation  to 


(a) 


Kind  of  timber  used 
for  ties? 


(b) 
Kind  of  ballast? 


(c) 


Character  of  sub-grade? 


(d) 
Tangent  vs.  Curve? 


le) 


Minimum  distance  be 
tween  face  of  ties? 


Yes,  there  should  be 
sufficient  ties  ao  that  the 
wood  will  not  be  stressed 
beyond  a  proper  work- 
ing limit. 

Yes 


Yes,  the  distributing 
power  of  the  ballast  will 
affect  the  number  of 
ties  to  be  used. 


Yes. 


Yes,  the  sustaining 
power  of  the  sub-grade 
will  affect  the  proper 
number  of  ties  to  be  used. 


Yes. 


Yes,  sufficient  ties 
should  be  used  to  take 
care  of  the  excess  load- 
ing at  curves. 


Six  inches. 


Yes,  it  is  dependent 
upon  strength  of  timber. 
Tie-plates  should  be  used 
distribute  the  load 
upon  the  ties  made  from 
weaker  woods. 


No,  use  practically 
only  soft  woods.  Mostly 
white  cedar,  and  classi- 
fication would  be  im- 
possible. 

No 


Yes,  inasmuch 
stone  ballast  has  greater 
carrying  capacity  and  is 
less  inclined  to  motion 
under  load  and  impact, 
the  percentage  may  be 
less  than  it  would  be 
with  gravel  or  sand. 


It  may  vary  with  the 
bearing  capacity  of  sub- 
grade. 


No. 


Yes 

Practically  none . 


Twelve  inches. 


Yes,  dependent  upon 
material  used  for  ballasl 
and  its  liability  ti 
motion. 


Usually     slightly     in- 
creased on  curves. 


Ten  inches. 


No. 


No. 


No. 


Yes. 


Inferior  ballast  should 
have  greater  bearing. 


Yielding  a  u  b-g  r  a  d  e 
should  have  greater 
bearing. 


Greater    bearing    sur- 
face needed  on  curves. 


Eight  inches... 
Twelve  inches. 


314 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


Has  this  percentage  any  relation  to 


(a) 


Kind   of  timber   used 
for  ties? 


This  percentage  has  no 
or  the  alinement. 


(bl 
Kind  of  ballast? 


relation  to  the  timber  in 


No. 


Practically  not,  be 
cause  spacing  of  ties  is 
fixed  by  other  condi- 
tions. 


To  some  extent . 


No,  we  are  using  prin- 
cipally treated  pine  ties 

None 


Not  if  tie-plates  are 
used  of  proper  width  and 
length.  If  tie-plates  are 
not  used,  very  soft  ties 
should  be  placed  close 
together. 

Good  hardwood  tim- 
ber ties. 

It  applies  to  standard 
conditions  for  each 
particular  piece  of  main 
track,  which  may  vary 
with  character  of  busi- 
ness done  over  that 
track. 

No 


Yes,  based  on  white 
oak  ties,  6x8x8.  Per 
cent,  should  vary  in- 
versely as  resistance  of 
wood  to  crushing. 


(c) 
Character  of  sub-grade? 


the  ties,  kind  of  ballast 


No. 


Practically  not,  al- 
though ties  might  be 
placed  closer  on  gravel  or 
sand,  where  tamping  is 
less  difficult  than  with 
stone  or  slag  ballast. 

To  some  extent .... 


Rock,  slag  and  gravel. 


Gravel . 


Yes,  number  of  ties 
depends  on  the  efficiency 
of  gravel.  Cementing 
gravel  and  slag  require 
less  bearing  area  for  the 
rail. 

Stone  or  gravel 


This  varies  with  stand 
ard  of  each  particular 
piece  of  main  track  as 
above. 


No. 


Yes,  it  should  vary  in- 
versely as  the  firmness 
of  the  ballast. 


(d) 
Tangent  vs.  Curve? 


character    of    sub-grade 


No. 


Not  if  ballast  is  suffi- 
ciently deep  to  properly 
transfer  weights  to  sub 
grade. 


No. 


Generally   sandy   and 
gravelly  earth  and  loam 

Clay 


Yes. 


Average  earth . 


This  also  varies  as  per 


No. 


Yes,  same  as  for  bal- 
last. 


(e) 


Minimum  distance  be- 
tween face  of  ties? 


The  minimum  dis 
tance  between  the  face  ol 
ties  is  about  12  in.  and 
this  necessarily  cannot  be 
very  much  less  as  if  nar- 
rower than  that  it  would 
interfere  with  the  use  ol 
the  shovel  in  taking  care 
of  the  ballast,  and  the 
width  of  the  shovel  is 
about  10  in.  Apparently 
this  would  look  as 
though  the  minimum 
distance  between  ties  at 
the  present  day  is  deter- 
mined by  the  width  of 
the  shovel.  I  do  not 
believe,  however,  the 
standard  on  this  railroad 
differs  materially  from 
that  on  other  roads,  and 
if  ties  were  placed  much 
closer  together  it  would 
be  difficult  to  tamp  the 
ballast  under  them. 


No Thirteen  inches 


Yes,  but  impracticable 
to  make  such  change  on 
account  of  tamping  re 
quirements. 


Yea. 


No  distinction . 


Both. 


Percentage  should  be 
increased  on  curves. 


Both. 


We  use  same  number 
of  ties  for  rail  on  tangents 
as  on  curves. 


No Maximum.  13VS  in 


Joints     9     in.   Inter- 
mediate  13  in. 


Yes. 


Eleven  inches. 


Ten  inches. 
Ten  inches . 


Ten  inches . 


See  standard  blue  print 
attached    and     marked 
F-l." 


Not  for  curves  of  less 
than  8  or  10  degrees. 


Yes,    inversely  as 
thickness  of  tie. 


315 


EXHIBIT   F—  Continued. 


Has  this  percentage  any  relation  to 


(a) 


Band  of  timber  used 
for  ties  ? 


No,  because  it  is  the 
maximum  bearing  area 
that  admits  proper 
tamping. 


Strictly  with  regard  to 
stresses,  yes. 


Yes,  resistance  of  tim- 
ber to  cutting  is  big 
factor. 


No,  if  tie-plates  are 
used,  otherwise  percent- 
age would  vary  with 
hardness  of  ties. 

We  use  only  hardwood 
ties  and  above  data 
refer  to  them. 

White  oak. 

No.  Tie  spacing  lim- 
ited by  minimum  dis 
tance  between  face  of 
ties  required  for  tamp 
ing. 

Based  on  sawed  ties 
(yellow  pine). 

No,  because  no  greater 
percentage  can  be  used 
without  too  much  en- 
croachment on  room 
needed  for  tamping.  If 
ties  are  soft  use  larger 
tie-plates. 


No,  for  reason  under 


Greater  bearing  sur- 
face probably  needed 
in  soft  ballast. 

Do  not  think  this  is  a 
factor  as  far  as  ties  only 
are  concerned.except  that 
wave  motion  of  rail  and 
consequent  rail  cutting 
of  ties  vary  with  differ- 
ent kinds  of  ballast. 

Independent  of  kind  of 
ballast,  provided  it  is 
first-class  and  is  suffi- 
cient in  quantity. 


No. 


Our  road  has  used 
nothing  but  white  oak 
timber  in  the  past. 


(b) 
Kind  of  ballast? 


No,  for  reason   under 


Greater  bearing  sur- 
face probably  needed 
in  soft  sub-grade. 

Same  as  b 


Stone, 
cinder. 


slag,     gravel, 


Stone  or  coarse  gravel 
No.    See  a. 


No. 


Less  ties  might  be 
used  on  stone  ballast  of 
great  depth,  but  where 
these  conditions  prevai 
traffic  is  generally  so 
heavy  that  full  comple- 
ment of  ties  is  needed 

No 


Stone  ballast  is  used. 


(O 
Character  of  sub-grade  ? 


Not  if  ballast  of  suffi- 
cient quantity  and 
quality  is  used. 


Existing  sub-grade  is 
now  generally  old  bal- 
last. 


No.    See  a. 


No. 


Bearing  surface  not 
affected,  but  if  sub- 
grade  is  hard  less  depth 
of  ballast  is  permis- 
sible. 


No. 


No. 


No. 


The  sub-grade  is  3  ft. 
below  top  of  rail  and  this 
3  ft.  is  made  up  of  track 
one  foot,  ballast  one  foot, 
sub-ballast  one  foot.  Our 
road  uses  20  ft.  roadbed, 
10  ft.  on  each  side  of  cen- 
ter line,  in  accordance 
with  the  standard  of  the 
Engineering  Association. 


No. 


(d) 
Tangent  vs.  Curve? 


(e) 


Minimum  distance  be 
tween  face  of  ties  ? 


No,  for  reason  under 


No. 


Increased  tendency  of 
rail  to  cut  ties  on  curve 
as  compared  to  tangent 
would  require  more  ties 
on  curves  than  tangents 
to  maintain  same  con- 
ditions. 

With  proper  elevation 
bearing  on  curve  and 
tangent  should  be  treat- 
ed the  same. 

We  make  no  distinc- 
tion except  to  use  tie- 
plates  on  curves. 


Both 

No.    See  a. 


Yes,  because  it  leave 
the  minimum  space  be 
tween  ties  within  whicl 
proper  tamping  may  tx 
done. 

Greater  bearing  sur 
face  probably  needec 
with  thin  ties. 

Depending  on  ballas 
and  roadbed  and  kirn 
and  size  of^ties. 


No Thirteen  inches 


About  7  in. 


Joint    ties   10   in.,  in 
termediate  ties  12  in. 


Ten  inches. 


Yes.   This  is  the  gov 
erning  point. 


If  superelevation  of 
curves  is  adjusted  to 
speed,  centrifugal  force 
and  gravity  are  in  equi- 
librium and  bearing  sur- 
face^should  not  be  chang- 
ed. 


No. 


We  make  no  difference 
in  the  spacing  of  ties  on 
tangent  or  curves.  All 
track  is  treated  the  same 


No. 


Ten  inches. 


There  should  not  b 
less  than  10  in. 

The  distance  betwee 
face  of  cross-ties  is  12  ii 
We  think  this  distant 
gives  an  opportunity  ft 
tamping  with  a  tampis 
pick  and  our  present  ru! 
is  to  space  ties  12  ij 
apart,  which  meal 
about  20  -  in.  center 
The  45  per  cent,  rule 
not  carried  out  absolut 
ly.  Ties  spaced  12  i 
apart  are  practically 
accordance  with  tl 
spirit  of  this  rule. 

Eleven  inches 


316 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


Has  this  percentage  any  relation  to 


(a) 


Kind  of  timber  used 
for  ties? 


(b) 
Kind  of  ballast? 


(c) 
Character  of  sub-grade? 


(d) 
Tangent  vs.  Curve? 


feO 

Minimum  distance  be- 
tween face  of  ties? 


Certainly.  It  would 
depend  entirely  on  class 
of  timber  used.  For 
soft  woods  per  cent,  of 
bearing  should  be  in- 
creased if  tie-plates  are 
not  used. 

No 


Yes,  the  less  bearing 
properties  the  ballast 
has  the  greater  the 
per  cent,  of  supported 
rail  length  should  be. 


No. 


Yes.  In  rock  cuts, 
hard  clay,  etc.,  bearing 
per  cent,  can  be  at 
a  minimum  of  34  per 
cent.;  on  wet,  soft  road- 
bed, bearing  per  cent, 
should  be  increased. 

No 


The  bearing  surface 
should  be  increased  on 
curves  exceeding  a  3 
degree. 


No. 


18  ties  and  17  spaces 
to  33-ft.  rail. 


No. 


Probably  some  advan- 
tage from  larger  bear- 
ing area  on  soft  ties, 
but  not  in  same  ratio. 
Poor  ties  make  poor 
track,  no  matter  how 
many  be  used. 


No.      Tie-plates    are 
used  on  soft  woods. 


Some  advantage  from 
high-grade  ballast  with 
wide  spacing  of  ties, 
but  much  greater  benefit 
derived  from  good  bal- 
last if  full  bearing  surface 
be  provided  at  same 
time. 

No 


Yes;  with  uniformly 
good,  firm  sub-grade, 
smaller  per  cent,  of 
bearing  surface  may  be 
provided. 


No. 


Higher  per  cent,  on 
curves  especially  of  short 
radius,  more  on  account 
of  gain  in  holding  aline- 
ment  than  for  bearing. 


No.  Hardwood  ties 
and  tie-plates  used  on 
curve. 


Twelve  inches;  less 
will  interfere  with  tamp- 
ing. 


Fifteen  inches. 


If  the  percentage  is 
capable  of  mathematical 
deduction,  please  give 
the  method. 


Is  crushing  hastened 
by  natural  checking  of 
ties  ? 


What   class   of   wood 
checks  most? 


Does  preservative 
treatment  tend  to  in- 
crease the  tendency  to 
check? 


Does  preservative 
treatment  affect  the  nat- 
ural crushing  unit  stress- 


No,     excepting     very 
crudely. 


Yes,  the  crushing 
strength  across  the  grain 
is  reduced  by  checking. 


To  a  large  extent . 


Yes. 


Wood  which  seasons 
rapidly  usually  checks 
the  most;  wood  like 
beech  and  gum  will 
check  more  than  oak. 


Hardwood;  in  oak, 
ash,  elm,  eucalyptus. 

Red  oak  family,  gum, 
beech,  chestnut  and 
other  inferior  woods. 


Not  when  wood  is  air- 
seasoned  and  treated 
without  steaming.  If 
wood  is  steamed  in 
treatment,  checking  will 
usually  be  more  rapid. 

No 


Based  on  20-fix8  ties  to 
33-ft.  rail  and  18-7x9 
ties  to  33-ft.  rail. 


We  do  not  find  check- 
ing of  ties  to  any  extent. 

Believe  checked  ties 
would  naturally  crush 
more  easily  than  solid 
timber. 


Yes,  by  allowing  de- 
cay to  start. 


In  these  woods  natu- 
rally liable  to  checking  in 
seasoning  the  use  of  salt 
sol  u  t  i  o  n  preservative 
likely  increases  the  tend- 
ency to  check. 

Are  not  treating  ties  to 
any  extent. 

Have  not  noticed  that 
treatment  by  creosote 
has  any  great  effect  in 
this  way,  but  believe 
that  checking  is  in- 
creased when  timber  is 
treated  by  the  zinc  chlo- 
ride process. 


Not  if  wood  is  air- 
seasoned  for  treatment 
and  not  steamed. 


Yes,  should  be  deter- 
mined by  actual  tests. 

No  apparent  difference 
between  treated  and  un- 
treated timber. 


Have  been  advised  by 
the  track  supervisors 
that  they  believe  the 
creosote  treatment  has  a 
tendency  to  soften  the 
wood  and  make  it  more 
easily  crushed.  Have 
not  confirmed  this,  and 
am  unable  to  express  a 
conclusion. 


Yes. 


317 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


If  the  percentage  is 
capable  of  mathematica 
deduction,  please  give 
the  method. 


Is  crushing  hastened 
by  natural  checking  of 
ties? 


What   class   of   wood     Does    preservative 
checks  most?  .treatment    tend    to    in- 

crease the  tendency  to 
check? 


Does  preservath 
treatment  affect  the  na 
ural  crushing  unit  stress 
es?    ~ 


I  do  not  think  this  per- 
centage is  capable 
mathematical  deduc- 
tion, there  being  too 
many  indeterminate  fac- 
tors. Further  more, 
within  a  few  years  a 
great  many  of  our  ties 
become  so  deteriorated 
they  do  not  retain,  by  a 
large  percentage ,  the 
same  efficiency  in  sup- 
porting the  rail  that  they 
do  when  new. 

18  tics  per  30-ft.  rail  is 
about  right  for  proper 
tamping. 

Too  many  theoret- 
ically indeterminate  fac- 
tors to  reduce  to  a 
forma  a. 

Do  not  consider  the 
matter  capable  of  math- 
ematical deduction. 


Crushing  is  no  doubt 
hastened  by  natural 
checking  of  ties. 


Hardwood     checks 
more  readily  than  soft 


Yes. 


Yes. 


Probably  only  in  so  far 
as  checking  hastens  de 
cay. 

Apparently  so,  espe- 
cially over-treated  tie; 
where  the  wood  has  been 
steamed  too  much  and 
zinc  chloride  used. 


No. 


Yellow  pine,  untreated 
(oak,  chestnut  and  yel 
low  pine  in  use). 


Have  not  had  experi 
ence  with  all  classes  of 
wood. 

Pine  ties  over- treated, 
s  per  No.  4. 


Red  oak . 


Yes,  checking  allows 
ties  to  disintegrate  fas- 
ter, consequently  has 
tens  crushing. 

Yes 


Beech,      oak,      gum, 
maple,  walnut,  locust. 


Elm. 


Problem  too  much 
complicated  by  inde- 
pendent variables. 


Need  all  the  ties  under 
a  rail  that  can  be  used 
and  leave  room  for  prop- 
er tamping.  No  mathe- 
matics used  to  deter- 
mine this. 

Too  many  i  n  t  e  r  d  e- 
pendent  variables  to 
attempt  it. 


Not    unless  checks 
come  close  to  edge. 


No. 


Yes. 


Beech,    maple,    hick- 
ory. 


All  hardwoods  check, 
beech,  birch  and  maple 
the  worst. 


Post  oak  worse  than 
white  oak.  In  general, 
wood  with  highest 
moisture  ratio  checks 
the  most. 


Treated  ties  have  a 
greater  tendency  to 
check  than  untreated 
ties. 


No. 


No. 


I  am  not  prepared  1 
say  whether  treated  ti< 
are  capable  of  sustainii 
less  unit  crushing  strei 
than  untreated  ties.  Aj 
parently,  the  wood  : 
rendered  somewha 
more  brittle  by  treatinj 


No,    think    not,    b( 
never  tested  it. 


Slightly,  if  at  all. 


I  understand  it  does, 
but  cannot  speak  from 
personal  observation. 

Zinc  chloride  and  high 
temperatures  naturally 
increased  the  checking 
of  our  pine  ties.  We  now 
use  creosote  only  with 
out  steaming  and  this 
diminishes  checking. 


No. 


Yes,   to  great  extent, 
beech  and  red  oak  ties 


Lessens  check. 


The  checking  occurs 
while  ties  are  seasoning 
and  so  before  treatment 


No,  ordinarily,  but  if 
heavily  steamed;  under 
old  process,  yes. 


Do  not  believe  it  does. 


Have  made  no  tests. 


Apparently  it  does,  ah 
diminishes  holding  po» 
er  of  driven  spikes. 


Yes,  some  processe 
particularly  ereosot 
oils. 

Yes,  but  to  small  e 
tent,  varying  with  diffe 
ent  types  of  treatment. 

No 

Preservative  t  r  e  a 
ment  softens  the  tii 
while  the  ties  are  w* 
from  the  treatment,  i 
they  crush  more  easi 
until  they  become  dr; 

No 


Believe  it  somewh 
decreases  elastic  limit 
compression,  especial 
in  loblolly  and  yelk 
pine  ties. 


318 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


If  the  percentage  is 
capable  of  mathematical 
deduction,  please  give 
the  method. 


Is  crushing  hastened 
by  natural  checking  of 
ties  ? 


What    class    of    wood 
checks  most? 


Does  preservative 
treatment  tend  to  in- 
crease the  tendency  to 
check? 


"Does  preservative 
treatment  affeot  the  nat- 
ural crushing  unit  stress- 


Cannot  be  mathemat 
ically  deduced  because 
of  the  widely  different 
character  of  sub-grade, 
ballast,  stiffness  of  rail, 
weight  of  loa"ds,  etc. 

Percentage  given  is  a 
matter  of  personal  judg- 
ment and  observation 
only. 

I  think  the  considera- 
tion should  start  from 
the  roadbed  and  the 
traffic  to  carry  and  the 
kind  (size)  of  rail  to 
carry  it,  to  get  the  maxi- 
mum carrying  capacity 
of  track;  the  wheel  load 
should  be  distributed 
uniformly  over  the  road- 
bed. This  involves  a 
relation  between  dis- 
tance between  ties  and 
depth  of  ballast.  The 
proper  relation  is  the  one 
which  will  give  uniform 
distribution  at  the  least 
cost  for  investment  and 
maintenance  and  is  de- 
pendent upon  the  relation 
of  cost  of  ties  and  ballast 


Yes,  directly  by  the 
separation  of  the  fiber, 
and  indirectly  by  decay, 
which  follows. 


Yes. 


I  think  so. 


Of  those   within   ray 
knowledge,  oaks. 


Our  experience  is  al 
most  wholly  with  cedar. 


Do  not  know. 


Think  not. 


Possibly  creosote  soft- 
ens the  wood. 


Practically    no    expe 
rience  with  treated  ties 


Zinc  treatment  seems 


Yes. 


The  majority  of  our 
ties  used  are  yellow  pine, 
and  they  check. 


The  percentage  is  a 
matter  of  experience  and 
experiment  rather  than 
mathematical  deduc- 
tion. 

We  have  given  above 
our  general  practice, 
which  has  proved  suc- 
cessful. 


I  believe  it  is. 


We    think    not  mate- 
rially in  hardwood  ties. 


The  harder  class  of 
oaks  would,  in  my  opin- 
ion, check  most. 


Chestnut,  of  which  we 
use  very  few. 


We  have  only  been 
using  treated  ties  to  any 
extent  for  two  years,  so 
cannot  give  satisfactory 
reply.  If  properly  treat 
ed  and  a  suitable  tie 
plate  to  provide  for 
mechanical  wear,  I 
should  think  the  check 
ing  would  be  decreased 
This  will  also  answer 
No.  7. 

I  do  not  know .... 


We  have  not  had  ex- 
perience with  treated 
ties. 


Somewhat. 
Yes 


Soft 

Do  not  know. 


Not  with  creosote, 
unless  excessive  steam 
pressures  are  used.  The 
sine  chloride  process 
probably  increases  tend- 
ency to  check,  as  it 
increases  the  moisture 
content  of  the  wood. 


Do  not  know. 


Answered  by  No. 


I  do  not  know. 


No  data. 


Decreases  crushing 
strength  but  very  little 
unless  excessive  heating 
takes  place  in  the  treat- 
ment. 


319 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


If  the  percentage  is 
capable  of  mathematical 
deduction,  please  give 
the  method. 


Is  crushing  hastened 
by  natural  checking  of 
ties? 


What   class   of   wood 
checks  most? 


Does      preservative 
treatment    tend   to 


crease  the  tendency  to  ural  crushing  unit  stress- 
check?  es? 


Does      preservative 
treatment  affect  the  nat- 


Percentage  of  bearing 
dependent  on  tie 
spacing,  which  must  be 
such  as  to  permit  of 
tamping.  On  the  Penn- 
sylvania Lines  we  use  18 
ties  to  a  33-ft.  rail,  which 
gives  a  distance  face  to 
face  of  ties  of  14J^  in. 
This  gives  (with  8-in.ties) 
36.3  per  cent,  of  base 
bearing  on  ties. 

Clearance  needed  for 
tamping  is  the  determin 
ing  factor.  This  space 
between  ties  should  be 
made  as  small  as  pos- 
sible. 


Conditions  vary 
through  wide  range.  No 
mathematical  deduc- 
tions  can  be  of  much 
value. 


We  have  no  evidence 
that  it  is. 


Not  to  any  great  ex- 
tent. 


Of  woods  now  used 
extensively  by  the  Penn- 
sylvania Lines,  i.  e.,  oak 
and  yellow  pine,  oak 
checks  most.  Chestnut, 
formerly  used  extensive- 
ly, checks  more  than 
oak. 


We  use  pine,  oak  and 
chestnut;  oak  checks  the 
most. 


No. 


No. 


No;  it  decreases  it. 


Checking  permits  en 
trance  of  moisture  that 
causes  decay  and  there- 
fore hastens  crushing. 


Yellow  pine 


No. 


Don't  know. 


Don't  know. 


It  is  probable  that  this 
percentage  was  not 
worked  out  mathemat 
ically  and  no  doubt  it 
represents  about  the 
maximum  amount  of 
timber  which  can  be 
used  under  rails  in  order 
to  leave  sufficient  open- 
ing between  the  ties  to 
give  the  trackman  prop- 
er opportunity  to  success- 
fully tamp  the  ballast 
with  tamping  picks. 

Basis  of  7-in.  x  9-in.  ties 
on  the  fiat  and  12-in. 
working  room  between 
ties. 


We  have  noticed  little 
or  no  crushing  where 
white  oak  ties  are  used. 


No  answer  is  given 
because  our  experience 
has  been  confined  to 
the  use  of  white  oak 
ties. 


No 


Have  no  method  ex 
cept  observation,  ex 
perience,  and  results  of 
both. 

33-ft.   rail  equals  396 

inches  long,  17  ties  per 

rail  with  8-in.  face  136 
in.,  percentage  .344. 


Yes.     Particularly  as 
checking  hastens  decay 


To  a  very  small  ex- 
tent. 


Yea. 


Not  appreciably 
good  white  oak.  It  is, 
to  some  extent,  in  soft  or 
unsound  woods. 


(Experience  in  the  soft 
northern  timber  only.) 


My  experience  has  only 
been  with  chestnut, 
white  and  post  oak;  of 
these  three,  chestnut  has 
the  greatest  tendency  to 
check. 


Don't  know 

Whether  preservatives 
increase  the  tendency  to 
check  is  the  question 
which  we  cannot  answer, 
because  in  the  past 
treated  ties  have  not 
been  used. 


Not  enough  experience 


Fir. 


Hard,    tough-grained 
wood. 


The  wood  is  usuallj 
made  softer  by  the 
preservatives  to  a  depth 
of  about  K  in.  to  %  in 
The  net  resistance  t< 
crushing  is  thereby  re- 
duced and  the  unit  stress 
increased. 

It  prevents  checking 
and  therefore  increase 
resistance  to  crushing  t< 
some  extent. 


Don't  know. 
See  No.  6... 


Not  enough  experience  Not  enough  experiene 
to  permit  of  reply  for  to  permit  of  reply  fo 
favorable  comparison,      favorable  comparison. 


Can't    say.      No    ex- 
Derience. 


Yes. 


Have  not  sufficient 
experience  to  state;  do 
not  think  so. 


No    experience    with 
preservatives. 


Lessens  unit  crushin 
stresses. 


320 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


8a 

With  the  increased 
consumption  and  the 
decreased  available  sup- 
ply, can  the  demand  for 
large  sectional  area  of 
ties  be  met? 


8b 

If  a  large  sectional  area 
of  tie  is  not  available, 
what  would  you  recom- 
mend as  next  best  thing 
to  do,  use  steel,  or  com- 
posite, or  what  not? 


Has  the  application  of 
screw  or  square  spikes 
any  effect  on  crushing? 


Relation   of   kinds   of 
ballast  to  tie-crushing. 


Relation  of  character 
of  sub-grade  to  tie-crush- 
ing. 


It  may  bo  met  in  terri- 
tories where  tie-making 
has  not  yet  become  a 
large  industry.  It  will  be 
difficult  when  all  present 
tie  sizes  are  well  estab- 
lished. 


Demand  can  be  met 
for  a  number  of  years. 


The  decreased  pro- 
duction which  is  indi- 
cated by  United  States 
forest  service  reports  is 
due  to  diminished  sup- 
ply and  indicates  that  it 
will  be  difficult  to  secure 
a  requisite  number  of  ties 
of  larger  sectional  area. 

Not  without  a  radical 
change  in  practice  or 
price. 


Probably   locally   but 
not  generally  for  many 


Yes,  as  it  is  counter- 
balanced by  increase  of 
timber  preservation. 

I  do  not  believe  we  can 
demand  a  larger  section- 
al area  per  tie,  as  the  cost 
per  tie  is  increased,  not 
oaly  by  the  additional 
size  of  the  tie,  but  by  the 
additional  cost  for  hand- 
ling and  applying,  and 
increased  amount  of 
ballast  (if  tie  is  length- 
ened). 


The  present  wood  tie 
sections  are  sufficient  if 
used  in  the  proper  num- 
ber to  give  proper  bear- 
ing, which  is  entirely 
feasible.  Ballast  depth 
must,  however,  be  much 
increased.  It  is  feasible 
and  within  limits  of 
proper  economy  to  place 
enough  6'x8*i8'  wood 
ties  under  track  to  prop- 
erly sustain  axle  ioads, 
which  the  present  kind 
of  steel  rail  will  sustain 
(per  wheel)  without  ex- 
cessive flowing. 

Use  reinforced  con- 
crete or  steel. 


As  a  first  resort, 
ties  spaced  narrowly. 


I  do  not  think  a  satis- 
factory substitute  for 
wood  has  been  brought 
out,  but  I  think  a  com- 
posite tie  using  wood 
cushion  for  rail  will  be 
necessary. 

Believe  this  is  a  ques- 
tion that  will  have  to 
be  solved  soon,  but  so 
far  as  my  knowledge 
goes,  a  solution  has  not 
yet  been  found.  Appar- 
ently the  practice  of 
treating  ties  will  con- 
serve the  available  tim 
ber  supply,  at  least  tern 
porarily. 


It  is  available  at  the 
present  time. 


I  do  not  believe  we  are 
prepared  to  give  up  yet 
the  use  of  the  wood  tie 
and  adopt  one  of  some 
other  material,  but  by 
the  use  of  heavier  rail 
and  tie-plates  we  can 
still  continue  to  use  the 
ties  that  we  have,  re- 
ducing the  number  to  the 
rail  by  one  or  two  if  rail 
of  100  lbs.  or  greater 
weight  per  yard  is  used. 
Greater  care  should  be 
exercised  in  the  applying 
of  ties  and  applying  of 
tie-plates,  and  I  think 
holes  should  be  bored 
even  for  the  insertion  of 
square  spikes,  all  of 
which  will  tend  to  in- 
crease the  life  of  the  tie. 


If  the  rail  is  held  close- 
ly to  the  tie,  wearing  or 
crushing  is  reduced.  The 
only  means  of  doing  this 
is  to  use  screw  spikes. 


Ballast  which  is  firm 
and  drains  quickly  and 
which  allows  only  a 
small  amount  of  motion 
will  reduce  crushing. 
Dry  timber  is  stronger 
in  resisting  crushing  than 
wet  timber. 


Same  as  No.  10. 


Have  no  data  for  com- 
parison. 


Screw  spikes  properly 
driven  or  used  with 
threaded  plugs  would 
preserve  the  wood  fiber 
and  naturally  tend  in 
some  degree  to  increase 
crushing  strength. 


Have  data  available 
but  think  that  the  more 
yielding  materials  have 
less  tendency  to  tie- 
crushing. 

Stone  ballast  with  its 
greater  bearing  capacity 
reduces  impact  and  con- 
sequently also  reduces 
tendency  to  crush.  Grav 
el  and  other  ballast 
composed  of  small  pieces 
tend  to  increase  the  load 
and  further  tie-crushing, 


The  better  the  sub- 
grade,  the  less  the  ties 
have  tendency  to  crush. 


This  relation  would  be 
similarly  indicated  by 
a  variation  in  bearing 
capaoity  of  sub-grade. 


Naturally,  yes;  but 
cannot  say  from  experi- 
ence as  to  the  compara- 
tive effects  of  the  two 
kinds  of  spikes;  would 
suppose  it  preferable  to 
use  screw  spikes,  and  it 
is  not  necessary  to  re- 
drive  them  so  often, 
thereby  not  breaking 
up  the  fiber  and  spike- 
killing  the  tie. 


Crushing  is  probably 
greater  in  stone  and  slag 
ballast  than  in  gravel 
and  other  lighter  bal- 
lasts, on  account  of  the 
more  rigid  tamping. 


The  character  of  the 
sub-grade  would  evi- 
dently have  an  effect 
upon  tie-crushing,  since 
a  hard  sub-grade  with 
rigid  ballast  would  give 
greater  crushing  stress 
with  the  impact. 


We 

spikes 


have    no    screw 
in  this  territory. 


The  most  severe  crush- 
ing in  my  experience  has 
been  in  gravel  ballast, 
but  that  was  due  to  the 
frequency  of  passenger 
trains  and  heavy  freight 
traffic,  which  are  the 
greatest  factors  in  crush- 
ing of  ties.  I  would  not 
put  this  forward,  how- 
ever, as  an  opinion  that 
gravel  is  more  severe 
than  other  ballast  on 
ties. 


The  life  of  tie  is  in- 
creased by  having  better 
ballast,  and,  necessarily, 
better  ballast  follows 
if  there  is  a  good  sub- 
grade. 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


With  the  increased 
consumption  and  the 
decreased  available  sup- 
ply, can  the  demand  for 
large  sectional  area  of 
ties  be  met  ? 


No. 
No. 


In  my  opinion  it  can 
be  met  for  some  years  to 
come. 


Yes,  by  consuming  the 
supply  proportionately 
faster. 


Yes,  by  reducing 
thickness  and  increasing 
stability  of  tie-plate. 

In  my  opinion,  yes. 


Yes. 


Increasingly  harder  to 
get  large  ties. 


No. 


Do  not  think  it  prac- 
ticable. 


8b 

If  a  large  sectional  area 
of  tie  is  not  available, 
what  would  you  recom- 
mend as  next  best  thing 
to  do,  use  steel,  or  com 
posite  or  what  not? 


Can't  say 

Use  heavier  rail  with 
tie-plates  of  ample  size 
and  thickness  on  all  ties. 
Adapt  the  number  of  ties 
to  suit  the  weight  of 
the  rail  section  as  far  as 
limitations  of  tie  spacing 
will  permit. 

Neither  a  steel  nor 
composite  tie  has  been 
found  which  will  entire- 
ly meet  all  requirements. 
Believe  energies  should 
be  directed  t  o  w  a  r  d  s 
design  of  a  composite 
tie. 

Am  decidedly  of  the 
opinion  that  the  coming 
tie  will  be  a  steel  or 
iron  tie.  Do  not  expect 
to  see  concrete  come 
into  general  use. 

Use  steel 


Do  not  consider  time 
has  arrived  for  elimina- 
tion of  wooden  ties. 


Steel. 


Tie-plates    and    more 
ties. 


Use  more  ties . 


Doubt  if  any  substi- 
tute will  ever  be  found 
for  wood  ties.  Steel  O. 
K.  in  certain  special 
cases.  I  think  ties  will 
be  imported  sometime 
from  South  America, 
Africa,  etc. 


Has  the  application  of 
screw  or  square  spikes 
any  effect  on  crushing '? 


Not  that  I  know. 


Square  spikes  injure 
the  fiber  of  the  wood 
and  therefore  promote 
softening  around  the  rail- 
seat  which  reaches  out 
under  the  entire  base  of 
the  rail,  promoting  de 
cay  and  crushing. 

Have  had  no  experi- 
ence with  screw  spikes, 
but  believe  screw  spikes 
would  possess  some  ad 
vantages  in  this  respect. 


Don't  know. 


Relation    of  kinds     of 
ballast  to  tie-crushing. 


Yes,  by  reducing  the 
sawing  motion  between 
rail  and  tie. 

No  experience  with 
them.  My  opinion  is 
that  screw  spikes  would 
appreciably  reduce 
crushing. 

On  account  of  destroy 
ing  more  or  less  fiber 
structure  it  should  slight- 
ly increase  crushing. 


No  experience . 


Do    not   think   effect 
would  be  perceptible. 


322 


Doubtless  contributes 
to  some  extent  to  tie- 
crushing,  but  the  differ- 
ence in  this  respect  be- 
tween various  kinds  of 
ballast  is  not  great. 


Have  no  definite  rec- 
ords. 


Have  observed  no  re- 
lation. 


Relation  of  character 
of  sub-grade  to  tie-crush- 
ing. 


A  poorly  drained  and 
soft  sub-grade  is  injurious 
in  permitting  move- 
ment of  the  ballast. 


With  proper  depth  and 
character  of  ballast,  can- 
not see  any  relation. 


Would  not  expect  ties 
to  crush  much  on  soft 
Missouri  mud. 


Ties  crush  more  in 
rock  slag  and  cementing 
gravel  than  in  loose  or 
other  classes. 


Stone  first,  hard  slag 
and  cinders  given  in 
order  of  ballast  that 
gives  most  tie-crushing 

The  better  the  ballast 
the  less  crushing  will 
occur. 

The  less  elastic  the 
ballast  the  more  the 
ties  will  crush;  also  the 
firmest  ballast  and  the 
higher  the  section  of  rail 
the  faster  the  rail  will 
wear  down  and  this 
must  be  met  by  harden- 
ing the  steel  in  the  rail  in 
proportion  to  increase  in 
stiffness  of  rail  section. 

In  general,  the  crush- 
ing should  vary  directly 
as  the  axle  load,  the 
rigidity  of  the  ballast 
and  sub-grade  and  as  the 
rail  deflection. 


The  more  resilient  the 
sub-grade  the  less  ties 
crush . 


The  better  sub-grade 
the  less  tie-crushing. 


The  better  the  sub- 
grade  the  less  crushing 
of  ties. 

Ties  will  crush  easier 
on  rock  sub-grade, 
especially  where  ballast 
cushion  is  insufficient. 


See  No.  10. 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


With  the  increased 
consumption  and  the 
decreased  available  sup 
ply,  can  the  demand  for 
large  sectional  area  of 
ties  be  met? 


Think  not,  economic 
ally. 


Hardly. 


For  a  time,  yes,  until 
it  commences  to  affect 
the  lumber  output;  even 
then  it  is  only  a  question 
of  price. 


The  demand  for  wood- 
en ties  cannot  be  met, 
unless  ties  suitable  for 
treating  are  available 


This  is  purely  a  matter 
of  dollars  and  cents; 
large  ties  can  undoubted- 
ly be  obtained  if  it  is 
worth  the  additional 
cost  involved. 


We  think  ties  having  a 
face  width  of  from  7  in. 
to 9  in.,  thickness  cf  7  in., 
length  of  8  ft.  6  in. .spaced 
18  to  a  33-ft.  rail,  joint 
ties  17  in.  c.  to  c,  in- 
termediate 24  in.  c.  to 
c,  with  tie-plates  for 
heavy  loads  and  traffic, 
are  sufficient,  and  such 
are  procurable. 

Yes,  by  treating  soft 
ties. 


Probably  not;  at  least 
not  for  an  unlimited 
length  of  time. 


8b 

If  a  large  sectional  area 
of  tie  is  not  available, 
what  would  you  recom- 
mend as  next  best  thing 
to  do,  use  steel,  or  com- 
posite or  what  not? 


Use  a  plate  large 
enough  to  distribute  the 
load  and  of  such  con- 
struction to  permit  the 
readjustment  of  the  rail 
without  disturbing  the 
initial  seat  of  plate  on 
the  tie. 

Would  recommend 
using  the  area  that  is 
available    and     do    not 


Has  the  application  of 
screw  or  square  spike 
any  effect  on  crushing? 


Think  the  displace- 
ment of  any  part  of  the 
wood  under  or  about 
the  rail  tends  to  weaken. 


We  use  no  screw- 
spikes;  square  spikes 
where  used  in  skimming 


know  yet  what  to  recom-, as  much  as  necessary  in 
mend  as  a  substitute.      I  some  cases  increase  tend- 
ency to  crush. 


Do  not  think  the  size 
of  tie  is  a  factor,  except 
as  to  thickness.  I  think 
the  bearing  area  on  road 
beds  and  rail  is  the  only 
thing  to  consider,  and 
this  is  controlled  by 
distance  between  ties 

Use  steel  or  tie  of  some 
other  composition  of 
permanent  construction 
that  is  to  take  care 
of  our  side-track  needs. 
The  operation  of  trains 
under  high  speed  in 
various  weather  con- 
ditions, etc.,  will  not 
permit  the  use  of  above 
tie   with  safety. 

Am  open  to  conviction. 
I  have  not  seen  any 
tie  for  substitution  for 
wood  that  I  can  uncon 
ditionally  approve. 


We  have  not  investi- 
gated other  than  wood 
ties. 


Composite. 


Do  not  know. 


Have  not  been  used 
sufficient  length  of  time 
to  determine.  If  proper- 
ly supplied  with  tie- 
plates,  I  think  the 
crushing  would  be  less. 


Probabl3'  the  crushing 
would  be  greater  with 
spike  than  screw  because 
of  more  vertical  move- 
ment after  having  been 
in  use  a  short  time. 


No  data. 


Relation   of    kinds   of 
ballast  to  tie  crushing. 


Not  with  tie-pin  tes 
of  proper  width  and 
thickness. 

Indirectly,  yes.  The 
cutting  and  disruption 
of  the  fibers  of  the  wood 
by  the  spikes  opens  up 
wood  and  hastens  pro- 
cess of  decay,  which 
reduces  crushing  resist- 
ance and  facilitates  the 
mechanical  wear  of  the 
wood.  Square  spike  has 
much  greater  effect  than 
screw  spike. 


Hard,  unyielding  bal- 
last increases  tendency 
to  crush. 


Think  it  worse  in  soft 
ballast  due  to  greater 
wave  motion  of  rail. 


If  this  includes  break- 
ing, the' softer  the  road- 
bed or  ballast,  the  great- 
er the  tendency  to  break; 
the  harder  the  ballast, 
the  greater  the  tendency 
to  break. 


Ties  crush  or  check 
under  stone  ballast  with 
the  same  traffic  as  under 
cinders,  gravel,  etc. 
This  on  account  of  track 
being  more  rigid.  This 
on  the  assumption  that 
all  the  ballast  mentioned 
above  has  good  drain- 
age. This  also  answers 
No.  11. 

I  believe  a  good  gravel 
ballast  is  better  than  a 
tone  ballast  to  reduce 
the  tie-crushing. 


Our  ties  are  removed 
on  account  of  decay, 
rather  than  crushing  or 
cutting.  Cutting  of  ties 
is  kept  down  by  use  of 
tie-plates.  And  we  think 
there  is  not  much  varia- 
tion due  to  ballast. 


Relation  of  character 
of  sub-grade  to  tie  crush- 
ing. 


Same  as  of  ballast. 


Think  it  worse  in  soft 
sub-grade  due  to  in- 
creased wave  motion  of 
rail. 


Same  as  No.  10. 


Answered  by  No.  10. 


The  harder  the  sub- 
grade,  the  greater  would 
naturally  be  the  crushing 
tendency.  With  suffi- 
cient ballast  the  effect  of 
sub-grade  upon  crushing 
can  be  eliminated. 

Very  remote  with  fair 
ballasted  track. 


The  more  rigid  and  un- 
yielding the  ballast,  the 
greater  the  tie  crushing 
Tie-crushing  is  greater, 
therefore,  under  stone 
ballast  than  under  grav- 
el. 


The  more  yielding  and 
elastic  the  sub-grade, 
the  more  give  there  is 
to  the  tie,  resulting  in 
less  tie  crushing. 


323 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


With  the  increased 
consumption  and  the 
decreased  available  sup- 
ply, can  the  demand  for 
large  sectional  area  of 
ties  be  met? 


8b 

If  a  large  sectional  area 
of  tie  is  not  available, 
what  would  you  recom- 
mend as  next  best  thing 
to  do,  use  steel,  or  com- 
posite or  what  not? 


Has  the  application  of 
screw  or  square  spikes 
any  effect  on  crushing? 


Relation   of   kinds  of 
ballast  to  tie-crushing. 


Relation  of  character 
of  sub-grade  to  tie  crush- 
ing. 


30 


No.  We  have  diffi- 
culty in  getting  ties  of 
our  present  standard 
cross-section,  i.  e., 
7  in.  by  8  in. 

No 


I  think  not. 


No. 


Not  ready  to  answer. 


Would  recommend 
some  form  of  steel  tie 
having  wood  insets  for 
rail-bearing  surface,  wood 
insets  to  be  deep  enough 
to  hold  screw  spikes. 


Use  tie-plates  not  less 
than  |  in.  thick  and  10  in. 
long  to  cover  entire  face. 
Use  preservative  process 
on  all  timber  in  track  and 
steel  or  composite  ties 
(where  conditions  make 
their  use  economical. 

Treat  ties  and  prevent 
destruction  from  wear 
by  use  of  properly  de- 
signed tie-plates  of  suffi- 
cient   area    and    proper 


No. 


Screw  spikes  decrease 
the  crushing,  as  they 
do  not  work  out  of 
place  as  readily  as 
square  spikes.  They 
hold  the  rail  down 
against  the  tie  and 
eliminate  much  of  the 
mpact. 


Experience  not  suffi- 
cient to  give  definite 
answer. 


If  all  ties  are  equally 
tamped,  so  that  support 
is  the  same,  kind  of 
ballast  does  not  affect 
crushing. 

Less  crushing  on  ash 
ballast  than  on  stone  and 
the  former  is  preferable 
on  roads  of  light  tonnage. 
On  roads  of  heavy  ton- 
nage the  additional 
tamping  required  on  ash 
ballast  would  more  than 
offset  the  increased 
crushing  if  stone  ballast 
were  used,  so  far  as  life 
of  tie  is  concerned. 

The  more  unyielding 
the  bed  the  sooner  the 
ties  crush.  Therefore, 
ties  crash  earlier  in  stone 
than  in  any  othei  kind 
of  ballast. 


No  relation,  provided 
ties  are  equally  tamped. 


More  crushing  on  rigid 
sub-grade,  except  where 
sub-grade  is  so  soft  that 
track  is  in  poor  surface 
most  of  the  time. 


Having  traveled  over 
the  timber  country 
which  now  supplies  the 
cross-ties  of  this  section 
of  the  country,  it  is  my 
opinion  that  any  demand 
for  larger  sectional  area 
of  ties  cannot  be  granted. 
A  standard  tie  at  the 
present  time  is  practi- 
cally 7  in.  thick  by  8. in. 
face.  A  very  few  ties 
of  larger  area. can  be 
secured. 


No. 


This  is  a  difficult 
question  to  answer,  un- 
less one  has  had  a  long 
experience  in  the  use  of 
steel  and  composite  ties. 
At  the  present  time  the 
P.  &  L.  E.  R.  R.  Co.  is 
experimenting  with  both 
steel  and  composite 
cross-ties.  Steel  cross- 
ties  have  been  in  use  four 
years.  Composite  ties 
have  been  under  test 
during  a  similar  period, 
but  not  one  design  has 
continued  in  use  for 
this  length  of  time. 
All  experience  shows 
that  any  opinion  re- 
specting the  merits  of 
steel  and  composite  ties 
is  more  or  less  worthless, 
unless  based  on  an 
experience  of  a  mini- 
mum of  10  years.  It 
is  practically  certain  that 
the  railroad  will  be 
forced  to  use  other  than 
wooden  ties  in  the  future, 
and  good  judgment  re- 
quires that  the  railroads 
begin  at  once  to  experi- 
ment with  both  steel  and 
composite  cross-ties, 
am  satisfied  that  both  of 
these  forms  will  be 
largely  used  in  the  future, 
but  would  not  hazard  a 
definite  opinion  at  the 
present  time.  More  ex- 
perience is  necessary  in 
order  to  develop  the 
data  whioh  should  form 
the  basis  of  an  opinion 


No  experience, 
think  not. 


We 


We  have  not  noticed 
any  crushing  of  white 
oak  ties. 


See  No.  10. 


324 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


8a 

With  the  increased 
consumption  and  the 
decreased  available  sup- 
ply, can  the  demand  for 
large  sectional  area  of 
ties  be  met? 


8b 

If  a  large  sectional  area 
of  tie  is  not  available, 
what  would  you  recom- 
mend as  next  best  thing 
to  do,  use  steel,  or  com- 
posite or  what  not? 


Has  the  application  of 
screw  Or  square  spikes 
any  effect  on  crushing? 


Relation   of    kinds  of 
ballast  to  tie  crushing. 


Relation  of  character 
of  sub-grade  to  tie  crush- 
ing. 


Yes. 


In  my  judgment,  no.  . 


Probably  a  local  ques- 
tion not  serious  on  West 
Coast. 


Do  not  think  so. 


Not     enough     experi- 
ence. 


Would  recommend  re 
inforced  concrete,  pro- 
vided they  have  a  proper 
wood  cushion. 

When  ties  cannot  be 
had  of  6  in.  x  8  in.  cross- 
section  re-inforced,  con- 
crete or  steel  ties  will 
probably  have  to  be 
used.  By  using  large 
tie-plates  and  preserv- 
ative treatment,  6  in.  x 
8  in.  timber  ties  can  be 
made  to  answer. 


No  experience  with 
screw  spikes.  Every 
time  a  spike  is  driven 
into  a  tie  it  cuts  fiber, 
weakens  the  tie  and 
must  affect  crushing. 

No  experience 


Screw     spikes     lessen 
crushing  effect. 


Use  steel  ties. 


Have  not  used  screw 
spikes. 


Improbable. 


Use  of  wood  preserva 
tive  and  tie-plates  should 
be  satisfactory  for  some 
years,  then  develop  a 
steel  tie. 


Square  spikes  effect 
not  severe  especially 
with  tie-plates. 


Have  no  data  on  this 
or  further  questions. 


The  more  rigid  the 
ballast,  the  greater  the 
tie-crushing. 


Elastic  ballast,  such  as 
gravel  or  zinc  tailings, 
should  lessen  crushing. 


Ties  crush  worse 
soft,  yielding  ballast  that 
permits  "working"  of 
the  ties,  or  very  hard, 
coarse  ballast  that  is  un- 
yielding. Good  stone  or 
gravel  of  uniform  charac- 
ter, elastic  without  being 
mobile,  is  best  to  pre- 
vent tie-crushing. 

Probably  more  mark 
ed  in  stone  ballast. 


The  more  rigid  the 
sub-grade,  the  greater 
the  crushing,  depending 
on  the  ballast. 

Well -drained,  solid 
sub-grade  should  lessen. 


Same  as  ballast,  very 
soft  or  very  hard  sub- 
grade  is  worse  for  crush- 
ing than  medium. 


Soft  roadbed  or  badly 
surfaced  track  increases 
tie-crushing. 


Relation  of  axle  load 
to  tie-crushing. 


13 

Relation  of  frequency 
of  maximum  axle  load, 
as  applied  to  a  tie,  to  tie- 
crushing. 


The  greater  the  axle 
load  the  greater  the 
crushing.  Usually  the 
greater  the  axle  the 
greater  the  speed.  There- 
fore, increased  axle  load 
increases  crushing  in 
greater  proportion  than 
direct  increase  in  load- 
ing. 

Increase  in  proportion 
directly  as  the  weight 
increases. 


14 

Relation  of  maximum 
axle  load  to  weight  of 
rail  and  consequent  tie 
crushing. 


Frequency  of  maxi- 
mum axle  -loads  affects 
life  of  ties  so  far  as  failure 
by  crushing  is  concerned. 


The  greater  the  traffic 
tho  quicker  the  ties 
will  crush. 


Relation  of  impact  at 
joints  to  tie-crushing. 


Stiffness  of  rail  varies 
about  as  square  of  its 
weight.  If  rail  is  not 
increased  to  proper  size 
for  maximum  load,  tie 
cutting  will  increase. 


Maximum  axle  load 
has  tendency  to  increase 
crushing  in  direct  pro 
portion  to  rail  tested. 


Relation  of  size  of  tie- 
plates  to  crushing  of 
ties. 


Impact  at  joints  causes 
increased  cutting  of  joint 
ties. 


No  data,  but  believe 
if  joints  be  kept  in  per 
feet  service  that  ties 
will  have  less  tendency 
to  crush  than  if  allowed 
to  remain  in  improper 
surface. 


Tie-plates  should  be  of 
sufficient  size  to  keep 
unit  crushing  force  well 
within  limits  of  crushing 
resistance  of  the  ties. 
Any  smaller  plate  than 
this  will  result  in  ex- 
cessive crushing. 


Face  of  tie  covered  by 
tie-plate  will  give  greater 
resistance  against  and 
decreases  directly  in 
proportion  as  size  of  tie- 
plate  decreases. 


325 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


Relation  of  axle  load 
to  tie-crushing. 


13 

Relation  of  frequency 
of  maximum  axle  load, 
as  applied  to  a  tie,  to  tie- 
crushing. 


14 


IS 


Relation  of  maximum'     Relation  of  impact  at 
axle   load   to  weight   of  joints  to  tie-crushing, 
rail  and  consequent  tie-1 
crushing. 


Relation  of  size  of  tie- 
plates  to  crushing  of 
ties. 


Increasing  axle  loads 
necessitates  more  equi- 
table distribution  of 
loading  to  avoid  crush- 
ing of  ties. 

Believe  the  crushing 
of  ties  is  greater  with 
heavy  axle  loading. 


This  is  interdependent 
with  rail  and  track 
structure.  Actual  rela- 
tion not  known. 


Believe  the    crushing 

would   be  greater   with 

frequency  of  maximum 
axle  load. 


This  is  interdependent!  The  increased  impact 
with  tie  and  track  at  joints  is  responsible 
structure.  Actual  rela-  for  increase  in  tie-crush- 
tion  not  known.  ing. 


The  heavier  rail  would 
lessen  the  crushing  effect 
under  the  maximum  axle 
load. 


Crushing  increase; 
with  load. 


Increased  axle  load 
and  frequency  of  trains 
increases  the  crushing  of 
tie.  This  also  applies 
to  your  questions  13  and 
14,  but  the  weight  of  rail, 
tie-plates  and  ballast  are 
all  a  factor  in  the  matter; 
that  is,  with  heavier  rail 
and  tie-plates  and  ballast 
the  tendency  of  crushing 
is  very  much  reduced. 


Directly  proportional. 

Increase  of  axle  load 
has  direct  effect  in  in- 
creasing the  crushing  of 
the  ties  in  direct  propor- 
tion to  the  load. 

Would  say  axle  load 
and  stiffness  and  width 
of  flange  of  rail  were 
much  more  closely  re- 
lated than  axle  load  and 
tie. 

Would  expect  crushing 
to  increase  with  the 
load. 


No  records . 


Proportional . 


Proportional 

Direct    proportion 
above. 


Undoubtedly  frequen- 
cy of  axle  load  with  a 
fixed  rail  section  bears 
an  important  part  in  the 
matter  of  tie-crushing. 


Would  expect  crushing 
to  bear  a  fairly  distinct 
relation  to  the  frequency 
of  the  application. 


No  records . 


Proportional  as  to  load 
in  inverse  proportion  as 
to  rail. 


The  greater  impact  of 
high  speed,  compared 
with  slow  speed,  would, 
I  believe,  increase  the 
tendency  to  crush.  This 
is  probably  increased  at 
the  joints,  since  they  are 
naturally  tamped  to  a 
rigid  foundation  more 
often  than  other  ties. 


Crushing  increases 
with  impact. 


Crushing  of  ties  at 
joints  far  exceeds  that 
at  any  other  part  of  the 
rail,  but  with  heavier 
rail,  etc.,  suggested 
above,  the  crushing  is 
lessened. 


The  tie-plates  of  great- 
er area  and  thickness  re- 
duce the  tendency  to 
crushing. 


Believe  there  would  be 
no  great  difference  in 
the  amount  of  crushing 
with  tie-plates  of  an 
area  equal  to  the  bear- 
ing which  the  rail  would 
have  without  a  plate. 
To  obtain  proper  value 
from  tie-plates,  so  far  as 
the  crushing  is  concern- 
ed, they  should  be  of 
greater  area  than  the 
natural  rail  contact. 

Crushing  decreases 
with  larger  tie-plates, 
which  should  distribute 
load  over  full  face  of  tie. 

I  am  unable  to  say 
what  the  size  of  tie- 
plates  should  be  to  the 
crushing  of  ties.  This 
factor  is  also  controlled 
by  the  weight  of  rail. 
Our  present  practice  is 
to  use  a  tie-plate  which 
affords  a  bearing  sur- 
face of  nearly  double 
that  of  the  rail  on  the 
tie.  These  tie-plates 
are  the  same  size  for  70, 
80  and  100  lb.  rail,  but 
the  crushing  surface 
under  the  100-lb.  rail  is 
less  than  under  the  light- 
er rail,  as  the  stresses 
are  distributed  over 
more  ties. 


In    proportion    to    the      The    crushing    is    in- 
space    over    which    the  creased  at  the  receiving 
load    is   distributed   by  end  of  the  rail, 
the    rail,    treating    the, 
rail  as  a  girder. 


Maximum  axle  load  is 
directly  related  to 
weight  of  rail  or  vice 
versa. 


Deep,  heavy  rails,  dis- 
tributing the  load  over 
more  ties,  would  nat- 
urally decrease  the 
crushing. 


No  records . 


Wheel  blow  on  rail 
end  at  joint  certainly 
must  have  some  effect 
on  crushing  of  joint  ties. 


The  greater  the  im- 
pact, the  greater  the 
crushing. 


No  records 


Nearly  in  direct  pro- 
portion, when  the  tie- 
plates  are  of  sufficient 
strength  to  equally  dis- 
tribute the  load. 

Somewhat  depends 
upon  type  of  plate  and 
kind  of  wood. 


The  larger  the  plate 
the  less  the  crushing. 


The  greater  the  bear- 
ing surface,  the  lesser  the 
crushing. 


326 


EXHIBIT   F— Continued. 


Relation  of  axle  load 
to  tie-crushing. 


This  has  important 
bearing  on  tie-crushing. 
The  more  weight  con- 
centrated at  one  point 
the  greater  the  crushing. 


When  speed  of  trains 
is  same,  tie-crushing 
should  increase  some 
in  proportion  to  axle 
load. 

Tie-crushing  increases 
with  axle  load. 


The  heavier  the  load 
the  sooner  the  ties  will 
crush. 


See  No.  10. 


Crushing  effect  varies 
directly  with  weight. 


Think  it  greater  under 
heavy  axle  load.  Have 
no  exact  data. 


Cannot  answer. 


The  heavier  the  axle 
load  the  quicker  the 
crushing. 


13 

Relation  of  frequency 
of  maximum  axle  load 
as  applied  to  a  tie,  to  tie 
crushing. 


This  varies  in   direct 
proportion. 


Quite  frequent . 


The  increasing  the 
number  of  maximum 
axle  loads  increases  the 
crushing. 

The  more  frequently 
the  load  is  applied,  the 
more  rapid  the  effect. 


No  effect  except  when 
maximum  axle  load  ap- 
plied exceeds  elastic 
limit  in  compression. 

Crushing  effect  varies 
directly  with  the  number 
of  applications. 


Think  it  greater  the 
more  frequently  maxi- 
mum axle  load  is  applied 
Have  no  exact  data. 


Cannot  answer. 


The  greater  tonnage 
with  heavy  axle  load,  of 
course,  will  permit  a 
horter  life  and  develop 
crushing. 


Relation  of  maximum 
axle  load  to  weight  of 
rail  and  consequent  tie 
crushing. 


Heavier  the  rail  over 
more  ties  is  the  weight 
distributed  and  conse 
quently  crushing  is  re 
duced. 


The  crushing  caused 
by  maximum  axle  loads 
is  reduced  by  increasing 
weight  of  rail. 

Use  as  stiff  a  rail  as 
practicable  and  spread 
load  over  as  many  ties 
as   practicable  thereby. 


See  No.  10  and  No.  13. 


Same  as  of  No.  12, 
of  course  modified  by 
stiffness  of  rail. 


Greater  axle  load  re- 
quires heavier  rail  to 
prevent  increased  crush- 
ing both  on  account  of 
wave  motion  and  unit 
stresses,  but  have  no 
data  as  to  proportion. 


Cannot  answer. 


If  the  weight  of  the 
rail  is  lighter  than  the 
axle  load,  the  greater 
the  motion  which  affects 
the  life  of  tie.  Tie-plates 
should  not  be  less  than 
7  in.  or  more  than  8  in. 
wide  and  should  be  so 
made  as  to  make  it 
a  part  of  the  tie  and 
not  the  rail.  They 
should  be  of  such  length 
as  to  prevent  them 
from  cutting  in,  buckling 
or  allowing  rail  to  roll 
out,  depending  on  traffic 
which  passes  over  same. 


Relation  of  impact  at 
joints  to  tie-crushing. 


Impact  at  joints  very 
hard  on  ties,  causing 
them  to  crush  rapidly 
in  case  joint  is  not  tight 
and  in  good  condition 


Will  increase  crushing 
very  much. 


The  greater  impact 
the  more  crushing  of 
joint  ties  will  occur. 


If  joints  of  insufficient 
strength  are  used,  or 
they  wear  out  under  the 
head  of  the  rail,  or  bolts 
are  allowed  to  run  loose, 
the  sooner  the  ties  will 
pound  out. 

See  No.  10  and  No.  13 


Directly  as  the  force 
of  the  impact. 


No  data. 


Cannot  answer., 


Relation  of  size  of  tie- 
plates  to  crushing  of 
ties. 


Plates  should  be  as 
wide  as  face  of  tie  and 
four  inches  longer  than 
width  of  base  of  rail. 
Size  of  plate  has  much 
to  do  with  crushing. 

When  tie-plates  are 
not  of  sufficient  bearing 
area,  they  tend  to  in- 
crease crushing  of  ties. 


Large    tie-plates    will 
reduce  crushing. 


Use  tie-plates  prac- 
tically full  width  of  face 
of  tie  and  as  long  only 
as  the  strength  of  the 
plate  will  allow,  without 
danger  of  buckling  under 
the  rail. 

Crushing  varies  in- 
versely as  the  area  of 
tie-plates  and  its  resist- 
ance to  deformation. 

Diminishes  as  area  ol 
plate  increases. 


There  is  a  very  pro- 
nounced relation  which 
seems  to  be  that  crush- 
ing diminishes  with  in- 
crease in  size  of  plate  up 
to  point  where  plate 
buckles  or  becomes  as 
wide  as  the  tie. 

Cannot  answer.  Would 
favor  larger  plates  as 
it  seems  to  better  pre- 
vent crushing  and  cutting 
the  ties. 


327 


EXHIBIT    F— Continued. 


Relation  of  axle  load 
to  tie-crushing. 


13 

Relation  of  frequency 
of  maximum  axle  load, 
as  applied  to  a  tie,  to  tie- 
crushing. 


14 

Relation  of  maximum 
axle  load  to  weight  of 
rail  and  consequent  tie- 
crushing. 


Relation  of  impact  at 
joints  to  tie-crushing. 


Relation  of  size  of  tie- 
plates  to  crushing  of 
ties. 


With  the  same  weight 
of  rail  I  believe  the 
tie-crushing  is  directly 
proportional  to  the  axle 
load. 


Tie  cutting,  we  think, 
is  proportional  to  axle 
load  and  density  of 
traffic,  but  reduced  by 
tie-plates. 


Unless  the  maximum 
load  is  applied  very 
rarely,  I  should  expect 
the  tie-crushing  to  be 
directly  proportional  to 
the  frequency  of  the 
maximum  load  applica- 
tion. 


Under  the  same  maxi- 
mum load  the  crushing 
should  be  less  as  the 
weight  of  the  rail  in- 
creases. 


Tie-crushing,  I  believe, 
is  directly  proportionate 
to  the  amount  of  impact 
at  the  joints. 


Our  minimum  axle 
load  on  coal,  coke  and 
ore  trains  is  43,000  lbs., 
maximum  60,000  lbs. 
empty  cars,  10,000  lbs. 
We  have  not  been  able 
to  observe  differences, 
except  as  to  frequency 
of  loads. 


Tie-crushing   varies 
directly  with  axle  load. 


Tie-crushing  increases 
with  frequency  of  appli- 
cation. 


Tie-crushing  probably 
increases  in  direct  pro- 
portion to  increase  of 
axle  loads. 


Crushing  is  less  where 
axle  load  is  less.  Flat 
wheels  naturally  do 
much  more  damage 
under  heavy  load  than 
where  load  is  light. 


The  N.  &  W.  Ry.  is 
generally  equipped  with 
85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  rail 
which  has  given  good 
service  under  above 
loads:  but  we  expect  bet 
ter  results  with  the  use  of 
100-lb.  A.R.A.  "B"  type 
rail,  purchased  since 
1910. 

Less  crushing  with 
heavier  weight  of  rails. 


The  heavier,  and 
therefore  stiff er,  the  rail 
in  proportion  to  maxi- 
mum load,  the  greater 
the  distance  over  which 
the  rail  will  distribute 
its  load.  The  more 
ties  the  axle  load  is 
carried  by,  the  less  the 
tie-crushing. 


We  have  secured  good 
results  by  the  general 
use  of  a  rigid  joint; 
our  standard  is  the 
Bonzano.  With  ties 
spaced  as  above,  we 
have  not  observed  more 
rapid  wear  on  joint  ties 
than  intermediate. 


A  large,  stiff  tie-plate 
would  undoubtedly  re- 
duce the  tie-crushing 
to  a  minimum. 


We  think  this  is  sub- 
stantially proportional. 


The  effect  of  impact 
at  joints  is  equivalent 
to  increasing  static  axle 
loads,  and  will  increase 
tie-crushing.  Crushing 
will  be  greater  with 
supported  joints  than 
with  suspended  joints 


Tie-crushing  probably 
increases  in  a  greater 
proportion  than  frequen- 
cy of  application  of 
load.  That  is,  if  the 
frequency  of  application 
is  doubled,  crushing 
is  more  than  doubled, 
Exact  relation  impos- 
sible of  statement. 

Frequency  has  very 
little  effect  except  in  the 
case  of  load  over  flat 
wheels.  The  higher  the 
speed  of  trains,  the 
greater  the  impact  from 
flat  wheels. 


Weight  of  rail  is,  of 
course,  factor  of  im- 
portance. As  weight 
(and  height)  of  rail 
increases,  distribution  of 
load  increases;  hence 
tendency  of  tie  to  crush 
decreases. 


Crushing  effect  in- 
creases directly  with  the 
maximum  axle  load  and 
the  base  area  of  road 
should  vary  proportion- 
ately. The  weight  of 
rail  has  not  kept  pace 
with  the  increase  in  axle 
load. 


Impact  at  joint  natu 
rally  increases  amount 
of  crushing. 


Less  crushing  with 
increased  width  of 
plate. 

To  reduce  crushing 
to  a  minimum,  tie- 
plates  should  be  full 
width  of  tie  and  project 
beyond  base  of  rail  as 
far  as  depth  of  tie-plate 
will  distribute  the  load. 
Non-uniformity  in 
tamping  ties  has  con- 
siderable effect  upon  the 
crushing.  A  well-tamped 
tio  adjacent  to  too 
loosely  tamped  ties  in  a 
very  rigid  roadbed  will 
get  the  maximum  crush- 
ing. 

Crushing  decreases  as 
size  of  tie-plates 
increases. 


The  crushing  at  joint 
ties  is  from  50  per  cent, 
to  75  per  cent,  more  than 
at  intermediate  ties 
This  increases  to  about 
200  per  cent,  after  the 
ties  are  in  track  five  or 
six  years. 


Tie-plates  should  be 
made  as  wide  as  the  ties 
and  extend  not  more  than 
3  in.  outside  the  rail. 
Tie-plates  greatly  de- 
crease the  crushing.  In 
fact,  a  tie-plate  designed 
as  above  would  practi- 
cally prevent  crushing 
altogether. 

Plates  should  be  large 
enough  to  prevent  cms 
ing. 


328 


EXHIBIT  F— Continued. 


Relation  of  axle  load 
to  tie-crushing. 


See  No.  10. 


The  greater  the  axle 
load  the  greater  the  tie 
crushing;  depends  also 
on  character  of  ballast 
and  sub-grade. 


Practically  directly  in 
proportion  to  axle  load- 
ing. 


The  heavier  the  axle 
load  the  greater  the 
crushing  tendency  in  an 
increasing  ratio;  after 
passing  limit  of  elasticity 
in  ballast  and  sub-grade 
entire  increment  of  axle 
load  tends  to  crushing. 

No  data  at  hand. 
Observation  shows  de- 
cided crushing. 


13 

Relation  of  frequency 
of  maximum  axle  load, 
as  applied  to  a  tie,  to  tie- 
crushing. 


See  No.  10. 


The  greater  the  fre- 
quency of  maximum 
load,  the  more  rapid  the 
tie-crushing. 


Same  as  No.  12. 


Crushing  increases 
with  frequency,  but  in 
small  ratio. 


No  data  at  hand. 
Tie-crushing  probably 
not  far  from  direct  pro- 
portion. 


14 

Relation  of  maximum 
axle  load  to  weight  of 
rail  and  consequent  tie- 
crushing. 


15 

Relation  of  impact  at 
joints  to  tie-crushing. 


See  No.  10. 


The  heavier  the  rail 
the  less  the  tie  crushes. 


Weight  of  rail  must  be 
increased  to  meet  in- 
creased axle  load. 


Heavy  rail  distributes 
axle  load  and  reduces 
tie-crushing. 


See  No.  10. 


The  effect  of  impact 
at  the  joint  would  depend 
largely  on  the  kind  of 
angle  bar  used.  The 
bar  giving  the  most 
uniform  distribution  of 
load  would  have  the 
least  tendency  to  crush. 

Tie  crushing  is  most 
marked  at  joints  and 
depends  upon  upkeep  of 
joints. 


Crushing  is  worse  at 
joint  tie  due  to  impact, 
but  the  nearer  a  perfect 
joint  be  approached  the 
less  such  effect  becomes. 


Tie-crushing  more 
marked  at  joints  than 
elsewhere. 


Relation  of  size  of  tie- 
plates  to  crushing  of 
ties. 


The  P.  &  L.  E.  R.  R. 
Co.  is  now  using  tie- 
plates  with  an  area  of 
about  72  sq.  ins.  White 
oak  ties  are  also  used. 
Tie-plates  are  joined  to 
the  ties  with  screw 
spikes.  This  area  seems 
to  be  the  minimum  re- 
quired for  effectiveness. 

The  greater  the  area 
and  thickness  of  the  tie- 
plate  the  less  the  crush- 
ing of  the  tie. 


Tie-plates  should  be 
increased  to  meet  in- 
creased loads.  They 
should  be  practically 
same  width  as  tie,  and 
increased  in  length  as 
axle  loads  are  greater. 

Crushing  is  worse  with 
small  plates;  also  worse 
with  thin  plates  which 
spring  under  maximum 
load  and  tend  to  "work" 
on  ties. 


Increase  in  thickness 
of  plates  has  materially 
lessened  tie-crushing. 


329 


330 


TIES. 


O    o 

IrS 

< D 

DC 
< 


L 


3? 

;3r 


3? 
31 


0- 

'o 


t- 


D 


H«3 


•  •■"  - 

"   *JC    • 
C    3   O  TJ 

J  C  0  5 

/v  E  ♦•     3 

■°  .  •  E  .5 
•5  •  2  <■* 


8  •-*« 


TIES.  331 


CONCLUSIONS. 

So  far  as  your  Committee  is  able  to  determine  it  is  not  feasible  to 
lay  down  any  fixed  rule  for  the  size  and  spacing  of  ties  based  on  the 
A,  B  and  C  classification  of  density  of  vtraffic,  for  the  following  reasons, 
each  of  which  in  itself  has  a  certain  definite  restriction,  as  well  as  an 
interrelation  with  all  others,  viz. : 

(i)  Character  of  subgrade  varies  radically  on  the  same  road  and 
in  different  parts  of  the  country. 

(2)  Kind  of  ballast  varies  widely. 

(3)  Necessary  depth  of  ballast  varies  with  weight  of  axle  loads,  as 
well  as  density  of  traffic. 

(4)  Necessary  distance  between  face  of  ties  varies  with  weight  of 
axle  load,  as  well  as  density  of  traffic. 

(5)  Kinds  of  timber  used  for  ties  vary  in  different  sections  of  the 
country. 

(6)  Width  of  base  of  rail  (or  weight  of  rail)  and  use  of  tie- 
plates. 

(7)  Treated  or  untreated  ties,  crushing  stress  and  durability. 

(8)  Amount  of  labor  spent  on  track  maintenance. 

(9)  Drainage. 

However,  in  general  it  may  be  considered  good  practice  for  Class  A 
and  perhaps  B  roads  to  space  ties  10-in.  to  12-in.  face  to  face ;  the  width  of 
tie  is  not  so  important  if  10-in.  to  12-in.  spacing  face  to  face  is  fol- 
lowed ;  provided,  however,  the  minimum  width  of  face  of  tie  is  limited 
to  7  in. 


332  TIES. 

(2)     TIE  RENEWALS   IN   CONTINUOUS   STRETCHES   VERSUS 
SINGLE  TIE  RENEWALS. 

The  Sub-Committee  appointed  to  investigate  the  comparative  merits 
of  "Tie  renewals  in  continuous  stretches  versus  single  tie  renewals" 
issued  the  following  letter  to  the  heads  of  the  proper  departments  of  the 
principal  railroads  operating  in  the  United  States  and  Canada : 

"It  is  desired  to  obtain  information  as  to  the  comparative  merits  of 
"Tie  renewals  in  continuous  stretches  versus  single  tie  renewals."  Will 
you  kindly  give  us  your  practice  and  opinion  in  reply  to  the  following 
questions : 

"(1)  What  is  the  practice  of  your  road  in  renewing  ties;  tie  re- 
newals in  continuous  stretches  or  single  tie  renewals? 

"(2)     Do  you  think  it  advisable  to  renew  ties  in  continuous  stretches? 

"(3)  What  would  be  the  advantage  of  this  latter  method  of  tie 
renewals? 

"(4)  What  are  the  advantages  or  disadvantages  of  single  tie  re- 
newals? 

"(5)     Which   practice   would   you   recommend?" 

Fifty  of  these  letters  were  sent  out  and  35  replies  were  received.  It 
is  noted  that  all  who  replied  gave  the  subject  the  most  careful  at- 
tention, and  thereby  furnished  the  Committee  with  some  valuable  infor- 
mation. The  replies  as  received  from  the  various  railroads  are  as  fol- 
lows: 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge,  Chief  Engineer,  New  York  Central  &  Hudson 
River  Railroad: 

1.  The  practice  of  our  road  is  to  renew  ties  under  the  method 
termed  "single  tie  renewals." 

2.  No. 

3.  There  are  no  advantages  in  renewing  ties  in  continuous  stretches, 
except  that  possibly  for  the  first  year  or  two  you  might  get  better  track 
than  by  renewing  singly. 

4.  The  advantages  of  single  tie  renewals  far  outweigh  the  disad- 
vantages ;  in  fact,  I  know  of  no  disadvantages.     The  advantages  are : 

(1)  You  are  able  to  let  a  single  tie  remain  in  the  track  until  entirely 
worn  out,  since  it  has  the  advantage  of  the  ties  on  each  side  of  it  being 
sound. 

(2)  The  track  is  always  kept  safe  by  having  a  large  proportion  of 
good  and  comparatively  new  ties  in  the  track.  With  continuous  renew- 
als there  comes  a  time  when,  even  before  the  ties  are  entirely  worn  out, 
the  track  is  not  safe,  and,  in  order  to  maintain  safety,  it  is  necessary  to 
take  the  ties  out  of  track  before  they  would,  under  other  conditions,  need 
to  be  removed,  thus  shortening  their  lives. 

5.  Unhesitatingly   I   recommend  the  practice  of  single   tie   renewals. 

Mr.  F.  S.  Stevens,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Philadelphia  &  Read- 
ing: 

1.  The  practice  of  our  road  is  to  "spot  in"  or  renew  only  such  ties 
as  will  not  do  their  work  another  year  on  account  of  being  too  soft  to 
carry  the  load. 


TIES.  333 

2.  Yes,  if  the  track  where  ties  are  to  be  renewed  can  be  taken  out 
of  service  while  work  is  being  done. 

3.  Advantages  of  this  method  are:  That  by  doing  this  work  with- 
out interruption,  the  labor  costs  less,  by  removing  the  ballast  to  subgrade 
and  forking  it  back,  dirt  is  removed  and  good  drainage  restored.  By  re- 
tamping  on  fresh  ballast  the  greatest  of  trouble  is  removed ;  i.  e.,  the  con- 
stant care  of  looking  after  and  retamping  "spotted  in"  ties  for  about  2 
years  after  being  placed  in  track. 

4.  The  sole  advantage  of  "spotting  in"  ties  where  track  can  be 
taken  out  of  service  while  renewals  are  being  made,  is  that  when  ties 
have  been  taken  out  of  track  they  are  very  liable  to  be  wasted  or  de- 
stroyed prematurely.  If  track  cannot  be  taken  out  of  service  to  permit 
tie  renewals  without  interruption,  the  increased  cost  of  labor  to  renew 
"out  of  face"  makes  this  method  prohibitive.  Therefore,  under  these 
conditions  the  "spotting  in"  method  is  most  economical.  As  far 
as  consistent  with  economy,  ties  should  then  be  renewed  in  pairs,  as 
labor  costs  nearly  as  much  to  renew  one  tie  as  two.  In  any  event,  bal- 
last_  should  be  renewed  at  same  time  with  ties,  as  this  will  make  good 
drainage.  This  is  important,  for,  unless  air  can  reach  the  under  side  of 
ties,  water  will,  and  then  trouble  begins  in  earnest. 

5.  Under  the  conditions  which  we  generally  have  to  work  I  recom- 
mend the  practice  of  "spotting  in."  However,  when  conditions  permit  I 
would  renew  ties  "out  of  face"  and  would  place  every  tie  which  will 
render  further  service  in  some  track  where  its  remaining  life  will  be  used 
to  best  advantage. 

Mr.  C.  S.  Millard,  Engineer  Track  and  Roadway,  Cleveland,  Cincinnati, 
Chicago   &   St.   Louis  Railway: 

1.  Single  tie  renewals. 

2.  Not  unless  all  ties  in  continuous  stretches  are  all  worn  out. 

3.  We  can  see  no  advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches, 
as  under  the  long  run  the  waste  of  tie  timber  would  be  prohibitive. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewal  is  that  you  avoid  any  waste  of 
tie  timber  and  by  that  method  track  is  kept  in  a  continuously  safe  con- 
dition. 

5.  Single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.  Samuel  Rockwell,  Chief  Engineer,  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern 
Railway: 

1.  We  ordinarily  renew  ties   singly. 

2.  We  do  not,  as  a  rule,  renew  ties  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  I  know  of  no  advantage  except  that  it  would  probably  afford  a  bet- 
ter record  of  the  life  of  the  ties. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewal  is  that  only  such  ties  as  need  to 
be  renewed  are  renewed;  whereas,  "out  of  face"  renewal  many  ties 
which  would  last  longer  are  taken  out  and  thrown  away. 

5.  I  would  recommend  taking  out  only  such  ties  as  need  to  be  taken 
out. 

Mr.   E.  J.  Correll,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Missouri   Pacific  Rail- 
way : 

1.  Single  tie  renewals. 

2.  No. 

3.  I  know  of  none.     Would  consider  it  a  disadvantage. 

4.  Disturbs  the  surface  less,  is  more  economical  and  makes  condition 
of  track  mere  uniform. 

5.  Single  tie  renewals. 


334  TIES. 

Mr.  R.  Trimble,   Chief  Engineer   Maintenance   of   Way,   Northwest   Sys- 
tem, Pennsylvania  Lines : 

i.  The  practice  of  our  road  is  to  renew  only  such  ties  as  will  not 
last  another  year.  This,  I  take  it,  is  what  is  termed  "single  tie  re- 
newal." 

2.  No.     By  doing  so  the  life  of  the  tie  is  considerably  shortened.     It 
is  known  that  a  tie  when  left  in  place  will  last  longer  than  if  taken  out, 
thrown  around,  loaded  and  unloaded,   and   then  put  in   somewhere   else. - 
The  chances  are  that  many  ties  which  would  last  another  year  or  two 
if  left  in  their  place,  would  be  wasted  and  not  used  elsewhere. 

3.  I  know  of  no  advantages  of  renewing  ties  in  continuous  stretches 
that  would  even  compensate  for  the  disadvantages. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewals  is  the  resultant  economy.  I 
know  of  no  disadvantage. 

5.  I  recommend  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.   C.   W.  Johns,   Engineer   Maintenance   of   Way,    Chesapeake  &   Ohio 
Railway : 

1.  Until  recent  years  it  has  been  the  practice  of  this  road  to  renew 
ties  in  continuous  stretches.  For  the  past  2  or  3  years  we  have  tried  to 
get  all  of  our  section  foremen  on  double  track  to  work  one  track  one 
year  and  the  other  track  the  next,  putting  in  single  ties  where  required. 
On  single  track  the  foremen  work  half  the  section  one  year  and  the  other 
half  the  next,  putting  in  single  ties  where  required. 

2.  No.  This  method  necessarily  allows  a  portion  of  the  track  to  be- 
come unsafe  before  the  ties  are  renewed;  at  least,  the  ties  get  so  soft  it  is 
impossible  to  maintain  good  surface,  while  by  slipping  in  single  ties  this 
condition  does  not  exist  and  there  are  always  sufficient  sound  ties  under 
each  rail  to  maintain  proper  surface  and  gage. 

3.  I  know  of  no  advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches. 

4.  Advantage  of  this  method  is  that  you  never  have  any  stretches 
of  rotten  or  unsound  ties  and  there  are  always  enough  sound  ties  to  main- 
tain proper  surface  and  gage. 

5.  I  prefer  the  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Berry,  Chief  Engineer,  Rock  Island  Lines : 

1.  Single  tie  renewals. 

2.  Not  unless  they  are  all  decayed  or  worn  out  so  that  they  need  to 
come  out  at  the  same  time. 

3.  I  know  of  none. 

4.  I  believe  the  economy  of  a  railroad  demands  that  no  tie  should 
be  taken  out  until  decayed  or  worn  out.  The  men  along  the  line  are 
educated  to  better  rules  of  economy  by  adopting  such  methods,  and  you 
never  can  keep  all  ties,  even  if  you  lay  them  in  a  continuous  stretch,  in 
the  same  condition  so  that  they  should  all  be  taken  out  at  the  same 
time. 

5.  I  favor  only  taking  ties  out  as  stated  above. 

Mr.  William  Twining,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,   Central  Railroad 
of  New  Jersey: 

1.  On  this  division  where  slag  and  engine  cinders  are  used  for  bal- 
last, it  is  the  practice  to  renew  ties  singly. 

2.  Do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  One  advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches  would  be  that 
it  avoids,  in  a  measure,  frequent  disturbance  to  the  ballast  bed  as  well 
as  the  line  and  surface. 

4.  The  advantage  of  single  renewal  is  that  greater  average  life  of 
the  tie  is  thereby  secured. 


TIES.  335 

5.  In  stone  or  heavy  slag  ballast,  and  under  heavy  traffic,  close  re- 
newal or  practically  entire  renewal  is  recommended.  In  light  slag  or 
cinder  ballast,  under  ordinary  traffic,  single  renewal  is  recommended. 

Mr.  L.  R.  Zollinger,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,   Pennsylvania  Rail- 
road: 

1.  Single  tie  renewals — method  known  as  "spotting." 

2.  By  no  means. 

3.  There  is  no  advantage. 

1 4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewal  is  economy,  permitting  of  ties  re- 
maining in  that  are  too  good  to  come  out,  based  on  the  knowledge  that 
all  material  is  not  the  same  and  does  not  have  the  same  lasting  quali- 
ties, and  permits  of  removal  of  those  ties,  the  lives  of  which  are  not  up 
to  the  average,  when  they  become  unfit  for  use. 
5.     We  recommend  the  practice  of  "spotting." 

Mr.  H.  S.  Wilgus,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Pittsburg,  Shawmut  & 
Northern : 

1.  It  is  our  practice  to  make  single  tie  renewals. 

2.  Do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches,  except 
in  difficult  places. 

3.  Advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches  is  less  frequency 
of  disturbing  roadbed. 

4.  Advantages  of  single  renewal  is  getting  full  value  out  of  all  ties. 
Disadvantage  is  in  covering  greater  distance  of  track  and  disturbing  more 
roadbed. 

5.  Would  recommend  single  tie  renewals  as  being  the  most  eco- 
nomical. 

Mr.   John  R.   Leighty,   Engineer   Maintenance  of  Way,   Missouri   Pacific 
Railway : 

1.  Single  ties  as  needed. 

2.  No. 

3.  Better  track  than  average,  once  in  about  6  or   7  years. 

4.  Track  kept  in  uniform  condition  at  all  times  and  ties  renewed 
only  when  they  need  to  be,  instead  of  before  or  afterward. 

5.  I  would  recommend  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.  J.  R.  W.  Davis,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Great  Northern  Rail- 
way: 

1.  It  is  the  practice  of  our  company  to  renew  ties  singly  or  in  groups 
of  2,  3  or  4  at  a  time  as  their  condition  may  make  it  necessary. 

2.  We  do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  I  doubt  there  being  any  advantage  in  continuous  tie  renewals. 

4.  Disadvantage  of  single  tie  renewals  are  yearly  disturbances  of 
track,  greater  labor  cost  of  distributing  and  placing  ties.  Advantage  is  a 
stronger  track  year  for  year  and  less  waste  of  material. 

5.  We  recommend  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.   P.  C.  Newbegin,  Maintenance  Engineer,  Bangor  &  Aroostook  Rail- 
road: 

1.  It  is  our  practice  to  renew  ties  singly. 

2.  Do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  ties  in  continuous  stretches, 
except  in  locations  where  paving  or  other  covering  must  be  removed  to 
reach  the  ties,  and,  possibly,  on  short  stretches  of  track  which  are  under 
exceptionally  heavy  traffic. 

3.  Advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches  is  that  it  lessens 


336  TIES. 

the  labor  cost  per  tie  and  disturbs  the  roadbed  less  frequently  than  mast 
be  done  where  ties  are  removed  singly. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  renewal  is  that  full  life  of  ties  can  be  utilized, 
and  no  ties  need  be  removed  until  they  are  worn  out.  This  in  all  but 
exceptional  cases  would  more  than  balance  the  saving  of  cost  from  remov- 
ing in  continuous  stretches  and  the  disadvantage  of  more  frequent  dis- 
turbing of  the  roadbed. 

5.  Except  in  rare  cases  I  would  recommend  single  tie  renewals.      -n 

Mr.  J.  M.  R.  Fairbairn,  Assistant  Chief  Engineer  Eastern  Lines,  Canadian 
Pacific  Railway: 

1.  It  is  our  practice  to  make  tie  renewals  only  as  they  require  it. 

2.  Would  not  consider  it  economy  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches 
and  see  no  advantage  gained  by  this  method.  It  is  our  practice  in  the 
spring  of  each  year  to  send  a  man,  well  versed  in  tie  conditions,  over  each 
sub-division,  and  he  marks  with  paint  the  ties  he  considers  not  good 
for  another  year's  service,  using  proper  judgment  and  taking  into  con- 
sideration condition  of  adjoining  ties.  These  are  replaced  during  the  sum- 
mer season  and  if  a  section  foreman  considers  that  a  tie  has  not  been 
marked  which,  in  his  opinion,  should  be  replaced,  he  takes  matter  up  with 
the  Roadmaster,  who  decides  whether  or  not  renewal  will  take  place. 

3.  Only  advantage  is  that  it  entails  less  work. 

4.  Advantages  of  single  tie  renewals  are  that  only  those  ties  are 
removed  which  have  served  their  life.  In  the  other  case  ties  are  removed 
which  have  another  year  or  two  of  service  in  them,  so  that  in  renewing  in 
continuous  stretches,  there  is,  therefore,  more  waste. 

5.  I,  of  course,  recommend  the  single  tie  renewal  system. 

Mr.  S.  A.  Jordan,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Rail- 
road: 

1.  Our  practice  is  to  renew  only  those  ties  that  will  not  last  another 
year. 

2.  No.  Our  ties  are  inspected  every  spring  by  a  regular  Tie  In- 
spector, who  marks  all  ties  that  are  to  come  out. 

3.  Do  not  think  there  is  any  particular  advantage. 

4.  Believe  that  renewals  as  made  by  the  B.  &  O.  are  better  than  in 
continuous  stretches.  By  taking  out  only  such  ties  as  will  not  last  an- 
other year  you  get  a  uniform  amount  of  good  timber  under  your  rail. 

5.  I  recommend  renewing  ties  singly. 

Mr.  W.  C.  Cushing,  Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Southwest  Sys- 
tem, Pennsylvania  Lines : 

1.  The  practice  of  our  Lines  is  to  renew  ties  as  worn  out  or  de- 
cayed, and  not  in  continuous  stretches. 

2.  No,  except,  possibly,  between  station  platforms  or  in  street  cross- 
ings where  the  labor  of  getting  at  the  ties  is  great. 

3.  I  believe  the  following  advantages  might  be  claimed  for  the 
method  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches:  (1)  Track  could  be  given 
uniform  lift,  and,  when  new  ties  were  in  place,  uniform  support  would  be 
furnished  them ;  (2)  Cost  of  laying  in  continuous  stretches  would  prob- 
ably be  less  than  laying  them  singly. 

4.  Advantages  of  single  tie  renewals  are:  (1)  The  track,  as  a  whole, 
is  kept  in  a  more  uniform  condition,  as  to  the  quality  of  the  supporting 
ties :  (2)  Only  ties  that  should  be  removed,  account  of  wear  or  decay, 
need  be  removed.  Disadvantages  of  this  method  are:  (1)  The  old  bed 
of  the  tie  must  be  dug  up  to  get  the  new  tie  in  place,  or  entire  track 
given  sufficient  raise  to  accomplish  this  result ;  (2)  Where  platforms, 
planking  or  interlocking  fixtures  must  be  disturbed  to  remove  ties,  this 


TIES.  337 

disturbance  takes  place  oftener  under  the  single  tie  renewal  system ; 
(3)  The  cost  of  renewal  per  tie  is  probably  somewhat  higher  under  this 
system  also. 

5.  We  would  recommend  the  renewal  of  ties  singly.  Because : 
(1)  The  general  safe  condition  of  the  track  is  greater;  (2)  The  average 
life  of  the  ties,  we  believe,  will  be  lengthened  by  the  single  tie  renewal 
method,  as,  when  renewing  in  continuous  stretches,  many  ties  are  neces- 
sarily taken  out  and  lost  which  might  safely  be  left  in  the  track  a  year  or 
two  longer  if  the  adjoining  ties  were  good. 

Mr.  Geo.   B.   Woodworth,  Inspector  of  Rail,   Chicago,   Milwaukee  &   St. 
Paul  Railway : 

1.  The  practice  of  our  road  is  to  make  single  tie  renewals. 

2.  From  a  financial  standpoint  I  do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew 
ties  in  continuous  stretches,  since  the  life  of  the  ties  is  variable  and  the 
usable  ties  taken  out  deteriorate  rapidly,  and  will  lose  25  to  50  per  cent, 
of  their  usefulness  before  they  can  be  used  again.  In  special  cases  it 
is  more  advantageous  from  every  point  of  view  to  renew  in  continuous 
stretches,  as  in  tunnels,  narrow  rock  cuts  or  over  very  busy  stretches  of 
track  where  the  track  can  be  given  over  for  a  short  time  to  a  large 
force  of  men. 

3.  Advantage  of  renewing  in  continuous  stretches  is,  that  after  the 
ties  are  placed,  roadbed  will  not  again  be  disturbed  for  a  long  time,  and 
a  better  general  condition  of  track  can  be  maintained. 

4.  Above  answer  also  covers  your  third  question. 

5.  As  a  general  proposition  I  should  recommend  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.  M.  C.   Hamilton,   Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,   New  York,   New 
Haven   &  Hartford  Railroad : 

1.  It  is  our  practice  to  renew  ties  singly. 

2.  This  depends  on  the  local  conditions;  on  four-track  sections  in- 
terior tracks,  or  adjacent  to  station  platforms,  the  renewing  of  ties  "out 
of  face"  is  considered  the  economical  practice. 

3.  We  do  not  consider  the  renewal  of  ties  "out  of  face"  the  eco- 
nomical practice  under  normal  conditions. 

4.  Advantages  of  single  tie  renewals  are  greater  economy  and  more 
uniform  condition  of  track. 

5.  I  would  recommend  the  renewing  of  ties  singly,  except  where 
unusual  conditions  demand  the  other  method. 

Mr.  C.  M.  James,  Engineer  Roadway,  Atlantic  Coast  Line: 

1.  The  practice  of  our  road  is  single  tie  renewals. 

2.  Under  the  conditions  existing  in  this  territory,  I  do  not  think 
it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  The  advantage  of  the  above  method  is  in  the  saving  of  labor,  but 
this  advantage  is  outweighed  by  the  disadvantage  that  material  is  used. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewals  is  in  the  fact  that  full  life  can 
then  be  gotten  from  each  individual  tie. 

5.  There  is  no  question  in  my  mind  but  that  single  tie  renewals  is 
the  better  practice. 

Mr.  G.  J.  Ray,  Chief  Engineer,  Delaware,  Lackawanna  &  Western  Rail- 
road: 

1.  Single  tie  renewals  is  the  method  practiced  as  much  as  possible. 
We  find  that  some  of  our  old  foremen  have  been  in  the  habit  of  renewing 
ties  in  continuous  stretches,  and  it  is  hard  to  break  them  of  this  practice, 
and  there  are  cases  where  we  permit  this   method  of  renewal   through 


338  TIES. 

station  grounds  where  it  is  more  difficult  to  get  at  the  track,  making  use 
of  the  better  ties  taken  out  for  sidetrack  purposes. 

2.  No.  If  all  the  ties  are  in  such  shape  that  they  should  come  out, 
I  do  not  think  the  track  is  in  first  class  shape,  and  am  not  an  advocate 
of  permitting  track  to  get  in  such  shape  that  all  ties  can  consistently  be 
taken  out  at  the  same  time. 

3.  Only  advantage  is  that  more  ties  can  be  placed  at  the  same  cost. 

4.  Full  life  of  service  can  be  gotten  out  of  every  tie,  and  this  advan- 
tage of  single  tie  renewal  will  more  than  outweigh  any  advantage  in  favor 
of  the  former  system. 

5.  Single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.  W.  L.  Breckinridge,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,   Chicago,   Bur- 
lington &  Quincy  Railroad : 

1.  We  practice  the  system  known  as  "single  tie  renewals." 

2.  No,  except  in  special  cases. 

3.  Only  advantage  I  know  of  in  renewing  in  continuous  stretches  is 
in  cases  where  the  life  of  the  rail  under  heavy  traffic  about  equals  the 
life  of  the  ties ;  that  is,  in  renewing  rail  where  the  traffic  is  heavy,  ties 
should  be  renewed  in  full  and  unless  ties  under  old  rail  are  almost  new, 
they  should  all  come  out.  You  will  then  have  a  track  which  will  not  have 
to  be  disturbed  during  the  life  of  the  new  rail  on  account  of  tie  re- 
newals. 

4.  Single  tie  renewals  is  all  right,  especially  on  less  important  main 
lines  where  the  life  of  the  rail  exceeds  that  of  the  tie.  We  are  also  able 
to  keep  yearly  check  on  our  gage  and  hold  track  to  a  more  perfect  gage, 
since  the  average  efficiency  of  a  proper  single  tie  renewal  track  is  almost 
constant,  while  with  a  continuous  renewal  track  the  holding  power  of 
spikes  and  general  efficiency  is  on  the  decrease.  Disadvantages  of  single 
tie  renewal  are:  (1)  Frequent  disturbance  of  roadbed;  (2)  Inability  to  get 
a  firm  and  equal  bearing  on  the  new  ties;  (3)  Taking  up  too  much  time 
in  the  Spring  for  this  sort  of  work  when  the  track  needs  picking  up ; 
(4)   Keeping  right  of  way  littered  each  year  with  new  and  old  ties. 

5.  I  would  recommend  continuous  renewal  only  when  relaying  rail 
on  main  line  heavy  traffic  road.  In  such  cases  the  life  of  the  rail  does 
not  exceed  that  of  the  ties.  In  all  other  cases  I  recommend  single  tie 
renewal,  as  the  life  of  tie  timber  varies  too  much  to  consistently  renew  in 
continuous  stretches. 

Mr.  L.  G.  Curtis,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Rail- 
road : 

1.  Our  practice  is  to  renew  ties  singly. 

2.  No,  only  under  extraordinary  conditions. 

3.  No  advantage. 

4.  The  change  to  single  tie  renewals  gives  you  sound  ties  through- 
out. 

5.  Would  recommend  single  tie  renewals,  excepting  in  rare  cases 
where  ties  are  all  poor. 

Mr.    Alexander    Bonnyman,    General    Manager,    Atlanta,    Birmingham    & 
Atlantic : 

1.  Single  tie  renewals.  When  a  tie  shows  signs  of  decay,  it  is 
taken  out. 

2.  No,  unless  traffic  is  very  heavy  and  the  roadbed  of  such  nature  as 
to  make  continuous  renewals  necessary. 

3.  No  advantage  unless  under  above  conditions. 

4.  Advantage  in  single  renewals  is  that ,  full  life  of  every  tie  is 
utilized. 


TIES.  339 

5.  I  would  recommend  that  where  the  earnings  of  a  road  demand 
economy,  ties  be  renewed  singly ;  where  traffic  is  heavy  and  the  Company 
is  able  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches,  that  this  be  done. 

Mr.   W.  J.  Towne,   Engineer  of  Maintenance,    Chicago   &   Northwestern 
Railway : 

1.  Tie  renewals  based  upon  actual  condition  of  tie,  except  joint  and 
center  ties ;  these  are  usually  renewed  together,  and  if  any  ties  removed 
are  serviceable  elsewhere,  they  are  properly  utilized. 

2.  No,  not  as  a  general  proposition.  In  slag  or  rock  ballast  I 
think  it  economy  to  renew  continuous  to  the  extent  that  any  ties  that 
will  not  last  2  years  or  more  be  taken  out. 

3.  Principal  advantage  would  be  in  securing  more  uniform  rail  bear- 
ing and  economy  when  the  life  of  the  tie  would  not  offset  the  labor  charge 
for  renewal  and  less  disturbance  of  track  bed  result  in  general  economy, 
in  rail,  etc.,  as  well  as  improved  roadbed. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewals  consists  wholly  in  conservation. 
Disadvantages  mentioned  in  reply  "three." 

5.  Depends  on  character  of  line,  volume  of  traffic,  ballast,  rail  and 
roadbed.  In  gravel  ballast  with  light  traffic  would  recommend  single 
tie  renewals ;  in  rock  or  slag  ballast  with  heavy  traffic  would  recommend 
renewal  joint  and  center  ties  together,  and  renewal  of  all  ties  that  would 
not  last  2  years,  both  as  a  matter  of  economy  and  other  reasons  before 
named. 

Mr.  E.  F.  Mitchell,  Chief  Engineer,  Missouri  Pacific  Railway : 

1.  Single  tie  renewal  is  the  practice  of  our  road. 

2.  No,  we  do  not  think  it  advisable. 

3.  The  average  life  of  a  tie  on  this  system  is  8  years.  For  the  sake 
of  argument  assume  that  the  best  method  of  renewing  ties  in  continuous 
stretches  would  be  to  renew  all  the  ties  under  1  rail  length  in  a  given 
year  at  one  time.  Then  about  6  years  later  it  would  be  necessary  to  re- 
new at  least  a  portion  of  these  ties,  possibly  50  per  cent,  of  them.  The 
balance  of  ties  under  this  rail  would  probably  last  from  one  to  four 
years. 

5.  If  the  ties  rotted  at  the  end  of  6  years  are  not  "spotted  in"  or 
renewed,  as  called,  in  single  ties,  but,  instead  of  this  the  entire  rail 
length  is  renewed  for  the  purpose  of  reducing  the  cost  of  labor  for 
renewal  per  tie,  then  about  one-half  the  ties  under  this  rail  will  be  re- 
newed when  they  have  from  one  to  four  years'  service  left. 

Mr.  W.  D.  Taylor,  Chief  Engineer,  Chicago  &  Alton  Railway : 

1.  Single  tie  renewals,  except  where  there  are  2  or  more  consecutive 
ties  to  be  renewed. 

2.  Only  when  renewing  in  track  to  be  surfaced,  as  we  do  not  think 
it  advisable  to  leave  old  ties  in  track  that  is  being  surfaced,  and  then 
have  to  again  disturb  the  track  and  ballast  the  next  year  to  change  out 
the  remaining  old  ties. 

3.  Advantage  of  single  tie  renewals  is  that  fewer  tie  renewals  are 
required  to  keep  track  in  good  condition  where  only  the  worst  ties  are 
taken  out  and  new  ties  put  in  in  this  way  than  would  be  the  case  where 
long  stretches  of  ties  are  taken  out,  and  the  track  shaken  up  and  ties 
knocked  around  for  spacing. 

4.  and  5.     Answered  in  the  above. 

Mr.  F.  R.  Layng,  Engineer  of  Track,  Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad : 

1.  Single  tie  renewals. 

2.  No,  I  do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches. 


340  TIES. 

3.  The  cost  of  renewals  per  tie  (labor  only)  would  be  less  when 
ties  are  renewed  "out  of  face."  This  is  on  account  of  the  fact  that  only 
about  half  as  much  ballast  per  tie  would  have  to  be  dug  out  to  make 
renewals.  Disadvantage :  In  renewing  in  stretches,  when  it  is  decided 
that  renewals  should  be  made,  track  is  in  weakened  condition.  This 
being  so,  chances  are  either  taken  to  run  the  ties  a  little  longer,  or,  if 
the  responsibility  rests  with  a  man  who  is  timid,  renewals  are  ordered 
at  a  time  when  most  of  the  ties  would  last  two  or  three  years  longer,  if 
not  disturbed.  Neither  of  the  above  conditions  tends  to  good  practice. 
The  ideal,  to  my  mind,  is  to  get  the  longest  possible  life  from  a  tie,  con- 
sistent with  safety,  without  disturbing  it. 

I  am  quite  sure  the  tendency  of  the  average  man  would  be  to  remove 
the  ties  in  ample  time  so  that  the  result  would  be  to  reduce  the  life  per 
tie  to  about  five  years.  This  would  increase  the  cost  of  tie  renewals 
from  15  to  20  per  cent.  Inasmuch  as  tie  renewals  make  up  the  largest 
single  item  in  maintenance  expense ;  most  roads  would  hesitate  to  in- 
crease same  unless  some  very  decided  advantage  resulted  therefrom. 

Another  disadvantage :  It  is  practically  impossible  to  select  ties 
which  would  decay  so  uniformly  that  any  great  length  of  track  could 
be  renewed  without  taking  out  some  ties  still  fit  for  service.  Some  use 
would  have  to  be  found  for  these  ties  and  they  would  no  doubt  be  used 
in  sidetracks.     Assuming  the  following: 

Cost  of  first-class  tie  delivered  along  track $0.70 

Cost  of  second-class  tie  delivered  along  track 60 

Average  life  of  first-class  tie  in  main  track 7  years 

Average  life  of  second-class  tie  in  siding 7  years 

Average  life  of  first-class  tie  removed  from  main 

and  used  in  siding   3  years 

We  arrive  at  the  figures  given  below : 

Cost  of  tie  removed  from  main   and  put  in   siding 

3  years  at  10c  per  year $0.30 

Cost  to   remove   from   main   track    03 

Cost    of    putting    in    siding .08 

Total   cost    $0.41 

Average   cost    per   year    in    siding $013  2-3 

Cost    of    second-class    ties $0.60 

Cost    of    putting    in    siding    08 

Total   cost    $0.68 

Average   cost   per    year    in    siding $0.09  5-7 

Cost  of  first-class   tie   in   siding    $0.70 

Cost    of    putting    in    siding 08 

Total    cost    $0.78 

Average   cost   per   year    in    siding $0.11  1-7 

The  above  shows  clearly,  if  my  assumption  is  correct,  that  it  does 
not  pay  to  use  same  in  sidings. 

4.  Advantages  of  single  tie  renewals:  (1)  Effective  life  of  tie  is 
longer;  (2)  Average  condition  of  track  as  to  safety  is  better;  (3)  Sin- 
gle track  renewals  disturb  roadbed  less ;  (4)  Trackmen  can  arrange  work 
to  better  advantage  in  single  tie  renewals;    (5)   Cost  of  tie  renewals  con- 


TIES.  341 

siderably  in  favor  of  single  tie  practice.  (Net  cost,  including  everything 
connected  with  this  item.) 

Disadvantages :  I  can  see  no  particular  disadvantage  in  the  method 
of  renewing  ties  singly.  The  most  expensive  thing  we  have  is  labor  and 
least  amount  of  labor  per  tie  is  expended. 

5.  Usual  argument  against  single  tie  renewals,  I  presume,  is  that 
after  making  same,  track  does  not  ride  smoothly  or  is  spotty.  Now  this 
is  usually  the  case,  but  it  is  the  result  of  poor  maintenance  and  is  not  a 
necessary  evil  which  follows  the  practice  of  single  tie  renewal.  If  the 
trackmen  will  properly  tamp  new  ties  a  week  or  ten  days  after  they  have 
been  put  in,  this  trouble  can  easily  be  taken  care  of. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony,  Chief  Engineer,  Quebec,  Montreal  &  Southern  Rail- 
way: 

1.  We  renew  all  ties  on  this  road  as  necessity  requires ;  i.  e.,  when 
they  are  decayed,  broken  or  otherwise  defective. 

2.  No. 

3.  4  and  5.  Tie  renewals  sometimes  occur  in  continuous  stretches, 
but  this,  no  doubt,  comes  under  your  classification  as  "single"  and 
practically  all  my  experience  has  been  on  this  line. 

Mr.   Earl    Stimson,    Chief   Engineer   Maintenance    of   Way,    Baltimore   & 
Ohio  Railroad : 

1.  Single  tie   renewals  is   the  practice  of  our   road. 

2.  No. 

3.  Can  see  no  advantage  of  renewing  ties  in  continuous  stretches. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  renewal  is  in  obtaining  extreme  life  of  each 
individual  tie. 

5.  I  would  recommend  single  tie  renewals.  As  a  general  proposi- 
tion would  not  consider  continuous  tie  renewals  as  having  any  advan- 
tage unless  it  might  be  in  first-class  track  in  which  treated  ties  of  the 
same  class  of  timber  were  used,  equipped  with  screw  spikes  and  tie- 
plates  and  laid  in  stone  ballast.  This  is  a  very  unusual  occurrence  and 
it  is  therefore  the  reason  I  answer  your  third  question  as  I  do. 

Mr.  J.   E.  McNeil,   Inspector  Roadway  and  Track,   Atchison,   Topeka  & 
Santa  Fe  Coast  Line : 

1.  Our  practice  is  single  tie  renewals. 

2.  Not  advisable  on  our  line,  at  least,  where  there  is  so  much  dif- 
ference in  the  length  of  time  our  ties  last. 

3.  There  would  be  no  advantage  on  western  lines. 

4.  We  find  that  the  life  of  tie  timber  received  at  the  same  time  and 
cut  in  the  same  forest  varies  from  one  to  five  years.  To  make  tie  re- 
newals in  continuous  stretches,  would,  we  think,  be  extravagant.  At 
one  time  in  the  Middle  West  where  we  got  eight  years'  service  out  of 
our  white  oak  ties,  and  the  inspection  was  such  as  to  have  them  about 
the  same  in  quality,  we  figured  on  renewing  about  one-eighth  of  the 
number  each  year.  In  this  way  the  work  could  be  done  with  a  small 
extra  gang. 

5.  In  this  part  of  the  country  where  we  have  such  a  variety  of 
tie  timber  and  their  lasting  quality  is  so  different,  I  would  recommend 
single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.    S.    M.    Braden,    General    Superintendent,    Chicago    &    Northwestern 

Railway : 

1.  We  make  tie  renewals  as  needed — very  seldom,  however,  in 
continuous  stretches. 


342  TIES. 

2.  No,  as  conditions  necessitating  continuous  renewals  would,  in 
our  opinion,  indicate  improper  previous  maintenance. 

3.  Can  see  no  advantage.  Increased  maintenance  expense  would 
be  a  disadvantage. 

4.  Principal  advantage  in  single  renewal  is  less  expense,  and,  in 
addition,  there  is  less  disturbance  as  to  surface  of  track. 

5.  We  would  recommend  the  method  of  single  tie  renewals. 

Mr.   J.   K.    Howard,   Engineer   Maintenance    of  Way,    Ann    Arbor   Rail- 
road: 

1.  Single  tie  renewals.  We  take  out  no  ties  which  will  last  an- 
other year. 

2.  Do  not  think  it  advisable  to  renew  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  No  advantage  in  above  method. 

4.  Advantage  of  single  renewal  is  that  only  ties  unfit  for  another 
year's  service  are  removed  and  I  would  call  this  the  more  economical 
practice. 

5.  I    recommend    single    tie    renewals. 

Mr.  G.   B.   Owen,   Engineer  Maintenance   of  Way,   Erie  Railroad : 

1.  The  practice  of  this  road  is  to  renew  ties  singly. 

2.  Do  not  think  it  advisable  to   renew  ties  in  continuous  stretches. 

3.  I  cannot  name  any  advantage  of  renewing  ties  in  continuous 
stretches. 

4.  The  advantage  of  single  tie  renewal  is  economy  and  uniformity 
in  maintenance,  and  uniformity  of  track  conditions  as  well  as  mainte- 
nance charges. 

5.  I  would  recommend  an  inspection  bv  a  competent  inspector  of 
the  old  ties  in  the  track  before  renewal,  and  that  only  such  ties  be  re- 
moved which  would  not  give  one  additional  year's  service  from  the 
time  the  inspection  was  made.  This  practice,  if  continued  from  year  to 
year,  will  result  in  a  stronger  condition  of  the  roadbed  with  the  employ- 
ment of  a  less  number  of  men  per  section  than  would  be  necessary 
where  continuous  renewals  were  made.  It  would  also  materially  assist 
the  purchasing  department  in  the  placing  of  their  contracts  for  ties. 
The  disadvantages  which  developed  from  our  tests  in  continuous  tie 
renewals  were  that  a  large  number  of  ties  were  removed  which  would 
give  one,  two,  three  or  four  years'  further  service.  An  effort  was  made 
to  utilize  these  ties  in  other  tracks,  but  it  is  manifestly  a  great  loss  of 
labor  to  remove  a  tie  until  it  has  worn  out  and  then  attempt  to  again 
replace  it  in  the  track.  A  further  disadvantage  resulted  in  an  effort  to 
reduce  the  forces  on  sections  where  continuous  tie  renewals  were  made 
in  order  to  make  up,  in  a  way,  the  excessive  cost  of  these  renewals.  In 
a  very  short  time  this  reduction  resulted  in  bad  surface  and  line  so  that 
in  the  end  there  was  really  no  saving  in  labor. 

From  the  excellent  information  received  it  is  evident  that  the  gen- 
eral practice  is  to  renew  ties  singly,  except  in  unusual  cases  at  station 
platforms,  highway  crossings,  narrow  tunnels  or  interlocking  plants 
where  it  requires  much  labor  to  get  at  the  ties  or  to  uncover  them  for 
the  purpose  of  renewal. 

CONCLUSION. 
The  Committee  recommends  the  practice  of  single  tie  renewals. 


TIES.  343 

(3)     METAL,    COMPOSITE    AND    CONCRETE    TIES. 

Your  Committee  was  directed  to  prepare  a  report  on  the  use  of 
metal,  composite  and  concrete  ties. 

During  the  year  the  members  of  the  Sub-Committee  dealing  with 
this  subject  held  two  meetings — one  at  Pittsburg,  September  5,  6  and  7, 
191 1,  at  which  time  an  inspection  of  the  following  ties  was  made: 

Rohm  Steel  Tie,  Sewickley,  Pa.,  Pennsylvania  Lines,  Northwest  Sys- 
tem. 

Universal  Steel  Tie,  Emsworth,  Pa.,  Pennsylvania  Lines,  Northwest 
System. 

Reigler  Concrete  Tie,  Emsworth,  Pa.,  Pennsylvania  Lines,  North- 
west System. 

Carnegie  Steel  Tie,   Pittsburg,    Pa.,   Pittsburg  &  Lake   Erie. 

Carnegie  Steel  Tie,  McKees  Rocks,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie. 

Universal  Steel  Tie,  Pittsburg,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie. 

Atwood  Steel  and  Concrete  Tie,  McKees  Rocks,  Pittsburg  &  Lake 
Erie. 

Bruckner   Concrete  Tie,   McKees  Rocks,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie. 

Snyder   Steel  Tie,  Derry,    Pa.,   Pennsylvania  Railroad. 

Mechling  &  Smith  Tie,  Wilkinsburg,  Pa.,  Pennsylvania  Railroad. 

Carnegie  Steel  Tie,  Port  Perry,   Pa.,  Union  Railroad. 

Carnegie  Steel  Tie,  Homestead,   Pa.,  Carnegie  Steel  Company. 

Carnegie  Steel  Tie,  North  Bessemer  to  Exposition  Park,  Bessemer 
&  Lake  Erie  Railroad. 

And  a  meeting  at  Baltimore,  Md.,  November  10,  191 1. 

In  connection  with  the  following  report  your  Committee  wishes  to 
point  out  that  it  is  of  the  opinion  that  no  single  design  of  substitute  is 
going  to  meet  all  the  conditions  to  be  found  on  railway  track  and  there 
should  be  at  least  two  designs  or  types: 

(1)  A  tie  for  heavy  service,  insulated  or  not  insulated,  as  re- 
quired. 

(2)  A  tie  for  light  service,  insulated  or  not  insulated,  as  re- 
quired. 

It  is  desirable  that  any  type  of  non-insulated  tie  should  be  capable 
of  being  insulated  without  having  to  be  removed  from  the  track. 

As  far  as  we  can  see,  very  few  designers  have  recognized  this 
distinction  and  as  a  result  attempt  to  meet  all  conditions  with  a  single 
design.  We  believe  this  is  neither  desirable  nor  economical,  and  that 
much  better  results  will  be  obtained  if  the  tie  be  designed  for  special 
service. 

Your  Committee  has  been  somewhat  disappointed  with  the  results 
obtained  with  the  concrete  tie,  the  concrete  and  metal  tie,  and  the 
asphalt  and  metal  tie,  for  reasons  given  in  our  conclusions. 

In  regard  to  steel  ties,  your  Committee  was  impressed  with  the 
number  of  steel  ties  in  use  on  the  Union  Railroad  and  the  Bessemer 
&   Lake   Erie   Railroad.     The  total   number   of   steel   ties   on   these   two 


344  TIES. 

roads  is  over  one  million,  or  enough   to   lay  312  miles  of  track,   using 
3,200  ties  to  the  mile. 

We  desire  to  call  attention  to  the  widespread  interest  that  is  now 
being  taken  in  finding  a  substitute  for  the  wood  tie.  This  is  not  con- 
fined to  any  particular  section  of  the  country,  nor  to  the  steam  rail- 
roads. The  portion  of  this  report  covering  the  Street  and  Interurbarr 
Electric  Lines  is  evidence  that  these  lines  are  seeking  a  substitute  tie. 

In  addition  to  the  personal  inspection  made   by   the   Committee   the 
following    reports    have    been    received    from    railroads    using    substitute 
ties: 
Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad  Company: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  pp.  504-529;  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 
page  385.) 

On  October  28,  191 1,  Mr.  Earl  Stimson,  Chief  Engineer  Mainte- 
nance of  Way,   states : 

"In  reply  to  your  letter  of  August  26,  I  would  advise  that  this  com- 
pany has  made  no  additional  installations  of  any  metal  or  composite 
ties.     I  have  nothing  further  to  report  thereon." 

Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  page  496;  Vol.  11,  Part  2, 
page  876,  and  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  371.) 

"Up  to  January  1,  191 1,  this  company  had  purchased  563,555  Car- 
negie steel  ties  and  during  191 1  we  will  receive  138,000,  making  a  total 
of  702,355  ties  to  be  received  by  January  1,  1912.  The  ties  if  laid  con- 
tinuously 3,200  to  the  mile  (our  standard  spacing  on  main  line)  would 
give  219.5  miles  of  steel  tie  track.  During  the  year  we  also  received  20 
sets  of  steel  switch  ties. 

"We  have  very  little,  if  any,  additional  information  to  report  this 
year.  The  ties  put  in  at  Claytonia  in  1904  are  still  in  and  there  has 
been  no  change  in  their  condition  since  our  last  report.  The  1,000  in- 
sulated ties  installed  in  June,  1506,  at  Conneaut,  Ohio,  are  still  in  and 
have  given  no  trouble  whatever. 

"This  road  will  continue  to  use  this  type  of  steel  tie  in  maintenance 
and  construction  work. 

"Accompanying  this  are  two  photographs,  one  showing  scene  of  a 
derailment  near  Queen  Junction,  Pa.,  and  one  near  Jamisonville,  Pa. 
Both  derailments  were  caused  by  a  broken  flange ;  in  each  case  but  one 
pair  of  trucks  was  derailed  and  the  car  derailed  was  a  steel  car  loaded 
with  55  tons  of  ore,  so  that  the  gross  weight  of  the  car  was  about  73 
tons.  These  derailments  happened  in  August,  1910,  and  the  ties  are 
still  in  the  track." 

Buffalo,  Rochester  &  Pittsburg  Railzmy: 

(See  previous  report.  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  371.) 

Mr.  E.  F.  Robinson,  Chief  Engineer,  says :  "On  account  of  the  in- 
stallation of  automatic  block  signals,  we  are  removing  1,500  Carnegie 
steel  ties  from  the  main  track,  near  Ridgway,  Pa.  It  is  our  intention  to 
make  no  further  increase  in  the  use  of  this  design  of  tie,  at  least  for 
the  present." 

Chicago   &  Alton  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  page  515;  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page 
893-) 

Mr.    E.    L.    Crugar,    Assistant    Chief    Engineer,    advised    August   28, 


TIES. 


345 


Fig.  r.     Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  R.  R.,  Near  Queen  Junction,  Pa. 


Fig.  2.     Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie  R.  R.,  Near  Jamisonvtlle,  Pa. 


346  TIES. 

1911:    "There  have  been  no  changes  as   regards   ties  in  track   on   this 
company's  lines.     We  have  put  in  no  metal  or  composite  ties." 

(This    line   placed   63    "Kimball"    ties    in    its    southward   track,    near 
Lockport,   Illinois,  October,    1905.) 
Cleveland,   Cincinnati,  Chicago   &  St.  Louis  Railway: 

(See  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  887;  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  383.) 

On  August  28,  191 1,  Mr.  C.  A.   Paquette,  Assistant  Chief  Engineer/ 
advised :   "Answering  your  letter  of  the  26th  instant,  we  have  no  addi- 
tional information  to  give  you  as  to  steel  ties  which  are  in  service  in  our 
main  track. 

"In  November,  1909,  there  were  20  concrete  ties  made  under  the 
Israel  patent  and  put  in  the  main  track  east  of  Paris,  111.,  on  our  St. 
Louis  Division.  On  February  12,  191 1,  we  found  it  necessary  to  remove 
three  of  these  ties  from  the  track,  the  ties  having  failed  completely.  The 
concrete  was  crushed  and  the  top  plate,  which  reaches  half  way  across 
the  tie  and  serves  as  a  support  for  the  rail  fastenings,  was  broken  in  sev- 
eral places.  As  to  the  balance  of  the  ties  85  per  cent:  of  them  have  the 
top  plate  either  cracked  or  broken. 

"This  experience  seems  to  indicate  that  these  ties  are  not  suitable. 
Their  life  may  be  considered  to  be  about  two  or  three  years,  and  the 
cost  is  considerably  greater  than  that  of  wooden  ties." 

Cornwall  &  Lebanon  Railroad: 

On  October  16  Mr.  A.  D.  Smith,  President  and  General  Superin- 
tendent, advised  as  follows   (for  design  see  P.  R.  R.  report)  : 

"With  reference  to  our  experience  with  the  200  Snyder  steel  ties 
which  were  installed  in  our  road  about  five  years  ago,  these  ties  •  are 
located  on  the  southbound  track  of  our  double  track,  lying  about  one 
mile  west  or  south  of  Mount  Gretna  in  a  2-degree  curve  and  on  a  1.5 
per  cent,  descending  grade.  One  coat  of  tar  paint  was  applied  when 
the  ties  were  put  in  and  another  coat  during  the  past  year.  This  is 
about  the  only  expense  we  have  been  put  to  in  the  matter  of  mainte- 
nance. 

"A  few  months  ago  in  passing  over  this  part  of  the  road  it  was 
noticed  that  the  asphalt  concrete  filling  showed  signs  of  disintegration 
at  the  open  ends  of  the  ties  and  upon  investigating  we  found  as  far 
back  as  the  hand  could  be  placed  that  the  filling  was  loose  and  in  par- 
ticles. In  order  to  ascertain  how  far  in  this  extended  the  tie  was  taken 
out  of  the  track  and  in  pulling  the  tie  out  the  filling  was  left  on  the 
ground  under  the  rails,  simply  a  mass  of  particles.  We  imagine  that  as 
a  result  of  this  condition  whenever  the  ties  are  tamped  some  material 
will  be  dropped  from  the  bottom  through  the  slight  raising  due  to  the 
tamping.  The  track  foreman  reported  that  he  had  noticed  the  mate- 
rial loosened  in  this  manner  several  months  ago.  The  track  at  this 
point  is  laid  with  80-lb.  rail  and  on  stone  ballast. 

"Approximately  half  a  million  tons  of  freight  per  year  pass  over  this 
track  in  the  southward  direction,  our  heaviest  locomotives  being  75 
tons  in  weight,  not  including  the  weight  of  the  tender.  During  the  sum- 
mer season  eight  or  ten  passenger  trains  pass  over  this  track  daily  and 
four  passenger  trains  the  remaining  portion  of  the  year,  probably  at  a 
speed  of  40  or  50  miles  per  hour. 

"There  has  been  no  trouble  at  all  in  connection  with  these  ties  as 
stated,  except  the  recent  crumbling  of  the  asphalt  filling.  Just  what  the 
effect  of  this  would  be  eventually  we  are  not  prepared  to  say : 

Duluth  &  Iron  Range  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  890;  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 
page  384.) 


TIES. 


347 


Mr.  W.  A.  Clark,  Chief  Engineer,  advised  August  28,  191 1,  that  he 
has  nothing  additional  to  offer.  "The  ties  covered  by  our  last  report 
are  still  in  the  track  and  giving  satisfactory  service." 

Duluth,  Missabe  &  Northern  Raihvay: 

Mr.  H.  L.  Dresser,  Chief  Engineer,  under  date  of  September  11, 
191 1,  writes  as  follows: 


Fig.  3.     Israel  Sectional  Tie. 


A  FINISHED  TIE 


SHOWING  THE  CAST  IRON  TOP  OF  ONE  SECTION  OF  .TIE  WITH  UNDEB  SIDE  CONSTRUCTION 


Fig.  4.     Israel  Sectional  Tie. 


"Your  letter  of  September  8,'  in  regard  to  a  report  as  to  the  steel 
ties  which  we  have  in  use  on  our  line ;  we  have  about  22,400  ties  of  the 
Carnegie  Steel  Company's  Section  M-21.  They  were  purchased  in  the 
summer  of  1908  and  we  started  to  put  them  in  the  track  in  the  fall  after 


348  TIES. 

the  ore  business  closed,  but  the  work  was  not  completed  until  the  spring 
of  1909.  Two  miles  of  these  were  placed  on  the  hill  between  Duluth  and 
the  yards  at  Proctor,  being  placed  in  the  double  track,  one  mile  in  each 
track.  This  portion  of  the  road  had  been  previously  ballasted  with 
crushed  granite  and  consequently  required  less  work  to  place  them  than 
it  did  the  others,  which  were  placed  where  the  track  crosses  the  big 
muskeg  swamp  about  fifty  miles  north  of  Duluth.  This  is  also  double 
track  and  we  have  two  and  one-half  miles  of  these  ties  in  each  track. 
This  portion  of  the  road  had  been  ballasted  with  gravel  and  had  always 
cost  us  a  great  deal  to  maintain  during  the  summer  season  on  account 
of  the  nature  of  the  soil  underneath  the  roadbed.  It  was  necessary  to 
keep  the  track  lined  with  men  during  the  ore  season  to  keep  the  track  in 
shape  and  to  keep  the  rails  spiked  to  line,  although  we  were  using  tie- 
plates,  but  owing  to  the  shaking  and  trembling  of  the  ground  under- 
neath which  set  up  a  vibration  in  the  train  the  rails  were  continually 
spreading  and  it  was  necessary  to  line  spike  this  track  every  season,  and 
more  or  less  would  have  to  be  lined  up  two  or  three  times  during  the 
summer. 

"We  removed  the  old  ballast  and  replaced  it  with  crushed  granite, 
leaving  the  original  roadbed  underneath  the  granite  sloping  from  the 
center  between  the  two  tracks,  as  shown  in  the  accompanying  blue- 
print. Owing  to  this  work  having  been  done  in  the  winter  when  there 
was  a  great  deal  of  snow  on  the  ground  and  more  or  less  ice,  these 
tracks  required  considerable  attention  during  the  summer  of  1009,  but 
by  the  time  winter  set  in  we  had  these  tracks  in  elegant  shape  and  dur- 
ing the  summer  of  1910  we  did  no  more  work  on  them  whatever.  Of 
course,  the  section  men  passed  over  them  going  to  and  from  their  work, 
but  no  work  was  done  in  either  surfacing  or  lining  during  the  entire 
summer,  which  was  something  very  unusual  for  that  track.  It  kept 
in  very  good  shape  until  late  in  the  fall,  at  which  time  by  careful  in- 
spection you  could  see  that  some  places  were  slightly  depressed,  but  it 
was  scarcely  noticeable  in  the  running  of  trains.  Early  in  the  season 
of  191 1  we  sent  an  extra  gang  over  this  track  and  brought  it  to  sur- 
face again.  Since  that  time  no  work  has  been  required  on  it,  although 
we  have  had  a  large  amount  of  rain  in  that   district  this  summer. 

"We  would  say  that  with  these  ties,  placed  18-in.  centers  as  we  have 
them,  carrying  100-lb.  rail,  it  is  impossible  for  a  small  section  crew  to 
line  and  surface  the  track  to  a  great  extent,  but  needs  a  small  extra 
gang  to  handle  it,  as  it  is  exceedingly  heavy  and  hard  to  move.  How- 
ever, it  requires  so  much  less  attention  than  our  old  track  with  the 
wooden  ties  and  80-lb.  rail  that  we  feel  there  is  economy  in  the  use  of 
these  ties,  notwithstanding  the  difference  in  first  cost  of  the  steel  and 
the  wood,  and  would  like  very  much  to  have  them  to  place  on  the  entire 
length  of  the  main  line,  but  as  our  tracks  run  through  a  forest  most  of 
the  way  where  the  settlers  are  getting  out  track  ties  more  than  any  other 
material  and  ship  them  over  our  road,  our  people  feel  that  we  ought 
to  use  their  product  while  it  lasts,  as  it  will  be  but  a  very  few  years  before 
all  timber  suitable  for  wooden  ties  lying  anywhere  near  our  road  will 
have  been  used  up. 

"The  two  miles  on  the  hill  between  Duluth  and  Proctor  have  re- 
quired scarcely  any  attention  since  they  were  put  in  place,  but  the  soil 
underneath  the  roadbed  at  this  point  is  solid  clay  and  has  never  caused 
the  trouble  the  tracks  across  the  big  swamp  have.  There  are  two  light 
curves  on  the  latter  two  miles  and  we  have  worn  out  the  new  rail  which 
was  placed  with  the  ties  in  some  instances  on  these  curves,  but  the  cost 
of  surfacing  and  relining  the  track  has  been  very  light  as  compared  with 
the  tracks  on  the  wooden  ties. 

"Accompanying  this  is  a  sketch  showing  our  standard  section  of  road- 


TIES.  349 

bed  where  steel  ties  were  used,  and  also  a  blueprint  showing  the  tie 
and  fastenings.  This  print  shows  a  clip  and  stop  on  each  side  of  the 
rail  on  each  tie,  which  was  the  plan  suggested  by  the  Carnegie  Steel 
Company,  and  when  the  time  arrived  they  were  drilled  in  this  manner, 
but  we  never  used  the  stop  on  the  gage  side  of  the  rail,  as  we  looked  upon 
it  as  useless.  We  have,  however,  used  the  clip  and  the  stop  both  on  the 
outer  side  of  the  rail  and  they  have  had  no  trouble  with  broken  clips, 
loose  bolts,  or  anything  of  that  nature,  and  are  very  much  pleased 
with  the  service  they  have  given  up  to  this  date." 

Elgin,  Jolict  &  Eastern  Railway: 

Mr.  A.  Montzheimer,  Chief  Engineer,  advises  as  follows :  "We  have 
put  in  this  year  500  Carnegie  Steel  Company  ties.  These  are  located  on 
the  main  line,  between  Gary  and  South  Chicago.  We  are  now  making 
up  list  of  switch  ties  for  next  year  and  expect  to  be  able  to  make  our 
next  year's  renewals  of  switch  ties,  consisting  of  about  350  sets,  with 
Carnegie  steel  ties.  In  addition  to  above  we  are  planning  to  use  Carnegie 
steel  ties  on  all  renewals  on  main  line  on  curves." 

EHc  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  12.  Part  1,  p.  386.) 

On  October  7,  191 1,  Mr.  W.  J.  Harahan,  Vice-President,  advised  as 
follows :  "No  further  installation  of  metal  ties  has  been  made  since  the 
report  of  November  30,  1910,  was  made,  and  therefore  the  Carnegie  steel 
switch  ties  at  Bergen  are  the  only  ties  of  this  character  in  use.  In  re- 
gard to  these  ties,  .would  advise  as  follows :  The  original  57  ties  are 
still  in  service.  One  of  these  ties  was  broken  off  outside  the  rail  and 
fastenings  by  derailment  of  a  car  August  30,  1911.  The  derailment  was 
caused  by  yardmaster  not  getting  the  switch  over  in  time.  Otherwise, 
these  ties  are  practically  as  good  as  new. 

"In  regard  to  the  fastenings  supplied  with  these  ties,  they  are  too 
small  for  the  service  required  of  them,  and  as  the  effect  of  rust  on  them 
is  very  great,  they  soon  fail  and  have  to  be  renewed.  The  fastenings 
on  these  ties  have  all  been  renewed  once,  and  some  of  them  twice  since 
the  original  installation  was  made,  which  was  in  April,  1909. 

"As  regards  the  desirability  of  these  steel  switch  ties  compared 
with  ordinary  yellow  pine  switch  ties,  would  state  they  compare  favor- 
ably, except  in  the  matter  of  fastenings,  which  feature  could  be  im- 
proved very  much  by  the  use  of  heavier  bolts  and  clips,  and  lohmanized 
material." 

Galveston,  Harrisburg  &  San  Antonio  Railway: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.   u,   Part  2,  page  894.) 
Mr.    D.    K.    Colburn,    Engineer    Maintenance    of    Way,    advises    that 
they  have  installed  200  Percival  Reinforced  Concrete  Ties,  100  at  Bayou 
Sale,    La.,    January    20,    1910,    and    100    at    Edgewater,    Texas,    October 
22,    1906. 

At  Bayou  Sale  the  ties  were  installed  under  76-lb.  rail,  gravel  bal- 
last. Traffic  at  this  point  low  speed  and  rather  heavy.  The  ties  are 
located  at  end  of  double  track  where  fires  are  cleaned  and  the  concrete 
ties  are  thus  far  satisfactory  in  all  respects,  except  that  the  wood  cush- 
ions under  the  rail  have  been  somewhat  damaged  by  fire,  but  their  re- 
newal is  an  easy  matter. 

At  Edgewater  «the  ties  are  under  80-lb.  A.S.C.E.  rail  gravel  ballast. 
Fifty  ties  at  this  point  were  installed  consecutively,  18  ties  to  a  33-ft. 
rail,  and  50  were  placed  alternately  with  cypress  ties.  Traffic  over  these 
ties  is  high  speed  and  rather  heavy,  and  at  the  time  of  making  this  re- 
port (September  7,  1911),  they  were  in  good  condition,  except  for  a 
few  minor  cracks. 


350  TIES. 

(For  design  of  this  tie  see  Figs.  5,  6  and  7.) 

In  regard  to  shape  of  this  tie  the  patentee,  Mr.  Percival,  advises 
that  the  tie  is  made  wider  at  the  top  than  elsewhere  and  of  somewhat 
rounded  bottom  for  the  following  reasons : 

1.  For  easy  tamping. 

2.  Economy  ajid  better  utilization  of  reinforcement. 

3.  For    reduction    of    section    and    consequent    weight. 

Mr.  Colburn  further  advises  that  these  ties  are  made  up  as  follows : 

Composition :  Six  parts  clear  granite  crushed  very  fine.  Two  and 
one-half  parts  crushed  sandstone  (largest  piece  passes  through  a  one- 
inch  ring).     Two  parts  Whitehall  cement. 

Reinforcement :.  Three  yl-in.  corrugated  bars  in  face.  One  34-in. 
corrugated  bar  in  base. 

The  bars  are  bound  together  with  strong  wire,  making  a  truss ; 
total  weight  of  reinforcement  25  lbs.,  total  weight  of  tie  445  lbs.,  cubical 
contents  of  tie  3.385   cu.   ft. 

Lake  Shore   &  Michigan  Southern  Railway: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  page  511;  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 
page   384.) 

On  September  20,  191 1,  Mr.  Samuel  Rockwell,  Chief  Engineer,  ad- 
vised :  "At  one  time  we  had  steel  ties  on  several  divisions  of  the  road 
in  experimental  stretches,  but  a  few  years  ago  they  were  all  taken  out. 
One  of  the  chief  troubles  we  had  with  them  was  the  insulation.  A  num- 
ber of  them  have  now  been  put  in  on  our  Sandusky  pier  branch  where 
the  speed  is  limited,  and  we  have  no  need  of  insulation,  and  where  we 
run  in  streets  part  of  the  way  and  good  permanent  construction  is 
needed.     They  are  well  adapted  for  this  service. 

"These  ties  are  mostly  of  the  Buhrer  nattern.  made  bv  the  Carnegie 
Steel  Company,  with  four  clip  fastenings  for  each  tie.  They  have  been 
in  track  for  about  six  years  and  are  in  first-class  condition  at  this  time. 
The  Roadmaster  is  of  the  opinion  that  they  will  last  from  ten  to  fifteen 
years  longer.  They  hold  the  track  in  line,  surface  and  gage  very  well, 
but  our  people  are  not  yet  convinced  that  they  are  the  tie  for  our  main 
line  with  its  heavy  high  speed  traffic." 

Lake   Terminal  Railway    (National   Tube   Company)  : 

(See  previous  report,  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  p.  890;  Vol.  12,  Part  1.  p.  384.) 
Mr.  F.  W.  Waterman,  Engineer,  advises,  Sept.  5,   191 1:     "We  placed 

18,645  Carnegie  Section  M-21  steel  ties  since  January  1.   191 1,  and  expect 

to  replace  all  our  wooden  ties  as  fast  as  they  are  worn  out,  with  steel 

ties." 

Long  Island  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  12.  Part  1,  page  386.) 

Mr.  E.  M.  Weaver,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  says,  Septenu-cr  6 
191 1 :  "I  have  nothing  whatever  to  offer  in  the  way  of  a  report." 

Michigan  Central  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  386.) 

Mr.  G.  H.  Webb,  Chief  Engineer,  on  August  29,  191 1,  says:  "There  is 
very  little  to  add  to  my  report  of  November  19,  1910,  with  the  excep- 
tion that  the  few  concrete  ties  which  we  have  in  our  track  at  Jackson, 
Mich.,  are  still  in  service,  though  they  are  somewhat  cracked,  but  not 
enough  so  as  to  necessitate  their  being  taken  up.  We  are  not  contem- 
plating any  further  installations  of  metal  or  composite  ties  at  this  time." 
Northern  Pacific  Raihvay: 

(See  previous  report,  Vol.  J2,  Part  1,  page  384.) 

On  August  30,  191 1,  Mr.  W.  C.  Smith,  Chief  Engineer,  Maintenance 


TIES. 


351 


Fig.  5.     Percival  Concrete  Steel  Ties. 


Fig.  6.     Percival  Concrete  Steel  Ties. 


352 


TIES. 


of  Way,  advised:  "We  have  made  no  additional  installation  during  the 
past  year.  In  fact,  we  have  removed  a  few  of  the  metal  ties  and  trans- 
ferred some  to  other  points  so  as  not  to  conflict  with  automatic  block 
signals  which  we  have  been  placing.  We  are  finding  it  very  difficult  to 
properly  insulate  them.  The  few  ties  which  we  have  in  place  have  given 
excellent  satisfaction.  We  are  simply  using  them  at  a  number  of  points 
where  engines  take  coal  and  water,  and  where  cinders  are  likely  to  be 
dropped." 


--;~r— ~tr  I 
'. 1 Ji? 


U>^I-t2t^O"?i 


SIDE    ELEVATION 


Fig.  7.     Percival  Reinforced  Concrete  Tie. 


=53*^ 


nrfa.? 


retaining  SAfl  rtmnmoH     BOLT  CENTERING 


JOINT  CLAMP 


SECTION  AT  JOINT  SECTION 

Fig.  8.    Snyder  Steel  Tie  for  ioo-lb.  Rail. 


Pennsylvania  Railroad: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  10,  P'art  1,  page  509;  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page 
891 ;  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  378.) 

Your  Committee  inspected  the  "Snyder"  ties  installed  at  Derry  on 
September  6,  191 1.  As  will  be  seen  from  previous  reports,  1,600  of  these 
ties  were  put  in  during  the  summer  of  1907  in  Conemaugh  yard  and 
966  in  Derry  yard,  both  on  the  Pittsburg  Division.  In  these  locations 
they  are  used  for  heavy  but  slow  traffic.    This  tie  consists  of  a  steel  shell 


TIES. 


353 


3/16-in.  thick,  the  ties  are  8  ft.  long,  7  ins.  wide,  7  ins.  deep,  and  open 
on  the  bottom.  The  interior  of  the  shell  is  filled  with  a  mixture  of 
asphalt  and  crushed  stone,  the  rails  are  fastened  to  the  tie  by  bolts  and 
clips,  and  these  ties  weigh  700  lbs.  per  tie.  (See  Fig.  8  for  details  of 
tie   and    fastenings.)      Our    inspection    developed   that    the   metal    of   the 


Fig.  9.     Snyder  Tie,  Pennsylvania  Railroad,  Derry,  Pa. 


Fig.  10.     Snyder  Tie,  Pennsylvania  R.  R.,  Showing  Asphalt  Filling 
Having  Deteriorated. 


Fig.  11.     Snyder  Steel  Tie,  Pennsylvania  Railroad,  Derry,  Pa. 


354 


TIES. 


tie  is  in  good  condition,  showing  very  little  if  any  loss  from  corrosion, 
that  the  fastenings  were  holding  well,  but  that  on  about  20  ties  the  mastic 
was  disintegrating  so  that  it  was  falling  out  of  the  ends  of  the  ties. 
(See  photographs  Figs.  9,  10  and  11.) 

Your  Committee  also  examined  an  experimental  tie  owned  by  Mech- 
ling  and  Tiechart,  Munhall,  Pa.,  of  which  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad 
has  installed  100  near  Wilkinsburg,  Pa.,  on  the  Pittsburg  Division.  (See 
Fig.  12  for  the  design  of  this  tie.) 


STEEL     CONNECTION    FOR     RAIL 


SIDE    VIEW 


WOOD    CONNECTION     FOR      RAIL 


Fig.   12.     Mechling  and  Smith   Steel  Tie,   Showing  Both   Wood  and 
Steel   Rail  Connections. 


. 

It 

m 

% 

H- 

f 

zi' 

ejb  6§3 


TEC  HEAD    TIE  BOL  T. 


CLIPS  <S  BOL  T3  FOR  31V  ITCH 
JCZ5   INSTALLED  ON  PFNNA  RR. 

USrO    WITH  CAKNSCie  3T£CL    TIES.  SSLfJ-ei . 


DROP  FORCE    RAIL    CLIP     NO.  19. 


Fig.  13. 


TIES. 


355 


356 


TIES. 


These  ties  are  installed  in  a  yard  track  (not  insulated)  over  which 
there  is  a  heavy  but  slow  movement.  Your  Committee  thinks  this  tie  is 
capable  of  further   development. 

Your  Committee  is  advised  that  this  company  is  about  to  install  six 
sets  of  steel  switch  ties  manufactured  by  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company. 
The  section  of  tie  used  is  the  modified  "I"  beam  known  as  Section  M-21 
and  weighs  19.7  lbs.  per  ft.  The  rail  is  fastened  to  the  tie  with  a  bolt 
and  clip,  details  of  which  are  shown  in  Fig.  13. 

Pennsylvania   Lines,  Northwest  System: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  page  505,  page  513;  Vol. 
11,  Part  2,  page  892;  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  383.) 

Your  Committee  examined  the  following  ties  in  this  company's 
tracks : 

Rohm  Steel  Tie  (see  Fig.  14)  :  Twelve  of  these  ties  were  placed 
in  the  eastbound  main  freight  track  at  Sewickley,  Pa.,  June,  1910.     They 


Fig.  15.    Universal  Steel  Tie. 


are  still  in  the  track  and  are  giving  satisfactory  service.  The  only 
trouble  these  ties  have  caused  has  been  with  the  insulation,  which  Mr.  A. 
A.  Wirth,  Division  Engineer,  pointed  out  could  be  taken  care  of  by  a 
slight  change  in  design.     This  tie  weighs  about  260  lbs. 

Universal  Steel  Tie  (see  Fig.  15)  :  Ninety-eight  of  these  ties  were 
installed  in  eastbound  main  freight  track  near  Emsworth,  Pa.,  in  Decem- 
ber, 1910.  The  Supervisor  in  charge  of  this  track  pointed  out  that  these  ties 
would  be  very  hard  to  line  on  account  of  the  projection  of  a  portion  of 
the  fastening  below  the  bottom  of  the  tie.  He  also  stated  that  it  was 
very  hard  to  hold  this  track  in  surface. 

Reigler  Combined  Steel  and  Concrete  Tie :  Details  of  this  tie  will 
be  found  in  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  893.  Fifteen  of  these  ties  were  put 
in  the  westbound  main  passenger  track  near  Emsworth,  Pa.,  May,  1908. 
They  are  still  in  the  track  and  with  the  exception  of  three  ties  are  in 
good  condition.     The  three  ties  referred  to  show  signs  of  failure  under 


TIES.  357 

the  rail,  but  the  inventor  thinks  that  repairs  can  be  readily  made  so  that 
the  ties  will  be  restored  to  their  original  condition.  One  other  feature 
noticed  by  the  Committee  was  that  several  of  the  nuts  were  loose  and  that 
same  could  not  be  tightened  unless  ties  are  taken  out  of  the  track.  This 
could  be  taken  care  of  if  the  shape  of  bolt  were  such  that  it  would  not 
turn  in  the  hole  through  the  concrete. 

Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  10,  Part  i,  page  503;  Vol.  11,  Part 
2,  page  883;  Vol.   12,  Part  1,  page  375.) 

Your  Committee  inspected  the  experimental  ties  on  this  road  in 
September,  1911,  and  as  a  result  of  this  inspection  would  advise  as  fol- 
lows : 

Carnegie  Steel  Ties  with  Wedge  Fastening:  The  six  ties  placed  in 
the  northbound  main  track  at  Pittsburg  Terminal  Station,  May,  1908,  are 
still  in  the  track.  The  fastenings  on  these  ties  were  for  90-lb.  A.S.C.E. 
rail  and  during  the  past  year  100-lb.  A.R.A.  section  B  rail  has  been  laid 
at  this  point,  without  any  change  in  fastening.  The  Supervisor  in- 
formed the  Committee  that  they  have  trouble  in  keeping  the  wedges 
tight  with  the  new  section  of  rail,  and  previous  report  (Vol.  12,  Part 
1,  page  375)  states  that  this  same  trouble  was  experienced  with  the  90- 
lb.   rail. 

With  Bolt  and  Clip  Fastening :  As  previously  reported,  3,000  ties 
of  this  design  were  laid  in  August,  1907,  at  McKees  Rocks.  Last  year's 
report  indicated  that  the  fiber  installation  on  these  ties  was  approaching 
the  end  of  its  life,  yet  the  Supervisor  in  charge  of  this  section  informed 
your  Committee  that  thej  had  experienced  no  trouble  from  this  cause 
as  yet.  Your  Committee  could  see,  of  course,  that  the  fiber  is  deteriorat- 
ing, but  they  think  that  in  view  of  the  fact  that  the  fiber  is  placed  di- 
rectly under  the  rail  and  not  protected  as  the  later  design  of  this  tie  is 
now  furnished  (Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  734)  excellent  results  have  been 
obtained  from  this   fiber. 

Universal  Metal  Tie:  One  hundred  of  these  ties  (see  Fig.  11  for 
plan  of  this  tie*)  were  installed  in  northbound  main  track  Pittsburg 
Terminal,  February,  191 1.  No  joint  ties  were  placed,  as  can  be  seen  in 
photograph  of  these  ties  (see  Fig.  16).  The  ties  have  not  been  in  long 
enough   for  your   Committee   to   draw   any   conclusions   therefrom. 

Atwood  Concrete  Steel  Tie :  Five  ties  of  this  design  were  placed 
in  No.  4  main  track,  McKees  Rocks,  Pa.,  in  October,  1908.  Your  Com- 
mittee found  these  ties  in  good  condition ;  track  was  in  good  line  and 
surface  and  the  Supervisor  advised  that  they  bad  had  no  trouble  with 
the  insulation.     (See  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  379,  for  design  of  this  tie.) 

Bruckner  Reinforced  Concrete  Tie :  Your  Committee  were  shown 
20  of  these  ties  which  had  not  been  installed  at  the  time  of  our  inspec- 
tion. Photographs  of  these  ties  were  furnished,  however,  by  Mr.  Edwin 
F.  Wendt,  Assistant  Engineer,  and  they  are  shown  in  Figs.  17,  18  and  19. 

One  tie  weighed  showed  a  total  weight  of  345  lbs.,  while  the  steel 
plates,  fastenings,  etc.,  weighed  25   lbs. 

International  Steel  Tie :  The  International  Steel  Tie  Company,  Cleve- 
land, Ohio,  advise  that  they  have  installed  24  of  these  ties  on  this  road 
near  Glassport,  Pa.  Design  and  photographs  of  these  ties  are  shown  in 
Figs.   20-23. 

In  addition  to  the  above,  M'r.  Edwin  F.  Wendt,  Assistant  Engineer, 
has  kindly  furnished  the  Committee  with  the  following  information  in 
regard  to  cost  of  maintaining  Carnegie   steel   ties  mentioned   above   and 


♦See  Pennsylvania  Lines.  N.  W.(  for  plan. 


►J 


^ 


u 


u 


Sz; 

E 


CO 


fe 


4 


Pi 


W 
w 
< 


h 


\ 


(j 


K 


pq 


flH 


360  TIES. 

which  were  installed  August,  1907  (bolt  and  clip  fastenings),  as  compared 
with  a  like  stretch  of  wood  ties : 

Length  of  Carnegie  White 

Calendar        Experimental  Steel  Ties,  Oak  Ties, 

Year.  Track  Section         Cost  of  Labor.     Cost  of  Labor. 

1908 4,400   ft.  $280.00  $417.00 

1909 "       "  153-00  95-00 

1910 "       "  428.00  128.00 

191 1 "       "  184.00  116.00 

These  experimental  sections  of  track  were  built  with  new  material 
and  new  limestone  ballast  in  1907.  The  maintenance  record  begins  with 
the  calendar  year  1908. 

These  ties  were  laid  in  the  main  line  freight  tracks,  equipped  with 
electric  circuits  in  connection  with  automatic  semaphore  signals.  Tracks 
are  used  by  freight  trains  only,  which  run  at  a  speed  of  about  thirty  (30) 
miles  per  hour. 

During  191 1  it  was  necessary  to  resurface  the  steel  tie  track  three 
times  and  the  white  oak  track  once. 

During  the  year  191 1,  fiber  plates  were  removed  from  track  on  account 


Fig.  16.    Universal  Metal  Cross-Tie,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad. 


TIES. 


361 


Fig.  22.    International  Steel  Tie,  P.  &  L.  E.  R.  R ,  Glassport,  Pa. 


Fig.  25.     International  Steel  Tie,  P.  &  L.  E.  R.  R.,  Glassport,  Pa. 


O-Z  -*H  "J*!l*<>r>Z  ■  7- 


,&-.B-*-'?','Z'E\ 


a 


.«•-?-, «?  fif/'fiiZ 


^ff- 


% 


■*Hi 


W- 


,t-,;-;»)',;y7-/; 


^5^ 


2L 


*;r 


362 


364 


TIES. 


of  being  cut  by  rail  base.     Twenty  bolts  in  steel  tie  clips  were  found  to 
be  loose. 

It  is  now  January  i,  1912,  52  months  since  these  steel  cross-ties  were 
laid  in  the  track  and  the  record  of  the  insulations  shows  that  no  fibers 
were  renewed  previous  to  191 1,  and  in  that  year  only  17  were  found  de- 
fective.    There  has  been,  practically  speaking,  no  signal  trouble  whatever. 

Pittsburg   Shazvmut    &   Northern   Railroad: 

(Previous  advices  state  this  company  installed  about  795  of  Car- 
negie ties  during   1907.     See  Vol.    10,    Part  2,   page  885 ;   Vol.    12,    Part 

1,  page  383.) 

On  August  28,  191 1,  Mr.  H.  S.  Wilgus,  Engineer  Maintenance  of 
Way,  says :  "I  have  nothing  further  to  report  except  that  the  ties  con- 
tine  to  give  full  satisfaction.  No  new  ties  have  been  installed  and 
further  installation  of  the  metal  tie  is  not  contemplated  at  this  time." 

Union  Railroad: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.   10,  Part  1,  page  504;  Vol.   11,   Part 

2,  page  378,  and  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  378.) 

Mr.  W.  S.  Gibson,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  advises  that 
they  have  purchased  up  to  September  1,  191 1,  310,116  Carnegie  steel 
cross-ties  and  392  sets  of  Carnegie  steel  switch  ties,  and  that  during 
the  remainder  of  the  year  191 1  they  will  purchase  30,000  additional  steel 
cross-ties   and   50  sets   of   steel   switch  ties. 

Your  Committee  made  a  careful  inspection  over  a  large  part  of 
the  main  line  of  this  road  and  they  were  very  favorably  impressed  with 
the  service  these  ties  are  giving. 


Fig.  19.     Bruckner  Reinforced  Concrete  Cross-Tie,  Pittsburg  &  Lake 

Erie    Railroad. 


TIES.  366 

On  this  road  the  Committee  inspected  5,000  Carnegie  ties  with  the 
wedge  fastening  (for  design  see  Vol.  10,  Part  1,  page  504).  Mr.  Gibson 
advised  that  they  had  no  trouble  with  the  wedges  and  he  further  said 
he  was  very  much  in  favor  of  this  fastening  as  compared  with  the  other 
fastenings    they    have    tried. 

The  Committee  tested  a  number  of  the  wedges  and  found  prac- 
tically all  of  them  tight. 

Hocking  Valley  Railroad: 

The  International  Steel  Tie  Company,  of  Cleveland,  Ohio,  advise  thev 
have  furnished  32  of  their  ties  which  were  installed  at  Columbus,  Ohio. 
(See  Figs.  24  and  25.) 


Fig.  24.     International  Steel  Tie,  Hocking  Valley  R.  R. 

Altoona  &  Logan  Valley  Railway  (Altoona,  Pa.): 

The   International   Steel  Tie   Company,  Cleveland,   Ohio,  advise  that- 
this  company  have  used  550  of  their  ties.     (See  Figs.  26  and  27  for  photo- 
graphs of  this  track.) 

Boston   Elevated   Railway: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  898,  and  Vol.  12, 
Part  i,  page  387.) 

Mr.  A.  L.  Plimpton  states  that  since  making  previous  report  they 
have  installed  the  following: 

1910,  71  Carnegie  Ties,  Sec.  M-25,  14^  lbs.  per  ft.,  7  ft.  long;  1911, 
1,711  Carnegie  ties,  Sec.  M-25,  *4^  lbs.  per  ft.,  7  ft.  long;  191 1,  12 
Lorain   Steel   Company   ties;    191 1,   614    McDonald   concrete   ties. 

No  details  are  given  as  to  the  design  of  the  concrete  ties. 

Brooklyn   Rapid    Transit    Company    (Brooklyn    Heights    Railroad    Com- 
pany) : 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.   12,   Part   1,  page  388.) 
Mr.  C.  L.  Crabbs,  Engineer  Way  and  Structures,  advises,  September 
22,    191 1,   as   follows:     "We   have  made  no   use  of  metal   or   composite 
ties  on  this   System  since  the   date   of  information  previously   furnished 
you,  about  one  year  ago." 


-"366  TIES. 

c  .; 

*r  Chicago  City  Railway: 

9>  Hi         (See  previous   reports,  Vol.    n,    Part  2,  page  898;   Vol.    12,    Part    1, 

^T.page  388.) 

—        Mr.  H.  B.  Fleming,  Chief  Engineer,  says:     "We  have  just  placed  an 

fc  Ujorder  with  the  Carnegie   Steel   Company   for  enough   steel  ties  and  fas- 

^"tenings  to  lav  one  mile  of  track." 


Fig.  25.     International  Steel  Tie,  Hocking  Valley     R.  R. 


Fig.  26.     International  Steel  Tie,  Altoona  &  Logan  Valley  Ry 


TIES. 


367 


Fig.  27.     International  Steel  Tie,  Altoona  &  Logan  Valley  Ry. 


Fig.  29.     International  Steel  Tie,  Cleveland  Railways  Company. 


368 


TIES. 


Cleveland  Railways  Company: 

The  International  Steel  Tie  Company,  Cleveland,  Ohio,  advise  that 
this  company  have  used  3,300  of  their  ties.  Photographs  of  this  track  are 
shown  in  Figs.  28  and  29. 

Lake  Shore  Electric  Railway  Company  (Sandusky,  Ohio): 

Mr.  A.  V.  Brown,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  says : 
"The   only  ties   we   have   installed   other  than   hardwood   and   cedar 
ties  are  steel  ties  manufactured  by  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company,  known 
as  their  section  M-25.     We  have  installed  about   iJ4  miles  of  this  style 


Fig.  28.     International  Steel  Tie,  Cleveland  Railways  Company. 


of  tie,  using  wide  base  uppermost  and  bolting  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E  rail  rigidly 
to  these  ties  by  means  of  their  No.  25  fastening.  This  fastening  was 
manufactured  by  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company  at  our  suggestion.  Some 
of  this  track  has  been  in  use  11  months  and  up  to  present  time  has  given 
excellent  satisfaction,  with  no  signs  of  deterioration. 

"Six  inches  of  concrete  is  used  as  sub-base  and  concrete  is  also  placed 
to  the  top  of  the  ties,  same  being  tamped  to  place  with  tamping  bars." 

Denver  City  Tramway  Company: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  898;  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 
page  388.) 

Mr.  A.  M.  Evans  advises :  "We  can  add  no  further  information, 
nor  have  we  made  any  additional  installation  of  steel  ties,  nor  contem- 
plate any  in   the  near  future." 


TIES. 


369 


New  York  State  Railways  (Rochester,  N.  Y.): 

Mr.  B.  E.  Tilton,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  advises : 
"We  have  put  in  to  date  2,035  section  M-25  and  10,310  section  M-24 
Carnegie  steel  ties.  These  ties  are  all  laid  in  concrete,  6  in.  of  concrete 
underneath  the  ties.  No  attempt  has  been  made  to  lay  the  steel  ties  on 
stone  ballast  in  our  city  lines  on  account  of  the  fact  that  the  pavement 
cannot  be  left  open  long  enough  to  give  the  ties  the  necessary  tampine 
No  steel  ties  have  been  laid  on  interurban  lines  " 

Scioto  Valley  Traction  Company  (Circleville,  Ohio): 

The  International  Steel  Tie  Company  (Cleveland,  Ohio),  advise  that 
this  line  has  used  2,200  of  their  ties. 

Twin  City  Lines: 

(See  previous  report,  Vol.  n,  Part  2,  page  897;  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page 
386.) 


"This 


Mr.    Geo.    L.    Wilson,    Engineer    Maintenance    of   Way,    says : 
company  has   nothing  further   to    report." 

Utica   &  Mohawk   Valley  Railway: 

(See  previous  reports,  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  897;  Vol.  12,  Part  1, 
page  387.) 

Mr.  M.  J.  French,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  advises :  "We 
have  used  713  Carnegie  M-25,  7~ft.  steel  ties  this  year  on  North  Genesee 
street,  Utica.  We  have  865  of  these  steel  ties  on  hand  for  use  next 
year  on  West  Dominick  street,  Rome,  N.  Y.  The  Oneida  Railway  Corn- 
et. 


Fig.   30.     Carnegie   Steel   Tie   M-25,   Showing   Braces   and   Bolts   for 

Girder  Rails. 


pany,  which  is  an  affiliated  company,  under  the  New  York  State  Rail- 
ways control,  has  an  order  placed  for  700  of  these  ties,  for  use  on  Madi- 
son and  Sconondoa  streets,  in  the  city  of  Oneida,  N,  Y.  These  ties  are 
for  use  with  T-rail  in  concrete  construction,  the  tracks  to  be  paved  with 
brick." 

Virginia  Railway  &  Power  Company: 

(For  previous  reports  see  Vol.  11,  Part  2,  page  898;  Vol.  12,  Part 
1,  page  387.) 

Mr.  T.  Norman  Jones,  Chief  Engineer,  advises  October  3,  191 1, 
that  they  are  laying  two  miles  of  track  with  115-lb.  9-in.  girder  rail  on 
Carnegie  M-25  tie  with  Lorain  brace  fastening.  (See  Fig.  30.)  We 
are  using  the  tie  inverted,  in  other  words,  with  the  broad  base  next  to 
the  rail. 


370  TIES. 


CONCLUSIONS. 

Your    Committee    respectfully    submits    the    following    conclusions : 

1.  The  concrete  tie,  a  combination  of  concrete  and  metal  tie,  or  a 
combination  of  asphalt  and  metal  tie  has  not  yet  proved  a  success  for 
the   following   reasons : 

(a)  Fracture    caused   by  vibration ; 

(b)  Excessive    weight   and   consequent    difficulty   in    handling; 

(c)  Deterioration    of   asphalt    filling. 

2.  A  combination  tie  of  steel  and  wood  gives  promise  of  develop- 
ing an  economic  substitute. 

3.  The  all  steel  tie  has  proved  a  satisfactory  substitute  for  the 
wood  tie  under  heavy  medium  speed  traffic.  It  ia  durable,  line  and  sur- 
face can  be  maintained,  has  sufficient  resiliency  and  can  be  insulated. 
The  fastenings  so  far  in  use  can  and  no  doubt  will  be  improved. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  TIES. 


REPORT  OP  COMMITTEE  V— ON  TRACK. 

J.  B.  Jenkins,  Chairman;  G.  J.  Ray,  Vice -Chairman; 

Geo.  H.  Bremner.  H.  T.  Porter. 

A.  Bruner.  W.  G.  Raymond. 

Garrett  Davis.  S.  S.  Roberts. 

Raffe  Emerson.  L.  S.  Rose. 

E.  G  Ericson.  R.  O.  Rote. 

J.  M.  R.  Fairbairn.  H.  R.  Safford. 

T.  H.  Hickey.  F.  A.  Smith. 

J.  R.  Leighty.  C.  H.  Stein. 

Thomas  Maney.  F.  S.  Stevens. 

CURTISS    MlLI.ARD.  W.  J.  TOWNE. 

P.  C.  Newbegin.  R.  A.  Van  Houten. 

R.  M.  Pearce.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Two  meetings  of  the  Committee  on  Track  have  been  held  since  the 
convention  of  191 1 — on  June  15  and  October  13. 

The  subjects  assigned  were: 

(1)  Present  general  specifications  covering  material  and  workman- 
ship for  frogs,  crossings  and  switches,  including  the  use  of  manganese 
and  other  special  alloys. 

(2  1  Present  general  specifications  for  track  bolts,  nut  locks,  tie-plates, 
common  track  spikes  and  screw  spikes. 

(3)      Study  designs   for  main   line   turnouts. 

FROGS,  CROSSINGS  AND   SWITCHES. 

Your  Committee  has  revised  the  plans  for  Nos.  8,  11  and  16  Rigid 
Frogs,  No.  11  Spring  Frog  and  for  n-ft,  16^-ft.,  22-ft.,  and  33-ft. 
switches  and  submits  them  for  adoption  as  general  plans  representing 
good  practice. 

Your  Committee  has  also  revised  and  combined  the  "General  Speci- 
fications for  Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches"  adopted  by  the  convention  of 
1910,  and  the  "General  Instructions  for  Ordering  or  Contracting  for  Frogs, 
Crossings  and  Switches,"  submitted  to  the  convention  of  191 1  and  received 
as  information,  and  submits  them  for  adoption  as  representing  good 
practice. 

At  the  convention  of  1909,  the  Association  instructed  the  Track  Com- 
mittee to  recommend  three  standard  lengths  of  switches  and  three  standard 
numbers  of  frogs ;  such   a  recommendation  was  made,  with  the  modifi- 

371 


372  TRACK. 

cation  that  a  fourth  length  of  switch  was  added  for  special  cases  requiring 
frogs  of  large  angle ;  the  recommendation  was  embodied  in  Conclusion 
(4)  of  your  Committee's  report,  which  was  adopted  by  the  convention  of 
1910,  but  was  referred  back  to  the  Committee  by  the  Board  of  Direction 
for  reconsideration. 

Your  Committee  reconsidered  and  reaffirmed  its  former  action;  the 
conclusion  was  not  resubmitted,  however,  excepting  as  the  proposed 
lengths  of  switches  and  numbers  of  frogs  were  embodied  in  the  "General 
Instructions  for  Ordering  or  Contracting  for  Frogs,  Crossings  and 
Switches"  which  was  received  only  as  information  by  the  Association  at 
the  convention  of  1911. 

In  determining  the  lengths  of  switches  your  Committee  considered  it 
necessary  to  provide  for  the  following  general  classes  of  turnouts : 

(a)  Turnouts  to  be  operated  over  the  divergent  route  at  the  maxi- 
mum practicable  limited  speed. 

(b)  Main  line  turnouts  and  crossovers  to  be  operated  over  the  di- 
vergent route  at  low  speed. 

(c)  Yard  turnouts. 

(d)  Turnouts  requiring  frogs  of  large  angle. 

The  second  point  considered  was  the  economical  cutting  of  a  33-ft. 
rail;  the  question  of  using  the  full  33  ft.  as  one  of  the  lengths  of  switch 
was  very  fully  discussed  by  your  Committee  at  meetings  held  in  three 
successive  years.  The  main  objections  to  the  use  of  a  33-ft.  switch  are  (1 ) 
the  length  being  the  same  as  that  of  stock  rail  unless  a  special  length  of 
stock  rail  is  used,  one  joint  of  the  latter  must  necessarily  come  near  the 
point  of  the  switch  and  the  other  joint  ahead  of  and  near  the  heel  of  the 
switch,  often  necessitating  the  clipping  of  the  angle  bars,  and  (2)  the 
great  length  of  laterally  unsupported  rail. 

Your  Committee  is  of  the  opinion  that  (1)  the  location  of  the  joints 
of  the  stock  rail  40  inches  ahead  of  the  point  and  heel  of  switch  is  not 
seriously  objectionable  and  the  clipping  of  the  angle  bars  is  not  an  ex- 
pensive operation  and  does  not  seriously  weaken  the  joint,  and  that  (2) 
switches  33  ft.  and  even  45  ft.  long  have  been  successfully  used  to  such 
an  extent  that  there  seems  to  be  little  ground  for  apprehension  on  account 
of  the  length  of  laterally  unsupported  rail. 

Twenty-seven  (27)  ft.  and  30-ft.  lengths  have  been  suggested  in  lieu 
of  a  33-ft.  length;  the  angles  would  be  respectively  22  per  cent,  and  10 
per  cent,  greater  than  that  for  33  ft. 

The  longest  switch  points  are  to  be  used  in  those  turnouts  where  the 
highest  speed  is  desired.  These  switch  points  will  necessarily  get  severe 
usage,  therefore  they  should  be  made  from  the  very  best  rail.  If  made 
from  the  second  or  third  rail  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  you  have  elim- 
inated as  far  as  possible  any  chance  of  defect  in  the  rail.  These  rails  are 
as  a  rule  33  ft.  in  length.  The  lengths  of  switches  recommended  can  be 
made  from  33  ft.  rails  without  any  waste. 

These  and  other  considerations  led  your  Committee  to  recommend  the 


TRACK.  373 

following  length  of  switch  points  for  the  four  general  classes  of  turnouts 
named  above : 

(a)  33  ft.;  (b)  22  ft.;  (c)  i6y2-it.;  (d)  11  ft. 

A  purely  theoretical  investigation  of  the  rate  of  turning  of  a  locomo- 
tive at  the  switch  point  and  of  the  angle  between  the  stock  rail  and  a  line 
passing  through  truck  centers  of  a  car  leaving  the  switch,  indicates  that  an 
approximate  balance  between  the  deflection  through  the  switch  point  and 
the  deflection  through  the  lead  is  attained  when  the  switch  angle  equals 
one-fourth  the  frog  angle.  This  proportion  has  been  found  to  work  out 
well  in  practice.  It  seems  to  be  certain  that  when  the  switch  angle  exceeds 
one-fourth  the  frog  angle,  the  switch  point  presents  the  worst  feature  in 
the  alinement  of  the  turnout  and  there  is  an  economic  loss  both  in  the 
space  occupied  by  the  turnout  and  in  the  cost  of  the  turnout. 

With  a  6j4-in.  heel  distance  and  J^-in.  thickness  of  point,  the  above 
relation  between  switch  angle  and  frog  angle  would  make  the  length  of 
the  switch  in  feet  equal  to  twice  the  frog  number. 

In  1908  the  frogs  most  used  appear,  from  a  table  compiled  by  the  En- 
gineering News,  to  have  been  numbers  10,  7,  8,  9,  6,  15,  12,  20,  11,  14  and 
16  in  the  order  named;  number  10  frogs  being  used  by  55%  of  the  roads 
tabulated  and  number  16  by  only  5%.  But  the  roads  using  No.  n's  in- 
cluded the  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy,  Great  Northern,  Michigan  Cen- 
tral and  Northern  Pacific  and  those  using  No.  16's  the  Baltimore  & 
Ohio,  Erie  and  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern.  ■ 

No.  7  frogs  are  rapidly  disappearing,  being  supplanted  by  No.  8's ;  the 
relative  number  of  No.  io's  is  also  diminishing,  with  a  corresponding  in- 
crease in  the  proportion  of  frogs  of  higher  numbers. 

It  seems  desirable  for  Class  (A)  turnouts  to  use  the  highest  number 
of  frog  which  is  economically  consistent  with  the  longest  switch  point; 
for  Class  (B)  the  great  preponderance  of  present  practice  is  in  favor  of 
No.  10  frogs,  but  the  choice  of  this  frog  would  leave  an  unfilled  gap  between 
this  and  the  highest  number  frog ;  besides,  a  No.  10  turnout  with  a  16^2  ft. 
switch  is  little  better  in  its  worst  feature  than  a  No.  8  turnout  with  the 
same  switch,  while  a  22-ft.  switch  would  unduly  increase  the  degree  of  lead 
curve;  for  Class  (C)  the  trend  of  present  practice,  if  not  the  preponder- 
ance of  practice  at  this  date,  is  in  favor  of  No.  8  frogs ;  for  Class  (D)  no 
number  of  frog  can  be  specified,  as  this  class  includes  a  multitude  of 
special  cases. 

Your  Committee  presents  its  former  recommendation  in  a  modified 
form: 

i6T/2-it.  switch  points  are  recommended  for  frogs  over  No.  6  up  to  and 
including  No.  10;  22-ft.  points  for  frogs  over  No.  10  up  to  and  including 
No.  14;  33-ft.  points  for  frogs  over  No.  14  and  11-ft.  points  for  No.  6 
and  under  where  they  are  required. 

Nos.  8,  11  and  16  frogs  are  recommended  as  meeting  all  general  re- 
quirements for  yards,  main  track  switches  and  junctions;  new  work  should 
be  laid  out.  so  far  as  practicable,  for  these  three  frogs,  so  as  to  effect  the 


374  TRACK. 

gradual  elimination  of  frogs  of  other  numbers,  lessen  the  cost  of  manufac- 
ture and  decrease  the  amount  of  stock  carried. 

TIE-PLATES  AND  TRACK  FASTENINGS. 

No  attempt  was  made  to  prepare  specifications,  but  your  Committee 
attempted  to  formulate  principles  as  to  the  functions,  material  and  form 
of  tie-plates  and  track  fastenings.  The  work  has  not  progressed  far 
enough  at  this  time  to  be  embodied  in  a  report. 

DESIGNS    OF  MAIN    LINE   TURNOUTS. 

The  work  of  your  Committee  on  this  subject  is  necessarily  held  in 
abeyance  pending  the  adoption  of  standard  numbers  of  frogs  and  lengths 
of  switches. 

VERTICAL  CURVES. 

In  order  to  get  the  benefit  of  experience  in  the  use  of  vertical  curves,  a 
series  of  questions  was  asked  members  of  the  Association  and  the  replies 
tabulated. 

Under  apparently  like  conditions,  widely  different  results  were 
obtained;  this  leads  to  the  conclusion  that  the  conditions  were  only 
apparently  alike  and  that  there  must  be  other  unknown  conditions.  The 
data  in  its  present  form  seems  to  give  very  little  information  of  value. 
Your  Committee  will  continue  its  investigations. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

Your  Committee  recommends : 

(r)  That  the  "General  Specifications  for  Frogs,  Crossings  and 
Switches"  be  adopted  as  representing  good  practice. 

(2)  That  the  plans  of  No.  8,  11  and  16  rigid  frogs,  No.  11  spring 
frog  and  11  ft.,  16^  ft.,  22  ft.  and  33  ft.  switches  be  adopted  as  general 
plans  representing  good  practice. 

*(3)  That  the  Committee's  recommendation  as  to  lengths  of  switches 
and  numbers  of  frogs  be  adopted. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  TRACK. 
*For  amendments,   see  Index. 


TRACK  375 


GENERAL    SPECIFICATIONS    FOR    FROGS,    CROSS- 
INGS AND  SWITCHES. 

GENERAL  INSTRUCTIONS. 

The  Company  will  furnish  to  the  manufacturer  specifications  and 
drawings.  The  drawings  will  show  rail  sections,  splice  drilling,  angles, 
alinement,  general  dimensions  and  such  details  as  the  Company  may  desire. 

When  requested,  manufacturers  shall  submit  for  approval  detail  draw- 
ings showing  construction  and  dimensions  of  all  parts  to  be  furnished  in 
accordance  with  these  specifications.  Conventional  shading  shall  be  used 
in  sectional  drawings.  All  dimensions  and  distances  shall  be  shown  plainly 
in  figures.    The  title  shall  be  placed  in  the  lower  right-hand  corner. 

The  detail  drawings  shall  be  on  sheets  twenty-two  (22)  in.  wide,  with 
a  border  line  one-half  (J*4)  in.  from  the  top,  bottom  and  right  hand  edge, 
and  one  and  one-half  (1^2)  in.  from  the  left  hand  edge.  The  standard 
length  of  sheets  shall  be  thirty  (30)  in.  except  that  when  necessary,  longer 
sheets  may  be  used  and  folded  back  to  the  standard  length.  Drawings  of 
one  subject  only  shall  appear  on  a  sheet.  Scale  of  general  drawings  shall 
be  i\/2  in.  =  1  ft.;  details  not  less  than  3  in.  =  1   ft. 

The  drawings  of  the  Company  and  the  manufacturers'  drawings 
approved  by  the  Company  shall  be  a  part  of  the  specifications.  Anything 
which  is  not  shown  on  the  drawings  but  which  is  mentioned  in  the  speci- 
fications, or  vice  versa,  or  anything  not  expressly  set  forth  in  either  but 
which  is  reasonably  implied,  shall  be  furnished  the  same  as  if  specifically 
shown  and  mentioned  in  both.  Should  anything  be  omitted  from  the 
drawings  or  specifications  that  is  necessary  for  a  clear  understanding  of 
the  work  or  should  any  error  appear  in  either  the  drawings  or  specifications 
affecting  the  work,  it  shall  be  the  duty  of  the  manufacturer  to  notify  the 
Company  and  he  shall  not  proceed  with  the  work  until  instructed  to  do  so 
by  the  Company. 

INSPECTION. 

Material  and  workmanship  shall  be  at  all  times  subject  to  inspection 
by  a  duly  authorized  representative  of  the  Company,  who  will  examine 
the  material  before  it  is  worked  in  the  shop.  He  will  inspect  the  work 
during  progress  and  will  also  inspect  the  finished  product,  with  power 
to  reject  materials  and  workmanship  found  to  be  unsatisfactory.  He  shall 
have  free  access  to  the  shops  and  mills  at  any  and  all  times  during  the 
progress  of  the  work. 

The  acceptance  of  any  material  by  an  inspector  shall  not  prevent  sub- 
sequent rejection  if  found  defective  after  delivery  or  during  the  progress 
of  the  work  and  such  defective  material  if  furnished  by  the  manufacturer 
fhall  be  replaced  by  him  at  his  own  expense. 


376  TRACK. 

All  facilities,  labor  and  tools  necessary  for  the  shop  inspection  shall  b« 
furnished  at  the  expense  of  the  manufacturer. 

When  the  manufacturer  furnishes  the  rails,  he  shall  supply  the  Com- 
pany with  a  certificate  of  inspection  made  by  some  competent  person 
acceptable  to  Ihe  Company. 

MATERIAL. 
Rail. 

No.  i  rail,  of  the  section  ordered,  as  called  for  by  the  specifications, 
shall  be  used. 

Fillers. 

Fillers  between  the  main  and  wing  rails  and  between  the  main  and 
easer  rails  shall  be  rolled  steel.     Throat  filler  blocks,  not  presenting  a 
running  surface,  may  be  cast-iron. 
Raiser  Blocks. 

Raiser  blocks  shall  be  hard  cast  steel. 

Foot  Guards. 

Metallic  foot  guards  shall  be  either  cast-iron,  malleable  iron  or  cast 
steel,  except  that  strap  foot  guards  shall  be  rolled  steel.  Wooden  foot 
guards  shall  be  of  best  quality  hard  wood. 

Bolts. 

Bolts  shall  be  of  double  refined  iron  or  mild  steel.  Bolt  metal  shall 
have  a  tensile  strength  of  not  less  than  50,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  and  an 
elongation  of  not  less  than  15  per  cent,  in  eight  inches.  When  nicked  and 
then  broken,  the  fracture  shall  be  free  from  flaws  and  unwelded  seams. 

Rivets. 

Rivets  shall  be  made  of  steel  which  may  contain  a  maximum  of  0.04 
per  cent,  basic  phosphorus,  0.04  per  cent,  acid  phosphorus  and  0.04  per 
cent,  sulphur.  It  shall  have  an  ultimate  tensile  strength  of  50,000  lbs.  per 
sq.  in.  It  shall  bend  flat  upon  itself  without  fracture  and  when  nicked 
and  bent  around  a  bar  of  the  same  diameter  as  the  rivet  rod  it  shall  give  a 
gradual  break  with  a  fine  silky  uniform  fracture. 

Reinforcing  Bars. 

Reinforcing  bars  shall  be  of  wrought-iron  or  mild  steel. 

Plates. 

Plates  shall  be  of  rolled  steel. 

Springs. 

Springs  shall  be  of  the  best  quality  spring  steel  and  of  dimensions  and 
capacity  shown  on  the  plans.     They  shall  meet  the  following  tests : 

(a)  Each  spring  shall  be  placed  on  the  testing  machine  and  forced 
down  solid  four  times. 

(b)  After  the  foregoing,  each  spring  shall  be  placed  on  end  on  a 
flat  plate,  and  the  distance  between  the  plate  and  the  other  end  of  the 
spring  measured  by  means  of  the  standard  depth  gage ;  this  measurement 


TRACK.  377 

being  the  free  length  of  the  spring.     The  free  length  must  conform  to 
the  plans  within  J^-in. 

(c)  Double  springs  shall  be  assembled  and  a  load  at  least  25  per  cent. 
greater  than  the  rated  capacity  of  the  spring  shall  be  applied  for  thirty 
seconds.  Upon  release  neither  spring  must  vary  from  its  original  free 
length.    If  either  one  does  so  vary,  it  shall  be  rejected. 

(d)  The  inner  and  outer  coils  of  springs  shall  be  coiled  in  opposite 
directions. 

Spring  Covers. 

Spring  covers  shall  be  made  of  malleable  iron. 

Braces. 

malleable  iron. 
Braces  shall  be  made  of    forged  sted 

Stops  and  Hold-downs. 

Stops  and  hold-downs  shall  be  made  of  mild  steel. 

Anti-creeping  Device. 

Anti-creeping  device  shall  be  made  of  mild  steel. 

Switch  Lugs. 

Switch  lugs  shall  be  mild  steel. 

Switch  Rods. 

Switch  rods  shall  be  mild  steel. 

WORKMANSHIP. 

Workmanship  shall  be  first-class.  All  bends  shall  be  made  accurately 
in  arcs  of  circles  and  without  injury  to  the  material.  Welding  will  not  be 
permitted  in  any  part  of  the  frogs  or  in  the  switch  rails.  Planing  shall  be 
such  that  abutting  surfaces  will  fit  accurately  together.  Ends  of  rails  shall 
be  cut  at  right  angles  to  the  axis  of  the  rail  except  where  otherwise  speci- 
fied.   All  burrs  shall  be  removed. 

No  paint,  tar  or  other  covering  shall  be  used  before  inspection. 

The  alinement  and  surface  of  all  finished  work  shall  be  even  and  true, 
and  shall  conform  to  the  angles  specified. 

FROGS. 
Fillers. 

Rolled  fillers  shall  fit  the  fishing  angles  and  the  web  of  the  rail  for  a 
distance  of  H-in.  above  and  below  the  base  and  head,  respectively,  and 
shall  maintain  the  required  flangeway.  Throat  filler  blocks  shall  fit  the 
rail  sufficiently  well  to  maintain  the  required  spacing.  Where  the  brand 
of  the  rail  interferes  with  the  fit  of  the  filler  the  brand  shall  be  chipped 
off.  Fillers  shall  be  grooved  or  cut  out  to  fit  over  rivet  heads. 
Heel   Raiser  Blocks. 

Heel  raiser-blocks  shall  fit  the  head,  base  and  web  of  rail  as  provided 
under  rolled  fillers. 


378  TRACK. 

Foot  Guards. 

Solid  Foot  Guards  shall  fit  the  rail  sufficiently  well  to  maintain  the 
required  spacing.  Strap  guards  shall  have  a  minimum  thickness  of  5^-in., 
of  the  width  shown  on  plan  and  shall  be  fastened  to  the  web  of  the  rail  by 
bolts  or  rivets  not  less  than  3/f-in.  in  diameter. 

Bolts. 

Bolts  must  be  round  and  true  to  size,  with  square  heads  and  nuts. 
Threads  must  be  accurately  cut  and  nuts  must  have  a  wrench-tight  fit. 
Each  bolt  must  be  provided  with  an  approved  head  lock  and  a  nut  lock  of 
approved  pattern  large  enough  to  give  full  bearing  for  the  nut.  A  J^-in. 
cotter  pin  shall,  when  required,  be  placed  outside  of  and  close  up  to  the  nut 
after  it  is  tightened.  Beveled  washers  must  be  used  wherever  necessary  to 
give  the  head  and  nut  a  full,  square  bearing.  Separate  head  lock  shall  be  of 
material  not  less  than  ?k-in.  thick.  Washers  used  under  heads  may  be  of 
such  design  as  to  act  as  head  locks.  Bolts  must  be  long  enough  to  allow 
the  nuts  to  be  brought  out  from  under  the  head  of  the  rail,  with  a  suitable 
washer  not  less  than  ^-in.  thick,  so  that  the  nuts  may  be  readily  tightened 
with  an  ordinary  wrench. 

Rivets. 

The  diameters  of  the  rivets  shall  be  of  full  size  shown  on  plan,  and 
the  diameters  of  the  rivet  holes  shall  not  be  more  than  -rs-in.  greater  than 
the  diameters  of  the  corresponding  rivets.  The  rivets  shall  be  of  sufficient 
length  to  provide  full,  neatly  made  heads  when  driven.  They  shall  be 
driven  tight,  bringing  all  adjacent  parts  into  contact. 

Rivets,  when  not  countersunk  or  flattened,  shall  have  standard  button 
luads  of  uniform  size  for  the  same  size  rivets.  The  heads  shall  be  full  and 
neatly  made  and  concentric  with  the  holes.  When  the  rivet  heads  are 
countersunk  they  shall  be  flush  with  the  plate  and  fill  the  holes. 

Reinforcing  Bars. 

Reinforcing  bars  shall  fit  the  fishing  angles  and  web  of  rail  through- 
out their  length. 

Plates. 

Plates  shall  be  flat  and  true  to  surface. 

Springs. 

Springs  shall  have  the  ends  square  with  the  axis,  so  that  when  the 
spring  is  placed  on  end  on  a  flat  surface  it  will  stand  perpendicular 
thereto. 

Spring  Covers. 

Spring  covers  shall  be  of  such  dimension  as  to  permit  a  proper  work- 
ing of  the  springs  and  shall  be  provided  with  a  spring  bearing  for  •'ach  end 
of  the  spring. 

Braces. 

Braces  shall  fit  the  head  and  web  of  rail  accurately. 


TRACK. 


379 


Stops  and  Hold-downs. 

*Stops  shall  be  so  placed  on  plates  as  to  hold  the  wing  rail  at  i^-in. 
opening  at  the  J^-in.  point.     Hold-downs  shall  fit  stops  so  as  to  allow  at 
least  2  in.  horizontal  play  and  not  more  than  ^-in.  vertical  play. 
Anti-creeping   Device. 

The  anti-creeping  device  shall  fit  accurately  to  the  parts  of  the  frog 
or  angle  bars. 

Holes  for  Main  Bolts. 

Holes  shall  be  drilled  from  the  solid.     No  punching  will  be  permitted 


10LLE0     5TEE 


WEIGHT 

or 

RAIL 

SIZE 

or  frog 

BOLTS 

100 

IV 

90 

IV 

SO 

IV 

10 

r 

to 

V 

SECTION    A- 


NO.  8    RIGID  FROG 


WEIGHT 

OF 

RAIL 

SIZE 

or  frog 

BOLTS 

too 

Hi 

so 

m 

BO 

lli 

70 

I' 

to 

tA 

NO.  11  RIGID  FROG 

except  of  bottom  plates  and  washers  Drilling  shall  be  accurately  done, 
on  bevel  where  necessary,  and  holes  shall  be  made  <rV-in.  less  in  diameter 
than  the  bolt  to  be  used.  Then  the  parts  shall  be  assembled  and  the  holes 
reamed  so  they  are  straight  and  true,  with  no  offsets  between  the  adjacent 
parts,  and  of  such  size  as  to  give  the  bolts  a  driving  fit  for  their  entire 
length. 


"For  amendments,   see   Index. 


380 


TRACK. 


In  lieu  of  the  above  specification  for  drilling  and  reaming,  the  manu- 
facturer may  assemble  and  accurately  fit  all  the  parts,  before  any  drilling 
whatever  is  done;  after  the  parts  are  securely  clamped  in  their  correct 
positions  the  holes  may  be  drilled  of  such  a  size  as  to  give  the  bolts  a 
driving  fit  for  their  entire  length. 


SECTION  AA 


SECTION  BB 


SECT/ON  CC 


WEIGHT 
OFRML 

5/Z£  OF 
FPOGBOLTS 

too 

Is- 

90 

n- 

80 

't- 

70 

/    ' 

60 

*" 

NO  II    SPRING  FROG 


SECTION  C-C 


•height 

OF  RAIL 

SIZE  OF    1 
FROG  BOLTS 

WO 

/"»" 

90 

iV 

BO 

/* 

70 

SO 

V 

NO    16  RIGID  FROG 


Marking. 

The  number  of  the  frog,  maker's  name,  weight  of  rail  and  the  date 
shall  be  plainly  stamped  with  24-in.  figures  and  letters  on  the  flare  of  one 
wing  rail  for  rigid  frogs  and  the  flare  of  both  wing  rails  for  spring  frogs, 
or  a  plate  shall  be  fastened  to  the  frog  with  the  same  information. 


TRACK.  381 

l 

SWITCHES. 
Throw. 

S  in.  at  center  line  of  No.  i  rod. 

Gage  of  Track. 
4  ft.  &y2  in. 

Switch  Ralls. 

Side  planing  and  bending  shall  conform  to  a  spread  at  the  heel  of  6% 
in.  between  the  gage  lines  of  the  stock  rail  and  the  switch  rail  and  a  thick- 
ness of  J4-in.  at  the  point.  The  bending  and  planing  shall  be  done  so  as  to 
give  a  straight  gage  line  to  the  switch  rail.  The  switch  rail  shall  after- 
ward be  ground  down  to  a  thickness  of  Ms-in.  at  the  point,  beginning  2  ft. 
back  from  the  point  of  the  switch;  the  point  of  the  switch  shall  then  be 
ground  down  to  a  sharp  edge  with  a  radius  of  1J/2  in.  The  head  of  switch 
rail  shall  fit  neatly  against  the  head  of  stock  rail  from  point  of  switch  rail 
to  point  of  divergence.  The  inner  edge  of  the  head  of  the  stock  rail  and 
the  outer  face  of  the  web  of  the  switch  rail  at  the  point  shall  be  in  the 
same  vertical  line  when  the  switch  rail  is  fitted  against  the  stock  rail. 

Top  planing  shall  conform  to  the  measurements  shown  on  Fig.  1  and 
Table  1. 


SfacAr /?a>//—? 


Fig.  1. 


*Table 

I. 

Switch. 

A.  B. 

33   ft. 

12  ft. 

22  ft. 

9  ft. 

16   ft.  6  in. 

5   ft. 

11   ft. 

5  ft. 

Bottom  of  switch  rail  shall  be  planed  to  fit  neatly  on  base  of  stock 
rail  where  bases  overlap. 

The  point  of  switch  rail  shall  be  as  shown  by  Fig.  2. 

Holes  for  switch  rod  lugs  and  stop  blocks  shall  be  §§-in.  in  diam- 
eter and  5  in.  center  to  center.  Holes  for  reinforcing  bars  shall  be  §§-in. 
diameter.    Number  and  location  as  provided  under  Reinforcing  Bars. 

Lugs. 

Lugs  shall  be  as  deep  as  the  section  of '  rail  will  permit. 

Distance  between  centers  of  holes  for  bolts  running  through  the  web 
of  the  rail  shall  be  5  in.  Diameter  of  holes  shall  be  Sf-in.  Switch  rod 
hnlt  hole  shall  he  r  J?  in.  in  diameter 


♦For  amendments,   see  Index. 


382 


TRACK. 


Switch  Rods. 

Switch  rods  shall  be  M*2^2  in-  and  shall  be  held  in  a  horizontal 
plane.  Bolt  holes  shall  be  la's  in.  in  diameter.  There  shall  be  at  least 
iV2  in.  of  metal  at  end  beyond  bolt  holes. 

Reinforcing  Bars. 

A  reinforcing  bar  ^-in.  thick  shall  be  riveted  to  each  side  of  each 
switch  rail  and  point  ends  shall  be  made  flush  with  point  of  switch  rail. 
The  bars  shall  be  as  long  as  the  heel  connections  will  permit.  Bars  shall 
fit  against  web  of  rail  and  shall  fill  the  space  between  head  and  flange  of 
rail.  There  shall  be  M$-in.  clearance  between  outer  bar  and  head  of  stock 
rail  where  the  bar  projects  under  the  head  of  stock  rail.     Top  of  inner 


Not  less 
thanlj" 


Sectionl£  from  point 


Length 
Switch 


11 


16  6" 


22'       i   11 


33' 


Dist. 
A 


_£ 


*XL 


YK 


^Ground  to  sharp  edge 


1 

Stock    Rail 

\- 

^d^L_ 

^g^^^ig^-  — -f^r--^^ 

r 

Hi 

| 

Point  Rail 

~*    ' "  ■      — j 

> 

r-A— H 

TOP    VIEW 

Fig.  2 — Details  of  Point. 

bar,  where  it  projects  beyond  the  head  of  switch  rail,  shall  not  be  less  than 

1%,  in.  below  the  top  of  stock  rail.     The  reinforcing  bar  shall  be  beveled 

to  an  angle  of  45  degrees  where  it  projects  beyond  the  head  of  the  rail. 

rivets 
Bars  shall  be   fastened   to  rail  with  54-in.  .    ,     '  except  that  at  the 

first,  second  and  fifth  holes,  and  the  holes  through  which  the  lugs  are 
fastened,  they  shall  be  bolted.  Center  of  first  hole  shall  be  \V2  in.  from 
point  and  center  of  last  hole  in  bar  shall  be  2  in.  from  heel  end  of  bar. 

Intermediate   "v£ s    shall  be   spaced  so  that  there  shall  be  fastenings  at 

intervals  not  greater  than  12  in. 


TRACK. 


383 


Stop  Blocks. 

Stop  blocks  shall  be  of  approved  design  with  holes  ii-in.  in  diameter. 
Stop  blocks  shall  be  spaced  as  nearly  as  practicable  at  equal  intervals  be- 
tween the  end  of  planing  and  heel  of  switch. 
Heel  Blocks. 

Heel  blocks  shall  be  of  approved  design  with  standard  rail  drilling. 
Bolts  and  Nuts. 

Bolts  fastening  lugs,  stop  blocks  and  foot  guards  to  switch  rails  shall 


HHEN  NO.  I  ROD  IS  OSEO  AS  LOCK  ROD,  TIES  MAr  BE 
3HKEO  AS  SHOHN  Br  BROKEN  LINES.  LOCATION  OF 
NO. 2  ROD    WILL  BE  CHANGED. 


/6'  6'  SWITCH 


WHEN  NO.  I  ROD  IS  USED  AS  LOCK  ROD .  TIES  MAY  BE 
SPACED  AS  SHOWN  Br  BROKEN  LINES .  LOCATION  OF 
NO.  2   ROD    WILL  BE   CHANGED. 


'        20'     1        22'      |       22'      I       22'      I       22'      \        22'      I 

I       twJ-i  IwMfl     I    j— — 1       I 

I        \.I2  ^2Q'  I       20     J      20'      |      20' 


11'  SWITCH 


be  34-in.  in  diameter.     Bolts  connecting  the  lugs  with  switch  rods  and  the 
switch-stand  connecting  bolt  shall  be  I  in.  in  diameter  and  machine  turned- 


384 


TRACK. 


All  bolts  shall  be  provided  with  nut  locks  and  cotters,     fain,  bolts  shall 
have  hexagonal  nuts  and  i  in.  bolts  shall  have  square  nuts. 

Rivets. 

The  diameters  of  the  rivets  shall  be  of  full  size  shown  on  plan,  and 
the  diameters  of  the  rivet  holes  shall  not  be  more  than  ds-in.  greater  than 


* 
K 


<0 


386  TRACK. 

the  diameters  of  the  corresponding  rivets.  The  rivets  shall  be  of  sufficient 
length  to  provide  full,  neatly  made  heads  when  driven.  They  shall  be 
driven  tight,  bringing  all  adjacent  parts  into  contact. 

Rivets,  when  not  countersunk  or  flattened,  shall  have  standard  button 
heads  of  uniform  size  for  the  same  size  rivets.  The  heads  shall  be  full 
and  neatly  made  and  concentric  with  the  holes. 

When  the  rivet  heads  are  countersunk  they  shall  be  flush  with  the 
plate  and  fill  the  holes. 

Plates. 

There  shall  be  on  each  tie  two  plates  of  suitable  length  %-in.  by  7  in., 
planed  down  to  receive  the  stock  rail  and  braces.  Three  holes  outside 
and  two  inside  are  required  for  %-in.  lag  screws  or  screw  spikes,  or  for 
ordinary  spikes,  as  may  be  specified,  on  all  switch  ties,  except  the  two 
head  ties,  where  there  shall  be  three  outside  and  five  inside,  one  of  the 
inside  holes  to  be  in  position  for  spiking  the  switch. 

Braces. 

Braces  shall  be  of  such  a  design  that  2^/2  in.  clearance  for  detector 
bars  may  be  obtained.  Three  holes  for  y%-\n.  lag  screws  or  screw  spikes 
shall  be  provided. 

Foot  Guards. 

Strap  foot  guards  shall  have  a  minimum  thickness  of  5^-in.  and 
shall  be  fastened  to  the  web  of  the  rail  by  24-in.  bolts  or  rivets. 


Note. — The  following  members  of  the  Committee  approve  the  report 
as  submitted  herewith :  J.  B.  Jenkins,  Chairman ;  L.  S.  Rose,  Garrett 
Davis,  J.  R.  Leighty,  Curtiss  Millard,  T.  H.  Hickey,  Raffe  Emerson, 
J.  M.  R.  Fairbairn,  H.  T.  Porter.  P.  C.  Newbegin,  W.  G.  Raymond,  S.  S. 
Roberts,  F.  A.  Smith,  R.  A.  Van  Houten,  W.  J.  Towne,  H.  R.  Safford, 
R.  M.  Pearce,  C.  H.  Stein,  Thos.  Maney. 

The  following  members  of  the  Committee  approve  the  report  con- 
ditionally ;  G.  J.  Ray,  A.  Bruner,  F.  S.  Stevens. 

The  following  members  dissent  from  portions  of  the  report :  Geo.  H. 
Rremner.  R.  O.  Rote. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE   I— ON  ROADWAY. 

J.  E.  Willoughey.  Chairman;  W.  M.  Dawley,  Vice-Chairman; 

J.  R.  W.  Ambrose.  W.  D.  Pence 

John  C.  Beye.  A.  C.  Prime. 

D.  J.  Brumley.  Hiram  J.  Slifer. 

W.  C.  Curd.  J.  A.  Spielmann. 

Paul  Didier.  John  G.  Sullivan. 

R.  C.  Falconer.  F.  L.  Wheaton. 

S.  B.  Fisher.  W.  P.  Wiltsee. 

T.  H.  Gatlin.  R.  C.  Young. 

C.  S.  Millard.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Roadway  respectfully  submits  its  report  to  the 
thirteenth  annual  convention. 

Two  meetings  of  the  full  Committee  were  held,  both  at  Chicago,  one 
on  June  23  and  the  other  on  November  28. 

That  each  of  the  four  subjects  assigned  to  your  Committee  might 
have  attention,  the  membership  of  the  Committee  was  grouped  into  a 
like  number  of  sub-committees. 


(1)     PRESENT  FORMULAE  OF  GENERAL  APPLICATION   FOR 

DETERMINING  WATERWAY  AREAS  UNDER  VARYING 

CONDITIONS,  WITH  THE  CONSIDERATION 

ALSO  OF  HYDRAULIC  FEATURES. 

W.  D.  Pence,  Chairman ;  John  C.  Beye,  Hiram  J.  Slifer,  R.  C.  Falconer. 
F.  L.  Wheaton,   Sub-Committee. 

Your  Committee  has  been  considering  for  several  years  the  possibility 
of  preparing,  or  of  selecting  from  the  various  formulae  in  common  u?e. 
one  that  can  be  recommended  for  general  application.  The  investigation 
made  since  the  Committee's  report  to  the  annual  convention  in  March. 
1909,  does  not  warrant  the  Committee  in  varying  from  the  opinion  then 
expressed  and  accepted  by  the  Association  (see  Proceedings,  Vol.  10,  Part 
2),  to-wit: 

"(1)  In  determining  the  size  of  a  given  waterway,  careful  considera- 
tion should  be  given  to  local  conditions,  including  flood  height  and  flow, 
size  and  behavior  of  other  openings  in  the  vicinity  carrying  the  same  stream, 
characteristics  of  the  channel  and  of  the  watershed  area,  climatic  condi- 
tions, extent  and  character  of  traffic  on  the  given  line  of  road  and  probable 

387 


388  ROADWAY. 

consequences  of  interruptions  to  same,  and  any  other  elements  likely  to 
affect  the  safety  or  economy  of  the  culvert  or  opening. 

"(2)  (a)  The  practice  of  using  a  formula  to  assist  in  fixing  the 
proper  size  of  the  waterway  in  a  given  case  is  warranted  to  the  extent 
that  the  formula  and  the  values  of  the  terms  substituted  therein  are  known 
to  fit  local  conditions. 

"(b)  Waterway  formulae  are  also  used  as  a  guide  in  fixing  or  veri- 
fying culvert  areas  where  only  general  information  as  to  the  local  condi- 
tions is  at  hand. 

"(c)  The  use  of  such  formulae  should  not  displace  careful  observa- 
tion and  the  exercise  of  intelligent  judgment  on  the  part  of  the  engineer. 

"(d)  No  single  waterway  formula  can  be  recommended  as  fitting  all 
conditions  of  practice." 

To  the  above  the  Committee  added  the  following  conclusions  in  its 
report  to  the  annual  convention,  March,  191 1  (Proceedings,  Vol.  12,  Part 
3),  to- wit : 

"(1)  There  is  a  general  relationship  between  the  best-known  water- 
way and  run-off  formulae.  This  relationship  may  be  expressed  by  two 
terms,  a  varying  co-efficient  and  a  varying  exponent,  substantially  as  shown 
by  the  accompanying  diagrams,  Figs.  2  and  3. 

"(2)  The  extent  of  this  relationship  for  large  and  small  areas  is 
indicated  by  the  Dun  waterway  data,  given  in  Table  1  and  shown  graphic- 
ally by  Fig.  1." 

The  Committee's  work  since  the  twelfth  annual  convention  has  been 
directed  toward  the  consideration  rather  of  the  hydraulic  features  of  the 
culvert,  and  while  some  progress  has  been  made,  the  Committee  is  not 
prepared  now  to  make  any  definite  recommendation. 


(2)    REPORT   ON  UNIT   PRESSURES   ALLOWABLE   ON   ROAD- 
BEDS OF  DIFFERENT  MATERIALS,  CONFERRING  WITH 
THE  COMMITTEE  ON   BALLAST. 

R.  C.  Young,  Chairman;  J.  R.  W.  Ambrose,  C.  S.  Millard.  S.  B. 
Fisher,  A.  C.  Prime,  Sub-Committee. 

The  Committee  has  been  collecting  information  for  two  years  for  the 
purpose  of  formulating  a  conclusion  as  to  what  unit  pressures  are  allow- 
able on  the  roadbed,  and  the  Committee  has  come  to  the  conclusion  that 
since  the  available  data  treats  of  the  sustaining  power  of  soils  below  the 
surface,  rather  than  of  that  of  soils  peculiarly  exposed  as  the  roadbed 
is  to  moisture,  to  the  action  of  frost,  and  to  the  loadings  peculiar  to  train 
service,  it  will  be  necessary  to  make  experiments  to  determine  the  magni- 
tude and  distribution  of  the  loads  transmitted  to  the  roadbed  through 
ballast  of  various  kinds  and  also  to  determine  by  test  the  bearing  power 
of  various  materials  under  varying  conditions  ordinarily  attained  in  the 
construction  of  the  roadway.  The  Committee  submits  as  information  the 
following  memorandum  prepared  by  Mr.  W.  M.  Dawley,  its  Vice-Chair- 
man, after  adjournment  of  the  November,  1911,  meeting: 

"The  safe  bearing  power  of  soils  depends  upon  their  character  or 
composition,  depth  of  strata,  amount  of  water  they  contain  or  are  liable 
to  receive  and  the  degree  to  which  they  are  confined. 


ROADWAY. 


389 


"Practically  all  of  the  published  data  in  relation  to  the  bearing  power 
of  soils  is  in  connection  with  foundation  work  for  bridges  and  buildings 
and  the  bearing  values  given  are  for  loads  applied  at  varying  depths  below 
the  surface  of  the  ground,  hence  on  soils  more  or  less  well  confined,  and 
serve  merely  as  a  rough  guide  to  the  bearing  power  of  soils  other  than 
rock  when  the  load  is  applied  at  the  surface  and  the  soil  is  unconfined. 

"The  following  table  from  'Data'  gives  the  safe  bearing  value  in  tons 
per  square  foot  of  soils  and  rock  which  may  be  placed  on  uniform  strata 
of  considerable  thickness  and  well  confined : 


Authority 

Character  of  Soil 

i.o: 

Baker 

G.  B. 

Francis 

Elmer  L.  Corthell 

G.  F. 
Gebhardt 

w.  w. 

Christie 

Min. 

Max. 

Min.   Max. 

Min.   Max. 

Av. 

Min.   Max. 

Min.   Max. 

ROCK— Granite,  etc.,  in 

200 

25 

15 

5 

30 
20 

10 

Ledge 
Rock     36 

Solid  Bed 
Rock  up  to 
20%  of  net 
Crushing 
Strength 

Solid    200 

ROCK — Limestone,  equal 

Bed 

ROCK— Sandstone,  equal 

ROCK— Soft  and  pliable 
as  shale,  equal  to  poor 

ROCK— Broken  and  well 

10.0     15.0 

5  to  25 

HARD  PAN— Gravel  and 
sand  well  cemented  with 

8 
6 
4 
1 

10 
8 
6 
2 

8 
3 

3        12 
2          8 

8.7 
5.08 

CLAY— Thick    beds    and 
CLAY— Thick   beds   and 
CLAY— Soft,    wet,    con- 

3.0      4.0 
2.0 

4 

2     

1.0 

1 

G RAVEL—  Coarse    and 
dry,  well  compacted  and 

5 

4     

1 

2.4  7.75 

2.5  8.5 
2.25    5.8 

1.5      6.2 

5.1 
4.9 
4.5 

2.9 

6.0        8.0 
1.5  

8 

SAND — Dry,       compact, 

well  cemented  with  clay. 

SAND— Clear    and    dry, 

4 
2 

o.; 

6 
4 

1 

4 

2.0  

2 

QUICKSAND— Marshy 
and  alluvial  soils,   silt, 

0.5  

0.5 

"Elmer  L.  Corthell  has  tabulated  various  existing  pressures  of  stable 
structures  which  have  shown  no  settlement.  Data  were  obtained  from  178 
separate  works,  in  response  to  letter  sent  to  prominent  engineers  through- 
out the  world,  requesting  their  experiences.  The  average  value  given.  Mr. 
Corthell  says,  is  low,  and  a  safe  one  lies  between  the  average  and  maxi- 
mum.    (See  'Allowable  Pressures  on  Deep  Foundations,'  Corthell,  1906.) 

"G.  F.  Gebhardt  gives  values  which  are  an  average  of  maximum  loads 
allowed  in  most  cities  under  the  building  laws. 

"Richard  Delafield,  Brevet  Major-Gencral,  Corps  of  Engineers,  United 
States  Army,  member  of  Light  House  Board  in  'Memoir  on  Foundations 
in  Compressible  Soils,'  Washington,  D.  C,  1881,  says,  on  page  13: 

"  'The  compressibility  of  oolitic  clays  can  only  be  overcome  by  piling, 
deep  sinking,  heavy  ramming  or  heavy  weighting.  The  point  of  bearing 
must  be  carried  below  the  possibility  of  upward  reaction.  The  depth  of  a 
foundation  in  compressible  ground  ought  not  to  be  less  than  one-fourth 
the  intended  height  of  the  building  above  ground;  that  is,  for  a  shaft 
of  200  ft.,  the  foundation  should  be  made  secure  to  a  depth  of  50  ft.  by 


390  ROADWAY. 

piling  or  by  well-sinking  and  concrete.  (Engineer  and  Architectural 
Journal,  for  1837.)  Masses  of  concrete,  brick  or  stone,  placed  on  a  com- 
pressible substratum,  however  cramped  and  bound,  may  prove  unsafe. 
Solidity  from  a  considerable  depth  alone  can  be  relied  upon.  Mere  en- 
largement of  a  base  may  not  in  itself  be  sufficient. 

"In  experiments  made  by  Hugh  Leonard  (M.  A.)  at  Akra  for  the 
purpose  of  testing  the  ordinary  undisturbed  alluvial  soil  of  Calcutta,  'The 
results  showed  that  for  Calcutta  the  weight  on  the  foundation  should 
not  be  more  than  one  ton  to  the  superficial  foot.'  Journal  of  Royal  Insti- 
tute of  British  Architects,  1900,  pp.  390-394. 

"In  Cunningham's  Dock  Engineering,  page  183,  speaking  of  founda- 
tions for  masonry  dock  walls,  it  is  stated  that  'The  maximum  intensity 
of  pressure,  at  any  point,  should  not  exceed  a  certain  limit,  dependent 
upon  the  nature  of  the  ground.  The  safe  intensity  of  pressure  on  nat- 
ural foundations  has  been  determined  as  follows : 

On  hard  rock 9      to  10      tons  per  sq.  ft. 

On  soft  rock  and  hard  clay..  .2      to     3      tons  per  sq.  ft. 

On  sand  and  gravel \l/>  to    2      tons  per  sq.  ft. 

On  compact  earth 1       to     V/i  tons  per  sq.  ft. 

On  soft,  uncertain  ground....  J/2  ton    per  sq.ft. 

"  'In  the  case  of  natural  foundations,  care  must  be  taken  that  there 
is  no  possibility  of  lateral  escape,'  and  again  at  page  247,  speaking  of 
Lock  Foundations : 

"  'As  a  general  rule,  hard  rock  and  stiff  clay,  in  which  there  are  no 
springs,  do  not  call  per  se  for  any  artificial  covering,  except  such  as  may 
be  judged  necessary  to  protect  their  surface  from  the  softening  and  scour- 
ing action  of  water.  On  the  other  hand,  alluvial  deposits,  sand,  gravel  and 
other  incohesive  strata,  need  the  confinement  afforded  by  a  superimposed 
mass  in  addition  to  the  lateral  support  of  sheet-piles. 

"  'Earth  of  a  porous  nature,  moreover,  is  not  only  unsuitable  for  a 
natural  floor,  but  is  equally  undesirable  as  a  foundation  for  an  artificial 
floor,  owing  to  its  efficacy  as  a  medium  for  the  transmission  of  water 
pressure,  on  which  account  any  covering  laid  upon  it  should  be  both 
strong  and  impervious.' " 

Mr.  Alfred  C.  Prime  (Pennsylvania  Railroad),  a  member  of  the  Com- 
mittee, reports  as  follows : 

ROCK    SUBGRADE 

"A  good  quality  of  rock  will  stand  up  under  the  heaviest  axle  loads 
and  under  Class  'A'  traffic  it  is  sustaining  axle  loads  on  one  pair  of  drivers 
of  61,500  lbs.  without  any  signs  of  failure.  Considering  this  load  as  dis- 
tributed over  two  ties,  gives  a  unit  pressure  of  850  lbs.  a  sq.  ft.  As  stated 
previously  the  limit  of  bearing  is  unknown,  but  a  good  quality  of  rock 
will  probably  sustain,  with  proper  ballast,  the  highest  axle  loads  that  can 
be  placed  upon  it. 

CLAY   SUBGRADE. 

"I  never  had  any  satisfaction  in  maintaining  tracks  where  roadbed 
subgrade  was  composed  of  clay.  It  has  always  resulted  in  a  high  main- 
tenance cost.  The  track  will  get  out  of  line  and  surface  and  will  require 
from  one-third  to  one-half  as  much  work  again  as  where  loam  or  sand 
is  used.  I  personally  believe  that  clay  should  never  be  used  in  fills  on 
account  of  its  high  maintenance  cost. 

"A  good  grade  of  yellow  clay  will  under  Class  'B'  traffic  and  axle 
loads  of  61,500  lbs.  with  6  in.  of  cinder  ballast  just  sustain  a  pressure  of 
about  900  lbs.  per  sq.  ft.     Speed  of  trains  average  60  miles  per  hour. 

SANDY  LOAM. 

"This  has   always  given   me   satisfaction   where   I   have  used  it   and 


ROADWAY. 


391 


had  to  maintain  track.  Under  Class  'A'  and  'B'  traffic,  speed  60-70 
miles  per  hour  with  a  proper  depth  of  ballast  it  will  maintain  the  heaviest 
axle  loads  that  can  be  placed  upon  it.  I  know  it  is  maintaining  pressures 
of  900  lbs.  per  sq.  ft.  and  how  much  more  it  is  capable  of  sustaining  is 
unknown. 

OCEAN    SAND. 

"For  Class  'C  traffic  this  is  a  satisfactory  subgrade  for  loads  up  to 
700  lbs.  per  sq.   ft.,  which  is  about  the  limit  of  economical  maintenance. 

"A  sand  subgrade  can  be  made  to  sustain  Class  'B'  traffic  by  raising 
track  about  18  in.  on  engine  cinders. 

"All  figures  given  above  are  for  a  single  track  roadway  20  ft.  wide 
with  slopes  ofij4  to  1,  and  good  drainage,  with  6  in.  of  cinder  ballast 
below  base  of  tie.     Tie  spacing  22  in. 

"The  only  cheap  and  inexpensive  method  for  determining  unit  pres- 
sures_  on  subgrades  known  to  me,  is  to  spread  some  pliable  substance  such 
as  fairly  thin  sheet  lead  on  top  of  your  subgrade  for  a  length  of  say  5  ft. 
As  long  as  this  remains  straight  and  undeformed  your  allowable  unit  pres- 
sure on  subgrade  is  not  being  exceeded,  but  the  moment  it  becomes  cupped 
and  dished  under  the  ties,  the  unit  pressure  for  this  class  of  roadbed  sub- 
grade  is  too  high. 

"In  connection  with  this  work  the  report  of  the  M.  W.  &  S.  Com- 
mittee on  Roadbed  of  the  Altoona  Railroad  Club  in  May,  1909,  on  'Drain- 
age of  a  Four-Track  Railroad,'  contains  some  interesting  matter,  also  a 
paper  by  Mr.  M.  L.  Byers  in  Bulletin  of  the  International  Railway  Con- 
gress for  September,  1909." 

Mr.  F.  T.  Llewellyn  in  December,  1898,  made  some  tests  to  determine 
the  safe  load  on  soils  at  New  Orleans.  Pits  4  ft.  x  4  ft.  x  5  ft.  deep, 
water  at  18  in.  below  surface-bottom  of  pit  in  blue  clay,  wood  foundation 
3  ft.  x  3  ft.  of  3  in.  x  12  in.  plank  doubled  and  crossed,  with  the  follow- 
ing results: 


Load 

PerSq.  Ft. 

Lbs. 

Total  Load 
Lbs. 

Settlement  in  Inches 

Dec.  13-17 

Dec.  19 

Dec.  24 

Pit  No.  1 

T650 
1000 
1300 

6100 
9280 
12000 

1 

t 

i 

1 

7 

IB 

6 

Pit  No.  2   

»» 

Pit  No.  3 

i 

Mr.  O.  E.  Selby,  Bridge  Engineer,  Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  & 
St.  Louis  Railway  (see  Proceedings,  Vol.  8,  pp.  54-59),  using  the  formula 
derived  by  Mr.  Thos.  H.  Johnson  (see  Proceedings,  Vol.  7,  pp.  104-105), 
calculates  the  average  pressure  on  subgrade  to  be  2.4  tons  per  sq.  ft.,  and 
the  maximum  to  be  3.6  tons  for  50,000-lb.  axle  loads  spaced  5  ft.  centers, 
80-lb.  rail,  7  in.  x  8  in.  x  8>y2  ft.  ties  spaced  20-in.  centers  on  12  in.  of 
gravel  ballast. 

From  what  has  preceded  it  will  be  observed  that  the  safe  bearing  power 
of  confined  soft  wet  clay,  clear  dry  sand  confined  in  natural  beds,  quick- 
sand, marshy  and  alluvial  soils,  silt,  etc.,  all  confined,  is  less  than  or  very 
slightly  in  excess  of  the  pressures  calculated  by  Mr.  Selby.  If  unconfined 
their  bearing  powers  will  all  be  somewhat  reduced. 

Semi-fluid  soils  such  as  quicksand,  alluvium,  etc.,  should  be  removed 


392  ROADWAY. 

where  practicable  or  the  foundation  carried  to  a  lower  stratum,  so  the  bear- 
ing power  of  such  need  not  be  considered  here. 

The  bearing  power  of  clay,  loam,  sand,  etc.,  depends  to  a  great  extent 
on  the  amount  of  moisture  present. 

Professor  Schubler  of  Tubingen  found  that  ioo  lbs.  of  dry  soil  would 
retain  the  following  amount  of  water  that  would  not  flow  off: 

Pure  Clay : . ' 70  lbs. 

Clay  Loam 50  lbs. 

Loamy  Soil   40  lbs. 

Sand  25  lbs. 

Drainage  Farm  Journal,  August,  1884. 

The  water  which  destroys  the  bearing  power  of  such  soils  may  come 
from  below  by  capillary  attraction.  The  vertical  capillary  movement  per 
each  horizontal  square  foot  per  24  hours  being  as  follows: 

In  fine  sand  through  1  ft.  vertical 2.37  lbs. 

In  fine  sand  through  2  ft.  vertical 2.07  lbs. 

In  fine  sand  through  3  ft.  vertical 1.23  lbs. 

In  fine  sand  through  4  ft.  vertical 91  lbs. 

In  medium  clay  loam  through  1  ft.  vertical 2.05  lbs. 

In  medium  clay  loam  through  2  ft.  vertical 1.62  lbs. 

In  medium  clay  loam  through  3  ft.  vertical 1.00  lbs. 

In  medium  clay  loam  through  4  ft.  vertical 90  lbs. 

See  page  65,  "Movements  of  Ground  Water,"  by  Franklin  H.  King  and 
Charles  S.  Slichter,  Government  Printing  Office,  Washington,  D.  C,  1899. 

If,  as  Professor  Baker  says,  dry  clay  will  sustain  a  load  of  from  6 
to  8  tons  per  sq.  ft.  and  soft  wet  clay  will  support  but  from  1  to  2  tons 
per  sq.  ft,  it  seems  that  the  bearing  power  of  clays  and  soils  similarly 
affected  by  the  presence  of  moisture  should  in  each  case  be  experimentally 
determined  for  varying  percentages  of  moisture  and  such  drainage  ar- 
rangements made,  and  at  such  depths,  as  will  always  secure  a  per- 
centage of  moisture  low  enough  to  bring  the  bearing  power  up  to  the 
load  it  is  required  to  carry. 

BEARING   POWER   OF   SOILS. 

Composing  Subgrade  of  Railroad  Track. 
(After  Rankine.) 

Let  p  =  Intensity   of  vertical  pressure  on  subgrade  per   sq.   ft. 

Let  q  =  Intensity  of  vertical  pressure  at  depth  d,  clear  of  super- 
structure, equals  weight  per  cu.  ft.  of  subgrade  soil  multiplied  by  depth  d 
in  feet. 

Let  d  =  Depth  of  soil,  clear  of  track,  the  weight  of  which  will  just 
balance  the  tendency  to  upheaval  due  to  the  load  transmitted  to  subgrade 
by  the  track. 

Let  <p  =  Angle  of  repose  of  the  material  composing  the  subgrade. 

Let  W  =  Weight  of  load  per  linear  ft.  of  track. 


ROADWAY.  393 

Let  w  =  Weight  per  cu.  ft.  of  subgrade  soil. 

Let  b  =  Breadth  in  ft.  of  track  and  ballast  imposing  load  on  subgrade. 

The  co-efficient  of  friction  is  equal  to  the  tangent  of  the  angle  of  re- 
pose, <f>,  of  the  soil  composing  the  roadbed. 

If  two  particles  of  earth  are  pressed  together  by  a  pair  of  equal 
thrusts  p  and  p'  normal  to  their  surface  of  contact,  it  requires  a  pair  of 
equal  thrusts  q  and  q'  tangential  to  that  surface  to  make  them  slide  upon 
each  other.  For  the  same  material,  when  q  is  just  sufficient  to  make  them 
slide,  it  is  a  constant  fraction  of  p.  The  fraction  which  q  must  be 
of  p  just  to  cause  slipping  is  the  co-efficient  of  friction  for  that  material. 
Hence,  the  co-efficient  of  friction  equals  q/p. 

The  condition  of  equilibrium  for  a  mass  of  earth  in  a  compound  state 
of  strain  is  that  at  every  point  the  obliquity  of  the  stress  on  the  plane 
upon  which,  of  all  others  through  the  point,  the  resultant  stress  is  most 
oblique,  shall  itself  not  be  greater  than  <t>. 

Since  earth  can  only  sustain  thrusts,  the  principal  stresses  at  any  point 
will  be  the  two  thrusts,  and  if  y  be  the  obliquity  of  the  resultant  stress  upon 
the  plane  through  the  point  upon  which  the  stress  is  most  oblique,  then 

Sin  y  =  

P  +  q 

p        I  -+-  Sin  y 

q        I  —  Sin  y 

By  increasing  y,  the  numerator  of  the  term  on  the  right  hand  side  of 
the  equation  increases,  while  the  denominator  decreases,  and  so  the  ratio 
p/q  increases.  But  0  is  the  greatest  value  of  y  for  which  equilibrium  is 
just  possible. 

rp       i  +  Sin  0 
q        I  —  Sin  0 

is  the  greatest  ratio  of  p  to  q  consistent  with  equilibrium ;  hence,  the  con- 
dition of  equilibrium  of  a  mass  of  earth  is  most  conveniently  stated  thus ; 
that  at  every  point  the  ratio  of  the  greater  to  the  lesser  principal  stress 
shall  not  exceed  that  of  (i  +  Sin  0)  to  (i  —  Sin  0). 

For  earth  whose  upper  surface  is  horizontal,  the  vertical  stress  due  to 
the  weight  and  the  horizontal  stress  are  for  all  points  the  principal  stresses, 
and  their  intensities  are  the  same  for  all  points  on  the  same  horizontal 
plane.  Generally  the  vertical  is  the  greater  principal  stress  in  any  ratio 
not  exceeding  the  above ;  whenever  it  exceeds  the  horizontal  thrust  by  a 
greater  ratio  the  earth  spreads.  But  the  horizontal  thrust  may  be  arti- 
ficially increased  till  it  exceeds  the  vertical  in  any  ratio  not  exceeding  the 
above;  whenever  it  exceeds  the  vertical  by  a  greater  ratio,  the  earth 
heaves  up. 

When  the  earth  at  the  side  of  the  track  is  just  on  the  point  of  heaving 
up,  for  points  at  depth  d  the  vertical  pressure  p  exceeds  the  horizontal 


394 


ROADWAY. 


■^ 


P 


a! 
>_L_ 


v 


SD^ 


d 


i_ 


*- 


q-       p 


Fig.  I. 

reaction  q  in  the  greatest  possible  amount,  that  earth  being  on  the  point 
of  spreading,  that  is, 

p        i  +  Sin  0 

q       I  —  Sin  0' 

while  for  points  just  clear  of  the  track,  p'  exceeds  q'  in  the  same  amount, 
that  earth  being  on  the  point  of  heaving  up,  therefore, 

p'       1  +  Sin  4> 

r> 
By  multiplication 


1  —  Sin  <p' 

1  +  Sin  <f>\  2 


pp'  _  /I  +  Sin  0\: 
qq'       Vi  —  Sin  <p) 


qq 

Now  p'  and  q  are  equal  horizontal  thrusts  on  the  same  horizontal  layer ; 
canceling  these  and  substituting  the  following  values : 

weight  per  linear  ft.  of  track  and  locomotive  W 

p  = =  — 

L.-eadth  of  track  and  ballast  b 

(q'  =  weight  of  column  of  subgrade  earth  1  ft.  square  and  depth  d  =  w  d) 
we  have 

W  /i  +  Sin  <t>\2 


b  w  d 


/I  +  bin  <p\: 
Vi  —  Sin  <p) 


whence 


Sin  <pj 
W    /i  —  Sin  0\2 


W    /i  —  bin  <p\ : 
d(tt.)   =  —  (  I) 

wb  \i  -f-  Sin  (p/ 


For  example,  assume  a  load  of  72,000  lbs.  per  linear  foot  of  track  in- 
cluding impact  on  a  roadbed  10  ft.  wide  or  3.6  tons  per  sq.  ft.  on  a  sub- 
grade  of  dry  loam  weighing  95  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  with  an  angle  of  repose  of 
1Y2  to  1  or  <p  =  33°  42' 

d  =  72Iooo;/i^5548x2=6_2ft( 
95x10  Vi  +  .5548/ 

the  depth  at  which  a  sidewise  motion  of  the  earth  under  the  track  will  cease. 
If  the  subgrade  should  be  wet  clay  weighing  120  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  with 


ROADWAY. 


395 


a  co-efficient  of  friction  of  .33  an  angle  of  repose  of  18°   15',  the  depth 
of  earth  required  to  balance  the  load  will  be 

d  =  72'°°°  C-^m2-)2^  164  ft. 

120 x  10  \i  +  .3132/ 

If  the  material  of  subgrade  has  an  angle  of  repose  of  400  and  weighs 
120  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  the  depth  will  be 


d  =  ^ooo_/i^-^42oy=28ft 
120  X  IO  \I  4-  .6420/ 


+  .6429^ 

The  above  analysis  suggests  a  simple  field  test  to  determine  the  bear- 
ing power  of  soils  which  should  be  experimented  with  to  determine  its 
practicability. 


The  preceding  figure  is  a  section  of  two  troughs  enclosing  earth,  and 
pressed  together  with  a  thrust  of  intensity  p  normal  to  MN,  the  plane 
where  the  troughs  just  approach  contact,  and  P  is  the  amount  of  this 
thrust.  A  thrust  of  intensity  q  tangential  to  the  plane  MN  tends  to  cause 
the  earth  to  slide  in  two  parts  along  MN ;  also  Q  is  the  amount  of  this 
thrust.  If  Q  be  just  sufficient  to  cause  slipping  along  MN,  then  the  co- 
efficient of  friction  of  the  earth  is, 


f 


Q 


=  Tan  <f> 


If  a  cube  of  the  soil  to  be  tested  be  enclosed  in  the  two  half  boxes  as 
indicated  in  the  sketch  and  weighted  down  with  a  load  P  so  that  the  in- 
tensity of  pressure  on  the  plane  MN  is  approximately  that  which  the 
soil  will  have  to  bear  under  the  track,  and  the  force  Q  which  is  necessary 
just  to  cause  slipping  along  the  plane  MN  be  measured  by  means  of  a 
spring  balance;  then  dividing  the  amount  of  Q  by  the  weight  of  the  upper 
half  of  the  earth  and  box  plus  the  load  P  will  give  the  tangent  of  tihe 
angle  of  repose  from  which  may  be  obtained  the  sine  of  the  angle  of  re- 


396  ROADWAY. 

pose  which  is  used  in  the  analysis  above  to  determine  the  bearing  power 
of  the  soil  tested. 

Tests  of  this  kind  might  be  made,  the  bearing  power  of  the  soil  cal- 
culated and  the  result  compared  with  actual  full  size  tests  of  the  bearing 
power  of  the  same  soil  and  if  found  to  agree  within  a  reasonable  limit  a 
standard  method  of  conducting  the  field  test  could  be  prescribed  and  the 
unit  pressures  specified  for  soils  according  to  their  co-efficient  of  friction 
as  thus  determined. 

(3)  REPORT   ON   TUNNEL   CONSTRUCTION    AND    VENTILA- 

TION. 

Paul  Didier,  Chairman ;  W.  M.  Dawley,  J.  A.  Spielmann,  D.  J.  Brum- 
ley,  W.  P.  Wiltsee,  Sub-Committee. 

Your  Committee  made  recommendation  to  the  annual  convention  of 
1910  as  to  the  cross-section  to  which  tunnels  should  be  constructed  to  eon- 
form  to  good  practice.  The  recommendation  was  adopted  (Manual  191 1, 
page  43),  and  the  Committee  has  since  that  convention  confined  its  atten- 
tion principally  to  the  question  of  ventilation.  No  definite  conclusion  has 
been  reached,  but  the  opinion  of  the  Committee  leans  to  a  belief  that  arti- 
ficial ventilation  is  usually  unnecessary  in  American  steam  railway  tunnels 
of  less  length  than  2,000  to  2,500  ft.,  and  that  probably  the  most  efficient 
form  of  artificial  ventilation  for  American  steam  railway  tunnels  is  to 
force  air  into  one  end  of  the  tunnel  by  fans  powerful  enough  to  drive  the 
smoke  out  ahead  of  the  train.  This  method  was  adopted  for  the  Elkhorn 
tunnel  on  Norfolk  &  Western  Railway  and  is  admirably  described  by  Mr. 
Chas.  S.  Churchill  in  the  Transactions  of  American  Society  of  Civil  Engi- 
neers, Vol.  54,  part  C.  Plants  similar  to  that  constructed  for  the  Elkhorn 
tunnel  have  been  installed  as  shown  by  the  record  given  as  Appendix  A. 
As  typical  single  track  tunnels  carrying  a  moderate  traffic,  there  is  included 
in  Appendix  A  a  record  as  to  the  clearing  of  smoke  in  three  single  track 
tunnels  on  the  Louisville  &  Nashville  Railroad.  The  Committee  has  advice 
that  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad  Company  is  now  experimenting  on 
single  and  double  track  tunnel  ventilation,  but  the  various  methods  used 
in  the  different  tunnels  are  at  such  great  variance  that  no  conclusion  has 
as  yet  been  reached. 

(4)  REPORT  ON  THE  QUESTION  OF  AGRICULTURAL  DRAIN- 

AGE AS  IT  AFFECTS  RAILWAYS. 

W.  C.  Curd,  Chairman ;  T.  H.  Gatlin,  John  G.  Sullivan,  Sub-Committee. 

The  Committee  during  the  past  two  years  collected  information  as  to 
the  drainage  laws  of  the  various  states,  but  has  never  been  able  to  fix 
upon  a  form  into  which  the  information  can  be  put  so  as  to  make  it  of 
value  to  the  Association.  The  Committee  is  of  the  opinion  that  further 
work  along  the  line  of  collecting  information  as  to  (a)  Laws  and  Assess- 


ROADWAY.  397 

ments  is  futile  because  the  laws  are  changing  constantly,  and  because  the 
Committee's  information  is  necessarily  general  and  not  subject  to  applica- 
tion to  specific  cases  without  legal  advice;  and  further,  questions  affecting 
the  laws  and  assessments  are,  in  all  railway  organizations,  handled  by  the 
railway's  attorneys.  The  Committee  recommends  that  it  be  discharged 
from  further  consideration  of  the  subject  as  to  Laws  and  Assessments. 

RECOMMENDATIONS  FOR  1012. 

Your  Committee  recommends  that  Subjects  1,  2  and  3  be  reassigned 
and  that  further  consideration  of  subject  4  be  confined  to  the  benefits  to 
the  roadway  to  be  derived  by  the  construction  of  agricultural  drainage 
ditches  and  levees. 

Your  Committee  believes  that  certain  additions  can  be  made  to  the 
specifications  as  now  printed  in  the  Manual,  for  example,  the  sodding  of 
slopes  of  cuts  and  fills. 

Your  Committee  directs  attention  to  a  resolution  passed  at  its  meet- 
ing on  November  28 : 

"Resolved,  That  the  Board  of  Direction  be  requested  to  set  aside  an 
appropriation  and  to  appoint  a  special  committee  consisting  of  members 
of  the  Roadway,  Ballast  and  Track  Committees,  to  make  experiments  to 
determine  the  magnitude  and  distribution  of  the  load  transmitted  to  the 
roadbed  through  ballast  of  various  kinds  and  also  to  determine  by  test 
the  bearing  power  of  various  materials  under  varying  conditions  ordinarily 
found  in  the  construction  of  the  roadway." 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE    ON    ROADWAY. 


Appendix    A. 

RECORD  OF  TUNNEL  VENTILATION. 

Under  Plans  of  Chas.  S.  Churchill  and  C.  C.  Wentworth. 


Location  of  Tunnel 

Date  of 
Installa- 
tion 

Rate  of 
Grade 

Loca- 
tion of 
Fans 

Length 

of  Tun- !  Section 

nel,         Sq.  Ft. 

Ft..   J 

1 

Con- 
tents 
Cu.  Ft. 

Cu.  Ft. 
Air  de- 
livered 
per  min. 
through 
Tunnel 

Remarks 

N.  &  W.  Ry. 
Elkhorn,  Coaldale.W.Va 

6-01 

+1-4%E 

Lower 
End 

3000 

ST235 

705000 

400000 

Train  ton  rating 
inc.  in  1901,  100 
tons. 

C.  &  0.  Ry. 

Big  Bend,  E.  Hinton,  W. 

Va 

12-02 

§Igth 
+0.4%E 

Upper 
End 

6500 

ST250 

1625000 

300000 

Train  ton  rating 
inc.  228  tons. 

P.  R.  R. 

Gallitzin,    W.     Altoona, 
Pa 

4-05 

+0.5%  W 

Lower 
End 

! 

3600    1    ST324 

1166400 

502000 

P.  R.  R. 

Washington,  D.  C,  Sta- 

12-07 

+0.13%S 

Upper 
End 

Tubes     1  tube 

4050     !       260 
Sta.  760  2  6  tracks 

3371800 

640000 

2  tubes,  520  sq. 
ft.  Station  end 
variable. 

P.  R.  R. 

North  and  East  Rivers, 
N.  Y.   .. 

9-10 

Special 
vent,  of 

installat 
tubes  th 

ion  14  fa 
at  are  41 

ns   for    e 
35  ft.  to 

225 

mergen 
7357   ft. 

cy    uses 

40000  to 

111000 

B.  &  0.  R.  R. 

Kingwood  Tunnelton,  W. 
Va 

12-10 

+1.0%E 

Lower 
End 

4138 

ST352 

1458000 

600000 

Train  ton  rating 
inc.  450  tons. 

C.  &  0.  Ry. 

Lewis,  Alleghany,  Va.  . . 

6-11 

+1.14%W 

Lower 
End 

4026 

ST318 

1280200 

508800 

N.  Y.  C.  Lines 

Weehawken,  N.  J 

8-11 

+  0.25%E 

Lower 
End 

4365 

DT469 

2047200 

512000 

144  trains  per 
day. 

P    R.  R. 

B.  &  P.  Tunnel,  Balti- 

9-11 

+  1.32%S 

Upper 
End 

4963 

DT432 

2150000 

500000 

193  trains  per 
day. 

Letter  of  R.   C.   Morrison,   Superintendent,   Louisville   &   Nashville 

Railroad. 
There  has  never  been  any  trouble  to  trainmen  from  smoke  in  either 
Dossett  or  Solway  tunnels,  excepting  in  one  instance ;  about  three  months 
ago  an  engineer  on  the  second  engine  of  a  heavily  loaded  double-headed 
freight  train  claims  to  have  been  overcome  by  the  gases  while  passing 
through  Solway  tunnel.     We  did  not  consider  this  claim  very  seriously. 

398 


ROADWAY.  399 

It  was  evidently  a  strike  on  the  part  of  the  engineer  against  double-head- 
ing. 

In  clear  weather  after  No.  32  passes  through  these  tunnels  if  no  firing 
is  done  immediately  before  entering  the  tunnels  or  during  the  passage 
through  the  tunnels,  it  leaves  the  tunnel  practically  clear,  whereas  after 
a  southbound  freight  train  it  takes  from  ten  to  fifteen  minutes  for  the 
tunnels  to  clear  sufficiently  to  see  through  them. 

Damp  weather  affects  the  clearing  of  these  tunnels  very  much.  In 
fact,  during  very  damp  weather,  doing  an  ordinary  business  Dossett  tun- 
nel never  gets  entirely  clear.  This  does  not  apply  so  much  in  the  case  of 
Solway  tunnel,  as  this  tunnel  seems  to  clear  itself  better  of  smoke  thanj 
any  tunnel  I  have  ever  known,  considering  the  length. 

We  keep  our  trains  ten  minutes  apart  passing  through  both  of  these 
tunnels,  both  tunnels  being  protected  by  electric  blocks.  I  am  inclined  to 
believe  that  the  smoke  in  both  of  these  tunnels  comes  out  from  the  far 
end  in  the  direction  the  train  is  moving,  that  is,  when  a  train  passes 
through  the  tunnel,  it  starts  up  a  current  of  air  that  seems  to  continue 
after  the  train  has  passed  and  has  a  tendency  to  draw  the  smoke  through 
the  tunnel  after  the  train. 

During  our  heaviest  business  we  have  never  been  bothered  with  delay 
to  traffic  on  account  of  smoke  in  either  of  these  tunnels. 

We  have  no  established  rules  or  instructions  governing  the  method  of 
firing  while  passing  through  tunnels.  It  is  customary  on  heavily  loaded 
freight  trains,  southbound,  to  put  in  a  heavy  fire  going  into  either  of  these 
tunnels.  It  is  very  seldom  necessary  while  passing  through  Dossett  tun- 
nel, but,  on  heavily  loaded  freight  trains,  they  do  have  to  put  in  a  fire  once 
and  sometimes  twice  while  in  Solway  tunnel. 

For  the  first  two  weeks  in  October,  average  number  of  trains  passing 
through  these  tunnels  per  24  hours  was  23.  Our  business,  however,  is  a  lit- 
tle light.  I  think  I  would  be  safe  in  saying  that  we  could  successfully 
operate  fifty  trains  per  day  through  these  tunnels  without  the  air  becoming 
so  foul  as  to  delay  traffic. 

Length  of  Dossett  tunnel  3,520  ft.,  single  track.  Grade  0.50  per  cent, 
rising  to  south.    Train  32  is  northbound  limited  train. 

Length  of  Solway  tunnel  2,170  ft.,  single  track.  Grade  0.50  per  cent. 
rising  to  south.    The  construction  shafts  in  both  tunnels  were  closed. 

Letter  of  E.  E.  Snyder,  Superintendent,  Louisville  &  Nashville 

Railroad. 

Muldraugh  tunnel  is  on  an  ascending  grade  to  the  south  of  70.3  ft. 
per  mile.  We  regard  the  tunnel  as  a  quick  clearing  one  from  smoke  and 
gases.  The  hardest  feature  is  on  a  southbound  double-heading  train  when 
the  crew  of  the  second  engine  gets  a  good  dose.  All  southbound  full  ton- 
nage trains  and  our  through  passenger  trains  are  double-headed,  helping 
engine  in  front. 

There  is  a  little  smoke  and  gas  after  a  northbound  freight  train  but 
not  a  great  deal  as  the  trains  roll  and  there  is  but  little  exhaust.     North- 


400 


ROADWAY. 


bound  passenger  trains  do  not  work  steam  through  the  tunnel.  The  help- 
ing engine  always  goes  through  the  tunnel  and  is  cut  off  at  Tunnel  Hill. 
We  have  about  40  train  movements,  divided  one-half  north  and  one-half 
south,  per  day,  not  including  the  return  movement  of  the  helping  engine. 

Letter  of  J.  F.  Burns,  Roadmaster,  Louisville  &  Nashville  Railroad.., 

In  regard  to  smoke  in  Muldraugh's  tunnel,  M.  S.  First  Division.  I  at- 
tach a  statement  showing  the  action  of  the  smoke  after  passage  of  south- 
bound trains  on  the  7th  inst.  (October  7,  1911),  from  which  it  appears  that 
tiains  are  from  one  minute  to  two  minutes  in  going  through  the  tunnel 
and  the  tunnel  is  clear  of  smoke  in  from  seven  to  twelve  minutes.  It  so 
happened  that  the  smoke  was  longest  in  clearing  after  passenger  train  5 
with  a  Ki  engine,  and  the  shortest  time  was  with  a  double-heading  freight 
train.  I  consider  this  tunnel  as  very  quick  clearing.  As  trains  are  never 
closer  together  than  fifteen  minutes  in  the  tunnel,  one  train  never  has  dis- 
advantage from  the  smoke  of  a  preceding  train. 

ACTION  OF  SMOKE  IN   MULDRAUGH's  TUNNEL. 

Main  Stem  First  Division  After  Passage  of  Southbound  Trains  on 
7th  of  October,  191 1. 


Time  Train  Going 

Time  After  Engine  Got 

No.  of  Train 

Engine 

Through  Tunnel 

Through  Tunnel  Until 

Clear  of  Smoke 

73 

1112  and  848 

2  minutes 

7  minutes 

2nd  73 

1107  and  848 

2  minutes 

8  minutes 

31 

881 

1J  minutes 

9  minutes 

5  Passenger 

153 

1  minute 

12  minutes 

2nd  5 

124  and  849 

1  minute 

11  minutes 

17 

731  and  849 

1J  minutes 

9  minutes 

75 

1176  and  849 

2  minutes 

10  minutes 

2nd  75 

709  and  848 

1J  minutes 

8  minutes 

REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  XIII— ON  WATER  SERVICE. 

Robert  Ferriday,  Chairman;  J.  L.  Campbell,  Vice-Chair  man; 

James  Burke.  E.  G.  Lane. 

H.  M.  Church.  G.  C.  Millett. 

C.  C.  Cook.  A.  Mordecai. 

G.  M.  Davidson.  W.  A.  Parker. 

A.  F.  Dorley.  C.  L.  Ransom. 

G.  H.  Herrold.  Chas.  E.  Thomas. 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Raihvay  Engineering  Association: 

The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  the  following  subjects  to  your  Com- 
mittee : 

(i)  Report  on  the  design  and  relative  economy  of  track  pans  from 
an  operating  standpoint. 

(2)  Present  typical  plans  and  specifications  for  tank  supports. 

(3)  Report  on  the  use  of  reinforced  concrete  for  water  tanks  and 
supports. 

Three  meetings  were  held,  all  of  them  in  the  Secretary's  office :  June 
21,  August  28,  October  30,  191 1. 

It  was  decided,  since  the  subject  of  "Water  Tanks,"  including  sup- 
ports, had  been  under  consideration  so  long,  to  request  the  Board  to  drop 
subject  No.  2  and  substitute  "Deep  Well  Pumps,"  approval  of  which  was 
given  later. 

A  Sub-Committee  on  Water  Treatment  was  appointed  with  the  idea 
that  your  Committee  should  have  such  a  sub-committee  every  year  whose 
duties  would  be  to  keep  informed  of  the  progress  in  this  subject,  and  make 
reports  as  seemed  desirable.  The  Board  was  asked  to  request  G.  M. 
Davidson  to  become  a  member  of  your  Committee,  and  he  was  appointed 
chairman  of  this  sub-committee  pending  such  arrangement. 

Sub-Committee  A  met  at  Painesville,  Ohio,  August  19,  and  the  filling, 
heating  and  drainage  systems  of  the  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern 
Railway  track  pan  installation  at  that  point  was  explained  by  Mr.  M.  U. 
Baillierre,  Assistant  Engineer,  who  had  charge  of  the  construction  of  the 
track  pans,  plans  of  which  were  included  in  the  191 1  Proceedings. 

Sub-Committee  B  met  in  the  Secretary's  office  August  4  and 
December  9. 

The  subjects  in  the  hands  of  your  Committee  stand  as  follows: 

REVISION  OF  THE  MANUAL. 

No  changes  to  recommend  until  the  Association  decides  on  the  future 
policy  now  under  consideration. 

401 


402  WATER  SERVICE. 

(i)  THE  DESIGN  AND  RELATIVE  ECONOMY  OF  TRACK  PANS 
FROM  AN  OPERATING  STANDPOINT. 
Report  progress.  No  further  report  is  made  for  the  reason  that  such 
additional  data  as  can  be  secured  is  from  elaborate  tests  made  by  the 
Pennsylvania  Railroad  at  Atglen,  Pa.,  which  are  not  yet  available.  Your 
Committee  also  hope  to  secure  report  prepared  for  a  Special  Commitfee 
of  the  New  York  Central  Lines  by  G.  W.  Vaughan,  Engineer  Main- 
tenance of  Way  of  that  railway. 

(2)    DEEP  WELL  PUMPS. 
Report   progress.     This    subject   has    not   been    developed    sufficiently 
to  report  otherwise. 

(3)     USE  OF  REINFORCED   CONCRETE   FOR   WATER   TANKS 
AND   SUPPORTS. 
Complete  report  is  hereinafter  submitted  with  the  request  that  it  be 
received  as  information. 

(4)    WATER  TREATMENT. 

Report  progress. 

In  view  of  the  brevity  of  its  report,  your  Committee  desires  to  sub- 
mit in  Appendix  "A,"  for  the  information  of  the  Association,  a  paper 
prepared  at  its  request  by  J.  R.  Francis,  regarding  an  unusual  occurrence 
of  locomotive  boiler  corrosion  which  followed  a  partial  installation  of 
water  softeners.  It  is  quite  possible  the  same  trouble  may  be  experienced 
by  our  members  under  similar  conditions,  and  information  regarding  the 
means  for  overcoming  it  will  be  of  value. 

Your  Committee  also  have  canvassed  the  membership  for  opinions 
and  criticism  of  the  General  Specifications  for  Steel  Tanks  submitted 
last  year,  and  same  have  been  revised  and  are  submitted  with  the  recom- 
mendation that  they  be  adopted  and  published  in  the  Manual. 

THE  USE  OF  REINFORCED  CONCRETE  FOR  RAILWAY  WATER 
TANKS  AND  SUPPORTS. 

As  part  of  its  work  for  the  year  1910,  the  Water  Service  Committee 
was  directed  by  the  Association  to  prepare  plans  and  specifications  for  a 
reinforced  concrete  water  tank.  The  result  of  the  Committee's  work  is 
published  as  information  in  the  191 1  Proceedings. 

For  the  year  191 1,  the  Committee  is  directed  to  report  on  the  use  of 
reinforced  concrete  for  water  tanks  and  supports. 

Many  reinforced  concrete  tanks  have  been  built  in  America  and 
Europe  ranging  in  capacity  from  10,000  gals,  to  more  than  1,000,000  gals, 
each.  Published  descriptions  of  a  large  number  of  these  can  be  found 
by  reference  to  the  Engineering  Index.  A  list  of  about  50  of  them  is 
published  on  page  124  of  the  Engineering  News  of  July  27,  191 1. 

In  connection  with  the  construction  of  a  new  concentrator,  the  Macte- 
zuma  Copper  Company,  Nacozari,  Sonora,  Mexico,  built  128  reinforced 
concrete  tanks  of  10,000  gals,  capacity  each  for  water  and  concentrates. 


WATER  SERVICE.  403 

They  are  water-tight  except  a  little  sweating  around  a  few  of  the  pipe 
connections  in  the  tank  bottom.  These  tanks  are  12  ft.  in  diameter  and 
12  ft.  high.  The  form  was  erected  complete  and  each  tank  was  poured 
in  one  operation,  thereby  eliminating  joints  in  the  shell,  which  is  6  in. 
thick.  The  bottom  is  12  in.  thick.  A  very  rich  concrete  was  used.  All 
of  the  stone  would  pass  through  a  screen  having  J^-in.  mesh.  The  steel 
in  the  shell  is  stressed  11,400  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  not  considering  the  tensile 
strength  of  the  concrete.  At  the  bottom  of  the  tank  the  concrete  in  the 
shell  is  stressed  only  6s  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  without  assistance  from  the  steel. 
The  concrete  in  these  tanks  can  carry  that  stress  without  breaking.  Con- 
sequently, the  stress  is  doubtless  divided  between  the  steel  and  the  con- 
crete and  the  unit  stress  must  be  very  low.  The  vertical  reinforcement 
of  the  shell  consists  of  ^-in.  rods  spaced  12  in.  c.  to  c. 

Reinforced  concrete  tanks  have  been  built  either  as  slandpipes  or  as 
elevated  tanks  on  concrete  towers. 

The  advantages  are : 

(1)  Low  maintenance  cost. 

(2)  Great  durability. 

This  may  be  true  only  of  well-designed,  well-built  and  water-tight 
tanks. 

The  disadvantages  are : 

(1)  Innovation  in  railway  service. 

(2)  Imperfections  in  materials  and  workmanship. 

(3)  Greater  first  cost. 

(4)  Porosity  of  the  concrete. 

(5)  Shrinkage  of  the  concrete. 

(6)  Stretch  of  the  concrete. 

(7)  Difficulty  of  waterproofing. 

(8)  Effect  of  frost  on  saturated  concrete. 

(9)  Ugliness. 

(10)  Immovability. 

No.  1  will  be  removed  in  time  if  the  concrete  tank  develops  sufficient 
merit. 

No.  2  is  more  incidental  than  fundamental,  but  the  making  of  a  strictly 
uniform  high-grade  monolithic  concrete  construction  without  local  imper- 
fections is  difficult  and  requires  highly  efficient  workmanship. 

No.  3  may  be  justified  by  the  advantages  named.  It  can  be  shown  in 
some  cases  that  a  reinforced  concrete  tank  costs  less  than  a  steel  tank  of 
like  capacity,  but  in  such  cases  the  design  is  probably  sparing  in  the  use 
of  steel  and  concrete.  A  thin  shell  and  a  high  stress  in  the  steel  are  liable 
to  result  in  a  leaky  tank.  Generally,  when  the  stress  in  the  steel  is  low 
enough  and  the  tank  shell  thick  enough  to  insure  against  leakage,  the 
cost  of  a  reinforced  concrete  tank  will  be  greater  than  that  of  a  steel  tank. 

No.  4  is  the  root  of  much  of  the  trouble  with  the  concrete  tank.  It 
is  not  an  insurmountable  difficulty.  'Careful  selection  and  grading  of 
sand  and  stone,  liberal  use  of  cement,  complete  and  uniform  mixing  and 
proper  placing  will  make  a  concrete  impervious  under  the  pressures  re- 
quired   for   railway   water   service.     Serious    leaks    will    be    due    to    local 


404  WATER  SERVICE. 

imperfections  rather  than  to  porosity  if  the  tank  has  been  well-designed 
and  constructed  of  a  proper  grade  of  concrete. 

No.  5  is  a  more  fundamental  difficulty.  Shrinkage  of  concrete  in 
setting  is  inevitable  and  it  is  increased  by  the  large  proportion  of  cement 
required  in  water  tank  construction.  This  frequently  produces  cracks, 
especially  along  the  joints  between  successive  courses  of  concrete.  Care- 
ful and  proper  making  of  the  joints  and  judicious  steel  reinforcement  are 
necessary  to  prevent  serious  shrinkage  cracks.  The  steel  dam  mentioned 
in  the  accompanying  general  specifications  is  a  desirable  thing  in  the 
joints  when  the  concrete  in  the  first  half  of  the  joint  has  hardened  before 
the  concrete  in  the  second  half  is  placed. 

No.  6  is  a  serious  difficulty  in  the  shell  of  the  tank  due  to  elasticity 
of  the  steel  reinforcement  and  its  stretch  under  the  water  load.  Any  con- 
crete, however  dense  and  impervious  in  its  unstrained  condition,  can  be 
stretched  beyond  its  breaking  strength  and  fine  cracks  through  which  water 
will  flow  under  pressure  may  be  opened  therein  by  stressing  the  steel  within 
the  elastic  limit  of  the  latter.  If  the  tank  could  be  maintained  constantly 
full  of  water  the  moderate  leakage  due  to  such  stretch  would  generally 
stop  through  deposits  of  suspended  matter  from  the  filtering  water.  In 
some  cases  this  would  be  assisted  by  chemical  precipitation.  But,  under 
general  service  conditions  there  is  a  wide  fluctuation  of  pressure  and  the 
elastic  recovery  of  the  steel  as  the  pressure  drops  appears  to  break  down 
the  plugging  action  of  the  leakage  above  indicated  in  those  cases  where 
the  steel  is  stretched  materially  beyond  the  breaking  point  of  the  concrete. 

Herein  appears  to  lie  a  formidable  handicap  of  the  concrete  tank  as 
a  competitor  of  the  steel  tank  on  the  basis  of  cost.  The  effectual  remedy 
appears  to  be  the  combination  of  that  low  stress  in  the  steel  with  that 
increased  thickness  of  the  shell  which  will  limit  the  stretch  of  the  concrete 
so  that  cracks  permitting  the  filtration  of  water  will  not  be  opened.  That 
increases  the  cost  of  concrete  and  steel,  making  the  latter  approach  the 
cost  of  steel  in  a  steel  tank. 

Your  Committee  is  of  the  opinion  that  the  ultimate  stress  of  the  steel 
without  assistance  from  the  tensile  strength  of  the  concrete  should  not 
exceed  10,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  and  that  the  minimum  thickness  in  inches 
of  the  concrete  at  any  point  should  be  such  that  when  the  total  tensile 
stress  due  to  water  load  at  that  point  is  diminished,  by  3,000  times  the 
sectional  area  in  sq.  in.  of  the  steel  at  that  point,  the  remaining  water  load 
will  stress  the  concrete  at  that  point  300  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  provided  that  in 
no  case  shall  the  thickness  of  concrete  be  less  than  4  in.  Your  Committee 
does  not  say  that  concrete  will  not  break  under  a  tensile  stress  of  300  lbs. 
per  sq.  in.,  although  experiments  indicate  that  concrete  of  the  high  grade 
required  for  tank  construction  may  have  an  ultimate  tensile  strength  of 
400  to  500  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

This  specification  as  to  thickness  of  concrete  is  an  arbitrary  one  in- 
tended to  secure  a  minimum  and  reasonable  thickness  somewhat  in  excess 
of  the  thickness  of  concrete  in  tanks  already  constructed  in  which  the 
stress  in  the  steel  has  been  12,000  lbs.  or  more  per  sq.  in.,  resulting  in 
some  leakage.     The  primary  object  is  to  secure  a  minimum  thickness  of 


WATER  SERVICE.  405 

wall  in  which  tension  cracks,  if  any,  will  be  localized  and  minute  and 
through  which  it  would  be  difficult  for  water  to  pass.  The  size  and  the 
arrangement  of  the  reinforcing  rods  have  an  important  bearing  on  the 
minimum  permissible  thickness  of  concrete.  The  shrinkage  of  the  con- 
crete around  large  rods  in  a  thin  wall  is  liable  to  crack  the  concrete. 

The  trouble  from  stretch  of  the  concrete  raises  the  question  as  to  the 
practicability  of  designing  a  tank  shell  to  be  in  compression.  This  could 
be  accomplished  by  building  the  shell  as  a  series  of  short,  flat,  abutting 
arches  convex  to  the  center  of  the  tank  with  the  reinforcing  steel  sup- 
ported by  exterior  pilasters  forming  the  abutments  of  the  arches,  as  indi- 
cated in  the  suggested  plan  and  elevation  of  a  section  of  concrete  tank 
shell  designed  to  be  in  compression  appearing  on  the  accompanying  draw- 
ing, showing  a  general  plan  and  general  section  for  a  suggested  concrete 
standpipe.  The  radius  of  the  arches  may  readily  be  proportioned  to 
make  the  total  compression  in  the  concrete  equal  to  the  total  tension  in 
the  steel.  The  reinforcing  rods  between  the  pilasters  may  be  covered  by 
metal  lath  and  cement  plaster.  The  density  and  imperviousness  of  the 
concrete  in  the  arches  would  be  increased  by  the  water  load.  The 
polygonal  form  of  the  tank  with  its  recessed  panels  would  break  the 
monotony  of  a  plain  cylinder  and  give  the  tank  an  improved  appearance. 
Doubtless  difficulties  would  arise  in  the  execution  of  such  a  design,  but 
without  going  into  details,  the  suggestion  is  offered  for  what  it  is  worth. 

No.  7  arises  from  4,  5  and  6.  The  problem  is  to  find  some  foreign 
substance  which,  when  incorporated  with  the  concrete,  will  close  the  per- 
centage of  voids  found  even  in  the  best  grade  of  concrete,  or,  when  applied 
to  the  surface,  will  be  impervious  and  will  not  crack  or  peel  off.  In  either 
case  the  trouble  is  aggravated  and  the  waterproofing  largely  nullified  by 
the  shrinking  and  stretching  of  the  concrete  unless  the  latter  is  properly 
reinforced  against  shrinkage  and  stretch.  Tanks  in  service  prove  that 
it  is  practicable  to  make  concrete  impervious  under  ordinary  tank  pressures 
by  proper  selection,  grading  and  mixing  of  materials.  Soap  and  alum 
incorporated  with  the  concrete  in  the  making  and  applied  as  washes  to  the 
surface  are  probably  the  best  proved  and  most  efficient  materials  for 
effective  waterproofing  of  concrete. 

No.  8  is  a  danger  which  will  be  eliminated  by  successful  solution  of 
waterproofing.  Since  the  latter  will  require  as  its  base  a  very  dense  con- 
crete, the  quantity  of  water  passing  through  the  latter  will  be  so  small 
that  the  action  of  frost  can  have  little  or  no  effect  on  such  close  grained 
and  practically  dry  concrete.  It  is  a  fact,  however,  that  in  our  northern 
latitudes  much  disintegration  of  porous  concrete  on  the  water  line  of  lakes 
and  streams  due  to  the  annual  effect  of  the  frost  season  is  apparent. 

Ugliness  is  a  sin  chargeable  to  some  railway  structures  other  than 
water  tanks.  Perhaps  a  little  additional  homeliness  is  not  unpardonable 
if  saved  by  the  grace  of  utility.  Monolithic  concrete,  especially  a  form- 
marked,  joint-marked,  leaky  efflorescent  tank  shell  possesses  a  lack  of 
beauty  which  is  not  hidden  by  frills.  The  attainment  of  a  water-tight 
tank  requires  a  high  grade  of  material  and  work  which  will  go  far  toward 
making  concrete  tanks  presentable  in  appearance. 


406  WATER  SERVICE. 

An  irremovable  objection  to  the  concrete  tank  is  its  immovability.  A 
wooden  tank  and  even  a  steel  tank  can  be  and  such  tanks  are  moved  from 
place  to  place  to  meet  changing  requirements  of  railway  water  supply. 
Discovery  of  new  and  better  water  supplies  sometimes  makes  changes 
in  locations  of  tanks  desirable.  A  concrete  tank  should  be  located  only 
at  those  points  where  there  is  no  probability  of  change. 

Considering  the  obvious  merits  of  the  concrete  tank,  this  Committee 
sees  no  reason  why  railways  engaged  in  permanent  reconstructions  for 
fixed  water  supplies  should  not  favorably  consider  a  beginning  in  rein- 
forced concrete  tank  construction.  Water- tightness  is  the  important 
problem.     The  stability  of  this  form  of  construction  is  well  established. 

Many  existing  concrete  tanks  are  practically  water-tight.  Generally, 
leakage  is  immaterial  in  amount  and  objectionable  principally  as  a  matter 
of  appearance  and  a  possible  danger  account  of  frost.  It  is  more  often 
the  result  of  local  imperfections,  bad  joints,  and  a  thin  shell  and  a  high 
stress  in  the  steel  than  porosity  and  permeability  in  a  proper  grade  of 
concrete. 

Your  Committee  submits  as  information : 

(i)  General  Specifications  for  Reinforced  Concrete  Standpipe  Water 
Tanks  for  Railways.  No  plans  of  tank  are  submitted  with  these  speci- 
fications. 

(2)     Suggestive  sketches  consisting  of: 

An  elevation  and  section  of  reinforced  concrete  standpipe  tank. 

A  section  through  valve  box  in  the  foundation. 

A  plan  and  elevation  for  reinforced  concrete  tank  shell  designed  to  be 
in  compression. 

An  elevation  and  section  of  reinforced  concrete  tank  on  a  reinforced 
concrete  substructure. 

A  plan,  elevation  and  section  of  reinforced  concrete  substructure. 

The  tank  should  be  located  away  from  the  main  line  track  and  should 
deliver  water  to  engines  through  water  columns. 

If  a  roof  is  required,  it  should  be  built  as  shown.  Where  ice  will 
not  form  to  an  injurious  or  troublesome  extent  and  sunlight  will  not 
cause  vegetable  growth  in  the  water,  the  roof  may  be  omitted. 

For  a  given  amount  of  available  storage  and  considering  piping,  frost- 
proofing,  and  collection  and  disposal  of  sludge,  the  standpipe  is  simpler 
and  more  economical  than  a  tank  on  a  tower,  notwithstanding  it  is  prac- 
ticable to  erect  a  concrete  tower  20  ft.  high  including  foundation  at  an 
expense  less  than  the  cost  of  the  foundation  and  lower  20  ft.  of  a  concrete 
standpipe.  This  refers  to  railway  service.  For  quantities  of  water  re- 
quired only  at  higher  elevations,  the  concrete  tower  may  readily  be  more 
economical  than  the  standpipe. 

The  construction  of  the  concrete  tank  on  the  concrete  substructure 
would  not  differ  materially  from  that  of  the  concrete  standpipe,  and  the 
general  specifications  for  the  latter  may  be  applied  generally  to  the  former. 

The  substructure  may  also  be  used  for  supporting  tanks  of  wood  or 
steel.  Its  general  design  consists  of  an  octagonal  foundation  slab  and  an 
octagonal   deck  slab,  the  latter  being  carried  on  the  reinforced   columns 


WATER  SERVICE. 


407 


GENERAL  ELEVATION. 

Fig.    i — Suggested    General    Plan    for   a   Reinforced    Concrete    Sub- 
structure and  a  Reinforced  Concrete  Water  Tank. 
(Substructure  may  be  used  for  Wood  or  Steel  Tanks.) 


408 


WATER  SERVICE. 


S3         RS^s 


TANK. 


**,^WM'A-^ 


P/PF&M/L  1//T  WFLL 


^—^^—-^^mM 


p**p^**^  I J  j| >»„,„„„„ 

X 


GENERAL  SECTION  ON  A-  B. 

Fig.    2 — Suggested    General    Plan    for   a    Reinforced    Concrete    Sub- 
structure and  a  Reinforced  Concrete  Water  Tank. 
(Substructure  may  be  used  for  Wood  or  Steel  Tanks.) 


-safe..; 


y£'V3f'\  \  '«  '  '.  !  I  i  •  ■'  i 'SRvS\ 

y^\     X<V\    'v    \    \    1     ill'     '    /     '   /    /     -*vSX    '^V 

/-!  - '->'    X   \  \  \  >  x>  .  \  \ '  '.  I ;  /  f '  i  '  i  /  /  ■''  /  -^xvV* 


-J-jj-!-> _~ 

-l-i-frf —       —"'"'-- -%'-J 

vSK\  /     /  /  /  ///ft 

X^;<<  /  /  ////ft   l 
N^oXn.-'  ////ft 

^  ■  ^>*\\'    /     *  I  I  I   ! 

<^-V  /  i :  ! 


!    !   '.  \  \  \  \  x/s/rs 


!  \  \  \  >i%'3 

I 

HALF   DECK  AND  HALF  FOUNDATION  PLAN 
OF  SUBSTRUCTURE 

SHOWING     REINFORCEMENT 

i     <-Dec/f. 


--  mii/imuiiiii'""11"1 


Dqor 


4— 


6 


P/p^  notes-. 

■  6  cP 


Foundation 


>»WlW,'>W)niijWftf 


'  '  ■'■■'■Ulllll/U/IM 


ELEVATION  OF  SUBSTRUCTURE. 

Fig.    3 — Suggested    General    Plan    for   a    Reinforced    Concrete    Sue- 
structure  and  a  Reinforced  Concrete  Water  Tank. 
(Substructure  may  be  used  for  Wood  or  Steel  Tanks.) 


410 


WATER  SERVICE. 


GENERAL  ELEVATION 

Fig.  4 — Suggested  General  Design  for  a  Reinforced  Concrete 
Standpipe. 


WATER  SERVICE. 


411 


GENERAL  SECTION 

Fig.  s — 'Suggested  General  Design  for  a  Reinforced  Concrete 
Standpipe. 


412 


WATER  SERVICE. 


-ftodsmaybe  cohered  &u 
cement  morfar  on  meter  bfh. 


±£S 


-44 


3E 


SUGGESTED  PLAN  AND  ELEVATION  FOR  A 

CONCRETE  TANKSHELL  DESIGNED  TO  BE 

IN  COMPRESSION 


SUGGESTED  SECTION 
THROUGH  VALVE  BOX 

Fig.  6— Suggested  General  Design  for  a  Reinforced  Concrete 
Standpipe. 


WATER  SERVICE.  413 

and  the  central  pipe  and  valve  well  resting  on  the  foundation.  The  plan 
shows  the  general  arrangement  of  the  reinforcement.  The  foundation 
slab  distributes  the  load  under  its  entire  area,  keeps  the  unit  load  low 
and  is  favorable  to  uniform  settlement,  if  any.  On  a  rock  foundation 
this  slab  may  be  omitted.  The  central  well  serves  for  enclosing  and  frost- 
proofing  the  piping  and  valves,  helps  to  support  the  deck  and  makes  the 
entire  sub  and  superstructure  stable  against  wind  pressure  without  assist- 
ance from  the  surrounding  columns.  The  plan  contemplates  a  substruc- 
ture not  more  than  20  ft.  high  above  the  ground,  in  which  case  the  col- 
umns require  no  lateral  bracing.  In  the  construction  of  the  substructure 
the  ordinary  approved  building  loads,  stresses,  materials  and  workman- 
ship for  reinforced  concrete  are  acceptable  and  sufficient.  The  question 
of  waterproofing  does  not  enter  unless  it  is  desired  to  make  the  deck 
slab  the  bottom  of  the  tank  when  the  latter  is  made  of  concrete. 

These  general  plans  are  submitted,  not  as  those  which  should  be 
adopted,  but  as  suggestions  for  a  number  of  good  designs  which  could 
be  made. 

GENERAL  SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  A  REINFORCED  CONCRETE 
STANDPIPE  WATER  TANK  FOR  RAILWAYS. 

NO    PLANS    SUBMITTED. 

Definitions. 

1.  The  words  "company,"  "engineer,"  "as  shown,"  "drawings,"  and 
"this  Association,"  appearing  in  these  specifications  are  defined  as  follows : 

"Company"  means  the  railway  company  building  a  tank  under  these 
specifications. 

"Engineer"  means  the  engineer  of  the  company. 

"As  shown"  means  as  shown  on  the  drawings. 

"Drawings"  means  the  drawings  of  the  tank  herein  specified  and 
forming  a  part  of  these  specifications,  including  such  working  drawings 
as  the  engineer  shall  prepare  or  approve. 

"This  Association"  means  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Asso- 
ciation. ,'■.(■! 

Kind. 

2.  This  tank  shall  be  of  reinforced  concrete  as  shown. 
Excavations. 

3.  In  earth,  excavation  for  the  foundation  should  be  as  deep  as  the 
lowest  frost  line.  In  rock,  only  the  excavation  for  the  valve  box  should 
be  carried  below  the  action  of  frost.  In  earth,  the  bottom  of  the  excava- 
tions should  be  thoroughly  tamped.  If  the  earth  will  not  sustain  the 
total  load,  including  wind  pressure,  without  material  or  unequal  settle- 
ment, the  foundation  should  be  supported  on  piles  of  the  number,  size  and 
arrangement  as  determined  by  the  engineer.  Such  piles  should  conform 
to  the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  piling  as  selected  by  the 
engineer. 


414  WATER  SERVICE. 

Foundation. 

4.  The  foundation  should  be  monolithic  concrete  of  the  form  and 
dimensions  as  shown.  If  the  depth  of  frost  is  excessive  the  foundation 
may  be  carried  on  broken  rock  uniformly  compacted  in  the  bottom  of  the 
excavation.  The  top  of  the  foundation  should  be  above  the  surface  of 
the  ground. 

Floor. 

5.  The  tank  floor  shall  be  constructed  on  the  foundation  as  shown. 

Valve  Box. 

6.  The  valve  box  shall  be  constructed  as  shown.  When  low 
temperatures  require  to  prevent  freezing  within  the  valve  box,  an  air 
space  should  be  constructed  in  the  middle  of  the  valve  box  walls  as  shown. 

Shell.     . 

7.  The  concrete  shell  shall  be  constructed  and  the  connection  between 
it  and  the  floor  shall  be  as  shown.  Its  thickness  should  have  a  proper 
relation  to  the  sizes  and  positions  of  the  reinforcing  rods  so  that  the  con- 
crete will  not  crack  in  shrinking  around  the  rods. 

Piping  and  Valves. 

8.  This  tank  should  be  equipped  with  standard  iron  pipes  and 
standard  gate  valves  located  in  the  valve  box  as  shown.  The  pipes  should 
pass  from  the  valve  box  in  iron  sleeves  with  lead  joints  into  the  tank  as 
shown.  There  should  be  a  tank  supply  pipe,  a  washout  pipe,  a  water 
column  supply  pipe,  and  if  required,  an  overflow  pipe.  For  a  gravity 
water  supply,  an  altitude  controlling  valve  in  the  valve  box  or  a  float 
valve  in  the  tank  should  be  placed  in  or  on  the  tank  supply  pipe  as  shown. 
The  tank  supply  pipe  and  the  water  column  supply  pipe  should  extend 
above  the  floor  of  the  tank,  but  the  water  column  supply  pipe  should  not 
rise  higher  than  the  top  of  the  water  columns  served.  The  washout  pipe 
should  terminate  flush  with  the  floor. 

Gage. 

9.  The  tank  should  be  equipped  with  a  gage,  indicator  and  float  as 
shown. 

Ladder. 

10.  The  tank  should  be  provided  with  a  ladder  as  shown. 
Concrete. 

11.  The  concrete  in  the  floor,  shell  and  roof  shall  be  a  thoroughly 
uniform  and  dense  mixture  of  cement,  sand,  stone  and  water,  made  and 
laid  in  accordance  with  the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  rein- 
forced concrete.  The  volume  of  the  sand  shall  be  in  excess  of  the  voids 
in  the  stone.  The  volume  of  the  cement  shall  be  in  excess  of  the  voids 
in  the  evenly  mixed  sand  and  stone.  The  excess  of  sand  and  cement 
shall  be  such  as  will  give  the  greatest  attainable  density  in  the  concrete. 
The  volume  of  water  shall  be  sufficient  to  give  the  concrete  a  fluidity  that 
will  cause  it  to  flow  and  mold  itself  into  the  forms  readily  and  com- 
pletely. An  unnecessary  quantity  of  water  shall  not  be  used.  The  engi- 
neer shall  determine  the  above  specified  voids  and  proportions. 


WATER  SERVICE.  415 

In  the  foundation,  the  concrete  shall  be  mixed  in  the  proportions 
specified  by  the  engineer  and  it  shall  fulfill  the  requirements  of  the  speci- 
fications for  concrete  of  this  Association. 

Mixing. 

12.  The  concrete  should  preferably  be  mixed  by  batch  mixing  ma- 
chines.    The  method  used  shall  yield  a  complete  and  even  mixture. 

Cleanliness. 

13.  All  dirt  and  foreign  matter  shall  be  excluded  from  all  materials, 
concrete  and  stages  of  the  work. 

Pouring  and  Mixing. 

14.  This  concrete,  after  mixing,  shall  be  poured  and  worked  into 
final  position  in  the  forms  before  its  initial  set  is  complete,  and  it  shall 
not  thereafter  be  disturbed.  As  it  is  thus  placed,  it  shall  be  thoroughly 
worked  throughout  by  flat  thin  bladed  tools  in  a  manner  that  will  elimi- 
nate all  voids  and  air  pockets  and  produce  unbroken  mortar  faces  against 
all  forms  and  secure  perfect  contact  with  every  part  of  all  reinforcing 
rods  therein. 

Joints. 

15.  The  surface  of  concrete  in  joints  should  be  free  of  laitance  and 
all  foreign  matter  and  should  be  rough,  fresh,  clean  and  wet  when  con- 
crete is  laid  thereon.  The  surface  should  be  covered  with  a  heavy  coat 
of  grout  or  mortar  immediately  in  advance  of  placing  concrete  thereon. 
The  surface  should  be  thoroughly  tooled,  scrubbed  and  washed  prepara- 
tory to  the  application  of  grout  and  concrete.  The  new  concrete  should 
be  worked  into  complete  contact  with  the  old  concrete. 

Muriatic  acid  or  equivalent  may  be  used  as  a  help  to  the  tooling  and 
scrubbing,  but  all  of  the  concrete  penetrated  by  the  acid  should  be  en- 
tirely removed. 

A  metal  dam  of  non-corrosive  metal  like  copper  should  be  inserted 
in  the  concrete  joints  intended  to  prevent  the  passage  of  water.  The 
metal  should  be  driven  edgewise  into  the  first  half  of  the  joint  to  a  depth 
equal  to  half  the  width  of  the  metal  before  the  initial  set  of  the  concrete 
is  complete.  The  contact  between  the  concrete  and  the  metal  should  be 
complete  and  perfect.  The  edges  of  the  metal  should  be  turned  over 
90  degrees  for  anchorage.  Joints  in  the  metal  dam  should  be  lapped  at 
the  ends  in  a  manner  that  will  secure  water-tight  joints. 

This  specification  for  joints  does  not  necessarily  and  preferably  may 
not  apply  to  the  joint  between  the  floor  and  the  foundation. 

The  entire  process  of  making  joints  shall  be  as  required. 

Wetting. 

16.  Rapid  drying  out  of  concrete  shall  be  prevented  by  regular,  fre- 
quent and  continued  wetting  of  all  exposed  concrete  surfaces  until  all 
danger  of  arresting  setting  and  hardening  is  past. 

Freezing. 

17.  Freezing  of  concrete  before  it  has  finally  set  shall  be  prevented. 


416  WATER  SERVICE. 

Broken. 

18.  Any  concrete  broken  or  displaced  in  any  manner  after  having  set 
shall  be  removed  from  the  work. 

Cement. 

19.  The  cement  shall  conform  to  the  specifications  of  this  Associa- 
tion for  Portland  cement.  It  shall  retain  its  original  purity  and  qualities 
until  it  is  incorporated  into  this  work.  Deteriorated  or  otherwise  dam- 
aged cement  shall  not  be  used. 

Sand. 

20.  The  sand  shall  be  clean,  sound  and  sharp  and  it  shall  be  of 
graded  sized  grains  giving  a  minimum  of  voids. 

Stone. 

21.  The  stone  shall  be  clean,  sound  and  durable.  The  word  "stone," 
includes  broken  rock  and  gravel.  The  stone  shall  be  of  graded  sizes 
giving  a  minimum  of  voids.  All  of  it  shall  be  able  to  pass  through  a  cir- 
cular hole  having  a  diameter  of  24-in. 

Water. 

22.  The  water  shall  be  clean  and  free  from  anything  injurious  to 
the  concrete. 

Forms. 

23.  The  concrete  forms  should  be  made  of  dressed  and  matched  lum- 
ber or  of  metal.  They  should  be  accurately  made  and  erected,  be  water- 
tight, and  should  have  ample  strength  and  rigidity  to  prevent  bending  ana 
warping  under  the  load  and  action  of  the  concrete.  They  should  be 
erected  in  such  manner  as  will  permit  the  concrete  to  be  poured  and 
worked  as  above  specified. 

Pointing. 

24.  Any  break  in  the  concrete  surfaces,  not  impairing  the  integrity 
of  the  structure,  shall  be  pointed  by  cement  mortar  as  the  engineer  shall 
direct.  Any  other  imperfections  in  the  concrete  shall  be  treated  and 
remedied  as  the  engineer  shall  direct. 

Reinforcement. 

25.  The  concrete  shall  be  reinforced  by  metal  rods  of  the  kind,  form, 
size,  number  and  arrangement  as  shown.  They  shall  be  maintained  in 
required  position  as  they  are  buried  in  the  concrete,  at  which  time  they 
shall  be  free  from  dirt,  paint,  oil,  grease  and  scale.  Splices  in  a  line  of 
rods  shall  be  lapped  far  enough  to  develop  the  full  strength  of  each  rod. 
Throughout  the  splice,  the  ends  of  the  rods  making  it  shall  be  far  enough 
apart  to  develop  maximum  total  adhesion  of  the  concrete.  Unnecessary 
splicing  shall  be  avoided.  No  splice  shall  be  opposite  a  splice  in  an  adja- 
cent line  of  rods. 

Reinforcing   Rods. 

26.  The  rods  shall  be  metal  rods,  plain  or  deformed.  Their  tensile 
strength  shall  be  not  less  than  50,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  Their  elastic  limit 
shall  be  not  less  than  30,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.     Their  ductility  shall  be  such 


WATER  SERVICE.  417 

that  any  rod  can  be  bent  180  degrees  on  a  radius  equal  to  2  diameters  or 

sides  of  the  rod  without  sign  of  fracture. 

Stresses. 

27.  Assuming  the  metal  rods  to  carry  the  water  pressure  and  other 
stresses  without  aid  from  the  tensile  strength  of  the  concrete,  the  stress 
per  sq.  in.  in  the  rods  should  not  exceed  10,000  lbs.  Vertical  reinforce- 
ment in  the  shell,  between  the  shell  and  the  foundation  and  across  joints 
in  the  concrete  should  be  ample  to  prevent  opening  of  cracks  in  the  con- 
crete. Reinforcement  in  all  necessary  directions  should  be  ample  to  pre- 
vent as  far  as  practicable  the  opening  of  cracks  in  the  concrete  due  to  its 
shrinkage  in  setting  and  to  its  stretching  under  the  water  load.  The 
minimum  thickness  in  inches  of  concrete  at  any  point  should  be  such  that 
when  the  water  load  in  pounds  at  that  point  is  diminished  by  3,000  times 
the  sectional  area  in  sq.  in.  of  the  metal  reinforcement  at  that  point,  the 
remaining  water  load  will  stress  the  concrete  not  more  than  300  lbs.  per 
sq.  in.  at  that  point,  provided  that  in  no  case  shall  the  thickness  be  less 
than  4  in. 

Loading. 

28.  The  weight  of  water  should  be  assumed  to  be  63  lbs.  per  cu.  ft. 
Wind  pressure,  acting  in  any  direction,  should  be  assumed  to  be,  in 
pounds,  30  times  the  product  of  the  height  by  two-thirds  of  the  diameter 
of  the  tank  in  feet. 

Waterproofing. 

29.  A  uniformly  dense  mixture  of  concrete  as  herein  specified  should 
be  the  primary  expedient  to  secure  water-tight  concrete.  This  may  be 
supplemented  by  mixing  with  the  concrete  some  form  of  waterproofing 
compound  of  proved  efficiency  or  by  washing  the  concrete  surface  there- 
with, or  by  both. 

The  engineer  shall  select  the  waterproofing  material  and  determine 
the  proper  proportions  and  methods  of  application. 

Waterproofing  by  the  application  of  rich  cement  mortar  may  be 
acceptable  if  the  foregoing  specification  for  making  joints  in  concrete 
work  is  complied  with. 

^GENERAL  SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  ORDINARY  STEEL  WATER 
AND  OIL  TANKS. 
(Revised  November,  191 1.) 
Ordinary  Tanks  Defined. 

1.  Ordinary  tanks  are  those  requiring  plates  not  more  than  %-m. 
thick. 

Scope  of  Specifications. 

2.  These  specifications  cover  ordinary  steel  tanks  commonly  used 
by  railways  for  usual  service  conditions  only. 

Quality  of  Metal. 

3.  The  metal  in  these  tanks  shall  be  a  special  refined  steel  or  open- 
hearth  steel. 


*For  amendments,   see  Index. 


418  WATER  SERVICE. 

The  special  refined  steel  shall  have  a  tensile  strength  per  sq.  in.  not 
less  than  50,000  lbs.  and  an  elastic  limit  not  less  than  30,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 
It  shall  contain  of 

Sulphur    Not  more  than  .02    per  cent. 

Phosphorus    Not  more  than  .005  per  cent. 

Carbon    Not  more  than  .02    per  cent. 

Manganese Not  more  than  .00   per  cent. 

Silicon     Not  more  than  .00    per  cent. 

The  open-hearth  steel  shall  conform  in  physical  and  chemical  prop- 
erties to  the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  steel  bridges. 

For  plates  not  more  than  ^-in.  thick,  5^-in.  rivets  shall  be  used.  For 
thicker  plates  the  diameter  shall  be  ^J-in. 

Loading. 

4.  The  weight  of  water  shall  be  assumed  to  be  63  lbs.,  crude  oil  56 
lbs.,  and  creosote  oil  66  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  Wind  pressure,  acting  in  any  direc- 
tion, shall  be  assumed  to  be,  in  pounds,  30  times  the  product  of  the  height 
by  two-thirds  of  the  diameter  of  the  tank  in  feet. 

Unit  Stresses. 

5.  Unit  stresses  shall  not  exceed  the  following: 

(a)  Tension  in   plates,    15,000  lbs.   per   sq.   in.  on   net  section. 

(b)  Shear  in  plates,  12,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  on  net  section. 

(c)  Shear  on  rivets,  12,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  on  net  section. 

(d)  Bearing  pressure  on  field  rivets,  20,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Cylindrical   Rings. 

6.  Plates  forming  the  shell  of  the  tank  shall  be  cylindrical  and  of 
different  diameters,  in  and  out,  from  course  to  course. 
Workmanship. 

7.  All  workmanship  shall  be  first  class.  All  plates  shall  be  beveled 
on  all  edges  for  caulking  after  being  punched.  The  punching  shall  be 
from  the  surface  to  be  in  contact.  The  plates  shall  be  formed  cold  to 
exact  form  after  punching  and  beveling.  All  rivet  holes  shall  be  ac- 
curately spaced.  Drift  pins  shall  be  used  only  for  bringing  the  parts 
together.  They  shall  not  be  driven  with  enough  force  to  deform  the 
metal  about  the  holes.  Power  riveting  and  caulking  should  be  used.  A 
heavy  yoke  or  pneumatic  bucker  shall  be  used  for  power  driven  rivets. 
Riveting  shall  draw  the  joints  to  full  and  tight  bearing. 

Caulking. 

8.  The  tank  shall  be  made  water  or  oil  tight  by  caulking  only.  No 
foreign  substance  shall  be  used  in  the  joints.  For  water  tanks,  the  caulk- 
ing shall  preferably  be  done  on  the  inside  of  tank  and  joint  only;  but  for 
oil  tanks  the  caulking  should  be  done  on  both  sides.  No  form  of  caulking 
tool  or  work  that  injures  the  abutting  plate  shall  be  used. 

Minimum  Thickness  of  Plates. 

9.  The  minimum  thickness  of  plates  in  the  cylindrical  part  of  the 
tank  shall  not  be  less  than  %-m.  and  in  flat  bottoms  not  less  than  iVin. 


WATER  SERVICE.  419 

In  curved  bottoms  the  thickness  of  plate  shall  be  not  less  than  that  of  the 
lower  plate  in  the  cylindrical  part. 

Horizontal  and   Radial  Joints. 

10.  Lap  joints  shall  generally  be  used  for  horizontal  seams  and 
splices  and  for  radial  seams  in  curved  bottoms. 

Vertical  Joints. 

11.  For  vertical  seams  and  splices,  lap  joints  shall  be  used  with  plates 
not  more  than  2^-in.  thick.  With  thicker  plates,  double  butt  joints  with 
inside  and  outside  straps  shall  generally  be  used.  The  edge  of  the  plate 
in  contact  at  the  intersection  of  horizontal  and  vertical  lap  joints  shall  be 
drawn  out  to  a  uniform  taper  and  thin  edge. 

Rivet  Holes,  Punching  and  Pitch. 

12.  The  diameter  of  rivet  holes  shall  be  i/i6-in.  larger  than  the  diam- 
eter of  the  rivets  used.  The  punching  shall  conform  to  the  specifications 
of  this  Association  for  such  work  on  steel  bridges.  A  close  pitch,  with 
due  regard  for  thickness  of  plate  and  balanced  stress  between  tension  on 
plates  and  shear  on  rivets,  is  desirable  for  caulking. 

Tank  Support. 

13.  If  the  tank  is  supported  on  steel  columns  with  bracing,  the 
metal  in  such  substructure  shall  conform  to  these  specifications,  and  the 
anchorage  and  workmanship  thereof  shall  conform  to  the  specifications 
of  this  Association  for  the  manufacture  and  erection  of  steel  bridges. 

Painting. 

14.  In  the  shop  the  metal  shall  be  cleaned  of  dirt,  rust  and  scale 
and,  except  the  surfaces  to  be  in  contact  in  the  joints  of  the  tank,  shall 
be  given  a  shop  coat  of  paint  or  metal  preservative  selected  and  applied 
as  specified  by  the  company. 

After  being  completely  erected,  caulked  and  cleaned  of  dirt,  rust  and 
scale,  all  exposed  metal  work  shall  be  painted  or  treated  with  such  coat 
or  coats  of  paint  or  metal  preservative  as  shall  be  selected  by  the  railway 
company. 

Plans  and  Specifications. 

15.  Under  these  specifications  and  in  conformity  thereto  the  railway 
company  shall  cause  to  be  prepared  or  shall  approve  detailed  plans  and 
specifications  for  such  tanks,  herein  specified,  as  it  shall  construct.  Such 
plans  and  specifications  shall  cover  all  necessary  tank  auxiliaries. 


CONCLUSION. 

That  the  specifications  for  steel,  water  and  oil  tanks  is  good  practice, 
and  should  be  included  in  the  Manual. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  WATER  SERVICE. 


Appendix  A. 

LOCOMOTIVE   BOILER   CORROSION    AND   TREATED   WATER. 

NOTE  BY  THE  COMMITTEE. 

The  installation  of  small  pumps  to  discharge  a  definite  quantity  of 
soda  ash,  in  solution,  into  water  tanks  instead  of  relying  upon  enginemen 
to  place  the  soda  ash  itself  in  the  engine  tender  is  not  new,  as  a  number 
of  such  outfits  are  in  service  for  the  purpose  of  relieving  conditions  where 
the  hardness  of  water  from  sulphates  occurs  at  points  which  are  not 
equipped  with  softeners  or  where  the  conditions  would  not  justify  that 
expense,  but  your  Committee  believe  such  installation  for  the  purpose  of 
preventing  pitted  flues,  as  described  in  this  article,  is  new  and  it  is  there- 
fore brought  to  your  attention. 

Your  Committee  wish  to  point  out  for  the  benefit  of  members  who 
may  not  have  had  enough  chemistry  to  fully  comprehend  the  suggestions 
which  would  otherwise  occur,  that  the  pitting  of  flues  was  stopped  by 
maintaining  in  the  boiler  at  all  times  water  slightly  caustic  from  sodium 
hydrate,  and  that  control  of  this  causticity  was  made  by  continuous  chem- 
ical examination  of  samples  of  water  taken  from  the  boilers  at  the 
terminal  or  at  points  between  terminals  as  may  at  times  seem  desirable, 
this  examination  being  for  the  double  purpose  of  maintaining  no  greater 
causticity  than  necessary  and  to  furnish  data  for  use  in  cases  of  alleged 
foaming  trouble  and  failure  to  use  blow-off  cocks.  It  is  the  practice  on 
some  roads  to  secure  more  effective  removal  of  sludge  through  blow-off 
cocks  by  connecting  them  to  a  perforated  pipe  which  is  laid  on  the  mud- 
ring  and  thus  withdraw  the  sludge  from  the  entire  ring  instead  of  only  in 
the  vicinity  of  the  cock. 

The  control  of  boiler  waters  required  to  make  these  caustic  soda  sta- 
tions successful  can  best  be  made  by  a  Chemist  and  Engineer  of  Tests, 
but  railroads,  suffering  from  thin  traffic  as  well  as  bad  water  and  unable 
to  afford  the  expense  of  a  man  to  devote  his  exclusive  services  to  such 
matters,  may  be  able  to  find  a  local  chemist  familiar  with  water  analysis 
who  would  be  equipped  to  do  such  work. 

LOCOMOTIVE   BOILER   CORROSION   AND   TREATED   WATER. 
By  J.  R.  Francis,  Indianapolis,  Ind.   • 

During  the  Fall  of  1908,  the  writer  at  the  time  being  in  charge  of  the 
chemical  work  for  the  company,  locomotive  boiler  corrosion  of  a  serious 
nature  developed  on  the  Peoria  &  Eastern  Division  of  the  Big  Four 
Railway. 

The  Division  referred  to  as  relates  to  engine  service  being  divided  at 
Indianapolis,  Indiana,  "West  End"  engines  working  between  Indianapolis 
and  Peoria  (Illinois),  and  "East  End"  engines  between  Indianapolis  and 
Springfield  (Ohio),  excepting  during  unusually  busy  periods,  when  engines 
were  occasionally  transferred  for  several  runs  from  one  district  to  the 
other,  engines  from  both  districts,  however,  running  into  Moorefield  round- 

420 


WATER  SERVICE.  421 

house  at  Indianapolis  and  taking  water  before  leaving  Indianapolis  on 
their  runs  from  Moorefield  water  softener,  the  latter  being  a  standard, 
Davidson  type,  continuous  system  machine,  using  lime  and  soda  ash  in 
the  usual  manner.  The  water  softener  referred  to  had  been  in  continuous 
service  ten  months  prior  to  the  first  evidence  of  corrosion  troubles,  and 
had  served  as  the  exclusive  water  supply  for  the  yard  engines  working  in 
Moorefield  yards,  the  stationary  boilers  at  Moorefield  shops  and  round- 
house, and  the  road  engines,  as  before  stated. 

The  first  evidence  of  corrosion  in  boilers  of  road  engines  was  re- 
ported under  date  of  October  8,  1908,  in  the  case  of  freight  engine  6169 
on  the  "East  End"  giving  up  train  on  account  of  bursted  flue,  which 
upon  examination  together  with  entire  set  of  flues,  revealed  a  bad  case 
of  pitting  and  corrosion.  Following  this  experience  in  rapid  succession 
and  extending  over  a  period  of  several  months,  engine  failures  due  to 
pitted  flues  were  frequent,  a  total  of  3,335  flues  being  scrapped  in  1909, 
and  1,069  in  1910.  At  about  the  time  of  the  first  case  in  question,  the 
General  Foreman  of  Moorefield  shops  and  roundhouse  reported  that  an 
occasional  nipple  or  elbow  in  the  feed  pipes  of  the  stationary  boiler  plant, 
between  the  feed  water  heater  and  boilers,  had  to  be  removed  on  account 
of  being  honeycombed  by  pitting,  and  that  this  trouble  had  developed 
after  the  installation  of  the  water  softener,  the  pipes  previous  to  the 
installation  of  the  latter  becoming  limed  up  badly  from  time  to  time. 
Within  a  short  time  after  this  report,  yard  engine  6522,  which  had  been 
in  service  at  Moorefield  yards  and  using  treated  water  from  Moorefield 
water  softener  exclusively,  was  taken  to  the  Division  shops  at  Urbana, 
Illinois,  where  upon  being  overhauled  it  was  found  that  the  entire  set 
of  flues  were  pitted  so  badly  that  they  had  to  be  scrapped.  In  the  light 
of  the  above-mentioned  cases,  namely,  road  engines  failing  on  account  of 
pitted  flues,  nipple  and  elbows  in  feed  water  line  of  stationary  boiler 
plant  pitting,  and  a  yard  engine  turning  up  with  entire  set  of  flues  useless 
on  account  of  pitting,  and  in  each  case  the  treated  (softened)  water 
having  been  used  exclusively  or  in  part,  it  is  not  surprising  that  sus- 
picion pointed,  as  it  did  on  the  part  of  the  Division  officials,  toward  the 
water  softener ;  in  fact,  it  was  the  only  new  or  unusual  thing  to  be 
found  in  connection  with  the  water  service. 

Upon  investigation,  by  a  process  of  elimination  as  it  were,  it  was 
found  that  the  stationary  boilers  of  the  Moorefield  plant  were  in  excellent 
condition,  with  no  evidence  whatever  of  any  pitting  or  corrosion ;  that 
the  yard  engine  in  question  had  been  in  service  at  another  point  where  a 
hard  water  had  been  used  before  coming  to  Moorefield  yards,  and  that 
the  road  engines  affected  were  confined  to  those  which  were  in  service 
exclusively  or  most  of  the  time  on  the  "East  End."  Samples  of  boiler 
waters  from  all  engines  coming  into  Moorefield  roundhouse  were  then 
called  for,  with  the  object  of  noting  by  chemical  examination  what  differ- 
ence, if  any,  existed  in  the  condition  of  concentrated  waters  of  "East  End" 
boilers  as  compared  to  "West  End"  boilers.  These  samples  were  drawn 
at  the  water  gage   in   a  bucket,   allowed  to   cool,   bottled,   tagged   as    to 


122  WATER  SERVICE. 

number  of  engine,  East  End  or  West  End,  dated,  and  forwarded  to  the 
laboratory  for  examination.  At  the  laboratory  the  examination  was  con- 
ducted as  follows : 

One  hundred  c.  c.  of  sample  was  titrated  with  phenolpthalein  indicator 
and  normal  ten  hydrochloric  acid,  the  number  of  c.  c.  of  acid  required 
being  noted  and  the  titration  completed  with  methyl  orange  indicator,  the~ 
number  of  c.  c.  of  additional  acid  required  with  this  indicator  noted,  and 
also  the  total  number  of  c.  c.  of  acid  required  with  both  indicators.  For 
the  purpose  of  explanation,  we  will  call  this  operation  the  "First  Step." 
Another  ioo  c.  c.  of  sample  was  then  taken  and  30  c.  c.  of  a  10  per  cent, 
solution  of  barium  chloride  added,  with  phenolpthalein  indicator,  and  the 
mixture  titrated  with  normal  ten  hydrochloric  acid,  the  number  of  c.  c.  of 
acid  required  being  noted  and  set  down  as  the  "phenolpthalein  titration  of 
the  second  step." 

In  arriving  at  results  from  the  above,  the  following  procedure  was 
observed :  If  the  acid  required  with  phenolpthalein  indicator  in  the  first 
step  exceeded  that  required  by  methyl  orange,  the  difference  was  charged 
to  hydrates  and  reported  in  equivalents  as  sodium  hydrate.  The  amount 
of  acid  required  with  phenolpthalein  indicator  in  the  second  step  was 
compared  with  the  amount  required  with  phenolpthalein  indicator  in  the 
first  step.  If  less,  the  difference  was  multiplied  by  two  and  charged  to 
alkaline  carbonates  and  reported  in  equivalents  as  sodium  carbonate.  The 
total  acid  required  by  sodium  hydrate  and  sodium  carbonate  was  then 
deducted  from  the  total  acid  required  by  both  phenolpthalein  and  methyl 
orange  indicators  (the  total  alkalinity),  and  the  difference,  if  any,  charged 
to  alkaline  earth  carbonates  and  reported  in  equivalents  as  calcium 
carbonate. 

In  case  the  acid  required  with  methyl  orange  in  the  first  step  was 
greater  than  that  required  with  phenolpthalein,  the  difference  was  charged 
to  bi-carbonates  and  reported  in  equivalents  as  sodium  bi-carbonate.  The 
second  step  was  then  conducted  same  as  before,  the  sum  of  the  sodium 
bi-carbonate  and  carbonate  substracted  from  the  total  alkalinity,  and  the 
difference  charged  to  alkaline  earth  carbonates  and  as  before,  reported  as 
calcium  carbonate. 

The  use  of  hydrochloric  acid  instead  of  sulphuric  acid  in  the  titration 
is  obvious,  on  account  of  the  use  of  barium  chloride. 

By  way  of  comment  on  the  above  procedure,  no  claim  is  made  for 
scientific  accuracy,  because  the  steps  as  outlined  are  not  absolutely  ac- 
curate. They  are,  however,  sufficiently  so  to  serve  the  purpose  to  which 
they  were  put,  and  reference  for  explanation  in  detail  will  be  found  in 
"Sutton's  Volumetric  Analysis,"  under  "Titration  of  Alkaline  Salts."  Be- 
sides the  above  figures  on  the  samples,  we  also  titrated  for  the  chlorine 
content  with  standard  silver  nitrate  solution  in  the  usual  manner,  save 
that  we  first  carefully  neutralized  the  sample  with  nitric  acid. 

The  following  is  a  transcript  of  results  of  laboratory  examinations  as 
per  above,  of  a  few  boiler  water  samples : 


WATER  SERVICE. 


42J 


BOILER  WATERS  EAST  END  PASSENGER  ENGINES 

(Corrosion  occurring) 

(Note  absence  of  Sodium  Hydrate  in  appreciable  quantity,  and  presence  of 

Sodium  Carbonate  and  Bi-Carbonate) 

Parts  per  100,000 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
Carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

October  30,  1908 

October  30,  1908 

October  30,  1908 

November  2,  1908  .... 

7077 
7113 
7071 
7071 

2.12 
2.12 
2.12 
4.24 

6!  84 
<L20 

0.80 
".40 

6.00 
8.00 
8.00 
2.00 

27.00 
30.80 
43.00 
35.80 

BOILER  WATERS  EAST  END  FREIGHT  ENGINES 

(Corrosion  occurring) 

(Note  absence  of  Sodium  Hydrate  and  presence  of  Sodium  Carbonate  and 

Sodium  Bi-Carbonatc) 

Parts  per  100,000 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
Carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

October  31,  1908 

November  2,  1908  .... 
November  24,  1908  . . . 
November  24,  1908  . . . 
November  24,  1908  . . . 

6595 
6577 
6571 
6586 
6597 

2.12 
2.12 
4.24 
5.30 
4.24 

3.36 
2.52 
1.68 
2.52 
2.52 

1.00 
5.00 
5.00 
3.00 
2.00 

24.20 
16.60 
35.20 
28.00 
29.80 

TECHNICAL  ANALYSES,  WATER  SUPPLIES,  EAST  END 
Station  No.  1.    Moorefield  treated   water.      Total  hardness  averaging   less  than  5   grains  per 
gallon  to  standard  noap  solution.    Total  causticity  averaging  about  3  grains 
per  gallon.    Sodium  chloride  average,  3.13  grains  per  gallon. 


cc 

S5 

O 

H 

-o 

< 

a 

■6 

a 

3 

0 

rfl 

0 

0 

J3 

EH 

< 

C3 

a; 

•a 

0  - 
0 

0 

QOO 

O  a 

si 

u 

3 

£ 

fe 

% 

•    £ 

►H 

< 

H 

Q 

Grains, 

U.  S.  Gallon 

Total  Solids 

25.62 

2.34 

23.28 

22.08 
1.20 

.54 

.12 

13.50 

2.37 

5.55 

21.93 

1.16 

20.77 

19.39 
1.38 

1.08 

.51 

11.74 

23.94 

0.20 

23.74 

22.14 
1.60 

1.35 

.24 

13.43 

22.68 
3.52 
19.16 

18.38 
0.78 

.60 

.12 

11.03 

38.73 
3.68 
35.08 

32.93 
2.12 

.99 

.15 

19.00 

22.77 

2.05 

20.72 

20.07 
.65 

.69 

.12 

10.80 

29.01 

2.15 

26.86 

Incrusting  Solids 

25.26 
1.60 

Composition    of    Tncrusting    Solids 
Hypothetical  Combinations: 

.81 

Iron  Oxide  and  Alumina 

.12 
14.93 

Magnesium  Sulphate 

Magnesium  Chloride 

Composition  of  Non-Incrusting  Sol- 
ids,    Hypothetical      Combina- 
tions: 

6.06 

7.12 

3.36 
3.27 

2.95 

9.47 

.37 

2.12 

4  26 

3.91 

.29 

.65 

4.63 

4.77 

1.20 
5.15 

.98 
.40 

.29 

.99 
.61 

.34 

.78 

1.60 

2.25 

6.31 

2.61 

3.19 

S  t  ation  No.  9.  Springfield,  Ohio,  treated  water,  averaging  same  as  Sample  No.  1.  Machine 
Standard^  American  Continuous  System.  Sodium  Chloride  average,  1.00 
grain  per  gallon. 


424 


WATER  SERVICE. 


BOILER  WATERS  WEST  END  PASSENGER  ENGINES 
(No  corrosion  occurring) 
Parts  per  100,000 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

October  28,  1908 
October  28,  1908 
October  29,  1908 
October  30,  1908  .    . 

7072 
6159 
7080 
7115 

19.08 
21.20 
19.08 
15.60 

14.00 
18.80 
14.60 
7.60 

2.00 
3.00 
0.00 
6.00 

16.40 
24.00 
18.20 
16.40 

BOILER  WATERS  WEST  END  FREIGHT  ENGINES 
(No  corrosion  occurring) 
Parts  per  100,000 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

October  28,  1908 

October  29,  1908 
November  24,  1908  . . . 

6591 
6584 
6589 

3.18 
4.24 
5.30 

1.20 
1.60 
4.00 

9.00 
5.00 
2.00 

30.20 
19.80 
26.00 

It  will  be  noted  that  the  average  chlorine  content  of  all  waters  on 
the  East  End  is  about  1.39  parts  per  100,000,  and  that  they  do  not  vary 
a  great  deal.  Comparing  this  average  figure  with  chlorine  content  of  East 
End  freight  engine  No.  6571  boiler  water,  reported  above  as  having  a 
chlorine  content  of  35.2  parts  per  100,000,  we  note  a  concentration  of 
about  25  times. 

Attention  is  called  to  this  observation  for  the  reason  that  where  the 
chlorine  content  of  water  supplies  within  a  district  are  approximately  the 
same,  by  comparing  the  average  figure  with  that  found  in  concentrated 
boiler  water  samples,  a  figure  is  obtained  which  serves  as  an  index  to  the 
concentration  of  the  boiler  water  and  may  be  used  to  check  up  engine 
crews  working  under  instructions  as  to  blowing  down  of  boilers,  and  to 
check  up  round  house  practice  as  to  washing  boilers,  changing  water,  etc. 

Concerning  the  general  character  of  the  water  supplies  of  the  East 
End  as  reported  in  the  analyses  above,  as  relates  to  the  corrosion  experi- 
enced, it  will  be  noted  that  none  of  them  are  "acid  waters."  On  the  con- 
trary, they  are  so-called  alkaline  waters,  and  two  are  treated  waters, 
showing,  as  a  result  of  treatment,  a  slight  causticity.  Ordinarily  one 
would  not  expect  to  find  corrosion  following  the  use  of  such  waters,  and 
with  corrosion  occurring,  as  it  did,  with  their  use,  it  is  quite  a  temptation 
to  theorize  as  to  the  exact  cause  of  the  corrosion.  By  way  of  comment 
it  may  be  stated  that  upon  chemical  examination  of  corroded  or  pitted 
spots  of  sections  of  affected  flues,  taken  while  yet  moist  and  before  sam- 
ples had  had  time  to  become  oxidized,  the  content  of  such  pitted  vesicles 
contained,  according  to  qualitative  analysis,  ferrous  iron  and  sulphuric 
anhydride,  while  on  surfaces  of  other  portions  of  the  sections,  alkaline 
earth  carbonates  were  in  evidence,  most  of  the  pitted  and  corroded  spots 
on  the  cleaner  flues  being  universally  on  the  under  or  lower  side. 

In  searching  for  a  cause  for  the  corrosion,  no  attention  was  paid  to 
the  composition   of  the   flues   in   use,   further  than  to   establish  the   fact 


WATER  SERVICE.  425 

that  the  flues  in  service  on  this  Division  were  no  different  from  flues  fur- 
nished other  Divisions  of  the  company  where  no  trouble  was  being  ex- 
perienced in  the  use  of  mixed,  treated  and  untreated,  waters. 

Attention  should  be  called  to  the  fact,  however,  that  many  of  the 
flues  affected  (not  all  of  them)  had  been  in  use  some  time  prior  to  the 
installation  of  water  softeners  at  each  end  of  the  district,  and  as  a  conse- 
quence were  heavily  covered  with  hard  scale,  the  worst  corrosion  when 
appearing  in  the  form  of  blisters  in  contradistinction  to  pitted  points, 
occurring  in  its  most  active  form  immediately  under  the  edge  of  adherent 
scale.    An  analysis  of  a  sample  of  scale,  showing: 

Per  cent. 

Silica  i-4§ 

Ferric  oxide  17-47 

Calcium  carbonate   9-32 

Calcium  sulphate  65.92 

Magnesium  oxide  562 

Ferrous   iron    Trace 

99.81 

Considering  the  ferrous  iron  and  sulphuric  anhydride  found  by 
qualitative  analysis  of  contents  of  pitted  vesicles  as  mentioned,  one  might 
theorize  that  the  sulphates  of  the  alkaline  earths  had  been  broken  down 
under  the  influence  of  carbon  of  organic  matter,  high  heat,  pressure,  etc., 
but  in  the  examination  of  the  water  supplies,  no  organic  matter  in  appre- 
ciable quantity  was  found.  Passing  by  the  exact  cause  of  the  corrosion, 
since,  under  the  conditions  under  which  it  took  place,  any  explanation 
would  of  necessity  be  hypothetical  in  its  details,  the  remedy  for  counter- 
acting and  stopping  the  trouble  was  based  on  the  information  obtained 
in  the  chemical  examination  of  the  boiler  waters  of  West  End  engines 
as  compared  to  those  of  the  East  End.  The  West  End  boilers  giving  no 
trouble  and  being  quite  caustic  in  comparison,  it  was  concluded  that  if 
East  End  boilers  had  caustic  in  some  form  added  by  the  injection  of  same 
into  the  raw  water  supplies,  thereby  keeping  the  East  End  boilers  slightly 
caustic  due  to  "hydrates,"  that  the  trouble,  pending  the  installation  of 
additional  standard  water  softeners,  would  cease. 

This  recommendation  accordingly  went  out  from  the  laboratory  in 
December,  1908,  and  again  in  January,  1909,  but  on  account  of  diversity 
of  opinion  as  to  the  cause  of  the  corrosion,  some  of  the  official  staff 
believing  that  Moorefield  treated  water  was  causing  the  trouble,  the  use 
of  the  caustic  was  not  begun  until  March  5,  1909.  On  this  date  the  use 
of  caustic  soda  at  Arcanum  (Ohio)  water  station  was  commenced.  Nine 
grains  per  gallon,  in  form  of  solution  being  injected  into  delivery  line 
from  the  large  pump  discharging  into  the  wayside  tank.  The  apparatus 
used  consisted  of  a  "Gould's  Plunger  Boiler  Feed  Pump  No.  2,"  Fig. 
485,  Fairbanks,  Morse  &  Co.'s  catalogue  1909,  price  about  $10,  and  having 
a  plunger  one  and  a  quarter  inches  in  diameter  which  was  attached  to 
the  large  pump  in  such  manner  that  it  had  a  stroke  of  three  inches  with 
each  stroke  of  the  large  pump.     This  small  pump  was  connected  to  iron 


426 


WATER  SERVICE. 


tank  having  a  capacity  of  about  200  gallons,  in  which  the  caustic  soda 
solution  was  diluted  to  the  desired  strength,  and  discharged  into  the  dis- 
charge line  of  the  large  pump.  It  is  advantageous  to  have  the  line  from 
small  pump  enter  the  discharge  line  of  the  large  pump  as  near  the  tank 
as  possible,  on  account  of  the  gradual  deposit  in  the  pipe  occasioned  by  the 
interaction  of  the  caustic  soda  with  chemical  salts  in  solution  in  the 
raw  water. 

On  May  1,  1909,  a  similar  outfit  was  put  in  operation  at  Troy  (Ohio) 
water  station,  and  four  grains  per  gallon  of  caustic  soda  used  there. 
Following  these  installations  at  stations  named,  a  passenger  engine  which 
had  been  overhauled  at  shops  and  given  an  entire  new  set  of  flues,  was 
caused  to  double  the  district  until  28,000  miles  had  been  made,  when  sev- 
eral flues  were  removed  for  examination.  These  were  found  to  be  with- 
out any  evidence  of  pitting  or  corrosion. 

During  the  treatment  of  these  waters  as  mentioned  above,  namely, 
nine  grains  per  gallon  of  caustic  soda  at  Arcanum  and  four  grains  per 
gallon  of  same  at  Troy,  Ohio,  boiler  water  samples  titrated  as  follows : 

BOILER  WATERS  EAST  END  PASSENGER  ENGINES 
(No  corrosion  occurring  at  this  time) 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

August  12,  1909 

September3,  1909.... 

7071 
7081 

3.8 
2.12 

4.40 
2.80 

1.00 

16.0 
13.0 

It  is  proper  to  explain  that  passenger  engines  on  the  East  End  on 
their  runs  east,  took  water  at  Moorefield  water  softener,  New  Castle  (Ind.), 
Arcanum  (Ohio),  and,  going  west,  at  Springfield  (Ohio)  water  softener, 
Troy  (Ohio)  and  Lynn  (Ind.).  This  being  true,  they  received  a  larger 
amount  of  caustic  soda  in  proportion  to  the  total  amount  of  water  used 
than  did  freight  engines  which  used  water  from  all  water  stations. 

BOILER  WATERS  EAST  END  FREIGHT  ENGINES 

During  treatment  of  waters  at  Arcanum  (Ohio),  and  Troy  (Ohio),  as  mentioned 

Parts  per  100,000 

Total  of  59  samples 


Date 

Engine 
Number 

Sodium 
Carbonate 

Sodium  Bi- 
carbonate 

Sodium 
Hydrate 

Calcium 
Carbonate 

Chlorine 

July,  1909 

Total 

40  Samples 

From  0.85 

to 

7.42 

19  Samples 

From  0.84 

to 

6.72 

5  Samples 

None 
35  Samples 
0.16  to  S.40 

40  Samples 

3.00 

to 

25.40 

Av.  of  5.43 

19  Samples 

From  2.12 

to 

9.54 

Av.  2.81 

Av.  14.24 

19  Samples 

From  12.00 

to 

17.20 

Av.  of  5.43 

Av.  of  2.92 

Av.  of  14.92 

It  will  be  noted  in  the  above  that  out  of  59  samples,  35  or  about  59 
per  cent,  of  them  showed  presence  of  sodium  carbonate  and  sodium  hy- 


WATER  SERVICE.  427 

drate.  Five  of  them,  or  approximately  8  per  cent.,  showed  sodium  car- 
bonate, but  no  sodium  hydrate.  And  that  nineteen  samples,  or  about  33 
per  cent.,  showed  sodium  carbonate  and  sodium  bi-carbonate. 

It  was  believed  at  this  time,  on  account  of  fewer  engine  failures 
account  of  flues,  that  under  this  treatment  the  corrosion  was  under  control. 
This  assumption,  however,  was  likely  not  true,  as  it  afterwards  was  demon- 
strated that  the  corrosion  did  not  entirely  stop  until  a  causticity  due 
to  "hydrates"  was  maintained  practically  all  of  the  time. 

The  treatment  of  the  waters  at  Arcanum  and  Troy,  in  the  propor- 
tions already  stated,  was  continued  until  November  1,  1909,  when  it 
was  reduced  one-half  on  account  of  complaint  on  the  part  of  enginemen 
that  the  treatment  of  the  water  was  causing  foaming. 

It  developed  later,  however,  that  the  greater  part  of  these  complaints 
was  occasioned  by  an  effort  on  the  part  of  the  enginemen  to  protect  one 
of  their  number  who  had  carelessly  allowed  the  water  to  run  low  in  a 
boiler  and  burned  a  crown-sheet.  This  reduction  in  treatment  lowered  the 
percentage  of  boiler  water  samples,  showing  the  presence  of  sodium  hy- 
drate so  much,  that  the  majority  of  the  samples  showed  the  presence  of 
sodium  bi-carbonate  instead. 

Within  four  months  after  the  reduction  in  the  treatment  several 
engine  failures  on  account  of  pitted  flues  again  occurred,  and  on  this 
account  the  treatment  of  the  waters  at  Arcanum  and  Troy  was  in- 
creased on  June  10,  1910,  to  the  figures  as  at  first  used,  following  which 
a  systematic  patrol  of  the  district  by  the  Road  Foreman  of  Engines 
quieted  the  complaints  on  the  part  of  enginemen  concerning  foaming, 
it  being  very  clearly  demonstrated  that  these  complaints  had  been  greatly 
exaggerated.  Sampling  and  examination  in  the  laboratory  of  boiler 
waters  was  continued  as  before,  the  object  being  to  raise  the  causticity 
due  to  sodium  hydrate  until  all  boiler  samples  showed  the  presence  of  at 
least  a  slight  amount. 

This  feature  was  not  finally  accomplished  until  a  third  caustic  soda 
treating  station  was  established  at  Maxwell,  (Ind.)  water  station,  August 
12,  1910,  where  two  grains  per  gallon  was  injected  into  the  raw  water 
supply.  With  this  additional  installation  in  operation  no  more  trouble 
was  experienced  as  to  samples  of  boiler  waters  failing  to  show  the  presence 
of  sodium  hydrate  in  appreciable  quantities.  This  point  for  the  third  in- 
stallation was  selected  on  account  only  of  its  distance  from  the  other  in- 
stallations. The  daily  sampling  of  locomotive  boiler  waters  and  chemical 
examination,  as  described,  was  continued  for  seven  months,  during  which 
time  more  than  90  per  cent,  of  all  samples  showed  the  presence  of  two  to 
15  parts  per  100,000  of  sodium  hydrate  along  with  about  an  equal  amount 
of  sodium  carbonate. 

Under  this  treatment  the  corrosion  entirely  ceased  and  no  more 
trouble  on  this  account  was  experienced,  neither  was  there  any  more 
complaint  of  moment  on  the  part  of  engine  crews  on  account  of  foam- 
ing boilers,  the  enginemen  apparently  having  learned  better  how  to 
handle  the  boilers  under  the  treatment. 

It  is  also  worthy  of  note  that  under  this  treatment  the  boilers  be- 
came and  remained  clean  and  practically  free  from  scale. 


428  WATER  SERVICE. 

To  recapitulate,  it  is  desired  to  call  attention  to  the  fact  that  between 
November  i,  1909,  and  June  10,  1910,  when  the  treatment  was  reduced, 
with  corrosion  re-occurring  as  already  stated,  that  the  freight  engine  boiler 
waters  did  not  show  the  presence  of  sodium  hydrate  in  appreciable  amounts 
with  any  regularity.  They  did,  however,  show  the  presence  of  small 
quantities  of  sodium  carbonate  and  bi-carbonate.  It  is  desired  to  em- 
phasize this  point  because  of  the  fact  that  only  after  a  sufficient  quantity 
of  caustic  soda  had  been  added  to  show  an  appreciable  amount  in  the 
concentrated  boiler  waters,  did  we  succeed  in  stopping  the  corrosion. 

It  is  also  worthy  of  note  that,  in  the  use  of  the  caustic  soda,  we  at 
no  time  used  an  amount  so  large  as  the  equivalent  of  the  half-bound  car- 
bonic acid  of  the  alkaline  earth  bi-carbonates  in  the  waters  naturally, 
therefore  it  must  have  followed  that  the  caustic  soda  so  used,  when  in- 
jected into  the  raw  waters,  became  sodium  carbonate  and  that  it  was 
finally  hydrolized  within  the  boiler  and  partially  re-converted  into  "hy- 
drate." The  question  naturally  arises  at  this  point  why  sodium  carbonate 
(soda  ash)  would  not  have  done  just  as  well  as  sodium  hydrate,  since 
it  is  obvious  that  the  latter  when  added  to  the  raw  water  first  became 
sodium  carbonate  and  afterwards  was  in  part  re-converted  by  hydrolysis 
into  "hydrate."  In  our  opinion  this  probably  would  have  been  the  case, 
since  it  is  clear  that  sodium  carbonate  and  sodium  bi-carbonate  are  par- 
tially hydrolized  within  a  boiler.  This  point  is  again  clearly  brought  out 
by  reference  above  to  the  titration  of  West  End  boiler  water  samples  from 
passenger  engines.  These  samples  showing  from  seven  to  eighteen  parts 
per  100,000  of  sodium  hydrate  along  with  a  slightly  larger  amount  of 
sodium  carbonate,  and  being  accounted  for  only  by  the  fact  that,  in  ad- 
dition to  the  treated  water  taken  at  Moorefield  shops,  two  raw 
waters  on  the  West  End  carry  sodium  bi-carbonate  naturally,  one  of  them 
about  four  parts  per  100,000  and  the  other  eight  parts  per  ioo,coo,  the 
presence  of  the  sodium  hydrate  occurring  on  account  of  the  partial 
hydrolysis  of  same  within  the  boiler  during  concentration. 

In  our  opinion,  the  features  worthy  of  note  concerning  the  above 
experience  consists  in  part  of  the  troubles  which  may  follow  the  in- 
stallation of  standard  water  softening  or  treating  apparatus,  where  waters 
in  part  only  are  treated  within  a  district. 

Also,  in  the  importance  of  chemical  laboratory  examination  and  con- 
trol of  boiler  waters,  where  corrosion  as  described  is  being  experienced, 
the  features  of  such  control  aiming  to  maintain  within  the  boilers  a 
causticity  due  to  the  presence  of  "hydrates"  in  an  appreciable  amount, 
and  that  whether  sodium  hydrate  or  soda  ash  be  used,  that  it  be  used 
in  sufficient  quantity  and  so  distributed  that  boiler  water  samples  upon 
chemical  examination  show  an  appreciable  amount  of  causticity  due  to 
"hydrates."  This  plan,  in  our  opinion,  insuring  a  sufficient  treatment  to 
counteract  '.!_.  "permanent  hardness"  of  all  waters  used,  therefore  con- 
truinng  ordinary  corrosion  troubles,  and  doing  so  without  using  an  undue 
excess  of  reagent,  thereby  guarding  against  any  unnecessary  aggravation 
of  foaming  troubles,  due  specifically  to  excessive  treatment. 


REPORT    OF    COMMITTEE    XIX- ON    CONSERVATION 
OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

E.  O.  Faulkner,  Chairman;  William  McNab,  Vice-Chairman ; 
R.  H.  Aishton.                                      W.  A.  McGonagle. 

Moses  Burpee.  G.  A.  Mountain. 

F.  F.  Busteed.  W.  L.  Park. 
C.  H.  Fisk.  G.  H.  Webb. 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railzvay  Engineering  Association: 

The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  the  following  subjects  to  your  Com- 
mittee : 

(i)     Continue  the  study  of  tree-planting  and  general  reforestation. 

(2)  Continue  the  study  of  coal  and  fuel  oil  resources. 

(3)  Continue  the  study  of  iron  and  steel  resources. 

The  Committee  held  a  number  of  meetings  during  the  year,  and  its 
researches  have  been  along  the  general  lines  suggested  by  the  Board  of 
Direction. 

In  presenting  the  report,  which  is  naturally  one  of  progress,  the  Com- 
mittee realizes  that  there  is  a  great  difference  between  the  practical  appli- 
cation of  "Conservation  of  Natural  Resources"  to  the  every-day  business 
conditions  met  with  by  the  members  of  the  Association  and  the  purely 
sentimental  ideals  which  may  be  indulged  in  by  the  world  in  general. 

It  is  felt  also  that  while  the  Committee  was  originally  formed  to  co- 
operate with  the  National  Conservation  Commission  of  this  country,  as 
well  as  with  the  Commission  of  Conservation  of  Canada,  yet  its  principal 
object  was  to  keep  under  special  observation  those  particular  features  in 
which  the  railways  were  directly  and  practically  interested. 

It  is  hoped  that  the  information  which  the  Committee  has  been  able 
thus  far  to  collect,  may,  in  the  method  and  form  in  which  it  is  here  given, 
be  easy  of  reference  as  well  as  productive  of  practical  benefit  to  our 
members,  and  through  them  to  the  railways  in  general. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

429 


430  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

UNITED  STATES. 
TREE  PLANTING  AND  GENERAL  REFORESTATION. 

As  leading  up  to  the  necessity  for  tree  planting  and  reforestation,  it 
would  seem  desirable  to  consider,  first,  the  extent  and  location  of  exist- 
ing forests,  their  annual  increment,  and  the  yearly  consumption  of  forest 
products. 

These  questions  were  very  fully  reported  upon  by  the  National  Conser- 
vation Commission.  The  Commission  was  assisted  in  its  labors  by  experts 
whose  papers  form  the  basis  of  the  report.  These  papers,  representing  as 
they  do  the  original  work  of  experts,  form  a  body  of  evidence  along  the 
various  lines  pertaining  to  the  timber  resources  of  the  country,  which  will 
be  found  valuable  for  reference. 

For  the  purpose  of  facilitating  a  thorough  examination  of  any  of  the 
subjects  treated  in  the  following  report,  references  are  given  to  these 
papers  as  well  as  to  other  sources  of  information,  easily  obtainable,  and 
which  present  the  matter  in  sufficient  detail  to  enable  a  careful  study  of  the 
various  problems  to  be  made. 

It  was  the  feeling  of  the  Committee  that  owing  to  the  magnitude  of 
the  questions  involved  the  best  results  would  be  obtained  by  a  general 
review  of  the  subject  supplemented  by  a  list  of  references  to  authoritative 
literature.  The  list  of  references,  while  small,  is  believed  to  cover  the 
ground  sufficiently  for  the  purpose.* 

The  original  forests  of  the  United  States  (note  A)  exceeded  in  the 
quantity  and  variety  of  their  timber  the  forests  of  any  other  region  of 
similar  size  on  the  globe.  Five  great  forest  types  were  distinguished — 
the  northern,  southern,  central,  Rocky  Mountain  and  Pacific  Coast.  The 
kinds   of  timber  and  extent  of  these   forests   are  presented   in  Table    i. 

Table  i. 

ORIGINAL  FORESTS  OF  THE  UNITED  STATES. 


Forest. 

Kinds  of  Timber. 

Quantity 
Billion  F.  B.  M. 

Extent 
Million 
Acres. 

Cone-bearing      trees      predomi- 
nating with  some  hardwoods. 

1,000 

150 

Coniferous    forest    with    yellow 
pine     predominating.       Inter- 
spersed with  the  pine  were  a 

1,000 

220 

This  is  the  only  forest  region  in 
the    United    States    in    which 
the    hardwoods    predominated. 

1,400 

280 

Rocky 

400 

110 

1,400 

90 

5,200 

850 

*A  very  complete  Bibliography  bearing  upon  the  subject-matter  of  this 
report  is  to  be  found  in  Fernow's  excellent  book,  "Economics  of  Forestry," 
B.  E.  Fernow,  New  York,  pp.  491-507. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  481 

In  addition  to  these  timbered  areas  there  were  probably  100,000,000 
acres  of  scrubly  forest  and  brush  land,  chiefly  in  the  West,  which  has  been 
and  still  is  a  source  of  much  post  and  fuel  material. 

The  Bureau  of  Corporations  (note  B)  estimates  that  there  is  a  total 
of  about  2,800  billion  board  feet  of  standing  timber  in  the  country.  Of  this 
about  2,200  billion  feet  is  privately  owned,  about  539  billion  feet  is  in  the 
National  forests,  and  about  90  billion  feet  is  on  the  unreserved  public  lands, 
national  parks,  state  lands,  and  Indian  reservations. 

The  results  of  the  Bureau's  investigation  of  the  amount  of  standing 
timber  in  the  United  States  may  be  summarized  as  shown  in  Table  2. 

Table  2. 

STANDING   TIMBER   IN   THE    UNITED    STATES. 

Billion 
Privately  owned  timber  in  investigation  area:  Feet. 

Pacific  Northwest 1,013 

Southern  Pine  Region 634 

Lake  States  100 

1,747 

Outside   of   investigation    area 450 

2,197 

Total  owned  by  Federal  Government  in  National  forests 539 

Total  otherwise  owned  by  Federal  Government,  owned  by  states 

and    on    Indian    reservations 90 

Grand    Total    2.826 

The  earliest  attack  was  upon  the  white  pine  of  the  Northeast,  the 
original  stand  of  which  is  almost  entirely  cut  out.  From  Table  2  it  is 
apparent  that  at  the  present  time  the  two  great  sources  of  timber  supply, 
so  far  as  privately  owned  timber  is  concerned,  are  the  Pacific  Northwest, 
with  1,013  billion  ft.  and  the  Southern  pine  region,  with  634  billion  ft. 
Moreover,  82  per  cent,  of  the  standing  timber  owned  by  the  United  States 
Government  is  in  the  Pacific  Northwest,  and  nearly  all  of  the  remainder 
is  in  the  other  states  of  the  Rocky  Mountain  region. 

The  yearly  growth  of  wood  (note  C)  in  our  forests  does  not  average 
more  than  12  cu.  ft.  per  acre.  This  gives  a  total  yearly  growth  of  less 
than  seven  billion  cubic  feet. 

That  our  forests  grow  very  slowly,  although  the  individual  trees  of 
many  kinds  grow  fast,  is  our  fault.  There  are  about  200  million  acres  of 
mature  forest  mainly  in  the  northern  Rockies  and  on  the  Pacific  Coast 
in  which  the  yearly  growth  is  balanced  by  decay. 

There  are  250  million  acres,  mostly  in  the  Southern  mountains  and 
Southern  pine  belt,  partly  cut  or  burned  over,  but  restocking  naturally 
with  young  growth  and  100  million  acres  chiefly  in  the  Lake  States  and 
Southern  pine  belt  which  have  been  cut  or  burned  over  upon  which  young 
growth  is  wholly  lacking  or  too  scanty  to  make  merchantable  timber. 

There  is  taken  from  the  forest  (note  D)  annually,  not  including  loss 
from  fire,  23  billion  cubic  feet  of  wood  or  over  three  times  its  yearly 
growth.  This  large  consumption  amounts  to  230  cubic  feet  per  capita, 
while  Germany  uses  37  cubic  feet  and  France  25  cubic  feet. 

Each  year  there  is  used  90,000,000  cords  of  fire  wood,  40,000,000,000 
board  feet  of  lumber,  more  than  1,000,000,000  posts,  poles  and  fence  rails, 


432     ,        CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

118,000,000  hewn  ties,  1,500,000,000  staves,  over  133,000,000  sets  of  heading, 
nearly  500,000,000  barrel  hoops,  3,000,000  cords  of  native  pulp  wood,  165,- 
000,000  cubic  feet  of  round  mine  timbers,  and  1,250,000  cords  of  wood  for 
distillation. 

The  condition  of  the  world  supply  of  timber  makes  us  already  de- 
pendent upon  what  we  produce.  There  is  exported  out  of  the  country 
one  and  one-half  times  as  much  timber  as  is  brought  in,  and  except  for 
finishing  woods,  relatively  insignificant  in  quantity,  we  must  rely  upon  our 
own  resources  for  the  future  supply. 

The  Forest  Service  estimates  the  yearly  drain  on  the  saw  timber  of 
the  country  at  about  50  billion  board  ft.  Without  allowing  either  for  new 
growth  or  for  any  increase  in  the  rate  of  consumption  the  total  for  all  the 
timber  in  the  United  States  (see  Table  2)  would  represent  about  55  years' 
supply,  and  that  for  privately  owned  timber  alone  only  44  years'  supply. 

These  conditions  affect  the  railroads  of  the  country  not  only  as  they 
are  concerned  in  the  production  of  timber  for  their  own  use,  but  from  the 
broader  viewpoint  of  developing  the  territory  traversed  by  their  lines. 
The  destruction  of  the  timber  is  followed  by  a  rapid  decline  of  the  indus- 
tries utilizing  the  products  of  the  forest  with  a  corresponding  loss  of 
revenue  for  the  roads  serving  the  region. 

Turning  our  attention  to  the  conservation  of  the  forest  it  will  be 
seen,  (1)  that  by  the  introduction  of  proper  forestry  methods  the  annual 
productivity  of  the  forest  can  be  considerably  increased  (note  E)  and,  (2) 
that  the  yearly  loss  from  avoidable  causes  is  much  greater  than  it  should 
be  (note  F). 

There  are  225  million  acres  of  producing  forest  in  the  country.  On 
this  area  the  stand  is  so  open  that  all  the  trees  could  be  grown  on  145 
million  acres,  which  would  be  producing  at  the  rate  of  70  cu.  ft.  per  acre 
annually.  By  growing  only  the  best  species  this  growth  can  be  increased 
to  80  cu.  ft.,  an  increase  of  1,450  million  cu.  ft. 

There  is  an  unutilized  area  of  80  million  acres  within  our  present  pro- 
ducing forest.  There  are  135  million  acres  of  absolute  forest  land  within 
our  virgin  or  mature  forests  now  unproductive.  There  are  90  million  acres 
of  waste  lands  which  can  be  made  productive  by  planting,  or  by  fire  protec- 
tion all  of  these  areas  can  be  made  to  produce  80  cubic  feet  per  acre,  or  a 
total  of  24,400  million  cu.  ft. 

The  total  increase  possible  in  the  productiveness  of  our  forests  is, 
therefore,  25,850  million  cu.  ft. 

Only  25  per  cent,  of  the  yield  of  our  present  producing  forest  is  saw 
timber.  It  can  be  made  from  50  per  cent,  to  75  per  cent,  saw  timber 
through  the  concentration  of  growth  on  the  best  trees  by  thinning  and 
the  holding  of  the  crop  until  it  reaches  good  size.  This  would  mean  an 
increase,  if  all  our  forest  land  were  productive,  from  27,000  million  board 
ft.  to  between  54,000  million  and  81,000  million  board  ft.  per  annum. 

The  enormous  loss  from  fire  in  our  forests  every  year  is  a  matter  of 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  433 

common  knowledge.  The  value  of  standing  timber  destroyed  each  season 
from  this  cause  has  varied  from  $25,000,000  to  more  than  $100,000,000, 
the  direct  annual  loss  in  recent  years  averaging  considerable  over  $50,- 
000,000.  The  destruction  of  young  growth,  though  never  included  in  esti- 
mates of  fire  damage,  is  a  principal  item  of  loss.  The  natural  restocking 
of  burned-over  lands  takes  place  very  slowly  or  not  at  all 

All  experiences  go  to  prove  that  damage  by  forest  fires  is  practically 
preventable.  This  stage  of  development  has  already  been  reached  in 
Europe.  For  example,  of  7  million  acres  in  Prussia,  an  average  of  only 
1,400  acres  or  one-fiftieth  of  1  per  cent,  was  burned  over  each  year  during 
the  period  from  1868  to  1895. 

Your  Committee  feels  that  the  railroads  by  working  with  the  State 
Forestry  officials  can  accomplish  a  great  deal  of  good  in  the  way  of  pre- 
vention of  fires  started  by  sparks  from  locomotives.  The  Committee  is 
assembling  information  from  both  the  railroad  companies  and  the  State 
Forest  officials  in  regard  to  the  laws  governing  the  subject  and  the  means 
used  in  different  parts  of  the  country  to  reduce  the  fire  risk  from  this 
cause. 

It  would  appear  that  a  concerted  action  on  the  part  of  the  railroads 
and  State  officials  is  desirable  as  the  forest  adjacent  to  the  railroad  right- 
of-way  is  often  left  in  such  a  condition  after  logging  operations  that  it  is 
a  difficult  matter  to  prevent  fire  starting,  even  when  the  greatest  precaution 
is  observed.  Several  roads  are  now  working  with  the  State  Foresters  to 
accomplish  this  result ;  notably  the  Chicago  &  Northwestern  in  the  State 
of  Wisconsin. 

While  the  chief  loss  in  timber  is  due  to  fire,  other  causes  contribute 
largely  to  the  prodigious  waste  which  has  accompanied  our  use  of  the 
forest.  One-fourth  of  the  standing  timber  is  left  or  otherwise  lost  in  log- 
ging. The  boxing  of  long  leaf  pine  for  turpentine  has  destroyed  one-fifth 
of  the  forests  worked.  The  loss  in  the  mill  is  from  one  third  to  two-thirds 
of  the  timber  sawed.  The  loss  in  the  mill  product  through  seasoning  and 
fitting  for  use  is  from  one-seventh  to  one-fourth.  Great  damage  is  done 
by  insects  to  forests  and  forest  products.  An  average  of  only  320  ft.  of 
lumber  is  used  for  each  1,000  ft.  which  stood  in  the  forest. 

Of  all  the  wood  in  every  form  now  in  use  in  the  United  States,  decay, 
fire,  insects  and  saltwater  borers  destroy  not  less  than  the  equivalent  of 
8,000  million  board  ft.  each  year.  Of  these,  decay  is  far  the  most  de- 
structive. 

The  first  attempt  in  this  country  to  prevent  decay  by  treating  wood 
was  in  1838  on  the  Northern  Central  Railroad.  About  a  mile  of  track  was 
laid  with  treated  ties,  but  owing  to  the  low  first  cost  of  the  ties  which 
were  chestnut  and  oak  and  were  delivered  to  the  railroad  at  fourteen  or 
sixteen  cents  apiece,  this  did  not  develop  into  a  permanent  industry. 

In  1880  for  the  first  time  the  United  States  census  undertook  to  ascer- 
tain what  remained  of  our  timber  resources ;  it  was  found  that  they  had 
been  very  rapidly  depleted.  Realizing  the  importance  of  the  question  the 
American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  appointed  a  committee  to  report  upon 


434  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

the  best  methods  of  preserving  wood,  in  order  to  lengthen  its  life.  This 
committee  was  appointed  in  1880  and  after  five  years  of  work  presented 
its  report  in  1885.  This  was  followed  by  the  movement  which  has  culmi- 
nated in  the  present  large  wood  preservation  industry  of  the  country. 

In  the  year  1910,  97,500,000  cu.  ft.  of  timber  was  treated.  Most  of  this 
material  consisted  of  cross-ties.  Sixty-three  million  cu.  ft.,  which  consti- 
tuted about  65  per  cent,  of  the  total,  were  treated  with  the  creosote  treat- 
ment and  the  remainder  with  zinc  chloride  and  zinc  creosote  treatment  in 
the  order  named. 

In  the  United  States  the  science  of  forestry  is  still  in  the  formation 
stage.  Knowledge  of  the  characteristics  and  requirements  of  the  many 
species  of  trees  composing  the  forests  is  limited ;  the  total  amount  and  dis- 
tribution of  forest  wealth  is  not  accurately  known ;  and  methods  of  admin- 
istration are  not  yet  settled,  but  are  subject  to  frequent  change.  In  Eu- 
rope, on  the  contrary,  forestry  as  practiced  to-day  is  the  result  of  centuries 
of  gradual  evolution,  and  is  consequently  thoroughly  systematized  and  its 
methods  firmly  established  (note  G).  Foreign  silvicultural  methods  are 
not  usually  applicable  without  change,  but  the  general  systems  have  been 
adapted  with  success  to  conditions  in  this  country,  and  should  be  still  more 
widely  used. 

A  striking  point  concerning  forestry  abroad  is  the  important  part 
taken  by  the  State  in  the  management  of  communal  and  private  as  well  as 
of  the  State  forests,  and  the  considerably  greater  returns  obtained  under 
State  management.  All  communal  forests  are  subject  to  some  form  of 
State  supervision,  and  many  of  them  are  managed  precisely  as  if  they  were 
State  property. 

Private  forests  necessary  for  the  protection  of  water  sheds  or  the  wel- 
fare of  the  general  public  are  also  subject  to  State  control;  they  cannot  be 
cleared,  cutting  must  be  done  as  prescribed  by  the  State,  and  all  cuttings 
must  be  reforested.  Other  private  forests  not  necessary  for  protective 
purposes  can  usually  be  managed  as  the  owner  desires,  but  co-operation 
with  the  State  in  the  management  of  such  forests  is  common. 

With  a  few  exceptions  comparatively  little  attention  has  been  paid  by 
the  railroads  to  forestry.  Tree  plantations  (note  H)  have  been  started  in  a 
number  of  cases,  some  of  which  have  been  on  a  large  scale,  but  for  the 
most  part  experimentally.  Forest  planting  in  some  cases  may  be  desirable 
when  a  railroad  has  waste  land  for  which  it  has  no  particular  use.  It  is 
a  good  object  lesson  to  the  farmers,  and  if  the  plantations  are  successful 
they  will  net  a  fair  return  on  the  investment  and  furnish  a  limited  supply 
of  ties  and  timber  for  the  future. 

It  should  be  observed,  however,  that  it  would  not  be  practicable  for 
the  individual  roads  to  plant  enough  trees  to  supply  their  timber  require- 
ments, and  further  the  critical  period  of  scarcity  and  high  prices  would 
come  before  any  of  the  trees  so  planted  would  reach  maturity.* 


•Refer  to  the  paper  entitled  "Preliminary  Report  of  Sub-Committee  on 
Future  Policy  of  Railroads  with  Reference  to  the  Tie  Supply,"  which  ap- 
peared in  the  ninth  volume  (1908)  of  the  Proceedings  of  the  American  Rail- 
way Engineering  and   Maintenance   of  "Way   Association. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  435 

The  information*  assembled  by  the  Committee  on  Ties  of  this  Associa- 
tion in  1910  shows  what  has  been  done  by  the  railroads  in  the  way  of  tree 
planting ;  the  situation  is  very  little  changed  at  the  present  time  and  in  the 
opinion  of  those  best  able  to  judge,  relief  from  this  source  is  very 
uncertain. 

If  the  railroads  wish  to  provide  against  future  scarcity  and  excessive 
prices  with  any  degree  of  certainty  it  will  be  necessary  for  them  to  actively 
engage  in  forestry  operations  having  for  their  purpose  the  management  of 
mature  timber  lands  and  the  cultivation  and  reforestation  of  the  cut-over 
lands  within  the  forest  area.  This  is  an  individual  problem  with  every 
road,  but  generally  speaking  it  is  the  only  sound  policy  which  will  provide 
for  the  future  requirements  fifteen  or  twenty  years  hence. 

Some  of  the  railroads  have  now  undertaken  to  preserve  the  timber 
lands  which  they  acquired  through  land  grants  and  otherwise.  The  South- 
ern Pacific  in  Northern  California  and  Southern  Oregon  still  have  quite 
large  areas  of  good  timber  from  which  they  can  cut  mature  trees.  The 
Northern  Pacific  has  been  co-operating  with  the  Government  for  some 
years  with  a  view  to  finding  how  best  to  handle  their  western  holdings  and 
provide  a  source  of  tie  supply  at  the  eastern  end  of  their  lines.  In  the 
East,  the  Delaware  &  Hudson  have  put  about  one  hundred  thousand  acres 
in  the  Adirondacks  under  management. 

RECOMMENDATION  FOR  NEXT  YEAR'S  WORK. 

(a)  Investigation  of  the  forest  fire  laws  of  the  different  States  as 
they  apply  to  railroads. 

(b)  The  best  methods  to  be  used  by  railroads  to  reduce  risk  from 
fires  caused  by  locomotives. 

BIBLIOGRAPHY  OF  ARTICLES  PERTAINING  TO  THE  TIMBER 
RESOURCES  OF  THE  UNITED  STATES. 

Note  A.  original  forests. 

Original  Forests,  R.  S.  Kellogg,  Vol.  2,  pp.  179,  180.  Report  of  the 
National  Conservation  Commission,  February,  1909,  Government  Printing 
Office,  Washington,  D.  C. 

Note  B.  existing  forests. 

Amount  of  standing  timber  in  the  United  States,  pp.  14-20,  Summary 
of  the  Report  of  the  Commission  of  Corporations  on  the  Lumber  Industry, 
Part  I.  Standing  Timber,  February  13,  191 1.  Government  Printing  Office, 
Washington,  D.  C. 

The  Forests  of  the  United  States:  Their  Use.  What  We  Have,  pp. 
5-7.     Forest  Service,  Circular  171,  December  11,  1909. 

Stand  of  Timber,  Herbert  K.  Smith,  Vol.  2,  pp.  188-190.  Report  of 
the  National  Conservation  Commission,  1909. 

Standing  Timber  in  Possession  of  the  Federal  Government,  G.  M. 
Homans,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  192-195. 

♦Report  of  Committee  on  Ties,  appendix  C,  Timber  and  Conservation; 
Proceedings  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  As- 
sociation, Vol.   11,   Part  2,   1910. 


436  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

Standing  Timber  Owned  by  the  States,  J.  Girvin  Peters,  ibed  Vol.  2, 
p.  191. 

Standing  Timber  in  Wood  Lots,  Wesley  Bradfield,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp. 
181-187. 

Note  C.  estimated  annual  increment. 

What  is  Produced.     Forest  Service,  Circular  171,  pp.  7,  8. 
Rate  of  Forest  Growth,  E.  A.  Ziegler,  Vol.  2,  pp.  203-223.     Report  "of 
National  Conservation  Commission,  1909. 

Note  D.  annual  consumption. 

What  is  Used.     Forest  Service,  Circular  171,  pp.  8,  9. 

Forest  Products,  R.  S.  Kellogg,  Vol.  2,  pp.  196-202.  Report  of  Na- 
tional Conservation  Commission,  1909. 

Forest  Products  of  the  United  States,  1909.  Bureau  of  the  Census. 
Government  Printing  Office,  Washington,  D.  C.     May  19,  191 1. 

Note  E.  increased  productivity. 

Methods  of  Increasing  Forest  Productivity,  E.  E.  Carter,  Vol.  2,  pp. 
270-279.     Report  of  the  National  Conservation  Commission,  1909. 

Note  F.  loss  due  to  avoidable  causes. 

Stopping  Forest  Fires,  ibed  Vol.  1,  pp.  61,  62. 

Forest  Fires,  Clyde  Leavitt,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  390-468. 

Waste  and  Reduction  of  Timber  Supplies  Caused  by  Insects  and 
Methods  of  Prevention  and  Control,  A.  D.  Hopkins,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp. 
469-497. 

Conservative  Turpentining,  George  B.  Sudworth,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp. 
498-511. 

Conservative  Logging,  Earle  N.  Clapp,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  512-546. 

Waste  in  Milling,  Louis  Margolin,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  547-567. 

Waste  in  Use  of  Timber,  McGarvey  Cline,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  568-580. 
What  is  Wasted,  ibed  Vol.  I,  pp.  57,  58. 

Conservative  Turpentining,  ibed  Vol.  1,  p.  64. 

Conservative  Logging,  ibed  Vol.  1,  pp.  64-66. 

Economy  in  the  Mill,  ibed  Vol.  1,  p.  66. 

Manufacture  of  By-Products,  ibed  Vol.  1,  pp.  66,  67. 

Wood  Preservation,  W.  F.  Sherfesee  and  H  F.  Weiss,  ibed  Vol.  2, 
pp.  658-667. 

Preservative  Treatment  of  Timber,  ibed  Vol.  1,  pp.  67,  68. 

Comparative  Statement  of  Material  Treated  in  the  United  States  dur- 
ing the  years  1907-1910.  Proceedings,  Wood  Preservers'  Association,  1911, 
p.  224. 

History  of  Wood  Preservation,  Octave  Chanute,  ibed  1909,  pp.  13-17. 

General  Review  of  Timber  Treating  in  this  Country  with  Special  Ref- 
erence to  the  Causes  that  have  and  are  Retarding  Its  More  Universal 
Adoption,  J.  T.  Logan,  ibed  191 1,  pp.  144-147. 

Review  of  Development  in  the  Timber  Treating  Industry,  ibed  191 1. 
pp.  147-156. 

Note  G.  forestry  in  foreign  countries. 

Economics  of  Forestry,  B.  E.  Fernow,  New  York,  1902,  pp.  274-330. 
Chapter  on  "Forest  Policies  of  Foreign  Nations." 

Cost  of  Forestry  in  Different  Countries,  H.  S  Graves.  Report  of  the 
National  Conservation  Commission,  Vol.  2,  pp.  371-374. 

Extent  to  Which  Foreign  Methods  of  Forest  Administration  are 
Suited  to  Conditions  in  the  United  States,  S.  T.  Dana,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp. 
375-389. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  437 


Note  H.  tree  planting. 

Forest  Planting,  A.  S.  Peck,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp.  668-686. 

Forest  Planting,  ibed  Vol.  i,  pp.  62,  63. 

Methods  Which  Should  Be  Adopted  by  Private  Owners  to  Insure 
the  Perpetuation  of  Our  Timber  Supply,  C.  S.  Chapman,  ibed  Vol.  2,  pp. 
711-747. 

Cost  of  Growing  Timber,  R.  S.  Kellogg  and  E.  A.  Ziegler,  American 
Lumberman  for  December  31,  1910. 

Timber  Supply  in  Relation  to  Wood  Preservation,  E.  A.  Sterling. 
Proceedings,  Wood  Preservers'  Association,  191 1,  pp.  140-144. 

LIST  OF  FIGURES. 

Fig.  1.     Opposite  page  180.     Loco  cite. 

Fig.  2.  Opposite  page  55  (Fig.  3)  Vol.  1,  Report  of  the  National 
Conservation  Commission,  1909. 

COAL  AND  FUEL  OIL  RESOURCES. 

The  Sub-Committee  dealing  with  the  above  subject  has  read  and  ex- 
amined a  large  mass  of  papers  and  various  data,  and  it  is  believed  that  the 
following  report  will  prove  of  value  to  the  Association. 

This  subject  has  not  heretofore  been  covered  by  the  Association.  The 
article  relating  to  relative  tests  of  oil  as  compared  to  coal  is  valuable  and 
probably  new  to  80  per  cent,  of  the  members.  The  standard  specifications 
proposed  by  Mr.  McAuliffe  are  worthy  of  endorsement  by  the  Association  ; 
the  Government  specifications  are  also  valuable  information. 

The  statistics  given  in  the  report  are  accurate  and  valuable  information. 

The  essence  of  the  report  on  this  subject  is  that  portion  relating  to 
"Methods  of  preventing  or  lessening  waste  in  the  petroleum  industry." 
This  paper  is  by  Mr.  David  T.  Day,  of  the  United  States  Geological  Sur- 
vey, and  is  worthy  of  a  great  deal  of  earnest  consideration. 

♦ADVANTAGES  OF  OIL  AS  FUEL  COMPARED  TO  COAL. 

The  principal  advantages  incident  to  burning  oil  as  compared  with 
coal  can  be  summed  up  as  follows: 

(1)  Cost.  This  item  depends  entirely  on  relative  price  at  mine  and 
well,  plus  freight  to  point  of  consumption.  In  computing  freight  haul, 
tariff  rates  must  govern  when  moved  over  foreign  lines  the  actual  cost 
of  moving  (not  including  what  is  known  as  fixed  charges)  ordinarily 
used  in  computing  cost  over  home  rails.  In  making  these  computations 
the  fact  that  from  1,000  to  1,500  lbs.  of  oil  equal  2,000  lbs.  of  coal  must 
be  taken  into  account. 

(2)  Decreased  cost  of  handling  oil  from  cars  to  engines  with  prac- 
tically no  loss  by  depreciation  due  to  such  handling,  all  coal  suffering 
badly  in  passage  through  coaling  plants  of  whatever  type. 

(3)  The  losses  by  evaporation  suffered  by  coal  do  not  apply  to  oil, 
neither  does  loss  by  theft  in  transit  occur,  oil  reaching  engine  tenders 
unimpaired  as  to  quality  and  undiminished  in  quantity. 

(4)  Saving  of  time  at  terminals  and  increased  mileage  per  engine, 
it  being  unnecessary  to  cut  engines  out  for  flue  cleaning;  the  oil  capacity 


•From   address   by   Mr.    Eugene    McAuliffe   before   International   Railway 
Fuel  Association. 


438  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

of  tender  approximating  150  per  cent,  of  that  of  coal,  making  longer  runs 
possible. 

(5)  Freedom  from  physical  failure  of  firemen  in  extreme  hot  weather, 
the  fireman's  work  being  actually  lighter  than  that  of  the  engineer. 

(6)  Stability  of  delivery,  oil  being  unaffected  by  labor  conditions 
which  has  made  the  production  of  coal  in  some  sections  so  uncertain  as 
to  necessitate  the  storage  of  immense  quantities  of  coal  at  great  expense, 
this  condition  occurring  at  frequent  intervals. 

(7)  Greater  cleanliness  in  handling  passenger  trains  with  almost 
absolute  immunity  from  right-of-way  fires,  saving  the  cost  of  fire-guards, 
and  reducing  also  claim  department  losses. 

The  drawbacks  to  the  use  of  oil  have  been  in  the  direction  of  un- 
certain supply.  The  expense  of  equipping  the  average  locomotive  to  burn 
oil  approximates  $800;  the  cost  of  constructing  steel  storage  tanks  of  large 
capacity  approximating  25c  per  barrel.  The  necessary  terminal  facilities, 
however,  cost  but  about  50  per  cent,  of  the  amount  required  to  handle  coal. 
With  coaling  facilities  usually  in  place,  however,  the  oil  facilities  when 
installed,  represent  a  duplication.  Frequently,  before  the  producer  is  able 
to  judge  his  production  sufficiently  well  to  warrant  the  making  of  definite 
contracts,  large  quantities  of  "pot"  oil  must  be  sacrificed  for  want  of 
storage  or  market  facilities.  After  the  production  is  reasonably  well 
determined,  an  interval  of  time  is  necessary  to  transform  locomotives, 
these  factors  being  embarrassing  both  to  the  oil  producer  and  the  railroad 
consumer.  With  the  development  of  new  fields  and  the  purchase  of  large 
numbers  of  cars,  together  with  the  increased  installation  of  oil-burning 
apparatus,  this  condition  will  grow  less  burdensome  in  the  future  than  it 
has  been  in  the  past. 

The  relative  cost  of  oil  and  coal  as  a  locomotive  fuel  is  governed  en- 
tirely by  local  conditions.  Any  road  contemplating  the  use  of  oil  must 
test  the  grade  of  oil  or  residuum  it  expects  to  burn  against  the  grade  of 
coal  for  which  it  is  to  be  substituted.  Different  coals  grade  within  greater 
extremes  than  do  oils,  which  fact,  if  proper  allowance  is  made  for  water 
and  sediment  in  the  case  of  crude  oil  purchases,  will  show  a  limited  varia- 
tion in  the  number  of  British  thermal  units  per  pound  of  fuel. 

♦PETROLEUM  AS  A  LOCOMOTIVE  FUEL. 

What  may  be  taken  as  an  indication  that  petroleum,  as  a  locomotive 
fuel,  is  coming  into  a  greater  degree  of  prominence  than  has  hitherto  been 
accorded  this  important  subject,  is  the  very  complete  equipment  for  han- 
dling and  using  this  fuel  on  the  Cascade  Division  of  the  Great  Northern 
Railway.  The  significance  of  this  work  is  all  the  more  marked  owing  to 
the  fact  that  the  region  in  which  this  division  is  located  is  convenient  to 
a  plentiful  supply  of  high-grade  coal  and  is  more  than  a  thousand  miles 
distant  from  the  source  of  oil  supply — the  direct  opposite  of  the  situation 
which  had  so  much  to  do  with  the  successful  development  of  locomotive 
oil-burning  apparatus  in  the  Southwest.  The  very  stumbling  blocks  to 
the  satisfactory  operation  of  its  Cascade  Division  by  means  of  coal-burning 
locomotives,  it  appears,  will  prove  a  vast  boon  to  the  Great  Northern,  not 
only  from  the  fact  that  by  the  use  of  fuel  oil  will  these  difficulties  be  cir- 
cumvented, but  at  the  same  time  there  is  given  promise  of  a  sufficient  sav- 
ing in  the  cost  of  operation  to  cover  the  entire  cost  of  the  fuel  oil  receiving, 
storage  and  handling  facilities,  approximately  $300,000,  during  the  first 
year   of  their   use. 

One  of  the  conspicuous  features  prompting  the  change  from  coal 
to  oil  in  this  instance  was  the  constant  danger  of  Hre  both  to  the  vast 
forest  preserves  through  which  the  line  passes,  and  to  the  numerous  timber 


♦Editorial  from  Railway  and  Engineering  Review,  December  9,   1911. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  439 

xnowsheds  which  the  road  maintains  in  this  locality.  Great  as  was  the 
relief  to  be  sought  from  the  damages  attending  the  use  of  coal  on  ac- 
count of  fires,  the  earliest  investigations  showed  the  possibility  of  ma- 
terial savings  in  the  cost  of  the  fuel  itself,  irrespective  of  the  distance 
from  the  source  of  supply.  In  addition  there  was  recognized  the  possi- 
bility of  reduced  cost  in  handling  and  transporting  the  fuel,  savings  due 
to  the  elimination  of  losses  following  the  exposure  of  coal  to  weather 
conditions,  theft,  etc.,  and  the  saving  in  time  owing  to  the  greater  con- 
venience of  oil  as  compared  with  coal,  besides  which  the  advantage  of 
being  able  to  concentrate  within  a  single  motive  power  unit  every  ounce 
of  power  of  which  the  locomotive,  as  a  machine,  is  capable  of  develop- 
ing and  the  general  effect  on  the  morale  of  the  employes  owing  to  the 
greater  ease  of  firing  and  the  improved  conditions  as  to  cleanliness,  are 
items  which  argue  strongly  in  favor  of  the  use  of  oil.  Other  and  more 
local  factors  adding  to  the  difficulty  of  operation  in  this  locality  are 
heavy  mountain  grades  and  extreme  weather  conditions,  through  all  of 
which  the  Great  Northern  has  set  itself  the  task  of  maintaining  an  effi- 
cient and  dependable  transcontinental  service.  The  care  with  which  the 
engineers  of  this  road  have  investigated  and  perfected  this  work  seems 
to  insure  a  successful  outcome,  which,  when  it  definitely  materializes,  will 
undoubtedly  mark  the  beginning  of  a  much  wider  application  of  this  fuel 
in  railway  service  than  at  present  obtains. 

^EVAPORATIVE  TESTS— OIL  AS  FUEL. 

A  large  number  of  locomotive  tests  have  been  made  by  the  Southern 
Pacific  Company,  covering  the  use  of  fuel  oil  as  well  as  in  comparison 
with  coal.  The  accompanying  table  shows  evaporative  results  on  some 
of  the  most  recent  tests  covering  about  the  heaviest  oil  firing  on  the 
Southern  Pacific  in  crossing  the  Sierra  Nevada  range.  Comparisons  of 
coal  and  oil  from  an  economic  standpoint  are  most  interesting  where  the 
two  fuels  come  in  competition,  and  relative  values  must  largely  depend 
on  the  conditions  and  form  of  boilers  under  which  either  fuel  is  burned. 
Some  engine  boilers  are  better  adapted  for  coal  than  oil,  or  vice  versa, 
depending  on  construction.  Comparisons  therefore  are  to  some  degree  a 
function  of  the  boiler  itself.  This  was  gone  into  quite  thoroughly  when 
the  locomotives  were  converted  and  a  summary  of  the  results  is  given 
as  follows : 

Evaporation 
2,000  lbs. 
Number  in         Equivalent   to 

Type  of  Locomotive.  Service.  Fuel  Oil,  Gals. 

Eight-wheel 50  144 

Ten-wheel     294  151 

MiOgul 176  146 

Twelve-wheel 67  158 

Consolidation 139  162 

Atlantic   19  144 

Mallet   17  No  coal  record 

These  figures  are  based  on  evaporative  tests  before  and  after  con- 
version. The  comparisons  are  with  ordinary  bituminous  coal  of  about  13,- 
350  b.  t.  u.  The  total  number  of  locomotives  accounted  for  above  is  745, 
and  the  mean  equivalent  is  152  gals,  or  3.62  bbls.  of  42  gals.,  equivalent  in 
heat  value  to  2,000  lbs.  of  coal.  The  average  equivalent  figures  in  the  table 
cover  much  careful  work  and  are  based  on  equivalent  evaporative  results 
from  many  service  tests.     It  should  be  borne  in  mind  that  the  figures  are 

♦Extract  from  a  paper  read  by  Mr.  Howard  Stillman  before  the  Ameri- 
can Society  of  Mechanical  Engineers. 


440 


CONSERVATION    OF    NATURAL    RESOURCES. 


DATA  FROM  EVAPORATION  TESTS   OF  LOCOMOTIVES,    SACRAMENTO 
DIVISION,     SOUTHERN     PACIFIC     COMPANY. 


Profile  of  Road,  Roseville  to  Summit 


Vertical  Scale,  l"=  4000  ft. 
Horizontal  Scale,  l"=  20  miles 


Elevation  above  Sea  Level. 
Max.  Grade,  Feet  imr  Mile. 
Distance  from  Roscville 


Class  of  engine. 


Service 

Date  of  test 

Number  of  single  trips  in  test 

Total  time  of  test < 

Actual  running  time 

Miles  run , 

Average  steam  pressure  (gage) ,  lb 

Smoke  box  temperature,  deg.  f ahr 

Total  gal.  water  evaporated 

Total  lb.  water  evaporated ...,-. 

Total  gal.  oil  burned 

Total  lb.  oil  burned , 

Equivalent  evaporation,  lb.  water  per 

lb.  oil 

Lb.  water  evaporated  persq.  ft.  heating 

surface  per  hr 

Lb.  oil  burned  per  sq.  ft.  heating  surface 

per  hr 

Number  of  cars  in  train .  . 

Weight  of  train,  tons 

Gross  ton  mileage 

Gal.  water  evaporated  per  1000  ton  ml. 
Lb.  water  evaporated  per  1000  ton  ml.. 
Gal.  fuel  oil  burned  per  1000  ton  miles. 
Lb.  fuel  oil  burned  per  1000  ton  miles. 

Boiler  efficiency,  per  cent 

Maximum  1.  h.  p 

Mean  i.  h.  p 

Dimensions  of  locomotive 

Engine  no 

Size  of  cylinders,  in 

Diameter  of  drivers,  in 

Total  weight  of  locomotive,  lb 

Weight  on  drivers,  lb 

Weight  of  tender,  lb 

Total  heating  surface,  sq.  ft 

Feed  water  heater.heatlng  surface,  sq.  ft.] 


10  whee. 


Passenger 


Consolidation 


Freight 


May  21  and  26,  1908  June  9  and  11,  1909 


17  hr.  39  mln. 

13  hr.  55  mln. 

315 

196.0 

797 

44147 

367642 

3951.6 

31613 

14.14 

8.698 

0.748 
7 

342 
107730 
409.79 
3413 
34.90 
279.20 
73.84 
1719 
1368 

231 
22X28 

63 
203300 
160000 
138070 

2994 


21  hr.  23  mln. 
12  hr.  59  min. 
174 
196.1 
738.5 
48103 
400858 
4328.4 
34627 

13.95 

8.809 

0.761 
14.5 
481 

83694 
574.75 

4790 

48.40 
387.20 

72.83 

1470 

1222 

25S4 
22X30 

57 
208000 
187000 
134745 

3403 


Mallet  consoli- 
dation 
Freight 
Nov.  6  and  8,  1909 
2 
29  hr.  2  mln. 
18  hr.  11  mln. 
174 
194.6 
451.3 
91087 
759058 
7692.1 
61537 

16.04 

6.392 

0.518 

24.6 

1056 
183744 
495.73 

4131 

39.61 
316.08 

78.52 

2486 

2057 

4001 

26  and  40X30 

57 

425900 

394150 

169765 

6394 

1221 


Note.— Train  weights  are  the  average  for  the  distance  hauled  and  are  exclusive  of  engine  and 
tender.  Tests  made  under  oidinary  se  vice  conditions.  Engines  unaided.  In  "water  evapor- 
ated and  oil  burned  per  sq.  ft.  heating  surface  per  hr.,"  the  figures  are  for  actual  running  time; 
the  allowance  of  15  gal.  of  oil  and  its  equivalent  In  water  is  made  per  hi.  while  standing.  In 
"gai.  and  lb.  oil  per  1000  ton  ml.,"  a  deduction  Is  made  of  15  gal.  per  hr.  while  standing  and 
3.5  per  cent  of  oil  for  evaporating  steam  for  atomizing  oil.  Quantity  of  oil  burned  corrected  to 
normal  temperature  of  70  deg.  fahr.  All  measuring  instruments  calibrated.  Analysis  of  fuel: 
Kern  River  oil;  gravity,  15.8  deg.  Baume;  flash  point,  230  deg.  fahr.;  fire  point,  278  deg.  fabr.; 
commercial  weight,  8  lb.  per  gal. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  441 

from  service  tests  and  represent  oil  burned  on  the  main  line  between  ter- 
minals only,  and  not  losses  in  transfer,  handling,  or  firing  up,  etc.  Our  Ac- 
counting Department  uses  a  figure  of  168  gals,  or  4  bbls.  of  oil,  equivalent 
to  one  ton  of  coal.  It  may  be  said  that  with  fuel  oil,  providing  engines 
are  burning  it  with  a  fair  degree  of  efficiency,  the  quality  of  fuel  is  a 
constant  factor.  Poor  or  bad  coal  as  accounting  for  engine  failures 
drops  from  the  delay  report — "cleaning  fires"  is  abolished. 

♦INSPECTION  AND  TESTS  OF  FUEL  OIL. 

SPECIFICATIONS    OF    FUEL    OIL. 

Inspection  and  Tests. 

The  matter  of_  oil  inspection,  more  particularly  where  crude  oil  is 
purchased,  is  an  important  one,  and  if  any  considerable  volume  of 
oil  is  purchased  a  competent,  reliable  inspector  should  be  employed,  one 
able  to  make  the  following  determinations : 

Flash  Test. — By  flash  point  is  understood  that  temperature  to  which 
an  oil  must  be  heated  to  give  off  vapors,  which,  when  mixed  with 
air,  produce  an  explosive  mixture.  The  results  of  this  test  will  vary 
according  to  the  quantity  of  air  over  the  surface  of  the  oil,  and  whether 
this  be  moving  or  still ;  also  according  to  the  distance  of  the  testing 
flame  from  the  surface  of  the  oil.  Furthermore,  the  size  of  the  flame, 
the  length  of  its  time  of  action,  its  form  and  dimensions,  and,  lastly, 
the  manner  of  heating  of  the  oil,  will  all  influence  the  result. 

Fire  Test. — The  fire  test  of  an  oil  is  the  temperature  at  which  it 
will  give  off  vapors,  which,  when  ignited,  will  burn  continuously.  It 
is  made  by  continuing  to  heat  the  oil  (the  cover  being  removed  in  the 
case  of  a  closed  tester  without  slipping  out  the  thermometer)  at  the 
same  rate  after  the  flash  test  is  made,  and  noting  the  point  as  indicated 
above.  The  flame  is  extinguished  by  a  piece  of  asbestos  board  and  the 
heating  discontinued.  In  the  case  of  ordinary  oils  this  point  is  from 
10  degrees  to  20  degrees  Fahrenheit  higher  than  the  flash  point. 

Specific  Gravity. — This  is  usually  affected  by  the  hydrometer;  a 
hydrometer  jar  is  four-fifths  filled  with  the  oil,  a  Baume  hydrometer 
introduced  into  it,  and  the  depth  read  off  to  which  the  instrument  sinks 
in  the  oil.  This  may  be  effected  by  placing  a  strip  of  white  paper 
back  of  the  jar  and  noting  the  point  at  which  the  meniscus  of  the  oil 
touches  the  scale.  The  temperature  of  the  oil  is  taken  at  the  same  time, 
and  in  case  it  be  not  60  degrees  Fahrenheit  for  every  increase  of  10 
degrees  Fahrenheit,  subtract  1  degree  Baume  from  the  hydrometer 
reading.  The  specific  gravity  may  be  found  by  the  formula 
140 

: —  representing  the  reading  Baume  at  60  degrees  Fahrenheit. 

130  -f  B.  Deg. 

Shrinkage. — Frequently  at  small  refineries,  or  where  the  residuum 
storage  capacity  is  inadequate,  oil  is  pumped  into  tank  cars  at  a  high 
temperature  and  when  subsequently  cooled  to  60  degrees  Fahrenheit, 
the  loss  from  shrinkage  is  material.  In  the  event  that  tank  cars 
are  partially  filled  in  cold  weather  and  the  oil  allowed  to  cool  materially 
below  60  degrees  Fahrenheit,  care  should  be  taken  to  see,  when  subse- 
quently topped  or  filling  is  completed,  that  due  allowance  is  made  for 
increased  volume  incident  to  the  expansion  that  will  occur  if  the  tem- 
perature of  the  oil  is  increased,  a  variation  of  20  degrees  Fahrenheit 
resulting  in  an  expansion  of  approximately  1  per  cent.  For  these  reasons 
that  feature  of  the  inspection  rules  (set  forth  below)  covering  the  shrink- 
age  should   be   carefully  observed. 

♦From  address  by  Mr.  Eugene  McAuliffe  before  International  Railway 
Fuel  Association. 


442  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

Water  Determination. — The  matter  of  determining  the  amount  of 
water  and  sediment  contained  in  crude  oil,  particularly  when  purchased 
from  wells  in  a  water-making  field,  or  storage  oil,  when  stored  in 
earthen  tanks  subject  to  additions  of  water  and  sediment  test  set  forth  in 
the   standard   specifications. 

Standard    Specifications. 

The  following  basis  for  standard  specifications  covering  the  purchase 
of  fuel  oil  by  RAILROAD  companies  will  quite  generally  cover  both 
crude  and  residuum  purposes. 

General  Requirements. — Fuel  oil  to  be  distilled  or  reduced  petroleum, 
free  from  sand  or  other  solid  matter  that  will  impede  or  prevent  free 
handling  through  ordinary-sized  pumps,  pipes  or  burners ;  to  be  of  a 
viscosity  that  will  permit  of  its  being  handled  freely  at  a  temperature 
of  60  degrees  Fahrenheit.  Whenever  practicable,  all  free  water  must 
be  drawn  from  working  tanks  before  delivery.  Swing  pipes  in  working 
tanks  must  be  adjusted  to  prevent,  as  far  as  possible,  free  water  entering 
into  delivery  pumps  or  lines. 

Sampling. — With  full  length  thief.  One  sample  will  be  taken  from 
each  car  promptly  after  being  unloaded,  with  a  thief  having  automatic 
valve  at  lower  end,  which  closes  at  instant  thief  touches  bottom  of  car, 
the  theory  of  this  thief  being  to  cut  out  a  section  of  the  fluid.  When  tak- 
ing sample,  thief  should  be  lowered  slowly  and  the  upper  end  must  have 
free  outlet  for  air  which  thief  contains  when  it  is  inserted  into  the  oil, 
thus  to  admit  of  liquid  replacing  the  air,  without  creating  undue  mo- 
tion, suction  or  pressure  at  the  bottom. 

Testing  Samples. — Same  to  permit  of  the  use  of  gasoline  or  Centri- 
fuge methods,  as  follows : 

Gasoline  Method. — Samples  should  be  thoroughly  shaken  and  mixed, 
then  50  cubic  centimeters  of  sample  placed  in  a  100  centimeter  gradu- 
ated glass  cylinder,  an  equal  quantity  of  not  less  than  68  degrees  gasoline 
should  be  mixed  with  the  sample  in  the  graduated  glass,  the  combined 
mixture  of  oil  and  gasoline  should  then  be  thoroughly  shaken  and  sample 
heated  to  a  temperature  of  from  120  degrees  to  130  degrees  Fahrenheit 
and  allowed  to  stand  for  from  three  to  six  hours,  the  actual  per  cent, 
of  water  equal  to  twice  the  per  cent,  shown  in  the  graduated  glass. 

Centrifuge  Method. — Samples  should  be  thoroughly  shaken  and 
mixed;  then  100  cubic  centimeters  of  sample  placed  in  a  200-centimeter 
graduated  glass  cylinder.  An  equal  quantity  of  not  less  than  68  de- 
grees gravity  gasoline  should  be  mixed  with  the  sample  in  the  graduated 
glass;  then  glass  placed  in  machine  and  the  machine  run  full  speed  for 
five  minutes,  when  reading  should  be  taken,  and  machine  then  run  for 
another  five  minutes  and  second  reading  taken ;  if  on  second  reading 
there  is  any  increase  over  first  reading  the  machine  should  be  run  for 
another  five  minutes,  making  a  total  of  fifteen  minutes,  when  final  reading 
should  be  taken,  the  per   cent,   of  water   doubled   as  before. 

Percentage  of  water  and  sediment  should  be  taken  by  representatives 
of  seller  and  buyer,  and  tickets  exchanged  showing  the  total  percent- 
age of  water  and  sediment  which  each  car  contains.  The  buyer  shall 
be  entitled  to  deduct  all  water  and  sediment  in  excess  of  one-half  of  one 
per  cent,  under  the  usual  tests,  and  may  refuse  to  accept  or  move  cars  con- 
taining in  excess  of  3  per  cent,  water  and  sediment. 

In  order  to  facilitate  the  movement  of  cars,  the  representatives  of 
buyer  and  seller  may,  from  time  to  time,  take  samples  of  oil  from  the 
filling  lines  as  cars  are  being  loaded,  for  the  purpose  of  determining 
approximately  the  quality  and  condition  of  the  oil  being  delivered,  and 
may,  for  their  personal  information  or  for  account  of  their  principals,  keep 
records  of  such  samples. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  443 

Adjusting  for  Temperature. — 'Rack  men  and  inspectors  will  regulate 
the  filling  of  cars,  being  governed  by  the  temperature  of  the  oil  at  the 
time  it  is  loaded.  If  cars  are  partially  filled  in  very  cold  weather,  care 
should  be  taken  not  to  allow  the  oil  to  rise  in  the  dome  when  topping  or 
refilling  is  done,  care  being  taken  to  see  that  sufficient  room  is  left 
for  possible  expansion.  When  oil  is  placed  in  the  car  at  a  temperature 
above  60  degrees  Fahrenheit  an  allowance  of  1  per  cent,  in  volume  for 
each  20  degrees  Fahrenheit  above  60  degrees  Fahrenheit  should  be 
made,  i.  e.,  100  gallons  on  each  tank  car  of  10,000  capacity. 

Fire  Test. — Buyer  may  refuse  to  accept  any  fuel  oil  showing  a  fire 
point  less  than  120  degrees  Fahrenheit  when  tested  by  the  open-cup 
Tagliabue  method,  namely:  Heating  the  oil  at  the  rate  of  2  degrees  per 
minute,  test  flame  to  be  applied  every  2  degrees  as  temperature  of  oil  is 
raised,  beginning  at  60  degrees   Fahrenheit. 

Gravity. — Buyer  may  refuse  to  accept  fuel  oil  of  less  than  15  degrees 
or  more  than  30  degrees  Baume  gravity. 

Tank  Cars. — Tank  cars  furnished  must  be  in  good  order  and  such 
cars  must  be  provided  with  caps  and  valves  that  can  be  readily  adjusted. 
Tank  cars  must  be  reasonably  clean  and  free  from  deposits  of  dirt,  sand, 
sediment  or  other  material  that  will  appreciably  affect  the  tests  of  the 
quality  of  the  oil.  Seller  may  refuse  to  accept  cars  furnished  that  are  not 
in  the  condition  above  specified,  unless  instructed  to  fill  cars  at  buyer's 
risk  as  to  loss  or  quality  of  oil.  Turning  oil  into  cars  at  racks  will  be 
understood  to  be  an  acceptance  on  the  part  of  the  seller. 

Receipts. — In  the  event  that  the  buyer  maintains  a  representative  for 
the  purpose  of  inspecting  shipments  of  oil  furnished  under  this  contract, 
such  representative  will,  when  tank  cars  have  been  loaded,  samples  taken, 
outlet  caps  and  manheads  placed,  immediately  sign  receipt  furnished  by 
the  representative  of  the  seller,  showing:  (1)  number  of  refinery,  well, 
or  number  of  storage  tank  loading  same;  (2)  station  from  which  car 
is  billed;  (3)  car  number  and  initial;  (4)  car  capacity  shown  in  Inter- 
state Commerce  Commission  tariffs;  (5)  actual  capacity  as  cars  are 
loaded  after  allowance  for  expansion  or  contraction  has  been  made  as 
provided  for  in  rules  governing  adjustment  for  temperature. 

GOVERNMENT  FUEL  OIL  SPECIFICATIONS. 

In  consequence  of  the  success  that  has  attended  the  use  of  heating- 
value  specifications  in  buying  and  selling  coal,  there  has  arisen  a  de- 
mand for  similar  specifications,  based  on  careful  tests,  to  govern  the 
purchase  of  fuel  oils  and  the  refined  products  of  petroleum.  The  bureau 
of  mines  has  therefore  issued  technical  paper  No.  3,  by  Mr.  Irving  C. 
Allen,  on  "Specifications  for  the  purchase  of  fuel  oil  for  the  Government," 
with  directions  for  sampling  oil  and  natural  gas. 

The  general  specifications  for  the  purchase  of  fuel  oil  are  given  as 
follows : 

In  determining  the  award  of  a  contract,  consideration  will  be  given  to 
the  quality  of  the  fuel  offered  by  the  bidders,  as  well  as  the  price,  and 
should  it  appear  to  be  to  the  best  interest  of  the  government  to  award  a 
contract  at  a  higher  price  than  that  named  in  the  lowest  bid  or  bids 
received,  the  contract  will  be  so  awarded. 

Fuel  oil  should  be  either  a  natural  homogeneous  oil  or  a  homo- 
geneous residue  from  a  natural  oil ;  if  the  latter,  all  constituents  having  a 
low  flash  point  should  have  been  removed  by  distillation;  it  should  not  be 
composed  of  a  light  oil  and  a  heavy  residue  mixed  in  such  proportions  as 
to  give  the  density  desired. 


444  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

It  should  not  have  been  distilled  at  a  temperature  high  enough 
to  burn  it,  nor  at  a  temperature  so  high  that  flecks  of  carbonaceous 
matter  began  to  separate. 

It  should  not  flash  below  60  degrees  Centigrade  (140  degrees  Fahren- 
heit)  in  a  closed  Abel-Pensky  or  Pensky-Martens  tester. 

Its  specific  gravity  should  range  from  0.85  to  0.96  at  15  degrees  Centi- 
grade (59  degrees  Fahrenheit)  ;  the  oil  should  be  rejected  if  its  specific 
gravity  is  above  0.97  at  that  temperature. 

It  should  be  mobile,  free  from  solid  or  semi-solid  bodies,  and  should 
flow  readily,  at  ordinary  atmospheric  temperatures  and  under  a  head  of  I 
foot  of  oil,  through  a  4-in.  pipe  10  ft.  in  length. 

It  should  not  congeal  nor  become  too  sluggish  to  flow  at  o  degrees 
Centigrade   (32  degrees  Fahrenheit). 

It  should  have  a  calorific  value  of  not  less  than  10,000  calories  per 
gram  (18,000  B.  T.  U.  per  lb.),  10,250  calories  to  be  the  standard.  A 
bonus  is  to  be  paid  or  a  penalty  deducted  according  to  the  method  stated 
under  section  21,  as  the  fuel  oil  delivered  is  above  or  below  this  standard. 

It  should  be  rejected  if  it  contains  more  than  two  per  cent,  water. 

It  should  be  rejected  if  it  contains  more  than  one  per  cent,  sulphur 

It  should  not  contain  more  than  a  trace  of  sand,  clay  or  dirt. 

Each  bidder  must  submit  an  accurate  statement  regarding  the  fuel  oil 
he  proposes  to  furnish.  This  statement  should  show:  The  commercial 
name  of  the  oil ;  the  name  or  designation  of  the  field  from  which  the  oil 
is  obtained ;  whether  the  oil  is  a  crude  oil,  a  refinery  residue  or  a  dis- 
tillate; the  name  and  location  of  the  refinery,  if  the  oil  has  been  refined 
at  all. 

The  fuel  oil  is  to  be  delivered  f.  o.  b.  cars  or  vessel,  according  to  the 
manner  of  shipment,  at  such  places,  at  such  times,  and  in  such  quantities 
as  may  be  required,  during  the  fiscal  year. 

Should  the  contractor,  for  any  reason,  fail  to  comply  with  a  written 
order  to  make  delivery,  the  government  is  to  be  at  liberty  to  buy  oil  in  the 
open  market  and  charge  against  the  contractor  any  excess  of  price, 
above  the  contract  price,  of  the  fuel  oil  so  purchased. 

Complete  copies  of  these  specifications  may  be  obtained  from  the 
director  of  the  bureau  of  mines,  Washington,  D.  C. 

♦METHODS  OF  PREVENTING  OR  LESSENING  WASTE  IN  THE 
PETROLEUM  INDUSTRY. 

CHECKING    UNNECESSARY    PRODUCTION. 

At  present  more  petroleum  is  being  produced  than  is  necessary  for 
the  legitimate  demands  of  the  industry.  Within  ten  years  the  present 
fields  will  be  unable  profitably  to  produce  enough  for  these  legitimate 
requirements.  Inasmuch  as  the  lands  now  owned  by  private  interests 
are  leased  by  rival  concerns,  it  is  impossible  to  prevent  each  rval  from 
producing  petroleum  as  rapidly  as  he  desires.  The  only  direction  in 
which  production  can  be  checked  is  with  the  petroleum  contained  in 
public  lands.  Offering  such  public  land  for  entry  at  a  nominal  price 
is  nothing  more  than  temptation  to  the  private  citizen  to  waste  petroleum 
by  overproduction,  since  lands  yielding  hundreds  of  dollars  per  rcre 
in  this  product  can  be  obtained  for  a  nominal  sum.  Every  acre  >f  pub- 
lic land  believed  to  contain  supplies  of  petroleum  or  natural  gas  should 
be  withdrawn  from  every  form  of  entry  and  should  be  subjected  to  an 
equitable  system  of  lease.  By  this  means  undoubtedly  a  large  mount 
of  petroleum  would  be  reserved  for  use  when  the  supply  becomes  in- 
adequate to  industrial   demands.     It  should  be  noted  that  since  the  ad- 


*From  Government  Report,   "Production  of  Petroleum  in  1910." 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


445 


*PRODUCTION    OF    PETROLEUM    IN    THE    UNITED    STATES 
FROM  1859-1910,  INCLUSIVE. 

PRODUCTION    OF    PETROLEUM    IN    THE    UNITED    STATES,    1859-1910, 
INCLUSIVE,  BY   YEARS  AND  BY   STATES,   IN   BAR- 
RELS  OF   42   GALLONS. 


Year. 

Pennsyl- 
vania and 
New  York. 

Ohio. 

West 
Virginia. 

California. 

Kentucky 

and 
Tennessee 

Colorad 

Indiana. 

Illinois. 

1859 

2,000 
500,000 

2,113,609 
3, 056, 690 
2,611,309 
2,116,109 
2, 497, 700 

3,597,700 
3,347,300 
3,646,117 
4,215,000 
5,260,745 

5,205,234 
6,293,194 
9,893,786 
10,926,915 
8,787,514 

8,968,906 
13,135,475 
15,163,462 
19,685,170 
26,027,631 

27,376,509 
30,053,500 
23,128,389 
23,772,209 
20,776,041 

25,798,000 
22,356,193 
16,488,068 
21,487,435 
28,458,208 

33,009,236 
28,422,377 
20.314,513 
19,019,990 
19,144,390 

20,584,421 
19,262,066 
15,948,464 
14,374,512 
14,559,127 

13,831,996 
13,183,610 
12,518,134 
12,239,026 
11,554,777 

11,500,410 
11,211,606 
10,584,453 
10,434,300 
9,848,500 

1860 

1861 

1862 

1863 

. 

1864 

1865 

1866 

1867 

1868 

1869 

: 

1870 

1871 

1872 

1873..   . 

1874 



1875 

1876 

31,763 

29,888 
38, 179 
29,112 
38,940 

33,867 
39,761 
47, 632 
90,081 
661,580 

1,782,970 
5,022,632 
10,010,868 
12,471,466 
16,124,656 

17,740,301 
16,362,921 
16,249,769 
16,792,154 
19,545,233 

23,941,169 
21,560,515 
18,738,708 
21,142,108 
22,362,730 

21,648,083 
21,014,231 
20,480,286 
18,876,631 
16,346,660 

14,787,763 
12,207,448 
10,858,797 
10,632,793 
9,916,370 

120,000 
172,000 
180, 000 
180,000 
179, 000 

151,000 
128,000 
126,000 
90,000 
91,000 

102,000 
145,000 
119,448 
544,113 
492,578 

2,406,218 
3,810,086 
8,445,412 
8,577,624 
8, 120, 125 

10,019,770 
13,090,045 
13,615,101 
13,910,630 
16,195,675 

14,177,126 
13,513,345 
12,899,395 
12,644,686 
11,578,110 

10,120,935 
9,095,296 
9,523,176 
10,745,092 
11,751,871 

12,000 
13,000 
15,227 
19,858 
40,552 

93, 862 
128,636 
142,857 
262,000 
325,000 

377,145 
678,572 
690,333 

1877 

::::::::::] 

4,/>5 
4/48 
5>64 

/726 

/,79l 

i,096 

6,400 

/6.000 

/  9,000 

6,500 

3,000 

'      1,500 

1,500 

1,680 
322 

5,568 
18,280 
62,259 

137,259 
185,331 

554,286 

76,295 
297,612 
316,476 
368,842 

665,482 
824,000 
594,390 
515,746 
438,232 

361,450 
384,934 
444, 383 
390,278 
317,385 

460,520 
396,901 
483,925 
501,763 
376,238 

327.582 
331,851 
379, 653 
310, 861 
239, 794 

1888 

33,375 
63,496 

136,634 

698,068 

2,335,293 

3,688,666 

4,386,132 

4,6S0,732 
4,122,356 
3,730,907 
3, 848, 182 
4,874,392 

5,757,086 
7,480,896 
9,186,411 
11,339,124 
10,964,247 

7,673,477 
5,128,037 
3,283,629 
2,296,086 
2,159,725 

1889..     . 
1890. 

1891 
1892 
1893 
1894 
1895 

1896 
1897 
1898 
1899 
1900. . . 

1901 
1902 
1903 
1904 
1905 

1906 
1907 
1908 

1909..    .. 
1910 

303,22 
307, 36 

323,60 
385,04 
470,17 
705,96 
1,208,48 

1,252,77 
1,903,41 
2,257,20 
2,642,09 
4,324,48/ 

8, 786, 3/ 
13,984,? 
24,382/ 
29,649>4 
33, 427/™ 

33,09698 

55  I.**" 
73^0,560 

1 
J 

1 
> 
1 

1 

r, 
\ 

1,460 
900 

675 
621 
400 
300 
200 

250 

500 
360 
360 
200 

250 
200 

998,284 
1,217,337 

1,213.548 

820,844 
0  727,767 
"639,016 
a  468, 774 

181,084 

4,397,050 
24,281,973 
33,686,238 
30,898,339 
33,143,362 

Total. 

718,292,662 

397,658,065 

217,059,857 

3^02,723 

7,112,135   S 

,804,593 

97,866,951 

126,593,490 

o  No  production  Tennessee  recorded. 


•From  Government  Report,    "Reduction   of  Petroleum   in   1910." 


446 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


PRODUCTION    OF    PETROLEUM    IN    THE    UNITED    STATES,    1859-1910, 

BY  YEARS  AND  EY   STATES,   IN  BARRELS 

OP  42  GALLONS— CONTINUED. 


Year. 


Wyo- 
ming. 


United 
States. 


Total  valae. 


1859. 
1860. 

1861. 
1862. 
1863. 
1864. 
1865. 


1867. . 
1868. . 
1869.. 
1870. . 

1871. . 
1872. . 
1873. . 
1874. , 
1875.. 

1876. 
1877. 
1878. 
1879. 
1880. 

1881. 
1882. 
1883. 
1884. 
1885. 

1886. 
1887. 


1891. 

1892. 


1894. 
1895. 


1897. 
1898. 
1899. 
1900. 

1901. 
1902. 
1903. 
1904. 
1905. 

1906. 
1907. 
1908. 
1909. 
1910. 


Total 


500 
1,200 

1,400 
5,000 
18,000 
40,000 
44,430 

113,571 

81,098 
71,980 
69,700 
74,714 

179,151 

331,749 

932,214 

4.250,779 

el2,013,495 

c21,718,648 
2,409,521 
1,801,781 
1,263,764 
1,128,668 


46,551,363 


48 
54 

54 
45 
50 
CO 
50 

1,450 
65,975 
546,070 
669,013 
836,039 

4,393,658 
18,083,658 
17,955,572 
22,241,413 
28,136,189 

12,567,897 
12,322,696 
11,206,464 
9,534, 467 
8,899,266 


147,460,188 


h 

132' 
a  1,602" 

6  2,335 
a  757 
o3,000 
a  2,572 
o3,100 

O3.500 
o4,000 
o 15,246 
o5,750 
03, 615 


30 
80 
10 
130 
37 

170 
625 


6,472 

10,000 
37,100 
138.911 
,366,748 
(«) 

■»24,128 

5^8,765 

'.9,218 

52,tf,718 


2,369 
3,455 

2,878 
3,650 
5,475 
5.560 
5,450 

5,400 
6,253 
8,960 
11,542 
8,454 

«7,000 
/9,339 
/17,775 
/20,056 
/115.430 


548, 617 

917,771 

2.958,958 

8,910,416 

9,077,528 
5,000,221 
5,788,874 
3,059,531 
6,841,395 


2,000 
500,000 

2,113,609 
3,056,690 
2,611,309 
2,116,109 
2,497,700 

3,597.700 
3,347,300 
3,646,117 
4,215,000 
5,260,745 

5,205,234 
6,293,194 
9,893,786 
10,926,945 
8,787,514 

9,132,669 
13,350,363 
15,396,868 
19,914,146 
26,286,123 

27,661,238 
30,349,897 
23,449,633 
24,218,438 
21,858/786 

28,064,841 
28,283,483 
27,612,025 
35,163,513 
45,823,572 

54,292,655 
50,514,657 
48,431,066 
49,344,516 
52,892,276 

60,960,361 
60,.475,516 
55,364,233 
57,070,850 
63,620,529 

69,389,194 
88,766,916 
100,461,337 
117,080,960 
134,717,580 

126,493,936 
166,095,335 
178,527,355 
183,170.874 
209,556,048 


J32.000 
4,800,000 


1,035 
3.209 
8.225 
20, 896 
16,459 


13,455 
8,066 
13,217 
23,730 
20,503 

22,591 
21,440 
18,100 
12,647 
7,368 

22,982 
31,788 
18,044 
17,210 
24,600: 

23,512 
23,631 
25,740 
20,476 
19,193 

20,028 
18,858! 
17,950 
26,963 
35,365 

30,526 
25,906 
28,932 
35,522 
57,691 

58,518 
40,929 
44,193 
64,603 
75,752 

66,417 
71,178 
94,694 
101,175 
84,157 

92,444 

120, 106 
129,079 
128,328 
127,896 


993 
174 

450 

754 

180 

503 
464 
527 
133 

822 
566 
520 
70S 
638 

051 
165 
252 
924 

694 

457 
606 
353 
340 
105 

553 

463 
326 
095 
279 

709 
611 

359 
904 
691 

335 
910 
050 
455 
399 

735 
749 
184 

487 
328 


46,082   190,7,142  239,046 


44,149,567 


2,378,907,864 


2,040,808,758 


a  Includes  the  production  of  Michiti. 

b  Includes  production  of  Michigan  i.\  small  production  in  Oklahoma. 

e  Includes  production  of  Oklahoma. 

&  Included  with  Kansas. 

«  Estimated. 

/  Includes  the  production  of  Utah. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


447 


vance  copies  of  this  report  appeared  in  the  public  press,  the  petroleum 
producers  of  Oklahoma  have  arranged  to  reduce  production  in  that  state. 

BETTER    COMBUSTION. 

The  use  of  petroleum  as  a  form  of  power  is  justified  on  the  Pacific 
Coast,  provided  attention  is  given  to  securing  the  maximum  amount  of 
power  per  unit  of  oil.  This  is  not  consistent  with  burning  oil  under 
stationary  boilers  for  the  production  of  steam,  but  prompt  study  should  be 
given  to  the  development  of  internal-combustion  engines  capable  of 
using  crude  petroleum  or,  more  particularly,  less  valuable  residuum. 
It  should  be  noted  that  private  enterprise  has  already  done  much  for 
the  successful  solution  of  this  problem. 


RANK  OF  PETROLEUM-PRODUCING  STATES,  WITH  VALUE  OF  PRO- 
DUCTION AND  PERCENTAGE  OF  EACH,  IN  1909  AND  1910. 


California 

Illinois 

West  Virginia. 

Oklahoma 

Pennsylvania. 

Ohio 

Texas 

Louisiana 

Indiana 

New  York 

Kentucky 

Kansas 

Colorado 

Wyoming 

Missouri 

Michigan 

Utah 


Total. 


S30.756,713 

19,788,864 

17,642,283 

17,428,990 

15,424,554 

13,225,377 

6,793,050 

2,022,449 

1,997,610 

1,878,217 

518,299 

491,633 

318, 162 

42,286 


128,328,487 


23.97 

15.42 

13.75 

13.58 

12.02 

10.31 

5.30 

1.58 

1.55 

1.46 

.40 

.38 

.25 


California 

Oklahoma 

Illinois 

West  Virginia. 
Pennsylvania. 

Ohio 

Texas 

Louisiana 

Indiana 

New  York 

Kansas 

Kentucky 

Colorado 

Wyoming 

Utah 

Michigan 

Missouri 


Total  . 


Value. 


$35,749,473 

19,922,660 

19,669,383 

15,720,184 

11,908,914 

10,651,568 

6,605,755 

3,574,069 

1,568,475 

1,414,668 

444,763 

324, 684 

243, 402 

98,330 


127,896,328 


Percent- 


27.95 

15.58 

15.38 

12.29 

9.31 

8.33 

5.16 

2.80 

1.21 

1.11 

.35 

.25 

.20 

.08 


RANK  OF  PETROLEUM-PRODUCING   STATES,    WITH   QUANTITY   AND 

PERCENTAGE  PRODUCED  BY  EACH,   IN  1909 

AND  1910,  IN  BARRELS. 


1909 

1910 

State. 

Rank. 

Quantity 

Percent- 
age. 

State. 

Rank. 

Quantity. 

Percent- 
age. 

1 
2 
3 
4 
5 
6 
7 
8 
9 
10 
11 
12 
13 
14 
15 
16 
17 

55,471,601 

47,859,218 

30,898,339 

10,745,092 

10,632,793 

9,534,467 

9,299,403 

3,059,531 

2,296,086 

1,263,764 

1,134,897 

639,016 

310,861 

1           25,806 

30.28 

26.13 

16.87 

5.87 

5.80 

5.21 

5.08 

1.67 

1.25 

.69 

.62 

.35 

17 

01 

California 

1 
2 
3 
4 
5 
6 
7 
8 
9 
10 
11 
12 
13 
14 
15 
16 
17 

73,010,560 

52,028,718 

33,143,3C2 

11,751,871 

9,916,370 

8,899,266 

8,794,662 

6,841,395 

2,159,725 

1, 128, 668 

1,053,838 

468, 774 

239,794 

I          119,045 

34.84 

15.82 

West  Virginia 

Ohio.     . 

West  Virginia 
Ohio 

5.61 
4.73 
4.25 

Pennsylvania 

Pennsylvania 

4.20 

Indiana 

Lidiana..     

New  York 

Kentucky 

1.03 
.54 
.50 

Kentucky 

.22 
.12 

Michigan 

Utah 

Michigan 

Missouri 

Total 

.05 

Utah 

Total 

183,170,874 

100.00 

209,556,048 

100.00 

448 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


PREVENTION    OF    WASTE    IN    EXTRACTION     AND    IN     USE. 

Legislation  tending  to  the  capping  of  gas  wells  in  petroleum  fields 
to  preserve  the  pressure  and  to  prevent  the  unnecessary  encroachment 
of  water,  should  be  extended  to  all  states  where  petroleum  is  produced. 
After  the  practical  exhaustion  of  the  field  by  this  encroachment  of  water, 
the  remaining  petroleum  can  frequently  be  washed  into  smaller  but  still 
profitable  pools — a  system  which  is  already  intelligently  used  in  this 
country. 

DISCOVERY    AND    DEVELOPMENT    OF    SUBSTITUTES. 

Alcohol  from  grain,  potatoes  and  waste  products  can  be  used  in  the 
place  of  petroleum  as  an  illuminant  and  for  power  in  place  of  gasoline 

TOTAL  QUANTITY  AND  VALUE  OF  PETROLEUM  PRODUCED  IN  THE 

UNITED   STATES   AND   THE   AVERAGE   PRICE   PER 

BARREL  IN  1909  AND  1910,  BY   STATES, 

IN  BARRELS. 


1909 

1910 

State. 

Quantity. 

Value. 

Average 

price  per 

barrel. 

Quantity. 

Value. 

Average 

price  per 

barrel. 

55,471,601 

310,861 

30,898,339 

2,296,086 

1,263,764 

639,016 

3,059,531 

|         5,750 

1,134,897 
10,632,793 
47,859,218 
9,299,403 
9,534,467 

\       20,056 

10,745,092 

$30, 756, 713 

318, 162 

19.788,864 

1,997,610 

491,633 

518,299 

2,022,449 

7,830 

1,878,217 
13,225,377 
17,428,990 
15,424,554 

6,793,050 

34,456 
17,642,283 

$0,554 
1.023 
.640 
.870 
.389 
.811 
.661 

1.362 

1.655 
1.244 

.364 
1.659 

.712 

1.718 
1.642 

73,010,560 

239, 794 

33,143,362 

2,159,725 

1,128,668 

468,774 

6,841,395 

3,615 

1,053,838 
9,916,370 
52,028,718 
8,794,662 
8,899,266 

115,430 

11,751,871 

$35, 749, 473 

243.402 

19,669,383 

1,568,475 

444,763 

324,684 

3,574,069 

4,794 

1,414,668 
10,651,568 
19,922,660 
11,908,914 

6,605,755 

93,536 
15,720,184 

$0,490 

1.015 

.593 

.726 

.394 

.693 

.522 

1.342 

Ohio 

1.074 

.383 

1.354 

.742 

Utah 

.810 

1.338 

Total 

183,170,874 

128,328,487 

.701 

209,556,048 

127,896,328 

.610 

WORLD'S   PRODUCTION   OF   CRUDE   PETROLEUM,    1906-1910, 
BY  COUNTRIES. 


1906 

1907 

1908 

1909 

1910 

Country. 

Rank. 

Barrels. 

Metric 
tons. 

Per 
cent  of 
total 
produc- 
tion. 

United  States. 

Russia 

Galicia 

Dutch   East 

Indies 

Rouraania 

120,493,936 
58,897,311 
5,467,967 

8,180,657 
6,378,184 
4,015,803 

166,095,335 
61,850,734 
8,455,841 

9,982,597 

8,118,207 

4,344,162 

1,000,000 

2,010,639 

756,226 

756, 631 

788, 872 

59,875 

a  30,000 

W8,527,355 
62, 186, 447 
12, 612, 295 

10,283,357 
8,252,157 
5,047,038 
3,481,410 
2,070,145 
1,011,180 
1,009,278 
527,987 
50,966 
a  30,000 

183,170,874 
65,970,350 
14,932,799 

11,041,852 
9,327,278 
6, 676, 517 
2,488,742 
1,889,563 
1,316,118 
1,018,837 
420,755 
42,388 
a  30,000 

1 

2 
3 

4 
5 
6 

8 
9 
10 
11 
12 
U 

209,556,048 
70,336,574 
12,673,688 

11,030,620 
9,722,958 
6,137,990 
3, 332, 807 
1,930,601 
1,330,105 
1,032.522 
315, 895 
42,388 
a  30,000 

27,940,806 
9,378,210 
1,762,560 

1 , 495, 715 

1,352,289 

818, 400 

444,374 

257,421 

177,347 

145,168 

42,119 

5,895 

4,000 

63.99 
21.48 
3.87 

3.37 
2.97 
1.87 

1.02 

1,710,7(58 
536,291 
578, 610 
509.753 
53,577 
a  30,000 

.59 

Peru 

.40 

Germany 

Canada 

Italy 

.32 
.10 

}        .02 

Total.... 

212,912,800 

264,249,119 

2S5.089.615 

298. 326, 073 

327,472,256 

43,824,304 

100.00 

a  Estimated. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  449 

whenever  the  necessity  arises.  No  practical  substitute  is  known  for 
mineral  lubricating  oils.  Animal  and  vegetable  oils  are  excluded  as  en- 
tirely too  expensive.  The  production  of  artificial  petroleum  from  vari- 
ous vegetable  and  animal  waste  products  has  received  sufficient  study 
to  indicate  the  possibility  of  good  results  if  scientific  research  is  en- 
couraged in  this  direction. 

NECESSITY    OF    SCIENTIFIC   RESEARCH. 

The  most  practical  recommendation  seems  to  be  the  encouragement 
of  scientific  research  in  the  study  of  the  conditions  of  occurrence  of 
petroleum  in  the  earth,  in  order  to  lessen  the  expense  of  discovery  of 
new  pools.  A  second  line  of  scientific  research  of  even  greater  value  should 
include  fundamental  studies  of  the  nature  of  all  kinds  of  petroleum,  with 
a  view  to  converting  less  valuable  varieties  into  higher  grades  and  to 
producing  greater  proportions  of  the  absolutely  necessary  lubricating  oils 
from  crude  petroleum.  Such  scientific  study  should  be  initiated  at  once 
to  be  of  benefit  when  the  present  petroleum  supply  becomes  inadequate. 

TIME     OF     EXHAUSTION. 

Regarding  the  limits  of  time  within  which  the  present  supply  will  be 
exhausted,  it  is  clear  that  considering  the  minimum  quantity  of  petroleum 
in  the  United  States  as  15,000,000,000  barrels,  and  continuing  the  present 
rate  of  increase  in  production,  the  supply  would  be  exhausted  about  1935. 
If  the  present  annual  production  were  continued  without  increase,  90  years 
would  be  required  to  exhaust  this  estimated  minimum  quantity.  A  rea- 
sonable view  of  the  situation  makes  it  probable  that  the  present  annual 
rate  of  production  will  be  increased  slightly  through  the  developments 
of  Illinois,  Oklahoma  and  California,  but  that  within  a  very  few  years 
a  marked  decline  will  be  noted,  and  this  will  continue  with  increasing 
value  for  the  oil  product  and  an  insufficient  quantity  for  the  legitimate 
demands  of  the  industry  after  another  decade,  and  that  the  production,  on 
a  reduced  scale,  will  continue  for  a  long  time,  but  in  an  amount  unsatis- 
factory to  industrial  necessity,  except  as  supplemented  from  new  fields. 

RECOMMENDATIONS. 

Three  conclusions  are  self-evident  from  this  report : 

(1)  It  is  absolutely  necessary  for  the  preservation  of  an  adequate 
supply  of  petroleum  that  all  public  lands  where  petroleum  is  probable 
should  at  once  be  withdrawn  from  entry. 

(2)  A  general  investigation  of  the  conditions  of  accumulation  of 
petroleum  and  its  geographic  distribution  should  be  undertaken  in  order 
that   the   petroleum-bearing   public   lands   may   be   selected. 

(3)  Fundamental  scientific  study  of  the  nature  of  petroleum,  espe- 
cially with  a  view  to  securing  the  greatest  yields  of  the  most  valuable 
constituents  and  even  for  transmuting  one  oil  into  another,  is  required 
for  its  most  intelligent  use. 

*COAL  FIELDS   OF  THE  UNITED   STATES. 

The  coal  areas  of  the  United  States  are  divided,  for  the  sake  of 
convenience,   into   two  great   divisions — anthracite   and   bituminous. 

The  areas  in  which  anthracite  is  produced  are  confined  almost  ex- 
clusively to  the  eastern  part  of  Pennsylvania,  and  usually  when  the 
anthracite  fields  of  the  United  States  are  referred  to,  those  of  eastern 
Pennsylvania  are  meant.  These  fields  are  included  in  the  counties  of 
Susquehanna,  Lackawanna,  Luzerne,  Carbon,  Schuylkill,  Columbia, 
Northumberland,  Dauphin  and  Sullivan,  and  underlie  an  area  of  about 
480  square  miles.     In  addition  to  these  well-known   anthracite  fields  of 


•Prom  Government  Report,    "Production  of  Coal   in   1910." 


450  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

Pennsylvania  there  are  two  small  areas  in  the  Rocky  Mountain  region 
where  the  coal  has  been  locally  anthracited,  although  the  production  from 
these  districts  has  never  amounted  to  as  much  as  100,000  tons  in  any  one 
year.  One  of  these  localities  is  in  Gunnison  County,  Colo.,  and  the  other 
in  Santa  Fe  County,  N.  M.  The  coal,  although  only  locally  metamor- 
phosed, is  a  true  anthracite  and  of  a  good  quality.  In  previous  years  wme 
coal,  which  was  classed  as  anthracite,  was  mined  and  sold  in  New  Eng- 
land. The  productive  area  was  confined  to  the  eastern  part  of  Rhode 
Island  and  the  counties  of  Bristol  and  Plymouth  in  Massachusetts.  In 
1909,  redevelopment  of  the  old  mines  at  Portsmouth  was  in  progress,  and 
the  result  of  rehabilitating  these  properties  and  of  utilizing  the  product 
will  be  watched  with  interest. 

The  bituminous  and  lignite  fields  are  scattered  widely  over  the 
United  States  and  include  an  area  of  something  over  496,000  square  miles. 
The  previous  classification  of  these  coal  areas  published  in  earlier  volumes 
of  the  report,  "Mineral  Resources  of  the  United  States,"  has  been 
changed  as  a  result  of  conferences  among  the  geologists  working  under 
Marius  R.  Campbell  on  the  economic  geology  of  coal.  The  areas  are 
divided,   primarily,  into   six   provinces,   as    follows : 

(1)  The  eastern  province,  which  includes  all  of  the  bituminous 
areas  of  the  Appalachian  region;  the  Atlantic  Coast  region,  which  in- 
cludes the  Triassic  fields  near  Richmond  and  Deep  River  and  Dan  River 
fields  of  North  Carolina,  and  also  the  anthracite  region  of  Pennsylvania. 
(2)  The  Gulf  province,  which  includes  the  lignite  fields  of  Alabama, 
Mississippi,  Louisiana,  Arkansas  and  Texas.  (3)  The  interior  province, 
which  includes  all  the  bituminous  areas  of  the  Mississippi  Valley  region 
and  the  coal  fields  of  Michigan.  This  province  is  subdivided  into  the 
eastern  region,  which  embraces  the  coal  fields  of  Illinois,  Indiana  and 
western  Kentucky;  the  western  region,  which  includes  the  fields  of  Iowa, 
Missouri,  Nebraska,  Kansas,  Arkansas  and  Oklahoma ;  and  the  south- 
western region,  which  includes  the  coal  fields  of  Texas.  The  Michigan 
fields  are  designated  as  the  northern  region  of  the  interior  province. 
(4)  The  northern,  or  Great  Plains,  province,  which  includes  the  lignite 
areas  of  North  Dakota  and  South  Dakota  and  the  bituminous  and  sub- 
bituminous  areas  of  northeastern  Wyoming  and  of  northern  and  eastern 
Montana.  (5)  The  Rocky  Mountain  province,  which  includes  the  coal 
fields  of  the  portions  of  Montana  and  Wyoming  which  are  in  the  moun- 
tainous districts  of  those  states,  and  all  the  coal  fields  of  Utah,  Colorado 
and  New  Mexico.  (6)  The  Pacific  Coast  province,  which  includes  all  of 
the   coal   fields   of   California,    Oregon    and   Washington. 

According  to  the  revised  estimates  the  supply  of  coal  in  the  ground 
when  mining  began  was  3,076,204,000,000  short  tons,  of  which  1,922,979,- 
000,000  are  considered  to  be  easily  accessible,  and  1,153,225,000,000  short 
tons  to  be  either  so  deep  or  the  beds  so  thin  that  they  are  accessible 
only  with  difficulty.  Classified  according  to  the  character  of  the  coal,  the 
original  supply  consisted  of  21,000,000,000  short  tons  of  anthracite,  1,661,- 
457,000,000  tons  of  bituminous  coal,  650,157,000,000  tons  of  sub-bituminous 
coal,  and  743,590,000,000  tons  of  lignite.  The  total  production  at  the 
close  of  1910  was  8,243,351,259  short  tons,  which,  including  the  loss  in- 
volved in  the  mining  and  preparation  of  the  coal,  represents  an  ex- 
haustion of  13,395,000,000  tons.  The  original  supply,  less  the  exhaustion 
at  the  close  of  1910,  leaves  as  the  apparent  supply  still  available  3,062,808,- 
972,000  tons,  or  99.6  per  cent,  of  the  original  supply,  or  in  other  words, 
in  all  the  time  since  coal  mining  began  in  the  United  States,  the  draft 
upon  the  original  supply,  including  loss  in  mining,  has  amounted  to  less 
than  one-half  of  one  per  cent.  The  annual  rate  of  exhaustion  at  the 
present  time,  as  represented  by  the  production  of  1910,  is  0.025  of  one 
per  cent,  of  the  supply.  The  quantity  of  coal  still  in  the  ground  at  the 
close  of  1010  was  6,000  times  the  production  of  that  year. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


451 


Mgl 

■<a     p. 


g-uj     2 


CI  i—  CO  cm  o  *o 


*OCOC 

co"cTc 


s  q  r-  co  -g*  ■*  co  r-i 


300        i^w*cCt*(O0CN 


co  fr- 
ee Oi 
iO  ^ 

iO  ;o 

io-< 


©  2*0-2 
>■  s«~  © 
<  a  o  «3 


3>— <Oi— l'«S*O>COt--CO''rfr-C0 
1  H  tN  Ci  CS  in  (N  CN  C.  C^  i-i  CK^i 


t£ 


u.St 


i oi <n  (N  co  w h  t-- oo  c 


HClCOSOiOCi 


J-h^CIOIC 


Hp 


CM  O         0<N         *?  00  05  O  ■-**  GO 


I'-ONNOtOO 


.-■  IO  CN--<  rH 


3  CM  lO  »0  "* 


.  -  to  o  c 
400  Nor 
r^io'cTco"* 


CM  CM 

if 


flQC'tCiOKOiOOHOliOSt 
'O  i-O  '--O  TC  *r  -i-  T  —  ?t  io  ~  CI   ~ 

•*r  a>— •r-CN-^'C^oot-H^j'co^-tO'' 
tirjNMN  -<  o*  c^"  vj  --'  m  t-.'  •*  c 


.-h  o  h  r-  t- 

HCl  Oi-» 


OHHwem  to  o  —  c.  t--  oi  a*,  oo 

[  -  C I  -r  -   C  J  CO  C  I  OO  t  -  O  O  &  1-"  CO 
C."  X  C  CJ  C  N  h  p- nV  N  H  h  I 


iMOCftOCN^aOt 


ItO  «5H 


_>^Oi-i  fr-CO 
CO  »0  O  Oi  to  to 


tDt-t  ^H 


IO  CO  fr-  «**  -*  IO  i-i  CM  CM  T-. 


_  —  -*^  —. 


<CM        ONr-iCN«DCOHN 


O        ■        -~<~H 


'Sen  *  • 
.  >o  to    •  ■ 

too* 

Ofr- 

»-i  OO 

o  to 
•v  »o 

05   *   • 

t-  i-H 

COO 

t> 

lOiO 

CO  to 
CO  .-< 

s 

r-  oo  •■*  co 

'Op  Ol  (N 
cm<m       i-i 


©  2.  c  © 


SfOeot^ocoNO'j'Wc 


>p40M(MNC 


>  rf  tO  O  O  CO  C 


'MrHHCC 


liOOiOWfHO'. 


^h  iO^h         CM.-1 


jHCJC-f  »o  to  oo 


"JCO^OOHMNOrtOfCXt'-t-H^XCMNI'H'tM 


OhoSconvhc.. 


IOOCOCOh- 


;--<h-i--CNC 


*-*  CM 


.2   P 
*d  © 

p§  ©  6 

3s-g 


jHVHoa^noooooioooi 


>COtP         QOOC.fiQN^Wh.OOlCOi 
IO  OO  Ol  .-i  iO  tOO  CO  iO  O  h-CM  Ci  ' 


HN>^C0«3H( 


i-i  CM         OOOi-MCM^rCOCOt— 


1.5 

ES 


o  a 

3'«M 


3!>! 


■S-a^-s  Si23'2  &  «  S  jg.S.H  5  5  oi^  ESS  S-S  •!=.£££ 


452 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 


SHORT  TONS 


50,000,000 


100,000,000 


Pennsylvania 
(bituminous) 


West  Virginia 

Illinois 

Ohio 

Indiana 

Alabama 

Kentucky 

Colorado 

Iowa 

Wyoming 

Tennessee 

Virginia 

Maryland 

Kansas 

Washington 

New  Mexico 

Missouri 

Montana 

Oklahoma 

Utah 

Arkansas 
Texas 
Michigan 
Other  Statss 


7,928,120 
^^$13,903,913 
HB  7  533,088 
^3$11,706,187 
■■7,121,380 
^$7,925,350 

B  6,507,997 
$5,877,486 
B5, 217, 125 
$5,835,058 

■  4,921,451 
g%|  $7,914,709 

■  3911,899 
^^$9,764,465 

■  3,508,321 
^j  $4,877,151 

52,982,433, 
^$5,328,285 

■  2,920,970 
^  $5,329,322 

■  2,646,226 
gl  $5,867,947 

■  2,517,809 
^$4,224,556 

■  1,905,958 
g  $2,979,213 

■  1,892,176 
0$3, 160,965 

■  1,534,967 
@  $2,930,771 

1660,431 
S$l,140,252, 


150,000,000 

150,521,526 


$160,275,302 


Figuee  1— Production  of  coal  in  the  United  States  in  1910,  by  States. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  453 

*DURATION  OF  SUPPLY. 

The  total  reserve  of  easily  accessible  and  now  available  coal  is 
estimated  at  1,382,780,000,000  tons.  The  assumption  that  a  constant  output 
has  been  reached  would  be  utterly  unwarranted.  On  the  other  hand,  the 
adoption  of  the  flat  rate  of  annual  increase  of  7.36  per  cent,  would  involve 
the  improbable  assumption  that  the  marvelous  record  of  the  past  and 
present  will  be  maintained  in  the  future  and  the  production  would  con- 
tinue to  approximately  double  every  decade.  Using  the  waste  allow- 
ance, on  the  basis  of  this  constant  rate  of  increase  in  production,  the 
1,382,780,000,000  tons  available  at  the  close  of  1907  would  be  exhausted 
in  107  years,  or  by  2015  A.  D.  Against  the  use  of  the  flat  rate  of  increase 
it  may  well  be  contended  that,  just  as  the  rate  of  increase  in  population 
tends  to  diminish,  so  this  rapid  increase  in  per  capita  consumption  of 
coal  cannot  persist,  and  a  constant  annual  production  will  be  reached. 
However,  the  figures  set  fifty  years  ago  by  statisticians  for  the  probable 
constant  annual  production  of  coal  in  England  have  already  been  ex- 
ceeded by  over  160  per  cent. 

Mr.  Henry  Gannett  has  made  an  estimate  based  upon  a  decreasing 
rate  of  increase  calculated  from  20-year  averages  of  production.  The 
use  of  10-year  averages  is  regarded  as  unsatisfactory  for  the  reason 
that  one  of  the  decades  may  consist  mainly  of  a  period  of  prosperity, 
while  the  preceding  and  succeeding  decades  contain  periods  of  business 
depression.  The  20-year  period,  however,  is  sufficiently  long  to  include 
a  period  of  prosperity  with  one  of  business  depression.  Taking  the  four 
20-year  periods  since  1828,  three  rates  of  increase  are  obtained  which 
show  a  rapid  decrease.  The  hyperbolic  curve  computed  from  these 
successive  rates  of  increase  will  indicate  the  constantly  diminishing 
rate  of  increase  for  the  successive  20-year  periods.  The  result  obtained 
by  this  method  is  that  the  easily  accessible  and  available  coal  will  be 
exhausted  about  the  year  2027,  and  all  coal  by  the  middle  of  that  century. 
It  is  recognized  that  the  data  upon  which  this  curve  has  been  con- 
structed are  few  and  the  curve  correspondingly  weak.  However,  in  the 
above  estimate  all  of  the  data  have  been  given  which  it  is  possible  to 
use,  and  this  estimate  is  believed  to  represent  the  best  use  that  can  be 
made  of  the  data  at  hand. 

Inasmuch  as  America  leads  the  world  not  only  in  present  production 
of  coal,  but  also  apparently  possesses  the  greatest  reserve  and  certainly 
is  mining  coal  at  much  lower  cost  than  any  other  country,  the  obvious 
tendency  will  be  for  European  countries  to  look  more  and  more  tc  the 
United  States  for  their  coal  supply.  Therefore,  while  our  present  coal 
production  and  consumption  are  practically  equivalent,  the  export  of 
coal,  unless  prohibited  by  federal  legislation,  must  eventually  become 
a  factor  and  increase  the  coal  production  in  the  United  States  beyond 
the  demands  of  home  consumption.  On  the  other  hand,  powerful  in- 
fluences will  come  to  bear  upon  coal  production,  which  favor  lengthening 
the  life  of  the  supply.  Thus  it  is  to  be  hoped  that  with  more  improved 
methods  in  the  utilization  of  coal  the  increased  efficiency  per  unit 
may  act  as  a  factor  in  reducing  coal  consumption,  and  improved 
mining  methods  should  likewise  decrease  the  waste  percentage.  The 
increased  utilization  of  water  power  should  also  tend  to  decrease  coal 
consumption.  Again,  as  soon  as  the  end  appears  in  sight,  prices  will 
rise  and  production  diminish,  and  that  progressively.  This  interference 
with  the  law  of  decreasing  increase  produced  by  growing  scarcity  will, 
of  course,  prolong  the  life  of  our  coal  reserves,  but  at  the  same  time 
will  greatly  hamper  our  industries  that  depend  on  this  fuel. 

With  so  many  indeterminate  factors  whose  importance  is  realized,  but 
cannot  be  measured,  prophecy  must  possess  a  questionable  value. 

*From  Bulletin  No.   394,   United  States  Geological   Survey. 


454  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

WASTE   IN    COAL    MINING. 

The  principal  loss  or  waste  attending  coal-mining  operations  is  that 
represented  by  the  quantity  of  coal  necessarily  left  in  the  ground  as  pillars 
to  support  the  roof.  In  some  cases  it  is  also  necessary  to  leave  a 
foot  or  more  of  coal  as  a  part  of  the  roof,  because  of  the  unstable 
character  of  the  material  underlying  the  coal,  which  itself  does  not 
make  a  good  roof.  It  has  also  been  frequently  the  case  that,  where 
portions  of  the  coal  bed  have  been  of  inferior  quality,  only  the  high-grade 
coal  has  been  mined  and  the  poorer  material  left.  The  coal  left  as  pillars, 
or  as  portions  of  the  roof,  may  be  considered  a  necessary  loss,  but  that 
which  is  left  because  of  its  inferior  quality  cannot  be  considered  un- 
avoidable waste  in  any  sense,  and  is  frequently  of  higher  grade  than 
coals  mined  and  used  in  other  portions  of  the  country. 

Enormous  quantities  of  coal  have  been  lost  beyond  recovery  from 
the  mining  of  beds  lying  below,  the  caving  of  which,  upon  the  with- 
drawal of  the  pillars,  has  so  broken  up  the  overlying  strata  as  to  render 
it  impossible  to  recover  the  coals  contained  therein.  This  has  been 
particularly  the  case  in  some  of  the  coal  beds  of  western  Pennsylvania, 
but  much  improvement  has  been  observed  in  this  regard  within  later 
years.  Notwithstanding  the  improvement  in  this  respect  it  is  probable 
that  a  large  amount  of  coal  will  be  wasted  in  the  western  states,  where  a 
great  number  of  coal  beds  are  closely  associated,  and  also  where  the 
intercalated  strata  are  weak,  forming  poor  roofs  to  the  mines. 

There  are  no  exact  figures  as  to  the  actual  loss  or  waste  sustained 
through  coal  left  in  the  mines  in  conducting  the  mining  operations,  but 
it  has  been  estimated  that  it  amounts  to  50  per  cent,  of  the  quantity 
produced  and  marketed.  In  some  cases,  through  careful  mining  and  where 
the  conditions  are  ideal  for  working,  practically  all  of  the  contents  of 
the  coal  beds  are  recovered.  In  other  cases,  particularly  when  the 
beds  are  of  enormous  thickness,  the  recovery  has  not  exceeded  30  per 
cent,  of  the  contents.  During  the  earlier  days  of  mining  in  the  anthracite 
regions  of  Pennsylvania  it  was  estimated  that  only  40  per  cent,  of  the 
coal  was  marketed.  This  was  partly  due  to  uneconomical  methods  of 
mining,  and  partly  to  the  large  amount  of  culm,  for  which  there  was  at 
that  time  no  market  and  which  was  piled  on  the  ground  in  unsightly 
mountains.  At  the  time  of  the  Anthracite  Coal  Waste  Commission, 
which  made  its  report  in  1893,  40  per  cent,  was  still  considered  a  maxi- 
mum recovery.  So  far  as  underground  workings  are  concerned,  there  has 
been  no  revolution  in  the  methods  employed  since  that  time,  but  there 
has  been  a  considerable  improvement  in  the  application  of  those  methods, 
which  has  resulted  in  the  recovery  at  the  present  time  of  a  materially  larger 
proportion  of  the  coal  in  the  ground  than  was  the  rule  at  that  date.  The 
earlier  methods  of  mining  consisted  in  leaving  comparatively  narrow 
pillars,  and  in  the  mining  of  large  rooms  the  result  was  that  the  pillars 
were  not  strong  enough  to  stand  the  pressure  and  were  crushed  beyond 
recovery.  It  is  now  customary  to  use  larger  pillars  between  the  rooms, 
which  makes  it  possible  to  better  control  the  roof  during  "robbing" 
operations  and  to  eventually  recover  a  larger  proportion  of  the  contents 
of  the  bed. 

Material  improvements  have  also  been  made  in  the  methods  of  the 
preparation  of  coal,  so  that  a  much  greater  proportion  of  the  product 
hoisted  is  now  being  sent  to  market  in  merchantable  condition.  Part  of 
this  is  due  to  better  and  more  systematic  methods  of  handling,  and  part 
to  the  saving  of  small  sizes  which  formerly  went  to  the  culm  banks. 
The  higher  prices  of  coal  and  the  development  of  methods  for  using 
these  small  sizes  have  also  made  it  possible,  through  washing  processes, 
to  rework  the  small  coal  formerly  thrown  on  the  culm  banks,  and  these 
are  now  furnishing  several  millions  of  tons  of  marketable  coal  annually. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  455 

CANADA. 
TREE  PLANTING  AND  REFORESTATION. 

The  Forestry  Branch  of  the  Department  of  the  Interior  (Government 
of  Canada)  has,  since  1900,  been  carrying  out  a  scheme  of  free  tree 
distribution  to  farmers  in  the  prairie  provinces  of  Manitoba,  Saskatche- 
wan and  Alberta.  During  that  time  some  eighteen  million  trees  have 
been  sent  out  from  the  nurseries  of  this  particular  branch.  The  trees 
are  planted  on  the  homesteads  throughout  these  provinces  for  wind- 
breaks, shelter  belts  and  wood  supply.  Nurseries  have  been  established 
also  on  some  of  the  forest  reserves,  and  some  planting  is  being  done. 

In  1894,  the  Government  of  the  Province  of  Ontario  established  a 
nursery  at  the  Ontario  Agricultural  College,  Guelph,  Ont.,  and  they  have 
since  been  distributing  trees  to  farmers  throughout  that  province.  This 
nursery  has  since  been  removed  to  St.  Williams.  Ont.,  where  the  Pro- 
vincial Department  of  Agriculture  has  acquired  some  1,300  acres  of 
sandy  land,  which  it  is  planting  up  with  forest  trees.  The  Province  of 
Quebec  has  also  established  a  forest  nursery  at  Berthier,  P.  Q.,  but  the 
distribution  from  there  has,  as  yet,  been  small.  In  a  few  instances, 
planting  or  sowing  has  been  undertaken  in  other  provinces  of  the 
Dominion  by  individuals  or  private  concerns. 

The  Canadian  Pacific  Railway  Company  has  also  taken  in  hand  the 
planting  of  trees  of  different  varieties  on  the  prairies.  The  trees  and 
shrubs  used  are  Russian  Poplar  and  Willows,  Box  Elder,  Ash,  Spruce, 
Scotch  Pine,  Caragana  and  Artemosia.  A  good  deal  of  this  work  is 
done  along  the  cuts,  in  order  that  the  trees  and  shrubs  may  serve  as 
permanent   snow    fences. 

There  is  also  a  permanent  plantation  at  Wolseley,  Sask.,  to  deter- 
mine the  values  of  different  species  of  trees  for  tie  purposes,  as  well  as 
for  the  correct  spacing  and  mixture.  The  species  selected  are  native 
tamarack,  Scotch,  red  and  jack  pine,  and  although  the  plantation  has 
not  been  established  long  enough  to  give  any  reliable  figures  as  to  growth, 
the  results  so  far  have  been  satisfactory.  This  plantation  is  situated 
on  dry  upland  prairie.  The  tamaracks,  or  larch,  used  were  transferred 
from  swamp  land  to  the  plantation,  and  the  growth  on  the  high  land,  so 
far,  has  been  three  times  faster  than  at  any  time  in  the  swamp.  It  is 
hoped  that  this  plantation  will  ultimately  afford  reliable  information  as  to 
the  selecting  and  planting  of  such  trees  as  will  eventually  be  suitable  for 
tie  timber. 

Investigations  are  also  being  made  by  the  Canadian  Pacific  Railway 
Company  as  to  the  value  of  cut-over  and  virgin  timber  lands  in  selected 
locations,  in  order  to  determine  the  value  of  these  lands  for  permanent 
tie  reserves.  The  information  obtained  from  this  source  is  not,  as  yet, 
sufficient  to  give  out  anything  of  a  definite  nature,  but  it  will  be  con- 
tinued, and  in  a  few  years  it  is  also  hoped  that  reliable  information 
will    be   obtained    regarding    this    reforestation. 


456  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES. 

The  consumption  of  timber  in  the  year  1910  was  as  follows: 

Lumber  4,901,649,000  ft.  B.  M. 

Square  timber   37.962  tons 

Shingles    1,976,400,000 

Lath    851,953,000 

Pulpwood  598,487  cords 

Poles 782,841 

Cross-ties    9,213,962 

Mining  timber   (round)     52.848,000   linear   ft. 

Mining  timber  (sawn)    22,305,000  ft.  B.  M. 

Cooperage  (slack),  including  staves, 

heading  and  hoops 161,641,000  pieces 

Cooperage  (tight)    8,370,000  pieces 

ANNUAL  FIRE  LOSS. 

The  information  in  regard  to  the  annual  fire  loss  is  not  definite,  as 
much  of  the  loss  occurs  in  districts  so  far  removed  from  settlement  that  it 
is  impossible  to  make  any  reliable  estimate.  The  annual  loss  from  forest 
fires  will,  however,  run  between  250,000,000  and  500,000,000  ft.,  board  meas- 
ure, per  annum.  In  very  wet  years  it  might  fall  below  the  minimum — 
in  very  dry  years  it  will  go  over  it.  The  value  of  the  timber  destroyed 
might  be  taken  at  one  dollar  per  thousand  at  the  stump.  In  the  districts 
where  railways  are  being  constructed,  they  are  the  most  frequent  cause  of 
fire — at  least  50  per  cent,  of  the  fires  bing  caused  by  them.  In  the  dis- 
tricts beyond  where  the  railways  are  constructed,  fires  are  mostly  due 
to  the  clearing  of  the  land  by  settlers. 

COAL  AND  FUEL  OIL  RESOURCES. 

In  the  Dominion  the  aggregate  area  of  coal  lands  is  29,957  square 
miles,  containing  about  172,100,000,000  tons  of  the  several  classes. 

Little,  as  yet,  has  been  done  towards  ascertaining  the  loss  incident 
upon  coal  mining  operations  in  Canada.  Nova  Scotia  has  recently  taken 
steps  to  secure  this  information  by  issuing  coal  depletion  statement  forms 
to  be  filled  in  by  the  mine  operators.  It  has  been  stated  by  some  authori- 
ties that  for  every  ton  of  coal  mined,  one-half  a  ton  is  lost  or  wasted ; 
and  in  thick  beds  the  recovery  probably  does  not  exceed  30  per  cent. 

The  wastes  attending  coal  mining  operations  may  be  enumerated  as 
follows : 

(1)  Coal  lost  beyond  recovery  by  mining  lowest  seams  first. 

(2)  Coal  left  in  pillars  to  support  the  roof. 

(3)  The  low  grade  coal  left  in  the  mines. 

(4)  Slack  coal  formed  during  mining  operations. 

In  Western  Canada  where  there  are  so  many  seams  of  great  thick- 
ness close  together,  it  is  looked  upon  as  important  that  the  upper  seams 
should  be  mined  first,  so  that  any  caving  as  a  result  of  removing  the 
pillars  will  not  render  it  impossible  to  get  at  the  other  seams. 


CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL  RESOURCES.  457 

Great  losses  have  resulted  also  from  improperly  burned  coal.  The 
loss  in  smoke  alone  with  bituminous  coal  has  been  estimated  at  about  10 
per  cent. 

PEAT  DEPOSITS  IN  CANADA. 

In  round  numbers  there  are  37,000  square  miles  of  peat  lands  scat- 
tered throughout  the  various  provinces. 

As  a  result  of  investigations  carried  on  in  Canada  it  has  been  demon- 
strated that : 

(1)  For  the  economic  production  of  fuel  from  peat,  machinery 
driven  by  power  must  be  substituted  as  far  as  possible  for  manual  labor. 

(2)  That  processes  so  far  invented  for  removing  the  water  content 
of  the  peat  by  pressure  or  artificial  heat  have  not  hitherto  led  to  profitable 
commercial  results. 

A  number  of  bogs,  however,  are  being  exploited  to  some  extent,  and 
the  result  of  the  operation  of  one  of  them  in  particular,  viz.,  the  plant  at 
Alfred,  Ont,  goes  to  prove  that  the  production  of  excellent  peat  fuel  is  a 
commercial  possibility. 

It  has  been  found  that  one  ton  of  peat  burned  under  boilers  is  equal 
to  about  5/9  of  a  ton  of  coal.  It  does  not  clinker,  nor  give  off  any  ob- 
jectionable volatile  matter  in  the  form  of  black  smoke,  and  as  a  domestic 
fuel,  it  is  clean,  easily  handled  and  efficient. 

CRUDE  PETROLEUM. 
The  waste  which  occurs  in  oil  production  in  Canada  is  not  so  much 
in  the  oil  itself  as  in  the  natural  gas  incident  to  the  oil  production.  The 
oil  when  obtained,  may  be  sold  at  once,  whereas  to  sell  the  gas.  long  ex- 
pensive pipe  lines  must  be  laid,  franchises  obtained  from  towns  or  cities 
and  their  market  is  but  limited. 

NATURAL  GAS  IN  CANADA. 

The  production  of  natural  gas  in  Canada  has  increased  in  value  nearly 
ten-fold  during  the  last  eighteen  years,  and  of  the  total  amount  the  Pro- 
vince of  Ontario  produced  about  95  per  cent. 

Steps  were  taken  by  the  Ontario  Government  in  1907  to  prevent  the 
waste  of  natural  gas,  and  a  law  was  passed  levying  a  tax  of  two  cents  per 
1,000  ft.  with  a  rebate  of  90  per  cent,  when  the  gas  is  used  in  Canada. 
This  provision  has  been  very  effective. 

In  Alberta  little  provision  has  as  yet  been  made  for  the  plugging 
of  the  gas  wells,  and  many  millions  of  cubic  feet  have  therefore  been 
wasted  annually  and  extended  areas  have  been  more  or  less  drained. 

In  order  to  conserve  the  supply  of  natural  gas,  the  gas  must  be  utilized 
(1)  for  the  purpose  for  which  it  is  most  valuable;  (2)  in  the  manner  that 
will  secure  the  greatest  efficiency;  and  (3)  as  near  as  possible  to  the  point 
of  production.  The  most  valuable  uses  for  natural  gas  are  for  domestic 
purposes  and  the  development  of  power. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  VIII— ON  MASONRY. 

G.  H.  Tinker,  Chairman;  F.  L.  Thompson,  Vice -Chairman; 

G.  J.  Bell.  W.  H.  Petersen. 

H.  E.  Boardman.  Philip  Petri. 

C.  W.  Boynton.  J.  H.  Prior. 

T.   L.  CONDRON.  F.   E.    SCHALL. 

L.  D.  Crear.  G.  H.  Scribner,  Jr. 

L.  N.  Edwards.  A.  N.  Taleot. 

A.  H.  Griffith.  Job  Tuthill. 

L.  J.  HOTCHKISS.  A.  A.   WlRTH. 

Richard  L.  Humphrey.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Masonry  has  held  meetings  as  follows :  At  Chi- 
cago, on  July  12,  September  I,  November  4,  191 1,  and  January  20,  1912. 

The  various  subjects  assigned  to  the  Committee  for  report  were  as- 
signed to  Sub-Committees  for  investigation. 

REVISION  OF  THE  MANUAL. 
The  Committee  recommends  no  changes  in  the  Manual  at  this  time. 

WATERPROOFING  OF  MASONRY. 

In  accordance  with  instructions  from  the  Board  of  Direction,  the  in- 
vestigation of  the  waterproofing  of  masonry  has  been  continued  during 
the  past  year.  A  circular  letter  requesting  information  relative  to  this 
subject  was  sent  to  the  members  of  the  Association.  The  circular  letter 
followed,  in  the  main  points,  the  circulars  issued  in  former  years,  adding 
such  additional  questions  as  appeared  to  your  Committee  called  for  in 
the  light  of  present  day  practice. 

The  replies  were  quite  numerous,  but  only  a  limited  number  contained 
information  on  the  subject  under  consideration. 

Abstracts  from  the  replies  containing  information  pertinent  to  the 
subject  are  appended;  a  perusal  of  these  brings  out  the  fact  that  while 
considerable  waterproofing  is  being  done  throughout  the  country,  the 
methods  followed  and  materials  used  are  much  the  same  as  described  in 
previous  reports  of  the  Committee. 

From  several  replies  it  will  be  seen  that  impervious  concrete  can  be 

459 


460  MASONRY. 

made  without  special  waterproofing,  by  using  a  suitable  gradation  of  ag- 
gregates and  the  proper  amount  of  cement  and  reinforcing  the  concrete 
to  counteract  temperature  and  shrinkage  stresses,  and  in  depositing  to  use 
the  proper  care  and  amount  of  work  to  secure  a  dense  concrete. 

It  will  also  be  noticed  that  in  using  waterproofing  material  such  as 
felt,  in  connection  with  coal-tar  pitch  or  asphaltum,  fair  results  are  ob- 
tained, when  the  weather  conditions  are  favorable,  and  when  the  work 
can  be  done  without  interference  or  obstructions  and  by  working  con- 
tinuously until  completed ;  it  is  also  noticed  that  when  the  work  is  done 
at  an  unfavorable  season,  or  when  work  is  done  in  distinct  separate  periods 
and  sections,  under  difficulties  such  as  track  operations,  undue  haste  in 
completing  the  work  necessitated  by  special  circumstances,  the  results 
have  generally  been  unsatisfactory. 

The  Committee  has  not  prepared  a  final  report  on  the  subject  of 
waterproofing;  the  appended  abstracts  are  submitted  as  information. 

ILLINOIS   CENTRAL  RAILROAD   COMPANY. 

Waterproofing  double-track  steel  viaduct,  through  girders  with  I-beam 
floor  encased  in  concrete.  Deck  girder  approaches  with  concrete  floor. 
Waterproofing  to  protect  steel,  no  head.  Waterproofing  consisted  of 
three  layers  of  felt,  one  layer  of  burlap,  two  layers  of  felt,  a  mopping  of 
pitch  on  the  concrete,  between  each  layer  of  felt  and  burlap  and  over  all. 
The  work  was  completed  in  1908  and  is  satisfactory  and  no  leak  on  last 
inspection  in  October,  191 1.  The  waterproofing  was  protected  by  a  layer 
of  fine  crushed  stone  and  screenings  embedded  in  and  covered  with  pitch. 
Expansion  was  provided  in  concrete,  but  no  provision  for  expansion  was 
made  in  the  waterproofing.  The  cost  of  the  waterproofing,  including  the 
protection,  was  15  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

CENTRAL  RAILROAD  COMPANY   OF  NEW  JERSEY. 

Mr.  Jos.  O.  Osgood,  Chief  Engineer.  Supplemental  answers  given 
to  Circular  122,  November  16,  1909. 

Bridge  No.  2Q$4,  Central  Division :  No  leaks  when  last  inspected  in 
May,  191 1. 

Bridge  No.  60^,  Central  Division :  No  leaks  when  last  inspected  in 
October,  191 1. 

Bridge  No.  42,  N.  J.  S.  Division  :  No  leaks  when  last  inspected  in 
May,  191 1. 

Bridge  No.  34,  Central  Division :  Leaks  appeared  along  the  webs  of 
main  girders  during  last  winter.  These  were  caused  by  throwing  the 
snow  during  the  flanging  of  the  tracks  along  the  webs  of  the  girders. 
When  a  thaw  set  in,  the  melting  snow  was  held  in  a  pocket  in  such  a 
manner  as  to  bring  the  water  above  the  flashing  angle  and  back  of  the 
waterproofing.  This  difficulty  has  been  remedied  in  our  later  bridges  by 
placing  the  flashing  angle  and  carrying  the  waterproofing  at  least  a  foot 
above  the  top  of  rail.  In  this  bridge  the  waterproofing  was  stopped  about 
on  a  level  with  the  base  of  rail. 

The  cost  of  forty  cents  per  sq.  ft.  includes  the  furnishing  and  applying 
of  waterproofing  materials  and  the  cost  of  the  protecting  brick  in  place. 
The  cost  of  the  brick  was  $8.00  per  thousand,  f.  o.  b   cars  at  the  work. 

Bridge  No.  63,  Central  Division,  and  13  other  bridges:  Leaks  ap- 
peared along  the  webs  of  the  girders  from  the  same  cause  as  stated  under 
Bridge  No.  34. 

Bridge  No.  4^,  Manufacturers'  Branch:  No  leaks  when  last  in 
spected  in  May,  191 1,  except  as  stated  in  former  report. 


MASONRY.  461 

Bridge  No.  136,  Central  Division,  Hampton,  N.  J. :  Waterproofed 
November,  1910,  with  four  layers  of  Barrett's  Specification  Felt  and  one 
intermediate  layer  of  Barrett's  Tartex,  cemented  together  with  Barrett's 
Specification  Pitch,  waterproofing  carried  to  the  under  side  of  flange  angles 
of  main  girders.  The  cost  of  waterproofing  this  bridge,  including  the 
brick  protection,  was  $0,273  per  sq.  ft. 

No  leaks  have  appeared  up  to  the  last  inspection  of  May,  191 1. 

Bridge  No.  19,  Central  Division:  Completed  September,  191 1.  Wa- 
terproofed with  four  layers  of  Barrett's  Specification  Felt  and  an  inter- 
mediate layer  of,Barrett's  Tartex,  cemented  together  with  Barrett's  Speci- 
fication Pitch.  Protected  by  brick  laid  flat  with  joints  poured  with  pitch. 
The  cost  per  sq.  ft,  including  brick  protection,  was  $0,123  for  materials 
and  $0,066  for  labor.  The  brick  cost  $8.00  per  thousand,  f.  o.  b.  cars  at 
the  work. 

Bridge  No.  218,  Central  Division :  A  double-track,  half-through  plate 
girder  structure  about  45  ft.  long,  with  I-beam  floor  encased  in  concrete. 
Completed  November,  1910. 

For  waterproofing  the  upper  surface  of  the  concrete  was  given  two 
coats  of  Hydrex  Waterproofing  Paint.  As  soon  as  the  painting  was  com- 
pleted the  ballast  was  placed  immediately  on  top  with  no  protection  for 
the  waterproofing.  Up  to  the  last  inspection  of  May,  191 1,  no  leaks  had 
appeared. 

The  concrete  at  the  main  girders  was  carried  up  to  the  flange  angles 
of  the  girders  which  were  about  20  in.  above  the  top  of  rail.  The  painting 
was  also  carried  to  that  point. 

The  general  practice  of  this  company  is  still  the  same  as  outlined  in 
the  concluding  paragraphs  of  my  letter  of  November  16,  1909,  above  re- 
ferred to. 

PENNSYLVANIA   LINES    WEST   OF   PITTSBURG. 

Mr.  R.  Trimble,  Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  states  that  the 
reply  to  Circular  122  in  1909  and  1910  contain  all  the  information  they 
have  on  the  subject. 

The  latest  examinations  made  show  the  conditions  to  be  the  same  as 
previously  reported. 

NEW    YORK   CENTRAL   &    HUDSON    RIVER  R.  R.  CO. 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge,  Chief  Engineer,  furnishes  the  following 
information : 

General  Remarks  :  Trouble  experienced  in  the  case  of  felt  and  coal- 
tar  pitch  is  mostly  on  account  of  the  poor  class  of  labor  used.  It  does 
not  prevent  leakage  when  the  body  walls  are  not  built  continuously. 
Trouble  is  also  caused  by  lack  of  care  in  joining  successive  sections  of 
work,  horizontally  or  vertically. 

SUBWAY   AT  PASSENGER   STATION' — BUFFALO. 

The  subway  leading  from  the  Buffalo  Passenger  Station  is  of  rec- 
tangular section,  20  ft.  in  width  and  7  ft.  in  height  inside,  serving  12 
tracks.  The  side  walls  are  of  monolithic  construction  similar  to  ordinary 
retaining  walls,  and  the  floor  is  extra  thick  of  the  same  construction.  The 
roof  is  of  20-in.  I-beams,  with  concrete  filling  between,  covered  with  three 
inches  of  cement,  with  waterproofing  and  with  a  protection  of  brick  on  top 
of  this  and  under  the  ballast.  The  entire  outside  of  walls  was  covered 
with  waterproofing  consisting  of  6-ply  tarred  felt,  each  layer  put  on  sep- 
arately, with  Sarco  compound,  and  outside  of  this  the  side  walls  and  the 
top  are  protected  with  brick  laid  in  cement.  The  floor  is  protected  by  6-in. 
layer  of  concrete  under  the  waterproofing,  the  floor  itself  above  the  water- 
proofing being  10  in.  thick,  the  extra  weight  being  given  to  prevent  float- 


462 


MASONRY. 


N.  Y.  C.  &  H.  R.  R.   R.   CO. 
INFORMATION  CONCERNING  APPLICATION  OF  WATERPROOFING-1902-1911 


Location 

Character  of  the 

Structure 

Waterproofed 

Conditions 
Requiring 
Water- 
Proofing 
Head  of 
Water,  if  any 

Materials 
Lsed 

Date 
Applied 

Date 

Examined 

Remarks 

Albany 

Subway  under  tracks 
at    passenger    sta- 
tion. 

Surface  water 

j-in.  asphalt 

Ap.      1902 
Ex.      1910 

Satisfactory  as  to 
walls;  roof  leaked 
badly;  copper  sub- 
roof  put  in  to  take 
care  of  moisture. 

Brewster 

Coaling  station  pit. . 

6-ft.  head 

6-ply  tar  and 
Felt 

Ap.      1910 
Ex.      1910 

Leaked  badly;  repair- 
ed by  Hydrolithic 
compound  applied 
by  the  Hydrolithic 
company 

Buffalo 

Scajacuada      Creek 
arch,  40-ft.  span 

Surface  water 
only 

i-in.  coal  tar 
pitch 

Ap.      1908 
Ex.      1910 

Good;  the  only  leaks 
showing  were  in  ver- 
tical joints 

Buffalo 

Belt  Line  reinforced 
concrete  arch 

Surface  water 
only 

Tarred    felt 
coa 1  tar 
pitch,  s- 
in.  cement 
mortar 

Ap.      1908 
Ex.      1910 

Satisfactory 

Buffalo 

Belt  Line  reinforced 
concrete  arch 

Surface  water 
only 

J-in.  coating 
s  t  r  a  ight 
run   coal 
tar  pitch 

Ap.      1908 
Ex.      1910 

Satisfactory 

Reinforced  concrete 
arch,      Columbia 
Street 

Surface  water 
only 

j-in.   plaster 
of  1:2   ce- 
ment over 
1  layer  of 
tarred  felt 
over  i-in. 
of  straight 
run  coal 
tar  pitch 

Ap.     1909 
Ex.      1910 

Satisfactory 

Onchiota 

Concrete  arch,  20-ft. 

Road  bed  sur- 
face   Drain- 
age 

i-in.  coal  tar 
pitch  over 
1-in  of  1:2 
Portl  and 
cement 
mortar 

Ap.     1906 
Ex.      1910 

Satisfactory 

Poughkeepsie. 

Back    of     retaining 
walls 

For       surface 
drainage 

i-in.  coal  tar 
pitch 

Ap.     1908 
Ex.      1910 

Fairly  satisfactory 

Poughkeepsie. 

Back     of    retaining 
walls 

For       surface 
drainage 

Medusa 
compound 

Ap.      1908 
Ex.      1910 

Water  stained;  walls 
nearly  always  let 
water  through  at 
horizontal  joints 
where  work  endsone 
day  and  begins  next 

Rippleton .... 

40-ft.concrete  arch . . 

Surface  drain- 
age 

i-in.  coal  tar 

Ap.     1906 
Ex.      1910 

Very  little  value;  leaks 
through  intrados 
every  3  or  4  feet 

Troy 

4-ft.  head 

f-in.  asphalt 
protected 
by  brick 

Ap.     1902 
Ex.      1910 

Miscellaneous 

Retaining  walls 

Ground      and 
surface    wa- 
ter    behind 
walls 

i-in.  coal  tar 
pitch 

Ap.      1900 
Ex.      1910 

Leakage  found  usually 
at  horizontal  and 
vertical  joints 
where  work  was  dis- 
continued 

MASONRY  463 

age,  and  prevent  its  being  cracked  by  the  upward  pressure  of  the  water. 
Waterproofing  of  sides  and  floor  was  made  continuous  as  far  as  possible. 

The  conditions  requiring  waterproofing  were  as  follows  :  This  con- 
struction is  in  a  bed  of  clay  which  extends  about  half  way  up  the  height 
of  the  subway,  the  remaining  6  ft.  or  so  is  of  a  loose  gravel,  so  that  all 
of  the  surface  water  coming  through  the  porous  matter  is  held  by  the 
clay  under  slight  head. 

The  construction  of  this  work  was  carried  on  under  considerable  dif- 
ficulty, it  being  necessary  to  work  while  the  traffic,  which  is  very  heavy 
at  this  point,  was  going  on,  and  it  was  possible  to  build  only  a  part  of 
the  subway  at  a  time,  andnot  make  a  continuous  job  of  it.  It  is  probable 
that  at  points  where  one  piece  of  work  left  off,  and  another  began,  the  con- 
nection between  the  waterproofing  was  imperfect,  as  cracks  began  to  de- 
velop, and  the  water  came  into  the  subway  in  small  quantities  in  numerous 
places  almost  as  soon  as  completed.  This  was  remedied  by  careful  appli- 
cation of  */>-in.  hydrolithic  cement  by  the  Waterproofing  Company,  on  the 
inside  of  the  subway,  so  that  the  structure  is  now  tight,  except  the  roof, 
where  on  account  of  the  vibration  of  the  trains,  it  was  practically  im- 
possible to  insure  an  absolutely  tight  job.  Great  care  was  taken  to  find 
all  cracks  and  dig  them  out,  and  fill  them  with  hydrolithic  cement.  The 
cost  of  the  hydrolithic  waterproofing  was  about  30  cents  per  sq.  ft,  and 
has  now  been  on  for  two  years,  and  has  given  good  satisfaction. 

Referring  to  letter  of  September  16,  191 1.  in  the  matter  of  water- 
proofing of  masonry :  I  sent  on  February  10  last  considerable  informa- 
tion on  this  subject  and  at  this  time  can  only  add  a  few  remarks  in  regard 
to  waterproofing  which  we  found  on  the  old  Park  Avenue  tunnel  roof 
where  a  portion  of  it  was  removed  at  59th  Street. 

The  roof  consisted  of  iron  beams  with  brick  arches  which  were  lev- 
eled up  with  concrete.  The  waterproofing  was  placed  directly  on  this  con- 
crete and  was  covered  with  about  two  ft.  of  earth  which  formed  the  soil 
for  the  parking  around  the  openings  in  the  roof  of  the  tunnel.  Drains 
were  provided  so  that  the  water  did  not  stand  in  the  earth.  The  materials 
were  of  felt  and  coal-tar  pitch,  three  plies  of  felt  being  used.  We  have 
no  information  as  to  the  method  of  application  or  the  cost  of  the  work.  I 
have  understood  indirectly  that  this  waterproofing  was  placed  when  the 
tunnel  was  built,  some  forty  years  ago.  From  recollection  of  the  tunnel 
for  the  past  ten  years  the  vegetation  over  this  waterproofing  was  in  such 
a  state  that  the  waterproofing  must  be  at  least  twenty  years  old.  The 
waterproofing  was  removed  on  account  of  changes  we  were  making  last 
winter,  and  it  was  in  fair  condition.  The  paper  had  become  somewhat 
brittle,  also  the  pitch  was  harder  than  pitches  we  apply  now,  but  the  sheet 
of  waterproofing  was  intact  and  capable  of  shedding  water.  Small  leaks 
would  not  have  been  detected;  the  only  protection  of  the  concrete  was 
the  soil  placed  over  it.  The  waterproofing  covered  the  tunnel  roof  from 
58th  to  59th  Street,  and  presumably  extends  a  good  deal  farther.  There 
was  no  provision  for  expansion  joints. 

MICHIGAN    CENTRAL   RAILROAD. 

(A)  Fifteenth  Street  Bridge,  3  spans,  through  plate  girders,  I-beam 
plate  ballast  floor ;  masonry  abutments. 

(B)  Twenty-fourth  Street  Bridge,  3  spans,  I-beam  plate  ballast  floor 
on  steel  bents ;  masonry  abutments. 

(C)  Vinewood  Avenue  Bridge,  3  spans,  I-beam  plate  ballast  floor 
bridge  on  steel  bents  and  masonry  abutments. 

(D)  Scotten  Avenue  Bridge,  same  as  Vinewood  Avenue. 

(E)  Clark  Avenue  Bridge,  same  as  Vinewood  Avenue. 

(F)  Twenty-third  Street  Bridge,  same  as  Vinewood  Avenue. 

(G)  Sixteenth  Street  Bridge,  same  as  Fifteenth  Street. 
(H)     Fourteenth  Street  Bridge,  same  as  Fifteenth  Street 


464  MASONRY. 

(  I  )  Beaubien  Street  Bridge  Peninsular  Spur,  same  as  Fifteenth 
Street. 

(  J  )     Brush  Street  Bridge  Peninsular  Spur,  same  as  Fifteenth  Street. 

(K)  Beaubien  Street  Bridge,  3  spans,  built  up  beams  on  concrete 
bents  and  concrete  abutments.     Beams  embedded  in  concrete. 

(L)  Brush  Street  Bridge,  3  spans,  Bethlehem  beams  on  concrete 
bents  and  abutments.     Beams  embedded  in  concrete. 

(M)     John  R.  Street  Bridge,  same  as  Brush  Street. 

(N)  Tecumseh  Road,  one  75  ft.  through  girder  span  with  I-beam 
floor  and  concrete  slab  on  top  of  1-bearns. 

(O)  Beecher  Avenue  Bridge,  3  spans,  built  up  beams  with  plate, 
ballast  floor,  on  steel  bents  and  concrete  abutments. 

(P)     Twentieth  Street  Bridge,  same  as  Beecher  Avenue. 

(R)     Military  Avenue  Bridge,  same  as  Beecher  Avenue. 

(S)     Livernois  Avenue  Bridge,  same  as  Beecher  Avenue. 

All  the  structures  mentioned  above  required  waterproofing  to  keep 
floor  dry  over  the  streets  as  follows : 

For  (A),  (B),  (C),  CD)  and  (E)  :  Mop  coat  of  Sarco  with  \V,  in. 
sand  and  Sarco  mastic  and  pouring  coat  of  No.  6  Sarco  on  top  of  mastic. 

For  (F)  :  M'op  coat  of  Sarco,  1J/2  in.  sand  and  pitch  mastic  to  cover 
rivet  heads,  on  top  of  this  5-ply  Barrett  Felt  and  pitch  protected  by  il/j 
in.  pitch  Torpedo  gravel  mastic. 

For  (G)  :  Mop  coat  of  Sarco,  ilA  in.  sand  and  Sarco  mastic  to  cover 
rivet  heads,  2-ply  Barrett  Felt  mopped  with  Sarco  No.  6,  i1/?  in  sand  aivl 
Sarco  mastic.     Pouring  coat  of  Sarco. 

For  (H)  :  Mop  coat  of  Sarco,  1  in.  coat  of  sand  and  Barrett  pitch 
to  cover  rivet  heads,  5-ply  Barrett  Felt  mopped  with  pitch,  \l/2  in.  of  Tor- 
pedo gravel  pitch  mastic  with  pouring  coat  of  Barrett  pitch. 

For  (I),  (J),  (K),  (L)  and  (M)  :  Paint  with  Sarco  Primer,  3-ply. 
8  oz.  Burlap  mopped  with  Sarco  No.  6,  il/2  in.  Sarco  mastic,  pouring  coat 
of  Sarco  No.  6. 

For  (N)  :  Paint  coat  of  Sarco  Primer,  3-ply,  8  oz.  Burlap  mopped 
with  hot  Sarco  No.  6,  izA  in.  protection  coat  of  Sarco  mastic  and  Torpedo 
gravel. 

For  (O)  and  (P)  :  One  and  one-half  in.  Sarco  sand  and  mastic,  3-ply. 
8  oz.  Burlap  mopped  with  No.  6  Sarco;  1^2  in.  Sarco  Torpedo  gravel 
mastic  and  pouring  coat  of  hot  mastic. 

For  (R)  and  (S)  :  One  and  one-half  in.  sand  pitch  mastic,  two  layers 
of  felt  mopped  with  Barrett  Pitch  and  one  layer  of  reinforcing  felt  mopped 
with  Barrett  Pitch ;  1  in.  Barrett  sand  and  pitch  protection  coat. 

COST  PER  SQUARE  FOOT  OF  SURFACE  COVERED. 

Labor  Material  Total                           Completed 

(A)  3-9/10  5-5/10          0-4/10 August,  1908 

(B)  2-9/10  6-4/10          9-3/10 June,  1909 

(C)  2-7/10  6-9/10          9-6/10 September,  1908 

(D)  2-5/10  7-2/10          9-7/10 June,  1008 

(E)  3-2/10  7-8/10        11           June,  190S 

(F)  7  7-4/10        14-4/10 June,  T909 

(G)  4-7/10  9-7/10        14-4/10 August,  1908 

(H)  7-5/10  6-8/10        14-3/10 July,  1908 

(  I)  20  16-4/10  36-4/10   Done  in  winter;  trouble  with  snow 

and  ice December,  1910 

(  J  )         9-3/io         16-9/10        36-2/10 December,  T910 

(K)         6-4/10        14-4/10        20-8/10 December,  1910 

(L)  9-5/10        15-5/10        25  March,  191 1 

(M)        8-5/10        17-1/10        25-6/10 January,  1911 

(N)       10  8-6/10        18-6/10 June,  1910 


MASONRY.  •466 

Labor        Material  Total  Completed 

(O)         7-3/10        18-8/10        26-1/10 November,  1910 

(P)  7-2/10         16-2/10        23-4/10 July,  1910 

(R)         4-6A0        10-  14-6/10 May,  1910 

(S)  S-8/10        10-8/10        15-6/10 May,  1910 

(A)  Leaks  badly  over  posts  at  gusset  plate  connections  and  small 
leaks  at  nearly  all  beam  connections  in  northbound  track.  Leaks  at  25 
per  cent,  of  beam  connections  in  southbound  track. 

(B),  (C),  (D),  (E)  and  (F).     No  leaks. 

(G)     Leaks  over  posts  at  gusset  plate  connections  only. 

(H)     Leaks  over  posts  at  gusset  plate  connections  only. 

(I),  (J),  (K),  (L)  and  (N).     No  leaks. 

(0)  Two  small  leaks  over  supporting  girder,  third  panel  from 
north  end. 

(P),  (R)  and  (S)     No  leaks. 

EL  PASO  &  SOUTHWESTERN  SYSTEM. 

Have  waterproofed  in  1008  about  194,000  sq.  ft  of  concrete  lined 
reservoirs,  using  the  Sylvester  process  of  soap  and  alum,  two  coats  of 
each,  and  by  painting  surface  with  asphalt  and  Elaterite  waterproofing. 
We  depended  largely  upon  this  waterproofing  for  water-tightness,  and  the 
concrete  was  not  as  rich  in  cement  as  it  otherwise  would  have  been.  Theo- 
retically the  mixture  was  1:2:4;  actually,  some  of  it  was  not  quite  as  rich. 
We  had  considerable  trouble  with  leakage  through  portions  of  the  con- 
crete and,  upon  examination,  such  parts  were  generally  found  to  be  evi- 
dently porous. 

After  a  period  of  three  years,  we  find  the  asphalt  and  Elaterite  coating 
to  be  a  pronounced  failure  on  account  of  peeling  off  in  the  winter  time 
through  action  of  frost.  We  find  the  Sylvester  process  of  soap  and  alum 
quite  efficient.  Except  in  places  where  the  concrete  is  evidently  quite  in- 
ferior, the  soap  and  alum  has  made  the  concrete  watertight.  Where  the 
concrete  was  good  and  the  work  thoroughly  done,  the  water  will  stand 
and  roll  on  the  surface  of  the  concrete  as  it  will  on  plate  glass.  Of  course, 
the  concrete  is  not  actually  as  impervious  as  the  glass,  but  drops  of 
water  on  the  concrete  so  waterproofed  disappear  by  evaporation  rather 
than  by  absorption. 

The  sand  and  gravel  used  in  lining  these  reservoirs  were  of  a  fair 
grade  only,  the  maximum  size  of  gravel  being  1^2  in.  The  concrete  lining 
was  from  4  to  6  in.  thick.  The  gravel  was  not  as  finely  graded  as  it 
should  have  been  and  the  larger  stones  were  evidently  too  large  for  that 
kind  of  work. 

The  cost  of  waterproofing  with  soap  and  alum  was  43/Too  cents  per 
sq.  ft. ;  with  asphaltum  1  4/10  cents  and  with  Elaterite  waterproofing  made 
by  the  Elaterite  Paint  Mfg.  Co.,  Des  Moines,  ij4  cents  per  sq.  ft.  (For 
former  report  on  this,  see  Proceedings,  Vol.  12,  Part  1.  page  513.) 

A  few  months  ago  we  completed  a  reinforced  concrete  septic  tank  30 
ft.  in  diameter  and  12  ft.  high,  with  shell  .6  in.  thick.  No  waterproofing 
was  used  in  this  concrete.  The  latter  was  theoretically  a  1:2:4  mix,  but 
we  actually  used  a  somewhat  greater  percentage  of  cement.  The  sand  and 
gravel  were  good.  The  specifications  for  the  gravel  required  it  all  to 
pass  through  a  l/>-'m.  screen.  This  tank  is  entirely  watertight  except  at 
the  joints  between  successive  courses  of  concrete.  It  appears  to  be  demon- 
strative of  the  possibility  of  making  concrete  watertight,  at  least  for  the 
light  pressure  existing  in  this  particular  tank. 

First-class  sand  and  stone,  carefully  graded,  to  reduce  the  voids,  and 
a  liberal  margin  of  cement  in  excess  of  the  voids  in  the  sand  and  stone, 
and  thorough  uniformity  in  the  mixing  and  laying  are,  we  believe,  more 
efficient  than  anything  else  in  making  concrete  waterproof.  The  maximum 
size  of  the  stone  should  not  exceed  f£'-in.  and  we  think  that  ^-in.  is  better. 


466  MASONRY. 

CHICAGO,  BURLINGTON  &  QUINCY  RAILROAD. 

In  1909  or  1910  we  furnished  the  Committee  with  some  discussion 
on  the  subject  of  waterproofing.  We  have  some  of  this  waterproofing  in 
service  for  about  three  years,  and  where  it  was  properly  put  on,  it  is  in 
good  shape. 

It  will  be  noted  at  the  right  hand  end  of  the  blueprint  enclosed  the 
old  method  is  shown.  Here  the  waterproofing  passes  down  over  a  steep 
slope.  In  some  cases  the  pressure  from  the  ties  has  forced  it  down  the 
slope,  tearing  it  apart.  In  order  to  avoid  this  trouble,  the  new  method 
shown  at  the  left  hand  end  of  the  blueprint  was  adopted.  The  slope  was 
made  flat  and  the  burlap  was  laid  over  a  long  piece  of  gas-pipe,  placed  at 
the  top  of  the  slope  and  withdrawn  as  the  work  proceeded,  leaving  some- 
thing in  the  way  of  an  expansion  joint. 

This  has  been  quite  successful,  but  if  we  have  more  of  this  kind  of 
work  to  do,  we  shall  make  the  subway  slabs  the  same  thickness  as  the 
roadway  slabs,  thus  getting  a  uniform  slope  from  the  center  of  the  street 
to  the  back  of  the  abutment. 

We  are  now  engaged  in  repairing  some  of  this  waterproofing  where 
leaks  have  occurred.  The  work  was  done  in  frosty  weather  and  we  find 
that  the  first  ply  of  burlap  was  not  saturated  at  all;  the  second  ply  begins 
to  be  saturated ;  the  third  one  a  little  more  and  the  fourth  and  fifth  ones 
are  well  saturated. 

On  all  of  this  cold  weather  work  so  far  examined,  the  mastic  pro- 
tection over  the  burlap  is  cracked  badly  and  the  burlap  at  the  bottom  of 
these  cracks  has  rotted.  For  purposes  of  comparison  with  this  work,  we 
have  cut  out  a  few  pieces  of  waterproofing  from  portions  of  the  structure 
put  in  the  same  year,  but  where  the  work  was  done  in  warm  weather ; 
here  the  waterproofing  is  in  perfect  condition.  We  attribute  the  cause 
of  the  trouble  entirely  to  the  fact  that  the  waterproofing  was  laid  in  cold 
weather  when  the  concrete  surface  upon  which  it  was  laid  was  cold,  and 
the  asphalt  chilled  before  it  had  an  opportunity  to  saturate  the  burlap. 

The  original  cost  of  this  work  was  13-3/10  cents  per  sq.  ft..  9-3/10 
cents  being  for  material  and  4  cents  for  labor.  (For  former  information, 
see  Proceedings,  Vol.  n,  Part  2,  pp.  991-992.) 

NORFOLK  &  WESTERN  RAILWAY. 

Subway  for  use  of  passengers  under  tracks  at  Petersburg,  Va.  Con- 
structed of  concrete,  a  6-in.  layer  of  concrete  is  placed,  on  the  area  of 
foundation,  upon  this  concrete  against  the  outer  forms  4-in.  brick  walls 
are  built,  and  on  the  concrete  base  and  against  the  brick  walls  the  water- 
proofing, consisting  of  a  coat  of  Sarco  concrete  primer  applied  hot,  a 
heavy  swabbing  of  Sarco  No.  6  waterproofing  and  3-ply  membrane  No.  16 
Sarco  Asphalt  felt;  the  felt  is  lapped  so  that  there  is  at  no  point  less  than 
three  thicknesses  of  felt,  each  thickness  being  heavily  swabbed  with  hot 
Sarco  No.  6  waterproofing  before  succeeding  thickness  is  applied. 

The  membrane  is  well  swabbed  with  Sarco  No.  6  and  while  this  coat 
is  still  hot  a  layer  of  8  oz.  burlap  is  applied,  this  layer  is  also  swabbed  with 
No.  6  Sarco  and  a  second  layer  of  8  oz.  burlap,  breaking  joints  with  the 
first,  is  laid. 

The  last  layer  of  burlap  when  dry  is  swabbed  with  hot  Sarco. 

The  concrete  walls,  floor  and  steps  of  the  subway  are  then  built 
against  the  waterproofing  above  described. 

The  concrete  subway  roof  reinforced  with  steel  rails  and  expanded 
metal,  laid  with  a  crown  of  1  in.  for  drainage  is  waterproofed  by  a  mat 
of  2-ply  burlap  and  3-ply  felt  laid  as  described  for  sidewalls,  except  that 
the  burlap  is  laid  first  or  on  the  bottom  of  the  mat.  The  roof  waterproof- 
ing is  protected  from  cutting  by  the  ballast  by  a  layer  of  i*4  in.  of  Sarco 
Asphalt  M'astic  applied  in  two  coats  of  3%-in.  each,  with  lapped  joints. 


MASONRY.  467 

This  work  was  done  about  a  year  ago  and  has  proven  satisfactory. 
Cost  of  waterproofing  complete  about  50  cents  per  sq.  fr. 

CHICAGO  CITY  RAILWAY  COMPANY. 

Car  Houses  and  Car  Repair  Shops.  Advise  that  the  old  roofs  are 
about  the  same  as  they  were  a  year  after  completion;  no  new  leaks  have 
developed  since  that  time.     (See  Proceedings,  Vol.  n,  Part  2.  page  971.) 

Particular  attention  is  called  to  the  design  of  roof  over  the  addition 
to  the  Thirty-eighth  and  Cottage  Grove  car  house,  constructed  a  year  and 
a  half  ago  and  to  this  date  shows  no  sign  of  a  leak.  No  waterproofing 
was  used,  water  tightness  was  obtained  by  dense  concrete  reinforced  to 
resist  shrinkage  and  temperature  stresses.  The  body  of  the  roof  slab  was 
mixed  in  1 :2  -.4  with  54-in.  top  finish  cement  and  sand  1  13  mix.  On  this 
structure,  expansion  joints  were  used.  Size  of  stone  specified  was  to 
pass  a  34-in.  TinS  and  under.     The  concrete  was  mixed  very  wet. 

INDIANAPOLIS  WATER  COMPANY. 

Mr.  William  Curtis  Makee  calls  attention  to  the  Clear  Water  Reser- 
voir at  Riverside  Pumping  Station.  Indianapolis,  257  ft.  by  377  ft.  with 
walls  10  ft.  high,  floor,  walls  and  roof  built  monolithic;  built  in  1907  and 
examined  in  191 1  and  showing  no  leaks.  The  cover  is  flat  and  supports 
two  feet  of  soil,  drainage  being  carried  off  by  means  of  open  jointed  drain 
pipes  laid  on  the  cover.     No  waterproofing  was  used. 

Concrete  was  of  dense  construction  reinforced  with  steel  bars  for 
shrinkage  and  temperature  stresses.  Proportions  1  cement  to  6  un- 
screened bank  gravel ;  head  of  water  contained  8  ft. 

Also  calls  attention  to  three  filter  covers  each  200  by  350  ft.  joined  at 
the  center  for  a  length  of  350  ft.  to  a  partition  wall  14  ft.  high.  The 
covers  are  laid  on  a  slope  of  5/10  per  cent,  and  required  to  shed  storm 
water;  2  ft.  depth  of  screened  cinders  are  placed  on  the  covers.  No 
leaks,  except  slight  seepage  at  junction  of  entrance  to  flat  slab. 

The  work  was  completed  in  ioo5  and  last  examination  in  191 1  shows 
the  results  above  noted.  No  regular  expansion  joints  were  used;  the  en- 
tire roof  slides  on  supporting  walls  on  paraffin  joint.  The  mixture  was 
1  cement,  2  parts  of  sand  and  4  parts  of  stone  mixed  very  wet.  The  water 
pressure  was  10-ft.  head  on  dividing  walls.  There  are  some  leaks  in 
dividing  walls  due  to  the  aggregate  stratifying;  the  leaks  being  in  hori- 
zontal seams  and  quite  small. 

PHILADELPHIA   &  READING  RAILWAY. 

(Waterproofing  of  Masonry,  P.  G.  &  N.  Elevated.) 

Refers  to  report  of  November  1,  1909,  on  the  same  subject  with  sup- 
plement as  published  in  Proceedings,  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  page  510. 

No  noticeable  difference  in  the  number  of  leaks  is  apparent  except 
perhaps  that  the  total  amount  of  leakage  is  not  so  great  and  those  struc- 
tures originally  reported  as  water  tight  are  still  in  the  same  condition. 
Last  inspection  was  made  in  September,  191 1. 

In  regard  to  new  work,  this  is  reported  under  three  heads :  (a) 
Bridge  on  Contract  No.  11,  P.  G.  &  N.  Elevated;  (b)  Waterproofing  of 
steel  Viaduct  between  Brown  and  Jefferson  Streets;  (c)  Bridge  over 
Master  Street — all  located  in  the  City  of  Philadelphia. 

(a)  Consist  of  nine  half-through  plate  girder  four-track  bridges. 
Total  area  of  bridge  floors,  56,500  sq.  ft. 

(b)  Top  of  deck  plate  girder  four  track  viaduct.  Total  area  of 
waterproofing,  197,300  sq.  ft. 

(c)  Deck  plate  girder  span  with  buckle  plate  floor.     Area,  3,050  sq.  ft. 
The  protection  of  the  steel  work  of  bridges  and  of  street  underneath 

required  the  waterproofing  and  applies  to  all  cases. 


468  MASONRY. 

Materials  used  for  (a)  and  (b)  natural  rock  asphalt  mastic  V/2  in. 
thick  applied  in  two  coats  and  supported  by  1  -.3 :6  concrete  filling  in 
troughs  of  steel  floor.  And  for  (c)  five  layers  Genasco  felt  protected  with 
irick  laid  on  concrete  filling  of  buckle  plate  floor. 

The  cost  for  (a)  is  reported  at  24  cents  and  31  cents  per  sq.  ft,  for 

(b)  24  cents  per  sq.  ft.  and  for  (c)  26  cents  per  sq.  ft.  These  costs  in- 
clude, in  all  cases,  the  concrete.  Under  (a)  the  troughs  were  12  in.  deep, 
and  under  (b)  6  in.  deep. 

Under  (a)  one-half  of  each  bridge  completed  October,  1910;  balance 
June,  191 1 ;  (b)  one-half  completed  in  December,  1910;  balance  May,  191 1 ; 

(c)  completed  December,  1910. 

Very  few  leaks  have  appeared  under  any  of  the  nine  bridges  under 
(a)  except  in  two  places  where  the  old  work  joined  with  the  new  on  ac- 
count of  connecting  the  two  sections.  This  joint  has  given  trouble  along 
one  girder. 

(b)  Is  generally  tight  except  at  expansion  joints;  these  joints  occur 
about  every  150  ft.,  and  are  now  being  treated  with  a  laver  of  pure  asphalt 
with  a  high  melting  point  and  a  low  brittle  point,  placed  over  the  joint. 
One-half  of  the  viaduct  has  been  so  treated  and  proved  very  effective. 

(a)  and  (b)  No  protection  of  waterproofing  was  used;  ballast  rest- 
ing directly  on  the  mastic.  For  (c)  the  waterproofing  is  protected  with 
a  layer  of  hard  brick  laid  in  waterproofing  compound. 

ST.  LOUIS  &  SAN  FRANCISCO  RAILROAD. 

Reports  on  reinforced  concrete  beam  subway  bridge — 2  spans,  25  ft. 
and  12^2  ft.,  supporting  3  tracks.  Waterproofed  by  using  16  parts  old 
process  coal  tar,  4  parts  Portland  cement,  1  part  kerosene,  applied  hot 
by  means  of  a  brush.  The  tar  was  heated  first  and  kerosene  and  cement 
added ;  3  heavy  coats  used  on  top,  2  heavy  coats  on  rear  face  of  abutments. 

Cost  of  labor  $0.00519  and  for  materials  $0.00418,  or  a  total  of  $0.0092 
per  sq.  ft.  of  surface  treated. 

Work  was  completed  in  October,  1910,  and  examined  in  October,  1911, 
and  no  leaks  discovered.  No  protection  to  the  waterproofing  was  used; 
12-in.  ballast  ties  on  top  of  the  reinforced  slab  and  cinder  filling  was  used 
against  the  abutments  of  each  joint. 

One  expansion  joint  over  supporting  columns  protected  by  raising 
concrete  along  each  side  of  joint.  The  surface  of  the  entire  structure  is 
small  and  sloped  for  drainage. 

PITTSBURG  &  LAKE  ERIE  RAILROAD. 

Reports  waterproofing  on  five  40  to  50  ft.  four-track  half  deck  and 
through  girder  bridges.  Floor  stringers  spaced  15  in.  center  to  center. 
Space  between  floor  stringers  filled  with  concrete. 

Waterproofed  to  protect  the  metal  work  and  also  against  dripping  to 
the  street  under  bridge. 

Waterproofing  consisted  of  Sarco  No.  6  waterproofing  with  8  oz. 
open  mesh  burlap;  i?4  lbs.  of  1:2  cement  mortar  protection  over  water- 
proofing. 

On  the  clean  dry  surface  of  concrete  floor  was  applied  a  coating  of 
Sarco  Concrete  Primer  thin  enough  to  penetrate  the  recesses  of  the  con- 
crete. Primer  in  some  cases  being  too  heavy  was  thinned  with  gasoline. 
After  the  primer  dried  (requiring  about  one  hour)  a  heavy  coating  of  hot 
Sarco  No.  6  Waterproofing  was  applied  and  while  the  material  was  still 
hot  a  layer  of  8  oz.  open  mesh  burlap  was  laid. 

To  apply  the  burlap  on  the  hot  Sarco,  first  have  it  rolled  on  a  2-in. 
round  stick  and  start  unrolling  immediately  after  applying  the  Sarco,  ex- 
ercising care  to  keep  it  straight  and  free  from  folds.  Follow  closely  the 
unrolling  of  burlap  by  brooming  with  a  rattan  broom.  This  method  was 
followed  until  three  layers  of  burlap  was  applied. 


MASONRY.  .  469 

On  top  of  the  last  layer  of  burlap  a  heavy  coating  of  hot  Sarco  was 
applied.  As  soon  as  convenient,  after  the  Sarco  waterproofing  was  ap- 
plied, a  i2i-in.  thickness  of  i  :2  cement  mortar  was  laid. 

Cost  of  labor  $0,026  per  sq.  ft.  treated  and  $0,044  for  material,  making 
a  total  of  $0,070  per  sq.  ft.  treated  for  3  bridges  on  which  complete  data 
were  kept.  Results  obtained  were  reported  in  paragraph  7,  Bulletin  130, 
Masonry  Committee  reports  on  "Waterproofing."  Last  examination  made 
September  25,  191 1. 

For  the  Sharon  Road  Bridge  and  Lion  Lane  Bridge:  No  leaks  in 
concrete  roof  apparent.  A  few  rivets  in  the  girders  show  that  at  some 
time  water  must  have  passed  through  waterproofing. 

Leopard  Lane  Bridge:  Under  No.  1  track  water  is  dropping  slowly 
at  three  places.  At  six  other  places  indications  point  that  water  has  been 
dropping  at  some  time  and  at  a  few  other  places  in  girders  indications  are 
that  water  has  passed  through  rivet  holes  at  some  time. 

Third  Street  Bridge:  No.  1  track,  no  leaks.  No.  2  track,  five  places 
at  edges  of  floor-beams  indicate  that  water  has  come  through  and  at  two 
of  these  places  it  was  dropping  slowly  at  last  inspection.  Track  No.  3, 
two  places  water  dropping.     Track  No.  4,  no  leaks. 

Second  Street  Bridge:  A  good  many  leaks  show  at  this  bridge.  This 
is  the  bridge  on  which  an  unfavorable  report  was  made  before  and  there 
is  no  indication  of  any  decided  change.  Leaks  show  at  edges  of  floor- 
beams  and  girders.  Water  is  slowly  dropping  through  at  many  of  the 
rivets. 

The  reason  advanced  for  the  unfavorable  condition  of  waterproofing 
on  these  bridges  is  that  the  concrete  was  not  allowed  to  set  up  naturally, 
artificial  heat  having  been  applied  to  dry  it  preliminary  to  applying  the 
Sarco  Primer,  and  in  some  cases  the  waterproofing  was  applied  in  un- 
favorable weather  conditions. 

Have  just  completed  bridge  at  Aliquippa,  which  was  waterproofed  in 
the  same  manner  as  those  above  described  but  with  all  conditions  favor- 
able for  a  fair  test,  such  as  dry  concrete  on  which  to  apply  the  first  coat 
(Primer)  and  dry  and  warm  weather  during  the  time  the  waterproofing 
was  applied.  It  will  be  interesting  to  observe  the  results  in  connection 
with  this  structure  which  is  known  as  the  Third  Street  Subway  at 
Aliquippa. 

Another  reason  advanced  for  the  failure  of  the  waterproofing  outlined 
in  the  first  paragraph  is  that  the  cement  mortar  cover  may  be  broken  under 
impact  of  traffic  and  the  ballast  may  have  cut  the  waterproofing. 

Third  Street  Subway,  Aliquippa,  Pa.:  This  is  a  ballast  bridge,  288  ft. 
wide,  and  supporting  about  20  tracks.  The  distance  between  abutments 
is  40  ft.  and  a  line  of  columns  supports  the  floor  structure  at  the  center. 

The  floor  is  made  of  15-in.  80-lb.  I-beams,  44  ft.  long,  spaced  15  in. 
c.  to  c.  and  filled  between  with  1 13  :S  concrete. 

The  structure  is  waterproofed  with  Sarco  No.  6  waterproofing,  with 
2-ply.  of  8-oz.  open  mesh  burlap,  using  same  method  given  in  answer  to 
question  No.  4  of  Circular  dated  September  16,  191 1,  except  that  two  layers 
of  burlap  were  used. 

The  area  covered  was  14,000  sq.  ft. 

Sarco  Primer,  151  gals.  @  $0.35  per  gal $  52.85 

Sarco  No.  6,  16,200  lbs.  @  $35-6o  per  ton 288.36 

Burlap,  1,560  lbs.  @  $o.oS  per  lb 124.80 

Total  cost  of  material $466.01 

Total  cost  of  labor 251.38 

Total  cost  of  labor  and  material $7 17.39 


470  MASONRY. 

Material  cost  $.033  per  sq.  ft. 
Labor  cost  $.018  per  sq.  ft. 

The  waterproofing  was  protected  by  T?4-in.  cement  covering  made  ot 
1 :2  mortar.    The  area  covered  13,320  sq.  ft. 

Sand  used,  52  tons  @  $0.65 $  33.80 

Cement,  131  bbls.  @  $0.85 111.33 

Labor    103.00 

Total    $248.15 

Material  cost  $.011  per  sq.  ft. 
Labor  cost  $.008  per  sq.  ft. 

The  waterproofing  was  applied  at  different  times  between  May  and 
August,  191 1,  under  favorable  weather  conditions  and  is  in  good  condi- 
tion at  this  date,  October  5,  1911. 

SANTA  FE  RAILWAY  SYSTEM: 

(Waterproofing  of  Scale  Pits  and  Hopper  Pits  for  Mechanical  Coal 

Chutes.) 
Pits  were  about  5  ft.  deep  and  water  level  was  within  1  ft.  of  surface. 
Three-ply  Hydrex  felt  was  used  on  one  scale  pit  with  poor  results ;  used 
ironite,  a  paint,  on  one  scale  pit  with  fair  results ;  used  8  per  cent,  hydrated 
lime  mixed  with  dry  cement  on  coal  chute  pits  obtaining  good  results. 
The  mix  of  the  mortar  was  1:1  and  the  concrete  1:1:2.  No  record  was 
kept  as  to  cost.  The  work  was  done  three  to  five  years  ago  and,  when 
examined  about  six  months  ago,  there  were  no  leaks. 

LONG  ISLAND  RAILROAD. 

(Reinforcing  Concrete  Floors  for  Steei  Bridges  Carrying  Railroad 

Tracks.) 

Six  layers  of  pitch,  four  of  felt  and  one  (the  middle)  reinforced  by 
cloth,  each  layer  thoroughly  swabbed  with  hot  pitch  on  the  felt.  The 
total  cost  per  square  foot  of  surface  treated  from  12  to  20  cents.  The 
work  was  done  from  1908  to  date — 10  bridges.  First-class  results  were 
obtained  and  on  last  examination,  October,  191 1,  there  were  no  leaks. 
The  waterproofing  is  protected  by  brick,  the  cost  of  which  is  included  in 
the  above  figures.     No  expansion  joints  were  used  in  any  of  the  floors. 

Have  used,  in  the  construction  of  a  small  concrete  water  tank  at 
Long  Island  City,  inside  plaster  with  mortar  mixed  1  cement,  1  sand  and 
2  gals,  soft  soap  and  about  2  qts.  of  granulated  alum  per  barrel  of  cement. 

The  results  obtained  are  not  stated 

CANADIAN    PACIFIC   RAILWAY. 

(Waterproofing  Subways.) 

McPhillips  Street  Subway:  Deck  of  subway  of  steel  plate.  Water- 
proofing used  dry  felt,  tarred  felt,  burlap  and  Gilsomite  asphalt,  applied 
as  follows : 

On  the  steel  deck  is  laid  a  layer  of  dry  felt,  then  a  layer  of  tarred  felt 
with  asphaltum,  over  this  is  laid  two  layers  of  burlap  each  mopped  with 
asphaltum,  then  a  layer  of  tarred  felt  mopped  with  asphalt,  over  this  is 
laid  a  layer  of  tarred  felt  not  mopped  and  last  a  layer  of  dry  felt.  The 
cost  of  this  waterproofing  was  12^2  cents  per  sq.  ft.  The  work  was  com- 
pleted in  191 1  and  at  last  inspection  during  October,  191 1,  was  found 
satisfactory.  Two  small  leaks  appeared  along  joint  made  with  previ- 
ously constructed  waterproofing.  Waterproofing  is  protected  by  a  coat 
of  tar  concrete  4  in.  thick.  The  cost  of  this  protection  is  9  cents  per  sq. 
ft. ;  this  is  not  included  in  the  above  price  for  waterproofing. 


MASONRY.  471 

The  work  covers  10,500  sq.  ft.  Expansion  is  taken  care  of  by  the 
layers  of  dry  felt. 

Rachael  Street  Subway:  Reinforced  concrete  deck  waterproofed  by 
burlap  and  pitch,  using  five  layers  of  burlap  and  pitch  between  each 
layer.  The  work  was  completed  in  1908  and  is  fairly  satisfactory.  On 
last  examination  in  October,  191 1,  a  few  small  leaks  showed.  No  pro- 
tection to  waterproofing  was  used.  The  ballast  was  laid  directly  on  top 
of  the  waterproofing. 

Weston  Shops  (Winnipeg):  Deck  of  subway,  old  rails  encased  in 
concrete.     Waterproofing  material,  burlap  and  asphaltum. 

The  concrete  was  first  covered  with  a  layer  of  asphaltum  on  which 
is  laid  one  thickness  of  burlap,  then  a  layer  of  asphaltum,  then  another 
thickness  of  burlap  and  then  a  good  covering  of  asphaltum  over  all.  The 
total  cost  of  this  waterproofing  is  8y2  cents  per  sq.  ft.  The  work  was 
done  in  November,  1910,  and  results  obtained  are  satisfactory;  last  exam- 
ination in  October,  191 1,  showed  no  leaks.  No  protection  was  used  over 
the  waterproofing.     Gravel   was  laid  directly  on  the  waterproofing. 

Union  Station  (Regina) :  Conditions  requiring  waterproofing;  sur- 
face water  and  leakage  from  tank  and  pipes  leading  from  dam  to  round- 
house, gardens  and  various  buildings.  Materials  used  were  cement  mortar 
and  pitch.  The  waterproofing  was  applied  as  a  plaster  against  the  wall 
and  afterwards  given  a  good  coating  of  pitch.  The  cost  of  the  waterproof- 
ing labor  was  1.93  cents;  the  cost  of  waterproofing  material  was  2.72  cents; 
total  cost  of  waterproofing  per  square  foot  of  surface  treated  was  4.88 
cents,  this  includes  superintendence.  Work  was  completed  in  August, 
191 1,  and  from  an  inspection  made  during  October,  1911,  the  results  ob- 
tained are  apparently  remarkably  good.  No  protection  was  used.  Back 
filling  was  placed  directly  against  waterproofing. 

UNION  AND  SOUTHERN  PACIFIC  SYSTEMS. 

Brick  Depot  Building:  Coating  brick  walls  on  interior  with  asphaltum 
paint,  before  applying  plaster;  the  paint  used  was  Toch  Brothers  B.  I.  W., 
applied  with  spraying  machine  or  three-coat  work  with  brush.  The  cost 
of  the  work  was  11  to  13  cents  per  sq.  yd.  applied  with  spraying  machine. 
The  work  was  done  in  1907  and  at  last  inspection,  September  30,  191 1,  the 
plaster  was  found  to  be  dry  and  decorating  in  good  condition. 

Hospital  Building  Basement:  Used  5  per  cent.  Medusa  compound, 
first  mixed  dry  with  cement,  then  added  to  other  aggregate,  proportion 
one  part  cement,  one  part  sand  and  five  parts  stone,  size  of  stone  34-in.  to 
iJ4  in.  The  mixture  was  so-called  wet  mixture  (water  appearing  freely 
on  surface).  The  work  was  done  in  1909  and  upon  last  inspection,  Sep- 
tember 28,  1911,  the  walls  and  floor  were  dry,  no  leaks  and  no  moisture 
appearing.  The  cost  of  the  work  account  waterproofing  was  increased 
$1.10  per  cubic  yard. 

Oregon-Washington  Railroad  &  Navigation  Co.:  Waterproofing  con- 
crete wall,  built  1 :3  :5  mixture,  blue  cross  cement,  ordinary  run  of  gravel 
and  sand,  maximum  size  of  gravel  passed  2-in.  ring.  Head  of  water  6  ft. 
Waterproofing  consisted  of  Wunners  Bitumen  Emulsion,  mixed  2Y2  pints 
of  this  material  with  one  bag  of  cement  and  2^/2  cu.  ft.  of  sand,  adding 
water  to  plaster  consistency  applied  to  surface  of  wall;  the  work  was 
done  September  1,  191 1,  and  at  last  inspection,  October  28,  191 1,  showed 
small  amount  of  surface  water  but  no  apparent  leaks. 

The  cost  was  about  10  cents  per  sq.  ft.  of  surface  waterproofed. 

PENNSYLVANIA    LINES. 

Enclosed  are  blueprints  of  statement  corrected  to  include  the  water- 
proofed bridges,  Twelfth  to  Twenty-sixth  Streets,  in  our  Chicago  Track 
Elevation  Work.    This  is  a  record  of  the  method  of  waterproofing  used  in 


472 


MASONRY. 


WATERPROOFING  BRIDGE  FLOORS— METHODS  USED  AND  RESULTS  OBTAI  NED. 
Pennsylvania  Lines  West  of  Pittsburg,  Southwest  System. 


Street 

Track  No. 

Method  of  Waterproofing 

Year 
Applied 

Result  of  Inspection 

April,  1909               April,  1910 

April.  1911 

Ashland 

1 
2 
3 
4 
5 

6-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 
1907 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
Leaks  badly 
Leaks  badly 
No  report 

No  report 
No  report 
No  report 
No  report 
No  report 

4  leaks 

4  leaks 

5  leaks 
4  leaks 

6  leaks 

Paulina 

1 

2 
3 
4 
5 
6 
7 
Driveway 
8 
9 

4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
3-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1906 
W06 
1906 
1906 
1907 
1907 
1907 
1906 
1907 
1907 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
6  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
26  leaks 
No  report 
Several  leaks 
Several  leaks 

7  leaks 

8  leaks 
No  leaks 

15  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
2  leaks 
No  report 
No  report 
No  leaks 

7  leaks 
6  leaks 

8  leaks 

3  leaks 
5  leaks 
5  leaks 

4  leaks 
8  leaks 
4  leaks 

Wood 

1 
2 
3 

4 
5 

4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1906 
1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 

No  leaks 

16  leaks 

4  leaks 

Several  leaks 

No  report 

13  leaks 
9  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  report 

10  leaks 
10  leaks 
10  leaks 
10  leaks 
10  leaks 

Lincoln 

I 
2 
3 
4 
& 
6 
7 
Driveway 
8 
9 

4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-j>ly  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
S-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-pJy  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
3-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

19Q6 
1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 
1907 
1907 
1906 
.1907 
1907 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

4  leaks 

3  leaks 

4  leaks 
10  leaks 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  report 
2  leaks 
No  report 

7  leaks 

7  leaks 
11  leaks 
17  leaks 

5  leaks 
10  leaks 
19  leaks 
10  leaks 
10  leaks 

9  leaks 

Robey 

1 

2 
3 
4 
5 

4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1906 
1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
24  leaks 
Several  leaks 
No  report 

15  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
1  leak- 
No  report 

7  leaks 
26  leaks 

5  leaks 
19  leaks 
19  leaks 

Hoyne 

1 
2 
3 
4 
5 
6 
7 
Driveway 
8 
9 

4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
3-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex   Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1906 
1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 
1907 
1907 
1906 
1907 
1907 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

4  leaks 

lleak 

No  leaks 

15  leaks 

No  leaks 

No  leaks 

8  leaks 
No  report 
No  leaks 

8  leaks 

13  leaks 
18  leaks 
6  leaks 

18  leaks 
6  leaks 

19  leaks 
19  leaks 

9  leaks 
9  leaks 
35  leaks 

Leavitt 

1 

2 
3 
4 
5 

5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  ConcreteTop 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  ConcreteTop 

1906 
1906 
1906 
1906 
1907 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

18  leaks 
9  leaks 
2  leaks 
5  leaks 
No  report 

9  leaks 
22  leaks 
22  leaks 

12  leaks 

13  leaks 

Oakley 

1 

2 
3 

4 
5 

Iron  "Bark  Concrete  Top 

Iron  Bark  Concrete  Top 

5  ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 

5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1905 
1905 
1906 
1906 
1907 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
Leaks  badly 
Leaks  badly 

No  leaks 
14  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  Report 

3  leaks 
6  leaks 
6  leaks 
6  leaks 
17  leaks 

Western 

1 
2 
3 
4 
5 

5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
4-ply  Barretts  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1907 
1907 
1905 
1905 
1907 

No  leaks 
10  leaks 
No  leaks 
Several  leaks 
Several  leaks 

5  leaks 

3  leaks 

No  leaks 

No  leaks 

No  report 

8  leaks 

9  leaks 
9  leaks 

23  leaks 
33  leaks 

Note. — Bridges  located  In  Chicago. 


MASONRY. 


473 


WATERPROOFING  BRIDGE  FLOORS-Continued. 


Street 

Track  No. 

Method  of  Waterproofing 

Year 
Applied 

Result  of  Inspection 

April,  1909               April,  1910 

April,  1911 

Marshall 

1 

2 
3 
4 

5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 
5-ply  Hydrex  Felt  Concrete  Top 

1908 
1908 
1908 
1908 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks, 

No  leaks 

1  leak 

No  leaks 

No  leaks 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 
No  leaks 

34th 

1 

2 
3 
4 

Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 

1904 
1904 
1904 
1904 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

Leaks- very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

8  leaks 
8  leaks 
10  leaks 
8  leaks 

35th 

1 

2 
3 
4 

Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt. 

1904 
1904 
1904 
1904 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

8  leaks 

8  leaks 

9  leaks 
7  leaks 

36th 

1 
2 
3 
4 

Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 
Concrete  and  Asphalt 

1904 
1904 
1904 
1904 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 
Leaks  very  badly 

6  leaks 
8  leaks 

7  leaks 
6  leaks 

Archer 

1 

2 
3 

4 

Concrete — Wire  Mesh 

3-ply  Hydrex  Felt 

3*-ply  Hydrex  Felt,  no  Concrete 

on  Top 
Concrete  and  Asphalt  Mastic 

;      1904      1  No  leaks 
1904      j  No  leaks 

1904-        No  leaks 
1904        No  leaks 

3  leaks 
No  leaks 

No  leaks 
No  leaks 

No  leaks 
1  leak 

1  leak 
No  leaks 

Western 

1 

2 
3 

4 

Concrete — No  Waterproofing 
Concrete — No  Waterproofing 
Concrete — No  Waterproofing 
Concrete — No  Waterproofing 

1905      1  Leaks  very  badly 
1905        Leaks  very  badly 
1905      j  Leaks  very  badly 
1905      |  Leaks  very  badly 

3  leaks 
16  leaks 
2  leaks 
6  leaks 

39  leaks 
36  leaks 
31  leaks 
30  leaks 

Normal 

1 

Asphalt  Mastic 

1904        No  report 

15  leaks 

30  leaks 

Wallace 

1 

Asphalt  Mastic 

1904      j  No  report 

No  leaks 

No  leaks 

Lowe 

1 

Asphalt  Mastic 

1904      1  No  repdrt 

14  leaks 

36  leaks 

Union 

1 

Asphalt  Mastic  Blocks 

1904 

No  report 

9  leaks 

27  leaks 

Emerald 

1 

2 
Side  Track 

Asphalt  Mastic  Blocks 
Asphalt  Mastic  Blocks 
Hydrex  Felt 

1904 
1904 
1907 

No  report 
No  report 
No  report 

20  leaks 
8  leaks 
4  leaks 

6  leaks 
15  leaks 
12  leaks 

Halsted 

1 

Hydrex  Felt 

1906 

No  report 

lleak 

No  leaks 

Mill 

All  Tracks 

Sandusky 

6-ply  Barretts  Felt.BrickoaTop 

1909 

7  small  leaks 

24  small  leaks 

Darby 

6-ply  Barretts  Felt,  Brick  on  Top 

1909      1 

1  small  leak 

7  small  leaks 

Note.— Above-named   bridges    located   ia    Chicago,    excepting    last    three, 
which    are   in   Columbus. 


474  MASONRY. 

all  of  our  track  elevation  bridges,  and  the  results  of  inspections  made  from 
time  to  time  thereafter. 

All  of  the  bridges  were  of  trough  floor,  the  troughs  being  filled  with 
concrete,  the  waterproofing  applied,  and  a  protection  coat  of  concrete  or 
brick  added  on  top  of  the  waterproofing. 

The  cost  of  applying  this  waterproofing  was  as  follows : 

Twelfth  Street   51.3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Ogden  Avenue  50.0  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Fifteenth  Street  47.4  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Sixteenth   Street    49.3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Eighteenth  Street   43.1  cents  per  sq.ft. 

Twenty-first  Street  39.3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Twenty-second  Street   23-3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Twenty-third  Street   57.3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Twenty-fourth  Street 48.3  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Twenty-fifth  Street 48.4  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

Twenty-sixth  Street  70.0  cents  per  sq.  ft. 

The  above  costs  cover  the  concrete  filling  in  the  troughs,  waterproof- 
ing the  protection  coating  of  concrete  or  brick,  and  the  concrete  parapet 
walls  at  the  ends  of  the  bridges.  We  have  not  added  any  material  or 
substance  to  concrete,  to  make  it  impervious.  We  have  not  used  a  per- 
centage of  hydrated  lime  in  any  of  our  concrete,  in  an  endeavor  to  make 
it  impervious. 


METHODS   OF   PATCHING   AND    REPAIRING   PLAIN    AND 
REINFORCED  CONCRETE. 

Your  Committee  having  been  instructed  to  collect  data  and  prepare 
a  report  on  "Methods  of  Patching  and  Repairing  Plain  and  Reinforced 
Concrete,"  reports  as  follows : 

A  circular  letter,  under  date  of  July  14,  191 1,  was  sent  to  members 
of  the  Association,  requesting  information  on  this  subject,  to  which  let- 
ter more  than  one  hundred  replies  have  been  received.  Nearly  all  of  the 
replies  contain  useful  information,  but  as  the  same  methods  are  frequently 
described  by  several  writers,  a  selection  has  been  made  from  these  replies 
and  is  presented  as  an  appendix  to  this  report. 

The  various  methods  referred  to  may  be  described  as  follows : 

(1)  Wet  Method:  The  surface  of  the  old  concrete  is  thoroughly 
roughened,  cleaned  and  drenched  with  water  and  covered  with  a  cement 
grout.  Then  the  new  concrete  is  mixed  to  a  sloppy  consistency  and  ap- 
plied, being  held  in  place  till  set  by  forms,  as  required. 

Comment:  From  the  reports  received  it  appears  that  many  suc- 
cesses and  many  failures  have  followed  this  method.  Where  it  has  been 
successful,  that  result  probably  has  been  due  to  painstaking  care  and 
expense  being  employed  in  the  preliminary  cleaning  and  thorough  wetting 
of  the  old  concrete  surfaces  before  the  new  concrete  is  applied. 

(2)  Moderately  Dry  Method:  The  surface  of  the  old  concrete  is 
thoroughly  roughened,  cleaned  and  drenched  with  water  and  powdered 
with  cement  or  painted  with  cement  grout — after  which  the  new  concrete 
is  applied  and  thoroughly  tamped  against  the  old  surface.  Generally, 
such  patches  are  kept  moist  by  sprinkling  them  with  water  for  several  days. 


MASONRY. 


41$, 


Comment:     The  same  comment  applies  here  as  to  the  wet  method. 

(3)  Dowel  Method:  This  is  a  modification  of  the  two  preceding 
methods  and  is  generally  used  for  other  than  horizontal  surfaces,  although 
it  may  be  applied  to  the  latter.  The  new  concrete  may  have  afiy  consist" 
ency  to  meet  the  particular  conditions  Or  the  ideas  of  the  Engineer  i« 
charge,,  but  usually  a  fairly  wet  concrete  is  used.  This  method  includes 
drilling  holes  and  setting  dowels  into  the  old  concrete,  with  projecting 
ends  to  engage  into  the  new  concrete.  Sometimes  steel  bars  cr  metal 
fabric  are  connected  to  these  dowels  to  further  insure  permanency  of  the' 
patch. 

Comment:  This  method  can  be  made  uniformly  successful,  but  can- 
not always  be  applied.  Where  any  considerable  mass  of  new  concrete 
is  to  be  connected  to  old  concrete  this  is  the  only  safe  method  to  pursue. 

(4)  Wedge  Method:  This  method  includes  the  cutting  out  of  de- 
fective concrete  in  such  a  manner  as  to  undercut  the  surrounding  good! 
concrete  so  that  the  new  concrete  will  be  held  in  place,  when  Set,  by" 
the  shape  of  the  binding  edges  of  the  old  concrete. 

Comment:  The  difficulty  of  undercutting  concrete  so  as  to  secure-' 
such  edges  is  too  great  to  make  this  method  applicable  in  ordinary  case?,, 
and,  except  where  a  considerable  depth  of  new  concrete  is  to  be  put  in, 
such  undercutting  could  not  be  successfully  done,  as  concrete  cannot  be 
cut  so  as  to  leave  sharp,  clean  edges. 

(5)  Cleaning  with  Steam:  This  is  a  method  of  cleaning  surfaces 
of  old  concrete  preparatory  to  putting  on  a  patch  of  new,  or  of  cleaning 
the  top  of  a  rough  concrete  floor  before  applying  the  "finish  coat." 
The  surface  of  the  old  concrete  is  brushed  as  clean  as  possible  with  stiff 
brushes  and  then  gone  over  at  least  twice  with  a  steam  jet— an  ordinary 
piece  of  half-inch  gas  pipe  makes  a  very  satisfactory  jet  nozzle.  This 
short  length  of  pipe  is  connected  to  a  steam  hose  so  that  it  can  be  readily 
moved  about.  The  steam  is  supplied  by  the  boilers  of  the  mixer  or 
noisting  engines.  The  steam  will  clean  and  heat  the  concrete  surface, 
leaving  it  perfectly  dry,  so  it  is  important  to  thoroughly  drench  the  sur- 
face with  water  after  cleaning  with  steam.  In  cold  weather  it  is  found 
advantageous  to  use  hot  water.  Immediately  after  the  surface  is  thor- 
oughly cleaned  and  drenched,  the  new  concrete  is  applied. 

Comment:  Excellent  results  have  followed  the  use  of  this  method 
of  cleaning,  but  it  is  essential  that  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete  be 
thoroughly  drenched  with  water  after  using  the  steam  jet,  otherwise 
the  new  concrete  will  not  adhere  to  the  old. 

(6)  Cleaning  with  Acid:  This  method  includes  washing  of  the 
surface  of  the  old  concrete  with  a  solution  of  hydrochloric  (muriatic) 
acid  (one  part  acid  to  two  parts  water),  after  which  the  surface  must  be 
carefully  and  thoroughly  washed  to  remove  any  free  acid. 

Comment:  This  is  a  very  commonly  applied  method  of  cleaning 
old  concrete  surfaces  preparatory  to  placing  new  concrete  against  them, 
and,  by  many,  is  considered  the  only  safe  one  to  use,  especially  where 
a  "finish  coat"  is  to  be  put  on  after  the  concrete  base  is  set. 


476  MASONRY. 

CONCLUSIONS 

Your  Committee  presents  the  following  conclusions  as  to  the  methods 
of  repairing  defective  or  worn  surfaces  of  concrete: 

(i)  In  all  cases  the  surface  to  be  repaired  must  first  be  thoroughly 
cleaned  of  all  loose  material,  laitance  and  dust  and  the  clean,  rough,  sound 
concrete  exposed  to  receive  the  patch.  Probably  the  best  method  of 
cleaning  is  by  means  of  a  steam  jet. 

(2)  After  cleaning,  the  surface  to  be  repaired  must  be  thoroughly 
saturated  with  water,  not  simply  moistened,  but  so  thoroughly  drenched 
that  the  old  concrete  will  not  absorb  water  from  the  new  mortar  or 
concrete  used  in  patching.  If  possible,  the  surface  should  be  kept  covered 
with  water  for  several  hours. 

(3)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  vertical  or  sloping 
surface  and  is  not  to  be  more  than  V/2  in.  thick,  the  surface  of  the  old 
concrete,  while  it  is  still  wet,  should  be  spattered  or  splashed  with  a 
cement  grout,  following  this  immediately  with  a  fairly  stiff  plaster  coat 
of  mortar  made  of  the  same  proportions  of  cement  and  sand  as  was  used 
in  the  original  concrete,  but  never  richer  than  1  cement  to  2.V2  sand. 
This  plaster  coat  should  not  be  thicker  than  J^-ih.  and  each  coat  should 
be  forced  into  the  surface,  but  not  dragged  with  a  trowel.  The  sur- 
face of  each  coat,  except  the  final  coat,  should  be  "scratched"  to  give  a 
bond  for  the  next  coat.  This  plastering  should  preferably  begin  at  the 
top  and  progress  downward,  and  only  enough  time  be  allowed  to  permit 
each  coat  to  receive  its  initial  set  before  the  next  coat  is  applied.  The 
final  coat  should  be  finished  with  a  wooden  float  and  only  enough  water 
used  to  properly  finish  the  surface.  This  patch  should  be  kept  damp  and 
protected  from  sun  or  frost  till  fully  set  up. 

(4)  If  the  repair  or  patch  or  "finish  coat"  is  to  be  made  on  a 
horizontal  or  nearly  horizontal  surface,  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete 
should  be  slushed  and  broomed  with  a  thin  cement  grout,  following  this 
immediately  with  a  wet  mortar  made  of  1  part  cement  and  2*4  parts  sand 
or  granite  screenings  and  of  the  full  thickness  required  (not  less  than 
J/2-in.  thick,  however).  When  this  mortar  begins  to  take  its  initial 
set,  it  should  be  floated  or  troweled  to  such  a  finish  as  may  be  desired. 

(5)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  vertical  or  sloping 
face  and  is  to  be  more  than  il/2  in.  thick,  it  will  be  advisable  to  embed 
dowels  into  the  old  concrete,  as  deeply  as  the  thickness  of  the  proposed 
patch,  and  spaced  sufficiently  close  together  to  firmly  anchor  the  patch  to 
the  old  concrete.  The  dowels  must  be  wedged  into  the  old  concrete  and 
it  will  be  advisable  to  fasten  wires,  metal  fabrics  or  bars  to  the  dowels, 
in  the  case  of  extensive  patching,  as  an  additional  safeguard.  The  patch- 
ing may  then  be  done  with  mortar  without  forms,  or  with  wet  concrete 
supported  by  forms,  depending  upon  the  thickness  and  the  extent  of  the 
patch. 

(6)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  horizontal  or  nearly 
horizontal   face  and   of  considerable   thickness,   dowels   may  be  used,   or 


MASONRY.  477 

the   concrete  may  simply  be   reinforced  by   fabric   or  bars   without   using 
dowels — treating  the  patch  as  a  block  of  masonry. 

(7)  Care  must  be  taken  not  to  have  thin  edges  on  patches.  To  avoid 
this,  it  may  be  necessary  to  cut  out  sound  concrete  around  a  piace  to  be 
patched,  so  as  to  give  deep  edges  to  the  patch.  If  possible,  the  edges 
should  be  undercut. 

ABSTRACT  OF  REPLIES. 

Lincoln  Bush,  Consulting  Engineer:  "During  the  years  1900  to  1909, 
inclusive,  the  Lackawanna  Railroad  put  in  907,000  cu.  yds.  of  concrete.  In 
building  this  masonry  the  general  practice  for  concrete  work  done  from 
1900  to  1903  was  to  make  the  body  of  the  masonry  in  proportions  of  I  :3  :S, 
with  a  2-in.  surface  finish  in  the  proportions  of  about  1 :2 :2. 

"The  concrete  built  from  the  years  1903  to  1909,  inclusive,  which  was 
generally  in  the  proportions  of  1  :3 15  for  the  entire  wall  without  any 
1:2:2  mixture  for  a  facing  coat,  has  given  by  far  better  results  than  the 
work  done  with  the  2-in.  facing.  My  observation  and  experience  show 
that  the  defects  and  shelling  off  of  the  2-in.  facing  may  not  take  place  for 
a  period  of  two  or  three  years  after  the  work  is  finished  and  that  these 
defects  and  the  shelling  off  continue. 

"I  advocate  very  strongly  the  use  of  a  uniform  mixture  for  the  entire 
wall,  omitting  the  surface  coat  of  richer  proportions  and,  if  it  is  desirable 
and  necessary  to  have  a  special  surface  finish  for  ornamentation  or  other 
purpose,  to  obtain  such  finish  by  bush  hammering,  treatment  with  acid  or 
rubbing  and  washing  while  concrete  is  green,  using  crushed  stone  of  such 
size  as  will  give  the  desired  surface  effect." 

Frank  H.  Alfred,  General  Superintendent,  Cincinnati,  Hamilton  & 
Dayton  Raihvay:  "Small  imperfections  in  finish,  we  repair  with  stiff 
cement  grout  immediately  after  the  removal  of  the  forms.  We  aim  to  sim- 
ply fill  in  small  cavities,  not  by  plastering,  but  by  working  the  grout  into 
each  individual  cavity,  finishing  afterwards,  while  the  grout  is  green,  by 
rubbing  with  a  small  block  of  wood. 

"Larger  cavities  we  fill  whenever  weather  conditions  are  favorable. 
In  filling  such  cavities,  we  aim  first  of  all  to  thoroughly  clean  the  cavity 
of  all  loose  stone,  cement  and  dirt.  We  are  very  particular  about  clean- 
ing the  cavity,  using  for  the  purpose  a  weak  solution  of  acid,  if  necessary, 
later  washing  all  remaining  acid  from  the  cavity.  We  then  use  one  to 
two  grout  or  a  lean  concrete  mixture,  mixed  rather  stiff.  This  mixture 
we  are  very  particular  to  thoroughly  mix,  that  is,  if  mixing  by  hand, 
where  three  turnings  would  suffice  for  ordinary  concrete,  we  give  the  ma- 
terial intended  for  patching  some  eight  or  a  dozen  turnings.  In  depositing 
this  material  in  the  cavity  we  seldom  use  anything  resembling  a  form  to 
retain  it  in  place,  but  put  the  material  in  with  trowels  in  small  layers, 
thoroughly  working  it  into  place.  If  the  mixing  and  depositing  is  thor- 
oughly done,  such  repairs  will  be  permanent." 

W.  J.  Harahan,  Vice-President,  Erie  Railroad:  "At  Hornell,  in  1907, 
one  of  the  forms  on  the  retaining  walls,  over  a  section  12  ft.  in  height  and 
20  ft.  in  length,  bulged  about  5  in.  at  the  bottom  near  the  center  and  the 
bulge  radiated  from  this  point  to  nothing  at  the  sides  and  top.  On  ac- 
count of  being  on  a  sidewalk  and  the  appearance  very  noticeable,  this 
extra  width  was  scabbled  off;  this  scabbling  left  a  rough  and  uneven 
surface.  The  finishing  surface  was  put  on  with  a  mixture  of  one  part 
cement  to  three  of  sand  made  into  a  dry  mortar ;  the  surface  of  the  rough 
wall  was  wet  down  thoroughly  while  finish  was  being  applied.  Commenc- 
ing at  the  top  and  at  one  end  of  the  section,  this  mortar  was  nut  on  with 
a  float,  a  small  amount  at  a  time,  starting  at  the  top  and  carrying  it  to  the 
bottom  in  sections  of  about  2  ft.  in  width ;  the  work  was  carried  on 
uninterruptedly  in  this  manner  until  the!,  whole  area  was  covered.  The 
thickness  of  this  veneer  is  generally  one  inch,  but  there  are  places  where 


4TS  MASONRY. 

the  scabbling  was  irregular  and  where  it  is  from  2  to  3  in.  thick  in  spots. 
There  has  been  no  indication  of  checking  and  the  appearance  of  the  wall 
is  generally  the  same  in  color  as  the  remainder,  which  was  made  of  con- 
crete i  :2^  :5>  and  there  is  no  reason  to  believe  that,  from  this  time  on, 
there  will  be  any  failure. 

"At  Buffalo,  on  an  abutment  composed  of  a  mixture  i  :2j^  :5,  after 
the  forms  were  removed,  a  point  about  2  ft.  above  the  foundations  indi- 
cated a  break  in  the  mixture  in  that  it  showed  a  sand  streak.  The  jentire 
abutment  was  gone  over  with  bush  hammer  as  a  test,  but  there  was  not 
further  indication  of  this  predominance  of  sand.  The  point  referred  to 
was  cut  over  an  area  4  ft.  high,  8  ft.  long  and  18  in.  deep  from  the  face 
of  the  wall.  In  taking  this  out  2  in.  of  the  hard  concrete  was  removed  to 
be  sure  that  all  of  the  sand  had  been  taken  out,  and  a  cross-section  showed 
that  at  8  in.  back  from  the  face  the  material  was  removed  for  a  distance 
of  6  inches  higher  and  wider  than  the  opening  at  face  of  wall  and  then  cut 
back  10  in.  deeper,  this  in  order  to  dove-tail  the  new  concrete  into  the  old. 
It  happened  that  there  were  some  one-inch  corrugated  bars  left  over  from 
reinforcement.  From  this  three  vertical  and  two  horizontal  rods  were  in- 
serted about  on  the  line  of  the  offset ;  that  is,  about  the  middle  of  the 
hole.  Then  it  was  filled  in  with  1 :2  14  concrete  and  after  setting  up  was 
bu:u  hammered.  This  work  was  done  on  June  10,  191 1,  examination  made 
on  July  22,  191 1,  did  not  show  any  indication  of  shrinkage  of  the  new  con- 
crete from  the  old  concrete,  and  no  indications,  by  sound,  of  any  cavi- 
ties." 

L,  W .  Walter,  Cement  Inspector,  Erie  Railroad:  "Of  these  three 
processes,  that  of  'pouring'  permits  of  the  use  of  mortar  or  concrete  and  is 
resorted  to  when  the  surface  to  be  bonded  is  very  irregular  or  when  the 
bulk  of  the  applied  material  is  too  great  to  permit  of  plastering  or  tamping. 
This  process  involves  the  erection  of  forms  and  the  depositing  of  con- 
crete or  mortar  in  the  usual  way,  but  further  requires  that  the  material 
be  very  wet,  and  that  it  be  agitated  near  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete 
to  bring  the  new  material  in  the  closest  possible  contact  with  the  old.  This 
method  is  frequently  unsuccessful  and  should  be  resorted  to  only  when  the 
bulk  of  the  applied  material  is  so  great  as  to  make  the  cost  of  plastering 
or  tamping  prohibitive.  It  is  of  course  understood  that  when  this  or  any 
other  method  is  used  it  is  necessary  to  remove  all  loose  particles  from, 
and  to  thoroughly  drench  the  surface  of  the  concrete. 

"In  the  process  of  plastering  on  old  concrete  surfaces  which  have 
been  scabbled  or  roughed,  both  the  conditions  and  the  requirements  are  so 
varied  that  results  are  frequently  not  satisfactory.  Plaster  will  adhere 
to  surfaces  prepared  by  furring  or  roughing,  as  is  customary  in  prepar 
ing  the  scratch  coat  to  receive  another  coat  in  straight  plaster  work,  but 
in  plastering  irregular  concrete  surfaces  it  is  necessary  to  use  very  wet 
mortar.  This  gives  it  a  tendency  to  loosen  from  the  surface,  by  its  own 
weight,  thereby  forming  hollow  areas  which  will  be  further  loosened  by 
frost.  where  there  is  considerable  moisture  present,  or  by  expansion  and 
contraction  due  to  temperature  changes. 

"The  practice  of  tamping  mortar  against  old  concrete  surfaces,  whether 
it  be  to  fill  voids  caused  by  air  bubbles,  or  whether  the  surface  be  honey- 
combed or  on  surfaces  made  rough  by  scabbling,  is  one  which  I  would 
personally  recommend,  as  I  have  tried  it  under  varying  conditions  and 
have  not  had  a  failure.  In  tamping  mortar  to  rough  surfaces  I  would  pro- 
ceed in  the  following  manner :  Working  downward  from  the  top  of  the 
area  to  be  treated  I  would  remove  all  loose  particles  and  would  wash 
the  surface  of  the  old  concrete  with  a  brush.  The  sand  and  cement  for 
use  in  the  mortar  should  be  the  same  kind  and  proportions  as  that  used 
in  the  concrete,  provided  it  be  not  richer  than  2^  parts  of  sand  to  one 
part  of  cement,  and  should  be  thoroughly  mixed  dry  and  water  added  by 
sprinkling  until  a  semi-plastic  consistency  is  had.     In  tamping  the  mortar 


MASONRY.  479 

against  the  surface  to  be  treated,  I  would  work  downward  from  the  top 
of  the  area  in  order  that  the  water  used  in  wetting  the  surface  of  the 
concrete  would  not  run  down  over  the  newly  applied  coat.  When  the 
surface  has  been  brought  to  the  proper  plane,  it  should  be  floated  with  a 
wooden  float,  and  only  such  amount  of  water  should  be  used  in  the  final 
floating  as  may  be  necessary  to  produce  a  dense  surface.  This  water  may 
be  applied  by  means  of  a  brush  or  by  dipping  the  float  in  vi  ater. 

"It  is  found  in  practice  that  a  rather  dry  mortar,  such  as  may  be 
tamped,  and  not  plastered,  on  a  concrete  surface,  is  less  apt  to  loosen 
from  contraction  and  expansion  due  to  temperature  changer  and  will  more 
nearly  resemble,  in  color,  the  adjoining  natural  surface. 

"In  such  work  as  renewing  the  top  or  wearing  which  has  loosened 
from  the  base  of  concrete  pavements,  on  account  of  its  having  been  placed 
after  the  base  had  set,  the  tamping  process  is  a  success.  It  is  necessary, 
however,  that  the  base  of  the  concrete  be  firm,  and  advisable  that  the 
base  be  washed  with  a  neat  cement  wash  and  the  new  top  be  well  floated. 
This,  in  my  opinion,  is  the  most  difficult  patch  work  to  be  encountered 
and  is  the  best  argument  I  have  to  offer  in  favor  of  using,  for  patch 
work,  a  relatively  dry  mortar. 

"For  patching  honey-combed  surfaces  I  would  recommend  tamping  to 
the  exclusion  of  the  old  practice  of  plastering." 

/.  M.  Meade,  Engineer  Eastern  Lines,  Atchison,  Topeka  &  Santa  Fe 
Railway:  "In  one  small  abutment  the  bridge  foreman  allowed  the  weight 
to  be  placed  upon  it  too  soon,  when  a  wedged  shaped  piece  of  the  abut- 
ment broke  out  with  about  half  of  the  bridge  seat  as  the  base,  and  extend- 
ing down  three  or  four  feet  on  the  face  of  the  abutment,  to  the  point  of 
the  wedge.  The  broken  face  was  thoroughly  roughened  up  and  form  built 
around  it  and  concrete  of  the  same  mixture  was  very  thoroughly  tamped 
into  position. 

"On  some  reinforced  work  we  did  last  winter  the  section  foreman 
knocked  off  a  part  of  the  form  in  connection  with  his  track  work,  and  in 
doing  so  knocked  off  several  corners  of  the  concrete.  We  built  up  forms 
around  these  and  thoroughly  tamped  in  a  rich  mixture  of  equal  amounts 
of  sand  and  cement,  and  today  the  break  cannot  be  detected. 

"Several  concrete  steps  in  Newton,  Kansas,  were  replaced  several 
years  ago  by  roughening  the  surface  and  putting  in  nails  for  dowel  pins. 
This  was  thoroughly  tamped  with  a  rich  mixture  and  has  never  shown  any 
signs  of  failure. 

"The  secret  in  patching  concrete  seems  to  have  been  in  having  a  rough 
surface  to  work  on,  and  in  thoroughly  tamping  the  concerete  and  putting 
in  dowels  or  anchors,  of  any  kind,  wherever  possible.  Also  in  leaving  it 
in  the  forms  until  it  was  thoroughly  set." 

F.  E.  Schall,  Bridge  Engineer,  Lehigh  Valley  Railroad:  "A  double 
track  ribbed  abutment,  supported  by  piling,  broke  in  two  about  the  center 
line,  and  opened  up  a  crack  about  1^4  in.  wide  (due  to  settlement  and 
leaning  of  piling  in  foundation)  ;  after  movement  of  piling  ceased,  a 
V-shaped  opening  about  one  foot  wide  and  about  6  inches  deep  was  cut 
in  the  face  of  the  abutment  and  that  opening  filled  with  comparatively  dry 
concrete;  after  setting  of  this  concrete,  the  crack  was  filled  with  con- 
crete grout.  A  slight  crack  due  to  contraction  of  concrete  appeared  along 
the  edges  of  the  V-shaped  patch  but  is  of  no  consequence.  The  patch 
has  been  in  place  about  il/2  years  and  is  giving  satisfaction." 

H.  F.  Hamilton,  Resident  Engineer,  Great  Northern  Railway:  "I  wish 
to  say  that  I  had  occasion  a  few  days  ago  to  look  over  Bridge  434,  and 
found  that  the  new  concrete  had  adTiered  very  nicely  to  the  old  surface  and 
was  apparently  as  solid  as  if  placed  at  one  time.  Method  used  was  to 
scabble  off  with  a  pick  and  bull  point  the  concrete  affected  by  the  frost. 


480  MASONRY. 

Then  to  wash  the  surface  exposed  with  water,  scrubbing  with  a  stiff 
broom.  This  was  then  gone  over  with  i  .3  solution  of  muriatic  acid  and 
again  washed.  New  concrete  was  applied  as  soon  afterwards  as  possible 
and  put  on  very  wet.  At  two  or  three  places  about  four  feet  above  the 
ground  line  there  was  a  hollow  sound  to  the  concrete,  and  it  appeared  that 
there  was  not  a  very  good  bond  in  about  an  inch  or  so  from  the  surface. 
As  there  was  a  slight  bulge  in  the  surface  of  the  wall,  I  think  this  is  some 
additional  put  on  with  a  trowel  after  the  forms  were  removed.  I  believe 
the  above  methods  will  give  good  results,  but  this  depends  on  how  clean 
the  old  surface  is  made  and  the  keeping  of  the  new  concrete  damp  for  a 
week  or  so  after  being  placed."    . 

/.  A.  Atzvood}  Chief  Engineer,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie  Railroad. 
"Cut  out  all  loose  concrete  and  wash  it  off  thoroughly,  then  apply  a  thin 
wet  mixture  of  mortar  of  about  one  to  one,  allowing  it  to  set  for  about 
an  hour  or  more  in  order  that  it  will  adhere  to  the  old  concrete  and  not 
slip  away  when  the  concrete  is  put  in.  We  then  use  a  wooden  float  to 
rub  the  outer  surface.  If  the  patches  are  too  large  we  insert  steel  dowels 
in  the  old  concrete." 

E.  A.  Hadley,  Engineer  of  Design,  Missouri  Pacific  Railway:  "Thor- 
oughly clean  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete,  with  a  stiff  brush,  remove  ail 
loose  particles  and  foreign  material.  If  the  surface  to  be  patched  was 
smooth,  the  same  was  made  rough  by  the  use  of  hand  drill. 

"After  the  surface  was  prepared  in  this  manner,  the  same  was  washed 
down  with  clean  water,  and  a  thin  layer  of  cement  mortar  mixed  one  to 
two.  spread  on  the  surface,  and  a  rich  mixture  of  concrete  immediately 
placed  on  the  bed  of  the  mortar. 

"The  tops  of  several  retaining  walls  were  repaired  in  this  manner  un- 
der my  direction,  and  the  face  of  a  bridge  pier,  on  which  the  forms  had 
bulged,  was  cut  down  to  a  true  surface  and  patched  up  in  this  manner. 

"This  work  was  done  in  the  early  fall  of  1909  and  was  examined  by  me 
personally  in  December,  1910,  and  it  was  found  that  the  patched  surfaces 
were  in  perfect  condition,  with  no  signs  of  cracking  or  peeling,  and  no 
hollow  sound  was  emitted  when  the  surface  was  struck  a  sharp  blow 
with  a  light  hammer." 

C.  E.  Carhvright,  Consulting  Engineer:  "The  surface  of  the  old  con- 
crete is  carefully  picked  so  that  all  loose  material  is  removed  and  irreg- 
ular holes  are  cut  so  that  a  mechanical  bond  will  be  made  between  the 
old  and  new  concrete.  If  the  concrete  will  be  subject  to  blows  iron 
dowels  will  be  set  at  different  angles  and  well  grouted. 

"Before  placing  the  new  concrete  the  old  surface  will  be  thoroughly 
soaked  with  water  for  a  couple  of  days.  It  will  then  be  well_  brushed  out 
with  a  steel  brush  and  water  and  immediately  before  pouring  the  con- 
crete a  coat  of  neat  grout  will  be  brushed  in. 

"If  the  repair  is  large  reinforcing  steel  will  be  used,  the  ends  being 
well  grouted  into  special  holes  drilled  for  the  purpose." 

F.  L.  Wheaton,  Engineer  of  Construction,  Delaware,  Lackawanna  & 
Western  Railroad:  "We  do  not  allow  surfaces  to  be  washed  or  plastered 
with  either  neat  cement  or  cement  and  sand  after  the  forms  are  removed, 
as  this  invariably  scales  off  in  time  and  leaves  an  unsightly  appearance. 
We  do  in  some  cases  allow  surface  to  be  smoothed  by  use  of  plain  water 
and  carborundum,  or  cement  bricks,  rubbing  off  the  white  lime  dust  after 
surface  is  dry,  but  prefer  surfaces  to  remain  without  treatment  of  any  kind, 
which  can  be  done  if  sufficient  care  is  taken  with  forms. 

"Where  bony  or  porous  places  occur  in  face,  due  to  improper  spading 
or  a  leak  in  forms,  which  allows  cement  and  sand  to  escape,  we  require 
voids  to  be  filled  immediately  upon  removal  of  forms  with  cement  mortar 
of  same  proportions  as  used  in  the  body  of  concrete  and  smoothed  with 


MASONRY.  4*1 

wooden  float,  not  troweled.     We  seldom  have  any  trouble  with  this  mor- 
tar falling  out  and  if  done  in  time  is  seldom  noticeable. 

"One  of  the  worst  defects  in  concrete  faces,  and  one  which  rarely 
develops  until  some  time  after  the  completion  of  the  structure  and,  there- 
fore, is  hard  to  repair,  is  caused  by  the  failure  to  remove  the  sludge  which 
invariably  rises  to  the  surface  of  wet  concrete  and  forms  a  slimy  coating 
of  variable  thickness  at  the  end  of  each  day's  work.  If  this  is  allowed  to 
remain,  and  the  next  day's  work  deposited  thereon,  it  will  later  dissolve, 
leaving  a  more  or  less  ragged  line  of  demarkation  on  the  surface.  While 
this  is  inexcusable,  it  sometimes  occurs  and  we  then  chisel  it  out  in  the 
form  of  a  dovetail,  filling  with  cement  mortar  and  stone  screenings,  tak- 
ing care  that  mixture  is  not  made  too  rich,  otherwise,  there  will  always 
remain  too  great  a  contrast  in  color.  This  should  be  floated  off  with 
wooden  float  or  wire  brush  so  as  not  to  leave  a  glossy  finish.  We  do  not 
depend  on  new  concrete  adhering  to  old,  but  cut  out  imperfection  to  suffi- 
cient depth  and  dovetail  in  the  patch." 

Hunter  McDonald,  Chief  Engineer,  Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis 
Railway:  "The  only  method  which  I  have  tried  for  restoring  the  sur- 
face which  has  been  worn  off  or  cracked  away  by  failure  of  the  top  coating 
to  adhere  to  the  concrete  beneath,  is  to  apply  to  the  old  concrete  a  solu- 
tion of  one  part  hydrochloric  acid  and  two  parts  of  water,  permitting  it 
to  stand  about  fifteen  minutes,  then  washing  it  off  thoroughly  and  apply- 
ing the  top  finish.  This  has  been  tried  in  only  a  few  isolated  cases  and 
the  success  of  the  efforts  has  not  been  sufficiently  demonstrated  for  lack 
of  time. 

"I  have  understood  that  in  a  reinforced  concrete  building  the  floor 
finish  put  on  the  rough  surface  by  this  method  has,  in  many  instances, 
come  loose.  Whether  this  is  due  to  bad  workmanship  or  an  imperfect 
process  I  am  unable  to  say. 

"In  finishing  the  floors  of  a  reinforced  concrete  warehouse  I  required 
that  the  top  surface  should  be  applied  within  three  hours  after  the  laying 
of  the  concrete.  This  plan  has  worked  well  in  every  instance,  except 
where  rain  came  up  and  roughened  the  floor  after  the  finishing  had  been 
done.  These  rough  places  I  have  endeavored  to  grind  out,  but  have  found 
no  successful  means  of  doing  so.  Efforts  to  patch  them  out  by  applying  ad- 
ditional finish  have  been  unsuccessful  on  account  of  the  fact  that  we  did 
not  remove  the  top  coating  for  a  sufficient  depth.  The  feather  edges  of  all 
patches  will  grind  off." 

G.  W.  Vaughan,  Engineer  of  Maintenance  of  Way,  New  York  Central 
&  Hudson  River  Railroad:  "It  is  the  usual  custom,  when  necessary,  to 
patch  or  add  to  old  concrete,  to  use  a  hose  with  water  under  pressure,  or 
a  brush  with  water  and  thoroughly  clean  the  old  concrete  with  a  view  of 
removing  every  particle  of  loose  material  and  dirt  and  leaving  same  per- 
fectly solid  and  clean.  Then  we  dust  dry  cement  over  the  old  work  and 
scrub  it  in  thoroughly  until  all  of  the  spaces  in  the  surface  of  the  old 
concrete  have  been  filled  with  the  dry  powder.  This  is  slightly  moistened 
and  the  new  concrete  applied. 

"In  building  concrete  abutment  piers  or  on  retaining  wall  work,  when 
for  any  reason,  the  work  is  stopped  for  a  time  and  the  top  becomes  set, 
it  is  usually  customary  to  thoroughly  wash  the  set  concrete  and  make  it 
perfectly  clean,  then  mix  up  a  thin  grout  and  pour  it  on,  after  which  the 
fresh  concrete  may  be  applied.  We  have  experienced  very  little  trouble 
with  this  method  and  it  seldom  shows  a  seam.  However,  to  build  an  ex- 
tension on  an  abutment  or  a  retaining  wall  at  the  end,  a  seam  nearly  al- 
ways develops. 

"Sometimes  when  applying  a  patch  we  have  been  successful  in 
handling  same  somewhat  different  than  first  described,  by  simply  cleaning 
away  all  loose  particles  of  concrete,  then  thoroughly  wetting  the  old  con- 


482  MASONRY. 

crete  and  applying  a  small  quantity  at  a  time  of  new,  letting  it  partially 
set  before  putting  on  more ;  following  this  process  until  the  work  has 
been  built  out  to  its  original  surface.  This  would  apply  particularly  to 
large  patches,  where  if  all  applied  at  once,  its  own  weight  might  cause  it 
to  sag  and  fall  away  from  the  old  work,  unless  we  went  to  the  expense 
of  putting  in  dowels. 

"For  instance,  at  Poughkeepsie  we  have  patched  the  underside  of  the 
protection  concrete  in  this  manner  and  it  has  been  most  successful.  The 
conditions  are  extremely  bad  at  this  place  on  account  of  the  old  concrete 
being  covered  with  a  coat  of  soot,  grease  and  smoke  from  the  exhaust 
of  engines.  This  was  scrubbed  with  lye  and  water  and  then  washed  off 
with  the  clear  water  before  applying  the  patch.  We  would  not  have  any 
trouble  with  this  under  ordinary  conditions,  as  it  lasted  well  until  the  cold 
weather  came  on,  so  that  when  the  hot  exhaust  from  the  locomotives,  the 
stacks  standing  directly  under  the  concrete,  came  in  contact  with  same, 
the  temperature  was  so  suddenly  changed  that  it  caused  the  concrete  to 
shell  off.  We  do  not  believe  that  patched  concrete  can  be  made  to  stand 
under  these  conditions. 

"In  some  instances,  the  surface  of  the  concrete  to  be  repaired,  has 
been  first  roughed  up  and  then  kept  thoroughly  saturated  with  water  for 
several  hours.  Then  a  coating  of  cement  mixed  two  to  one  is  thoroughly 
troweled  on  and  kept  moist  for  a  considerable  period  of  time.  A  very 
good  way  to  keep  the  surface  moist  is  to  place  several  layers  of  burlap 
on  top  of  the  fresh  surface  and  keep  the  burlap  soaked  with  water. 

"Where  the  surface  to  be  repaired  is  of  a  considerable  thickness, 
\Y2  in.  and  upward,  anchor  pins  are  used,  spaced  about  four  to  a  square 
foot  of  surface.  This  is  particularly  effective  where  the  surface  is  per- 
pendicular. 

"In  some  cases  our  experience  has  been  that  about  the  only  successful 
way  to  do  this  kind  of  work  is  to  cut  out  the  old  work,  dove-tailing  it  and 
putting  in  anchor  bolts  and  care  should  be  taken  to  see  that  the  old  work 
is  roughened  up  and  dove-tailed,  care  being  taken  to  avoid  feather  edging. 
Also  in  doing  this  class  of  work  care  should  be  taken  to  see  that  the  new 
concrete  is  not  mixed  too  soft,  as  it  should  be  of  such  consistency  that  it 
can  be  lightly  rammed. 

"In  repairing  concrete  work,  where  netting  is  used  on  the  outer  sur- 
face, care  should  be  taken  to  see  that  the  old  concrete  is  removed  back 
of  the  netting,  so  as  to  get  a  bond  with  the  netting. 

"Ordinarily  the  methods  of  patching  and  repairing,  as  outlined  above, 
have  been  successful." 

F.  L.  Thompson,  Engineer  of  Bridges  and  Buildings,  Illinois  Central 
Railroad:  "In  general,  our  practice  in  patching  small  surfaces  is  as  fol- 
lows :  A  mortar  is  made  up  with  the  same  proportions  of  cement  and 
sand  as  has  been  used  in  the  concrete  which  is  to  be  patched.  This  mor- 
tar is  quite  stiff  and  considerable  pressure  is  used  in  applying  it  to  the 
cavity  which  is  first  cleaned  and  thoroughly  wet.  After  the  mortar  has 
partially  set  the  surplus  is  rubbed  off  with  a  wooden  float,  leaving  the 
surface  of  the  patch  flush  with  the  surface  of  the  wall. 

"To  lighten  the  patch  and  make  it  as  near  the  color  of  the  old  work 
as  possible,  a  small  quantity  of  lime  paste  is  added  to  the  mortar.  Where 
there  are  deep  cavities,  it  is  sometimes  necessary  to  partly  fill  them  and 
after  the  mortar  has  set  make  a  second  application." 

H.  Rettinghouse,  Division  Engineer,  Chicago  &  Northwestern  Rail- 
way: "I  have  had  several  cases,  when  horizontal  surfaces,  especially 
bridge  seats  had  been  damaged  by  frost,  to  a  depth  of  from  four  to  eight 
inches.  After  removing  the  frozen  and  spoiled  concrete,  we  chipped  the 
surface  down  to  a  nearly  uniform  level,  equal  to  the  deepest  frozen  spot. 
In  one  case  which  I  have  in  mind,  the  entire  bridge  seat  of  a  three  track 


MASONRY.  481 

bridge  had  been  severely  damaged  by  frost.  We  placed  dowel  pins  in 
squares  of  two  feet,  securely  anchoring  them  in  the  sound  concrete,  then 
carefully  and  thoroughly  cleaned  and  washed  off  the  entire  surface  and 
placed  new  concrete.  We  performed  work  of  that  kind  early  this  spring 
(in  April),  and  recent  inspection  would  indicate  that  it  is  an  entire  suc- 
cess 

''During  the  past  three  years,  we  have  successfully  jacketed  with  con- 
crete, old  masonry,  which  had  badly  deteriorated.  The  method  pursued 
was  the  use  of  hook  dowel  pins  and  expanded  metal.  The  jackets  varying 
from  ten  to  fourteen  inches  in  thickness.  We  took  great  care  to  remove 
all  deteriorated  and  loose  portions  of  masonry,  cleaning  out  joints,  etc., 
and  have  been  entirely  successful  in  securing  a  perfect  adhesion  of  con- 
crete jackets  to  the  old  masonry,  so  much  so,  indeed,  that  we  are  grad- 
ually treating  all  our  more  or  less  deteriorated  masonry  of  bridges  on  the 
Towa  Division  in  this  manner.  We  have,  unfortunately,  a  great  deal  of 
poor  stone  in  bridge  masonry.  Some  years  ago,  before  I  came  to  this 
territory,  there  had  been  a  great  many  back  walls  of  bridges  built  up  with 
from  four  to  eight  inches  of  concrete  on  top  of  old  masonry,  on  account 
of  track  being  raised  by  ballasting.  In  all  of  these  cases  no  dowels  were 
used  and  the  method  proved  a  failure." 

C.  H.  Fake,  Chief  Engineer,  Mississippi  River  &  Bonne  Terre  Rail- 
way: "In  a  larger  case  I_  was  successful,  where,  in  building  two  abut- 
ments for  a  deck  girder  bridge,  the  abutments  were  found  to  be  two  feet 
too  far  apart.  The  abutments  were  both  on  solid  rock,  so  there  was  no 
danger  from  uneven  settlement  and  a  two-foot  slab  was  patched  on  as 
follows :  The  face  of  one  of  the  abutments  was  scabbled  until  thor- 
oughly roughened.  Holes  about  iTA  to  2  in.  diameter  were  drilled  in  the 
roughened  face  a  foot  to  a  foot  and  a  half  deep  and  an  area  of  a  hole 
to  1 V*  to  2  sq.  ft.  They  were  not  drilled  in  rows  or  to  line,  but  irregular 
and  promiscuously.  Bolts  of  1%  in.  iron  with  swelled  end  and  split,  with 
wedges  were  driven  into  these  holes,  not  tight  enough  to  damage  the  old 
concrete  but  firmly  enough  so  they  could  not  be  pulled  out.  These  bolts 
were  carefully  grouted,  leaving  the  ends  stick  out  from  1  ft.  to  22  in.  The 
form  was  then  built  and  concrete  of  the  same  proportions  as  the  abut- 
ments was  filled  in  and  in  course  of  a  couple  of  months  the  girder  was 
put  in  place.  The  end  of  the  girder,  64  ft.  long,  rested  on  this  patch 
which  on  one  end  of  abutment  is  about  7  ft.  high  and  other  end  10  or 
more  feet  high.  The  work  has  been  done  between  eight  and  nine  years  and 
no  sign  of  separation  has  shown." 

H.  L.  Ripley,  Engineer  of  Construction,  New  York,  New  Haven  & 
Hartford  Railroad:  "The  method  we  have  used  with  success  is  to  knock 
off  all  loose  concrete  ;  go  over  the  surface  with  a  mason's  point  and  break 
a  new  face  on  the  stone  aggregate;  wash  down  the  surface  thoroughly 
with  scrubbing  brushes  and  a  water,  or  better  yet  a  steam  jet;  wet  the 
surface  until  it  has  absorbed  practically  all  the  moisture  the  concrete  will 
take  up ;  paint  on  a  wash  of  neat  cement ;  as  soon  as  it  commences  to  set 
put  on  under  considerable  pressure  a  plaster  coat  of  new  concrete.  (If 
any  oil  has  been  used  around  the  concrete  a  steam  jet  is  about  the  only 
method  I  know  that  will  entirely  remove  it). 

"By  keeping  the  new  concrete  moist  (not  drenched)  and  protecting  it 
from  the  direct  rays  of  the  sun  by  curtains  or  otherwise,  we  have  met 
with  fair  success  in  patching  old  concrete  using  this  method.  Of  course, 
concrete  must  be  absolutely  protected  from  frost  during  the  work  and 
for  three  or  four  days  afterward." 

L.  B.  Merriam.  Civil  Engineer,  Winnipeg:  "I  have  frequently  used 
the  ordinary  method  of  thoroughly  cleaning  the  surface  to  be  patched, 


484  MASONRY. 

then  soaking  the  original  concrete  at  the  place  where  the  patch  is  to  be 
made.  I  believe  my  success  has  depended  entirely  upon  using  a  sufficient 
quantity  of  water  in  the  soaking  process.  The  water  should  be  applied  ac 
intervals  or  constantly  for  a  period  of  at  least  ten  hours,  preferably  for 
twenty-four  hours  before  the  patch  is  put  on.  Those  failures  that  I  have 
had  indicated  that  the  original  concrete  had  robbed  the  new  concrete  of 
its  water  before  the  final  set  was  completed  owing  to  the  application  of 
water  for  too  short  a  period  prior  to  placing  the  patch.  I  have  plastefed 
large  surfaces  successfully  where  the  body  concrete  was  thoroughly  satur- 
ated before  applying  the  plaster." 

George  W .  Kittredge,  Chief  Engineer,  New  York  Central  &  Hudson 
River  Railroad:  "Our  practice  on  all  the  breaks  where  there  is  a  hole 
of  not  more  than  2  in.  in  depth  to  fill  up,  has  been  to  clean  off  the 
surface  of  the  concrete  thoroughly,  wet  it  and  then  apply  about  a  half 
inch  of  mortar,  allowing  this  to  stand  until  it  has  dried  out  slightly, 
when  another  coat  of  about  the  same  thickness  is  applied;  this  process 
being  repeated  until  the  hole  is  filled  up  flush  with  the  face  of  the  con- 
crete from  which  the  piece  has  been  broken,  after  which  it  is  floated.  In 
most  cases  the  repaired  spot  can  hardly  be  detected,  and  I  do  not  know 
of  any  cases  where  the  pieces  have  broken  out  again. 

"At  different  times  we  have  used  the  following  method:  Square  out 
the  holes,  making  the  area  at  the  back  of  the  hole  larger  than  on  the  face, 
and  fill  it  up  with  mortar.  This  shape  of  hole  served  to  key  in  the  new 
piece.  This  method  was  not  as  satisfactory  as  the  one  which  is  described 
above,  as  the  patches  show  more  plainly,  and  it  was  also  somewhat  more 
expensive." 

E.  B.  Temple,  Assistant  Chief  Engineer,  Pennsylvania  Railroad:  "At 
South  Fork,  Pa.,  we  built  a  retaining  wall  in  the  winter  of  1909-1910.  The 
weather  was  unusually  severe,  and  before  the  concrete  set  properly  the 
surface  concrete  was  frozen.  In  the  spring,  the  face  of  the  wall  showed 
signs  of  disintregation ;  and,  after  a  careful  examination,  it  was  decided 
to  remove  as  much  as  possible  of  the  faulty  concrete.  This  was  done  by 
picking  the  surface  with  a  small  hand  pick  to  a  depth  varying  from  1  to 
18  in.  The  body  of  the  wall  thus  exposed  was  good  substantial  concrete, 
and  was  carefully  cleaned.  Dowels  of  steel  were  driven  into  this  surface, 
the  dowels  being  placed  about  6  in.  apart,  and  to  these  dowels  a  light 
reinforcing  mesh  wire  was  firmly  attached.  The  forms  for  the  face  of  the 
wall  were  then  placed ;  and,  after  the  concrete  had  been  thoroughly  wet, 
the  forms  were  carefully  backfilled  with  cement  and  sand  in  the  propor- 
tion of  approximately  1  part  cement  to  2  of  sand.  This  wall  has  been  stand- 
ing for  about  fifteen  months,  and  apparently  is  in  as  good  condition  today 
as  when  put  in  place." 

A.  Q.  Campbell,  Assistant  Superintendent,  Oregon  Short  Line  Rail- 
road: "The  methods  that  I  have  used  in  this  work  have  varied  to  a  cer- 
tain extent  with  the  class  and  the  nature  of  the  material  to  connect  with. 
The  most  successful  method  I  have  used  has  been  the  channelling  of  the 
old  concrete,  say  one  inch  deep  and  one  inch  wide,  or  the  width  of  a 
chisel,  these  channels  to  be  made  in  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete  in  the 
shape  of  a  checker  board,  the  size  of  the  squares  depending  on  the  size  of 
the  surface  to  be  covered. 

"I  successfully  covered  a  depot  platform  in  this  way  with  ij^  in. 
topping,  that  has  now  been  in  service  for  four  years  with  but  one  or  two 
cracks  coming  in  same.  The  success  with  which  the  covering  is  put  on 
in  the  case  of  sidewalks  or  beams  would  depend  very  largely  on  the  class 
of  material  used  in  the  concrete  and  the  nature  of  the  old  concrete.  I 
have  in  some  instances  sprinkled  the  face  of  the  old  concrete  with  cement 


MASONRY.  485 

before  applying  the  patching  mixture,  which  has  acted  very  successfully. 
So  much  in  cases  of  this  kind  depends  on  the  nature  of  the  old  concrete 
and  the  personal  factor  of  the  man  doing  the  work,  as  well  as  the  mate- 
rial to  be  used  in  the  patching  mixture,  that  what  may  be  successful  in  one 
place  would  not  be  successful  in  another.  My  experience  has  been  that  the 
best  material  for  making  a  patching  mixture  is  crushed  screenings,  of 
about  the  ratio  of  one  to  two.  Where  heavy  masses  are  being  joined  to- 
gether the  channelling  of  the  old  mass  has  in  most  cases  been  sufficient  to 
make  successful  bond." 

T.  E.  Calvert,  Chief  Engineer,  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy  Rail- 
road: "The  old  concrete  is  thoroughly  cleaned  and  wetted  and  about  %- 
in.  of  mortar  put  on.  When  this  has  set  enough  to  become  stiff  the  surface 
is  roughened  with  the  point  of  a  trowel  and  another  layer  of  similar  thick- 
ness put  on ;  this  is  continued  until  the  hole  is  filled,  the  surface  being 
finished  flush  with  the  old  concrete. 

'We  have  patched  holes  3  and  4  in.  deep  and  with  an  area  of  2  or  3 
sq.  ft.  successfully.  Some  of  this  work  has  stood  for  three  years  without 
signs  of  trouble.  We  have  not  succeeded  in  making  patches  less  than  ij^ 
in.  thick  stick,  as  the  mortar  cracks  and  scales  off." 

G.  J.  Ray,  Chief  Engineer,  Delaware,  Lackazmnna  &  Western  Rail- 
road: "The  only  extensive  job  which  we  have  had  to  contend  with  was  a 
concrete  bridge  consisting  of  several  33-ft.  arches.  The  concrete  in  this 
structure  showed  signs  of  either  poor  cement  or  acid  bearing  water  used 
in  making  the  concrete,  with  the  result  that  it  scaled  off  in  large  quantities 
every  year.  It  was  an  easy  matter  to  dig  down  into  the  solid  concrete, 
but  if  the  solid  concrete  was  exposed  for  any  length  of  time  it  again  would 
start  to  deteriorate.  The  entire  structure  was  repaired  by  covering  the 
same  completely  with  from  a  foot  to  eighteen  inches  of  reinforced  con- 
crete, the  new  concrete  being  bonded  to  the  old  by  a  large  number  of 
dowel  pins,  which  were  drilled  into  the  old  concrete  and  fastened  in  a 
substantial  manner.  This  repair  job  has  proved  to  be  very  satisfactory. 
To  make  the  work  permanent  the  entire  outside  of  the  old  structure  was 
excavated  and  properly  waterproofed." 

W.  H.  Courtenay,  Chief  Engineer,  Louisville  &  Nashville  Railroad: 
"Our  practice  has  been  that  when  the  forms  are  removed  we  patch  such 
surfaces  where  the  mortar  did  not  come  out  to  the  forms  by  merely 
washing  them  clean  and  plastering  over  the  defective  surface  with  fresh 
mortar.     Such  patches  are  unsightly,  but  they  generally  hold." 

Fred  G.  Simmons,  Superintendent,  C.  &  M.  of  Way,  Milwaukee  Elec- 
tric Railway:  "One  reason  why  new  concrete  does  not  adhere  perfectly  to 
old  is  that  in  hardening  the  fresh  concrete  shrinks  in  volume,  pulling  away 
from  the  contact  sides  and  leaving  air  spaces  between  the  two  surfaces. 
These  spaces  are  small  at  first,  but  with  changes  of  temperature,  vibra- 
tion, etc.,  gradually  widen  out  until  there  is  not  enough  adhesion  between 
the  patch  and  the  body  of  the  concrete  to  hold  the  former  in  place.  The 
metal  mesh  firmly  attached  to  the  main  mass  of  concrete  and  being  part 
of  the  patch  overcomes  this  trouble." 

/.  P.  Congdon,  Supervising  Engineer,  Oregon  Short  Line  Railroad: 
"Cut  off  the  surface  of  the  concrete  to  be  patched  so  as  to  remove  ail 
dust  and  laitance  and  give  a  surface  of  good,  hard  concrete.  Roughen 
this  surface  with  pick  or  otherwise  so  that  it  will  present  pockets  or  irreg- 
ularities into  which  the  patch  can  key. 

"Wet  the  surface  thoroughly.  Sometimes  it  is  dusted  with  neat 
cement,   but   good    results   have   been   obtained   without   this.      Patch   the 


486  MASONRY. 

spot  with  concrete  or  mortar,  depending  upon  the  size  of  the  patch,  of  the 
same  consistency  and  mixed  in  the  same  way  as  the  original  concrete.  This 
will  prevent  difference  in  the  contraction  and  expansion  of  the  masonry 
and  also  keeps  the  color  uniform  providing  the  same  cement  is  used. 

"After  the  concrete  is  well  set  rub  the  surface  down  with  a  wooden 
float.  The  surface  is  usually  wet  with  water,  to  which  considerable  ce- 
ment has  been  added  to  give  it  the  color  of  the  concrete.  Sometimes  ja 
cement  or  sand  brick  is  used.  Very  good  results  have  been  obtained  in 
this   way   on   our   work." 

C.  F.  Lozveth,  Chief  Engineer,  Chicago,  Mikvaukee  &  St.  Paul 
Railway:  "The  surface  of  the  old  concrete  is  first  well  roughened  up 
with  track  chisels  to  secure  the  removal  of  all  old  mortar  surface  and 
any  loose  stones  are  at  the  same  time  taken  out.  The  surface  is  then 
thoroughly  wetted  to  avoid  any  danger  of  the  removal  of  any  moisture 
from  the  new  concrete  or  mortar  by  capillary  action.  A  thin  wash  of 
neat  cement  of  about  i-i6~in.  thick  is  then  painted  on  the  roughened  sur- 
face. To  this  is  then  applied  a  thin  coat  of  about  lA'in.  of  mortar  made  in 
the  same  proportions  as  that  used  in  the  adjacent  concrete.  To  this  is 
immediately  applied  the  new  concrete  which  is  well  tamped  into  place. 
Whenever  conditions  are  such  as  will  permit  it,  small  dowels  are  drilled 
into  the  old  concrete  to  serve  as  anchors  of  the  old  and  new  work. 

"Where  a  concrete  surface  has  pockets  in  it  which  require  patching, 
a  mixture  of  mortar  similar  to  that  used  in  the  balance  of  the  work  is  em- 
ployed, being  mixed  stiff  as  practicable  to  avoid  shrinkage,  and  the  face 
of  the  patch  worked  with  a  wooden  instead  of  a  steel  float  to  secure  a  sur- 
face in  harmony  with  the  balance  of  the  work." 

Edivin  F.  Wendt,  Assistant  Engineer,  Pittsburg  &  Lake  Erie  Rail- 
road: "When  the  surface  of  a  concrete  structure  fails  on  account  of 
frost  having  had  access  to  it  before  the  concrete  is  thoroughly  set,  it  is  a 
doubtful  question  whether  it  can  be  resurfaced  so  that  permanently  good 
results  are  accomplished.  This  is  also  true  in  cases  where  surfaces  have 
been  damaged  from  any  cause.  If  a  small  surface  is  to  be  repaired  we 
have  obtained  good  results  by  cutting  out  all  damaged  parts  and,  in  addi- 
tion, cutting  into  the  surface  from  two  to  four  inches,  and  if  this  does  not 
pass  reinforcing  steel  cut  the  sides  of  section  taken  out  'to  an  angle  of 
about  sixty  degrees  to  the  surface,  then  the  surface  to  be  repaired  should 
be  freed  of  all  loose  gravel  and  dust  and  thoroughly  saturated  with  wa- 
ter, using  a  hose  if  good  pressure  can  be  obtained.  If  water  pressure  is 
not  obtainable  use  a  stiff  brush  and  thoroughly  wash  the  surface.  Next 
we  apply  to  this  rough,  clean,  saturated  surface  a  neat  cement  grout  about 
the  consistency  of  thick  whitewash,  using  a  good  whitewash  brush.  This 
should  be  well  rubbed  in,  then  immediately  applying  a  mortar  of  one  of 
cement  to  two  of  good  clean  sand  in  half-inch  layers,  allowing  each  layer 
to  take  its  initial  set,  roughening  the  surface  before  the  succeeding  layer 
is  applied  and  carrying  on  this  process  until  the  original  surface  is 
reached.  The  patched  surface  should  be  kept  moist  and  protected  from 
the  sun  or  anything  adverse  to  good  results  in  concrete  structures,  until 
the  patched  surface  has  taken  its  final  set.  We  have  applied  this  method 
of  repairing  to  plain  concrete,  such  as  walls,  roofs  of  bridges,  machin- 
ery foundations,  sidewalks,  etc.,  and,  in  one  particular  case  of  patching  a 
machinery  foundation  we  found  it  intact  after  five  years  of  use." 

W.  L.  Darling,  Chief  Engineer,  Northern  Pacific  Railway:  "We  have 
found  that  wherever  concrete  is  patched  or~repaired  in  thin  surfaces  that 
failure  almost  surely  results.  Wherever  concrete  work  has  disintegrated 
on  the  surface  or  has  become  damaged,  as  it  sometimes  does  by  the  ac- 
tion of  ice  on  concrete  that  has   not  yet   thoroughly  set,  it  has  been  re- 


MASONRY.  487 

paired  by  cutting  out  a  block  of  sufficient  dimensions  then  drilling  dowels 
into  the  old  structure,  the  bond  between  the  two  being  assisted  by  roughing 
up  the  old  concrete  and  cleaning  with  a  wire  brush." 

Samuel  Rockwell,  Chief  Engineer,  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern 
Railway:  "I  have  attempted  this  at  a  number  of  different  times  and  under 
a  number  of  different  conditions,  but  have  never  had  any  very  marked 
success,  especially  when  the  patches  were  small.  It  is  largely  the  same 
problem  as  filling  teeth,  and,  as  with  that,  it  is  necessary  to  prepare  a 
cavity  in  such  a  way  that  it  will  assist  to  hold  the  patch.  Then,  if  the 
sides  are  carefully  cleaned  and  wet,  a  patch  can  be  put  on  that  will  hold 
and  show  but  little,  but  all  attempts  at  plastering  up  shallow  holes  with- 
out such  preparation  are  abominations  pure  and  simple,  as  is  also  any 
attempt  to  wash  or  plaster  over  the  general  surface  of  concrete." 

W.  S.  Thompson,  Division  Engineer,  Pennsylvania  Railroad:  "It  has 
been  my  experience  that  such  work  is  very  unsatisfactory  and  I  have 
never  been  successful  in  making  a  good  job.  In  case  the  surface  scales, 
it  is  usually  better  to  bush-hammer  the  surface  smooth  and  let  it  go.  This 
applies  to  surface  defects." 

G.  J.  Bell,  Division  Engineer,  Santa  Fe:  "Have  never  made  any  re- 
pairs that  could  be  considered  a  success.  We  brush  the  loose  particles 
from  the  concrete  to  be  repaired,  then  drench  with  clear  water  until  thor- 
oughly soaked  and  sprinkle  a  little  neat  cement  before  the  mortar  or  con- 
crete is  put  on.  Have  never  made  any  repairs  that  were  entirely  satis- 
factory." 

R.  B.  Abbott,  Division  Engineer,  Philadelphia  &  Reading  Railway: 
"The  first  thing  done  is  to  scrape  or  pick  off  thoroughly  all  those  portions 
of  concrete.  The  damaged  face  is  then  roughened  up  and  holes  6  in. 
deep  drilled  therein,  spaced  about  2  ft.  apart.  The  diameter  of  each 
hole  is  roughly  4  in.  and  the  outline  is  made  irregular.  Enough  of  the 
old  work  is  removed  so  that  the  new  coat  will  have  a  minimum  depth 
of  1  in.  Along  the  perimeter  of  the  damaged  surface,  the  concrete  is 
cut  out  to  a  depth  of  2  in.  with  a  slight  overhang  so  that  the  old  con- 
crete will  tend  to  lock  in  the  new.  The  damaged  surface  is  then  brushed 
with  a   1:1  cement  wash. 

"Commencing  at  the  extreme  lowest  point  of  the  work  the  form  is  then 
built  up  1  ft.  at  a  time  so  that  each  filling  can  be  thoroughly  tamped. 
A  mixture  of  one  part  cement  to  two  parts  fine  sharp  sand  is  used  in  the 
actual  work  of  restoring  the  surface. 

"After  the  material  has  set  and  the  form  been  removed,  the  surface 
is  again  wetted  and  treated  to  a  1:2  cement  wash.  This  is  a  refinement, 
however,  and  is  only  employed  where  the  maximum  of  neat  finish  is 
required.  For  ordinary  railroad  work,  we  have  not  found  it  necessary 
except  in  cases  where  the  boards  used  in  the  forming  were  rough  and 
warped." 

METHODS  OF  DEPOSITING  CONCRETE  UNDER  WATER. 
Pursuant  to  the  instructions  of  the  Board  of  Direction,  letters  and 
circulars  of  inquiry  were  sent  to  the  members  of  the  Association,  request- 
ing information  on  the  subject  of  "Methods  of  Depositing  Concrete  Un- 
der Water."     This  inquiry   embodied   the   following  questions: 

(1)  Methods  used  for  depositing  concrete. 

(2)  Depth  of  water. 

(3)  Results. 


488  MASONRY. 

(4)  Precautions  necessary  to  secure  desired  results. 

(5)  A  statement  of  the  cost  of  plant  and  relative  cost  of  deposit- 
ing concrete  per  cubic  yard,  as  compared  with  concrete  deposited  by  the 
usual  methods,  will  be  of  value  in  this  investigation. 

Seventy-one  replies  were  received,  fifty-six  of  which  contain  in- 
formation of  value,  covering  nine  methods  of  depositing,  viz.,  bottom-dump 
bucket,  tremie  (a  closed  chute),  sacks,  sacks  withdrawn,  paper  bags, 
open  chutes,  open  depositing,  pneumatic  grouting  of  broken  stone,  con- 
crete blocks.  From  an  examination  of  the  replies,  the  Committee  draws 
the   following : 

CONCLUSIONS. 

(1)  Concrete  may  be  deposited  successfully  under  water,  if  so 
handled  as  to  prevent  the  washing  of  the  cement  from  the  mixture. 

(2)  Cofferdams  should  be  sufficiently  tight  to  prevent  current  through 
the  pit,  and  the  water  in  the  pit  should  be  quiet. 

(3)  The  concrete  should  be  deposited  :n  place  either  by  means  of 
a  drop-bottom  bucket  or  a  tremie,  and  should  not  be  allowed  to  fall 
through  the  water. 

(4)  Where  a  bucket  is  used,  it  should  be  carefully  lowered  to  the 
bottom  and  raised  to  the  surface,  so  as  to  cause  as  little  disturbance  as 
possible  of  the  water. 

(5)  Where  a  tremie  is  used,  it  should  be  kept  filled  with  concrete 
up  to  the  top  of  the  water  level,  and  the  discharge  end  should  be  kept 
buried  in  the  freshly  deposited  mass  to  prevent  emptying,  and  raised  a 
few  inches  at  a  time  as  the  filling  progresses. 

(6)  The  surface  of  the  concrete  must  be  kept  as  nearly  level  as 
possible  to  avoid  the  formation  of  pockets  which  will  retain  laitance  and 
sediment. 

(7)  Where  concrete  is  not  deposited  continuously,  all  sediment 
should  be  removed  from  the  surface  of  the  concrete,  by  pumping  or  other- 
wise,  before   depositing   fresh   concrete. 

(8)  The  concrete  should  be  a  1:2 14  mixture  and  of  a  "quaking" 
consistency. 

(9)  Freshly  deposited  concrete  should  not  be  disturbed. 

(10)     In  open  water,  where  the  flow  of  water  through  the  pit  cannot 
be  prevented,  concrete  should  be  deposited  in  cloth  sacks. 

An  abstract  of  replies  containing  information  is  presented  with  this 
report. 

ABSTRACT  OF  REPLIES. 

Moses  Burpee,  Chief  Engineer,  Bangor  &  Aroostook  Railway: 
1  a.  A  box  of  one  cubic  yard  capacity  was  used,  with  double  leaf  trap 
bottom,  leaves  hinged  on  opposite  edges,  making  bottom  of  box  "V" 
shaped  at  center,  trap  bottom  tripped  with  tag  line.  The  box,  when  filled, 
was  covered  with  canvas  fastened  at  four  corners,  b.  On  special  oc- 
casions a  tremie  was  used,  but  for  general  purposes  the  trap  bottom  box 


MASONRY.  489 

was  preferred.  2.  Any  depth.  My  experience  about  15  ft.  3a.  Perfectly 
satisfactory.  3b.  Tremie  method  satisfactory.  5.  Cost  was  not  kept  for 
comparative  purposes.  It  would  probably  exceed  ordinary  concreting,  not 
more  than  fifty  cents  per  cubic  yard. 

F.  L.  Thompson,  Engineer  Bridges  and  Buildings,  Illinois  Central 
Railroad:     ia.     Bottom  dump  buckets.     The  bucket  was  covered  before 

placing  under  water,  and  the  concrete  dumped  on  the  bottom  of  founda- 
tion, b.  Telescope  chutes  extending  through  the  water  to  the  bottom 
of  foundation,  c.  Depositing  concrete  in  cloth  sacks.  2.  From  5  to  50 
ft.  3a.  Good  results  with  proper  handling.  I  consider  this  the  best 
method,  b.  Good  results  with  proper  handling,  c.  Fair  results,  however 
not  so  good  as  by  methods  (a)  and  (b).  4a.  Bucket  should  be  lowered 
to  within  2  ft.  of  the  bottom,  and  then  tripped,  letting  the  contents 
deposit  slowly,  without  moving  the  bucket,  b.  A  continual  stream  of 
the  concrete  should  be  kept  through  the  chute,  the  bottom  of  the  chute 
being  kept  within  a  few  inches  of  the  foundation. 

/.  P.  Snow,  Consulting  Engineer:  ia.  Tremie.  b.  Bottom  dump 
bucket.  2.  Five  to  30  ft.  3.  Good  in  all  cases.  Bottom  dump  buckets 
so  made  that  the  concrete  is  enclosed  in  the  bucket  when  the  bottom  opens, 
gives  better  results  on  small  jobs  than  a  tremie.  The  cost  of  installing  a 
suitable  traveler  is  too  great  on  a  small  job  to  make  a  tremie  pay.  4.  To 
keep  the  stone  from  separating,  and  to  keep  the  outside  of  the  work  solid 
with  no  voids,  the  tremie  should  be  carried  on  a  traveler  capable  of  mov- 
ing over  any  part  of  the  work,  and  operations  on  a  layer  commence  and 
finish  in  the  interior  of  the  work,  so  that  the  depositing  will  be  con- 
tinuous at  the  sides  of  the  work.     Layers  should  not  be  over  2  ft.  thick. 

T.  W.  Fat'herson,  Division  Engineer,  Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific 
Railway:  ia.  Collapsible  bucket  with  boom  and  hoisting  engine  for 
heavy  work.  b.  Funnel  and  tube  on  light  work  when  mixing  is  done  by 
hand.  2a.  Fourteen  feet.  b.  Twelve  feet.  4.  Water  should  not  be  agi- 
tated by  pumping  while  concrete  is  being  deposited,  else  the  cement  will 
be  washed  out  of  the  concrete. 

Walter  H.  Norris,  Bridge  Engineer,  Maine  Central  Railroad:  1. 
Wooden  spout  about  18  in.  square.  2.  Fifteen  feet.  3.  Good.  4.  Keep 
the  spout  full  of  cement  to  exclude  water  and  prevent  wash.  5.  About 
50  cents  per  cubic  yard  more  than  by  usual  method. 

E.  H.  Connor,  Chief  Engineer,  Missouri  Valley  Bridge  and  Iron  Com- 
pany: 1,  Bottom  dump  bucket.  2.  Eight  to  20  ft.  3.  Good,  hard 
cement.  4.  Keep  depositing  continuously,  until  all  the  concrete  is  in 
position. 

C.  E.  Smith,  Superintendent,  Sabine  &  Northern  Railway:  ia. 
Tremie.  b.  Bottom  dump  bucket,  orange  peel  or  clam  shell.  2.  Twenty 
feet.     3.    Hard  uniform  texture.     4.    Very  rich  mixture,  1 :2 :3  very  wet. 

/.  L.  Simmons,  Bridge  Engineer,  Rock  Island  Lines:  1.  Bottom 
dump  bucket.  2.  About  10  ft.  3.  Very  satisfactory.  4.  Lower  the 
bucket  as  far  as  possible  before  depositing  concrete,  thus  preventing  the 
concrete  from  dropping  through  the  water  for  any  great  depth. 

C.  H.  Fake,  Chief  Engineer,  Mississippi  River  &  Bonne  Terre  Rail- 
zuay:  We  have  filled  cement  or  other  sacks  with  concrete,  tying  mouth  of 
sack  with  slip  knot ;  lowered  it  into  place  and  pulled  string  to  untie  knot, 
then  withdrawn  sack  carefully.     This   serves  the  purpose  fairly  well  on 


490  MASONRY. 

small  job.  b.  We  have  used  spout  on  larger  jobs,  feeding  the  concrete 
slowly  and  carefully.  2.  Two  to  6  ft.  3.  Presumed  to  be  good.  No 
examination  has  been  made,  but  no  settlement  or  movement  has  occurred. 
4.     Deposit  with  cars  and  avoid  haste. 

/.  M.  Brown,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Chicago,  Rock  Island 
&  Pacific  Railway:  1.  Eight  years  ago  concrete  was  deposited  under 
water,  covering  an  area  of  about  40  ft.  in  length  and  16  ft.  in  width.  This 
was  in  a  pit  excavated  in  sand  with  cofferdam  about  same.  The  depth 
of  the  concrete  was  about  2  ft.  It  was  a  1:2:4  mixture,  the  work  being 
limestone  crushed  to  about  1^2  in.  The  depositing  was  done  through  a 
wooden  box  or  tube  about  12  in.  square  and  about  25  ft.  in  length.  This 
tube  was  suspended  from  a  derrick,  the  boom  of  which  swung  over  the 
entire  area  concreted.  At  the  bottom  of  the  tube  was  a  slide  which  was 
opened  after  the  tube  was  filled  with  concrete.  The  concrete  was  then  fed 
into  thft  'ube  continuously,  while  it  was  moved  over  the  area.  The  tube 
was  dropped  to  the  bottom  of  the  water,  and  gradually  raised  as  the  con- 
crete was  deposited.  2.  About  11  or  12  ft.  3.  Everything  that  could 
be  desired.  The  concrete  was  deposited  practically  level.  Water  was 
pumped  out  after  the  concrete  had  been  allowed  to  settle  for  about  10 
days.  4.  The  mixture  must  be  homogeneous,  and  deposited  as  quickly  as 
possible  after  being  mixed.     Running  water  should  be  avoided. 

Charles  S.  Churchill,  Chief  Engineer,  Norfolk  &  Western  Railway: 
ia.  Three  years  ago  this  company  removed  a  concrete  pier  built  in 
1889  in  about  20  ft.  of  water.  This  concrete  was  deposited  in  cast  iron 
shell  in  which  piles  had  already  been  driven.  It  was  deposited  by  means 
of  a  telescope  tube,  the  bottom  of  which  was  always  kept  close  to  the  top 
of  the  concrete,  as  it  flowed  out  of  the  tube  into  the  water  contained  in- 
side the  cast  iron  shell,  b.  More  recently  a  bottom  dump  bucket  has  been 
used,  filled  with  concrete  and  lowered  into  place  before  the  bottom  was 
opened,  the  bottom  being  opened  by  a  diver.  The  amount  of  concrete  so 
placed  was  not  great,  because  the  object  of  placing  it  in  this  manner  way 
to  seal  the  bottom  of  cofferdam.  After  the  cofferdam  was  sealed,  the 
water  was  pumped  out.  2a.  About  25  ft.  b.  Thirty  ft.  of  water.  3a. 
On  removal  the  concrete  was  found  to  be  in  a  very  fair  condition,  al- 
though not  so  solid  as  it  would  have  been,  had  it  been  deposited  above 
water  level.  This  was  due  to  the  fact  that  as  thoroughly  tamping  could 
not  be  carried  out,  partly  on  account  of  being  under  water,  and  partly  on 
account  of  the  piles,  b.  On  unwatering  the  cofferdam,  the  character  of 
the  concrete  was  found  to  be  good.  4.  We  have  found  in  all  cases  when 
concrete  has  been  deposited  in  sea  water,  and  has  been  allowed  to  set 
before  making  any  additions,  that  there  was  on  top  surface  of  finished 
course  of  concrete  a  thin  deposit,  which  was  evidently  a  precipitate  of  the 
cement  with  sea  water,  and  that  it  was  necessary  to  remove  this  thin  coat- 
ing before  any  adhesion  could  be  secured  between  any  two  layers  of  the 
concrete. 

G.  H.  Scribner,  Jr.,  Contracting  Engineer:  1.  When  there  are  piles 
in  the  foundation,  it  is  best  to  use  two  tubes,  one  being  the  larger,  ar- 
ranged so  that  it  will  slide  up  and  down  on  the  upper  and  smaller  tube. 
I  have  also  put  grout  into  gravel  bottom  of  3  ft.  in  thickness  by 
this  same  method.  2.  This  method  can  be  used  to  a  depth  of  40  ft.  3. 
The  pier  of  Manchac  draw  span  for  Illinois  Central  Railroad  was  put  in 
in  the  above  manner,  an  iron  casing  being  used  for  pier  with  piles  driven 
in  foundation.  Good  results.  Grouting  gravel  by  same  method  satis- 
factory. 4.  Tamp  to  prevent  arching  between  piles.  5.  Two  outfits  (four 
tubes),  a  one-half  yard  mixer  was  kept  running  to  about  one-half  of  its 
capacity. 


MASONRY.  491 

Hans  Ibsen,  Bridge  Engineer,  Michigan  Central  Railroad:  ia.  Tremie 
consisting  of  12-in.  square  wooden  pipe  handled  by  hand  power,  b.  De- 
posited by  Lockwood  Automatic  concrete  buckets.  2a.  Tremie  from 
4  to  20  ft.  b.  Buckets  26  ft.  3b.  In  all  cases  concrete  was  found  to 
have  set  well  at  the  place  where  it  was  deposited  by  buckets.  There  was 
from  2  to  3  in.  of  soft  sediment  on  top  of  hard  concrete  when  water  was 
pumped  out,  but  concrete  underneath  this  was  in  good  condition.  4a.  In 
using  tremie,  care  must  be  taken  to  keep  same  full  of  concrete  while  the 
work  is  going  on  and  in  not  lifting  it  too  far  from  the  bottom  b.  Bucket 
should  be  closed  at  top  while  being  lowered  through  the  water  and  care 
should  be  exercised  that  it  is  not  raised  too  rapidly,  so  that  the  suction 
will  retain  the  concrete  in  the  bucket  too  long.  5a.  The  cost  of  deposit- 
ing by  tremie  is  probably  about  twice  as  much  as  by  ordinary  methods, 
due  to  the  fact  that  concrete  cannot  be  deposited  in  bulk,  but  has  to  be 
dumped  on  a  platform  and  shoveled  into  the  tremie.  b.  Depositing  by 
buckets  should  cost  very  little  more  than  depositing  in  the  dry,  when  work 
is  of  such  an  extent  as  to  require  a  plant  for  depositing  by  bucket 
method. 

L.  B.  Martin,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Illinois  Traction  System: 
I.  Dry  mixture  was  slowly  dumped  by  wheelbarrows  into  the  water  until 
it  had  reached  the  surface  of  the  water ;  then  dumping  was  continued 
in  same  place  and  the  accumulation  worked  down  with  a  shovel  until  it 
had  covered  the  whole  excavation.  2.  Two  to  3  ft.  3.  Very  good.  Con- 
crete set  up  satisfactorily  in  24  hours.  4.  Mixture  should  not  be  dumped 
in  such  a  manner  as  to  separate  the  coarse  aggregate  from  the  cement  and 
sand.  It  should  not  be  thrown  into  the  water  with  a  shovel.  It  is  a 
good  idea  to  have  the  mixture  very  damp  before  it  is  deposited  in 
water,  as  the  coarse  and  fine  aggregate  will  adhere  to  each  other  better 
in  this  way. 

C.  G.  Delo,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Chicago  Great  West- 
ern Railroad:  1.  Bottom  dump  buckets  were  lowered  to  the  bottom,  un- 
latched, and  raised  slowly.  2.  Fifteen  ft.  3.  Some  of  the  cement  was 
removed  and  found  to  be  first-class.  4.  The  unlatched  bucket  should  be 
raised  slowly  to  prevent  wash.  5.  Cost  practically  the  same  as  when 
handled  by  ordinary  derrick  and  bucket. 

F.  S.  Stevens,  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Philadelphia  &  Reading 
Railway:  ia.  By  means  of  a  tube  in  still  or  enclosed  water,  the  tube  being 
raised  slightly  from  time  to  time  to  allow  concrete  to  escape  from  the 
bottom,  b.  I  have  also  known  of  the  use  of  paper  bags.  c.  I  have  known 
of  the  use  of  burlap  sacks.  2.  Any  depth  in  still  water.  3a  and  b.  Satis- 
factory results,  c.  Fairly  satisfactory,  but  paper-bag  method  is  probably 
better.  The  paper  to  be  broken,  and  as  much  of  it  as  possible  withdrawn 
after  concrete  has  reached  its  bed.  4.  The  water  must  be  enclosed  to  cut 
off  current,  and  to  prevent  escape  of  cement. 

W.  H.  Courtenay,  Chief  Engineer,  Louisville  &  Nashville  Railroad: 
ia.  A  large  number  of  piles  in  sea  water  were  protected  from  attack  by 
teredo  by  covering  the  submerged  portions  of  piles  with  from  2  to  4  in. 
thickness  of  concrete.  Forms  were  placed  around  the  piles  and  then 
the  concrete  was  deposited  by  pouring  it  through  a  tube.  b.  A  bridge 
pier,  built  many  years  ago,  was  partially  undercut  by  the  river,  and  an 
attempt  was  made  to  fill  the  space  vertically  under  the  pier  with  con- 
crete. The  concrete  was  mixed  moderately  dry,  and  poured  through  an 
8-in.  wrought  iron  pipe  from  the  track  level,  c.  For  a  bridge  foundation 
recently  constructed  in  30  ft.  of  water,  the  cofferdam  was  first  built  of 
steel  piles.     Wooden  bearing  piles  were  then  driven  within  the  cofferdam 


492  MASONRY. 

and  cut  off  at  the  level  of  the  river  bed.  The  material  around  these 
piles  was  then  excavated  to  a  depth  of  about  4  ft.  with  centrifugal  pumps, 
and  then  about  4  ft.  of  concrete  deposited  between  heads  of  the  piles 
by  running  it  through  iron  pipes,  the  idea  being  to  place  4  ft.  depth  of 
concrete  around  the  piles  before  attempting  to  pump  out  the  water  from 
within  the  cofferdam,  for,  on  account  of  the  nature  of  the  bottom,  it  was 
not  feasible  to  pump  the  water  out  otherwise.  2a.  Water  ranged  from 
about  18  ft.  down.  3a.  Successful.  At  times,  however,  mud  at  the 
bottom  of  the  forms  became  mixed  with  concrete,  greatly  impairing  the 
strength  of  the  concrete.  Upon  examination  by  diver,  some  of  this 
concrete  was  found  to  be  good  and  some  bad.  3b.  During  the  progress 
of  this  work,  the  surface  of  the  water  within  the  cribs  was  at  all  times 
covered  with  a  thick  foamy  scum.  This  work  was  constructed  20  years 
ago,  and  has  given  no  trouble.  3c.  After  this  concrete  had  been  deposited 
and  set,  an  effort  was  made  to  pump  out  the  interior  of  the  cofferdam, 
which  was  not  successful.  Examination  by  a  diver  disclosed  the  fact 
that  the  concrete  in  one  spot  of  limited  area  was  inferior  in  quality,  and 
the  water  pressure  was  such  as  to  create  a  blowout  through  this  inferior 
concrete.  The  poor  concrete  was  excavated  by  diver,  and  good  concrete 
substituted,  by  lowering  it  in  bags  and  having  it  placed  by  a  diver,  after 
which  the  water  within  the  dam  was  pumped  out,  and  the  remainder  of  the 
pier  constructed.  4.  Although,  as  a  general  proposition,  it  would  seem 
that  concrete  can  be  deposited  under  water  at  less  cost  than  would  be 
necessary  for  constructing  water-tight  cofferdams,  and  pumping  the 
water  out  of  the  foundation  before  concrete  is  placed,  the  experience  of 
the  writer  leads  him  to  believe  that  it  is  generally  unsatisfactory  and  should 
not  be  resorted  to  if  foundations  can  be  pumped  out  at  reasonable  cost. 

E.  I.  Cantine,  Contracting  Engineer:  1.  In  1891  it  seemed  impossible 
to  lower  the  water  for  pier  foundation  as  part  of  the  construction  of  granite 
viaduct  at  Viaduct,  Idaho,  on  the  line  of  the  Northern  Pacific  Railway. 
The  usual  cofferdam  sheet-piling  construction  had  been  followed  and  an 
attempt  was  made  to  use  the  pumps  to  lower  the  water  to  the  elevation 
of  bottom  of  foundation;  this  seeming  impossible,  the  concrete  was  de- 
posited under  water  by  use  of  circular  pipe.  This  delivered  the  con- 
crete at  desired  elevation  below  cut-off  of  piles.  3,  Satisfactory.  Founda- 
tions are  standing  and  are  in  good  condition.  _  4.  There  should  be  a 
continuous  flow  of  concrete  to  reduce  to  a  minimum  separation  of  con- 
crete beneath  the  water  which  tends   to  wash  cement  from  the  mixture. 

H.  T.  Douglas,  Jr.,  Chief  Engineer,  Wheeling  &  Lake  Erie  Railway: 
1.  We  have  had  no  experience  except  with  cofferdams  or  caissons  con- 
structions. One  of  the  most  fruitful  sources  of  disaster  to  poor  concrete 
and  which  sometimes  results  in  disaster  to  structure  is  the  presence  of 
flowing  water  in  the  foundations  of  concrete  construction,  carrying  away 
the  greater  part,  if  not  all,  of  the  cement  from  the  mixture.  The  best 
results  that  I  have  seen  in  the  use  of  concrete  under  water  was  to  mix 
the  concrete,  tie  it  up  in  bags  and  deposit  these  bags  around  on  the  out- 
side of  the  foundations  to  give  stability  to  the  cofferdam  and  for  the 
further  purpose  of  lessening  the  amount  of  leakage.  To  place  concrete 
in  any  foundation  where  water  is  in  motion,  in  my  judgment,  would  re- 
sult, without  doubt,  in  failure. 

A.  C.  Everham,  Assistant  Chief  Engineer,  Kansas  City  Terminal 
Railway:  ia.  At  Detroit,  Mich.,  in  the  construction  of  the  Detroit  River 
Tunnel,  there  was  deposited  about  100,000  cu.  yds.  of  concrete  through 
tremie  pipes,  the  concrete  being  mixed  upon  a  scow  and  poured  in 
tremie,  the  lower  end  of  which  was  always  kept  embedded  in  the  soft 
concrete  or  in  the  mud  at  the  bottom  of  the  river.     The  concrete  was 


MASONRY.  493 

placed  around  the  steel  tubes  which  formed  the  waterproofing  of  the 
tunnel  and  was  retained  by  cross  partitions  and  a  wooden  form  on  the 
outside  of  the  tubes,  thus  forming  a  ''pocket"  which  permitted  the  con- 
crete to  set  with  minimum  of  disturbance.  The  mass  of  concrete  for  the 
enclosed  tube  was  about  56  ft.  wide  at  the  top,  about  32  ft.  deep,  and,  when 
under  water,  about  40  ft.  of  water.  On  account  of  the  pockets  and  lower 
end  of  the  tremie  pipe  always  being  in  soft  cement,  there  was  little,  if 
any,  disturbance  of  the  cement  in  the  concrete,  ib.  In  Toledo,  Ohio,  last 
year  there  was  built  by  the  C.  H.  &  D.  an  ore  dock  of  reinforced  con- 
crete, supported  on  piles,  the  lower  y/2  ft.  of  which  was  deposited  in  water. 
Concrete  was  mixed  on  a  scow  and  carried  by  pipe  from  hopper  to 
point  of  deposit.  The  first  few  batches  were  deposited  in  the  open  water 
without  protection,  and  possibly  some  of  the  cement  was  lost.  3a.  The 
character  of  the  concrete  was  ascertained  as  nearly  as  possible  by  taking 
samples  with  a  calyx  drill  and  obtaining  a  great  many  cores,  from  which 
several  were  selected  at  random  and  submitted  to  compression  tests  in  the 
crushing  machine.  Of  four  cores  taken  thus  at  random,  the  concrete 
being  a  1:3:6  mixture,  there  was  found  an  average  crushing  strength 
of  3.239  lbs.,  the  maximum  being  over  4,000  lbs.  In  order  to  compare 
this  concrete  with  concrete  placed  under  normal  conditions  in  retaining 
walls,  some  cores  were  taken  from  a  retaining  wall  at  Detroit  with  same 
grade  of  concrete.  Of  four  samples,  the  average  was  2,320  lbs.,  as 
against  3,239  lbs.  of  the  four  samples  deposited  by  tremie.  3b.  On  ex- 
amination this  concrete  was  shown  to  be  of  excellent  quality. 

E.  D.  Jackson,  Assistant  Engineer,  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad: 
ia.  Bottom  dump  buckets,  lowered  to  a  little  above  the  surface  of  concrete 
deposited  before  emptying,  b.  A  spout  of  a  size  which  can  be  conven- 
iently raised  or  lowered,  and  the  outlet  moved  to  accommodate  the  dis- 
charge of  concrete  when  required.  2.  Five  to  15  ft.  3.  Masonry  piers 
(concrete)  in  Mississippi  River,  which  have  proved  successful  construc- 
tion, were  on  pile  foundation;  also  piers  in  Rum  River,  near  Anoka. 
Minn.,  Great  Northern  Railway.  4.  Tight  cofferdams  should  be  used,  as 
far  as  possible,  to  prevent  any  wash  of  current.  Courses  of  an  even  thick- 
ness  throughout   should   be   maintained   while    depositing   the   concrete. 

Lewis  Kingman,  Office  Engineer,  National  Railways  of  Mexico:  I. 
In  several  cases  we  have  used  No.  10  centrifugal  pumps,  and  have  low- 
ered the  water  as  much  as  possible,  then  excavated  3  or  4  ft.  below  the 
water  level.  We  used  a  12-in.  spout,  with  a  hopper  at  top  end.  We  kept 
the  lower  end  of  this  spout  practically  embedded  in  concrete  and  the 
spout  and  hopper  full  of  concrete.  2.  Not  over  4  ft.  3.  O.  K.  4.  The 
deposit  of  concrete  should  be  made  without  allowing  the  water  to  wash  the 
cement  out  of  the  mixture. 

H.  L.  Ripley,  Engineer  of  Construction,  New  York,  New  Haven  & 
Hartford  Railroad:  1.  Bottom  dump  buckets,  preferably  cylindrical,  with 
height  two  or  three  times  the  diameter,  bottom  opening  full  size.  Bucket 
should  be  lowered  until  same  rests  on  bottom,  latch  released  and  bucket 
raised  slowly  to  prevent  concrete  from  separating.  2.  Eighteen  to  20  ft. 
maximum  rise  and  fall  of  tide ;  outside  of  dam,  6  ft.  3.  Twenty-four  hours 
after  depositing  10  ft.  of  concrete,  the  water  was  pumped  out  and  a  de- 
posit of  laitance  averaging  less  than  Vz-'m.  was  removed  from  the  top 
of  the  concrete;  after  the  surface  was  thoroughly  cleaned,  concreting 
was  continued.  The  percentage  of  laitance  will  depend  upon  the  care 
exercised  in  placing  concrete.  4.  Bucket  should  be  lowered  to  the  bot- 
tom carefully  before  latch  is  released.  After  bucket  is  opened,  it  should 
be  raised  slowly  to  deposit  concrete  directly  on  the  bottom,  thus  pre- 
venting the  material  from  separating.     Concrete  should  not  be  disturbed 


494  MASONRY. 

after  it  is  deposited.  5.  An  ordinary  ^2-yd.  Ransom  mixer  discharged  into 
cylindrical  buckets  set  on  a  lower  platform ;  a  derrick  handled  the  buckets, 
which  were  unlatched  by  a  jerk  line.  Cost  no  more  than  lowering  concrete 
into  ordinary  open  forms  of  equal  depth. 

Frank  H.  Alfred,  General  Superintendent,  Cincinnati,  Hamilton  & 
Dayton  Railway:  1.  We  have  used  a  spout  of  10-in.  metal  pipe,  having 
at  its  top  a  hopper  large  enough  to  hold  a  batch.  This  spout  and  hopper 
we  handled  with  a  derrick,  the  hopper  being  filled.  We  raised  the  spout 
and  hopper  a  small  amount  until  the  concrete  ran  out  of  the  hopper,  and 
not  out  of  the  spout  proper,  which  was  always  kept  filled  with  concrete. 
2.  Three  to  20  ft.  3.  A  very  good  quality  of  concrete.  4  A  rich  mix- 
ture, about  1:2:4,  should  be  used,  and  thoroughly  mixed.  Apparatus 
should  be  carefully  manipulated  to  prevent  concrete  from  running  out  of 
spout.  Mixture  should  be  rather  stiff,  and  deposited  in  two  layers. 
Care  should  be  used  alongside  of  forms ;  worked  best  from  form  toward 
center.     Forms  must  be  tight  to  prevent  current. 

E.  B.  Temple,  Assistant  Chief  Engineer,  Pennsylvania  Railroad:  1. 
Last  year  there  was  successfully  constructed  a  truss  bridge  across  the 
Schuylkill  River  in  connection  with  the  Philadelphia  Terminal  improve- 
ments, where  was  deposited  concrete  under  water  for  four  piers  of  the 
bridge.  The  method  pursued  was  as  follows :  A  cofferdam  of  12  in.  by  12  in. 
timbers  was  built  near  the  shore  and  sunk  at  low  tide  on  the  site  of  the 
pier.  All  possible  excavating  was  done  with  a  dredge  previous  to  sink- 
ing the  dam,  and  the  rock  foundation  was  cleaned  as  thoroughly  as 
could  be  done  by  dredging.  After  the  box,  which,  of  course,  was  open 
at  the  bottom,  was  placed,  a  suction  hose  was  used  to  remove  material 
that  could  not  be  taken  out  by  the  dredge,  or  that  drifted  into  the  tide 
during  the  setting  of  the  box.  The  bottom  was  also  carefully  examined 
by  divers.  Concrete  was  then  deposited  by  means  of  a  bottom  dump 
bucket,  with  a  cover  on  top.  The  bucket  was  lowered  carefully  to 
within  2  ft.  of  the  bottom,  and  after  resting  a  moment  the  bottom  was 
released  and  the  concrete  gradually  settled  into  place.  The  top  of  the  con- 
crete was  kept  as  level  as  possible  by  having  the  buckets  dumped  uni- 
formly over  the  entire  surface.  This  concrete  was  carried  up  to  within 
2  ft.  of  low  water  and  allowed  to  set  for  at  least  a  week  before  the  cut- 
stone  piers  were  started,  ib.  A  bridge  was  constructed,  in  1902,  over  the 
Schuylkill  River  in  about  the  same  depth  of  water  as  the  one  above  referred 
to,  by  the  usual  method  of  pumping  out  the  dam,  so  that  the  concrete 
could  be  deposited  in  the  open  air  all  the  way  down  to  the  rock.  Sev- 
eral months  were  consumed  in  the  attempt,  and  finally  from  about  6  to  8 
ft.  of  the  foundation  had  to  be  constructed  under  water,  as  it  was  im- 
possible to  keep  the  dam  tight  at  the  bottom  and  pump  out  all  of  the 
water.  2.  The  water  in  the  deepest  pier  was  40  ft.,  and  no  trouble 
whatever  was  experienced  in  this  method  of  construction.  5.  The  cost  of 
a  plant  for  depositing  the  concrete  in  this  way  would  practically  be  the 
same  as  for  depositing  it  in  the  open  air.  The  stone  and  sand  were 
brought  to  the  site  on  scows,  and  the  concrete  mixer  and  derricks 
were  also  on  floating  equipment.  With  such  a  plant,  and  following  the 
usual  method  of  pumping  out  the  cofferdams  before  depositing  the  con- 
crete under  water,  the  cost  would  be  about  $25  per  cu.  yd.  By  de- 
positing the  concrete,  as  done  in  this  case,  the  cost  averaged  about  $21 
per  cu.  yd.  These,  apparently,  high  prices  include  excavation  or  dredging, 
cofferdams  and  all  cost  in  connection  with   the  operation. 

R.  N.  Begien,  Assistant  to  General  Manager,  Baltimore  &  Ohio 
Railroad:  ia.  In  still  water  less  than  12  ft.,  after  solid  foundation  is 
secured  and  made  level,  concrete  should  be  mixed  2  sand  and  4  stone, 


MASONRY.  495 

stiff  enough  to  bear  a  man  immediately  after  being  mixed.  This  should 
then  be  lowered  to  the  bottom  of  water  in  round  drop-bottom  buckets, 
holding  from  one-half  to  three-quarters  of  a  cubic  yard.  The  concrete  so 
placed  should  be  kept  reasonably  level  over  the  entire  surface.  If  the  water 
is  of  greater  depth  than  12  ft,  a  diver  should  be  employed.  After  concrete 
is  deposited,  it  should  not  be  disturbed  any  more  than  possible,  b.  Con- 
crete to  be  deposited  under  running  water  should  be  placed  in  cloth 
sacks  filled  two-thirds  full  and  sewed  at  the  extreme  top,  and  lowered 
in  drop-bottom  bucket  or  scale  box.  By  using  care  a  good  level  and  solid 
mass  can  be  obtained,  and  foundation  put  in  any  reasonable  depth  of 
water.  3.  We  have  known  of  concrete  to  be  put  in  in  this  way,  and  have 
never  heard  of  any  failure.  4.  Careful  workmanship,  absolutely  no  haste, 
thorough  supervision  of  each  man,  as  well  as  using  the  best  of  materials. 
The  work  should  be  carried  on  as  continuously  as  possible.  5.  The  same 
plant  necessary  for  putting  in  cofferdam  work,  where  water  has  been 
pumped  out,  will  install  concrete  in  water.  In  my  opinion,  such  a  plant 
would  cost  approximately  $2,000.  Where  concrete  can  be  put  in  founda- 
tion for  $6  per  cu.  yd.,  it  would  cost  in  still  water  about  $7.50  per  CU-  yd. 
In  running  water,  where  cloth  sacks  are  used,  the  cost  would  be  about 
$9.50  per  cu.  yd. 

F.  W.  Gilcreast,  Chief  Engineer,  Lehigh  &  Nezv  England  Railway: 
1.  All  pumping  of  water  should  be  stopped  and  concrete  deposited  by 
means  of  a  spout,  the  bottom  of  which  being  2  or  3  in.  above  the  level 
of  the  concrete  and  moved  about  slowly.  Care  should  be  taken  to  keep 
the  spout  full  of  concrete.  2.  Ten  to  15  ft.  3.  Good.  4.  Foundation 
must  be  enclosed  to  stop  all  flow  of  water  Concrete  should  be  mixed  as 
dry  as  possible  and  spread  evenly  over  foundation  in  layers  about  6  in. 
at  a  time. 

W.  C.  Smith,  Chief  Engineer  of  Maintenance  of  Way,  Northern 
Pacific  Railway:  1.  Bottom  dump  bucket  of  2-yd.  capacity,  no  top 
cover.  A  tremie  in  some  cases.  Usually  deposited  in  a  crib  sunk  by  open 
excavation  or  for  sealing  the  bottom  of  a  cofferdam  where  character  of 
bottom  is  such  that  dam  cannot  be  pumped  out.  2.  Thirty  to  45  ft.  3. 
Satisfactory  in  all  instances  observed.  In  all  cases  where  cribs  have  been 
pumped  out  after  footing  has  been  deposited  through  the  water,  concrete 
has  been  found  to  be  sound  and  as  well  set  up  as  material  deposited  in 
open  air.  4.  Concrete  should  be  deposited  continuously  and  carried  in 
even  layers  across  the  bottom  of  the  excavation  in  order  to  prevent  the 
formation  of  pockets  of  laitance.  It  is  very  important  that  there  be  no 
interruption  in  depositing  concrete  through  the  water  after  same  has  once 
been  begun.  Cribs  or  cofferdams  must  be  tight  and  no  flow  of  enclosed 
water  permitted.  Bucket  must  be  down  on  same  mass  when  dumped, 
and  care  used  in  withdrawing  bucket  to  prevent  lifting  and  dropping  the 
load  through  the  water.  5.  It  is  but  little  more  expensive  to  deposit 
concrete  through  the  water  by  means  of  a  bucket  than  to  deposit  with  a 
bucket  in  open  excavation. 

George  H.  Bremner,  Engineer,  Illinois  District,  Chicago,  Burlington 
&  Quincy  Railroad:  1.  Caissons  filled  with  dry  mixture  of  concrete 
and  water.  Bottom  dump  buckets,  lowered  windlass,  were  used  for  de- 
positing. 2.  About  50  ft.  3.  Water  was  pumped  out  the  following  day  and 
concrete  was  in  good  condition. 

Joseph  0.  Osgood,  Chief  Engineer,  Central  Railroad  of  Nezv  Jersey: 
ia.  In  long,  narrow  walls  the  operation  has  been  commenced  at  one  end 
and  concrete  deposited  in  bottom  dump  buckets  until  the  concrete  showed 
above  the   level   of  the   water,   from   which    point    an    ordinary    bucket 


496  MASONRY. 

was  used  and  the  concrete  deposited  on  top  of  portion  showing  above 
water,  gradually  forcing  the  concrete  below  water  toward  opposite  end 
from  which  the  operation  was  commenced.  The  level  of  the  concrete 
was  kept  nearly  on  a  plane  with  the  level  of  the  water,  by  which  means  the 
setting  of  the  concrete  was  slow,  and  the  mass  was  forced  gradually  for- 
ward without  having  the  concrete  roll  down  the  side.  The  water  beyond 
the  concrete  remained  clear  during  the  whole  of  the  operation,  b.  Bottom 
dump  bucket,  with  lid  or  cover  over  the  top.  2a.  Three  to  ten  feet.  The 
operation  was  commenced  at  the  3-ft.  end.  b.  About  10  ft.  3.  Very  good 
4.  The  flow  of  the  water  must  be  cut  off  in  such  a  way  that  there  will  be 
no  current  in  the  area  in  which  the  wall  is  to  be  constructed,  b.  Bucket 
must  be  so  constructed  that  there  will  be  no  rush  of  water  through  it 
and  the  concrete  while  being  lowered.  5.  Cost  nc  greater  than  for  de- 
positing by  usual  methods  above  water.  Building  dam  to  cut  off  the  cur- 
rent is  an  added  expense. 

John  D.  Isaacs,  Consulting  Engineer,  Harriman  Lines:  la.  Bottom 
dump  bucket  lowered  slowly  through  the  water  and  dumped  when  rest- 
ing on  the  bottom,  b.  Tremie,  handled  by  means  of  a  winch,  derrick  or 
chain  hoist,  and  moved  to  any  desired  position  by  means  of  a  trolley 
way.  c.  Concrete  blocks,  molded  and  permitted  to  become  thoroughly  set 
in  open  air.  2a.  Twenty-two  to  55  ft.  b.  Six  to  135  ft.  3a.  Good  in  all 
cases.  Probably  better  results  can  be  attained  by  this  method  than  by 
the  use  of  a  tremie.  In  one  instance  work  was  discontinued  for  several 
months,  and  the  surface  of  the  concrete  in  the  form  at  this  time  being 
about  8  ft.  below  the  surface  of  the  water.  Examination  showed  that  the 
upper  surface  of  the  concrete  had  taken  a  very  hard  permanent  set, 
and  that  the  character  thereof  was  fully  as  good  as  concrete  placed  above 
water.  In  the  structure  herein  referred  to,  about  4,000  cu.  yds.  of  concrete, 
included  in  piers  below  water,  was  handled  bv  method  above  described, 
b.  Generally  good,  but  in  cases  of  deep  foundations  where  tremie  had  to 
be  lifted  to  clear  bracing  of  cofferdam  and  tops  of  piles,  it  is  possible 
that  the  results  are  not  so  good  as  though  the  operation  were  carried  on 
continuously,  since  the  charge  in  the  tremie  drops  and  the  recharging 
has  to  be  done  through  the  water  in  the  tube.  c.  Good.  This  method  is 
especially  adapted  to  locations  where  it  is  impossible  to  avoid  current 
in  the  water.  4.  There  should  be  practically  no  current  in  the  water. 
Bottom  dump  method.  The  bucket  should  rest  upon  the  foundation  before 
the  concrete  is  dumped.  Bucket  should  be  raised  and  lowered  so  as  to 
cause  least  disturbance  of  water  possible.  Tremie  method.  The  con- 
crete should  be  permitted  to  run  out  at  the  discharge  end  as  fast  as  it  is 
deposited  in  hopper  end.  Concrete  should  be  distributed  in  as  even  layers 
as  possible.  Laitance  or  other  inert  materials  which  may  have  accumu- 
lated by  reason  of  discontinuance  of  operations  should  be  cleaned  off  be- 
fore additional  concrete  is  deposited.  The  amount  of  cement  in  the  mix- 
ture should  be  slightly  over  that  used  for  depositing  the  dry  in  order  to 
offset  any  loss  which  may  occur  by  wash.  5.  The  relative  cost  depends 
much  upon  the  depth  of  water  through  which  the  concrete  is  deposited. 
Cost  data  kept  for  constructive  work  on  the  Oregon-Washington  Rail- 
road &  Navigation  Company  indicate  a  cost  of  approximately  $t.oo  per 
cu.  yd.  for  depositing  with  bottom-dump  bucket  when  it  would  cost  75 
cents  per  cu.  yd.  in  the  dry.  Under  similar  conditions  the  cost  with  the 
tremie  was  about  $1.40  per  cu.  yd. 

R.  Budd,  Chief  Engineer,  Spokane,  Portland  &  Seattle  Railway:  ia. 
Bottom-dump  bucket,  having  single  leaf,  about  34-yd.  capacity  b.  Tremie 
consisting  of  steel  pipe  of  about  24  in.  diameter  choked  down  to  12  in.  at 
lower  end.  c.  Two  wooden  tremies  of  same  diameter  throughout  entire 
length.    2a.    Six  ft.    b.    Fifteen  ft.    c.    Twelve  ft.     3a.    Successful,    b.    As 


MASONRY.  497 

concrete  would  not  flow  freely,  bottom-dump  bucket  was  substituted,  c. 
Successful.  Charges  were  very  seldom  lost,  and  when  this  did  happen, 
an  extra  quantity  of  cement  was  used  in  refilling  the  tube.  4a.  Bucket 
should  be  of  large  capacity,  and  should  be  handled  slowly  under  water 
Bucket  should  rest  on  bottom  before  it  is  dumped.  Bottom  constructed 
with  two  leaves  is  better  than  with  one,  as  it  causes  less  disturbance  of 
the  water,  c.  Tremies  should  be  handled  very  slowly  to  avoid  disturb- 
ance of  the  water.  Avoid  losing  charge.  Tube  should  be  of  same  diameter 
throughout,  and  it  is  well  to  have  hopper  at  upper  end. 

M.  J.  Caples,  Vice-President,  Chesapeake  &  Ohio  Railway:  1.  Con- 
crete was  placed  in  loosely  woven  gunny  sacks  and  dropped  through  the 
water  into  position.  The  concrete  in  bags  was  leveled  with  long  poles 
as  the  work  began.  2.  Six  ft.  3.  This  work  was  done  twenty-one  years  ago, 
when  concrete  was  used  much  less  than  it  is  to-dav.  The  object  in  view  in 
depositing  this  concrete  was  to  even  up  the  foundation  for  a  bridge  abut- 
ment. The  foundation  was  limestone  rock,  as  I  recall  it,  about  50  cu.  yds. 
of  concrete  being  used  in  this  way.  The  abutment  built  upon  this  founda- 
tion is  still  in  excellent  condition. 

F.  L.  Wheaton,  Engineer  of  Construction,  Delaware,  Lackaivanna  & 
Western  Railroad:  ia.  Bottom-dump  bucket  with  lid,  first  landed  on 
bottom  of  foundation,  after  the  water  had  become  still,  was  carefully 
raised,  leaving  the  concrete  upon  the  bottom,  b.  Movable  chute.  Chute 
should  be  filled  with  concrete  to  a  point  above  the  water  line,  raised 
and  moved  with  a  derrick,  allowing  concrete  to  flow  out  the  bottom  as 
fast  as  it  is  deposited  on  top.  3.  Very  satisfactory.  4.  The  concrete 
should  be  mixed  much  drier  for  use  under  water  than  for  use  above, 
as  in  this  way  there  is  less  danger  of  the  cement  washing  out  of  the 
aggregate.  5a  and  b.  The  cost  of  depositing  concrete  by  these  methods 
is  only  slightly  more  than  if  water  were  pumped  out. 

Lincoln  Bush,  Consulting  Engineer:  1.  I  have  used  steel  buckets 
for  this  purpose,  with  opening  at  the  bottom.  The  buckets  were  lowered 
to  full  depth  before  the  concrete  was  deposited.  2.  About  15  ft.  3. 
Very  satisfactory.  4.  Buckets  should  be  tight,  to  prevent  flow  of  water 
through  the  concrete  in  lowering,  lowered  full  depth  before  concrete  is 
deposited.  Before  the  day's  work  is  started,  the  inert  deposit  on  top  of 
concrete  which  has  accumulated  from  previous  day's  work  should  be 
pumped  off.  This  can  be  done  by  lowering  suction  pipe  down  on  the 
concrete,  and  moving  the  suction  about  over  entire  area,  the  concrete 
of  previous  day's  work  having  set  sufficiently  to  prevent  the  removal 
of  the  cement  by  pumping. 

A.  J.  Himes,  Engineer  Grade  Elimination,  New  York,  Chicago  & 
St.  Louis  Railroad:  ia.  Concerning  the  deposition  of  concrete  under 
water,  my  experience  has  been  confined  to  comparatively  shallow  depths. 
I  have  used  a  rough  wooden  box  as  a  substitute  for  a  tremie.  b.  I 
have  permitted  concrete  to  slide  gently  into  the  water  through  chutes, 
first  forming  a  pile  of  concrete  in  form  of  cone,  and  permitting  it  to 
raise  to  the  surface  of  the  water,  then,  as  further  concrete  is  deposited, 
the  mass  is  permitted  to  extend  horizontally  under  its  own  weight.  This 
method  gives  very  good  results,  c.  I  have  placed  concrete  under  water 
in  gunny  sacks.  The  use  of  the  sacks  was,  of  course,  a  simple  device  to 
prevent  the  washing  of  the  concrete,  d.  I  have  inspected  the  deposition 
of  concrete  50  ft.  below  water  surface  under  compressed  air,  where  air 
pressure  was  allowed  to  decrease  as  the  surface  of  concrete  rose,  so  that 
the  water  surface  was  maintained  at  approximately  the  surface  of  the 
concrete.  2a  and  b.  Comparatively  shallow,  d.  Eighty  feet.  3a.  Very 
good  results,     b.     Very  good  results,     d.     Wholly  successful  for  depths 


498  MASONRY. 

as  great  as  80  ft.  4.  The  concrete  should  be  mixed  rather  wet,  and 
all  agitation  thereof  should  be  avoided  after  it  has  been  placed  in  the 
water.  Workmen  generally  seem  determined  to  stir  up  the  concrete 
and  shovel  it  around  beneath  the  water,  and  it  is  oftentimes  hard  to 
overcome  this  disposition.  The  only  precaution  necessary  is  to  insure 
that  the  surging  or  washing  of  the  water  does  not  wash  the  cement 
from  the  aggregate.  Any  method  which  will  prevent  this  condition  will 
be  successful,  in  so  far  as  the  proper  hardening  and  durability  of  the 
concrete  is   concerned. 

*Job  Tutliill,  Assistant  Engineer,  Kansas  City  Terminal  Railway: 
ia.  Filled  8  ft.  in  bottom  of  a  circular  sheet  pile  crib  with  a  cubical 
box  having  bottom  in  halves,  hinged  to  the  sides.  Box  closed  and 
handled  with  load  by  one  rope,  and  placed  where  concrete  was 
wanted,  then  box  dumped  by  second  rope  similar  to  the  way  orange  peel 
buckets  are  handled,  and  pulled  in.  2.  Fourteen  feet.  3.  Very  satis- 
factory. The  concrete  was  nearly  level  and  spread  out  against  sides  of 
crib  when  pumped  out.  4.  Handle  carefully.  After  the  steel  tubes 
forming  the  river  section  of  the  La  Salle  Street  Tunnel  under  Chicago 
River,  Chicago,  111.,  had  been  sunk  in  place,  it  was  necessary  to  con- 
struct a  cofferdam  at  each  end  of  the  tubes,  behind  which  the  water 
could  be  pumped  out,  permitting  connections  to  be  made  to  the  land  sec- 
tions. At  each  end  of  the  river  section  there  was  a  timber  crib  11  ft. 
wide,  securely  fastened  to  the  tubes  and  reaching  3  ft.  above  the  surface 
of  the  river.  From  the  ends  of  these  cribs  pockets,  approximately 
i7z/2  ft.  square,  were  formed  by  driving  Friestedt  steel  sheeting  of  from 
50  to  65  ft.  in  length.  Within  these  pockets  the  depth  of  water  ranged 
from  45  to  53  ft.  On  account  of  this  extreme  depth,  it  was  not  deemed 
advisable  to  fill  the  pockets  entirely  with  clay,  but  to  fill  the  bottom  with 
concrete  to  a  depth  below  water  level  of  about  37  ft.,  and  in  the  same 
operation  fill  the  space  between  the  shell  of  the  tubes  and  the  bottom 
of  the  excavation.  Reference  to  the  accompanying  sketch  will  give  a 
clear  idea  of  the  construction  of  the  cribs,  pockets,  etc.  An  attempt  was 
made  to  deposit  concrete  by  the  tremie  method,  by  use  of  a  12-in.  diameter 
pipe  and  permitting  the  concrete  to  spread  from  the  bottom  end  _  of  the 
pipe.  This  method  did  not  prove  successful  on  account  of  the  difficulty 
of  keeping  tremie  full  of  concrete,  and  the  difficulty  of  manipulating  the 
same  in  this  depth  of  water.  An  examination  by  diver  indicated  a  con- 
siderable segregation  of  the  sand  and  stone  to  the  extent  that  this  method 
was  abandoned. 

The  following  method  was  then  determined  upon:  Gas  pipes,  ilA  in. 
diameter,  were  bent  to  the  radius  of  the  tunnel  tubes  and  placed  so  that  they 
would  discharge  at  varying  distances  underneath  the  tubes.  Four  of  these 
pipes  were  placed  in  each  pocket  and  rigidly  fastened  in  position  by  sub- 
marine divers.  As  indicated  on  accompanying  sketch,  these  pipes  did  not 
have  well  points  attached  to  the  ends.  In  addition  to  the  bent  pipes, 
each  pocket  contained  twelve  to  fifteen  2-in.  diameter  pipes,  equipped  with 
well  points,  stripped  of  the  netting,  at  bottom  ends,  and  placed  so  as  to 
be  about  2  ft.  above  the  bottom  of  the  excavation.  The  top  end  of  all 
pipes  was  threaded  for  attachment  to  the  grouting  machine.  About  5  ft. 
of  broken  stone  was  then  spread  over  the  bottom  of  the  pocket  and  grout 
under  a  pressure  varying  from  35  to  100  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  was  then  forced 
through  the  pipes  to  fill  the  voids  in  the  layer  of  stone. 

In  general,  the  grout  consisted  of  a  mixture  of  about  five  bags  of 
cement  to  one  barrow  of  torpedo  sand.  All  lumps,  gravel,  etc.,  which 
would  clog  the  well  points,  were  removed  from  the  cement  and  sand 
before  mixing.  The  grout  was  thoroughly  mixed  before  being  put  into 
the  McMichael's  compressed  air  mixer.  After  placing  the  bottom  course 
as  above,  a  second  set  of  pipes  and  another  layer  of  broken  stone  were 

♦Acknowledgment  is  made  of  valuable  information  furnished  by  the 
engineers  of  the   La   Salle  Street  Tunnel,   Chicago,    for  use   in   this  abstract. 


MASONRY.  499 

placed  and  grouted  as  before.  This  process  was  continued  until  the  de- 
sired height  of  concrete  was  obtained.  This  method  made  use  of  quite  a 
large  number  of  pipes,  as  it  was  impossible  to  remove  them  after  the 
grouting  was  complete.  The  method  used  in  the  south  cofferdam  was 
similar  to  that  used  in  the  north,  except  that  in  the  main  section  of  the 
pockets,  only  one  set  of  pipes  was  used.  After  these  had  been  put  in 
position,  the  whole  volume  of  broken  stone  was  deposited.  Grout  was 
then  forced  through  the  pipes,  and  as  the  grouting  continued,  the  pipes 
were  worked  up  and  down  through  the  mass  of  stone  until  the  voids 
were  filled.  This  method  appeared  to  be  as  successful  as  that  used  in 
the  north  dam,  although  about  three  hundred  bags  less  of  cement  were 
used.  During  the  operation  of  grouting,  whenever  the  grout  was  flowing 
freely  into  the  voids,  the  pressure  was  from  40  to  50  lbs.  per  sq.  in., 
but  when  the  voids  were  practically  filled,  this  pressure  became  90  to  100 
lbs.  The  operation  at  all  times  continued  until  no  more  grout  could  be 
forced  into  the  pipes.  After  the  concrete  had  sufficiently  set,  the  remain- 
ing volume  of  the  pockets  was  filled  with  clay;  the  north  dam  proved  in  all 
respects  securely  watertight,  leaks  were  slight,  and  the  water  apparently 
flowed  along  the  line  of  separation  between  the  clay  and  the  concrete.  In 
the  south  dam,  one  bad  leak  developed,  the  water  apparently  coming  from 
the  river  underneath  the  concrete. 

John  R.  Leighty,  Engineer  Maintenance,  Missouri  Pacific  Railway: 
1.  Wood  forms  were  made  from  3x6  piers  and  set  on  solid  rock  bot- 
tom of  river ;  concrete  lowered  into  form  in  steel  buckets  with  swing- 
ing drop  bottom ;  bottom  unlatched  and  bucket  lifted,  allowing  concrete 
to  drop  to  bottom  of  form.  2.  Two  to  six  feet.  3.  Three  small  piers 
were  built  up  to  about  1  ft.  above  surface  of  water,  and  false  work 
was  placed  upon  them  to  carry  the  ends  of  the  two  double-track  spans, 
175  ft.  each,  under  traffic  of  one  hundred  trains  per  day.  After  use  of 
about  three  months,  they  were  abandoned.  They  did  the  work  without 
any  trouble.  4.  The  forms  were  built  of  rough  lumber  and  were  not 
water  tight.  Buckets  were  lifted  carefully,  so  as  to  agitate  water  as 
little  as   possible. 

1 

J.  R.  IV.  Ambrose,  Engineer  Grade  Separation,  Grand  Trunk  Ry. 
System:  r.  Box  chute  with  funnel  arrangement  on  top.  2.  Six  to 
10  ft.  3.  Good  where  water  remains  quiet.  4.  Box  must  be  filled 
and  kept  filled. 

C.  D.  Purdoii,  Chief  Engineer,  St.  Louis  &  Southwestern  Railway: 
ia.  Tremie.  b.  Bottom-dump  bucket.  3.  Appear  to  have  been  satis- 
factory, as  no  trouble  has  been  experienced  with  any  of  the  foundation 
so  deposited.  4a.  Tremie  should  be  kept  full  and  deposit  made  in  small 
quantities,  b. '  Bucket  should  touch  bottom  before  it  is  opened,  so  that 
the  concrete  may  pass  through  as   little  water  as  possible. 

W.  A.  Clark,  Chief  Engineer,  Duluth  &  Iron  Range  Railroad:  l. 
About  6,000  cu.  yds.  were  deposited  by  means  of  bottom-dump  bucket 
in  ore  dock  foundation.  Trial  with  tremie  in  this  case  did  not  seem  to 
secure  equally  as  good  results.  2.  Four  and  one-half  feet.  3.  Drill 
cores  were  not  secured,  so  that  results  were  not  absolutely  known,  but 
samples  deposited  in  same  way  and  afterwards  removed  and  examined, 
showed  very  little  separation.  4.  Bucket  should  have  large  discharge 
opening  and  have  canvas  cover,  to  decrease  washing  and  consequent 
separation.  In  this  case  water  was  at  a  temperature  of  32  degrees  and  28 
degrees  Fahrenheit,  and  so  retarded  the  setting  of  the  cement  that  there 
was  danger  of  slight  wave  action  causing  separation,  so  it  was  thought 
necessary  to  heat  the  water  with  a  steam  jet  to  a  temperature  of  45  to 
50  degrees. 


500 


502  MASONRY. 

George  W.  Boschkc,  Chief  Engineer,  Oregon-Washington  Railroad 
&  Navigation  Company:  i.  Bottom  dump  bucket  with  single  line.  2. 
From  no  to  135  ft.  3.  First-class.  4.  The  material  should  be  distributed 
evenly  and  buckets  covered  before  reaching  bottom,  which  can  be  done 
by  using  single  line.  This  arrangement  is  patented  by  George  T.  Forsyth, 
Portland,  Oregon.  5.  Derricks  were  used,  the  same  as  those  used  on 
shore.  The  only  difference  in  cost  of  plant  is  additional  length  of  cables 
and  additional  time  necessary  for  lowering  to  greater  depth. 

Robert  Armour,  M'asonry  Engineer,  Grand  Trunk  Railway  System: 
ia.  Tremie  or  spout,  b.  Bottom-dump  bucket.  Both  have  been  used 
to  a  limited  extent  only ;  both  good.  Bottom-dump  bucket  generally 
preferable_  as  being  more  easily  handled.  Bucket  should  be  of  largest 
size  practicable,  and  have  cover.  2.  Five  to  8  ft.  3.  There  has  been 
no  subsequent  examination  by  diver  or  unwatering,  but  concrete  set  well, 
and  there  is  no  failure  to  report.  Either  method  is,  without  doubt,  satis- 
factory, if  used  with  care.  4.  A  slow,  regular  movement  of  tremie,  with 
bottom  raised  just  enough  to  allow  concrete  to  flow  out.  b.  Bucket 
should  be  discharged  when  it  is  close  to  bottom.  Rich  concrete  should 
be  used,  thoroughly  mixed,  of  "quaking"  consistency.  Materials  should 
not  be  used  dry,  as  air  in  voids  when  displaced  by  water  carries 
cement  with  it.     Disturb  it  as   little  as  possible  after  placing  it. 

REPORT   ON   WORK   OF  JOINT   COMMITTEE    ON    CONCRETE 
AND  REINFORCED  CONCRETE. 

The  Joint  Committee  on  Concrete  and  Reinforced  Concrete  held  a 
meeting  at  Atlantic  City,  June  30,  191 1,  at  which  time  the  work  of  the 
Committee  was  gone  over  and  the  previous  record  carefully  studied,  with 
the  view  of  putting  it  in  shape  for  final  report. 

The  work  of  revising  the  report  was  allotted  to  a  number  of  sub- 
committees. Although  these  committees  have  reported  back  and  the  data 
put  in  shape  to  again  present  to  the  Committee  as  a  whole,  the  meeting 
has  not  been  called  for  ratification  of  the  report ;  therefore,  your  Com- 
mittee can  only  present  a  progress  report,  believing  that  the  work  of  the 
Joint  Committee  on  Concrete  and  Reinforced  Concrete  will  be  finished 
sometime  during  the  present  year. 

UNIFICATION  OF  PORTLAND  CEMENT  SPECIFICATIONS. 

(Specifications  for  Natural  Cement  were  not  considered.) 
Early  in  the  year  1911  two  Government  Boards  or  Committees  were 
appointed  to  deal  with  the  question  of  Cement  Specifications.  One  of 
these,  appointed  by  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  United  States  Army,  was 
instructed  to  revise  Professional  Papers  No.  28 ;  the  other  was  made  up  of 
representatives  from  the  various  departments,  appointed  by  the  head  of 
each  department.  This  Committee  was  instructed  to  prepare  and  report 
to  the  departments  a  single  Standard  Specification  for  the  Government. 
This  body  was  known  as  "The  Departmental  Committee  for  the  Unifica- 
tion of  Government  Specifications  for  Portland  Cement." 

On  September  12  the  Army  Board  held  a  meeting  at  which  repre- 
sentatives from  the  various  engineering  bodies  interested  in  cement  sped- 


MASONRY.  503 

cations,  from  the  Association  of  American  Portland  Cement  Manufacturers 
and  representatives  from  one  or  two  commercial  laboratories,  were  in 
attendance.  At  this  meeting  the  Army  Board  received  suggestions  for 
the  revision  of  Professional  Papers  No.  28. 

Following  this  meeting  the  Departmental  Committee  issued  a  tentative 
specification,  which  was  sent  out  with  request  for  criticism  and  suggestion. 

On  November  24  a  meeting  was  held  at  Washington  which  was  at- 
tended by  representatives  from  the  Departmental  Committee,  the  Army 
Board  and  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association.  Committee 
C-i,  American  Society  for  Testing  Materials,  and  Committee  on  Uniform 
Tests  for  Cement,  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers,  were  not  repre- 
sented, though  they  had  previously  accepted  the  invitation  to  be  present. 
It  was  apparent  that  the  tendency  of  the  Departmental  Committee  was  to 
adhere  quite  closely  to  the  standard  adopted  by  the  American  Society 
for  Testing  Materials,  which  is  also  the  standard  of  this  Association. 

On  November  27  a  meeting  was  held  in  Philadelphia,  attended  by 
representatives  from  the  Committee  on  Uniform  Tests  for  Cement,  Ameri- 
can Society  of  Civil  Engineers,  Standard  Specifications  for  Portland  Ce- 
ment (C-i),  American  Society  for  Testing  Materials,  and  through  its 
membership  on  Committee  C-i  this  Association  was  represented.  The 
Association  of  American  Portland  Cement  Manufacturers  and  the  Depart- 
mental Committee  were  also  represented.  The  principal  question  before 
this  meeting  was  that  of  Uniform  Methods,  and  an  agreement  was  reached 
on  every  point  excepting  the  use  of  the  Vicat  Needle  vs.  Gilmore  Needle 
in  determining  time  of  set,  and  Vicat  Needle  vs.  Ball  Test  in  determining 
normal  consistency. 

On  January  8,  1912,  representatives  from  the  Departmental  Committee 
and  Committee  on  Uniform  Tests  for  Cement  of  the  American  Society  of 
Civil  Engineers  met  with  the  Army  Board  to  further  consider  the  points 
of  difference  in  the  respective  specifications.  Agreement  had  been  reached 
upon  all  points  excepting  those  previously  mentioned,  and  at  this  meeting 
the  representatives  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  expressed 
preference  for  retaining  the  Vicat  Needle,  but  offered  to  compromise  and 
accept  the  Ball  Method  as  the  means  of  determining  normal  consistency 
if  the  Government  representatives  would  accept  the  Vicat  Needle  as  the 
method  of  determining  the  time  of  set. 

After  due  consideration  the  Government  representatives  were  con- 
vinced that  the  Gilmore  Needle  should  be  retained  in  their  specifications ; 
also,  that  the  Ball  Test  for  determining  normal  consistency  is  preferable 
to  the  Vicat  Needle,  and  a  specification  which  agrees  with  the  standard  of 
this  Association  in  other  particulars  was  approved  by  the  Departmental 
Committee  and  the  Board  of  Engineer  Officers  and  recommended  for 
adoption  as  a  United  States  Government  Standard  Specification  for 
Portland  Cement. 

The  Committee  on  Uniform  Tests  for  Cement,  upon  making  their  re- 
port to  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  in  January,  stated  that 
they  had  been  unable  to  get  together  with  the  Army  Board  and  the  De- 
partmental Committee  on  Methods  of  Tests,  and,  considering  their  work 


504  MASONRY. 

finished,  asked  to  be  dismissed.     The  Committee  was  accordingly  relieved 
from  further  duty. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

Your    Committee    recommends    the    adoption    of    the    following    con- 
clusions : 

(i)     That  the  conclusions  in  reference  to  Miethods  of  Patching  and 
Repairing  Plain  and  Reinforced  Concrete  be  approved  as  good  practice. 
(2)     That   the    conclusions   in    reference    to    Methods    of    Depositing 
Concrete  Under  Water  be  approved  as  good  practice. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  MASONRY. 


REPORT   OF  COMMITTEE  XI— ON  RECORDS  AND 
ACCOUNTS. 

H.  J.  Pfeifer,  Chairman;  M.  C.  Byers,  Vice -Chairman; 

J.  M.  Brown.  Guy  Scott. 

Edw.  Gray.  W.  A.  Christian. 

E.  E.  Hanna.  G.  J.  Graves. 

Henry  Lehn.  C.  W.  Cochran. 

J.  H.  Milburn.  G.  T.  Warren. 

C.  W.  Pifer.  H.  Stephens. 

Committee. 
To  the  Members  of  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Records  and  Accounts  respectfully  submits  here- 
with its  report : 

The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  the  following  work  to  your  Commit- 
tee for  the  current  year : 

(i)  Make  a  comprehensive  study  of  the  forms  in  the  Manual  which 
were  adopted  a  number  of  years  ago. 

(2)  Study  the  economical  way  of  managing  a  storehouse  so  as  to 
assure  a  minimum  stock  of  materials  at  all  times. 

(3)  Make  concise  recommendations  for  next  year's  work. 

The  following  Sub-Committees  were  appointed : 

Sub-Committee  A — Study  of  Forms  in  Manual:  C.  W.  Cochran, 
Henry  Lehn,  J.  H.  Milburn,  Guy  Scott,  H.  Stephens,  G.  T.  Warren. 

Sub-Committee  B  —  Economical  Storehouse  Management:  J.  M. 
Brown,  W.  A.  Christian,  G.  J.  Graves,  Edw.  Gray,  E.  E.  Hanna,  C.  W. 
Pifer. 

EXPLANATORY  STATEMENT. 

Two  meetings  were  held  during  the  year ;  one  of  Sub-Committee  B  at 
St.  Louis  on  October  23,  191 1,  attended  by  Messrs.  Brown,  Byers  and 
Pfeifer,  and  another  of  the  entire  Committee  at  Chicago  on  November  28, 
191 1,  attended  by  Messrs.  Byers,  Brown,  Christian,  Graves,  Milburn  and 
Pfeifer. 

The  Committee  devoted  by  far  the  greatest  part  of  its  time  to  sub- 
ject (2),  the  first  point  discussed  relating  to  the  scope  of  the  instructions 
as  follows :  Should  the  internal  economy  of  the  storehouse  be  solely  con- 
sidered, or  should  the  effects  of  storehouse  management  on  the  broader 
economies  of  maintenance  and  operation  be  also  taken  into  consideration. 
As  the  first  involves  a  storekeeping  rather  than  a  maintenance  or  operating 
problem,  the  Committee  decided  to  base  its  investigation  and  report  on  the 
second  interpretation. 

505 


506  RECORDS  AND  ACCOUNTS. 

Material  and  labor  are  required  in  the  construction,  maintenance  and 
operation  of  railroads ;  and  since  it  is  impossible  to  secure  materials  when, 
and  in  the  quantities  required,  by  direct  purchase,  a  reserve  stock  is  ac- 
cumulated which  is  drawn  upon  to  meet  the  demands  as  they  arise. 

The  following  figures  are  taken  from  the  report  of  the  Interstate 
Commerce  Commission  for  the  year  ending  June  30,  1909: 

Operating  expenses  of  the  railroads  of  the  United  States  for  the  year 
ending  June  30,  1909,  amounted  to  $1,599,443,410  (p.  75). 

Machinists,  carpenters,  other  shopmen,  section  foremen,  other  track- 
men, other  employes  and  laborers,  whose  efficiency  depends  to  a  great 
extent  on  their  having  proper  materials  and  tools,  received  in  wages 
$466,138,215,  or  about  29  per  cent.  (p.  46)  of  the  entire  operating  expenses. 

The  general  balance  sheet  for  the  same  period  gives  the  value  of  ma- 
terials and  supplies  on  hand  at  $206,849,619  (p.  82).  Five  per  cent,  per 
annum  on  this  sum  is  $10,342,481,  about  2.2  per  cent,  of  what  was  paid 
during  the  year  to  the  classes  of  employes  above  mentioned 

Assuming  that  it  is  possible  to  reduce  the  stock  on  hand  to  the  ex- 
tent of  50  per  cent,  the  saving  per  annum  would  be  only  1.1  per  cent,  of 
the  amount  paid  annually  in  wages  to  the  above  mentioned  employes,  so 
that  even  a  slight  loss  in  their  efficiency  through  failure  to  secure  materials 
and  tools  as  required,  will  soon  absorb  much  more  than  the  amount  saved 
by  reduced  investment  in  stock.  It  would  seem,  therefore,  that  the  most 
important  function  of  a  storehouse  is  the  prompt  delivery  of  materials  and 
tools  so  that  delays  to  labor  resulting  from  their  lack  may  be  reduced  to 
a  minimum. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

It  is  recommended — 

(1)  That  no  changes  be  made  in  the  forms  appearing  in  the  Manual. 

(2)  That  the  following  statement  embodies  the  general  principles 
governing  the  economical  management  of  a  railway  storehouse : 

REASONS   FOR   MAINTAINING   A   STOREHOUSE. 

The  object  of  a  storehouse  is  to  provide  material  and  tools  when  re- 
quired so  that  the  cost  of  work  may  be  a  minimum,  bearing  in  mind  the 
factors  of  deiay  to  work  or  labor,  also  interest  on  investment  in  stock. 

The  following  essential  elements  enter  into  the  problem : 

(a)  Standardization. — The  standardization  of  materials  and  instruc- 
tions in  regard  to  their  use  will  reduce  to  a  minimum  the  number  of  items 
of  material  of  the  various  classes  which  should  be  carried  in  stock.  The 
amount  of  each  item  which  should  be  carried  in  stock  will  depend  upon 
the  rate  of  consumption,  time  required  for  the  purchase  and  delivery  of 
material,  and  also  upon  local  conditions. 

(b)  Classification  of  Material. — This  is  necessary  so  as  to  reduce 
to  a  minimum  the  cost  and  time  of  handling.  An  approved  classification 
should  be  followed  in  making  requisitions. 

(c)  Stock  Account. — An  account  should  be  kept  of  stock  showing 
at  all  times  a   record   of   receipts,   disbursements   and   amount   on   hand. 


RECORDS  AND  ACCOUNTS.  507 

Stock  should  be  replenished  when  the  amount  of  any  item  has  been  re- 
duced to  a  fixed  minimum.  Inventories  should  be  made  at  stated  periods. 
A  proper  stock  account  furnishes  a  check  on  excessive  supply  and  obsolete 
material. 

(d)  Distribution. — When  material  is  shipped,  notice  should  be  sent 
to  consignee  showing  partial  or  complete  filling  of  requisition  and  if  par- 
tial, when  final  shipment  may  be  expected. 

(e)  Organization.— The  storekeeper's  place  in  the  general  organiza- 
tion should  be  so  fixed  and  adjusted  that  the  measure  of  his  efficiency  is 
primarily,  the  promptness  and  accuracy  with  which  he  fills  requisitions,  and, 
secondly,  his  ability  to  hold  down  the  stock  investment  to  the  lowest 
amount  consistent  with  the  first  requirement. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  RECORDS  AND  ACCOUNTS. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  XVI— ON  ELECTRICITY. 

George  W.  Kittredge,  Chairman;       J.  B.  Austin,  Jr.,  Vice-Chair  man; 

R.  D.  Coombs.  C.  E.  Lindsay. 

A.  O.  Cunningham.  W.  S.  Murray. 

L.  C.  Fritch.  J.  R.  Savage. 

George  Gibes.  W.  I.  Trench. 

G.  A.  Harwood.  H.  U.  Wallace. 

E.  B.  Katte.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Raihvay  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  presents  herewith  its  second  annual  report,  its  first 
annual  report  appearing  in  Vol.  12,  Part  1,  of  the  Proceedings  of  the 
Association  for  the  year  191 1,  which  report  contains  the  History  and 
Bibliography. 

The  Association  directed  that  the  outline  of  Committee  work  for  the 
year  191 1  be  as  follows: 

(1)  Continue  the  consideration  of  the  subject  of  Clearances. 

(2)  Continue  the  preparation  of  Standard  Specifications  for  Over- 
head Transmission  Line  Crossings. 

(3)  Report  on  effect  of  electrolytic  action  on  metallic  structures  and 
best  means  of  preventing  it. 

(4)  Method  of  insulation  and  protection. 

In  accordance  with  the  instructions  of  the  Board  of  Direction,  that 
two  subjects  would  be  the  maximum  for  the  action  of  the  convention,  your 
Committee  has  confined  itself  to  the  following  subjects: 

(1)  Clearances. 

(2)  Transmission  Lines  and  Crossings. 

Two  meetings  have  been  held  in  New  York,  one  on  August  7,  191 1, 
at  which  were  present  Messrs.  Kittredge,  Coombs,  H.  A.  Currie  (repre- 
senting Mr.  Katte),  Harwood,  Lindsay  and  Savage,  and  at  New  York  on 
January  29,  1912,  at  which  were  present  Messrs.  Kittredge,  Austin,  Coombs, 
Fritch,  Gibbs,  Harwood,  Katte.  Lindsay  and  Trench. 

The  balance  of  the  work  of  the  Committee  has  been  done  by  corre- 
spondence and  by  the  chairmen  of  the  Sub-Ccmmittees  on  "Clearances'' 
and  "Transmission  Lines  and  Crossings,"  Messrs.  Harwood  and  Coombs, 
respectively. 


509 


510  ELECTRICITY. 


CLEARANCES. 

At  the  last  meeting  of  the  Association  at  which  our  report  was  con- 
sidered it  was  decided  that  in  view  of  the  fact  that  the  American  Railway 
Association  had  a  Committee  on  Clearance  Lines  and  the  American  Elec- 
tric Railway  Engineering  Association  also  had  a  Committee  on  Clearance 
Lines,  and  because  of  the  fact  that  the  Committee  on  Electricity  had  not 
been  able  for  various  and  sundry  reasons  to  reach  conclusions  with  them 
and  agree  upon  lines  satisfactory  to  all  concerned,  to  accept  the  report  on 
clearance  as  one  of  progress  only,  with  the  idea  of  prior  to  the  next  meet- 
ing agreeing  with  the  other  associations  mentioned  upon  lines  that  would 
be  satisfactory  to  all. 

The  chairman  of  the  Sub-Committee  on  Clearances  has  subsequently 
been  in  communication  with  representatives  of  the  committees  of  the  other 
two  associations  mentioned  with  the  result  that  the  diagram  "A,"  shown 
on  page  525,  is  now  submitted  as  the  recommended  clearance  lines  for 
equipment  and  permanent  way  structures  adjacent  to  third  rail  and  for 
third  rail  structures. 

It  is  believed  that  similar  diagrams  will  be  recommended  to  the 
American  Railway  Association  by  the  Committee  on  Electric  Working  and 
by  the  Committee  considering  the  subject  of  Clearance  of  the  American 
Electric  Railway  Engineering  Association. 

Diagrams  have  been  obtained  from  all  the  principal  railwavs  in  the 
United  States  using  third  rail  showing  outlines  of  their  third  rail  struc- 
tures and  from  some  of  the  principal  steam  railroads  diagrams  showing 
outlines  of  maximum  equipment.  These  various  diagrams  are  made  a 
part  of  this  report  and  were  used  as  a  basis  in  establishing  clearance  lines 
for  third  rail  structures,  permanent  way  structures  adjacent  to  third  rail 
and  equipment. 

On  page  524  there  also  appears  a  table  showing  "Data  regarding 
Third  Rail  Clearances,"  which  is  made  a  part  of  this  report  and  which  has 
been  prepared  from  information  recently  received  from  various  companies 
with  a  view  of  ascertaining  what  proportion  of  track  mileage,  of  roads 
using  both  steam  and  electricity,  will  clear  the  recommended  clearance 
lines. 

From  an  inspection  of  this  table  it  will  be  noted  that  out  of  a  total 
mileage  of  1,988.04  using  steam  and  electricity,  9"3-8o  miles  will  clear.  It 
will  also  be  noted  that  the  mileage  not.  clearing  is  mainly  interurban  elec- 
tric roads  which  handle  steam  equipment  as  secondary  traffic  and  ele- 
vated roads  in  cities  which  do  not  handle  steam  equipment. 

At  the  last  meeting  of  the  Association  the  definition  for  "Third  Rail 
Gage"  as  follows  was  adopted : 

"Distance,  measured  parallel  to  plane  of  top  of  both  running  rails, 
between  gage  of  running  rail  and  center  line  of  third  rail." 

It  is  now  proposed  changing  the  definition  to  read  as  follows: 

"Third  Rail  Gage. — Distance  measured  parallel  to  plane  of  top  of  both 
running  rails  between  gage  of  nearest  running  rail  and  inside  gage  line  of 
third  rail." 


ELECTRICITY.  511 


TRANSMISSION    LINES    AND    CROSSINGS. 

The  Sub-Committee  Chairman,  Mr.  Coombs,  has  been  working  in 
conjunction  with  Committees  of  the  National  Electric  Light  Association, 
American  Institute  of  Electrical  Engineers,  American  Electric  Railway 
Association,  Association  of  Railway  Telegraph  Superintendents,  and  rep- 
resentatives of  the  telephone  and  telegraph  companies,  in  connection  with 
the  preparation  of  specifications  for  overhead  crossings  of  electric  light 
and  power  lines,  and  the  following  specification  is  submitted  which  is 
identical  with  the  specific  tions  that  have  been  adopted  by  the  other  asso- 
ciations mentioned,  excepting  in  paragraphs  Nos.  10,  13,  18,  24,  29,  31,  32, 
34,  45,  49,  51,  55,  60  and  61,  which  changes  it  will  be  noted  by  comparing 
the  specifications  are  in  line  with  more  clearly  expressing  the  condition 
or  of  making  them  more  satisfactory  from  the  point  of  view  cf  the  rail- 
roads. 

For  the  convenience  of  the  members  the  paragraphs  mentioned  are 
given  as  Appendix  "B"  to  this  report  in  the  form  in  which  they  have  been 
adopted  by  the  other  associations  mentioned  above. 


RECOMMENDATIONS. 

(A)  The  Committee  recommends  for  adoption  by  the  Association: 

(1)  Definition:  "Third  Rail  Gage. — Distance  measured  parallel  to 
plane  of  top  of  both  running  rails  between  gage  of  nearest  running  rail 
and  inside  gage  line  of  third  rail." 

(2)  The  lines  shown  on  diagram  "A"  as  equipment  clearance  lines. 

(3)  The  lines  shown  on  diagram  "A"  as  permanent  way  structure 
adjacent  to  third  rail  clearance  lines. 

(4)  The  lines  shown  on  diagram  "A"  as  third  rail  structure  clear- 
ance lines. 

(5)  The  adoption  of  the  Specifications  for  Overhead  Crossings  of 
Electric  Light  and  Power  Lines. 

(B)  The  Committee  recommends  a  continuation  of  work  already  out- 
lined, particularly  consideration  of  clearance  for  overhead  third  rail  work- 
ing conductors,  electrolysis  and  insulation  and  the  consideration  of  any  new 
information  that  may  develop  in  reference  to  maintenance  organization  and 
relation  of  track  structures,  and  asks  for  such  other  direction  or  instruc- 
tions as  seem  necessary  or  desirable. 

Respectfully  submitted  for  the  Committee, 

George  W.  Kittredge, 

Chairman. 


Appendix   A. 

*SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  OVERHEAD  CROSSINGS  OF  ELECTRIC 
LIGHT  AND  POWER  LINES. 

GENERAL  REQUIREMENTS. 

Scope. 

1.  These  specifications  shall  apply  to  overhead  electric  light  and 
power  line  crossings  (except  trolley  contact  wires),  over  railroad  right-of- 
way,  tracks,  or  lines  of  wires ;  and,  further,  these  specifications  shall  apply 
to  overhead  electric  light  and  power  wires  of  over  5,oco  volts  constant 
potential,  crossing,  or  constructed  over  telephone,  telegraph  or  other  similar 
lines. 

Location. 

2.  The  poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span  preferably  shall 
be  outside  the  railroad  company's  right-of-way. 

3.  Unusually  long  crossing  spans  shall  be  avoided  wherever  prac- 
ticable. 

4.  The  poles,  or  towers,  shall  be  located  as  far  as  practicable  from 
inflammable  material  or  structures. 

5.  The  poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span,  and  the  adjoin- 
ing span  on  each  side,  preferably  shall  be  in  a  straight  line. 

6.  The  wires,  or  cables,  shall  cross  over  telegraph,  telephone  and  simi- 
lar wires  wherever  practicable. 

7.  Cradles,  or  overhead  bridges,  shall  not  be  used. 
C'sarance. 

8.  The  side  clearance  shall  be  not  less  than  12  ft.  from  the  nearest 
rail  of  main-line  track,  nor  less  than  6  ft.  from  the  nearest  rail  of 
sidings.    At  loading  sidings  sufficient  space  shall  be  left  for  a  driveway. 

9.  The  clear  headroom  shall  be  not  less  than  30  ft.  above  the  top  of 
rail  under  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  temperature  and  loading. 
For  constant  potential,  direct-current  circuits,  not  exceeding  750  volts, 
when  paralleled  by  trolley  contact  wires,  the  clear  headroom  need  not  ex- 
ceed 25  ft. 

10.  The  clearance  of  alternating-current  circuits  above  any  existing 
wires,  under  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  temperature  and  load- 
ing, shall  be  not  less  than  8  ft.  wherever  practicable.  For  constant 
potential,  direct-current  circuits,  not  exceeding  750  volts,  the  minimum 
clearance  above  telegraph,  telephone  and  similar  wires  may  be  2  ft.  with 
insulated  wires  and  4  ft.  with  bare  wires. 

11.  The  separation  of  conductors  carrying  alternating  current,  sup- 
ported by  pin  insulators,  for  spans  not  exceeding  150  ft.,  shall  be  not  less 
than: 

Line  Voltage.  Separation. 

Not  exceeding  6,600  volts 14V?.  in. 

Exceeding    6,600,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 24      in. 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000 30      in. 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35,000 36      in. 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 45       in. 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  70,000 60       in. 

*For  amendments,   see  index. 

512 


ELECTRICITY.  513 

For  spans  exceeding  150  ft.  the  pin  spacing  should  be  increased, 
depending  upon  the  length  of  the  span  and  the  sag  of  the  conductors. 

Note. — This  requirement  does  not  apply  to  wires  of  the  same  phase 
or  polarity  between  which  there  is  no  difference  of  potential. 

With  constant  potential,  direct-current  circuits  not  exceeding  750 
volts,   the   minimum   spacing   shall   be    10   in. 

12.  When  supported,  by  insulators  of  the  disc  or  suspension  type,  the 
crossing  span  and  the  next  adjoining  spans  shall  be  dead-ended  at  the 
poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span,  so  that  at  these  poles, 
or  towers,  the  insulators  shall  be  used  as  strain  insulators. 

13.  The  clearance  in  any  direction  between  the  conductors  nearest 
the  pole,  or  tower,  and  the  pole  or  tower  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line   Voltage.  Clearance. 

Not  exceeding  10,000  volts  9  in. 

Exceeding  10,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 12  in. 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000. 15  in. 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35,000 18  in. 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 21  in. 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  70,000 24  in. 

Conductors. 

14.  The  normal  mechanical  tension  in  the  conductors  generally  shall 
be  the  same  in  the  crossing  span  and  in  the  adjoining  span  on  each  side, 
and  the  difference  in  length  of  the  crossing  and  adjoining  spans  gen- 
erally shall  be  not  more  than  50  per  cent,  of  the  length  of  the  crossing 
span. 

15.  The  conductors  shall  not  be  spliced  in  the  crossing  span  nor  in 
the  adjoining  span  on  either  side. 

16.  The  method  of  supporting  the  conductors  at  the  poles,  or 
towers,  shall  be  such  as  to  hold  the  wires,  under  maximum  loading,  to 
the  supporting  structures,  in  case  of  shattered  insulators,  or  wires 
broken  or  burned  at  an  insulator,  without  allowing  an  amount  of  slip 
which  would  materially  reduce  the  clearance  specified  in  paragraphs 
No.  9  and  No.  10. 

Guys. 

17.  Wooden  poles  supporting  the  crossing  span  shall  be  side-guyed  in 
both  directions  if  practicable,  and  be  head-guyed  away  from  the  crossing 
span.  The  next  adjoining  poles  shall  be  head-guyed  in  both  directions. 
Braces  may  be  used  instead  of  guys. 

18.  Strain  insulators  shall  be  used  in  guys  from  wooden  poles  carry- 
ing any  power  wire  of  less  than  6,600  volts,  provided  the  guys  are  not 
through  grounded  to  permanently  damp  earth.  Strain  insulators  shall 
not  be  used  in  guying  steel  structures,  nor  required  on  wooden  poles 
carrying  wires,  all  of  which  are  6,600  volts  or  more,  provided  the  guys 
are  through  grounded  to  permanently  damp  earth. 

Clearing.  "', ■"■-.] 

19.  The  space  around  the  poles,  or  towers,  shall  be  kept  free  from 
inflammable  material,   underbrush  and   grass. 


514  ELECTRICITY. 

Signs. 

20.  In  the   case   of   railroad   crossings,   if   required   by  the    railroad 
company,   warning  signs   of  an   approved   design   shall  be  placed   on   all 
poles  and  towers  located  on  the  railroad  company's  right-of-way. 
Grounding. 

21.  For  voltages  over  5,000  volts,  wooden  crossarms,  if  used,  shall 
be  provided  with  a  grounded  metallic  plate  on  top  of  the  arm,  which  shall 
be  not  less  than  H-in.  in  thickness  and  which  shall  have  a  sectional  area 
and  conductivity  not  less  than  that  of  the  line  conductor.  Metal  pins 
shall  be  electrically  connected  to  this  ground.  Metal  poles  and  metal 
arms  on  wooden  poles  shall  be  grounded. 

22.  The  electrical  conductivity  of  the  ground  conductor  shall  be  ad- 
justed to  the  short-circuit  current  capacity  of  the   system  and   shall  be 
not  less  than  that  of  a  No.  4  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  wire. 
Temperature. 

23.  In  the  computation  of  stresses  and  clearances,  and  in  erection, 
provision  shall  be  made  for  a  variation  in  temperature  from  — 20  de- 
grees Fahrenheit  to  +  120  degrees  Fahrenheit.  A  suitable  modification 
in  the  temperature  requirements  shall  be  made  for  regions  in  which 
the  above  limits  would  not  fairly  represent  the  extreme  range  of 
temperature. 

Inspection. 

24.  If  required  by  contract,  all  material  and  workmanship  shall  be 
subject  to  the  inspection  of  the  company  crossed;  provided,  that  reasonable 
notice  of  the  intention  to  make  shop  inspection  shall  be  given  by  such 
company;  if  such  notification  is  not  given,  the  company  crossed  shall  be 
furnished  with  certified  reports  of  shop  inspection  of  material  and  work- 
manship made  by  a  properly  qualified  inspector.  Defective  material  shall 
be  rejected,  and  shall  be  removed  and  replaced  with  suitable  material. 

25.  On  the  completion .  of  the  work,  all  false  work,  plant  and  rub- 
bish, incident  to  the  construction,  shall  be  removed  promptly  and  the  site 
left  unobstructed  and  clean. 

Drawings. 

26.  If  required,   by  contract,    (  ) 

complete    sets    of   general    and    detail    drawings    shall    be    furnished    for 
approval,    before    any    construction    is    commenced. 

LOADS. 

27.  The  conductors  shall  be  considered  as  uniformly  loaded  through- 
out their  length,  with  a  load  equal  to  the  resultant  of  the  dead  load  plus 
the  weight  of  a  layer  of  ice  ^2-in.  in  thickness,  and  a  wind  pressure  of 
8  lbs.  per  sq.  ft.  on  the  ice-covered  diameter,  at  a  temperature  of  o 
degrees  Fahrenheit. 

28.  The  weight  of  ice  shall  be  assumed  as  57  lbs.  per  cu.  ft. 
(0.033  lbs.  per  cu.  in.). 

29.  Insulators,  pins  and  conductor  attachments  shall  be  designed  to 
withstand,  with  the  designated  factor  of  safety,  the  tension  in  the  con- 


ELECTRICITY.  515 

ductors    under    the    maximum    loading,    assuming    the    conductor    to    be 
broken  on  one  side  of  the  structure. 

30.  The  pole,  or  towers,  shall  be  designed  to  withstand,  with  the 
designated  factor  of  safety,  the  combined  stresses  from  their  own  weight, 
the  wind  pressure  on  the  pole,  or  tower,  and  the  above  wire  loading  on 
the  crossing  span  and  the  next  adjoining  span  on  each  side.  The  wind 
pressure  on  the  poles,  or  towers,  shall  be  assumed  at  13  lbs.  per  sq.  ft. 
on  the  projected  area  of  solid  or  closed  structures,  and  on  iVz  times  the 
projected  area  of  latticed  structures. 

31.  The  poles,  or  towers,  shall  also  be  designed  to  withstand  the  most 
unfavorable  condition  of  the  loads  specified  in  paragraph  30,  combined 
with  the  unbalanced  tension  of 

Two  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  5  wires  or  less. 
Three  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  6  to  10  wires. 
Four  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  11  or  more  wires. 

32.  Crossarms  shall  be  designed  to  withstand  the  loading  specified 
in  paragraph  30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  tension  of  the  wire,  which, 
when  broken,  produces  the  highest  fiber  stress  in  the  arm. 

33.  The  poles,  or  towers,  may  be  permitted  a  reasonable  deflection 
under  the  specified  loading,  provided  that  such  deflection  does  not  reduce 
the  clearances  specified  in  paragraph  No.  10  more  than  25  per  cent,  or 
produce  stresses  in  excess  of  those  specified  in  paragraphs  Nos.  65  to  69. 

FACTORS  OF  SAFETY. 

34.  The  ultimate  unit  stress  divided  by  the  allowable  stress  shall  be 
not  less  than  the  following : 

Wires  and  cables 2 

Pins  2 

Insulators,    conductor   attachments,    guys 3 

Wooden  poles  and  crossarms 6 

Structural  steel 3 

Reinforced  concrete  poles  and  crossarms 4 

Foundations  2 

Note. — The  treating  of  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  is  recommended. 
The  treatment  of  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  should  be  by  thorough 
impregnation  with  preservative  by  either  closed  or  open-tank  process. 
For  poles,  except  in  the  case  of  yellow  pine,  the  treatment  need  not  ex- 
tend higher  than  a  point  2  ft.  above  the  ground  line. 

Insulators. 

35.  Insulators  for  line  voltages  of  less  than  9,000  shall  not  flash  over 
at  four  times  the  normal  working  voltage,  under  a  precipitation  of  water 
of  1/5  of  an  in.  per  minute,  at  an  inclination  of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of 
the  insulator. 

36.  Each  separate  part  of  a  built-up  insulator,  for  line  voltages  over 
9,000,  shall  be  subjected  to  the  dry  flash-over  test  of  that  part  for  five 
consecutive  minutes. 

37.  Each  assembled  and  cemented  insulator  shall  be  subjected  to  its 
drv  flash-over  test  for  five  consecutive  minutes. 


516  ELECTRICITY. 

The   dry  flash-over  test  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Test  Voltage. 

Exceeding    9,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000.  . . .  65,000 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000.  ..  .  100,000 
Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35,000.  ..  .  125,000 
Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000. ..  .  150.000 
Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  60,000.  . .  .  180,000 
Exceeding  60,000 3  times  line  voltage 

Each  insulator  shall  further  be  so  designed  that,  with  excessive  po- 
tential, failure  will  first  occur  by  flash-over  and  not  by  puncture. 

38.  Each  assembled  insulator  shall  be  subjected  to  a  wet  flash-over 
test,  under  a  precipitation  of  water  of  1-5  in.  per  minute,  at  an  inclination 
of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of  the  insulator. 

The  wet  flash-over  test  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Test  Voltage 

Exceeding    9,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000.  ..  40.000 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000.  . .  60,000 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35,000. . .  80,000 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000.  . .  100,000 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  60,000.  . .  120,000 

Exceeding  60,000 twice  the  line  voltage. 

39.  Test  voltages  above  35,000  volts  shall  be  determined  by  the 
A.  I.  E.  E.  Standard  Spark-Gap  Method. 

40.  Test  voltages  below  35,000  volts  shall  be  determined  by  trans- 
former ratio. 

MATERIAL. 
Conductors. 

41.  The  conductors  shall  be  of  copper,  aluminum,  or  other  non- 
corrodible  material,  except  that  in  exceptionally  long  spans,  where  the 
required  mechanical  strength  cannot  be  obtained  with  the  above  ma- 
terials, galvanized  or  copper-covered  steel  strand  may  be  used. 

42.  For  voltages  not  exceeding  750  volts,  solid  or  stranded  con- 
ductors may  be  used  up  to  and  including  4/0  in  size ;  above  4/0 
in  size,  stranded  conductors  shall  be  used.  For  voltages  exceeding  750 
volts,  and  not  exceeding  5,000  volts,  solid  or  stranded  conductors  may  be 
used  up  to  and  including  2/0  in  size;  above  2/0  in  size,  conductors 
shall  be  stranded.  For  voltages  exceeding  5,000  volts,  all  conductors 
shall  be  stranded.  Aluminum  conductors  for  all  voltages  and  sizes  shall 
be  stranded. 

The  minimum   size  of  conductors   shall  be   as   follows : 
No.  6  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  for  voltages  not  exceeding  5,000  volts. 
No.  4  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  for  voltages  exceeding  5,000  volts. 
No.  1  B.  &  S.  gage  aluminum  for  all  voltages. 
Insulators. 

43.  Insulators  shall  be  of  porcelain  for  voltages  exceeding  5,000 
volts. 


ELECTRICITY.  517 

44-  Strain  insulators  for  guys  shall  have  an  ultimate  strength  of 
not  less  than  twice  that  of  the  guy  in  which  placed.  Strain  insulators  shall 
be  so  constructed  that  the  guy  wires  holding  the  insulator  in  position 
will   interlock   in   case  of  the   failure  of  the   insulator. 

Strain  insulators  for  guys  shall  not  flash  over  at  four  times  the 
maximum  line  voltage,  under  a  precipitation  of  water  of  1/5  in.  per  min- 
ute, at  an  inclination  of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of  the  insulator. 

Pins. 

45.  For  voltages  of  5,000  and  over,  insulator  pins  shall  be  steel, 
wrought  iron,  malleable  iron,  or  other  approved  metal  or  alloy,  and  shall 
be  galvanized,  or  otherwise  protected  from  corrosion.  Pins  shall  be  locked 
with  cotter,  nut,  or  other  device,  to  prevent  raising  out  of  the  socket  or 
hole  in  the  crossarm. 

Guys. 

46.  Guys  shall  be  galvanized  or  copper-covered  stranded  steel  cable, 
not  less  than  5/16-in.  in  diameter,  or  galvanized  rolled  rods  of  equivalent 
tensile  strength. 

47.  Guys  to  the  ground  shall  connect  to  a  galvanized  anchor  rod, 
extending  at  least  one  foot  above  the  ground  level. 

48.  The  detail  of  the  anchorage  shall  be  definitely  shown  upon  the 
plans. 

Wooden  Poles. 

49.  Wooden  poles  shall  be  of  selected  timber  of  approved  species, 
peeled,  free  from  defects  which  would  decrease  their  strength  or  durability, 
not  less  than  7  in.  minimum  diameter  at  the  top,  and  meeting  the  re- 
quirments  as  specified  in  paragraphs  17,  30,  31  and  34. 

Concrete. 

50.  All  concrete  and  concrete  material  shall  be  in  accordance  with 
the  requirements  of  the  Report  of  the  Joint  Committee  on  Concrete 
and   Reinforced   Concrete. 

STRUCTURAL    STEEL. 

51.  Structural  steel  shall  be  open-hearth,  in  accordance  with  the 
Manufacturers'  Standard  Specifications. 

52.  The  design  and  workmanship  shall  be  strictly  in  accordance 
with   first-class   practice. 

53.  The  form  of  the  frame  shall  be  such  that  the  stresses  may  be  com- 
puted with  reasonable  accuracy,  or  the  strength  shall  be  determined  by 
actual  test. 

54.  The  sections  used  shall  permit  inspection,  cleaning  and  painting, 
and  shall  be  free  from  pockets  in  which  water  or  dirt  can  collect. 

55.  The  length  of  a  main  compression  member  shall  not  exceed  150 
times  its  least  radius  of  gyration.  The  length  of  a  secondary  compression 
member  shall  not  exceed  180  times  its  least  radius  of  gyration. 

56.  The  minimum  thickness  of-  metal  in  galvanized  structures  shall 


518  ELECTRICITY. 

be   %-in.   for   main   members,   and    %-in.    for   secondary   members.     The 
minimum  thickness  of  painted  material  shall  be  J-4-in. 

PROTECTIVE  COATINGS. 

57.  All  structural  steel  shall  be  thoroughly  cleaned  at  the  shop 
and  be  galvanized,  or  given  one  coat  of  approved  paint. 

Painted  Material. 

58.  All  contact  surfaces  shall  be  given  one  coat  of  paint  before 
assembling. 

All  painted  structural  steel  shall  be  given  two  field  coats  of  an 
approved  paint. 

The   surface   of  the   metal   shall   be   thoroughly   cleaned   of   all    dirt, 
grease,    scale,    etc.,    before   painting,    and    no    painting   shall    be    done    in 
freezing  or  rainy  weather. 
Galvanized  Material. 

59.  Galvanized  material  shall  be  in  accordance  with  the  Specifica- 
tions for  Galvanizing  Iron  and  Steel   (Appendix). 

Bolt  holes  in  galvanized  material  shall  be  made  before  galvanizing. 

FOUNDATIONS. 

60.  The  foundations  for  steel  poles  and  towers  shall  be  designed  to 
prevent  overturning. 

The  weight  of  concrete  shall  be  assumed  as  140  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  In 
good  ground,  the  weight  of  "earth"  shall  be  assumed  at  100  lbs.  per  cu.  ft. 
In  swampy  ground,  special  measures  shall  be  taken  to  prevent  uplift  or 
depression. 

61.  The  top  of  the  concrete  foundation,  or  casing,  shall  be  not  less 
than  12  in.  above  the  surface  of  the  ground  or  extreme  high  water. 

62.  When  located  in  swampy  ground,  wooden  crossing  and  next  ad- 
joining poles  shall  be  set  in  barrels  of  broken  stone  or  gravel,  or  in 
broken  stone  or  timber  footings. 

63.  When  located  in  the  sides  of  banks,  or  when  subject  to  washouts, 
foundations  shall  be  given  additional  depth,  or  be  protected  by  cribbing 
or  riprap. 

64.  All  foundations  and  pole  settings  shall  be  tamped  in  6-in.  layers, 
while  back  filling. 

WORKING  UNIT  STRESSES. 

Obtained  by  dividing  the  ultimate  breaking  strength  by  the  factors  of 
safety  given  in  paragraph  34. 

Structural  Steel. 

Lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

65.  Tension   (net  section)    18,000 

Shear   14,000  1 

Compression   18,000  —  60  - 


ELECTRICITY. 


519 


Rivets,  Pins. 

66.  Shear 10,000 

Bearing   20>°°0 

Bending  20>oo° 

Bolts. 

67.  Shear    8>5QO 

Bearing   T7.ooo 

Bending  17,000 

Wires  and  Cables. 

Lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

68.  Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  4/0,  3/0,  2/0.  .25,000 

Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  1/0 27,500 

Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  No.  t 28,500 

Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  No.  2,  4,  6.  ...30,000 

Copper,  soft-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S 17,000 

Copper,  hard-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S 30,000 

Copper,  soft-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S 17,000 

Aluminum,  hard-dr'n,  stranded,  B.  &  S.  gage  under  4/0.-12,000 
Aluminum,  hard-dr'n,  stranded,  B.  &  S.  gage  4/0  and 

nvPr         ".SOO 


Untreated  Timber. 

Bending. 

69.     Eastern  white  cedar 600  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Chestnut    850  lbs.  per  sq.  in . 

Washington  cedar 850  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Idaho    cedar    850  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Port  Orford  cedar 1150  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Long-leaf  yellow  pine 1100  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Short-leaf  yellow  pine   .  .  05O  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Douglas  fir  1000  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

White  oak 95©  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Red    cedar    700  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Bald   cypress    (heartw'd)  800  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Redwood    ..'..'. 850  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

Catalpa    500  lbs.  per  sq.  in . 

Juniper  550  lbs.  per  sq.  in . 

L— Length  in  inches. 

D  =  Least  side,  or  diameter,  in  inches. 


Compression. 

L 


.    600   ( 
.    850 

•  850 

•  850 
■  1150 
.IIOO 

•  950 
.1000 

.  950 

.  700 
.  800 

.  850 

.  500 

550 


60  01 


SPECIFICATION  FOR  GALVANIZING  FOR  IRON  OR  STEEL. 

These  specifications  give  in  detail  the  test  to  be  applied  to  galvanized 
material.     All  specimens  shall  be  capable  of  withstanding  these  tests. 


520  ELECTRICITY. 

Coating. 

(A)  The  galvanizing  shall  consist  of  a  continuous  coating  of  pure 
zinc  of  uniform  thickness,  and  so  applied  that  it  adheres  firmly  to  the 
surface  of  the  iron  or  steel.    The  finished  product  shall  be  smooth. 

Cleaning. 

(B)  The  samples  shall  be  cleaned  before  testing,  first  with  car- 
bona,  benzine  or  turpentine  and  cotton  waste  (not  with  a  brush),  and 
then  thoroughly  rinsed  in  clean  water  and  wiped  dry  with  clean  cotton 
waste. 

The  sample  shall  be  clean  and  dry  before  each  immersion  in  the 
solution. 

Solution. 

(C)  The  standard  solution  of  copper  sulphate  shall  consist  of  com- 
mercial copper  sulphate  crystals  dissolved  in  cold  water,  about  in  the 
proportion  of  36  parts,  by  weight,  of  crystals  to  100  parts,  by  weight,  of 
water.  The  solution  shall  be  neutralized  by  the  addition  of  an  excess  of 
chemically  pure  cupric  oxide  (Cu  O).  The  presence  of  an  excess  of  cupric 
oxide  will  be  shown  by  the  sediment  of  this  reagent  at  the  bottom  of  the 
containing  vessel. 

The  neutralized  solution  shall  be  filtered  before  using  by  passing 
through  filter  paper.  The  filtered  solution  shall  have  a  specific  gravity  of 
1. 186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit  (reading  the  scale  at  the  level  of  the 
solution)  at  the  beginning  of  each  test.  In  case  the  filtered  solution  is 
high  in  specific  gravity,  clean  water  shall  be  added  to  reduce  the  specific 
gravity  at  1.186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit.  In  case  the  filtered  solution  is 
low  in  specific  gravity,  filtered  solution  of  a  higher  specific  gravity  shall 
be  added  to  make  the  specific  gravity  1.186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit. 

As  soon  as  the  stronger  solution  is  taken  from  the  vessel  containing 
the  unfiltered  neutralized  stock  solution,  additional  crystals  and  water 
must  be  added  to  the  stock  solution.  An  excess  of  cupric  oxide  shall 
always  be  kept   in  the   unfiltered   stock  solution. 

Quantity  of  Solution. 

(D)  Wire  samples  shall  be  tested  in  a  glass  jar  of  at  least  2  in.  in- 
side diameter.  The  jar  without  the  wire  samples  shall  be  filled  with 
standard  solution  to  a  depth  of  at  least  4  in.  Hardware  samples  shall 
be  tested  in  a  glass  or  earthenware  jar  containing  at  least  :/2  pint  of 
standard  solution  for  each  hardware  sample. 

Solution  shall  not  be  used  for  more  than  one  series  of  four 
immersions. 

Samples. 

(E)  Not  more  than  seven  wires  shall  be  simultaneously  immersed, 
and  not  more  than  one  sample  of  galvanized  material  other  than  wire  shall 
be  immersed  in  the  specified  quantity  of  solution. 

The  samples  shall  not  be  grouped  or  twisted  together,  but  shall  be 


ELECTRICITY.  521 

well  separated  so  as  to  permit  the  action  of  the  solution  to  be  uniform 
upon  all  immersed  portions  of  the  samples. 

Test. 

(F)  Clean  and  dry  samples  shall  be  immersed  in  the  required 
quantity  of  standard  solution  in  accordance  with  the  following  cycle 
of  immersions. 

The  temperature  of  the  solution  shall  be  maintained  between  62 
degrees  and  68  degrees  Fahrenheit  at  all  times  during  the  following  test: 

(1)  Immerse   for  one  minute,   wash   and   wipe   dry. 

(2)  Immerse  for  one  minute,  wash   and  wipe   dry. 

(3)  Immerse   for  one  minute,   wash   and   wipe   dry. 

(4)  Immerse   for   one   minute,   wash   and  wipe  dry. 

After  each  immersion  the  samples  shall  be  immediately  washed  in 
clean  water  having  a  temperature  between  62  degrees  and  68  degrees 
Fahrenheit,  and  wiped   dry  with   cotton   waste. 

In  the  case  of  No.  14  galvanized  iron  or  steel  wire,  the  time  of  the 
fourth  immersion  shall  be  reduced  to  V2  minute. 

Rejection. 

(G)  If  after  the  test  described  in  section  (F)  there  should  be 
a  bright  metallic  copper  deposit  upon  the  samples,  the  lot  represented 
by  the  sample  shall  be  rejected. 

Copper  deposits  on  zinc  or  within  1  in.  of  the  cut  end  shall  not 
be  considered  causes  for  rejection. 

In  the  case  of  a  failure  of  only  one  wire  in  a  group  of  seven  wires 
immersed  together,  or  if  there  is  a  reasonable  doubt  as  to  the  copper 
deposit,  two  check  tests  shall  be  made  on  these  seven  wire-;  and  the 
lot  reported  in  accordance  with  the  majority  of  the  sets  of  tests. 

Note.— The  equipment  necessary  for  the  tests  herein  outlined  is  as 
follows : 

Filter  paper. 

Commercial   copper   sulphate   crystals. 

Chemically  pure   cupric   oxide    (Cu   O). 

Running  water. 

Warm  water  or  ice,  as  per  needs. 

Carbona,   benzine   or   turpentine 

Glass  jars  at  least  2  in.  inside  diameter  by  at  least  41/   in.  high. 

Glass  or  earthenware  jars  for  hardware  samples. 

Vessel  for  washing  samples. 

Tray  for  holding  jars  of  stock  solution. 

Jars,  bottles  and  porcelain  basket  for   stock  solution. 

Cotton  waste. 

Hydrometer  cylinder  3  in.  diameter  by  15  in.  high. 

Thermometer  with  large  Fahrenheit  scale  correct  at  62  and  68  degrees. 

Hydrometer   correct   at    1.186   at   65   degrees   Fahrenheit. 


Appendix  B. 

PARAGRAPHS   IN    SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  OVERHEAD   CROSS- 
ING OF  ELECTRIC  LIGHT  AND   POWER  LINES  AS 
ADOPTED  BY  OTHER  ASSOCIATIONS  RE- 
FERRED TO  IN  REPORT  OF  COMMIT- 
TEE ON  ELECTRICITY. 

10.  The  clearance  of  alternating-current  circuits  above  any  existing 
wires,  under  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  temperature  and  loading, 
shall  be  not  less  than  8  ft.  wherever  possible.  For  constant  potential, 
direct-current  circuits,  not  exceeding  750  volts,  the  minimum  clearance 
above  telegraph,  telephone  and  similar  wires  may  be  2  ft.  with  insulated 
wires  and  4  ft.  with  bare  wires. 

13.  The  clearance  in  any  direction  between  the  conductors  nearest 
the  pole,  or  tower,  and  the  pole,  or  tower,  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Clearances. 

Not  exceeding  14,000  volts 9  in. 

Exceeding  14,000  but  not  exceeding  27,000 15  in. 

Exceeding  27,000  but  not  exceeding  35,000 18  in. 

Exceeding  35,000  but  not  exceeding  47,000 21  in. 

Exceeding  47,000  but  not  exceeding  70,000 24  in. 

18.  Strain  insulators  shall  be  used  in  guys  from  wooden  poles  carry- 
ing any  power  wire  of  less  than  6,600  volts.  Strain  insulators  shall  not 
be  used  in  guying  steel  structures,  nor  required  on  wooden  poles  carry- 
ing wires  all  of  which  are  6,600  volts  or  more. 

Inspection. 

24.  If  required  by  contract,  all  material  and  workmanship  shall  be 
subject  to  the  inspection  of  the  company  crossed;  provided  that  reason- 
able notice  of  the  intention  to  make  shop  inspection  shall  be  given  by  such 
company.  Defective  material  shall  be  rejected,  and  shall  be  removed  and 
replaced  with  suitable  material. 

29.  Insulators,  pins  and  conductor  attachments  shall  be  designed  to 
withstand,  with  the  designated  factor  of  safety,  the  tension  in  the  con- 
ductors under  the  maximum  loading. 

31.  The  poles,  or  towers,  shall  also  be  designed  to  withstand  the 
loads  specified  in  paragraph  No.  30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  ten- 
sion of: 

Two  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  5  wires  or  less. 
Three  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  6  to  10  wires. 
Four  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  11  or  more  wires. 

32.  Crossarms  shall  be  designed  to  withstand  the  loading  specified 
in  paragraph  No.  30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  tension  of  one  wire 
broken  at  the  pin  farthest  from  the  pole. 

34.  The  ultimate  unit  stress  divided  by  the  allowable  unit  stress  shall 
be  not  less  than  the  following : 

522 


ELECTRICITY.  523 

Wires  and  cables 2 

Pins    2 

Insulator,  conductor  attachments,  guys 3 

Wooden  poles  and  crossarms 6 

Structural  steel  3 

Reinforced  concrete  poles  and  crossarms 4 

Foundations    2 

Note: — The  use  of  treated  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  is  recom- 
mended. The  treatment  of  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  should  be  by 
thorough  impregnation  with  preservative  by  either  closed  or  open-tank 
process.  For  poles,  except  in  the  case  of  yellow  pine,  the  treatment  need 
not  extend  higher  than  a  point  2  ft.  above  the  ground  line. 

Pins. 

45.     For  voltages  of  5,000  and  over,  insulator  pins  shall  be  of  steel, 
wrought  iron,  malleable  iron,  or  other  approved  metal  or  alloy,  and  shall  be 
galvanized,  or  otherwise  protected  from  corrosion. 
Wooden  Poles. 

49.  Wooden  poles  shall  be  of  selected  timber,  peeled,  free  from  de- 
fects which  would  decrease  their  strength  or  durability,  not  less  than  7  in. 
minimum  diameter  at  the  top,  and  meeting  the  requirements  as  specified 
in  paragraphs  17,  30,  31  and  34. 

51.  Structural  steel  shall  be  in  accordance  with  the  Manufacturers' 
Standard  Specifications. 

55.  The  length  of  a  main  compression  member  shall  not  exceed  180 
times  its  least  radius  of  gyration.  The  length  of  a  secondary  compres- 
sion member  shall  not  exceed  220  times  its  least  radius  of  gyration. 

60.  The  foundations  for  steel  poles  and  towers  shall  be  designed  to 
prevent  overturning. 

The  weight  of  concrete  shall  be  assumed  as  140  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  In 
good  ground,  the  weight  of  "earth"  (calculated  at  30  degrees  from  the 
vertical)  shall  be  assumed  as  100  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  In  swampy  ground, 
special  measures  shall  be  taken  to  prevent  uplift  or  depression. 

61.  The  top  of  the  concrete  foundation,  or  casing,  shall  be  not  less 
than  6  in.  above  the  surface  of  the  ground,  nor  less  than  1  ft.  above  ex- 
treme high  water. 


;24 


ELECTRICITY. 


boc  <u  ID 

so£ 


o 

:o 

.   ;0 

:   :   '. «   : 

:<m   . 

o 

.  t- 

.    .0 

.   .   .0   . 

.  in    : 

.00   . 

:o   . 

1a 

"oo 

•      '  LO 

'    *  to    ■ 

'  Tf      • 

"in    • 

"C5      " 

CO 

"      '  ^f 

•  ■     -to     • 

*  *    '  1-i     ' 

;o3    ; 

;to    • 

•«<      laai 


O  N  O  O  C-l 

OlOlflOCO 


•OOO  to  b- 

■  eooi  to  icci 

•"•*  <M  *<^  Or-t 

•iH        <M  rH 


0)T3 

b04)         13  ® 

•2goS5 


:       :    :    ■  0    :    •    • 

:    :  0       :    :    -    : 

■ «    .    .    .    . 

.    .   :©    .   •    : 

.    . co       .    .    ;    . 

c-i    '    '    '    ' 

•    •    -ci    '    ■    • 

■    "o         •    •    .    • 

;    ;oj        ;    ;    •    ; 

d  c  ^  fl 
~        ft"" 


O  <N>  o  O  <M      •  ,_|  O  O  ' 


•^''•W^        OH^O 


y  02  t,     •  B3 

3  <u  ca  fto) 


<Z-~Z-  -  ^    z- 


O    (1) 


Q    d 

8  -8 

H   fc 

hr      0) 

Q    > 

g* 

0 

H 

Q 


m  Cp,c 

W  ID  3  a 


-     £-     -     bH         Z-     -     (H-     Z>H 


:  o 


O  4) 
Z>H 


1  "O 

P4  0) 


(HA*    "    fH 


4>  ft 

■a  o 


■^1 


T-lC"lCO-^i^,cot^        00OH- 


Oo 


i+S  > 


5  £2 


4>'£ 

5o5i 

02  O  fe  G 

PQPQZU 


01  s. 

ri  to 


« 


•1« 

^  c 
c  3i£ 

o   K 


"d  O    :M 

;  dp-      ai  a)  1- 
5.JJSSZ     Oh 


O 


o 


;    «a     o 

"a      >>d 
C  d^Pn 

^  d  c 


4>n»    . 

o-gdcs™b  . 


■so 


® 


H  d  >, 

01  4>_i 
O  •"  *^  Co 

tni:     d 

O  -i'O 

>.  n.„ 
'  cwj:  C 


ELECTRICITY. 


525 


4-/i't>J  6a/<jurij  /sajp&u  jo  ab'ec)' 


s«* 


I 


b^o  b  I 

<5  S  5  Si  ^§    S     * 

*|l  5.1 

£  ?  1>  £*£  °N  «      N 


Is 

11 

■§*§ 

I* 

r& 


^ 


*, 


At  ^  I 

M«i  til 

*  Jill  Rt  { 

vNllil  ft!  * 


«  ^ 


*  9 

H 

I 


526 


ELECTRICITY. 


te* 


Hi 

I 


ELECTRICITY. 


527 


52S 


ELECTRICITY. 


ELECTRICITY. 


529 


/ts#j£>  eberiQ 


aSenQ-f 


Is 

3 


530 


ELECTRICITY. 


J 


I 


~7- 


/ 


J 


ELECTRICITY. 


531 


//0j£c//t/ur>SJO  &&/>&£)  , 


532 


ELECTRICITY. 


<0 

! 


ELECTRICITY. 


533 


im/p*6*"*)-} 


534 


ELECTRICITY. 


ELECTRICITY. 


535 


536 


ELECTRICITY. 


23_RRs_S\.     .__/__  ~JE&—  -S3_ 4I_ J. 23 I JR.R 


1484494 


63373 


1231734 


3771975 


2049551 


Total  Number  of  Failures 


16799 


1039957 


Tons  Laid 
224331 


CLASSIFIED  RAIL  FAILURES  DIAGRAM  I. 

Comparison  between  different  WEIGHTS  OF  RAIL. 

BESSEMER  STEEL 
Record  for  Period  of  One  Year  ending  Oct.  31. 1910. 

See  Sheets  Nos.  72.  73  and  74  for  names  of  Railroads  and  Tons  Laid. 


15  RRs. 
TbnsLaid 
289 1 55 


—  22. 

629647 


21  _ 
400173 


12, 

3624 73 


Total  Number  of  Fai lures 


9  RRs. 
Tons  Laid 
97335 


169 

I3S 

611 

592 

210 

243 

584 

407 

75 

IS 

- 

lis 

19 

1 

II 

L5 

?;:a 

- 

3 

2 

— 

- 

1.6 

.... 

4 

7 

- 

9 

7 

- 

9 

4 

d.2_ 

— • 

s 

l_ 

16 ,1 

U2 

- 

7. 

7 

-,^ 

A.[_h 

y 

M 

If 

LS 

0,5 

<& 

lA. 

1 

"(H 

AS. 

1 

U 

ftjj 

3S, 

1 

Mftj 

JZ 

1 

lA 

1 

^az 

1 

& 

1 

y 

1 

^M 

xi 

J^ 

|| 

UmrlUu 

1 

5 

f 

3 

1 

1 

*: 

i 

<*> 

1 

* 

* 

<ti 

1 

* 

5: 

* 

1 

^ 

5: 

V, 

1 

i; 

X 

OQ 

1 

■K 

Si 

<*> 

1 

i: 

i 

* 

I 

1 

* 

S 

00 

1 
1 

* 

5 

Tangent  Curve 

T. 

c. 

T. 

c. 

r 

c. 

Tangent 

Curve 

IOOLB. 

90 

85 

80 

7SL8. 

CLASSIFIED    RAIL  FAILURES  DIAGRAM  2. 

Comparison  between  different  WEIGHTS  OF  RAIL. 
OPEN  HEARTH  STEEL. 

Record'  for  Period  of  One  Year  ending  Oct.  31,1910- 
See  Sheets  A/oe.  75 and  7S  for  names  of  Railroads  and  Tons  Laid. 


.    -r'    7    -■■■    ■■'--    SEC  C\S 

:-  --*  _ 

Record  for  Per 

8ESSEMEQ  STEEL. 

V.  1910. 

See  Sheets  Nos~  77.  7 

79.80end8lfcrnSmescf#a 

was  tnd  T 

ins  Lmkt 

\er  Ry.AssoCiah'on  Type, 
tftSeettfyCMt f«p» 


r-- -_---  >_--  :■.■-..-=-  j-  -■->'==-•  ?--,"-  c-vs  3r  fl^/z. 

OP£/V   *£> 

RTH  STEEL. 

5^  5-?-S    Vi  -J  53  ,?---.-\.'  \r-   "£~ 

es  ::■'    ",,■    ~:jj$  snc  Tons  u 

tfd 

CLASSIFIED  RAIL  FAILURES. 


Diagram   i. 


Comparison     between    different    Weights    of    Rail 

Bessemer  Steel. 

Diagram  2. 

Comparison    between    different    Weights    of    Rail — 
Open-Hearth  Steel, 

Diagram  3. 

Comparison    between    different    Sections    of    Rail — 
Bessemer  Steel. 

Diagram  4. 

Comparison     between    different    Sections    of    Rail — 
Open-Hearth   Steel. 

Diagram  5. 

Comparison  of  Failures  at  different  Lengths  of  Lifc 
— All  Kinds  of  Steel. 


UJ 

111 

-    -- 

""      III 

KIT" 

"TTTI 

---  --j— 

TTTT 

- 

jl 

1 

1 

Is 

W 

3 

r 

-' 

J'  - 

! 

1 

i— 4 

—  J- 

B  ! 

1 

f  1 

I 

I  :  ~ 

1 

s                 ll 

E 

1 

1 

i    j 

ffli 

y  i  - ! 

:               I         = 

i||       \ 

1 

1 

I 

I 

1    1      ft 

li 

1         a 

j  i 

I  T 

I 

i 

1 

D 

1         ! 

=      1        '    p 

J  lu  il- 

^;"d  S 

1 1 

'  1 

J  J              L 

II  III 

-tflt 

h  =  = 

Il     a 

7 '  la  ^lil 

m       1 

lUIl 

J=l 

'  I1!1 

H  If!!!!  1 

B 

j"  n 

1 

| 

1     1      ' 

il 

111MW        Bfc  IIMIHI 

ill 

j  ii il  mi i iii 

p  li1  , 

CpJ 

y 

lit  =i 

1 1  it1 

■  "  h 

1             1    __ 

2 

~_ 

E 

1  = 

-     --.-       - 

1  !|  g'l  i  §1 'i  j#|Ll  ill   i    II  jB||| 

2     Ip      | 

II 1  1 H  1 

-  i  i  -■'  ^ir 

tw  i'J» 

i_         -         -:~ 

Lw,  -„     --:_---  *  •  -  n  1 1 1 1 1 1 J  i  n^       '^..hi :.  --;;:.:--    r    f  -   :     mmmmMm^mmmm 

r4lH  l^JiP?«M|F*|^P?jri : 

Ltt#^ill5iMi5l^llllN|lf 

P?:",   '".=        :  ,  '    ;     "  ;" 

^illW*                                         ;:"';pI|'pK 

too      \      90      [as   j«j|»   n  H      ioo       [      90      \      es      \  eo  p|  is  ft 

100      \       90       \       85        \eo\   75  fs|    «70     |9o|     55      |»|w|s!    / 

JO    \sO\    85     |«Jp|  75  p    /£W    |s|    55     |  BO  f?|   75  fSf    /<30 

Pj  55  |  50  p|    75  p|    /£W   |s|  55  |  SO  Jsj  75   |s 

100   ^|  55  |«|     75    W    /05  |§|  55  \So\     75         100   Jsjs 

i  55    SO]     75     K 

o  In  1  Year                                                           /  fa  2 

_'~.?                                              Jto< 

4-foS 

5*6 

6/07                                  ~'o8 

3  to  9                         9  to  10                     Over  10  Years. 

ELECTRICITY. 


537 


538 


ELECTRICITY. 


5 


£ 


I- I.KCTRICITY 


a 


2k 

Id 


.40 


ELECTRICITY. 


<0 

I 

II 


ELECTRICITY. 


541 


P*te*3f3  ujais&MtyJOM 


\ 
\ 


<c  k    :*    •» 


S| 


8 


i 

g 


542 


ELFXTRICITY. 


i 
t 


ELECTRICITY. 


543 


544 


ELECTRICITY. 


ELECTRICITY. 


545 


546 


ELECTRICITY. 


S 

I 

i 

i 


ELECTRICITY. 


547 


548 


ELECTRICITY. 


IP 


<0    - 


ELECTRICITY. 


549 


550 


ELECTRICITY. 


s^l  f 
I 

I 


ELECTRICITY. 


551 


I 

V 


552 


ELECTRICITY. 


kl  i 


ELECTRICITY. 


553 


8 


k 
"m 
$ 
^ 


I 


554 


ELECTRICITY. 


ELECTRICITY. 


555 


1 


I 


556 


ELECTRICITY. 


I 

S3  I 


3 
s  i 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  IV— ON  RAIL. 

Chas.  S.  Churchill,  Chairman;  R.  Montfort,  V ice-Chairman; 

F_  B.  Ashby,  John  D.  Isaacs, 

J.  A.  Atwood,  Thos.  H.  Johnson, 

A.  S.  Baldwin,  Howard  G.  Kelley, 

J.  B.  Berry,  C.  A.  Morse, 

M.  L.  Byers,  George  W.  Kittredge, 

W.  C.  Cushing,  J.  T.  Richards 

F.  A.  Delano,  J.  P.  Snow, 

P.  H.  Dudley,  A.  W.  Thompson, 

C.  H.  Ewing,  Robert  Trimble, 

C.  W.  Huntington,  M.  H.  Wickhorst, 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  presents  the  following  report : 

During  191 1,  meetings  were  held  at  Chicago,  March  20,  191 1;  Atlantic 
City,  June  29,  1911;  Chicago,  November  14,  1911;  New  York,  November 
23  and  24,  1911;  New  York,  February  13,  1912. 

At  the  meetings  held  in  New  York,  November  23  and  24,  representa- 
tives of  the  Manufacturers'  Committee  were  also  present.  In  addition  to 
the  above  meetings,  several  meetings  of  the  Sub-Committees  were  also  held. 

Reports  have  been  submitted  during  the  year,  as  a  part  of  the  Rail 
Committee's  work,  as  follows : 

(A)  A  Study  of  Seventeen  Good  Service  Rails,  by  Robert  Trimble 
and  W.  C.  Cushing  (Bulletin  No.  135,  May,  1911),  with  notes  by  M.  H. 
Wickhorst.  These  rails  contained  carbon  within  or  a  little  above  the 
usual  limit  for  85-lb.  rails,  namely,  0.45  to  0.55.  With  this  carbon  the 
phosphorus  was  close  to  0.10  or  above,  the  manganese  was  mostly  within 
the  usual  limits  of  0.80  to  1.10.  Some  of  the  rails  were  of  fairly  uniform 
composition  throughout  the  section  as  indicated  by  the  etching,  but  others 
were  more  or  less  segregated.  This  study  did  not  perhaps  lead  to  any  very 
definite  results,  but  indicates  that  under  some  conditions  segregated  rails 
high  in  phosphorus,  and  possibly  also  in  carbon,  may  give  long  service, 
although  it  does  not  define  these  conditions  either  of  track  or  material. 

(B  and  C)  Rail  Failure  Statistics  for  the  Year  Ending  October  31, 
1910,  and  Segregation  and  Other  Rail  Proprties  as  Influenced  by  the  Size 
of  Ingot,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst  (Bulletin  No.  137,  July,  1911). 

Mr.  Cushing  made  a  study  of  the  Rail  Failure  Statistics  and  below 
are  his  comments  on  the  subject: 

559 


560  RAIL. 

(i)  Study  of  these  general  statistics  does  not  furnish  accurate  and 
specific  information  so  as  to  determine  the  value  of  different  sections  of 
rail,  because : 

(a)  The  conditions  of  traffic  are  different. 

(b)  The  conditions  of  roadbed  are  different. 

(c)  The  conditions  of  ingot  making  and  rolling  practice  are  so  differ- 
ent that  the  quality  of  the  material  varies  widely,  and,  at  the  present  time, 
this  difference  in  quality  of  the  material  eliminates  differences  in  section ; 
nevertheless,  when  the  time  comes  that  the  difference  in  quality  of  ma- 
terial will  be  less,  the  influence  of  the  section  will  be  more  apparent,  for 
there  is  no  doubt  that  one  section  is  stiffer  and  stronger  than  another  ac- 
cording to  the  distribution  of  the  material.  Inasmuch  as  we  are  endeavor- 
ing to  eliminate  the  differences  in  quality  of  material  and  bring  it  to  a 
high  state  of  perfection,  we  should  not,  in  the  meantime,  lose  sight  of 
the  desirable  features  of  the  rail  section,  but  keep  them  constantly  in 
mind,  so  that  when  we  arrive  at  a  good  quality  of  metal,  we  will  also  have 
a  desirable  rail  section. 

(2)  A  study  of  these  general  statistics  tends  to  disclose  unusual  re- 
sults, and  were  it  not  for  their  compilation,  we  would  not  have  much  in- 
formation relative  to  the  difference  between  Bessemer  and  Open-Hearth 
steel  and  concerning  the  various  alloys. 

(3)  The  general  statistics  are  also  important,  in  showing  a  relation 
between  broken  rails  and  failure  of  head,  web  and  base. 

(4)  Their  tabulation  discloses  the  difference  between  Steel  Com- 
panies when  the  sections  and  chemical  composition  are  practically  the 
same. 

The  report  by  Mr.  Wickhorst  covers  an  investigation  made  at  the 
South  Works  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company,  to  throw  light  on  the  rela- 
tionship of  the  size  of  ingots  of  Bessemer  Rail  steel  to  the  segregation  of 
the  metalloids,  locations  of  pipes  and  blow  holes,  and  the  properties  of 
ihe  rails.  This  investigation  showed  that  under  the  conditions  of  the  tests, 
the  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  collected  or  segregated  toward  the  in- 
terior and  upper  part  of  the  ingot  and  that,  in  a  general  way,  such  segre- 
gation increased  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increased.  The  manganese  also 
segregated  some,  but  to  a  much  smaller  extent,  while  the  silicon  showed 
little  or  no  tendency  to  segregate. 

The  elements  which  segregated  as  described  also  showed  a  lowering 
in  the  top  part  of  the  ingot,  below  the  average  composition  of  the  steel, 
and  this  lowering  extended  downward  along  the  sides  of  the  ingot.  The 
"negative"  segregation  increased  in  general  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  in- 
creased and  also  extended  down  further  along  the  sides  of  the  ingot. 
There  was  also  a  region  of  negative  segregation  in  the  interior  and  lower 
part  of  the  ingot,  but  the  lowering  of  the  elements  was  not  as  great  in 
this  region. 

This  investigation  also  indicated  that  the  material  was  distributed  in 


RAIL.  561 

the  rail  bar  about  the  same,  relatively,  as  it  was  in  the  ingot  from  which 
the  rail  bar  had  been  rolled. 

(D)  Tests  of  Rail  Steel  Ingots  and  Derivative  Shapes  Made  at  Water- 
town  Arsenal,  being  a  Review  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst  of  the  Report  Published 
by  the  Watertown  Arsenal  (Bulletin  No.  139,  September,  1911). 

This  report  covers  a  digest  and  analysis  of  the  Government  investi- 
gation at  the  Watertown  Arsenal  of  rail  steel  ingots  and  derivative  shapes 
as  embodied  in  the  Report  of  Tests  of  Metals,  etc.,  made  at  the  Water- 
town  Arsenal  for  the  year  1909. 

The  work  indicated  that  the  interior  cavities  of  an  ingot  cooled  di- 
rectly after  pouring  are  about  the  same  or  slightly  less  than  in  a  similar 
ingot  placed  in  the  soaking  pit  and  then  cooled.  This  same  result  was  also 
indicated  as  true  of  blooms  made  from  such  ingots. 

It  was  shown  that  almost  the  full  tensile  strength  and  ductility  of  the 
metal  of  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  were  obtained  rolling  to  about  one- 
tenth  of  the  original  cross-section,  but  with  the  metal  of  the  upper  part 
of  the  ingot  it  was  necessary  to  reduce  the  cross-section  to  one-twenty- 
fifth  or  less  of  the  original  amount. 

A  great  many  etchings  were  made  and  it  was  shown  that  the  structure 
of  the  cross-section  as  developed  by  etching  varies  from  the  top  to  the 
bottom  of  the  ingot  and  that  each  structure  finds  its  counterpart  in  suc- 
ceeding shapes  and  at  about  the  same  proportionate  distance  from  the 
top  end.  It  was  also  shown  that  the  structure  was  considerably  altered  by 
changing  the  position  in  which  the  ingot  was  allowed  to  cool,  as  for  in- 
stance allowing  it  to  cool  on  its  side  after  stripping. 

(E)  Influence  of  Rolling  Temperature  on  the  Properties  of  Bessemer 
Rails,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst,  November,  191 1. 

This  report  covers  an  investigation  made  at  the  works  of  the  Carnegie 
Steel  Company  to  determine  the  influence  of  the  temperature  of  rolling 
on  the  properties  of  Bessemer  Rails.  This  work  indicated  that  the  ductil- 
ity and  deflection  in  the  drop  test  were  influenced  little,  if  any,  by  the 
rolling  temperature.  The  number  of  blows  that  it  took  to  break  the 
rails  in  the  drop  test  was  uninfluenced  by  the  temperature  of  rolling.  The 
yield  point  and  tensile  strength  in  the  tension  tests  were  influenced  little, 
if  any.  The  elongation  in  the  tension  test  decreased  some  as  the  temp- 
erature increased.  The  influence  of  temperature  showed  most  prominently 
in  the  tension  test,  in  the  reduction  of  area,  which  decreased  as  the  temp- 
erature of  rolling  increased.  The  size  of  the  grain,  as  shown  by  the  micro- 
scope, increased  as  the  temperature  increased. 

In  this  report  it  is  also  pointed  out  that  the  ductility  in  the  drop  test 
with  the  head  of  the  rail  in  tension  more  nearly  indicates  the  ductility 
of  the  interior  metal  as  measured  in  the  tension  test,  than  does  the  ductil- 
ity in  the  drop  test  with  the  base  of  the  rail  in  tension,  which  is  usual  in 
inspection  work. 

Each   report  mentioned  above  gives  a  short  summary   of  the  matter 


562  RAIL. 

contained  in  it,  but  the  main  principles  that  seem  to  have  been  brought  out 
by  the  year's  work  are  brought  out  in  the  brief  reviews  above. 

The  general  plan  of  our  research  work  during  the  year  has  been  to 
direct  attention  to  some  one  item  which  enters  as  a  factor  in  the  properties 
of  the  finished  rail  and  attempt  to  obtain  definite  information  concerning 
its  influence  by  the  experimental  method  of  obtaining  as  great  a  range  as 
practicable  in  the  one  item  under  consideration,  but  leaving  all  other  con- 
ditions as  near  alike  as  obtainable  in  the  several  experiments.  It  is  thus 
hoped  to  establish  in  the  course  of  time  the  metallurgical  principles  and 
laws  that  apply  to  the  manufacture  of  steel  rails. 

(i)  The  first  item  of  work  for  the  Rail  Committee  according  to  the 
instructions  for  191 1,  was  to  recommend  changes  in  the  specifications  for 
steel  rails. 

Considerable  work  has  been  done  during  the  past  year  in  the  prepara- 
tion of  specifications,  and  the  specifications  submitted  herewith  are 
recommended  by  your  Committee.  Some  paragraphs,  such  as  Nos.  5,  6, 
14  and  15,  are  not  to  be  considered  as  final,  it  being  thought  that  the 
Committee  did  not  have  sufficient  information  in  its  possession  to  make 
these  sections  in  the  specifications  mandatory. 

One  of  the  sections  in  question,  No.  14,  refers  to  the  ductility  test. 

The  requirements,  in  the  specifications,  for  ductility  are  somewhat 
lower  than  some  members  of  your  Committee  think  desirable,  and  it  is 
hoped  that  sufficient  information  will  be  obtained  during  the  coming  year 
to  enable  the  Committee  to  make  some  revision  in  these  respects. 

Paragraph  No.  15,  referring  to  deflections  as  a  method  of  classifying 
rails,  is  also  tentative.  It  is  the  intention  when  sufficient  data  is  at  hand 
to  prescribe  maximum  and  minimum  limits  for  deflections  under  the  drop 
test. 

(2)  Present  recommendations  on  standard  rail  sections. 
The  Committee  reports  progress. 

(3)  Continue  investigation  of  the  breakage  and  failure  of  rails  and 
present  summary  of  conclusions  drawn  from  reports  received. 

Bulletin  No.  137,  July,  191 1,  contains  the  rail  failure  statistics  for  the 
year  ending  October  31,  1910,  and  the  conclusions  in  regard  to  the  matter 
are  presented  in  that  report. 

(4)  Report  on  the  results  obtained  from  the  use  of  Open-Hearth  and 
Special  Alloy  Steel  Rails,  and  the  Chemical  Composition  of  such  rails. 

Bulletin  No.  137,  referred  to  above,  containing  the  report  of  the  rail 
failure  statistics,  also  gives  all  the  information  that  the  Committee  has  in 
regard  to  Open-Hearth  and  Special  Alloy  Steel  Rails. 

In  regard  to  the  remaining  part  of  the  outline  of  work  for  the  year 
191 1,  the  Committee  reports  no  progress. 

The  Committee  desires  to  call  attention  to  the  valuable  services  ren- 
dered by  Mr.  M.  H.  Wickhorst,  Engineer  of  Tests,   for  the  Committee. 


RAIL.  563 

Mr.  Wickhorst  has  succeeded  in  winning  the  confidence  of  the  Manufac- 
turers and  has  thereby  succeeded  in  securing  their  co-operation  in  the 
work  which  is  being  done.  Considerable  light  has  been  thrown  upon  the 
subject  by  these  investigations  of  Mr.  Wickhorst,  and  it  is  hoped  that 
in  the  future  considerable  good  will  be  accomplished  as  a  result  of  the 
investigations. 

Your  Committee  desires  to  acknowledge  the  very  generous  manner  in 
which  the  various  Rail  Manufacturers  have  offered  us  the  material  and 
facilities  of  their  mills  to  carry  on  this  research  work.  The  condition  of 
co-operation  that  we  are  working  under  is  very  gratifying  and,  it  would 
seem,  must  work  toward  the  best  interests  of  the  railroads,  the  steel  mills 
and  the  general  public. 

The  Committee  recommends  the  following  lines  for  investigation  dur- 
ing the  coming  year : 

(i)     Recommend  changes  in  specifications  for  steel  rails. 

(2)  Present  recommendations  on  standard  rail  sections. 

(3)  Continue  investigation  of  the  breakage  and  failure  of  rails  and 
present  summary  of  conclusions  drawn  from  reports  received. 

(4)  Report  on  the  results  obtained  from  the  use  of  Open-Hearth  and 
Special  Alloy  Steel  Rails,  and  the  Chemical  Composition  of  such  rails. 

(5)  Present  reports  on  the  results  of  tests  made  on  the  various  kinds 
of  rail  in  conjunction  with  the  Manufacturers'  Committee  on  the  revolv- 
ing machine  at  South  Chicago. 

(6)  Report  on  standard  drilling  for  rails. 

Special  Investigations  by  Mr.  Wickhorst. 

(1)  Test  Open-Hearth  Steel  in  ingots  of  various  sizes. 

(2)  Influence  of  height  of  ingot  with  usual  cross-section — 

(a)  Bessemer  Steel ; 

(b)  Open-Hearth  Steel. 

(3)  Influence  of  temperature  of  rolling  on  high  carbon  Open-Hearth 
steel. 

(4)  Drop  Tests.  Influence  of  temperature  of  test  piece  on  ductility 
and  deflection  in  drop  test. 

(5)  Tests  with  reciprocating  machine,  especially  to  determine  in- 
fluence of  interior  segregation. 

(6)  Influence  of  Titanium — 

(a)  Bessemer  Steel ; 

(b)  Open-Hearth  Steel. 

(7;  Influence  of  thickness  of  mold  on  segregation  and  cavities,  cast 
in  sand  and  in  molds  of  various  thickness — 

(a)  Bessemer  Steel ; 

(b)  Open-Hearth  Steel. 

(8)  Influence  of  methods  of  cooling  on  the  cooling  beds,  especially 
with  high  carbon  steels ;  also  the  effects  of  cold  straightening. 

(9)  Influence  of  the  temperature  of  the  liquid  steel  when  poured 
into  molds. 


564  RAIL. 

(10)     Experiments  with  methods  of  casting  ingots  for  improvement, 
as  regards  blow  holes,  pipes,  etc. 

(ii)     Drop  Tests,  Permanent  Set,  Ductility,  etc. 

(a)  Influence  of  carbon. 

(b)  Influence  of  phosphorus. 

(c)  Influence  of  manganese. 

(d)  Influence  of  span  of  supports. 

(e)  Influence  of  moment  of  inertia. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  RAIL. 


RAIL. 


565 


AMERICAN  RAILWAY   ENGINEERING  ASSOCIATION. 
SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  CARBON  STEEL  RAILS. 

1912. 


INSPECTION. 

Access  to  Works. 

1.  Inspectors  representing  the  purchaser  shall  have  free  entry  to  the 
works  of  the  manufacturer  at  all  times  while  the  contract  is  being  exe- 
cuted, and  shall  have  all  reasonable  facilities  afforded  them  by  the  manu- 
facturer to  satisfy  them  that  the  rails  have  been  made  in  accordance  with 
the  terms  of  the  specifications. 

Place  for  Tests. 

2.  All  tests  and  inspections  shall  be  made  at  the  place  of  manufac- 
ture, prior  to  shipment,  and  shall  be  so  conducted  as  not  to  interfere  un- 
necessarily with  the  operation  of  the  mill. 

MATERIAL. 
Material. 

3.  The  material  shall  be  steel  made  by  the  Bessemer  or  Open-Hearth 
process  provided  by  the  contract. 

CHEMICAL  REQUIREMENTS. 
Chemical   Composition. 

4.  The  chemical  composition  of  the  steel  from  which  the  rails  are 
rolled,  determined  as  prescribed  in  Section  7,  shall  be  within  the  following 
limits : 


For  Bessemer  Process 

For  Open-Hearth  Process 

Elements 

70  lbs.  and  over, 
but  under  85  lbs. 

85  -  100  lbs. 
inclusive 

70  lbs.  and  over, 
but  under  85  lbs. 

85  -  100  lbs. 
inclusive 

0.40  to  0.50 

0.80  to  1.10 

0  20 

0.10 

0.45  to  0.55 

0.80  to  1.10 

0.20 

0.10 

0.53  to  0.66 

0.60  to  0.90 

0.20 

0.04 

0.63  to  0  76 

0.60  to  0  90 

Silicon  not  to  exceed . 

Phosphorus  not  to  exceed .  . 

0.20 
0.04 

Modification  of  Carbon  for  Low  Phosphorus. 

5.  When  the  material  used  at  any  mill  is  such  that  the  average  phos- 
phorus content  of  the  ingot  metal  used  in  the  Bessemer  process  is  run- 
ning below  0.08  and  in  the  Open-Hearth  process  is  running  below  0.03, 
and  if  it  seems  mutually  desirable,  the  carbon  may  be  increased  at  the 
rate  of  0.035  f°r  eacb  0.01  that  the  phosphorus  content  of  the  ingot  metal 
used  averages  below  0.08  for  Bessemer  steel,  or  0.03  for  Open-Hearth  steel. 


566  RAIL 

Average  Carbon. 

6.  It  is  desired  that  the  percentage  of  carbon  in  an  entire  order  of 
rails  shall  average  as  high  as  the  mean  percentage  between  the  upper  and 
lower  limits  specified. 

Analyses. 

7.  In  order  to  ascertain  whether  the  chemical  composition  is  in  ac- 
cordance with  the  requirements,  analyses  shall  be  furnished  as  follows : 

(a)  For  Bessemer  process  the  manufacturer  shall  furnish  to  the  in- 
spector, daily,  carbon  determinations  for  each  heat  before  the  rails  are 
shipped,  and  two  chemical  analyses  every  twenty-four  hours  representing 
the  average  of  the  elements,  carbon,  manganese,  silicon,  phosphorus  and 
sulphur  contained  in  the  steel,  one  for  each  day  and  night  turn  respectively. 
These  analyses  shall  be  made  on  drillings  taken  from  the  ladle  test  ingot 
not  less  than  one-eighth  inch  beneath  the  surface. 

(b)  For  Open-Hearth  process,  the  makers  shall  furnish  the  inspectors 
with  a  chemical  analysis  of  the  elements,  carbon,  manganese,  silicon, 
phosphorus  and  sulphur,  for  each  heat. 

(c)  On  request  of  the  inspector,  the  manufacturer  shall  furnish  drill- 
ings from  the  test  ingot  for  check  analyses. 


PHYSICAL  REQUIREMENTS. 

Physical   Qualities. 

8.  Tests  shall  be  made  to  determine : 

(a)  Ductility  or  toughness  as  opposed  to  brittleness. 

(b)  Soundness. 

Method  of  Testing. 

9.  The  physical  qualities  shall  be  determined  by  the  Drop  Test. 

Drop  Testing    Machine. 

10.  The  drop  testing  machine  used  shall  be  the  standard  of  the  Amer- 
ican Railway  Engineering  Association. 

(a)  The  tup  shall  weigh  2,000  lbs.,  and  have  a  striking  face  with  a 
radius  of  five  inches. 

(b)  The  anvil  block  shall  weigh  20,000  lbs.,  and  be  supported  on 
springs. 

(c)  The  supports  for  the  test  pieces  shall  be  spaced  three  feet  be- 
tween centers  and  shall  be  a  part  of,  and  firmly  secured  to  the  anvil.  The 
bearing  surfaces  of  the  supports  shall  have  a  radius  of  five  inches. 

Pieces  for  Drop  Test. 

11.  Drop  tests  shall  be  made  on  pieces  of  rail  not  less  than  four  feet 
and  not  more  than  six  feet  long.  These  test  pieces  shall  be  cut  from  the 
top  end  of  the  top  rail  of  the  ingot,  and  marked  on  the  base  or  head  with 
gage  marks  one  inch  apart  for  three  inches  each  side  of  the  center  of  the 
test  piece,  for  measuring  the  ductility  of  the  metal. 


RAIL  567 

Temperature   of  Test  Pieces. 

12.  The  temperature  of  the  test  pieces  shall  be  between  60  and  100 
degrees  Fahrenheit. 

Height  of  Drop. 

13.  The  test  piece  shall,  at  the  option  of  the  inspector,  be  placed 
head  or  base  upwards  on  the  supports,  and  be  subjected  to  impact  of  the 
tup   falling  free  from  the   following  heights  : 

For  70-lb.  rail 16  feet 

For  80,  85  and  90-lb.  rail 17  feet 

For  100-lb.   rail 18  feet 

Elongation  or  Ductility. 

14.  Under  these  impacts  the  rail  under  one  or  more  blows  shall  show 
at  least  6  per  cent,  elongation  for  one  inch,  or  5  per  cent,  each  for  two 
consecutive  inches  of  the  six-inch  scale,  marked  as  described  in  Section  11. 

Permanent  Set. 

15.  It  is  desired  that  the  permanent  set  after  one  blow  under  the 
drop  test  shall  not  exceed  that  in  the  following  table,  and  a  record  shall 
be  made  of  this  information. 


Permanent  Set 

,  measured  by 

Rail 

Middle  Ordinate  in  Inches 
in  a  Length  of  3  Feet 

Section 

Weight 
per  Yard 

Moment 
of  Inertia 

Bessemer  Process      O.-H.  Process 

A.R.A.-A 

100 

48.94 

1.65                           1.45 

A.R.A.-B 

100 

41.30 

2.05 

1.80 

A.R.A.-A 

90 

38.70 

1.90 

1.65 

A.R.A.-B 

90 

32.30 

2.20 

2.00 

A.R.A.-A 

80 

28.80 

2.85 

2.45 

A.R.A.-B 

SO 

25.00 

3.15 

2.85 

A.R.A.-A 

70 

21.05 

3.50 

3.10 

A.R.A.-B 

70 

18.60 

3.85 

3.50 

Test  to   Destruction. 

16.  The  test  pieces  which  do  not  break  under  the  first  or  subsequent 
blows  shall  be  nicked  and  broken,  to  determine  whether  the  interior 
metal  is  sound. 

Bessemer  Process  Drop  Tests. 

17.  One  piece  shall  be  tested  from  each  heat  of  Bessemer  steel. 

(a)  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  at  the  first  blow  and  shows  the 
required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be 
accepted,  provided  that  the  test  piece  when  nicked  and  broken  does  not 
show   interior   defect. 

(b)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the 
required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  test  piece  shows  the  required 
elongation  but  when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect,  all  of  the 
top  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

(c)  A  second  test  shall  then  be  made  of  a  test  piece  selected  by  the 
inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  second  rail  of  the  same  heat,  preferably 


568  RAIL. 

of  the  same  ingot.  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  at  the  first  blow,  and 
shows  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the  remainder  of  the 
rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided  that  the  test  piece  when 
nicked   and  broken   does   not   show   interior   defect. 

(d)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the  required 
elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  piece  shows  the  required  elongation  but 
when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect,  all  of  the  second  rails  from 
that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

(e)  A  third  test  shall  then  be  made  of  a  test  piece  selected  by  the 
inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  third  rail  of  the  same  heat,  preferably 
of  the  same  ingot.  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  at  the  first  blow  and 
<>hows  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the  remainder  of  the 
rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided  that  the  test  piece  when  nicked 
and  broken  does  not  show  interior  defect. 

(f)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the  required, 
elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  piece  shows  the  required  elongation   but 
when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect,  all   of  the   remainder  of 
the  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

Open-Hearth   Process   Drop  Tests. 

18.  Test  pieces  shall  be  selected  from  the  second,  middle  and  last 
full  ingot  of  each  Open-Hearth  heat. 

(a)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  do  not  break  at  the  first  blow  and  show 
the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be 
accepted,  provided  that  these  test  pieces  when  nicked  and  broken  do  not 
show  interior  defect. 

(b)  If  two  of  the  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow,  or  do  not  show 
the  required  elongation,  or  if  any  of  the  pieces  that  have  been  tested  under 
the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show  interior  defect,  all  of  the  top 
rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

(c)  Second  tests  shall  then  be  made  from  three  test  pieces  selected  by 
the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  second  rails  of  the  same  heat,  prefer- 
ably of  the  same  ingots.  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  do  not  break  at 
the  first  blow  and  show  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the 
remainder  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided  that  the 
pieces  that  have  been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  do  not 
show  interior  defect. 

(d)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow  or  do  not  show 
the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  any  of  the  pieces  that  have 
been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show  interior  defect, 
all  of  the  second  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

(e)  Third  tests  shall  then  be  made  from  three  test  pieces  selected 
by  the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  third  rails  of  the  same  heat, 
preferably  of  the  same  ingots.  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  do  not  break  at 
the  first  blow,  and  show  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the 
remainder  of  the   rails   of   the   heat   shall   be   accepted,    provided   that   the 


RAIL.  569 

pieces  that  have  been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  do  not 
show   interior  defect. 

(f)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow  or  do  not  show 
the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  any  of  the  pieces,  that  have 
been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show  interior  defect, 
all  of  the  remainder  of  the  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

No.  1    Rails. 

19.  No.  1  classification  rails  shall  be  free  from  injurious  defects  and 
flaws  of  all  kinds. 

No.  2  Rails. 

20.  (a)  Rails,-  which,  by  reason  of  surface  imperfections,  or  for 
causes  mentioned  in  Section  30  hereof,  are  not  classed  as  No.  1  rails,  will 
be  accepted  as  No.  2  rails,  but  No.  2  rails  which  contain  imperfections  in 
such  number  or  of  such  character  as  will,  in  the  judgment  of  the  in- 
spector, render  them  unfit  for  recognized  No.  2  uses,  will  not  be  accepted 
for  shipment. 

(b)  No.  2  rails  to  the  extent  of  5  per  cent,  of  the  whole  order  will 
be  received.  All  rails  accepted  as  No.  2  rails  shall  have  the  ends  painted 
white  and  shall  have  two  prick  punch  marks  on  the  side  of  the  web  near 
the  heat  number  near  the  end  of  the  rail,  so  placed  as  not  to  be  covered 
by  the  splice  bars. 

DETAILS  OF  MANUFACTURE. 

Quality  of  Manufacture. 

21.  The  entire  process  of  manufacture  shall  be  in  accordance  with 
the  best  current  state  of  the  art. 

Bled    Ingots. 

22.  Bled  ingots  shall  not  be  used. 

Discard. 

23.  There  shall  be  sheared  from  the  end  of  the  bloom,  formed  from 
the  top  of  the  ingot,  sufficient  metal  to  secure  sound  rails. 

Lengths. 

24.  The  standard  length  of  rails  shall  be  33  feet,  at  a  temperature  of 
60  degrees  Fahrenheit.  Ten  per  cent,  of  the  entire  order  will  be  accepted 
in  shorter  lengths  varying  by  1  foot  from  32  feet  to  25  feet.  A  variation 
of  one-fourth  inch  from  the  specified  lengths  will  be  allowed.  No.  1  rails 
less  than  2>2>  feet  long  shall  be  painted  green  on  both  ends. 

Shrinkage. 

25.  The  number  of  passes  and  speed  of  train  shall  be  so  regulated 
that  on  leaving  the  rolls  at  the  final  pass,  the  temperature  of  the  rail  will 
not  exceed  that  which  requires  a  shrinkage  allowance  at  the  hot  saws, 
for  a  rail  23  feet  in  length  and  of  ico  lbs.  section,  of  six  and  three-fourths 
inches  and  one-eighth  inch  less  for  each  ten  lbs.  decrease  in  section. 


570  RAIL. 

Cooling. 

26.  The  bars  shall  not  be  held  for  the  purpose  of  reducing  their 
temperature,  nor  shall  any  artificial  means  of  cooling  them  be  used  after 
they  leave  the  finishing  pass.  Rails,  while  on  the  cooling  beds,  shall  be 
protected  from  snow  and  water. 

Section. 

27.  The  section  of  rails  shall  conform  as  accurately  as  possible  to 
the  template  furnished  by  the  Railroad  Company.  A  variation  in  height 
of  one-sixty-fourth  inch  less  or  one-thirty-second  inch  greater  than  the 
specified  height,  and  one-sixteenth  inch  in  width  of  flange,  will  be  per- 
mitted ;  but  no  variation  shall  be  allowed  in  the  dimensions  affectmg  the 
fit  of  the  splice  bars. 

Weight. 

28.  The  weight  of  the  rails  specified  in  the  order  shall  be  maintained 
as  nearly  as  possible,  after  complying  with  the  preceding  Section.  A  vari- 
ation of  one-half  of  1  per  cent,  from  the  calculated  weight  of  section,  as 
applied  to  an  entire  order,  will  be  allowed. 

Payment. 

*2Q.     Rails  will  be  accepted  and  paid  for  according  to  actual  weights. 

Straightening. 

30.  The  hot  straightening  shall  be  carefully  done,  so  that  gagging 
under  the  cold  presses  will  be  reduced  to  a  minimum.  Any  rail  coming 
to  the  straightening  presses  showing  sharp  kinks  or  greater  camber  than 
that  indicated  by  a  middle  ordinate  of  4  inches  in  33  feet,  for  A.  R.  A. 
type  of  sections,  or  5  inches  for  A.  S.  C.  E.  type  of  sections,  will  be  at 
once  classed  as  a  No.  2  rail.  The  distance  between  the  supports  of  rails 
in  the  straightening  presses  shall  not  be  less  than  42  inches.  The  supports 
shall  have  flat  surfaces  and  be  out  of  wind. 

Drilling. 

31.  Circular  holes  for  joint  bolts  shall  be  drilled  to  conform  accurately 
in  every  respect  to  the  drawing  and  dimensions  furnished  by  the  Railroad 
Company. 

Finishing. 

32.  (a)  All  rails  shall  be  smooth  on  the  heads,  straight  in  line  and 
surface,  and  without  any  twists,  waves  or  kinks.  They  shall  be  sawed 
square  at  the  ends,  a  variation  of  not  more  than  one-thirty-second  inch 
being  allowed ;  and  burrs  shall  be  carefully  removed. 

(b)  Rails  improperly  drilled  or  straightened,  or  from  which  the  burrs 
have  not  been  removed,  shall  be  rejected,  but  may  be  accepted  after  being 
properly  finished. 


*Amend  to  read,  "29.     Rails  accepted  will  be  paid  for  according  to  actual 
weights." 


RAIL.  571 

Branding. 

33.  The  name  of  the  manufacturer,  the  weight  and  type  of  rail,  and 
the  month  and  year  of  manufacture  shall  be  rolled  in  raised  letters  and 
figures  on  the  side  of  the  web.  The  number  of  the  heat  and  a  letter  in- 
dicating the  portion  of  the  ingot  from  which  the  rail  was  made  shall  be 
plainly  stamped  on  the  web  of  each  rail,  where  it  will  not  be  covered  by 
the  splice  bars.  The  top  rails  shall  be  lettered  "A,"  and  the  succeeding 
ones  "B,"  "C,"  "D,"  etc.,  consecutively ;  but  in  case  of  a  top  discard  of 
twenty  or  more  per  cent.,  the  letter  "A"  will  be  omitted.  Open-Hearth 
rails  shall  be  branded  or  stamped  "O.  H."  All  markings  of  rails  shall  be 
done  so  effectively  that  the  marks  may  be  read  as  long  as  the  rails  arc  in 
service. 

Separate  Classes. 

34.  All  classes  of  rails  shall  be  kept  separate  from  each  other. 

Loading. 

35.  All  rails  shall  be  loaded  in  the  presence  of  the  inspector. 


572  RAIL. 


Appendices  to   Report  of  Committee   IV — On   Rail. 

Your  Committee  submits  the  following  statements  as  Appendices  to 
its  report.     They  consist  of : 

(A)  A  Study  of  Seventeen  Good  Service  Rails,  by  Robert  Trimble 
and  W.  C.  Cushing  (Bulletin  135,  May,  1911),  with  notes  by  M.  H. 
Wickhorst. 

(B)  Rail  Failure  Statistics  for  the  Year  Ending  October  31,  1910; 
Comparative  Wear  of  Bessemer,  Open-Hearth  and  Nickel  Steel  Rail 
on  Pennsylvania  Railroad,  by  Jos.  T.  Richards,  Chief  Engineer  Main- 
tenance of  Way. 

(C)  Segregation  and  Other  Rail  Properties  as  Influenced  by  the 
Size  of  Ingot,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst   (Bulletin  137,  July,  1911). 

(D)  Tests  of  Rail  Steel  Ingots  and  Derivative  Shapes  Made  at 
Watertown  Arsenal,  being  a  Review,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst,  of  the  Report 
published  by  the  Watertown  Arsenal  (Bulletin  139,  September,  191 1). 

(E)  Influence  ef  Rolling  Temperature  on  the  Properties  of  Bes- 
semer Rails,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst  (Bulletin  143,  January,  1912). 

(F)  Hearing  before  Railroad  Commission  of  Indiana  (Bulletin  144, 
February,  1912). 


Appendix    A. 

A  STUDY  OF  SEVENTEEN  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS 

By 

Robert  Trimble  and  W.  C.  Cushing. 

With  discussion  by 

M.  H.  Wickhorst,  Engineer  of  Tests — Rail  Committee. 

This  report  covers  a  study  of  seventeen  Bessemer  rails  that  gave  good 
service  on  the  Pennsylvania  Lines  West  of  Pittsburgh,  ten  of  them  on 
the  Northwest  System,  the  reports  of  which  were  furnished  by  Mr. 
Trimble,  Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  and  the  other  seven  on 
the  Southwest  System,  the  reports  of  which  were  furnished  by  Mr.  Cush- 
ing, Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way.  The  rails  gave  from  seven 
to  seventeen  years'  service  in  main  tracks  and  were  removed  under  direc- 
tions of  Messrs.  Trimble  and  Cushing  for  special  examination.  The  tests 
(which  were  made  by  R.  W.  Hunt  &  Co.)  consisted  of  the  following: 

i.  Etching  of  a  section  with  picric  acid. 

2.  Etching  of  a  section  with  sulphuric  acid. 

3.  Analysis  of  borings  from  the  interior  of  the  head. 

4.  Tensile  strength  of  a  sample  from  the  interior  of  the  head,  from 

eleven  of  the  rails. 

5.  Five  transverse  microphotographs  along  the  center  line  of  the  rail, 

one  at  the  top  and  the  others  at  J4  in->  V2  in.,  Y$  in.  and  1  in., 
respectively  from  the  top,  from  each  rail,  etched  with  picric- 
acid  and  magnified  about  65  diameters. 

These  various  reports  and  other  information  were  presented  to  the 
Rail  Committee  and  then  edited  for  publication  as  this  report  by  M.  H. 
Wickhorst.  The  rails  were  given  numbers  from  1  to  17,  inclusive,  the 
first  ten  being  rails  examined  by  Trimble,  and  the  other  seven  examined 
by  Cushing.  The  main  information  concerning  these  rails  is  shown  in  Table  1, 
and  for  more  convenient  comparison  the  carbon,  phosphorus,  manganese, 
tensile  strength  and  elongation  are  shown  graphically  in  Fig.  1.  The 
present  specification  limits  for  carbon,  phosphorus  and  manganese  are 
shown  on  the  diagrams,  namely,  carbon,  .45  to  .55  per  cent ;  phosphorus, 
not  exceeding  .10  per  cent.,  and  manganese,  .80  to  1.10  per  cent.  Although 
we  have  no  standard  tensile  requirements,  I  show  a  line  at  12  per  cent, 
elongation,    as    Bessemer    rail    steel    should   give   this   amount   below    the 


Report   No.    18,   April,   1911. 

578 


574 


RAIL. 


OOfOlOH  CSOOMMOl  Ol  CO  Ci  CJ  OC  LOW 

"*  Oi  t—  t-  iO  rf  CO  Tf  <X>  ^  "*  CO  "^  t-  i-t  CO*T5 

OOOOO  OiH  i-H  i-h  i-H  rH  ,-t  iHOt-H  HO 

IfllflH^O  Olt-COHH  TJ-COCO00CD  00  O* 

00  O  O  O  C-  OOOC5050  OOOt^Oi  oi> 

MCH^W  ^      

^t4  O  CO  ^  LO  H*<       •       ■       »       •                •■ 

OOOOO  o     

C"-  l.ft  00  V  ©*  tf>  OO  H  CI  t>  ^r|«0  0)H  CO  «£> 

ci  co  >— (ir:oo  t  cr.  o  o  oi  q  Oi  m  h  o  hoi 

,H  ,_,  ,_,  y-t  j-i  r-«©7-*i-tO  0©i-*tHi-H  1-i  O 

iCCOt-OH  HNOIOCO  OIWMHM  LO  <X> 

r-~  lo  o  o  tp  Ciu^oooct-  i>- 1>  ci  a;  U5  hi> 

-<r  us  •*  io  «>  m^T-rj''**'  lo  *<*  "^  10  m  10  ■**< 


CO  tf5  h-  rH 


bo     . 


CO  CO  coco 


>  03      toeooc  -j-  m 


oooo      oooco      oo 

Cl^lOOO         Irt  lO -H '■J' Tf         00  O 

HC1HH         MtiHHH         HO 


w 


HhS 


CI  O  M  O  W 


HEihcHEH     HH 


<!WM<!<!     <Jh3JJJ     J^M^J     JJ 


as  <d  <d  a>  o) 

bo  bo  oo  oo'bo 
a>  a3  a>  a>  a3 

CCCCC 

v&  co  c3  cd  d 
OOOOO' 


•^i  in  w  to  03 
(m—  — c  •«  — 
m  O  O  O  O 

c  c  a  a  a 


0) 

03  43  03 

be 

oo  oo  bo 

0) 

03   03   03 

C 

(-1 

c  c  c 

i- 

J-    —    ■— 

Rj 

p 

u 

ooo 

03   03 

00  00 
03   03 

-   - 


(U   03. 


•-o  '.O  C~  t-  t— 


H    •    .HW 

HH 

c 

KKtfKtf 

«««««' 

.««   .    . 

o  .  .oo 

OO 

■g 

pHtf««p; 

K«K«« 

^  « „•  A 

en        com 

coco 

OQ 

CLkkkPn 

Ph  pL,  fL,  PL.  Oh 

*'*N«i 

«H 

tlMCO^lO         U5t— 00CJ5O        HMMTflO        CO  t- 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


575 


86  Lb    RaiLs. 

Yearns 
Service 

16 

16 

17 

17 

17 

17 

14 

14 

I41 

14 

If 

15* 

1* 

II 

(1 

?i 

7 

Curve  or 

2° 

2° 

T 

T 

rt 

2°8' 

40' 

£°ao 

40*  2&o 

T 

T 

T 

T 

T 

T 

T 

High   or 

Low  RaiL 

H 

L 

L 
M 

L 
H 

L 

L 

H 

H 

Section 

P  R  R 

AS. 

PRR 

ASCE 

rYa.iL 
Number 

1 

8 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

II 

12 

13 

»4 

15 

16 

17 

A^ 

B 

B 

A 

A 

A 

L 

L 

L 

L 

L 

A 

B 

A 

L 

L 

L 

Kl         50_ 

5  *, 

-30 

— 

~ 

o 

<:      .to  _ 

a. 

— 

— 

--- 

— 

— 

— 

X       .-40. 

5:    «» 

— 

,£"    l4QoOO_ 

to 

'  I20/ooo  _ 
fc    IOq«oo_ 

* 

0-1    .6- 

FIG.  i. 


576  RAIL. 

brittle  zone  near  the  top  of  the  ingot.  In  both  Table  I  and  Fig.  i,  I  show 
the  probable  ingot  position  of  the  rail  as  indicated  by  the  etchings ;  A 
means  the  top  rail  of  the  ingot,  B  means  the  second  rail,  and  L  means 
that  the  rail  is  probably  from  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot. 

The  carbon  results  -are  within  the  prescribed  limits,  or  only  a  little 
above,  except  in  rail  5,  which  shows  carbon  .641  per  cent.  The  phos- 
phorus is  above  .10  per  cent,  in  over  half  the  cases,  and  in  several  of 
them  very  much  so,  namely : 

Rail  5 :i8o.  per  cent  phosphorus 

"'    4 156     "      " 

"    6 146    "      "  " 

"    2 135     "      " 

These  rails  also  show  carbon  above  .55  per  cent,  and  the  etching 
indicates  them  to  be  A  rails  except  that  rail  2  seems  to  be  a  B  rail.  The 
manganese  is  pretty  well  within  the  specified  limits,  except  that  several 
rails  show  a  little  below  the  minimum.  The  elongation  in  the  eleven 
rails  of  which  tensile  tests  were  made  showed  very  well  except  in  rails  12 
and  14,  which  gave  low  elongations.  The  etchings  indicate  these  to  be 
A  rails. 

Most  of  these  rails  would  be  called  good  commercial  rails,  and 
although  some  of  them  come  outside  the  specified  limits  for  carbon  and 
phosphorus,  there  is  not  a  sufficiently  high  combination  of  these  elements 
to  result  in  very  brittle  or  fragile  material,  except  in  rail  5  and  possibly 
also  in  rails  4  and  6.  Unfortunately,  no  tensile  tests  were  made  on  these 
rails,  but  rail  5,  at  the  location  where  the  analysis  was  made,  must,  it 
would  seem,  have  been  very  brittle  material,  and  would  have  been  ex- 
pected to  result  in  a  split  head.  According  to  the  record,  this  rail  was 
in  service  on  the  low  rail  of  a  2°  08'  curve  on  the  westbound  track  west 
of  Crestline,  Ohio,  for  ten  years,  changed  to  the  high  side  and  left  in 
service  for  seven  years  more.  The  microphotographs  show  that  at  the 
top  of  the  head  and  54  ni-  below  the  top  the  metal  is  of  low  carbon,  prob- 
ably not  over  .35  or  .40  per  cent.,  although  below  this  the  metal  is  of  high 
carbon,  as  shown  by  the  analysis,  namely,  .641  per  cent,  but  still  the  rail 
seems  not  to  have  flowed  badly  while  on  the  inner  side  of  the  curve. 
Whether  this  means  that  the  rail  was  not  subjected  to  very  severe,  or  there 
was  some  other  reason  for  its  long  service,  I  cannot  say. 

On  the  high  rail  of  a  curve  the  rail  seems  not  to  be  particular!}' 
subject  to  failure,  and  in  this  connection  the  following  figures  will  be 
interesting.  In  Reports  12  and  13,  covering  studies  of  failed  rails,  Mr. 
Gushing  included  52  split  Bessemer  rails,  and  these  were  distributed  as 
follows : 

Straight  High  Rail  Low  Rail 

Line.  of  Curve.  of  Curve.  Total. 

25  rails  4  rails  23  rails  52  rails 

48  per  cent.  8  per  cent.  44  per  cent.  100  per  cent. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS.  577 

As  to  what  the  relative  probability  is  of  failure  on  straight  line  and 
on  curve,  the  above  figures  do  not  show,  as  we  cannot  say  the  number 
of  miles  of  track  represented  by  the  above  failures,  but  they  would  seem 
to  indicate  that  the  liability  to  failure  is  about  15  per  cent  on  the  high  of 
what  it  is  on  the  low  rail. 

Conclusion. — This  study  indicates  that  the  present  specifications  for 
Bessemer  rails  are  consistent  with  long  service  and  that  under  some 
conditions  a  segregated  rail  high  in  phosphorus,  and  possibly  also  carbon, 
may  give  long  service,  although  it  does  not  define  these  conditions,  either 
of  track  or  of  material. 

REPORTS    OF    INDIVIDUAL   RAILS. 

The  rest  of  this  report  deals  with  statements  concerning  the  indi- 
vidual rails,  photographs  of  sections  etched  with  picric  acid  and  five 
microphotographs  of  each  rail.    The  following  abbreviations  are  used : 

C  = carbon. 

P  =  phosphorus. 

S  =  sulphur. 

Mn  =  manganese. 

Si  =  silicon. 

E.  L.  =  elastic  limit. 

T.  S.  =  tensile  strength. 

Elong.  =  elongation. 

Red.  area  =  reduction  of  area 


578 


RAIL. 


RAIL  i. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  April,  1893, 
heat  890.  High  rail  of  2-degree  curve,  east  of  Highland,  Pa.,  grade  .87 
per  cent.  In  service  16  years.  Rail  was  originally  in  eastbound  track. 
In  1904  this  became  eastbound  freight  track.  Some  of  this  rail  still  in  track 
in  good  condition.  Speed  on  main  track,  60  miles  per  hour.  Speed  on 
freight  track,  40  miles  per  hour. 

C  .475,  Mn  .85,  P  .127,  Si  .040,  S  .043. 


Fig.  2.    Rail  i,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


579 


Fig.  3.     Rail  i,  at  Top  of  Head. 


Fig.  4.    Rail  i,  *4  in-  Below  Top 


Fig.  5.     Rail  i,  }/i  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  6.    Rail  i,  Va  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  7-    Rail  i,  i  in.  Below  Top. 

mlcrophotographs  of  rail  i,  magnified  about  65  diameters- 


i80 


RAIL. 


RAIL  2. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  December,  1892, 
heat  4803.  Low  rail  of  2-degree  curve,  east  of  Highland,  Pa.,  grade  .87  per 
cent.  In  service  16  years.  Rail  originally  in  eastbound  main  track.  In 
1904  this  became  eastbound  freight  track.  Some  of  this  rail  still  in  track 
in  good  condition.  Speed  on  main  track,  60  miles  per  hour.  Speed  on 
freight  track,  40  miles  per  hour. 

C  .556,  Mn  1.05,  P  .135,  Si  .090,  S  .050. 


Fig.  8.     Rail  2,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


581 


Fig.  g.     Rail  2,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  10.    Rail  2,  l/i  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  11.    Rail  2,  ]/2  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  12.    Rail  2,  24  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  13.    Rail  2,  1  in.  from  Top. 

Microphotographs  of  Rail  2,  Magnified  About  65  Diameters. 


582 


RAfL 


RAIL  3. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  August,  [892. 
heat  2753.  On  tangent,  eastbound  track,  East  Division,  west  of  Crestline. 
O.     In  service  17  years.     Some  still  in  track  in  good  condition. 

C  .497,  M'n  1.01,  P  .118,  Si  .076,  S  .031. 


Fig.  14.    Rail  3,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


583 


yx    ■  ■.  y;  t ■.  j.\r- 

*2»  ^'■^h-^^.J- 


Fig.  is.     Rail  3,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  16.    Rail  3,  J4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  17.    Rail  3,  >4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  18.    Rail  3,  %.  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  ig.    Rail  3,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL    3,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT   65    DIAMETERS. 


584 


RAIL. 


RAIL  4. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  August,  1892, 
heat  2764.  On  tangent,  eastbound  track,  East  Division,  west  of  Crestline, 
O     In  service  17  years.    Some  still  in  track  in  good  condition. 

C  .560,  Mn  1.04,  P  .156,  Si  .075,  S  .044. 


Fig.  20.    Rail  4,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


585 


Fig.  21.    Rail  4,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  22.    Rail  4,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  23.    Rail  4,  l/2  in.  Below  Top. 


^,^9$^> 


/.■■■,'■■■ 


Fig.  24.    Rail  4,  54  *N-  Below  Top.  Fig.  25.    Rail  4,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL    4,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT    65    DIAMETERS. 


586 


RAIL. 


RAIL  5. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  April,  1892, 
heat  1872.  High  rail  2  degrees,  08  minute  curve,  East  Division,  west  of 
Crestline,  O.,  westbound  track.  In  service  17  years.  Rail  originally  on  low 
side  of  curve,  but  was  changed  to  high  side,  probably  about  1903. 

C  .641,  Mn  .70,  P  .189,  Si  .051,  S  .053. 


Fig.  26.    Rail  5,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


587 


Fig.  27.    Rail  5,  at  Top  of  Head. 


><$£^  ■ 


rt 


4j#"      ^1 


j  1  ....^ 


Fig.  28.    Rail  5,  J4  in.  Below  Top. 


I" 


A 

)«i 


■*• 


K  1 

Fig.  29.    Rail  5,  J<£  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  30.    Rail  5,  H  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  31.  Rail  5,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL   5,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT   65    DIAMETERS. 


588 


RAIL. 


RAIL  6. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  April,  1892, 
heat  1894.  High  rail  of  2  degrees,  08  minute  curve,  westbound  track,  East 
Division,  west  of  Crestline,  O.  In  service  17  years.  Rail  was  originally 
on  low  side,  but  was  changed  to  high  side,  probably  about  1903. 

C  .591,  Mn  .69,  P  .146,  Si  .049,  S  .044. 


Fig.  i>2.    Rail  6,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


589 


'-  ~% 


Fig.  33.    Rail  6,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  34.    Rail  6,  J4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  35.    Rail  6,  P2  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  36.    Rail  6,  Ya  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  37.  Rail  6,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL    6,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT    65    DIAMETERS. 


590 


RAIL. 


RAIL  7. 

Illinois  85-lb:  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  November,  1895, 
heat  39420.  Low  rail  of  o  degree,  40  minute  curve,  westbound  track,  West 
Division,  east  of  Valparaiso,  Ind.     In  service  14  years. 

C  .452,  Mn  .87,  P  .098,  Si  .168,  T.  S.  112,120  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
71,470  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  20.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  37.39  per  cent. 


Fig.  38.    Rail  7,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


591 


^"^S 

^¥ 

%^E£e?\ 

y&*&4 

Fig.  39.    Rail  7,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  40.    Rail  7,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  41.    Rail  7,  ^  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  42.    Rail  7,  ^  in.  Below  Top.         Fig.  43.    Rail  7,  1  in.  Below  Top. 
Microphotographs  of  Rail  7,  Magnified  About  65  Diameters. 


592 


RAIL. 


RAIL  S. 

Illinois  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  November,  1895, 
heat  39503.  Low  rail  of  2  degrees,  20  minute  curve,  West  Division,  east  of 
Valparaiso,  Ind.     In  service  14  years,  laid  1896. 

C  .489,  Mn  .96,  P  .ioi,  Si  .142,  T.  S.  121,240  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
70,900  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  18  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  37.59  per  cent. 


Fig.  44.    Rail  8,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


593 


Fig.  45.    Rail  8,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  46.    Rail  8,  $4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  47.    Rail  8,  rA  in.  Below  Top. 


■■■■***»•■ 


V-«/^:;iL 


Fig.  48.    Rail  8,  54  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  49-    Rail  8,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

mlcrophotographs  of  rail  8,  magnified  about  65  diameters. 


594 


RAIL. 


RAIL  g. 

Illinois  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  November,  1895, 
heat  39420.  High  rail  of  o  degree,  40  minute  curve,  westbound  track,  West 
Division,  east  of  Valparaiso,  Ind.     In  service  14  years,  laid  1896. 

C  .480,  Mn  .91,  P  .102,  Si  .163,  T.  S.   116,450  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L 
74,940  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  18.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  31.74  per  cent. 


y  I  ■ 


J^***., 


r 


Fig.  50.    Rail  9,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS 


595 


Fig.  si.    Rail  g,  at  Top  of  Head. 


Fig.  52.    Rail  g,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  S3.    Rail  g,  Yz  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  54.    Rail  g,  $4  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  55.  Rail  g,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL   g,    MAGNIFIED   ABOUT   65    DIAMETERS. 


596 


RATL. 


RAIL    so. 

Illinois  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section  bessemer  steel,  rolled  November,  1895, 
heat  39513.  High  rail  of  2  degrees,  20  minute  curve,  westbound  track,  West 
Division,  east  of  Valparaiso,  Ind.    In  service  14  years,  laid  1895. 

C  .478,  Mn  1.01,  P  .097,  Si  .149,  T.  S.  117,580  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
66,230  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  19  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  30.11  per  cent. 


Fig.  56.    Rail  10,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


597 


Fig.  57.  Rail  10,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  58.  Rail  10,  ^4  IN-  Below  Top. 


Fig.  59.  Rail  10,  l/2  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  60.  Rail  10,  YA  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  61.  Rail  10,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL    10,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT   65    DIAMETERS. 


598 


RAIL. 


RAIL  n. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  section,  heat  10639,  rolled  March,  1899. 
Laid  May,  1899,  on  straight  line,  and  removed  August  4,  1910.  In  service 
11  years. 

C  .579,  Mn  1.04,  P  .094,  Si  .149.  T.  S.  121,650  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
88,840  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  16  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  22.21  per  cent. 


Fin.  62.    Rail  ii,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


599 


Fig.  63.  Rail  ii,  at  Top  of  Head.   &H        Fig.  64.  Rail  ii,  J4  in-  Below  Top. 


Fig.  65.  Rail  ii,  14  in.  Below  Top. 


V"\ 


'-  ■>«: ■-*■•♦*- 


.,*:      -y    v     ■    : 


*\-<r> 


'XU^  _•/. 


T^^fe 


Fig.  66.  Rail  ii,  ?4  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  67.  Rail  ii,  i  in.  Below  Top. 

mlcrophotographs  of  rail  ii,  magnified  about  65  diameters. 


600 


RAIL. 


RAIL  12. 

Illinois,  South  Works,  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section,  rolled  in  November, 
1894.  Laid  January,  1895,  on  straight  line,  removed  July  18,  1910.  In 
service   iSjA  years. 

C  .476,  Mn  1.06,  P  .091,  Si  .133,  T.  S.  113,450  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
82,160  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  6.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  4.75  per  cent. 


Fig.  68.    Rail  12,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


601 


Fig.  69.  Rail  12,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  70.  Rail  12,  J4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  71.  Rail  12,  Yt.  in.  Below  Top. 


'  4*$jL 

•  ■  ™  ■  "'■ 

• 

•yl$|r 

Fig.  72.  Rail  12,  %  in.  Below  Top.         Fig.  73-  Fail  12,  1  in.  Below  Top. 
Microphotographs  of  Rail  12,  Magnified  About  65  Diameters. 


602 


RAIL. 


RAIL  13. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  section,  rolled  December,  1892.  Laid  Janu- 
ary, 1893,  on  straight  line,  removed  July  26,  1910.     In  service  17V2  years. 

C  .493,  Mn  1.06,  P  .126,  Si  .149,  T.  S.  116,510  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
79,720  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  18  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  26.39  per  cent. 


Fig.  74.    Rail  13,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


60c 


Fig.  75.  Rail  13,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  76.  Rail  13,  J4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  77.  Rail  13,  14  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  78.  Rail  13,  Y\  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  79.  Rail  13,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

Microphotographs  of  Rail  13,  Magnified  About  65  Diameters. 


604 


RAIL. 


RAIL  14. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  section,  rolled  March,  1899.  Laid  April, 
1899,  on  straight  line,  removed  March,  1910.     In  service  11  years. 

C  .591,  Mn  .78,  P  .119,  Si  .079,  T.  S.  117,540  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
78,730  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  4  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  5.57  per  cent. 


Fig.  80.    Rail  14,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


605 


Fig.  8i.  Rail  14,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  82.  Rail  14,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  83.  Rail  14,  *A  in.  Below.  Top. 


Fig.  84   Rail  14,  yi  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  85.  Rail  14,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF   RAIL    14,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT   65    DIAMETERS. 


006 


RAIL. 


RATL   15. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  section,  rolled  March  1899.  Laid  May,  1899, 
on  straight  line;  removed  July  29,  1910.     In  service  11  years. 

C  .558,  Mn  .96,  P  .101,  Si  .118,  T.  S.  118.440  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
83,850  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.   15  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  19  per  cent. 


Fig.  86.    Rail  15,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


607 


Fig.  87.  Rail  15,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  88.  Rail  15,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  89.  Rail  15,  y2  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  90.  Rail  15,  24  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  91.  Rail  15,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

Microphotographs  of  Rail  15,  Magnified  About  65  Diameters. 


608 


RAIL. 


RAIL  16. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  section,  rolled  November,  1902.  Laid 
August,  1903,  on  straight  line ;  removed  August  19,  1910.  In  service  7 
years. 

C  .515,  Mn  1 .08,  P  .113,  Si  .135,  T.  S.  117,580  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
85,580  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  18.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  28.43  per  cent. 


Fig.  92.    Rail  i6,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY  OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


609 


A        /"*>      '-If*  M 


&    i  a. 


Fig.  93.  Rail  16,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  94.  Rail  16,  ^4  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig  95.  Rail  16,  V2  in.  Below  Top. 


M'«mrJr&:, 


Fig.  96.  Rail  16,  54  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  97.  Rail  16,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS   OF   RAIL    l6,    MAGNIFIED   ABOUT  65    DIAMETERS. 


610 


RAIL. 


RAIL  17. 

Carnegie  85-lb.  A.  S.  C.  E.  section,  rolled  January,  1903.  Laid  Feb- 
ruary, 1903,  on  straight  line ;  removed  August  20,  1910.    In  service  7  years. 

C  .476,  Mn  .79,  P  .096,  Si  .056,  T.  S.  102,900  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  E.  L. 
74,940  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  elong.  23.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.,  red.  area  38.82  per  cent. 


Fig.  98.    Rail  17,  Etched  with  Picric  Acid. 


A  STUDY   OF  GOOD  SERVICE  RAILS. 


611 


Fig  99.  Rail  17,  at  Top  of  Head.  Fig.  100.  Rail  17,  %  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  ioi.    Rail  17,  y2  in.  Below  Top. 


Fig.  102.    Rail  17,  54  in.  Below  Top.  Fig.  103.  Rail  17,  1  in.  Below  Top. 

MlCROPHOTOGRAPHS    OF    RAIL    17,    MAGNIFIED    ABOUT    65    DIAMETERS. 


Appendix    B. 

REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  IV— ON  RAIL. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

The  Committee  on  Rail  submits,  for  your  information,  the  Rail  Fail- 
ure Statistics  for  the  year  ending  October  31,  1910.  The  work  of  col- 
lecting and  compiling  these  statements,  as  well  as  the  study  of  the  sta- 
tistics, was  done  by  Mr.  Cushing.  The  work  entailed  in  compiling  and 
digesting  the  statistics  is  quite  large.  After  the  receipt  of  the  various 
reports,  a  great  deal  of  correspondence  was  necessary  to  supply  small 
omissions  or  clear  up  uncertainties,  all  of  which  required  time,  with  the 
result  that  it  has  taken  until  the  middle  of  June  to  finish  the  work. 

The  Committee  decided  not  to  publish  all  of  the  detail  statements 
submitted.  These  can  be  secured,  upon  request  to  the  Secretary,  by  any- 
one desiring  to  make  use  of  them. 

RAIL   FAILURE    STATISTICS    FOR   ONE    YEAR   ENDING 
OCTOBER  31,  1910. 

The  responses  to  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association 
circular  have  been  much  more  complete  than  before  and  show  that  the 
majority  of  the  railroads  are  now  keeping  a  record  of  their  rail  failures. 
Answers  were  received  from  125  companies,  42  of  whom  either  have  no 
information  to  furnish  or  the  reports  were  too  incomplete  to  be  of  any 
service.  Eighty-three  companies  furnished  statistics  of  failures  relating 
to  11,759,039  tons  of  rail. 

The  report  consists  of  the  following  divisions : 

(1)  A  tabulation   of  the  information   received  from   each  company,   pp. 

1  to  63. 

(2)  A  summary  by  sections,  weights  and  kinds  of  steel,  pp.  64  to  71. 

(3)  A  tabulation  of  data  for  Diagrams  1  to  5,  pp.  72  to  86. 

(4)  A  report  of  failures  classified  according  to  the  position  in  the  ingot, 

pp.  87  to  141. 

(5)  A  report  on  the  comparative  wear  of  special  rails,  pp.  142  to  162. 

(6)  Diagrams    1,    2,    3,   4    and    5,    showing    the    comparison    of   failures 

graphically   for  different  studies. 

These  details  will  not  be  printed  with  this  dige§t,  but  can  be  pro- 
cured from  the  Secretary  by  anyone  desiring  them, 

613 


614 


RAIL. 


c 

■aE 

td 

a 

mti      a 

it 

ft 
=3 

& 

2 

c  = 
3  a> 

cUcO 

to 

•eg 

B 

c  c  ,,  S 

03 
O 

oi 

0 

1I|i 

u. 

3^2 

S.S 

03  =>,2  03 

'3 

.3.S°8.E 

So       g  o3'E  r 

1    ,3'3  8'E 

^QhPj^!        S  C 

O                      c 

6   >>ft  B 

00|0 

mS 

c 

»  -  ^  - 

0 
X 

c 

5 
X 

C 

c 
c 
I 

P- 

1 
c 

c 

X 

u 

c 

£ 

1    = 

c 
C 

a 

E 

ft 

7 

c 
Eh 

c 

c 

ft 

E 

0 

> 

0 

0 

-;  — 
5  : 

2 

cs  cj 

11 

s 

% 

At 
c 

c 
PC 

0  c 
020: 

- 
1 

2 

C 

o 

10  m 

CN 

to 

m 

— 

0 

0 

a. 

ti 

t>. 

o 

a 

— 

c; 

onoc 

DQ 

O 

*-<  <N 

<M 

01 

N  C 

N  c 

c-i 

a 

a 

—  — 

0 

0 

oooooooo»oooo 

ja 

ffl  c 

ooc 

C  -c 

^  OS 

— .  :/: 

:i  /: 

CI 

a> 

00 

O 

rH 

« 

- 

-1 

•* 

rt 

rt 

w 

"-1 

-1 

■T3 

- 

00 



- 

:^ 

00  0 

O  C 

a 

02 

ft 

r  - 

0  c 

0 

>o 

cocoiocoeo-^poooccooer 

o 

ia  -r 

ujTfw: 

«©•«* 

lO  CD 

IQ  -1- 

IC  ■* 

-* 

0 

c 

C3 

*o           0 

t4 

oof 

oc 

»o  0  't  c 

— 

'T4  a:  O  CN 

•OC 

c,7 

•T 

9sio7 

rorogc- 

22c 

cr 

- 

^c 

Ph 

'^  c 

a 

— 

*H 

"H 

a) 

E 

of 

B 

2 

0 
> 

r 

1 

C 

E 

'5 

c 

x 
c 

"> 

>- 

r 
E 

-£ 

r 

•E 

'c 

E 

'S 

1 

D       it 

'e 

E 

c, 
1 

)      V 

"c 

.8 

c 
c 
a 

I 

% 

e 

1 

c 

E 
r 

| 

a 
S 
0 

c 

1 

1 

_;  c 

E  — 

'c 

SSC 

HP 

Izsk 

c 

S5SC 

ChH 

<- 

.- 

4 

mOww 

o> 
ED 

t-   u 

0  a  0  c 

O 

E  £  £ 

f=F 

F 

ESSE 

- 

SEEE 

at 

yt: 

fc 

fe 

asss 

c 

00c 

8)   C 

a 

r    r   c    - 

O    03    O   C 

S  S  S  m 

O  CD  Q>  a 

0  a 

O    8 

c 

0 

O   0)   0)  0) 

mfflo: 

«ff 

PC 

pppppppc 

IS 

cscafflc: 

pace 

pqp: 

PC 

PC 

ffiEPMPQ 

g 

o 

-<PQp£ 

pp< 

PC 

WW 

l1*?"?^ 

w> 

B 

B 

£ 

B 

HS 

<<c 

<< 

< 

do 

<<<«c 

OC 

OC 

C 

C 

OO 

o 
02 

P^PhCC 

£p: 

pq 

02  cocoa: 

CO 

pjtfp^a 

03  CC 

ma: 

cc 

a, 

02  QQ  02  CO 

<■<< 

« 

< 

0«!<P- 

ft 

<<<;<< 

-<<: 

« 

< 

< 

^«<00 

OC 

OC 

c 

e 

0  0  »o  »o 

-2  t- 

OC 

3 

C53  00  00  0C 

00  00000c 

£s 

» 
1 

RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS. 


615 


CO 

f 

3 
■3 

so 

g 

s 

o 

H 
=8 

c 

T3 

3 

c 

c 

o 

e 

O 

3> 

a 

3 

Q 

& 

a 

0 
9 

c3 

a 
3 

►2  =8 

Z  .2 
=8o 

IS 
O 

•8  o 

0) 

=3 

a 

B 
M 

23 

T3 

•w 

& 

■a 

c 
(3 

> 

a 

h 

o 

33  & 

C3 

a 
O 

'3 
a 

ja 

1 

c 

a 

o 

(LI 

0 

S 

o 
0 

s 

B 

M 

O 

s 

n 

o 

3 
o 

«8 

a 
o 

a 

"a 
os 
an 

M 

o  m 
bo  a 

c3> 

■a 

o 

03 

id 

J3 

-C    CD 

ja 

O 

33 

« 

ffl 

B 

Hi 

u 

a 

s 

OH 

CM 

fc 

M 

c 

o   o 


£     5    ^ 

1 1  85 


D         w  w 


O     <!     <     O     O     O 


-2S 
o  o> 


|'S6 

Ph-S'S 

|p333 
$3333 

1£s 


£0 


00*00*00*000 


O  0*0  O  -*  *0  *0 


0000*00*00*000      000000    •  00000*000000000000000000      £2r^rt!    '2312! 

3§OONONONOM        O  OS  QO  -h  F^  O      •  t^  O IK  00  0«  35*-  06*-  0«0  0**0  CB !©Q«  OB  CO  C»  00        ^  ^  °°.      !  ^  ^  ^ 


OS  CO  OS      ■  *o 

CM  O  CO       -^  O 

000    •  o  — • 


<M*ococ©ioo*oo<N*oeNiioaseNiioiococo    •  coco*ocn*oo*ocococo      ^^^^^^S^^S^^^^^S    iSSS 

Ba£>CCNO00O00<DN«l>10i>l0OCDN      •  CO  r—  o  CO  t-  l^  00  co t—  CO       *0  t-  *o  O  *o  CO  iO  r-  *o  t-  CO  t-  co  t—  00     •  "<r  *o  CD 


^  __,  _«  ^-,  *-t  O 


OOO  O  O  OJO  ZJ>  1  ^— ' 


OS  OS         OS  OS 


o       01  O       01  OS  o 

—1       o  — «       o  o  ~^ 

OS         OS  OS         OS  OS  OS 


33 

33 

:33 

33 

33 

33     : 

33 

33 

§33 

33 

33 

33 

=8 

=8 

£^ 

c 

=8 

a 

0 
i 

.S 

=« 

=8 

E 

1 

1 

|     1 

.i   i 

°3^ 

X 

:     1 
'5    "> 

> 

,  0 

— 

c 

7 

S    C     oq     O 


n    e-i    h 


"o  » 

OH 


O  ^  C3  a>        ,^        ^        r^        -- 


aatnKaKMWW 


000000000 


"Em      Em 
c3  03        C3  « 


aaaaaaaaa 


00000000 


<  <     <     <<     Wh     H 

<  «sj     •<!     <<!     <)o    o 
33    33    33    3333    33co    05    0 


a     W     H     H 

dodo 


hh    a 
dd   d 


Z     Z     ai     ai     co     m     aj     coco     cdco33 


-<     «<     <i<     <<     <JOOO<!«i!<J-«)ai     <J<!     <<0<3 


o      00      00      o 


00        CO        00 


00      iomo 


616 


RAIL. 


1 

■A 

6 

c 

O 

^ 

•-» 

2 

o 

c 

s 

1 

6 

a. 

iJ 

<c 

3 

■s 

E 

i 

.S 

h3 

o 

Ti 

s 

S5    i 

1 

o 

'3 
pq- 

i 

a 

<3 

o 
E 
c 

S 

CO 

=3   d 

•      Pi 

.       J3 

i 

v. 

.  c 
tfPM 

p 
fa 

o 

a 

O  if) 

.  » 

.►J 

O        s! 

2  1 

'•3 

*^ 

c 

PQ 

o 

PC 

E 

._ 

o 

PJ.2 

*2 

fiP 

a  o 

.2     a     I 

0 

03 

S  a 

~  - 

.« 

n 

s 

U 

o 

(J 

'/ 

u 

pq 

0 

PL.& 

P3 

UPm 

PhU 

WOO 

+3 

§ 

C  m 

1] 

11 

13 

X 

w 

X 

a 
— 

-d 

-3 

pq 

-TJT3 

a 

S3 

0 

g 

— 

8>    •? 

J3  w 

<D          05          SI 

W      M      u     ,- - 
o3        o3        ct      <J 
.«      .US      .*       „ 

J2=3     -rj 

esO 
e3  °< 

a 

a 

3>i 

d>    .  —  o 

£ 

fao.         Q.Q.         t-D-Cl.** 

O 

CO 

a. 

a 

pq 

CO 

pq 

pq 

pq 

CO 

pqcq 

O 

pqco 

coco 

pqco  co  P3 

a 

o 

<M 

■O" 

CO 

!5 

'55 

2 

e» 

US 

£1 

GO 

o 

oo 

o 

o 

a 

o 

"3 
a 

s 

c 

c 

c 

_ 

c 

c 

ooc 

mo 

»OOOoOOO        O        !>■  O 

GO 

ocmo 

eq  cj 

l» 

(M 

ci 

<N 

Tl 

CJ 

-him 

O0<l 

a 

a  - 

a  - 

o  a 

a  us 

■a  a 

a  e 

ooo 

ooc 

>MO 

oo«o 

o  »o  o  o  »o  U5  >o 

O 

* 

c 

OlOlOO        O        CO 

8 

© 
a 

GO 

fc 

o 

7 

~ 

oo 

o-< 

oo 

O 

:  a. 

CC  T 

■a  -* 

u~  S 

--3  -i- 

»o  -r 

io  5 

IQ  -r 

U5  IC 

o»o»c 

tO-*u 

5  kO  •«*  lO  -^  -^ 

»T3  -^i  to  lO  CO  >0  t— 

t~ 

o 

t^ 

oc 

c 

OJ                     00 

fa 
(3 

s 

1 

7 

T 

1 

c 

c 
1 

3 

OE 

E 
- 

Vr 

1 

Y7 

CO<T 

2  g  2 

o     2     o 

a 

a 

c~ 

oocr 

Ci 

CiO 

»-( ^ 

^H 

*-»•- 

t-l                          «-4 

fa 

s 

03 

CO 

3 

E 

(i 

c 

E 

a 

P 
< 

1 

a 

= 

03        m 

S 

a 

a 

c 
a 

03        ol 

03 

■R 

i     T 

1)         « 

°K 

P 

i 

0      tub 

ill 

03        03        O 

•J    O    Q 

"3 

9 

E 

a 

E 

- 

! 

i 

Jt 

Jtt 

b^    S 

3S 

=  c 

.    03 

e 

i 

7 

- 

!= 

«  03        C3 

H)  e 

O 

PC 

C. 

L 

>     C. 

1- 

L 

H 

tj 

ShJ       O 

P5L 

oc; 

o"aJ 
coo 

:    "3 

o 

:    !S 

01 

s 

in  o 

s 

fflg 

Si? 

i    i    i  w 

< 

< 

I 

IB    < 

<u 

'.  < 

(D    ' 

<b       a> 

pq 

c 

>      PC 

ft 

1    ff 

pt 

ft 

PC 

PC 

ft 

PQff 

PQ 

OP 

PQff 

)    pq    pq    O 

pa 

p 

5     t 

3     C 

r  - 

:    & 

1     & 

3     P= 

3     & 

5     & 

3      :& 

3     i 

a 

:    w& 

J     W     W     H 

o 

< 

< 

«     C 

>    «* 

i    C 

C 

>     C 

)     C 

)     C 

)    C 

)    PJC 

i   <: 

o 

:    OC 

)    o    o    o 

o 

s 

CO 

PS 

p 

5     a 

3      P 

3     a 

i     o 

i     v 

j     a 

5     a 

5    a 

j    pja 

5    Ph 

CQ0 

>     cQcy 

2      CO      CO      CO 

< 

*■ 

1     < 

5      C 

)     -a 

;   < 

J     < 

I     - 

1     < 

J     < 

J        Ph<I 

:    < 

<a 

^     << 

1     <!     <!     <J 

if  org 

;      oc 

>     o 

0>i- 

i      mit 

>      o      o      o 

o 

a 

a 

3      o 

c 

J 

>     t- 

t> 

a 

oa 

No.  of 

Failures 

per  10,000 

Tons  Laid 

>      c%a 

>      t^ 

oa 

•>         MO 

>       CO       -*<       CO 

: 

3        t^. 

CO 

o 

1          D 

1       c- 

1          T 

1      c 

B 

3      r 

*         U 

3     « 

•>        t* 

>      a 

c 

»■ 

1        CO 

h  i-' 

"- 

r- 

a 

3      a 

c 

> 

RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS. 


617 


_j 

od 

OC 

CD 

>-> 

K 

s 

& 

Es 

m 

a 
o 

O 

00 

«§    5 

h) 

-* 

n 

>i 

cq 

00 

o        CO 
cd      J4 

•a 

3 

C 

a 
P- 

c 
(- 
a 

—     *»     >> 

O   .  02     .2 
«      1      > 

QJ        O        J3 

i-3      « 
=3      o 

3      a 

ng  Valle 
li  Valley 

Lines— 
h.  Valley 
Pacific. 

Lines— 
&S.  F. 
lia. 

em  Paci 
ng  &  La 

are  &  B 
Pacific. 
3  Centra 
hore&M 
Trunk. 

■&       a 

ra      J      - 

S       a      -c 

w    -o 

c 

iz 

d^3      2     -2      »     <»      o     a      9     '3     .2      9H^-S      5     »     ^     .2     §8      S 

- 

4  4  4 

T3      -a 

a 

iw  a 

£ 
- 

a 

cr 

n     ~ 

T 

9 

>s 

T3      -C 

■C 

~ 

m  1ST 

SWtr 

a  *  g  §  -s 

b!      fcl      & 

o    o    Sf 
■e   -a   3 

S 

g 

3 

0,1— 
O  — 

<- 

s 

■J 

a 

* 

H 

cc 

a    tr 

■w      ■*- 

W    tr 

"2     '**■ 

c3     • 
c3ja  j: 

^  2  °  °  s 

Is     °8       &       &      * 

k 

P- 

Mac 

CC 

(1 

^ 

a 

a 

'     ft 

L 

a 

00       OC 

w    a 

cqoo    PC 

m    Pc 

P=l      OC 

oo    oo    pq 

10 

>c 

.- 

lO 

c 

o 

O 

o 

c 

c 

c 

a 

o 

e 

o 

CO 

o 

1Q 

o  3 

C)  CI 

ci 

o 

Cl  Cl 

o 

C!    7 

IM 

c 

Cl 

c 

c 

c 

OS3 

O  C 

S3  C 

IOC 

>o  c 

oc 

OK5 

»o  cc 

o 

OC 

o 

oc 

o  — 

oc 

cl  oc 

—  X 

C  i  V 

f\  s 

►H  0( 

a 

o  — 

-HCO^H 

c 

<r 

a 

e 

C 

c 

c 

o 

a 

K 

o 

o 

o 

— 

o 

O 

O 

- 

ui 

W 

lO 

o 

cz 

o 

cc 

oo>* 

«*  re 

oo  a 

O  IC 

not- 

I-  - 

oio 

oo 

lO 

IOC 

M  >C 

IOC 

no 

r/3-f 

o  -+ 

•  o  -t- 

m  -i- 

■^lO 

iOcou" 

>o  iO  «o 

oc 

X 

a 

a 

o 

o 

03 

03 

OS 

-o 

1 
cc 

cc 

I 

i 

<o 

cm. 

a 

oa 

o 

1 

Y 

CI 

C 

A 

BO 

c-> 
2 

00 

a 

93 

o 
— 

_j 

1 

1 

T 

C 

T 

2 

= 

o: 

a 

~ 

OS 

C5 

CC 

Oi 

ca 

> 

» 

cS 

aj 

s 

a 

£ 

i 

a 

OB 

1 

c* 

> 

<n 

E 

d 

= 

B 

B 
C 

^ 

°c 

B 

t 

E 

1        b 

a 

B 

2 

1 

E 
a 

c 

1 

■a 

i 

'c 
c 

b 
C 

1        b 

c 

■ 

'c 

J 
c 

b 

0 

f 

b 

a 

E 

'3 
i 

a 

o 
S 

S3 

-5 

a 

a 

- 

r— 

L 

C 

pq 

M 

u 

h-i 

u 

> 

K 

u 

U 

u 

u 

h-1 

(J 

u 

a 

U 

3 

t-5 

■    Q 

H 

0 

0 

a 

a 

tr 

a 

0 

a 

0 

o 

j«   tr 

a 

0 

tr 

J 

0 

3 

a 

0 

a 

1 

0 

cr 

3 

D 

n 

w 

ft 

cc 

& 

c 

cc 

PO 

PC 

tapq 

& 

cc 

C 

PQ 

PC 

pq 

Ch 

cq 

pq 

CC 

pq 

CC 

pq 

ca 

pq 

o 

H 

H 

w 

w 

W 

a 

a 

W 

w 

W 

<5 

<j 

K 

H 

W 

H 

H 

H 

« 

m 

O 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

O 

O 

o 

O 

O 

O 

O 

o 

00 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

CO 

DC 

oo 

OO 

PC 

Pi 

00 

oo 

00 

00 

00 

od 

00 

a 

od 

< 

< 

«! 

<! 

«* 

<! 

O 

< 

< 

O 

P^ 

< 

O 

<! 

<J 

<4 

< 

<! 

< 

<; 

<4 

O 

< 

< 

1C 

a 

a 

a 

o 

a 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

o 

to 

■n 

0 

oc 

at 

cc 

cr 

— 

— 

a 

a 

OS 

OS 

oc 

03 

00 

CO 

00 

03 

OS 

CTi 

00 

93 

O 

oo 

t~ 

CO 

t^ 

-* 

— 

x 

in 

»Q 

-f> 

CI 

s 

DO 

-f 

cc 

eci 

i-C 

o 

o 

O 

03 

03 

OS 

03J 

CO 

o 

CO 

r^- 

CO 

0B 

o 

CM 

cc 

-r 

»o 

CO 

Cl 

c 

CM 

cc 

CO 

CC 

CC 

00 

CC 

* 

■* 

-r 

■<# 

■* 

618 


RAIL. 


DQ      ^ 

d 
O 

6 

4 

ias?  i  i  ^ 

£fi    §    1   ^ 

sS^  a  a  / 

O 

s 
3 

3, ;!,  ,  |  '■* 

3        K 
•3      i-i 

h3 

a 

o 
"3 

c 

<y  pc 

°3      ^ 

a 

| 

a  ■»  =5  ^ 
=3    »  > 

°3 

,d  £  M       <3        03                 "c 

* 

PC 

«   3  . 

"  s  | 

J3       (- 

3 

gj'! 

el 

PC 

r 

- 

F- 

o     .1: 

3    C 

ta 

c 

0 

Sx           C 

o 

reQ^ 

Ph    Pi    <_ 

< 

> 

L 

L 

O       H 

P 

c 

PQ     P 

hQ    c 

CQ 

+3 

TO    CO 

.3  9 

X 

T 

c: 

T 

T 

s 

■5 

t: 

T 

•       X 

m'T 

«    tr 

- 

* 

t 

w    . 

tr 

P 

„ 

•0 

\    cc 

a  = 

,45  S[r 

c 

f- 

C 

«5      l& 
e3      ^= 

h        u 

o   c 

B 

die 

caja-<- 

M     r- 

CO 

« 

< 

K 

«fe 

* 

Jl 

=8     "S 

* 

•k 

OS       "« 

tj 

a 

- 

c 

0>    Tj'~ 

o 

Cm 

reCQC 

DC 

a. 

PI 

l» 

re 

a, 

p 

03      ff 

re 

re 

CQUre 

PQ      03 

PQ 

0 

a 

P. 

n 

03 

ooo 

IB 

"- 

-So 

oo 

C 

C 

o 

O 

1" 

i 

1 

DD 

•CS 

CM 

<N 

c 

CJ  C 

*"H 

NO-io 

ON- 

CS  CM        CN 

IM        cs 

CN 

0000000000"OCMOO»OOOOOOCMOOOOOOO 

O 

£ 

CI  c 

cm 

00 

—  X 

iH  X 

:i  /: 

rH   _ 

^h  oo  Oi  00  <M  OC 

i— i  CO  OS  OC 

-HOO-h 

a 

— 

~ 

C 

— 

C 

~ 

o      c 

-*      c 

o 

0) 

Ph 

c 

c 

a 
03 

a 

00  IB 

IB  ^ 

oe  ic 

ONCOiOiflfc 

OO  CC  CO 

o 

•■«* 

u:  -?■ 

«3  -r 

OTf 

e 

OC 

a 

OS       o- 

= 

o 

w; 

u 

05  *?  7 

<= 

'T 

o 

c 

o      o 

2    3 

§ 

- 

<c 

c 

s 

- 

- 

io      a- 
o      o- 

C 

s 

2    S 

o 

- 

H      *"" 

^^ 

s> 

!        e3 

OS 

3 
03 

_a 

a 

B 
E 

_e 

T 

— 

E 

.s 

DL 

« 

a 

a 

a 

a    e 

.     -0       S 

3 
8 
c3 

& 

3 

!&* 

c 

a 

B 

1 

^ 

- 

E 

c 

B 

£ 

a 

F 

e      c 

J      J< 

Ai 

0 

D 

— 

o 

0 

»           cj 

sS^ 

<_ 

C 

M 

h- 

(_. 

~ 

fe 

O     C 

L 

L. 

O     C 

PQ     i-C 

J 

o'© 

-5 

cm 

Kg? 

i    i 

■HWsr 

M 

0 

a 

a 

a 

a 

o       a 

o 

OPQP 

PC 

cc 

P 

co 

PC 

PQ 

ffi 

PQ     P 

PC 

P 

PQ     P 

ZOP 

CQ 

<wpq 

H 

R 

H 

m 

K 

O 

W 

H 

P 

H 

W     W 

w    w 

w 

§ 

<dc 

C 

C 

C 

c 

C 

c 

C 

<c 

U 

O     C 

o    o 

o 

a 
DQ 

#03  03 

re 

re 

03 

03 

re 

CQ 

cc 

03       K 

Pi 

re 

re    re 

03      03 

re 

^<<< 

-«! 

< 

0 

0 

< 

O 

< 

O       <l 

<! 

<! 

<!     -^ 

<    < 

< 

OOC 

ira      o 

o 

m 

lO       o 

o     o 

caoo  cr 

c 

c 

- 

00 

OC 

oo 

- 

•XS 

o.  of 

0,000 
s  Lai 

HffiC 

l-~       cc 

■t 

■<t 

CO        CM 

-H        o 

oo 

OiOOCC 

OC 

OC 

0C 

X 

r~       t- 

t^        t~ 

•7  aj'-1  O 

N 

lO       cc 

r* 

cc 

Oi       o 

*-l        CM 

CO 

4  r* 

<* 

-I 

<r 

IC 

"■ 

>c 

u- 

RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS. 


619 


Pi 


< 

> 

•w 

tfbi 

c 

.a  o 

.2'J2 

a  a 

=>    O 

- 

sa 

1 


CO      tCZ 

cj  o 

P*     • 

gtf 

5  « 


*     -8 


o    pq    o    cq 


s§  -a  -3 

S     CQ     CQ 


O     -13     to 


fc>   Z    0    co    % 


a 

Ji  -sal* 


»«8     =3 


■w°8 


CQ       CO       DQ  PQ  00  CO       X       CQ       O       X  X 


K    ffi 


s   w   s 


Or>  be  oj)     ,~ 
o  jj  d     33 


o  <t>       — 


U       X       CQ       X       XXCQCQ       CO 


^  ^3  T3   bO  bO 
fin  X  X  CQ  CQ 


o>  o>      jj       ._; 


o 

O 

o 

=8 

=8 

°8 

X 

a 
/ 

a 

X 

^-    —    —     —  CM  .-<    M  CM 


'/:  r?  o       co  i-H 

O  ^  Tl         O  O 


^h  ^h  CM         ONM         Ol         ~h  tM  (M 


o  o  a  o  c  a  la 

00HO>H«rt© 


OWNCCOO 


t>.         00  O  GO  CM  GO  i— t  00  •— t  CO  »-i  CO  •-<  00  *-t  O 


^-  O  O  ^H  »-.  ^H  O  ^h  O 


-  cs  co  o  as 


O         fH         W         rH 


OiOO        COO        COcO*OtOtO»OiOiO 

Tt<ioo      vio      -^  l': t  m  Tf  io  t  io 


'f  iO  c:  d  to  O  03  O 
tOCO'rfiO^cO-^iO 


aa      cocoooioioooocx      co  co  co 

CO         TjiiOTj<tO-*?itOiOCO-^r»-Tp         ^iq^i 


o      ^      cs  X;      £; 


1-H  O  O  ^~H 

II  II 

■*         «-i         GO         CCi 


oo      ao 


i  T 


^H  -H  O  — 

I  I  I        § 

o      o      o      2 


s    5 

=5         01 

O     CQ 


'5>     *      s-     fe 


'a  b     5  S 

3  2        C-« 


J    hJ    o    o    oh    oj 


O     O     =3     kQ     O     PQ     O 


©fljoSSSSooj*-       35  53       35       <5       53       53   '•       55ci533ci5a5<i5a5<S 

CC      CQ      CQCC      CQ      CQ      PQ      CQ      CQO      PQCQ      «      ffl     ffl      CQO      CQCQpQPQCQpqpqcq 


s 

H    : 

H 

o 

<i 

o>> 

o 

CO 

=8 
CQ 

cc-a 

.    3 

CO 

< 

QO 

oo 

occo 

oo 

a 

CQ 

W  : 

HH 

H 

H 

H 

o 

<! 

O  : 

OO 

O 

O 

O 

X 

« 

88  X 

ccco 

X 

X 

X 

<j 

< 

<JPh 

<< 

< 

-«) 

<) 

<j 

<< 

H 

H 

W 

<< 

^ 

d 

>>      : 

d 

d 

T 

tf 

Pi 

CO      K 

=3    ^ 

CO 

CO 

OP-l<i«i<dQO«i^ 


CO         5C  CO 


co  -o       CO 


o  >o      oo 

CiGO         GOCS 


tO        «5iC        *C  *0        *0        "O 


CM  CO         -rpiO         CO 


io      »o      to      to 


iO         ~4         CN         CO 


•CO         OOCOCOGOCOGOCOG© 


620  RAIL. 

In  Vol.  12,  Part  2,  page  143,  et  seq.,  will  be  found  the  drawings  of 
nearly  all  of  the  rail  sections  referred  to,  an  effort  having  been  made  to 
make  this  collection  of  drawings  as  complete  as  possible,  for  future  refer- 
ence. 

GENERAL   SUMMARY    (PP.    I   TO  63). 

In  considering  the  statistics  as  tabulated,  all  lots  of  less  than  1,000 
tons  have  been  ignored,  as  they  usually  lead  to  exaggerated  results. 

The  number  of  failures  range  from  o  to  1129  per  10,000  tons  of  new 
rail  laid. 

There  were  no  failures  reported  for  the  various  lots  of  rail  listed  in 
Table  1. 

It  will  be  noticed,  however,  that  nearly  all  of  these  lots  are  of  the 
years  1909  and  1910,  the  rail  being  thus  too  new  to  have  begun  failing. 
In  the  few  cases  where  the  rail  is  of  an  earlier  date,  it  is  quite  likely 
that  the  poor  rails  have  already  been  weeded  out. 

In  addition  to  the  above,  there  are  many  lots  in  which  there  was  only 
one  failure,  or  even  but  two  or  three,  but  to  have  listed  them  also  would 
have  required  too  much  space. 

For  these  various  lots,  the  prescribed  chemical  constituents  run  about 
as  follows : 

For  P.  .10    the  C.  runs  from  .43  to  .58. 

For  P.  .085  the  C.  runs  from  .55  to  .65. 

For  P.  .06     the  C.  runs  from  .55  to  .68. 

For  P.  .04     the  C.  runs  from  .63  to  .76,  and  even  .80. 

For  P.  .03     the  C.  runs  from  .70  to  .85. 

The  1 129  failures  per  10,000  tons  were  of  the  90-lb.  A.S.CE. 
chromium-nickel  rail  of  the  year  1909,  on  the  Central  Railroad  of  New 
Jersey,  the  chemical  composition  of  which  is  not  given.  The  rate  of 
failure  is  higher  than  ever,  and  it  will  be  found  on  page  61  that  70  per 
cent,  of  them  were  breakages  and  nearly  all  the  rest  split  heads.  The 
failures  are  characteristic  of  this  product,  the  breakages  occurring  from 
hair-line  cracks,  and  the  "split  heads"  being  longitudinal  seams  instead  of 
the  usual  split  head.  After  the  first  shower  after  being  laid,  dark  purple 
stains    appear. 

In  Table  2  the  maximum  number  of  failures  in  diminishing  order 
down  to  50  have  been  listed  for  convenience  in  studying  the  effect  of  the 
specified  chemical  composition,  and  Table  1  should  be  considered  in  con- 
nection with  it. 

We  are  forced  to  conclude,  after  an  examination  of  both  tables,  that 
the  specified  chemical  composition  does  not  account  for  all  the  differ- 
ences, although  it  undoubtedly  has  its  effect  and  must  be  kept  within 
certain  limits  in  order  to  prevent  disastrous  results. 

For  instance,  why  were  there  fewer  failures  of  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B 
Cambria  rail  (No.  57)  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio,  or  of  100-lb.  A.R.A.-B 
Carnegie  (71)  on  the  Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie,  than  of  100-lb.  A.R.A.-B 
Carnegie   rail    (1)    of   the   same   specified  composition   on    the   Baltimore 


RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS.  621 

&  Ohio?  It  is  considered  possible  that  the  failures  of  Baltimore  &  Ohio 
No.  I  might  be  due  to  a  small  discard,  as  low  as  5  per  cent.,  as  a  very 
large  percentage   occurred  in   "A"   rails. 

Again,  is  C.  .65  to  .80  too  high  when  P.  is  .04  for  the  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B 
Bethlehem  rail  (2)  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio?  We  cannot  tell,  because 
there  are  considerably  fewer  failures  in  the  case  of  the  90-lb.  A.S.C.E. 
Bethlehem  (24)  on  the  Lehigh  Valley,  with  C.  .70  to  .80  and  P.  .04,  and 
indeed  with  the  same  composition  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  had  no  failures 
of  their  100-lb.  A.R.A.-B  Bethlehem  and  Cambria  rails,  in  Table  1.  In 
the  case  of  the  Lehigh  Valley,  a  possible  explanation  is  that  their  discard 
was  from  15  to  20  per  cent. 

The  failures  of  85-lb.  P.  S.  Gary,  Nos.  31  and  73,  on  the  Pennsyl- 
vania Lines,  have  been  traced  in  almost  every  instance  to  the  former 
practice  of  protecting  the  ingot  stools  with  scrap  material,  and  it  has 
been  found  since  the  practice  was  stopped,  in  1909,  that  the  number  of 
failures  has  been  greatly  reduced.  The  experience  with  the  Gary  rail 
on  the  Union  Pacific,  the  Southern  Pacific,  and  the  Rock  Island  Lines 
has  been  precisely  the  same. 

In  the  case  of  Nos.  5,  7  and  12  on  the  Big  Four,  Northern  Pacific 
and  Union  Pacific,  respectively,  breakages  were  the  most  predominant 
kinds  of  failures,  being  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Carnegie  rail,  85-lb.  A.S.C.E. 
Carnegie  rail  and  80-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Lackawanna  rail,  and  the  question 
naturally  arises:  Is  it  due  to  the  high  specified  carbon  .50  to  .60? 
Breakages  are  also  predominant  in  8  and  9,  in  the  case  of  75-lb.  A.S.C.E. 
Illinois  rail  on  the  Chicago,  Indianapolis  &  Louisville  Railway  and  of 
75-lb.  B.&M.  Lackawanna  rail  on  the  Boston  &  Maine,  with  much  lower 
carbon  specified.  Furthermore,  in  the  case  of  the  St.  Louis  &  San  Fran- 
cisco No.  87,  85-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Illinois  rail  and  Union  Pacific  No.  84,  90-lb. 
C.S.  Illinois  rail,  we  have  a  low  number  of  breakages  with  the  same 
specified   high   carbon. 

Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey  No.  22,  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Carnegie  rail 
is  very  high  in  hardeners,  C.  .54  to  .64  and  Mn.  1.05  to  1.30,  and  has  a 
pretty  considerable  number  of  failures,  but  not  as  many  as  in  the  case  of 
others  with  lower  hardeners,  such  as  Chicago,  Indianapolis  &  Louisville 
No.  8,  75-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Illinois,  C.  .40  to  .50  and  Mn.  .75  to  1.05. 

However,  where  breakages  are  predominant,  they  are  found  to  be  in 
most  cases  of  the  higher  specifications  for  carbon,  .48  to  .58  and  .50  to  .60 
in  the  case  of  Bessemer  rail,  while  it  is  not  so  pronounced  in  the  case  of 
Open-Hearth.  It  may  possibly  be  considered,  therefore,  that  those  are  a 
little  beyond  the  limits  for  P.  .10. 

It  is  difficult  to  understand  why  breakages  are  prevalent  in  the  case 
of  Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey  No.  14,  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Bethlehem 
Open-Hearth,  with  C.  .57  and  P.  .031,  unless  it  is  the  difficulty  usually 
experienced  by  a  mill  when  just  beginning  a  new  process  of  manufacture. 

On  page  71  is  a  condensed  summary  for  all  rail,  which  shows  very 
clearly  the  superiority  of  Open-Hearth  over  Bessemer  steel.  The  average 
number  of  failures  per  10,000  tons  of  new   rail  laid  for  Open-Hearth  is 


622 


RAIL. 


S3 
3 

OSO 

© 

OS  © 

OSO 

OSO 

o 

OSO 

o 

©l-H 

O-H 

O^H 

O— i 

O^H 

OS  OS 

3S 

OS  OS 

OS  OS 

OS  OS 

OS 

OS  OS 

OS 

W 

CM  CO 

CO«ti 

CO  *o 

COO 

CM 

u 

d 

M 

Jj 

03 
ft 

<u 

03 

PQ 

• 

H|nHr, 

HH 

H* 

t-  OS 

CM 

coos 

00<N 

lO  CO 

o 

9 

« 

H 

00(N 

wo 

OSi-H 

OS  CM 

C^i-I 

O 

<D 

^ 

J3 

s 

'3 

_3 

ft 

'3 

^3 

ft 

£ 

•^  OS 

o* 

CO  Oj 

COlO 

coco 

01 

03 
+5 

m 

O 

E-i 

*5 

CD 

t>0 
o3 

e 
co 

W 

O  CO 

O  CO 

CO  CO 

o-^ 

o 

■^»o 

io  -<f 

coco 

CO  -^ 

CO 

g 

CO 

o 

ta 

a> 

ft 

J3 

03 

'3 
ft 

* 

T3 

03 

O 

0) 

« 

.fl 

00^. 

^  CO 

OS  CO 

CO  b- 

1-H  os 

00     * 

CO 

W3  Tfl 

GO 

t^.iC 

COLO 

t-  CO 

CM 

UO  T* 

CO 

GO 

pq 

V 

3 

5) 

ft 

« 

OS  CO 

-*  00 

HO  -^ 

IC 

CO  CO 

<N<N 

o 

a 

a> 

,« 

g 

ft 

O  "■** 

m 

t^T* 

COO 

»bco 

OS 

CO  05 

*# 

(M  CO 

HN 

~HCO 

^w 

CM  CO 

W5 

ft 

1 

"S 

Tj 

■g 

^_ 

a 

-C 

'1 

u 

0 

a 

o 

*n 

o 

*o 

o 

oo 

*o 

b 

'8 

o 

OS 

OS 

CO 

CO 

►J 

3 

w 

H 
<! 
3 

0 

2; 
<n    . 

<  5 
ft  ^ 

ft  d 

a  | 
3  z 
p  ft 


H  m 

ft  § 
O  2 

u  ft 
<  H 
*•« 

2  02 
O  W 

M     PJ 

ft  S 
02   <i 

*ft| 

£   fe    I 
ft    ° 

#  ft 

w  s 

^  3  I 

Q  & 

ft* 

O  ft 

£5 
§3 

o  ft 

ft   ^ 

£° 

□Q  Q 

ft  « 

o% 
ft  « 
ft   . 

Q 

w 

o 


W5 

d 

C.S. 
Lacka. 
A.  S.  C.  E. 

CD 

Mo.  P. 
P.  R.  R. 

B.&M. 
A.  S.  C.  E. 
C.S. 

• 

o 

CO 

d 

ft 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

Dudley 
A.  S.  C.  E. 
Camb. 

CO 

d 

A.  S.  C.  E. 

P.  S. 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

Mo.  P. 

Q. 

ft 

Mo.  P. 

P.  R.  R. 

P.  S. 

A.  S.  C.  E. 

Q. 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

o 

d 

S.  F. 

G.  N. 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

A.  R.  A.-B. 

C.S. 

D.  L.  &  W. 

A.  S.  C.E. 

03 

ft 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

G.  N. 

D.  L.  &W. 

A.  S.  C.  E. 

C.S. 

A.  R.  A.-B. 

o 

ft 

d 

A.  R.  A.-B. 

A.  R.  A.-A. 

P.  &R. 

A.  S.  C.  E. 

Dudley. 

P.  S. 

N.  Y.  N.  H.  &  H. 

P.  R.  R. 

OJ 

ft 

N.  Y.  N.  H.  &H. 
A.  R.  A.-B. 
P.  S. 
P.  R.  R. 
A.  R.  A.-A. 
P.  &  R. 
A.  S.  C.  E. 
Dudley 

*-<CNicOT*iosor~oo 

RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS.  623 

iiy2,  as  against  33  for  Bessemer.  In  this  table  the  alloys  do  not  show 
to  very  good  advantage,  but  upon  examination  in  detail  it  will  be  found 
that  the  poor  results  are  due  to  special  cases. 

Examining  the  details  of  this  same  table,  the  kinds  of  failures  are 
classified  as  follows,  and  a  comparison  with  the  six  months  ending  Octo- 
ber 31,  1909,  is  given,  taken  from  the  previous  report : 

One  Year  Ending    Six  Months  End- 
Oct.  31,  1910.        ing  Oct.  31,  1909. 

"Broken"     2914%  19% 

Head    failures 5554%  66y2% 

Web   failures 7%  Sy2% 

Base  failures &l/2%  6% 

The  above  are  subdivided  as  follows  in  Table  3  for  the  different 
weights  of  rail  and  between  Bessemer  and  Open-Hearth  steel,  the  com- 
parison being  also  given  for  the  1909  period : 

Breakages  form  a  larger  percentage  than  before  and  are  largest  for 
100-lb.  Bessemer,  except  in  the  case  of  72-lb.  and  78-lb.  This  may  be 
due  to  a  difference  in  classification,  as  the  head  failures  are  fewer.  The 
web  failures  have  rather  diminished,  while  the  base  failures  have  increased 
in  some  cases  and  diminished  in  others.  As  to  which  failures  predom- 
inate, as  between  Bessemer  and  Open-Hearth,  there  is  not  much  differ- 
ence. 

If,  from  pages  64  to  70,  we  endeavor  to  determine  the  superiority 
of  different  rail  sections  by  the  relative  number  of  failures  per  10,000  tons 
or  new  rail  laid,  we  arrive  at  the   results  given   in  Table  4. 

If  N.Y.N. H.&H.  100-lb.  section  stands  first  when  made  of  Bessemer 
steel,  why  does  the  same  section  stand  seventh  when  made  of  Open- 
Hearth,  and  so  on?  The  reason  is,  of  course,  that  the  section  of  rail 
does  not  control  the  quality  of  material,  although  it  should  have  some 
effect  on  it,  because  some  sections  of  material  are  better  rolling  sections 
than  others,  and  undoubtedly  some  sections  are  stronger  than  others 
when  the  quality  of  the  material  is  the  same.  At  the  present  time,  how- 
ever, the  quality  of  the  material  is  so  variable  that  neither  minor  differ- 
ences in  sections  nor  in  chemical  composition  have  serious  weight.  Ulti- 
mately, however,  when  the  art  of  rail-making  becomes  more  refined, 
they  ought  to  have  weight,  and,  consequently,  in  the  meantime,  should 
not  be  entirely  lost  sight  of.  These  points  will  be  further  brought  out  in 
the  study  of  the  diagrams  which  follow : 

DIAGRAM     I — COMPARISON    BETWEEN     DIFFERENT    WEIGHTS    OF    RAIL,    BESSEMER 

STEEL. 

The  information  for  this  diagram  is  tabulated  on  pages  72  to  74. 
As  in  former  reports,  the  head  failures  are  the  most  numerous  and  those 
for  the  90-lb.  rail  again  lead.  Those  for  95-lb.,  85-lb.  and  80-lb.  come 
next  and  are  about  the  same  in  number,  while  the  100-lb.  and  75-lb.  are 
closely  the  same. 

The  number  of  breakages  are  a  little  more  numerous  for  85-lb.  than 
for  75-lb.,  while  the  web  and  base  failures  are  quite  insignificant. 


624  RAIL. 

DIAGRAM     2 — COMPARISON      BETWEEN      DIFFERENT      WEIGHTS     OF     RAIL,     OPEN- 
HEARTH    STEEL. 

The  information  for  this  diagram  is  tabulated  on  pp.  75  and  76. 

The  superiority  of  Open-Hearth  over  Bessemer  steel  is  again  empha- 
sized in  this  diagram  as  compared  with  No.  1.  The  breakages  and  head 
failures  for  the  80-lb.  predominate  and  are  quite  few  for  all  the  others. 

DIAGRAM    3 — COMPARISON     BETWEEN     DIFFERENT     SECTIONS    OF    RAIL,    BESSEMER 

STEEL. 

The  information  for  the  construction  of  the  diagram  is  tabulated  on 
pp.  tj  to  81. 

Diagram  1  showed  that  the  greatest  number  of  head  failures  occurred 
in  the  case  of  90-lb.  rail.  This  diagram  shows  that  they  are  most 
numerous  in  the  case  of  A.R.A.-B,  C.S.  and  A.S.C.E.  sections. 

The  A.R.A.-B  is  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  and  is  No.  1  in  Table  2, 
and  there  is  nothing  peculiar  about  the  specified  chemical  composition. 
The  C.S.  is  Nos.  27,  33  and  42  of  Table  2  on  the  Oregon  Short  Line, 
Union  Pacific  and  Illinois  Central,  respectively,  and  the  specified  chemical 
composition  is  somewhat  different  from  the  general  run,  having  C.  .50  to 
.60  for  the  first  two,  and  .55  to  .65  in  the  last,  with,  however,  lower  P., 
viz.,  .085. 

The  next  largest  number  of  head  failures  occurred  in  the  case  of 
A.R.A.-A  85-lb.,  then  C.B.&Q.  85-lb.  and  Cambria  80-lb.  The  first  is 
No.  35  of  Table  2  and  is  Bessemer  rail  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company  on 
the  Atchison,  Topeka  &  Santa  Fe.  It  is  a  section  designed  by  that  com- 
pany in  accordance  with  the  principles  laid  down  by  the  American  Railway 
Association,  as  that  Association  did  not  make  any  specific  design  for  85-lb. 
rail.  The  specified  chemical  contents  are  in  accordance  with  the  usual 
practice,  and  the  reason  for  the  numerous  head  failures  and  breakages 
is  not  apparent.  The  C.B.&Q.  85-lb.  is  No.  4  of  Table  2  and  has  higher 
carbon  than  is  usual,  .48  to  .58. 

With  reference  to  breakages,  the  largest  number  in  diminishing  order 
are  in  the  case  of  A.R.A.-A  85-lb.  (35),  D.L.&W.  90-lb.,  C.S.  90-lb.  (27, 
33  and  42),  Cambria  540,  Dudley  100-lb.  (85)  and  A.S.C.E.  90-lb.  The 
A.R.A.-A  85-lb.  on  the  Santa  Fe  and  the  C.S.  90  have  already  been 
spoken  of  above.  The  D.L.&W.  rail  is  shown  on  page  15,  but  the  chem- 
ical composition  is  not  given.  It  is  a  1908  lot  of  4,192  tons  of  Lackawanna 
rail.     The  Dudley  100-lb.  was  somewhat  high  in  phosphorus. 

It  is  noticeable  that  all  failures  of  A.R.A.-B  90-lb.  rail  are  more 
numerous  than  A.R.A.-A  90-lb.,  but  the  reverse  is  the  case  with  the  100-lb. 
section. 

The  web  failures  of  the  P.&R.  100-lb.  are  rather  noticeable.  This 
is  Maryland  1910  rail  of  the  following  composition : 

C 55  to  .65 

P 07 

Mil 90  to  1. 00 

Si 20 


RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS. 


625 


It  is  thought  they  were  due  to  sponginess,  and  the  presence  of  slag  in 
"A"  rails. 

In  Table  No.  5  is  given  a  statement  of  number  of  head  failures  per 
10,000  tons  of  new  rail  laid,  in  diminishing  order,  with  the  object  of  trying 
to  discover  whether  the  different  sections  of  rail  have  any  influence  on 
the  number  of  head  failures,  i.  e.,  whether  a  thin  or  heavy  head  is  the 
better,  or  whether  a  stiff  or  low  section  is  the  better.  Opposite  to  each  a 
letter  has  been  set,  indicating  whether  the  section  has  a  heavy  or  thin 
head  and  whether  it  is  of  stiff  or  low  design,  using  the  A.R.A.-A  as  stand- 
ard for  thin  head  and  stiff  design  and  A.R.A.-B  as  standard  for  heavy 
head  and  low  design ;  except  in  the  case  of  85-lb.  C.P.R.  is  used  as  stand- 
ard for  thin  head,  the  Dudley  for  the  stiff  design,  and  the  P.S.  for  heavy 
head  and  low  design. 

TABLE  5— STATEMENT  OF  HEAD  FAILURES  PER  10,000  TONS  OF  RAIL  LAID 
IN  DIMINISHING  ORDER 


Section 

Weight 

Tangent 

or 
Curve 

Number  of  Head 

Failures 
per  10,000  Tons 

Heavy 

or 

Thin  Head 

Stiff 
or  Low 
Design 

A.  R.  A.-B 

A.  R.  A.-A 

Cam.  540 

90 
85 
80 
85 
85 
90 
90 
90 

100 
85 
95 
75 

100 

100 
80 
90 
85 

100 
95 
85 
90 

100 
75 

100 

100 
90 

C 
T 
T 
C 
T 
T 
C 
T 
C 
C 
C 
T 
T 
T 
T 
C 

c 
c 

T 
T 
T 
C 
C 
T 
C 
C 

60.8 
40.7 
27 
25.5 
22.9 
22.7 
20.1 
18.3 
16.9 
16.4 
15.3 
14.7 
14.3 
13.8 
13.8 
13.1 
11.8 
11.6 
11.1 
11.1 
10.8 
10.7 
10.6 
9.2 
9.1 
8.4 

H 

T 

T* 

T 
T 
T 
H 
H 
T 
T 
T 
T 
H 
H 
H 
H 
T 
T 
T 
T 
T 
T 
T 
H 
T 

L 

S 

A.  R.  A.-A 

C.  B.  &Q 

s 

L 

C.S 

S 

c.s 

s 

A.  S.  C.  E 

P.  &R 

L 
L 

C.  B.  &Q 

L 

B.  &A 

L 

C.S 

s 

A.R.A.-A 

A.  S.  C.  E 

A.  S.  C.  E 

A.  S.  C.  E 

P.S 

S 

s 

L 
L 
L 

A.R.A.-A 

B.  &A 

S 
L 

A.S.C.E 

A.  R.  A.-A 

S 
S 

s 

C.S 

s 

s 

P.S 

L 

G.  N 

L 

Of  the  ioo-lb.,'  the  N.Y.N.H.&H.  100-lb.  section  makes  the  best 
showing,  and  can  be  classed  as  stiff  section  with  heavy  head. 

The  next  best  is  the  A.R.A.-B  of  heavy  head  and  low  design,  and 
then  the  P.S.  of  heavy  head  and  low  design,  while  last  year  the  A.R.A.-A 
of  thin  head  and  stiff  design  preceded. 

Of  the  90-lb.  the  first  is  the  A.R.A.-A  of  thin  head  and  stiff  design 
and  then  the  Great  Northern  of  thin  head  and  low  design,  while  last  year 
the  Great  Northern  came  first. 

Of  the  85-lb.  the  Mo.  Pac.  comes  first  and  then  the  P.R.R.  and  P.S., 
both  of  heavy  head  and  low  design. 

Of  the  80-lb.  the  best  showing  is  made  by  the  A.R.A.-A  of  thin  head 
and  stiff  design  and  then  the  Dudley  of  heavy  head  and  stiff  design. 


626 


RAIL. 


DIAGRAM  4— COMPARISON  BETWEEN  DIFFERENT  SECTIONS  OF  RAIL,  OPEN-HEARTH 

STEEL. 

The  information  for  the  diagram  is  tabulated  on  pp.  82  to  84. 

It  presents  a  very  different  appearance  from  Diagram  No.  3  and  again 
shows  the  superiority  of  Open-Hearth  over  Bessemer  rail.  We  are  re- 
minded, however,  by  some  irregularities  that  Open-Hearth  steel  is  not 
perfect  and  there  are  defects  of  manufacture  or  material  to  be  overcome 
in  its  case,  as  well  as  in  the  case  of  the  Bessemer. 

The  greatest  number  of  head  failures  is  of  P.R.R.  100-lb.,  the  next 
C.B.&Q.  85-lb,  the  next  Mo.Pac.  85-lb.  and  then  A.S.C.E.  90-lh,  the  two 
latter  being  about  equal. 

In  order  to  determine  the  effect,  if  any,  of  chemical  composition,  the 
percentages  of  ingredients  are  given  below : 


P.  R.  R.  100 
Pa.  Steel  1905 

C.  B.  &  Q.  85 

Beth.  1908 

Mo.  P.  85 
C.  F.  &  I.  1910 

A.  S.  C.  E.  90 
Bethlehem  1907-1909 

C.  R.  R.  of  N.  J. 

L.  V.  R.  R 

C.      .85 
P.      .012 
Mn    .65 
Si.     .041 

.55  to     .67 

.04 
.70  to  1.00 

.63 
.06 
.85 

.20 

.57 
.031 
.82 

.70  to     .80 

.04 
.80  to  1.05 

The  P.R.R.  rail  was  but  a  small  experimental  lot,  made  by  the  Penn- 
sylvania Steel  Company  in  1905,  and  may  have  been  too  hard  with  the 
high  carbon,  although  the  phosphorus  is  very  low.  On  the  other  hand,  the 
C.B.&Q.  and  the  C.R.R.  of  NJ.  rail  may  have  been  too  soft.  The  Mo. 
Pac.  rail  was  reported  by  the  Denver  &  Rio  Grande,  no  reports  at  all 
having  been  received  from  the  Missouri  Pacific. 

There  is  nothing  else  unusual  in  connection  with  the  diagram,  except 
the  number  of  breakages  of  A.S.C.E.  90-lh,  the  composition  of  which  has 
already  been  given  above.  The  best  showing  has  been  made  by  the 
A.R.A.-B  100-lb,  A.RA.-A  100-lb,  C.S.  75-lb.,  S.Fe  90-lb.  and  P.&R.  100-lb. 

The  A.R.A.-B  is  Bethlehem,  Cambria  and  Maryland  1910  rail  on  the 
B.  &  O.,  Illinois  Steel  1009  on  the  Chicago  &  Northwestern,  Bethlehem 
1910  rail  on  the  Erie,  and  Algoma  1910  rail  on  the  Michigan  Central,  the 
chemical  composition  of  which  conforms  with  the  usual  limits,  except  that 
a  portion  of  it  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  has  pretty  high  carbon,  .65  to  .80, 
for  .04  phosphorus. 

The  A.RA.-A  is  Maryland,  Bethlehem  and  Pennsylvania  1910  rail, 
on  the  Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey,  and  Gary  1910  rail  on  the  Rock 
Island.     The  chemical  composition  differs  in  each  case  and  is  as  follows : 


Pennsylvania 

Maryland 

Bethlehem 

Gary 

c. 
p. 

Mn. 
Si. 

.70  to  .85 

.04 
.60  to  .90 

.20 

.62  to  .75 

.04 
.60  to  .90 

.20 

.70  to  .83 

.04 
.60  to  .90 

.20 

.63  to  .76 

.04 
.60  to  .901 
.10  to  .20] 

RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS.  627 

It  will  be  noted  that,  in  some  of  these  cases,  the  carbons  are  even 
higher  than  above,  and  the  phosphorus  lower. 

The  C.S.  75-lb.  is  Bethlehem  1909  and  C.F.&I.  1907-1910  rail  on  the 
Oregon  Railroad  &  Navigation  Company,  and  Maryland  1906  on  the  Ari- 
zona &  Eastern.  The  O.R.R.&N.Co.  rails  ought  to  be  very  soft  with 
C.  .45  for  P.  .025.  The  Maryland  rail  ought  to  have  been  classed  as  Besse- 
mer with  .085  phosphorus. 

The  Santa  Fe  90-lb.  is  Illinois  1909  and  1910  steel,  with  C.  .59  to  .72, 
P.  .04,  Mn.  .60  to  .90  and  Si.  .20. 

The  P.&R.  100-lb.  is  Pennsylvania  1909  and  1910  steel  with  C.  .70  to 
.85,  P.  .03,  Mn.  .60  to  .90  and  Si.  .20. 

Last  year  there  were  no  head  failures  of  N.Y.N. H.&H.  100-lb.,  but 
this  year  there  are  some  breakages  of  10,741  tons  of  Bethlehem  1908  and 
1910  rail  with  C.  .70  to  .77,  P.  -02  to  .035,  Mn.  .70  to  1.00  and  Si.  .10  to  .21. 

In  addition  to  the  above  there  is  but  one  failure  of  9,825  tons  of  Penn- 
sylvania steel  for  1908  to  1910,  with  C.  .71  to  .90,  P.  .009  to  .028,  Mn.  .60  to 
.90,  Si.  .05  to  .13  and  S.  .02  to  .079.  It  is  to  be  noted  that  there  are  a  few 
base  failures  with  this  section,  and  reference  to  Vol.  12,  Part  2,  page  149, 
will  show  that  it  has  a  thin  base. 

It  was  also  mentioned  last  year  that  there  were  very  few  failures  of 
the  D.L.&W.  90-lb.,  while  this  year  there  are  some  breaks.  It  is  Bethle- 
hem 1908-1910  rail,  with  C.  .67  to  .80,  P.  .04,  M'n.  .75  to  1.05,  Si.  .20  and 
S.  .05. 

Last  year  there  were  no  failures  of  the  Dudley  100-lb.,  but  this 
year  there  are  a  few,  principally  head  failures.  There  are  but  a  few  tons, 
4,404,  divided  between  Lackawanna  and  Bethlehem,  in  1908  and  1909. 

DIAGRAM  5 — COMPARISON  OF  FAILURES  FOR  DIFFERENT  PERIODS  OF  LIFE. 

The  information  for  the  diagram  is  tabulated  on  pp.  85  and  86. 
There  are  comparatively  few  failures  during  the  first  year,  the  prin- 
cipal exception  being  P.R.R.  100-lb. 

The  most  failures  occurred  from  the  first  to  the  sixth  year. 

FAILURES   WITH    RESPECT  TO   THEl  POSITION   IN    THE  INGOT,    PP.   87  TO    141. 

The  marking  of  the  rails  to  distinguish  the  position  in  the  ingot  has 
become  very  general,  and  the  reports  were  much  more  complete  than  ever 
before. 

For  convenient  reference,  Table  No.  6  has  been  made  from  the  re- 
ports. The  failures  of  "A"  rails  are  the  most  numerous,  but  there  are 
also  very  many  failures  of  "B"  and  "C"  rails  and  no  inconsiderable 
number  of  "D"  and  "E",  while  there  are  occasional  ones  even  lower  down. 

Unless  there  is  an  improvement  in  the  making  of  the  ingots,  it  will  re- 
quire the  elimination  entirely  of  the  "A",  "B"  and  "C"  rails  to  be  sure  of 
having  only  sound  ones  in  the  track.  As  this  would  mean  a  great  waste  of 
material,  with  resultant  loss  of  economy,  it  emphasizes  the  necessity 
for  continued  study  of  rail  manufacture  in  order  to  obtain  rails  as  nearly 
faultless  as  possible,  without  extravagance. 


628 


RAIL. 


^OOWQOCNNMN^OOiUS^OOOOaoON^OOOOiNMrt-HiOQOaooooO^iCOJCiOOCOtDiOCC* 


^-.i-H  CO 


.-^*-i^^-i      -(CHCON 


*  C*  *0  *->*$<  — C*  *Q         M      ■'H'HO 


5i-iiO'*'*«CO00C*<C>T-<'*J<cOe*OSi-il-~N^ 


■  CS      •  OO  Ci      •  ^ 


■  W      •iC'-HOO      -NNCCinOiOOJ 


•  c$co*-t     -<ho<d«cd 


■  uj^ttHHM      .^^o^'-^-*      -OOiO^O      'NO~h*0      -OWN00 


W  CD      •        »-H         CO  -CO 


■-^<N»-<00 


.rH^iiOM^^NiHMCOiNOOiOH      ■  CO -h  •<*<  lO  C*  ~l  <M  CC  CS  00 
OO        ^  ^  it*  -CO  *-»<N 


•fhC3NOOCCW<00 


•^iC  CIO  OO 


■MC:0«»CNNH 


■OWQO^i-i'*C>«NINNecWO 


©' §  ©' ©"g  ©"g  «   ■g'gd'g©   -doi^d   •©' 3   ■  d'g  cid  S'g  g^"gg  cs   •'gd'gcjo-^ 

SJ  0  C3  03  M   C3.3  d—   OS*  ^=3   *—   «3   ~—   S—   CS   03  c3   =3  3   3   c3  .2   JS.3.2   c3   3  —  «J  c!   *  3  03   *i 


«'  * 


.Sod 


ssssasssaEssessHHESEsassssacSssEcsasEEsaaasss 

©©©©©©©©©©©©0©0©C;©©©©C>OCJ—    —wC-yi-C-wwOi-O    £*©©©©©©©© 


<-i;<<;mfpw'w'^  ;  :  :  :  :  :  :  :  :  [^<<^n(a^a^^^  .  .  :hhhh«h«w 
<<<;^<ij«5iQQQ  >..tf  :  :  :  :  :  :c^(^<<<'i<<<<<oooo'^  ■  |  idddocJOVO 


'3  v. 


SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOiOiO»-OiOW3iO»CiOiO 
OCOCOOOOOOOOOCOOOC«C.03  0)fflOClC©0'.0»aO©O©0»00l»00  00(»C0Q0Q0M 


o^.s.so^oo 


tf 


*=h*'l"fl 


3J 

^o 


"3*0 
3  Spjoj 


•-C  c!  08 


..5.s.s.Stftfdd«£c'dd££B::w 

kWiJiJ_u_u_1..u,;    .  u  o  jj  ..    -o'er? 


IJIJbdd^pIe!-* 


&Z.Z 


nd£(2si«««d£d££££££^««o^M««£2u^ 


RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS. 


629 


^h         ~h  CM  i-H  — t         Oa  ^**  i-H  CM  CO  CO  t*  ^  «-•         cOt-i*^  rtWCO 


*#         QO         CO 
OO         CO         CO 


3  o 


00-^  — «  -*  O" 


OK 


©hh^do^cjom       r— co 

W  i«  i-t  Tp  W  N  W  i-H  CM 


OO         i-l         GO 


CD  -**  CM  -^  CO 


CN  i-t      --H      -CO  CO*H 


^h  CM         COCN 


1  i-r  CllO  i-t  CM  ■**<  i-t 


■*  to  CO  iO  *"-  ^  C^  ~H  CM  CO  CO  CO        COCOCO 


i-<CNOSCOTt<I>>COCO 
CO^ft         CO 


^h      .  »c  »o  i-H  ■**  CO  00 

~*      -**      ~t 


COCMt^CM~HQOTf*CO 

CO'*  r-l  ^  -M 


-h  CO  CM      "HiO-t      •  CO  —i  CO  r*.  CM  CM         i-t 
i-h  ^H       •  CM  ~H  CM 


CMCM^^CMCMCJiOSCMt^-^CMCMCOTP         —ii-(^«CM'-<fHiOCM 


r^cs^cot^CMCM-^i: 
i-h  ~h       co      ^*« 


•o       o       -j 

CM         ^         ■* 


N         ^         (D 


c3  g  a>  © 
"fi  cj'Sb'3) 

03  S  c8  03  —  —  O  ca 


B   03  fh  03  Bfifl  tt 

c  a  K3-*  a  g  cja  g  gja 

S  03  «  ©   03   ffl  —   0)   05-3—   4) 


-'  oj  oj 

2  ©^ 
gSxjI 


6§ 

03  oj 
OPh 


|°2.S°| 

,"§   CO    S  «<    00    o 

31&113 

WhOOSW 


ddddddddddddddddd 


66666666 


s    a 
.2    J    .3 


o-c? 

fcP^p^OOQ 


111°?"^^  :  :    w««w  :  :  :<y 
pj<i-<<i<!-<d°8  :  :    dodo  |  :  :=8 


^'aiiii^ala^P^^-i^-tJ-JjClOO    -ax^-^p^d 


•5  w   a 

p   «i   <i 


bf>H 

'S  t, 


w  »o  iC  «o  WJ  iO  »o  o 
aoaoccQoccooooQO 


soooooooooC'^oo©©©       io  io  ic  «  »o  u;  w  io 

)OOOOOOOQO>0)aO)0>0!0>Q        OOOOOOOOCOOOOOOO 


tftf  c  c  s=8^U 


d,a,(2(2(2doiz; 


jtf~-^««>< 


tfjrtdjtfdJaJS^ 


*1d5o« 


fio? 


tfP^««P^«.-af<Pq  3°8  m>^1 


•8  3  5    ^^.-jtftfjj. 

^Z        _y  jj  jj  ni  ^J  ^J  ►_] 


•a  =8  <««««*-;« 


CiJ^pIfcPM^fSfcddtnpQ&hJQOO     ^Z^df^PLifSd 


!5     2 
"3     "3 

<  «  « 

•a   pi   « 
mod 


630  RAIL. 

COMPARATIVE   WEAR  OF   SPECIAL    AND  ALLOY   RAIL,   PP.    142   TO    162. 

Several  of  the  companies  are  making  trials  of  experimental  lots  of 
both  Special  Bessemer  and  Open-Hearth  steel,  and  with  different  alloys, 
such  as  ferro-titanium,  nickel,  chromium-nickel,  etc.,  but  in  some  instances 
the  results  have  not  been  very  satisfactory,  The  failures  are  given  in  de- 
tail on  pp.  61,  62,  63,  67  and  68.  and  the  record  of  wear  on  pp.  142  to  162. 
The  average  number  of  failures  per  10,000  tons  of  rail  laid  for  the  differ- 
ent kinds  tested  are  as  follows : 

Open-Hearth  Steel,  with  ferro-titanium 12 

Bessemer    Steel,  with    ferro-titanium 13^ 

Bessemer  Steel,  with  nickel 96 

Open-Hearth   Steel,    with   chromium-nickel 640 

Ferro-Titanium  Treatment: 

The  record  for  failures  is  bad  on  the  Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey, 
being  1,019  per  10.000  tons  of  rail,  but  the  quantity  tested  is  very  small — 
373  tons.  This  is  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  section,  rolled  by  the  Lackawanna  Steel 
Company  in  1909,  with  C.  .45  to  .55,  P.  .10,  Mn.  .84  to  .114,  Si.  .20  and 
F.T.  .3.  Other  lots  of  the  rail  have  made  a  better  showing.  The  failures 
E.rc  thought  to  be  due  to  imperfect  rolling  and  not  to  the  ferro-titanium. 

The  comparative  wear  tests  were  made  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio,  Lake 
Shore  &  Michigan  Southern  and  New  York  Central  Lines. 

The  following  tests  are  being  made  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio : 

90-lb.  A.R.A.-B  Maryland  Bessemer  rail  with  ferro-titanium  is  being 
compared  with  Maryland  Open-Hearth  rail  on  Kessler's  Curve.  The  per 
cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  was  3.8  and  4.4  for  ferro-titanium  and  4.2 
for  Open-Hearth  in  four  months. 

Also  100-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Maryland  Bessemer  steel  with  ferro-titanium 
was  compared  with  Maryland  Bessemer  steel  on  the  same  curve,  and  in 
one  year  ten  months  the  per  cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  was  9.5  for 
ferro-titanium  and  17.7  for  Bessemer.  This  Bessemer  rail  was  worn  out 
and  replaced  by  Cambria  Bessemer,  which  wore  6.4  per  cent,  in  less  than 
six  months. 

On  the  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern,  ico-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Lackawanna 
steel  with  ferro-titanium  is  being  compared  with  ordinary  Bessemer  rail. 
In  some  of  these  tests  not  much  superiority  is  shown  for  the  ferro- 
titanium,  while  in  others  there  is  considerable. 

On  the  New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River  Railroad,  80-lb.  Dudley 
Lackawanna  steel  with  metallic  titanium  .033  is  being  compared  with  80-lb. 
Dudley  ordinary  Bessemer,  the  record  for  one  year  and  six  months  show- 
ing less  wear  for  the  ordinary  Bessemer  than  for  the  ferro-titanium,  al- 
though the  difference  is  but  slight. 

It  will  thus  be  observed  that  up  to  the  present  time  the  results  are 
conflicting,  the  one  good  test  on  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  perhaps  being  due 
to  the  higher  carbon,  while  the  other  tests,  where  the  results  are  about 
the  same,  are  with  the  usual  carbon  for  that  quality  of  steel. 


RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS.  631 

The  large  number  of  failures  on  the  Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey, 
mostly  broken  base,  is  rather  alarming  and  discouraging. 

Steel  with  Chromium-Nickel : 

The  record  for  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Open-Hearth  rail  with  chromium  and 
nickel  on  the  Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey  has  been  very  bad  so  far  as 
failures  are  concerned,  there  having  been  1,129  per  10,000  tons  of  rail 
laid,  mostly  breakages.  It  is  Bethlehem  steel,  1909  manufacture,  but 
the  chemical  composition  is  unknown. 

Small  lots  have  also  been  tested  on  the  B.  &  O.  and  the  Erie,  with 
a  large  number  of  failures.  That  on  the  B.  &  O.  is  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B 
Bethlehem  rail,  1909  and  1910,  with  595  failures  per  10,000  tons,  and  that 
on  the  Erie,  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Bethlehem  1909  rail  with  289  failures  per  10,- 
000  tons,  both  on  page  63.  The  amount  of  nickel  is  2  per  cent,  to  2*/2 
per  cent.,  and  the  chromium  .5  per  cent,  to  .9  per  cent.  In  the  case  of  the 
B.  &  O.  the  carbon  is  rather  low  for  Open-Hearth  steel,  while  on  the 
Erie  it  is  more  nearly  the  usual  amount. 

A  small  lot  on  the  New  York,  Ontario  &  Western  has  given  better 
results,  and  also  a  larger  amount  on  the  Lehigh  Valley,  although  the 
number  of  failures,  especially  breakages,  is  very  considerable. 

Comparative  tests  for  wear  are  being  conducted  by  the  Baltimore 
&  Ohio  and  the  Lehigh  Valley  Railroad. 

The  Baltimore  &  Ohio  is  comparing  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B  Bethlehem  steel, 
containing  nickel  and  chromium,  with  ordinary  Bethlehem  Open-Hearth 
rail  on  different  curves,  ranging  in  degree  from  4  deg.  30  min.  to  9  deg.  30 
min. 

The  results  are  variable,  in  one  case  the  chrome-nickel  showing  a 
greater  percentage  of  wear  than  the  Open-Hearth,  while  in  other  cases 
the  Open-Hearth  shows  50  per  cent,  greater  wear  than  chrome-nickel, 
the  duration  of  time  being  one  and  one-half  years.  It  is  difficult  to  under- 
stand the  difference,  as  the  respective  kinds  of  material  are  the  same  in 
each  case. 

When  compared  with  ordinary  Cambria  Bessemer  rail,  the  per  cent, 
of  area  of  head  abraded  was  from  2T/2  to  3  times  as  much  for  the  Bessemer 
rail  as  for  the  chromium-nickel  rail. 

In  the  Lehigh  Valley  tests,  90-lb.  A.S.C.E.  Bethlehem  steel,  with  nickel 
and  chromium,  was  compared  with  ordinary  Open-Hearth  rail  and  the 
per  cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  in  from  8  to  18  months  was  70  per  cent, 
greater  in  the  case  of  the  Open-Hearth  than  of  the  chrome-nickel. 

Rail  of  Mayari  Ore: 

A  test  is  being  conducted  by  the  Pennsylvania  Lines  of  85-lb.  P.  S. 
Pennsylvania  Steel  Company's  Open-Hearth  rail  of  Mayari  ore  from  Cuba, 
and  in  ten  months  ordinary  Maryland  Bessemer  steel  shows  twice  the  wear. 
The  chemical  composition  is:  C.  .805,  P.  .022,  Mn.  .87,  Si.  .17,  S.  .035, 
Nickel  .97  and  Chromium  .21.  It  will  be  noted  that  it  is  a  chromium- 
nickel  rail,  but  of  very  different  composition  from  the  tests  cited  above. 


632  RAIL. 

Manganese  Steel: 

The  Norfolk  &  Western  is  comparing  85-lb.  A.S.C.E.  manganese  steel 
with  ordinary  Carnegie  Bessemer,  and  up  to  the  present  time  the  per 
cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  is  a  trifle  over  three  times  as  much  for 
the  Bessemer  as  for  the  manganese.  The  composition  of  the  manganese 
rail  is:  C.  .77,  P.  .06,  Mn.  9.93,  Si.  .25,  S.  .038,  and  the  test  has  lasted 
for  nineteen  months. 

On  the  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern,  85-lb.  P.  R.  R.  manganese 
rail  of  the  Pennsylvania  Steel  Company  is  being  compared  with  ferro- 
titanium  steel,  and  in  eight  months  the  ferro-titanium  shows  a  little  more 
than  twice  as  much  wear  as  the  manganese. 

Miscellaneous: 

The  Baltimore  &  Ohio  made  a  comparative  test  between  90-lb. 
A.R.A.-A  Illinois  steel  and  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B  Carnegie  steel  on  a  7  deg. 
curve.  In  two  years  the  per  cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  was  23.4  for 
the  "A"  and  13.4  for  the  "B". 

The  Baltimore  &  Ohio  compared  the  wear  of  90-lb.  A.R.A.-B  Bethle- 
hem Open-Hearth  rail  with  Cambria  Bessemer  on  a  7  deg.  5  min.  curve, 
rnd  in  one  year  the  per  cent,  of  area  of  head  abraded  was  9.8  for  the  Open- 
Hearth  and  26.9  for  the  Bessemer. 

The  Lake  Shore  &  Michigan  Southern  compared  80-lb.  A.S.C.E.  rail 
made  by  the  electric  process  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company  with  ordinary 
Bessemer  rail,  with  the  result  that  in  eight  months  but  little  difference 
between  them  was  shown. 

The  New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River  Railroad  compared  basic 
Open-Hearth  rail  of  Bethlehem  and  Lackawanna  manufacture,  100-lb. 
Dudley  section,  with  ordinary  Bessemer  rail,  same  section,  with  but  little 
difference  in  the  comparative  wear  in  a  year  and  one-half. 


RAIL  FAILURE  STATISTICS.  633 


THOUGHTS  RESULTING  FROM'  THE  STUDY. 

The  most  of  the  thoughts  stated  in  Vol.  12,  Part  2,  page  28,  may  be 
repeated  after  this  study,  but  some  additional  comments  will  be  made : 

(1)  Study  of  these  general  statistics  does  not  furnish  accurate  and 
specific  information  so  as  to  determine  the  value  of  different 
sections  of  rail,  because : 

(a)  The  conditions  of  traffic  are  different. 

(b)  The  conditions  of  roadbed  are  different. 

(c)  The  conditions  of  ingot  making  and  rolling  practice  are  so 
different  that  the  quality  of  the  material  varies  widely,  and, 
at  the  present  time,  this  difference  in  quality  of  material  elimi- 
nates differences  in  section ;  nevertheless,  when  the  time 
comes  that  the  difference  in  quality  of  material  will  be  less, 
the  influence  of  the  section  will  be  more  apparent,  for  there 
is  no  doubt  that  one  section  is  stiffer  and  stronger  than  an- 
other, according  to  the  distribution  of  the  material.  Inas- 
much as  we  are  endeavoring  to  eliminate  the  differences  in 
quality  of  material  and  bring  it  to  a  high  state  of  perfec- 
tion, we  should  not,  in  the  meantime,  lose  sight  of  the  de- 
sirable features  of  the  rail  section,  but  keep  them  con- 
stantly in  mind,  so  that  when  we  arrive  at  a  good  quality  of 
metal  we  will  also  have  a  desirable  rail  section. 

(2)  A  study  of  these  general  statistics  tends  to  disclose  unusual  re- 

sults, and  were  it  not  for  their  compilation,  we  would  not  have 
much  information  relative  to  the  difference  between  Bessemer 
and  Open-Hearth  steel  and  concerning  the  various  alloys. 

(3)  The  general  statistics  are  also  important,  in  showing  a   relation 

between  broken  rails  and  failure  of  head,  web  and  base. 

(4)  Their  tabulation  discloses  the  difference  between  Steel  Companies 

when  the  sections  and  chemical  composition  are  practically  the 
same. 


COMPARATIVE   WEAR    OF  BESSEMER,   OPEN-HEARTH  AND 
NICKEL  STEEL  RAIL  ON  PENNSYLVANIA  RAILROAD. 

To   the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

The  Committee  on  Rail  submits  for  your  information  the  following 
statement  and  accompanying  Exhibits  "A"  and  "B,"  from  Mr.  Joseph  T. 
Richards,  Chief  Engineer  Maintenance  of  Way,  Pennsylvania  Railroad,  in 
regard  to  comparative  wear  of  Bessemer,  Open-Hearth  and  Nickel  Steel 
rail  on  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad. 

June  22,  191 1. 
Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill, 

Chairman,  Committee  on  Rail.   American  Railway  Engineering  Asso- 
ciation, Roanoke,  Va. 

Dear  Sir : — From  what  I  can  gather  from  the  progress  reports  of  the 
work  of  the  Committee  to  date,  particularly  the  reports  made  to  the 
Committee  by  Mr.  Wickhorst,  I  am  impressed  that  we  are  doing  a  great 
deal  of  work,  but  along  the  line  which  may  be  called  experimental — we  are 
to  a  degree  hunting  something  new  in  the  composition  of  rail,  like 
''Chromium"  and  "Nickel." 

If  I  am  correct,  I  believe  our  Committee  should  turn  its  attention  to 
perfecting  the  rail  as  we  know  it  under  the  present  well  worked  out 
analyses  and  specifications.  If  we  fail  in  doing  this,  as  railroad  men  I 
believe  we  are  not  doing  our  part,  because  a  good  rail  can  be  made  under 
our  specifications  and  well-known  composition,  if  the  mill  practice  is  right. 

Experimenting  outside  of  this  line  is  "only  beating  around  the  bush," 
and  working  with  a  line  ahead  as  long  as  a  life  line,  and  we  will  be  con- 
tinuing the  long  chase  very  much  as  we  have  been  for  the  last  generation, 
whereas,  to  get  the  rail  we  are  seeking  for  requires  prompt  action  in  the 
direction  above  outlined. 

I  am  firmly  convinced  that  the  mills  can  make  a  good  rail.  We  all 
know  very  well  what  the  mill  practice  did  in  making  the  old  "John  Brown" 
and  "Charles  Cammel"  rail  more  than  forty  years  ago  at  the  crude  mills 
and  under  the  imperfect  specifications  of  that  time. 

We  have  had  Open-Hearth  rails  made  by  the  mills  and  tested  under 
heavy  tonnage  on  our  main  line  near  Union  Furnace,  Middle  Division,  on 
a  6-deg.  curve  in  the  eastbound  track,  carrying  both  passenger  and  freight 
trains.  The  analyses  of  these  rails  are  shown  on  the  diagram  presented. 
On  this  sheet  is  also  marked  the  wear  and  life  of  the  rail.  (See  diagrams 
marked  Exhibit  "A.") 

635 


C36  RAIL. 

It  will  be  observed  that  the  carbon  was  high  and  the  phosphorus  low. 
The  comparison  was :  Open-Hearth,  Carbon  .79,  Phosphorus  .024,  shown  in 
red;  Open-Hearth,  Carbon  .896,  Phosphorus  .009,  shown  in  blue;  Open- 
Hearth,  Nickel,  shown  in  green,  and  ordinary  Bessemer,  shown  in  black. 

As  we  are  developing  the  Open-Hearth  rail  I  would  call  special  atten- 
tion to  it  in  this  test.  It  is  shown  in  measurement  No.  3  that  the  Bessemer 
rail  was  worn  out  and  removed  from  track  after  service  of  405  days,  so 
that  it  is  not  shown  in  the  following  measurements,  No.  4  to  No.  8. 

As  to  the  Nickel  Rail,  High  Carbon  and  Open-Hearth — the  last  meas- 
urement was  taken  after  being  in  use  818  days.  This  High  Carbon  rail  did 
not  fail  or  break  during  the  test,  and  was  not  nearly  as  much  worn  in  818 
days  as  the  Bessemer  was  in  405  days. 

This  shows  the  value  and  economy  in  using  the  High  Carbon  Open- 
Hearth  rail,  and  we  were  so  delighted  that  we  thought  great  progress  had 
been  made.  In  asking  the  mills  to  reproduce  this  rail  we  have  met  with 
some  success,  although  in  some  cases  they  have  failed  to  give  us  rail  that 
will  come  up  to  this  test  in  durability;  but  it  impresses  me  as  a  member 
of  the  Committee  that  we  should  work  on  the  principle  of  the  Economy 
Engineer,  who  emphasizes  the  importance  of  working  on  the  "ratchet  prin- 
ciple," i.  e.,  holding  on  to  what  he  has  and  adding  to  it,  rather  than  allow- 
ing himself  to  slip  back. 

Of  course,  I  am  speaking  of  Open-Hearth  rail,  because  the  Bessemer 
process  might  well  be  eliminated,  for  the  reason  that,  as  we  all  know, 
ore  suitable  for  Bessemer  steel  has  practically  disappeared,  and  the  mills 
have  largely  been  rebuilt  for  the  Open-Hearth  process.  We  are  marking 
time  when  we  pay  too  much  attention  to  the  Bessemer  process. 

In  the  long  line  that  we  are  following  in  rail  making  I  will  give  you 
another  statement  (see  Exhibit  "B")  to  show  the  results  from  Open- 
Hearth  rails  made  under  specifications  in  1907  prepared  jointly 
by  the  mill  men  and  railroad  men,  and  it  is  rather  surprising  to  see  this 
following  about  two  years  after  our  trial  of  1905,  in  which  an  Open-Hearth 
rail  was  found  to  last  so  well  and  not  break  in  track.  I  think  the  poor  re- 
sults shown  in  this  statement  are  largely  due  to  the  fact  that  these  rails 
have  been  too  low  in  carbon  and  consequently  too  soft.  It  has  turned  out 
so  badly  that  some  of  the  railroads  have  reported  to  me  that  this  rail  is 
no  better  than  Bessemer  rail;  yet  it  will  be  noted  that  the  railroads  have 
paid  $31.00  to  $35.00  per  ton  for  this  rail,  when  the  ordinary  rail  was 
selling  at  $28.00  per  ton. 

It  is  a  well-known  principle  that  as  the  phosphorus  is  decreased  carbon 
should  be  increased.  It  can  safely  be  done,  and  will  give  us  a  rail  that 
will  wear  longer  and  not  break. 

As  to  the  Titanium  and  Chrome-Nickel  rail — i.  e.,  experimenting  with 
these  new  elements,  I  see  no  objection  whatever — it  is  all  proper  in  its 
way  as  a  side  issue ;  but  it  is  slow,  and  should  in  no  way  hold  back  our 
perfecting  the  Open-Hearth  rail,  as  we  know  it  from  mill  practice  and 
srecifications. 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL.  637 

As  a  further  statement,  I  will  give  you  the  result  of  the  Titanium  rail 
placed  in  track  on  one  of  our  branch  lines — the  Tyrone  Division. 

Four  tons  of  85-lb.  P.R.R.  section  of  rail,  with  a  percentage  of 
Titanium,  was  laid  on  a  13-deg.  50-min.  curve,  Tyrone  Division,  P.R.R.,  in 
September,  1908.     The  composition  was  as  follows : 

Carbon 53 

Phosphorus    074 

Manganese    91 

Silicon  098 

Sulphur    056 

This  rail  was  removed  worn  out  in  November,  1909  (14  months). 
Ordinary   Bessemer  lasts  on  this  curve   12  to  15  months;   hence  the 
Titanium  rail  did  not  show  any  marked  superiority. 

We  have  another  test  of  about  95  tons  of  Titanium  rail,  which  was 
laid  on  the  Buffalo  Division  in  June,  1910.  The  time  has  been  too  short 
to  produce  results,  but  it  may  be  of  value  for  a  future  report. 

Respectfully, 

(Signed)  Jos.  T.  Richards, 
Chief  Engineer  M.  W.,  and  Member  of  Committee. 


638 


RAIL. 


2 
O 


co  <o  en 

«Vj    Cn  «v5  K 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


639 


U 


u 


X 


640 


RAIL. 


O 


Hi 

o 

H 
m 

W 
H 

W 
> 

H 
< 
Pi 
< 

o 
u 


^  ^  ?  ^ 

^    ^  ^  ^ 


X 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIT, 


641 


c 
o 

•e 

u 


c 
o 

■e 

U 

■a 


x 


642 


RAIL. 


o 


03 

o 

H 
en 
W 
H 

W 

> 


Oh 


^ 


°£>  ^  ^   S> 


o 
u 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR. OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


643 


U 


u 


X 


644 


RAIL. 


o 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


645 


U 


tr>~ 


646 


RAIL. 


O 


w 

w 

H 

CO 

•J 

W 

u 


p 

H  pi 

< 


> 

CO  Ph 

w 
o 


t/3 

w 

W 
> 


U 


u 


u 


M 


J      ffi 


u 


<n  <o  <n 

ill 

^  19  ^ 

<h  p>  ^> 
^  *o  ^ 


-.- 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL 


RAIL. 


647 


U 


U 


648 


RAH- 


§ 


< 

-J 

W 
H 

U 


00  CO  ?0 

^  ^  & 
VO  ^o  ^ 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


649 


c 
o 

■8 

u 


650 


RAIL. 


O 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


651 


c 
o 

u 
Rl 
U 


652 


RAIL. 


ft 

O 


o 

H 

W 
H 

W 

> 

i— i 

H 
< 

< 
c 

u 


co  «n  <n 
rr  ^r  > 
to  jo  ^ 

5  5  S? 

5 


M 
< 

K 


COMPARATIVE  WEAR  OF  STEEL  RAIL. 


653 


c 

o 

u 


u       r. 


J       W 


O 


^  /' 


\   I 


w 


O 

j. 

O 


&Q    o 

O  o       i 


£*  3 

K  S    5 
ft  z 


O 


# 
o 

w 

o 

« 

o 

►J 

ac 
ft 


6 

o 
w 


u 


00O  CO         CO 


coo 


O  »it>o  o  O 


co  00  o  o  o 


t-  O  OC>J 


o  o  >  > 

■w  «  o   0 

«"•  o  c 


o  o  o 


IOO 

o  o 

Of-. 


«  ©  o 

O  0   >  >  > 
*'*'  o  o  o 

OO   *3   *.   « 

tot-  o  o  o 


•it  >, « 
.£  e 


a  >■ 


I  s 


oPJ 


gO 


5a 


II 


■?  J.  §5 


I?- 

5 


'J—   o         3 


S.al: 

"  co  a 

o  o.d.2  £ 
Os  073.= 


^s  o 
.q2  ° 


*2     Ja=.2* 


o  oT  g  ■ 
u  o  t-  >-  2 

»   £   p,XI   c 

"So5  & 
=  £°'%£ 
£2     0* 

g  c  o  n 


am--1 
a    *° 

0.-.T3     . 

§o§o^ 

■OpiSo  o  — 
—  .0      -*  &o 

iOȣ3iC  CO    -      . 

8  -°-  ;»> 

<J  0  "2  §"2  S  2 
o  g  o  g  c-t 


t>    CO    P       '  *s 
O   3  -    41 

fa  a        O^        ', 

O       _S 

CO ,  J2  lO    r. 

a  c3    •  a 
—  as  a     .  B  oj 

08  o      +-  ■ 

«a-s"S5 1 

o  g  a  S  - 


o  g  a'S  5 


s 

-5 

0 

— 

- 

0 

w 

c-. 

X 

"5 

i 

e 

0 

'J 

c 

a 

i 

>T1 

73 

03 

0 
— 

^s 

BJ'S 

S 

= 

2 

2 

•- 

0 

E 

Appendix  C. 


SEGREGATION    AND    OTHER    RAIL    PROPERTIES    A 
INFLUENCED  BY  SIZE  OF  INGOT. 

By 

M.  H.  Wickhorst,  Engineer  of  Tests,  Rail  Committee. 

This  report  covers  an  investigation  to  throw  light  on  the  relationship 
of  the  size  of  ingots  of  Bessemer  rail  steel  to  the  segregation  of  the  metal- 
loids, locations  of  pipes  and  blow  holes,  and  the  properties  of  the  rails. 
A  series  of  five  ingots  was  made  of  the  following  bottom  sizes',  all  5  ft. 
high,  namely,  12  in.  x  12  in.,  15  in.  x  15  in.,  18  in.  x  18  in.,  20  in.  x  24  in.  and 
25  in.  x  30  in.  These  were  split  open,  one-half  used  to  obtain  borings 
for  a  chemical  survey  of  the  ingot,  and  the  other  half  for  etching.  Another 
similar  set  of  ingots  was  rolled  into  rails  with  only  sufficient  discard  from 
the  top  of  the  bloom  to  allow  rolling  into  rail,  and  the  entire  rail  bars 
from  these  ingots  were  used  for  drop  tests,  etchings  and  chemical  analyses, 
except  that  no  rails  were  rolled  from  the  12-in.  ingot,  as  an  attempt  to  do 
so  resulted  in  a  "cobble"  on  account  of  the  small  size  of  the  ingot. 
Finally,  two  other  sets  of  rails  are  to  be  rolled  from  the  15  in.  x  15  in., 
18  in.  x  18  in.,  20  in.  x  24  in.  end  25  in.  x  30  in.  ingots.  These  are 
intended  for  service  tests  on  the  Cumberland  Division  of  the  Baltimore  & 
Ohfo  Railroad,  one  set  on  the  high  rail  of  a  5-degree  or  6-degree  curve, 
and  the  other  set  on  the  low  rail. 

MANUFACTURE. 

The  steel  used  was  all  Bessemer  steel  made  from-  Lake  Superior  ores. 
The  iron  from  the  blast  furnaces  was  poured  into  a  mixer,  from  here. it  was 
weighed  into  a  ladle,  poured  into  the  converter  and  blown,,  scrap  steel 
being  .added'  during  the  blowing.  After  blowing,  spiegel  was  added  to 
the.  converter,  the  metal  was  poured  into  an  intermediate  ladle,  then  into 
the  pouring  ladle  and  finally  into,  the  molds  through  a  i^-in.  nozzle.  The 
various  series  of  ingots  were  made  from  different  heats,  ,  as  one  .  set 
required  almost  a  whple  heat,  but  were  all  made  from  s.teel  of  about  the 
same  composition.  The  work  was  done  at  South  Chicago  at  the  South 
Works  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company,  who  very  generously  furnished  all 
the  material,  labor  and  facilities  for  splitting,  analyzing  and  otherwise 
testing  the  ingots  and  rails  from  two  heats  of  steel.  As  these  tests 
involved  considerable  expense,  the  special  thanks  of  the  Rail  Committee 
—* 

Report  No.   19,   June,   1911. 

655 


656 


RAIL. 


are  due  to  the  officers  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company  for  their  generosity 
and  efficiency  in  doing  this  work. 

The  amounts  of  materials  used  to  make  the  two  heats  are  shown  in 
table  i. 

TABLE   I — BESSEMER  AMOUNTS. 

Heat  No 4,520  5,731 

Purpose  Ingots  Rails  for  test 

Mixer  metal,  lbs 28,100  30,200 

Scrap  steel,  lbs 2,200  1,800 

Spiegel,  lbs 3,520  3,380 

Special  samples  of  the  mixer  metal  and  the  spiegel  gave  the  results 
shown  in  tables  2  and  3. 

TABLE  2 — MIXER   METAL. 

Heat.  C.  P.  S.  Mn.  Si. 

4520  4.00  .091  .032  .70  1.68 

5731  3-89  -094  -050  .68  1. 1 8 

TABLE  3 — SPIEGEL. 

Heat.  C.  P.  S.  Mn.  Si. 

4520  4.44  .102  ....  11.50  1.08 

5731  4.30  .085  .010  12.00  1.40 

The  various  Bessemer  operations  occurred  at  the  times  shown  in 
table  4. 

TABLE  4 — TIME  OF  BESSEMER   OPERATIONS. 

Heat   4520  5731 

Date   3-23-1 1  4-5-1 1 

Started  blowing 2.19  p.  m  10.16  a.  m. 

Finished    blowing 2.31  p.  m.         10.27  a.  m. 

Time  used  to  blow 12  min.  1 1  min. 

Started  to  pour  into  ladle 2.32  p.  m.         10.29  a-  m 

Started  to  pour  into  molds 2. 38^  10.36  a.  m. 

Time  from  finish  of  blowing  to  start  of  pouring  into 

molds   7^2  min.  9  min. 

Finished  pouring  into  molds 2.49  p.  m.         10.46  a.  m. 

As  stated  above,  five  different  sizes  of  ingots  were  made,  and  the 
dimensions  and  weights  of  the  molds  used  are  shown  in  table  5.  Previous 
to  casting  the  molds  were  sprayed  with  tar.  In  order  to  avoid  having 
the  size  of  mold  either  increase  or  decrease,  as  the  height  of  metal 
in  the  ladle  decreased,  the  ingots  were  poured  in  the  following  order, 
15  x  15,  20  x  24,  12  x  12,  25  x  30  and  18  x  18. 


Size 12x12 

Height     62^4  hi. 


TABLE   5 — MOLDS. 

15x15  18x18  20x24 

63  in.  74,y2  in.        yyY2  in. 


25x30 
81  in. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


657 


& 


658 


RAIL. 


Bottom,  inside.... 12^x12^  15    xi5lA  i8&xi8#  20^x24^  25^x30^ 

Bottom,  outside.. 21 1^x21 5^  24     x24l/2  26^x26^  30    X34  41     X45 

Top,  inside   io^xio5/6  13^x13^  i6^xi6}4  18^x22^  24    x20j^ 

Top,  outside  17^x17^  20^x20^  21^x22  26^x30^  35    X40J4 

Weight,  lbs 3,600  4.500  5,300  8,600  15,700 

INGOTS. 

The  first  set  of  ingots  was  used  direct  for  chemical  survey  and  etch- 
ing of  longitudinal  sections,  ingot  numbers  as  follows:     12x12,  IL4;  15x15. 


Fig.  2 — Ingots  after  Splitting. 

IL5;  18x18,  IL6;  20x24,  IL7;  25x30,  IL8.  After  pouring,  they  were  switched 
around  at  intervals  for  about  20  minutes,  and  were  then  allowed  to  cool 
in  the  molds.  Fig.  1  is  a  view  of  the  ingots  on  their  stools  in  the  molds, 
showing  a  rather  interesting  assortment.  In  addition  to  the  test  ingots, 
the  metal  left  in  the  ladle  made  another  ingot  of  about  5,000  lbs.  The 
dimensions  and  weights  of  the  test  ingots  when  cold  are  shown  in  table  6. 


IL7 

IL8 

20x24 

25x30 

59^  in. 

58^  in. 

19^5x23^ 

24ifx29^ 

I8^X22J4 

23^x28^ 

7,000 

10,600 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF   INGOT.  659 

TABLE    6— INGOTS. 

Ingot  No IL4               IL5  IL6 

Ingot  size   12x12            15x15  18x18 

Length  60  in.            59  in.  60  in. 

Size,  bottom   12x12  14^x14%  i8Axi8^t 

Size,  top  ioyAynoy2  I3j4xi3-fe  i6j4xi6ffe 

Weight,  lbs.  2,000  3,000  4,600 

When  cold,  the  ingots  were  split  open  (across  the  small  diameter  in 
the  case  of  the  oblong  sections),  by  first  slotting  on  opposite  sides  to  a 
depth  of  four  to  six  inches,  with  a  tool  about  -)4  inch  wide,  and  then 
splitting  under  the  steam  hammer  by  means  of  wedges.  It  might  be  stated 
that  when  broken  these  ingots  gave  off  the  odor  of  ammonia  from  the 
fracture,  and  also  turned  phenolphthalein  paper  red.  The  fractures,  which 
showed  up  the  pipes  and  blow  holes  nicely,  are  reproduced  in  Fig.  2, 
which  shows  the  hve  ingots  together.  It  will  be  noted  that  the  "pipe" 
or  shrinkage  cavity  goes  deepest  in  the  smallest  ingot,  and  becomes  less 
deep  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The  per  cent,  of  the  height  of 
the  ingot  that  the  pipe  extends  downward  from  the  top  is  very  roughly 
as  follows: 

12x12  ingot 80  per  cent. 

15x15  "  75 

18x18  " 60 

20x24  "  40 

25x30  "  35 

These  figures  refer  simply  to  the  shrinkage  cavity  and  not  to  the 
blow  holes. 

One-half  of  each  ingot  was  then  planed  down  to  below  the  fractured 
surface  and  finally  finished  by  hand  filing.  These  were  then  etched  with  a 
10  per  cent,  water  solution  of  copper  ammonium  chloride  by  leveling  the 
surface  of  the  ingot,  pouring  on  the  solution  and  allowing  it  to  remain 
for  several  minutej.  The  surface  was  then  washed  off  with  a  hose  and 
scrub-brush,  and  then  water  containing  a  little  ammonia  poured  over 
the  surface  to  prevent  a  slight  rust  discoloration.  The  etched  surface 
was  then  photographed  at  once  while  wet.  It  was  hoped  that  the  etching 
would  show  a  "structure"  corresponding  to  the  distribution  of  the  carbon, 
but  this  did  not  prove  to  be  the  case  with  the  condition  of  the  surface 
and  method  used.  The  photographs  showed  the  cavaties  and  blow  holes 
very  nicely,  however,  and  are  reproduced  in  following  figures : 

Fig.  3.  12x12  ingot. 

Fig.  4-  15x15   mgot. 

Fig.  5.  18x18  ingot. 

Fig.  6.  20x24  ingot,  20-inch  diameter. 

Fig.  7.  25x30  ingot,  25-inch  diameter. 

These  figures  represent  surfaces  below  the  axis  of  the  ingot,  and 
therefore  the  pipes  do  not  show  in  them,  but  cavities  and  blow  holes  in 


660 


RAIL. 


Fig.  3— Etched  Section  of  12x12  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


661 


Fig.  4— Etched  Section  of  15x15  Ingot. 


662 


RAIL. 


Fig.  5— Etched  Section  of  18x18  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


66.: 


Fig.  6 — Etched  Section  of  20x24  Ingot,  2o-inch  Diameter. 


664 


RAIL. 


■■ 


Fig.  7— Etched  Section  of  25x30  Ingot,  25-iNCH  Diameter. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE  OF  INGOT. 


665 


Vertical 
Rows 

A    B     C       D      £ 


I 
5 

10 

15 

20 


%    *5 
K    30 

,     35 


% 

o 


so 


60 


70 


80 


90 


99 


o  o  o  o  o 
o  o    o    o    6 

o  o  o  o  o 

o  o  o  o  o 

o  o  o  o  <> 

O   O  O  O  <) 

00006 
00000 
00006 

000  00 
000  o  0 
00000 


H6Lt 


•5 


i>  o     o     o     <p 

Vr 

o  9   <j>    <|>   ( > 

-f-diam.  -*\ 

j£  <£««»!.  — 

OOOO6 


pIG   g — Drilling  Diagram  for  Ingots. 


666 


RAIL. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


667 


the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  are  well  shown.  The  condition  of  "sponginess" 
extends  downward  about  the  same  distance  from  the  top  in  all  the  ingots, 
namely,  about  30  per  cent.  The  blow  holes  toward  the  axis  of  the  ingot 
had  a  coating  of  slag  appearing  very  much  like  a  coat  of  varnish,  while 
those  near  the  walls  of  the  ingot  appeared  to  be  free  from  such  slag 
coating. 

ANALYSES  OF  INGOTS. 

One  of  the  halves  of  each  of  the  split  ingots  was  used  for  making 
a  chemical  survey  of  the  ingot,  the  drillings  for  analysis  being  taken 
as  shown  on  the  drilling  diagram,  Fig.  8.  It  will  be  noted  that  we 
obtained  five  vertical  rows  of  drillings  from  one-half  of  the  section, 
making  a  total  of  75  samples,  less  the  number  of  samples  that  could 
not  be  obtained,  due  to  cavities  in  the  ingot.  The  five  ingots,  after  drill- 
ing, are  shown  together  in  Fig.  9.  On  each  sample  determinations  were 
made  of  carbon  (by  combustion),  phosphorus,  sulphur,  manganese  and 
silicon,  and  the  results  are  shown  in  tables  as  follows  : 

12x12  ingot,  tables     7  to  11  inclusive. 

15x15  ingot,  tables   12  to   16  inclusive. 

18x18  ingot,  tables   17  to  21  inclusive. 

20x24  ingot,  tables  22  to  26  inclusive. 

25x30  ingot,  tables  27  to  31  inclusive. 


TABLE  7 — CARBON  IN  12X12  INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

I 

5 

.48 

10 

•50 

15 

•53 

20 

•53 

25 

•55 

30 

■57 

35 

•  5g 

40 

.58 

50 

08 

60 

.61 

70 

.58 

80 

.60 

90 

.61 

99 

•63 

B. 

48 
50 

54 
57 
53 

50 
59 

bo 

59 

00 

58 
59 

60 
61 

62 


Vertical 

Row.. 

C. 

D. 

.46 

•49 

.67 

.78 

.69 

■  77 

.64 

■70 

.61 

.67 

.58 

.66 

.62 

.62 

•59 

.62 

.61 

.60 

.61 

•58 

•  59 

•  58 

•  50 

•  56 

•57 

56 

.61 

.61 

E, 

45 

82 
77 
71 

70 

69 
69- 
6q 

55- 

60 

5* 

56 

56 
61 


668 


RAIL. 


TABLE   8 — PHOSPHORUS  IN    12X12   INGOT. 


Per  Cent, 

Vertical  Row. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

I 

068 

058 

066 

.062 

5 

063 

067 

10 

067 

077 

116 

171 

.188 

15 

08' 

084 

108 

169 

.162 

20 

082 

078 

097 

114 

•  157 

25 

084 

080 

088 

116 

.142 

30 

092 

093 

094 

111 

.116 

35 

089 

099 

101 

102 

.114 

40 

09-r 

099 

100 

099 

.101 

50 

098 

099 

100 

099 

.009 

60 

.092 

.096 

.100 

091 

.094 

7o 

095 

006 

098 

086 

.084 

80 

096 

095 

.098 

089 

.085 

90 

094 

096 

090 

089 

.085 

99 

.092 

.092 

093 

093 

•  093 

TABLE    9 — SULPHUR    IN     12X12     INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical 

Row. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.023 

.019 

023 

.020 

5 

.020 

.022 

10 

.022 

.027 

.041 

.060 

.070 

15 

.029 

.026 

.039 

059 

.064 

20 

•  032 

.031 

•037 

.041 

.058 

25 

.031 

•  032 

•034 

.042 

.058 

30 

•034 

.034 

.032 

.042 

.044 

35 

.031 

.032 

•037 

.038 

.044 

40 

.032 

•034 

•037 

.035 

•039 

50 

•033 

.034 

•034 

•  033 

•  034 

60 

•  033 

•  033 

•  035 

.032 

•033 

70 

.032 

•034 

•  033 

.031 

.030 

80 

.032 

.032 

•034 

•  033 

.033 

90 

•035 

•037 

.033 

.029 

.029 

99 

.031 

.033 

•033 

•  033 

■033 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


669 


TABLE  10 — MANGANESE  IN    12X12  INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Row. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

I 

•  95 

•97 

.98 

.98 

5 

•97  . 

.98 

IO 

.96 

.99 

1.04 

1.08 

1.08 

15 

.98 

.98 

1.03 

1.04 

1.08 

20 

1. 01 

1. 00 

1.02 

•99 

1.04 

25 

1.02 

1. 00 

* 
1.02 

1.03 

1. 00 

30 

1.02 

1.02 

1. 01 

1.03 

1. 01 

35 

.98 

.98 

1. 00 

1. 01 

1. 01 

40 

.99 

•  99 

.98 

•  99 

1. 00 

50 

1. 00 

•  99 

1. 01 

•  99 

.98 

60 

98 

1 .00 

1. 01 

•97 

.98 

70 

1. 00 

.98 

•  99 

•  99 

.98 

80 

.98 

1. 00 

1. 01 

.96 

.98 

90 

.98 

1. 00 

•97 

1. 00 

•97 

99 

.98 

•97 

1. 01 

.98 

.98 

TABLE 

1 1 — SILICON 

IN  12X12 

INGOT. 

Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Row. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.144 

.144 

.141 

.141 

5 

•134 

.141 

10 

.136 

•  137 

•  137 

.140 

•137 

15 

•134 

•  134 

•139 

.136 

•143 

20 

•138 

.136 

.138 

•143 

.136 

25 

.I36 

.138 

•  133 

.140 

.141 

30 

■133 

.136 

.138 

.136 

.126 

35 

•135 

.128 

•135 

•  136 

•131 

40 

.126 

.128 

.126 

.126 

•125 

50 

•131 

.141 

•  137 

.136 

•133 

60 

•135 

.126 

•131 

.123 

•134 

70 

.124 

•  139 

•131 

.123 

.128 

80 

.128 

.132 

•  135 

•133 

•137 

90 

.130 

.140 

•134 

.122 

.127 

99 

•139 

.133 

.129 

•125 

.127 

G70 


RAIL. 


TABLE    12 — CARBON    IN    15X15    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

I 

47 

44 

44 

52 

42 

5 

39 

46 

10 

39 

46 

64 

15 

41 

48 

70 

78 

79 

20 

43 

53 

65 

74 

82 

25 

53 

50 

65 

66 

69 

30 

55 

52 

56 

63 

7i 

35 

59 

54 

58 

58 

61 

40 

55 

55 

59 

59 

69 

50 

54 

56 

58 

55 

S6 

60 

55 

•55 

58 

57 

56 

70 

55 

55 

55 

54 

53 

80 

54 

•55 

53 

52 

5i 

90 

•5i 

•53 

.56 

50 

50 

99 

54 

54 

55 

55 

57 

TABLE   13 — PHOSPHORUS   IN    I5XI5  INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

1 

079 

065 

5 

054 

074 

10 

055 

069 

15 

060 

074 

20 

080 

084 

25 

087 

075 

30 

•094 

080 

35 

094 

089 

40 

.094 

097 

50 

098 

099 

60 

098 

098 

70 

093 

o95 

80 

.094 

094 

90 

093 

096 

99 

.091 

092 

C. 

D. 

E. 

060 

.084 

054 

121 

120 

.165 

181 

124 

.162 

198 

115 

.130 

136 

092 

•125 

148 

104 

.106 

114 

109 

.107 

135 

106 

.096 

105 

103 

.098 

090 

097 

.091 

087 

094 

.087 

086 

091 

.084 

084 

092 

.092 

092 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


671 


TABLE  14- 

-SULPHUR 

IN  ISXI5 

INGOT. 

Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

c. 

D. 

E. 

i 

.026 

.022 

.021 

.028 

.020 

5 

.018 

.026 

.... 

10 

.019 

.025 

•039 

15 

.019 

.025 

.050 

.070 

.076 

20 

.024 

.025 

•043 

.060 

.085 

25 

.038 

.026 

.040 

.047 

.056 

30 

.040 

.029 

•033 

.046 

.061 

35 

•034 

•033 

•033 

.040 

•  045 

40 

.O42 

.042 

.044 

.041 

•059 

50 

•039 

.042 

•045 

.042 

.041 

60 

•039 

.041 

.044 

.042 

•039 

7o 

•033 

•033 

.032 

.031 

.030 

80 

•033 

.032 

.032 

.032 

.030 

90 

•034 

.032 

.038 

.038 

.036 

99 

•039 

.041 

.041 

•039 

•  039 

TABLE    15— MANGANESE   IN    15x15    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

1.03 

1.02 

■99 

.98 

•98 

5 

1. 00 

.96 

10 

•97 

.98 

1.03 

15 

•94 

•99 

1.07 

1. 10 

1  -15 

20 

•  99 

•99 

1.06 

1.09 

1.08 

25 

•99 

1. 00 

1. 01 

1.07 

1.07 

30 

•99 

•99 

.  1. 01 

1.05 

1.07 

35 

•  99 

1. 00 

1.03 

1.03 

i-03 

40 

.98 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1.04 

50 

•  99 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

60 

.98 

.08 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

70 

1. 00 

1. 01 

•99 

•  99 

•98 

80 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

.98 

.98 

90 

■99 

1. 00 

.98 

■97 

•97 

99 

•97 

-97 

•97 

•97 

•97 

672 


RAIL. 


TABLE  l6 — SILICON   IN    1 5x15   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

1 

.130 

150 

5 

.128 

125 

10 

•134 

128 

is 

.130 

130 

20 

.130 

128 

25 

.132 

124 

30 

.124 

126 

35 

.125 

.122 

40 

.128 

118 

50 

.126 

117 

60 

.113 

no 

70 

•  131 

.127 

80 

.124 

124 

90 

.120 

122 

99 

.114 

TABLE  17— 

108 

-CAR 

Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

1 

•47 

53 

5 

•45 

47 

10 

•  47 

52 

15 

.46 

5o 

20 

.48 

48 

25 

•  52 

56 

30 

•54 

56 

35 

•55 

57 

40 

•53 

57 

50 

•  54 

57 

60 

•57 

54 

70 

•5i 

53 

80 

•53 

55 

90 

■54 

55 

99 

•54 

55 

C. 

D. 

E. 

160 

145 

155 

134 

137 

137 

137 

129 

132 

136 

130 

126 

133 

130 

128 

125 

132 

133 

126 

112 

132 

128 

118 

122 

138 

122 

122 

112 

118 

123 

118 

118 

114 

119 

112 

118 

113 

120 

128 

124 

CARBON    IN    l8xl8   INGOT. 


Vertical  Row. 

C. 

D. 

.46 

50 

•52 

.58 

62 

•57 

75 

•59 

73 

.61 

62 

.62 

62 

.62 

58 

•52 

54 

•  50 

51 

•54 

52 

•  52 

52 

.  =2 

<# 

•49 

47 

•53 

52 

■So 

73 
61 

59 
54 

51 
50 

47 
45 

52 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


673 


TABLE     l8 — PHOSPHORUS    IN     l8xl8    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Row. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C.       D. 

E. 

i 

.064 

.092 

.067      .072 

069 

5 

061 

.069 

.085 

10 

059 

.085 

.  104      .  128 

15 

067 

.072 

.098      .173 

20 

.086 

.072 

. 102      . 154 

... 

25 

082 

.087 

.108      .112 

192 

30 

089 

.091 

.111      .112 

149 

35 

094 

.098 

.113      -107 

126 

4° 

092 

.100 

.110      .101 

101 

50 

096 

.101 

.105      .099 

096 

6o 

096 

.099 

.097      .096 

000 

70 

095 

.096 

.091      .089 

082 

80 

093 

.097 

.093      .084 

075 

90 

097 

•  093 

.084      .078 

P77 

99 

091 

•093 

.094      .092 

090 

TABLE    19 — SULPHUR    IN     l8xl8    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Row. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.019 

.031 

.022 

.025 

027 

5 

.019 

.020 

.028 

10 

.019 

.024 

.029 

.040 

15 

.021 

.022 

•  035 

.060 

20 

.024 

.025 

.032 

.058 

25 

.029 

•  030 

•039 

.040 

081 

30 

•033 

■  034 

.041 

.040 

063 

35 

•  036 

.036 

.041 

.040 

045 

40 

.028 

•  037 

.040 

.040 

040 

50 

•  034 

.039 

•037 

.039 

034 

60 

.029 

.032 

•033 

.031 

028 

7o 

•  034 

.031 

.029 

.030 

029 

80 

•034 

•  037 

■034 

.032 

030 

90 

•  035 

•  035 

•033 

.028 

025 

99 

•034 

■033 

•035 

•  034 

034 

674 


RAIL. 


TABLE   20 — MANGANESE   IN    l8xl8   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Row. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.90 

96 

.98 

94 

96 

5 

•93 

92 

.96 

10 

.92 

96 

•97 

97 

15 

•  94 

97 

•99      1 

04 

20 

.96 

93 

1. 00      1 

04 

25 

•97 

.98 

1. 00      1 

.01      1 

09 

30 

•95 

.96 

.99      1 

.01      1 

05 

35 

•99      1 

00 

1. 00      1 

.01      1 

01 

40 

•  95 

97 

•  99 

•97 

98 

50 

.96 

97 

•97 

•97 

98 

60 

•  98 

98 

•98 

•97 

95 

70 

.98 

97 

.98 

•97 

97 

80 

1.03      1 

03 

1.02      1 

.00 

99 

90 

1.02      1 

.01 

1. 01 

.98 

94 

99 

1.03      1 

03 

1.03      1 

.00      1 

02 

TABLE     21 — SILICON     IN     l8xi8    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

Vertical  Re 

w. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

•  125 

142 

150 

124 

124 

5 

.125 

130 

128 

10 

.119 

127 

126 

123 

15 

128 

140 

135 

151 

20 

.139 

133 

134 

148 

... 

25 

.140 

136 

134 

137 

149 

30 

.129 

130 

128 

129 

128 

35 

•133 

128 

128 

126 

134 

40 

.140 

142 

138 

143 

141 

50 

.140 

.138 

136 

134 

130 

60 

.138 

137 

136 

142 

137 

70 

.147 

144 

143 

130 

133 

80 

.142 

141 

136 

135 

141 

90 

•  U7 

134 

134 

.142 

134 

09 

•  137 

137 

129 

137 

138 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


675 


TABLE    22 — CARBON     IN     20x24     INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

i 

.40 

•  39 

48 

39 

41 

•  5 

.41 

.46 

IO 

.41 

•5i 

56 

59 

15 

•43 

•5i 

57 

77 

20 

.46 

•47 

66 

78 

•• 

25 

•  47 

•52 

60 

63 

85 

30 

•  54 

•55 

59 

59 

7i 

35 

.56 

•54 

59 

59 

66 

40 

•55 

•55 

60 

62 

65 

50 

•54 

.56 

58 

55 

55 

60 

•56 

•  56 

58 

55 

53 

70 

•56 

•  56 

56 

52 

48 

80 

•54 

•  55 

53 

5o 

47 

90 

•54 

•55 

52 

50 

49 

99 

•  55 

•54 

55 

53 

54 

TABLE  23- 

-PHOSPHORUS 

[N  20X24  INGOT. 

Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E 

1 

•055 

.050 

074 

.050 

056 

5 

.051 

.067 

10 

.054 

•073 

•  085 

099 

15 

.058 

•075 

.085 

.165 

20 

.064 

.072 

•093 

•135 

25 

.071 

.080 

.094 

.102 

.199 

30 

.088 

.O96 

.107 

.099 

.136 

35 

.090 

.097 

.iog 

.096 

.149 

40 

.097 

.098 

.112 

.104 

.109 

50 

.094 

.097 

.104 

.097 

.088 

60 

•009 

.097 

099 

.092 

.081 

70 

•095 

.097 

.096 

.089 

.080 

80 

1094 

.099 

.092 

.085 

.078 

90 

.006 

.098 

.088 

.085 

.084 

99 

.094 

.O94 

•  093 

•093 

.094 

676  RAIL. 


TABLE    24 — SULPHUR    IN     20X24    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

c. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.018 

.016 

.030 

.016 

017 

5 

.017 

.023 

10 

.019 

.024 

.028 

.034 

15 

.019 

.025 

.027 

.065 

20 

.022 

.026 

.031 

•  055 

25 

.023 

.028 

•031 

.041 

084 

30 

.031 

•033 

.037 

.036 

061 

35 

.036 

■  037 

.041 

•035 

058 

40 

•034 

•034 

•039 

.040 

045 

SO 

.031 

•  035 

•037 

•034 

030 

60 

■033 

.031 

•034 

•  033 

032 

70 

•033 

•  035 

.033 

.032 

028 

80 

.032 

•033 

•  033 

.028 

027 

90 

•035 

.036 

.031 

.027 

029 

99 

.031 

.032 

•033 

.032 

032 

TABLE  25- 

-MANGANESE  IN  20X24 

INGOT. 

Per  Cent. 

from 

Top. 

A. 

B. 

c. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.92 

.94 

•97 

1. 00 

99 

5 

.90 

•94 



10 

.92 

•95 

•99 

1. 00 

15 

•95 

•98 

1. 00 

1. 10 

20 

•94 

•97 

•99 

1.07 

... 

25 

.96 

1. 00 

1.03 

1.04      1 

10 

30 

.98 

1. 00 

1.04 

1.03      1 

09 

35 

1. 01 

1 .01 

1.02 

1. 00      1 

.03 

40 

•  99 

1. 00 

1.09 

1.02      1 

.02 

50 

I.C2 

1. 00 

1. 01 

•  99 

97 

60 

•99 

1. 00 

1.03 

1.02 

.98 

70 

•99 

1. 00 

1. 01 

•95 

.96 

80 

1. 00 

1. 01 

1. 00 

1. 01 

97 

90 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00 

1. 00      1 

01 

99 

•99 

•  99 

•99 

1. 01      1 

02 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


677 


TABLE   26 — SILICON    IN    20X24   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.120 

•  137 

133 

•152 

.129 

5 

.122 

.124 

10 

.128 

.130 

130 

.140 

15 

.124 

.123 

124 

.130 

20 

.123 

•135 

134 

.142 

25 

•  125 

.121 

126 

■  133 

•  134 

30 

.130 

.127 

137 

.128 

•  133 

35 

•  134 

•  137 

134 

.130 

•  135 

40 

•  133 

•  131 

133 

.130 

.128 

50 

.128 

•  133 

131 

•  133 

.127 

60 

.129 

•  133 

.130 

•  135 

.124 

70 

.132 

.128 

•  125 

.129 

.129 

80 

.130 

.138 

.130 

.132 

.130 

90 

.132 

•  134 

.136 

.129 

.130 

99 

.129 

.132 

.132 

•  134 

.132 

TABLE   27 — CARBON    IN    25x30   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

•  47 

.40 

.46 

48 

49 

5 

.42 

•  37 

.41 

59 

61 

10 

•  39 

•  45 

.60 

62 

IS 

•42 

•47 

.66 

88      1. 

04 

20 

.42 

•  49 

.66      1 

00      1 

18 

25 

.46 

•5i 

•  76 

85 

88 

30 

.46 

•  fo 

.66 

69 

77 

35 

•  47 

•  56 

.65 

68 

77 

40 

•  53 

.56 

.62 

64 

70 

5o 

•5i 

•54 

.60 

55 

52 

60 

•52 

■  57 

•54 

54 

49 

70 

•  55 

•56 

•55 

•5i 

49" 

80 

•54 

•54 

•49 

.46 

45 

00 

•  53 

■  5,3 

•4« 

.48 

48 

99 

•54 

•54 

•54 

•55 

•54 

678 


RAIL. 


TABLE    28 — PHOSPHORUS    IN    25x30   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.074 

.062 

.066 

.086 

.083 

5 

.052 

.064 

.066 

.108 

.116 

10 

.052 

.064 

.110 

.110 

15 

•  053 

.072 

.121 

.205 

•  295 

20 

.065 

.072 

.110 

.265 

.302 

25 

.062 

.077 

.128 

•174 

.199 

30 

.072 

.078 

.120 

.142 

.174 

35 

.070 

.083 

.121 

.132 

.176 

40 

.087 

.080 

.117 

.122 

•  134 

50 

.089 

.088 

.106 

.101 

•  095 

60 

.094 

.100 

.096 

.094 

.082 

70 

•09s 

.100 

.100 

.089 

.080 

80 

.094 

.102 

.085 

.076 

.072 

90 

.094 

•  095 

.085 

.082 

.083 

99 

•  093 

.096 

•095 

•  995 

•  095 

TABLE    29 — SULPHUR    IN    25x30    INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.027 

.022 

.022 

027 

.030 

5 

.017 

.020 

.022 

039 

•  039 

10 

.013 

.020 

•  035 

.040 

15 

.020 

.024 

.041 

084 

.124 

20 

.023 

.026 

•043 

no 

.164 

25 

.029 

.032 

•  055 

072 

.083 

30 

.027 

.027 

.043 

053 

.068 

35 

.027 

.031 

•  043 

047 

.072 

40 

.031 

.029 

.044 

048 

.058 

50 

.031 

.030 

.041 

039 

•  035 

60 

•  035 

.038 

.036 

037 

.031 

70 

.032 

.040 

.044 

032 

.027 

80 

.034 

•  043 

.032 

038 

.026 

90 

.036 

.036 

.030 

029 

.031 

99 

•  035 

.032 

.037 

037 

.041 

INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


679 


TABLE   30 — MANGANESE   IN   25x30   INGOT. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.91 

94 

95 

95 

96 

5 

.92 

92 

92      1 

01      1. 

02 

10 

.91 

94      x. 

03 

1. 

04 

15 

.92 

94      1 

00      1 

18      1 

24 

20 

•95 

96      1. 

01      1 

19      1 

26 

25 

•95 

.96      1 

05      1 

12      1 

15 

30 

•  95 

96      1. 

06      1 

08      1 

10 

35 

•95 

96      1 

03      1 

04      1 

07 

40 

•97 

96      1. 

03      1 

04      1 

03 

50 

.98 

.98 

99 

98 

08 

60 

.98 

.98 

98 

97 

96 

70 

.98 

•  99 

99 

98 

98 

80 

.98 

99 

98 

97 

97 

90 

.98 

.98 

96 

96 

96 

99 

•  98 

.98 

98 

97 

98 

TABLE  31— 

SILICON  IN 

25x30  INGOT. 

Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

c. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.116 

.150 

136 

123 

128 

5 

.122 

.122 

125 

.132 

134 

10 

.127 

•139 

131 

137 

15 

.130 

.122 

143 

.144 

152 

20 

.132 

■  133 

.140 

.158 

.150 

25 

.120 

.126 

140 

•  139 

137 

30 

•133 

•  133 

•  139 

.141 

144 

35 

.136 

.136 

139 

144 

147 

40 

•139 

.136 

135 

138 

144 

50 

.138 

.130 

138 

136 

135 

60 

.130 

.136 

138 

.136 

136 

70 

.130 

.130 

134 

133 

130 

80 

.127 

.130 

.130 

.130 

128 

90 

.128 

•  131 

135 

•  137 

139 

99 

.132 

.132 

.132 

•  134 

.130 

1)80  RAIL. 

Probably  the  five  samples  from  the  bottom  of  the  ingot  represent 
pietty  well  the  average  steel  in  the  ingot,  and  the  average  results  are  shown 
in  table  32. 

TABLE    32 — AVERAGES    OF    SAMPLES    99A-B-C-D    AND    E. 

Ingot.          C.  P.      S.     Mn.  Si. 

12x12 (.616)  .0926  .0326    .984  -I31 

15x15  552  .0918  .0398    .970  .119 

18x18  532  .0920  .0340  1.022  .136 

20x24  542  .0936  .0320  1. 000  .132 

25x30  542  -0948  .0364    -978  -132 

Average  54  -093  -Q35     -99  .13° 

The  general  average  of  each  element  shown  in  the  table  can  probably 
be  taken  as  representing  the  heat.  The  carbon  in  the  12x12  ingot  shows 
.616  per  cent.,  which  is  considerably  higher  than  in  the  other  ingots, 
namely,  .542  per  cent.,  and  it  has  been  omitted  in  obtaining  the  general 
average,  although  it  can  probably  be  taken  as  correct  for  the  12x12  ingot, 
as  the  determinations  were  thoroughly  checked. 

A  study  of  the  analyses  shows  that  in  general  the  extreme  variations 
in  composition  at  any  given  distance  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  are  shown 
by  the  axis  and  the  walls  of  the  ingot,  in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot 
the  axis  showing  considerably  higher  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur 
than  the  walls,  while  in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  the  axis  shows  lower 
amounts  of  these  elements.  Manganese  also  shows  a  similar  separation, 
but  to  a  much  smaller  extent.  Silicon  remains  fairly  evenly  distributed 
throughout  the  ingot.  In  order  to  show  conveniently  the  changes  of 
composition  from  the  top  to  the  bottom  of  the  ingot,  I  give  in  Figs.  10 
to  14,  inclusive,  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  diagrams  for  the  five 
ingots.  The  distance  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  in  per  cent.,  is  plotted 
horizontally,  and  the  amount  of  the  element  vertically,  and  both  the  axis 
and  the  wall  are  represented.  These  diagrams  show  some  very  inter- 
esting results,  and  should  be  studied  closely.  The  average  carbon,  phos- 
phorus and  sulphur  in  the  heat,  as  deduced  above,  are  shown  on  the  dia- 
grams, and  it  will  be  noticed  that  the  axis  shows  very  strong  segrega- 
tion of  the  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  in  the  upper  part  of  the 
ingot,  while  in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  these  elements  go  somewhat 
below  the  average  amount,  or  show  "negative"  segregation.  Close  to  the 
top  the  axis  shows  negative  segregation  also.  The  wall  of  the  ingot 
shows  negative  segregation  in  the  upper  third,  and  about  the  average 
composition  in  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot.  The  maximum  carbon  found 
in  the  axis,  the  minimum  in  the  axis  in  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot,  and 
the  minimum  amount  found  in  the  wall,  are  shown  for  the  several  ingots 
in  table  33. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


681 


12  x  12     INGOT 


Side 


10  2.0         30  40  5  0  €0  ?0  SO  90        100 


10         20         30         40         50         60         70         80         9o        too 


CentcT 


'      J03S 


I 


<*«-<£ 


Side. 


10         20         30         40         50         GO        70         60         90       \60 

Percent    from    Top    ©/   Imgot 

Fig.  10 — Carbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  Diagrams  of  the  12x12 

Ingot. 


682 


RAIL. 


15x15   INGOT 


IO        20         30        40         50        60        7Q        80        90      loo 

Percent    /rom    Top    o/    Ingot 

Fig.  11 — Carbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  Diagrams  of  the  15x15 

Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


18x18   I  NG-OT 


.80 


.60 


O 

K.40 

8 
O20 


.'60 

(0 

o 

Pp80 

to 
o 

5^° 


»•©-■ 


10         20  Jt   30         40         50         60         70         80         90       loc 


10        20        30        40        50        60        70        60        90      100 


10         20         30         40         50         60         70         SO  90       loo 

Percent    from    Top     0/    Ingot 


Fig.  12 — Carbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  Diagrams  of  the  18x18 

Ingot. 


684 


80 


o 


20 


0.|  2 

$08 

>04 


08 


k06 

fi<04 

">o2 


RAIL. 
20x24    INGOT 


10        20        30       40        50        60        70        80        90       KX 


tO       20       30       40       50       60        70        80       90      loc 


IO        20       30       40        50        60        70        80        90      loo 

Per  cert  t    from    Top    o/  Ingot 

Fig.  13 — Carbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  Diagrams  of  the  20x24 

Ingot. 


25x30  INGOT 


120 


f-oo 


fc«0 
o 

0 

^.40 


20 

o 

.28 
.24 


5-20 

k 
o 
<I6 

R. 

0.12 
.08 


.04 


16 


k.,2 

R.08 
(004 


fO      20       30      40      50      60       70       80      90     loc 


IO       20       30       40        50        60        70        80        SO      IOO 

Percent  from    Tojo     of    Ingot 

Fig.  14 — Carbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  Diagrams  of  the  25x30 

Ingot. 


686 


RAIL. 


Axis 

Wall 

Minimum. 

Minimum 

•  55 

.48 

•5o 

•39 

•45 

•45 

•47 

.40 

•  45 

•39 

TABLE  33 — MAXIMUM   AND    MINIMUM    CARBON. 

Axis 
Ingot.  Maximum. 

12x12  82 

15x15  82 

18x18  80 

20x24  85 

25x30  1  •  18 


The  average  carbon  in  the  heat  was  .54  per  cent.,  except  in  the 
12x12  ingot,  where  it  was  about  .62  per  cent.,  as  explained  above.  Why 
this  difference  should  have  been  I  cannot  say,  but  of  the  causes  that 
can  be  conjectured,  a  reasonable  one  seems  to  be  that  the  additional 
carbon  may  have  been  absorbed  from  the  tar  used  to  spray  the  molds. 
It  must  be  recognized,  however,  that  this  explanation  is  purely  a  con- 
jecture. The  maximum  segregation  is  seen  from  the  diagrams  to  occur 
at  about  10  to  20  or  25  per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the  ingot.  In  general, 
the  maximum  segregation  seems  to  occur  about  20  per  cent.,  by  distance, 
from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  which  would  be  about  15  per  cent.,  or  a  little 
more,  by  weight,  and  in  general  the  per  cent,  of  segregation  increases 
as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases,  as  indicated  by  table  34. 


TABLE    34 — POSITIVE    SEGREGATION    OF    CARBON. 

Maximum 

Ingot.                                        Carbon.  Increase. 

12x12 82  32  per  cent. 

15x15- 82  52 

18x18 80  48 

20x24 85  57 

25x30 1. 18  119        " 


The  per  cent,  of  segregation  in  the  12x12  ingot  is  probably  greater 
than  shown  above,  due  to  the  uncertainty  of  the  average  carbon. 

The  lowest  carbon  content  or  greatest  negative  segregation  occurs 
close  to  the  top  of  the  ingot.  Considering  the  walls  of  the  ingot,  the 
least  carbon  is  found  about  5  per  cent,  from  the  top,  and  it  gradually 
increases  until  the  average  carbon  is  reached,  somewhat  above  the  middle 
of  the  ingot,  when  the  amount  remains  about  constant  the  rest  of  the 
way  down.  In  other  words,  in  the  upper  third  of  the  ingot  the  walls 
are  softer  than  the  average  steel,  The  per  cent,  of  greatest  decrease  of 
carbon   is   shown  in  table  35. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


687 


TABLE    35 — .NEGATIVE    SEGREGATION    OF    CARBON. 

Minimum 
Ingot.  Carbon.  Decrease. 

12x12 

15x15 

18x18 


.48 

23 

per  cent. 

•39 

28 

" 

•45 

17 

" 

.40 

26 

" 

•39 

28 

" 

20x24 

25x30 

The  per  cent,  of  the  maximum  decrease,  as  shown  in  this  table,  seems 
to  bear  no  relation  to  the  size  of  the  ingot. 

The  maximum  phosphorus  found  in  the  axis,  the  minimum  in  the 
axis  in  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot,  and  the  minimum  phosphorus  found 
in  the  wall,  are  shown  in  table  36  for  the  several  ingots. 

TABLE    36 — MAXIMUM    AND    MINIMUM     PHOSPHORUS. 


Ingot. 

12X12  

15X15  

I8xl8  

20X24  

25X30  


Axis. 

Wall. 

ax. 

Increase. 

Min. 

Min.     Decrease. 

188 

102% 

.084 

.063            32% 

198 

113% 

.084 

•  054            42% 

192 

106% 

•075 

•  059            36% 

199 

114% 

.078 

•  051            45% 

302 

225% 

.072 

•  052            44% 

No  samples  for  analysis  were  taken  from  the  axis  between  1  per  cent, 
and  25  per  cent,  from  the  top  from  the  18x18  and  20x24  ingots,  account  of 
cavities  or  sponginess,  but  a  study  of  the  diagrams  in  connection  with  the 
results  in  table  36  seems  to  show  that  the  segregation  of  phosphorus  in- 
creases as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The  average  phosphorus  in  the 
heat  was  about  .093  per  cent.,  and  the  maximum  segregation  of  phosphorus, 
or  increase  above  the  average  amount,  ranged  from  about  100  per  cent, 
in  the   12x12  ingot,  to  over  200  per  cent,  in  the  25x30  ingot. 

The  greatest  negative  segregation  of  phosphorus  in  the  wall  of  the 
upper  third  of  the  ingot  ranged  from  32  to  45  per  cent,  showing  a  slight 
tendency  to  increase  with  the  size  of  the  ingot. 

In  table  37,  the  results  for  sulphur  are  given  similar  to  the  ones 
given  for  phosphorus. 


TABLE    37 — MAXIMUM    AND    MINIMUM    SULPHUR. 


Ingot.  Max. 

12x12  070 

15x15  085 

18x18  081 

20x24 .084 

25x30  164 


Axis. 

Wall. 

Increase. 

Min. 

Min. 

Decrease. 

100% 

.029 

.020 

43% 

143% 

.030 

.018 

49% 

131% 

.028 

.019 

46% 

140% 

.027 

.017 

51% 

369% 

.026 

.013 

63% 

688  RAIL. 

The  average  sulphur  in  the  heat  was  .035  per  cent.,  and  the  maximum 
segregation  ranged  from  100  per  cent,  in  the  12x12  ingot,  to  369  per  cent. 
in  the  25x30  ingot.  The  greatest  negative  segregation  of  sulphur  in  the 
wall  of  the  ingot  ranged  from  43  per  cent,  to  63  per  cent.,  increasing  in 
general  somewhat  with  the  size  of  the  ingot. 

From  the  above  discussion  and  the  diagrams,  it  will  be  noted  that 
the  greatest  segregation  occurred  with  the  sulphur,  the  next  in  per-^ 
centage  with  the  phosphorus,  arid  carbon  ranked  third  in  per  cent,  of 
segregation.  Another  point  of  interest  is  that  the  various  elements 
segregate  together,  that  is,  the  concentrations  occur  in  the  same  areas, 
although  the  percentages  differ  for  the  different  elements. 

In  order  to  show  more  clearly  than  the  tables  the  separation  of  the 
elements  into  areas  of  different  concentrations,  Fig.  15  is  given,  show- 
ing the  distribution  of  phosphorus  throughout  the  ingot  for  each  of 
the  five  different  ingots.  These  diagrams  show  regions  of  six  different 
concentrations  of  phosphorus,  as  follows : 

A — Below  .070  per  cent. 

B — .070  to  .085  per  cent. 

C — .085  to  .105  per  cent. 

D — '.105  to  .135  per  cent. 

E — .135  to  .175  per  cent. 

F — Above  .175  per  cent. 
The  same  diagrams  would  represent  regions  of  different  concentra- 
tions of  carbon  and  of  sulphur,  but  phosphorus  was  selected  for  this 
purpose,  as  it  seems  to  have  been  very  uniform  throughout  the  heat 
before  pouring,  while  the  average  carbon  in  the  12x12  ingot  seems  to 
have  been  materially  higher  than  in  the  other  ingots,  and  the  sulphur  seems 
to  show  some  variations,  although  of  considerably  less  importance. 

The  amounts  of  carbon  and  sulphur  represented  by  the  above  regions 
would  be  about  as  follows  : 


Carbon. 

Sulphur. 

A 

Below  .47  per 

cent. 

Below  .024  per  cent. 

B 

•47  to  .51     " 

" 

.024  to  .030    "        " 

C 

■51  to  .57     " 

" 

.030  to  .042     "        " 

D 

.57  to  .66    " 

" 

.042  to  .055     ' 

E 

.66  to  .77    " 

" 

.055  to  .070    ' 

F 

Above  .77     " 

" 

Above  .070     "        " 

The  area  of  maximum  concentration  indicated  by  F,  and  for  which 
the  minimum  limit  of  .175  per  cent,  phosphorus  has  been  chosen,  is  seen 
to  lie  in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot,  and  also  to  extend  lower  down 
into  the  ingot  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The  middle  of  this 
region  extends  from  about  10  per  cent,  of  the  length  from  the  top  of 
the  12x12  ingot,  to  a  little  over  20  per  cent,  from  the  top  in  the  25x30 
ingot.  By  weight  the  amounts  would  be  several  per  cent.  less.  Area 
C  represents  steel  of  average  composition,  while  B  represents  steel  with 
negative  segregation.  AH  the  ingots  show  some  of  the  B  area  in  the 
lower  part  of  the  ingot,  but  its  proportionate  amount  increases  in  general 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


689 


1       1 

i      i      i 

i      i 

1       1 

x^Mc 

llll^ 

■-. 

=^$^2 

o  "' 

^3  >-' 


3        o 


Uh 


690  RAIL. 

as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The  greatest  negative  segregation  is 
seen  in  area  A  at  the  top  of  the  ingot,  which  contains  less  than  .070 
per  cent,  phosphorus.  This  area  includes  the  walls  of  the  upper  part 
of  the  ingot,  and  is  seen  to  extend  downward  along  the  walls  an  in- 
creasing distance  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The  area  A  would 
also  represent  carbon  below  about  .47  per  cent.,  with  the  average  in  the 
steel  .54  per  cent.  The  distance  that  area  A  extends  downward  from 
the  top  along  the  walls  of  the  ingot,  and  the  distance  downward  that 
it  is  necessary  to  go  along  the  walls  to  reach  the  average  of  .093  per  cent, 
phosphorus  and  .54  per  cent,  carbon,  are  shown  in  table  38. 

TABLE   38 — NEGATIVE    SEGREGATION    IN    WALLS   OF   INGOT. 

Area  A  extends  Distance  of  Average 

Ingot                                       down  from  top.  Steel  from  top. 

12x12 13%  30% 

15x15 15%  30% 

18x18 15%  35% 

20x24 24%  35% 

25x30 30%  50% 

RAILS  FOR  SPECIAL  TESTS. 
A  second  series  of  five  ingots  was  made  similar  to  the  first  series, 
for  rolling  into  rails  for  drop  tests,  etchings  and  chemical  analyses, 
with  ingot  numbers  as  follows:  12x12,  II9;  15x15,  II 10;  18x18,  II  11 ; 
20x24,  II  12 ;  25x30,  II 13.  After  stripping,  the  three  smaller  ingots  were 
placed  into  a  soaking  pit  at  the  rail  mill,  and  after  remaining  in  the  pit 
for  two  hours,  were  rolled  into  rails  of  100  lbs.  A.  R.  A. -type  B  sec- 
tion, Illinois  Steel  Company  section  10030,  making  only  sufficient 
cropping  from  the  ends  of  the  blooms  to  allow  of  rolling  into  rails.  On 
account  of  its  small  size  the  12x12  in.  ingot  gave  trouble  by  catching 
in  the  various  rolls,  and  finally  made  a  "cobble"  in  the  roughing  rolls. 
The  20x24  in.  and  25x30  in.  ingots  were  too  large  to  enter  the  bloom- 
ing rolls  of  the  rail  mill,  so  they  were  first  bloomed  down  at  the 
structural  mill  at  South  Chicago,  after  heating  in  the  soaking  pit.  The 
20x24  in-  ingot  was  in  the  soaking  pit  2  hrs.  20  min.,  bloomed  to  16x16 
in.,  reheated  for  V2  hr.,  bloomed  to  14x14  in.  and  cut  in  two.  The 
second  heating  was  not  intended,  but  was  necessary,  because,  after  the 
first  blooming,  the  bloom  had  become  too  cold  to  shear  in  two.  The 
25x30  in.  ingot  was  in  the  pit  2  hrs.  40  min.,  rolled  to  16x16  in.,  and 
the  bloom  cut  in  two.  These  blooms  were  then  brought  to  the  rail  mill, 
put  into  the  soaking  pit  for  3  hrs.,  and  rolled  into  rails  as  above.  The 
two  parts  from  the  25x30  in.  ingot  were  each  cut  in  two,  after  bloom- 
ing to  about  8x8  in.,  as  the  rail  bar  would  otherwise  have  been  too  long 
for  the  runways.  The  rail  bars  of  the  15x15  and  18x18  ingots  were  each 
rolled  in  one  piece,  the  20x24  ingot  in  two  pieces,  and  the  25x30  ingot  in 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT.  691 

four  pieces.     There  were  no  croppings  from  any  of  the  rail  bars,  except 
from  the  25x30  ingot. 

The  weights  of  the  individual  rails  are  shown  in  table  39. 

TABLE    39 — WEIGHTS    OF    RAILS. 

Ingot  number    II  10 

Ingot    size    15x15 

Rail  A   1,085 

B   1,109 

C  660 

D 


E 
F 
G 

II 


11 II 

11  12 

11 13 

18x18 

20X24 

25x30 

1,100 

1,076 

1,107 

1,128 

1,095 

1,102 

1,120 

990 

1,114 

1,000 

1,075 

i,H5 

1,098 

1,080 

936 

1,100 
1,097 
1,110 

Total    2,854        4,348        6,270        8,825 

The   several   croppings    from   the   rail   bar   of   the  25x30  ingot   were 
as  shown  in  table  40. 

TABLE  40 — CROPPINGS  FROM  25x30  RAIL  BAR. 

A  rail,  top  end 44  lbs. 

B    "      back  end 120   " 

C     "      top  end 75    " 

D    "      back  end 260" 

F    "      back  end 296    " 

Total    795  lbs. 

The   total   weights   of  the   ingots,    as    determined    from   the    weights 
of  the  rails,  and  the  bloom  and  rail  croppings,  are  shown  in  table  41. 

TABLE     41 — WEIGHTS     OF     INGOTS. 

Ingot  number    II 10         II 11  II  12  II 13 

Ingot    size    15x15       18x18  20x24  25x30 

Rails     2,854        4,348  6,270  8,825 

Bloom  Crops — - 

Top    97           115  118  218 

1st  intermediate 125  115 

2nd  intermediate 113  109 

Bottom    103             78  115  130 

Rail  crops    795 

Total    3,054        4,54i.       6,741       10,192 

The  lengths  of  the  full-length  rails  were  measured,  and  are  shown 
in  table  42. 


692 


RAIL. 


TABLE    42 — LENGTH    OF    RAILS. 


Ingot  number  U  10 
Ingot  size  15x15 
Rail  A    

B   ....    33'  o" 

C 

D 

E 
F 
G 
H 


II  11 
18x18 

33'  0%' 
33    0% 


II  12 
20x24 

32'  1 1 24' 


32  n  34 


11 13 

25x30 

33'  oy4f 

32  nVs 

33  oy& 
33    °lA 

32  nVs 


33     o 

The  saws  are  usually  set  for  this  section  for  a  shrinkage  of  6^4  in., 
and  this  was  the  allowance  in  this  case,  although  I  did  not  measure 
the  saw  setting  at  the  time  these  rails  were  rolled. 

The  various  rails  in  this  series  were  divided  into  units  of  one-third 
rail,  or  11  ft.  each,  for  drop  tests,  analyses  and  etchings.  From  each 
unit  1  ft.  was  cut  for  etching  and  analysis,  then  5  ft.  for  drop  test 
with  the  head  in  tension,  and  the  other  5  ft.  for  drop  test  with  the  base 
in  tension.  The  pieces  from  each  rail  were  given  numbers  as  folV)ws : 
No.  1.     1  ft.     Analysis  and  etching. 

2.  5  ft.     Drop  test,   head  tension. 

3.  5  ft.     Drop  test,  base  tension. 

4.  1  ft.     Analysis  and  etching. 

5.  5  ft.     Drop  test,  head  tension. 

6.  5  ft.     Drop  test,  base  tension. 

7.  1  ft.     Analysis   and    etching. 

8.  5  ft.     Drop  test,    head    tension. 

9.  5  ft.     Drop  test,  base   tension. 

The  distance  of  each  test  piece  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  expressed 
in  lbs.,  is  shown  in  tables  43  to  46,  inclusive.  The  samples  for  analysis, 
and  the  section  for  etching,  were  taken  from  the  lower  end  of  the 
i-ft  piece,  and  the  distances  are  shown  to  the  lower  end  of  the  piece, 
but  the  5-ft.  pieces  were  struck  in  the  drop  test  at  the  middle  of  the 
piece,  and  the  distances  are  calculated  to  the  middle. 

TABLE   43 — TEST    PIECES    OF    1 5X1 5    INGOT — LBS.    FROM    TOP    OF    INGOT. 


Test.              Lbs.       Test.  Lbs. 

II10A1 130    II10B1 1,215 


A2. 
A3. 
A4. 
A5. 
A6. 
A7. 
A8. 


213 
380 
496 
579 
746 
862 

945 
A9 1,112 


B2. 
B3- 
B4. 
B5- 
B6. 

B7- 


1,298 
1465 
1,581 
1,664 
.1,831 
•  1,947 


Test.  Lbs. 

II 10  Ci 2,324 

C2 2  407 

C3 2,574 

C4 2,690 

C5 2,773 


B8 2,030 

B9 2,197 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT.  693 

TABLE   44 — TEST   PIECES    OF    l8xl8  INGOT — LBS.   FROM   TOP   OF    INGOT. 

Test.            Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.  Test.            Lbs. 

11  ii  Ai 148    II 11  Bi 1,248    II  11  Ci 2,376      II11D1 3,496 

A2 231  B2 1,333  C2 2,459  D2 3,579 

A3 398  B3 1,498  C3 2,626  D3 3,746 

A4 514  B4 1,614  C4 2,742  D4 3,862 

A5 597  B5 1,697  C5 2,825  D5 3,945 

A6 764  B6 1,864  C6 2,992  D6 4,112 

A7 880  B7 1,980  C7 3,108  D7 4,228 

A8 963  B8 2,063  C8 3,191  D8 4,311 

A9 1,130  B9 2,230  C9 3,358 

TABLE  45 — TEST  PIECES  OF  20X24  INGOT — LBS.  FROM   TOP  OF  INGOT. 

Test.              Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.  Test.              Lbs. 

II12A1 151     II12B1 1,227     H12C1 2,322 

A2 234  B2 1,310  C2 2,405 

A3 401  B3 1,477  C3 2,572 

A4 517  B4 1,593  C4 2,688 

A5 600  B5 1,676  C5 2,771 

A6 767  B6 1,843  C6 2,938 

A7 883  B7 1,959  C7 3,054 

A8 966  B8 2,042  C8 3,137 

A9 1,133  B9 2,209 

TABLE    45 — CONTINUED. 

Test.             Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.  Test.             Lbs. 

II12D1 3,550    II 12  Ei 4,625     II12F1 5,723 

D2 3,663  E2 4,708  F2 5,806 

D3 3,8oo  E3 4,875  F3 5,973 

D4 3,916            E4 4,991  F4.  ....6,089 

D5 3,999  E5 5,074  F5 6,172 

D6 4.166  E6 5,241  F6 6,339 

D7 4,282  E7 5,357  F7 6,455 

D8 4,365  E8 5,440  F8 6,538 

D9 4,532  E9 5,607 

TABLE  46 — TEST  PIECES  OF  25x30  INGOT — LBS.   FROM  TOP  OF  INGOT. 

Test.            Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.  Test.           Lbs  Test.           Lbs. 

II  13  Ai 295     II  13  Bi 1,392     II  13  Ci 2,699      H13D1 3,813 

A2.....    378  B2 1,485  C2 2,782  D2 3,896 

A3 545  B3 1,652  C3 2,949  D3 4,063 

A4 661  B4 1,768  C4 3,065  D4 4,179 

A5 744  B5 1,851  C5 3,148  D5 4,262 

A6 911  B6 2,018  C6 3,315  D6 4,429 

A7 1,027  B7 2,134  C7 3,431  D7 4,545 

A8 1,110  B8 2,217  C8 3,514  D8 4,628 

A9 1,277  B9 2,388  C9 3,681  D9 4.795 


694  RAIL. 

TABLE    46 — CONTINUED. 

Test,           Lbs.  Test.            Lbs.      Test.            Lbs.  Test.            Lbs. 

II13E1 5,412    U15F1 6,492    H13G1 7,888      II  13  Hi 8,985 

E2 5,494  F2 6,575  G2 7,971  H2 9,068 

E3 5,662  F3 6,742  G3 8,138  H3 9,235 

E4 5,778  F4 6,858  G4 8,254  H4 9,351 

E5 5,86i  F5 6,941  G5 8,337  H5 9,434 

E6 6,028  F6 7,108  G6 8,504  H6 9,601 

E7 6,144  F7 7,224  G7 8,620  H7 9,717 

E8 6,227  F8 7,307  G8 8,703  H8 9,800 

E9 6,394  F9 7,474  G9 8,870  H9 9,967 


DROP  TESTS. 

Six  drop  tests  were  made  of  each  full  length  rail,  three  with  the 
head  in  tension,  and  three  with  the  base  in  tension,  in  the  standard 
rail  drop  test  machine.  The  tup  was  2,000  lbs.,  the  height  of  drop  was 
20  ft.,  the  supports  were  3  ft.  apart,  and  the  anvil  was  the  standard 
spring-supported  anvil  of  20,000  lbs.  The  deflection  was  taken  as  the 
distance  between  a  3-ft.  straight  edge  and  the  part  of  the  rail  where 
struck  by  the  tup.  Gage  marks  1  inch  apart  were  put  on  the  side  in 
tension  for  a  distance  of  6  inches,  and  the  stretch  of  each  inch  was 
determined  after  the  rail  was  broken.  The  results  of  the  drop  tests  are 
shown  in  the  following  tables : 

Table  47 — 15x15  Ingot. 

Table  48 — 18x18  Ingot. 

Table  49 — 20x24  Ingot. 

»l  VIJ  Ul  « J  ;  TabIe  50—25x30  Ingot. 

In  these  tables  the  permanent  deflection,  after  the  first  blow,  would 
represent  the  stiffness  of  the  rail  under  impact,  and  the  elongation  of 
the  inch  which  stretched  most  at  breaking  would  represent  the  ductility 
of  the  metal.  The  number  of  blows  which  it  took  to  break  each  rail  is 
also   shown. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


695 


TABLE  47 — DROP  TESTS  OF   I 5X1 5  INGOT. 


H 

II  10  A2 

A3 
A5 


A6 
A8 


m  q      u-, 


o  c 

Head 
Base 
Base 


Base 
Head 


.2^ 


do   ^ 
£pq   Q  £ 


i -Inch  Marks  After  Failure, 
i.      2.       3.       4.       s.       6. 


i. os  1.08  1.09  1  08  1.06 

1.54  1.06  1.08  1. 11  1. 13  1. 13 

1.58  1.04  1.08  1. 10  1. 12  1. 13  1. 12 


1.53  1. 10  1. 12  1. 16  1. 16  1. 14  1. 10 
1.70  1.06  1. 11  1. 16  1. 19  1. 18  1. 13 


Remarks. 


Tested  base 
tension  by 
mistake. 


A9      Base         3     1.65  1.06  1. 10  1. 12  1. 14  1. 14  1. 12 

II10B2      Head        3     1.70  1.09  1.14  1.18  1.20  1.18  1.14 
B3      Base  1     ....  Neglected  to  put  on  gage  marks. 

B5      Head        3     1.69  1.12  1 .  14  1.20  1.19  1.15  1.09 
B6      Base  1     ....  1.02  1.03  1.03  1.03  1.03  1.02 

B8      Head        4     1.68  1.17  1.22  1.22  1.19  1.14  1.10     Not     broken. 

Bent     sidewise. 
B9      Base  3     1.68  1.06  1. 10  1. 13  1. 14  1. 12  1. 10  Diagonal  break 

not    at   bend. 

II 10  C2  Head  3  1.65  1.09  1.13  1.15  1.14  1.11  1.07  Broke  at  sup- 
port. 

C3      Base  1     1. 00  1.02  1.02  1.02  1.02  1.02    Broke  at  sup- 

port. 

C5      Head        4     1.72  1.09  1.14  1.18  1.18  1.17  1.12 


696  RAIL. 


TABLE  48 — DROP  TESTS   OF   l8xl8  INGOT. 

d  -2* 

fflo  vw  „;  t>J2 

**               fc'S  °  &  eW      i-Inch  Marks  After  Failure. 

H             ffiH  fcg  Q  2       i-      2.       3.       4-      5-       6.         Remarks. 

11  11  A2  Head  5  1.92  1.17  1.24  1.32  1.36  1.32  1.22  Not      broken. 

Base  split. 

A3  Base  4  1.73  1. 13  1. 16  1. 18  1. 19  1. 19  1. 12 

A5  Head  1  1.04  1.05  1.06  1.06  ....   1.04 

A6  Base  4  1.60  1.14  1.19  1.20  1.18  1.12  1.08 

A8  Head  1  1.07  1.09  1.09  1.08  1.06  1.04 

A9  Base  4  1.58  1. 11  1. 15  1.17  1.17  1.14  .... 

II11B2      Head        2     1.69  1.05  1.07  1.09  1.10  1.09  1.06 
B3      Base         s     1.64  1. 13  1. 18  1.21  1.21  1.20  1.17 
Bs      Head         4    1.61  1.14  1.20  1.25  1.25  1  21  1.20   Broke  at  sup- 
port. 
B6      Base         5     1.70  1.11  1.16  1.22  1.26  1.26  1. 21    Broke  at  sup- 
port. 
B8      Head         4    1.74  1. 14  1. 19  1.24  1.25  1.22  1. 15 
B9      Base         5     1.68  1.18  1.20  1.20  1.17  1.14  1.11    Broke  at  sup- 
port. 
II 11  C2      Head         3     1.79  1.07  1 .  12  1.15  1.18  1.15  ....  Base     cracked 

under       tup 
1st  blow. 

1. 65  1. 11  1. 15  1. 17  1. 17  1. 16  1. 12 

1.70  1.08  1. 12  1. 18  1.22  1.22  1. 18 

1. 71  1.08  1.08  1. 13  1. 13  1.08 

1.70  1. 12  1. 16  1. 17  1. 17  1. 13  1. 10  Flange  broke. 

1.64  1. 10  1. 14  1. 17  1. 18  1. 18  1. 16 

1.80  1.08  1. 10  1. 14  1. 21  1.24  1.24 
1.64  1. 14  1. 17  1.18  1. 17  1. 14  1. 10 
1.75  1. 14  1. 18  1.23  1.23  1. 14 

1.66  1. 10  1. 15  1. 17  1. 17  1. 16  1. 12 
1.68  1.06  1. 10  1. 14  1. 16  1. 17  1. 14 


•c3 

Base 

4 

cs 

Head 

3 

C6 

Base 

3 

cs 

Head 

3 

Cg 

Base 

4 

II11D2 

Head 

5 

D3 

Base 

3 

D5 

Head 

4 

D6 

Base 

3 

D8 

Head 

3 

INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE  OF  INGOT. 


697 


TABLE    4Q DROP    TESTS    OF    20X24    INGOT. 


w 

c 

pq.c 

O    G 

fflH 

n    . 
.2  £ 

-M  COO  .8 

0  &^pq     i-Inch  -Marks  After  Failure. 
£5p2       i-      2.       3.       4.      5.       6. 

Remarks. 

li  12  A2 

Head 

4 

I.96    I. 13    I. 18    I.24    J. 22    I. 18   I. 12 

Laminated. 

A3 

Base 

4 

I.80    I. 12    I. 17    I. 18   I. 17   I. 14    I. IO 

Broke  at  sup 
port. 

A5 

Head 

2 

I.84   1.08    I. II    I. 13    I. 14    I.08 

A6 

Base 

3 

I.76    1.08    I. 12    I. 14    I. 13    I. II    I.08 

A8 

Head 

2 

i. 71  1.07  i. 10  —  i. ix  i. 10  1.07 

Ao 

Base 

3 

1.66  1. 12  1. 13  1. 12  1.09  ....   1.08 

II12B2 

Head 

1 

. ...  1.04  1.05  1.06  1.06  1.06  1.04 

B3 

Base 

3 

1.59  1. 10  1. 12  1. 12  1. 11  1.08  1.06 

BS 

Head 

2 

1.66  1.08  1. 10  1. 13  1. 13  1. 10  1.07 

B6 

Base 

3 

1.62  1.08  1. 10  1. 12  1. 12  1. 12  1. 10 

B8 

Head 

2 

1.66  1.04  1.06  1.08  1. 10  1. 11  1. 12 

B9 

Base 

3 

1.64  1. 10  1. 13  1. 16  1. 16  1. 12  1. 10 

11  12  C2 

Head 

2 

t.64  1.08  1. 12  1. 17  1. 17  1. 13  1.09 

C3 

Base 

3 

[.72  1.06  1.09  1. 15  1.20  1.22  1. 16 

C5 

Head 

3 

[.64  1. 11  1. 18  1.20  1. 18  1  14  1.09 

C6 

Base 

3 

[.64  1. 11  1. 16  1. 18  1. 18  1. 14  1. 10 

C8 

Head 

3 

[.64  1. 10  1. 16  1.22  1.22  1. 19  1. 12 

11  12  D2 

Head 

4 

[.69  1. 14  1. 18  1.20  1.20  1. 16  

D3 

Base 

5 

[.62  1. 16  1. 19  1. 19  1. 18  1. 14  .... 

D5 

Head 

4 

[.72  1. 15  1.20  1.24  1.23  1. 18  1. 11 

D6 

Base 

5     1 

.58  1. 12  1. 17  1.20  1.22  1.20  .... 

D8 

Head 

4     J 

.65  1. 18  1.24  1.26  1.22  ....   1. 10 

Do 

Base 

4     l 

.62  1. 12  1. 16  1.20  1.20  1. 18  1. 14 

11 12  E2 

Head 

4     i 

.74  1. 18  1. 21  1.20  1. 11  1.06 

E3 

Base 

5     i 

.65  1. 15  1.20  1.22  1.22  1. 18  1. 12 

E5 

Head 

4     I 

.69  1 . 14  1. 18  1. 21  1.22  1. 17  1. 13 

E6 

Base 

5     J 

.72,  1  10  1. 14  1. 19  1.20  1.20  1. 18 

E8 

Head 

4     1 

.75  1.08  1. 10  1. 13  1. 19  1.22  1.22 

Eg 

Base 

3     i 

.69  1.08  1. 12  1. 14  1. 16  1. 15  1. 13 

Broke  at  sup 
port. 

11  12  ¥2 

Head 

3     1 

.74  1. 10  1. 14  1. 17  1. 17  ....   1. 10 

F3 

Base 

3     1 

.68  1.08  1. 11  1. 15  1. 17  1. 17  1. 15 

F5 

Head 

3     1 

.68  1. 14  1. 21   1.25  1.25  1. 19  1. 12 

¥6 

Base 

4     1 

.70  1. 10  1. 14  1. 18  1. 17  1. 16  1. 13 

F8 

Head 

I 

...   1.02  1.04  1.04  1.05  1.04  1.03  \ 

_arge  horizon- 

tal     flaw     in 
head. 


H98  RAIL. 


TABLE  50 — DROP  TESTS  OF  25x30  INGOT. 

a  .2* 

m  o  mh  ^  3.2 

*J  £  g  °^  i^ffl      i-Inch  Marks  After  Failure. 

£  Sh  2WQ2       ^      2-       3-       4-      5-       6.         Remarks. 

II13A2       Head        5     2.12  1. 19  1.24  1.26  1.24  1 .  18  1.14  Not  broken. 
A3       Base  4     1.93  1. 12  1. 17  1.22  1.26  1.26  1.23  Laminated  in 

web. 
A5       Head         3     1.92  1.12  1 .  18  1. 21  1.20  1 .  16  1.11 
A6      Base  5     1.82  1.08  1.14  1.18  1.24  1.32  1.36  Base    not 

broken. 
A8      Head        2     1.86  1.07  1 .  10  1 .  14  1.15  1.J4  1.10 
A9      Base         2     1.82  1.07  1. 10  1.  n  1. 12  1. 11  1.08 

II 13  B2      Head         1     ....   1.06  1.07  1.08  1.08  1.08  1.07 
B3      Base  3     1.78  1. 12  1. 16  1. 19  1.24  1. 18  1. 14 

B5      Head         1     1.02  1.04  1.05  1 .07  1.05  1.04 

B6      Base  2     1.72  1.06  1.08  1.10  1.11  1.10  1.07 

B8  Head  1  ....  1.02  1.04  1.07  1.08  1.07  1.06 
B9      Base  2     1.72  1.07  1.08  1. 10  1. 12  1. 11  1.08 

[1  13  C2      Head         2     1.68  1.09  1.09  1.08  1.06 1.06 

C3  Base  2  1.66  1.04  1.07  1. 10  1. 12  1. 14  1. 12 
C5  Head  2  1.68  1.04  1.07  1.10  1.15  1.20  1.15 
C6  Base  4  1 .62  1.09  1. 14  1. 18  1.20  1.22  1. 17 
C8  Head  2  1.68  1.05  1.07  1.10  1.11  1.10  1.07 
C9      Base  4     1.59  1. 12  1. 15  1. 17  1. 17  1. 16  

[1  13  D2       Head         3     1.52  1.07  1.12  1.16  1.19  1. 17  1. 12 
D3       Base  4     1.58  1. 11   1. 16  1. 18  1. 16  1. 16  1. 12 

D5  Head  3  1.60  1.08  1.12  1.18  1.18  1.17  1.12 
D6      Base  4     1.58  1. 10  1.16  1.18  1.18  1.17  1.14 

D8  Head  3  1.65  1.12  1.18  1.20  1.18  1.14  1.08 
D9      Base  4     1.58  1.06  1. 10  1. 14  1. 18  1. 18  1. 15 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


699 


TABLE    50 — CONTINUED. 


in 

<L> 

H 

d 

PQO 

0  c 

M-l     if) 
O     £ 

6    O 

.2  £ 

i-Inch  Marks  After  Failure. 
1.      2.       3.       4.       5.       6. 

Re 

narks. 

11 

13  E2 

Head 

2 

1. 61 

1.04  1.07 

I.IO    I. II    ] 

.11 

1.09 

E3 

Base 

3 

1.58 

1.08  1. 12 

I. 14    I. 14    1 

.12 

1.08 

ES 

Head 

2 

1.74 

1.08  1. 10 

I. 12    I. 12 

.09 

1.07 

E6 

Base 

4 

1.60 

1.08  1. 12 

LIS    I-I5    J 

.14 

I.IO 

Broke  at  both 
supports. 

E8 

Head 

2 

1.72 

1. 12  1 .  16 

I. l6    I. 15 

•13 

1.07 

Eg 

Base 

3 

1.66 

1 . 08  1 . 1 1 

I. 14    I. l6 

•15 

11 

13  F2 

Head 

3 

1.70 

1.06  1. 12 

I. If    1.20 

.18 

1. 14 

F3 

Base 

4 

1.67 

1.08  1. 12 

I.l6    I. l8 

.18 

1.16 

F5 

Head 

4 

1.76 

I. IO    LIS 

I. 20   I. 23 

.26 

1.20 

F6 

Base 

5 

1-77 

I. 12    I. 18 

I . 20   I . 20    1 

.18 

1. 14 

F8 

Head 

3 

1.74 

I. 14    I. l8 

I . 20    I . 20   1 

.16 

1 .  10 

Only 
bas 

side    of 
e  broken. 

Fg 

Base 

4 

1.70 

I . 12    I. l6 

I. 18    I. l8 

.16 

1.14 

n 

13  G2 

Head 

5 

1.86 

I. IO    I. 14 

I.2I    I.25    ] 

•  32 

1.28 

■ 

G3 

Base 

5 

1.72 

I. 12    I. 17 

I. 20    I . 20 

[.18 

1. 14 

G5 

Head 

3 

1.84 

I.06    I. II 

I. l6    1.22 

[.22 

1. 18 

G6 

Base 

3 

i-73 

I. 12    I. 13 

I. l6    I.  l6 

r-i3 

1.08 

G8 

Head 

4 

i.8g 

I.IO    I. 12 

I.  l8    I.23 

[.27 

1.26 

Gg 

Base 

4 

i-73 

I. 14    I. l8 

f.22    I.2I 

.18 

1 -13 

11 

13  H2 

Head 

3 

1.80 

I. 12    I. l6 

I . 22    I . 20 

.16 

I.IO 

H3 

Base 

4 

1-73 

I . 13    I.20 

I . 22    I. 24 

[.23 

1.18 

H5 

Head 

5 

1.78 

I. 14    I.24 

T.36    1-45 

[-39 

1.26 

H6 

Base 

5 

1.72 

I. IO  i. 14 

I. 16    I. 18 

[.17 

1. 16 

Not 

broken. 

H8 

Head 

4 

1. 71 

1-23    I.34 

i . 36  i . 2g 

[.20 

1 .13 

Hg 

Base 

4 

1.74 

1. 15   I -17 

1.18  1 . 15 

[-13 

1.08 

700  RAIL. 


DUCTILITY. 


The  results  showing  the  ductility  of  the  rails  in  the  drop  test,  are 
shown  in  Fig.  16,  in  which  the  distance  of  the  piece  tested  is  shown 
horizontally  in  pounds  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  and  the  elongation  of 
the  metal  at  breaking  is  shown  vertically.  The  per  cent,  of  elongation 
of  the  inch  which  stretched  most  is  taken  as  representing  the  ductility. 
A  close  study  of  these  diagrams  proves  very  interesting.  Consider-"" 
ing  the  18x18,  20x24  and  25x30  ingots,  it  will  be  noticed  that  the 
rail  bar  at  the  top  end  shows  a  good  ductility,  which  rapidly  decreases  as  we 
pass  through  a  "brittle  zone"  about  20  per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the 
ingot.  The  ductility  again  increases  until  a  distance  of  about  50  per  cent, 
from  the  top  of  the  ingot  is  reached,  after  which  the  change  of  ductility 
is  not  great.  The  rail  bar  from  the  15x15  ingot  shows  a  somewhat 
similar  result,  except  that  the  brittle  zone  starts  in  with  the  topmost 
pieces  tested,  although  it  is  possible,  or  even  probable,  that  the  material 
of  good  ductility  at  the  top  of  this  small  ingot  was  cut  off  with  the  portion 
which  it  was  necessary  to  crop  off  the  top  end  of  the  bloom  before  rolling. 
Another  point  of  considerable  interest  is  that  the  top  half  of  the  ingot 
shows  greater  ductility  when  tested  with  the  base  in  tension  than  with 
the  head  in  tension,  especially  in  the  brittle  zone,  but  the  lower  half 
shows  somewhat  greater  ductility  when  tested  with  the  head  in  tension. 
This  does  not,  however,  necessarily  mean  that  the  rail  from  the  lower 
part  of  the  ingot  would  stand  more  impact  with  head  tension,  since  a 
given  impact  causes  considerably  more  stretch  when  the  head  is  in  tension 
than  when  the  base  is  in  tension,  although  the  deflection  of  the  rail  is 
about  the  same. 

In  order  to  more  conveniently  compare  the  results  from  the  different 
ingots  the  average  results  in  the  head  tension  tests  are  shown  together 
in  Fig.  17,  and  the  results  of  the  base  tension  tests  are  also  shown 
together  by  themselves,  also  in  Fig.  17.  Two  of  the  base  tension  results 
of  15x15  ingot,  Nos.  II  10  B6  and  II  10  C3,  gave  very  low  elongation. 
It  seems  very  probable  that  these  results  were  abnormal  and  were  not 
used  in  drawing  the  average  curve.  Likewise,  the  last  piece  from  the 
20x24  ingot  tested  with  head  tension,  broke  with  very  low  elongation,  evi- 
dently due  to  an  internal  flaw  in  the  head,  and  this  result  was  not  con- 
sidered. It  will  be  noticed  that  in  the  brittle  zone,  which  is  about  20 
per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  with  head  tension,  fracture  occurs 
at  about  6  or  7  per  cent,  stretch,  and  the  ductility  is  about  the  same 
in  the  various  ingots.  In  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot  the  elongation  goes  up 
over  20  per  cent.,  increasing  somewhat  with  the  size  of  the  ingot.  At  the 
top  of  the  ingot  also  the  elongation  is  over  20  per  cent.  With  base  tension 
the  minimum  elongation  is  about  12  per  cent.,  except  in  the  18x18  in- 
got, which  showed  a  minimum  of  17  per  cent.  In  the  lower  half  of  the 
ingot  the  elongation  is  about  20  per  cent,  for  the  different  ingots.  As 
already  explained,  the  20x24  and  25x30  ingots  had  to  be  bloomed  down 
somewhat  and  cut  in  two  before  the  rail  mill  could  take  them.  The 
two  parts  of  the  20x24  ingot  showed  a  continuity  of  results  in  the  drop 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


mi 


/5x/5I/VGOT 


4-  -heacd.  tension 


\"*~6ase  tension 


200© 


40OO 


2.00O 


4000 


DROR     TESTS 

100 Lb  Bessemer  Rails 

ARA  typeB  seotion-2,eoolbTup 

SO  ft  drop  -  3ft  supports 


zpoo  ipoo  e,ooo 

Pounds  from  Top  of  Ingot 


10,000 


Fig.  i6 — Elongation   Diagrams  with  the  Individual  Results  Plotted. 


ro2 


RAIL. 


2  ooo 


*fpoo 


6,000 


8000 


/Oraoo 


Fig. 


Pounds  jrom  Top  0/  Ingot 

17 — Average  Elongation  Diagrams  for  the  Various  Sizes  of  Ingots. 


Average   Duct i Lit y  0/  RaLL 

5 

for    aLL    sizes    of   ingots 
Bessemer   SteeL 

\\ 

\n 

6a.se  t 

'TJSIOT1 

'"'/* 

^&—— 

-head  t< 

'xston 

30 


<^20 
.0 

&  10 

8 

o 

o  20  40  6  0  <?0  loo 

Percent  of-  Uleight  from  Top    of  Ingot 

Fig.  18 — "Characteristic"  Elongation  Curves  of  ioo  lb.  A.  R.  A.  Type 

B  Section  Rails  Made  of  Bessemer  Steel  from 

Various  Sizes  of  Ingots. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE  OF  INGOT. 


70; 


tests,  but  in  the  25x30  ingot,  the  upper  end  of  the  lower  half  shows  a 
considerable  drop  in  ductility  in  both  the  head  tension  and  base  tension 
tests.     Why  this  should  be  I  am  unable  to  say. 

The    ductility   curves   of  the   various    sized    ingots    are   a   good   deal 
alike,   and   one   average   curve    for   head   tension    and    another    for    base 


zo& 


gooo  4,000  6,«©c  6>ooo 

Pounds  J™™  Top  of  Ingot 


I 'O.ooo 


Fig.  19 — Deflection   Diagrams  with  the  Individual  Results  Plotted. 


tension,  representing  distance  from  top  in  per  cent,  of  total  weight  of 
ingot,  represent  the  various  ingots  nicely.  I  show  such  curves  in 
Fig.  18,  and  these  may  be  called  the  "characteristic"  ductility  curves 
of  these  rails  made  from  Bessemer  steel.  The  point  of  most  interest 
and  importance  is  probably  the  zone  of  least  ductility,  which  occurs  at 
about   20  per    cent,    from    the   top    of    the    ingot,    and    in    this    zone    the 


704 


RAIL. 


ductility,  when  the  rail  is  tested  with  the  head  in  tension,  is  about  half 
of  what  it  is  when  tested  with  the  base  in  tension.  In  the  lower  half 
of  the  ingot  the  rail  shows  a  little  more  ductility  when  tested  with  the 
head  in  tension. 

DEFLECTION. 

The  results  of  the  drop  tests,  showing  deflection  or  permanent  set 
after  the  first  blow,  are  plotted  in  Fig.   19,  in  which  the  distance  from 


Deflection  after  First  BLocu 

Drop    tests    /OO  lb    bessemer    ra  i is  -  ARAtype  B- 
SpooLb  tup  -  20 Jt  drop  -  3ft  support s  —    Curves    rep- 
resent   average   of  /react  and    base    tension    resuLtS. 


2-M 


<ooo  ^000  6/>oo  Qpoo 

Pounds  jrom  Top  0/  Ingot 


IO.o<x 


Z-ot 


ZO  40  60  80  loo 

Percent   from  Top  0/   Ingot 

Fig.  20 — Average  Deflection  Curves. 

the  top  of  the  ingot  in  pounds  is  plotted  horizontally  and  the  deflection 
is  plotted  vertically.  It  will  be  noticed  that  the  deflection  is  greatest 
in  the  rail  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  least  at  a  distance  varying  from 
about  20  to  45  per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  and  greater  again 
in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot.  The  deflection  is  a  little  greater  all 
along  the  rail  bar  when  the  rail  is  tested  with  the  head  in  tension  than 
when  tested  with  the  base  in  tension,  although  the  average  difference 
amounts  to  only  several  hundredths  of  an  inch.  Tn  Fig.  20  I  give  curves 
showing  the  average  of  the  head  tension  and  base  tension  results  for 
each  ingot,  one  set  of  curves  on  the  basis  of  distance  from  the  top  of 
the  ingot  in  pounds,  and  the  other  set  on  the  basis  of  distance  from  the 
top  in  per  cent,  of  the  total  weight  of  the  ingot.  The  deflection  with 
head  tension  would  average  slightly  greater  than  shown,  and  with  base 
tension  slightly  less.  These  curves  indicate  that  the  zone  of  least?  de- 
flection  or   of  maximum    stiffness    under  the   drop   moves    downward?  as 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


705 


the   size   of   the   ingot   increases,   and   they   indicate   roughly   that   these 
zones  occur  at  the  following  distances  from  the  top  of  the  ingot : 

15x15  ingot 20  per  cent. 

18x18    "      25 

20x24    " 30        " 

25x30    "      40 

The  average  minimum  deflection  ranges  between  1.60  and  1.65  inches. 
The  average  maximum  deflection  of  the  15x15,  18x18  and  20x24  ingots  is 
about  1.70  inches,  and  of  the  25x30  ingot  it  is  about  1.78  inches,  except 
at  the  top  of  the  ingot  where  it  is  greater. 

NUMBER  OF  BLOWS. 
The  number  of  blows  which  was  applied  to  each  piece  of  rail  tested 
is  shown  for  convenience  of  comparison  in  table  51.     The  number  given 


Rail. 
A 


Piece 
Number 
2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 


TABLE  51 — NUMBER  OF   BLOWS. 


15X15 

Ingot. 

H.T.  B.  T. 

1     3 

4 

3     3 


18x18 

Ingot. 

H.  T.  B.  T. 

5  4 
1  4 
I     4 


20x24 

Ingot. 

H.T.  B.  T. 

4     4 

2     3 

2     3 


25x30 

Ingot. 

H.  T.  B.  T. 

5     4 

3     5 

2     2 


H 


2  and  3  3 
5  and  6  3 
8  and  9   4 

2  and  3  3 
5  and  6  4 
8  and  9 

2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 

2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 

2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 

2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 

2  and  3 
5  and  6 
8  and  9 


706 


RAIL. 


shows  the  number  of  blows  which  broke  the  rail,  except  in  a  few  cases 
where  the  rail  did  not  break.  These  results  are  plotted  in  Fig.  21  for 
more  convenient  comparison.  It  will  be  noticed  that  with  the  head  in 
tension  all  of  the  ingots  gave  one  or  more  tests  that  broke  on  the  first 
blow  from  20  ft.  With  the  base  in  tension  the  15x15  ingot  gave  three 
tests  that  broke  on  the  first  blow,  although,  as  already  noted,  these  seem 


^6 
to 
"*"*  4 

g. 

i- 

O  o 

s 

r 

4 


2 
0 

Fig. 


_.    base  tension 


2,ooo 


4,ooo 


I8*W  Ingot 


4,ooo 


DROP     TESTS 
Number  of  6iows  applied 


base  tension     /° 


\ 


-  0—0-0  -o--o 


V 


20x24.  Ingot 


head  tension 


Z,o»o 


4,ooo 


6,000 


8poo  /Or«ot 


2,Ooo  4,ooo  6,000  Bpoo  IO,ooo 

Pounds  f-rom    Top    0/  Ingot 

21 — Diagrams  of  the  Number  of  Blows  that  Broke  the  Rails  in 
the  Drop  Test. 


to  be  abnormal,  due  possibly  to  some  delays  in  rolling  or  other  unexplained 
cause.  The  18x18  and  20x24  ingots,  with  the  base  in  tension,  gave  a 
minimum  number  of  three  blows  in  any  one  test.  With  the  25x30  ingot 
ihc  minimum   was   two  blows.     The   general   appearance  of  the   various 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE    OF  INGOT. 


707 


diagrams  suggests  that  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  stands  a  decreasing 
total  height  of  drop  with  the  base  in  tension,,  as  the  size  of  the  ingot 
increases. 

ANALYSIS    OF   RAILS. 

As   already    explained,   analyses    were    made    of   samples   taken    each 
eleven   feet  along  the  rail  bar.     From  each   section  three   samples   were 


7b  />e  of/nax/'/nu/n  d/a/neter* 

Fig.  22 — Drilling  Diagram  for  Borings  for  Analysis  from  Rails. 

taken  as  shown  in  Fig.  22,  A  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head,  B  from 
the  interior  of  the  head  near  its  junction  with  the  web,  and  C  from  near 
the  edge  of  the  flange,  which  are  the  locations  recommended  by  the  Rail 
Committee  in  March,  191 1.  The  analyses  are  shown  in  tables  52  to  55, 
inclusive. 

TABLE  52 — ANALYSIS   OF  RAILS,    15x15   INGOT. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn. 

10- A- 1 

Ai 

•39 

•  135 

.029 

.065 

•94 

Bi 

•44 

•137 

•039 

.081 

•94 

Ci 

•43 

•133 

.029 

.065 

.89 

10- A -4 

Ai 

•5i 

.144 

.046 

.098 

•94 

Bi 

•56 

.146 

.061 

.119 

•97 

Ci 

•50 

•  i47 

.046 

.094 

•94 

70S 


RAIL. 


table   52 — analysis    of    rails,    15x15    ingot — Continued. 
Marked  Carbon        Sil.  Sul.  Phos.  Mn. 

10-A-7     Ai  .49  -138  046  .094  .98 


Bi 
Ci 

10-B-1  Ai 
Bi 
Ci 

10-B-4  Ai 
Bi 
Ci 

10-B-7  A 1 
Bi 
Ci 

io-C-i  Ai 
Bi 
Ci 

10-C-4  Ai 
Bi 
Ci 


•134 

•  139 

•  134 
.126 
.118 

•  i39 
.126 
.126 

.142 
.138 
.144 

.130 
.130 
•134 

•  134 
.130 
.130 


.052 
.047 

.046 
.044 
.044 

.048 
•043 
.043 

.044 
.042 
.042 

.042 
.044 
.044 

.044 
.040 
.046 


102 
094 

097 
097 
098 

098 

095 
096 

094 
.090 
092 

094 
090 
093 

093 
087 
,092 


TABLE   S3 — ANALYSES  OF   RAILS,    l8xl8   INGOT. 


Vlarked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn. 

11-A-1 

Ai 

•35 

.144 

.027 

.061 

.89 

Bi 

■56 

.148 

.056 

.117 

•97 

Ci 

.40 

.141 

.029 

.064 

•91 

11-A-4 

Ai 

•44 

.140 

•034 

.078 

.88 

Bi 

.66 

•147 

.084 

.164 

1. 00 

Ci 

•45 

.148 

•039 

.082 

.89 

11-A-7 

Ai 

•49 

•  MS 

.046 

.092 

•93 

Bi 

.64 

•143 

.078 

•154 

1. 00 

Ci 

.48 

•143 

•045 

•095 

•93 

ii-B-i 

Ai 

•49 

.138 

.044 

.096 

.92 

Bi 

•56 

•  139 

•053 

.108 

•93 

Ci 

•49 

.138 

.044 

•093 

•9i 

11-B-4 

Ai 

.48 

.136 

.044 

•093 

.92 

Bi 

•49 

.138 

.049 

.100 

•93 

Ci 

•49 

.136 

•049 

.096 

94 

INFLUENCE   OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


709 


table  53— analysis  of  rails,    18x18   ingot — Continued. 


Markec 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mr. 

11-B-7 

Ai 

•50 

134 

.046 

095 

.92 

Bi 

.48 

131 

.044 

090 

.92 

Ci 

■49 

135 

•045 

093 

•93 

ii-C-i 

Ai 

•49 

136 

.046 

095 

.92 

Bi 

•45 

131 

•045 

088 

.91 

Ci 

•49 

130 

.044 

093 

.92 

11-C-4 

Ai 

•49 

M3 

.046 

095 

•92 

Bi 

.48 

144 

•043 

085 

.92 

Ci 

•49 

139 

.044 

093 

•93 

11-C-7 

Ai 

•49 

139 

.046 

094 

.92 

Bi 

.46 

139 

.041 

083 

•91 

Ci 

•45 

136 

.044 

095 

•92 

ii-D-i 

Ai 

•50 

144 

.044 

095 

.91 

Bi 

.46 

141 

.040 

083 

.90 

Ci 

••51 

135 

.042 

092 

•9i 

11-D-4 

Ai 

•50 

147 

•045 

095 

.92 

Bi 

•47 

138 

.046 

081 

.91 

Ci 

•49 

145 

.044 

092 

.91 

11-D-7 

Ai 

.50 

133 

.048 

093 

•94 

Bi 

•47 

135 

.047 

091 

•93 

Ci 

.46 

136 

.046 

094 

•93 

TABLE   54 — ANALYSES   OF  RAILS,  20X24   INGOT. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn. 

12-A-1 

Ai 

•4i 

.131 

.029 

.063 

•94 

Bi 

.40 

•133 

.029 

.061 

.91 

Ci 

•45 

.128 

.030 

.065 

.92 

12-A-4 

Ai 

•45 

.128 

.032 

.077 

•94 

Bi 

•47 

•131 

.040 

.088 

•93 

Ci 

•42 

.127 

.029 

.069 

.91 

12-A-7 

Ai 

•47 

•133 

•043 

.087 

93 

Bi 

.64 

•137 

.067 

•135 

•99 

Ci 

.49 

•  139 

•043 

.086 

•93 

12-B-1 

Ai 

•52 

•134 

.048 

.094 

•93 

Bi 

•59 

.136 

.069 

•134 

1. 00 

Ci 

•5i 

•131 

.048 

.094 

•94 

1710 


RAIL. 


TABLE 

54 — ANA 

LYSIS 

Marked 

Carbon 

12-B-4 

Ai 

49 

Bi 

.60 

Ci 

•49 

12-B-7 

Ai 

49 

Bi 

•58 

Ci 

.48 

I2-C-I 

Ai 

52 

Bi 

•56 

Cr 

■50 

I2-C-4 

Ai 

•50 

Bi 

•53 

Ci 

50 

I2-C-7 

Ai 

•5i 

Bi 

49 

Ci 

•52 

I2-D-I 

Ai 

•50 

Bi 

.48 

Ci 

50 

12-D-4 

Ai 

47 

Bi 

.48 

Ci 

.46 

12-D-7 

A 1 

52 

Bi 

•49 

Ci 

•51 

12-E-1 

Ai 

•51 

Bi 

.48 

Ci 

•5i 

12-E-4 

Ai 

•51 

Bi 

•47 

Ci 

5i 

12-E-7 

Ai 

•5o 

Bi 

45 

Ci 

.50 

12-F-1 

A 1 

•52 

Bi 

47 

Ci 

•51 

rails,  20x24  ingot — Continued. 
Sil.  Sul. 

131  -050 

132  -065 
132     .049 


135  -048 
141  .059 

136  .048 

145  -047 

145  052 

137  -045 

144  .044 

145  .044 
147  -045 

134  048 

132  .047 

132  .046 

143  .044 

143  043 

144  .044 

134  .048 

134  .047 

135  -046 

133  044 

127  .042 

135  044 

130  .046 

128  .043 

131  .049 

134  -044 
134  039 

132  .044 

132  .044 

130  .039 
126  .043 

133  .046 

131  .040 
131  046 


'hos. 

Mn. 

.097 

•95 

.125 

•98 

.096 

•95 

.094 

•95 

.114 

•98 

.094 

•94 

•095 

•95 

.102 

•95 

•093 

•93 

.096 

•94 

.097 

•93 

■095 

•93 

.098 

•97 

•095 

•94 

.096 

.96 

.094 

•93 

.O96 

•93 

.092 

.92 

•095 

.96 

.094 

•95 

•095 

•95 

097 

•95 

O93 

•94 

•095 

96 

.097 

•95 

.089 

•92 

.096 

•95 

O95 

•93 

.084 

•91 

•093 

•95 

•094 

•95 

085 

•93 

O92 

94 

.094 

•95 

.083 

•92 

•093 

•94 

INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


711 


table  54 — 'Analysis  of  rails,  20x24  ingot — Continued. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn. 

12-F-4 

Ai 

•5i 

.130 

.044 

.092 

•93 

Bi 

•47 

.130 

.044 

.087 

.92 

Ci 

•5i 

•  131 

.047 

094 

•94 

12-F-7 

Ai 

•50 

.130 

.049 

.096 

•94 

Bi 

•5i 

.132 

•045 

.094 

.92 

Ci 

•5i 

.138 

.041 

.092 

.92 

TABLE   55 — ANALYSES    OF   RAILS,   25x30   INGOT. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn. 

13-A-1 

Ai 

•35 

•152 

.025 

•055 

.89 

Bi 

•35    ' 

•152 

.024 

.048 

.89 

Ci 

.38 

•134 

.027 

063 

.88 

13-A-4 

Ai 

■33 

.130 

.027 

•057 

■87 

Bi 

•49 

■  139 

.042 

.098 

■95 

Ci 

■37 

.130 

.029 

.063 

.88 

13-A-7 

Ai 

.41 

.126 

.029 

.065 

.88 

Bi 

•51 

•153 

.046 

.092 

•97 

Ci 

.42 

.129 

.036 

.071 

.88 

13-B-1 

Ai 

.40 

.130 

•034 

.068 

.89 

Bi 

.66 

.161 

.081 

.160 

1.04 

Ci 

.40 

.129 

.029 

.065 

.00 

Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul.     i 

Phos. 

Mn. 

13-B-4 

Ai 

•44 

.130 

.036 

.076 

•91 

Bi 

■77 

•  152 

.025 

.210 

1.06 

Ci 

•45 

•  131 

.032 

.072 

.91 

13-B-7 

Ai 

•44 

.129 

.037 

.072 

.89 

Bi 

•79 

.146 

.136 

.187 

1.08 

Ci 

•43 

.128 

.032 

.066 

.89 

13-C-l 

Ai 

•45 

.130 

.030 

.077 

•93 

Bi 

.72 

•134 

.102 

.174 

1.04 

Ci 

•45 

•  134 

■033 

•075 

.92 

13-C-4 

Ai 

•44 

.129 

•037 

.077 

•93 

Bi 

.61 

•152 

.085 

•155 

1. 00 

Ci 

•45 

•131 

.041 

.080 

•95 

I3-C-7 

Ai 

•43 

.129 

.040 

.084 

89 

Bi 

•58 

•139 

.067 

.128 

98 

Ci 

•50 

.130 

.042 

.092 

•94 

712 


RAIL. 


table  55 — analysis  of  rails,  25x30  ingot — Continued. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn 

13-D-1 

Ai 

.48 

144 

•039 

090 

92 

Bi 

•52 

135 

•045 

106 

•94 

Ci   ' 

•50 

142 

.040 

093 

.92 

13-D-4 

Ai 

•50 

130 

.048 

094 

•96 

Bi 

•57 

136 

.060 

123 

•97 

Ci 

•49 

130 

.046 

095 

•9i 

13-D-7 

Ai 

•50 

126 

.047 

096 

•94 

Bi 

•53 

144 

.057 

117 

•95 

Ci 

•51 

150 

.051 

099 

•93 

13-E-i 

Ai 

■50 

134 

.049 

IOI 

.92 

Bi 

•50 

130 

•055 

109 

•94 

Ci 

.48 

140 

•045 

094 

.91 

13-E-4 

Ai 

•49 

160 

.047 

097 

•93 

Bi 

•52 

144 

•057 

109 

.92 

Ci 

•47 

134 

.043 

093 

•9i 

13-E-7 

Ai 

•50 

138 

.048 

103 

.92 

Bi 

•52 

125 

.052 

105 

•96 

Ci 

•47 

128 

•045 

096 

•94 

13-F-l 

Ai 

•49 

148 

.048 

097 

•92 

Bi 

•47 

138 

•049 

094 

.92 

Ci 

.48 

136 

•045 

094 

•93 

13-F-4 

Ai 

•51 

134 

•053 

IOI 

•95 

Bi 

•44 

141 

•039 

087 

•93 

Ci 

•50 

128 

.049 

097 

•93 

13-F-7 

Ai 

•49 

.144 

.048 

098 

•94 

Bi 

•43 

143 

.042 

081 

•92 

Ci 

•49 

145 

.046 

095 

•93 

13-G-1 

Ai 

•47 

128 

.043 

095 

•93 

Bi 

•39 

127 

039 

075 

.89 

Ci 

.48 

.128 

.044 

095 

•94 

13-G-4 

Ai 

•49 

•135 

.040 

095 

95 

Bi 

•42 

138 

.038 

075 

•92 

Ci 

•49 

.141 

.042 

094 

-94 

13-G-7 

Ai 

•47 

i34 

•045 

092 

•94 

Bi 

•39 

140 

.038 

073 

.89 

Ci 

•50 

•134 

•045 

094 

•97 

13-H-i 

Ai 

•49 

130 

.046 

093 

•94 

Bi 

.40 

132 

•033 

074 

.88 

Ci 

•SO 

.146 

•045 

089 

.92 

INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


713 


table  55 — analysis  of  rails,  25x30  ingot — Continued. 


Marked 

Carbon 

Sil. 

Sul. 

Phos. 

Mn 

13-H-4    A 1 

.46 

•  135 

•043 

.092 

•93 

Bi 

•44 

.136 

.041 

.080 

.90 

Ci 

■49 

•134 

•045 

•005 

91 

13-H-7    Ai 

•47 

.142 

.046 

.092 

.91 

Bi 

•47 

.136 

.046 

.091 

.92 

Ci 

•SO 

.136 

•045 

.092 

.91 

In  order  to  show  the  chemistry  in  convenient  form  for  comparison,  I 
have  plotted  the  carbon  results  from  the  corner   of  the  head  and   from 
•60 


•40  £ 


20 


s*0 
o 

-0.40 
U20 


o 
20 


g-r  »«$ 


J*9^_|_ 


/Sx/S    Irtaot 

I  I 


Z.OOO 


4poo 


S.occ 


4<ooo 


^©-C^BvJ-qL 


Carbon   in  /Rails 


Interior   of    head 
near  web 


«--—  Upper  corner  of  head. 


4S7o 


eOx24    Ingot 


2.000 


4,000 


6,000 


S,ooo  /  0,000 


-80 
.60 
AO 
.20 


2,ooo  4  000  6,000  8000 

Pounds    from    To-p  0/    Ingot 

Fig.  23 — Diagrams  of  Carkon  in  Rails. 


714 


RAIL. 


the  interior  of  the  head  in  Fig.  23,  in  which  the  distance  from  the  top  of 
the  ingot  in  pounds  is  shown  horizontally  and  the  per  cent,  of  carbon  is 
shown  vertically.  In  a  general  way,  these  diagrams  show  conditions 
already  found  in  the  ingot.  The  average  carbon  in  the  heat,  as  indicated 
by  the  samples  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head  in  the  lower  end  of 
the  rail  bar,  was  .49  per  cent.  The  interior  of  the  rail  at  the  top  end  of  the 
rail  bar  shows  negative  segregation,  but  going  down  the  ingot,  it  soon 
develops  considerable  positive  segregation,  which  reaches  a  maximum  at 
about  20  per  cent,  by  weight  from  the  top.  The  lower  end  of  the  rail 
bar  again  shows  negative  segregation  in  the  interior.  The  outer  portion 
of  the  section  of  the  rail,  as  shown  by  the  samples  from  the  upper  cor- 
ner of  the  head,  shows  negative  segregation  in  the  top  end  of  the  rail  bar, 
which  gradually  becomes  less  as  we  go  downward,  until  the  average  car- 
bon content  is  reached,  which  then  remains  about  constant  for  the  rest 
of  the  bar.  The  point  at  which  the  average  carbon  is  reached  seems  in 
general  to  be  farther  down  from  the  top  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases, 
varying  from  about  15  or  20  per  cent,  to  about  35  per  cent.  I  say,  in  gen- 
eral, since  the  rail  bar  from  the  20x24  ingot  seems  to  show  less  variation 
as  regards  both  positive  and  negative  segregation  than  the  rail  bar  from 
the  18x18  ingot.  Similar  diagrams  for  phosphorus  are  shown  in  Fig.  24 
and  for  sulphur  in  Fig.  25,  and  they  show  distributions  for  these  two 
elements  similar  to  the  carbon  distribution.  The  maximum  amounts  of 
carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  found  in  the  interior  of  the  head,  with 
the  samples  taken  as  explained  and  the  percentages  of  increase  above  the 
average  in  the  heat,  are  shown  in  table  56. 


Ingot 

15x15 
18x18 
20x24 
25x30 
Ave.  in  heat 


TABLE  56 — SEGREGATION    IN    RAILS. 

Carbon — Phosphorus — 

Max.  Increase        Max.  Increase 
.56        14%  .119        27% 

.164 

•135 
.210 
.094 


.66 
.64 
•79 


35% 

3i% 

61% 


75% 

44% 

123% 


•49 


Sulphur — 

Max.  Increase 


.061 

33% 

.084 

83% 

.069 

50% 

.136 

195% 

.04: 

5 

The  concentrations  found  in  the  rails  were  not  as  great  as  found  in 
the  ingots,  but  in  the  ingots  it  will  be  remembered  that  the  maximum 
concentrations  were  found  in  the  axis,  while  the  samples  taken  from  the 
rails  were  some  distance  from  the  axis  of  the  section. 

Table  57  shows  the  minimum  amounts  of  carbon,  phosphorus  and 
sulphur  found  in  the  upper  corner  of  the  head  and  also  shows  the  per- 
centages of  decrease  below  the  average  in  the  heat. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


715 


2,ooo  ^}<ooo  6,000  Q/>oa 

Pounds     from     7ojd     of    Ingot 


f0,ooo 


Fig.  24 — Diagrams  of  Phosphorus  in  Rails. 


716 


RAIL. 


Ingot 

15x15 
18x18 
20x24 
25x30 
Ave.  in  heat 


TABLE    5/ — NEGATIVE   SEGREGATION    IN    KAILS 

Carbon —      — Phosphorus — 

Min.  Decrease       Min.  Decrease 
.39        20%  .065        31% 


•35 
.41 

•33 


29% 
16% 
33% 


.061 
.063 
•055 


36% 
33% 
43% 


.49 


.094 


Sulphur 

Min.  Decrease 
.029  37% 
.027  41% 
.029  37% 
.025  46% 
.046 


In  this  table  the  percentages  of  decrease  are  in  some  cases  less  than 
found  in  the  ingots,  and  in  other  cases  more. 


Sulphur   in    Rails 


Interior    of    head, 
near    web 
—  -•—Upper    corner  of  hea.cC 


2.ooo  *?/>oo  6000  8,000  IO,ooO 

Pounds     from    T073    0/  Ingot 

Fig.  25 — Diagrams  of  Sulphur  in  Rails. 

A  comparison  of  the  analyses  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head  and 
from  the  edge  of  the  flange  shows  that  in  the  great  majority  of  cases  the 
results  are  closely  alike,  and  it  would  seem  unnecessary  to  take  borings 
from  the  flange  except  for  some  special  purpose. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


tj: 


RAIL    ETCHINGS. 

Sections  were  cut  each  eleven  feet  along  the  rail  bars  and  etched 
with  a  concentrated  solution  of  copper  ammonium  or  copper  potassium 
chloride.  Photographs  of  the  etched  sections  are  reproduced  in  figures 
as  follows : 

15x15  Ingot — Figures  26  to  33,  inclusive. 

18x18  Ingot — Figures  34  to  45,  inclusive. 

20x24  Ingot — Figures  46  to  63,  inclusive. 

25x30  Ingot — Figures  64  to  87,  inclusive. 

It  will  be  noted  that  the  sections  from  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot 
show  streaks  and  spots  which  correspond  with  the  condition  of  spongi- 
ness  found  in  the  ingot.  There  may  also  be  a  dark  area  or  "dark  core" 
in  the  interior  of  the  section  corresponding  with  the  region  of  strong 
segregation  found  in  the  ingot.  The  sections  from  the  lower  part  of  the 
ingot  also  show  a  core,  but  of  lighter  color,  or  a  "light  core,"  which  cor- 
responds to  the  region  of  negative  segregation  in  the  ingot  found  by 
analysis.  This  light  core  shows  up  most  prominently  in  the  largest  ingot. 
The  figures  showing  the  etched  sections  from  the  smaller  ingots  do  not 
show  the  light  core  prominently,  and  in  fact  it  does  not  always  show  well 
in  the  original  etching. 

•     ;;f ! 


Fig.  26— Etched  Section  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  15x15  Ingot. 


718 


RAIL. 


Fig.  27 — Etched  Section  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  15x15  Ingot. 


Fig.  .28 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  15x15  Ingot 


INFLUENCE   OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


719 


Fig.  29 — Etched  Section  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  15x15  Ingot. 


Fig.  30 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  15x15  Ingot. 


F20 


RAIL. 


Fig.  31 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  15x15  Ingot 


Fig.  32— Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  15x15  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


721 


Fig.  33 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  15x15  Ingot 


Fig.  34 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


722 


RAIL. 


Fig.  35 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


ia| 

!* 

.<n 

JIA7 

^^^k 

Fig.  36 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT.  72:; 


Fig.  37— Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


Fig.  38-Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


724 


RAIL. 


Fig.  39 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


Fig.  40 — -Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE    OF  INGOT. 


Fig.  41 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


Fig.  42 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


r26 


RAIL. 


Fig.  43 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


Fig.  44— Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


727 


Fig.  45 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  18x18  Ingot. 


Fig.  46 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


728 


RAIL. 


Fig.  47 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  20x24  Ingot 


Fig.  48 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


729 


Fig.  49 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  50 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


730 


RAIL. 


Fig.  51 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  52 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT.  731 


Fig-  53 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  54— Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


732 


RAIL. 


Fig.  55 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  56 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


738 


Fig.  57 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  58 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


m 


RAIL. 


Fig.  59 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  60 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


Fig.  6i — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  62 — .Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


RAIL. 


Fig.  63 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  20x24  Ingot. 


Fig.  64 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


737 


Fig.  65 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  25x30  Ingot 


Fig.  66 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  A  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


738 


RAIL. 


Fig.  67 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  68 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE  OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT. 


738 


Fir,.  69 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  B  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  70 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


74o 


RAIL. 


F\r,.  y\ — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  72 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  C  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF  INGOT.  "41 


Fig.  73 — Etched  Section,  i   ft.  from   Top   End  of  D  Rail,  25x30   Ingot. 


Fig.  74 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


742 


RAIL. 


Fig.  75- — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  D  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  76 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE    OF  INGOT.  743 


Fig.  7J — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  78 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  E  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


744 


RAIL. 


Fig.  79 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  80 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE    OF  INGOT.  745 


Fig.  8i — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  F  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  82 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  G  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


746 


RAIL. 


Fig.  83 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  G  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  84 — Etched  Section.  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  G  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   SIZE   OF   INGOT. 


747 


Fig.  85 — Etched  Section,  i  ft.  from  Top  End  of  H  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


Fig.  86 — Etched  Section,  12  ft.  from  Top  End  of  H  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


748 


RAIL. 


Fig.  87 — Etched  Section,  23  ft.  from  Top  End  of  H  Rail,  25x30  Ingot. 


SUMMARY. 


1.  This  report  covers  an  investigation  to  throw  light  on  the  relation- 
ship of  the  size  of  ingots  of  Bessemer  rail  steel  to  the  segregation  of  the 
metalloids,  locations  of  pipes  and  blow  holes,  and  the  properties  of  the 
rails.  A  series  of  five  ingots  was  made  of  the  following  bottom  sizes,  all 
5  ft.  high,  namely,  12  in.  x  12  in.,  15  in.  x  15  in.,  18  in.  x  18  in.,  20  in.  x  24 
in.  and  25  in.  x  30  in.  These  were  split  open,  after  cooling  in  the  molds, 
one-half  used  to  obtain  borings  for  a  chemical  survey  of  the  ingot,  and  the 
other  half  for  etching.  Another  similar  set  of  ingots  was  rolled  into  rails 
with  only  sufficient  discard  from  the  top  of  the  bloom  to  allow  rolling 
into  rail,  and  the  entire  rail  bars  from  these  ingots  were  used  for  drop 
tests,  etchings  and  chemical  analyses,  except  that  no  rails  were  rolled 
from  the  12-in.  ingot,  as  an  attempt  to  do  so  resulted  in  a  "cobble"  on 
account  of  the  small  size  of  the  ingot.  The  15  x  15  and  18  x  18  ingots 
were  rolled  direct  into  rails  according  to  the  usual  practice  at  South 
Chicago,  but  the  20  x  24  and  25  x  30  ingots  were  too  large  for  the  rail 
mill  and  were  first  bloomed  down  to  about  14  x  14  or  16  x  16  in.  in  a  two 
high  mill,  cut  in  two,  brought  back  and  placed  into  the  rail  mill  soaking 
pits  and  then  rolled  into  rails.  In  this  there  was  a  considerable  divergence 
from  the  usual  practice. 

The  statements  and  conclusion  in  this  nummary  refer  to  Bessemer 
steel,  made  under  the  conditions  prevailing  in  these  tests,  the  object  of 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE   OF  INGOT.  749 

which  was  stated  in  the  previous  paragraph,  and  proper  care  must  be 
used  when  applying  them  to  other  material  and  other  conditions.  The 
rail  section  tested  was  the  ioo-pound  A.  R.  A.  type  B  section. 

Especial  attention  is  called  to  the  fact  that  the  investigation  of  the 
ingots  was  necessarily  made  after  they  had  been  allowed  to  become  cold ; 
a  condition  which  does  not  obtain  in  regular  rail  mill  practice,  and  one 
which  it  is  often  claimed  exaggerates  the  size  of  the  pipe  as  compared 
with  ingots  which  are  not  allowed  to  cool. 

2.  With  ingots  five  feet  high  and  varying  in  cross-section  from 
12x12  inches  to  25x30  inches,  the  "pipe"  or  shrinkage  cavity  extends  down- 
ward a  decreasing  distance  as  the  diameter  of  the  ingot  increases.  The 
variation  is  from  about  80  per  cent,  in  the  small  ingot  to  about  35  per 
cent,  in  the  largest  ingot. 

3.  The  condition  of  "sponginess"  extends  downward  about  30  per 
cent,  from  the  top  in  all  the  ingots. 

4.  The  blowholes  around  the  axes  of  the  ingots  were  slag-coated, 
while  those  close  to  the  walls  seemed  to  have  a  clean  metallic  surface 
free  from  slag. 

5.  The  chemical  survey  of  the  ingots  shows  a  concentration  or  seg- 
regation of  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur,  and  to  a  much  smaller  extent 
also  of  manganese,  in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  around  the  axis.  The 
concentration  increases  in  general  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases.  The 
increases  above  the  average  content  of  the  steel  vary  from  32  per  cent, 
in  the  12x12  ingot  to  119  per  cent,  in  the  25x30  ingot  in  carbon,  from  102 
per  cent,  to  225  per  cent,  in  phosphorus,  and  from  100  per  cent,  to  369  per 
cent,  in  sulphur. 

6.  The  top  of  the  ingot  along  the  axis  shows  a  decrease  in  the  above 
elements,  and  the  axis  also  shows  some  decrease  in  the  lower  part  of  the 
ingot.  The  region  figured  as  a  percentage  of  the  total  volume  of  the  ingot 
covered  by  this  metal  of  lower  content  of  metalloids  increases  in  general 
as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases. 

7.  In  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  the  outside  portion  or  walls  of  the 
ingot  show  negative  segregation  or  decrease  of  carbon,  phosphorus  and 
sulphur.  The  negative  segregation  is  greatest  at  the  top  and  gradually 
becomes  less  until  the  average  composition  of  the  steel  is  reached,  when 
the  walls  remain  of  about  the  average  composition  for  the  rest  of  the 
distance  to  the  bottom  of  the  ingot.  The  greatest  decrease  is,  roughly, 
about  25  per  cent,  in  carbon  for  all  the  ingots.  The  greatest  decrease  in 
phosphorus  ranged  from  32  to  45  per  cent.,  and  in  sulphur  from  43  to  63 
per  cent.,  showing  a  tendency  to  increase  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases. 
The  distance  that  the  negative  segregation  in  the  wall  extends  downward 
from  the  top  of  the  ingot  increases  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases, 
ranging  from  about  30  per  cent,  to  about  50  per  cent. 

8.  Drop  tests  were  made  of  the  complete  rail  bars  from  15x15,  18x18, 
20x24  and  25x30-inch  ingots.  The  ductility  of  the  material  was  deter- 
mined by  putting  gage  marks  one  inch  apart  over  a  space  of  six  inches 
on  the  part  in  tension,   and  the  per  cent,  of  stretch  in  the  inch  which 


W  RAIL. 

stretched  most  at  failure  in  the  drop  machine,  is  taken  as  the  measure 
of  ductility.  Both  with  the  head  in  tension  and  with  the  base  in  tension, 
the  rail  bar  at  first  decreases  in  ductility  as  we  go  down  the  ingot,  until 
the  minimum  ductility  is  reached  at  about  20  per  cent,  by  weight  from  the 
top  of  the  ingot  for  all  sizes  of  ingots.  Then  the  ductility  again  increases 
until  the  middle  of  the  ingot  is  reached,  when  the  ductility  remains  about 
constant  for  the  rest  of  the  bar.  With  the  head  in  tension  the  minimum 
ductility  is  about  6  per  cent,  elongation,  and  with  the  base  in  tensiop 
about  12  per  cent.  In  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot  the  rail  shows  more 
ductility  with  the  head  in  tension  than  with  the  base,  averaging  about 
23  per  cent,  elongation  with  the  head  in  tension,  and  about  19  per  cent, 
with  the  base  in  tension.  These  are  average  results,  applying  to  all  sizes 
of  ingots. 

9.  The  deflection  or  permanent  set  in  the  drop  test  was  measured 
after  the  first  blow  from  a  height  of  20  ft.  of  a  tup  of  2,000  lbs.  and  with 
a  span  of  supports  of  3  ft.  The  deflection  is  greatest  at  the  top  end  of 
the  rail  bar  and  gradually  becomes  less  as  we  go  down  the  ingot,  until 
a  minimum  deflection  is  reached  at  distance  varying  from  about  20  per 
cent,  to  40  per  cent,  from  the  top.  That  is,  the  rail  bar  is  stiffest  at  about 
this  distance  from  the  top.  The  zone  of  maximum  stiffness  moves  down- 
ward as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases,  20  per  cent,  applying  to  the  15x15 
ingot  and  40  per  cent,  to  the  25x30  ingot.  The  minimum  deflection  is, 
roughly,  the  same  for  all  the  ingots,  but  the  maximum  seems  to  increase 
in  general  with  the  size  of  the  ingot.  Passing  the  zone  of  maximum  stiff- 
ness, the  deflection  again  increases,  but  does  not  become  as  great  as 
in  the  extreme  top  end.  The  deflection  with  the  head  in  tension  is  slightly 
greater  than  with  the  base  in  tension. 

10.  The  zone  of  minimum  ductility  corresponds  roughly  with  the 
region  of  greatest  interior  segregation,  and  the  zone  of  maximum  stiffness 
corresponds  roughly  with  the  region  where  negative  segregation  in  the 
walls  of  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  ceases. 

11.  In  the  zone  of  minimum  ductility  all  the  rail  bars  failed  under 
one  blow  of  the  tup  with  the  head  in  tension,  while  in  the  more  ductile 
regions  the  rail  may  stand  four  or  five  blows  with  the  head  in  tension. 
With  the  base  in  tension  in  the  ductile  regions  the  rail  may  stand  four 
or  five  blows  with  all  the  rail  bars.  In  the  zone  of  least  ductility  and 
with  the  base  in  tension  the  number  of  blows  necessary  to  break  the  rail 
becomes  less  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increases,  the  number  of  blows 
varying  from  two  to  three  or  four. 

12.  Analyses  of  samples  from  the  finished  rail  bar  indicate  that  the 
distribution  of  the  elements  is  about  the  same  as  in  the  ingot. 

13.  The  carbon,  phosphorus,  sulphur  and  manganese  in  general  seg- 
regate together ;  that  is,  they  collect  into  the  same  regions,  although  the 
percentages  of  concentration  differ. 

14.  The  samples  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head  and  from  the 
edge  of  the  flange  show  practically  the  same  composition  in  almost  all 
cases. 


INFLUENCE  OF  SIZE  OF  INGOT.  751 

15.  Etchings  of  sections  of  rail  from  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot 
show  streaks  and  spots  which  correspond  to  the  region  of  sponginess 
in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot.  Etchings  of  rail  sections  from  the  upper 
part  of  the  ingot  may  also  show  a  "dark  core"  corresponding  to  the  region 
of  strong  segregation  found  in  the  ingot,  and  from  the  lower  part  of  the 
ingot  may  show  a  "light  core"  corresponding  to  the  region  of  negative 
segregation. 

16.  In  conclusion,  I  wish  to  again  acknowledge  the  prompt  and  effi- 
cient work  done  by  the  Metallurgical,  Chemical  and  other  departments  of 
the  South  Works  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company  in  carrying  out  this 
investigation. 


Appendix    D. 

*TESTS    OF  RAIL    STEEL   INGOTS  AND   DERIVATIVE 
SHAPES   MADE  AT  WATERTOWN  ARSENAL. 

DIGEST    AND    ANALYSIS. 

By 

M.  H.  Wickhorst,  Engineer  of  Tests,  Rail  Committee. 

This  report  is  intended  primarily  as  a  digest  and  analysis  of  the 
investigation  of  rail  steel  ingots  and  derivative  shapes  made  at  Water- 
town  Arsenal,  Mass.,  under  the  direction  of  James  E.  Howard,  and 
shown  in  "Tests  of  Metals,  etc."  for  1909.  Its  main  purpose  is  to  de- 
termine, if  possible,  what  conclusions  may  be  drawn  from  the  results 
of  the  tests. 

The  general  method  of  the  work  is  explained  on  page  5  of  "Tests 
of  Metals,"  as  quoted  below:  (Unless  otherwise  stated,  page  numbers 
hereafter  refer  to  "Tests  of  Metals,"  1909.)  "Beginning  with  the  ingot. 
the  structural  state  of  the  metal  was  examined  by  taking  cross  sec- 
tions and  longitudinal  sections.  This  method  was  carried  through  the 
various  successive  derivative  shapes,  and  the  results  obtained  are  shown 
in  the  large  number  of  illustrations  which  form  the  body  of  the  report. 
The  illustrations  are  so  arranged  as  to  show  the  progressive  changes 
in  the  character  of  the  metal  from  its  initial  state  in  the  ingot  to  its 
final  condition  in  the  finished  product.  Tensile  test  bars  were  taken  at 
successive  stages  of  the  rolling,  from  the  blooming  passes  to  the  rail 
mill." 

The  greater  part  of  the  work  was  devoted  to  Bessemer  rail  steel, 
five  acid  Bessemer  heats  being  made  for  this  series  of  tests,  each  heat 
furnishing  six  ingots  about  19^x20^2  in.  at  the  bottom  and  about  5  ft. 
high.  The  schedule  of  tests  and  operations  is  shown  on  page  14  and  is 
herewith  given  as  table  1 : 

CAVITIES  IN  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 

The  Report  contains  a  great  many  interesting  and  very  well  executed 
illustrations  of  longitudinal  and  transverse  sections  of  ingots  and  shapes, 
both  plain  and  etched,  and  they  throw  considerable  light  on  the  matter 
of  cavities,  blow  holes  and  general  sponginess  in  the  ingot  and  succeed- 
ing rolled  shapes.  A  number  of  the  longitudinal  sections  of  ingots  and 
blooms  are  reproduced  herewith  as  Figs.  1  to  9,  inclusive.     Fig.  1  shows 


♦Report  No.  20,   September,  1911. 

753 


754 


RAIL. 


Table  i — Schedule  of  Bessemer  Ingots  and  Their  Treatment, 
eeat  NO.  1. 


Distin- 
guishing 
marks. 

Treatment  of  ingot. 

Time  in  furnace. 

Remarks. 

Hours. 

Min- 
utes. 

1A 

IB 

1C 

ID 
IE 

IF 

Cooled  in  vertical  position  without 

soaking. 
Soaked  and  then,  cooled  in  vertical 

position. 
Charged  hot  and  soaked  as  usual . . . 

do 

Rolled  into  blooms  and  then  cut 

in  center  at  shears. 
Rolled  into  75-pound  section  rails. 
Rollefl  into  blooms,  then  cut  in 

center  at  shears. 

Rolled  into  75-pound  section  rails. 

1 
1 

1 

6 

6 

30 

30 

30 
00 

00 

Laid  on  side  to  cool  immediately 
after   stripping,    head    side   up; 
reheated. 

do 

HEAT  NO.  2. 


2  A 
2B 
2C 

2D 

2E 


Cooled  in  vertical  position  without 

soaking. 
Soaked  and  then  cooled  in  vertical 

position. 
Cnarged  hot  and  soaked  as  usual . . . 

.do.. 


Laid  on  side  to  cool  immediately 
after  stripping,  head  side  up; 
reheated. 

....do 


1 

30 

1 

30 

1 

9 

30- 
00 

9 

00 

Rolled  into  blooms  and  then  cut 

in  center  at  shears. 
Rolled  into  75-pound  section  rails. 
Rolled  into  blooms,  then  cut  in 

center  at  shears. 

Rolled  into  75-pound  section  rails. 


HEAT  NO.  3. 


3A 
3B 

3C 

:!D 
RE 


Cooled  in  vertical  position  without 

soaking. 
Soaked  and  then  cooled  in  vertical 

position. 
Charged  hot  and  soaked  as  usual . . 

...do 


Laid  on  side  to  cool  immediately 
after  stripping,  web  side  up;  re- 
heated. 

....do 


1 

30 

1 

30 

1 

9 

30 
00 

9 

00 

Rolled  into  blooms  and  then  cut 

in  center  at  shears. 
Rolled  into  75-pound  section  rails. 
Rolled  into  blooms,  then  cut  in 

center  at  shears. 

Rolled  into75-po'und  section  rails. 


HEAT  NO.  4. 


4  A 
4B 

4C 

4D 
4E 


Charged  hot  and  soaked  as  usual . . 
do 


.do. 
.do 

.do. 


1 

30 

1 

40 

1 

2 
2 

50 
00 
10 

2 

20 

Rolled  through  third  roughing 

pass. 
Rolled   through   filth   roughing 

pass. 
Rolled  through,  squabbing  pass. 
Rolled  through  first  forming  pass. 
Rolled  through  second  forming 

pass. 
Rolled  through  finishing  pass. 


HEAT  NO.  5. 


5  A 

&B 
5C 

5D 
5K 
5F 


Charged  hot  and  soaked  as  usual . . . 

.do 

do 

Cooied  in  vertical  position  jreheated 

...  .do 

do 


1 

30 

1 

30 

1 

30 

8 

00 

8, 

00 

8 

00 

Rolled  3  passes  in  bloom  mill. 
Rolled  6  passes  in  bloom  mill. 
Rolled  9  passes  in  bloom  mill. 
Rolled  3  passes'  in  bloom  mill. 
Rolled  6  passes  in  bloom  mill. 
Rolled  9  passes  in  bloom  mill. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  755 

a  longitudinal  section  one  inch  from  the  axis  of  an  ingot  that  was 
cooled  in  a  vertical  position  without  soaking,  and  Fig.  2  shows  an  axial 
longitudinal  section  of  a  similar  ingot  which  was  first  soaked  for  il/> 
hours'  and  then  cooled  in  a  vertical  position.  For  the  purpose  of  com- 
paring the  interior  cavities  in  the  two  treatments  of  the  ingot,  the  com- 
parison is  best  made  with  axial  longitudinal  sections,  but  unfortunately 
such  a  section  is  not  shown  for  the  first  ingot,  and  Fig.  3  is  given,  show- 
ing a  longitudinal  section  one  inch  from  the  axis  of  the  second  ingot. 
A  study  of  these  three  figures  shows  that  the  central  ''sponginess"  or 
"honeycomb"  extends  downward  to  about  the  middle  in  both  ingots,  al- 
though most  of  it  is  confined  to  the  upper  third.  The  difference  between 
the  two  is  not  great,  but  the  central  sponginess  seems  to  have  been 
aggravated,  if  anything,  by  the  soaking  given  the  second  ingot  before 
final  cooling.  The  sponginess  in  the  walls  of  the  direct-cooled  ingot 
extend  downward  about  25  per  cent,  from  the  top,  and  in  the  soaked  ingot 
it  extends  downward  a  somewhat  greater  distance,  or  about  30  per  cent. 
It  should  also  be  stated  that  the  direct-cooled  ingot  showed  a  large 
transverse  crack  about  the  middle,  covering  almost  the  entire  cross 
section  of  the  ingot. 

Next  are  given  three  illustrations  of  longitudinal  axial  sections  of 
blooms  at  different  stages  of  reduction  from  ingots  which  were  charged 
hot  and  rolled  after  soaking  11/,  hours.  Fig.  4  shows  -an  axial  section 
of  a  bloom  after  the  third  pass,  reduced  to  18.3x18.6  in.  from  about 
19^x20^  in.  The  central  sponginess  extends  down  to  about  the  middle 
of  the  bloom  with  most  of  it  contained  in  the  upper  third  and  the 
peripheral  sponginess  extends  downward  about  25  or  30  per  cent.  Fig. 
5  shows  a  section  of  a  similar  ingot  after  six  passes,  bloomed  to  12.5x19.3 
in.,  and  Fig.  6  shows  one  after  nine  passes  bloomed  to  11.7x12.7  in.  or  a 
reduction  to  about  one-third  of  the  original  cross-sectional  area.  Here 
again  the  central  sponginess  extends  down  to  about  the  middle  of  the 
bloom  with  most  of  it  in  the  upper  third  of  the  bloom,  and  the  cavities 
are  seen  to  have  been  not  closed  up  by  a  two-thirds  reduction.  The  small 
peripheral  holes  seem  to  have  been  largely  closed  up  after  the  sixth 
pass  or  about  one-half  reduction,  and  after  the  ninth  pass  do  not  show 
in  the  photograph  of  the  planed  surface.  The  reproductions  of  etched 
sections,   however,  given  in  the  Report,  show  them   distinctly. 

The  next  three  illustrations,  Figs.  7,  8  and  9,  show  axial  longitudinal 
sections  of  blooms  at  different  stages  of  reduction,  of  ingots  that  had 
been  allowed  to  cool  in  a  vertical  position  and  then  put  in  the  furnace 
for  eight  hours.  Fig.  7  shows  a  bloom  after  the  third  pass,  Fig.  8  shows 
one  after  the  sixth  pass,  and  Fig.  9  shows  one  after  the  ninth  pass.  The 
same  remarks  apply  to  these  blooms  that  have  been  made  regarding  the 
previous  ones,  except  that  the  cavities  in  the  upper  third  of  the  bloom 
compose  a  somewhat  smaller  part  of  the  volume  of  the  material  than  in 
the  blooms  made  from  ingots  which  were  at  once  placed  in  the  soaking 
pit.  This  corresponds  to  what  was  found  on  examination  of  the  ingots 
before  any  work  of  rolling  was   done  on  them. 


"5fi 


RAIL. 


Fig.  i— Ingot  i  A,  Cooled  in  Ver- 
tical Position  Without  Soak- 
ing. Longitudinal  Section  i 
In.  from  Axis. 


pIG  3— Ingot  i  B,  Soaked  and 
Cooled  in  Vertical  Position. 
Longitudinal  Section  i  In.  from 
Axis. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  757 


Fig.  2 — Ingot  i  B,  Soaked  and 
Cooled  in  Vertical  Position. 
Axial  Longitudinal  Section. 


Fig.  4 — Bloom  After  3rd  Pass 
18.3  x  18.6  In.  from  Ingot  5  A, 
Charged  Hot  and  Soaked  as 
Usual.  Axial  Longitudinal 
Section. 


758 


RAIL 


Fig    s-Bloom  After  6th  Pass  12.5  x  19.3  ]?■  from  Ingot  5  B.     Charged 

Hot  and  Soaked  as  Usual.     Axial  Longitudinal  Section 

of  Small  Diameter. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


759 


Fig.  6 — Bloom  After  o/th  Pass, 
11.7x127  In.  from  Ingot  5  C. 
Charged  Hot  and  Soaked  as 
Usual.  One  Surface  on  Axial 
Plane  and  Other  i  In.  from 
Axis. 


he.  7 — -Bloom  After  3rd  Pass, 
18.3  In.  Sq.  from  Ingot  5  D, 
Cooled  in  Vertical  Position  ane 
Then  Put  in  Furnace  for  i. 
Hrs.  Axial  Longitudinal  Sec- 
tion. 


760 


RAIL. 


Fig.  8 — Bloom  After  6th  Pass, 
12.4  x  19.4  In.  from  Ingot  5  E, 
Cooled  in  Vertical  Position  and 
Then  Put  in  Furnace  for  8 
Hrs.  Axial  Longitudinal  Sec- 
tion. 


Fig.  9 — Bloom  After  9th  Pass, 
11.3x12.7  In.  from  Ingot  5  F, 
Cooled  in  Vertical  Position 
and  Then  Put  in  Furnace  for 
8  Hrs.  Axial  Longitudinal 
Section  of  Upper  Half  of  Bloom. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


761 


The  above  discussion  concerning  ingots  and  blooms  indicates :  First, 
that  the  upper  third  of  the  ingot  is  very  spongy;  second,  that  the  cavities 
compose  a  little  larger  part  of  the  volume  of  the  material,  both  of  the 
ingot  and  of  the  bloom,  where  the  ingot  is  soaked  without  first  cooling 
down;  third,  that  the  cavities  are  distributed  in  the  bloom  about  as  they 
were  in  the  ingot  from  which  it  was  rolled. 

Beyond  the  bloom  the  interior  of  the  shapes  is  represented  mostly 
by  etched  cross  sections  and  they  show  that  the  larger  cavities  persist 
well  toward  the  finished  rail.  The  smaller  cavities  seem  not  to  show 
directly  in  the  plain  surfaces  of  the  much-reduced  sections,  but  the  etched 
sections  show  spots  and  streaks  corresponding  to  the  cavities  in  the  ingot 
and  bloom,  although  the  spots  and  streaks  seem  to  be  more  numerous 
than  the  cavities  shown  by  the  cross  sections  of  the  ingot  and  bloom. 


CARBON  IN  BLOOMS. 

Carbon  determinations  by  color  are  shown  in  the  Report,  on  two  axial 
longitudinal  sections  of  blooms,  one  after  the  sixth  blooming  pass  and  the 
other  after  the  ninth  blooming  pass,  the  ingots  having  been  charged  hot 


-7b  70 


IO  20  30 

Location  jrom  Top  oj    BLoom 

Fig.    10 — Carbon    in    Blooms. 


^0  ~L                   50 
Bottom »- 


and  soaked  as  usual.  From  each  bloom  samples  were  taken  from  twelve 
longitudinal  rows  of  holes.  The  holes  in  each  row  were  spaced  apart 
about  two  per  cent,  of  the  length  of  the  bloom  and  were  numbered,  be- 
ginning with  one  at  the  top  end  of  the  bloom.     At  any  given  distance 


762  RAIL. 

from  the  top  end  of  the  bloom,  the  extreme  differences  of  carbon  in 
the  cross  section  are  generally  shown  by  the  samples  at  the  axis  and 
in  the  walls  of  the  bloom,  as  shown  by  a  study  of  the  results,  following 
page  93  for  the  bloom  from  ingot  5B  after  the  sixth  blooming  pass,  and 
following  page  99  for  the  bloom  from  ingot  5C  after  the  ninth  blooming 
pass.  In  order  to  show  the  variations  of  composition  throughout  the 
bloom,  I  have  plotted  the  carbon  for  two  of  the  rows  of  samples  of 
each  bloom,  row  G  representing  the  axis  of  the  bloom  and  row  L  repre- 
senting the  wall,  as  shown  in  Fig.  10  herewith.  The  per  cent,  of  carbon 
is  plotted  vertically,  and  the  number  of  the  hole  from  the  top  end  of 
the  bloom  is  plotted  horizontally.  Other  work  has  indicated  that  the 
samples  from  the  wall  of  an  ingot  below  the  middle  represent  fairly 
closely  the  average  steel  of  the  ingot,  and  assuming  this  to  hold  with 
the  present  blooms,  the  average  carbon  in  these  blooms  was  about  .50 
per  cent. 

At  the  top  end  of  the  bloom  the  axis  shows  carbon  below  the  average 
or  negative  segregation,  reaching  a  minimum  at  about  6  or  8  per  cent, 
from  the  top,  but  the  carbon  soon  increases  and  shows  considerable 
positive  segregation,  reaching  a  maximum  at  about  24  per  cent,  from  the 
top  end  of  the  bloom  from  ingot  5B,  and  at  about  22  per  cent,  in  the 
bloom  from  ingot  5C.  Toward  the  middle  of  the  bloom,  the  carbon  at 
the  axis  again  gets  down  to  about  the  average,  and  in  the  lower  quarter 
again  shows  some  negative  segregation,  coming  up  to  about  normal  at 
the  bottom.  The  negative  segregation  in  the  lower  quarter  is  well  shown 
in  bloom  5C,  but  through  only  a  small  percentage  of  the  length  in  bloom 
5B. 

The  walls  of  the  upper  part  of  the  bloom  show  negative  segrega- 
tion of  carbon,  which  rises  until  the  average  carbon  content  of  the  bloom 
is  reached  and  it  then  in  general  remains  about  the  average  for  the 
rest  of  the  distance  down  the  bloom.  Successive  samples  from  the 
wall  in  the  upper  part  of  the  bloom  show  considerable  variations  in  car- 
bon, but  the  average  content  is  reached  at  about  25  per  cent,  down  from 
the  top  end  in  bloom  5B,  and  about  35  per  cent,  down  in  bloom  5C. 

The  maximum  and  minimum  carbon  found  in  these  blooms  is  shown 
in  table  2  herewith. 

TABLE    2 — MAXIMUM    AND    MINIMUM    CARBON. 

Bloom  sB.  Bloom  5C. 

Axis,  maximum   85  .77 

Axis,   increase    70%  54% 

Walls,  minimum    34  -37 

Walls,  decrease 32%  26% 

TENSILE  TESTS. 

Tensile  tests  were  made  of  specimens  taken  at  various  stages  from 
the  ingot  to  the  finished  rail,  and  the  results  are  interesting  as  having 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  763 


60: 


Cl 


0 


N 


M 


EOU-UOOOQ 


'5- 


3'. 


Fig.   11 — Locations  of  Tensile  Specimens  from  Longitudinal  Slice  of 
Ingot  iA  Passing  Through  Axis. 


Fig.    12 — Locations   of   Longitudinal   Tensile   Specimens    from    Upper 
Side  of  Bloom,  iE. 


•  u;     13 — Locations  of  Longitudinal  Tensile  Specimens  from    Section 
After  Third  Roughing  Pass,  4A. 


[';•! 


Rail. 


Frr,.   14 — Locations  of  Longitudinal  Tensile   Specimens  from    S&tihx 
After  Fifth  Roughing  Pass,  4B. 


Fig.   15 — Locations  of  Longitudinal  Tensile  Specimens  from   Section 
After  Squabbing  Pass,  4C. 


Fig.    16 — Locations  of  Tensile   Specimens   from    Section   After   First 
Forming  Pass,  4D- 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  T>>~ 

a  bearing  on  the  question  of  the  amount  of  work  or  reduction  necessary 
in  rolling  to  develop  the  full  physical  qualities  of  the  steel.  In  table  3 
I  give  a  list  of  the  illustrations  which  are  herewith  reproduced,  show- 
ing how  the  tensile  test  specimens  were  taken  from  the  different  shapes. 
The  specimens  as  tested  were  .798  diameter,  which  equals  a  sectional  area 
of  .50  sq.  in.,  and  the  gage  length  was  10  in. 

TABLE   3 — ILLUSTRATIONS    OF   LOCATIONS    OF   TENSILE   SPECIMENS. 

Fig.  Number  From  page  of 

Pass.                                     of  this  Report.  Tests  of  Metals. 

Ingot    11  65 

Bloom    12  in 

Third  roughing 13  169 

Fifth  roughing  14  241 

Squabbing    15  291 

First  forming   16  335 

The  areas  of  the  various  passes  represented  by  tensile  tests  are 
shown  in  table  4. 

TABLE  4— AREAS  AT  VARIOUS  PASSES. 

Area, 
Pass.  sq.  in. 

Ingot,  top,  18x19  342 

Ingot,  5  per  cent,  from  top 345 

Ingot,  25  per  cent,  from  top 357 

Ingot,  50  per  cent,  from  top 371 

Ingot,  90  per  cent,  from  top 393 

Ingot,   bottom,    19.5x20.5 400 

Bloom,  7.65  in.  x  7.8  in 59-7 

Third  roughing  pass    32.2 

Fifth  roughing  pass    24 . 3 

Squabbing   pass    178 

First  forming  pass 14- l 

Second  forming  pass   10.8 

Finished  rail,  75  lb 7-4 

In  order  to  show  up  more  conveniently  than  shown  by  the  tables, 
the  relation  between  the  distance  from  the  top  end  of  the  shape  and  the 
tensile  properties,  I  have  plotted  the  tensile  strength  and  elongation  for 
the  various  passes,  of  metal  representing  the  axis  of  the  section,  and 
also  the  exterior  of  the  section,  showing  the  distance  from  the  top  end 
of  the  shape  in  per  cent.,  horizontally,  and  the  tensile  strength  and 
elongation  vertically.  The  various  tables  of  tensile  results  given  in 
Tests  of  Metals,  which  I  have  drawn  from  for  these  diagrams,  are  shown 
in  table  5  herewith. 


7©6 


RAIL. 


TABLE    5- 


TENSILE    TESTS. 

Fig.  Number 
of  this  Report. 
•• 17 


Pass. 

Ingot    

Bloom    18 

Third  roughing  pass  19 

Fifth  roughing  pass   20 

Squabbing  pass  2  [ 

First  forming  pass    22 

Second  forming  pass 23 

Rail    24 


From  page  of 
Tests  of  Metals. 
82 
152 
232 
282 
327 
368 
416 
583 


These  various  tests  are  all  from  heat  No.  4,  except  those  on  the 
ingot,  which  was  ingot  A  of  heat  1,  and  those  on  the  bloom,  which  were 
made  from  ingot  iE.  The  interior  metal  is  represented  in  the  diagrams 
in  the  shapes  from  the  third  roughing  to  the  first  forming  pass,  inclusive, 


JJj  0,50,000 

RNj2b,ooo 

20 

IA3 

Side   oj-   INGOT 

"£  ft:  fc 

Cr  0/  "x  10 

Si     "*  0 

2 

6 

A 

0 

6 

0 

8 

0 

100 

Percent   /row    Top  0/    /ngot 

Fig.  17 — Tensile  Tests  from  Side  of  Ingot. 

and  the  results  used  for  plotting  are  of  the  test  pieces  taken  from  the 
center  of  the  section  or  the  web.  The  test  pieces  were  almost  .8  in. 
in  diameter,  and  in  the  shapes  of  large  sectional  area  represent  fairly 
well  only  the  axial  metal,  but  in  the  smaller  shapes  considerable  of  the 
exterior  metal  is  also  included.  The  exterior  metal,  or  what  was  the 
wall  of  the  ingot,  is  represented  in  the  diagrams  in  the  shapes  from 
the  ingot  to  the  first  forming  pass,  inclusive.  In  the  ingot  the  samples 
were  taken  from  the  middle  of  the  side,  but  in  the  other  shapes  the 
samples  were  taken  from  the  upper  corners,  that  is,  the  corners  which 
would  later  make  the  upper  corners  of  the  head,  and  for  the  diagrams 
I   have  used  the  average   of  the   two  upper  corner   results.     The  bloom 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


7»M 


was  not  a  normal  one,  as  it  had  been  placed  on  its  side  to  cool  im- 
mediately after  stripping,  but  it  is  entirely  probable  that  the  corners  were 
set  when  this  was  done  and  probably  the  results  may  be  used  along  with 
the  others  for  the  present  comparison.  I  could  not,  however,  use  the 
interior  results  from  this  bloom.  The  diagrams  of  the  second  forming 
and  the  finishing  passes  show  results  from  the  center  of  the  head,  which 
would  represent  metal  originally  between  the  axis  and  the  wall  of  the 
ingot,  although  the  results  can  probably  be  taken  as  approximating  the 
axial  metal.  On  the  diagrams  showing  the  second  forming  pass,  I  have 
also  shown  the  results  from  the  base  as  an  interesting  comparison. 

Considering  now  the  various  diagrams,  Figs.  17  to  24,  inclusive,  it 
will  be  noticed  that  the  metal  of  the  ingot  is  fragile,  having  a  low  tensile 
strength  (below  50,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.),  and  but  little  stretch.  Passing 
on  to  the  bloom,  Fig.  18,  where  the  metal  has  been  reduced  from  about 
400  sq.  in.  at  the  bottom  of  the  ingot  to  about  60  sq.  in.  in  the  bloom, 
it  will  be  noticed  that  the  metal  at  the  corners  of  the  bloom  has  acquired 


100,0 


"k>$  75,ooo 
* 

£  1.50,000 


(0"O  25,ooo 

20 

I  IS" 

S      "-  0 


IE 

Upper    Corners  0+  BLOOM 

> 

2 

0 

4 

0 

a 

0 

8 

0 

100 

Percent  /rom    Top    £rtcL   of  Shape 

Fig.  18 — Tensile  Tests  from  Corners  of  Bloom. 


a  tensile  strength  of  about  110,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  and  an  elongation 
of  about  14  per  cent,  in  10  inches,  except  the  sample  from  the  top  end 
of  the  bloom,  which  showed  weak  and  brittle.  Unfortunately,  we  have 
no  results  of  the  interior  metal  in  the  normal  bloom,  but  the  results  seem 
to  show  that  the  exterior  metal  acquires  almost  its  full  physical  prop- 
erties in  its  reduction  to  the  bloom. 

The  tensile  strength  and  elongation  curves  of  the  third  roughing 
pass,  Fig.  19,  again  show  good  physical  properties  of  the  metal  from 
the  upper  corners  of  the  head,  except  at  the  upper  end  of  the  shape, 
but  the  axial   metal    shows   low    strength    and   low   elongation,   except   in 


:68 


RAIL. 


the  lower  quarter  of  the  shape,  where  fair  physical  properties  are  shown. 
It  is  also  interesting  to  note  that  the  top  end  of  the  shape  also  shows 
fair  properties  at  the  axis.     The  curves  of  the  fifth  roughing  pass,  Fig. 

lOO.ooo. , ■  <D 


^£75/>oo 

fc-- 

8j£ 

<S<0 

^  l^50ooo 

a 

„   R. 

0) 

•v)  « 

£-025,ooo 

fc 

£ 

20 

t: 

.o+i    R 

&£Q'° 

tfck  *^ 

s«  ~. 

Oft.    R 

ThLrd  Roug h img  Pass 

• Center-    of     section 

o l/pper   corners  of  head. 


20  40  60  80  IOC 

Percent  from   Tap  End  oj  Shape 
Fig.    19 — Tensile  Tests  from   Third  Roughing   Pass. 

20,  show  results  similar  to  those  just  described,  but  there  is  considerable 

increase  in  the  elongation  where  it  was  low  before.     The  tensile  strength 

of   the    exterior   metal    also   shows   some   increase   in  the   upper    quarter 

1 00,ooo 


Ch  £75,000 
Si 
<0    50,ooo 

OJ     ^N 

'*•  *>  2  5ooo 


20 
Si       -  0 


Fifth   Roughing  Pass 

• Center-    of     Sect  con 

o— . —  Upper   corners  0/  head 


20  40  60  80 

Percent    from   Top  End  of  Shape 


Fig.    20 — Tensile   Tests   from    Fifth    Roughing    Pass. 

of  the  shape,  but  the  tensile  strength  of  the  axial  metal  has  decreased 
in  the  region  between  20  per  cent,   and  40  per  cent,   from  the  top   end 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


769 


of  the  shape.  It  is  again  interesting  to  note  that  the  top  end  shows 
fair  physical  properties,  this  time  across  the  whole  section.  In  the 
squabbing  pass,  Fig.  21,  there  is  considerable  improvement  of  the  tensile 

!00,«06  , ^_    -"- P— 0— ■  — T-       g-1 — °~ "" T    ■  1 1*1 


*»k  50,000 


00  Q, 
4) 

It 


ScfuabbcTig     Pass 

*         Center    of      Section 

o Upper    corners  of  head 


20 

It-S 

•s  *  * 
•«*         o_ 

2  0  40  60  80 

Percent    from     Top   End.     of    Shape 

Fig.  21 — Tensile  Tests  from  Squabbing  Pass. 

strength   of  the  axial  metal,   but  a  drop   in  the   elongation   of  this  meta 
in  the  region  between  20  and  60  per  cent,  from  the  top   end. 

The   curves  of  the  first  forming  pass,   with   an  area  of   14. 1    sq.   in. 


100,000 


W*75,ooo 

25  1^50,000 


* 


ft 


■o     '*** 


10 


First  Forming  Pass 

• Center     of    section 

o Upper    corners  of  head 


4D 


20  40  60  80 

Percent  from  Top  End   0+  Shape 
Fig.  22 — Tensile  Tests  from  First  Forming  Pass. 

Fig.  22,  are  particularly  interesting  and  should  be  studied  closely,  as  we 
seem  here  to  have  developed  almost  the   full   physical  properties  of  both 


770 


RAIL. 


the  exterior  and  interior  metal.  The  tensile  strength  of  the  metal  at 
the  upper  corners  of  the  head  is  seen  to  first  go  up  and  then  remain 
roughly  even  for  the  rest  of  the  length  of  the  bar.  The  strength  of 
the  interior  metal  starts  at  about  95,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  increases  until 
it  reaches  a  maximum  at  about  25  or  30  per  cent.,  of  about  116,000 
lbs.,  then  decreases  again  until  a  minimum  is  reached  at  about  80  per  cent., 
of  about  99,000  lbs.,  and  then  increases  again  to  about  107,000  near  the 
bottom  end  of  the  bar.  These  strengths  of  both  the  exterior  and  interior 
metal  follow  closely  the  distribution  we  have  already  found  of  the  carbon 
in  the  bloom.  The  strength  curves  of  Fig.  22  and  the  carbon  curves  of 
Fig.  10  have  a  similarity  that  is  rather  interesting.     The  ductility  in  the 


/  00,000 


t*   ft 


$75.< 


ft  K. 


k50,< 


Vi    Oj 

r>  O25,ooo 
ft^ 


20 

J*  ft  .K 

B   Op. 

p    Q)  ■■•> 

O    R   R 

«*i  0 


10 


jfi. 

•* 

-y-v 

*=«**= 

,~~^-f> 

g  ^ 

*    ""^ 

- — q-j 

4E 

Second  For  mi 

• Sa  TTtjatc  s     /ro 

m    head 

0 Samples     from     base 

«^q 

— 0 

o=d3= 

®"» 

/ 

-6 

p**^S>5 

~o-" 

2 

0 

4 

0 

6 

0 

e 

0 

100 

Percent    -from    Tbjo   End  0/    Shape 

Fig.    23 — Tensile   Tests    from    Second    Forming    Pass. 


first  forming  pass  shows  in  a  very  general  way  some  increase  as  we  go 
down  the  bar.  Fig.  23  shows  curves  of  the  metal  from  the  second  form- 
ing pass  representing  the  centers  of  the  head  and  the  base,  and  there- 
fore mostly  what  was  interior  metal  in  the  ingot,  but  not  axial  metal. 
These  curves  are  somewhat  similar  to  the  ones  of  the  first  forming  pass 
just  discussed.  Fig.  24  shows  just  a  few  results  from  the  head  of  the 
finished  rail. 

From  the  above  discussion  it  may  be  gathered  that  the  metal  in 
the  walls  of  the  ingot  takes  comparatively  little  work  or  reduction  to 
impart  to  it  what  may  be  called  its  full  physical  properties  of  tensile 
strength  and  ductility.  In  fact,  these  are  practically  reached  in  the 
bloom  at  six  reductions,  except  at  the  top  end.  The  axial  metal  at  the 
bottom  of  the  ingot  also  soon  reaches  its  full  qualities,  but  in  the  upper 
half  of  the  ingot  it  must  be  carried  through  the  first  forming  pass  or 
25  reductions  before  this  point  is  reached. 

In  order  to  show  up  somewhat  more  clearly  the  rate  of  improvement 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


771 


of  the  physical  qualities  of  the  steel  as  the  process  of  reduction  pro- 
ceeds, the  tensile  properties  have  been  plotted  on  the  basis  of  times 
reduced ;  that  is,  the  ratio  of  the  area  of  the  original  cross  section  of 
the  ingot  to  the  area  of  the  shape.  For  this  purpose  four  distances  in  per 
cent,  from  the  top  end  have  been  selected  as  typical  of  the  different 
regions  to  be  found  in  the  ingot,  namely,  5  per  cent.,  25  per  cent,  50 
per  cent,  and  00  per  cent.  The  times  reduced  in  rolling  at  these  dis- 
tances for  the  different  passes  are  shown  in  table  6  herewith.  The  ex- 
pression, ''times  reduced,"  means  the  same  as  times  elongated,  and  while 
perhaps  not  a  strictly  correct  expression,  its  convenience  probably  justifies 
its  use  in  this  report,  and  its  meaning  will  be  the  ratio  above  explained. 
I00,« 


75, 


50, 


,<CO 

— m 

*»"■  !   

«F 

OOO 

Rati 

Samples    from   head 

?0 

***>• 

10 

n 

2 

0 

4 

0 

6 

0 

8 

0 

100 

a,  £ 


O  O  1 

*  J! 


Percent  from   Top   End    0/    RaiL   Bar 
Fig.   24 — Tensile   Tests   from    Head  of  Rail. 

table  6 — reductions  in  various  passes. 

Distance  from  top  of  shape. 
Pass.  5%        25%        50%      00% 

Bloom   5-8 

Third    roughing     10.7 

Fifth    roughing    14-2 

Squabbing  194 

First    forming    24.5 

Second    forming    31.9 

Finishing   467 

Fig.  25  shows  the  metal  at  5  per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  at 
the  various  stages  of  reduction.  The  metal  originally  in  the  corner  of 
the  ingot  is  weak  and  brittle  until  the  stage  of  about  14  reductions  is 
reached,  while  the  axial  metal  reaches  fair  qualities  somewhat  sooner. 
The  metal  at  25  per  cent,  from  the  top  end  is  shown  in  Fig.  26,  and 
it   will  be    noted   that   the   exterior   metal    shows    very    fair   qualities   of 


6.0 

6.2 

6.6 

II. I 

ii-5 

12.2 

147 

15.3 

16.2 

20.1 

20.9 

22.1 

25.2 

26.3 

277 

33-1 
48.3 

34-3 

36.2 

50.2 

53-2 

RAIL. 


5js£  75.000 
(/)  *•  5  O.ooo 

«J  ft. 

I" 


..O 


CM 


7^ 


=*===* 


-head 


Me  fat     ai     5    percent 
from       top       end     0/  shape 
•  Center       0/     section 

O Upper     corners  of  head 


Fig.  25 — Metal  at  5  Per  Cent  from  Top  at  Various  Stages  of 

Reduction. 


— *^°                      O-t-head 

I00/Ooo 

r>. 

5       £ 

-u— 

^75,000 

<0    .    50.000 

\. 

">  .£25,000 

Metal,   at  /Z.O    percent 
from     tojo     end  0/    shape 

•          Center     of    section 
O— — — Upper    corners  of  head 

20 

ft 

0  5°  "10 

O— - 

y— * 

o-«- 

> 

head 

O     ft  R 

>*i      "~   0 

y 

X 

/ 

Fig. 


TO  20  30  40  50 

26 — Metal  at  25  Per  Cent  from  Top  at  Various  Stages  of 
Reduction. 


20 

30 

fri 

Times 

Reduced 

<: 

n* 

0 

E 

£ 

k 

Jo 

0 
<0 

■Kl 

WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  77.'] 

strength  and  ductility  in  the  bloom  at  six  reductions,  and  its  full  qualities 
are  reached  at  about  20  reductions,  showing  a  tensile  strength  of  about 
105,000  lbs.  with  about  16  per  cent,  elongation  in  10  inches.  The  axial 
metal  at  25  per  cent,  does  not  reach  its  full  qualities  until  about  25  re- 
ductions is  reached  at  the  first  forming  pass,  and  even  here  the  test 
pieces  would  contain  some  of  the  outer  metal.  Fig.  27  shows  the  metal 
at  50  per  cent,  and  here  the  exterior  metal  shows  good  qualities  from 
the  bloom  on  with  but  little,  if  any,  improvement  beyond  this  stage, 
but  the  axial  metal  does  not  reach  its  full  qualities  until  over  25  reduc- 
tions is  reached  in  the  first  forming  pass  or  beyond.  Fig.  28  shows  the 
metal   at  00  per   cent.,   and  here   again   the  exterior  metal   shows   its   full 


(O  fc50,ooo(£ 


*>^25,600 

B 


-^"G 


Metal   at  DU    percent 
from     top     end    of   shape 

•    '       Center     0/     section 

O Upper     corners  of  head 


10 

ZO                        30 

k. 

Tcmes      Reduced 

•v. 

0 

0) 

■0        £              !; 

<0           -2                   £ 

Fig.  27 — Metal  at  50  Per  Cent  from   Top  at  Various    Stages   of 

Reduction. 


qualities  in  the  bloom  with  but  little  or  no  improvement  beyond  this 
stage.  The  axial  metal  also  shows  its  full  qualities  at  the  third  rough- 
ing pass  at  twelve  reductions.  We  have  no  results  before  this  stage 
of  reduction,  which  is  unfortunate,  as  it  would  be  very  interesting  to 
see  whether  the  axial  metal  at  the  bottom  of  the  ingot  also  reaches  its 
full  qualities  in  the  bloom. 

This  study  indicates  that  the  metal  in  those  portions  of  the  ingot 
where  it  is  of  fairly  even  composition  and  free  from  sponginess,  soon 
reaches  its  full  physical  qualities  of  tensile  strength  and  ductility.  Ten 
reductions,  or  a  reduction  to  one-tenth  of  the  original  cross-sectional 
area  of  the  ingot,  suffices,  but  the  interior  portion  of  the  upper  part  of 


774 


RAIL. 


the  ingot  requires  25  or  more  reductions  to  have  its  full  qualities  de 
veloped,  that  is,  the  original  cross-sectional  area  of  the  ingot  must  be 
reduced  below  four  per  cent. 


TENSILE  TESTS  OF  RAILS. 

Vol.  2  of  Tests  of  Metals  contains  an  interesting  series  of  tensile 
tests  of  samples  from  the  head  of  the  rail  bar  from  ingot  D  of  heat  1, 
charged  hot  and  soaked  in  the  usual  manner.  The  test  specimens  were 
.798  in.  diameter  with  a  sectional  area  of  .5  sq.  in.  and  a  gage  length 
of  10  in.,  and  were  taken  along  the  whole  length  of  the  rail  bar,  from 
the  middle  of  the  head.     The  results   of  the  tensile  tests  are   collected 


<M  n. 


-J! 


20 


fc  s  .. 

Vi  0 


Metal  at    Z/CJ  percent 
/rom     top      end    0/  snape 

*         Center      of     section 
O— -Upper    corners  of  head 


^..-5^:2=. 


te==j 


20 


30 


-head- 


"to 


50 


Times        Reduced 


Fig.    28 — Metal    at    90    Per    Cent    from    Top    at    Various    Stages 

Reduction. 


on  pages  485  and  486,  and  I  have  plotted  the  tensile  strength  and  elonga- 
tion in  Fig.  29  herewith  on  the  basis  of  per  cent,  of  distance  from  the 
top  end  of  the  rail  bar.  It  will  be  noted  that  starting  with  a  tensile 
strength  of  about  107,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  at  6  per  cent.,  the  strength 
rapidly  goes  up  until  a  maximum  of  about  129,000  lbs.  is  reached  at  14 
per  cent.  The  strength  then  gradually  drops  until  a  minimum  is  reached 
of  about  102,000  lbs.  at  86  per  cent.,  after  which  it  rises  again,  reaching 
about  111,000  lbs.  near  the  bottom  end  of  the  bar.  The  elongation  in 
10  in.  starts  at  12  per  cent,  reaches  a  minimum  of  8  per  cent,  where 
the  tensile  strength  is  greatest,  and  then  gradually  increases  until  18 
per  cent,  is  reached  at  about  82  per  cent,  from  the  top,  after  which  it 
again  drops   somewhat. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


775 


In  this  series  of  tests,  then,  we  again  -find  a  distribution  of  the  tensile 
properties  along  the  bar,  corresponding  in  a  general  way  to  the  dis- 
tribution found  of  the  carbon '  in   the  interior  of  the  bloom. 

A  similar  series  of  tensile  tests  from  the  head  of  the  rail  was  made 
of  ingot  F  of  heat  i,  which  was  laid  on  its  side  to  cool  immediately 
after  stripping,  head  side  up,  and  then  reheated.  With  an  ingot  kept 
in  the  usual  vertical  position  there  is  a  concentration  of  carbon,  phos- 
phorus and  sulphur  and  of  blow  holes,  in  the  interior  and  upper  part 
of  the  ingot,  and  the  effect  of  placing  the  ingot  on  its  side  to  cool  im- 
mediately after  stripping  and  while  the  interior  is  still  liquid,  would  be, 
it  would  seem,  to  orient  the  above-mentioned  condition  along  almost 
the  whole  of  the  side  uppermost  in  cooling,  in  this  case,  into  the  head  of 
the  rail  for  most  of  the  length  of  the  rail  bar.     The  results  of  the  tests 


IZ!y>eo 


«     5  0»c 
,J    25,oo 


20 

2  t  k: 

£« 


**— «■  V  «w» 


Head    of    Rati 

Ingot  ID  charged,    hot  and 

soakad     as     usuctt 


20  40  60  60 

Percent    from    Top    £r?d  of  Rait   Bar 

Fig.   29 — Tensile  Tests   from    Head   of   Normal   Rail. 


too 


are  shown  on  pages  551  and  552  of  Tests  of  Metals,  and  I  have  plotted 
these  in  Fig.  30  herewith  in  the  same  manner  as  the  previous  results. 
At  6  per  cent,  from  the  top  of  the  rail  bar  the  results  are  a  good  deal 
the  same  as  in  the  normal  rail,  but  the  elongation  at  once  decreases, 
and  the  tensile  strength  soon  follows,  so  that  at  20  per  cent,  the  ductility 
is  practically  all  gone  and  the  tensile  strength  down  to  70,000  lbs.  per 
sq.  in.  The  tensile  strength  again  goes  up  quickly,  but  afterwards  varies 
considerably  between  about  98,000  and  121,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  The  elonga- 
tion also  remains  low,  varying  mostly  between  2  and  6  per  cent,  until 
about  89  per  cent,  is  reached,  when  it  is  about  the  same  as  in  the  normal 
rail  for  the  rest  of  the  rail  bar,  namely,  above  15  per  cent.  The  tensile 
strength  is  also  about  normal   for  the  bottom  10  per  cent. 


T7<; 


RAIL. 


These  tests  shozv,  then,  that  the  effect  of  placing  the  ingot  on  its 
side  to  cool  immediately  after  stripping,  head  side  up,  is  to  render  the 
metal  in  the  head  generally  weak  and  brittle  in  tensile  test,  except  for 
about  10  per  cent,  from  each  end  of  the  rail  bar,  where  the  metal  ex- 
hibits its  normal  properties,  due,  presumably,  to  having  set  previous  to 
stripping. 


ETCHINGS   OF   CROSS   SECTIONS. 

The  Tests  of  Metals  contains,  a  great  many  most  excellent  repro- 
ductions of  iodine  etched  cross  sections  of  shapes  from  the  ingot  to  the 
finished  rail,  showing  the  progressive  change  both  from  one  end  to  the 
other  of  the  ingot  or  bar,  and  also  through  the  various  passes.  Start- 
ing from  the  top  end  of  a  shape,  the  structure  as  developed  by  etching 
l25;ooo 


5£ 


75,. 


50, 


25,c 


ao 


ki  o 


Head   of  Rati 

ingot  IF  Laid  on    side     imme- 
diately    after     stripping, 
head  side     up;   reheated. 


100 


20  40  60  60 

Percent     j-rom     Top  End   »/   RaiL   Bar 

Fig.  30 — Tensile  Tests  from  Head  of  Rail  Made  from  an  Ingot  that 
Had  Been  Laid  on   Its  Side  to  Cool  Immediately  After  Strip- 
ping,  Head   Side  Up,  and   Reheated. 


progressively  changes  to  the  bottom  end,  and  each  region  has  its  char- 
acteristic structure.  The  various  structures  can,  perhaps,  be  fairly  well 
represented  by  distances  of  10,  20  and  65  per  cent,  from  the  top  end 
of  the  shape.  At  10  per  cent,  the  larger  sections  contain  cavities  of 
various  sizes,  distributed  throughout  the  section,  while  the  smaller  sec- 
tions show  spots  with  a  somewhat  similar  distribution,  but  more  numerous. 
At  about  20  per  cent,  all  passes,  except,  perhaps,  the  largest  sections, 
show  a  dark  "core"  with  some  dark  spots  distributed  around.  In  the 
lower  part  of  the   shape,    as  typified  by   sections  at  about  65   per  cent., 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  777 

the  sections  also  show  a  core,  but  it  is  apt  to  show  light.  This  lighter 
colored  core  first  shows  up  about  half  way  down,  increasing  in  area 
until  a  distance  of  about  90  per  cent,  from  the  top  end  is  reached, 
when  the  cross  section  becomes  almost  structureless  on  etching. 

Figs.  31  to  56,  inclusive,  are  given  to  show  the  progressive  changes 
through  the  different  passes  for  distances  of  about  10,  20  and  65  per  cent, 
from  the  top  end  of  the  shape,  and  table  7  (page  40  of  this  report)  shows 
the  pages  of  Tests  of  Metals,  1909,  from  which  these  are  reproduced. 


Fig.   31 — Quarter  Ingot,   Cross   Section   Slice,  i  B  4,   11.26%   by 
Distance,  10.4%  by  Volume,  from  Top  of  Ingot. 


Fig.  32 — Sixth  Blooming  Pass,  Quarter  Section  5  B  4 — 10.3% 
from  Top  of  Ingot. 


RAIL. 


fife        *2 

Fig-   33 — Ninth    Blooming   Pass,   Quarter   Section   5  C  3- 
9.1%  from   Top  of  Ingot. 


Fig.  34 — Third  Roughing  Pass,  Cross  Section   Slice  4  A 
14.47%  from  Top  End  of  Shape. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  779 


FJG-  35 — Squarbing   Pass,   Cross   Section    Slice  4  C  8 — 8.84%   fkom 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  36 — First  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section   Slice  4  D  12 — 9.89%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


780 


RAIL. 


Fig.  2>7 — Second  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  E  14—9.69%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.   38  —  75~LB-   Rail,   Cross    Section    Slice   4  F  16 — 9.89%   from 
Top   End  of  Rail  Bar. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         781 


Fig.  39 — Quarter  Ingot,  Cross  Section  Slice  i  B  8 — 23.79%  by  Distance, 
22.2%  by  Volume  from   Top  of  Ingot. 


Fig.   40 — Sixth    Blooming    Pass,    Quarter    Section    5  B  7 — 20.2%    from 

Top  of  Ingot. 


782 


RAIL. 


Fig.  41— Ninth  Blooming  Pass,  Quarter  Section  5C11 — 21.6% 
from  Top  of  Ingot. 


Fig.  42 — Third  Roughing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  A  16—24.72%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.  783 


Frc.  43 — Fifth  Roughing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  B  16 — 17.04%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  44 — Squabbing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  C  16 — 19.77%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  45 — First  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  D  30 — 19.62%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  46 — Second  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  E  44 — 21.85%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES. 


Fig.  47 — 75-lb.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  4F41 — 21%  from  Top 
End  of  Rail  Bar. 


Fig.  48 — Quarter  Ingot,   Cross   Section   Slice   i  B  22 — 67.64%    by    Dis- 
tance, 65.7%  by  Volume,  from  Top  of  Ingot. 


786 


RAIL. 


Fig.  49 — Sixth  Blooming  Pass,  Quarter  Section  5  B  21 — 63%  from 
Top  of  Ingot. 


Fig.    50 — Ninth    Blooming    Pass,    Quarter   Section    5  C  37 — 62%    i-rom 

Top  of  Ingot. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         787 


Fig.  51— Third  Roughing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  A  43 — 64.49%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  52 — Fifth  Roughing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  B  66 — 67.52%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


RAIL 


Fig.  53 — Squabbing  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  C  83 — 73.43%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  54 — First  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  D  97 — 65.23%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         789 


Fig.  55 — Second  Forming  Pass,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  E  130 — 68.39%  from 
Top  End  of  Shape. 


Fig.  56 — 75-LB.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  4  F  140 — 64.83%  from  Top 
end  of  Rail  Bar. 


"'.HI 


RAIL. 


TABLE    /  —  PAGES    OF   TESTS    OF    METALS,    IQOp, 

on    which    are    shown  etchings  of   cross    sections,   which   are   reproduced 
as  figures  of  this  report. 


10  Per  Cent. 

20  Per  Cent. 

65  Per  Cent. 

Pass. 

Page 

Fig. 

Page 

Fig. 

Page 

41 
95-18 
99-20 
165-11 
237-10 
287-10 
331-16 
371-13 
575-13 

Fig. 

48 
49 
50 
51 
52 
53 
54 
55 
56 

Ingot   

23 

95-3 

99-1 

165-3 

31 
32 
33 
34 

35 
36 
37 
38 

27 
95-6 
99-7 
165-5 
237-2 
287-5 
331-6 
371-6 
575-4 

39 
40 
41 
42 
43 
44 
45 
46 
47 

Third    roughing    

Fifth  roughing   

287-3 
331-4 
371-2 
575-2 

First  forming   

Rail    

The  rails  made  from  ingot  3F  are  interesting,  as  showing  how  the 
interior  structure  as  developed  by  etching  may  be  changed  by  manipulat- 
ing the  ingot.  This  ingot  was  laid  on  its  side  to  cool  immediately  after 
stripping,  web  side  up,  and  then  reheated  for  9  hours.  Four  etched  sec- 
tions of  rails  are  herewith  reproduced  as  Figs.  57  to  60,  inclusive,  at  dis- 


Fig.  57— 75-LB.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  3  F  16— 10.80%  from  Top  End 

of  Rail  Bar.     Ingot  Laid  on  Side  to  Cool,  Immediately 

After  Stripping,  Web  Side  Up. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         791 


Fig.  58— 75-lb.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  3  F  39— 20.51%  from  Top  End 

of  Rail  Bar.     Ingot  Laid  on  Side  to  Cool,  Immediately 

After  Stripping,  Web  Side  Up. 


Fig.  59 — 75-lb.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  3  F  hi— 50.41%  from  Top  End 

of  Rail  Bar.     Ingot  Laid  on  Side  to  Cool,  Immediately 

After  Stripping,  Web  Side  Up. 


792 


RAIL. 


Fig.  60 — 75-lb.  Rail,  Cross  Section  Slice  3  F  173 — 74.71%  from  Top  End 

of  Rail  Bar.     Ingot  Laid  on  Side  to  Cool,  Immediately 

After  Stripping,  Web  Side  Up. 


tances  of  approximately  10,  20,  50  and  75  per  cent,  from  the  top  end 
of  the  rail  bar,  and  it  will  be  noted  how  the  streaks  and  spots  have 
been  oriented  toward  the  side  that  was  "uppermost  in  the  cooling  ingot. 
There  is  now  a  similarity  of  appearance  along  practically  the  whole  bar, 
except  that  the  upper  third  of  the  length  of  the  bar  shows  some  spots 
on  the  side  that  was  below  in  cooling,  which  spots  are  generally  absent 
in  the  lower  part  of  the  length. 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF  INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         79J 


SUMMARY. 

i.  The  Report  of  Tests  of  Metals,  etc.,  made  at  Watertown  Arsenal, 
Mass.,  for  the  year  1909,  is  devoted  largely  to  tests  of  rail  steel  ingots 
and  derivative  shapes.  Etchings  were  made  of  sections  of  the  ingot  and 
of  successive  shapes  to  the  finished  rail,  and  the  report  consists  largely 
of  the  illustrations  of  these  etchings,  showing  the  changes  in  structure 
from  one  end  of  a  shape  to  the  other,  and  through  the  successive  shapes. 
Tensile  test  bars  were  also  taken  at  successive  stages  of  the  rolling,  and 
a  carbon  survey   of  two  blooms   is  also  given. 

2.  Below  are  given  statements  of  the  various  conclusions  that  seem 
to  be  indicated  by  the  tests  as  applying  to  the  Bessemer  steel  dealt  with 
in  this  investigation,  and  to  the  conditions  under  which  it  was  made, 
and  care  should  be  exercised  when  applying  them  to  other  steel  and 
other  conditions  of  manufacture.  The  ingots  were  about  19^x20^4  in. 
at  the  bottom  and  5  ft.  high. 

3.  Examination  of  ingots  shows  that  the  upper  third  of  the  ingot 
is  very  spongy,  that  is,  it  contains  a  great  many  cavities  of  various  sizes. 
The  sponginess,  in  general,  tapers  toward  the  center. 

4.  Examination  of  successive  shapes  shows  that  the  larger  central 
cavities  persist  well  beyond  the  blooming  passes,  and  that  the  spongi- 
ness extends  downward  from  the  top  end  of  the  shape  about  the  same 
proportionate  distance  as  in  the  ingot. 

5.  The  cavities  of  a  cold  ingot,  which  had  been  placed  in  the  soak- 
ing pit  directly  after  stripping,  and  then  cooled  down,  constitute  a  little 
larger  part  of  the  volume  of  the  ingot  than  where  the  ingot  is  cooled 
down  directly  without  soaking. 

6.  The  cavities  of  a  cold  bloom  made  from  an  ingot  which  had  been 
placed  in  the  soaking  pit  directly  after  stripping,  and  rolled  into  a  bloom 
upon  removal  from  the  soaking  pit,  also  constitute  a  little  larger  part 
of  the  volume  of  the  bloom,  than  where  the  ingot  is  first  cooled  down 
after  pouring,  reheated  and  then   rolled  into  a  bloom. 

7.  A  carbon  survey  of  two  blooms  shows  that,  starting  from  the 
top  end  of  the  bloom,  the  axis  at  first  shows  negative  segregation  of 
carbon,  that  is,  carbon  below  the  average  in  the  steel,  reaching  a  minimum 
at  about  6  or  8  per  cent,  from  the  top,  but  the  carbon  soon  increases 
and  shows  considerable  positive  segregation,  reaching  a  maximum  at 
about  22  or  24  per  cent,  from  the  top  end.  About  half  way  down,  the 
carbon  at  the  axis  again  reaches  the  average  amount,  and  in  the  lower 
half  again  shows  some  negative  segregation,  coming  up  to  about  the 
normal  at  the  bottom.  The  maximum  segregation  of  carbon  was  70  per 
cent,  in  one  bloom  and  54  per  cent,  in  the  other,  above  the  average  con- 
tent. 


794  RAIL. 

The  walls  of  the  upper  part  of  the  bloom  show  negative  segregation 
of  carbon,  which  rises  until  the  average  carbon  content  of  the  bloom 
is  reached  at  about  25  or  35  per  cent,  from  the  top  end.  The  greatest 
negative  segregation  was  32  per  cent,  in  one  bloom  and  26  per  cent,  in 
the  other,  that  is,  the  carbon  was  this  much  below  the  average  content 
of  the  bloom. 

8.  Tensile  tests  were  made  of  specimens  taken  at  various  stages 
from  the  ingot  to  the  finished  rail,  and  they  throw  light  on  the  question 
of  the  amount  of  work  or  reduction  necessary  in  rolling  to  develop" 
the  full  physical  qualities  of  the  steel.  The  results  indicate  that  the 
metal  in  the  walls  of  the  ingot  takes  comparatively  little  work  or  reduc- 
tion to  impart  to  it  what  may  be  called  its  full  physical  properties  of 
tensile  strength  and  ductility.  These  are  reached  in  the  bloom,  except 
at  the  top  end.  The  axial  metal  at  the  bottom  of  the  ingot  also  soon 
reaches  its  full  physical  properties,  but  in  the  upper  half  of  the  ingot 
it  must  be  carried  well  toward  the  finished  rail  before  these  properties 
are  fully  developed. 

Where  the  metal  is  of  fairly  even  composition  and  free  from  spongi- 
ness,  it  reaches  its  full  physical  qualities  of  tensile  strength  and  ductility 
at  about  ten  reductions  or  a  reduction  to  one-tenth  of  the  original  cross 
section  of  the  ingot,  but  the  interior  portion  of  the  upper  part  of  the 
ingot  requires  25  or  more  reductions  to  have  its  full  physical  qualities 
developed,  that  is,  the  cross-sectional  area  must  be  reduced  below  1/25 
of  its  original  amount. 

9.  Tensile  tests  were  made  of  specimens  taken  from  the  center  of 
the  head  of  a  rail  bar  which  was  made  in  the  usual  manner,  and  were 
taken  along  the  whole  length  of  the  bar.  The  tensile  strength  corre- 
sponds, in  a  general  way,  with  the  distribution  of  the  carbon  in  the 
interior  of  the  bloom,  that  is,  it  first  goes  up  as  we  go  down  the  bar, 
reaching  a  maximum  at  14  per  cent,  down,  then  the  strength  gradually 
drops  until  a  minimum  is  reached  at  86  per  cent,  down,  after  which 
it  rises  again.  The  maximum  tensile  strength  in  this  bar  was  129,000 
lbs.  per  sq.  in.,  and  the  minimum  was  102,000  lbs.  The  elongation,  in 
general,  varied  inversely  as  the  strength  between  limits  of  8  per  cent, 
in  10  inches  and  18  per  cent. 

10.  A  similar  series  of  tensile  tests  was  made  on  specimens  from 
a  rail  bar  made  from  an  ingot  that  had  been  laid  on  its  side  to  cool  im- 
mediately after  stripping,  head  side  up,  and  then  reheated.  The  effect 
of  this  treatment  of  the  ingot  is  to  render  the  metal  of  the  head  gen- 
erally weak  and  brittle  in  tensile  test,  except  for  about  10  per  cent,  from 
each  end  of  the  rail  bar,  where  the  metal  exhibits  its  normal  properties. 

11.  Etchings  were  made  of  cross  sections  of  shapes  from  the  ingot 
to  the  rail,  showing  the  progressive  change  from  one  end  of  the  shape 
to  the  other,  and  also  through  the  various  passes.  Each  region  along 
the  length  of  the  shape  has  its  characteristic  structure.  Near  the  top 
end,  the  ingot  and  larger  passes  show  holes  generally  distributed,  while 
the  smaller  passes  show  spots  and  streaks  on  etching.     About  one-fifth 


WATERTOWN  TESTS  OF   INGOTS  AND  SHAPES.         795 

or  one-fourth  way  down,  the  sections,  particularly  the  smaller  ones,  show 
a  dark  core  with  a  few  spots  and  streaks.  The  cross  sections  from  the 
bottom  half  of  the  shapes  also  show  a  core,  but  entirely  different  in 
appearance,  and  it  generally  shows  lighter  colored.  Each  structure  finds 
its  counterpart  in  the  succeeding  shapes  and  at  about  the  same  propor- 
tionate distance  from  the  top  end. 

12.  Among  the  illustrations  are  etchings  of  cross  sections  of  a  rail 
bar  made  from  an  ingot  that  had  been  laid  on  its  side  to  cool  imme- 
diately after  stripping,  web  side  up,  and  then  reheated.  This  treatment 
of  the  ingot  changes  the  structure  entirely  and  its  effect  is  to  orient 
the  spots  and  streaks  along  the  side  that  was  uppermost  in  cooling  and 
for  most  of  the  length  of  the  rail  bar. 


Appendix  E. 

INFLUENCE    OF    ROLLING    TEMPERATURE    ON    THE 
PROPERTIES   OF   BESSEMER  RAILS 

By 

M.  H.  Wickhorst,  Engineer  of  Tests,  Rail  Committee. 

This  report  covers  an  investigation  to  throw  light  on  the  influence 
of  the  rolling  and  finishing  temperature  on  the  properties  of  Bessemer 
steel  rails.  A  series  of  five  ingots,  all  of  the  same  heat,  were  rolled  into 
85-lb.  rails,  all  in  the  same  manner  except  as  to  temperature  of  rolling. 
A  range  of  temperature  was  used  from  "cold"  rolling  to  very  hot  rolling, 
corresponding  to  shrinkages  in  a  33-ft.  rail,  varying  from  an  average  of 
6J4  in.  on  the  first  rail-bar  to  an  average  of  7  in.  on  the  last  rail-bar. 
The  rails  were  then  examined  by  means  of  drop,  tensile  and  microscopic 
tests  and  in  addition  an  ingot  of  the  same  heat  was  split  open  and  a 
chemical  survey  made  of  it.  The  rails  were  made  at  the  Edgar  Thomson 
Works  at  Braddock,  Pa.,  of  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company,  who  kindly 
furnished  a  heat  of  steel  and  all  the  means  and  facilities  involved  in 
carrying  out  the  tests,  and  the  thanks  of  the  Committee  are  due  to  the 
various  officers  of  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company  for  their  kindness  and 
the  efficient  manner  in  which  the  work  was  carried  out. 

MANUFACTURE. 

The  steel  used  was  Bessemer  steel  made  from  Lake  Superior  ores. 
The  iron  from  the  blast  furnaces  was  poured  into  a  mixer  from  which 
it  was  weighed,  poured  into  the  converter  and  blown,  scrap  steel  being 
added  at  the  same  time.  After  blowing,  the  metal  was  poured  into  the 
teeming  ladle,  the  spiegel,  in  liquid  condition,  being  poured  in  at  the 
same  time,  and  the  mixture  was  then  poured  into  the  molds.  The  amounts 
of  materials  used  to  make  this  heat  (No.  4,824  of  August  24,  191 1)  are 
shown  in  table  I. 

TABLE     I — BESSEMER     AMOUNTS. 

Mixer    metal 30,600  lbs. 

Scrap    steel 2,500    " 

Spiegel    3,280    " 

Total   36,380    " 


Report  No.  21.  November,  1911. 

797 


798  RAIL. 

Analyses  of  special  samples  of  the  mixer  metal  and  spiegel  and  of  the 
regular  heat  sample,  taken  about  the  middle  of  the  heat,  gave  the  results 
shown  in  Table  2. 

TABLE  2 — ANALYSES. 

C.  P.  S.  Mn.         Si. 

Mixer    metal 4.27        .089        .060        .62         1.38 

Spiegel     4.20        .099        .014     10.52         1.50 

Heat  sample 487      .095        .067       1.10  .19 

(I  was  told  that  the  mixer  metal  generally  contained  less  carbon  than 
shown  above,  and  it  was  conjectured  that  this  sample  may  possibly  have 
had  an  excess  of  graphite.) 

The  various  Bessemer  operations  occurred  at  the  times  shown  in 
table  3. 

TABLE   3 — TIMES    OF   BESSEMER   OPERATIONS. 

Date    Aug.  24, 1911 

Started    blowing 8.29  a.  m. 

Finished    blowing 8.40 

Time  used  to  blow 11  min. 

Started  to  pour  into   ladle 8.40  a.  m. 

Started  to  pour  into  molds 8.43 

Time  from  finish  of  blowing  to  start  of  pouring  into  molds.  . .  3  min. 

Finished  pouring  into   molds 8.52  a.  m. 

The  heat  made  seven  ingots  and  a  "butt,"  six  of  which  were  used  for 
the  experimental  work.  The  ingots  were  about  i8^4  in.  by  19^  in.  at  the 
bottom,  about  51  in.  high  and  weighed  about  4,400  lbs.  each.  After  strip- 
ping, the  ingots  were  placed  in  the  soaking  pit  in  a  vertical  position  in 
the  usual  manner,  and  after  soaking  varying  lengths  of  time  were  roiled 
into  blooms  about  g]/2  in.  square  in  seven  passes.  The  discard  from  the 
top  of  the  bloom  was  as  small  as  practicable  to  allow  of  satisfactory  roll- 
ing. The  bloom  was  cut  in  two,  the  two  halves  were  placed  in  a  re- 
heating furnace  and,  when  raised  to  the  desired  temperature,  were  rolled, 
without  being  held  at  any  stage,  into  85-lb.  rails  in  13  passes,  as  follows : 
seven  roughing,  five  forming  and  one  finishing  pass,  making  a  total  of 
20  passes  from  the  ingot  to  the  rail.  Just  before  entering  the  finishing 
rolls,  the  rail-bar  was  flooded  with  strong  jets  of  water  to  knock  off  the 
scale.  The  section  used  was  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  System,  85-lb.  P. 
S.  section,  illustrated  on  page  162,  Vol.  12,  part  2,  1911,  Proc.  Am.  Ry. 
Engr.  &  M.  W.  A.    Each  ingot  made  four  rails. 

As  stated,  there  were  seven  ingots  in  the  heat.  The  first  ingot  of 
the  pouring  was  not  used  for  this  test  work  and  the  fourth  was  used 
for  splitting  open  and  making  a  chemical  survey.  Ingots  2,  3,  5,  6  and  7 
were  given  test  numbers  respectively  as  follows :  ET6,  ET7,  ET8,  ET9 
and  FT10,  and  were  used  for  making  rails  for  test.     The  fourth  ingot 


INFLUENCE   OF  ROLLING   TEMPERATURE.  799 

was  given  test  number  ETu.  The  six  ingots  were  all  placed  in  the 
soaking  pit  about  the  same  time  (about  9.50  a.  m.),  but  drawn  at  differ- 
ent times,  as  the  making  of  the  test  rails  proceeded.  The  lengths  of  time 
they  were  in  the  soaking  pit  are  shown  in  table  4. 

TABLE    4 — TIME    IN    SOAKING    PIT. 

Ingot  Time  in  Pit.  Used  For. 

ET6 1    hr.   29  min Rails 

ET7 2    "     23      "    " 

ET8 2    "     25      "    " 

ET9 3    "     12      "    " 

ET10 3    "     13      "    " 

ETu 2    "     24      "    Splitting 

The  lengths  of  time  that  the  pairs  of  blooms  from  each  ingot  were 
in  the  reheating  furnace  are  shown  in  table  5. 

TABLE    5 — TIME    IN    REHEATING    FURNACE. 

Blooms  from  Ingot.  Time  in  Furnace. 

ET6 30   min. 

ET7 17      " 

ET8 32      " 

ET9 38      " 

ET10 55      " 

The  temperatures  of  the  various  rail  bars  were  determined  after 
leaving  the  finishing  rolls  by  means  of  a  Thwing  radiation  pyrometer,  the 
tube  of  the  instrument  being  directed  toward  the  top  of  the  head  of  the 
rail.  The  shrinkages  were  also  determined  by  measuring  the  saw  set- 
tings and  the  rails  after  cooling.  These  temperatures  and  shrinkages 
are  shown  in  table  6. 

TABLE  6 — SHRINKAGES   AND  FINISHING  TEMPERATURES. 

Shrinkage,  Inches. Temperature. 

A              B                  CD  A&B         C&D 

Ingot.                   Rail.         Rail.             Rail.  Rail.         Rails.  Rails. 

ET6    63-16  67-16           62-16  65-16        935°C         94o°C 

Average    64-16  9380 

ET7     67-16  611-16          67-16  68-16        965°             9600 

Average     ...                                 68-16  „   9630 

ET8     612-16  615-16         610-16  615-16      9850             9950 

Average    ...                               6  13-16  9900 

ET9    614-16  7  3-i6           613-16  73-16      10250           10300 

Average    ...                                7  10280 

ET10    615-16  73-16           614-16  71-16      10200           10250 

Average     ...                                 7  I023° 

It  will  be  noted  that  for  the  first  four  ingots  there  was  a  graded 
difference   of  finishing  temperature  and   of  shrinkage,  but   the   last   was 


800 


RAIL. 


about  the  same  as  the  one  previous,  although  it  had  been  intended  to  have 
this  finished  the  hottest.  The  range  in  finishing  temperature  of  the  head 
of  the  rail  as  measured  with  a  radiation  pyrometer,  between  the  average 
of  the  four  rails  of  ingot  ET6  and  ET9  was  go°C,  and  the  range  in  shrink- 
age was  54  in-.  or  from  6%  to  7  in. 

The  lengths  of  the  cold  rails,  their  camber  and  whether  "head  sweep" 
or  "base  sweep"  are  shown  in  table  7.  In  sawing  the  rails,  the  two  rails 
from  each  half-ingot  were  sawed  at  one  time.  The  setting  for  the  first 
pair  of  saws  that  cut  the  A  and  C  rails  was  33  ft.  6  11-16  in.,  and  for 
the  second  pair  that  cut  the  B  and  D  rails  was  33  ft.  6*A  in. 


TABLE  7 — LENGTHS   AND  CAMBERS  OF  RAILS. 


Length. 

Rail.  Ft.             in. 

ET6A    33  08-16 

B    33  01-16 

C    33  09-16 

D    33  03-16 

ET7A    33  04-16 

B    32  11  13-16 

C 33  04-16 

D    33  o 

ET8A    32  11  15-16 

B    32  11  9-16 

C    33  01-16 

D    32  11  9-16 

ET9A    32  11  13-16 

B    32  11  5-16 

C     32  11V& 

D    32  11  5-16 

ET10A    32  11  12-16 

B    32  11  5-16 

C    32  11  13-16 

D    32  11  7-16 


Camber. 

in. 

H 

itI 

A 

% 

H 
ilA 

% 


2 
iVs 

Vs 


Concave. 
Head  or 
Base  Side. 
Head 


Head 

Base 
Head 


Base 


Head 

Base 
Head 
Base 
Head 

Base 
Head 
Base 
Head 


Rail  ET6D  was  classified  on  inspection  as  a  No.  2  rail,  due  to  rough- 
ness at  the  under  corner  of  the  head  at  two  or  three  places  near  the 
middle  of  its  length,  and  rail  ET7D  was  also  so  classified  on  account  of 
a  flaw  in  the  web  near  the  middle  of  its  length. 

The  various  discards  from  the  blooms  and  the  rail  bars  and  the 
weights  of  the  ingots  are  shown  in  table  8. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING   TEMPERATURE. 


801 


ETil 


Fig.  i — Longitudinal  Section  of  Ingot  ETii  about  %  in.  from  Axis. 
Drilled  for  Analysis. 


802  RAIL. 

TABLE  8 — DISCARDS — WEIGHTS   OF   INGOTS. 

ET6  ET7  ET8  ETo  ETio 

Discard    from  bloom,   top 235  270  220  278  334 

Discard  from  bloom,  bottom 185  108  185  260  204 

Discard  from  rail   bar,  top 21           54  57  67  63 

First  intermediate    ....  46          43  47  53  59 

Second  intermediate  43          52  59  86  70 

Bottom     34          49  45  49  52" 

Total    discard     564        576        613        793        782 

Weight  of  four  rails 3,740     3,740     3,740     3,740     3,740 

Total    weight    of    ingot 4,304     4,316      4,353      4,533      4,522 

The  weight  of  ingot  ET11,  which  was  used  for  splitting  and  chemical 
survey,  was  4,580  lbs.,  weighed  whole  after  cooling. 

INGOT. 

As  stated  the  fourth  ingot  of  the  pouring,  given  test  number  ET11, 
was  set  aside  for  direct  examination  after  soaking  2  hrs.  24  min.  This 
ingot  was  split  across  the  small  diameter  and  planed  to  a  smooth 
surface.  Fig.  1  shows  this  longitudinal  section  about  34  in.  from  the 
axis  of  the  ingot  and  after  drilling  for  analysis.  It  will  be  noted  that 
the  central  cavity  extends  downward  from  the  top  about  one-third  the 
length  of  the  ingot,  with  a  few  smaller  holes  still  lower.  The  general 
sponginess  at  the  top  of  the  ingot  extends  downward  about  15  per  cent. 
This  ingot  was  51  in.  high,  i8J4  x  *9/4  in-  at  the  bottom  and  17x1834 
in.  at  the  top. 

ANALYSES  OF  INGOT. 

This  section  of  the  ingot  was  drilled  for  a  chemical  survey,  the 
samples  for  analysis  being  taken  as  shown  on  the  drilling  diagram,  Fig.  2. 
It  will  be  noted  that  we  obtained  five  vertical  rows  of  drillings  from 
one-half  of  the  section,  making  a  total  of  75  samples,  less  the  number 
that  could  not  be  obtained,  due  to  cavities  in  the  ingot.  The  thick  half  of 
the  ingot  was  used  and  the  drilling  cut  through  the  axial  plane.  In  addi- 
tion, two  samples  were  taken  from  the  bulge  at  the  bottom  of  the  ingot  and 
called  samples  100D  and  100E.  The  ingot  after  drilling  is  shown  in 
Fig.  1.  On  each  sample  determinations  were  made  of  carbon  (by  com- 
bustion), phosphorus  and  sulphur,  and  on  samples  99A,  B,  C,  D  and  E, 
and  100D  and  E,  the  manganese  and  silicon  were  also  determined  as 
representing  the  average  in  the  ingot.  The  results  on  carbon,  phosphorus 
and  sulphur  are  shown  in  tables  9,  10  and  11,  respectively.  The 
manganese  and  silicon  are  shown  in  table  12. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


803 


Vert  ica.L 

Rows 

A   B     C      D     if 

/ 

0    O      O      O      (> 

5 

O    O      O      O      <|) 
1 

10 

o  o     o     O     <) 

15 

O    O      O      O      <) 
1 

20 

o  o     o     O     <) 

%    25 

O    O      O      O      <) 

a 

£    30 

O    O      O      O      ( 

> 

Si 

Z. 

,     35 

o  o     o     o     < 

) 

«. 

£     40 

o  o     o     o     < 

> 

E 

0 

k 

^K 

50 

o   o     o     o     < 

> 

(i 

U 

& 

V 

i{  eo 

o  o    o     o    < 

> 

**il 

Q 

70 

D    O      O      O      < 

> 

HoUs 

#v 

am.-  /"rfjep. 

80        < 

b  o    o    o    < 

> 

■* 

"3 

U» 

90         ( 

>    9     <})     <j>     < 

> 

« 

99        [( 

i -i  diam  ^ 

)    O       O       O       < 

) 

Fig.  2 — Drilling   Diagram   for   Ingot. 


804 


RAIL. 


TABLE  9- 

-CARBON 

IN  INGOT 

ETII. 

Per  Cent 

from  Tor. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

i 

•415 

470 

•435 

•453 

.419 

5 

•473 

455 

.482 

•472 

•493 

10 

•525 

510 

•532 

15 

•514 

395 

•542 

•834 

20 

•531 

523 

•554 

.624 

25 

•530 

■519 

.528 

•599 

30 

•515 

523 

.568 

.482 

.662 

35 

.518 

•515 

•535 

•523 

■530 

40 

•540 

483 

•529 

.464 

•519 

50 

•514 

.501 

.464 

.502 

.446 

60 

.489 

•435 

.486 

.426 

•459 

70 

•513 

524 

.482 

.480 

•452 

80 

•503 

•497 

.492 

•457 

.411 

90 

•515 

•445 

■497 

•454 

.468 

99 

.492 

•471 

.491 

•489 

•483 

100 

.482 

•494 

TABLE    IO — PHOSPHORUS   IN   INGOT  ETII. 


Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

C. 

D. 

E. 

1 

.068 

064 

055 

070 

062 

5 

.077 

080 

075 

074 

080 

10 

.085 

075 

082 

15 

.086 

082 

075 

184 

20 

.091 

080 

092 

"5 

25 

.090 

090 

088 

117 

30 

.092 

090 

098 

098 

095 

35 

.092 

083 

103 

105 

096 

40 

.091 

095 

089 

075 

098 

5o 

.082 

091 

077 

086 

100 

60 

•095 

094 

099 

080 

080 

70 

.100 

081 

090 

105 

084 

80 

.076 

097 

093 

092 

088 

90 

.092 

095 

090 

088 

086 

99 

.089 

094 

095 

092 

096 

100 

095 

094 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


80£ 


TABLE 

11— 

-SULPH 

Per  Cent. 

from  Top. 

A. 

B. 

i 

O58 

061 

5 

069 

060 

IO 

OS8 

059 

15 

069 

061 

20 

07I 

074 

25 

O70 

074 

30 

083 

073 

35 

075 

083 

40 

O77 

074 

50 

079 

069 

60 

07I 

074 

70 

O78 

075 

80 

O76 

078 

90 

074 

074 

99 

079 

076 

100 

TABLE  I 

2 — MANGA! 

JESE  A 

Per 

Cent 

from  To] 

x     A. 

Manganese 

99 
100 

1.04 

99 
100 

■19 

SULPHUR    IN    INGOT    ETII. 


c. 

D. 

.049 

048 

.067 

048 

.047 

•OS7 

136 

.074 

118 

.065 

099 

.085 

093 

.074 

081 

.079 

082 

•073 

067 

.068 

069 

.070 

072 

.067 

066 

.069 

063 

.077 

069 

084 

•054 

.061 


104 
092 

075 
086 
065 
075 

070 
067 
073 
073 


B. 


■17 


c. 

D. 

E. 

1.15 

1. 12 

115 

I.04 

1.08 

•17 

.18 

■19 

.18 

.18 

P.            S.  Mn.         Si. 

.093        .076  1.08        .18 

.095        .067  1. 10        .19 

closely  except  as  to  sulphur. 


Probably  the  seven  samples  at  the  bottom  of  the  ingot,  99  A,  B,  C, 
D  and  E  and  100  D  and  E,  represent  fairly  closely  the  average  steel  in 
the  ingot  and  I  give  below  their  average  composition,  and,  for  compari- 
son, the  results  on  the  heat  sample : 

C. 

Average  of  seven  bottom  samples 486 

Heat    sample 487 

It  will  be  noticed  that  the  two  results  agree 
where  there  is  a  difference  of  .009  per  cent,  more  as  shown  by  the  aver- 
age of  the  samples  from  the  bottom  of  the  ingot. 

At  any  given  distance  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  the  extreme  variations 
in  composition  are,  in  general,  shown  by  the  axis  and  the  walls  of  the 
ingot,  and,  to  show  conveniently  the  changes  from  the  top  to  the  bottom 
of  the  ingot,  I  give  Fig.  3,  showing  the  plotted  results  for  carbon,  phos- 
phorus and  sulphur  for  the  axis  and  the  wall  of  the  ingot,  showing  the 
amount  of  the  element  vertically  and  the  per  cent,  from  the  top  of 
the  ingot  horizontally.  Where  samples  could  not  be  obtained  from  the 
axis  on  account  of  cavities,  the  results  from  row  D  were  taken  as  repre- 


806 


RAIL. 


senting  the  axis.  Lines  are  also  shown  representing  the  average  carbon, 
phosporus  and  sulphur  in  the  ingot.  It  will  be  noticed  that  the  axis  at 
the  top  shows  negative  segregation  of  the  three  elements,  but  the  amounts 
increase    rapidly    and    show    considerable    positive    segregation,    reaching 


SO 


fc-60 

o 

U 

.20 


16 

R 
2-08 

.04 


.16 


^>.08 
.04 


TO  20  30  40  50  «0  70  60  90  i« 


10  20  30  40  50  60  70  80  90         IM 


20  30  40  50  60  70  BO 

Per  cent    from     Top     of     Ingot 


90 


100 


Fig.  3 — Cakbon,  Phosphorus  and  Sulphur  in  the  Axis  and  Wall  of 

Ingot  ETii. 


a  maximum  at  about  15  per  cent,  by  distance  from  the  top  of  the 
ingot.  At  about  halfway  down,  the  elements  again  reach  the  aver- 
age amount  in  the  ingot  and  continue  to  decrease,  showing  some 
negative  segregation  in  the  lower  half  of  the  ingot.  The  amounts  again 
rise  close  to  the  bottom  and  reach  the  average  content  of  the  ingot. 


INFLUENCE   OF   ROLLING   TEMPERATURE. 


801 


The  wall  of  the  ingot  also  shows  negative  segregation  of  the  three 
elements  at  the  top,  but  the  amounts  gradually  rise  until  the  average 
amount  is  reached,  about  15  to  20  per  cent,  by  distance  from  the  top, 
after  which  it  remains  roughly  uniform. 

The  maximum  positive  segregation  found  at  the  axis  and  the  maxi- 
mum negative  segregation  found  in  the  wall  ore  shown  in  table  13. 

TABLE    13 — POSITIVE    AND    NEGATIVE    SEGREGATION. 

Carbon.       Phosphorus.     Sulphur. 

Maximum    at    axis 834  .184  .136 

Increase    72%  98%  79% 

Minimum  in  wall 415  .068  .058 

Decrease     16%  27%  31% 


A 

10% 

yz/A 

cavity  ^ 

% 

20% 

30% 

^&/// 

40% 

\cX 

v/V/X/N 

50% 

Vyv 

60% 

70% 

NcStS/N^ 

%£ 

80% 
90% 

Fig.  4 — Distribution  of  Phosphorus  in   Ingot  ETii.     A,   Below  .070: 

B,  .070  to  .085;  C,  .085  to  .105;  D,  .105  to  .135;  E,  .135  to  .175; 

F,  Above  .175. 


808  RAIL. 

It  was  considered  unnecessary  for  the  purposes  of  this  investiga- 
tion to  determine  the  manganese  and  silicon  on  all  the  samples,  as  other 
work  has  shown  that  manganese  segregates  to  a  much  smaller  extent  than 
the  carbon,  phosphorus  or  sulphur,  and  silicon  shows  no  noticeable 
segregation. 

Fig.  4  is  given  to  show  the  separation  of  the  phosphorus  into  regions 
of  different  concentrations,  and  the  same  diagram  can  be  taken  to  repre- 
sent the  distribution  of  the  carbon  and  sulphur.  Six  concentrations  o-f 
phosphorus  were  selected,  as  shown  in  lable  14,  and  the  approximate 
amounts  of  carbon  and  sulphur  represented  by  these  regions  are  also 
shown  in  the  same  table. 

TABLE     14 — REGIONS    OF    VARIOUS    CONCENTRATIONS. 

Phosphorus.  Carbon.  Sulphur 

A Below  .070  Below  .45  Below  .060 

B 070  to  .085  .45  to  .48  .060  to  .068 

C 085  to  .105  .48  to  .53  .068  to  .080 

D 105  to  .135  .53  to  .60  .080  to  .100 

E 135  to  .175  .60  to  .70  .100  to  .125 

F Above  .175  Above  .70  Above  .125 

It  should  be  stated  that  there  is  considerable  irregularity  in  the  results 
and  the  various  regions  are  not  sharply  defined  as  shown  on  the  dia- 
gram, although  they  are  correct  in  a  very  general  way.  The  region  of 
greatest  concentration  is  shown  by  F  in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  sur- 
rounding the  "pipe,"  about  15  per  cent,  from  the  top  by  distance,  and  prob- 
ably about  10  per  cent,  by  weight.  The  top  5  per  cent,  of  the  ingot 
shows  considerable  negative  segregation,  with  a  region  of  milder  nega- 
tive segregation  for  about  10  or  15  per  cent,  below  this,  and  there  is  also 
a  region  of  some  negative  segregation  in  the  interior  and  lower  part 
of  the  ingot. 

TESTS  MADE  OF  RAILS. 

The  entire  rail-bar  of  each  of  the  ingots  used  for  rails  was  used 
for  drop  tests,  tensile  tests  and  microphotographs,  and  was  divided  into 
units  of  one-third  rail  length,  or  11  ft.,  each.  From  each  11  ft.,  1  ft.  was 
cut  for  tensile  tests,  then  5  ft.  for  drop  test  with  the  head  in  tension, 
and  the  other  5-ft.  piece  was  used  for  drop  test  with  the  base  in  tension. 
From  each  i-ft.  piece  three  tensile  tests  were  made,  one  from  the  upper 
corner  of  the  head,  one  from  the  interior  of  the  head  near  its  junction 
with  the  web,  and  the  third  from  the  flange.  Microscopic  tests  were  made 
of  the  three  tensile  test  pieces  from  the  top  end  of  the  rail.  From  each 
rail,  then,  nine  tensile  tests  and  three  microscopic  tests  were  made.  In  all. 
nine  pieces  were  cut  from  each  rail,  as  shown  in  table  15. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.      809 

TABLE    15— TESTS    FROM    EACH    RAIL. 

No.    i — i  ft.     Tensile  and  microscopic  tests. 

Drop  test,  head  tension. 

Drop  test,  base  tension. 

Tensile   tests. 

Drop  test,  head  tension. 

Drop  test,  base  tension. 

Tensile  tests. 

Drop  test,  head  tension. 

Drop  test,  base  tension. 
The  distance  of  each  piece  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  expressed   in 
lbs.  and  in  per  cent.,  is  shown  in  tables  16  to  20,  inclusive.    This  distance 
is  figured  to  the  middle  of  the  test  piece. 


I- 

-1 

ft. 

2- 

-5 

ft. 

3- 

-5 

ft. 

4- 

-1 

ft. 

5- 

-5 

ft. 

6-5 

ft. 

7- 

-1 

ft. 

8-5 

ft. 

9- 

-5 

ft. 

TABLE    10— 

-TEST    PII 

ICES    OF   INGOT 

ETO — DISTA 

NCE    FRO 

M    TOP 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

ET6AI.. 

. .    270 

6.3 

ET6B1.. 

..1,205 

28.0 

A2.. 

•  •    355 

8.3 

B2.. 

..I,200 

30.0 

A3.. 

•  •    497 

11-5 

B3.. 

••1,432 

33-3 

A4.. 

..    582 

13-5 

B4.. 

■•1,517 

35-2 

A5.. 

..    667 

15.5 

B5.. 

.  .  1,602 

37-2 

A6.. 

..    809 

18.8 

B6.. 

•  •  i,744 

40.6 

A7.. 

..    894 

20.8 

B7.. 

. .  1,829 

42-5 

A8.. 

•  ■    979 

22.8 

B8.. 

..1,914 

44-5 

A9.. 

.  .1,121 

26.0 

B9.. 

•  .2,056 

47-8 

ET6C1.. 

.  .2,229 

51-8 

ET6D1.. 

•  -3,164 

73-6 

C2.. 

•  2,314 

53-8 

D2.. 

•  -3,249 

75-5 

c3.. 

•  .2,456 

57-0 

D3.. 

•  -3,391 

78.8 

c4.. 

•  .2,541 

59-i 

D4.. 

•  -3,476 

80.8 

c5.. 

.  .2,626 

61. 1 

D5.. 

•  .3,561 

82.8 

C6.. 

.  .2,768 

64.4 

D6.  . 

•  -3,703 

86.1 

c7.. 

.  .2,853 

66.3 

D7.. 

•  .3,788 

88.1 

C8.. 

•  .2,938 

68.3 

D8. . 

•  -3,873 

90.0 

c9.. 

..3,080 

71.6 

D9.. 

•  .4,015 

93-3 

TABLE    17- 

-TEST    PIECES    OF    INGOT 

ET7 — DISTANCE   FROM    TOP. 

Test.  • 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

ET7A1.. 

••      338 

7-8 

ET7BI.. 

..1,273 

29-5 

A2. 

■  •      423 

9-8 

B2.. 

..i,358 

31-5 

A3. 

•••      565 

I3-I 

B3.. 

..i,5oo\ 

34-8 

A4. 

,  .  .     650 

I5-I 

B4.. 

..1,585 

36.8 

AS- 

•  ■■    735 

17. 1 

B5.. 

.  .1,670 

38.7 

A6. 

...    877 

20.3 

B6.. 

..1,812 

42.0 

A7. 

. .  .    962 

22.3 

B7.. 

..1,897 

44.0 

A8. 

...1,047 

24-3 

B8. . 

. .  1 ,982 

46.0 

Ag. 

...1,189 

27.6 

Bg.. 

.  .2,124 

49-3 

810 


RAIL. 


ET7C1 


Ci 

•  ••2,303 

53-3 

C2 

...2,389 

55-3 

c3 

•••2,530 

58.6 

C4 

...2,615 

60.6 

cs 

. .  .2,700 

62.6 

C6 

. . .  2,842 

65-9 

C; 

. . .  2,927 

67.9 

cs 

..  .3,012 

69.8 

c9 

•  ••3,i54 

73-1 

ET7D1... 

•3,238 

75-0 

D2... 

■3,323 

77.0 

D3... 

•  3,465 

80.3 

D4... 

•  3,550 

82.3 

D5... 

•3,635 

84.3 

D6... 

■3,777 

87.5 

D7... 

.3,862 

895 

D8... 

•3,947 

91-5 

D9... 

.4,089 

94.8 

TABLE     l8 — TEST    PIECES    OF    INGOT    ET8 — DISTANCE     FROM     TOP. 


Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent 

ET8A1 

. . .    291 

6.7 

ET8B1... 

.1,226 

28.2 

A2 

...    376 

8.7 

B2... 

•  i,3H 

30.1 

A3 

...    518 

11.9 

B3... 

•i,453 

33-4 

A4 

...    603 

13.9 

B4... 

.1,538 

35-3 

A5 

...    688 

15-8 

B5... 

.1,623 

37-3 

A6 

. ...    830 

19.1 

B6. .. 

•1,765 

40.5 

A7 

...    915 

21.0 

B7... 

.1,850 

42.5 

AS 

.  .  .  .1.000 

23.0 

B8. .. 

•  i,935 

44-5 

Ao 

1,142 

26.2 

B9... 

•  2,077 

47-7 

ET8C1. 

..  .2,267 

52.1 

ET8D1... 

.3,202 

73-5 

C2 

...2,352 

54.0 

D2... 

•3,287 

75-6 

c3 

...2,494 

57-3 

D3... 

•3,429 

78.8 

c4 

•••2,579 

59-3 

D4... 

.3,514 

80.7 

C5 

. .  .  2,664 

61.2 

D5... 

■3,599 

82.7 

C6 

...2,806 

64-3 

D6... 

■3,741 

86.0 

c7 

. .  .2,891 

66.5 

D7... 

.3,826 

88.0 

C8 

. .  .2,976 

68.4 

D8... 

•3,9n 

90.0 

C9 

...3,u8 

71.6 

D9... 

■4,053 

93-2 

TABLE    19 — TEST    PIECES    OF    INGOT    ET9 — DISTANCE    FROM    TOP. 


Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent 

ET9A1.. 

•    359 

7-9 

ET9B1. 

..1,294 

28.6 

A2.. 

•    444 

9.8 

B2. 

•  •1,379 

30.5 

A3.. 

.  .    586 

12.9 

B3- 

••i,52i 

33-6 

A4.. 

.  .    671 

14.8 

B4. 

.  .  1,606 

35-5 

As-. 

••    756 

16.7 

B5- 

.  .1,691 

37-4 

A6.. 

.  .    898 

19.8 

B6. 

..1,833 

40.5 

A7-. 

•    983 

21.7 

B7. 

..1,918 

42.4 

A8.. 

..1,068 

23.6 

B8. 

.  .2,003 

44-3 

A9.. 

.  .1,210 

26.8 

B9. 

•  .2,145 

47-4 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


811 


ET9CI.. 

.  .2,368 

52.3 

ET9D1.. 

.3,303 

730 

C2.. 

•  -2,453 

54-2 

D2.. 

.3,388 

74-9 

P3-. 

•  -2,595 

57-3 

D3.. 

•  3,53o 

78.0 

c4.. 

.  .2,680 

59-2 

D4.. 

•3,615 

79-9 

c5.. 

•  .2,765 

61.1 

D5.. 

•  3,700 

81.8 

C6.. 

.  .2,907 

643 

D6.. 

•3,842 

85.0 

c7.. 

•  2,992 

66.1 

D7.. 

•3,927 

86.8 

C8.. 

■  .3,077 

68.0 

D8. . 

.4,012 

88.6 

C9.. 

•  -3,219 

71.2 

D9.. 

•  4,i54 

918 

TABLE  20 — TEST   PIECES   OF   INGOT 

ETIO — DISTANCE   FROM    TOP. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent. 

Test. 

Lbs. 

Per  Cent 

ET10A1 . . 

. .    411 

9-i 

ET10B1.. 

•  i,346 

29.8 

A2.. 

..    496 

11.0 

B2.. 

•  i,43i 

31-7 

A3.. 

..   638 

14.1 

B3.. 

•1,573 

34-8 

A4.. 

•  •    723 

16.0 

B4.. 

..1,658 

36.7 

A5.. 

..    808 

17.9 

B5.. 

•  1,743 

38.6 

A6. . 

•  •    950 

21.0 

B6. . 

.1,885 

41.7 

A7.. 

.•1,035 

22.9 

B7.. 

.1,970 

43-6 

A8. . 

.  .1,120 

24.8 

B8.. 

■  -2,055 

45-5 

A9.. 

.  .1,262 

27.9 

B9.. 

•  -2,197 

48.6 

ET10C1.. 

.  .2,410 

53-3 

ET10D1.. 

•  -3,345 

74.1 

C2.. 

•  -2,495 

55-2 

D2.. 

•  -3,430 

76.0 

c3.. 

•  -2,637 

58.3 

D3-. 

•  -3,572 

79.1 

c4.. 

.  .2,722 

60.2 

D4.. 

•  -3,657 

81.0 

c5.. 

.  .2,807 

62.1 

D5.. 

•  -3,742 

82.9 

C6.. 

.  .2,949 

65-3 

D6.. 

-  .3,884 

86.0 

c7.. 

•  .3,034 

67.2 

D7.. 

•  -3,069 

87.9 

C8.. 

•  3,119 

69.1 

D8. . 

•  -4.054 

89.8 

Cg.. 

•  .3,261 

72.2 

Dp.. 

.  .4,196 

92.9 

DROP  TESTS. 

Six  drop  tests  were  made  of  each  rail,  three  with  the  head  in  tension 
and  three  with  the  base  in  tension.  The  tup  was  2,000  lbs.,  the  height  of 
drop  was  18  ft.,  the  supports  were  3  ft.  apart,  and  the  anvil  was  the 
standard  spring  supported  anvil  of  20,000  lbs.  The  deflection  or  set  was 
taken  as  the  distance  between  a  3-ft.  straight  edge  and  the  part  of  the 
rail  where  struck  by  the  tup.  Gage  marks  1  inch  apart  were  put  on  the 
side  in  tension  for  a  distance  of  6  inches,  and  the  length  of  the  space 
which  stretched  most  at  failure  was  determined  and  taken  as  a  measure 
of  the  ductility  of  the  rail.  The  results  of  the  drop  tests  are  shown  in 
table  21  to  25,  inclusive,  showing  the  test  number,  the  distance  from  the 
top  of  the  ingot  in  per  cent,  of  the  weight,  whether  head  or  base  in  ten- 
sion, the  set  after  the  first  blow,  the  number  of  blows  that  it  took  to  break 
the  rail  and  the  per  cent,  of  stretch  of  the  inch  that  stretched  most  at 
failure.  The  averages  of  each  test  piece  location  of  the  various  rail-bars 
are  shown  in  table  26. 


812 


RAIL. 


TABLE  21 — DROP   TESTS,   INGOT   ET6,    AVERAGE    SHRINKAGE,   6  4~l6   IN. 

Per  Cent.       Head  or       Set        No.     Maximum 


Test 

From  Top 

Base  in 

I  St 

of 

Elongation 

Remarks. 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

Blow. 

Blows. 

Per  Cent. 

ET6A2 

8-3 

Head 

1.80 

2 

10 

A3 

1 1-5 

Base 

1.69 

2 

14 

AS 

15-5 

Head 

1.65 

2 

11 

A6 

18.8 

Base 

1.67 

4 

23 

A8 

22.8 

Head 

1.68 

3 

19 

A9 

26.0 

Base 

1.66 

4 

20 

ET6B2 

30.0 

Head 

1.60 

4 

18 

Not  broken. 

B3 

33-3 

Base 

1.72 

4 

20 

B5 

37-2 

Head 

1.68 

4 

20 

B6 

40.6 

Base 

1.67 

4 

18 

B8 

44-5 

Head 

1.71 

3 

21 

B9 

47-8 

Base 

1.67 

4 

18 

ET6C2 

53-8 

Head 

1.78 

3 

21 

C3 

57-0 

Base 

1.72 

2 

6 

Broke  about  5  in. 
from   support. 

C5 

61.1 

Head 

1.87 

3 

22 

C6 

64.4 

Base 

1.78 

4 

19 

C8 

68.3 

Head 

1.80 

4 

19 

Co 

71.6 

Base 

1.80 

3 

12 

Broke   at    support. 

ET6D2 

75-5 

Head 

1.76 

4 

30 

D3 

78.8 

Base 

1.72 

S 

32 

Not  broken. 

D5 

82.8 

Head 

(2.02) 

2 

12 

Not  broken 
through   head. 

D6 

86.1 

Base 

1.80 

5 

20 

D8 

00.0 

Head 

1.78 

3 

26 

Broke  near  sup- 
port. 

Do 

93-3 

Base 

1.80 

5 

24 

Average 

I-73I 

3-5 

19.0 

TABLE  22 — DROP   TESTS,   INGOT   ET7, 

AVERAGE    SHRINKAGE,   6  8-l6   IN. 

Per  Cent. 

Head  or 

Set 

No. 

Maximun: 

1 

Test 

From  Top 

Base  in 

1st 

of 

Elongatior 

1         Remarks. 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

Blow. 

Blows 

.    Per  Cent 

ET7A2 

9.8 

Head 

Broke 

1 

6 

A3 

13-1 

Base 

1.70 

3 

14 

As 

17. 1 

Head 

1.63 

3 

18 

A6 

20.3 

Base 

1.68 

3 

13 

A8 

24-3 

Head 

1.65 

2 

10 

Ao 

27.6 

Base 

1.68 

4 

20 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


813 


ET7B2 

3i-5 

Head 

1.74 

2 

10 

B3 

34-8 

Base 

1.65 

5 

24 

B5 

38.7 

Head 

1.76 

2 

10 

B6 

42.0 

Base 

1-73 

4 

17 

Broke  near  sup 
port. 

B8 

46.0 

Head 

1.66 

2 

14 

B9 

49-3 

Base 

1.71 

5 

20 

ET7C2 

55-3 

Head 

1.77 

4 

23 

■ 

C3 

58.6 

Base 

1-73 

3 

18 

C5 

62.6 

Head 

1.70 

5 

20 

C6 

65-9 

Base 

1.72 

5 

20 

C8 

698 

Head 

1.76 

4 

26 

c9 

73-1 

Base 

1.78 

3 

16 

ET7D2 

77.0 

Head 

1.80 

5 

33 

Not  broken  u 
head. 

D3 

80.3 

Base 

1.81 

4 

22 

Broke     near     sup 

port. 

D5 

84-3 

Head 

1.77 

5 

27 

D6 

87.5 

Base 

1.78 

5 

22 

D8 

91-5 

Head 

1.77 

4 

24 

Dp 

94-8 

Base 

1.70 

4 

22 

,     1.728 

46 

18.7 

TABLE  23 — DROP  TESTS,  INGOT  ET8,  AVERAGE  SHRINKAGE,  6  I3-I6  IN. 

Per  Cent.      Head  or      Set        No.     Maximum 


Test    ■ 

From  Top 

Base  in 

I  St 

of 

Elongation        Remark 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

Blow. 

Blows 

.    Per  Cent. 

ET8A2 

8-7 

Head 

1.81 

2 

10 

A3 

1 1.9 

Base 

1.69 

2 

10 

A5 

15-8 

Head 

1.67 

2 

10 

A6 

19.1 

Base 

1.68 

2 

10 

A8 

23.0 

Head 

1.69 

3 

16 

Ao 

26.2 

Base 

1.66 

4 

17 

ET8B2 

30.1 

Head 

173 

3 

18 

B3 

33-4 

Base 

1.65 

4 

18 

B5 

37-3 

Head 

•  175 

3 

20 

B6 

40.5 

Base 

173 

3 

23 

B8 

44-5 

Head 

1.76 

4 

24 

Bo 

477 

Base 

174 

5 

22 

' 


814 


RAIL. 


ET8C2 

54-0 

Head 

1.76 

3 

20 

C3 

57-3 

Base 

1.70 

4 

20 

c5 

61.2 

Head 

1.81 

3 

17 

C6 

64-3 

Base 

1.72 

4 

20 

C8 

68.4 

Head 

1.80 

3 

24 

c9 

71.6 

Base 

1.70 

5 

18 

ET8D2 

75-6 

Hea.- 

1.79 

4 

24 

D3 

78.8 

Base 

1.70 

5 

23 

D5 

82.7 

Head 

1.80 

5 

23 

D6 

86.0 

Base 

1.70 

4 

23 

D8 

90.0 

Head 

1.82 

5 

28 

Dg 

93-2 

Base 

1.78 

4 

25 

Average 

1-735 

3-6 

19-3 

TABLE  24 — DROP  TESTS, 

INGOT  ET9,   AVERAGE  SHRINKAGE,  7  IN. 

Per  Cent. 

Head  or 

Set 

No. 

Maximum 

Test 

From  Top 

Base  in 

I  St 

of 

Elongation        Remarks. 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

Blow. 

Blows. 

Per  Cent. 

ET9A2 

9-8 

Head 

Broke 

1 

4 

A3 

12.9 

Base 

1.63 

3 

8 

A5 

16.7 

Head 

1.78 

2 

10 

A6 

19.8 

Base 

1.71 

5 

22 

A8 

23.6 

Head 

1.76 

2 

17 

A9 

26.8 

Base 

1.72 

4 

20 

ET9B2 

30.5 

Head 

1-73 

4 

23                                        "| 

B3 

33-6 

Base 

1.65 

4 

18 

B5 

37-4 

Head 

1.72 

4 

21 

B6 

40.5 

Base 

i-75 

5 

18 

B8 

44-3 

Head 

1.71 

4 

24 

B9 

47-4 

Base 

i-75 

3 

18 

ET9C2 

54-2 

Head 

1.80 

4 

22 

c3 

57-3 

Base 

1.70 

5 

20 

C5 

61.1 

Head 

1.82 

4 

22 

C6 

643 

Base 

1.71 

4 

22 

C8 

68.0 

Head 

1.77 

4 

24 

C9 

71.2 

Base 

i-73 

5 

24 

ET9D2 

74-9 

Head 

1.92 

5 

31          Broke   at    support. 

D3 

78.0 

Base 

1.84 

5 

24          Not  broken. 

D5 

81.8 

Head 

1.85 

5 

29 

D6 

85.0 

Base 

1.85 

4 

26 

D8 

88.6 

Head 

1.86 

4 

34 

D9 

91.8 

Base 

1.86 

4 

25 

Average 

1.709 

3-9 

21. 1 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


815 


TABLE  25 — DROP  TESTS, 

INGOT  ETIO,    AVERAGE  SHRINKAGE,  7   IN. 

Per  Cent. 

Head  or 

Set 

No. 

Maximum 

Test 

From  Top 

Base  in 

ISt 

of 

Elongation         Remarks. 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

Blow. 

Blows 

.    Per  Cent. 

ET10A2 

11.0 

Head 

Broke 

1 

5 

A3 

14.1 

Base 

1.70 

2 

11 

A5 

17.9 

Head 

i-75 

2 

10 

A6 

21.0 

Base 

1.67 

3 

14 

A8 

24.8 

Head 

1.71 

2 

9 

Ag 

27.9 

Base 

1.78 

3 

16 

ET10B2 

31-7 

Head 

1.80 

4 

19 

B3 

34-8 

Base 

1.71 

5 

22 

B5 

38.6 

Head 

1.72 

3 

18 

B6 

41-7 

Base 

1.72 

5 

20 

B8 

45-5 

Head 

1.70 

4 

22 

Bo 

48.6 

Base 

1.76 

5 

20 

ET10C2 

55-2 

Head 

1.83 

4 

29 

C3 

58.3 

Base 

174 

3 

18 

C5 

62.1 

Head 

1.84 

5 

23          Not  broken. 

C6 

65-3 

Base 

1.83 

3 

15 

C8 

69.1 

Head 

1.83 

3 

22 

c9 

72.2 

Base 

1.78 

4 

24 

ET10D2 

76.0 

Head 

1.89 

3 

20 

D3 

79.1 

Base 

1.81 

5 

27         Broke   at    sup 

D5 

82.9 

Head 

1.86 

4 

36 

D6 

86.0 

Base 

1.86 

4 

26 

D8 

89.8 

Head 

1.86 

4 

33 

Do 

92.9 

Base 

1.83 

4 

22 

Average . 

1.784 

3.S 

20.0 

TABLE  26— AVERAGE  RESULTS   IN  DROP  TESTS. 


Per  Cent. 

Head  or 

Maximum 

Test 

From  Top 

Base  in 

Set 

Number 

Elongation 

Number. 

of  Ingot. 

Tension. 

1st  Blow. 

of  Blows. 

Per  Cent. 

A2 

9-5 

Head 

1. 805 

i-4 

7.0 

A3 

12.7 

Base 

1.682 

2.2 

11.4 

A5 

16.6 

Head 

1.696 

2.2 

11.8 

A6 

19.8 

Base 

1.682 

3-4 

16.4 

A8 

237 

Head 

1.698 

24 

14.2 

A9 

26.9 

Base 

1.700 

3-8 

18.6 

816 


RAIL. 


B2 

30.8 

Head 

1.720 

3-4 

17.6 

B3 

34-0 

Base 

'    1.676 

4-4 

20.4 

B5 

37-8 

Head 

1.726 

3-2 

17.8 

B6 

41. 1 

Base 

1.720 

4.2 

19.2 

B8 

45-0 

Head 

1.708 

3-4 

21.0 

B9 

48.2 

Base 

1.726 

4.4 

19.6 

C2 

54-5 

Head 

1.788 

3-6 

23.0 

C3 

577 

Base 

1.718 

3-4 

16.4 

C5 

61.6 

Head 

1.808 

4.0 

20.8 

C6 

64.8 

Base 

1-752 

4.0 

19.2 

C8 

68.7 

Head 

1.792 

3-6 

23.0 

c9 

7i-9 

Base 

I.7S8 

4.0 

18.8 

D2 

75-8 

Head 

1.832 

4.2 

27.6 

D3 

79.0 

Base 

T.776 

4-8 

25.6 

D5 

82.9 

Head 

1.820 

4.2 

25-4 

D6 

86.1 

Base 

1.798 

4.4 

23-4 

D8 

90.0 

Head 

1.818 

4.0 

29.0 

D9 

93-2 

Base 

1-794 

4.2 

23.6 

rage. .. 

•  -  -     1.750 

3-6 

19.6 

DUCTILITY  IN  DROP  TESTS. 

As  stated,  the  inch  space  which  stretched  most  at  failure  was  taken 
as  the  measure  of  ductility  of  the  piece  of  rail  tested,  and  the  elongation 
results  are  shown  in  Fig.  5.  One  set  of  diagrams  represents  the  results 
with  the  head  in  tension  and  the  other  set  with  the  base  in  tension,  the 
elongation  of  the  inch  which  stretched  most  being  represented  vertically 
and  the  distance  from  the  top  end  of  the  ingot  in  per  cent,  of  the  total 
weight  being  represented  horizontally.  It  will  be  noticed  that  in  general 
the  curves  for  the  various  rail-bars  fall  within  a  zone,  crossing  and  re- 
crossing  each  other  with  but  little,  if  any,  relationship  to  the  tempera- 
ture at  which  the  bars  were  rolled.  The  most  prominent  exceptions  are 
with  the  rail-bar  ET6  which  had  the  lowest  rolling  temperature,  and 
rail-bar  ET7  which  had  the  next  higher  rolling  temperature.  Considering 
the  results  with  the  head  in  tension  it  will  be  noticed  that  ET6  gave 
one  low  result  toward  the  lower  end  of  the  bar,  and  all  the  results  of) 
the  A  and  B  rails  of  ET7,  except  one,  showed  low  ductility.  With  the 
base  in  tension,  two  of  the  tests  of  the  C  rail  of  ET6  showed  much 
lower  elongation  than  the  average  and  fell  considerably  below  the  zone 
of  results. 

Whether  these  low  elongation  results  of  the  two  rail-bars  that  were 
rolled  at  the  lowest  temperatures  are  in  some  way  a  function  of  the 
lower  rolling  temperature,  cannot  be  determined  from  these  few  results, 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING   TEMPERATURE. 


817 


but  since  one  rail  from  each  of  these  bars  had  some  surface  flaws  sufficient 
to  classify  them  as  "No.  2"  rails,  the  query  naturally  arises  whether 
such  poor  ductility  results  and  the  surface  flaws  which  occurred  in  these 
rails    may   not   have  been   due   in    some  way  to   the   lower   rolling   tem- 

A 


40  60  80 

Pe-rce-nt    from   Top    of   Ingot 

Fig.  s — Ductility  of  Rails  in  Drop  Test  in  Relation  to  Distance  from 

Top  of  Ingot. 


818 


RAIL. 


perature.     Judgment  on  this  matter  must,  however,  be  withheld  until  we 
can  obtain  the  returns  from  more  extended  experience. 

In  order  to  show  the  average  ductility  in  more  convenient  form,  I 
give  Fig.  6,  showing  one  average  ductility  curve  for  the  head  tension 
results  and  another  for  the  base  tension  results.  Starting  at  10  per  cent, 
from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  the  elongation  with  the  head  in  tension  starts 
at  about  8  per  cent,  and  continuously  rises  as  we  go  down  the  ingot, 
reaching  about  21  per  cent,  at  00  per  cent,  from  the  top.  The  base 
tension  results  are  similar,  but  show  more  ductility  in  the  upper  part  of 


20  40  60  60 

Percent     from     Top    of    Ingot 

Fig.  6— Average  Ductility  in  Drop  Test  with  the  Head  in  Tension 
and  with  the  base  in  tension. 


the  ingot  and  less  in  the  lower  part,  starting  with  about  12  per  cent, 
at  12  per  cent,  from  the  top  and  reaching  about  24  per  cent,  at  90  per  cent, 
down.  The  ductility  also  seems  to  be  about  stationary,  for  the  space  be- 
tween 40  per  cent,  and  65  per  cent.,  although  this  feature  may  perhaps  be 
peculiar  to  this  lot  of  tests.  In  my  report  No.  19  on  the  influence  of  size  of 
ingot,  with  ingots  about  60  in.  high  the  minimum  ductility  was  found  at 
about  20  per  cent,  from  the  top,  but  in  this  case  with  an  ingot  about  51  in. 
high  the  ductility  increases  continuously  beyond  10  per  cent,  from  the 
top.  The  experiments,  unfortunately,  did  not  cover  material  closer  to 
the  top,  so  we  can  say  nothing  of  its  ductility  in  this  region. 

DEFLECTION. 

The  results  showing  the  permanent  deflection  or  set  on  the  first  blow 
under  18-ft.  drop  show  but  small  differences  between  the  different  rail-bars. 
Fig.  7  shows  the  average  deflection  curves  for  the  head  tension,  the  base 


INFLUENCE   OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


819 


tension  and  the  general  average  results,  the  set  on  the  first  blow  being 
shown  vertically  and  the  distance  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  in  per  cent,  of 
the  weight  being  shown  horizontally.  This  set  includes  the  local  indenta- 
tion caused  by  the  tup.  It  will  be  noted  that  starting  at  about  16  per  cent, 
the  average  set  is  1.69,  and  it  increases  continuously  to  1.81  in.  at  90  per 
cent,  down,  an  average  increase  of  about  7  per  cent.,  although  the  rate  of 
increase  varies  in  different  regions.  It  looks  also  as  if  the  deflection  is 
greater  closer  to  the  top  also,  but  the  data  are  insufficient  to  determine  this. 
The  set  with  the  head  in  tension  averages  about  .04  in.  greater  than  with 
the  base  in  tension. 


20  <{0  60 

Percent  /rom    Top  0/   Ingot 

Fig.  7 — Set  of  Rails  Under  i8-ft.  Drop. 


100 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE  IN  DROP  TEST. 

The  average  drop  test  results  of  the  24  test  pieces  from  each  rail-bar 
and  the  general  averages  for  all  the  rail-bars  are  shown  in  table  27  show- 
ing the  shrinkage,  set  after  the  first  blow,  number  of  blows  from  18  ft. 
that  it  took  to  break  the  rail  and  the  elongation  of  the  inch  that  stretched 
most  at  failure. 


TABLE    27 — GENERAL    AVERAGE    RESULTS    IN    DROP    TESTS. 

Shrinkage, 

Ingot.  inches. 

ET6    64-16 

ET7    68-16 

ET8 613-16 

ETo    7 

ET10    7 

Average   6  1 1— 16         1.750 


Set, 

Number 

Elongation 

1st  blow. 

of  blows. 

per  cent. 

I-73I 

3-5 

19.0 

1.728 

3-6 

18.7 

1-735 

3-6 

19-3 

1.769 

3-6 

21. 1 

1784 

3-5 

20.0 

3.6 


19.6 


820 


RAIL. 


These  results  are  shown  graphically  in  Fig.  8,  which  should  be  studied 
closely  in  connection  with  the  table  as  they  summarize  the  important 
points  brought  out  by  the  investigation  as  revealed  by  the  drop  tests.  Ac- 
cording to  these  results  the  temperature  at  which  the  rail's  are  rolled  has 
no  very  decided  influence  on  the  rails  as  developed  by  the  drop  test.  The 
average  set  for  each  rail-bar  is  the  average  of  24  test  pieces,  12  with  the 
head  in  tension  and  12  with  the  base  in  tension,  but  as  the  top  piece, 
which  was  tested  with  head  in  tension,  broke  on  three  of  the  rail-bars 
on  the  first  blow,  the  set  could  not  be  obtained,  and  for  obtaining  the 
average  was  assumed  to  be  1.81  in.,  the  average  of  the  two  which  did  not 
break  on  the  first  blow.     There  seems  to  be  a  very  slight  increase  of  de- 


20 

=^=f20 

fc 

elonotfte'on^ 

1      eg 

'    £> 

U6$ 

J* 

Mi     12 

0 
1 

0 

8 

.8*> 

K$ 

0  "S 

*$4 

.4 

77. 

*mber    0/     6Loims 

1        1 

> 

6*/«"  6*/,a"  6'W  7" 

S h  rink  age. 

Fig.  8 — Results  of  Drop  Test  in  Relation  to  Shrinkage. 

flection  as  the  temperature  increases,  but  the  differences  are  small,  rang- 
ing from  about  1.73  in.  to  178.  The  ductility  also  seems  to  increase  a 
little  as  the  temperature  rises,  the  averages  for  the  entire  rail-bars  rang- 
ing from  18.7  per  cent,  to  21. 1  per  cent.  The  average  ductility  of  the 
bars  with  the  lowest  rolling  temperatures  is  lowered  considerably  by  a  few 
very  low  results  on  those  bars.  The  number  of  blows  that  it  took  to 
break  the  rails,  or  the  accumulatied  foot-lbs.  of  work,  was  just  about  the 
same  for  the  different  rail  bars. 


TENSILE  TESTS. 

Three  tensile  tests  were  made  from  each  third  o\  a  rail  length  along 
each  of  the  rail-bars,  one  sample  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head  marked 


INFLUENCE.   OR   ROULTNG   TEMPERATURE. 


821 


a,  one  from  the  interior  of  head  near  the  web  marked  b,  and  one  from  the 
flange  marked  c,  as  shown  in  Fig.  9.  The  samples  from  the  corner  of  the 
head  and  the  flange  were  taken  from  the  side  that  was  uppermost  in 
rolling.  The  test  pieces  were  10  in.  long  turned  to  J/2  in.  diameter  for  a 
gage  length  of  2  in.  and  the  ends  were  Y  hi.  diameter.     The  tests  were 


■r-4 


\t~tv 


/o- 


'"^D/am. 


LD/am. 


-H 


-A    ," 


Tejf  P/ece  f#r  7e/?s//e  7?sf 

Fig.  9— Tensile  Test — Test  Piece  and  Locations. 


made  in  a  200,000  lb.  Olson  test  machine  and  the  pieces  were  held  with 
wedge  grips.  The  yield  point  was  determined  by  means  of  a  Capp's  mul- 
tiplying dividers.    The  results  of  the  tests  are  shown  in  tables  as  follows: 

Table  28  Yield  point. 

Table  29  Tensile  strength. 

Table  30  Elongation  in  2  in. 

Table  31  Reduction  of  area.  ! 

Table  32  Ratio  of  yield  point  to  tensile  strength.     \ 


822  RAIL. 

TABLE   28 — YIELD   POINT,   LBS.    PFR   SQ.    IN. 


per  cent. 

Test 

from 

Piece. 

Ingot  6. 

Ingot  7. 

Ingot  8. 

Ingot  9. 

Ingot  10. 

Average. 

top 

Aia 

68,170 

64,700 

64,300 

64,160 

65,210 

65,308 

7.6 

Aib 

65,820 

64,640 

65,360 

65,540 

63,980 

65,068 

Aic 

64,040 

66,940 

64,240 

66,000 

64,700 

65,184 

A4a 

66,740 

66,630 

65,260 

64,820 

63,840 

65,458 

14.7' 

A4b 

74,890 

72,960 

70,810 

73,630 

70,820 

72,622 

A4C 

68,040 

66,740 

68,265 

70,020 

67,300 

68,073 

A7a 

67,760 

66,020 

64,910 

65,280 

65,520 

65,898 

21.7 

A;b 

71,020 

68,770 

66,440 

65,780 

65,000 

67,402 

Aye 

69,280 

68,770 

78,610 

67,360 

67,500 

70,304 

Bia 

67,640 

66,380 

66,360 

67,910 

66,140 

66,886 

28.8 

Bib 

68,500 

67,250 

63,430 

70,555 

64,160 

66,77g 

Bic 

71,420 

67,740 

67,760 

68,470 

68,130 

68,704 

B4a 

68,420 

65,870 

66,020 

66,080 

64,140 

66,106 

35-9 

B4b 

62,710 

61,280 

62,680 

64,550 

63,580 

62,960 

B4C 

66,990 

77,860 

66,460 

68,060 

66,100 

69,094 

B7a 

64,395 

65,980 

66,480 

65,060 

64,500 

65,283 

43-0 

B7b 

63,040 

61,950 

62,920 

63,780 

62,200 

62,778 

B7C 

66,990 

68,830 

66,940 

67,140 

66,700 

67,320 

Cia 

66,820 

67,400 

68,740 

66,500 

65,360 

66,964 

52.6 

Cib 

61,130 

61,740 

62,120 

61,710 

61,340 

61,608 

Cic 

68,820 

68,880 

67,980 

67,780 

77,890 

70,270 

C4a 

66,690 

66,120 

65,090 

64,280 

65,270 

65,670 

59-7 

C4b 

60,630 

60,220 

61,000 

60,040 

60,420 

60,462 

C4C 

70,450 

66,740 

68,740 

67,020 

67,350 

68,060 

C7a 

67,760 

67,260 

64,480 

65,210 

64,300 

65,802 

66.8 

C7b 

62,020 

61,790 

60,340 

60,120 

58,590 

60,572 

C7C 

69,180 

67,200 

67,920 

68,100 

67,400 

67,960 

Dia 

64,500 

65,060 

66,630 

63,950 

64,800 

64,988 

73-8 

Dib 

63,940 

61,800 

60,800 

59,98o 

58,440 

60,992 

Die 

68,370 

69,815 

68,640 

66,450 

66,160 

67,887 

D4a 

66,410 

65,920 

65,390 

64,230 

64,450 

65,280 

80.9 

D4b 

62,150 

60,220 

59,720 

58,500 

57,960 

59,7io 

D4C 

66,940 

67,350 

65,690 

65,900 

65,58o 

66,292 

D7a 

66,940 

66,940 

65,130 

65,120 

63,340 

65,494 

86.7 

D7b 

60,880 

61,140 

60,520 

57,600 

57,060 

59,440 

D7C 

64,060 

67,240 

66,140 

66,240 

63,900 

65,696 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


823 


TABLE  29 — TENSILE   STRENGTH,   LBS.    PER   SQ.   IN. 


Average 
per  cent. 

Test 

from 

Piece. 

Ingot  6.     Ingot  7.       3 

ngot  8.     Ingot  9.     Ingot  10.    Average. 

top. 

Ala 

114,010       i 

13,350 

[13,910 

[16,450 

115,020 

[14,548 

7.6 

Aib 

117,010      ] 

16,325 

[19,920 

[26,550      ] 

19,105 

[19,782 

Aic 

114,480      i 

15,025      i 

12,530       ] 

15,680       ] 

19,200 

[15,383 

A4a 

121,250 

[  18,200 

[16,500 

[16,450 

[18,400 

[18,160 

14-7 

A4b 

129,800      i 

22,520 

15,800 

13,700 

[16,600 

[19,684 

A4C 

117,250      ] 

20,390      i 

18,600       ] 

19,540      ] 

20,300 

19,216 

A7a 

121,750      ] 

16,820      1 

19,080 

19,250      ] 

18,000 

[19,340 

21.7 

A7b 

129,400      ] 

20,640 

[28,400 

20,300 

109,800 

[21,708 

A7C 

1 18,200 

[18,500 

[23,500 

[21,660 

[22,  IOO 

[20,792 

Bia 

121,680      ] 

19,450 

[18,300 

20,220 

[l8,700 

[19,668 

28.8 

Bib 

123,950      i 

26,350      i 

20,630       i 

22,700       ] 

23,730        1 

23,472 

Bic 

118,880      ] 

22,600 

[21,500      ] 

25,830      ] 

2I,800 

22,122 

B4a 

117,780      ] 

19,150 

[18,700 

[18,800 

[  18,  IOO 

[18,506 

35-9 

B4b 

114,580      ] 

14,310      i 

17,080       ] 

18,65c      i 

22,750 

17,474 

B4c 

120,020      ] 

20,810      ] 

21,070       ] 

21,150      ] 

22,500 

21,110 

B7a 

117,780      ] 

16,660 

[18,190 

[18,700 

[21,750 

[  18,816 

43-0 

B7b 

1 16,250      ] 

14,580 

15,640      i 

16,650      ] 

17,200 

[16,064 

B7C 

121,040      ] 

18,500      i 

20,380      i 

20,840      i 

21,250 

20,402 

Cia 

116,610       ] 

17,900 

17,880      ] 

i7,95o 

18,850 

[17,838 

52.6 

Cib 

116,750       1 

12,940 

[14,050 

16,450 

[I7,IOO 

15,458 

Cic 

108,000      ] 

19,100 

23,010      i 

25,170 

22,900 

19,636 

C4a 

117,780      ] 

17,180 

[  18,660 

18,450 

[l8,4IO 

[18,096 

59-7 

C4b 

1 12,780      ] 

14,080      i 

14,350       i 

13,250      i 

18,400 

[14,572 

C4C 

H9,350 

120,280 

[23,070 

[22,300 

[22,110 

21,422 

C7a 

116,090      ] 

18,290 

[  16,500 

120,490 

[  l8,200 

[17,914 

66.8 

C7b 

112,480       ] 

14,780 

[12,830      ] 

14,620      i 

13,450 

[13,632 

C7C 

1 19,290      ] 

20,830 

21,560 

[23,740 

[23,050 

[21,694 

Dia 

1 16,560        ! 

[16,550 

[17,780 

[19,600 

[  19,400 

[17,978 

73-8 

Dib 

113,040 

12,220 

[12,530 

[12,750 

[14,550 

[13,018 

Die 

117,420        I 

18,470 

[20,010 

21,700 

22,250 

19,970 

D4a 

II9,O20        j 

16,910 

[18,400      ] 

18,690 

[17,350 

1 18,074 

80.9 

D4b 

II3,IOO 

[  10,800 

[12,190 

[11,850 

11,400 

[11,868 

D4C 

119,160 

[18,250 

[21,090 

[22,000 

[19,450 

[19,990 

D7a 

117,820 

[16,870 

17,700 

[18,560 

[17,950 

[17,780 

86.7 

D7b 

1 10,800     s 

11,820 

12,200      ] 

09,660 

U9,350 

[12,766 

D7C 

"5,790 

[17,180 

1 17,690 

r  20,660 

17,850        ) 

[17,834 

824  RAIL. 

TABLE  30 — ELONGATION,    PER   CENT.    IN    2   IN. 


Average 
per  cent, 
from 


Test 

Piece.  Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  0.  Ingot  10.  Average,     top. 

Aia            18.5  15  15.5            16.5             9  14.9  m 

Aib            17.5  15  9              15                5  12-3 

Aic            18.5  IS  10              l6-5            *4  H-8 


A4a 

16.5 

19 

15 

11 

17-5 

15-8 

14.7 

A4b 

5 

5-5 

4 

3 

4 

4-3 

A4C 

14 

17-5 

12.5 

10.5 

15 

13-9 

A7a 

16 

17 

18 

18 

17-5 

17-3 

21.7 

A7b 

IS 

5 

10.5 

6 

4-5 

8.2 

A7C 

17 

16.5 

17 

17-5 

16.5 

16.9 

Bia 

17 

18 

16 

17 

16 

16.8 

28.8 

Bib 

14 

15 

14 

6 

10 

11.8 

Bic 

16.5 

18 

IS 

16 

14 

1 5-9 

B4a 

19 

18.5 

15-5 

15-5 

17.5 

17.2 

35-9 

B4b 

19 

10 

16 

8 

12 

13 

' 

B4C 

18.5 

18.5 

16 

15 

17 

17 

B7a 

18.5 

16.5 

16 

15 

17 

16.6 

43-0 

B7b 

18 

14 

15-5 

6 

11 

12.9 

B7C 

18 

17 

15-5 

16 

17 

16.7 

Cia 

17 

16.5 

16 

18 

17.5 

17.0 

52.6 

Cib 

18 

17 

16.5 

17-5 

17-5 

17-3 

Cic 

17 

15-5 

17 

16 

17-5 

16.6 

C4a 

18.5 

18.5 

18.5 

18 

18 

18.3 

59-7 

C4b 

20 

19-5 

i4S 

18.5 

17 

17.9 

C4C 

17-5 

18 

17 

16.5 

16 

17.0 

■ 

C7a 

17 

18 

18.5 

17 

17-5 

17.6 

66.8 

<C7b 

16 

18 

18 

18 

19 

17.8 

C7C 

16 

14-5 

17 

17 

17 

16.3 

Dia 

17 

16.5 

16.5 

16.5 

17.5 

16.8 

738 

Dib 

16.5 

17 

16 

17 

18.5 

17 

Die 

16.5 

17 

16 

17-5 

17-5 

16.9 

D4a 

19 

19 

17-5 

18 

17-5 

18.2 

80.9 

D4b 

19 

19 

18.5 

18 

18 

18.7 

' 

D4C 

19 

19 

17 

16.5 

17-5 

17.8 

D7a 

18.5 

19 

18 

18 

18.5 

18.4 

86.7 

D7b 

19-5 

18.5 

18 

18.5 

18.5 

18.6 

D7C 

19-5 

19 

J8.5 

18 

18.5 

18.7 

INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.  825 

TABLE   31 — REDUCTION    OF   AREA,    PER    CENT. 

Average 
per  cent. 
Test  from 

Piece.  Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  9.  Ingot  10.    Average,      top. 

Aia  30.8  15.7  21.9  23.7  7.8  19.98          7.6 

Aib  28.4  21.5  23.9  20.1  4.3  19-64 

Aic  27.8  19-0  9-7  22.5  16.5  19- 10 

A4a  26.7  30.8  20.8  8.2  23.3  21.96        147 

A4D  40  3-2  2.3  2.4  3.2              3.02 

A4C  14.6  31.4  12.7  10.1  19.8  17.72 

A7a    -  25.0  25.1  29.1  27.8  25.4  26.48        21.7 

A7D  9.7  5.1  10.9  6.0  3.6             7.06 

A7C  24.0  25.0  26.0  25.5  25.7  25.22 

Bia  23.7  34.4  23.3  23.6  20.5  25.10        28.8 

Bib  16.4  31.4  29.0  5.2  7.5  17.90 

Bic  21.9  31.5  21.2  23.6  20.8  23.80 

64a  35.1  30.8  22.9  19.7  28.0  27.30        35-9 

B4b  34.4  9.0  21.2  7.8  10.9  16.66 

B4C  35.0  36  21.9  19.7  27.5  21.54 

B7a  34.1  22.9  22.6  20.8  24.7  25.02        43.0 

B7b  30.5  25.7  20.8  52  9-8  18.04 

B7C  28.4  23.6  21.5  19.0  25.4  23.58 

Cia  27.5  24.5  21.9  31.5  27.1  26.5          52.6 

Cib  30.1  26.4  23.6  24.7  26.1  26.18 

Cic  25.0  14.3  25.4  23.6  25.8  22.82 

C4a  341  321  30.8  28.5  18.7  28.84        59.7 

C4b  347  33-1  23.3  30.8  22.6  28.00 

C4C  32.4  28.4  23.6  25.8  27.4  27.52 

C7a  24.7  31.0  30.2  24.3  28.5  25.74        66.8 

C7b  19.8  29.8  26.4  25.0  28.8  25.96 

C7C  24.4  28.4  26.4  22.6  24.3  25.22 

Dia  ,  26.7  25.4  24.0  25.8  28.2  26.02        73.8 

Dib  24.3  24.7  21.9  25.7  27.1  24.74 

Die  24.3  24.0  21.9  25.1  24.3  27.92 

D4a...  29.2  32.8  29.8  28.8  25.7  29.26        80.9 

D4b  27.1  30.8  25.4  26.1  27.4  27.36 

D4C  28.1  31.8  25.8  26.4  26.4  27.70 

F>7a  35-4  347  29.5  28.5  27.4  31.10        86.7 

D7b  31.4  27.8  27.1  30.5  28.0  28.96 

D7c  347  31-8  29.0  28.5  31.2  31.04 


826  RAIL. 

TABLE   32 — RATIO   YIELD    POINT   TO   TENSILE  STRENGTH,    PER    CENT. 

Average 
per  cent. 
Test  from 

Piece.      Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.     Ingot  9.  Ingot  10.    Average,      top. 

Aia  59.8  57.0  56.5  55-1  56.6  57               7.6 

Aib  55-3  55-6  54-5  5i-7  57-9  55 

Aic  56.1  58.2  57-1  57-1  54-3  56.56 

A4a  55-i  56.3  56.7  55-6  53-9  55-52        14.7 

A4D  57.8  59.6  61.2  64.8  60.7  60^2 

A4C  58.1  55-4  57-5  58.5  55-9  57.08 

A7a  55-7  56-5  54 1  54-7  56.0  55.40        21.7 

A7b  55-0  57-i  5i-7  54.2  59,2  55-44 

A7C  5&-6  58.0  63.6  55-2  55-2  58.12 

Bia  55-6  55-6  56.1  56.4  55-6  55-86        28.8 

Bib  55-2  53-2  52,6  57-6  51.8  54-o8 

Bic  60.2  55-2  55-8  544  56.0  56.32 

B4a  582  53-2  55-7  55<6  54*6  55-46        35-9 

B4b  54-8  53-6  53-5  54-4  51-8  53-62 

B4C  55-6  64.5  54-8  56,2  54.0  57.02 

B7a.  54-7  56.6  56.2  54-9  53-0  55-08        430 

B7b  54,3  54-1  54-4  54-8  53$  54-14 

B7c  55-3  58.0  55-5  55-8  55-0  55-92 

Cia  57-3  57-2  58.3  56-3  54-9  56.80        52.6 

Cib  52.4  54-7  54-5  53-0  52-3  53-38 

Cic  63.7  57-8  55-2  54-i  63.4  58.84 

C4a  56.7  56.3  55-6  54-2  55- 1  55-58        59-7 

C4b  53-8  52-8  53-3  53-0  51.0  52.78 

C4C  58.9  55-3  55  8  54-8  55- 1  55-98 

C7a  58.3  56.8  55-3  54- 1  54-4  55-78        66.8 

C7b  55-2  53.8  53-5  52-5  5i-6  53-32 

C7c  580  55-6  55-8  55-0  54-7  55-88 

Dia  55-3  55-7  56,6  53-5  54-2  55-06        73-8 

Dib  55-6  S5-0  54-0  53-2  510  53-76 

Die  58.2  58.9  57.1  54.7  540  56.58 

D4a  55-8  563  55-2  54- 1  54-9  55-26        80.9 

D4b  54-9  54-3  53-2  52.3  52.Q  53-35 

D4C  56.1  56.9  54-2  54-0  54-9  55-22 

D7a  56.8  57-2  55-4  55-Q  53-7  55-62        86.7 

D7b  54-9  547  54-4  52-7  47-8  52.00 

D7C  56.2  57-3  56.2  55-Q  54-2  55-78 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


827 


The  average  results  of  the  five  rail-bars  are  shown  in  Fig.  10,  plotted 
in  relation  to  their  distance  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  the  distance  from 
the  top  in  per  cent,  being  shown  horizontally  and  the  various  results  of 
yield  point,  tensile  strength,  elongation  and  reduction  of  area,  being  shown 
vertically.  It  will  be  noted  that  in  the  samples  from  the  corner  of  the 
head  and  from  the  flange  the  yield  point  and  the  tensile  strength  are  about 
uniform  along  the  length  of  the  bar,  with  perhaps  a  slight  upward  tend- 
ency down  to  about  20  per  cent,  from  the  top.     The  yield  point  and  the 


l25,oo« 

■ft  . 

>>«>  ^100,000 

SJ0J  to**** 


50,< 


y    *  I  25 

3»k  k 


20 


ft 

-S^  ft 

<5  ft.  "" 


15 


10 


Xi 


w 


—  d,  corner    of    head. 

"t>>  LTiterior  of  head. 

C,  fLang& 


20  4  0  60  80  100 

Percent     from     Top    of    Ingot 

Fig.   10 — Average  Results  of  Tensile  Tests  in  Relation  to  Distance 
from  Top  of  Ingot. 


tensile  strength  of  the  samples  from  the  flange  average  about  2,000  lbs. 
more  than  those  from  the  corner  of  the  head,  the  yield  point  averaging 
about  68,000  and  66,000  lbs.,  respectively,  and  the  tensile  strength  about 
120,000  and  118,000  lbs.,  respectively.  The  samples  from  the  interior 
of  the  head,  however,  do  not  show  uniform  yield  point  and  tensile 
strength  along  the  bar,  These  at  first  increase  in  the  upper  part  of 
the  ingot  to  above  the  results  from  the  corner  of  the  head  and  the 
flange  and,  in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  they  are  less,  corresponding 
in  a  general  way  to  the  distribution  of  the  hardening  element,  carbon  and 
phosphorus 


828  RAIL. 

The  elongation  and  reduction  of  area  of  the  samples  from  the  corner  of 
the  head  and  the  flange  increase  continuously  in  a  general  way  as  we  go 
down  the  ingot,  and  the  samples  from  the  corner  of  the  head  run  a 
little  higher  in  both  properties  than  those  from  the  flange.  In  the 
corner  of  the  head  the  elongation  runs  from  about  15  per  cent,  in  2 
in.  at  10  per  cent,  down,  to  about  iSy2  per  cent,  at  85  per  cent,  down,  and 
in  the  flange  it  runs  about  one  per  cent,  lower.  The  reduction  of  area 
in  the  corner  of  the  head  runs  from  about  21  per  cent,  at  10  per  cent, 
down,  to  about  30  per  cent,  at  85  per  cent,  down,  and  in  the  flange  it 
averages  about  2  per  cent,  less  in  the  upper  part  of  the  ingot  but  about 
the  same  in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot.  In  the  interior  of  the  head  the 
elongation  and  reduction  of  area  start  about  the  same  at  8  per  cent,  down 
as  in  the  other  locations,  but  they  fall  off  to  only  a  few  per  cent,  at  about 
15  per  cent,  down,  after  which  they  again  rise,  and  for  the  lower  half  of 
the  ingot  are  about  the  same  as  in  the  corner  of  the  head  and  the  flange, 
or  a  little  higher. 

The  averages  of  the  12  results  from  each  section  location  of  each  of 
the  rail-bars  and  the  general  average  of  the  36  results  from  each  rail-bar 
are  shown  in  table  as  follows: 

Table  33  Yield  point. 

Table  34  Tensile  strength. 

Table  35  Elongation  in  2  in. 

Table  36  Reduction  of  area. 

Table  37  Ratio  of  yield  point  to  tensile  strength. 

TABLE  33 — AVERAGE    YIELD    POINTS. 

Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  9.  Ingot  10.  Average. 

Corner  of  head..   66,853  66,190  65,807  65,233  64,739        65,761 

Interior  of  head.  .  63,060  64,420  63,011  63,482  61,962        63,366 

Flange    67,956  68,675  68,115  67,388  67,392        67,903 

General    average..  66,512  66,150  65,644  65,359  64,698        65,677 

TABLE    34 — AVERAGE    TENSILE    STRENGTHS. 

Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  9.  Ingot  10.  Average. 

Corner   of   head.  .118,177  117,277  117,708  118,634  118,427       118.059 

Interior  of  head.. 117,495  ? 15,947  116,301  116,427  116,952       116,624 

Flange    117,421  119,161  120,329  121,689  121,230       119,964 

General    average..  11 7,698  117,461  118,110  118,916  118,869       118,216 

TABLE    35 — AVERAGE    ELONGATIONS,    PER    CENT.    IN    2    IN. 

Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  9.  Ingot  10.  Average. 
Corner   of  head..  17.70          17.62          16.75          16.54          16.75  17.07 

Interior  of  head.. 16.45  14-45  14-20  12.62  12.91  14-15 

Flange    17-32  17-12  15.70  16.08  16.45  16.54 

General    average.. 17.16  16.40  15.55  15.08  15.37  15-92 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


829 


28.35 

25-56 

25.10 

2377 

26.10 

22.37 

21.31 

1745 

16.60 

20.36 

24.40 

22.09 

22.70 

24-59 

24-43 

25.04 

22.99 

21.75 

21.67 

2363 

TABLE    36 AVERAGE    REDUCTIONS    OF    AREA. 

Ingot  6.      Ingot  7.      Ingot  8.     Ingot  9.     Ingot  10.  Average. 
Corner  of  head.  .29.33 
Interior  of  head.. 24.23 

Flange    26.71 

General    average.. 26.78 

TABLE  37 — AVERAGE  RATIOS  OF  YIELD  POINT  TO  TENSILE  STRENGTH. 

Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.     Ingot  9.     Ingot  10.  Average. 

Corner   of   head.  .56.44  56.22  55.97 

Interior  of  head.. 54.93  54-87  54-23 

Flange     57-91  57-59  56-55 

General    average. .  56.48  56.24  55.58 

1 2.5,ooo 
^  > 

So  r^c- 

Oj  C0«O  75,000 


54-95 

54-74 

55-70 

54-51 

53-35 

54-37 

55-4Q 

55-55 

56.60 

54-95 

54-56 

55-50 

•Corner   c J-  head,  a. 
Interior  of  head,  6> 


' /•  ta.77cjre, 


Fig.   11- 


6"//6  6®/©  .6  ,s//6  7 

Shrinkage* 

-Results  of  Tensile  Tests  in  Relation  to  Shrinkage. 


830 


RAIL. 


The  average  results  of  each  of  the  three  section  locations  are  plotted 
in  Fig.  ii  in  relation  to  temperature  of  rolling,  the  shrinkage  in  a  33-ft. 
rail  being  plotted  horizontally,  and  the  yield  point,  tensile  strength,  elonga- 
tion and  reduction  of  area  being  plotted  vertically.  It  will  be  noted 
that  the  yield  point  seems  not  to  be  influenced  by  the  temperature  of 
rolling.  The  tensile  strength  is  likewise  not  influenced,  except  that  the 
flange  seems  to  increase  a  little  in  tensile  strength  as  the  shrinkage  or 
temperature  of  rolling  increases.  The  elongation  of  the  corner  of  the 
head  and  of  the  flange  decreases  a  little  as  the  rolling  temperature  in- 
crease*. The  decrease  of  elongation  in  the  interior  of  the  head  is  more, 
ranging  from  about  16.5  per  cent,  in  2  in.  at  6  4-16  in.  shrinkage,  to 
about  12.8  per  cent,  at  7  in.  shrinkage.  The  influence  of  the  rolling 
temperature  is  seen  most  prominently,  however,  in  the  reduction  of  area 
which  decreases  as  the  temperature  increases.  The  range  in  the  corner 
of  the  head  is  from  about  29.3  per  cent,  at  6  4-16  in.  shrinkage  down 
to  about  24J/2  per  cent,  at  7  in.  shrinkage,  in  the  flange  from  about 
26.7  per  cent,  to  about  23.7  per  cent.,  and  in  the  interior  of  the  head 
from  about  24.2  per  cent,  to  about  17  per  cent. 

DUCTILITY  IN  DROP  TESTS  AND  TENSION  TESTS 
COMPARED. 

A  comparison  of  the  ductility  of  the  rails  as  measured  in  the  drop 
test  and  in  the  tension  test,  is  interesting,  and  Fig.   12  is  given,  showing 


20  40  60 

Percent    from    Top    0/  Ingot 
Fig.  12 — Ductility  in  Drop  Test  and  Tension  Test  Compared. 


the   comparison,  the  distance   from  the  top  of  the  ingot  in  per  cent,  of 
weight  being  plotted  horizontally  and  the  per  cent,  elongation  vertically. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.      831 

The  curves  of  the  average  elongation  in  the  head  tension  and  in  the 
base  tension  tests  are  reproduced  as  representing  the  ductility  in  the 
drop  test.  The  curve  showing  the  average  elongation  in  tension  of  the 
samples  from  the  interior  of  the  head  and  another  curve  showing  the 
average  of  the  samples  from  the  corner  of  the  head  and  from  the  flange, 
are  given  as  representing  the  ductility  as  measured  in  the  tension  test. 
In  the  tension  test  the  elongation  is  measured  on  a  test  piece  J^  in. 
diameter  and  in  a  gage  length  of  2  in.,  and  includes  the  local  necking 
down  where  fracture  occurs.  In  the  drop  test  the  elongation  is  measured 
in  a  gage  length  of  I  in.,  this  being  the  inch  of  six  i-in.  spaces  which 
stretches  most  at  fracture.  Observation  of  the  fractures  in  the  drop 
test  has  shown  that  the  fracture  generally  starts  at  some  point  within 
the  section  and  not  at  the  outside  where  the  greatest  stretching  occurs. 
In  tests  with  the  head  in  tension,  with  rail  from  the  upper  and  segrej 
part  of  the  ingot,  the  fracture  generally  starts  in  the  interior  of  the 
head  well  down  toward  the  web,  but  with  rail  from  the  lower  part  of 
the  ingot  the  fracture  starts  nearer  to  the  top  surface,  or  sometimes  it 
may  start  at  the  surface,  where  the  material  is  stretched  most.  In  tests 
with  the  base  in  tension  the  results  are  of  a  similar  nature,  although 
they  do  not  show  up  as  prominently  because  the  base  is  thinner,  and 
also  possibly  because  the  segregated  metal  is  closer  to  the  neutral  axis 
and  may  not  influence  the  result  so  readily.  In  other  words,  the  initial 
point  of  the  fracture  in  the  drop  test  generally  occurs,  not  where  the 
greatest  stretching  occurs,  but  internally  at  some  point  of  lower  ductility. 

In  the  tension  test,  the  exterior  metal  as  represented  by  the  flange  and 
the  corner  of  the  head,  shows  good  ductility  along  the  whole  rail-bar, 
although  there  is  a  general  increase  as  we  go  down  the  ingot  from  about 
14^2  per  cent,  elongation  in  2  in.  at  10  per  cent,  from  the  top,  to  about 
18J/2  per  cent,  elongation  at  90  per  cent.  down.  The  results  from  the 
interior  of  the  head  near  the  web,  however,  differ  considerably  from 
these,  and  while  there  is  fair  ductility  near  the  top,  the  elongation  drops 
off  to  less  than  5  per  cent,  at  about  15  per  cent,  from  the  top.  It  then 
rises  again  and  in  the  lower  part  of  the  rail-bar  averages  slightly  above 
the  results  from  the  exterior  of  the  section. 

In  the  drop  test,  with  the  base  in  tension,  the  elongation,  as  measured 
in  this  test,  runs  from  12  per  cent,  to  24  per  cent,  between  the  limits 
mentioned  above  along  the  rail-bar.  With  the  head  in  tension  there  is 
also  a  continuous  increase  in  the  same  part  of  the  rail-bar,  but  the 
differences  in  elongation  are  much  greater,  ranging  from  8  per  cent,  to 
27  per  cent.  In  this  respect  there  is  considerable  similarity  between  the 
ductility  of  the  interior  metal  as  measured  in  the  tension  test  of  samples 
from  the  interior  of  the  head  and  the  ductility  as  measured  in  the  drop 
test  with  the  head  in  tension.  It  would  seem,  therefore,  that  this  latter 
test  may  be  more  useful  to  ascertain  the  ductility  of  the  interior  metal 


832  RAIL. 

than   the   drop   test   with   the  base   in   tension,   as   is    usual    in  inspection 
work. 


MICROSTRUCTURE. 

Microphotographs  were  made  of  the  etched  ends  of  the  three  tensile 
test  p:'eces  from  the  top  end  of  each  rail.  The  pieces  were  polished, 
etched  with  nitric  acid  and  magnified  50  diameters  in  the  photographs. 
In  Figs.  13  to  27,  inclusive,  are  reproduced  the  etched  cross-section  s~" 
from  the  top  end  of  the  C  rail  of  each  of  the  five  ingots.  Figs.  13  to 
17,  inclusive,  show  the  cross-sections  from  the  upper  corner  of  the  head 
from  the  "top"  side,  that  is,  the  side  that  was  uppermost  in  rolling, 
Figs.  18  to  22,  inclusive,  those  from  the  interior  of  the  head,  and  Figs. 
23  to  27,  inclusive,  those  from  the  "top"  flange.  These  photographs  show 
the  grains  of  "pearlite"  inclosed  in  the  web  of  "ferrite,"  and,  in  general, 
the  grains  are  smallest  in  the  flange,  somewhat  larger  in  the  corner  of  the 
head  and  largest  in  the  interior  of  the  head.  The  main  purpose  of  the 
microscopic  tests  was  to  determine  the  influence  of  the  rolling  tempera- 
ture on  grain  size,  and  table  38  is  given,  showing  the  approximate  num- 
ber of  grains  per  .001  sq.  in.  of  cross-section  for  each  of  the  60  samples 
examined. 

TABLE  38 — GRAINS  PER  .001  SQ.  IN. 

Test  Piece.   Ingot  6.  Ingot  7.  Ingot  8.  Ingot  g.  Ingot  10.  Average. 

Aia  120     80     50     45     50  69 

Bia  100     95     75     45     35  70 

Cia  100    100     50     80     90  84 

Dia  80     60     60     60     50  62 

Average  ..100     84     59     58     56      71 

Aib  55  55  40  -20  20  38 

Bib  30  25  25  18  20  24 

Cib  100  85  45  40  25  59 

Dib  50  50  35  25  20  36 

Average  .  .  59     54     36     26     21      39 

Aic  180  140  100  85  85  118 

Bic  150  100  50  45  50  79 

Cic  140  100  90  50  50  86 

Die  80  70  40  40  40  54 

Average  ..138    103     70     55     56      84 
Gen.  Ave...  99     80     55     46     44     65 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.      833 


Fig.  13— Ingot  6,  Shrinkage  6%  in.      Fig.  14— Ingot  7,  Shrinkage  6l/2  in. 


Fig.  15 — Ingot  8,  Shrinkage  6  13-16  in. 


Fig.  16 — Ingot  9,  Shrinkage  7  in.  Fig.  17— Ingot  10,  Shrinkage  7  in. 

Cross  Section  Microphotographs  from  the  Upper  Corner  of  the  Head 
of  the  Rail,  from  the  "Top"  Side  or  Side  Uppermost  in  Rolling.  Top 
End  of  C  Rail.    Etched  with  Nitric  Acid  and  Magnified  50  Diameters. 


SCiB 


7  C  i  B 


Fig.  18— Ingot  6,  Shrinkage  6^4  in.       Fig  19— Ingot  7,  Shrinkage  6^2  in. 


Fig.  20 — Ingot  8.  Shrinkage  6  13-16  in. 


Fig.  21 — Ingot  9,  Shrinkage  7  in.  Fig.  22 — Ingot  10,  Shrinkage  7  in. 

Cross  Section  Microphotographs  from  the  Interior  of  the  Head  of 
the  Rail  near  Its  Junction  with  the  Web.  Top  End  of  C  Rail.  Etched 
with  Nitric  Acid  and  Magnified  50  Diameters. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE. 


835 


•C\s4 


Fig.  23 — Ingot  6,  Shrinkage  6J4  in-       Fig.  24 — Ingot  7,  Shrinkage  6l/i  in. 


Fig.  25 — Ingot  8,  Shrinkage  6  13-16  in. 


Fig.  26 — Ingot  9,  Shrinkage  7  in. 


Fig.  27 — Ingot  10,  Shrinkage  7  in. 


Cross  Section  Microphotographs  from  the  Flange  of  the  Rail,  from 
the  "Top"  Side  or  Side  Uppermost  in  Rolling.  Top  End  of  C  Rail. 
Etched  with  Nitric  Acid  and  Magnified  50  Diameters. 


836 


RAIL. 


The  average  results  for  the  four  rails  of  each  ingot  are  plotted  in 
Fig.  28,  the  shrinkage  being  shown  horizontally  and  the  number  of  grains 
per  .001  sq.  in.  vertically,  for  each  of  the  three  locations  in  the  section. 
It  will  be  noted  that  as  the  rolling  temperature  increases,  the  number 
of  grains  per  unit  of  area  of  cross-section  decreases ;  that  is,  the  size 
of  the  grain  increases.  In  the  flange  the  number  of  grains  per  .001 
sq.   in.   runs   from    138,   in  ingot  6,  with  the   lowest  rolling  temperature, 

160 


£*I20 

fiangQ 

1 

*^ 

<>j£    corner 

1       < 
t>  80 

?/  head 

■' 

^r— ^  * 

«0 

.£40 

z* 

0 

interior 

of  head 

II 

6*/,4'  <?«//«"  6'V/6 

Shrinkage. 

Fig.  28 — Size  of  Grain   in  Relation  to   Shrinkage. 


rpO 


down  to  55  or  56  where  the  temperature  was  hottest.  In  the  corner 
of  the  head  the  range  is  from  100  down  to  56,  and  in  the  interior  of  the 
head  from  59  to  21. 


SUMMARY. 

1.  A  series  of  five  ingots  from  one  heat  of  Bessemer  steel  was  rolled 
into  85  rails,  all  in  a  similar  manner,  except  as  to  the  temperature  at 
which  they  were  rolled.  One  ingot  was  rolled  ''cold"  and  the  tempera- 
ture was  increased  with  the  succeeding  ingots,  finally  rolling  the  last 
ingot  very  hot.  The  ingots  were  about  18^2  x  19^  in.  at  the  bottom, 
about  51  in.  high  and  weighed  about  4,400  lbs.  each.  After  soaking  in 
the  usual  manner,  the  ingots  were  rolled  into  blooms  about  9^2  in. 
square  and  a  smaller  discard  than  usual  made  from  the  top.  Each 
bloom  was  then  cut  in  two,  the  two  parts  reheated  at  the  same  time, 
and  were  rolled  into  85-lb.  P.  S.  section  rails  (Pennsylvania  Railroad 
System),  four  rails  being  made  from  each  ingot.  In  addition  one  ingot 
of  the  same  heat  was  used  for  splitting  open  and  making  a  chemical  sur- 
vey, this  ingot  having  been  placed  in  the  soaking  pit  and  then  cooled 
down.    This  work  was  all  done  at  the  works  of  the  Carnegie  Steel  Com 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.  837 

pany,   who  kindly   furnished  all   the   material   and   facilities   for  the  test 
work. 

2.  The  rails  were  examined  hy  means  of  drop,  tensile  and  micro- 
scopic tests.  The  comparison  ingot  was  split  open  to  determine  the  in- 
terior condition  as  regards  cavities,  and  analyses  were  made  of  about 
75  samples  from  one  side  of  a  longitudinal  section  near  the  axis  to  de- 
termine the  distribution  of  the  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur. 

3.  The  shrinkage  after  sawing  varied  from  6%  in.  in  a  33-ft.  rail, 
as  the  average  of  ihe  four  rails  from  a  whole  rail-bar,  to  7  in.  The 
temperature  of  the  head  of  the  rail  just  after  leaving  the  finishing  rolls, 
determined  by  a  heat  radiation  pyrometer,  varied  from  940  deg.  C.  to 
1,030  deg.  C,  a  range  of  90  deg.  C. 

4.  The  upper  15  per  cent,  of  the  comparison  ingot  was  spongy  with 
blow  holes  generally  distributed,  and  the  central  cavity  extended  down- 
ward about  one-third  way  from  the  top. 

5.  The  axis  of  the  ingot  showed  considerable  segregation  of  the 
carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur,  reaching  a  maximum  at  about  15  per  cent 
by  distance  from  the  top.  The  maximum  increases  found  were  72  per 
cent,  in  carbon,  98  per  cent,  in  phosphorus  and  79  per  cent,  in  sulphur, 
above  the  average  content  of  the  ingot.  The  axis  also  showed  a  little 
negative  segregation  in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot. 

6.  The  walls  or  outer  part  of  the  section  showed  negative  segrega- 
tion at  the  top  part  of  the  ingot  for  a  distance  of  about  15  or  20  per 
cent,  down,  after  which  the  composition  is  about  the  average  to  the  bottom 
of  the  ingot.  The  greatest  decreases  amounted  to  16  per  cent,  in  carbon. 
27  per  cent,  in  phosphorus  and  31  per  cent  in  sulphur  below  the  average 
content  of  the  ingot. 

7.  The  ductility  in  the  drop  tests  was  determined  by  putting  gage 
marks  one  inch  apart  for  a  distance  of  three  inches  each  side  of  the 
middle  longitudinally  on  the  side  in  tension,  and  measuring  the  space 
which  stretched  most  at  failure. 

8.  The  tests  covered  the  rail-bar  from  about  10  per  cent,  from  the 
top  down  to  about  90  per  cent,  from  the  top,  and  the  remarks  below  refer 
to  this  part  of  the  rail-bar.  In  both  head  tension  and  base  tension  tests 
the  ductility,  as  an  average  of  all  the  rail-bars,  increased  continuously 
along  the  rail-bar,  starting  from  the  top  end.  With  head  tension  the 
range  was  from  about  8  per  cent,  to  about  27  per  cent,  and  with  base 
tension  from  about  12  per  cent,  to  about  24  per  cent. 

9.  The  permanent  deflection  or  set  was  measured  under  the  first 
blow  of  a  2,000-lb.  tup  falling  from  a  height  of  18  ft.,  with  a  span  of  sup- 
ports of  3  ft.  The  set  measured  was  the  distance  between  a  3-ft.  straight- 
edge and  the  part  of  the  rail  where  struck  by  the  tup. 

10.  As  an  average  of  the  head  tension  and  base  tension  results,  the 
set  at  about  16  per  cent,  by  weight  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  was  1.69  in. 
and  increased  continuously  down  the  rail-bar  until  at  90  per  cent,  down 
it  was   1. 81    in.,   an   average    increase   of  about   7   per   cent.,   although   the 


838  RAIL. 

rate  of  increase  varied  in  different  parts  of  the  bar.  The  set  with  the 
head  in  tension  averaged  about  .04  in.  greater  than  with  the  base  in 
tension.  The  results  from  the  bar  above  16'  per  cent,  from  the  top  were 
insufficient  to  allow  of  conclusions,  but  it  seems  that  the  set  was  greater 
than  at  16  per  cent.  down. 

11.  Differences  of  rolling  temperature  corresponding  to  shrinkages 
of  6%  in.  to  7  in.,  in  a  33-ft.  rail,  resulted  in  only  small  differences  in  the 
rails  as  determined  by  the  drop  test.  The  deflection  seems  to  have 
increased  slightly  as  the  temperature  increased,  the  averages  of  the  bars 
ranging  from  1.73  in.  to  1.78  in.  The  ductility  also  seems  to  have  in- 
creased some  with  an  increase  of  temperature  of  rolling,  ranging  from 
18.7  per  cent,  to  21. 1  per  cent,  for  the  averages  of  the  bars.  The  number 
of  blows  that  it  took  to  break  the  rails  averaged  just  about  the  same  for 
the  different  bars,  namely,  3J/2  blows. 

12.  Tensile  tests  were  made  along  the  rail-bars  from  three  locations 
in  the  section,  the  corner  of  the  head,  the  interior  of  the  head  near 
its  junction  with  the  web,  and  the  flange. 

13.  Considering  the  average  results  of  the  five  bars,  the  yield  point 
and  tensile  strength  were  about  uniform  along  the  bar  in  the  samples  from 
the  corner  of  the  head  and  the  flange,  with  perhaps  a  slight  upward  ten- 
dency down  to  about  20  per  cent,  from  the  top.  The  flange  averaged  about 
2.000  lbs.  higher  than  the  corner  of  the  head  both  in  yield  point  and  ten- 
sile strength,  the  yield  point  averaging  about  68,000  and  66,000  ibs., 
respectively,  and  the  tensile  strength  about  120,000  and  118,000  lbs., 
respectively. 

The  yield  point  and  tensile  strength  of  the  interior  of  the  head  at 
first  increase  to  above  the  results  from  the  two  other  locations,  and 
in  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  they  are  less,  corresponding  in  a  general 
way  to  the  distribution  of  the  hardening  elements,  carbon  and  phosphorus. 

14.  The  elongation  and  reduction  of  area  of  the  corner  of  the  head 
and  the  flange  increased  continuously,  in  a  general  way,  downward  of 
the  ingot,  the  corner  of  the  head  showing  a  little  higher  in  both  properties 
than  the  flange.  In  the  corner  of  the  head  the  elongation  averaged  from 
15  per  cent,  in  2  in.  to  18J/2  per  cent.,  between  the  limits  of  10  per  cent, 
and  85  per  cent,  down  from  the  top  of  the  ingot  and  in  the  flange  the 
results  were  about  1  per  cent  lower.  The  reduction  of  area  in  the  corner 
of  the  head  ranged  from  21  per  cent,  to  30  per  cent,  in  the  same  region, 
and  in  the  flange  it  averaged  about  2  per  cent,  less  in  the  upper  part  of 
the  ingot,  but  about  the  same  in  the  lower  part. 

In  the  interior  of  the  head  the  elongation  and  reduction  of  area  started 
at  upper  part  of  the  ingot  about  the  same  as  in  the  other  locations,  but 
they  soon  fell  off  to  only  a  few  per  cent,  at  about  15  per  cent,  down, 
after  which  they  increased,  and  in  the  lower  half  (if  the  ingot  they  were 
about  the  same  as  in  the  corner  of  the  head  and  the  flange,  or  were  a 
little  higher. 


INFLUENCE  OF  ROLLING  TEMPERATURE.  839 

15.  Differences  of  rolling  temperature  corresponding  to  shrinkages 
of  6%  in.  to  7  in.  in  a  33-ft.  rail,  resulted  in  little  or  no  differences  in  the 
yield  point.  The  tensile  strength  was  likewise  not  influenced,  except  that 
the  flange  seems  to  have  increased  a  little  in  tensile  strength  as  the 
temperature    of    rolling    increased. 

16.  The  elongation  of  the  corner  of  the  head  and  the  flange  decreased 
a  little  with  increase  of  temperature,  but  the  interior  of  the  head  decreased 
more  in  elongation  with  increase  of  temperature,  ranging  from  about  16.5 
per  cent,  in  2  in.  at  6%  in.  shrinkage  to  about  12.8  per  cent,  at  7  in, 
shrinkage. 

17.  The  influence  of  the  temperature  of  rolling,  as  determined  by  the 
tensile  test,  is  seen  most  prominently  in  the  reduction  of  area,  which  de- 
creased as  the  temperature  increased.  The  range  in  the  corner  of  the 
head  was  from  about  29.3  per  cent,  at  6%.  in.  shrinkage  down  to  about  24^2 
per  cent,  at  7  in.  shrinkage,  in  the  flange  from  about  26.7  per  cent,  to 
about  23.7  per  cent,  and  in  the  interior  of  the  head  from  about  24.2  per 
cent,  to  about  17  per  cent. 

18.  A  discussion  is  given  comparing  the  ductility  as  developed  by 
the  drop  test  and  the  tension  test.  In  both  tests  the  ductility  increased 
in  a  general  way,  downward  of  the  ingot,  except  that  the  ductility  of  the 
interior  metal  in  the  tension  test  was  at  its  minimum  at  about  15  per  cent, 
from  the  top.  The  exterior  metal  shows  good  ductility,  as  shown  by  the 
tension  test,  along  the  whole  rail-bar,  but  the  interior  metal  is  of  very  low 
ductility  at  about  15  per  cent,  by  weight  from  the  top.  This  seems  to  show 
its  influence  in  the  drop  test,  to  some  extent  in  the  tests  with  the  base  in 
tension,  but  more  prominently  in  the  tests  with  the  head  in  tension. 

19.  Microphotographs  were  made  of  etched  sections  from  three  loca- 
tions in  the  section ;  namely,  the  upper  corner  of  the  head,  the  interior 
of  the  head  near  its  junction  with  the  web,  and  the  flange.  As  the  rolling 
temperature  increased,  the  number  of  grains  per  unit  of  area  decreased, 
that  is,  the  size  of  the  grain  increased.  In  the  flange  the  number  of 
grains  per  .001  sq.  in.  averaged  from  138  with  the  lowest  temperature 
used  to  55  with  the  highest  temperature  used.  In  the  corner  of  the  head 
the  range  was  from  100  down  to  56,  and  in  the  interior  of  the  head  from 
59  to  21. 

20.  Finally,  the  influence  of  the  temperature  of  rolling,  as  ascer- 
tained by  the  tests  made,  may  be  summed  up  as  follows :  The  ductility 
and  deflection  in  the  drop  test  were  influenced  little,  if  any,  by  the  tem- 
perature. The  number  of  blows  that  it  took  to  break  the  rails  in  the  drop 
test  was  uninfluenced  by  the  temperature  of  rolling.  The  yield  point  and 
tensile  strength  in  the  tension  tests  were  influenced  little,  if  any.  The 
elongation  in  the  tension  test  decreased  some  as  the  temperature  increased. 
The  influence  of  temperature  showed  most  prominently,  in  the  tension 
test,  in  the  reduction  of  area,  which  decreased  as  the  temperature  o( 
rolling  increased.  The  size  of  grain,  as  shown  by  the  microscope,  increased 
as  the  temperature  increased. 


Appendix    F. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

On  January  8,  1912,  the  following  order  was  issued  by  the  Railroad 
Commission   of   Indiana  : 

STATE   OF   INDIANA. 

RAILROAD   COMMISSION   OF   INDIANA.  , 

Inquiry  as  to  the  condition  of  steel  rails  now  being  manufactured,  ) 
purchased    and    put    in    by    the    railroad    companies    operating    in   -  No. 
the  State  of  Indiana.  ) 

Whereas,  It  is  the  duty  of  this  Commission  "to  keep  informed  as  to 
the  condition  of  railroads  and  railways  with  reference  to  the  security 
of  the  public,"'  and 

Whereas,  This  Commission  is  advised  that  the  steel  now  manufac- 
tured and  put  in  on  the  railways  in  this  state  is  inferior  to  the  lighter 
grades  heretofore  used,  and  that  there  is  a  difference  of  opinion  between 
the  manufacturers  and  carriers  as  to  whether  this  steel  should  be  still 
heavier  to  sustain  the  heavier  equipment  and  loads,  or  should  be  of  such 
better  quality  as  were  said  lighter  grades : 

Therefore,  Upon  consideration,  a  formal  inquiry  by  the  Commission 
as  to  this  matter  is  now   instituted  and  commenced. 

It  is  Ordered,  That  the  General  Managers,  General  Superintendents, 
Engineers  in  charge  of  Maintenance  of  Way,  and  Expert  Testers  of  new 
steel,  and  such  Purchasing  Agents,  and  such  authorities  00  steel  rail 
manufacture,  and  such  roadmasters  as  the  Commission  may  hereafter 
summon  shall  attend  a  conference  on  this  subject  at  Room  83  of  the  State 
House  on  Tuesday,  February  20,  1912,  10  a.  m. 

It  is  Further  Ordered,  That  any  expert  on  steel  rail  manufacture  and 
use,  who  may  desire  to  give  the  Commission  scientific  or  practical  in- 
formation on  this  subject,  may  appear  and  be  heard  at  said  conference, 
to  the  end  that  such  concerted  course  of  action  may  be  adopted  by  the 
Commission  as  will  tend  to  secure  for  use  on  the  railways  of  this  State 
a  high  grade  of  steel,  as  perfect  as  to  materials  and  manufacture  and  shape 
and  weight  as  can  be  practically  made.  It  is  understood  that  the  Com- 
mission will  ask  the  aid  and  counsel  of  the  American  Railway  Associa- 
tion, who  have  collected  a  great  deal  of  valuable  data  and  information  on 
this  subject. 

It  is  Ordered,  That  the  Secretary  transmit  a  copy  of  this  order  to 
each  steam  and  interurban  railroad  operating  in  the  State  of  Indiana. 

I,  J.  L.  Reiley,  Secretary  of  the  Railroad  Commission  of  Indiana, 
hereby  certify  that  the  above  and  foregoing  is  a  true  and  complete  copy 
of  the  order  issued  by  the  Commission  on  the  8th  day  of  January,   1912. 

Given  under  my  hand  and  seal  this  8th  day  of  January,  1912. 

(Signed)    J.  L.   Reiley, 

Indianapolis,    Indiana.  Secretary. 

841 


842  RAIL. 

A  meeting  between  Mr.  W.  J.  Wood,  Chairman  of  the  Railroad  Com- 
mission, and  Mr.  W.  J.  Jackson,  Chairman  of  the  Special  Committee  on 
Relation  of  Railway  Operation  to  Legislation,  to  determine  the  hest  method 
for  conducting  the  hearing,  resulted  in  the  appointment  of  a  committee 
of  railway  nun  t< >  arrange  for  the  information  on  the  rail  question  which 
was  to  lie  presented  to  the  Commission.  This  committee  was  as  follows: 
Mr.  F.  A.  Delano,  Receiver,  Wabash  Railroad;  Mr.  Fairfax  Harrison, 
President,  C.  I.  &  L.  Railway;  Mr.  G.  L.  Peck,  General  Manager,  Penn- 
sylvania Lines ;  Mr.  W.  C.  Cashing,  Chief  Engineer  M.  of  W.,  PenrP 
sylvania  Linos.  South  West  System,  and  Dr.  P.  H.  Dudley,  Consulting 
Engineer,   New   York   Central  Lines. 

At  a  conference  between  the  members  of  this  committee,  on  Febru- 
ary 9,  a  sub-committee  consisting  of  Dr.  P.  H.  Dudley,  Dr.  Thos.  H.  John- 
son and  Mr.  W.  C.  dishing,  with  the  latter  as  Chairman,  was  appointed 
to  draw  up  statements  of  the  work  which  had  been  done  by  the  railway 
companies  in  the  past  for  the  improvement  of  rail  design  and  specifica- 
tions, to  be  read  before  the  Commission  as  the  statement  of  the  railway.-. 
The  sub-committee  divided  this  task  up  into  three  parts,  each  member 
taking  one  part,  as   follows  : 

Part  I:    The  early  history  of  rail  development  up  to  the  time  the  subject 
was  taken  up  by  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers,  together 
with  the  questions  of  relative  quality  of  earlier  and  later  rails,  and 
foreign  rail  steel  as  compared  with  American,  by  Dr.  P.  H.  Dudley. 
Part  II:     The  history  of  the  connection  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil 
Engineers  with  rail  design  and  specifications,  together  with  the  ques 
tions   of   lower   carbon   and   heavier   rail   sections,   by   Dr.   Thos.   H. 
Johnson. 
Part  III:     The  question  of  the  improvement  of  rail  design  and  specifica- 
tions from  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers'  report  in   1893 
to   the   present   time,   together   with   a   discussion   on   the   subject   of 
fixed  percentage  of  discard,  by  Mr.  W.   C.   Gushing. 
These  papers  were  prepared  in  the  very  short  time  allotted,  and  read 
before  the  Commission   at  its  hearing  on  February  20,  and  are  submitted 
with  this  report. 

in  addition  to  the  above,  addresses  were  made,  upon  request  of  Chair- 
man Wood,  by  Mr.  F.  A.  Delano,  Mr.  E.  J.  Buffington.  Dr.  Benjamin 
and  Mr.  R.  Montfort,  after  which  the  hearing  was  adjourned  until  April  2. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  IV— ON  RAIL. 


Part     I. 

THE  HISTORY,  DEVELOPMENT  AND  USE  OF  RAILS  BY  RAIL- 

ROAD  COMPANIES  OF  THE  UNITED  STATES 

FROM    1830  TO   DATE. 

BY    P.   H.    DUDLEY. 

The  inception,  projection  and  construction  of  350,000  or  more  miles 
of  track  and  equipment  in  the  United  States,  nearly  one-half  of  that  of 
the  world,  by  private  enterprise,  in  the  past  eighty  years,  represent  an 
expenditure  of  energy  and  capital  without  parallel  by  older  nations,  and 
express  by  deeds  the  abiding  faith  of  the  people  in  the  growth,  welfare 
and  stability  of  this  great  country. 

Our  railroads  were  installed  to  furnish  the  most  efficient  means  of 
inland  transportation,  to  develop  a  new  country  of  vast  extent  of  territory. 
great  diversity  of  topographic  features  and  climate,  yet  of  limited  accumu- 
lation of  capital,  but  rich  in  natural  resources,  to  be  converted  by  indus- 
try into  wealth. 

The  opening  of  the  Stockton  &  Darlington  Railway  in  England,  Sep- 
tember 27,  1825,  by  George  .Stephenson's  "Locomotion"  having  only  a  flue 
boiler,  therefore  of  limited  steam  generating  capacity,  indicated  that 
steam  could  replace  horse  power  for  railroad  transportation,  snd  the  re- 
sult was  received  with  great  interest  in  this  country. 

This  was  followed  by  a  charter  for  the  Mohawk  &  Hudson  Railroad  in 
1826.  Several  other  lines  were  chartered  in  the  United  States,  the  Balti- 
more &  Ohio,  the  Delaware  &  Hudson  Canal  Company,  the  Camden  & 
Amboy  and  the  Philadelphia  &  Columbia  Division  of  the  Pennsylvania 
Railroad.  The  construction  of  the  lines  was  commenced,  and  in  1830 
there  were  23  miles  in  operation.     (See  Table  1.) 

The  railroads  at  their  inception  were  local  affairs  of  few  miles  in 
extent,  and  without  previous  experience  in  construction  and  operation 
the  tracks  and  equipment  were  of  necessity  only  in  the  experimental  stages 
of  development,  and  some  tracks  had  not  been  constructed  sufficiently 
strong  to  demonstrate  the  possibilities  of  steam  railroad  transport. 

The  Delaware  &  Hudson  Canal  Company's  Railroad  was  designed  and 
constructed  for  steam  power,  but  when  the  locomotive  "Stourbridge  Lion,'' 
built  in  England,  arrived  in  1829  and  made  a  short  run  it  was  found  too 
heavy  for  the  track,  and  abandoned,  a  great  disappointment  to  the  advo- 
cates of  steam  power. 

Work  was  commenced  upon  the  Mohawk  &  Hudson  Railroad  in  1830, 
after  Stephenson's  "Rocket,"  with  its  multitubular  boiler,  at  the  trials  at 
Rainhill,  England,  October,  1829,  had  fulfilled  the  stipulation  and  won 
the   prize   of   five   hundred   pounds   sterling,   offered   by   the   Liverpool    & 

843 


844  RAIL. 

Manchester  Railway  Company  for  the  best  engine,  and  the  result  gave  a 
world-wide   impulse   to   steam   railroad   transportation. 

The  first  ten  miles  of  the  Philadelphia  &  Columbia  Railroad,  strap 
rails  were  laid  upon  stone  sills,  which  were  in  continuous  parallel  lines. 
The  strap  iron  rails  were  fifteen  feet  long  and  were  attached  by  small 
spikes  driven  into  cedar  plugs  in  the  stone  sills.  Seventy-one  and  six 
tenths  (71.6)  miles  were  laid  with  rolled  edge  rails  with  chairs.  The, 
strap  iron  rails  and  wooden  stringers  were,  however,  generally  employed 
for  the  first  railways,  but  did  not  form  a  smooth  and  substantial  track 
and  by  their  frailty  forced  our  civil  and  mechanical  engineers  to  develop 
the  American  type  of  locomotive  and  equipment.  They  were  resourceful 
men  and  brought  up  in  the  trying  school  of  experience  and  they  proved 
equal   to   the   great   task. 

It  will  be  noticed  from  Table  I  that  in  1840  only  2,818  miles  had  been 
constructed.  Nearly  all  of  the  first  railroad  companies  were  bankrupt  and 
passed  into  receivers'  hands,  owing  to  the  great  expense  and  cost  of  operat- 
ing mi  tracks  which  had  been  built  as  permanent  structures  to  endure 
for  many  years,  hut  were  destroyed  by  the  generated  wheel  effects  of 
three  to  four  tons  upon  the  drivers,  and  one  and  one-half  to  two  tons  on 
the  wheels  of  the  ordinary  rolling  stock.  All  of  the  early  strap  iron  rails 
were  imported  from  England  or  Wales,  as  rolling  mills  had  not  been 
built   in   this    country. 

The  strap  iron  rails  were  increased  to  one  and  one-half  inches  m 
thickness  and  three  inches  in  width,  and  between  1840  and  1850  so  many 
accidents  occurred  from  their  use  that  in  New  York  State,  in  1844,  their 
further  employment  was  discontinued. 

Robert  Stevens,  in  1830,  for  the  Camden  &  Amboy  Railroad  designed  a 
"T"  section  of  iron  rail,  nearly  similar  to  those  of  the  present  type  in 
use.  That  is  the  only  form  of  the  early  rail  which  has  remained  as  a 
survival  of  the  fittest  of  the  many  different  sections  employed.  Fear- 
shaped  iron  rails  were  imported  from  England,  and  many  of  these,  made 
out  of  refined  iron,  lasted  several  years  under  the  light  wheel  loads,  but 
when  they  increased  to  ten  or  twelve  thousand  pounds  upon  the  drivers 
the   rails   failed   with   great   rapidity. 

The  mileage  in  1800  had  increased  to  30,626  miles  on  iron  rails.  The 
eight-wheeled  passenger  car  was  soon  followed  by  the  eight-wheeled 
freight  car,  constituting,  with  the  four-wheel  front  truck  locomotive,  dis- 
tinct types  of  American  equipment. 

The  physical  properties  of  the  iron  were  adequate  only  for  the  in- 
stallation of  the  railroads,  but  proved  inadequate  when  the  driving  wheel 
loads  reached  ten  and  twelve  thousand  pounds,  and  when  the  speeds  of 
trains  attained  twenty-five  and  thirty  miles  per  hour  the  iron  rails  broke 
and  laminated  with  such  rapidity  that  the  operations  of  the  railroads 
were  conducted  with  great  difficulty  and  expense. 

Broken  rails  were  so  numerous  in  the  sixties  that  the  railroad  offi- 
cials tried  the  Booth  steel-capped  rail,  which  had  a  surface  of  about  one- 


RAIL.  845 

quarter  04)  in.  of  crucible  steel  rolled  on  to  a  stem  of  wrought  iron, 
hut  the  surfaces  were  not  welded  and  did  not  last  long  in  the  track. 

Bessemer's  invention  to  make  steel  by  blowing  air  for  fifteen  to 
twenty  minutes  through  molten  iron  of  five  or  more  tons  in  a  converter 
and  burn  out  the  three  to  four  per  cent,  carbon  of  the  cast-iron,  and  sub- 
sequently recarburize  it,  giving  it  the  percentage  of  carbon  required  for 
the  steel,  was.  after  some  failures,  successful.  The  iron  selected  had  to 
be  low  in  the  impurities,  phosphorus  and  sulphur,  for  none  could  be  re- 
duced in  the  acid-lined  converter.  The  output  of  steel  rails  was  large 
compared  to  the  output  of  iron  rails. 

Bessemer  rails  were  rolled  in  England  and  tried  by  many  of  the 
railroads,  commencing  about  i860,  and  in  1863  a  number  of  trial  orders 
were  placed  for  similar  rails  in  this  country.  The  cost  at  the  time  of 
one  hundred  to  one  hundred  and  twenty  dollars  per  ton,  in  gold,  to  which 
was  added  the  premium  of  forty  or  more  per  cent,  in  our  currency,  forced 
the  railways  to  use  as  light  a  section  as  possible  of  the  steel.  Many  of 
the  sections  of  56  to  58  lbs.  per  yard,  four  inches  in  height  with  com- 
paratively a  thick  base  but  thin  heads,  were  imported  and  tried.  The 
steel  rails  in  places  of  severe  service  would  outlast  ten  to  fifteen  of  the 
best  iron  rails  which  could  be  secured.  Bessemer  steel  works  were  in- 
augurated in  this  country  about   1866. 

The  sections  were  only  four  to  four  and  one-quarter  inches  in  height, 
and  the  deflections  of  the  rails  under  the  passing  wheel  loads  permitted 
nearly  the  entire  concentration  of  the  wheel  load  on  each  cross-tie.  The 
rail  sections  were  not  stiff  enough  to  distribute  only  a  small  part  of  the 
load  in  the  wheel  spacing  and  while  the  cost  of  maintenance  for  track 
work  was  high  the  loss  of  metal  per  yard  was  quite  small.  The  light 
sections  did  not  permit  the  development  of  the  wheel  loads  and  enlarge- 
ment of  the  locomotives  and  cars  as  much  as  was  desired  by  the  rail- 
roads for  the  demands  of  transportation.  The  loss  of  metal  per  yard  in 
service  proved  to  be  so  small  that  the  consensus  of  opinion  was  general 
that  from  the  excellent  wear  of  the  thin-headed  sections  a  residual  sec- 
tion might  be  designed  of  sufficient  strength  to  carry  the  traffic  and  add 
to  the  head  the  amount  of  metal  desired  for  wear.  The  base  of  the 
rails  were  made  thinner  and  fifty  per  cent,  or  more  of  metal  put  into  the 
heads  of  the  rails.  These  sections  when  rolled  out  of  practically  the 
same  chemical  composition  did  not  give  the  results  of  former  sections, 
owing  to  more  massive  heads  and  coarser  structure  of  metal  incident  to 
the  greater  heat  units  in  the  metal  of  the  head  to  cool. 

The  change  in  this  form  of  section  was  made  by  a  committee  of 
Engineers  in  about  1870  and  sections  they  recommended  were  in  service 
in  1874.  The  excellent  results  which  they  expected  to  obtain  were  not 
secured  in  subsequent  service  and  the  increased  demands  of  transporta- 
tion for  better  and  smoother  rails  that  would  reduce  the  generated  wheel 
effects  of  the  moving  trains  was  so  important  and  there  was  such  a 
diversity  of  opinion  in  reference  to  the  sections  of  rails  that  in  1878  I  de- 
signed my  Track  Indicator  and   constructed  a  car  in  which  the  measure 


S4G  RAIL. 

ment;s  of  the  undulations  of  the  tracks  could  be  made     Passing  over  sev- 
eral of  the  important  lines,  the  New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River  Rail 
road,   the  Boston  &  Albany  Railroad,   Philadelphia  &   Reading  and   Balti- 
more &  Ohio,  it  was  found  that  rails  in  the  track  had  characteristic  per- 
manent  sets.      These   I   could   classify,    and    while    the    railroad    companies 
thought  they  could  make  their  tracks  as  smooth  as  they  desired  by  more 
ballast  and  labor,  it  was  shown  by  repeated  inspection  of  the  tracks  that 
while  they  might  temporarily  improve  the  surface  of  the  track  it  did  not' 
remain  but  a  short  time  before  it  was  more  or  less  out  of  surface. 

One  part  of  the  mechanism  of  the  apparatus  summed  the  und'niatioris 
in  the  rails  under  the  special  truck,  into  feet  and  inches  per  mile,  by  which 
a  comparison  could  be  made  of  the  different  conditions  of  the  track  per 
mile.  It  also  recorded  by  large  diagrams,  on  a  scale  of  one  inch  of  paper 
to  fifty  feet  of  track,  the  actual  vertical  undulations  and  low  joints  in  the 
tracks.  The  conditions  or  smoothness  of  the  steel  was  an  important 
factor,  and  also  the  stiffness  of  the  rails. 

This  led  to  the  design  of  the  five  (5)  in.  80-lb.  rail  for  the  New  York 
Central  &  Hudson  River  Railroad  in  1883,  which  was  rolled  and  placed 
in  the  tracks  in  1884.  By  adding  fifteen  pounds  to  the  ordinary  65-lb., 
four  and  one-half  (4TA)  in.  rails,  then  used  for  the  heaviest  service,  and 
making  an  80-lb.  section,  five  (5)  in.  high,  the  actual  stiffness  of  the  sec- 
tion was  increased  sixty-six  per  cent,  over  the  ordinary  65-lb.,  four  and 
one-half  in.  rail. 

There  was  a  great  difference  of  opinion  as  to  what  would  be  the 
value  of  the  increased  stiffness  for  track  purposes,  the  majority  of  opin- 
ions being  that  the  value  obtained  would  not  be  equal  to  the  increased 
cost. 

The  section  was  rolled  and  placed  in  the  tracks  in  July,  1884,  and 
demonstrated  at  once  that  the  increased  stiffness  in  the  rail  was  of  de- 
cided advantage  to  the  stability  and  capacity  of  the  track,  and  raised  the 
standard  of  maintenance. 

Several  of  the  Eastern  roads  adopted  either  a  five  (5)  in.  80-lb.  sec- 
tion or  one  of  heavier  weight,  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  making  a  five 
(5;    in.  85-lb.  section. 

I  made  for  the  Boston  &  Albany  Railroad  a  five  (5)  in.  95-lb.  section 
and  rolled  it  out  of  0.06  phosphorus  and  0.65  carbon  steel  for  their  heavy 
gradients  and  sharp  curvature.  They  commenced  to  lay  the  rail  in  1891 
and  completed  the  entire  line  in  1897. 

I  had  stated  on  my  condensed  diagrams  in  1883,  for  the  Boston  & 
Albany  Railroad,  after  I  had  designed  the  five  (5)  in.  80-lb.  rail,  and 
before  it  was  rolled,  that  it  would  be  possible  to  reduce  the  undulations 
per  mile,  as  measured  by  my  car,  to  two  and  one-half  feet,  or  between 
the  fifteenth  and  sixteenth  line  on  my  condensed  diagram,  by  similar  stiff 
sections.  When  the  line  was  completed  in  1897  and  I  had  made  the  in- 
spection, the  average  for  the  entire  four  hundred  miles  of  track  was 
fifteen    and    forty-two    hundredths    on    the    condensed    diagram. 


RAIL  SIT 

In  1892  my  six  (6)  in.  100-lb.  rail  was  laid  through  the  tunnel  of  the 
Harlem  Line.  This  gave  a  greater  stability  to  the  track  than  was  possible 
in  sections  with  five  and  one-eighth   (SJ/i)   in.  80-lb.  rails. 

TONNAGE    UPON     DIFFERENT    WEIGHTS    OF    RAILS. 

The  four  and  one-half-in.  65-lb.  section  of  the  New  York  Central  & 
Hudson  River  Railroad,  in  service  eight  and  one-half  years  in  the  Fourth 
Avenue  Tunnel,  carried  51,000,000  tons,  with  a  loss  of  about  one-quarter 
of  an  inch  in  depth  of  the  metal  upon  the  head  of  the  rail.  This  was 
an  English  make  of  rail  with  a  heavy  base  and  thin  head.  The  five-in. 
80-lb.  section  which  replaced  this  section  was  in  service  eight  years  and 
carried  65,000,000  tons,  with  a  loss  of  about  one-eighth  of  an  inch  of  metal 
upon  the  head  before  it  was  removed.  The  six-in.  100-lb.  New  York 
Central  section,  which  was  rolled  in  1892,  and  replaced  the  five-in.  80-lb. 
section,  was  removed  in  July,  1899,  carried  95,000,000  tons,  and  is  still 
in  yard  service.  The  loss  of  metal  on  the  top  of  the  head  of  the  rails, 
in  all  the  sections  in  the  tunnel,  was  about  twice  as  rapid  as  it  was  from 
the   same   tonnage   outside. 

The  six-in.  100-lb.  section  of  rail  in  1895  of  0.06  phosphorus  and  0.65 
in  carbon  on  the  "Inbound  Main"  from  1895  until  August,  1907,  carried 
375,000,000  tons  with  a  loss  of  about  one-eighth  of  an  inch  in  depth  on 
the  head  of  the  rail. 

The  light  earlier  sections  could  carry  from  60,000,000  to  75,000,000  tons 
before  they  were  rough  and  unsuitable  for  passenger  traffic,  and  when 
in  a  location  where  the  tonnage  was  only  250,000  to  500,000  tons  per 
month,  would  last  in  the  track  many  years.  The  heavier  sections  which 
replaced  the  light  ones  carried  much  greater  tonnages  from  the  increase 
in  the  density  of  traffic.  Their  larger  area  of  metal  also  gave  them  a 
capacity   for   greater   tonnages. 

The  100-lb.  rails  in  the  Fourth  Avenue  Tunnel  at  the  present  time 
carry  daily  from  one  hundred  and  fifty  to  two  hundred  train  movements. 
The  tonnage  per  month  is  in  some  places  nearly  as  much  as  the  light  rails 
were   subjected  to  in  one   or  two  years'   service. 

Table  1  shows  the  increase  in  freight  ton  miles  from  1890  to  1900, 
nearly  doubled,  while  it  trebled  for  1910. 

It  has  often  been  stated  that  the  reason  why  the  former  rails  seem 
to  last  so  well  was  due  to  the  elimination  of  the  poorer  ciuality  of  rails 
by  the  service  in  the  track.  This  statement  is  not  the  complete  explana- 
tion. The  older  rails  were  cold  rolled  by  the  light  wheel  loads  until  the 
surface  was  sufficiently  hardened  to  bear  the  recent  heavier  loads  without 
much  increased  abrasion.  New  rails  of  the  same  section  and  practically 
the  same  physical  properties  would,  when  subjected  to  heavier  wheel 
loads,  lose  more  of  the  metal  by  wear,  before  the  surface  was  rolled  as 
hard  as  the  former  sections,  and  their  rate  would  be  much   faster. 

It  is  not  considered  advisable  at  the  present  time  to  make  the  com- 
position of  the  rails  which  are  to  be  subjected  to  the  present  heavy  wheel 
loads    so  hard  that  at  first  they  will  entirely  resist  the  cold  rolling  effect 


848  RAIL. 

of  the  passing  wheels.  It  is  better  to  make  the  physical  properties  oi 
the  rails  such  that  a  slight  flow  of  the  metal  will  take  place  under  the 
various  worn  wheel  treads  which  will  run  over  the  rails,  and  in  this  way 
the  surface  will  accommodate  itself  to  the  average  treads  passing  over 
the  heads,  the  surface  becoming  gradually  hard,  and  in  a  short  time  the 
flow  is  practically  arrested. 

In  rails  which  are  too  soft  the  surface  may  be  worn  away  by  the  wheel 
loads  before  it  becomes  sufficiently  hardened  for  the  long  wear,  or  the  driy-. 
ers  slip  on  the  rails,  producing  a  layer  so  hard  as  to  require  their  removal 
from   the   track. 

Table  i  also  shows  another  important  matter.  The  mileage  shown 
for  1830  to  1850  had  been  constructed  mostly  with  strap  iron  rails.  The 
mileage  1850  to  1870  was  mostly  iron  rails,  though  about  one-fifth  was 
steel  rails.  The  mileage  for  1880  was  more  than  one-half  of  it  laid  with 
steel  rails,  while  that  shown  for  1890,  1900  and  1910,  the  mileage  would 
be  mostly  steel.  It  would  have  been  impossible  to  have  constructed  the 
mileage  shown  for  1910  without  the  invention  of  Bessemer  steel.  We 
have  in  the  United  States  about  40,000,000  tons  of  steel  in  the  track, 
of   which    2,500,000   tons    are    of    basic    open   hearth    steel. 

The  possibility  of  developing  the  railroad  mileage  of  the  world  has 
been  due  to  a  great  extent  to  the  study  given  in  all  countries  to  the 
manufacture  of  the  steel  rails.  I  was  a  delegate  to  the  International 
Railway  Congress,  London,  1895,  and  Reporter  for  the  United  States  on 
the  "Nature  of  Metal  for  Rails,"  Sixth  Session  of  the  Congress  at  Paris, 
1900.  I  was  also  Reporter  for  America  at  the  Seventh  Session  of  the 
Congress  at  Washington,  D.  C,  1905,  on  "Rails  for  Fast  Lines,"  and  also 
a  Delegate  to  the  International  Congress,  Eighth  Session,  at  Berne,  191c. 
Collecting  information  for  the  United  States  railroads,  and  being  famil- 
iar with  the  practice  in  England,  Germany,  France,  Belgium  and  Switzer- 
land, where  the  wheel  loads  are  much  lighter  than  in  the  United  States, 
has  given  me  an  opportunity  to  study  the  comparative  tracks  in  reference 
to  the  rail  sections  and  composition  in  the  various  countries. 

Basic  Bessemer  steel  and  Basic  open  hearth  steels  are  used  abroad 
in  Germany,  England,  also  in  Africa,  and  the  different  delegates  stated 
that  the  wear  on  the  rails  under  their  light  wheel  loads,  particularly  on 
the  curves,  was  much  more  rapid  than  was  desired.  The  temperatures 
in  those  countries  do  not  fall  as  low  as  they  do  in  our  Northern  states  and 
Canada.  They  use  higher  carbon  rails  in  France  as  a  rule  than  we  do 
in  this  country,  with  excellent  effect.  Their  wheel  loads  are  also  much 
lighter  and  they  maintain  their  rotundity  for  a  longer  period  than  the 
wheels  here,  under  our  heavier  wheel  loads  and  long  distance  runs. 

One  of  the  problems  confronting  the  railroads  to-day,  in  those  states 
where  the  temperatures  fall  to  20  and  40  degrees  below  zero,  is  to  secure 
a  sufficiently  homogeneous  metal  in  the  33  and  36-in.  wheels  for  the  entire 
circumference  of  the  tire  or  wheel  tread  to  maintain  its  rotundity.  The 
36-in.  wheels  make  560.2  revolutions  per  mile,  and  with  their  static  load  of 
five  tons,  the  accumulated  tonnage  upon  the  tread  of  the  tire  or  wheel  would 


RAIL.  849 

be  2,8o'i  tons  for  each  mile  run.  The  tonnage  for  the  run  FrOih  New 
YOrfc  to  Chicago  would  he  2./00,oco  Ions,  from  Boston  to  Chicago,  2,800, • 
000  tons  and  from  New  York  to  St.  Louis  3,200,000  tons. 

The  locomotive  drivers  of  79  in.  in  diameter  make  255.3  revolutions 
pei*  mile.  The  Pacific  type  engines  have  static  loads  of  14.3  tons  per 
driver,  consequently  the  static  load  per  mile  run  upon  the  metal  is  t,,<)5\ 
tons.  These  figures  are  sufficient  to  show  that  their  tonnage  upon  each 
portion  of  the  bearing  surface  on  the  tread  repeats  the  load  for  each  revo- 
lution and  for  high  speed  trains  with  great  rapidity,  consequently  the 
accumulated  tonnage  on  the  tires  and  wheels  enlarges  according  to  the 
distance  run. 

THE    EFFECT    OF    COI.D    ON    KAILS    IN    A    PERMANENT    WAV. 

First,  the  direct  one  which  affects  the  metal,  decreasing  its  ductility  but 
increasing  its  tensile  strength,  elastic  limits  and  modulus  of  elasticity  to  a 
slight  extent  and  making  it  more  sensitive  to  shocks. 

Second,  indirect  effect  by  contraction  of  the  metal  which  may  set  up 
the  tensile  stresses  of  some  magnitude  in  the  rails  before  the  ends  render 
in  the  splice  bars.  The  intensity  of  this  effect  on  the  rails  is  greater  in 
countries  subject  to  low  temperatures  near  or  below  zero,  and  subject  to 
cold  waves  from  the  North,  where  the  temperatures  fall  many  degree; 
below  zero,  or  fall  in  a  short  time  and  continue  cold  for  a  few  days  until 
broken   by   a   warm   wave   from   a  tropical   climate. 

The  experience  of  the  railroad?  in  the  Northern  and  Western  states 
this  winter  is  more  severe  than  ever  before  experienced.  The  effects  have 
been  so  great  that  rails  which  have  heretofore  been  quite  free  from  break- 
ages have  been  rendered  more  susceptible  to  the  wheel  effects  of  the 
passing  trains  and  a  larger  number  broken  than  ever  before  reported. 
Such  conditions  have  been  studied  quite  extensively  for  the  purpose  to 
render  the  rails  more  ductile  or  of  greater  tenacity  and  toughness  to 
withstand  the  shock  of  passing  wheels  in  temperatures  of  from  20  to 
40   degrees   below   zero. 

The  service  tests  of  rails  of  large  ductility  or  tenacity  and  tough 
ness  of  metal  in  large  tonnages,  scattered  in  many  states,  show  during  the 
past  winter  an  almost  entire  freedom  from  breakages  and  indicate  that 
much  has  already  been  accomplished.  It  is  now  possible  from  a  definite 
chemical  composition  to  determine  what  ductility  or  toughness  may  be 
secured  when  the  steel  is  properly  purified  in  the  bath,  and  thus  increase 
the  factor  of  safety  in  the  output  of  the  rails. 

To  most  Engineers  of  Maintenance  of  Way  who  are  not  conversant 
fully  with  the  actual  steps  of  the  different  processes  of  manufacture  it 
seems  that  a  specification  for  chemical  composition  and  a  few  subsequent 
tests  for  quality  would  be  sufficient  to  secure  rails  to  withstand  the  pres- 
ent service.  This  is  by  110  means  the  case,  for  it  is  only  by  a  knowledge 
of  the  manufacture  of  the  steel  and  its  subsequent  use  in  the  track  that 
one  obtains  the  requisite  knowledge  to  provide  for  the  various  conditions 
of  service  to  which  rails  are  subjected. 


S50 


KAIL. 


It  is  the  duty  of  users  of  rail  to  advise  the  manufacturers  of  the  type 
and  as  far  as  possible  the  cause  of  failures  and  breakages  of  rails  in  the 
tracks. 

The  gathering  of  statistics  of  rail  failures  of  the  past  few  years 
and  discussing  them  with  the  manufacturers  has  resulted  in  a  co-opera- 
tion to  improve  the  quality  of  the   output. 

I  was  present  on  the  15th  instant  at  a  conference  of  the  Presidents 
and  Rail  Manufacturers,  in  New  York,  in  which  the  subject  was  thor- 
oughly discussed.  The  Presidents  from  the  Northern  and  Western  States' 
stated  that  they  had  experienced  lower  temperatures  and  for  a  longer 
period  to  that  date  than  had  previously  occurred  in  all  their  experience  in 
railroading.  The  Eastern  roads  have  experienced  the  effects  of  these  low 
temperatures  for  a  number  of  years  and  found  it  necessary  to  make  some 
preparation  for  them. 

I  have  been  making  a  series  of  observations  and  tests  for  some  years 
in  anticipation  of  severe  climatic  conditions,  and  the  recent  results  seem 
promising.  It  has  been,  however,  necessary  to  develop  the  manufacture 
of  the  steel  to  the  highest  state  of  the  art  and  subject  the  product  to  severe 
tests   in    the   track   to   see   what   has  been   accomplished. 

The  results  so  far  indicate  that  decided  progress  has  been  made.  This 
has  come  from  a  large  experience  in  dealing  with  tenacity  and  toughness 
in  rail  steels  for  the  past  two  decades.  The  results  of  this  work  have 
been  carefully  studied  for  the  benefit  of  our  service. 

Should  it  seem  advisable  to  supply  some  illustrations  of  the  early  sec- 
tions to  show  what  work  has  been  required  to  develop  a  suitable  section 
for  the  present  railroad  service,  it  would  be  a  pleasure  to  supply  them. 

It  must  be  remembered  that  with  the  present  wheel  loads  and  high 
speeds  of  the  train  movements,  the  time  factor  for  reversal  of  the  stresses 
under  the  wheels  and  in  the  wheel  spacing  has  been  materially  shortened 
by   the   present    schedules. 

The  wheel  loads  also  require  stresses  of  large  magnitude  to  be  dis- 
tributed in  a  shorter  time  than  was  necessary  with  slower  speeds  and 
lesser  wheel  loads. 

The  question  of  recent  sections  will  be  treated  more  in  detail  by  Mr, 
Johnson  in  Part  II,  and   specifications  by  Mr.   dishing  in  Part  III. 


1830 

1840 

1850 

1860      1870 

1880 

1890 

1900 

1910 

Miles   of    lines  operated 
exclusive     of        side 
tracks,  yards  and  ter 

23 

2,818 

9,1)21 

30,62f)  52.922 

93,296 

163,597 

199,875 

76,207,047 

11,847,785 

1,265,880 

19,288,301 

192,556 

258,784 

141,599,159 

16,039,007 

2,023,702 

37,210,720 

239,652 

349,159 

255,528,643 

Passengers  one  mile, 
Locomotive    weights 

without  tenders  (tons  1 
Freight  cars — total   <•;•- 

- 

33,949,936 
4,271,000 
74,043,000 

Part    II. 

STEEL  RAILS. 

INVESTIGATIONS    BY    THE   AMERICAN    SOCIETY    OF    CIVIL    ENGINEERS. 
BY    THOS.     H.    JOHNSON. 

The  first  action  taken  by  an  organized  body  of  engineers  in  relation 
to  the  character  and  quality  of  the  rails  used  on  the  railroads  of  this 
country  was  had  by  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  in  1874,  in 
the  appointment  of  a  Committee  to  investigate  and  report  on  "The  Form. 
Weight,  Manufacture  and  Life  of  Rails." 

This  Committee  made  a  progress  report  in  June,  1874,  again  in  May. 
1875,  and  a  final  report  in  June,   1876. 

At  these  dates  the  use  of  steel  rails  was  in  its  infancy,  and  compara- 
tively few  had  been  laid  on  American  railroads.  Such  as  had  been  laid 
had  been  down  too  short  a  time  to  warrant  the  Committee  in  drawing 
conclusions  in  regard  to  them;  hence,  the  reports  of  this  Committee 
dealt  almost  exclusively  with  iron  rails,  with  only  incidental  reference  to 
the  use  of  steel,  and  therefore  they  have  no  bearing  on  the  questions 
now  before  us. 

Steel  rails  first  appeared  as  an  established  commodity  in  the  market 
reports  in  1868.  From  the  first  they  rapidly  began  to  displace  the  old 
iron  rails,  and  in  1882  the  latter  had  ceased  to  appear  as  a  market  com- 
modity. 

Sections. 

During  the  first  fifty  years  of  railroad  development  many  different 
sections  had  come  into  use,  and  there  was  no  common  standard.  In 
1887  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  again  appointed  a  Commit- 
tee, this  time  charged  to  consider  "the  proper  relation  to  each  other  of  the 
sections  of  rails  and  wheels."  This  Committee  made  a  progress  report  in 
1888,  and  a  final  report  in  1889,  and  in  the  following  year,  1850,  following 
the  subject  still  further,  another  Committee  was  appointed  to  prepare  and 
submit  to  the  Society  a  series  of  '"Standard  Sections,"  for  rails  of  different 
weights  per  yard. 

The  Committee  made  a  preliminary  report  in  1891,  and  a  final  report 
in  1893.  This  latter  report  was  accompanied  by  a  series  of  sections  for 
rails,  weighing  from  40  lbs.  to  100  lbs.  per  yard,  varying  by  intervals  of 
5  lbs.  These  sections  were  approved  by  the  Society,  and  promulgated  as 
the  "A.S.C.E.  Standard  Sections." 

They  met  with  favor  and  were  adopted  by  many  railroads,  so  that  in 
a  very  few  years  about  two-thirds  of  the  output  of  the  rail  mills  con- 
formed to  those  sections. 

851 


852  RAIL. 

Specifications. 

As  might  be  expected,  with  the  engineers  of  the  country  acting  inde- 
pendently, with  imperfect  understanding  as  to  the  effect  on  the  finished 
product  of  different  elements  in  different  proportions,  accented  by  more 
or  less  variation  in  the  process,  as  practiced  at  different  mills,  a  large 
number  of  specifications  came  into  existence,  differing  in  their  require- 
ments as  to  chemistry  and  physical  requirements. 

The  oldest  specification  now  before  the  writer  bears  date  1876,  and 
makes  no  mention  of  the  chemistry.     It  required  a  tensile  test  from  each  - 
heat,  the  test  piece  to  be  cut  from  the  head  of  the  rail. 

The  next  issue  of  the  same  specification,  1879,  requires  that  the  car- 
bon shall  be  between  0.30  and  0.50  per  cent.,  but  it  is  silent  as  to  other 
elements.  In  later  issues,  manganese  and  phosphorus  were  added,  and 
still  later  silicon. 

This  is  probably  typical  of  the  process  of  development  of  rail  specifi- 
cations generally,  but,  as  already  stated,  the  resulting  specifications  dif- 
fered   from    each    other   in   many    respects. 

With  the  growing  prosperity  of  the  country,  there  was  an  increas- 
ing demand  on  the  transportation  facilities,  which  led  to  a  gradual  in- 
crease in  the  weights  of  rolling  stock.  This  was  met  by  the  engineers 
by  correspondingly  increasing  the  strength  of  the  rails.  But  it  was  soon 
found  that  the  larger  sections  wore  out  faster  on  curves  than  the  smaller 
sections  had  done.  This  was  due  to  the  fact  the  larger  sections  cooled 
more  slowly  and  underwent  a  partial  annealing  rendering  the  metal  softer 
and  less  resistant  to  the  grinding  action  of  the  flanges  against  the  side 
of  the  head.  Some  engineers  sought  to  remedy  this  by  specifying  an 
increased  proportion  of  carbon,  varying  with  the  size  of  the  section.  This 
added  still  further  to  the  diversity  of  the  specifications. 


Part    III. 

THE   QUESTION    OF  THE   IMPROVEMENT    OF   RAIL   DESIGN 
AND  SPECIFICATIONS,  FROM  1893  TO  THE  PRESENT  TIME. 

BY    W.    C.    CUSHING. 

The  period  between  1893,  the  year  of  the  adoption  of  the  standard  rail 
sections  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers,  and  the  First  An- 
nual Convention  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance 
of  Way  Association  in  1900,  was  occupied  by  the  railway  engineers  in  the 
study  of  the  behavior  in  the  track  of  the  rails  rolled  according  to  the  new 
designs,  which  were  rapidly  put  into  service  by  the  different  railroads 
of  the  country. 

A  preliminary  meeting  of  the  railway  engineers  was  held  in  Chicago 
on  October  21,  1898,  for  the  purpose  of  organizing  the  American  Railway 
Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association,  and  at  that  meeting  a 
committee  was  appointed  to  draft  the  Constitution  and  By-Laws. 

On  March  30,  1899,  the  permanent  organization  of  the  Association 
was  effected  in  Buffalo,  by  the  adoption  of  the  Constitution  and  the  elec- 
tion of  officers. 

As  stated  in  the  Constitution,  the  object  of  the  Association  was  the 
advancement  of  knowledge  pertaining  to  the  scientific  and  economic 
location,  construction,  operation  and  maintenance  of  railroads,  and  the 
means  to  be  employed  for  this  purpose  were  to  be  : 

(1)  Meetings  for  the  reading  and  discussion  of  papers,  and  social 
intercourse. 

(2)  The  investigation  of  matters  pertaining  to  the  objects  of  the 
Association,  through  Standing  and   Special   Committees. 

(3)  The   publication   of   papers,   reports   and   discussions. 

The  real  and  final  object  was,  however,  for  the  members  to  ex- 
change information  and  experience  with  each  other  and  to  bring  about  the 
unification,  as  much  as  possible,  of  specifications  for  the  purchase  of  the 
large  amount  of  material  and  supplies  used  by  railroads,  which  ought  to 
result  in  the  mutual  benefit  of  the  manufacturers  and  the  railway  com- 
panies. 

In  order  to  hear  the  first  reports  of  Standing  Committees,  the  first 
convention  was  held  in  March,  1900,  in  Chicago,  and  among  the  Standing 
Committees  was  one  on  Rail. 

The  report  of  the  Committee  was  largely  historical,  but  it  was  de- 
veloped at  that  and  subsequent  meetings  that  the  subject  was  going  to  be 

853 


854  RAIL. 

one  of  the  most  important  and  most  interesting  of  those  to  come  before 
the  Association  in  the  future,  and  in  closing  the  discussion,  the  President 
said  : 

"Of  course,  we  realize  that  we  do  not  expect  to  exhaust  the  subject 
at  this  meeting,  or  in  the  next,  or  in  our  lifetime,  but  we  are  simply 
laying  the  foundation  now  for  our  future  work,  and  I  presume  at  the 
next  meeting  the  Committee  will  not  be  still  'fuller'  than  they  are  now. 
but  that  there  will  be  more  of  them  present  and  that  they  will  continue 
the  consideration  of  this  matter." 

The  work  of  the  Committee  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engi- 
neers was  undertaken  with  the  object  of  improving  the  design  or  cross- 
section  of  rails,  and  did  not  undertake  the  preparation  of  specifications  for 
their  manufacture  or  inspection,  but  each  railway  company  issued  its  own 
specifications,  which  were  not  specifications  for  manufacture,  but  for  in- 
spection. These  specifications  differed  from  each  other  in  various  de- 
tails, such  as  the  method  of  testing,  the  allowable  variations  from  the 
templates,  the  smoothness  of  the  surface  and  the  workmanship  generally, 
while  but  little  was  said  about  the  chemical  composition.  Indeed,  this 
state  of  affairs  must  have  been  quite  annoying  and  expensive  to  the  rad 
manufacturers,  and,  as  all  railroads  were  striving  for  exactly  the  same 
object,  viz.,  to  obtain  the  best  material  which  would  make  an  absolutely 
safe  steel  rail,  the  unification  of  the  specifications  seemed  to  be  very  de- 
sirable, and  if  it  could  be  brought  about,  the  existence  of  the  Association 
would  be  entirely  justified. 

At  the  Annual  Convention  in  1901,  it  was  ascertained  that  the  rail 
sections  or  designs  of  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  were  in 
use  by  about  70  per  cent,  of  the  railroads  of  the  country,  and  it  soon  de- 
veloped in  the  discussion  that  the  rail  steel  in  use  by  the  railroads  was  not 
giving  very  good  satisfaction.  This  dissatisfaction  pertained  to  all  sections 
of  rails,  and  the  railway  engineers  thought  that  the  trouble  was  largely 
due  to  the  temperature  of  rolling  being  entirely  too  high,  leading  to  the 
expression  of  one  member  that  "the  material  was  squirted  through  the 
rolls."  The  engineers  of  the  rail  manufacturers,  who  were  also  members 
of  the  Association,  contended,  on  the  other  hand,  that  the  fault  was  due 
to  the  rail  sections,  and  especially  to  the  thin  base  designs  of  the  Ameri- 
can Society  of  Civil  Engineers.  It  thus  developed  that  the  railway  engi- 
neers believed  the  trouble  was  entirely  due  to  improper  processes  of  manu- 
facture, while  the  rail  manufacturers'  engineers  placed  the  fault  on  the 
design  of  the   rail  cross-section. 

It  was  apparent,  therefore,  that  the  committee  must  study  both  the 
question  of  design  and  the  question  of  rail  manufacture,  the  latter  with  the 
special  object  of  devising  tests  and  methods  of  inspection  which  would 
more  surely  determine  whether  the  material  came  up  to  the  requirements 
of  service  or  not.     It  was  quite  evident  that  this  work  would  be  of  long 


RAIL.  855 

duration,  because  it  was  necessary  that  more  study  than  ever  before  should 
be  placed  upon  both  the  question  of  rail  design  and  its  manufacture,  and 
it  would  be  necessary  to  proceed  slowly  and  carefully,  in  order  to  avoid 
the  misinterpretation  of  statistics  and  information.  Sir  Lowthian  Bell 
is  reported  to  have  said,  at  the  London  meeting  of  the  American  Society 
of  Civil  Engineers,  in  1900,  that  "As  he  had  been  25  years  a  manufacturer 
of  rails  and  25  years  a  director  in  the  North  Eastern  Railway,  he  repre- 
sented both  maker  and  user,  and  he  had  at  his  disposal  3S,coo  analyses 
to  go  upon  in  making  deductions.  From  these  he  could  prove  and  dis- 
prove everything  that  could  be  said  for  or  against  any  composition  of  a 
rail — a  facility  beloved  by  the  expert."'  It  is  well  for  any  investigator  not 
to  forget  Sir  Lowthian  Bell's  remark.  It  has  been  brought  home  to  the 
Rail    Committee   many   times    in    its    prolonged    investigation. 

Prior  to  this  time,  so  much  had  been  said  by  railway  engineers  about 
the  necessity  for  rolling  at  lower  temperature  that,  in  1900,  the  Kennedy- 
Morrison  process  of  holding  rails  just  before  the  final  passes  until  they 
came  to  the  desired  temperature,  after  which  they  were  put  through  the 
final  passes  at  that  temperature,  was  introduced  by  the  Carnegie  Steel 
Company,  and  great  expectations  of  the  value  of  the  results  were  held. 
At  the  same  time  other  rail  manufacturers  began  rolling  at  lower  temper- 
ature and  claimed  to  accomplish  the  same  results.  The  process  did  not, 
however,  give  the  results  expected,  as  the  effect  was  only  skin  deep,  for 
when  the  skin  wore  off,  the  ordinary  metal  was  exposed  underneath. 
The  rails  rolled  after  its  introduction  developed  rather  more  failures  than 
usual,  and  since  that  time  the  value  of  rolling  at  low  temperature  has  been 
rather  uncertain.  This  experience  is  mentioned  to  show  that  the  value  of 
many  changes  in  process  of  manufacture  can  only  be  developed  after  long 
experience,  which  is  one  of  the  reasons  why  an  investigation  of  this  kind 
is  bound  to  cover  a   long  period  of  time. 

In  1895.  at  Zurich,  Switzerland,  the  International  Association  foi- 
Testing  Materials  was  organized  to  bring  about  "the  development  and 
unification  of  standard  methods  of  testing,  for  the  determination  of  the 
properties  of  materials  of  construction,  and  of  other  materials,  and  also 
the  perfection  of  apparatus  for  that  purpose."  On  June  16,  1898,  or  but  a 
few  months  prior  to  the  organization  of  the  American  Railway  Engineer- 
ing and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association,  there  was  formed,  at  Philadel- 
phia, the  American  section  of  the  International  Association,  which,  a  few 
years  later,  was  renamed  "The  American  Society  for  Testing  Materials." 
The  American  section  was  composed  of  manufacturers  as  well  as  of  con- 
sulting engineers,  railway  engineers,  and  others,  and  had  already  begun 
the  study  of  rail  specifications.  Therefore,  at  its  Annual  Convention  in 
1901  the  Rail  Committee  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Associa- 
tion submitted  the  rail  specifications  recommended  by  the  American 
Branch  of  the  International  Association  for  discussion,  in  order  to  get 
the  subject  under  way. 

Specifications  for  steel  rails  have  always  consisted  of  three  general 
parts : 


856 


RAIL. 


(i)     Chemical  requirements  or  properties; 

(2)  Physical    requirements;   and 

(3)  Details  of  manufacture. 

Up   to   that   time   the    various    railway  companies   emphasized   one   or 

mure  of  these  parts,  according  to  their  individual  preference  or  experience. 
Some  almost  ignored  the  chemical  requirements,  others  were  more  or  less 
elaborate  in  their  physical  requirements,  while  some  barely  touched  upon 
details  of  manufacture,  and  others  treated  the  subject  quite  elaborately. 

Chemical    Requirements   or    Properties. 

The  chemical  properties  of  these  proposed  specifications  for  Bessemer 
steel  rails  were  those  of  the  Carnegie  Steel  Company,  and  they  arc  to- 
day the  standard  chemical  specifications  of  all  the  steel  rail  manufacturers. 
and  of  the  American  Society  for  Testing  Materials,  with  scarcely  any 
alterations.     They  were  as  follows: 


50-60  lbs. 

60-70  lbs.       70-80  lbs. 

80-90  lbs. 

90-100  lbs. 

.38  to    .48      .40  to  .  50 

.10                       .1(1 

. 20                    .  20 

.70-1.00          ,75-1.05 

.43  to  .53 

.10 

.20 

.80-1.10 

.45  to    .55 

.10 

.20 

Manganese 70-1 .  00 

.80-1.10 

The   specifications   for   foreign   use   were   practically   the   same. 

The  only  changes  which  have  been  made  in  these  specifications  by 
the  steel  manufacturers  and  by  the  American  Society  for  Testing  Mate- 
rials up  to  the  present  time  are  to  make  the  carbon  for  60  to  70-lb.  rail  .3? 
to  .45,  and  the  manganese  for  90  to  100-lb.  rail  .84  to   1.14. 

With  few  exceptions,  the  railroads  of  the  United  States  have  accepted 
these  chemical  constituents  as  recommended  by  the  rail  manufacturers, 
because  they  have  considered  that  the  chemical  properties  were  only  a 
minor  part  of  the  specifications  for  rail  steel,  compared  with  the  physical 
requirements. 

To  show  that  the  railway  engineers  have  been  justified  in  taking 
this  view  of  the  matter,  the  following  quotation  is  made  from  an  artick 
in  the  Journal  of  the  Franklin  Institute  for  [889,  by  Capt.  R.  W.  Hunt, 
once  a  manufacturer  of  steel  rails  and  now  a  steel  rail  inspector  of  wide 
experience : 

"Rails  made  by  John  Brown  &  Co.  of  England,  and  put  down  on 
American  railroads  some  years  ago.  have  been  generally  held  up  as  ideal 
rails,  and  the  American  makers  for  a  long  time  supposed  that  when  these 
rails  did  wear  out  so  that  they  could  lie  analyzed  the  secret  of  their  good 
service  would  be  told.  As  an  illustration  of  how  little  regularity  or  purity 
of  chemical  composition  influenced  the  wear,  1  call  your  attention  to  the 
analyses  of  thirteen  of  John  Brown  rails,  all  of  which  had  filled  years  of 
faithful  service  and  have  been  selected  as  bright  examples  of  what  good 
rails  should  be  : 


RAIL. 


857 


C. 

Si. 

Ph. 

S. 

Mn. 

Cu. 

1 

0.35 
0.39 
0.36 
0.70 

0.36 
0.44 
(1  45 
0.30 
0.24 
0.37 
0.32 
0.35 
0.28 

0.08 
0.071 
0.103 
0.306 

0.069 
0.208 
()  102 
0.087 
0  068 
0.051 
0.089 
0.069 
0.032 

0.128 
0.156 
0.125 
0.111 
0.153 
0.098 
0.128 
0.148 
0.131 
0.096 
0.145 
0.077 
0.084 

0.068 
0.155 
0.060 
0.008 
0.131 
0.059 
0.105 
0.181 
0.104 
0.050 
0.077 
0.099 
0.053 

0.742 
0.662 
0.815 
0.681 
0.621 
1.046 
0.616 
0.625 
0.645 
0.639 
0.745 
0.945 
0  312 

0  048 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

0.32 
Trace 

0.016 
0.143 

7 

8 

0.056 

9 

0  005 

10 

11 

12 

Trace 
Trace 

13. 

"You  will  observe  that  carbon  ranged  from  0.24  to  0.70;  silicon  from 
0.032  to  0.306;  phosphorus  from  0.077  to  0.156;  sulphur  from  0.050  to 
0.155,  an(J  manganese  from  0.312  to   1.046. 

"These  13  rails,  taken  as  a  whole,  were  chemically  a  'poor  lot,'  but 
physically  most  excellent." 

Physical    Properties. 

Two  general  methods  for  testing  the  physical  requirements  had  been 
in  use  up  to  the  year  1900,  viz.,  a  bending  test  of  a  small  bar  lA  in.  to 
•)4  in.  square  and  10  in.  to  20  in.  long,  and  a  drop  test,  which  consisted 
in  letting  fall  a  weight  of  about  2, coo  lbs.  on  a  piece  of  rail  with  a  span 
of  3  to  4  feet.  Some  railways  used  one  method,  some  the  other  and  some 
both,  but  by  iqco  the  small  bar  test  had  been  generally  abandoned  in 
favor  of  the  drop  test. 

It  was  customary  to  make  a  test  of  every  fifth  heat  of  steel,  and  to 
let  the  weight  fall  from  varying  heights,  according  to  the  pleasure  of  the 
maker  of  the  specifications.  The  proposed  specifications  of  the  American 
branch  retained  this  method  of  testing  the  physical  properties  by  dropping 
the  weight  of  2,000  lbs.  on  every  fifth  heat  of  steel,  from  a  height  of  16 
ft.  for  rail  weighing  55  to  65  lbs.  per  yard,  17  ft.  for  rail  weighing  65  ro 
75  lbs.  per  yard,  18  ft.  for  rail  weighing  75  to  85  lbs.  per  yard,  and  19  ft. 
the  rail  weighing  85  to  100  lbs.  per  yard,  but  these  conditions  were  not 
accepted  by  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association,  as  there  was 
a  strong  feeling  among  the  railway  enginers  that  more  severe  condi- 
tions of  testing  were  necessary.  They  felt  that  the  chemical  properties 
could  be  left  to  the  greater  experience  and  chemical  knowledge  of  the 
rail  manufacturers,  but  that  they  must  be  the  ones  to  prescribe  the  physi- 
cal tests  which  the  finished  rails  must  ^and  in  order  to  be  accepted  for 
such  important  service  as  carrying  the  railway  traffic  of  the  country.  In 
1904,  therefore,  the  Engineering  Association  decided  that  each  heat,  instead 
of  every  -fifth  heat  of  steel,  must  be  tested,  and  that  the  height  of  the 
drop   should    be   increased. 

It  was  also  ascertained  that  the  rail  butts  heretofore  tested  under 
the  falling  weight  had  been  from  the  bottom  of  the  ingot,  and  it  was  now 
made  a  part  of  the  specifications  that  the  test  piece  should  be  taken  from 


858  RAIL. 

the  top  of  the  ingot,  on  account  of  the  probability  that  the  metal  would 
be  less  perfect  at  that  end. 

Testing  every  heat  instead  of  every  fifth  heat,  as  formerly,  was  con- 
sidered little  short  of  a  revolution  in  the  method  of  testing  at  that  time. 
Details  of   Manufacture. 

Except  in  the  case  of  a  few  companies,  the  specifications  in  regard 
to  details  of  manufacture  were  not  elaborate,  the  specifications  being  con- 
fined almost  entirely  to  allowing  for  variations  from  the  standard  tem- 
plate and  from  the  length  of  the  rail,  to  smoothness  and  perfection  of 
finish,  to  branding,  etc. 

In  view  of  the  agitation  for  colder  rolling,  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad 
had  introduced  into  its  specifications  in  iqoo  a  clause  requiring  that  the 
rail  at  the  last  pass  should  be  at  a  red  heat,  preferably  a  dull  red,  but  in 
iooi  they  replaced  it  with  a  so-called  "Shrinkage  Clause,"  which  was  in- 
tended to  control  the  temperature  of  the  rail  when  being  finished,  by  pre- 
scribing that  the  shrinkage,  after  the  rail  was  sawed,  should  not  exceed 
a  certain  number  of  inches.  This  clause  was  also  introduced  into  the  pro- 
posed specifications  of  the  Engineering  Association,  making  an  additional 
requirement   in   the   details   of   manufacture. 

Lately  there  has  been  a  great  deal  of  argument  on  the  part  of  the 
rail  manufacturers  to  have  the  railway  engineers  specify  a  definite  per- 
centage of  discard  from  the  ingot,  in  order  to  cut  off  material  which  is 
more  subject  to  segregation  and  more  liable  to  have  interior  defects  from 
the  shrinkage  cavity,  gas  bubbles,  etc.,  but  the  railway  engineers  have- 
rigidly  set  their  faces  against  such  a  requirement,  because  they  feel  that 
they  are  much  better  safeguarded  by  the  clause  introduced  into  the  specifi- 
cations of  the  American  branch  of  the  International  Association  of  Test- 
ing Materials,  which  was  that  "sufficient  material  should  be  discarded 
from  the  top  of  the  ingots  to  insure  sound  rails." 

When  that  clause  was  adopted,  in  1901,  and  for  a  number  of  years 
afterwards,  the  positions  of  the  rail  manufacturers  and  the  railway  engi- 
neers were  reversed,  the  railway  engineers  believing  that  it  was  best  to 
specify  a  definite  amount  of  discard,  while  the  rail  manufacturers  took  the 
opposite  view.  It  was  well  expressed  by  an  engineer  of  one  of  the  steel 
companies,  who  said :  "I  do  not  think  this  Association,  nor  any  other, 
should  state  definitely  how  much  should  be  sheared  from  the  bloom. 
The  matter  is  entirely  one-sided.  If  we  agree  here  that  25  per  cent,  shall 
be  sheared  from  the  bloom,  we  might  assume  that  would  settle  it,  but  it 
will  not.  The  Association  will  be  perfectly  safe  in  making  the  claim  that 
sufficient  shearing  will  be  done  to  eliminate  piping.  If  the  manufactur- 
ers can  remove  the  piping  by  shearing  15  per  cent.,  they  will  not  agree  to 
shear  25  per  cent.  The  object  in  shearing  is  to  get  rid  of  the  piping,  and 
the  only  matter  of  agreement  will  be  to  reach  the  point  where  sufficient 
shearing  is  done  to  remove  the  piping.  For  that  reason,  I  think  the  As- 
sociation will  make  a  mistake  I"  demand  that  25  per  cent,  be  sheared  off." 

The  railway  engineers  of  to-day  unanimously  agree  with  that  point 
of  view,  and  their  positon  has  been  further  strengthened  by  an  additional 


KAIL.  s:'!l 

test,  which  will  be  described  later.  Furthermore,  the  records  of  rail 
failures  which  have  been  kept  for  a  number  of  years  disclose  the  incon- 
trovertible fact  that,  where  a  15  per  cent,  discard  might  do  for  one  ingot, 
50  per  cent,  would  not  be  adequate  for  another. 

In  1902,  the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  deemed  it  advis- 
able, in  view  of  the  continual  criticism  of  the  sections  of  rail  which  they 
had  previously  designed,  to  take  up  once  more  the  study  both  of  rail  de- 
sign and  specifications,  and  accordingly  a  committee  was  appointed  for  the 
purpose. 

The  Committee  of  the  American  Society  for  Testing  Materials  also 
continued  its  study  of  the  rail  question,  and  joint  meetings  of  all  three 
committees  were  held  so  that  each  would  derive  benefit  from  the  work  of 
the   other. 

On  April  25,  1906,  the  Committee  on  Standard  Rail  and  Wheel  Sec- 
tions was  appointed  by  the  American  Railway  Association,  and  on  Octo- 
ber 24,  1906,  the  Committee  was  directed  to  report  in  addition  on  the  sub- 
ject of  specifications  for  the  manufacture  of  steel  rails,  in  connection 
with  its  report  on  standard  sections.  The  rail  manufacturers  were  asked 
to  co-operate  with  the  committee  by  sending  representatives  to  study  the 
question  with  it  at  its  meetings,  and  in  addition  the  committee  employed 
disinterested  men  of  national  reputation  in  their  knowledge  of  steel  mak- 
ing and  the  properties  of  steel,  to  give  expert  advice  on  the  subject.  After 
many  meetings  together  a  report  was  submitted,  October  30,  1907,  con- 
taining the  recommended  rail  sections  and  specifications,  both  for  Bes- 
semer and  Open  Hearth  steel. 

Further  advice  was  obtained  from  disinterested  persons  who  had  a 
wide  knowledge  of  the  properties  of  steel  and  its  manufacture,  and  final 
report  was  submitted  by  the  committee  on  April  22,  1908,  with  the  rec- 
ommendation that  there  were  many  details  of  the  development  and  the 
following  up  of  the  results  in  service  of  the  new  types  of  section,  rolled 
under  the  new  specifications,  which  would  require  considerable  time  and 
much  careful  study,  and  that  they  could  be  more  efficiently  and  more 
appropriately  handled  by  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association. 
The  sections  and  specifications  were,  therefore,  referred  to  the  American 
Railway  Engineering  Association,  with  the  request  that  they,  follow  up  the 
question  in  its  various  details  and  keep  a  careful  record  of  the  results, 
with  a  view  to  determining  whether  any  changes  should  be  made,  either 
in  the  specifications  or  designs. 

As  the  question  of  discard  was  dealt  with  in  these  reports  quite  fully, 
it  is  advisable  to  make  quotations  therefrom,  because  the  earnest  consid- 
eration given  to  the  question  led  to  the  development  of  an  additional 
test,  which  is  considered  of  great  importance  in  determining  the  quality 
of  metal  by  eliminating  a  large  number  of  the  so-called  "piped  rails,"  or 
rails  with  interior  defects : 

"In  the  matter  of  discard,  there  was  a  desire  on  the  part  of  the  rail- 
road members  to  arrange  for  a  greater  discard,  and  a  strong  disposition  to 
insist    upon   a   uniform   minimum    percentage.     The   manufacturers,    how- 


860  RAIL. 

ever,  presented  considerable  evidence  which  tended  to  show  that  a  fixed 
minimum  percentage  requirement  would  be  not  only  unfair  but  unscien- 
tific, claiming  that  the  extent  of  piping  and  segregation  is  influenced  by 
the  size  of  the  ingot,  the  rate  of  pouring  into  the  mould,  and  other  details 

of  mill  practice 

"With  regard  to  the  discard  question,  the  Committee  has  always  been 
of  the  opinion  that  it  would  be  preferable  to  test  the  finished  product 
rather  than  specify  as  to  details  of  mill  manufacture 

"In  pursuing  its  investigation  of  this  discard  question,  the  Commit- 
tee received  a  suggestion  from  Mr.  Win.  Metcalf  to  the  effect  that  it 
would  be  reasonably  practicable  to  apply  the  above  theory  to  the  manu- 
facture of  rails  by  arranging  to  test  to  destruction  a  number  of  rail  butts 
representing  a  certain  portion  of  the  total  output,  and  to  base  rejections 
on   the   results  of  these  tests 

"In  order  to  avoid  the  unnecessary  waste  of  good  material,  the  Com- 
mittee set  about  to  devise  means  by  which  the  rejection  of  defective  ma- 
terial could  be  insured  without  requiring  an  arbitrary  and  definite  per- 
centage of  discard  in  every  case,  and  a  Committee  of  the  Pennsylvania 
Railroad  System  pursuing  the  same  line  of  investigation  had  adopted  a 
tentative  specification  which  provided  for  a  physical  test  of  this  nature, 
and  which  further  provided  that  when  physical  defects  were  discovered  ail 
top  rails  of  the  heat  should  be  rejected.  This  would  result  in  a  discard 
of  about  25  per  cent,  to  30  per  cent,  of  the  entire  metal  in  the  heat  when- 
ever physical  defects  were  discovered,  and  it  was  felt  that  a  requirement 
of  this  nature  would  not  only  provide  for  the  rejection  of  defective  mate- 
rial, but  would  insure  the  greatest  care  on  the  part  of  the  manufacturer. 

"A  trial  lot  of  the  rails  of  a  section  corresponding  to  Type  'B'  was 
recently  rolled  under  these  specifications  as  to  discard,  and  the  results  con- 
vinced the  Committee  that  a  development  of  this  idea  would  prove  the 
best  solution  of  the  discard  problem." 

In  connection  with  the  Details  of  Manufacture,  an  important  addi- 
tion was  made  by  requiring  that  the  brand  on  the  rail  should  also  con- 
tain a  letter  marking  the  position  which  the  rail  originally  occupied  in 
the  ingot,  so  as  to  enable  a  study  to  be  made  of  the  effect  of  that  position. 

On  June  5,  1907,  a  committee  of  the  Civil  and  Mechanical  Engineers 
of  the.  Pennsylvania  Railroad  System  and  two  rail  manufacturers  was 
appointed  to  take  up  the  study  of  the  rail  question,  and  design  new  rail 
sections  and  recommend  new  specifications,  with  the  object  of  improv- 
ing the  quality  of  the  material  used  in  rails  manufactured  for  that  System. 

The  first  meeting  was  held  on  June  12,  1907,  and  the  new  rail  designs, 
known  as  the  "P.  S."  sections,  were  adopted  on  September  20,  1907.  Ten- 
tative specifications  were  recommended  on  November  15,  1907,  and  10,000 
tons  of  rail  rolled  in  accordance  therewith.  They  were  subsequently 
modified,  on  criticism  of  the  manufacturers,  and  issued  February  4,  1508. 

The  new  rail  designs  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad  System  and  the 
American  Railway  Association  provided  for  a  more  even  distribution  of 
the  metal  in  the  head,  web  and  base,  and  for  a  thicker  base,  to  meet  the 


RAIL.  861 

views  of  the  rail  manufacturers,  who  believed  that  a  better  distribution 
of  the  metal  would  result  in  an  improved  quality,  due  to  more  favorable 
rolling  conditions.  All  of  these  sections  are  still  in  service  and  are  being 
closely  watched  to  determine  whether  the  expected  improvement  will  be 
realized. 

The  Pennsylvania  Railroad  System  specifications  have  been  modified 
several  times,  in  the  light  of  additional  experience,  and  contain  the  im- 
provements which  have  been  brought  about  from  time  to  time  through 
the  experiences  and  researches  of  its  own  committee  and  the  commit- 
tees of  the  other  associations. 

So  far  as  the  chemical  requirements  are  concerned,  they  are  prac- 
tically the  same  as  adopted  by  the  Rail  Manufacturers,  and  other  associa- 
tions. 

The  Physical  Requirements  are  determined  by  the  Drop  Test  with  the 
standard  machine,  and,  in  addition,  the  test  piece  is  nicked  and  broken  to 
reveal  the  presence  or  absence  of  interior  defect. 

In  the  Details  of  Manufacture,  the  discard  is  required  to  be  sufficient 
to  secure  sound  rails,  and  the  shrinkage  clause  to  regulate  the  tempera- 
ture of  rolling  is  retained.  The  rails  are  marked  for  position  in  the 
ingot,  for  the  purpose  of  subsequent  identification,  in  order  to  study  the 
effect  of  that  position. 

Similar  studies  and  investigations  are  being  conducted  by  the  New 
York  Central  Lines,  the  Harriman  Lines,  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad. 
Norfolk  &  Western  Railway,  Lehigh  Valley  Railroad,  Reading  Railway 
and  other  companies,  and  the  specifications  are  being  improved  as  new 
knowledge  is  obtained.  The  first  named  company  has  been  foremost  in 
the  study  of  the  effect  of  Titanium  in  steel  making. 

Through  the  assignment  of  the  rail  question  to  the  American  Rail- 
way Engineering  Association  by  the  American  Railway  Association,  the 
work  of  the  Committee  was  given  an  official  character,  and  its  real  work 
commenced.  The  first  thing  of  importance  accomplished  was  the  intro- 
duction of  a  standard  drop  testing  machine  at  all  the  rail  mills,  so  that  the 
results  obtained  at  any  one  mill  were  comparable  with  those  obtained  at 
any  other.  Up  to  that  time,  1908,  machines  of  different  design  and  set- 
ting were  used,  and  the  results  were  unreliable.  With  the  year  1909  began 
the  collection  of  a  large  amount  of  information,  obtained  from  research 
work,  bearing  on  the  disputed  points  of  rail  manufacture,  and  on  prov- 
ing or  testing. 

In  1910,  the  specifications  for  Bessemer  rail  formerly  adopted  by  the 
American  Railway  Engineering  Association  were  withdrawn,  and  new 
ones,  for  both  Bessemer  and  Open  Hearth,  were  presented  for  considera- 
tion by  the  Association,  which  embodied  all  the  improvements  in  the 
methods  of  determining  the  physical  properties  and  the  details  of  manu- 
facture which  had  been  brought  forward  up  to  that  time.  It  was  recog- 
nized, however,  that  numerous  disputed  points  could  only  he  cleared  up 
by  experimental  research  conducted  by  a  trained  engineer  physicist,  and 
accordingly  such  an  investigator  was  added  to  the  Committee  to  devote  all 


862  RAIL. 

his  time  to  that  work.     The  Engineer  of  Tests,  M.   H.  Wickhorst,  since 
his  appointment,   has  heen   constantly  busy   with   research   work,   and   has 
added  a  great  deal  to  our  knowledge  of  the  subject. 
He  has  made  reports  on  the  following  subjects: 

Influence  of  Carbon  on  Deflection. 

Drop,  Bending  and  Tensile  Tests  on  Bessemer,  Titanium  Bessemer, 
and  Open-Hearth  Rails,  rolled  by  different  mills,  including  chemical  an- 
alyses and  etched  sections. 

Investigation  of  a  Split  Head  Rail.  .. 

Segregation,  as  Influenced  by  Fire  Clay  on  Ingot. 

Strength  of  Rail  Head. 

Drop  Tests  of  Rails — Effect  of  Impact  Energy  variously  distributed. 

Flow  of  Rail  Heads  under  Wheel  Loads. 

Segregation  and  other  Rail  Properties  as  influenced  by  Size  of  Ingot 

Tests  of  Steel  Rail  Ingots  and  derivative  shapes  made  at  Watertown 
Arsenal. 

Influence  of  Rolling  Temperature  on  the  Properties  of  Bessemer 
Rails. 

In  all  of  this  work,  Mr.  Wickhorst  has  been  afforded  every  facility  by 
the  rail  manufacturers  for  carrying  on  the  investigations,  and  their  ma- 
chinery, material  and  laboratory  assistants  have  been  placed  at  his  dis- 
posal. In  addition,  their  officers  have  been  freely  consulted  by  the  Com- 
mittee, and  have  attended  some  of  its  meetings. 

While  at  the  present  time  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Associa- 
tion has  not  adopted  standard  specifications  for  rails,  yet  it  has  had  con- 
stantly before  it  for  consideration  and  study  a  set  of  proposed  specifica- 
tions which  have  embodied  the  best  knowledge  of  the  subject,  and  they 
have  been  changed  from  time  to  time  in  the  light  of  new  experimental 
investigation.  The  most  energy  has  been  devoted  to  the  improvement  of 
methods  of  testing  to  determine  the  physical  properties,  and  practically  no 
changes  have  been  made  in  the  chemical  requirements  from  the  standard 
specifications  of  the  rail  manufacturers.  The  railway  engineers  prefer  to 
subject  the  finished  material  to  such  tests  as  will  cast  aside  the  defective 
rails.  Their  specifications,  therefore,  include  many  additional  tests  over 
those  in  use  ten  years  ago.  The  results  of  the  work  of  the  American 
Railway  Engineering  Association  have  been  closely  followed  by  the  Rail- 
way Companies  and  vice  versa,  so  that  the  specifications  of  the  Railway 
Companies  have  been  improved  from  time  to  time,  and  now  embody  the 
additional  tests  devised.  Rails  have  been  rolled  in  accordance  with  these 
new  specifications  for  several  years,  and  it  is  believed  that  a  marked 
improvement  is  apparent  in  the  rails  being  laid  in  the  tracks  since  their 
adoption. 

February,    1912. 


REPORT   OF   COMMITTEE  XVII— ON   WOOD 
PRESERVATION. 

Eakl   Sixmson,  Chairman;  E.  H.  Bowser,  Vice-Chair  man; 

G.  M.  Davidson.  E.   A.    Sterling. 

If.   B.  Dick.  C.   M.   Taylor. 

\V.   W.   Drinker.  Dr.  H.  von   Schkenk. 

Dr.  W.  K.  Hatt.  Charles  Yoder. 

V.  K.  Hendricks.  C.  E.  Knickerbocker. 

George  E.  Rex.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 
The    Board   of   Direction   assigned   to   your   Committee   the    following 

subjects  : 

(i)     Continue   investigation   of   the   proper  grouping   of   the   different 

timbers  for  antiseptic  treatment. 

(2)  Compile   available  information   from   service  tests. 

(3)  Investigate  the  merits  of  various  preservatives,  giving  special 
attention  to  oil  from  water  as  tar  and  to  the  use  of  refined  coal-tar  in 
creosote   oil. 

(4)  Report  on  the  advisability  of  revising  the  adopted  specifications 
for  creosote  oil. 

(5)  Recommend  forms  for  the  inspection  of  preservative  processes. 

(6)  Present  specifications  for  impregnation  with   creosote   oil. 

(7)  Report  on  the  value  of  impregnation  with  crude  oil. 

(8)  Report  on  the  value  of  brush  coating  and  dipping. 

A  Sub-Committee  was  assigned  to  the  consideration  of  each  one  of 
these  subjects. 

Two  meetings  of  the  Committee  were  held  at  the  Association  rooms, 
Chicago;  one  on  October  11,  1911,  those  present  being  Earl  Stimson. 
Chairman ;  E.  H.  Bowser,  Vice-Chairman ;  H.  B.  Dick,  Dr.  W.  K.  Hatt, 
V.  K.  Hendricks,  George  E.  Rex,  E.  A.  Sterling,  C.  M.  Taylor,  Dr.  H.  von 
Schrenk,  C.  E.  Knickerbocker;  the  other  meeting  on  December  7,  iqii, 
those  present  being  Earl  Stimson,  Chairman ;  E.  H.  Bowser,  Vice-Chair- 
man :  V.  K.  Hendricks>,  G.  M.  Davidson,  Dr.  W.  K.  Hatt,  H.  B.  Dick, 
E.  A.  Sterling,  C.  M.  Taylor. 

(1)    GROUPING  OF  TIMBERS   FOR  ANTTSEPTTC   TREATMENT. 

The  Sub-Committee  on  Grouping  was  instructed  to  continue  the 
investigations  of  the  proper  grouping  of  timbers  for  antiseptic  treatment. 
Last  year  arrangements  were  made  for  a  series  of  co-operative  experi- 
ments at  several  plants  to  determine  the  best  method  of  grouping  various 

863 


864  WOOD   PRESERVATION. 

species  in  different  regions.  These  tests  have  not  been  completed,  but 
scmie  progress  has  been  made,  the  results  of  which'  are  submitted  as 
Appendix  "A"  to  this  report.  During  the  coming  year  additional  experi« 
mental  work  will  be  done  at  several  plants.  This  work  will  be  system- 
atized, so  that  uniform  results  will  be  obtained  and  as  definite  a  basis 
as  possible  established  for  grouping  under  representative  conditions. 

Considerable  time  must  elapse  before  the  experimental  work  will  be 
brought  to  a  point  where  final  conclusions  can  be  drawn.  Past  expe- 
rience, however,  has  demonstrated  certain  fundamental  facts  in  relation 
to  grouping,  and  it  is  recommended  that  such  principles  as  have  received 
recognition  in  standard  practice  be  embodied  in  the  Manual.  These 
fundamentals  can  be  elaborated  upon  in  the  future  as  additional  informa- 
tion becomes  available. 

The  principles  recommended  at  the  present  time  for  insertion  in  the 
Manual  are  as  follows : 

(i)  Ties  of  approximately  the  same  period  of  seasoning  should  he- 
grouped  together  for  treatment;  green  ties  should  never  be  mixed  witii 
seasoned  ones. 

(2)  Pine  ties  should  be  separated  on  the  basis  of  heartwood  and  sap- 
wood;  it  would  also  be  advisable  in  some  cases  to  group  hardwoods  O" 
the  same  basis,  but  it  is  not  generally  practical  to  do  so. 

(3)  Grouping  on  the  basis  of  species  and  families,  as,  for  example, 
red  oaks,  pines,  beeches,  etc.,  if  a  further  division  into  hardwood  classes 
is  made  with  pine,  is  usually  a  satisfactory  practice.  From  this  it  fol- 
lows that  red  oak.  beech,  long-leaf  pine,  loblolly  pine  and  gum  should  be 
treated  separately.  Birch  and  bard  maples  and  certain  other  combi- 
nations, depending  on  the  locality,  can  be  grouped  together  to  advantage. 

(4)  The  separation  in  the  yard,  on  the  basis  the  ties  are  to  be 
grouped   for  treatment,  is  an  essential   and    economical    practice. 

(2)  RECORDS  FROM  SERVICE  TESTS. 

The  recommendations  of  the  report  of  the  Committee  for  191 1 
included  the  recommendation  that  certain  sections  of  track  be  selected 
on  each  railroad  for  the  purpose  of  making  accurate  tests  covering  the 
life  of  treated  and  untreated  ties.  To  ascertain  the  extent  to  which  this 
had  been  done  in  the  past,  and  the  results  which  have  been  obtained, 
the  Committee  sent  out  a  circular  letter,  the  replies  to  which  are  abstracted 
in  Appendix  "B"  to  this  report. 

(3)   MERITS  OF  VARIOUS  PRESERVATIVES. 

Your  Committee  was  directed  to  give  special  attention  to  the  merits 
of  oil  from  water  gas  tar  and  to  the  use  of  refined  coal-tar  in  creosote  oil. 
Sufficient  information  has  not  been  obtained  to  enable  report  to  be  made 
on  these  subjects  at  this  time.  The  investigations  will  be  continued  the 
coming  year. 


WOOD   PRESERVATION.  865 

(4)    REVISION    OF   THE   ADOPTED    SPECIFICATIONS    FOR 
CREOSOTE  OIL. 

After  careful  consideration  it  seems  desirable  to  change  the  first 
clause  in  the  adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote  Oil  to  provide  that  it 
shall  be  a  pure  product  from  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar  and  free 
from  any  foreign  admixture,  including  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar. 

With  this  change,  the  entire  specifications  for  creosote  oil  will  read 
as  follows : 

STANDARD    SPECIFICATIONS    FOR    CREOSOTE    OIL. 

The  oil  used  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of  coal-tar  creosote ; 
that  is,- it  shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained  from  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven 
tar  and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from  petro- 
leum or  any  other  source,  including  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar;  it 
shall  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  and 
shall  be  free  from  suspended  matter;  the  specific  gravity  of  the  oil  at 
thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall  be  at  least  1.03.  When  dis- 
tilled by  the  common  method — that  is,  using  an  eight  (8)  ounce  retort, 
asbestos  covered,  with  standard  thermometer,  bulb  one-half  (^2)  inch 
above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the  creosote,  calculated  on  the  basis  of  the 
dry  oil,  shall  give  no  distillate  below  two  hundred  (200)  degrees  centi- 
grade, not  more  than  five  (5)  per  cent,  below  two  hundred  and  ten  (210) 
degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than  twenty-five  (25)  per  cent,  below  two 
hundred  and  thirty-five  (235)  degrees  centigrade,  and  the  residue  above 
three  hundred  and  fifty-five  (355)  degrees  centigrade,  if  it  exceeds  five 
(5)  per  cent,  in  quantity,  shall  be  soft.  The  oil  shall  not  contain  more 
than  three    (3)    per   cent,  water. 

In  addition  to  the  above  standard  specification,  the  two  following 
grades  can  be  used  in  cases  where  the  higher  grade  oil  cannot  be  pro- 
cured. It  should  be  understood  that  where  it  is  necessary  to  purchase 
grades  No.  2  and  No.  3  consideration  should  be  given  to  the  use  of  a 
greater  quantity  of  creosote  oil  per  cubic  foot. 

SPECIFICATIONS    FOR    NO.    2   GRADE   CREOSOTE   OIL. 

The  oil  used  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of  coal-tar  creosote ; 
that  is,  it  shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained  from  coal  gas  tar  or  coke 
oven  tar,  and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from 
petroleum  or  any  other  source,  including  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar ;  it 
shall  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  and 
shall  he  free  from  suspended  matter;  the  specific  gravity  of  the  oil 
at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall  be  at  least  1.03.  When 
distilled  by  the  common  method — that  is,  using  an  eight  18)  ounce 
retort,  asbestos  covered,  with  standard  thermometer,  bulb  one-half  (lA) 
inch  above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the  creosote,  calculated  on  the  basis  of 
the  dry  oil,  shall  give  not  more,  than  eight  (8)  per  cent,  distillate  below 
two  hundred  and  ten  (210)  degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than  thirty- 
five  (35)  per  cent,  below  two  hundred  and  thirty-five  (235)  degrees  cen- 
tigrade, and  the  residue  above  three  hundred  and  fifty-five  (355)  de- 
grees centigrade,  if  it  exceeds  five  (5)  per  cent,  in  quantity,  shall  be  soft. 
The  oil  shall  not  contain  more  than  three  per   cent,  water. 

SPECIFICATIONS    FOR   NO.    3   GRADE   CREOSOTE  OIL. 

The  oil  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of  coal-tar  creosote;  that 
is,   it   shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained   from   coal   gas  tar   or   coke   oven 


866  WOOD  PRESERVATION. 

tar  and  shall  he  free  from  any  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from  petro- 
leum or  any  other  source,  including  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar;  it 
shall  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  and 
shall  be  free  from  suspended  matter ;  the  specific  gravity  of  the  oil  at 
thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall  be  at  least  1.025.  When  dis- 
tilled by  the  common  method — that  is,  using  an  eight  (8)  ounce  retort, 
asbestos  covered,  with  standard  thermometer,  bulb  one-half  (lA)  inch 
above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the  creosote,  calculated  on  the  basi^  of 
the  dry  oil,  shall  give  not  more  than  ten  (10)  per  cent,  distillate  below 
two  hundred  and  ten  (210)  degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than  forty  (40^ 
per  cent,  below  two  hundred  and  thirty-five  (235)  degrees  centigrade, 
and  the  residue  above  three  hundred  and  fifty-five  (35s)  degrees  cen- 
tigrade, if  it  exceeds  five  (5)  per  cent,  in  quantity,  shall  be  Noft.  The 
oil  shall  not  contain  more  than  three    (3)    per  cent,   water. 

No  change  is  recommended  at  this  time  in  the  "Specifications  for 
Analysis  of  Creosote  Oil,"  except  that  this  heading  should  be  changed 
to  read  "Specifications  for  the  Fractionation  of  Creosote  Oil."  This 
specification  merely  covers  the  fractionation  and  does  not  cover  the  chem- 
ical analysis  which  would  be  necessary  in  order  to  determine  the  presence 
of  adulteration.  The  determination  in  regard  to  adulterants  can  be  made 
chemically  in  several  manners  with  the  same  results,  and  there  does  not, 
therefore,  seem  to  be  the  necessity  for  preparing  a  complete  specification 
covering  chemical  analysis  that  there  is  for  preparing  the  specification 
covering  the  fractionation,  the  latter  giving  different  results  when  made 
by  different   methods. 

For  the  purpose  of  obtaining  more  information  in  regard  to  the  rel- 
ative merits  of  the  flask  and  retort  for  the  fractionation  of  creosote  oil, 
and  also  for  the  purpose  of  obtaining  other  information  on  which  to 
base  further  consideration  of  the  specification  for  fractionation,  it  has 
been  arranged  that  various  samples  of  creosote  oil  be  submitted  to  the 
various  railroads  for  analysis  by  various  methods,  the  reports  obtained 
being  submitted  in  writing  to  the  Committee  as  soon  as  possible  for  action 
by  the  Committee  next  year. 

(5)  FORM'S  FOR  REPORTING  INSPECTION. 

It  is  found  that  the  various  railroad  and  timber-treating  companies 
have  their  own  forms  for  the  inspection  and  recording  of  the  various 
preservative  processes,  each  meeting  their  own  peculiar  conditions,  although 
similar  in  the  essential  details.  Your  Committee  is  not  now  prepared  to 
submit  report  on  this  subject,  but  will  continue  its  consideration  the 
coming  year. 

(6)    SPECIFICATION    FOR    IMPREGNATION    WITH 
CREOSOTE    OIL. 

A  specification  for  impregnation  with  creosote  oil  has  already  been 
adopted  by  the  Association  and  is  contained  in  the  Manual.  It  is  the 
sense  of  your  Committee  that  this  specification  is  in  accordance  with 
good  practice,  and  no  change  is  recommended. 


WOOD  PRESERVATION.  867 

(7)   VALUE  OF  IMPREGNATION  WITH  CRUDE  OIL. 

Your  Committee  is  not  in  position  to  report  at  this  time  and  recom- 
mends the  continuance  of  the  subject  for  the  coming  year. 

(8)    VALUE  OF  BRUSH   COATING  AND  DIPPING. 

A  circular  letter  was  sent  out  making  inquiry  as  to  these  methods  of 
treatment.  Out  of  thirty-eight  replies,  thirty-one  report  that  neither 
process  has  been  used,  and  seven  report  that  no  definite  conclusions  can 
be  drawn  from  their  experience.  It  is  recommended  that  further  con- 
sideration be  given  this  subject. 

CONCLUSIONS. 

It  is   recommended: 

(i)  That  the  four  principles  of  Grouping  of  Timbers,  as  given 
under  subhead  (i),  Grouping  of  Timbers  for  Antiseptic  Treatment,  be 
accepted  for  insertion  in  the  Manual. 

(2)  That  the  revised  Standard  Specifications  for  Creosote  Oil,  and 
the  Specifications  for  No.  2  Grade  and  No.  3  Grade  Creosote  Oil.  as 
given  under  subhead  (4"),  Revision  of  Adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote 
Oil,  be  adopted. 

(3)  That  the  heading  "Specifications  for  Analysis  of  Creosote  Oil,'' 
as  it  now  stands  in  the  Manual,  be  changed  to  read  as  follows:  "Speci- 
fications for  the  Fractionation  of  Creosote  Oil." 

OUTLINE  OF  WORK  FOR   1912, 

Your  Committee  recommends  : 

(1)  Continue  investigations  of  the  merits  as  a  preservative  of  od 
from  water  gas  and  the  use  of  refined  coal-tar  in  creosote  oil. 

(2)  Continue  the  compilation  of  available  information  from  Service 
Tests. 

(3)  Continue  the  investigation  of  the  proper  grouping  of  the  dif 
ferent  timbers  for  antiseptic  treatment. 

(4)  Continue  consideration  of  the  revision  of  the  Specifications 
for  Fractionation  of  Creosote  Oil. 

(5)  Report  on  the  value  of  impregnation  with  crude  oil. 

(6)  Report  on  the  value  of  brush  coating  and  dipping. 

(7)  Report  on  methods  of  accurately  determining  the  absorption 
of  creosote  oil,  including  check  of  gage  readings  and  the  keeping  of 
corrected  records. 

(8)  That  the  Board  of  Direction  assign  the  work  of  drawing  up  a 
Standard  Specification  for  Timber  for  Treatment  to  a  Joint  Commit- 
tee of  the  Committee  on  Wood  Preservation  and  the  Committee  on 
Grading   of   Lumber. 

Respectfully  submitted, 
COMMITTEE   ON   WOOD    PRESERVATION. 


Appendix  A. 

GROUPING  OF  TIMBERS  FOR  ANTISEPTIC  TREATMENT. 


CHICAGO    TIE    AND    TIMBER    PRESERVING    COMPANY. 

The  information  furnished  by  this  company  covers  the  treatment  of 
red  oak  and  mixed  beech  ties  by  the  Card  process.  The  weights  as 
given  in  the  table  are  not  taken  from  selected  lots,  but  cover  the  daily 
practice.  The  cubical  contents  in  each  charge  was  estimated  by  displace- 
ment. The  computations  from  the  daily  log  sheets  were  made  by  the 
Forest  Products  Laboratory : 

Beech    (mixed)— Card  Process 
(includes-   gum,   elm,   basswnod,   etc. ) 
Weight       Absorption       No.    Ties 


Oak — Card  Process. 
Weight      Absorption       No.    Ties 
per  cu.  ft.    per  cu.  ft. 


used 


Pounds 

Pounds 

42 

14.6 

2,670 

43 

14-3 

7,5i6 

44 

14.6 

19.472 

45 

13-7 

32,727 

46 

13.8 

32,498 

47 

1 3-8 

10,323 

48 

144 

1,569 

49 

50 

13-9 

1,113 

5i 

13-3 

2,228 

52 

13.2 

1,668 

53 

12.5 

2,308 

per  cu. 

ft.     per  cu.   ft. 

used 

Pounds 

Pounds 

37 

20.6 

507 

38 

18.7 

1,723 

39 

21.6 

57i 

40 

18.5 

2,818 

4i 

19-3 

1,707 

42 

18.4 

3,972 

43 

17.4 

1,702 

44 

17.0 

5,H4 

45 

17.1 

3,414 

46 

17.2 

3.982 

47 

15-7 

4,027 

48 

15-6 

4.553 

49 

14.9 
Total 

2,313 

■36,463 

Total 114,092 

The  table  and  accompanying  diagram  show  clearly  that  the  absorp- 
tion per  cubic  foot  with  both  mixed  beech  and  red  oak  ties  falls  off  as 
the  treating  weights  of  the  ties  increase.  Thus  the  absorption  of  red 
oak  at  42  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  is  about  14^  lbs.  of  solution,  and  at  53  lbs.  per 
cu.  ft.  about  I2J/2  lbs.  For  mixed  beech  the  difference  is  even  more 
marked,  varying  from  about  21  lbs.  of  solution  at  37  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  to 
15   lbs.  absorption   at  a  treating  weight  of  49  lbs.  per  cu.   ft. 

GUI.FPORT    CREOSOTING    COMPANY. 

No  report  submitted. 


WOOD  PRESERVATION. 


860 


INTERNATIONAL    CREOSOTING    >V    CONSTRUCTION    COMPANY. 
No  report  submitted. 

KETTLE    RIVER    COMPANY. 

Report  that  they   never   reached  the  point  of   making  any  actual   ex- 
periments. 

DIAGRAM    SHOWING    THE    ABSORPTION    OF    RED    OAK    AND    MIXED 

BEECH  TIES  AT  VARIOUS  TREATING  WEIGHTS  PER   CU.   FT. 

CARD    PROCESS. 


< 

1 

it 

O  20 

Ik! 

ID 

a. 
in  i« 

3 

( 

1 

< 

> 

2    18 

5 

c 

>/ 

j 
0 

If)    17 

( 

'      c 

>>  /< 

/    c 

> 

0 

r 

O    16 

1- 

0. 

/<. 

1 

01 

?  r 

Mix 

zv 

bEE 

;cri 

< 

14 

A 

3 

< 

J 

Ret 

;>  C 

Al^ 

1 

t 

( 

> - 

! 

-j 

3 — < 

>    < 

) 

13 

5 — c 

> 

— ( 

Weight  or  TTE5  iN  L&5.  petr.  Cu.  Ft:  at  Time  or  "Treatment 

Basis   114,092  Red  Oak  Ties;   36,463  Mixed   Beech  Ties. 
Treated  by  the   Indiana  Zinc-Creosoting  Company,    Terre   Haute,    Ind.,    July, 

1909— January,   1910. 


NORTHERN     PACIFIC     RAILWAY. 

The   report  submitted  concerns  the   seasoning  and  treatment  of  pine, 
oak,  beech,  elm,  ash   and  hemlock  crossties  at  the   Paradise,   Mont.,   plant 


870  WOOD  PRESERVATION. 

of  the  Northern  Pacific  Railway.     The  data  were  compiled  by  the  Forest 
Products  Laboratory. 

Two  ties  of  each  of  the  above  species,  with  the  exception  of  the 
birch  and  hemlock,  of  which  foiir  ties  were  used,  were  piled  to  air-season 
in  a  shed  where  the  air  was  artificially  heated.  All  were  hewn  ties 
7  in.  by  9  in.  by  8  ft.  and  contained  an  average  of  sapwood  for  Minne- 
sota timber.  The  ties  were  weighed  from  time  to  time  to  ascertain  the 
rate  at  which  they  were  seasoning;  Fig.  1,  in  the  accompanying  diagram, 
showing  graphically  the  results  obtained.  After  the  ties  had  seasoned 
to  the  minimum  weight  shown  in  the  figure  they  were  placed  in  the  treat- 
ing cylinder  and  given  a  Lowry  treatment,  all  being  treated  in  exactly 
the  same  manner.  Fig.  2  shows  the  amount  of  creosote  absorbed  by  the 
ties  under  these  conditions.  Just  before  treatment  the  ties  had  the  fol- 
lowing weights  : 

Pine     1 10.50  lbs. 

Oak 164.25 

Birch   I53-50     ' 

Elm    135.75 

Ash 1 26.00 

Wisconsin    hemlock 168.00     " 

Of  special  note  is  the  rate  at  which  hemlock  seasoned,  as  compared 
with  the  other  woods,  and  the  large  amount  of  oil  absorbed  by  the  ash 
ties  as  compared  with  those  cut  from  oak  and  hemlock,  it  being  approxi- 
mately four  times  as  great. 

PENNSYLVANIA    RAILROAD    COML'AXY. 

At  the  Mt.  Union  and  Greenwich  plants  of  the  Pennsylvania  Railroad 
definite  experiments  are  under  way  to  determine  the  length  of  time  to 
season  the  different  species  handled,  the  results  from  various  methods 
of  piling  and  the  period  of  seasoning  which  will  give  the  best  results 
from  the  standpoint  of  treatment.  As  the  experiments  have  not  been 
in  progress  long  enough  to  arrive  at  a  definite  solution  of  the  several 
points,  it  will  only  be  possible  at  this  time  to  outline  the  nature  of  the 
work. 

The  experiments  at  the  two  plants  are  to  be  identical  in  character, 
the  tests  at  Mt.  Union  to  be  made  with  beech,  maple  and  red  oak  and 
at   Greenwich  with  beech,   red  oak,  black  gum   and   sap  pine. 

Two  definite  lines  of  experiments  are  under  way.  In  the  first  2; 
ties  of  each  species  are  to  be  weighed  and  piled  7x1,  and  at  the  end  of 
each  month  two  ties  of  each  kind  will  be  weighed  and  treated.  This 
work  was  started  in  April,  191 1,  but  another  series  will  be  conducted 
later  to  determine  the  inHueuce  of  climatic  conditions  in  different  seasons 
of  the  year.  The  data  eventually  produced  should  indicate  the  rapidity 
with  which  each  species  seasons  and  show  after  what  period  of  season- 
ing  the   treatment   is   most   effective. 


Wool)   PRESERVATION. 


871 


0 

5 

r    \ 
o    \ 

Ptrir- 
Oak. 

r 

LI 

If  i  t*i 

15 

IL 
O 

Asri 

h 

r 
■j 
u 

K 

U 
Cl- 
in 

o 

_) 

LI 

F 

IT) 
O 

Z 

Wl5CCt 

Isiri  He 

-lLOCK_ 

i 

IO  1ST  TO  25"  J>0  VS  AO  A3  50 

"5EA30NIMG   PERIOD -RAYS 

Fic    i — Rates  of  Artificial  Air  Seasoning  of  Untreated  Ties. 


Fig.2- 

A&50RPTIOr 

or  Creosote  (Lowry  Process 

or  Air  5easomed  TTes 

1 

Asri 

1 

tO  V5  30  55  .4-0  -43  SO  55  SO 

ad50rptioh-  poumds  per.1te 
Fig.  j — Absorption  of  Creosote  (Lowry  Process)  of  Air  Seasoned  Ties. 


872  WOOD  PRESERVATION. 

The  second  line  of  experiments  will  be  a  comparison  of  the  7x7  witfc 
the  7x1  piling  systems,  and  of  open  blocks  as  compared  with  solid  ones. 
In  this  test  a  whole  block  (six  piles  square)  of  oak  ties  at  Mt.  Union 
were  piled  solid  7x7;  adjoining  this  was  a  block  of  ties  7x7,  but  with 
2-foot  alleys  between  each  two  rows  of  piles;  while  another  adjoining 
block  was  piled  according  to  the  Company's  present  system,  with  the 
7x1  arrangement  in  the  piles,  2- ft.  alleys  between  each  two  tiers  of 
piles  and  4-ft.  alleys  between  the  blocks.  In  each  of  these  experimental 
blocks  a  large  number  of  ties  has  been  weighed,  marked  and  placed  in 
various  places  in  the  different  piles;  yet  in  each  block  the  marked  ties 
will  be  in  approximately  the  same  position.  These  ties  are  to  be  left 
for  8  or  0  months,  and  just  before  treatment  the  marked  ties  will  be 
weighed   and   the   comparative    rates    of    seasoning   noted. 

TEXAS   TIE   AND    LUMBER    PRESERVING    COMPANY. 

This  company  reports  that  the  grouping  and  seasoning  of  pine  ties. 
as  described,  is  in  connection  with  the  Rueping  empty-cell  process. 

"We  have  carried  the  segregation  of  pine  timber  a  little  further  than 
is  customary  when  we  can  do  so  and  have  tried  to  separate,  when  possible, 
ties  that  had  more  than  50  per  cent,  sapwood  from  those  that  had  less  and 
treated  them  in  different  charges.  Our  ties  at  Somerville  are  also  divided 
approximately  50  per  cent,  hewn  and  50  per  cent,  sawn,  and  of  our  sawn 
ties  we  get  approximately  65  per  cent,  heartwood  ties  with  very  little  sap, 
and  of  our  hewn  ties  we  get  only  about  10  per  cent,  of  long-leaf  ties, 
which  have  very  little  sapwood  on. 

''In  treating  ties  with  the  Rueping  process  we  find,  for  instance,  that 
we  have  to  put  in  from  ten  to  fifteen  pounds  more  air  in  the  sawn  tie 
that  are  65  per  cent,  heartwood  than  we  do  in  the  hewn  ties  that  are  only 
10  per  cent,  long  leaf,  with  small  sapwood  to  leave  in  the  same  amount 
of  oil  at  the  finish  of  the  treatment.  We  also  find  when  we  separate 
the  hewn  ties  in  saps  and  hearts  that  we  have  to  make  about  15  lbs. 
difference  in  the  air  to  leave  in  the  amount  of  oil  when  the  tie  is  treated. 
This  is  about  the  extent  of  our  findings  on  this  subject,  and  it  may  not  be 
of  interest  to  those  not  using  the  Rueping  process.'' 


Appendix  B. 
RECORD  OF  SERVICE  TESTS. 


OF 


any 
i  on 
is  of 
with 
they 

can 
t  all 
•ules 
rted 
;ame 
:orm 
light 
fere 

■ring 
De- 

eady 
year 


pre- 
ions 

data 

•555. 

bsti- 

3ro- 

)ers, 

55. 


APPENDIX    B 
RECORD  OF  SERVICE   TE5TS 

Us^ 

Qnof  E~jr  MoTW 

t 

'    ' 

■"'    ■ 

>-* 

? 

...-, 

■<". 

'-- 

De5cr>p 

?= 

,.„ 

-•' 

-J-'. 

5S 

■'- 

- 

If 

,,., 

"■ 

■~ 

OiTWrt 

-^K 

ss: 

"^ 

^ 

JS* 

= 

,. .  ,<.fl 

e-  ;■ 

<V-.—  ».,..-^,l:»ir--H 

"V 

"ill^ 

'^' 

- 

i— 

«* 

- 

- 

i 

- 

>  - 

,-.' 

,,,„ 

~ 

^Sf 

;:-;; 

» 

B 

-4T7 

■-:  ' 

-   DO 

ooo 

»' 

-  = 

_:„,  - 

." 

,„,.. 

.— 

, 

,U 

Wl„,n   .-...-..,-., 

■*-■■.- 

BO* 

50^ 

UM 

*- 

-„-. 

-j0-q| 

616 

soo 

»" 

»)l4. 

MO    • 

0.00 

DOO 

RM  il  !!,-„,   $«*. 

W 

:,, 

ssSS 

..' 

^.-.5 

Hi 

-V„.  IjhNIMVAIh 

V* 

SM5U™ 

MS', 

5 

g| 

*•»- 

*-=- 

= 

sS  ir~ 



— 7  * 

iHv~ 

'.  .. 

Vnngmn 

-7>:  :"  --      . 

-=;r    -'.':    E-.5f 

Variou, 

--.-.- 

« 

- 

[ 

- 

E 

«. 

K-r. 

- 

— 

=55 

^,. 

■  p 

""" 

B- 

— 

-2- 

Jz 

;n~45 

- 

•■"• 

— 

,, 

Pen.4u-.Jr,  -*«T  *fpt 
Vrt.k.y       ftbfW' 

_.'.•" 

-■* 

Hl'o 

REPORT  OF   SPECIAL  COMMITTEE  ON   GRADING  OF 

LUMBER. 

Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk,  Chairman;         B.  A.  Wood,  Vice-Chairman; 
D.  Fairchild.  W.  H.  Norris. 

R.  Koehler.  F.  B.  Walker. 

A.  J.  Neafie.  C.  W.  Richey. 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Special  Committee  on  Grading  of  Lumber  lias  not  held  any 
formal  meetings  during  the  year,  the  discussions  having  been  carried  on 
by  correspondence.  The  Committee  wishes  to  re-submit  the  Definitions  of 
Defects  and  Lumber  Grading  Rules  submitted  in  its  report  last  year,  with 
certain  slight  changes,  indicated  below.  The  Committee  believes  that  they 
fairly  represent  Specifications  for  Maintenance  of  Way  Lumber  as  it  can 
be  purchased  in  the  market  to-day.  The  rules  submitted  may  not  suit  all 
conditions.  It  is  pointed  out,  however,  that  the  acceptance  of  these  rules 
by  the  Association,  with  a  proviso  that  individual  grades  can  be  departed 
from  where  the  requirements  of  any  particular  road  seems  to  make  same 
necessary,  will  represent  a  great  step  forward  in  bringing  about  uniform 
rules  for  the  grading  of  lumber.  It  appears  to  the  Committee  that  slight 
differences  of  opinion,  concerning  one  or  more  grades,  should  not  interfere 
with  the  acceptance  of  these  rules  in  a  general  way. 

The  rules  as  submitted  last  year  have  been  changed  so  as  to  bring 
them  into  harmony  with  those  already  published  in  the  Manual.  The  De- 
scriptions and  Definitions  of  Defects  are  in  accord  with  those  already 
adopted  by  the  Association  ns  standard.  There  have  been  added  this  year 
Grading  Rules  for  Cypress  Lumber. 

RECOMMENDATIONS. 

Your  Committee  recommends  that  the  Lumber  Grading  Rules  as  pre- 
sented last  year,  subject  to  the  corrections  and  including  the  additions 
made  below,  be  adopted  as  standard. 

*Following  is  a  list  and  reference  to  the  Proceedings  where  the  data 
included  in  these  recommendations  can  be  found : 

(i)  Classification  and  Grading  Rules  for  Douglas  Fir  (pp.  5,48-555, 
Vol.  12,  Part  3,  Proceedings  for  191 1). 

(2)  Specifications  for  Douglas  Fir  Structural  Timbers.  (Substi- 
tute for  paragraphs  38-51,  inclusive,  pp.  556,  557,  Vol.  12,  Part  3,  Pro- 
ceedings, the  Specifications  for  Douglas  Fir  Bridge  and  Trestle  Timbers, 
as  given  on  pp.   143  and   144,  Manual,   191 1.     For  paragraphs  54  and   55, 

*See  also  Bulletin   133,   March,   1911. 

873 


874  GRADING    OF   LUMBER. 

page  557,  Vol.  12,  Part  3,  Proceedings,  substitute  paragraphs  1,  2,  3,  6  and 
7,  as  given  on  page  145,  Manual,  1911). 

(3)  Classification,  Grading  and  Dressing  Rules  for  Northern  Pine, 
including  White  and  Norway  Pine  and  Hemlock  (pp.  565,  577,  Vol.  12, 
Part  3,  Proceedings,  1911). 

(4)  Classification,  Grading  and  Dressing  Rules  for  Southern  Yellow 
Pine  (pp.  578-600,  Vol.  12,  Part  3,  Proceedings,  1911).  (For  paragraphs 
43-59>  inclusive,  substitute  paragraphs  1-14,  inclusive,  as  given  on  pp.  141 
and  142,  Manual,  1911.) 

(5)  Standard  Specifications  for  Construction  Oak  Timbers  (pp.  601- 
606,  Vol.  12,  Part  3,  Proceedings,  1911). 

(6)  Classification  and  Grading  Rules  for  Cypress  Lumber  and  Shin- 
gles, presented  in  this  report. 

Respectfully  submitted, 
SPECIAL  COMMITTEE  ON  GRADING  OF  LUMBER. 


Appendix   E. 

CLASSIFICATION  AND  GRADING  RULES  FOR   CYPRESS 
LUMBER  AND  SHINGLES. 

GENERAL  INSTRUCTIONS. 

Cypress  lumber  shall  be  graded  according  to  the  following  rules  and 
specifications,  bearing  in  mind  that  as  no  arbitrary  set  of  rules  and  speci- 
fications can  be  maintained  in  every  case,  much  must  be  left  to  the  common- 
sense  and  best  judgment  of  the  inspector: 

1.  Lumber  shall  be  manufactured  and  shipped  in  standard  lengths  and 
thicknesses. 

2.  Tank,  ist  and  26.  and  worked  partition  shall  be  graded  from  the 
poorer  side. 

3.  Select  lumber,  flooring,  ceiling,  bevel  siding  and  finishing  shall  be 
graded  from  the  better  or  finished  side,  but  the  reverse  side  should  in  no 
case  be  more  than  one  grade  lower. 

4.  All  lumber  shall  be  tallied  surface  or  face  measure,  the  tally  counted 
up,  and  the  one-quarter  or  one-half  added  to  the  total  where  the  lumber  is 
one  and  one-quarter  or  one  and  one-half  inches  thick,  and  2  in.  and  thicker 
to  be  multiplied  by  the  thickness. 

5.  In  the  measurement  of  all  lumber,  fractions  exactly  on  the  one-half 
foot  are  to  be  given  alternately  to  the  buyer  and  the  seller ;  the  fractions 
below  the  one-half  foot  are  to  be  dropped,  and  all  fractions  above  the  one- 
half  foot  are  to  be  counted  to  the  next  higher  figure  on  the  board  rule. 

6.  In  "line  boards,"  pieces  14  ft.  and  longer  shall  be  given  the  ad- 
vantage in  grade ;  pieces  12  ft.  and  shorter  shall  be  reduced  in  grade. 

7.  Recognized  defects  in  cypress  are  knots,  knot  holes,  shake,  splits, 
wane,  worm  holes,  stained  sap  and  peck. 

STANDARD  DEFECTS. 

8.  A  standard  knot  is  sound  and  not  to  exceed  i]4  in.  in  diameter. 

9.  A  small  sound  knot  is  one  not  exceeding  Y\  in.  in  diameter. 

10.  Two  small  knots  not  to  exceed  in  extent  or  damage  one  1^4  in. 
knot. 

11.  One  straight  split  not  to  exceed  in  length  the  width  of  the  piece. 

12.  Worm,  grub,  knot  and  rafting  pin  holes  not  exceeding  in  damage 
one  iJ4  'n-  knot. 

13.  Ordinary  season  checks  shall  not  be  considered  a  defect  in  any 
grade. 

14.  Ordinary  season  checks  are  such  as  occur  in  lumber  properly 
covered  on  yard,  or  season  checks  of  equal  size  in  kiln-dried  lumber. 

15.  Bright  sap  is  not  a  defect  in  select  or  below. 

16.  Pin  worm  holes,  sound  knots  and  stained  sap  shall  not  be  con- 
sidered a  defect  in  No.  1  barn  or  below. 

875 


876 


GRADING    OF   LUMBER. 


Standard  Sound  Knot. 


Rotten  Knot. 


GRADING   OF   LUMBER. 


877 


Two  Small  Knots  Equal  to  One  Standard  Knot. 


Small  Sound  Knot. 


878 


GRADING    OF   LUMBER. 


STANDARD   LENGTHS. 

17.  All  random  standard  length  stock  may  be  furnished  in  odd 
as  well  as  even  foot  lengths,  but  there  shall  not  he  to  exceed  20  per  cent, 
of  odd  lengths  in  any  one  item. 

18.  Tank  stock  and  No.  1  barn  shall  he  8  ft.  and  longer. 

19.  1st  and  2d  and  select  shall  be  10  to  20  ft. 

20.  Finish,  flooring,  ceiling,  partition,  bevel  and  drop  siding  shall  be 
10  to  20  ft. 


Pec 


KY    L.YPRESS. 


21.  Moldings  and  battens  of  all  sizes  6  to  20  ft,  in  both  odd  and  even 
foot  lengths,  but  not  exceeding  10  per  cent,  of  6,  7,  8  and  9  ft.  lengths. 

22.  No.  2  barn,  6  ft.  and  longer. 

23.  Cull  or  peck,  4  ft.  and  longer. 


STANDARD   FINISHED   SIZES   OF   CYPRESS. 

24.  All  lumber  shipped  in  the  rough  (except  8/4  in.  No.  1  and  No.  2 
"Dimension,"  which  grades  may  be  %-in.  under  or  J4_m-  over  tne  size 
specified,  both  in  thickness  and  width)  shall  be  of  sufficient  thickness  to 
S2S  to  standard  thickness,  as  follows : 

25.  4/4  lumber  SiS  or  S2S  shall  be  13-16  in.  thick. 

26.  5/4  select,  1st  and  2d  clear,  selected  common  tank  and  tank  lum- 
ber SiS  or  S2S,  shall  be  xTA  in.  thick. 

27-  5/4  peck,  No.  1  and  No.  2  barn  and  finishing  lumber  SiS  or  S2S, 
shall  be  1  1-16  in.  thick. 

28.  6/4  select  1st  and  2d  clear,  selected  common  tank  and  tank  lumber 
SiS  or  S2S,  shall  be  i^j  in.  thick. 


GRADING   OF  LUMBER.  879 

29.  6/4  peck,  No.  I  and  No.  2  barn  and  finishing  lumber  SiS  or  S2S, 
shall  be  1  5-16  in.  thick. 

30.  8/4  lumber,  except  No.  1  and  No.  2  barn  or  dimension  SiS  or 
S2S  shall  be  1^/4  in.  thick. 

31.  8/4  No.  1  and  No.  2  barn  or  dimension  SiS  or  S2S  shall  be  ify& 
in.  thick. 

32.  10/4  lumber  SiS  or  S2S  shall  be  2*4  in.  thick. 

33.  12/4  lumber  SiS  or  S2S  shall  be  2^4  in.  thick. 

34.  All  lumber  SiE  takes  off  }i  in.    S2E,  y2  in. 
35-     All  flooring  shall  be  S2S  and  C.  M. 

36.  4/4  flooring  shall  be  13/16  in.  by  2J4  in.,  3TA  in.,  4%  i"->  Sl4  in- 
face. 

37.  5/4  flooring  shall  be  1  1/16,  6/4  shall  be  1  5/16,  by  same  widths 
as  4/4. 

38.  Y%  ceiling  shall  be  worked  5/16  in.,  SiS  only. 
39-     ZA  ceiling  shall  be  worked  7/16  in.,  SiS  only. 

40.  Y%  ceiling  shall  be  worked  9/16  in.,  SiS  only. 

41.  Va,  ceiling  shall  be  worked  11/16  in.,  SiS  only. 

42.  All  widths  of  ceiling  to  be  the  same  as  flooring,  unless  otherwise 
specified.  Ceiling  up  to  3%  in.  face  to  have  one  bead  on  one  edge  and  ceil- 
ing wider  than  3%  in.  face  to  be  beaded  center  and  edge. 

43.  Partition  to  be  finished  the  same  as  ceiling,  but  on  both  faces. 

44.  Drop  siding  shall  be  worked  54  in.  by  3%  in.,  4%  in.,  5%  in., 
y%  in.,  g%  in.  face,  S2S  and  C.  M.  or  shiplapped. 

45.  Bevel  siding  or  bevel  cribbing  shall  be  worked  J4  in.  less  in  width 
than  the  rough  strip  measure. 

TANK   STOCK. 

46.  This  grade  shall  be  random  widths,  and  will  not  be  furnished 
in  specified  widths,  and  shall  be  graded  from  the  poorer  side. 

47.  This  grade  shall  be  5  in.  and  wider,  il/2  in.  to  4  in.  thick  and  8  ft. 
and  over  in  length.  Pieces  up  to  7  in.  shall  be  free  from  sap.  Pieces  7  in. 
to  13  in.  may  have  1  in.  of  sound  sap  on  one  edge,  not  to  exceed  half  the 
length  and  half  the  thickness  of  the  piece.  Pieces  14  in.  and  wider  may 
have  1  'n.  of  sound  sap  on  both  edges  not  to  exceed  half  the  length  and 
half  the  thickness  of  the  piece.  In  all  widths  sound  knots  that  do  not 
impair  usefulness  for  tank  purposes  may  be  admitted. 

FIRST  AND  SECOND  CLEAR. 

48.  This  grade  shall  be  random  widths,  and  will  not  be  furnished  in 
specified  widths,  and  shall  be  graded  from  the  poorer  side. 

49.  This  grade  shall  be  8  in.  and  wider,  1  in.  to  4  in.  thick  and  10  ft. 
and  over  in  length.  Pieces  8  in.  to  10  in.  may  have  1  in.  of  bright  sap  on 
each  edge,  or  its  equivalent  on  one  or  both  edges,  otherwise  they  must  be 
clear.     Pieces  10  in.  and  under  12  in.  may  have  i%  in.  of  bright  sap  on 


880  GRADING   OF  LUMBER. 

each  edge  or  3  in.  on  one  edge,  and  may  have  one  standard  knot  or  its 
equivalent.  Pieces  12  in.  wide  may  have  2  in.  of  bright  sap  on  each  edge, 
or  4  in.  on  one  edge  and  may  have  one  standard  knot;  or,  in  lieu  of  sap, 
may  have  two  standard  knots  or  their  equivalent.  Pieces  wider  than  12 
in.  may  admit  of  defects  as  specified  above  in  proportion  as  width  in- 
creases. Pieces  10  in.  and  wider  may  admit  of  cne  end  split,  which  shall 
not  exceed  in  length  the  width  of  the  piece.  Pieces  12  in.  and  less  in 
width,  free  from  other  defects,  may  have  bright  sap  across  one  face  at  one 
end,  but  this  sap  shall  not  exceed  in  length  one-tenth  of  the  length  of  the 
piece.    In  pieces  13  in.  and  wider  bright  sap  is  not  a  defect. 

SELECTS. 

50.  This  grade  shall  be  random  widths,  and  will  not  be  furnished  in 
specified  widths,  and  shall  be  graded  from  the  better  side,  but  the  reverse 
side  shall  not  be  of  a  lower  grade  than  No.  1  shop  or  No.  1  barn. 

51.  This  grade  shall  be  7  in.  and  wider,  but  will  not  be  furnished 
wider  than  12  in. ;  shall  be  1  in.  to  4  in.  thick,  10  ft.  and  longer.  Pieces 
10  in.  and  under  in  width  shall  admit  two  standard  knots  or  their  equivalent 
and  an  additional  standard  knot  or  its  equivalent  for  every  2  in.  in  width 
over  10  in.  Pieces  free  from  other  defects,  10  in.  and  over  in  width,  to  ad- 
mit pin  worm  holes  on  one  edge  one-tenth  the  width  of  the  piece.  Bright 
sap  is  not  a  defect  in  this  grade.  Slight  wane  on  pieces  10  in.  and  over  in 
width  is  allowed  on  one  edge  not  over  3  ft.  in  length.  When  no  other 
defect  appears,  slight  amount  of  stained  sap  may  be  allowed.  Pieces  10  in. 
and  wider  may  admit  of  one  end  split,  which  shall  not  exceed  in  length  the 
width  of  the  piece. 

SELECTED   COMMON    TANK    STOCK. 

52.  This  grade  shall  be  4  in.  .wide,  or  wider,  iY2  in.  and  2  in.  thick, 
8  ft.  and  over  in  length.  Sound  sap  no  defect  in  this  grade,  but  must  be 
free  from  unsound  knots  or  other  defects  that  extend  through  the  thick- 
ness of  the  piece,  and  must  be  square  edged  to  work  the  full  length 
of  the  piece. 

NO.    I   BARN  OR  DIMENSION. 

53.  This  grade  shall  be  specified  widths  only,  shall  be  3  in.  and  wider, 
1  in.  and  thicker,  8  ft.  and  over  in  length,  admitting  sap,  bright  or  stained, 
shake,  season  checks,  knots,  pin  worm  holes,  a  small  amount  of  peck  on 
one  side  and  one  edge,  or  very  slight  peck  on  both  sides  and  both  edges  of 
pieces  comparatively  free  from  coarse  defects ;  which  defects,  however, 
shall  not  be  sufficient  to  seriously  impair  the  strength,  or  prevent  the  use 
of  each  piece  for  "common"  purposes  in  its  full  length  and  full  width.. 

NO.    2   BARN    OR   DIMENSION. 

54.  This  grade  shall  be  specified  widths,  3  in.  and  wider,  1  in.  and 
thicker,  6  ft.  and  over  in  length,  admitting  all  the  defects  allowed  in  No.  1 


GRADING   OF  LUMBER.  881 

barn,  but  same  may  be  larger  and  coarser,  and  in  addition  will  admit 
peck  on  both  sides ;  however,  the  defects  shall  not  be  sufficient  to  prevent 
the  use  of  each  piece  in  full  length  and  full  width  for  low-grade  fencing 
and  other  very  common  purposes. 

CULL  OR  PECK. 

55.  This  grade  may  be  random  or  specified  widths  3  in.  and  wider, 

1  in.  to  4  in.  thick,  4  ft.  and  over  in  length.  Shall  admit  all  pieces  below 
the  grade  of  No.  2  boxing,  and  shall  also  admit  the  product  of  that  part 
of  the  log  known  as  "pecky;"  however,  each  piece  shall  have  sufficient 
strength  and  nailing  surface  to  permit  its  use  as  a  low  grade  boxing,  crat- 
ing, sheating  and  foundation  material. 

FINISHING. 

56.  Shall  be  specified  widths  4  in.  and  wider,  1  in.  to  2  in.  thick,  10  ft. 
and  over  long,  and  shall  be  graded  from  the  better  side,  A,  B  and  C,  but 
the  reverse  side  should  not  be  more  than  one  grade  lower.  All  grades  of 
finish,  rough  or  SiS  or  S2S  may  vary  J4  in-  from  the  width  specified. 

57.  "A"  Finish. — Pieces  4  in.  and  5  in.  wide  shall  be  clear  of  sap, 
knots  and  other  defects.  Pieces  6  in.  wide  may  have  1  in.  of  bright  sap: 
or  in  lieu  of  sap  one  small  sound  knot.    Pieces  7  in.  and  8  in.  wide  may  have 

2  in.  of  bright  sap,  or  in  lieu  of  sap  one  small  sound  knot.  Pieces  9  in. 
and  10  in.  wide  may  have  3  in.  of  bright  sap,  or  in  lieu  of  sap  two  small 
sound  knots,  or  1J/2  in.  of  bright  sap  and  one  small  sound  knot.  Pieces 
12  in.  wide  may  have  4  in.  of  bright  sap,  or  in  lieu  of  sap  one  standard  knot, 
or  two  small  sound  knots,  or  2  in.  of  bright  sap  and  one  small  sound  knot. 
Pieces  14  in.  or  wider  may  have  more  defects  in  proportion  as  the  width 
increases. 

58.  "B"  Finish. — Pieces  4  in.,  5  in.  and  6  in.  wide  may  have  2  in.  of 
bright  sap  and  one  or  two  small  sound  knots,  or  in  lieu  of  knots  may  have 
all  bright  sap.  Pieces  7  in.  and  8  in.  wide  may  have  3  in.  of  bright  sap  and 
two  small  sound  knots,  or  in  lieu  of  knots  may  have  all  bright  sap.  Pieces 
9  in.  and  10  in.  wide  may  have  4  in.  of  bright  sap  and  one  standard  knot 
or  three  small  sound  knots,  or  in  lieu  of  knots  may  have  all  bright  sap. 
Pieces  12  in.  wide  may  have  6  in.  of  bright  sap  and  one  standard  or  four 
small  sound  knots,  or  in  lieu  of  knots  may  have  all  bright  sap.  This 
grade  will  not  be  furnished  wider  than  12  in. 

59.  "C"  Finish. — All  widths  in  this  grade  shall  admit  small  sound 
knots,  stained  sap,  pin  worms  and  other  defects  except  shake;  but  none 
that  will  prevent  the  use  of  same  in  its  full  width  and  length  as  a  paint 
grade,  and  will  admit  pieces  containing  one  coarse  defect  which  can  be  re- 
moved by  making  two  cuts  with  a  waste  of  not  to  exceed  5  per  cent,  in  the 
one  piece  removed,  but  which  pieces  are  otherwise  "B"'  grade  or  better. 
This  grade  will  not  be  furnished  wider  than  12  in. 

60.  "D"  Finish. — All  widths  will  admit  sound  knots,  stained  sap,  pin 
worms,  slight  shakes,  and  other  defects ;  but  none  that  will  prevent  the  use 


882  GRADING    OF   LUMBER. 

of  same  in  its  full  width  and  length  as  a  common  paint  grade.    This  grade 
will  not  be  furnished  wider  than  12  in. 

SIDING. 

61.  Siding  shall  be  4  in.  and  6  in.  in  width,  10  ft.  to  20  ft.  in  length, 
and  graded  from  the  finished  side,  A,  B,  C  and  D. 

62.  "A"  Siding. — May  have  1  in.  of  bright  sap  on  thin  edge,  and  may 
contain  one  small  sound  knot. 

63.  "B"  Siding. — May  have  any  amount  of  bright  sap,  or  if  not  all 
bright  sap,  may  have  three  small  sound  knots,  shake,  split  or  pin  worm  holes 
not  exceeding  in  damage  the  three  small  knots  as  above,  and  may  have 
slight  wane  on  the  thin  edge.  In  the  absence  of  other  defects  a  small 
amount  of  stained  sap  will  be  permitted. 

64.  "C"  Siding. — May  have  one  to  five  knots,  the  whole  not  aggre- 
gating over  3  in.  in  diameter,  or  knots,  splits  or  other  defects  that  can  be 
removed  in  two  cuts  with  waste  not  exceeding  10  per  cent,  of  the  length, 
or  may  have  small  amount  of  stained  sap  and  pin  worm  holes  not  exceed- 
ing in  damage  the  five  small  knots  above  described. 

65.  "D"  Siding. — May  have  stained  sap  and  pin  worm  holes,  or  may 
have  other  defects  that  will  not  cause  a  waste  to  exceed  one-third  the  piece. 

FLOORING    AND    CEILING. 

66.  Shall  be  specified  widths,  10  ft.  to  20  ft.  in  length  and  graded 
from  the  finished  side,  or  if  both  sides  are  finished,  it  shall  be  graded  from 
the  better  side,  A,  B,  C  and  D. 

67.  "A" — May  have  bright  sap  on  one  edge  one-fourth  its  width,  other- 
wise must  be  clear. 

68.  "B" — May  have  one-half  of  its  face  bright  sap  if  otherwise  clear, 
or  in  lieu  of  sap,  may  contain  two  small  sound  knots,  or  may  have  a  split 
not  to  exceed  9  in.  at  one  end. 

69.  "C"  (10  to  20  ft.) — May  have  all  bright  sap,  or  may  have  one  to 
five  knots,  the  whole  not  aggregating  over  3  in.,  or  knots  or  other  defects 
that  can  be  removed  in  two  cuts  with  waste  not  exceeding  10  per  cent, 
of  the  length,  or  may  have  three  pin  worm  holes,  or  may  have  check  or 
split  at  one  end,  not  to  exceed  10  per  cent,  of  the  length. 

70.  "C"  (4  to  9  ft.) — May  have  all  bright  sap,  small  sound  knots, 
stained  sap,  pin  worm  holes  and  other  defects  except  shake,  but  none  that 
will  prevent  the  use  of  each  piece  the  full  length. 

71.  "D" — May  have  stained  sap  and  pin  worm  holes,  or  may  have 
unsound  knots  or  other  defects  that  will  not  cause  a  waste  to  exceed  one- 
third  the  piece. 

PARTITION. 

72.  Shall  be  same  widths  and  lengths  as  flooring  and  ceiling,  but  shall 
be  graded  from  the  poorer  side,  A,  B,  C  and  D,  same  grading  to  apply  as  in 
flooring  and  ceiling. 


GRADING   OF   LUMBER.  883 


72,.     Shall  be  graded  No.  1  and  No.  2. 

74.  1  in.  by  1  in.  shall  be  Headed  and  S4S  to  13-16  in.  by  13-16  in. 

75.  iH  in.  by  1%  in.,  shall  be  Headed  and  S4S  to  1  1-16  in.  by 
1  1-16  in. 

76.  iy2  in.  by  il/2  in.  shall  be  Headed  and  S4S  to  1  5-16  in.  by  1  5-16  in. 

77.  1  in.  by  3  in.  shall  be  Headed  and  S4S  to  Y\  in.  by  2^/2  in. 

78.  No.  1. — Shall  be  well  manufactured,  bright  sap,  no  defect  and  may 
contain  one  small  sound  knot. 

79.  No.  2. — Shall  admit  stained  sap,  sound  knots,  pin  worm  holes, 
slight  shake,  and  pickets  thrown  out  of  the  No.  1  grade  because  of  poor 
manufacture. 


80.  Battens,  both  flat  and  O.  G,  are  not  moldings.  Same  are  in- 
variably used  with  "common"  lumber  and  shall,  therefore,  be  graded  No. 
1  barn  and  better,  admitting  all  defects  allowed  in  No.  1  barn,  but  none 
that  will  prevent  the  use  of  each  piece  in  full  length  for  Batten  purposes. 
Y%  in.  Battens  shall  be  1  in.  strips  S2S  to  13-16  in.  by  2^/2  in.  and  re- 
sawed,  or  1  in.  by  2V4  in.  to  3  in.  S2S  and  resawed.  Unless  otherwise 
specified,  Y%  in.  or  flat  battens  shall  be  S2S  only  and  resawed. 

81.  O.  G.  Battens  shall  be  manufactured  in  the  sizes  and  pattern 
shown  in  the  Universal  Molding  Book. 

CAR   ROOFING   AND   SIDING. 

82.  "C  and  Better"  Grade. — This  grade  will  admit  sound  knots, 
stained  sap,  pin  worm  holes,  very  siight  shake  and  other  defects,  but  none 
that  will  prevent  the  use  of  each  piece  in  its  full  width  and  length  for 
car  roofing  and  car  siding ;  may  be  random  or  specified  lengths  and  may  be 
worked  to  pattern  specified  and  graded  from  pattern  side  or  S2S  and  C  M 
and  graded  from  the  better  side. 

car  lining. 

83.  Shall  be  specified  widths  and  8  to  20  ft.  in  length.  Will  admit 
tight  knots,  stained  sap,  pin  worm  holes,  slight  shake  and  other  defects, 
but  none  that  will  prevent  the  use  of  each  piece  in  its  full  width  and  length 
for  car-lining  purposes. 


84.  Bests. — A  dimension  shingle,  4,  5  and  6  in.  in  width,  16  in.  long, 
each  width  packed  separately,  5  butts  to  measure,  2  in.,  to  be  all  heart 
and  free  of  shake,  knots  and  other  defects. 

85.  Primes. — A  dimension  shingle,  4,  5  and  6  in.  in  width,  16  in.  long, 
each  width  packed  separately,  5  butts  to  measure  2  in.,  admitting  tight 
knots  and  sap,  but  free  of  shake  and  other  defects,  but  with  no  knots  within 
8  in.  of  the  butts. 


884  GRADING   OF   LUMBER. 

86.  This  grade  may  contain  shingles  clipped  two-thirds  of  the  width 
and  one-eighth  of  the  length  on  the  point. 

87.  Star  a  Star. — A  random  width  shingle  3  in.  and  wider,  14  in. 
to  16  in.  long,  otherwise  the  same  as  primes. 

88.  Economy. — Dimensions  4,  5  and  6  in.,  each  width  separately 
bunched,  admitting  sap  and  sound  knots,  may  have  slight  peck  5  in.  from 
butts,  imperfections  on  points  no  objection  and  admitting  14  in.  shingles. 

89.  Clippers. — All  shingles  below  the  above  grades  which  are  sound 
for  5  in.  from  the  butts,  worm  holes  and  slight  peck  excepted,  random 
widths  2^2  in.  and  wider. 

90.  The  count  of  our  manufacture  of  shingles,  of  all  grades,  is  based 
on  4,000  linear  inches  in  width,  making  1,000  standard  shingles,  conse- 
quently there  would  be  only  667  6-in.  shingles  packed  and  counted  as 
1,000  standard  shingles ;  5  in.  dimension  being  counted  in  like  proportion. 

91.  In  making  re-inspections  of  shingles,  one  bundle  out  of  20  bundles 
taken  at  random,  shall  be  cut  open,  the  results  of  this  investigation  to  form 
the  basis  of  arriving  at  the  grade  of  the  entire  shipment. 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  VI— ON  BUILDINGS. 

Maurice  Coburn,  Chairman;  M.  A.  Long,  P'ice-Cliairman; 

G.  W.  Andrews.  A.  T.  Hawk. 

W.  G.  Arn.  N.  H.  LaFountain. 

J.  P.  Canty.  E.  N.  Layfield. 

O.  P.  Chamberlain.  H.  A.  Lloyd. 

D.  R.  Collin.  John  S.  Metcalf. 

C.  G.  Delo.  J.  W.  Orrock. 

W.  T.  Dorrance.  W.  F.  Schultz. 

C.  H.  Fake.  W.  S.  Thompson. 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  on  Buildings  has  held  several  meetings  during  the 
year  at  Chicago,  Pittsburg  and  Buffalo,  besides  various  meetings  of  sub- 
committees. 

The  following  subjects  were  assigned  the  Committee  by  the  Board  of 
Direction: 

(i)  Report  on  the  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  various  types  of 
freight  house  floor  construction. 

(2)  Continue  the  study  of  roof  coverings. 

(3)  Present  principles  covering  the  design  of  inbound  and  outbound 
freight  houses. 

(4)  Continue  the  study  of  concrete  coaling  stations. 

The  Committee  reports  progress  on  subject  (1)  Report  on  the  ad- 
vantages and  disadvantages  of  various  types  of  freight  house  floor  con- 
struction. 

No  recommendations  are  made  as  to  revision  of  the  Manual. 

ROOF  COVERINGS. 

The  Committee  presents  as  information  some  miscellaneous  correc- 
tions and  additions  to  last  year's  report  on  roofing.  As  yet  the  report  is 
incomplete. 

The  Committee  had  hoped  this  year  to  present  specifications  for  coal- 
tar  pitch,  but  we  were  unable  to  offer  sufficient  inducements  to  extract  the 
necessary  information. 

Page  numbers  refer  to  the  annual  report  in  Vol.  12,  Part  1. 

Page  589,  last  paragraph:  A  single  asphalt  fluxed  by  a  single  oil  is 
ordinarily  an  imperfect  and  unsatisfactory  roofing  material.  Like  a  cut 
back  tar  pitch,  it  lacks  stability.  The  oil  is  liable  to  separate  out,  some- 
times supposedly  by  capillary  attraction  into  the  felt,  leaving  a  brittle  com- 
pound. The  successful  asphaltic  roofing  compounds  are  ordinarily  com- 
posed of  several  different  materials. 

885 


8SG  BUILDINGS. 

Page  590,  last  paragraph :  Elaterite  occurs  in  Utah  in  territory  near 
where  gilsonite  is  found,  and  has  much  the  same  appearance,  but  is  found 
only  in  narrow  veins.  Its  qualities  are  considerably  different  from  those 
of  gilsonite,  said  to  be  in  part  due  to  the  presence  of  considerable  sulphur. 
From  it  is  made  a  high-priced  product  which  is  supposed  to  be  espe- 
cially valuable  as  a  constitutent  of  the  protective  coating  of  ready  roofs. 
We  are  of  the  opinion  that  some  products  advertising  elaterite  contain  it 
in  only  small  quantities,  if  at  all. 

Page  591,  paragraph  2:  Rock  Asphalt  or  Mastic  Rock. — There  is  also 
bitumen  saturated  limestone  of  which  that  found  in  Uvalde  Countv,  Texas, 
is  an  example. 

Page  591,  last  paragraph :  The  first  two  sentences  should  be  changed 
to  read  as  follows :  "Eastern  oils  are  largely  made  up  of  compounds  of 
the  paraffine  series,  which  vary  in  consistency  from  comparatively  thin 
oil  to  hard  scale  paraffine." 

There  are  other  members  of  the  paraffine  series  which  are  light  gases. 

Page  592,  paragraph  1  :  The  method  of  distillation  of  California  oils 
profoundly  modifies  the  character  of  the  residual. 

Page  592,  paragraph  2 :  The  blown  oils  are  coming  to  be  more  appre- 
ciated. They  can  be  made  into  a  very  uniform  product  of  great  value  for 
many  purposes,  and  now  that  certain  patents  covering  them  are  expired, 
their  use  will  probably  broaden  considerably. 

Page  592,  paragraph  4 :  The  bitumen  in  the  coal-tar  includes,  besides 
the  hydrocarbons,  other  organic  compounds,  which  are,  however,  present 
in  roofing  pitch  only  in  small  quantities. 

Page  593,  last  paragraph:  Water  Gas  Tars. — In  making  carburetted 
water  gas,  the  procedure  is  as  follows :  Steam  is  blown  through  a  bed 
of  incandescent  coal  or  coke,  where  it  is  broken  up,  forming  blue  water 
gas,  which  consists  of  about  equal  quantities  of  hydrogen  and  carbon 
monoxide.  This  gas,  which  has  no  illuminating  value,  is  passed  into  a 
second  chamber,  which  is  filled  with  checker  brick  and  which  has  been 
previously  raised  to  a  high  temperature.  Into  this  chamber  is  sprayed 
petroleum  oil,  which,  by  the  intense  heat,  is  broken  down  into  permanent 
gas  and  a  tar  consisting,  in  the  main,  of  aromatic  hydrocarbons  similar 
to  those  occurring  in  coal-tar.  This  permanent  gas  is  of  high  illuminat- 
ing value  and  imparts  its  luminosity  to  the  blue  water  gas,  while  the  tars 
drop  out  further  on  in  the  process  of  manufacture.  It  is  from  this  tar 
that  water  gas  tar  pitch  and  other  products  are  obtained. 

Water  gas  tar  contains  some  free  carbon,  but  usually  not  over  2  per 
cent.  Its  pitch  is  not  acted  upon  by  water.  There  is  a  very  general  opin- 
ion among  practical  roofing  men  that  the  water  gas  tar  products  are  less 
stable  than  the  coal  tar  pitches,  but  we  cannot  find  that  there  has  been  any 
accurate  proof  of  this.  Its  small  percentage  of  free  carbon  materially  in- 
terferes with  its  value  as  a  roofing  pitch.  It  is  said  that  carbon  can  be 
added,  but  we  doubt  the  commercial  practicability  of  such  a  scheme. 

Page  596,  paragraph  6:  Burlap  decays  much  more  readily  than  the 
average  cotton  felt. 


BUILDINGS.  887 

Page  597,  last  paragraph:  To  combat  severe  conditions  encountered 
like  those  at  locomotive  engine  houses,  instead  of  the  dry  sheet,  an 
asphalt  or  oil-saturated  felt  is  sometimes  used.  This  does  not  so  readily 
deteriorate.  One  roofer  uses  for  this  purpose  asphalt  asbestos  sheets, 
which  are  perhaps  better  yet. 

Page  600,  last  paragraph :  General  specifications  for  an  asphalt 
built-up  roof  cannot  well  be  prepared  because  of  the  differences  in  ma- 
terials, and  ordinarily  must  come  from  the  manufacturers  of  the  ma- 
terials. 

The  successful  laying  of  an  asphalt  built-up  roof  in  cold  weather  is  a 
difficult  matter.  If  the  asphalt  is  hot  enough  to  be  properly  handled,  there 
is  chance  of  charring  the  felts.  On  steep  slopes  thorough  mopping  is 
difficult  and  there  is  chance  of  danger  to  the  men.  One  of  the  chief  rea- 
sons for  deterioration  of  the  asphalt  is  supposed  to  be  gradual  absorp- 
tion, due  to  capillary  action  of  the  flux  into  the  felt. 

Page  601,  second  paragraph  :  Asbestos  Asphalt  Built-Up  Roofings. — 
It  is  claimed  that  asbestos  felt,  acting  as  it  does  more  as  a  protection  to 
the  layers  of  waterproofing  material  and  not  merely  as  a  medium  for 
carrying  them,  does  not  have  any  capillary  action  on  the  oil  fluxes,  and 
that  the  bitumen  is  so  protected  that  it  retains  its  elasticity  and  water- 
proofing qualities  much  longer  than  with  the  other  types  of  felt.  If  this 
point  is  sustained,  asbestos  felts  have  a  superiority  for  asphalt  roofing 
over  the  ordinary  felts  which  may  more  than  overbalance  the  increased 
costs.  While  the  experience  obtained  from  this  material  is  not  nearly  as 
extended  as  that  which  has  been  had  from  rag  felts,  these  roofings  have 
been  in  use  for  about  eleven  years,  and  we  have  so  far  found  nothing  to 
disprove  this  claim. 

The  asbestos  felt  has  advantage  due  to  its  freedom  from  action  by 
fire  and  decay,  and  it  is  claimed  that  the  asbestos  roofings  have  a  consid- 
erable value  in  their  blanketing  influence  on  fires  inside  the  building  cov- 
ered, which  the  ordinary  felts  do  not  have,  points  the  value  of  which  we 
consider  have  been  overemphasized.  The  asbestos  felt  is  not  in  any  dan- 
ger of  being  charred  by  hot  asphalt  which  sometimes  happens  with  rag 
felts. 

The  asbestos  built  up  roofings  also  avoid  the  gravel  or  slag  necessary 
with  the  ordinary  "wool"  felt  built-up  roofing.  This  freedom  from  the 
use  of  gravel  or  slag  with  its  tendency  to  roll. or  be  washed  off  the  roof 
into  the  gutters  would  seem  to  be  of  some  advantage.  This  also  makes  it 
easier  to  locate  a  leak  and  leaves  the  asbestos  roofings  much  lighter  in 
weight  than  the  other  types,  an  advantage  which  is  probably  to  some  ex- 
tent offset  by  the  insulating  power  of  the  much  greater  amounts  of  ma- 
terial used  with  the  "wool"  felt.  As  with  all  built-up  asphalt  roofings, 
difficulties  encountered  in  the  mopping  make  a  slope  of  not  more  than 
three  inches  to  the  foot  desirable. 

Tar  has  not  been  successfully  used  with  asbestos  felts. 

As  compared  with  a  five-ply  tar  and  gravel  roof  a  four-ply  asbestos 
roof  will  ordinarily  cost  at  least  from  one  to  two  dollars  more  a  square. 


888  BUILDINGS. 

A  three-ply  roof  is  supposed  to  give  good  results  over  concrete,  but  for 
wood  sheathing  it  would  seem  to  be  approaching  too  closely  to  the  condi- 
tions met  with  in  ready  roofing,  for  first-class  work. 

Page  609,  paragraph  2:  Concrete  Roofings. — The  Asbestos-Portland 
.  cement  shingles  seem  to  be  gaining  ground.  The  different  manufacturers 
use  different  methods  and  the  results  obtained  must  be  used  with  caution, 
as  it  is  claimed  that  the  methods  of  manufacture  have  an  important  bear- 
ing on  the  results  which  may  be  expected.  Shingles  of  this  type  are  said 
to  have  been  successfully  used  abroad  for  many  years.  Recent  changes 
are  said  to  have  much  improved  the  quality  of  the  material. 

For  small  buildings,  or  where  the  design  is  such  as  to  make  tile  un- 
desirable, they  have  especial  advantages.  The  growing  difficulty  of  ob- 
taining good  slate  should  tend  to  increase  their  sale.  Their  cost  is  some- 
what greater  than  good  slate,  but  their  uniformity  is  such  that  they  can 
more  successfully  be  laid  French  or  diagonal  method  than  can  slate.  A 
considerable  saving  can  be  made  by  laying  them  French  method,  but  we 
do  not  consider  this  good  practice  especially  with  large  sheets  (see  dia- 
gram). The  material  is  somewhat  brittle  and  with  this  method  consid- 
erably greater  amounts  of  breakage  are  to  be  expected,  especially  on  the 
points. 

When  new,  some  water  may  be  absorbed,  but  as  they  grow  older  this 
defect  tends  to  disappear. 

The  corrugated  sheets  should  have  value  as  a  substitute  for  corru- 
gated iron  sheets.  They  must  be  laid  with  good  fastenings  and  sufficient 
lap  to  insure  against  leakage.  They  must  not  be  nailed.  Some  of  these 
materials  are  strengthened  by  wire  mesh  and  some  with  perforated  steel 
sheets  grading  toward  the  metal  protected  by  asphalt  and  asbestos. 

Gutters. 

Gutters  for  many  classes  of  railway  buildings  may  and  should  be 
omitted.  This  is  more  particularly  true  of  buildings  with  steep  roofs  near 
tracks  where  cinders  from  passing  locomotives  roll  down  the  roof  into  the 
gutters  and  in  time,  unless  more  care  is  taken  to  keep  them  clean  than  is 
usual  in  railway  buildings,  the  downspouts  become  choked  and  fail  to 
carry  off  the  water. 

Gutters  may  be  of  metal,  wood,  or  be  formed  in  roof  of  the  materials 
used  in  the  construction  of  the  roof,  the  latter  being  ordinarily  preferable 
where  the  design  of  the  building  permits. 

Wood  gutters  are  usually  of  Ogee  form  on  the  outside  and  owing  to 
the  thickness  of  shell  the  capacity  is  small  for  the  size  of  the  gutters. 
They  are  made  in  three  sizes,  3x4,  4x5  and  4x6.  The  capacity  of  these 
sizes  is,  however,  scarcely  more  than  one-fourth  the  same  size  of  metal 
gutters  of  equal  outside  dimensions.  They  are  the  most  durable  kind  of 
gutters  for  buildings  exposed  to  smoke  and  cinders.  They  are  usually 
made  of  fir,  white  pine  or  cypress  and  should  be  painted  inside  and  out 
every  few  years. 

Metal  gutters  are  made  of  copper,  galvanized  steel,  iron,  tin  or  zinc. 
For  permanent  buildings,  copper  is  preferable.     All  joints  should  be  sol- 


BUILDINGS.  889 

dered  and  riveted  with  not  less  than  four  rivets  for  smaller  sizes  and 
should  be  well  braced  at  least  every  four  feet  and  proportionately  increased 
in  number  for  larger  sizes.  The  common  grades  of  galvanized  "steel  often 
used  cannot  be  depended  on  for  more  than  two  or  three  years.  Some  of 
the  refined  irons  now  on  the  market  should  be  of  value  for  this  purpose. 
Cast-iron  gutters  are  used  to  a  limited  extent. 

Gutters  may  be  built  in  the  roof,  or  hanging,  as  the  design  of  the 
building  requires.  Hanging  gutters,  which  are  easier  to  repair,  and  which 
do  not  damage  the  building  if  defective,  are  generally  preferable.  They 
should  be  given  as  much  slope  as  practicable  to  the  various  downspouts 
and  the  outer  edge  of  hanging  gutters  should  be  low  enough  to  avoid 
chance  of  damage  by  possible  backing  up  of  water  due  to  stopped-up  gut- 
ters and  conductor  pipes. 

Copper  gutters  should  be  given  a  coat  of  linseed  oil  and  tin  gutters  a 
coat  of  iron  oxide  paint  soon  after  hanging,  and  galvanized  iron  should 
not  be  painted  until  about  a  year  of  exposure  to  the  weather  unless  a 
special  acid  treatment  is  applied  to  provide  a  surface  which  will  hold  the 
paint.  If  a  galvanized  iron  roof  is  used  where  copper  gutters  are  applied, 
care  should  be  taken  to  insulate  or  separate  the  two  metals  so  that  gal- 
vanic action  will  be  prevented. 

FLASHINGS. 

The  following  definitions,  together  with  the  diagrams,  are  presented 
as  information  concerning  flashings.  The  numbers  accompanying  the  dif- 
ferent diagrams  refer  to  the  numbers  of  the  definitions. 

(i)  Flashings  are  the  mechanical  unions  between  roof  surfaces  and 
other  parts  of  the  structure  intersecting  and  bounding  the  plane  of  the 
roof,  and  between  roofs  in  different  planes. 

(2)  Vertical  Flashings  are  flashings  between  roofs  and  other  parts 
of  the  structure  which  intersect  the  plane  of  the  roof  and  extend  through 
or  above  the  roof.     (Examples:     Walls,  parapets,  combings,  soil  pipes.) 

(3)  Lateral  Flashings  are  flashings  between  roofs  and  other  parts 
of  the  structure  which  bound  the  roof  or  which  intersect  the  plane  of  the 
roof  without  extending  above  it,  or,  flashings  between  roofs  in  different 
planes.  (Examples:  Cornices,  eaves,  gutters,  leader  heads,  ridges,  hips, 
valleys.) 

(4)  Head  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  approximately  at  right 
angles  to  the  general  slope  of  the  roof,  at  the  top  of  the  incline. 

(5)  Side  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  approximately  parallel  to 
the  general  slope  of  the  roof. 

(6)  Foot  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  approximately  at  right 
angles  to  the  general  slope  of  the  roof,  at  the  foot  of  the  incline 

(7)  Expansion  Flashings  are  flashings  built  of  two  independent  parts, 
each  of  which  is  respectively  an  integral  part  of  the  roof,  and  of  the  ad- 
joining structure. 

(8)  Base  Flashing  is  that  part  of  an  expansion  flashing  which  is  an 
integral  part  of  the  roof. 


890  BUILDINGS. 

(9)  Cap  or  Counter  Flashing  is  that  part  of  an  expansion  flashing 
which  is  an  integral  part  of  the  adjoining  structure. 

(10)  Continuous  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  integral  parts  of 
both  roof  and  adjoining  structure,  without  slip  or  expansion  joint. 

(11)  Protective  Flashing  is  that  part  of  a  continuous  flashing  which 
is  an  integral  part  of  the  adjoining  structure,  but  which  does  not  form  an 
expansion  joint  with  a  base  flashing. 

(12)  Homogeneous  Flashings  are  flashings  built  of  the  same  ma- 
terials as  the  roof. 

(13)  Mixed  Flashings  are  flashings  formed  of  materials  other  than 
materials  of  the  roof.  (Examples:  A  metal  base  flashing  for  a  felt 
roof.) 

(14)  Natural  or  Structural  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  formed 
structurally  integral  with  the  roof  or  adjoining  structure.  (Example:  A 
cap  flashing  built  into  a  raglet  in  a  parapet  wall.) 

(15)  Artifical  Flashings  are  flashings  which  are  not  structurally  in- 
tegral with  either  the  roof  or  the  adjoining  structure.  (Example:  A 
"base"  or  "continuous"  flashing  supported  upon  the  adjoining  structure 
by  adhesion  of  materials,  or  outside  cleats.) 

The  accompanying  diagrams  are  designed  to  be  only  illustrative  of  the 
distinctions  denned  above.  No  effort  has  been  made  to  formulate  recom- 
mendations for  details  of  applications  of  different  materials  under  differ- 
ent conditions. 

The  report  has  been  signed  by  Maurice  Coburn,  M.  A.  Long,  G.  W. 
Andrews,  J.  P.  Canty,  O.  P.  Chamberlain,  D.  R.  Collin,  C.  G.  Delo,  W.  T. 
Dorrance,  C.  H.  Fake,  C.  F.  W.  Felt,  A.  T.  Hawk,  E.  N.  Layfield,  W.  G 
Arn. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON  BUILDINGS. 


8 

fe  I  b  i,  ^ 

eels 


ri 


fe 


S    Q 


892 


BUILDINGS. 


BUILDINGS. 


893 


894 


BUILDINGS. 


BUILDINGS. 


y//////////.'::y///////////y///A 

Details  of  Flashing  and  Counter  Flashing  for  Roofs  and  Walls. 


896 


BUILDINGS. 


45fTI/VG  FOJ2  SZ./ZT^&OOF 


M/xeo  c*p  «/?5y/,v6 


Off  HEAP  P/.rfS/1/i\G 


FOOT  FZ.jZSJYIsYG  sSCrfZ/V&T 

N° 2-6-8-9-11-14 

Details  of  Flashing  and  Counter  Flashing  for  Roofs  and  Walls. 


BUILDINGS. 


897 


'«gS 


a;  ,Crt  O 
.-J-'-1  fc.  *j  t3 


O       *J  *->  0> 

•°  d  •-•  '£  -0 

(•So?- 

en  v<M  0J  CJ  rt 

g  t-iSaw 

»  <D     ■ 

CD 


0) 


-*-*  —    Ui    TO 

■aiSS-S'S'e 

"O  c  03  Jj  £  — 

5  '^  —  '*-'_-  TD 

-  S  £  >•<:  c 

i.  XJ  ta  t,    .2 

a) —     3!  cm 
-^  S      --Q 

cS        P    .  P 

t.  +j  o  s-.  r  c 
cfl  in  sz  <a  o  <ti 

C        H->  01 

-       tn  o3       w 

£  ta-7  45  a.c 

c  <1> 

0)  >   >.       ., 

4) 

N 


tn  tn 

o  —  **-* 


03  o  ' 

o> 


M>J-7v^9)  « 

•S  4><iS>bfl 

^  «  C  ^ 

tn  o>  +->      to  +j 
o  .     O 

»  tn  O  -5  ra 
a>  0)  0    . 

in  bo  „  *-•"  <u 
d  C  t,«  -  > 

C  <n  S  C  5 
i     .  ,    w  a  4) 

_•  >>£•  c  o  £ 

i        £o^* 
50  C  i  ■g  .S  Ml 

*■*  V  c      o  c 

°tDO  mftBl 
O  .  bD""1 

g°ftrart§ 

<i  JU  oS  G  of  w 
a    '7—9' 

cd,Qr-<  C5 


REPORT  OF  COMMITTEE  IX— ON   SIGNS,  FENCES 
AND  CROSSINGS. 


C.  H.  Stein,  Chairman; 

H.    E.    BlLLMAN. 

G.  E.  Boyd. 
L.  C.  La wto n. 
E.  R.  Lewis. 


A.  M.  Funk,  J'ice-Clhiirimiu ; 

J.  B.  Myers. 

F.  M.  Patterson. 

C.  H.  Splitstone. 

W.  D.  Williams. 

Committee/ 


To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

The  following  subjects  were  assigned  your  Committee  by  the  Board 
of  Direction : 

(i)  Continue  the  investigation  of  ways  and  means  for  securing  a 
proper  quality  of  fence  wire  to  resist  corrosion  and  secure  durability. 

(2)  Report  on  the  relative  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  the  dif- 
ferent kinds  of  fence  posts. 

(3)  Report  on  the  best  form  of  track  construction  and  flangeways 
at  street  crossings  in  paved  streets. 

(4)  Report  on  the  relative  advantages  ami  disadvantages  of  the 
different  kinds  of  telegraph  poles. 

A  general  Committee  meeting  was  held  at  the  Fort  Pitt  Hotel,  Pitts 
burg,  Friday,  September  22,  191 1,  at  10:00  a.  m.,  which  discussed  the  sub- 
jects assigned.    Those  present  were  C.  H.  Stein,  Chairman;  H.  E.  Billman, 
G.  E.  Boyd,  E.  R.  Lewis,  L.  C.  Lawton,  W.  D.  Williams. 

In  the  afternoon  the  Committee  visited  the  Donnra  plant  of  the 
American  Steel  and  Wire  Company,  and  investigated  their  process  of 
making  wire  from  the  ingot  to  the  finished  woven  wire  product. 

The  Committee  decided  to  devote  its  attention  to  the  first  three  sub- 
jects assigned  by  the  Board  of  Direction,  and  also  to  investigate  the  gen- 
eral subject  of  miscellaneous  signs  for  railroad  purposes.  A  series  of 
questions  were  prepared  for  submission  to  the  various  railways  with  a 
view  to  determining  the  practice  in  vogue  at  this  time  and  to  secure  the 
benefit  of  data  that  had  been  accumulated  from  experiments  made  in  recent 
years  with  various  forms  of  fencing  wires,  and  by  various  processes,  as 
well  as  with  various  kinds  of  wooden  and  concrete  fence  posts.  Replies 
were  received  from  44  railways  of  the  United  States  and  Canada,  repre- 
senting 61,000  miles  of  track,  which  developed  the  following  information : 

(1)     28  roads  are  using  woven  wire  exclusively; 
6  roads  are  using  barb  wire  exclusively; 
2  roads  are  using  ribbon  wire  exclusively ; 
5  roads  are  using  both  barb  and  woven  wire. 

900 


SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS.  901 

Woven  wire  49  in.  to  55  in.  in  height  appears  to  be  generally  used. 
Specifications  in  use  refer  merely  to  method,  form  of  erection,  and  style 
of  fence,  and  give  practically  no  consideration  to  quality  of  wire  or  process 
of  manufacture.  The  wire  companies  seem  to  control  this  latter  feature 
exclusively.  In  a  couple  of  cases  compliance  with  the  specifications  of 
the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association  is  recommended  but  not 
explicitly  demanded.  Only  two  of  the  roads  are  making  any  experiments 
in  the  development  of  the  subject.  Experiments  in  one  case,  started  April 
1,  1909,  are  being  conducted  with  wires  grouped  in  four  classes,  as  follows: 

(a)  Galvanized  after  weaving; 

(b)  Ordinary   dip   process; 

(c)  Special  galvanized ; 

(d)  Sherardized. 

When  examination  was  last  made,  less  than  a  year  ago,  (a),  galvanized 
after  weaving,  was  found  to  be  in  perfect  condition;  (b),  ordinary  dip 
process,  began  to  corrode  during  the  first  year.  The  corrosion  was 
not  so  rapid  during  the  second  year,  but  was  sufficiently  pro- 
gressive to  indicate  that  deterioration  would  soon  become  serious,  and 
the  wire  go  to  pieces  at  points  where  stay  wires  were  woven  around  the 
longitudinal  ones;  (c),  special  galvanized,  was  found  to  be  in  excellent 
condition.  No  corrosion  was  apparent,  and  the  wires  were  still  bright. 
This  process  is  still  in  an  experimental  stage,  and  investigations  will  be 
continued,  (d),  Sherardized.  This  is  a  process  in  which  the  wire  is 
placed  in  air-tight  receptacles  and  zinc  flue  dust  packed  about  it.  The 
receptacles  are  then  heated  for  a  given  period  of  time  at  a  temperature 
somewhat  below  the  melting  point  of  zinc,  the  zinc  forming  a  coating  over 
the  wires.  At  the  time  the  test  was  commenced,  this  process  was  not  yet 
far  advanced,  and  later  developments  may  give  some  promise  of  success. 
The  results  in  this  case,  however,  were  not  good. 

Similar  tests  were  commenced  under  the  auspices  of  the  American 
Society  for  Testing  Materials  on  the  grounds  of  the  Carnegie  Technical 
School,  Pittsburg,  Pa.,  on  September  26,  1908.  The  results  of  these  tests 
will  be  watched  with  interest  and  profit.  Several  rolling  mills  are  now 
rolling  what  is  claimed  to  be  a  pure  metal,  running  about  99.95  per  cent, 
pure  iron,  and  exceedingly  low  in  sulphur,  carbon  and  phosphorus.  This 
is  being  used  for  a  variety  of  purposes,  and  we  understand  that  it  can  be 
drawn  into  wire.  This  may  develop  into  a  proper  material  for  wire 
making  purposes  with  efficient  rust  resisting  properties. 

Copper  clad  wire  is  also  a  form  of  material  that  is  attracting  consid- 
erable attention.  This  consists  of  a  steel  core  surrounded  by  a  copper 
jacket  applied  by  mechanical  means.  The  American  Consul  at  Birmingham 
recently  called  the  attention  of  the  State  Department  of  this  Government 
to  the  announcement  in  a  British  Journal  of  a  new  rust-proofing  process 
for  iron  and  steel  that  is  said  to  be  cheap  and  efficient. 

The  article  to  be  protected  is  boiled  in  a  solution  whose  proportions 
are:     Water,  one  gallon;  phosphoric  acid,  four  ounces,  and  one  ounce  of 


90^  SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS. 

iron  filings.  This  produces  a  black  non-corroding  coating  that  is  durable. 
These  different  products  and  methods  will  be  further  investigated  during 
the  coming  year. 

It  might  be  stated  that  English  roads  use  a  much  heavier  wire  than 
those  in  this  country,  usually  No.  4  to  No.  6  gage.  All  of  it  is  unwiped, 
and  it  is  said  they  use  a  better  grade  of  spelter  than  we  do. 

At  the  present  time,  undoubtedly  the  wire  galvanized  after  weaving 
has  proved  most  durable  and  efficient,  but  only  certain  forms  of  weaving 
appear  at  this  writing  to  be  adapted  to  that  process.  Progress  is  being 
made,  however,  and  if  tests  now  being  conducted  demonstrate  that  this 
is  the  only  manner  in  which  desired  results  may  be  obtained,  the  larger 
wire  mills  will  discover  a  means  of  accomplishing  it  if  the  railway  com- 
panies  insist   upon   it. 

(2)  Report  on  the  relative  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  the  dif- 
ferent kinds  of  fence  posts. 

Nine  roads  which  replied  to  circular  are  beginning  to  use  concrete 
posts,  and  we  know  of  others  using  them,  which  gave  us  no  information. 
Experiments  have  been  conducted  for  too  short  a  period,  however,  to  enable 
them  to  make  a  definite  statement  as  to  their  durability,  economy  and 
efficiency. 

The  tendency  toward  the  use  of  concrete  posts,  however,  is  becoming 
very  pronounced,  and  we  should  in  the  course  of  the  next  year  or  so  be 
able  to  secure  some  very  valuable  and  satisfactory  information.  The  prices 
for  concrete  posts  appear  to  vary  between  18  and  40  cents,  but  the  figure 
largely  prevailing  for  the  most  popular  form  of  post  now  on  the  market  is 
18  to  22  cents.  Since  the  cost  of  the  various  kinds  of  wood  posts  now  in 
use  ranges  from  12  cents  to  40  cents,  the  prevailing  cost  being  12  to  15 
cents,  the  difference  is  not  so  great  as  to  act  as  a  prohibition  to  the  use  of 
concrete.  The  woods  used  are  necessarily  those  native  to  the  road  and 
consist  of  Oregon  fir ;  red,  white  and  Michigan  cedar ;  black,  yellow  and 
honey  locust;  catalpa;  tamarack;  mulberry,  juniper;  hois  d'arc,  chestnut: 
white  and  pin  oak. 

Several  forms  of  metal  posts  are  now  being  manufactured,  and  it  is 
claimed  by  a  large  manufacturer  that  they  will  have  a  life  of  at  least  thirty 
years  and  can  be  delivered  at  reasonable  distances  at  a  price  of  23  cents 
f.  o.  b.  line  of  road.  These  will  also  receive  our  attention  during  the  cur- 
rent year,  in  connection  with  the  further  investigation  of  concrete  posts. 

(3)  Report  on  the  best  form  of  track  construction  and  flangeways  at 
street  crossings  in  paved  streets. 

The  customary  practice  is  the  very  old  one  of  turning  an  old  light 
rail  on  its  side  and  backing  it  up  with  wood  plank,  planking  solid  with 
wood  or  planking  next  to  rail  and  paving  with  blocks  or  brick  between. 
The  rail  or  plank  forms  the  flangeway.  Five  roads  of  the  forty-four 
referred  to   use  some   special  form  of  rail  or  flangeway  through   paved 


SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS.  903 

streets.  In  several  of  the  cases  a  141-lb.  girder  rail  is  employed  with 
suitable  compromise  bars  at  each  end  to  connect  to  the  tee-rail  sections. 
In  three  cases  a  special  form  of  rolled  filler  or  flangeway,  similar  to  angle 
bar  construction,  with  extension  beyond  the  rail  head  similar  to  street 
car  flangeways,  is  being  considered  and  gives  promise  of  successful  appli- 
cation. Correspondence  is  now  in  progress  with  the  steel  company  to  roll 
a  trial  order,  and  it  is  hoped  the  experiment  may  be  made  during  the  course 
of  this  year,  which  would  perhaps  enable  us  to  make  a  definite  recom- 
mendation at  the  next  convention. 

(4)  Report  on  the  relative  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  the 
different  kinds  of  telegraph  poles. 

This  subject  was  not  investigated,  as  very  few  experiments  have  thus 
far  been  conducted  with  this  form  of  construction.  The  industry  is  grow- 
ing, however,  and  attention  will  be  given  it  this  year. 

SIGNS    FOR    RAILROAD     PURPOSES. 

There  is  a  growing  demand  for  uniformity  of  signs  for  all  railroad 
purposes.  It  is  obvious  that  it  would  be  a  desirable  end  to  be  obtained 
if  all  signs  for  use  in  giving  information  to  ihe  public  or  employes  were 
of  a  similar  design  in  all  parts  of  the  country.  The  Committee  has  been 
investigating  the  subject  with  the  purpose  of  producing  uniformity,  and 
securing  substantial  and  economic  signs,  but  has  not  progressed  to  the 
point  where  a  conclusion  can  be  reached.  It  will  recommend  the  subject 
for  definite  recommendations  at  the  next  convention. 

Much  information  has  been  received  in  regard  to  the  foregoing  sub- 
jects, but  it  has  not  been  in  a  sufficiently  substantial  form,  nor  in  the 
nature  of  such  new  information,  that  would  warrant  the  Committee  in 
making  any  recommendations  in  the  shape  of  conclusions.  The  various 
subjects,  however,  are  in  a  progressive  stage,  and  with  the  mass  of  informa- 
tion now  at  hand  it  appears  that  the  Committee  will  be  enabled  at  the 
next  convention  to  put  the  matters  in  definite  shape. 

We  have  been  handicapped  very  much  in  failing  to  secure  information 
from  our  letters  of  inquiry.  Many  roads  from  whom  we  expected  to  get 
beneficial  data  have  failed  entirely  to  reply  to  our  circulars  for  informa- 
tion. It  is  possible  that  this  is  due  to  the  fact  that  there  are  so  many 
committees  of  the  Association  reporting  on  so  many  different  subjects 
that  it  is  practically  impossible  for  the  engineering  officers  to  compile  the 
necessary  information  and  satisfy  all  of  the  inquiries.  The  solution  to 
this  problem  would,  therefore,  be  that  fewer  subjects  should  be  assigned 
for  investigation  and  thus  relieve  the  roads  of  the  great  amount  of  labor 
that  is  now  necessary  in  securing  and  compiling  the  data  on  the  multitude 
of  subjects  on  which  information  has  been  sought  during  past  years. 

The  matter  of  a  proper  quality  of  fencing  wire  to  resist  corrosion  and 
secure   durability  has  been  under  consideration  by  the   American   Society 


904  SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS. 

for    Testing    Materials,    and    we    would,    therefore,    make    the    following 
recommendations : 

(i)  That  the  Hoard  of  Direction  instruct  our  Committee  to  endeavor 
to  co-operate  with  a  similar  committee  of  the  American  Society  for  Test- 
ing Materials  in  reaching  a  conclusion  on  this  latter  subject. 

(2)  That  subjects  Nos.  2,  3  and  4.  assigned  last  year,  be  reassigned 
for  study  and  a  report  made  when  the  Committee  considers  that  it  has 
sufficient  data  to  warrant  conclusions. 

(3)  That  the  Board  of  Direction  assign  the  subject  of  "Uniform 
Railway  Signs  for  all  purposes  as  applicable  to  the  Public  and  to  Railway 
Operation." 

Respectfully  submitted, 

COMMITTEE  ON   SIGNS,  FENCES  AND   CROSSINGS. 


REPORT    OF    COMMITTEE   XVI— ON   ECONOMICS    OF 
RAILWAY  LOCATION. 

A.  K.  Shurtleff,  Chairman;  R.  N.  Begien,  Vice-Chairman; 

C.  Frank  Allen.  Fred  La  vis. 

WlLLARD  BEAHAN.  C.  J.  PARKER. 

C  K.  Conard.  F.  W.  Smith. 

A.  C.  Dennis.  Francis  Lee  Stuart. 

C.  P.  Howard.  Walter  Loring  Webb. 

W.  A.  James.  M.  A.  Zook.  . 

Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Committee  realizes  that  some  of  the  members  of  our  Association 
may  be  disappointed  in  its  failure  to  produce  a  report  having  some  logical 
conclusions.  The  failure  to  report  at  the  191 1  convention  was  explained 
at  the  time,  but  during  the  past  year  the  Committee  has  been  greatly 
encouraged  in  its  work  by  the  receipt  of  considerable  valuable  operating 
information. 

Under  date  of  October  26,  191 1,  the  Chairman  was  able  to  send  to 
such  members  of  the  Committee  as  had  shown  any  interest  in  the  work  a 
tabulated  statement  by  accounts  of  the  operating  costs  of  nine  large 
railways,  comprising  13  per  cent,  of  the  main  track  mileage  of  the 
United  States,  over  18  per  cent,  of  the  freight  train  mileage,  and  over 
16  per  cent,  of  the  passenger  train  mileage.  In  some  cases  the  more 
important  accounts  covering  "Conducting  Transportation"  were  separated 
between  Passenger  and  Freight  Service,  which  will  be  of  particular 
value  to  your  Committee  in  the  final  analysis  of  the  questions  to  be 
considered. 

In  addition  to  the  cost  data,  infoimation  has  been  tabulated  covering 
the  density  of  traffic  per  mile  of  main  track  in  train  miles,  car  miles 
and  ton  miles. 

The  working  members  of  your  Committee  have  been  devoting  such 
time  as  they  could  spare  to  the  study  of  the  statistics  tabulated,  and  to 
a  portion  of  them  it  becomes  apparent  that  no  fixed  values  can  be 
established  for  distance,  curvature,  rise  and  fall,  or  gradient.  A  care- 
ful study  of  the  data  covering  costs  by  primary  accounts  apparently 
indicates  that  costs  in  some  of  the  accounts  vary  with  the  number  of 
train  miles  and  the  ratio  of  freight  train  mileage  to  passenger  train 
mileage. 

905 


906  ECONOMICS  OF  RAILWAY  LOCATION 

In  other  cases  the  logical  unit  of  variation  is  the  ton  mile,  or  car 
mile  depending  entirely  on  the  account  in  question.  Further,  the  density 
of  traffic  both  as  to  tiain  mileage  and  ton  mileage  enters  into  the  costs. 

The  result  is  that  your  Committee  has  refrained  from  presenting  any 
conclusions  for  your  consideration  until  it  has  had  time  to  thoroughly 
digest  the  information  now  at  hand. 

A  portion  of  your  Committee  believes  that  each  case  must  be  con- 
sidered by  itself,  with  a  probability  that  the  values  used  for  the  unit 
costs  will  vary  widely,  depending  on  local  conditions  of  traffic  with 
reference  to  car  loading,  character  and  density  of  traffic,  etc.,  and  in 
some  cases  on  climatic  conditions. 

Your  Committee  hopes  to  present  a  report  during  the  coming  year 
which  will  show  one  or  more  methods  of  practical  analysis  of  the  question 
covering  conditions  that  exist  with   each  case. 
Respectfully  submitted, 

A.  K.  Shurtleff,  Chairman. 


REPORT   OF   SPECIAL   COMMITTEE   ON  UNIFORM 
GENERAL  CONTRACT  FORMS. 

J.  C.  Irwin,  Chairman.  W.  G.  Atwood,  Vice -Chair  man. 

E.  F.  Ackerman.  H.  C.  Phillips. 

W.  L.  Breckinridge.  J.  H.  Roach. 

R.  G.  Kenly.  H.  A.  Woods. 

E.  H.  Lee.  C.  A.  Wilson. 

C.  A.  Paquette.  Committee. 

To  the  Members  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association: 

Your  Special  Committee  on  Uniform  General  Contract  Forms  presents 
progress  report  as  follows : 

The  Committee  was  instructed  by  the  Board  of  Direction  to  report 
on  "General  Contract  Forms." 

General  meetings  of  the  Committee  were  held  as  follows:  At  Bur- 
lington, Vt.,  August  30,  1911,  attended  by  J.  C.  Irwin,  Chairman;  W.  G. 
Atwood,  C.  A.  Paquette,  J.  H.  Roach,  H.  A.  Woods;  at  Buffalo,  N.  Y., 
September  29,  191 1,  attended  by  J.  C.  Irwin,  Chairman;  E.  H.  Lee,  C.  A. 
Paquette,  H.  A.  Woods,  C.  A.  Wilson. 

The  text  of  the  report  of  the  Committee,  published  in  Bulletin  133, 
of  March,  191 1,  was  thoroughly  discussed  and  revised,  and  the  reports 
of  the  Committee  on  Buildings,  published  in  Bulletin  68,  and  of  the 
Special  Contract  Committee,  made  at  the  Tenth  Annual  Convention  in 
2909  and  published  in  Bulletin  108,  have  been  studied.  As  the  report  of 
March,  191 1,  in  Bulletin  133,  was  not  acted  upon,  the  following  portion 
of  that  report  may  be  repeated: 

"The  plan  of  having  an  agreement  form  of  two  pages  separate  from 
the  general  contract  conditions  and  as  referred  to  on  page  11 76  oi  the 
Proceedings  of  the  Tenth  Annual  Convention,  is  approved  by  this  Com- 
mittee, and  the  agreement  form  presented  in  that  report  has  been  recon- 
sidered and  revised  and  is  presented  herewith  with  recommendations  for 
adoption. 

"In  small  or  unimportant  contracts  this  agreement  form,  which  is 
designated  as  Form  A,  may  be  used  alone,  but  in  larger  contracts  the  Gen- 
eral Conditions  statement  designated  as  Form  B  may  be  inserted,  using 
the  agreement  form  as  a  folder  with  the  introductory  page  at  the  begin- 
ning of  the  contract  and  the  signature  at  the  end. 

"Specifications  relating  to  the  particular  work  can  either  be  included 
in  the  folder  or  attached  to  the  back. 

"The  Committee  has,  in  the  agreement,  made  the  'Contractor'  the 
party  of  the  first  part,  and  the  'Company'  the  party  of  the  second  part, 
and  has,  therefore,  in  preparing  the  'General  Conditions,'  placed  the  pro- 
visions relating  especially  to  the  duties  and  rights  of  the  'Contractor'  first 
and  those  relating  to  the  duties  and  rights  of  the  'Company'  last." 

907 


908  UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS. 

The  Committee  has  considered  and  presents  herewith,  for  discussion, 
the  form  suggested  for  Agreement  A,  and  also  the  following  sections 
for  the  General  Conditions  B : 

i.  Bond. 

2.  Contractor's  Understanding. 

3.  Intent  of  Plans  and  Specifications. 

4.  Permits. 

5.  Protection. 

6.  Rights  of  Various  Interests. 

7.  Consent  to  Transfer.  -2 

8.  Superintendence. 

9.  Timely  Demand  for  Points  and  Instructions. 

10.  Report  Errors  and  Discrepancies. 

11.  Preservation   of   Stakes. 

12.  Inspection. 

13.  Defective  Work  or  Material. 

14.  Insurance. 

15.  Indemnity. 

16.  Settlement  for  Wages. 

17.  Liens. 

18.  Work  Adjacent  to  Railroad. 

19.  Risk. 

20.  Order  and  Discipline. 

21.  Contractor  Not  to  Hire  Company's  Employes. 

22.  Intoxicating  Liquors  Prohibited. 

23.  Cleaning  Up. 

24.  Engineer  and  Chief  Engineer  Defined. 

25.  Power  of  Engineer. 

26.  Adjustment  of  Dispute. 

27.  Order  of  Completion.     Use  of  Completed  Portions. 

28.  Changes. 

29.  Extra  Work. 

30.  Property  and  Right  of  Entry. 

31.  Unavoidable  Delays.    Extension  of  Time  on  Parts  of  Work. 

32.  Suspension  of  Work. 
37.  Monthly  Estimate. 

The  Committee  has  discussed,  but  not  formally  acted  upon,  the  fol- 
lowing Sections,  33,  34,  35,  36  and  38. 

The  Committee  especially  presents  for  approval : 

(1)  The  general  scheme  of  having  the  two-page  general  agreement, 
Form  A,  as  a  folder,  within  which  the  other  portions  of  the  contract  can 
be  bound,  thus  permitting  a  concise  contract  form  or  a  large  contract 
form,  according  to  the  requirements  of  the  case. 

(2)  The  Agreement — Form  A — as  presented  herewith. 

(3)  Sections  1  to  32  and  Section  37  of  B  General  Conditions. 
For  next  year's  work  recommendations  are  made  as  follows: 

(1)  Reconsider  standard  contract  form  so  far  as  presented  in  the 
light  of  discussions  presented  at  the  convention  or  by  letter. 

(2)  Complete  the  construction  of  final  sections  of  contract. 

(3)  Consider  advisability  of  having  any  supplementary  standard 
forms  in  conjunction  with  Uniform  General  Contract  Form,  and  prepare 
such  contract  forms  as  may  be  considered  advisable. 

Respectfully  submitted, 

SPECIAL  COMMITTEE  ON  UNIFORM 

GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS. 


UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS  909 

CONSTRUCTION    CONTRACT 

A — AGREEMENT. 

This  Agreement,  made  this  day  of in 

the  year  by  and  between   

party  of  the  first  part,  hereinafter  called  the  Contractor,  and 

party  of  the 

second  part,  hereinafter  called  the  Company. 

Witnesseth,  That,  in  consideration  of  the  covenants  and  agreements 
hereinafter  mentioned,  to  be  performed  by  the  parties  hereto  and  of  the 
payments  hereinafter  agreed  to  be  made,  it  is  mutually  agreed  as  follows: 

The  Contractor  shall  furnish  all  the  necessary  transportation,  ma- 
terials, superintendence,  labor  and  equipment,  and  shall  execute,  con- 
struct and  finish,  in  an  expeditious,  substantial  and  workmanlike  manner, 
to  the  satisfaction  and  acceptance  of  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Company. 


in  accordance  with  the  plans  hereto  attached  or  as  herein  described,  and 
the  following  general  conditions,  requirements  and  specifications,  form- 
ing part  of  this  contract. 

The  work  covered  by  this  contract  shall  be  commenced ; 

and  be  completed  on  or  before  the 

day  of  ,  191 


910  UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS. 

And  in  consideration  of  the  completion  of  the  work  described  herein, 
and  the  fulfillment  of  all  stipulations  of  this  agreement  to  the  satisfac- 
tion and  acceptance  of  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Company,  the  said 
Company  shall  pay,  or  cause  to  be  paid,  to  said  Contractor,  the  amount 
due  the  Contractor,  based  on  the  following  prices : 








This  agreement  shall  inure  to  the  benefit  of  and  be  binding  upon  the 
legal  representatives  and  successors  of  the  parties  respectively. 

In  Witness  Whereof,  The  parties  hereto  have  executed  this  agree- 
ment in   the  day  and  year  first  above  written. 

Witness  : 


UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS.  911 

CONSTRUCTION    CONTRACT. 

B.      GENERAL   CONDITIONS. 

Bond. 

1.  The  Contractor  agrees,  at  the  time  of  the  execution  and  delivery 
of  this  contract  and  before  the  taking  effect  of  the  same,  to  furnish  and 
deliver  to  the  Company  a  good  and  sufficient  bond  of  indemnity  to  the 
amount  of dollars,  as  security  for  the  faith- 
ful performance,  by  the  Contractor,  of  all  the  covenants  and  agreements 
on  the  part  of  the  Contractor  contained  in  this  contract.  The  security 
in  such  bond  of  indemnity  must  be  satisfactory  and  acceptable  to  the  Com- 
pany. 

This  bond  shall  remain  in  force  and  effect  in  such  amount,  not  greater 
than  that  specified,  as  shall  be  determined  by  the  Chief  Engineer,  until 
the  final  completion  and  acceptance  of  the  work. 

Contractor's   Understanding. 

2.  It  is  understood  and  agreed  that  the  Contractor  has,  by  careful 
examination,  satisfied  himself  as  to  the  nature  and  location  of  the  work, 
the  conformation  of  the  ground,  the  character,  quality  and  quantity  of 
the  materials  to  be  encountered,  the  character  of  equipment  and  facilities 
needed  preliminary  to  and  during  the  prosecution  of  the  work,  the  gen- 
eral and  local  conditions,  and  all  other  matters  which  can  in  any  way 
affect  the  work  under  this  contract.  No  verbal  agreement  or  conversation 
with  any  officer,  agent  or  employe  of  the  Company,  either  before  or  after 
the  execution  of  this  contract,  shall  affect  or  modify  any  of  the  terms 
or  obligations  herein  contained. 

Intent    of    Plans   and    Specifications. 

3.  All  work  that  may  be  called  for  in  the  specifications  and  not 
shown  on  the  plans,  or  shown  on  the  plans  and  not  called  for  in  the 
specifications,  shall  be  executed  and  furnished  by  the  Contractor  as  if 
described  in  both  these  ways ;  and  should  any  work  or  material  be  required 
which  is  not  denoted  in  the  specifications  or  plans,  either  directly  or  in- 
directly, but  which  is  nevertheless  necessary  for  the_  proper  carrying  out 
of  the  obvious  intentions  thereof,  the  Contractor  is  to  understand  the 
same  to  be  implied  and  required,  and  shall  perform  all  such  work  and 
furnish  any  such  material  as  fully  as  if  they  were  particularly  delineated 
or  described. 

Permits. 

4.  Permits  of  a  temporary  nature  necessary  for  the  prosecution  of 
the  work  shall  be  secured  by  the  Contractor.  Permits  for  permanent 
structures  or  permanent  changes  in  existing  facilities  shall  be  secured 
by  the  Company. 

Protection. 

5.  Whenever  the  local  conditions,  laws  or  ordinances  require,  the 
Contractor  shall  furnish  and  maintain,  at  his  own  cost  and  expense,  neces- 
sary passageways,  guard  fences  and  lights  and  such  other  facilities  and 
means  of  protection  as  may  be  required. 

Rights  of  Various  Interests. 

6.  Wherever  work  being  done  by  Company  forces  or  by  other  Con- 
tractors is  contiguous  to  work  covered  by  this  contract  the  respective 
rights  of  the  various  interests  involved  shall  be  determined  by  the  En- 
gineer, to  secure  the  completion  of  the  various  portions  of  the  work  in 
general  harmony. 


912  UNIFORM   GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS. 

Consent  to  Transfer. 

7.  The  Contractor  shall  not  let  or  transfer  this  contract  or  any  part 
thereof  (except  for  the  delivery  of  material)  without  consent  of  the 
Chief  Engineer,  given  in  writing.  Such  consent  does  not  release  or 
relieve  the  Contractor  from  any  or  all  of  his  obligations  and  liabilities 
under  the  contract. 

Superintendence. 

8.  The  Contractor  shall  constantly  superintend  all  the  work  embraced 
in  this  contract,  in  person  or  by  a  duly  authorized  manager  acceptable 
to  the  Company. 

Timely  Demand  for  Points  and   Instructions. 

9.  The  Contractor  shall  not  proceed  until  he  has  made  timely  demand 
upon  the  Engineer  for,  and  has  received  from  him,  such  points  and  in- 
structions as  may  be  necessary  as  the  work  progresses.  The  work  shall 
be  done  in  strict  conformity  with  such  points  and  instructions. 

Report  Errors  and   Discrepancies. 

10.  If  the  Contractor,  in  the  course  of  the  work,  finds  any  discrepancy 
between  the  plans  and  the  physical  conditions  of  the  locality,  or  any  errors 
in  plans  or  in  the  layout  as  given  by  said  points  and  instructions,  it  shall 
be  his  duty  to  immediately  inform  the  Engineer.  Any  work  done  after 
such  discovery,  until  verified,  will  be  done  at  the  Contractor's  risk. 

Preservation  of  Stakes. 

11.  The  Contractor  must  carefully  preserve  bench  marks,  reference 
points  and  stakes,  and  in  case  of  wilful  or  careless  destruction,  he  will 
be  charged  with  the  resulting  expense  and  shall  be  responsible  for  any 
mistakes  that  may  be  caused  by  their  unnecessary  loss  or  disturbance. 

Inspection. 

12.  All  work  and  materials  shall  be  at  all  times  open  to  the  inspec- 
tion, acceptance  or  rejection  of  the  Engineer  or  his  duly  authorized  repre- 
sentative. The  Contractor  shall  at  all  times  provide  reasonable  and  neces- 
sary facilities  for  such  inspection. 

Defective  Work  or  Material. 

13.  Any  omission  or  failure  on  the  part  of  the  Engineer  to  dis- 
approve or  reject  any  work  or  material  shall  not  be  construed  to  be  an 
acceptance  of  any  defective  work  or  material.  The  Contractor  shall  re- 
move, at  his  own  expense,  any  work  or  material  condemned  by  the  En- 
gineer, and  shall  rebuild  and  replace  the  same  without  extra  charge,  and  in 
default  thereof  the  same  shall  be  done  by  the  Company  at  the  Contractor's 
expense — or}>  in  case  the  Chief  Engineer  should  not  consider  the  defect 
of  sufficient  importance  to  require  the  Contractor  to  rebuild  or  replace  any 
imperfect  work  or  material,  he  shall  have  power,  and  is  hereby  authorized, 
to  make  any  deduction  from  the  stipulated  price  that  he  may  deem  proper. 

Insurance. 

14.  The  Contractor  shall  secure  in  the  name  of  the  Company  and 
for  its  benefit,  policies  of  fire  insurance  on  such  structures  and  in  such 
amounts  as  shall  be  specified  by  the  Chief  Engineer  not  exceeding 

Indemnity. 

15.  The  Contractor  shall  indemnify  and  save  harmless  the  Com- 
pany for  and  from  all  claims,  demands,  payments,  suits,  actions,  re- 
coveries and  judgments  of  every  nature  and  description  brought  or  re- 
covered against  it,  by  reason  of  any  act  or  omission  of  the  said  Con- 
tractor, his  agents  or  employes,  in  the  execution  of  the  work  by  or  in 
consequence  of  any  negligence  or  carelessness  in  guarding  the  same. 


UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS.  913 

Settlement  for  Wages. 

16.  Whenever,  in  the  opinion  of  the  Chief  Engineer,  it  may  be  neces- 
sary for  the  progress  of  the  work  to  secure  to  any  of  the  employes  of 
the  Contractor  any  wages  which  may  then  be  due  them,  the  .Company  is 
hereby  authorized  to  pay  said  employes  the  amount  due  them  or  any  lesser 
amount,  and  the  amount  so  paid  them,  as  shown  by  their  receipts,  shall  be 
deducted  from  any  moneys  that  may  be  or  become  payable  to  said  Con- 
tractor. 

Liens. 

17.  If  an  established  lien  be  filed  against  the  Contractor  for  labor 
or  material  furnished  in  the  performance  of  the  work,  the  Company  is 
hereby  authorized  to  pay  and  discharge  the  same,  if  it  shall  deem  best 
so  to  do,  and  to  deduct  the  amount  so  paid  from  any  moneys  which 
may  be  or  become  due  and  payable  to  the  Contractor. 

Work  Adjacent  to  Railroad. 

18.  Whenever  the  work  embraced  in  this  contract  is  near  the  tracks, 
structures  or  buildings  of  this  Company  or  of  other  railroads,  the  Con- 
tractor shall  use  proper  care  and  vigilance  to  avoid  injury  to  persons 
or  property.  The  work  must  be  so  conducted  as  not  to  interfere  with 
the  movement  of  trains  or  other  operations  of  the  railroad;  or,  if  in 
any  case  such  interference  be  necessary,  the  Contractor  shall  not  pro- 
ceed until  he  has  first  obtained  specific  authority  and  directions  there- 
for from  the  proper  officer  of  the  Company  and  has  the  approval  of  the 
Engineer. 

Risk. 

19.  The  work  in  every  respect  shall  be  at  the  risk  of  the  Contractor 
until  finished  and  accepted,  except  damage  or  injury  caused  directly  by 
Company's  agents  or  employes. 

Order  and  Discipline. 

20.  The  Contractor  shall  at  all  times  enforce  strict  discipline  and 
good  order  among  his  employes,  and  any  employe  of  the  Contractor  who 
shall  appear  to  be  incompetent,  disorderly  or  intemperate,  or  in  any  other 
way  disqualified  for  or  unfaithful  to  the  work  entrusted  to  him,  shall 
be  discharged  immediately  on  the  request  of  the  Engineer,  and  he  shall 
not  again  be  employed  on  the  work  without  the  Engineer's  written  consent. 

Contractor  Not  to  Hire  Company's  Employes. 

21.  The  Contractor  shall  not  employ  or  hire  any  of  the  Company's 
employes  without  the  permission  of  the  Engineer. 

Intoxicating    Liquors    Prohibited. 

22.  The  Contractor,  in  so  far  as  his  authority  extends,  shall  not 
permit  the  sale,  distribution  or  use  of  any  intoxicating  liquors  upon  or 
adjacent  to  the  work,  or  allow  any  such  to  be  brought  upon,  to  or  near 
the  line  of  the  railway  of  the  Company. 

Cleaning   Up. 

23.  The  Contractor  shall,  as  directed  by  the  Engineer,  remove  from 
the  Company's  property  and  from  all  public  and  private  property,  at  his 
own  expense,  all  temporary  structures,  rubbish  and  waste  materials  re- 
sulting from  his  operations. 

Engineer  and  Chief  Engineer  Defined. 

24.  Wherever  in  this  contract  the  word  Engineer  is  used,  it  shall  be 
understood  as  referring  to  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Company,  acting 
personally  or  through  an  assistant  duly  authorized  in  writing  for  such 


914  UNIFORM    GENERAL   CONTRACT    FORMS. 

act  by  the  Chief  Engineer,  and  wherever  the  words  Chief  Engineer  are 
used  it  shall  be  understood  as  referring  to  the  Chief  Engineer  in  person, 
and  not  to  any  assistant  engineer. 

Power  of  Engineer. 

25.  The  Engineer  shall  have  full  power  to  reject  or  condemn  all 
work  or  material,  which,  in  his  opinion,  does  not  conform  to  this  con- 
tract ;  to  direct  the  application  of  forces  to  any  portion  of  the  work 
which,  in  his  judgment,  requires  it;  to  order  the  force  increased  or 
diminished,  and  to  decide  every  question  that  may  arise  between  the 
parties  relative  to  the  execution  of  the  work. 

Adjustment  of  Dispute. 

26.  All  questions  or  controversies  which  may  arise  between  the  Con- 
tractor and  the  Company,  under  or  in  reference  to  this  contract,  shall 
be  subject  to  the  decision  of  the  Chief  Engineer,  and  his  decision  shall 
be  final  and  conclusive  to  both  parties. 

Order  of  Completion;   Use  of  Completed  Portions. 

27.  The  Contractor  shall  complete  any  portion  or  portions  of  the 
work  in  such  order  of  time  as  the  Engineer  may  require.  The  Company 
shall  have  the  right  to  take  possession  of  and  use  any  completed  or  par- 
tially completed  portions  of  the  work,  notwithstanding  the  time  for  com- 
pleting the  entire  work  or  such  portions  may  not  have  expired ;  but  such 
taking  possession  and  use  shall  not  be  deemed  an  acceptance  of  the  work 
so  taken  or  used  or  any  part  thereof.  If  such  prior  use  increases  the 
cost  of  or  delays  the  work,  the  Contractor  will  be  entitled  to  such  extra 
compensation,  or  extension  of  time,  as  the  Chief  Engineer  may  determine. 

Changes. 

28.  The  Company  shall  have  the  right  to  make  any  changes  that  may 
be  hereafter  determined  upon,  in  the  nature  or  dimensions  of  the  work, 
either  before  or  after  its  commencement,  and  such  changes  shall  in  no 
way  affect  or  void  this  contract.  If  such  changes  diminish  the  quantity 
or  extent  of  the  work  to  be  done,  they  shall  not.  under  any  circumstances, 
be  construed  as  constituting,  and  shall  not  constitute  a  claim  for  damages 
or  for  anticipated  profits  on  such  work. 

In  case  quantities  in  the  completed  work  vary  from  the  quantities 
shown  on  the  original  plans,  and  provided  for  in  the  specifications,  then 
the  final  payment  shall  be  adjusted  on  the  basis  of  unit  rates  specified 
in  this  contract. 

Note. — First  paragraph  of  Section  28  to  be  used  in  unit  price  and 
force  account  contracts,  i.  e.,  in  all  contracts  not  on  lump-sum  prices. 
Should  be  omitted  in  lump-sum  contracts. 

Extra  Work. 

29.  No  bill  or  claim  for  extra  work  or  material  shall  be  allowed 
or  paid  unless  the  doing  of  such  extra  work  or  the  furnishing  of  such 
extra  material  shall  have  been  authorized  in  writing  by  the  Engineer 
before  any  part  of  such  work  was  done  or  material  furnished. 

The  price  for  such  work  shall  be  determined  by  the  Chief  Engineer, 
who  may  either  fix  a  unit  price  or  a  lump-sum  price,  or  may,  if  he  so 
elects,  provide  that  the  price  shall  be  determined  by  the  actual  cost,  to 

which  shall  be  added  per  cent,  to  cover  general  expense  and 

superintendence,  profits,  contingencies,  use  of  tools,  Contractor's  risk  and 
liability.  If  the  Contractor  shall  perform  any  work  or  furnish  any  ma- 
terial which  is  not  provided  for  in  this  contract,  or  which  was  not  author- 
ized in  writing  by  the  Engineer  previous  to  the  doing  of  the  work  or  the 
furnishing  of  material,  said  Contractor  shall  receive  no  compensation  for 
such  work  or  material  so  furnished,  and  does  hereby  release  and  dis- 
charge the  Company  from  any  payment  therefor. 


UNIFORM   GENERAL   CONTRACT   FORMS.  915 

If  the  Contractor  shall  proceed  with  such  extra  work  or  the  furnish- 
ing of  such  extra  material  after  receiving  the  written  authority  therefor, 
as  hereinbefore  provided,  then  such  work  or  material,  stated  in  the  written 
authority  of  the  Engineer,  shall  be  covered,  governed  and  controlled  by 
all  the  terms  and  provisions  of  this  contract,  subject  to  such  prices  as 
may  be  agreed  upon  or  fixed  by  the  Chief  Engineer. 

If  the  Contractor  shall  decline  or  fail  to  perform  such  work  or  furnish 
such  extra  material  as  authorized  by  the  Engineer  in  writing,  as  afore- 
said, the  Company  may  then  arrange  for  the  performance  of  the  work  in 
any  manner  it  may  see  fit,  the  same  as  if  this  contract  had  not  been 
executed,  and  the  Contractor  shall  not  interfere  with  such  performance 
of  the  work. 

Property  and  Right  of  Entry. 

30.  The  Company  shall  provide  the  lands  upon  which  the  work  under 
this  contract  is  to  be  done,  except  that  the  Contractor  shall  provide  land 
required  for  the  erection  of  temporary  construction  facilities  and  storage 
of  his  material,  together  with  right  of  access  to  the  same. 

The  Contractor  shall  not  enter  upon  said  lands,  nor  ship  any  ma- 
terial or  equipment,  until  he  has  received  written  notice  from  the  En- 
gineer that  he  may  proceed  with  said  work  or  any  part  thereof. 

Unavoidable  Delays;  Extension  of  Time  on  Parts  of  Work. 

31.  If  the  Contractor  shall  be  delayed  in  the  performance  of  the 
work  from  any  cause,  for  which  the  Company  is  responsible,  he  shall,  upon 
written  application  to  the  Chief  Engineer  at  the  time  of  such  delay,  be 
granted  such  extension  of  time  as  the  Chief  Engineer  shall  deem  equitable 
and  just. 

Suspension  of  Work. 

32.  The  Company  may  at  any  time  stop  the  work,  or  any  part  thereof, 
by  giving  ten  (10)  days'  notice  to  the  Contractor  in  writing.  The  work 
shall  be  resumed  by  the  Contractor  in  ten  (10)  days  after  the  date  fixed 
in  the  written  notice  from  the  Company  to  the  Contractor  so  to  do.  The 
Company  shall  not  be  held  liable  for  any  damages  or  anticipated  profits 
on  account  of  the  work  being  stopped,  or  for  any  work  done  during  the 
interval  of  suspension.  It  will,  however,  pay  the  Contractor  for  expense 
of  men  and  teams  necessarily  retained  during  the  interval  of  suspension, 
provided  the  Contractor  can  show  that  it  was  not  reasonably  practicable  to 
move  these  men  and  teams  to  other  points  at  which  they  can  be  engaged. 
The  Company  will  further  pay  the  Contractor  for  time  necessarily  lost 

during  such  suspension  at  the  rate  of  per  cent,  per  annum 

on  the  estimated  value  of  all  equipment  and  fixtures  owned  by  the  Con- 
tractor and  employed  on  the  work  which  are  necessarily  idle  during  such 

suspension,  said  rate  of per  cent,  per  annum  being  understood 

to  include  depreciation,  interest  and  insurance.  But  if  the  work,  or  any 
part  thereof,  shall  be  stopped  by  the  notice  in  writing  aforesaid,  and  if 
the  Company  does  not  give  notice  in  writing  to  the  Contractor  to  resume 

work  at  a  date  within  of  the  date  fixed  in  the 

written  notice  to  suspend,  then  the  Contractor  may  abandon  that  portion 
of  the  work  to  suspend  and  he  will  be  entitled  to  the  estimates  and  pay- 
ments for  such  work  so  abandoned,  as  provided  in  Sections   

of  this  contract. 

Annulment,  Contractor's  Fault. 

33.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 

Annulment,  Without  Fault  of  Contractor. 

34.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 


916  UNIFORM  GENERAL  CONTRACT  FORMS. 

Removal  of  Equipment  in  Case  of  Annulment. 

35.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 

Measurement  and  Approval  of  Work. 

36.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 

Monthly  Estimate. 

37.  So  long  as  the  work  herein  contracted  for  is  prosecuted  in  ac- 
cordance with  the  provisions  of  this  contract,  and  with  such  progress  as 
may  be  satisfactory  to  the  Chief  Engineer,  the  said  Chief  Engineer  will, 
on  or  about  the  first  day  of  each  month,  make  an  approximate  estimate 
of  the  proportionate  value  of  the  work  done  and  of  material  furnished 
or  delivered  upon  the  Company's  property  at  the  site  of  the  work,  up  to 
and  including  the  last  day  of  the  previous  month.     The  amount  of  said 

estimate,  after  deducting per  cent,  and  all  previous  payments, 

shall  be  due  and  payable  to  the  Contractor  at  the  office  of  the  Treasurer 
of  the  Company  on  or  about  the  20th  day  of  the  current  month. 

Final  Estimate. 

38.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 


DISCUSSIONS 


DISCUSSION  ON  RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION. 

(For   Report,    see   pp.    65-6S.) 
LIST  OF  SPEAKERS  TAKING   PART   IN   DISCUSSION   ON  RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION. 

F.  D.  Anthony.  H.  E.  Hale.  C.  H.  Stein. 

A.   S.  Baldwin.  E.  R.  Lewis.  John  G.  Sullivan. 

J.  B.  Berry.  G.   W.   Merrell.  E.  E.  R.  Tratman. 

W.  M.  Camp.  C.  A.  Morse.  Walter  Loring  Webb. 

H.  M.  Church.  H.  T.  Porter.  Edwin  F.  Wendt. 

L.  A.  Downs.  E.  T.  Reisler.  C.  C.  Wentworth. 

C.  H.  Ewing.  L.  S.  Rose.  H.  S.  Wilgus. 
Robert  Ferriday. 

The  President: — We  will  now  take  up  the  report  of  the  Committee 
on  Rules  and  Organization.  Mr.  Osgood,  the  Chairman  of  the  Commit- 
tee, at  the  last  minute,  was  prevented  from  coming  here,  so  that  he  has 
not  had  an  opportunity  to  instruct  the  other  members  of  his  Committee 
fully  as  to  the  preliminary  announcements.  Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony  will  be 
kind  enough  to  state  the  general  work  of  the  Committee  in  order  that  the 
report  may  be  discussed. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony  (Quebec,  Montreal  &  Southern)  : — The  report  of 
the  Committee  is  well  set  forth  in  Bulletin  141,  and  I  do  not  know  that 
there  is  much  to  say  on  the  subject  except  to  leave  it  to  the  convention 
for  criticism. 

The  President : — The  first  recommendation  of  the  Committee  is  on 
the  first  page,  in  which  they  state,  "That  no  change  be  made  in  the  Gen- 
eral Rules  for  the  Government  of  Employes  of  the  Maintenance  of  Way 
Department  heretofore  adopted  by  the  Association."  Then  they  state 
"That  to  the  rules  heretofore  adopted  by  the  As30ciation  be  added  Instruc- 
tions as  follows :"  Then  follows  a  list  of  26  rules.  What  is  your  pleas- 
ure in  regard  to  the  consideration  of  these  instructions  or  rules?  If 
agreeable  we  will  adopt  the  usual  course,  and  have  the  Secretary  read 
each  paragraph,  and  any  members  having  any  criticisms  to  make  will 
please  state  them;  the  adoption  of  each  separate  paragraph  will  not  be 
put  to  vote,  except  in  the  case  of  a  dispute,  or  something  of  that  nature. 

(The  Secretary  then  read  the  paragraphs  under  the  heading  Instruc- 
tions.) 

The  Secretary: — "(1)  The  roadbed,  ballast  and  track  shall  conform 
to  the  standard  plans.  No  changes  in  the  sections  shown  shall  be  made 
without  proper  authority. 

"(Note:  It  is  understood  that  cross-sections  for  wet  cuts  will  be 
included  in  the  standard  plans.) 

919 


920  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

"(2)  All  ditches,  including  intercepting  ditches  on  the  upper  side 
of  cuts,  must  be  kept  clean. 

"(3)  Where  heaving  or  wet  spots  develop,  special  drainage  shall  be 
provided." 

The  President: — Mr.  Tratman  has  a  suggestion  to  make  in  regard  to 
No.  3. 

Mr.  E.  E.  R.  Tratman  (Engineering  News)  : — My  suggestion  is  that 
after  the  word  "develop"  we  insert  the  words  "investigation  as  to  cause 
must  be  made,"  so  that  it  will  read,  "Where  heaving  or  wet  spots  de- 
velop, investigation  as  to  cause  must  be  made  and  special  drainage  pro- 
vided." 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — We  might  add  "Investigation"  to  every  rule  of 
similar  nature.  Investigation  is  a  foregone  conclusion.  The  Committee 
think  that  is  unnecessary. 

The  President: — Do  you  wish  to  make  any  motion  as  to  that,  Mr. 
Tratman  ? 

Mr.  Tratman:— No. 

The  Secretary: — "(4)  Before  re-ballasting  track,  line  and  grade 
stakes  shall  be  set  by  the  Engineer.  All  unsuitable  material  shall  be  re- 
moved and  the  roadbed  widened  to  proper  section,  the  waste  material  being 
used  to  widen  banks,  or  otherwise,  as  may  be  directed. 

"(5)  Track  must  be  kept  in  good  line  and  surface  while  ballasting, 
open  track  avoided  as  far  as  practicable,  and  such  track  carefully  watched." 

Mr.  Tratman : — It  seems  to  me  that  sentence  is  rather  long,  especially 
as  it  deals  with  two  distinct  subjects.  I  propose  that  it  be  divided  into 
two  parts,  to  read,  "Track  must  be  kept  in  good  line  and  surface  while 
ballasting.  Open  track  must  be  avoided  as  far  as  practicable,  and  such 
track  carefully  watched." 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony : — That  is  merely  a  matter  of  punctuation. 

The  President: — Is  the  Committee  willing  to  accept  it? 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony : — No ;  we  would  prefer  to  let  the  rule  stand  as 
recommended  in  the  report. 

The  President: — Do  you  wish  to  make  a  motion?  Any  further 
criticism? 

The  Secretary: — '"(6)  After  ballast  is  distributed  it  shall  be  trimmed, 
and  the  track  lined  and  surfaced  to  conform  to  the  standard  plans." 

Mr.  Tratman : — I  seem  to  be  coming  unduly  to  the  front  here,  but  it 
seems  as  if  that  paragraph  could  be  changed  grammatically  and  be  im- 
proved by  wording  it  as  follows :  "After  ballast  is  distributed,  it  shall  be 
trimmed  to  conform  to  the  standard  plans,  and  the  track  lined  and  sur- 
faced." We  do  not  line  and  surface  to  the  standard  plans  (as  worded  in 
the  original),  but  the  track  is  to  be  trimmed  to  the  standard  plans. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — It  is  my  opinion  and  also  the  opinion  of  one 
other  member  of  the  Committee  that  rule  No.  6  is  not  right,  as  ballast 
is  usually  distributed  in  anticipation  of  a  lift.  It  seems  to  me  the  lift  is 
the  first  thing  after  the  distribution  of  the  ballast,  and  I  would  suggest 


DISCUSSION.  921 

this :    "After  ballast  is  distributed  and  the  track  lifted,  the  track  should  be 
lined  and  surfaced  and  the  ballast  trimmed  to  conform  to  standard  plans." 
(Motion  seconded  and  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "(7)  Where  track  is  bonded,  ballast  must  be  kept  at 
least  one  inch  below  the  base  of  rail.  At  road  crossings,  platforms,  etc., 
where  this  is  not  practicable,  only  clean  gravel  or  rock  ballast  shall  be 
used." 

Mr.  Tratman : — I  move  that  the  word  "electrically"  be  inserted  before 
"bonded."  We  all  know  what  "bonded"  means,  but  as  these  are  rules  to 
be  sent  out  for  trackmen  and  track  officials,  I  think  it  should  be  explained 
more  fully. 

The  President: — The  Acting  Chairman  says  there  is  no  objection  to 
making  that  change. 

The  Secretary :—"  (8)  Ties  stored  along  right-of-way  shall  be  piled 
to  conform  to  the  standard  plan. 

"(Note:  The  standard  plan  should  show  the  minimum  distance  to 
the  nearest  rail.) 

"(9)  The  ties  in  track  must  be  inspected  at  stated  times  each  year 
and  those  which  will  not  last  until  the  next  inspection  marked  for  re- 
newal. 

"(10)     The    renewal  of  ties   shall   be  started   when   directed  by  the 

'.'7... v. When  ties  are  being  renewed,  the  line  and  surface 

shall  be  corrected  and  ballast  trimmed." 

Mr.  H.  M.  Church  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  would  like  to  change  the 
last  three  words  of  Rule  10  "and  ballast  trimmed,"  so  that  it  shall  read, 
"unsuitable  material  removed  and  ballast  trimmed." 
Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — There  is  no  objection  to  that. 
The  Secretary: — "(11)     All  defective  ties  removed  from  track  shall 
each  day  be  placed  for  burning  or  loading  on  cars." 

Mr.  Tratman : — I  propose  a  little  grammatical  change  there.  In- 
stead of  "shall  each  day,"  substitute  "removed  from  track  each  day  shall 
be  placed  for  burning  or  for  loading  on  cars." 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — The  Committee  does  not  see  any  object  in 
changing  the  wording  as  recommended. 

The  Secretary:— "(12)  The S!E$ shall  frequently  in- 
spect ties  removed  from  track  to  see  if  any  have  been  removed  which 
might  have  remained  in  the  track  with  safety  until  the  next  inspection." 

Mr.  Tratman : — >I  think  that  could  be  simplified  in  the  second  line ; 
instead  of  "if  any  have  been  removed  which  might  have  remained,"  sub- 
stitute "if  any  of  them  have  been  removed."  That  makes  it  a  little  less 
involved. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — There  is  no  objection  to  that  correction. 
The   President : — The  Committee  accepts  that. 

The  Secretary: — "(13)  Ties  shall  be  spaced  according  to  the  stand- 
ard plans.  All  ties  shall  be  placed  square  to  the  line  of  rails.  The  out- 
side ends  on  double  tracks,  and  the  ends  on  one  side  throughout  on  single 
track,  must  be  lined  parallel  with  the  rail. 


022  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

"(14)  The  heart  side  of  ties  must  be  turned  down.  The  largest  and 
best  tics  shall  be  selected  for  use  at  joints.  Twisted  or  badly  hewn  ties 
must  not  be  notched,  but  the  bearings  must  be  made  true  with  the  adze." 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb  (Consulting  Engineer)  :— I  think  the  last 
sentence  is  a  little  indefinite.  It  says,  "Twisted  or  badly  hewn  ties  must 
not  be  notched,  but  the  bearings  must  be  made  true  with  the  adze."  I 
suppose  what  is  intended  is  that  ties  shall  be  hewn  so  that  there  is  a  good 
surface,  instead  of  there  being  a  mere  notch.  It  seems  to  me  the  reading 
could  be  improved  a  little,  to  bring  out  the  real  meaning,  for  even  a  notch 
may  have  the  surface  I'rvic,  which  evidently  is  not  what  is  intended.  It 
might  be  made  to  read,  "Twisted  or  badly  hewn  ties  must  not  be  notched, 
but  must  be  hewn  for  the  full  length  of  the  tie,"  of  words  to  that  effect. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — The  intention  of  the  Committee  is  that  they 
shall  be  properly  adzed.  But  not  notched — it  is  a  question  of  forming  the 
surface.     What  would  you  suggest  as  a  change? 

Mr.  E.  R.  Lewis  (Michigan  Central)  : — I  assume  we  all  realize  the 
immense  importance  of  the  proper  method  of  laying  ties.  The  first 
sentence  of  Rule  14  reads:  ''The  heart  side  of  ties  must  be  turned  down." 
So  far  as  I  know,  this  is  a  dogma  of  railway  rule  books;  a  positive  order, 
leaving  absolutely  nothing  to  the  judgment  of  the  practical  trackman 
who  has  been  laying  tics  for  fifty  years.  This  rule  most  vitally  concerns 
the  whole  track  structure,  the  very  foundation  of  it.  It  affects  the  con- 
struction and   maintenance  of  all  railways. 

I  opposed  this  rule  in  the  Rules  Committee  of  my  own  road  and  I 
oppose  it  here,  because  I  believe  it  is  wrong  and  I  believe  it  impossible 
of  successful  application.  I  am  rather  curious  to  know  its  origin.  I 
would  like  to  ask  the  Committee  why  a  tie  should  not  be  laid  heart  side 
up. 

In  the  actual  manual  labor  of  laying  track,  in  the  direct  charge  of 
maintenance  and  construction  work,  I  have  had  this  problem  pretty  close 
in  front  of  me  for  over  twenty  years,  and  I  presume  others  have  had 
more  experience.  I  have  studied  it  from  all  angles,  and  I  have  investi- 
gated many  hundreds  of  thousands  of  ties  with  this  very  point  in  view. 
I  am  aware  that  this  rule  is  contained  in  the  Rule  Books  of  a  great  many 
of  the  best  railways  in  this  country.  So  much  the  worse  for  the  Rule 
Books.  They  are  wrong.  The  tracks  of  these  very  roads,  whose  Rule 
Books  contain  this  rule,  arc  not  laid  in  accordance  therewith.  I  make 
this  statement  without  fear  of  contradiction,  because  I  know  it  to  be  im- 
possible, because  I  know  that  these  roads  have  their  ties  not  so  laid. 
What  is  the  tie  for?  This  definition  is  taken  from  the  Manual  of  this 
Association:  "The  tie  is  that  transverse  member  of  a  railway  track 
which  supports  the  rails  and  by  means  of  which  the  rails  are  retained  in 
position."  The  purposes  mentioned  in  this  definition  cannot  be  best 
served  by  placing  the  tie  heart  side  down.  The  heartwood  of  the  tie 
is  denser  than  the  sapwood.  Its  cell  walls  are  thicker  and  the  cells  con- 
tain less  moisture  when  the  wood  is  green.  Therefore  it  loses  less  moisture 
when  the  wood  is  seasoning.     The  cell  walls  of  the  sapwood  are  thinner 


DISCUSSION.  923 

than  the  cell  walls  of  the  hardwood,  the  cells  arc  larger;  the  sapwood 
is  not  so  dense,  and  cannot  hold  the  spike  as  well.  Witn  the  sap  side  up, 
you  get  only  the  point  of  the  spike  into  the  densest  wood.  Jn  the  less 
dense  sapwood  the  neck  of  the  spike  has  a  tendency  to  work  out  ot  gage 
and  give  way  a  little  more  than  does  the  point.  \\  hat  is  especially  neces- 
sary is  to  get  the  neck  of  the  spike,  that  part  of  the  spike  nearest  to  the 
rail,  where  it  will  do  the  most  good  and  hold  the  gage  best.  When  any 
timber  starts  to  check,  it  checks  from  the  sap  siae  first;  because  the 
sapwood  loses  sap  first,  loses  more  of  it,  and  allows  shrinkage  to  take 
place  more  quickly,  also  it  shrinks  more  than  the  heartwood.  The  heart- 
wood  being  denser  contains  less  moisture  and  absorbing  less  moisture  is 
longer  lived  than  the  sapwood.  The  sapwood  will  dry  out,  check  and  warp 
away  from  the  heart  side  of  the  stick.  This  applies  to  all  sorts  of  timber 
as  any  timberman  will  agree.  In  the  town  where  1  reside  we  cut  some- 
thing like  two  hundred  million  feet  of  timber  every  year.  Every  lumber- 
man in  the  Saginaw  Valley  has  agreed  with  me  that  timber  will  warp 
away  from  the  heart;  every  lumberman  in  every  other  valley  will  tell 
you  the  same  thing.  Therefore  I  say  that  the  tie  should  be  laid  heart  side 
up,  because  any  shrinking  and  warping  of  the  tie  is  away  from  the  heart 
side.  Therefore  the  heart  side  is  the  convex  side.  Now,  you  cannot  get 
a  good  bearing  for  a  tie  unless  you  lay  it  with  the  convex  side  up.  If  you 
lay  it  with  the  concave  side  up  you  are  working  against  the  law  of  grav- 
ity, and  you  obtain  a  rocking  chair  effect  instead  of  a  stable  foundation  for 
a  railway. 

Ask  any  good,  practical  laborer  how  to  lay  a  tie  and  he  will  tell  you 
"belly  up."  This  is  the  trackman's  rule  the  world  over.  I  estimate  that 
90  per  cent,  of  the  ties  that  are  laid  in  track  are  perceptibly  warped  or 
crooked.  They  are  not  precisely  straight.  There  is  a  choice  of  bearing. 
I  do  not  think  any  track  foreman  ever  should  allow  a  tie  to  be  put  in  the 
track  without  choosing  the  bearing,  the  side  which  should  go  up.  Irre- 
spective of  sap  side  or  heart  side,  he  must  get  the  convex  side  up. 

According  to  the  Government's  statistics,  about  80  per  cent,  of  the  125,- 
000,000  ties  bought  by  the  railways  of  the  United  States  in  191 1  were 
hewn  ties.  This  hewn  tie  is  a  pole  tie.  A  man  going  into  the  business  of 
making  ties  is  not  going  to  pick  out  timber  which  has  to  be  split  and 
worked  out  on  four  sides.  He  picks  out  pole  timber  that  requires  work- 
ing on  only  two  sides.  The  other  timber  is  worked  up  into  something  else 
more  valuable  to  him.  Sawed  ties  are  manufactured  from  large  logs ;  all 
the  boards  possible  being  sawed  from  four  sides  of  the  stick,  leaving 
a  box  heart  tie.  You  cannot  put  the  heart  side  of  such  a  tie  up  or  the 
heart  side  down.  The  heartwood  is  in  the  center.  The  same  is  true  of 
the  pole  tie. 

Besides  being  wrong  in  principle,  I  believe  this  first  sentence  of  Rule 
14  is  unnecessary.  In  only  5  or  10  per  cent,  of  the  ties  is  the  heartwood 
on  one  side.  Even  that  5  or  10  per  cent,  we  should  not  lay  wrong  side  up. 
In  the  past,  when  we  used  untreated  ties,  most  of  them  failed  us  through 
decay.     In  the  future,  with  the  crcosoted  tie,  it  will  be  the  other  way. 


924  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

We  will  lose  our  ties  through  wear,  and  we  want  the  best  wearing  wood 
where  it  will  do  the  most  good.  We  want  the  heart  side  where  it  will 
do  the  most  good.     Put  it  where  it  will  give  the  greatest  amount  of  wear. 

There  is  one  best  way  of  doing  everything.  There  is  only  one  best 
way  of  laying  a  tie  and  that  is  to  lay  it  the  best  way.  Why  not  say  so? 
To  this  end  I  move  that  this  part  of  Rule  14  be  amended  to  read:  "Ties 
must  be  laid  so  as  to  obtain  the  best  bearing."  We  want  the  best  rail- 
way, and  we  cannot  get  it  unless  we  lay  the  ties  convex  side  up. 

Mr.  Robert  Ferriday  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — 
I  second  the  motion. 

(The  motion  carried.) 

Mr.  L.  S.  Rose  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — 1  ask 
why  the  rule  is  made  to  square  the  ends  of  the  ties  on  double  track  on  the 
outside. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony : — My  impression  is  that  is  a  pretty  general  prac- 
tice. That  was  the  decision  of  the  Committee,  and  I  am  personally  not  in 
a  position  to  explain  it. 

The  President: — Do  you  make  any  motion? 

Mr.  Rose : — I  have  not  any  motion  to  make.  I  know  that  is  pretty 
common  practice.  I  have  seen  some  track  laid  where  the  ties  were  squared 
on  the  inside.  There  ought  to  be  some  reason  for  it.  Personally  I  would 
square  the  ties  on  the  inside  on  double  track  just  for  the  looks  of  it. 

The  President: — The  Acting  Chairman  of  the  Committee  is  unwilling 
to  accept  the  suggestion,  so  unless  some  motion  is  made  we  will  pass  to 
Rule  15. 

The  Secretary: — "(15)  Whenever  spikes  are  drawn  from  ties, 
wooden  tie  plugs  must  be  driven  into  all  holes  except  in  ties  which  are 
to  be  renewed  that  season.  In  replacing  spikes  they  should  be  driven  into 
the   plugs." 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs  (Illinois  Central)  : — I  think  we  should  make  some 
reference  to  the  use  of  treated  plugs  in  treated  ties. 

The  President: — Have  you  any  suggestion  for  a  complete  sentence? 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — Add  to  the  present  paragraph,  "When  spikes  are 
withdrawn  from  treated  ties,  plugs  of  treated  material  should  be  used." 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — It  seems  to  me  that  rule  is  general.  It  does  not 
refer  particularly  to  either  treated  or  untreated  ties.  These  rules  may 
be  supplemented  by  such  special  rules  as  local  conditions  may  require. 
It  seems  to  me  this  rule  is  general  enough. 

The  Secretary: — "(16)  In  unloading  rails  from  cars  they  should  be 
skidded  or  otherwise  carefully  lowered  to  avoid  injury.  Where  it  is  neces- 
sary to  drop  them,  both  ends  must  be  dropped  together  and  the  greatest 
care  taken  to  avoid  their  falling  on  hard  and  uneven  surfaces." 

Mr.  E.  R.  Lewis : — In  the  interest  of  brevity,  I  would  move  that  the 
last  sentence  of  Rule  16  be  eliminated.  I  understand  that  it  is  put  in 
there  for  emphasis,  but  there  is  emphasis  in  brevity.  I  think  if  we  say: 
"In  unloading  rails  from  cars  they  should  be  skidded  or  otherwise  care- 
fully lowered  to  avoid  injury,"  we  have  said  all  that  is  necessary. 


DISCUSSION.  926 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — I  second  the  motion  in  the  interest  of  good  prac- 
tice and  not  for  the  sake  of  brevity. 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter  (Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie)  : — As  I  understand  it,  the 
second  sentence  is  provided  for  those  cases  where  they  have  not  the 
equipment  to  carefully  lower  the  rails.  On  a  sandy  roadbed,  with  rea- 
sonable care,  you  can  drop  the  rails  without  danger  of  breaking,  and  I 
would  judge  that  a  very  large  percentage  of  the  rails  in  this  country  are 
unloaded  without  their  being  skidded  or  lowered  carefully  with  some 
device. 

Mr.  E.  R.  Lewis: — I  think  the  first  sentence  covers  that  point.  If 
you  carefully  drop  them,  you  carefully  lower  them. 

Mr.  Ferriday : — I  would  suggest  the  word  "unloaded"  in  place  of 
"lowered." 

The  President : — There  is  a  motion  before  the  Association,  ti  has 
been  moved  and  seconded  that  the  second  sentence  of  Rule  16  be  elim- 
inated. 

(A  vote  was  taken  on  the  motion  and  it  was  lost.) 

The  President: — Any  further  discussion? 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony  :-*-Mr.  Tratman's  correction,  striking  out  the  word 
"new"  in  the  first  sentence,  has  been  accepted. 

The  Secretary: — "(17)  The  bottom  of  the  new  rail  and  the  bearing 
surface  of  the  tie  shall  be  cleaned  before  the  new  rail  is  laid. 

"(18)  When  replacing  rail  with  rail  of  the  same  section,  only  two 
rows  of  spikes  shall  be  drawn ;  in  replacing  with  rail  of  a  different  section, 
three  rows  of  spikes  shall  be  drawn. 

"(19)  In  laying  new  rail,  standard  expansion  shims  shall  be  used. 
The  temperature  of  the  rail  shall  be  taken  by  placing  the  thermometer  on 
the  rail.  The  openings  between  3s  ft-  rails  shall  be  in  accordance  with  the 
table. 

"The  rail  should  be  laid  without  bumping  and,  when  practicable,  laid 
rail  by  rail." 

Mr.  Ferriday: — If  it  is  permissible,  I  would  like  to  return  to  Rule  18. 
I  do  not  think  the  rail  section  should  determine  whether  two  rows  of 
spikes  shall  be  left  or  three  rows.  It  depends  upon  certain  parts  of  the 
section.  I  know  that  in  a  great  many  cases  but  two  rows  of  spikes  are 
drawn,  in  laying  rails  of  different  sections,  although  the  sections  are 
quite  different.  It  depends  upon  the  gage  of  the  track,  and  the  difference 
in  sections,  that  is,  the  width  of  the  base  and  the  width  of  the  head. 
1  would  make  a  motion  to  add,  after  that  paragraph,  the  words,  "if  neces- 
sary." 

The    President : — That   is   accepted   by   the   Committee. 

The  Secretary: — "(20)  The  rails  shall  be  brought  squarely  into 
line  and  at  least  two  bolts  tightened  before  spiking.  All  joint  bars  shall  be 
securely  fastened  with  the  full  number  of  bolts,  tightening  those  at  the 
center  first.  At  permanent  connections  of  rails  of  different  sections  step 
chairs  and  offset  splices  must  be  used." 

Mr.  Tratman : — I  propose  that  after  Rule  19  there  should  be  added  a 


926  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

paragraph,  giving  the  specia1  requirements  for  expansion  spacing  in  tun- 
nels. The  figures  which  are  given  in  the  table  under  Rule  19  are  for  open 
track.  Some  railways  note  on  their  tunnel  plans  that  above  a  certain  tem- 
perature all  rails  shall  be  laid  close,  but  not  bumped  together.  I  think 
it  would  be  well  to  insert  a  paragraph  relating  to  spacing  in  tunnels  and, 
possibly,  on  long  bridges,  where  expansion  joints  have  to  be  considered. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — I  think  the  Committee  had  in  mind  that  this 
would  come  under  the  head  of  special  rules  to  govern  local  conditions? 
However,  if  the  convention  wants  to  insert  that  rule,  I  would  like  to  hear 
it  discussed. 

The  President: — Any  discussion?  The  Committee  does  not  feel  like 
accepting  that  paragraph,  unless  there  is  a  motion  adopted  by  the  Asso- 
ciation. 

Mr.  Tratman : — In  Rule  20  the  terms  "step  chairs"  and  "offset  splices" 
are  used.  Then  in  Rule  22  the  term  "compromise  joints"  is  used.  Those 
are  three  names  for  one  device,  and  I  think  in  Rule  20  the  words  "com- 
promise joints"  should  be  used. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony: — Do  you  mean  in  place  of  offset  joints? 

The  President: — Do  you  mean  "compromise"  instead  of  "offset?" 

Mr.  Tratman: — Either  use  the  two  or  change  it.  I  would  move 
that  "offset  splices"  be  changed  to  "compromise  joints." 

The  President : — The  Committee  will  accept  "compromise  splices." 

The  Secretary: — "(21)  All  spikes  must  be  driven  vertically  with 
the  face  in  contact  with  the  base  of  the  rail.  They  should  not  be  straight- 
ened while  being  driven.  The  rail  must  be  full  spiked  and  the  spikes 
staggered  so  that  the  outside  spikes  shall  be  on  the  same  side  of  the  tie 
and  the  inside  spikes  on  the  opposite  side. 

"(22)  In  making  temporary  connections  in  main  tracks  an  old  rail 
should  be  cut  and  fastened  to  the  new  rail,  using  compromise  joints  when 
necessary.  Switch  points  shall  be  used  for  this  purpose  only  during  the 
presence  of  the  Track  Foreman." 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — I  move  that  we  eliminate  the  last  sentence. 

(Motion  seconded  and  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "(23)  After  new  rail  is  laid  the  track  must  be  lined 
and  surfaced. 

"(24)  All  kinked  or  crooked  rails  must  be  straightened  before  being 
laid ;  if  bent  in  service  they  must  either  be  removed  or  straightened." 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin  (Illinois  Central)  : — This  says,  "If  bent  in  service 
they  must  either  be  removed  or  straightened."  After  straightening,  I 
think  it  is  unsafe  to  lay  them  back  in  the  main  track. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony : — This  does  not  say  they  shall  be  laid  back  in  the 
main  track.    It  may  be  laid  in  a  siding. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — The  presumption  from  the  context  is  that  that 
is  what  is  referred  to. 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis)  : — Does 
it  necessarily  mean  that  a  rail  is  unsafe  because  it  has  been  straightened? 
Do  I  understand  Mr.  Baldwin  to  mean  that?     If  that  is  true,  the  curv- 


DISCUSSION.  927 

ing  of  rails  is  bad  practice.  I  recall  having  straightened  as  many  as 
2,000  rails,  some  of  which  are  still  in  service  to-day,  and  that  was  twenty 
years  ago. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin: — It  is  true  that  the  curving  of  a  rail  is,  in  a 
measure,  the  bending  of  it.  Of  course,  by  the  roller  rail  bender,  so- 
called,  it  is  a  very  gradual  process,  and  I  have  seen  cases  where  surface 
bent  rails  in  the  main  track  were  taken  out  and  straightened  and  then 
relaid  in  the  main  track,  and  I  found  they  were  liable  to  breakage  at  the 
point  where  the  straightening  had  been  done,  and  I  have  known  of  quite 
a  number  of  cases  where  they  did  break  at  that  point.  From  the  nature 
of  steel,  it  seems  to  me  it  is  not  a  safe  practice  to  take  a  surface  bent 
rail  and  straighten  it  and  put  it  back  into  the  main  track,  under  very  high, 
heavy   service. 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter: — A  surface-bent  rail  means  a  rail  that  is  bent 
vertically.  Any  power  that  is  sufficient  to  bend  it,  is  liable  to  damage  the 
structure  of  the  rail,  but  a  rail  can  be  bent  sideways  or  horizontally  be- 
cause, on  account  of  the  section,  it  is  not  so  stiff  in  that  dire:tion.  So  it 
can  be  bent  sideways  and  horizontally  and  straightened  again  and  put  back 
in  the  track  again  without  taking  any  great  chances.  I  do  not  think  this  is 
intended  to  refer  to  surface-bent  rail,  but  that  it  means  rails  bent  out 
of  line. 

The  President: — Any  further  discussion?  There  is  no  motion  before 
the  house. 

Mr.  C.  C.  Wentworth  (Norfolk  &  Western)  : — I  merely  want  to  call 
attention  to  the  fact  that  switch  points  are  bent  cold  almost  invariably 
before  they  are  planed,  and  we  do  not  find  them  breaking. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse  (Santa  Fe)  : — It  seems  to  me  these  rules  are  rather 
too  general  for  a  railway,  for  the  reason  that  we  have  first,  second,  third 
and  fourth  class  track.  We  build  light  branches  for  the  development  of 
a  country  and  take  most  anything  and  lay  it  there.  To  make  a  rule  that 
you  cannot  straighten  a  bent  rail  is  impracticable,  because  none  of  us 
follow   it. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin:— I  think  after  a  rail  has  been  bent  that  is  kinked, 
as  referred  to  in  the  first  part  of  this  rule,  and  then  straightened,  it  should 
be  treated  as  if  it  were  a  second-quality  rail.  After  we  get  from  the  mills 
a  new  second-quality  rail,  it  does  not  come  up  to  the  first-class  specifica- 
tions and  we  use  it  for  switch  leads  in  points  of  main  line  where  there 
is  no  very  high  speed,  and  other  places  like  that,  and  after  a  rail  has  been 
kinked  I  think  it  should  be  treated  as  a  second-quality  rail,  and  be  put  to 
the  same  uses  as  a  second-quality  rail. 

Mr.  E.  R.  Lewis : — I  move  that  Rule  24,  as  printed  in  Bulletin  141,  be 
adopted. 

(Motion  seconded  and  carried  by  a  rising  vote,  resulting  as  follows: 
For,  41 ;  opposed,  24.) 

The  Secretary:— "(25)  Rails  for  curves  of  2  degrees  and  over  should 
be  curved  before  being  laid.  In  curving  or  straightening  rails,  the  rail 
bender  must  be  used." 


928  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

Mr.  S.  A.  Jordan  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  would  like  to  ask  the 
members  of  the  Committee  what  kind  of  a  rail  bender  they  would  use  in 
curving  the  rail  for  a  2-degree  curve  and  get  anything  like  a  uniform 
curve  in  the  rail. 

Mr.  F.  D.  Anthony:— Do  you  mean  what  style  of  machinery? 

The  President :— The  Committee  says  it  is  unable  to  answer  that 
question. 

Mr.  H.  E.  Hale  (Missouri  Pacific)  : — I  move  that  it  be  changed  to  rea"d 
4  degrees  instead  of  2. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse: — The  rule  says  that  the  rail  bender  must  be  used. 
I  understand  there  are  some  roads  in  the  country  that  have  not  been 
using  a  rail  bender  on  the  outside  rail.  They  curve  the  inside  rail  and 
then  spring  the  outside  rail  to  gage  with  it.  We  have  done  that  in  a 
few  cases  on  our  road,  and  have  found  it  very  satisfactory,  rather  tend- 
ing to  get  away  from  the  short  kinks  that  are  there,  whether  you  can 
see  them  or  not,  when  the  rail  bender  is  used. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  McDonald: — May  I  ask  the  Chairman  whether  the  Manual  shows 
whether  any  action  has  been  taken  on  this  matter  in  the  past?  I  think 
it  has  already  been  fixed  at  2  degrees. 

The  President : — A  hasty  examination  of  the  Manual  does  not  show 
any  action  to  have  been  taken,  but  the  Chair  rules  this  will  be  a  matter 
for  the  editor  of  the  Manual  to  take  care  of  when  the  time  comes  to 
print  this.  Rule  25  has,  therefore,  been  changed  to  read  "4  degrees" 
instead  of  "2,"  unless  there  is  a  division  requested. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan  (Canadian  Pacific)  : — The  word  the  is  a  definite 
article,  and  it  would  lead  one  to  believe  that  the  Committee  had  a  special 
kind  or  make  in  mind.     I  would  suggest  a  rail  bender. 

The  President: — The  Committee  accepts  that. 

The  Secretary: — "(26)  When  surfacing  (picking  up  low  joints  or 
other  low  places),  the  general  level  of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed." 

Mr.  J.  B.  Berry  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific)  : — I  move  to  strike 
out  everything  in  the  parenthesis.  There  cannot  be  two  different  kinds 
of  low  joints.  Surfacing  means  picking  up  the  track,  and  it  is  covered 
by  the  balance  of  the  rule. 

The  President : — The  Committee  accepts  that.  The  rules  are  now 
open    for   a   motion  to   adopt  them  as  a   whole  as   amended. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse : — Before  doing  that,  there  is  a  question  on  Rule  26, 
as  amended  by  Mr.  Berry.  It  would  read,  "When  surfacing,  the  general 
level  of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed."  I  think  that  is  misleading.  If 
you  are  surfacing  to  a  face,  you  certainly  have  got  to  disturb  the  surface 
of  the  track  and  any  track  has  got  to  be  surfaced  to  a  face  occasionally. 

The  President: — Do  you  wish  to  move  to  put  those  words  back? 

Mr.   C.  A.   Morse : — .Not  exactly  those  words. 

The  President : — The  words  were  eliminated  by  consent  of  the  Com- 
mittee and  not  by  vote;  therefore,  it  is  subject  to  amendment,  if  you 
wish. 


DISCUSSION.  929 

Mr.  W.  M.  Camp  (Railway  and  Engineering  Review)  : — Does  not 
Rule  4,  on  reballasting,  cover  that  point? 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter: — I  would  like  to  offer  an  amendment  to  Rule  26, 
as  follows:  "When  picking  up  low  joints  or  other  low  places,  the  general 
level  of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed."  The  word  "surfacing"  is  a 
general  term  and  applies  to  lifting  track,  when  you  are  simply  lifting 
one  side  or  lifting  joints,  or  when  you  are  lifting  up  a  foot  in  order  to 
put  in  new  ballast;  so  that  "surfacing"  is  the  general  term;  whereas,  as 
I  read  it,  this  clause  is  to  warn  the  foreman  that,  when  he  is  simply  pick- 
ing up  low  joints  and  other  low  places,  they  must  not  disturb  the  general 
surface  of  the  track.  Now,  that  is  a  source  of  a  great  deal  of  difficulty 
on  track  maintenance.  Old,  experienced  foremen  can  often  go  through  a 
section,  in  the  spring  and  early  summer,  and  put  it  in  first-class  shape 
with  little  or  no  effort,  whereas  I  have  seen  a  young  foreman,  when  it 
was  only  necessary  to  pick  up  his  joints  at  low  places,  do  more  harm 
to  the  track  than  he  did  good  by  attempting  to  do  what  this  rule  says 
he  must  not  do,  namely,  not  disturb  the  general  level  of  the  track. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Stein  (Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey)  : — I  would  like 
to  call  attention  to  the  fact  that  this  reads,  "when  picking  up  low  points" 
—a  typographical  error,  no  doubt.  I  think  this  would  read  better,  "when 
picking  up  joints  or  other  low  places,  the  general  level  of  the  track  must 
not  be  disturbed,"  and  not  duplicate  the  word  "low,"  because  that  is 
very  clear  by  inference. 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter:— I  accept  that. 

Mr.  G.  W.  Merrell  (Norfolk  &  Western)  :— I  would  like  to  ask  if  the 
word  "maintained"  would  not  be  better — "the  general  level  of  the  track 
shall  be  maintained?" 

Mr.  C.  H.  Ewing  (Atlantic  City  Railway)  :— I  hope  the  motion 
will  not  carry.  I  think  all  of  us  know  that  surfacing  simply  covers  pick- 
ing up  low  joints  and  low  spots.  Raising  track  is  an  entirely  different 
proposition;  so  that  the  rule  as  agreed  to  by  the  Committee  should  stand. 

Mr.  Camp: — I  think  it  is  a  little  unfortunate  that  those  words  "pick- 
ing up  low  joints  and  other  low  places"  were  eliminated  because  they  ex- 
plain what  the  Committee  meant  by  the  word  "surfacing." 

I  am  heartily  in  accord  with  this  paragraph,  because  I  do  not  believe 
that  track  should  be  raised  out  of  face  unless  grade  stakes  be  set  for  the 
lift,  and  that  is  provided  for  in  Rule  4.  I  agree  with  Mr.  Porter  when  he 
says  that  a  great  deal  of  injury  to  track  is  done  by  raising  it  entirely  out 
of  face  when  really  all  that  is  needed  is  to  pick  up  the  low  spots.  On 
this  point  the  paragraph  in  question  is  important. 

Were  those  words   stricken  out  by  motion? 

The  President :— They  were  stricken  out  by  the  Committee  itself  on 
suggestion  of  a  member  of  the  house. 

Mr.  E.  T.  Reisler  (Lehigh  Valley)  :— I  would  like  to  ask  the  intention 
of  the  Committee,  in  case  bringing  up  a  low  joint  does  not  make  the 
track  level. 


930  RULES   AND   ORGANIZATION. 

The  President :— Any  further  discussion  on  the  motion?  The  motion 
is  to  change  Rule  26  to  read,  "When  picking  up  joints  or  other  low 
places,  the  general  level  of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed." 

(Motion   carried.) 

The  President: — The  Instructions  as  amended  now  stand  for  action 
by  the  convention  and  I  desire  to  read  the  rules  for  the  consideration 
of  reports. 

(The  President  read  the  same.) 

What  is  the  pleasure  of  the  convention  in  regard  to  these  Instruc- 
tions ? 

(A  motion  was  made  to  adopt  the  Instructions  as  amended.) 

Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt  (Pittsburgh  &  Lake  Erie)  : — I  desire  to  offer 
a  statement  respecting  Rule  24  before  this  motion  passes.  Every  rule 
under  the  head  of  "Rail,"  on  pagi  67,  seems  to  refer  to  the  laying  of  new 
rails  for  the  first  time.  In  Rule  24  the  second  paragraph  refers  to  rails 
bent  in  service.  Therefore,  it  seems  to  me  that  Rule  24  should  be  divided 
into  two  sections.  The  first  section  relates  to  new  rails  being  laid  for 
the  first  time  and  the  second  section  refers  to  rails  which  have  already  been 
in  use  and  have  become  bent.  I  think  we  are  a  little  inconsistent  in  mix- 
ing up  rails  bent  in  service  with  rails  which  have  not  yet  been  in  the 
track;  and,  furthermore,  I  do  not  like  Rule  24,  especially  in  its  relation 
to  the  attitude  of  public  bodies,  such  as  railroad  commissions  and  courts 
of  law,  with  respect  to  what  is  called  "kinked"  rails.  I  would  like  to  ask 
the  Committee  if  they  will  eliminate  the  second  section  of  Rule  24,  which 
refers  to  rails  which  have  been  in  service  and  bent,  either  by  reason  of 
imperfectly  balanced  locomotives,  or  from  some  other  cause — omit  that 
entirely  and  allow  the  first  section  of  the  Rule  to  be  consistent  with  the 
others  ?  And  if  the  Committee  will  accept  that,  I  would  like  them  to  elim- 
inate the  word  "crooked"  and  let  it  read  "kinked  rails  must  be  straight- 
ened before  being  laid." 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter: — It  seems  to  me  that  all  these  rules,  from  16  to  26, 
apply  to  laying  rails,  whether  new  or  relaying  rails.  As  far  as  Rule  24 
is  concerned,  I  would  be  very  glad  to  see  that  word  "crooked"  eliminated. 
The  rest  of  it  I  would  like  to  see  remain. 

The  President : — The  Chair  will  have  to  rule  that  that  is  not  strictly 
in  accordance  with  the  discussion  on  the  motion  as  it  is  now  put.  There 
has  been  no  second  to  either  suggestion  so  far. 

Mr.  H.  S.  Wilgus  (Pittsburg,  Shawmut  &  Northern)  :— If  it  is  not 
too  late,  I  would  like  to  refer  to  Rule  25.  It  seems  to  me  that  the  Rule 
refers  to  the  construction  of  entirely  new  track.  It  does  not  apply  to 
rail  replacement,  and  it  seems  that  a  sentence  may  be  added,  reading  like 
this:  "However,  for  renewals  it  will  not  be  necessary  to  curve  the  rail; 
it  may  be  sprung  into  place." 

The  President: — The  Chair  thinks  it  is  out  of  order  to  amend  any 
particular  Rule  now,  in  view  of  the  fact  that  this  motion  for  adoption 
has  been  put. 


DISCUSSION.  931 

Mr.  Stein : — It  seems  to  me  that  these  paragraphs  16  to  26,  inclusive, 
refer  to  the  laying  of  new  rail  and  not  the  renewal  of  rail  with  other 
second-hand  rail ;  that  the  title  of  these  paragraphs  should  be  changed  and 
it  should  specify  new  rail  instead  of  simply  "rail."  It  appears  to  me  as  if 
there  is  confusion  in  those  various  classes,  and  that  confusion  seems 
to  have  carried  itself  through  the  minds  of  the  Committee,  because  they 
appear  to  have  had  in  mind,  in  clause  24,  that  it  might  be  a  replacement 
of  rail  in  the  track  with  other  second-hand  rail.  I  think  the  title  should 
be  "new  rail,"  if  this  refers  to  new  rail. 

The  President: — The  question  is  demanded. 

(A   vote  was  then  taken   and  the   motion   was   carried.) 

The  President : — 'The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  SIGNALS  AND  INTERLOCKING. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  69-76.) 

LIST    OF    SPEAKERS     TAKING    PART    IN    DISCUSSION     ON     SIGNALS     AND     INTERN- 
LOCKING. 

,'  L.   R.   Clausen.  Hunter  McDonald. 

W.  H.  Elliott.  L.  S.  Rose. 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Sig- 
nals and  Interlocking,  of  which  Mr.  A.  H.  Rudd  is  Chairman.  In  the 
absence  of  the  Chairman,  Mr.  L.  R.  Clausen,  the  Vice-Chairman,  will 
present  the  report. 

Mr.  L.  R.  Clausen  (Chicago,  Milwaukee  &  St.  Paul): — The  Com- 
mittee on  Signals  and  Interlocking  was  assigned  four  subjects,  which 
appear  en  page  69.  The  Committee  has  no  report  on  subjects  2,  3  and 
4.  The  Committee  has  a  report  on  subject  1,  and  they  have  also 
submitted  a  revised  table  of  insulation  resistances  for  rubber-covered 
wires.  The  table  of  insulation  resistances  is  changed  as  the  result  of 
investigations  of  the  Committee  of  the  Railway  Signal  Association  and 
was  submitted  to  that  Association  at  its  annual  meeting  in  October 
last,  and  by  vote  of  the  convention  the  table  of  insulation  resistances 
was  submitted  to  letter  ballot  and  approved.  The  changes  are  com- 
paratively slight  and  in  order  to  make  the  American  Railway  Engineer- 
ing Association  specifications  conform  to  the  Railway  Signal  Association 
specifications,  the  Committee  would  desire  to  have  this  revised  table 
approved  by  this  Association.  I  make  a  motion  to  the  effect  that  the 
revised  table  of  insulation  resistances  shown  on  page  70  be  adopted  by 
this  Association. 

Mr.  W.  H.  Elliott  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  :— I 
second  the  motion. 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis)  :— I 
move  that  the  table  of  insulation  resistances  be  adopted  in  accordance 
with  Rule  16-g,  as  provided  in  the  General  Rules. 

Mr.  Clausen : — We  accept  the  amendment. 

The  President: — The  motion  is  that  this  revised  table  be  adopted 
for  publication  in  the  Manual. 

(The  motion  was   carried.) 

Mr.  Clausen : — The  adoption  of  the  table  of  insulation  resistances 
carries  with  it  the  approval  of  the  same  table  for  the  specifications  of 
cables,  both  braided  and  lead-covered,  which  are  covered  by  conclusions 
2  and  3,  at  the  top  of  page  70.  I  would,  therefore,  as  representing  the 
Committee,  move  the  adoption  of  this  same  table,  to  be  included  in  the 


DISCUSSION.  933 

specifications  for  mineral  matter,  rubber-compound  insulated,  braided 
cables,  and  also  for  rubber-compound  insulated  lead-covered  cables,  as 
covered  by  conclusions  2  and  3. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Clausen : — The  instructions  to  the  Committee,  No.  1,  are  as 
follows :  "Continue  investigation  of  outline  and  description  of  a  com- 
prehensive and  uniform  signal  system,  suitable  for  general  adoption, 
conferring  with  proper  committee  of  the  American  Railway  Association." 
A  report  of  the  Signal  Practice  Committee  of  the  Railway  Signal 
Association  has  been  submitted  to  the  Railway  Signal  Association 
and  has  been  rejected  by  that  Association.  In  view  of  that  fact  the 
Committee  presents  the  report  which  is  found  on  pages  71-4,  as 
information.  I  move  that  the  report  as  indicated  on  these  pages  be 
received  as  information. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  L.  S.  Rose  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — I 
move  that  the  report  on  pages  75-6  be  received  as  information. 

Mr.  Clausen : — I  failed  to  cover  the  entire  report ;  the  motion 
should  have  included  pages  75-6. 

The  President: — The  Chair  will  accept  that,  without  any  motion, 
that  it  includes   the   minority  report  also. 

The  Committee  is   dismissed   with   the  thanks   of  the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  IRON  AND  STEEL  STRUCTURES. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.   81-88.) 

LIST     OF      SPEAKERS      TAKING      PART     IN      DISCUSSION      ON      IRON      AND      STEEL 

STRUCTURES. 

F.  J.  Bachelder.  Thomas    Earle.  Albert   Reichmann. 

A.   S.  Baldwin.  E.  A.   Frink.  O.   E.   Selby. 

E.  C.  Brown.  J.  M.   Meade.  John   G.   Sullivan. 

J.  L.  Campbell.  H.  T.   Porter.  Edwin  F.  Wendt. 
C.  H.  Cartlidge. 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Iron 
and  Steel  Structures,  of  which  Mr.  C.  H.  Cartlidge  is  Chairman.  We 
will  ask  the  Chairman  of  the  Cotnmittce  to  make  the  opening  state- 
ment. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Cartlidge  (Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy)  :— Your 
Committee  reports  on  the  following  subjects: 

Subject  No.  I — Investigation  on  Impact  and  Secondary  Stresses: 
Appendix  B  contains  a  report  from  Prof  F.  E.  Turneaure,  Chairman 
of  Sub-Committee  on  Impact,  giving  an  outline  of  the  work  done  by  the 
Committee  during  the  past  year. 

Subject  No.  2 — Influence  of  Theory,  Experiment  and  Experience  on 
Bridge  Design :  It  was  unanimously  decided  by  the  Committee  that  it 
was  unable  to  report  adequately  on  this  subject,  and  the  request  is 
therefore  made  that  the  subject  be  dropped. 

Subject  No.  3— Rules  for  Instruction  and  Guidance  of  Inspectors  in 
Mills,  Shop  and  Field :  The  Committee  reports  progress.  The  Chair- 
man of  the  Sub-Committee  has  received  discussion  from  two  of  the 
members  of  his  Sub-Committee,  and  will  probably  be  able  to  submit  s 
paper  giving  the  results  of  their  findings  during  the  next  few  months. 

Subject  No.  4 — Design  of  Built-up  Columns :  The  tender  of  the 
services  of  this  Committee  to  collaborate  with  the  Joint  Committee  of 
the  American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  was  made  and  very  promptly 
accepted.  Sufficient  time  has  not  yet  elapsed  to  permit  the  organization 
of  any  actual  work  on  this  subject.  The  program  proposed  by  the 
American  Society  of  Civil  Engineers  Committee  is  very  elaborate  and 
comprehensive  and  when  carried  out  will  immensely  increase  our  knowl- 
edge of  the  subject.  In  order  that  this  Committee  do  any  practical 
work  on  this  subject,  it  will  be  necessary  to  have  funds.  Your  Com- 
mittee understands,  of  course,  that  none  of  the  funds  of  the  Association 
are  available  for  this  purpose.  We  feel  warranted,  however,  in  recom- 
mending that  individual  roads  be  asked  to  contribute  for  the  purpose  of 

934 


DISCUSSION.  935 

making  these  tests.  This  work  and  that  of  the  Impact  Committee  are 
original  research  work  and  it  is  hardly  necessary  for  us  to  point  out 
the  ultimate  value  of  the  work  done  in  the  manner  in  which  it  has 
been  done.  It  will  probably  be  necessary  in  the  near  future  to  take 
cognizance  of  these  experiments  in  our  specifications  for  design,  but  the 
Committee  does  not  recommend  that  any  change  be  made  at  present, 
nor  until  further  experiments  on  secondary  stresses  have  been  made,  and 
if  possible,  considerable  work  on  columns.  The  Committee  will  present 
later  a  more  definite  report  of  the  probable  amount  of  money  needed 
for  the  first  year's  work.  It  is  expected  that  this  will  be  very  small 
and  that  it  can  easily  be  raised. 

Subject  No.  5 — Specifications  for  Erection  of  Steel  Bridges:  The 
Committee  presents  for  the  consideration  of  the  Association  a  set  of 
specifications,  revised  in  accordance  with  the  discussion  at  the  last  con- 
vention and  with  the  written  discussions  from  members  and  others  re- 
ceived  since  the  convention. 

The   recommendations  of  the   Committee   are  as   follows : 
(i)     That    the    specifications    for    Bridge    Erection    be    adopted    and 
printed   in   the    Manual. 

(2)  That  the  report  of  the  Impact  Committee  be  received  as  in- 
formation. 

(3)  That  no  change  be  made  at  present  in  the  specifications  for 
steel  railway  bridges  printed  in  the  Manual. 

I  move  the  adoption  of  the  specifications  for  the  erection  of  rail- 
road bridges  printed  in  Appendix  A. 

The  President : — We  will  read  each  one  of  these  sections  contained 
in  Appendix  A,  as  was  done  in  the  previous  case. 

The  Secretary: — "1.  The  Contractor  shall  erect,  rivet  and  adjust 
all  metal  work  in  place  complete,  and  perform  all  other  work  herein- 
after  specified. 

"2.  The  Contractor  shall  provide  all  tools,  machinery  and  appli- 
ances necessary  for  the  expeditious  handling  of  the  work,  including 
drift  pins   and  fitting   up  bolts. 

"3.  The  method  of  erection  and  plans  for  falsework  and  erection 
equipment  shall  be  subject  to  approval  by  the  Engineer,  but  such 
approval  shall  not  relieve  the  Contractor  from  any  responsibility.  False- 
work will  be  built  by  * Falsework  material  of 

every   character   will   be   provided  by  the   * 

"The  temporary  structure  for  use  during  erection  and  for  maintain- 
ing the  traffic  shall  be  properly  designed  and  substantially  constructed 
for  the  loads  which  will  come  upon  it.  All  bents  shall  be  thoroughly 
secured  against  movement,  both  transversely  and  longitudinally.  The 
bents  shall  be  well  secured  against  settling,  and  piles  used  wherever 
firm  bottom  cannot  be  obtained.  Upon  completion  of  the  erection,  the 
temporary  structure,  if  the  property  of  the  Railway  Company,  shall  be 
removed  without  unnecessary  damage,  and  neatly  piled  near  the  site  or 


936  IRON   AND   STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

loaded  on  cars,  as  may  be  directed.  If  the  property  of  the  Contractor, 
it  shall  be  removed  in  a  manner  subject  to  the  approval  of  the  Engineer. 

"Falsework  placed  by  the  Railway  Company  under  an  old  structure 
or  for  carrying  traffic  may  be  used  as  far  as  practicable  by  the  Con- 
tractor during  erection,  but  it  shall  not  be  unnecessarily  cut  or  wasted." 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin  (Illinois  Central)  : — I  would  ask  the  object  of 
the  third  clause  of  Section  3,  which  provides  that  "Falsework  placed 
by  the  Railway  Company  under  an  old  structure  or  for  carrying  traffic 
may  be  used  as  far  as  practicable  by  the  Contractor  during  erection, 
but  it  shall  not  be  unnecessarily  cut  or  wasted.''  That,  it  seems  to  me, 
is  a  special  case,  and  does  not  apply  here.  You  cannot  make  a  rule 
of  that  kind  to  apply  to  all  cases.  I  would  suggest  the  elimination  of 
that  clause.  You  have  already  provided  for  the  falsework  in  the  first 
paragraph  of  the  section,  and  here  comes  a  modifying  clause  which 
might  cause  complication,  and  I  think  it  should  be  a  case  for  special 
arrangement  between  the  Contractor  and  the  railway  at  the  time  the 
contract  was  made. 

I  move  that  the  third  paragraph  of  clause  3  be  eliminated. 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter  (Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie)  : — It  is  not  an  uncommon 
thing  to  put  bents  under  a  truss  that  has  become  light.  I  had  a  case 
where  I  had  to  do  that,  so  I  took  up  the  question  with  a  bridge  com- 
pany as  to  a  plan  of  falsework  which  could  be  used  in  the  erection  of 
a  new  structure.  They  put  the  falsework  under  our  old  bridge  and 
used  it  when  they  came  to  erect  a  new  bridge. 

Then  in  another  case,  where  the  old  bridge  was  wrecked  by  a 
washout  and  an  engine  going  onto  it,  we  had  to  build  a  trestle  across 
the  river  in  order  to  keep  the  traffic  open,  so  we  built  our  trestle  over 
the  river,  and  it  was  used  for  falsework  by  the  Contractor  in  erecting 
a  truss.  This  is  a  specification  for  erection,  and  I  call  your  attention 
to  the  fact  that  this  covers  cases  that  do  happen  in  ordinary  experi- 
ence, and  I  see  no  objection  to  leaving  it  in  here.  It  simply  makes 
the  specification  more  complete. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — The  trouble  is  there  are  no  two  cases  that 
will  be  alike,  in  all  probability,  and  consequently  it  cannot  be  covered 
by  a  general  rule.  I  think  it  is!  well  to  call  attention  to  matters  like 
that,  and  I  suggest  the  following  modification — 

The  President : — There  is  a  motion  now  before  the  house  to  elimi- 
nate the  paragraph. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — I  withdraw  the  motion. 

(Seconder  agreed,   and   the  motion  was  withdrawn.) 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — I  make  a  motion  that  this  clause  be  modified 
as  follows :  "If  falsework  has  been  placed  by  the  Railway  Company 
under  an  old  structure,  or  for  carrying  traffic,  the  use  of  it  by  the 
Contractor  must  be  subject  to  a  special  arrangement,  to  be  made  with 
the  engineer  of  the  Railway  Company." 


DISCUSSION.  937 

Mr.  O.  E.  Selby  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  :— I 
think  that  the  clause  as  it  stands  does  not  represent  a  special  case, 
but  a  very  usual  case.  It  frequently  happens  that  falsework  has  been 
placed  under  a  bridge  for  the  purpose  of  strengthening  a  weak  bridge,  to 
enable  it  to  carry  the  traffic,  and  it  would  be  unwise  to  throw  it  away  and 
not  take  advantage  of  it  for  erection  purposes. 

I  do  not  see  how  it  would  lead  to  complications  with  the  Contractor, 
because  it  represents  an  existing  condition  at  the  time  bids  are  asked  for 
and  the  contract  is  let.  If  the  falsework  is  there,  it  is  there  when 
the  bidder  examines  the  job,  and  he  is  expected  to  examine  the  job 
and  take  note  of  all  the  existing  conditions.  I  think  that  the  existence 
of  that  falsework  should  be  taken  cognizance  of,  and  the  way  it  is  put 
in  the  specifications  here  does  that  in  a  satisfactory  manner. 

Mr.  J.  M.  Meade  (Santa  Fe)  :— I  wish  to  say  that  the  Santa  Fe 
has  done  a  great  deal  of  work,  almost  exactly  as  outlined  in  this  re- 
port, and  I  strongly  endorse  what  Mr.  Porter  says.  I  believe  we  should 
leave   that  paragraph   in   the   specifications   as   written. 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — In  making  these  specifications  we  desired  to  adapt 
them  as  widely  as  possible  to  any  conditions  which  are  to  be  met  with. 
It  is  possible,  of  course,  that  we  have  tried  to  cover  some  conditions 
which  are  not  so  nearly  universal  as  some  of  the  others  covered.  On 
the  other  hand,  it  seems  to  the  Committee  that  any  clause  such  as 
this,  which  may  not  meet  with  the  approval  of  the  Engineer  or  the 
Railway  Company  letting  the  contract,  can  be  eliminated  in  the  draft 
of  the  contract  made  at  the  time  the  work  is  let.  These  specifications 
are  not  intended  to  be  used  verbatim,  but  as  a  model  or  guide  for 
drawing  up  specifications.  With  that  explanation  of  the  purpose  of  the 
specifications,  we  think  that  some  of  the  clauses  may  be  allowed  to 
stand  as  being  suggestions  for  practice,  rather  than  clauses  which  must 
be  incorporated  in  all  contracts. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — I  think  the  members  have  misunderstood  the 
object  that  I  had  in  view  in  making  this  motion.  It  is  not  that  the 
falsework  should  not  be  used ;  it  is,  of  course,  in  the  line  of  economy 
that  anything  that  is  existent  on  the  railway  should  be  used;  but  I 
wanted  to  have  the  clause  so  worded  that  the  Railway  Company  would 
be  sure  to  get  proper  credit  for  it.  Take  a  case  in  which  a  Railway 
Company  is  about  to  let  a  contract  for  the  erection  of  all  its  bridges 
for  a  year.  The  Contractor,  in  figuring  for  these  bridges,  would  figure 
on  the  falsework  for  all  of  the  bridges ;  then,  at  any  point  where  he 
found  falsework,  there  would  be  that  much  net  gain  to  him  to  which 
he  was  not  entitled,  whereas,  if  the  provision  is  made  in  the  way  I 
have  proposed  where  the  Contractor  comes  to  a  bridge  for  which  the 
falsework  has  been  provided,  it  becomes  necessary  for  him  to  make 
a  special  arrangement  for  that  bridge  with  the  Railway  Company  and 
the  Railway  Company  gets   credit   for  the   material   put  in. 

Mr.   Porter: — If  this  clause   is   left   in   the  specification,   then   it   does 


938  IRON    AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

not  have  to  be  handled  as  a  special  matter,  and  if  a  iailway  is  letting 
a  contract  for  all  of  its  bridges  for  a  year,  and  takes  competing  bids, 
if  this  clause  is  in  the  specification,  the  chances  are  that  some  of 
these  contractors,  at  least,  will  take  this  into  consideration,  in  making 
their  bids,  and  the  Railway  Company  would  get  a  lower  bid  than  if 
this  clause  is  left  out.  If  the  clause  is  left  out  of  the  general  speci- 
fication, the  Engineer  may  omit  to  take  it  into  consideration  when  he 
calls  for  bids,  so  I  think  it  is  the  proper  place  for  it  and  it  should 
remain. 

Mr.  F.  J.  Bachelder  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — This  clause  seems  to 
be  covered  in  the  forepart  of  the  section.  It  says :  "The  method 
of  erection  and  plans  for  falsework  and  erection  equipment  shall  be 
subject  to  approval  by  the  Engineer,  but  such  approval  shall  not  relieve 
the    Contractor    from    any    responsibility.      Falsework    will    be    built    by 

* Falsework   material   of    every    character    will 

be  provided   by   the  * "     That,    it    seems   to   me, 

covers  these  particular  cases,  and  we  could  eliminate   the   latter   clause. 

(The  motion  was  lost.) 

The  Secretary: — "4.  The  work  shall  be  prosecuted  with  sufficient 
force,  plant  and  equipment  to  expedite  its  completion  to  the  utmost 
extent  and  in  such  a  manner  as  to  be  at  all  times  subordinate  to  the 
use  of  the  tracks  by  the  Railway  Company,  and  so  as  not  to  interfere 
with  the  work  of  other  contractors  or  to  close  or  obstruct  any  thor- 
oughfare  by   land  or  water,   except   under   proper   authority. 

"Reasonable  reduction  of  speed  will  be  allowed  upon  request  of  the 
Contractor. 

"Tracks  shall  not  be  cut  nor  shall  trains  be  subjected  to  any  stop- 
page  except   when  specifically   authorized  by  the   Engineer. 

"The  Contractor  shall  protect  traffic  and  his  work  by  flagmen  fur- 
nished by  and  at  the  expense  of  the  Railway  Company.  The  Contractor 
shall  provide  competent  watchmen  to  guard  the  work  and  material 
against  injury." 

Mr.  E.  A.  Frink  (Seaboard  Air  Line)  : — The  second  paragraph  of 
this  section  reads :  "Reasonable  reduction  of  speed  will  be  allowed 
upon  request  of  the  Contractor."  That  means  that  upon  the  request 
of  the  Contractor  the  Railway  Company  will  issue  a  "slow  order" 
limiting  the  speed  over  the  structure  to  a  certain  degree.  I  think 
there  should  be  a  clause  added  specifying  that  the  Railway  Company 
will  not  be  responsible  for  any  injury  to  the  property  or  structure  of 
the  Contractor,  due  to  failure  on  the  part  of  the  Railway  Company  to 
carry  out  the  "slow  order."  I  say  that  for  this  reason :  In  one  case 
in  our  experience  on  the  Seaboard  Air  Line  we  had  a  "slow  order" 
over  the  structure  and  the  Contractor  was  engaged  in  building  a  coffer- 
dam which  he  tied  up  to  the  structure.  Some  of  the  trains  over  the 
structure    exceeded    the    speed    limit    and    the    Contractor    thereupon    set 


DISCUSSION.  939 

up  a  claim,  which  he  substantiated  in  court,  that  the  Seaboard  Air 
Line  was  responsible  for  the  damage  to  his  work  because  it  did  not 
maintain  the  slow  order.  Therefore,  Mr.  Chairman,  I  move  to  amend 
that  paragraph  by  adding:  "The  Railway  will  not  thereby  in  any  way 
incur  any  responsibility  for  damage  to  the  work  or  materials  of  the 
Contractor   for   failure   to    maintain    such    reduction   in    speed." 

Mr.  Thomas  Earle  (Pennsylvania  Steel  Company)  : — It  seems  to 
me  that  the  addition  of  this  clause  would  nullify  the  balance  of  the 
paragraph.  What  is  the  advantage  of  a  slow  order  to  a  Contractor 
if  he  knows  beforehand  that  he  is  not  to  expect  that  slow  order  to 
be  fulfilled,  and  in  addition  if  there  is  a  slow  order  of  thirty  miles 
an  hour  and  a  train  goes  through  at  sixty  miles  an  hour  and  the 
Contractor's  plant  is  destroyed  and  he  has  to  pay  for  it,  of  what 
benefit  is  the  clause  to  him?  It  will  add  a  burden  on  the  Contractor, 
but  in  the  end  the  Railway  Company  will  pay  for  all  such  clauses, 
because  the  Contractor  must  eventually  be  reimbursed  for  all  such 
expenses  by  his  customers,  who,  in  this  particular  case,  are  the  rail- 
ways. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell  (El  Paso  &  Southwestern)  : — I  agree  with  the 
remarks  of  the  speaker  who  has  just  preceded  me.  I  do  not  think 
we  can  enforce  a  clause  of  that  kind.  I  do  not  believe  that  you  can 
release  a  Railway  Company  from  proper  responsibility  by  the  insertion 
of  such  a  clause,  and  I  believe  it  would  impair  the  force  and  effective- 
ness and  dignity  of  the  work  of  this  Association  to  put  such  a  clause 
as  that  in  the  specification. 

Mr.  F.  J.  Bachelder : — This  clause  does  not  specify  the  speed  re- 
striction which  is  to  be  placed  on  the  structure.  It  simply  provides 
for  a  reasonable  reduction  of  speed.  I  think  the  clause  should  stand 
as  written. 

Mr.  Frink: — It  is  true  that  this  clause  does  not  specify  the  speed 
limit,  but  when  you,  at  the  request  of  the  Contractor,  do  lower  your 
speed,  then  you  have  to  specify  that  speed  limit.  If  the  Contractor 
asks  for  a  reduction  of  speed,  you  ask  the  operating  department  to 
put  on  a  reduction,  and  then  you  have  fixed  the  speed  limit. 

In  answer  to  Mr.  Campbell,  I  will  say  it  is  like  this — if  you  put 
a  four-mile  slow  order  on  the  train,  and  some  trains  go  through  at 
eight  miles  per  hour,  if  the  Contractor  can  bring  witnesses  to  testify 
that  the  train  passed  over  the  structure  at  eight  miles  per  hour  and 
his  work  was  injured,  then  you  are  liable.  It  does  not  require  a  speed 
of  sixty  miles  an  hour;  it  does  not  require  a  speed  of  more  than  six 
miles  an  hour.  It  is  simply  a  question  of  whether  the  Contractor  can 
get  witnesses  to  testify  that  the  speed  of  the  train  was  greater  than 
the  limit  of  the  slow  order  and  injured  his  work.  This  may  in  some 
cases  impose  a  hardship  on  the  Contractor,  but  I  think  if  you  do  not 
put  it  in  it  may  in  more  cases  impose  a  hardship  on  the  Railway 
Company. 


940  IRON   AND   STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

Mr.  Albert  Reichmann  (Resident  Engineer,  American  Bridge  Com- 
pany) : — I  think  the  words,  "reasonable  reduction  of  speed  will  be 
allowed,"  are  sufficient.  In  my  opinion  the  word  "reasonable'  takes 
care  of  that. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan  (Canadian  Pacific)  : — The  trouble  with  this 
clause  is  this — that  in  case  the  Contractor  asks  for  a  certain  speed  and 
the  speed  is  exceeded,  if  anything  happens,  the  Contractor  will  en- 
deavor to  make  the  Railway  Company  responsible.  Would  it  not  be 
better  to  say  "a  reasonable  reduction  of  speed  will  be  allowed  on  the 
recommendation  of  the  company's  Engineer?''  Leave  it  in  the  hands 
of  the  Engineer,  rather  than  the  Contractor.  He  is  responsible  merely 
for  the  work,  and  if  the  structure  is  going  to  fail  by  running  trains  at 
sixty  miles  an  hour  he   is  not  going  to   allow   it. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Stein  (Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey)  : — I  favor  the 
clause  just  as  it  reads.  I  believe  the  point  that  has  been  raised  is 
practically  covered  by  a  succeeding  paragraph  which  reads :  "The 
Contractor  shall  protect  traffic  and  his  work  by  flagmen  furnished  by 
and  at  the  expense  of  the  Railway  Company."  It  is  the  business  of 
the  Contractor  to  see  that  these  flagmen  carry  out  their  instructions 
and  hold  the  speed  of  the  trains  down  to  the  limit  placed  on  them 
by  the  Engineer  in  charge  and  the  operating  department,  so  that  I  do 
not  think  it  is  necessary  to  introduce  any  additional  clause  in  these 
specifications. 

Mr.  Porter : — I  offer  an  amendment  to  read  as  follows :  "Reason- 
able reduction  of  speed,  upon  request  of  Contractor,  can  be  provided  for 
in  the  contract." 

The  President : — That  is  so  different  from  the  amendment  already 
proposed  that  it  cannot  be  received. 

Mr.  Porter : — The  point  I  want  to  make  is  that  in  some  contracts 
you  do  not  want  any  reduction  of  speed  whatever,  and  you  may  require 
the  Contractor  to  take  out  the  old  bridge  and  put  in  a  new  bridge,  in 
between  trains,  without  either  stopping  or  delaying  the  trains.  This 
being  a  general  specification,  the  contract  let  under  this  specification 
entitles  the  Contractor  to  a  reasonable  reduction  of  speed  if  he  should 
so    request. 

(The  motion  was  lost.) 
.    Mr.    E.    C.    Brown    (Carnegie    Steel    Company)  : — Is    it    not    a    fact 
that  some   railway  companies    do   not   admit   of   any  reduction   whatever 
in  the  speed?     It  seems  to  me  that  this   clause   should  take  cognizance 
of  that  fact. 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — I  have  practically  the  same  answer  to  make  to 
Mr.  Brown  as  I  made  to  Mr.  Baldwin,  that  the  specification  attempts 
to  cover  all  cases,  and  such  clauses  as  apply  to  particular  cases,  which 
are  not  required  at  the  time  of  letting  the  contract,  may  be  very  readily 
eliminated. 


DISCUSSION.  941 

The  Secretary :— "5.  If,  under  the  contract,  work  train  or  engine 
service  is  furnished  the  Contractor  free  of  charge,  such  service  shall 
consist  only  in  unloading  materials  and  in  transferring  the  same  from 
a   convenient   siding   to   the   bridge    site.      Other    engine    service    shall   be 

paid    for   by   the   Contractor   at   the   rate    of   $ per    day    per 

engine,  the  time  to  include  the  time  necessary  for  the  engine  to  come 
from  and  return  to  its  terminal.  When  engine  service  is  desired,  the 
Contractor  shall  give  the  proper  railway  officials  at  least  24  hours' 
advance  notice  and  the  Railway  Company  will  furnish  the  service  as 
promptly  as   possible,  consistent   with   railroad   operations. 

"When  derrick  cars  are  used  on  main  tracks,  their  movements  shall 
be  in  charge  of  a  train  crew,  and  the  expense  of  the  crew  and  any 
engine  service  other  than  as  noted  above  shall  be  charged  to  the  Con- 
tractor." 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin: — I  think  it  is  good  practice  to  require  the 
Contractor  to  pay  part  of  the  cost  of  the  work  train  service.  Where 
the  full  expense  of  the  work  train  service  is  paid  for  by  the  Railway 
Company,  the  contractors  call  for  work  trains  where  they  could  be 
avoided  and  are  negligent  in  letting  them  go,  and  I  have  made  it  a 
practice  to  give  a  price  for  the  service  of  the  work  train  per  day  that 
will  about  divide  the  cost  between  the  Railway  Company  and  the  Con- 
tractor. 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — The  Committee  spent  more  time  over  that  clause 
than  any  other  in  the  specification.  It  is  a  very  difficult  one  to  cover. 
The  practice  is  very  widely  variant  on  different  roads,  and  we  have 
this  further  point  to  consider:  In  making  a  specification,  if  the  speci- 
fication does  not  set  forth  the  conditions  under  which  the  Contractor 
must  make  his  bid,  he  is  likely  to  add  something  for  good  measure  to 
cover  the  question  at  issue :  in  other  words,  if  he  has  an  indefinite 
amount  of  train  service  to  pay  for,  he  will  put  in  his  estimate  a  flat 
price  sufficient  to  cover  all  that  he  will  have  to  pay,  and  it  is  necessary 
in  a  general  specification  either  to  put  all  of  it  at  the  expense  of  the 
Railway  Company  or  all  of  it  at  the  Contractor's  expense.  It  will  be 
very  easy  to  amend  these  specifications  for  particular  cases,  but  it  would 
be  very  difficult  so  to  word  them  as  to  provide  for  all  cases  which  may 
arise   in   practice. 

The  Secretary : — "6.  When  transportation  of  equipment,  materials 
and  men  is  furnished  free  over  the  Railway  Company's  line,  it  shall  be 
subject  to  such  conditions  as   may  be   stated  in  the  contract." 

Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt  (Pittsburgh  &  Lake  Erie)  : — I  do  not  wish 
to  oppose  this  section,  but  I  rise  to  state  that  for  some  years  our 
company  followed  the  practice  of  furnishing  free  transportation  for 
materials  and  work  train  service.  There  is  so  much  difficulty  in  con- 
nection with  this  practice  that  we  found  it  convenient  to  abolish  it, 
and  at  the  present  time  we  compel  all  contractors  to  bid  on  just  one 
condition,  namely,  the  bid  shall  include  all  transportation  of  both  men 
and  materials  and  all   cost  of  work  train   service.     Where  this   practice 


942  IRON   AND    STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

can  be  followed,  the  Engineer  has  a  great  deal  less  trouble  in  connec- 
tion with  his  field  work  and  his  accounts,  and  I  believe  this  is  the 
practice  to   which  we  are   rapidly   tending  in   our   country  to-day. 

The  Secretary : — "7.  The  Railway  Company  will  furnish  all  ma- 
sonry to  correct  lines  and  elevations,  and,  unless  otherwise  stated  in 
the  contract,  will  make  all  changes  in  old  masonry  without  unneces- 
sarily impeding  the  operations  of  the  Contractor.  The  Railway  Com- 
pany's engineers  will  establish  lines  and  elevations  and  assume  re- 
sponsibility therefor,  but  the  Contractor  shall  compare  the  elevations, 
distances,  etc.,  shown  on  plans,  with  the  masonry  as  actually  constructed 
as  far  as  practicable,  before  he  assembles  the  steel.  In  case  of  dis- 
crepancy, he  shall   immediately  notify  the  Engineer. 

"8.  Cars  containing  materials  or  plant  shall  be  promptly  unloaded 
upon  delivery  therefor,  and  in  case  of  failure  to  do  so  the  Contractor 
shall  be  liable  for  demurrage  charges.  Material  shall  be  placed  on  skids 
above  the  ground,  laid  so  as  not  to  hold  water,  and  stored  and  handled 
in  such  a  manner  as  not  to  be  injured  or  to  interfere  with  railroad 
operations.  The  expense  of  repairing  or  replacing  material  damaged  by 
rough  handling  shall  be  charged  to  the  Contractor.  The  Contractor, 
while  unloading  and  storing  material,  shall  compare  each  piece  with 
the  shipping  list  and  promptly  report  any  shortage  or  injury  discovered. 

"9.  When  traffic  is  to  be  maintained  it  will  be  carried  on  in  such  a 
manner  as  to  interfere  as  little  as  practicable  with  the  work  of  the 
Contractor. 

"Changes  in  the  supporting  structure  or  tracks  required  during 
erection  shall  be  at  all  times  under  the  direct  control  and  supervision  of 
the  Railway  Company." 

The  Secretary: — "10.  Unless  otherwise  specified,  metal  work  in 
the  old  structure  shall  be  dismantled  without  unnecessary  damage  and 
loaded  on  cars  or  neatly  piled  at  a  site  immediately  adjacent  to  the 
tracks,  and  at  a  convenient  grade  for  future  handling,  as  may  be 
directed.  When  the  structure  is  to  be  used  elsewhere,  all  parts  will  be 
matchmarked  by  the  Railway  Company ;  when  the  old  bridge  is  com- 
posed of  several  spans  the  parts  of  each  shall  be  kept  separate. 

"11.  Material  shall  be  handled  without  damage.  Threads  of  all 
pins  shall  be  protected  by  pilot  and  driving  nuts  while  being  driven  in 
place. 

"Light  drifting  will  be  permitted  in  order  to  draw  the  parts  to- 
gether, but  drifting  for  the  purpose  of  matching  unfair  holes  will  not 
be  permitted.     Unfair  holes  shall  be  reamed  or   drilled. 

"Nuts  on  pins  and  on  bolts  remaining  in  the  structure  shall  be 
effectively    locked   by   checking   the   threads. 

"All  splices  and  field  connections  shall  be  securely  bolted  prior  to 
riveting.  When  the  parts  are  required  to  carry  traffic,  important  con- 
nections, such  as  attachments  of  stringers  and  floor  beams,  shall  have  at 
least  fifty  (50)  per  cent,  of  the  holes  filled  with  bolts  and  twenty-five 
(25)   per  cent,  with  drift  pins.     All  tension   splices   shall  be  riveted  up 


DISCUSSION.  943 

complete  before  blocking  is  removed.  When  not  carrying  traffic,  at 
least  thirty-three  and  one-third  (33  J/3)  per  cent,  of  the  holes  shall  have 
bolts. 

''Rivets  in  splices  of  compression  members  shall  not  be  driven  until 
the  members  shall  have  been  subjected  to  full  dead  load  stresses.  Rivets 
shall  be  driven  tight.  No  recupping  or  calking  will  be  permitted.  The 
heads  shall  be  full  and  uniform  in  size  and  free  from  fins,  concentric 
and  in  full  contact  with  the  metal.  Heads  shall  be  painted  immediately 
after  acceptance. 

"Rivets  shall  be  uniformly  and  thoroughly  heated  and  no  burnt 
rivets  shall  be  driven.  All  defective  rivets  shall  be  promptly  cut  out 
and  redriven.  In  removing  rivets  the  surrounding  metal  shall  not  lie 
injured;   if  necessary,   the   rivets   shall  be   drilled  out." 

M'r.  Earle: — The  fourth  paragraph  of  section  11  reads:  "All  splices 
and  field  connections  shall  be  securely  bolted  prior  to  riveting.  When 
the  parts  are  required  to  carry  traffic,  important  connections,  such  as 
attachments  of  stringers  and  floor  beams,  shall  have  at  least  fifty  (50) 
per  cent,  of  the  holes  filled  with  bolts  and  twenty-five  (25)  per  cent. 
with  drift  pins."  I  think  50  per  cent,  with  drift  pins  and  25  per  cent, 
with  bolts  will  give  better  results.  Drift  pins  absolutely  fill  the  holes, 
and  if  you  have  drift  pins  and  bolts,  both  in  the  same  splice,  the  drift 
pins  will  carry  all  the  stresses,  as  they  are  the  only  ones  actually  in 
contact. 

Mr.  Cartlidge: — I  think  it  is  conceded  that  not  all  rivets  fill  all 
the  holes  and  that  a  good  many  of  our  structures  are  being  carried  on 
friction. 

Mr.  Earle: — If  the  drift  pins  fill  the  hole,  that  is  the  first  thing 
which  will  be  affected.  The  hole  is  absolutely  filled  with  the  drift  pin 
and  the  bolt  cannot  offer  any  frictional  resistance  until  the  drift  pin 
begins   to   move. 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — The  style  of  drift  pins  with  which  I  am  familiar 
are  tapered  and  the  largest  diameter  of  the  drift  pin  is  the  diameter  of 
the  rivet  hole,  and  that  diameter  occurs  in  only  one  place  in  the  length 
of  the  drift  pin.  It  is  a  little  difficult  to  see  how  such  a  pin  can  be 
any  better  than  a  bolt ;  that  is,  a  tapered  drift  pin  in  a  cylindrical  hole. 

Mr.  Selby : — These  specifications  are  intended  to  represent  recom- 
mended practice,  and  to  a  great  extent  common  practice,  and  I  would 
ask  Mr.  Earle  if  he  knows  of  it  being  common  practice  to  use  two-thirds 
drift  pins  and  one-third  bolts? 

Mr.  Earle : — That  is  practically  the  way  we  do  work  where  we 
carry  heavy  traffic.  It  is  seldom  we  have  to  carry  heavy  traffic  on 
steel  work  of  that  kind,  but,  where  we  do,  that  is  the  way  we  do  it, 
if  it  has  the  approval  of  the  Engineer. 

As  far  as  the  drift  pin  is  concerned,  quite  a  distance  of  the  upper 
end  of  the  drift  pin  is  cylindrical,  and  it  is  always  driven  so  far  that 
the  cylindrical  part  of  the  drift  pin  will  be  entirely  in  the  hole. 

Mr.  Cartlidge  :■ — It  is  the  opinion  of  the   Committee  that  it  is  diffi- 


944  IRON   AND   STEEL   STRUCTURES. 

cult  to  insure  that  the  cylindrical  part  of  the  drift  pin  shall  coincide 
with  the  cylindrical  part  of  the  hole.  But  I  will  state  that  the  opinion 
of  the  Committee  is,  as  far  as  common  practice  goes,  the  bolts  should 
be  the  larger  proportion  and  the  drift  pins  in  the  minority,  and  that 
this  practice   represents   the  better   practice    followed  by   the   railways. 

The  Secretary: — "12.  Correction  of  minor  misfits,  and  a  reasonable 
amount  of  reaming  shall  be  considered  as  a  legitimate  part  of  the 
erection. 

"Any  error  in  shop  work  which  prevents  the  proper  assembling  and 
fitting  up  of  parts  by  the  moderate  use  of  drift  pins,  and  a  moderate 
amount  of  reaming  and  slight  chipping  or  cutting  shall  be  immediately 
reported  to  the  Engineer  and  the  work  of  correction  done  in  the 
presence  of  the   Engineer,  who   shall   check  the  time  expended. 

''The  Contractor  shall  render  an  itemized  bill  for  such  work  of 
correction   for  the   approval  of  the  Engineer. 

"13.  Holes  for  all  anchor  bolts,  except  where  bolts  are  built  up 
with  the  masonry,  shall  be  drilled  by  the  Contractor  after  the  metal  is 
in  place  and  the  bolts  shall  be   set  in  Portland  cement  grout. 

"14.  Bed  plates  resting  on  masonry  shall  be  set  level  and  have  a 
full  even  bearing  over  their  entire  surface;  this  shall  be  attained  by 
either  the  use  of  Portland  cement  grout  or  mortar,  or  by  tightly  ram- 
ming in  rust  cement  under  the  bed  plates  after  blocking  them  accurately 
in  position. 

"15.  The  * will  frame  and  place  the  per- 
manent timber  deck. 

"16.     The  paint  will  be  furnished  by  * and 

shall   be  of   such   color,   quality   and  manufacture   as   may   be   specified. 

"Surfaces  inaccessible  after  erection,  such  as  bottoms  of  base  plates, 
tops  of  stringers,  etc.,  shall  receive  two  coats  of  paint  before  assembling 
in  place.  After  erection,  the  entire  structure  shall  receive  two  coats  of 
paint,  allowing  enough  time  between  coats  for  the  first  coat  to  dry 
before  applying  the  second.  No  paint  shall  be  applied  in  wet  or  freezing 
weather,  nor  when  the  surface  of  the  metal  is  damp.  Painting  shall  be 
done  in  good  and  workmanlike  manner,  subject  to  strict  inspection  dur- 
ing progress  and  after  completion,  and  in  accordance  with  special  in- 
structions which  shall  be  given  by  the  Engineer.  All  metal  shall  be 
thoroughly  cleaned  of  dirt,  rust,  loose  scale,  etc.,  before  the  paint  is 
applied. 

"17.  The  Contractor,  after  completion  of  the  work  of  erection,  shall 
remove  all  old  material  and  debris  resulting  from  his  operations  and 
place  the  premises  in  a  neat  condition. 

"18.  During  the  entire  progress  of  the  work  the  Contractor  shall 
have  a  competent  superintendent  in  personal  charge  and  shall  employ 
only  skilled  and  competent  workmen.  Instructions  given  by  the  En- 
gineer to  the  superintendent  shall  be  carried  out  the  same  as  if  given 
to   the    Contractor.      If   any    of   the    Contractor's    employes   by    unseemly 


♦Insert   "Railway    Company"   or   "Contractor"  as  the  case  may  be. 


DISCUSSION.  945 

or  boisterous  conduct,  or  by  incompetency  or  dishonesty,  show  unfitness 
for  employment  on  the  work,  they  shall,  upon  instructions  from  the 
Engineer,  be  discharged  from  the  work,  nor  thereafter  be  employed 
upon   it   without   the   Engineer's   consent. 

"19.  The  work  of  erection  shall  at  all  times  be  subject  to  the 
inspection   and  acceptance  of  the   Engineer. 

"20.  The  Contractor  shall  assume  all  responsibility  for  loss  or 
damage  to  his  own  work,  materials  or  plant,  due  to  any  cause ;  also, 
for  all  loss  or  damage  to  the  Railway  Company's  materials  or  property, 
and  to  other  property  adjacent  to  the  railroad,  due  to  causes  within 
his   reasonable   control. 

"The  Contractor  shall  assume  all  responsibility  for  injury  to  the 
workmen  and  the  public,  or  to  any  individual ;  and  in  case  of  accident 
or  suit  he  shall  defend  the  suit  in  person  and  relieve  the  Railway 
Company  from  all  costs  and  expenses,  and  pay  any  judgments  that 
may  be   recovered   thereon. 

"The  Contractor  shall  comply  with  the  laws  and  ordinances  affecting 
the  manner  of  doing  work;  shall  take  out  all  necessary  permits  and 
comply  with  their  requirements,  and  shall  take  such  precaution  as  may 
be  necessary  to  protect  life  and  property." 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — After  talking  this  last  section  over  with  the  Com- 
mittee, I  move  the  elimination  of  section  20  from  the  specification,  as 
it  is  properly  a  clause  of  the  contract  and  not  of  the   specification. 

(The  motion   was   carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "21.  The  Contractor  shall  carry  such  liability  in- 
surance as  is  necessary  to  protect  himself  and  the  Railway  Company 
against  loss  or  damage  caused  by  injuries  to  his  men,  and  shall  furnish 
the  Railway  Company  a  bond  in  form  and  of  a  surety  acceptable  to 
the  Railway  Company,  providing  for  the  faithful  performance  of  the 
work  and  all  matters  pertaining  thereto,  in  such  sum  as  shall  be  speci- 
fied in  the  contract." 

Mr.  Cartlidge : — The  Committee  wishes  to  move  the  elimination  of 
section  21  also  on  the  same  ground. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "22.  The  term  "Engineer,"  as  used  herein,  shall 
be  understood  to  mean  the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Railway  Company,  or 
his    accredited    representative." 

The  President: — These  proposed  specifications  are  now  before  you 
for  action. 

Mr.  Wendt : — I  move  that  these  specifications  be  approved  for 
publication  in   the   Manual   under   "General  Rule   16-g." 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Cartlidge: — I  move  that  the  report  of  the  Impact  Committee 
be    received    as   information. 

(The    motion    was    carried.) 

The  President :— The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  WOODEN  BRIDGES  AND   TRESTLES. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  77-SO.) 
LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING     PART    IN    DISCUSSION     ON     WOODEN     BRIDGES     AND 

TRESTLES. 

G.  A.   Mountain.  C.  C.  Wentworth. 

The  President: — The  report  of  the  Committee  on  Wooden  Bridges 
and  Trestles  will  next  be  disposed  of.  Mr.  C.  C.  Wentworth,  the 
Chairman,  will  make  the  opening  statement. 

Mr.  C.  C.  Wentworth  (Norfolk  &  Western)  : — Mr.  Chairman  and 
gentlemen,  the  work  assigned  to  the  Committee  last  year  was,  first, 
to  report  on  the  formulas  for  use  in  determining  the  strength  of 
sheet  piling;  second,  to  report  on  equipment  required  for  pile  driving; 
third,  to  collect  information  on  special  methods  of  driving  sheet 
piles  in  cofferdams  where  conditions  do  not  permit  the  use  of  ordinary 
equipment;  fourth,  to  collect  information  on  actual  experience  on  the 
bearing  power  of  piles  and  on  the  practical  results  of  the  use  of 
formulas;  fifth,  to  report  on  the  use  of  guard  rails  for  wooden  bridges 
and  trestles;  sixth,  to  report  on  fire  protection  of  wooden  bridges 
and  trestles.  Of  the  above  subjects  those  numbered  i,  4,  5  and  6 
were  considered.  It  seemed  to  the  Committee  that  the  pressure 
against  steel  sheet  piling  in  place  was  something  that  was  yet  to  be 
determined,  and  I  am  glad  to  be  able  to  say  that  Cornell  University 
is  about  to  undertake  a  series  of  experiments  to  determine  just  what 
that  pressure  is.  The  experiments  which  they  will  undertake  are 
not  precisely  those  given  on  pp.  78  and  79,  of  Bulletin  141,  but  along 
different  lines.  This  the  Committee  is  not  at  all  objecting  to,  because 
it  gives  the  problem  an  additional  point  of  attack;  and  the  more 
points  of  attack  we  can  give  it  the  better.  As  for  collecting  informa- 
tion on  the  other  three  subjects,  I  beg  to  say  a  very  large  amount 
of  data  has  been  brought  together.  This  has  been  formulated  and 
tabulated  and  put  in  shape  for  the  use  of  the  Committee  during  the 
coming  3rear,  but  the  present  Committee  does  not  wish  to  make  any 
recommendation  to  this  meeting  for  its  adoption.  I  make  a  motion, 
then,  to  receive  our  report  as  a  progress  report  and  information. 

The  President: — Would  anyone  like  to  say  anything  on  either 
of  these  subjects  mentioned  by  the  chairman? 

Mr.  G.  A.  Mountain  (Canadian  Railway  Commission): — Does  this 
include  the  whole  of  the  report? 

The  President: — Yes;  you  can  make  remarks  on  any  subject. 

Mr.  Mountain: — Under  subject  5,  I  would  like  to  ask  for  informa- 
tion, whether  that  is  a  necessity  where  oil-burning  engines  are  used. 

Mr.  Wentworth: — Mr.  Mountain,  as  we  have  simply  adopted  this 
as  a  progress  report,  I  think  we  had  better  not  take  the  matter  up  in 
detail. 

The  President: — Tt  would  be  perfectly  proper  to  answer  accord- 
ing to  your  individual  opinion  if  you  liked. 

(The  motion  was  then  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association,  946 


DISCUSSION  ON  YARDS  AND   TERMINALS. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.   89-92.) 
LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART    IN    DISCUSSION    ON    YARDS    AND    TERMINALS. 

C.  E.  Lindsay.  C.  H.  Spencer. 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Yards  and  Terminals,  of  which  Mr.  C.  H.  Spencer  is  Chairman.  The 
Chairman  of  the  Committee  will  make  the  preliminary  announcement. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Spencer  (Washington  Terminal  Company) : — The  Com- 
mittee on  Yards  and  Terminals  have  done  a  great  deal  of  work  this 
year  in  the  collection  of  data  on  three  of  the  subjects  assigned  to 
the  Committee:  (i)  report  on  typical  situation  plans  for  passenger 
stations,  etc.;  (2)  report  on  developments  in  the  handling  of  freight 
by  mechanical  means;  (3)  report  on  developments  in  the  design  and 
operation  of  hump  yards. 

The  information  received  was  of  such  a  nature  that  it  was  thought 
best  to  hold  this  over  for  a  future  report,  a  portion  of  which  is  to  be 
written  in  the  coming  year. 

The  work  presented  to  the  Association  this  year  is  in  tue  way  of 
a  report  on  subject  (4),  report  on  typical  situation  plans  for  a  division 
engine  terminal,  which  will  be  found  on  page  91.  The  Committee  is 
a  large  one,  representing  about  seventeen  or  eighteen  different  roads, 
and  naturally  a  great  deal  of  discussion  occurred  on  this  subject  and 
the  report  presented  is  the  boiled-down  opinion  of  the  Committee 
after  the  examination  of  a  large  number  of  plans  of  engine  terminals 
that  were  presented  for  the  consideration  of  the  Committee. 

The  Secretary: — "(1)  The  engine  terminal  should  be  so  located 
as  to  afford  easy  access  to  both  Main  Line  and  Yards,  with  the  fewest 
possible  reverse  or  conflicting  movements." 

Mr.  Spencer: — I  move  the  adoption  of  conclusion  No.  1. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "(2)  The  facilities  provided  should  be  arranged 
to  permit  of  the  most  direct  and  rapid  handling  of  an  engine  in  its 
terminal  in  the  order  of  its  needs." 

Mr.  Spencer: — I  move  the  adoption  of  conclusion  No.  2. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River): — I 
agree  with  the  conclusion  except  it  does  not  state  in  what  order  of 
needs  the  facility  should  be  provided. 

The  President: — It  is  very  general. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — The  Committee  provides  that  coal  shall  be  taken 
when  going  out.     From  a  motive-power  standpoint  that  is  desirable, 

947 


948  YARDS  AND  TERMINALS. 

but  from  an  operating  standpoint  and  considering  the  question  of 
time  after  the  engine  is  ordered,  it  is  desirable  to  coal  an  engine 
coming  in,  so  that  there  will  not  be  any  necessity  for  its  delay  after 
it  is  ordered  in  going  to  its  point  of  departure.  The  plan  does  not 
provide  any  facility  for  coaling  an  engine  coming  in,  and  if  the  plan 
was  modified  so  that  it  might  be  possible  to  coal  the  engine  coming 
in  or  going  out,  in  the  same  manner  that  they  take  water  coming  in 
or  going  out,  the  conclusion  would  be  much  more  desirable. 

The  President: — This  is  simply  offered  as  information,  and  the 
conclusions  need  not  affect  the  plan  at  all. 

Mr.  Spencer: — I  call  attention  to  the  fact  that  provision  is  made 
in  the  plan  for  coaling  on  the  inbound  track  ?  one  track  is  placed  next 
to  the  coal  wharf  for  that  purpose. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — Side  coaling  arrangement? 

Mr.  Spencer: — Yes. 

(The  motion  to  adopt  conclusion  2  was  put  to  vote  and  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  BALLAST. 

(For   Report,  see  pp.  95-300.) 
LIST     OF     SPEAKERS    TAKING     PART    IN     DISCUSSION    ON     BALLAST. 

H.    E.    Hale.  C.  E.   Lindsay.  C.    A.    Morse. 

Walter  Loring  Webb.  S.  N.   Williams. 

The  President: — We  will  next  consider  the  report  on  Ballast. 
Mr.  H.  E.  Hale  is  Chairman;  Mr.  Hale  will  please  make  the  opening 
statement. 

Mr.  H.  E.  Hale  (Missouri  Pacific): — The  Ballast  Committee  would 
like  to  have  the  Association  approve  the  definition  of  "Depth  of  Bal- 
last" first,  and  then  the  conclusions  of  the  three  sub-committees. 

The  definition  is  as  follows: 

"Depth  of  Ballast. — The  distance  from  the  bottom  of  the  tie  to  the 
top  of  the  subgrade."  (For  definition  of  "subgrade,"  see  Manual, 
191 1,  page  16.) 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb  (Consulting  Engineer): — As  a  matter 
of  information,  I  would  like  to  ask  that  the  definition  of  sub-grade 
in  the  Manual  be  read. 

The  Secretary: — "Subgrade:  The  tops  of  embankments  and  bot- 
tom of  cuttings  ready  to  receive  the  ballast." 

Mr.  Hale : — The  conclusion  on  page  97,  proper  depth  of  ballast 
to  produce  uniform   pressure  on   the   subgrade,   etc.,   I   move  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse  (Santa  Fe) : — Regarding  this  report,  which  is 
based  on  the  Pennsylvania  experiment,  on  the  value  of  cinders  to 
help  make  up  the  24-inch  depth  of  ballast,  we  had  an  experience  ten 
or  fifteen  years  ago  on  a  piece  of  line  about  twenty  miles  in  length, 
with  a  foot  and  a  half  or  two  feet  of  cinders  for  ballast.  We  covered 
this  with  ten  inches  of  slag  ballast,  and  for  at  least  four  years  we 
were  having  to  work  on  that  slag  ballast  continuously  on  account  of 
the  settlement  of  the  cinders  under  it.  While  it  showed  up  well  as 
an  experiment,  it  did  not  show  up  well  in  practice  with  us. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — I 
am  sure  the  Committee,  in  using  the  words  "cinder  ballast,"  does  not 
preclude  gravel  ballast  or  better  ballast? 

The  President: — No;  the  Committee  would  be  glad  to  add  gravel, 
if  that  would  tend  to  make  it  more  acceptable  to  the  Association.  If 
there  is  no  further  discussion,  the  question  will  be  put. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Hale: — Under  the  heading  of  "Physical  Tests  of  Stone  for 
Ballast,"  your  Committee  recommends: 

"For  the  description  of  the  physical  tests  of  stone  for  ballast  as 
recommended  by  the  Association  and  full  instructions  as  to  how  the 
samples  should  be  obtained  and  shipped  to  the  Government,  see  Pro- 
ceedings of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  and  Maintenance  of 
Way  Association,  Vol.   11,  Part  2,  pp.  910-914,  and  report  of  Ballast 

949 


950  BALLAST. 

Committee  of  1912.  If  blueprints  of  the  machines  used  in  making  the 
tests  are  desired,  they  can  be  obtained  from  the  Department  of  Agri- 
culture, United  States  Government,  Washington,  D.  C." 

Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill  (Norfolk  &  Western) :— While  I  think  that 
this  test  may  be  all  right,  it  is  one  that  the  railroads  cannot  ordinarily 
make,  because  they  do  not  have  ready  at  hand  a  diamond  drill  of 
this  size,  and  do  not  have  the  means  of  cutting  this  core  required  in 
the  test.  We  have  been  conducting,  for  several  years,  a  test  by  means 
of  cubes  cut  with  a  chisel  and  the  relative  strength  of  every  stone 
can  be  determined  in  that  way,  just  as  well  as  it  can  by  means  of 
the  cores.  Therefore,  while  I  do  not  wish  to  suggest  that  this  test  be 
not  agreed  to,  I  think  there  should  be  some  latitude  given  for  another 
form  of  compression  test,  such  as  can  be  readily  made  by  any  rail- 
road without  going  to  the  Government. 

Mr.  Hale: — The  physical  tests  of  stone  which  are  recommended 
in  the  Manual  are  covered  by  a  description  in  the  Proceedings  of  the 
Association  and  are  made  by  the  Government  at  Washington.  They 
were  originally  started  for  testing  material  for  wagon  roads,  and 
they  were  the  most  complete  set  of  physical  tests  for  stone  that  your 
Committee  could  find,  and  the  fact  that  the  Government  makes  them 
at  Washington  for  any  railroad  or  corporation  or  individual  free  of 
charge  by  sending  the  sample  to  the  Government,  made  it,  in  the 
opinion  of  the  Committee,  very  advantageous  to  accept  these  tests 
as  described  by  the  Government  for  use  by  the  Association.  It 
makes  a  very  uniform  test  and  is  readily  comparable  with  other 
stone  known  to  the  railroads.  A  sample  of  stone  desired  by  Govern- 
ment for  test  is  easily  obtained  by  following  the  proposed  instructions 
in  the  Manual. 

I  move  that  that  be  incorporated  in  the  Manual. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President: — There  are  no  further  conclusions  by  this  Com- 
mittee, the  one  on  page  102  simply  being  a  recommendation  in  regard 
to  the  continuance  of  the  work.  Would  any  member  like  to  ask  any 
questions  of  the  Committee?  If  not,  the  Committee  will  be  dis- 
missed, with  the  thanks  of  the  Association. 

Prof.  S.  N.  Williams  (Cornell  College): — I  would  like,  as  a  mem- 
ber of  the  Committee  on  Ballast,  to  express  the  high  appreciation 
which  the  Committee  has  for  the  experiments  made  by  the  Pennsyl- 
vania Railroad  Company  in  reference  to  the  necessary  depth  of  stone 
ballast,  and  if  it  is  not  too  late  I  would  like  to  have  a  resolution 
passed,  expressing  our  appreciation,  as  I  know  this  matter  has  been 
of  great  service  to  us,  and  is  one  of  those  things  we  cannot  properly 
reward  in  any  other  way.  I  personally  feel  very  grateful  to  Mr. 
Cushing  and  the  company  and  also  to  the  United  States  Department 
of  Agriculture  for  the  help  they  have  given  us  in  our  Committee 
work.     I  make  this  as  a  motion. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 


DISCUSSION  ON   TIES. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  301-370.) 
LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART    IN     DISCUSSION    ON    TIES. 

W.  M.   Camp.  George  W.  Kittredge.  C.   A.   Morse. 

W.  C.  Cushing.  C.  E.  Lindsay.  W.  L.  Seddon. 

L.  A.   Downs.  Hunter  McDonald.  Edwin   F.  Wendt. 

John  C.  Sesser.  L.  C.  Fritch. 

The  President :— The,  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Ties,  of  which  Mr.  L.  A.  Downs  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Downs  will  make 
the   opening  statement    for   the    Committee. 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs  (Illinois  Central)  : — Mr.  Chairman,  the  Com- 
mittee on  Ties  was  assigned  six  different  subjects  to  make  a  study  of 
and  report,  and  we  have  reported  on  three.  First,  "the  size  of  cross- 
ties  required  for  the  stresses  to  which  they  are  subjected,"  and  the 
conclusions  to  that  are  found  on  page  331.  The  second  was,  "tie  re- 
newals in  continuous  stretches  vs.  single  tie  renewals."  The  conclusion 
to  that  is  found  on  page  342,  and  the  third  one  we  reported  on  is  "the 
use  of  metal,  composite  and  concrete  ties ;"  the  conclusion  of  that  is 
found  on  page  370.     I  would  suggest  that  we  take  them  up  in  order. 

First,  "The  size  of  cross-ties  required  for  the  stresses  to  which 
they  are  subjected."  We  sent  out  circulars  and  were  very  much  grati- 
fied at  the  number  of  replies  that  we  received,  and  you  will  find  in 
Exhibit  F,  which  commences  on  page  312  and  ends  on  329,  some  valua- 
able  information  from  members  of  the  Association  who  replied  to  our 
questions  and  gave  their  experiences  on  different  phases  of  the  subject. 
On  page  331   you   will  find   our  conclusions,   which   I   will   read : 

"So  far  as  your  Committee  is  able  to  determine  it  is  not  feasible  to 
lay  down  any  fixed  rule  for  the  size  and  spacing  of  ties  based  on  the 
A,  B  and  C  classification  of  density  of  traffic,  for  the  following  reasons, 
each  of  which  in  itself  has  a  certain  definite  restriction,  as  well  as  an 
interrelation   with   all   others,   viz. : 

"(1)  Character  of  subgrade  varies  radically  on  the  same  road  and 
in  different  parts  of  the  country. 

"(2)     Kind  of  ballast  varies  widely. 

"(3)  Necessary  depth  of  ballast  varies  with  weight  of  axle  loads, 
as  well  as   density  of  traffic. 

"(4)  Necessary  distance  between  face  of  ties  varies  with  weight  of 
axle   load,   as  well   as   density    of   traffic. 

"(5)  Kinds  of  timber  used  for  ties  vary  in  different  sections  of 
the  country. 

"(6)     Width  of  base  rail   for  weight  of  rail)   and  use  of  tie-plates. 

951 


952  TIES. 

"(7)     Treated    or    untreated    ties,    crushing    stress    and    durability. 

"(8)     Amount   of  labor   spent   on  track  maintenance. 

"(9)     Drainage. 

"However,  in  general  it  may  be  considered  good  practice  for  Class 
A  and  perhaps  B  roads  to  space  ties  10-in.  to  12-in.  face  to  face;  the 
width  of  tie  is  not  so  important  if  10-in.  to  12-in.  spacing  face  to  face 
is  followed;  provided,  however,  the  minimum  width  of  face  of  tie 
is  limited  to  7  in." 

I  move  the  adoption   of  the  conclusions. 

The  President: — The  conclusions  just  read  have  been  moved  for 
adoption. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  :— It  occurs  to  me  that 
the  Committee  has  left  out  a  very  important  consideration  in  regard 
to  the  stresses  to  which  ties  are  subjected.  I  think  they  should  give 
us  some  information  on  what  stresses  ties  are  really  being  subjected 
to  with  our  heavy  wheel  loads,  and  before  we  adopt  these  conclusions 
we  ought  to  have  some  information  on  that  line,  and  for  that  purpose 
I  think  it  would  be  better  to  refer  the  subject  back  to  the  Committee 
for  next  year's  work.  The  conclusions  given  are  not  definite  and  they 
do  not  give  us  much  information,  except  in  the  instance  of  the  last 
paragraph,  and  I  doubt  very  much  whether  all  the  members  of  the 
Association  will  agree  with  the  Committee  on  the  last  clause  of  their 
conclusion.  There  are  many  members  who  think  that  the  width  of  the 
tie  is  an  important  question,  even  if  the  spacing  is  10  to  12  inches,  and 
it  occurs  to  me  that  the  conclusions  as  they  now  stand  are  hardly 
suitable   for   adoption. 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — The  first  nine  paragraphs  enumerated  are 
restrictions,  rather  than  conclusions.  The  last  paragraph  is  a  con- 
clusion that  the  Committee  saw  fit  to  make  after  taking  into  considera- 
tion the  nine  reasons  why  a  fixed  rule  cannot  be  set  for  A,  B  and  C 
traffic.  It  is  a  very  hard  matter  to  determine  the  stresses  in  ties,  and 
we  enumerated  nine  objections,  after  carefully  considering  the  proposi- 
tion as  to  why  a  fixed  rule  cannot  be  adopted  for  the  railways  to 
follow,  and  then  we  came  to  the  conclusion  in  the  last  paragraph  which 
we  have  up  for  adoption. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — What  I  have  in  mind  is  this — in  designing  a 
bridge  we  assume  a  certain  load.  In  designing  a  track  we  assume 
practically  no  load,  and  I  think  the  time  has  come  when  we  should 
pay  more  attention  to  the  designing  of  track  structure,  just  as  we  do 
to  the  designing  of  the  bridge  structure.  We  should  assume  certain 
heavy  wheel  loads  and  ballast  conditions  and  design  the  track  structures 
to  conform  to  these,  just  as  we  do  in  the  case  of  the  bridge  structure. 
I  assume  that  this  is  an  important  subject  for  the  railways.  I  am  of 
the  opinion  that  many  of  us  think  that  the  ties  are  too  small,  and  are 
being  subjected  to  too  heavy  stresses,  and  we  should  have  more  in- 
formation on  that  line. 


DISCUSSION.  953 

Mr.  L.;  A.  Downs : — In  designing  a  bridge  you  have  something  to 
start  out  with ;  you  have  an  absolute  foundation,  which  is  solid.  You 
build  the  abutments  and  design  the  bridge  for  certain  wheel  loads. 
You  have  absolutely  known  factors  to  work  on.  In  designing  a  track 
structure  you  must  figure  on  subgrade,  which  is  an  uncertain  quantity. 
As  we  enumerated  in  these  nine  paragraphs,  we  cannot  lay  down  any 
fixed  rule  on  account  of  the  nine  reasons  given — the  kind  of  ballast 
varies,  the  depth  of  ballast  varies,  the  kind  of  timber  used  for  ties 
varies,  and  there  are  various  other  reasons,  and  it  is  a  very  different 
subject  altogether  from  a  bridge  proposition,  where  you  have  to  start 
with   some  known  quantity  to  work   from. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — I  do  not  quite  agree  with  the  Chairman  of  the 
Committee.  We  can  assume  conditions  which  we  can  hope  to  reach. 
While  the  bridge  structure  is  a  different  proposition,  yet  the  principle 
is  the  same.  We  can  assume  certain  conditions  of  ballast,  foundation 
and  load,  and   design  the   structure  accordingly. 

Mr.  W.  M.  Camp  (Railway  and  Engineering  Review)  : — I  take 
issue  with  M'r.  Fritch.  If  he  wishes  the  Committee  to  arrive  at  the 
design  of  the  tie  by  mathematical  investigation,  I  think  his  proposition 
is  impracticable.  Theoretical  men  have  been  trying  to  do  that  for  the 
past  thirty  or  forty  years,  and  they  have  made  all  kinds  of  assump- 
tions, but  I  have  never  seen  a  result  that  seemed  to  be  worked  out 
on  practical  considerations.  In  designing  a  bridge  one  has  a  truss  or 
plate  girder  which  rests  upon  supports  at  two  points  and  the  remainder 
of  the  structure  hangs  clear.  In  the  tie  we  have  nothing  hanging  free, 
and  the  strength  of  the  tie  depends  to  a  large  extent  on  the  stability 
of  the  ballast  or  the  earth  supporting  it. 

Now,  in  reference  to  the  conclusion  as  expressed  in  the  last  para- 
graph, I  agree  with  the  Committee  if  they  intend  what  is  my  under- 
standing of  it,  and  that  is,  that  the  width  of  the  tie,  so  long  as  it  is 
up  to  standard  size,  is  relatively  not  important.  Of  course,  if  it  could 
be  construed  to  include  a  culled  tie,  I  would  not  support  the  conclu- 
sion ;  but  if  the  necessary  wrords  were  inserted  to  make  it  understood 
that  the  tie  referred  to  is  a  tie  of  standard  width  of  face,  or  larger, 
then   I  would   agree  with   the    Committee. 

Many  times  we  find  the  tie  spacing  referred  to  as  a  certain  dis- 
tance from  center  to  center.  If  the  ties  vary  in  the  width  of  face, 
that  method  of  spacing  is  not  a  proper  one.  It  results  in  a  more 
uniform  bearing  surface  to  space  the  ties  from  face  to  face,  rather 
than   from  center   to  center. 

The    President : — The    Committee   says   it   will   admit   that. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell  (El  Paso  &  Southwestern)  : — Many  of  the 
railways  are  still  carrying  their  track  across  steel  bridges  and  wooden 
bridges  on  wooden  ties,  and  it  seems  to  me  if  we  should  assume  the 
conditions  which  undoubtedly  exist,  or  nearly  exist  on  the  bridges,  we 
might    arrive   at    some    conclusions    along    the    lines    which    Mr,    Fritch 


954  TIES. 

suggested.  I  believe  it  would  be  a  good  thing  to  determine  just  what 
the  unit  stresses  are  in  a  case  of  that  kind. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse  (Santa  Fe)  : — In  discussing  this  tie  question, 
and  in  figuring  on  adopting  a  resolution  for  the  Manual,  it  seems  to 
me  we  should  not  put  anything  in  the  Manual  except  what  would  be 
of  particular  benefit.  We  all  know  that  we  are  up  against  the  varying 
conditions  set  forth  by  the  Committee  to  start  with,  and  their  report 
reminds  me  a  good  deal  of  the  Underwriters'  Code,  which  gives  you  a 
lot  of  negatives,  but  does  not  tell  you  what  you  can  do. 

We  are  up  against  this  proposition,  but  there  are  a  lot  of  different 
practices  in  vogue  on  the  various  roads,  and  it  seems  to  me  the  Com- 
mittee should  take  these  conditions  as  they  exist  and  investigate  as  to 
what  is  the  best  practice  on  all  the  roads,  or  on  the  various  roads, 
and  give  a  recommendation  based  on  the  best  practice.  As  I  under- 
stand the  conclusion  offered  by  the  Committee,  it  practically  gives  no 
recommendation  at  all.  I  do  not  know  how  the  rest  of  the  members 
use  the  Manual,  but  every  once  in  awhile,  when  I  get  up  against  some- 
thing that  causes  me  trouble,  I  hunt  up  the  Manual  to  see  what  other 
people  are  doing.  If  I  simply  found  the  conclusion  in  the  Manual  as 
given  by  the  Committee,  it  would  be  of  no  value. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — I  speak 
in  support  of  the  position  taken  by  Mr.  Fritch.  Assuming  a  stable 
condition  of  subgrade  and  a  desirable  condition  of  ballast,  the  maximum 
spacing  of  the  ties  would  be  determined  by  the  height  of  rail  and  the 
weight  of  it.  The  minimum  condition  would  be  established  largely  by 
the  method  of  track  work  and  kind  of  tool  used  for  tamping.  Between 
these  two  conditions  there  would  be  a  wide  range  of  possibilities.  I 
believe  it  is  possible  to  assume  conditions  and  determine  with  reason- 
able accuracy  what  is  the  best  type  of  construction. 

Mr.  John  C.  Sesser  (Great  Northern)  : — I  wish  to  say  that  we 
have  ties  that  have  a  face  dimension  of  over  18  inches.  I  believe  that 
the  size  of  the  tie  should  be  limited. 

Mr.  Edwin  F.  Wendt  (Pittsburgh  &  Lake  Erie)  : — This  proposition 
may  be  stated  in  another  way.  There  is  a  very  practical  matter  which 
comes  before  engineers.  In  one  section  of  the  country  it  may  be  said 
that  a  standard  tie  is  6  inches  by  8  inches  by  8  feet  long.  In  another 
section  of  the  country  it  may  be  said  that  the  standard  tie  is  y  inches 
by  8  inches  by  8  feet  6  inches.  The  managements  of  railways  are 
demanding  from  time  to  time  the  reasons  why  it  is  necessary  to  pur- 
chase the  higher  standard  of  ties ;  that  is,  a  tie  7  inches  thick  instead  of  6 
inches  thick  and   one  that  is  8  feet  6  inches  long,   instead  of   8  feet. 

It  would  be  very  helpful  to  the  engineers  if  this  Committee  would 
approach  this  subject  from  the  reverse  standpoint  from  that  which  has 
been  followed  and  first  determine  the  stresses  to  which  various  ties 
are  subjected  and  then  draw  a  conclusion  as  to  what  size  of  tie  is  the 


DISCUSSION.  956 

most  economical  under  the  loads  which  prevail  in  the  railway  practice 
of  to-day. 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs: — In  Exhibit  F  you  will  notice  in  regard  to 
question  No.  n  the  variety  of  answers  received  to  that  question  from 
the  different  members  of  the  Association  who  have  given  this  subject 
study.  Exhibit  D  shows  the  various  kinds  of  ties  used  by  the  differ- 
ent railways  and  the  number  of  miles  on  which  a  certain  size  of  tie 
is  used,  and  the  number  of  miles  on  which  another  size  of  tie  is  used. 
Without  having  something  definite  to  work  on  from  the  bottom,  as  we 
have  in  bridge  work,  it  is  very  hard  to  determine  stresses  in  ties. 

Of  course,  it  is  an  easy  matter  to  refer  the  report  back  to  the 
Committee  for  further  consideration,  investigation  and  report,  but  we 
must  have  some  foundation  to  work  on,  and  I  think  the  conclusion  as 
presented  shows  that  we  have  considered  something  that  is  good  practice. 

The  President : — I  desire  to  make  a  statement  on  behalf  of  the 
Board  of  Direction.  In  assigning  this  subject  to  this  Committee  the 
Board  had  in  mind  that  the  report  would  be  made  on  two  lines,  one 
line  which  the  Committee  has  reported  on  to-day  and  the  other  line 
in  harmony  with  what  Mr.  Fritch  and  Mr.  Wendt  have  just  stated.  We 
knew,  of  course,  when  the  subject  was  assigned  that  it  required  a  num- 
ber of  assumptions  to  come  to  any  conclusion  regarding  a  subject  of 
this  kind,  but  because  this  subject  is  hard  we  did  not  consider  that  we 
ought  to  balk  at  it.  A  great  many  European  engineers  have  already 
made  studies  on  this  line,  and  the  Board  thought  it  was  about  time 
that  the  engineers  in  this  country  took  it  up  and  tried  to  furnish  some 
additional  light. 

It  certainly  is  a  very  interesting  study,  and  it  will  not  do  any  harm 
to  have  such  a  study  made.  In  going  over  this  matter  yesterday  the 
Board  mistrusted  that  a  misinterpretation  of  the  subject  had  been  made 
by  the  Committee,  and  they,  therefore,  proposed  a  rewording  of  the 
instructions  in  line  with  what  Mr.  Fritch  has  already  stated,  namely, 
that  they  would  like  to  have  a  study  of  possible  stresses  in  the  ties, 
and  from  that  work  to  a  rational  design  or  size  for  a  tie. 

The  Committee  admits  that  they  have  been  unable  as  yet  to  draw 
any  conclusion  from  the  collection  of  facts  sent  by  the  railways.  It 
is,  therefore,  a  very  interesting  subject  for  the  Committee  to  pursue, 
and  the  Board  would  very  much  like  to  have  the  Committee  do  that, 
if  the  Association,  after  this  explanation,  feels  that  it  is  a  good  thing 
to  do. 

(The  President  put  to  vote  the  motion  for  the  adoption  of  the 
conclusions  on  page  331,  but  the  motion  was  not  agreed  to.) 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — I  move  this  portion  of  the  Committee's  report 
be  referred  back  to  it  for  further  consideration ;  that  it  be  received  as 
information  as  at  present  submitted,  and  that  the  Committee  give 
additional  study  to  the  subject  along  the  lines  of  the  remarks  on  the 
subject. 


956  TIES. 

(The   motion    was    carried.) 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs: — The  second  subject  referred  to  the  Committee 
was  "Tie  renewals  in  continuous  stretches  vs.  single  tie  renewals."  We 
sent  out  fifty  letters  to  the  different  railways,  asking  certain  questions 
in  connection  with  this  subject,  and  we  were  much  gratified  to  receive 
thirty-five  replies.  The  Committee  considered  these  replies  and  came 
to  the  conclusion  which  appears  on  the  bottom  of  page  342 :  "The 
Committee  recommends  the  practice  of  single  tie  renewals."  I  move 
that  the  conclusion  be  adopted. 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St  Louis)  : — I 
rise  with  a  good  deal  of  timidity  to  take  issue  with  the  Committee.  I 
did  not  receive  the  Committee's  circular.  If  I  had  done  so,  what  I 
have  to  say  now  would  have  been  printed  in  their  report.  I  do  not 
think  it  is  sufficient  reason  to  adopt  this  method  of  tie  renewal  as  the 
policy  of  the  Association  simply  because  it  is  the  common  practice  in 
this  country.  The  replies  received  by  the  Committee  to  its  circular 
and  the  statements  of  the  Committee  do  not  show  that  there  have  been 
any  very  great  or  deep  investigations  as  to  cost  and  other  factors.  They 
simply  express  the  opinion  that  it  is  the  best  policy,  without  giving  any 
facts  to  back  up  that  opinion.  I  think  this  habit,  you  might  say,  of 
single  tie  renewals  has  grown  up  because  of  conditions  for  which  none 
of  us  are  responsible — because  the  managements  of  the  railways  are  un- 
willing to  incur  the  initial  expense  necessary  to  introduce  another  policy ; 
in  other  words,  if  it  should  be  shown  to  be  desirable  to  have  12  inches 
of  ballast  under  your  track,  and  your  ties  all  put  in  at  one  time,  on 
given  stretches  of  track,  so  that  it  would  require  very  little  work  to 
be  done  for  five  or  six  years,  it  would  entail  necessarily  a  large  initial 
expense,  which  would  continue  until  the  entire  division  had  been  so 
overhauled.  After  that  time,  I  am  firmly  convinced  that  the  cost  of 
maintaining  the  track  would  be  very  much  less  than  it  is  under  the 
present   policy. 

Another  reason  why  this  habit  has  grown  up  is  because  of  the 
waste  of  the  remaining  life  in  cross-tie  that  would  come  out  under  this 
renewal  plan.  There  would  undoubtedly  be  ties  in  the  track  that  would 
last  at  least  two  years,  and  the  Roadmaster  would  come  along  and 
criticise  the  section  foreman  for  taking  it  out.  On  the  other  hand,  if 
that  tie  was  left  in  the  track,  in  order  to  secure  the  additional  length 
of  life,  which  would  probably  represent  30  cents  in  value  left  in  the 
tie,  I  believe  it  would  require  at  least  one  dollar  in  labor  to  keep  the 
track  in  condition  while  the  value  of  the  tie  was  being  extracted.  The 
labor  thus  expended  is  a  concealed  loss. 

I  realize  that"  this  problem  is  one  that  depends  on  a  good  many 
variable  conditions ;  among  them  are  the  life  and  price  of  ties,  cost  and 
efficiency  of  labor,  density  of  traffic,  depth  and  condition  of  ballast, 
condition  of  the  underlying  roadway  and  the  standard  of  excellence  to 
which  the  track  has  to  be  maintained.     I   have  endeavored  to  ascertain 


DISCUSSION.  957 

what  the  labor  costs  are  for  maintaining  the  track  in  accordance  with 
the  plan  recommended  by  the  Committee.  I  have  sought  from  our 
own  accounts  and  from  the  accounts  of  other  roads  to  find  it  out.  I 
have  found  an  utter  lack  of  uniformity  in  the  method  of  keeping  road- 
way labor  accounts,  and  it  is  simply  impossible  to  make  any  comparison 
between  the  present  method  and  any  other  method.  I  think  we  need 
a  much  closer  analysis  of  our  labor  costs  than  we  are  now  securing 
under  the  Interstate  Commerce  Commission  distribution  of  costs.  I 
think  it  would  be  well  for  our  Committee  on  Records  and  Accounts  to 
endeavor  to  formulate  some  standard  subdivision  of  roadway  and 
labor  costs  in  order  that'  we  may  arrive  at  some  definite  knowledge  by 
which   we  may   compare  these  things. 

For  the  past  eight  or  ten  years  one  of  our  Roadmasters  has  been 
very  diligent  in  observing  the  small  amount  of  labor  required  to  main- 
tain stretches  of  track  on  which  all  the  ties  had  been  renewed  at  one 
time  and  he  was  so  much  impressed  with  the  reduction  in  the  labor 
cost  of  subsequent  maintenance  of  these  stretches  that  he  received 
permission  to  try  one  experimental  mile.  That  was  put  in  in  1008,  and 
we  were  paying  40  cents  for  first-class  white  oak  ties.  The  track  was 
laid  with  80-lbs.  rails;  more  than  half  the  mile  consists  of  2-degree 
curves  running  in  opposite  directions,  with  450  feet  of  tangent  between 
them.  The  grades  are  slightly  undulating.  The  freight  traffic  amounts 
to  2,000,000  tons  per  annum,  and  there  are  ten  regular  passenger  trains 
per  day,  running  at  a  maximum  speed  of  75  miles.  The  heaviest  freight 
engines  weigh  346,000  lbs.,  with  a  maximum  axle  load  of  48,300.  The 
heaviest  passenger  engine  weighs  314,000  lbs.,  with  a  maximum  axle 
load  of  51,300  lbs.  There  was  9  inches  of  clean  ballast  under  the  track 
and  a  3-inch  additional   lift  was  given.     The  cost  was   as    follows: 

3,000  ties   at  40  cents $1,200.00 

1,263  cubic  yards  of  ballast  at  50  cents 631.50 

Labor  putting  in  ties  and  ballast  and  dressing  up 844.00 

Total,  per  mile   $2,675.50 

A  close  account  has  been  kept  of  the  cost  of  maintaining  this  mile 
of  track.  The  section  foreman  has  been  given  special  instructions  to 
report  each  month  the  amount  of  labor  expended  in  maintaining  this 
track  in  line  and  surface.  For  the  first  year  the  cost  was  $23;  second 
year,  $29.80;  third  year,  $35.20.  We  have  just  gone  through  the  winter 
of  the  fourth  year,  and  estimate  the  total  expense  will  be  $50;  the 
fifth  year  we  estimate  at  $75;  and  the  sixth  year,  $110;  in  other  words, 
we  do  not  expect  to  renew  any  of  the  cross-ties  in  that  mile  of  track 
inside  of  six  years.  This  view,  I  think,  is  concurred  in  by  a  committee 
of  engineers  from  an  eastern  road  who  visited  our  line.  The  cross- 
ties  are  all  of  first-class  white  oak.  The  average  of  the  above  figures 
for  the  cost  of  maintenance  of  the  track  per  annum  for  six  years  would 
be  $53-83- 


958  TIES. 

Assuming  that  this  track  would  run  six  years  without  any  serious 
overhauling,  one-sixth  of  the  initial  expense  to  put  it  in  would  be 
$445.83,  and  with  the  estimated  annual  expense  for  maintenance  $53.83 
would  give  an  average  cost  per  annum  per  mile  of  $499.66. 

We  do  not  know  how  this  compares  with  results  on  other  roads 
or  even  on  our  own  line.  We  hope,  however,  to  be  able  to  tell  you 
something  about  it  in  the  near  future.  Since  this  mile  was  put  up  the 
results  have  been  so  encouraging  that  we  are  now  carrying  out  the 
same  policies  on  45  miles  of  stone-ballasted  track  on  that  division. 

From  the  best  information  I  can  get  I  believe  the  cost  per  annum 
of  carrying  out  the  policy  recommended  by  the  Committee,  putting  the 
price  on  the  same  basis  as  I  have  stated  with  reference  to  this  experi- 
ment, would  be  about  as  follows : 

Ties     $154-44 

Labor    putting    in 77.22 

One  and  one-half  inches  of  ballast  every  two  years 118.50 

Labor  surfacing  and  applying  ballast 250.00 

Labor    of    maintaining 100.00 

Total     $700.16 

This,  as  you  see,  would  make  a  difference  of  about  $200  a  mile. 
Naturally,  we  assume  that  the  ballast  is  clean  to  start  with.  I  have 
taken  no  account  of  the  fact  that  at  the  end  of  the  first  six  years  the 
necessary  raising  of  the  ballast,  after  it  is  overhauled  again,  would  not 
require  as  much  as  three  inches,  and  the  annual  cost  would,  therefore, 
be  somewhat  reduced. 

We  lack  some  standard  method  of  comparing  the  excellence  of 
our  track.  We  can  send  a  dynagraph  car  over  the  track,  and  get 
some  idea  as  to  what  the  line  and  surface  condition  is,  but  if  we 
could  devise  some  simple  method  of  comparing  the  condition  of  the 
tracks  with  some  standard,  it  would  greatly  simplify  the  matter  of 
comparing  cost   of   maintenance. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse:— In  line  with  what  Mr.  McDonald  said,  I  will 
say  that  on  the  Santa  Fe  we  have  a  stretch  of  55  miles  of  what  we 
call  an  experimental  track.  Upon  22.5  miles  we  dug  the  track  out 
and  laid  the  ties  to  face,  as  Mr.  McDonald  suggested.  We  put  in  12 
inches  of  rock  ballast,  used  creosoted  ties,  3,200  to  the  mile,  90-lb.  rail, 
and  we  have  divided  up  our  sections,  so  as  to  have  them  divide  at 
either  end  of  this  22.5-mile  stretch,  with  an  idea  of  keeping  an  account 
of  the  cost  of  renewals  and  repairs  to  see  how  it  will  compare  with 
the  renewal  of  ties  individually.  It  has  rather  struck  everyone  that 
has  looked  at  it  that  it  may  turn  out  that  that  will  be  the  proper  way 
to  carry  on  renewals.  We  expect  to  get  at  least  ten  years  out  of 
these  creosoted  pine  ties.  On  the  basis  that  our  rail  has  to  be  renewed 
at  the  end  of  ten  years,  it  has  seemed  to  us  that  the  proper  way  to  carry 


DISCUSSION.  959 

on  the  renewal  of  ties  would  be  to  renew  the  ties  to   face  at  the  time 
you    renewed   your    rail. 

Mr.  W.  M.  Camp : — I  will  suggest  that  there  is  abundant  opportunity 
at  hand  with  almost  any  railway  engineer  to  determine  the  relative 
economy  of  the  method  of  renewing  ties  in  continuous  stretches,  with- 
out going  into  specially  conducted  experiments.  This  opportunity  may 
be  found  on  any  piece  of  new  track.  On  such  track,  after  the  roadbed 
and  ballast  have  become  consolidated,  there  is  an  interval  of  several 
years  during  which  no  tie  renewals  have  to  be  made ;  so  that  the  ex- 
pense of  maintaining  the  track  surface,  with  the  disturbing  element 
of  tie  renewals  eliminated,  can  be  ascertained.  This  average  yearly 
expense  should  be  taken  in  connection  with  the  proportional  yearly 
cost  of  renewing  all  of  the  ties  at  one  time,  as  soon  as  the  conditions 
may  warrant;  and  in  addition  the  expense  of  getting  the  track  into 
normal  surface  condition  and  the  ballast  into  the  normal  state  of  com- 
pactness, after  the  general  overhauling;  and  in  addition,  still,  the  waste 
of  timber  in  ties  thrown  out  that  would  do  for  further  service.  The 
average  annual  expense  of  these  various  items,  collectively,  can  then 
be  compared  with  the  usual  expense  of  maintaining  track  in  timber 
and  in  surface  where  the  ties  are  renewed  in  patches,  and  solely  with 
regard   to   their   condition,   individually,   as  to   decay. 

Mr.  W.  L.  Seddon  (Seaboard  Air  Line)  : — I  think  the  results 
mentioned  by  Mr.  McDonald  and  Mr.  Morse  are  predicated  on  a  much 
more  uniform  basis  than  the  average  railways  get,  and  it  seems  to 
me  that  their  conclusions  are  not  based  on  the  average  results  secured 
by  the  average  railway.  I  think  it  is  the  uniform  experience  that  when 
a  new  track  is  laid,  that  it  is  a  very  much  more  expensive  proposition 
to  keep  this  track  in  condition  by  renewing  all  the  ties  at  one  time 
than  it  would  be  to  replace  the  ties  one  at  a  time.  In  the  South, 
where  we  use  pine  ties  and  cypress  ties,  we  begin  to  take  out  some 
of  the  ties  from  the  track  four  years  after  the  track  is  laid,  while  some 
of  the  ties  remain  in  service  fifteen  years.  I  do  not  think  it  is  fair 
to  criticise  the  Committee's  results  by  comparing  what  they  propose 
with  track  laid  with  selected  ties  or  treated  ties.  I  think  the  Com- 
mittee's   conclusions    are    correct. 

(The  President  put  the  motion  on  the  adoption  of  the  conclusion, 
which  was  approved.) 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs: — The  third  and  last  subject  assigned  to  the 
Committee  was  "the  use  of  metal  composite  and  concrete  ties,"  and 
the  conclusions  are  given  on  page  370.  I  move  that  the  conclusion 
No.    1   be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — I  will  state  in  regard  to  the  second  conclusion 
that  the  Committee  has  not  gone  far  enough  in  its  investigations  to  .be 
able  to  report  anything  definite,  but  the  Committee  has  found  that  it 
promises  to  develop. 


960  TIES. 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  :— 
I   move  that  the  conclusion  be  accepted  as  information. 

(The   motion    was   carried.) 

Mr.  L.  A.  Downs : — I  move  that  conclusion  No.  3  be  accepted 
as  information. 

(The   motion   was   carried.) 

The  President : — The  Committee  has  furnished  us  with  some  very 
excellent  information,  giving  the  experience  of  the  railways  with  refer- 
ence to  different  kinds  of  ties.  It  is  extremely  valuable.  The  Com- 
mittee is   dismissed   with   the   thanks  of   the   Association. 

WRITTEN    DISCUSSION   ON   REPORT   OF  COMMITTEE  ON   TIES. 

Mr.  W.  C.  Cushing  (by  letter)  : — The  report  of  the  Committee  on 
Ties  is  always  looked  forward  to  by  the  members  of  the  Association  on 
account  of  its  interesting  statement  relative  to  the  progress  and  develop- 
ment in  the  use  of  concrete  and  metal  ties,  as  well  as  for  the  treatment 
of  the  other  subjects  embodied  in  it,  and  the  report  this  year  is  no  excep- 
tion to  the  rule.  Our  information  with  reference  to  the  concrete  and 
steel  ties  under  examination  from  time  to  time  has  been  brought  down  to 
date. 

The  relative  life  of  wcoden  and  iron  or  steel  cross-ties  is  a  subject 
of  much  speculation,  because  no  metal  ties  have  been  in  use  in  this  country 
for  a  sufficiently  long  period  to  enable  their  life  to  be  accurately  deter- 
mined, and  consequently  we  keep  looking  to  Europe,  and  especially  to 
Germany  and  Switzerland,  where  the  metal  tie  is  most  widely  used  in 
Europe,  for  information  of  that  nature. 

The  writer,  therefore,  submits  the  latest  note  on  the  subject,  taken 
from  the  Bulletin  of  the  International  Railway  Congress,  No.  2,  February, 
1912: 

"THE   LIFE   OF    WOODEN    AND   IRON    TRANSVERSE    SLEEPERS. 

By  Mr.  Cauer. 
(Zeitung  des  Vereins  deutscher  Eisenbahnverwaltungen.) 

"One  of  the  most  important  advances  made  in  technical  matters  is  the 
recognition  that  in  determining  the  value  of  any  technical  system,  one  of 
the  most  important  considerations  is  its  economy.  Naturally  we  strive 
for  perfection  in  our  designs.  But  even  the  most  ingenious  design  is  to 
be  condemned,  if  it  does  not  prove  economically  satisfactory;  there  is  no 
justification  for  taking  the  technical  point  of  view  alone  and  declaring  a 
design  satisfactory,  if  it  is  not  so  from  the  economic  point  of  view  as 
well.  Hence,  it  is  very  satisfactory  if  a  question  of  very  great  economic 
importance,  such  as  the  life  of  superstructure  materials  and  especially  of 
transverse  sleepers,  is  brought  nearer  to  solution,  as  has  been  done  by 
the  work  of  Mr.  Biedermann,  permanent  way  and  traffic  inspector  in  Ger- 
many. Short  particulars  of  his  first  paper  in  the  Organ  fur  die  Fort- 
schritte  des  Eisenbahnwesens  and  of  a  more  detailed  lecture  to  the 
Verein  fiir  Eisenbahnkunde  have  already  been  published  in  the  Zeitung 
des  Vereins  deutscher  Eisenbahnverwaltungen.  Considering  the  great 
importance  of  this  question,  we  give  a  more  detailed  account  of  Mr. 
Biedermann's  investigations  and  their  results,  as  described  in  the  lecture 
jn  question. 


DISCUSSION.  .  961 

"Mr.  Biedermann  takes  as  his  basis  that  the  superior  superstruc- 
ture is  that  which  for  an  equal  outlay  gives  the  greatest  advantages,  or 
that  for  which  a  greater  outlay  is  justified  economically  by  important 
technical  advantages.  In  this  connection  he  considers  more  especially 
the  question  of  what  are  the  most  advantageous  sleepers ;  as  regards  this 
point,  technical  opinion  varies  widely.  While  England,  France,  Belgium, 
Holland  and  Austria,  in  short  nearly  all  other  European  countries  except 
Switzerland,  and  also  the  United  States  of  America,  use  wooden  sleep- 
ers nearly  exclusively,  the  German  railways  have  very  extensively 
adopted  iron  sleepers.  But  the  different  railway  administrations  in  Ger- 
many are  also  not  unanimous  on  the  subject.  At  the  end  of  1909  about  31 
per  cent,  of  the  total  track  of  the  German  railways  was  laid  on  iron 
transverse  sleepers.  An  important  factor  as  regards  this  ratio  is  the 
system  of  the  Prussian-Hessian  State  Railway;  30.4  per  cent,  of  its 
track  was  on  iron  sleepers.  The  practice  of  the  other  State  railway  ad- 
ministrations in  this  respect  is  noteworthy.  While  Saxony,  Oldenburg  and 
Mecklenburg  have  no  iron  sleepers,  except  on  experimental  sections, 
Baden,  on  the  other  hand,  has  iron  sleepers  nearly  exclusively.  Bavaria, 
with  a  total  of  12,000  kilometers  (7,450  miles),  has  about  3,900  kilo- 
metres (2,420  miles)  laid  on  iron  sleepers,  and  Wurtemberg,  with  a  total 
3,500  kilometres  (2,175  miles),  has  nearly  1,800  kilometres  (1,120  miles)  on 
iron  sleepers,  that  is,  more  than  half.  On  the  other  hand,  Alsace-Lorraine, 
with  4,400  kilometers  (2,735  miles),  has  only  about  350  kilometers  (218 
miles)  on  iron  sleepers,,  or  8  per  cent.  It  is  specially  noteworthy  that 
Saxony,  a  busy  industrial  state  with  much  traffic,  follows  the  examples  of 
England  and  Belgium.  These  countries,  although  their  iron  works  and 
rolling  mills  are  highly  developed,  still  use  wooden  sleepers,  which  they 
cannot  obtain  from  their  own  forests,  while  Baden,  poor  in  iron  works,  but 
rich  in  forests,  has  since  1890  been  adopting  iron  sleepers  at  a  quicker  rate 
than  even  Prussia. 

"The  cost  of  procuring  iron  sleepers,  even  if  we  allow  for  the  higher 
value  of  the  wornout  sleepers,  is  materially  higher  than  that  of  wooden 
sleepers.  Thus,  for  instance,  according  to  Mr.  Biedermann,  the  price  of  a 
standard  iron  sleeper  on  the  Prussian-Hessian  State  Railway  was  6.55 
marks  ($1.64)  in  191 1,  while  that  of  a  standard  pine  sleeper,  pickled  with 
creosote,  was  4.20  marks  ($1.05).  The  iron  sleeper  must  accordingly 
present  great  advantages,  if  this  much  higher  expenditure  is  to  be  justi- 
fied. 

"Mr.  Biedermann  is  now  of  opinion  that  in  this  respect  the  compara- 
tive life  of  two  different  sleepers  is  a  criterium  of  their  technical  value. 
The  life,  he  states,  registers  'automatically  and  conscientiously  the  tech- 
nical advantages  and  disadvantages  together  with  the  quality  coefficients 
which  are  to  be  used  in  a  technical  and  also  economical  comparison.  They 
represent  a  summary  of  the  incommensurable  alleged  or  real  technical 
advantages  and  disadvantages.' 

"These  assertions  go  somewhat  too  far.  Thus  the  more  or  less  easy 
or  difficult  maintenance  of  the  gage  and  alinement  of  the  track  is  of  con- 
siderable importance  in  determining  the  technical  value  of  a  system  of 
sleepers  not  only  because  this  maintenance  costs  more  or  less,  but  also 
because  a  track  which  is  easy  to  maintain  is  on  the  average  in  better  con- 
dition for  the  traffic.  Moreover,  there  are  other  considerations,  such  as 
the  nature  of  the  ballast,  which  depends  on  the  kind  of  sleepers  used,  the 
greater  or  lesser  stability  of  the  track  when  a  train  passes,  the  suitabil- 
ity for  switches,  the  greater  or  lesser  difficulty  of  using  the  sleepers  again 
when  alterations  are  made,  etc. ;  all  of  these  are  of  importance  when  con- 
sidering the  merits  of  the  system,  and  they  find  no  expression  in  a  mere 
statement  as  to  the  life.  But  subject  to  these  limitations,  we  are  able  to 
agree  with  Mr.  Biedermann  to  this  extent,  that  the  life  of  the  sleeper  is  the 


962  TIES. 

most  important  factor  in  determining  whether  the  higher  price  of  a  system 
of  sleepers  is  justifiable,  but  it  will  also  be  necessary  to  consider  the  cost  of 
bajlasting  and  of  maintenance. 

"Mr.  Biedermann  next  sets  forth  that  it  is  not  a  question  of  the  life 
of  a  few  specially  favorable  cases,  but  of  the  mean  life  of  a  given  system, 
and  that  we  have  hitherto  had  no  information  about  this  point.  While 
the  limits  of  the  mean  life  of  wooden  sleepers  have  been  gradually  de- 
termined by  observations  made  during  the  last  seventy  years  in  countries 
in  which  there  are  railways,  we  have  to  depend,  as  regards  the  length  of 
life  of  iron  sleepers,  on  a  few  isolated  observations,  or  even  on  esti- 
mates. Thus  railway  engineers  have  made  estimates  of  the  life  of  iron 
sleepers  varying  between  fifteen  and  fifty  years. 

"As  against  this  Mr.  Biedermann  emphasizes  that  reliable  figures  can 
only  be  obtained  if  a  considerable  length  of  track  laid  uniformly  with 
sleepers  of  one  kind  is  kept  under  observation  during  a  longer  period  of 
years,  and  if  the  ratio  is  determined  of  the  yearly  replacement  of  sleep- 
ers (reckoned  as  length  of  track)  to  the  total  length  of  the  railway  net- 
work in  question.  For  this  purpose,  Mr.  Biedermann  has  devised  a 
graphic  method,  which  he  then  applies  to  the  figures  concerning  the  lay- 
ing and  the  maintenance  of  sleepers,  published  in  the  statistics  of  the  Ger- 
man Reichseisenbahnamt.  In  his  calculations  he  uses,  not  the  number  of 
the  sleepers,  but  the  length  of  track  equipped  with  the  sleepers  in  question. 

"This  graphic  method,  which  the  lecturer  explained  in  detail  with  the 
help  of  lantern  slides,  can  only  be  briefly  described  here.  As  a  basis  the 
simplified  assumption  is  made  that  the  track  in  question  laid  on  uniform 
sleepers  has  only  been  renewed  once  in  course  of  maintenance.  Laying 
the  sleepers  and  maintenance  are  represented  by  two  curves  whose  ab- 
scissae represent  the  time  since  the  sleepers,  in  question  were  laid  or  main- 
tenance began ;  while  the  ordinates  represent  the  total  sleepers  used  up  to 
the  time  in  question;  in  the  case  of  the  laying  curve,  the  sleepers 
originally  laid;  in  the  case  of  the  maintenance  curve,  the  sleepers 
aised  for  maintenance.  The  ordinate  of  the  maintenance  curve  is  always 
smaller  than  the  ordinate  of  the  laying  curve  for  the  same  year,  because 
the  sleepers  laid  during  late  years  have  not  arrived  at  the  period  of  regu- 
lar renewal.  If  we  consider  a  period  of  time  from  the  point  of  view  of 
the  sleepers  renewed  in  it,  then  the  last  ordinate  of  the  maintenance  curve, 
which  represents  the  sum  of  all  the  renewals  made  during  the  period  in 
question,  corresponds  to  an  equal  ordinate  of  the  laying  curve,  a  number 
of  years  ago,  which  represents  the  sum  of  the  sleepers  laid  up  to  the 
period  in  question.  In  this  the  assumption  is  made  that  the  renewal  has 
extended  exactly  over  the  period  the  laying  curve  covers  up  to  the  ordi- 
nate in  question.  The  mean  center  of  the  part  of  the  laying  curve  extend- 
ing thereto  represents  the  mean  time  of  laying  all  the  sleepers ;  the  mean 
center  of  the  whole  maintenance  curve  (up  to  the  last  ordinate)  the  mean 
time  of  the  renewals.  Accordingly  the  horizontal  distance  between  these 
two  mean  centers  represents  the  mean  life  of  the  sleepers  which  have  been 
replaced.  In  the  case  of  the  older  tracks,  sleepers  were  replaced  two 
or  more  times ;  in  these  cases  the  method  is  supplemented  by  another 
method,  allowing  for  this  repeated  replacement,  and  there  is  also 
a  furthr  supplementary  method.  In  addition,  special  attention  has  to  be 
paid  to  the  switch  sleepers,  and  corrections  or  subsidiary  calculations  are 
necessary  when  wooden  sleepers  have  been  replaced  by  iron  sleepers  or 
vice  versa,  when  the  system  of  iron  longitudinal  sleepers  was  adopted  and 
when  it  was  abolished,  finally,  also,  in  order  to  allow  for  the  constantly 
varying  number  of  sleepers  used  per  unit  length  of  track. 

"The  lecturer  then  applied  his  method  in  order  to  determine  the 
mean  life  of  the  wooden  and  iron  transverse  sleepers  used  on  the  Prus- 
sian-Hessian   State   Railway.     He   found  that   the  mean   life   of  wooden 


DISCUSSION.  963 

sleepers  differed  but  slightly  from  that  of  iron  sleepers,  in  fact,  it  was 
slightly  lower  in  the  case  of  iron  sleepers.  In  both  cases  it  varied  be- 
tween about  15  and  20  years.  Similar  results  were  obtained  when  this 
method  was  applied  to  the  iron  sleepers  of  the  Baden  State  Railway. 

"Mr.  Biedermann  himself  remarks  that  these  results  are  to  be  inter- 
preted with  caution.  The  wooden  sleepers  renewed  include  oak  and 
beechwood  sleepers,  formerly  used  in  greater  quantities  ;  moreover  the  time 
covers  the  older  years  before  the  increasing  traffic  made  the  many  im- 
portant improvements  since  adopted  necessary,  such  as  the  newer  systems 
of  pickling,  the  use  of  treenails,  reducing  the  spaces  between  sleepers, 
using  longer  sleepers,  fastening  the  rails  more  securely,  etc.  But  accord- 
ing to  Mr.  Biedermann  the  figure  determined  by  him  for  the  life  of 
wooden  sleepers  is  especially  lowered  by  the  fact  that  he  treats  all  the  lines 
taken  over  by  the  Prussian  State  Railway  as  newly  laid  lines,  whereas 
in  reality  the  sleepers  of  these  lines  were  already  in  part  considerably 
worn.  On  the  other  hand  the  life  determined  for  the  iron  sleepers,  which 
in  some  cases  is  less  than  15  years,  is  too  low,  for  all  the  sleepers  are  in- 
cluded which  were  used  in  the  early  years  of  experiment;  now  it  is  only 
comparatively  recently  that  the  present  heavy  and  good  shapes  are  used 
while,  as  in  the  case  of  wooden  sleepers,  the  number  of  sleepers  per  rail 
length  is  increased,  and  the  quality  of  the  ballast  is  also  continually  being 
improved.  Taking  everything  into  consideration,  Mr.  Biedermann  draws 
the  conclusion  that  the  present  creosoted  pinewood  sleeper,  when  hard 
broken  stone  is  used  as  ballast,  will  have  a  life  of  18  to  20  years,  and 
that  the  life  of  iron  sleepers  will  hardly  exceed  this.  On  the  other 
hand,  the  new  iron  ribbed  sleeper  should  have  a  life  of  34  years,  taking 
into  consideration  its  higher  price,  and  the  more  expensive  fastenings  and 
ballast  required,  if  it  is  to  be  economically  equal  to  a  wooden  sleeper  hav- 
ing a  life  even  of  only  15  years.  According  to  M'r.  Biedermann,  this  de- 
cides the  economic  contest  in  favor  of  the  creosoted  pinewood  sleeper. 

"Mr.  Biedermann's  statements  met  with  much  approval ;  in  opposition 
to  them,  one  speaker  specially  emphasized  that  it  was  only  comparatively 
recently  that  the  original  shape  of  the  iron  sleepers,  which  proved  un- 
satisfactory, was  altered  and  more  suitable  designs  were  introduced,  so 
that  the  life  determined  by  the  lecturer  was  much  too  short,  and  that 
the  question  of  the  economy  therefore  still  remained  an  open  one.  The 
following  criticisms  of  Mr.  Biedermann's  researches  may  also  be  brought 
forward. 

"In  the  first  place,  what  he  only  incidentally  remarks  must  be  em- 
phasized, that  his  graphic  method  only  gives  the  mean  life  of  the  sleepers 
which  have  actually  been  taken  out  and  renewed,  not  that  of  all  the 
sleepers  laid.  Hence,  particularly  in  the  case  of  lines  where  the  sleepers 
have  not  yet  attained  the  longest  age  or  even  the  average  age  of  the  kind  in 
question,  it  gives  too  low  figures  for  the  mean  life,  for  the  sleepers  which 
are  renewed  do  not  include  just  those  which  have  the  longest  life.  On  old 
lines  this  error  it  is  true  becomes  reduced  to  a  minimum,  but  it  always 
remains,  so  that  it  may  be  said  that  the  Biedermann  method  always  gives 
too  low  values  for  the  life,  which  in  the  case  of  old  lines  approach  the 
true  values  asymptotically.  Now  this  fact  must  affect  and  have  an  un- 
favorable effect,  as  regards  iron  sleepers,  on  the  results  of  Mr.  Bieder- 
mann's investigations,  for  the  newer  designs  of  these  sleepers  have  not 
yet  been  in  use  during  the  period  of  time  which  may  be  estimated  to 
represent  their  average  life,  and  accordingly  there  are  probably  still  many 
of  them  having  a  long  life  which  do  not  at  all  appear  in  the  calcula- 
tions. On  the  other  hand,  Mr.  Biedermann  does  not  take  into  consider- 
ation the  cost  of  maintenance,  which  is  greater,  particularly  the  first  few 
years,  with  iron  sleepers  than  with  wooden  sleepers,  and  accordingly  is 
unfavorable  to  iron  sleepers  in  making  an  economic  comparison.     It  must 


964  TIES. 

also  be  taken  into  consideration  that  during  alterations  wooden  sleepers 
frequently  become  useless  which  otherwise  could  still  have  remained  in 
use  for  a  much  longer  number  of  years,  while  iron  sleepers  do  not  show 
this  disadvantage.  It  remains  doubtful  what  influence  the  rebuilding  of 
stations  has  from  this  point  of  view  exercised  on  the  life  of  the  iron  and 
wooden  sleepers  as  determined. 

"Finally,  the  statistics  utilized  by  Mr.  Biedermann  give  no  informa- 
tion about  the  reasons  why  the  wooden  and  iron  sleepers  were  renewed. 
Wooden  sleepers  are,  as  a  rule,  finally  taken  out,  also  in  the  case  of  sid- 
ings, if  they  have  become  so  damaged  by  the  traffic  and  by  the  repeated 
fixing  of  the  rails  that  the  screws  no  longer  hold.  The  question  then 
arises  in  the  case  of  iron  sleepers,  to  what  extent  the  reason  for  renewal 
was  their  becoming  damaged  in  a  similar  way,  to  such  an  extent  that  they 
became  useless,  and  to  what  extent  other  causes  were  operative,  which 
could  be  removed  or  ameliorated  by  increasing  the  weight  of  the  sleepers, 
or  improving  their  shape  or  the  fastenings. 

"But  even  if  we  assume  that  the  life  of  iron  sleepers  as  compared  with 
that  of  wooden  sleepers  should  prove  on  careful  investigation  (which 
would  involve  sundry  other  points  which  it  would  take  too  long  to  dis- 
cuss here)  to  be  considerably  more  favorable  than  as  determined  by  Mr. 
Biedermann,  yet  the  difference  as  calculated  by  him  is  so  great  that  in 
comparing  the  two  kinds  of  sleepers,  the  scale  seems  to  turn  strongly  in 
favor  of  wooden  sleepers.  Hence,  it  would  be  very  desirable  that  the 
administrations  using  iron  sleeners  on  the  large  scale  should  give  par- 
ticulars of  their  experience,  which  would  probably  elucidate  the  reasons 
why  the  sleepers  were  renewed  and  show  what  final  conclusions  can  be 
drawn  so  as  to  settle  the  problem  of  the  sleepers." 


DISCUSSION  ON  TRACK. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.   371-386.) 
LIST  OF   SPEAKERS   TAKING  PART  IN   DISCUSSION   ON   TRACK. 

F.  J.  Bachelder.  C.  H.  Ewing.  C.  A.  Morse. 

J.  B.  Berry.  L.  C.  Fritch.  H.  T.  Porter. 

Geo.  H.  Bremner.  J.  B.  Jenkins.  L.  S.  Rose. 

W.  M.  Camp.  George  W.  Kittredge.  J.  A.  Spielmann. 

J.  L.  Campbell.  C.  E.  Lindsay. 

The  President :— The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Track, 
of  which  Mr.  J.  B.  Jenkins  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Jenkins  will  make  the  pre- 
liminary statement  for  the  Committee. 

(Mr.  Jenkins  read  the  preliminary  statement  of  the  report,  and 
said:) 

Mr.  J.  B.  Jenkins  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  :— Your  Committee  has  re- 
vised the  plans  for  Nos.  8,  n  and  16  Rigid  Frogs,  No.  n  Spring  Frog 
and  for  n-ft.,  i6J/2-it,  22-ft,  and  33-ft.  switches  and  submits  them  for 
adoption  as  general  plans  representing  good  practice. 

Your  Committee  has  also  revised  and  combined  the  "General  Speci- 
fications for  Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches,"  adopted  by  the  convention  of 
1910,  and  the  "General  Instructions  for  Ordering  or  Contracting  for  Frogs, 
Crossings  and  Switches,"  submitted  to  the  convention  of  191 1  and  received 
as  information,  and  submits  them  for  adoption  as  representing  good 
practice. 

At  the  convention  of  1909,  the  Association  instructed  the  Track  Com- 
mittee to  recommend  three  standard  lengths  of  switches  and  three  stand- 
ard numbers  of  frogs ;  such  a  recommendation  was  made,  with  the  modifi- 
cation that  a  fourth  length  of  switch  was  added  for  special  cases  requir- 
ing frogs  of  large  angle ;  the  recommendation  was  embodied  in  Conclusion 
(4)  of  your  Committee's  report,  which  was  adopted  by  the  convention  of 
1910,  but  was  referred  back  to  the  Committee  by  the  Board  of  Direction 
for  reconsideration. 

Your  Committee  reconsidered  and  reaffirmed  its  former  action;  the 
conclusion  was  not  resubmitted,  however,  excepting  as  the  proposed  lengths 
of  switches  and  numbers  of  frogs  were  embodied  in  the  "General  In- 
structions for  Ordering  or  Contracting  for  Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches." 
which  was  received  only  as  information  by  the  Association  at  the  con- 
vention of  191 1. 

In  determining  the  lengths  of  switches  your  Committee  considered  it 
necessary  to  provide   for  the   following  general   classes   of  turnouts: 

(a)  Turnouts  to  be  operated  over  the  divergent  route  at  the  maxi- 
mum practicable  limited  speed. 

965 


966  TRACK. 

(b)  Main  line  turnouts  and  crossovers  to  be  operated  over  the  di- 
vergent route  at  low  speed. 

(c)  Yard  turnouts. 

(d)  Turnouts  requiring  frogs  of  large  angle. 

With  regard  to  the  second  and  third  subjects  assigned  to  the  Commit- 
tee, the  Committee  has  been  studying  the  question  of  track  fastenings 
and  has  made  good  progress,  but  has  nothing  as  yet  to  report. 

In  regard  to  the  third  subject,  "Study  Designs  for  Main  Line  Turn- 
outs," we  considered  it  necessary  to  hold  that  subject  in  abeyance  pend- 
ing the  adoption  of  three  standard  numbers  of  frogs  and  three  standard 
lengths  of  switches,  provided  it  is  the  wish  of  the  Association  to  adopt 
such  standards.  If  the  Association  wishes  to  adopt  a  greater  number  of 
standards,  the  Committee  will  prepare  designs  in  conformity  with  those 
standards,   and  then  the  range  of  our  study  will  be  much   larger. 

On  the  first  subject  we  originally  submitted  the  plans  for  frogs 
and  switches  as  a  part  of  the  specifications,  but  there  has  been  some  ob- 
jection on  the  part  of  some  members  of  the  Association  on  account  of 
the  plans  being  in  too  great  detail,  and  on  the  part  of  others  because  they 
are  not  in  sufficient  detail.  Part  of  the  Association  considered  that  the 
plans  should  not  be  a  part  of  the  specifications,  another  part,  apparently, 
thought  the  specifications  should  be  accompanied  by  complete  and  detailed 
plans.  The  Committee,  at  the  last  convention,  submitted  plans  for  these 
frogs  and  switches,  which  we  have  subsequently  gone  over  carefully 
and  revised ;  we  also  revised  and  combined  the  "General  Specifications  for 
Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches,"  which  were  adopted  in  1910  with  the 
"General  Instructions  for  Ordering  or  Contracting  for  Frogs,  Crossings 
and  Switches,"  which  were  submitted  in  191 1,  and  received  only  as  in- 
formation ;  we  now  wish  to  submit  them  for  adoption.  We  wish  to  sub- 
mit the  specifications   and  the  plans   separately. 

At  the  request  of  the  President,  the  Committee  will  ask  action  on 
conclusion  No.  2,  that  the  plans  of  No.  8,  No.  11  and  No.  16  rigid  frogs, 
No.  11  spring  frog  and  11  ft.,  \6l/2  ft..  22  ft.,  and  33  ft.  switches  be 
adopted  as  general  plans  representing  good  practice.  We  ask  action  on 
this  under  Rule  16-g.  The  adoption  of  these  plans  has  no  bearing  on 
conclusion  No.  3,  which  recommends  these  frog  numbers  and  lengths  of 
switches.  The  adoption  of  conclusion  No.  2  only  carries  with  it  the  rec- 
ommendation of  these  plans  for  these  frog  numbers  and  lengths  of 
switches.  The  plans,  it  may  be  stated,  are  general  plans,  principally  for 
dimensions.  I  move  that  conclusion  No.  2  be  adopted  with  recom- 
mendation to  publish  in  the  Manual. 

(The  motion  was  seconded  and  carried.) 

The  President : — It  is  open  for  discussion. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell  (El  Paso  Southwestern)  :— Referring  to  the  plans 
for  the  33-ft.  switch  on  page  385,  as  a  matter  of  information,  I  would 
like  to  ask  if  the  Committee  came  to  any  conclusion  in  relation  to  the 
joints  in  the  main  line  rails.  As  far  as  I  see,  this  plan  does  not  show 
the  location  of  any  of  the  joints;  and  also  whether  or  not  the  Commit- 


DISCUSSION.  967 

tee  has  considered  special  rail  lengths  for  these  turnouts.  How  does  the 
Committee  propose  to  handle  turnouts  in  case  the  proper  length  does  not 
make  up  commercial  lengths  of  rails?  Where  would  the  Committee  put 
the  joints  in  the  main  line  for  this  switch? 

Mr.  Jenkins : — -The  Committee  has  considered  both  questions  raised. 
In  regard  to  the  joint  for  the  33-ft.  switch,  we  consider  that  the  best 
practice  would  be  to  use  a  60-ft.  stock  rail. 

The    President: — Any   additional    remarks    on   this    motion? 

Mr.  Jenkins : — The  plans  for  the  switches  are  general  plans  and  are 
the  ones  the  Committee  had  in  mind  in  drawing  up  the  specifications,  al- 
though we  wish  to  detach  them  from  the  specifications.  The  specifica- 
tions say,  "Heel  blocks  shall  be  of  approved  design,  with  standard  rail 
drilling."  The  plan  itself  says  :  "Filler  of  approved  design."  We  could 
not  indicate  more  than  one  form  of  heel  block  on  the  plan,  so  we  only 
indicated  the  one  shown. 

Mr.  J.  A.  Spielmann  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — Mr.  President,  on  page 
381,  first  paragraph,  .five  inches  is  recommended  for  throw  of  switch.  I 
would  like  very  much  to  know  how  the  Committee  arrived  at  this  conclu- 
sion. I  think  five  inches  is  more  than  necessary  and  that  4l/2  inches  is 
quite  sufficient. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — There  is  sometimes  a  little  drag  in  the  switch  point 
in  throwing  the  switch,  especially  with  the  longer  switches ;  this  inter- 
feres somewhat  with  the  fiangeway,  and  with  some  of  the  heavier  sec- 
tions with  the  broader  head,  4^  inches  does  not  seem  to  be  quite  suffi- 
cient and  slA  seems  to  be  preferable.  In  other  words,  the  switch  rail 
does  not  always  take  the  same  curve  when  the  switch  is  thrown  and  does 
not  always  leave  the  same  distance  between  the  stock  rail  and  the  back  of 
the   switch. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — The  draw- 
ings on  pp.  382,  383,  384,  385,  all  have  relation  to  the  drawing  Fig.  2, 
page  382,  and  you  will  note  that  the  first  pair  of  holes,  5  inches  apart, 
are  1J/2  inches  from  the  point.  That,  I  believe,  is  done  at  the  behest  of 
some  of  our  signal  friends  who  desired  to  put  on  a  modern  type  of  front 
rod  for  the  locking  apparatus  at  interlocking,  and  that  requires  alternate 
spacing  of  ties.  If  it  is  safe  to  allow  the  switch  point  to  project  (as  it 
will  for  the  use  of  the  head  rod  of  that  type  in  those  holes)  over  a  foot 
beyond  the  first  rod,  it  would  be  better,  it  seems  to  me,  to  adopt  the  alter- 
nate spacing  of  ties  shown  here,  rather  than  the  primal  one,  because  it 
would  be  safe  to  fasten  a  head  rod  at  these  first  pair  of  holes  and  between 
the  ties.  I  do  not  consider  the  alternate  spacing  of  the  ties  shown  on 
the  plans  as  necessary  in  any  way  whatever,  and  it  is  objectionable  be- 
cause it  necessitates  a  change  in  these  ties  when  changing  from  a  hand- 
thrown  switch  to  an  interlocked  one.  The  plates  on  the  first  two  ties 
are  also  unnecessarily  long. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — We  do  not  think  that  all  roads  would  want  the  first 
spacing  of  ties  shown,  but  some  of  them  would  prefer  the  alternate  spac- 
ing,  so   we   have   shown  both  of  them  qn  the  plans   for   that   reason.     If 


968  TRACK. 

any  road  desires  lo  use  the  first  spacing  for  interloeKed  switches  and 
considers  that  the  hest  practice,  there  is  no  reason  why  they  should  not 
follow  that  spacing  throughout. 

The  President: — If  there  are  no  further  remarks,  the  motion  will  be 
put  on  the  adoption  of  this  resolution  to  go  in  the  Manual. 

(A  vive  voce  vote  not  being  definite,  a  rising  vote  was  then  taken, 
as  follows :  In  the  affirmative,  23 ;  opposed,  13,  which  caused  hearty 
laughter.) 

Mr.  Jenkins : — The  Committee  asks  consideration  of  the  third  con- 
clusion. This  recommendation  was  made  with  full  knowledge  of  the 
consequences.  We  were  asked  by  the  Board  of  Direction,  or  rather  by 
the  Association  itself,  to  recommend  three  frogs  and  three  lengths  of 
switches.  We  thought  it  necessary  to  include  the  fourth  length  of  switch 
for  industrial  sidings  and  other  short  turnouts,  where  such  turnouts  are 
required.  In  recommending  these  three  lengths  of  switches,  with  one  ad- 
ditional length  for  special  cases,  we  took  the  33-ftl  rail  as  a  basis  and 
took  such  fractional  parts  of  that  length  as  to  cut  the  rail  economically, 
making  the  lengths  33,  22,  i6l/2  and  1 1  feet.  Our  principal  reason  for 
doing  this  is  that  we  want  the  very  best  rail  for  the  longest  turnout,  and 
we  can  probably  get  the  best  rail  by  using  a  33-ft.  length.  We  will  prob- 
ably also  want  to  specify  that  this  rail  shall  come  from  a  certain  part  of 
the  ingot.  As  to  the  frogs,  we  are  perfectly  aware,  in  recommending 
No.  u's,  that  there  are  very  few  of  them  in  use  at  the  present  time  and 
that  more  roads  use  No.  10  than  any  other  number  of  frog ;  but  if  we 
adopt  a  No.  8  for  yards  and  No.  10  for  main  line  turnouts,  that  only 
leaves  us  one  other  turnout  to  use  for  both  the  low  and  the  highest  re- 
stricted speed,  and  while  the  No.  11,  with  the  22-ft.  switch  point,  will 
answer  for  the  low-speed  turnout  controlled  by  interlocking  just  about 
as  well  as  the  No.  12,  while  the  No.  16  will  answer  fairly  well  for  the 
highest  restricted  speed,  because  the  deflection  of  an  engine  through  the 
lead  of  No.  16  is  about  the  same  as  that  through  the  33-ft.  switch  point. 
So  the  No.  11,  if  we  are  confined  to  three  numbers,  will  answer  the  pur- 
pose of  the  present  No.  10  and  12,  while  the  No.  16  will  answer  the 
purpose  of  the  14,  15,  16,  18  and  possibly  the  20.  As  to  the  No.  8's :  I 
think  the  present  practice  for  yard  turnouts  is  tending  very  strongly  to- 
wards No.  8,  so  that  our  recommendation  in  that  regard  is  not  at  vari- 
ance with  practice.  Another  reason  for  the  No.  11  is  that  if  we  adopt  a 
standard  for  general  use,  we  want  to  take  that  number  of  frog  which  will 
give  the  most  economical  use  of  the  rails,  and  if  you  will  refer  to  the 
table  of  practical  leads  in  the  Manual,  you  will  find  that  a  No.  11  is  best 
suited  for  that  purpose. 

Our  Committee  would  like  definite  action  on  this,  either  adoption,  or 
rejection  with  further  instructions,  because  our  study  of  main  line  turn- 
outs depends  on  your  action  on  this  conclusion.  If  the  Association  thinks 
that  three  numbers  of  frogs  are  not  sufficient,  we  will  very  gladly  take  up  a 
recommendation  for  a  greater  number ;  but  the  Committee  itself  feels  that 
these  three  frogs  are  sufficient.     Of  course,  every  railway  which  uses  No. 


DISCUSSION.  969 

io's  would  not  want  to  tear  out  all  the  No.  io's  and  put  in  No.  irs;  but 
there  is  no  necessity  for  doing  so.  When  new  work  is  laid  out  it  can 
be  done  with  No.  n's  and  eventually  the  railways  will  come  to  these 
three  standards,  which  will  be  economical  standards.  I  move  the  adop- 
tion of  conclusion  3,  and  that  the  recommendation  be  published  in  the 
Manual. 

(The  motion  was   seconded.) 

The   President:- — The   subject  is   now   open   for   discussion. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — Mr.  Chairman,  the 
Chairman  of  the  Committee  has  given  me  a  suggestion  in  his  remarks  that 
might  make  that  conclusion  acceptable,  that  in  all  new  work,  the  length 
and  the  switches,  the  numbers  of  frogs  recommended  by  the  Committee 
be  adopted. 

The  President: — New  work  and  renewals? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — No,  not  as  broad  as  renewals — in  all  new  work. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — The  recommendation  of  the  Committee  itself  is  that 
all  new  work  should  be  laid  out,  so  far  as  practicable,  with  these  three 
frogs,  so  as  to  effect  the  gradual  elimination  of  frogs  of  other  numbers, 
lessen  the  cost  of  manufacture  and  decrease  the  amount  of  stock  carried. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — Then  I  move  it  be  included  in  No.  3. 

The  President: — There  is  no  objection  to  putting  those  words  in  the 
conclusion. 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge   (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  ***;>., 
I  am  not  altogether  satisfied  with  the  reasons  given  why  we  should  go 
from  No.  10  to  No.  11.    I  know  a  great  many  roads  that  use  No.  10  quite 
generally,  and  it  was  only  a  few  years  ago  that  a  No.  10  frog  was  consid- 
ered  one   of   the   maximum   numbers   to  be   used   in   any   location. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — It  is  in  the  lead  that  we  use  the  rail  to  better  advan- 
tage. We  have  a  33-ft.  rail  and  practically  no  cutting,  with  the  No.  11 
frog  and  a  22-ft.  switch  point.  Take  the  No.  10  frog;  for  the  best  re- 
sults we  ought  to  have  a  slightly  shorter  switch  point,  somewhere  around 
20  ft.  Of  course  there  is  not  very  much  difference  practically,  but  a 
No.  11  frog  with  a  22-ft.  switch  point  would  give  a  little  better  turn- 
out than  a  No.  10,  and  will  give  but  little  sharper  turnout  than  a  No. 
12,  which  is  now  very  generally  used  for  low-speed  turnouts  which  are 
controlled  by  interlocking. 

Mr.  C.  A.  Morse  (Santa  Fe)  : — I  favor  the  motion,  for  the  reason 
that  I  think  if  we  are  going  to  work  plans  out,  as  the  Chairman  says, 
and  get  results  in  regard  to  our  frogs  and  switches,  that  we  will  have 
to  come  to  some  standard.  On  our  road  we  have  been  through 
the  agony  of  changing  standards.  We  could  not  wait  for  the  Associa- 
tion and  we  adopted  8,  10  and  14.  I  think  8,  11  and  16  are  all  right. 
In  regard  to  Mr.  Fritch's  proposition  to  add  to  that  a  new  frog,  I  do 
not  believe  any  road  that  has  adopted  a  set  of  standards  is  going  to 
change  them  to  go  with  this,  but  there  are  a  good  many  roads,  I  pre- 
sume, that  are  about  up  to  the  point  where  they  will  have  to  change 
their  standards,   the   same  as   we  were  a   few  years  ago  when  we  were 


970  TRACK. 

using  6!/2  and  9.  We  finally  adopted  8,  10  and  14.  I  favor  the  recom- 
mendation. 

Mr.  W.  M.  Camp  (Railway  and  Engineering  Review)  : — 'What  degree 
of  turnout  curve  results  from  the  combination  of  a  No.  11  frog  and  a 
i6l/2-it.    switch   point? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — I  want  to  offer  the  suggestion  that  conclusion  3 
be  subdivided  into  two  parts,  one  governing  recommendation  in  regard 
to  length  of  switches,  and  one  in  regard  to  number  of  frogs.  It  is  pos- 
sible that  some  can  agree  on  the  number  of  frogs,  who  would  not  agree 
on  the  switches,  and  vice  versa. 

The  President: — There  is  no  objection  to  that;  so  the  motion  will 
be  revised  to  include  frogs  only.  The  Association  will  consider  that  the 
motion  is  revised  so  as  to  include  frogs  only  at  the  present  time. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell : — In  that  connection  I  wish  to  suggest  that  it 
probably  would  be  of  interest  to  a  great  many  members  of  the  Asso- 
ciation to  hear  from  the  engineers  who  have  adopted  and  use  a  33-ft. 
switch  rail. 

The    President : — We   will   wait   until   we    come   to   that   part. 

Mr.  Kittredge: — We  have  already  adopted  the  plans  for  Nos.  8,  11  and 
16  frogs.  It  might  be  a  little  inconsistent  if  we  voted  any  other  way  than 
to  adopt  the  frogs. 

The  President: — We  are  not  adopting  the  numbers  in  adopting  the 
plan. 

Mr.  Jenkins: — The  No.  11  frog,  with  22-ft.  switch  point,  takes  four 
33-ft.  rails  for  the  lead  curve,  one  of  which  is  cut  to  32.85  or  i^  inches 
cut  off  of  one  of  the  four  rails. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — Is  Fig.  2  adopted  by  our  adoption  of  conclusion  No.  2? 

Mr.  Jenkins : — It  was  not  so  intended.  Figs.  1  and  2  are  a  part  of  the 
specifications. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Jenkins : — I  move  that  the  Committee's  recommendation  in  re- 
gard to  lengths  of  switches  be  adopted,  with  recommendation  to  publish 
in  the  Manual. 

(The  motion  was  seconded  and  carried.) 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — I  move  to  amend  the  recommendation  by  specify- 
ing the  switches  11  ft.,  i6y2  and  26  ft. 

(The  motion  was  seconded.) 

Mr.  Jenkins : — It  is  the  opinion  of  the  Committee  that  26  ft.  does 
not  give  quite  a  small  enough  angle  for  the  highest  restricted  speed  for 
junctions;  that  we  should  use  as  long  a  switch  point  as  possible,  and 
that  in  addition  we  want  to  use  the  full  length  of  rail  in  order  to  have 
every  possible  assurance  of  getting  the  very  best  rail  for  that  switch 
point.     I   would  like  to  hear  from  Mr.   Porter  on  that  subject. 

Mr.  H.  T.  Porter  (Bessemer  &  Lake  Erie)  : — Several  years  ago,  when 
the  matter  was  brought  before  the  Committee,  they  came  to  the  conclu- 
sion that  for  high-speed  crossovers  and  turnouts,  it  was  desirable  to  have 
as  long  a  switch  point  as  practicable,  under  the  conditions  that  we  were 


DISCUSSION.  971 

working  with.  After  conferring  with  the  railmakers  of  this  country  we 
found  that  93  or  94  per  cent,  of  the  rail  which  they  sent  out  was  to  a 
standard  of  33-ft.  lengths.  Now  I  suppose  it  is  not  necessary  at  all  to  tell 
anyone  who  has  had  any  experience  with  switches  that  if  we  could  get 
a  switch  point  100  per  cent,  better  than  anything  we  ever  saw,  it  would 
be  a  very  desirable  thing.  Therefore,  we  felt  that  we  should  get  the  best 
possible  rail,  considering  every  little  detail.  If  you  accept  the  33-ft  rail, 
then  you  can  specify  just  the  part  of  the  ingot  it  comes  from.  The  rails 
being  rolled  now  are  marked  A,  B,  C,  D,  depending  on  whether  the  top 
rail  of  the  ingot,  the  middle  rail  of  the  ingot,  or  the  last  rail  of  the 
ingot.  So  we  can  put  it  in  the  power  of  the  engineers  to  specify  where 
that  rail  shall  come  from,  and  they  can  do  that  with  the  33-ft.  length 
switch,  or  with  switches  made  out  of  33-ft.  length  rails.  Five  per  cent,  of 
the  rails  are,  as  a  rule,  of  shorter  lengths,  dropping  down  according  to 
the  various  specifications,  either  a  foot  at  a  time  or  two  feet  at  a  time.  So, 
if  you  have  a  26-ft.  switch,  the  chances  are  you  will  get  it  out  of  a  shorter 
rail.  So  much  for  the  rail.  Another  object  in  having  the  longest  rail 
we  could  get  was  to  make  the  curve  in  the  lead  as  light  as  possible.  In 
France  they  are  using  now,  at  their  junctions,  a  rail  39  feet  and  some 
inches  long,  and  they  are  using  them  successfully  and  are  maintaining  a 
speed  through  the  switches,  even  on  the  branch  line,  of  62  miles  an  hour 
without  a  shock.  That  seems  to  be  the  tendency  in  France,  and  I  believe 
in  some  of  the  other  European  countries,  they  are  making  experiments  in 
the  same  direction.  So  we  feel  that  we  ought  to  at  least  go  as  far  as  33 
ft.  in  order  to  get  as  light  a  curve  as  possible. 

After  adopting  the  switch  point  that  gave  us  the  lightest  curve  in  the 
lead,  it  was  figured  out  by  one  of  the  members  of  the  Committee  to  put 
the  frog  on  a  par  with  that  condition,  a  frog  that  would  give  a  curve  pro- 
ducing the  same  deflection  as  an  engine  passing  through  that  point,  and 
it  was  found  to  be  a  No.  16  frog.  So,  for  the  purpose  of  getting  the  best 
rail,  the  lightest  curve,  and  to  get  a  point  that  would  give  the  same  de- 
flection as  the  curve  of  a  No.  16  frog,  we  feel  that  we  ought  to  use  a  33- 
ft.  point.  Furthermore,  we  feel  that  we  ought  to  try,  in  a  measure,  to 
keep  pace  with  the  other  countries  in  trying  to  get  leads  whereby  we  can 
obtain  speeds  the  same  as  they  are  doing  in  Europe. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Berry  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific)  : — In  looking  at 
the  bottom  of. page  386,  I  find  five  members  of  this  Committee  who  do 
not  agree  with  this  report,  and  I  would  like  to  ask  the  Chairman  why. 
It  occurs  to  me  that  perhaps  they  have  some  such  a  reason  as  I  would 
suggest.  We  have  passed  a  resolution  here  that  we  accept  the  plans  for 
the  frogs  as  a  whole.  I  think  there  are  probably  very  few  who  would 
object  to  Nos.  8,  11  and  16  rigid  frogs,  but  some  of  us  might  seriously 
question  whether  we  wanted  to  adopt  No.  11  spring  frog.  While  the  As- 
sociation passed  them  altogether,  it  seems  to  me  these  five  members  had 
something  in  mind  as  I  have  suggested.  It  may  be  unwise  to  commit  this 
Association  to  that  type  of  a  spring  rail  frog;  others  of  us  believe  there 
is  equally  as  good,  if  not  a  better,  spring  rail  frog,  and  it  would  seem 


972  TRACK. 

The  President : — Mr.  Berry,  I  do  not  think  you  are  in  order  on  the 
frog  question  now.  This  is  strictly  on  the  switch  points.  The  resolution 
for  the  frogs  has  been  passed. 

Mr.  Berry: — I  thought  the  split  switches  were  concluded.  Here  is 
this 

The   President: — This  is  on  switch  points. 

Mr.  Berry : — What  did  those  five  members  say  about  switch  points, 
those  who  dissented  from  the  majority  of  the  Committee? 

The  President: — Any  remarks  from  the  Committee? 

Mr.  Berry : — When  I  am  in  order,  I  wish  you  would  put  me  right, 
and  I  will  start  in  again. 

The  President: — We  will  now  adjourn  and  the  remaining  questions 
will  be  taken  up  in  the  morning,  on  the  length  of  switches,  and  also  the 
specifications. 

(Adjourned  until  9  o'clock  a.  m.,  Wednesday.) 

The  President : — The  further  consideration  of  the  report  of  the  Com- 
mittee on  Track  will  now  be  taken  up.  The  consideration  of  the  report 
was  suspended  last  evening  while  we  were  discussing  conclusion  3  on 
page  374,  with  reference  to  the  lengths  of  switches  and  number  of  frogs, 
and  this  question  is  now  open  for  discussion.  Mr.  Jenkins,  the  Chairman 
of  the  Committee,  will  continue  the  presentation  of  the  report. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — The  question  was  asked  yesterday  as  to  the  particulars 
in  which  the  dissenting  members  of  the  Committee  disagreed  with  the 
majority;  I  did  not  have  all  the  letters  with  me  at  that  time,  but  I  think 
I  have  all  the  information  here  at  the  present  time. 

Mr.  George  H.  Bremner  disagreed,  not  in  regard  to  the  conclusions, 
except  that  he  wished  the  conclusions  "presented"  as  representing  good 
practice,  instead  of  "adopted"  as  representing  good  practice.  He  also 
objected  to  some  portions  of  the  presentation  of  the  facts  in  connection 
with  the  choosing  of  the  numbers  of  frogs  and  lengths  of  switch  points, 
evidently  taking  that  part  of  the  report  as  an  argument.  I  did  not  have 
that  intention.  I  wanted  to  give  the  facts  for  and  against  rather  than  to 
present  an  argument  for  the  conclusions  of  the  Committee. 

Mr.  Rote  writes :  "I  am  willing  to  agree  that  the  report  of  the  Com- 
mittee represents  good  practice,  but  I  am  not  willing  to  agree  to  a  re- 
port favoring  the  switch  with  the  raised  switch  rail  for  the  solid-plated 
frog  over  flat  switch  and  a  frog  on  individual  tie-plate.  As  you  perhaps 
know,  our  company  (Lake  Shore)  uses  the  flat  switch  and  does  not  use  a 
single  solid  plate  under  ordinary  frogs,  and,  therefore,  I  do  not  approve 
of  the  findings  of  this  Committee  in  this  respect." 

Mr.  Ray  writes:  "I  am  willing,  of  course,  to  go  on  with  the  Com- 
mittee, assuming  that  the  majority  are  in  favor  of  the  report  as  sub- 
mitted. I  do  not  agree,  however,  with  the  Committee  on  the  recommended 
length  of  switch  for  frogs  over  No.  14,  that  is,  33-ft.  switch  points.  I  do 
not  believe  that  the  33-ft.  switch  point  is  in  every  way  practical.  Your 
plan  does  not  indicate  how  the  stock  rail  joint  is  to  be  made  or  where 
it  is  to  be  placed.     Furthermore,  I  do  not  see  the  advantage  of  a  No.  11 


DISCUSSION.  973 

over  a  No.  10  frog  for  ordinary  yard  work.  You  are  given  permission 
to  sign  my  name  to  the  report  with  the  understanding  that  I  do  not  agree 
with  the  recommendations  referred  to  above." 

It  may  be  stated  that  I  do  not  think  there  is  any  disagreement  be- 
tween Mr.  Ray  and  the  rest  of  the  Committee  concerning  the  relative 
merits  of  the  No.  10  and  No.  u  frog  for  ordinary  yard  work.  The 
Lackawanna  uses  No.  10  almost  entirely  for  yards,  while  most  roads  use 
7's  and  8's,  and  some  roads  6's,  in  similar  places. 

Mr.  Bruner  writes:  "I  subscribe  to  the  Committee  report,  excepting 
the  detail  drawings  of  frogs  and  switches  and  frog  numbers." 

Mr.  Stevens  writes:  "In  relation  to  the  report  of  the  Track  Com- 
mittee, I  have  crossed  and  marked  out  such  portions  of  the  proposed  text 
as  in  my  opinion  should  be  omitted  and  have  signed  a  copy  and  returned 
it  to  you  by  mail." 

The  portions  marked  by  Mr.  Stevens  are  several  slight  changes  in 
that  part  of  the  report  which  precedes  the  conclusions,  and  crossing  out 
three  paragraphs  on  page  372  following  "(d)  Turnouts  requiring  frogs  of 
large  angle."  Mr.  Stevens  wished  me  to  omit  these  three  paragraphs  as 
not  being  a  proper  portion  of  the  argument.  As  stated  before,  I  consider 
this  as  introductory  rather  than  as  an  argument  for  the  position  of  the 
Committee.  Mr.  Stevens  wanted  the  conclusion  in  regard  to  switch  points 
to  read  22-ft.  points  for  No.  10  frogs  instead  of  16^2  points.  He  wanted 
conclusions  No.  1  and  2  to  read :  "The  Committee  recommends  General 
Specifications,  etc.,  as  representing  good  practice,"  and  "The  Committee 
recommends  the  General  Plan,  etc.,  as  representing  good  practice." 

His  only  objections  are  in  regard  to  those  two  points  mentioned.  I 
would  like  to  state  that  the  question  of  33-ft.  switch  points  has  had  a 
great  deal  of  discussion  covering  a  period  of  about  three  years,  in  the 
Committee,  and  the  Committee  is  very  nearly  unanimous  in  concluding 
that  33-ft.  switch  points  are  desirable.  It  is  to  be  remembered  that  30-ft. 
switch  points  came  into  use  when  the  longest  rail  rolled  was  30  ft.,  and 
it  was  not  possible  at  that  time  to  have  a  stock  rail  without  a  joint.  Now 
with  the  33-ft.  switch  point  we  can  very  readily  obtain  a  60-ft.  stock  rail, 
when  it  is  desired  to  have  an  A  No.  1  track.  On  the  other  hand  I  do  not 
think  that  the  33-ft.  stock  rail,  with  the  33-ft.  switch  point,  will  make 
a  bad  job,  or  a  job  that  you  would  be  ashamed  to  have  in  your  main 
track  at  fairly  high-speed  points,  if  the  switch  is  properly  looked  after. 

Mr.  Berry: — I  hope  I  proved  yesterday  that  I  was  a  good  soldier  by 
quitting  when  I  got  orders.  It  occurred  to  me,  after  thinking  over  the 
matter,  that  perhaps  the  Chairman  misunderstood  what  I  said  in  the'  be- 
ginning of  my  talk  yesterday,  and  that  was  that  while  the  switch  poims 
were  under  discussion  there  were  probably  five  members  of  this  Com- 
mittee who  dissented  from  the  conclusions  of  the  Committee.  We  had 
already  voted  and  passed  upon  the  question  of  frogs ;  we  had  not  heard  a 
word  from  the  dissenting  members,  and  we  were  rapidly  approaching  a 
vote  on  split  switch  points  without  hearing  from  them.  I  discovered  one 
of  the  dissenting  members  on  the  floor  of  the  house,  and  I  asked  him 


974  TRACK. 

afterwards  why  he  did  not  go  up  on  the  platform,  and  he  said,  there  was 
no  room.  As  a  side  issue,  let  us  provide  room  for  the  members.  He  is 
on  the  platform  this  morning,  however.     - 

Mr.  Chairman,  with  that  understanding  I  did  talk  to  the  point  about 
switch  points,  but  I  had  this  in  mind. 

The  President: — The  Chair  apologizes  to  the  "good  soldier." 
Mr.  Berry: — The  Committee  had  said  that  the  length  of  the  switch 
points  was  so  bound  up  with  the  question  of  the  numbers  of  frogs  that 
if  you  disturb  one  you  would  disturb  the  other,  the  vote  had  got  past 
frogs.  In  my  opinion,  I  thought  we  ought  to  give  the  dissenting  mem- 
bers a  chance  to  say  something,  and  while  I  was  not  privileged  to  speak 
about  frogs,  as  it  had  passed,  I  took  exception  to  some  of  the  conclusions 
and  thought  the  dissenting  members  might  have  the  same  views  in  regard 
to  the  matter,  hence  went  into  the  frog  question  first.  If  I  had  started  on 
the  switch  points  first  and  reached  the  frogs  later,  I  suppose  it  would 
have  passed  through.  That  was  the  reason  why  I  thought  the  five  dissent- 
ing members  ought  to  have  something  to  say.  This  Association  wants  to 
know  everything  there  is  about  a  subject,  so  that  it  can  pass  upon  it  in- 
telligently. This  Committee  were  intending  to  incorporate  in  the  Manual 
and  Proceedings  the  recommendation  in  regard  to  frogs  and  split  switch 
points,  with  five  dissenting  members.  To  me  it  is  a  very  important  thing 
what  we  put  in  the  Manual.  We,  nearly  all  of  us,  in  times  of  doubt,  go 
to  the  Manual  or  Proceedings  to  see  what  is  best  to  do.  As  long  as  the 
members  of  this  Association  do  that,  outsiders  will  do  it.  As  an  evidence 
of  the  effect,  of  placing  matter  in  the  Manual,  I  would  like  to  read  from 
the  Chicago  Record-Herald  of  this  morning,  under  the  title,  "For  Third 
Rail  Plan."     It  says  : 

"It  is  regarded  as  certain  that  the  standard  will  be  adopted,  and  its 
approval  will  mean  that  every  railroad  in  the  country  agrees  to  the  specifi- 
cations that  have  been  prepared.  At  the  present  time  some  roads  have 
a  third  rail  located  several  inches  from  the  tracks,  a  number  construct- 
ing it  at  a  low  level,  and  others  at  a  much  higher  level." 

You  can  see  what  the  newspaper  says  before  these  Proceedings  ap- 
pear in  the  Manual,  and  I  know  that  a  great  many  people  outside  of  this 
Association  take  whatever  they  find  in  the  Manual  as  the  best  practice 
and  find  fault  with  other  people  who  do  not. 

I  think  we  ought  to  let  the  five  members  say  something  or  have  their 
views  thoroughly  understood. 

There  is  another  question.  This  report  says  that  55  per  cent,  of  the 
railroads — not  of  the  mileage — use  No.  10  frogs.  They  do  not  say  any- 
thing about  the  length  of  switches,  but  15  feet  is  the  usual  length,  so  you 
see  there  is  over  one-half  of  the  roads  in  this  Association  still  using  a 
No.  10  frog,  with  a  split  switch  presumably  15  feet  long.  Is  it  justifiable 
to  go  to  a  i6j4-foot  split  switch  and  incidentally  a  No.  11  frog?  We 
can  readily  see  why  we  go  to  the  shorter  split  switch  and  a  No.  8  frog, 
because  we  have  had  a  great  deal  of  trouble  in  maintaining  a  No.  7. 
We  can  also  understand  why  it  is  desirable  to  use  a  No.  30  or  33-foot 


DISCUSSION.  975 

switch  with  a  16-foot  frog,  because  they  are  on  high-speed  lines,  but  a 
i6j/2-foot  split  switch  with  No.  10  frog  is  a  different  proposition.  We 
have,  none  of  us,  had  trouble  maintaining  them,  and  it  is  a  question  whether 
we  want  to  change  from  No.  10  to  No.  u  frogs.  It  was  not  to  find  fault, 
but  I  wanted  these  five  members  to  have  something  to  say,  so  that  the 
Association  could  vote  upon  it  intelligently. 

There  is  another  important  thing  I  would  like  to  bring  up.  Every 
railroad  in  this  Association  that  has  from  5,000  to  10,000  miles  of  rail- 
road, has  in  stock  anywhere  from  $5,000,000  to  $io,oco,ooo  in  its  supplies. 
I  think  everyone  will  say  that  the  storekeepers  and  the  officers  are  con- 
tinually objecting  to  getting  so  many  different  parts.  If  a  No.  15  split 
switch  is  good  enough  and  a  No.  10  frog,  why  add,  even  on  new  work, 
No.  11?  It  makes  simply  so  much  additional  material  to  carry  in  stock, 
and  I  thought  perhaps  this  might  have  been  the  opinion  of  the  dissenting 
members,  hence  I  would  like  to  have  it  clearly  brought  out  by  them  what 
their  objections  are,  so  that  before  the  vote  is  taken  on  the  split  switches 
we  might  understand  their  objections,  and  perhaps  this  Association  would 
like  to  reconsider  its  decision  upon  the  frog  question  after  they  had  heard 
from  the  five  members. 

I  like  to  abide  by  the  decisions  of  this  Association,  but  I  am  free  to 
confess,  and  one  of  the  dissenting  members  said  he  thought  that  this  was 
not  the  best  practice,  there  are  a  number  of  members  in  this  Association 
who  feel  the  same  way.  If  we  are  tied  down  to  one  thing,  with  only  a 
single  illustration,  it  may  embarrass  some  of  us. 

The  President : — Do  any  of  the  members  of  the  Committee  desire  to 
say  anything? 

Mr.  L.  S.  Rose  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — I  wish 
I  could  talk  like  Mr.  Berry— we  could  get  by  with  this  report.  I  think  the 
Chairman  has  explained  the  dissension  of  the  dissenting  members.  He 
has  read  the  letters  giving  the  reasons  that  they  do  not  care  to  sign  the 
report  in  full.  He  has  explained  that  it  is  not  the  question  of  the  length 
of  switches,  except  in  one  case,  it  is  some  other  detail.  There  is  a  little 
difference  of  opinion  as  to  how  this  report  should  be  worded.  It  is  a 
large  Committee  and  practically,  as  the  Chairman  says,  agrees  with  the 
exception  of  details.  One  of  the  dissenting  members  is  here,  and  I  sus- 
pect he  will  talk  for  himself.  It  is  not  a  question  of  safety.  The  lengths 
of  switches  and  the  numbers  of  frogs  are  figured  out,  we  think,  on  a  scien- 
tific basis.  It  is  not  anything  very  radical.  It  will  not  put  anybody  in 
court  if  they  do  not  adopt  it,  because  it  is  a  question  of  standards,  not 
of  safety.  We  might  have  a  switch  that  conformed  to  these  standards 
that  would  not  be  as  safe  as  some  switch  that  did  not.  It  might  be  a 
question  of  the  size  of  the  rail  or  some  other  detail.  I  do  not  think  that 
the  safety  question  can  be  brought  up,  it  is  a  question  of  design.  Mr. 
Berry  also  says  that  we  carry  large  stocks.  I  submit  that  the  frog  and 
switch  stocks  change  very  rapidly  on  a  well-regulated  railroad.  They 
are  worn  out.     Also  we  were   instructed  to  give  a  recommendation  for 


976  TRACK. 

three  lengths  of  switches,  for  three  numbers  of  frogs,  to  keep  the  stock 
down,  so  that  when  a  road  adopted  this  recommendation  there  would 
be  only  three  to  carry  and  that  would  take  care  of  all  needs.  We  tried 
to  give  four,  but  the  convention  said,  "No,  only  three." 

I  further  think  that  we  have  got  the  best  three.  No  road  need  change 
their  standards  if  they  do  not  care  to,  and  they  will  not  get  into  trouble 
about  it — but  we  think  we  have  the  best  three.  We  can  take  care  of  junc- 
tions the  best  that  anyone  can  take  care  of  them,  up  to  our  present  art. 
We  might  change  our  plan  on  switches  a  little;  might  have  curved 
switches,  but  we  do  not  think  we  are  up  to  that  yet.  The  roads  do  not 
want  to  carry  so  many  different  kinds  in  stock.  They  want  a  switch 
that  they  can  use  anywhere.  A  few  years  ago,  I  think  two  or  three,  a 
circular  was  sent  out  by  the  International  Railway  Congress,  asking  what 
roads  were  increasing  the  speeds  at  junctions,  and  nearly  everybody  made 
a  report.  The  question  of  getting  trains  over  the  railroads  and  getting 
them  through  junctions  quickly,  is  important;  it  saves  time.  The  33-foot 
switch  will  take  care  of  that,  the  No.  16  frog  will  take  care  of  it.  We 
have  one  for  yards  and  one  for  yard  turnouts,  and  I  submit  it  is  better  to 
take  the  recommendation  of  this  Committee  than  to  take  some  other 
recommendation  that  has  not  been  given  study. 

Mr.  George  H.  Bremner  (Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy)  : — This  re- 
port was  very  carefully  considered  by  the  Committee,  and  I  think  the 
Chairman  is  to  be  congratulated  that  he  got  as  near  a  unanimous  opinion 
from  the  Committee  as  he  has,  and  that  the  Committee  have  come  as 
near  together  as  they  have  in  these  conclusions. 

There  is  no  dissent  in  the  Committee  from  the  fact  that  the  practice 
recommended  in  these  conclusions  is  good  practice.  Conclusion  No.  1  is 
unanimously  agreed  to.  On  the  other  two  conclusions  there  is  consider- 
able difference  of  opinion,  as  you  have  heard,  and  a  number  of  members 
of  the  Committee  do  not  agree  that  they  represent  the  best  practice,  al- 
though they  all  agree  that  they  represent  good  practice. 

Considering  the  number  of  frogs,  it  is  very  questionable  whether  a 
No.  8,  a  No.  11  and  a  No.  15  will  fulfill  all  conditions.  It  is  not  likely 
there  are  more  than  two  or  three,  if  there  are  any  roads  in  the  country 
that  have  frogs  of  these  three  numbers  as  their  standard,  not  but  many 
roads  have  some  of  them  as  standards,  but  to  use  the  combination  as  pre- 
sented by  the  Committee  would  probably  change  the  practice  of  every  road 
in  the  country  to  some  extent.  By  a  fuller  study  of  the  situation  on  the 
various  roads,  a  combination  of  frog  numbers  might  be  found  which 
would  only  change  the  practice  of  a  part  of  the  roads  in  the  United 
States  and  Canada,  and  still  give  fully  as  good  results.  The  frog  num- 
bers recommended  do  not  nearly  represent  the  needs  common  to  most 
roads.  The  No.  15  frog,  for  instance,  is  not  the  only  frog  that  is  used 
for  terminals,  nor  can  it  be  claimed  as  the  best.  Some  roads  use  20's,  some 
use  24's,  some  possibly  22's  for  their  ends  of  double  tracks  and  similar 
places.     Frogs  lower  than  No.  8  are  very  common,  in  fact  they  are  gen- 


DISCUSSION.  977 

eral  in  yards  where  it  is  necessary  to  save  room  and  where  the  work  is 
done  by  switch  engines,  so  that  the  limits  prescribed  by  the  numbers  of 
the  frogs  submitted  is  inside  of  what  is  to-day  good  practice  and  also,  it 
may  be,  the  best  practice.  Frogs  are  all  the  time  becoming  sharper  on 
account  of  the  higher  speed,  heavier  and  stiffer  engines  and  longer  equip- 
ment; so  that  where  to-day  the  Committee  recommends  a  No.  8,  a  few 
years  ago  they  would  have  recommended  a  No.  6,  and  a  No.  o.  will  be 
better  in  the  very  near  future.  Likewise  a  No.  15  is  likely  to  be  replaced 
by  a  No.  20,  or  even  higher  frog.  Practice  is  constantly  changing  and 
track  material  is  being  improved  very  rapidly  at  the  present  time. 

Concerning  the  length  of  switch  points,  those  recommended  are  good 
practice,  but  they  are  not  the  only  good  practice,  and  the  same  arguments 
in  regard  to  their  lengths  will  apply  that  apply  to  the  numbers  of  the 
frogs.  There  are  few  roads  in  the  United  States  to-day  that  are  using  33- 
foot  switch  points  to  a  great  extent,  although  they  can  be  used.  I  note 
German  roads  are  beginning  to  use  switch  points  even  longer  than  that. 
They  have  been  trying  switch  points  with  a  fixed  heel.  The  heel  on  all  of 
our  switch  points  is  pivoted.  By  the  use  of  this  fixed  heel  they  get  a 
curved  switch  point,  which,  if  it  can  be  properly  made,  I  think  we  will 
all  admit  is  very  desirable,  and  it  is  very  likely  to  come,  if  we  can  find  a 
construction  that  will  make  a  proper  fit  for  the  point  against  the  stock 
rail.  They  have  a  special  section  of  rail  for  this  switch  point,  and  I  see 
no  reason  why  the  practice  may  not  become  the  practice  in  this  country. 
The  use  of  a  special  shaped  head,  and  of  hardened  steel  or  toughened 
steel  for  our  points  is  surely  within  the  lines  of  reason  and  economy, 
if  a  proper  design  can  be  made  by  which  we  can  get  a  curved  switch 
point  for  high-speed  trains.  Consequently,  while  this  question  is  open, 
I  think  it  is  proper  for  this  convention  to  adopt  these  resolutions,  not  as 
the  action  of  the  convention  as  recommended  practice  to  bind  the  Asso- 
ciation, but  as  good  practice  which  we  can  agree  to  but  not  recommend 
as  the  best  practice. 

Mr.  Jenkins: — Mr.  Chairman,  I  wish  to  call  attention  particularly  to 
the  fact  that  two  of  the  dissenting  members  dissented  more  from  the 
text  of  the  argument  than  from  anything  else;  that  they  objected  to  my 
introducing  matter  which  weighed  against  the  Committee's  report.  My 
intention,  and  I  think  the  wish  of  most  of  the  members  of  the  Com- 
mittee, was  to  present  full  information  to  the  Association,  so  that  the 
subject  could  have  proper  consideration,  and  two  of  the  dissenters  simply 
objected  because  my  argument  was  not  strong  enough. 

Mr.  Rose: — Is  there  a  motion  before  the  house? 

The  President : — There  is  a  motion  before  the  house  for  the  accept- 
ance of  this. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Ewing  (Atlantic  City  Railroad)  : — I  would  like  to  ask  the 
Committee  if  they  can  advise  us  the  difference  in  the  angle  of  a  30-foot 
switch  and  a  33-foot  switch. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — Just  10  per  cent,  difference, 


978  TRACK. 

Mr.  Ewing: — What  is  that  in  minutes? 

Mr.  Jenkins : — It  is  approximately  six  minutes. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch :— I  think  perhaps  the  convention  could  reach  a  con- 
clusion, or  a  unanimous  opinion  on  this  subject  if  the  form  of  the  rec- 
ommendation were  changed.  It  has  developed  in  this  discussion  that  the 
general  practice  on  main  line  turnouts  is  No.  10,  and  there  is  a  very  wide 
practice  in  the  use  of  No.  15  on  high-speed  turnouts.  If  the  recommenda- 
tions were  changed  to  read  something  like  this:  "That  for  yard  work 
No.  8  frogs  are  recommended  as  good  practice,  for  general  main  line 
turnouts  No.  10  or  11  frogs  are  considered  good  practice,  and  for  high 
speed  turnouts  No.  15,  16,  or  a  higher  number  of  frogs  are  good  practice." 
This,  however,  departs  from  the  instructions  of  the  Committee.  The 
Committee  is  following  its  instructions  to  make  recommendations  for 
a  minimum  number  of  frogs  and  switches,  to  be  adopted  as  good  practice, 
but  we  have  discussed  this  matter  for  five  or  six  years  and  do  not  seem 
to  be  any  nearer  a  conclusion  than  we  were  five  years  ago,  and  I  doubt 
if  we  ever  will  reach  a  conclusion  on  three  numbers  of  frogs,  or  three 
switches,  and  I  would  suggest  that  this  form  of  recommendation  be 
changed. 

Mr.  Rose : — I  do  not  think  we  agree  with  Mr.  Fritch  on  that. 

The  President : — It  would  not  be  advisable  to  make  any  change  now, 
without  a  motion  for  reconsideration,  because  the  length  of  frogs  has 
been  passed  upon  already. 

Mr.  Rose : — I  mean  as  an  argument.  I  do  not  think  we  can  agree 
to  put  in  that  sort  of  a  recommendation.  We  have  tried  that  before, 
and  we  have  been  instructed.     I  would  not  agree  to  that  anyway. 

The  President: — The  motion  before  the  house  is  that  the  11,  16^2,  22 
and  33-foot  switch  point  lengths  be  adopted  and  put  in  the  Manual. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — Was  not  that  amended  by  changing  it  to  read 
n,  16H  and  26? 

The  President : — It  was  not  seconded,  as  I  recollect. 

A  Member : — I  second  it. 

The  President : — Then  the  amendment  will  be  put  first. 

Mr.  Rose : — I  asked  a  little  while  ago  if  there  was  a  motion  before 
the  house  and  I  had  in  mind  Mr.  Fritch's  motion.  I  think  we  should 
discuss  his  side  of  it  before  we  put  it  to  a  vote,  if  that  is  the  question. 

The  President: — The  amendment  before  the  house  is  that  the  lengths 
of  22-foot  and  33-foot  switch  points  be  combined  into  one  of  26  feet  in 
length. 

(The  amendment  was  put  to  vote  and  lost.) 

The  President : — We  will  now  vote  on  the  original  motion  as  stated. 

(The  vote  on  the  original  motion  not  being  definite,  a  standing  vote 
was  called  for  and  58  voted  in  the  affirmative,   14  opposed.) 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — I  move  to  reconsider  the  question  of  the  number 
of  frogs  recommended  by  the  Committee  to  be  adopted  as  representing 
good  practice-. 

(Motion  seconded  by  Mr.  Berry.) 


DISCUSSION.  979 

The  President : — Did  the  mover  of  the  motion  vote  for  or  against  the 
motion  as  originally  adopted? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — I  did  not  vote  on  the  question  of  frogs. 

(The  President  put  the  motion  of  Mr.  Fritch,  and  it  was  not 
adopted.) 

Mr.  Jenkins : — I  move  that  this  conclusion  be  printed  in  the  Manual, 
under  General  Rule  16-g. 

In  connection  with  these  specifications,  I  wish  to  state  that  these  were 
before  the  Association  last  year  in  a  slightly  different  form.  The  sub- 
stance of  the  specifications  is  practically  the  same  as  that  which  was 
considered  paragraph  by  paragraph  last  year,  but  it  has  been  rearranged 
and  the  general  instructions  and  general  specifications  combined ;  we  took 
all  reference  to  frog  numbers  and  length  of  switch  points  out  of  the 
specifications,  so  as  to  have  them  acted  on  separately  and  rejected  if  the 
convention  saw  fit  to  reject  them,  without  impairing  the  specifications. 
Tbe  specifications  this  year,  therefore,  do  not  contain  the  drawings  of 
frogs  and  switches  which  they  contained  last  year,  at  the  time  they  were 
considered,  but  the  specifications  carry  with  them  Fig.  i  on  page  381  and 
Fig.  2  on  page  382,  showing  the  planing  of  the  switch  point  and  the  de- 
tails of  the  point,  giving  the  dimensions  of  the  holes  and  distances  from 
center  to  center. 

If  the  convention  does  not  wish  to  take  the  time  to  go  through  these 
specifications  paragraph  by  paragraph,  as  we  did  last  year,  we  could 
simply  act  on  it  as  a  whole.  I  move,  in  order  to  save  time,  that  we  con- 
sider the  specification  as  a  whole  without  reading  it  paragraph  by  para- 
graph. 

The  President : — In  view  of  the  facts  stated  by  the  Chairman  of  the 
Committee  it  seems  to  be  a  good  plan,  considering  that  you  have  had  this 
Bulletin  before  you  for  some  time,  to  take  the  course  recommended  by 
the  Chairman  of  the  Committee,  and  with  your  consent  the  Chair  will 
simply  ask  those  who  have  made  up  their  minds  that  they  want  to  make 
some  special  criticism  on  some  particular  paragraph  to  make  such  criti- 
cism, without  the  necessity  of  reading  the  specifications  in  detail,  after 
which  the  specifications  will  be  presented  to  you  as  a  whole. 

Mr.  F.  J.  Bachelder  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  would  suggest  that  under 
"Foot  Guards,"  we  add  a  clause  that  foot  guards  shall  conform  to  the 
requirements  of  State  laws  in  the  States  for  which  the  material  is  ordered. 
In  some  States  the  law  specifies  a  certain  type  of  foot  guard. 

The  President: — Does  not  that  go  in  any  case  without  saying? 

Mr.  Bachelder : — It  would  save  time  to  have  it  definitely  understood. 

The  President : — Do  you  make  that  as  a  motion  ? 

Mr.  Bachelder: — Yes. 

(Motion  not  seconded.) 

Mr.  Lindsay : — Under  "Bolts,"  the  specifications  differ  from  the  specifi- 
cations previously  submitted  in  omitting  the  "U.  S.  standard."  The 
previous  specification  required  that  the  bolts  must  be  round  and  true  to 


980  TRACK. 

size,  with  the  U.  S.  standard  square  heads  and  nuts,  and  the  thread  should 
also  be  specified.    I  refer  to  the  second  paragraph  on  page  378. 

Mr.  Rose:— That  was  done  on  a  motion  made  by  Mr.  Ewing.  He 
wanted  that  cut  out  so  that  we  could  use  a  special  bolt. 

The  President :— Any  additional  criticism? 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  think  that  the  word  "spring"  should  be  substituted 
for  the  word  "wing"  at  the  top  of  page  379. 

Mr.  Jenkins:— It  may  be  either  "spring  rail"  or  "wing  rail,"  but  the 
Committee  will  accept  the  suggestion. 

Mr.  Lindsay : — On  page  381  under  Fig.  1  there  is  a  table  which  shows 
the  length  A.  B.  for  the  different  lengths  of  switches;  figuring  that  out 
in  feet  per  inch,  the  first  one  is  1  inch  in  16  feet,  the  second  one  1  in 
12,  and  the  remainder  1  inch  in  62A  feet.  I  think  the  16-foot  6-inch  switch 
would  be  very  much  better  if  A.  B.  was  longer.  I  move  the  substitution 
of  7  feet  for  5  feet  in  the  length  A.  B.  in  that  switch. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  ask  for  information  concerning  Fig.  2,  page  382,  if 
the  distance  A  is  the  theoretical  distance  or  the  practical  distance? 

Mr.  Jenkins : — That  is  the  theoretical  distance.  I  will  explain  that  as 
the  heel  distance  of  the  switch  is  6%  inches,  and  the  distance  of  the  gage 
line  from  the  stock  rail  is  *4-inch,  it  makes  a  difference  of  6  inches  for 
the  length  of  the  switch,  consequently  the  theoretical  distance  from  the 
bend  of  the  stock  rail  to  the  point  of  switch  is  just  1/24  the  length  of 
the  switch. 

(The  specifications  as  amended  were  then  put  to  vote  and  carried.) 

The  President : — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the 
Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  ROADWAY. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  387-400.) 
LIST    OF   SPEAKERS   TAKING   PART   IN   DISCUSSION    ON    ROADWAY. 

W.  M.  Dawley. 

The  President : — The  next  is  the  Committee  on  Roadway.  In  the 
absence  of  the  Chairman,  Mr.  W.  M.  Dawley,  the  Vice-Chairman,  will 
make  the  opening  remarks  in  regard  to  the  report. 

Mr.  W.  M.  Dawley  (Erie)  : — The  subjects  assigned  to  the  Roadway 
Committee  have  not  been  carried  out  to  a  conclusion.  There  was,  for 
the  first  subject  of  discussion,  the  formula  for  general  application,  for  de- 
termining waterways  under  various  conditions  with  consideration  of  the 
hydraulic  features.  We  have  been  considering  for  several  years  the  pos- 
sibility of  preparing  or  selecting,  from  various  formulae,  in  common  use, 
one  that  should  be  recommended  for  general  application.  The  investiga- 
tion made  since  the  Committee's  report  to  the  annual  convention  in  March, 
1909,  does  not  warrant  the  Committee  varying  from  the  opinion  then  ex- 
pressed and  accepted  by  the  Association. 

The  Committee's  work  since  the  twelfth  annual  convention  has  been 
directed  toward  the  consideration  rather  of  the  hydraulic  features  of  the 
culvert,  and  while  some  progress  has  been  made,  the  Committee  is  not 
prepared  now  to  make  any  definite  recommendation. 

On  the  second  question,  "unit  pressures  allowable  on  roadbeds  of  dif- 
ferent materials,  conferring  with  the  Committee  on  Ballast,"  no  definite 
conclusion  has  been  reached,  because  of  a  lack  of  information  obtainable. 
There  is  nothing  published  in  the  way  of  literature  covering  the  condi- 
tions as  they  exist  under  the  roadbed,  that  is,  defining  the  bearing  power  of 
soils,  as  we  use  them  in  railroad  work,  and  before  any  conclusion  can 
be  drawn  it  would  be  necessary  to  make  some  full-sized  tests,  as  in  actual 
practice,  and  measure  by  some  means  yet  to  be  determined  what  actual 
pressure  is  transmitted  to  the  roadbed  through  the  ballast,  and  how  it 
varies,  both   longitudinally  and  transversely   of  the  track. 

On  the  third  subject,  "Report  on  tunnel  construction  and  ventilation," 
some  information  was  collected  and  published  merely  as  information,  and 
the  Committee  has  some  other  material  relating  particularly  to  ventilation 
of  subways  in  cities,  and  ventilation  of  the  Hudson  and  Manhattan  tubes, 
under  the  Hudson  River,  but  that  has  not  yet  been  published.  The  chair- 
man of  the  sub-committee,  Mr.  Paul  Didier,  advises  that  he  has  consider- 
able information,  but  has  been  unable  to  work  it  into  shape  on  account  of 
being  so  busily  engaged  in  constructing  tunnels,  he  has  not  had  time  to 
theorize. 

The  fourth  subject,  "The  question  of  agricultural  drainage  as  it  affects 
railways,"  the  Committee  during  the  past  two  years  collected  information 

981 


982  ROADWAY. 

as  to  the  drainage  laws  of  the  various  states,  but  has  never  been  able  to 
fix  upon  a  form  into  which  the  information  can  be  put  so  as  to  make  it  of 
value  to  the  Association.  The  Committee  is  of  the  opinion  that  further 
work  along  the  line  of  collecting  information  as  to  (a)  Laws  and  Assess- 
ments is  futile  because  the  laws  are  changing  constantly,  and  because  the 
Committee's  information  is  necessarily  general  and  not  subject  to  applica- 
tion to  specific  cases  without  legal  advice;  and  further,  questions  affecting 
the  laws  and  assessments  are,  in  all  railway  organizations,  handled  by  the 
railway's  attorneys.  The  Committee  recommends  that  it  be  discharged 
from  further  consideration  of  the  subject  as  to  Laws  and  Assessments. 

The  recommendation  of  the  Committee  on  subjects  I,  2  and  3  is  that 
they  be  reassigned  for  further  consideration,  and  subject  4  be  confined  to 
the  benefits  the  railways  will  derive  by  the  construction  of  agricultural 
drainage  ditches  and  levies. 

The  Committee  has  been  collecting  information  for  two  years  for  the 
purpose  of  formulating  a  conclusion  as  to  what  unit  pressures  are  allow- 
able on  the  roadbed,  and  the  Committee  has  come  to  the  conclusion  that 
since  the  available  data  treats  of  the  sustaining  power  of  soils  below  the 
surface,  rather  than  of  that  of  soils  peculiarly  exposed  as  the  roadbed 
is  to  moisture,  to  the  action  of  frost,  and  to  the  loadings  peculiar  to  train 
service,  it  will  be  necessary  to  make  experiments  to  determine  the  magni- 
tude and  distribution  of  the  loads  transmitted  to  the  roadbed  through 
ballast  of  various  kinds  and  also  to  determine  by  test  the  bearing  power 
of  various  materials  under  varying  conditions  ordinarily  attained  in  the 
construction    of    the    roadway. 

I  would  suggest  that  the  Committee  on  Ties  be  added  to  that. 

The  President : — 'No  action  on  the  part  of  the  Association  is  neces- 
sary, as  these  are  progress  reports.  The  Committee  has  furnished  us  a 
starter  for  some  valuable  information  in  regard  to  unit  pressures,  and 
we  will  hope  for  a  continuation  along  that  line.  The  Committee  is  dis- 
missed with  the  thanks  of  the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  WATER  SERVICE. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.    401-428.) 
LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING   PART   IN    DISCUSSION    ON    WATER    SERVICE. 

J.  B.  Berry.  Robert  Ferriday.  F.  E.  Schall. 

Geo.  H.  Bremner.  C.  E.  Lindsay.  W.  F.  Steffens. 

J.  L.  Campbell. 

The  President :— The  next  Committee  is  that  on  Water  Service,  Mr. 
Robert  Ferriday,  Chairman.  The  Chairman  will  make  the  opening  re- 
marks in  regard  to  the  report. 

Mr.  Robert  Ferriday  (Cleveland,  Cincinnati,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — 
The  Committee  has  no  changes  to  recommend  in  the  Manual  until  the 
future  policy  now  under  consideration  is  decided.  On  the  subject  of 
"the  design  and  relative  economy  of  track  pans  from  an  operating  stand- 
point," the  Committee  reports  progress. 

On  the  subject  of  deep  well  pumps  we  report  merely  progress,  be- 
cause the  subject  has  not  been  developed  sufficiently  to  report  otherwise. 

On  the  subject  of  the  use  of  reinforced  concrete  for  water  tanks 
and  supports,  this  report  is  submitted  as  information.  The  Committee- 
believes  it  is  an  interesting  and  impartial  statement  of  the  subject.  The 
field  of  reinforced  concrete  is  being  rapidly  expanded,  and  it  may  de- 
velop that  the  use  of  such  material  for  this  purpose  can  be  made  with  no 
doubt  of  definite  success,  but  the  Committee  did  not  feel  prepared  to  offer 
conclusions  one  way  or  the  other  until  its  performance  had  become  more 
definitely  determined. 

A  sub-committee  on  water  treatment  has  been  made  part  of  the  Com- 
mittee organization  for  the  purpose  of  keeping  that  subject  alive  and 
reporting  any  developments.  There  is  nothing  to  report  at  this  time,  but 
the  Committee  submits,  in  Appendix  A,  for  the  information  of  the  Associ- 
ation, a  paper  prepared  at  its  request  by  J.  R.  Francis,  regarding  the 
unusual  occurrence  of  locomotive  boiler  corrosion,  which  followed  a 
partial  installation  of  water  softeners.  It  is  quite  possible  that  some 
conditions  may  be  experienced  by  our  members,  under  similar  conditions; 
and  information  regarding  the  means  for  overcoming  it  may  be  of  value. 

Your  Committee  has  canvassed  the  membership  for  opinions  and  criti- 
cisms of  the  general  specifications  of  steel  tanks  submitted  last  year,  and 
same  have  been  revised.  The  Committee  was  anxious  to  include  with 
the  specifications  for  open-hearth  steel  also  those  for  a  material  which 
would  resist  rust  better  than  ordinary  steel,  and  they  are  included  as 
printed  in  the  Bulletin.  But  through  an  error  the  circular  issued  to  the 
membership  failed  to  include  the  specifications  for  refined  steel  and  it  has 
since  appeared  to  the  Committee  desirable  to  omit  the  specifications  for 
refined  steel  for  the  present,  and  with  the  consent  of  the  convention,  the 

983 


984  WATER  SERVICE. 

Committee  desires  to  amend  the  specifications  as  follows  and  to  submit 
same  for  the  Manual. 

If  there  are  no  objections  I  would  recommend  that  we  take  up  the 
specifications  for  steel  tanks,  paragraph  by  paragraph,  and  I  can  outline 
the  changes  that  we  desire  to  make: 

(i)  Change  the  title  to  read  as  follows:  "General  Specifications  for 
Steel  Water  and  Oil  Tanks." 

"i.  Ordinary  Tanks  Defined.  Ordinary  tanks  are  those  requiring 
plates  not  more  than  5^-in.  thick. 

"2.  Scope  of  Specifications.  These  specifications  cover  ordinary  steel 
tanks  commonly  used  by  railways  for  usual  service  conditions  only." 

(2)  Combine  paragraphs  1  and  2  to  read :  "1.  Scope  of  Specifica- 
tions. These  specifications  are  intended  for  steel  tanks  requiring  plates 
not  more  than  54-in.  thick." 

(3)  Change  the  numbering  of  the  paragraphs  in  consequence  of  con- 
solidating paragraphs  1  and  2. 

"3-  Quality  of  Metal.  The  metal  in  these  tanks  shall  be  a  special 
refined  steel  or  open-hearth  steel. 

"The  special  refined  steel  shall  have  a  tensile  strength  per  sq.  in.  not 
less  than  50,000  lbs.  and  an  elastic  limit  not  less  than  30,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 
It  shall  contain  of 

Sulphur    Not  more  than  .02    per  cent. 

Phosphorus   Not  more  than  .005  per  cent. 

Carbon   Not  more  than  .02   per  cent.  "\ 

Manganese  Not  more  than  .00    per  cent. 

Silicon  Not  more  than  .00   per  cent. 

"The  steel  shall  conform  in  physical  and  chemical  properties  to  the 
specifications  of  this  Association  for  steel  bridges. 

"For  plates  not  more  than  ^-in.  thick,  §^-in.  rivets  shall  be  used. 
For  thicker  plates  the  diameter  shall  be  24-in." 

(4)  Change  paragraph  3  in  the  Bulletin  to  read,  "2.  Quality  of  Metal. 
The  metal  in  these  tanks  shall  be  open-hearth  steel.  This  steel  shall  con- 
form in  physical  and  chemical  properties  to  the  specification  of  this  Associ- 
ation for  steel  bridges." 

"4.  Loading.  The  weight  of  water  shall  be  assumed  to  be  63  lbs., 
crude  oil  56  lbs.,  and  creosote  oil  66  lbs.  per  cu.  ft.  Wind  pressure,  acting 
in  any  direction,  shall  be  assumed  to  be,  in  pounds,  30  times  the  product 
of  the  height  by  two-thirds  of  the  diameter  of  the  tank  in  feet. 

"5.  Unit  Stresses.     Unit  stresses  shall  not  exceed  the  following: 

(a)  Tension  in  plates,  15,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  on  net  section. 

(b)  Shear  in  plates,  12,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  on  net  section. 

(c)  Shear  on  rivets,  12,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  on  net  section. 

(d)  Bearing  pressure  on  field  rivets,  20,000  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

"6.  Cylindrical  Rings.  Plates  forming  the  shell  of  the  tank  shall  be 
cylindrical  and  of  different  diameters,  in  and  out,  from  course  to  course. 

"7.  Workmanship.  All  workmanship  shall  be  first  class.  All  plates 
shall  be  beveled  on  all  edges  for  caulking  after  being  punched.    The  punch- 


DISCUSSION.  985 

ing  shall  be  from  the  surface  to  be  in  contact.  The  plates  shall  be  formed 
cold  to  exact  form  after  punching  and  beveling.  All  rivet  holes  shall  be 
accurately  spaced.  Drift  pins  shall  be  used  only  for  bringing  the  parts 
together.  They  shall  not  be  driven  with  enough  force  to  deform  the 
metal  about  the  holes.  Power  riveting  and  caulking  should  be  used.  A 
heavy  yoke  or  pneumatic  bucker  shall  be  used  for  power  driven  rivets. 
Riveting  shall  draw  the  joints  to  full  and  tight  bearing. 

"8.  Caulking.  The  tank  shall  be  made  water  or  oil  tight  by  caulking 
only.  No  foreign  substance  shall  be  used  in  the  joints.  For  water  tanks, 
the  caulking  shall  preferably  be  done  on  the  inside  of  tank  and  joint  only; 
but  for  oil  tanks  the  caulking  should  be  done  on  both  sides.  No  form  of 
caulking  tool  or  work  that  injures  the  abutting  plate  shall  be  used. 

"g.  M'inimum  Thickness  of  Plates.  The  minimum  thickness  of  plates 
in  the  cylindrical  part  of  the  tank  shall  not  be  less  than  J^-in.  and  in  flat 
bottoms  not  less  than  Tjj-in.  In  curved  bottoms  the  thickness  of  plate  shall 
be  not  less  than  that  of  the  lower  plate  in  the  cylindrical  part. 

"10.  Horizontal  and  Radial  Joints.  Lap  joints  shall  generally  be  used 
for  horizontal  seams  and  splices  and  for  radial  seams  in  curved  bottoms. 

"n.  Vertical  Joints.  For  vertical  seams  and  splices,  lap  joints  shall 
be  used  with  plates  not  more  than  ->£-in.  thick.  With  thicker  plates,  double 
butt  joints  with  inside  and  outside  straps  shall  generally  be  used.  The 
edge  of  the  plate  in  contact  at  the  intersection  of  horizontal  and  vertical 
lap  joints  shall  be  drawn  out  to  a  uniform  taper  and  thin  edge. 

"12.  Rivet  Holes,  Punching  and  Pitch.  The  diameter  of  rivet  holes 
shall  be  -rs-in.  larger  than  the  diameter  of  the  rivets  used.  The  punching 
shall  conform  to  the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  such  work  on 
steel  bridges.  A  close  pitch,  with  due  regard  for  thickness  of  plate  and 
balanced  stress  between  tension  on  plates  and  shear  on  rivets,  is  desirable 
for  caulking." 

(5)  Change  paragraph  12  in  the  Bulletin  to  read,  "11.  Rivets,  Rivet 
Holes,  Punching  and  Pitch.  For  plates  not  more  than  )^-in.  thick,  5^-in. 
rivets  shall  be  used.  For  thicker  plates,  J^-in.  rivets  shall  be  used.  The 
diameter  of  rivet  holes  shall  be  tt-in.  larger  than  the  diameter  of  the 
rivets  used.  The  punching  shall  conform  to  the  specifications  of  this 
Association  for  such  work  on  steel  bridges.  A  close  pitch,  with  due 
regard  for  thickness  of  plate  and  balanced  stress  between  tension  on 
plates  and  shear  on  rivets,  is  desirable  for  caulking." 

"13.  Tank  Support.  If  the  tank  is  supported  on  steel  columns  with 
bracing,  the  metal  in  such  substructure  shall  conform  to  these  specifica- 
tions, and  the  anchorage  and  workmanship  thereof  shall  conform  to  the 
specifications  of  this  Association  for  the  manufacture  and  erection  of 
steel  bridges." 

(6)  Change  paragraph  13  in  the  Bulletin  to  read,  "12.  Tank  Support. 
If  the  tank  is  supported  on  a  steel  substructure,  the  latter  shall  conform 
to  the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  the  manufacture  and  erection 
of  steel  bridges,  except  that  allowance  shall  be  made  for  wind  pressure, 
but  not  for  impact." 


986  WATER  SERVICE. 

Mr.  W.  F.  Steffens  (Boston  &  Albany)  :— I  should  like  to  ask  the 
Committee  why  they  change  from  the  unit  stresses  adopted  by  the  Com- 
mittee on  Iron  and  Steel  Bridges? 

Mr.  Ferriday : — These  specifications  were  drawn  up  by  the  Commit- 
tee with  the  help  of  Prof.  Pence  and  Mr.  A.  F.  Robinson,  who  has  built 
a  number  of  tanks  during  the  last  sixteen  years. 

Mr.  Steffens : — I  should  like  to  ask  the  Committee  if  they  would  be 
willing  to  put  that  in  the  shape  of  a  factor,  a  constant,  in  other  words, 
against  the  specifications  for  steel  bridges.  It  is  rather  awkward  to  have 
two  sets  of  unit  stresses,  one  for  bridges  and  another  for  tanks. 

Mr.  Ferriday : — I  do  not  think  that  would  be  satisfactory.  I  do  nor 
believe  it  would  be  desirable  to  have  to  make  a  computation  from  the 
specifications  for  steel  bridges.  I  see  no  objection  to  including  them 
just  as  given. 

The  President : — Have  you  any  motion  ? 

Mr.  Steffens : — I  move  that  the  unit  stresses  be  referred  to  the 
corresponding  specifications  for  steel  bridges,  with  a  corresponding  reduc- 
tion factor. 

The  President : — There  being  no  second,  we  will  pass  on. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  :— Do  I 
understand  that  the  cylindrical  sections  as  required  in  paragraph  6  alter- 
nate, first  in  and  then  out? 

Mr.  Ferriday: — 'Yes. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  think  the  reference  to  the  specification  for  steel 
bridges  would  require  a  person  to  have  a  full  set  of  the  bridge  specifica- 
tions.    Why  could  not  these  clauses  be  embodied  in  the  specification? 

Mr.  Ferriday: — I  think  it  has  been  the  practice  of  all  the  committees, 
for  the  sake  of  brevity,  to  refer  to  the  other  specifications,  without  re- 
peating them  in  detail.  In  the  case  of  the  Masonry  Committee,  they 
refer  to  the  specifications  for  cement,  and  that  is  the  reason  it  was  done 
here. 

The  President: — Any  further  discussion  on  No.  12,  as  revised? 

Mr.  Ferriday: — The  Committee  wishes  to  make  the  following  change 
in  that  paragraph:  "12.  Tank  Support.  If  the  tank  is  supported  on  a 
steel  substructure,  the  latter  shall  conform  to  the  specifications  of  this  As- 
sociation for  the  manufacture  and  erection  of  steel  bridges." 

The  President: — Is  there  any  discussion  on  the  revised  form  of  13? 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  make  the  same  comment  as  before.  As  to  Mr. 
Ferriday's  comment  about  our  cement  specification,  I  would  say  that  our 
cement  specification  is  an  entity,  it  is  a  complete  specification  in  itself,  but 
the  specification  for  steel  bridges  goes  into  a  great  many  things  not 
involved  in  Water  Service,  and  we  would  have  to  go  over  the  specifica- 
tion and  pick  out  the  paragraphs  here  and  there,  to  get  what  we  wanted, 
and  we  would  have  to  rearrange  them,  to  get  the  matter  complete. 

The  President :— Your  idea  is  that  if  the  extract  is  not  too  long,  it 
can  be  embodied  in  the  specifications  for  ordinary  steel  water  and  oi! 
tanks  ? 


DISCUSSION.  987 

Mr.  Lindsay : — Yes. 

The  President : — I  think  the  Committee  would  accept  that  general 
practice. 

Mr.  Ferriday: — "14.  Painting.  In  the  shop  the  metal  shall  be  cleaned 
of  dirt,  rust  and  scale  and,  except  the  surfaces  to  be  in  contact  in  the 
joints  of  the  tank,  shall  be  given  a  shop  coat  of  paint  or  metal  preservative 
selected  and  applied  as  specified  by  the  company. 

"After  being  completely  erected,  caulked  and  cleaned  of  dirt,  rust  and 
scale,  all  exposed  metal  work  shall  be  painted  or  treated  with  such  coat 
or  coats  of  paint  or  metal  preservative  as  shall  be  selected  by  the  railway 
company." 

Mr.  Campbell,  Chairman  of  the  Sub-committee  which  prepared  this 
report,  feels  that  we  should  not  accept  Mr.  Lindsay's  suggestion. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell  (El  Paso  Southwestern)  : — I  feel,  and  I  believe 
it  is  the  feeling  of  the  Committee,  that  the  specification  paragraph  13, 
now  paragraph  12,  as  amended,  should  stand  as  it  has  been  amended  by 
the  Committee.  These  are  general  specifications  and  they  avoid  going 
into  specific  details,  and  it  appeared  to  the  Committee  that  by  reference 
to  the  specifications  for  steel  bridges,  the  Association  has  a  specification 
governing  the  designing  and  erection  of  the  substructure,  which  would 
meet  the  case.  When  it  comes  to  the  matter  of  designing  a  particular 
structure,  as  to  that  particular  part  of  the  water  tank,  the  supports,  we 
immediately  go  into  the  field  of  bridge  engineering,  and  we  would  nat- 
urally turn  to  the  specifications  for  the  designing  of  a  steel  structure  tak- 
ing stresses  similar  to  those  carrying  railway  trains,  and  it  would  seem 
to  the  Committee  to  be  a  very  simple  thing  merely  to  refer  to  these  specifi- 
cations, and  that  it  is  not  necessary  to  go  into  detail  and  embody  these 
specifications  in  the  general  specifications  for  water  tanks.  It  will  con- 
siderably lengthen  the  latter  specifications  if  we  do  that.  The  stresses 
that  occur  in  the  substructure  are  quite  different  from  those  in  the  shell. 
and  it  would  be  necessary  for  us  to  include  all  the  specifications  covering 
the  designing  of  columns,  and  that  sort  of  thing. 

Mr.  George  H.  Bremner  (Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy)  : — It  would 
seem  to  be  proper  to  refer  to  the  other  specifications  printed  in  the  Man- 
ual, but  the  Committee  should  at  the  same  time  give  us  the  location  of  the 
specifications  and  give  the  numbers  or  the  paragraphs  in  the  bridge  specifi- 
cations that  are  needed  to  complete  the  water  and  oil  tank  specifications, 
so  that  they  can  be  readily  accessible  to  the  members  without  going 
through  the  entire  bridge  specifications. 

Mr.  F.  E.  Schall  (Lehigh  Valley)  : — Do  I  understand  that  the  columns 
for  steel  substructure  of  tank  are  to  be  designed  under  the  requirements 
of  specifications  for  steel  railroad  bridges?  No  indications  as  to  require- 
ments for  compressive  unit  stresses  are  given.  The  tank  proper  is  to  be 
designed  for  unit  tensile  stress  of  15,000  lbs.  per  square  inch,  or  about 
50  per  cent,  higher  than  is  allowed  for  railroad  bridges,  not  considering 
impact;  this  unit  stress  in  my  judgment  is  about  right:  the  compression 
unit  stresses  should  be  gaged  in  the  same  manner. 


988  WATER  SERVICE. 

The  President: — The  Committee  intends  to  recommend  that  the  sub- 
structure shall  be  designed  in  accordance  with  the  specifications  for  steel 
bridges. 

Mr.  Schall: — The  specifications  are  not  clear  as  to  this  requirement. 
The  compression  unit  stresses  for  steel  bridges  are  based  on  impact  be- 
ing added  to  stresses. 

The  President: — That  section  was  changed  to  read  as  follows:  "If 
the  tank  is  supported  on  a  steel  substructure  the  latter  shall  conform  to 
the  specifications  of  this  Association  for  the  manufacture  and  erection 
of  steel  bridges."     That  is  the  recommendation  of  the  Committee. 

Mr.  Schall: — What  is  the  reason  for  allowing  a  practically  50  per 
cent,  increase  in  tension  stresses  for  tanks  over  those  allowed  for  in 
steel  bridges  (excluding  impact  in  the  latter),  and  building  the  columns 
under  the  unit  stresses  for  steel  railroad  bridges  making  the  columns 
heavier  than  they  need  be? 

Mr.  Ferriday: — I  do  not  believe  I  quite  understand  the  point.  The 
unit  stresses  given  in  paragraph  5  are  intended  to  cover  the  tank. 

Mr.  Schall : — The  Committee  provides  for  a  specific  unit  stress  in 
tension  for  the  shell  of  the  tank,  based  upon  a  static  load,  and  intends 
to  apply  for  the  column  supports  the  unit  stresses  of  steel  railroad  bridges 
which  are  based  upon  addition  of  impact. 

The  water  tank  specifications  are  not  complete  without  providing  a 
clear  requirement  for  compression  unit  stresses  and  also  providing  unit 
stresses  for  shop  and  field  rivets. 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell : — That  is  quite  true,  and  the  Committee  took  that 
into  consideration.  The  members  of  such  substructure  will  be  light  in 
many  cases,  and  it  requires  a  certain  thickness  of  metal  for  a  proper 
margin  against  corrosion  and  for  other  considerations,  and  the  Committee 
believes  it  will  be  found  that  the  substructure  for  a  water  tank  designed 
in  accordance  with  the  specifications  for  steel  bridges  will  not  be  expensive 
in  the  use  of  material,  and  will  not  put  more  material  in  the  substructure 
than  should  be  there  in  any  case. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Berry  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific)  : — I  suggest  the 
preparations  of  plans  and  specifications  as  to  tools  for  erection,  and  I 
do  it  for  this  reason — when  we  started  to  equip  our  line  with  steel  tanks, 
it  had  to  be  done  by  division  forces.  We  looked  everywhere  as  to  the 
best  and  most  economical  plan  to  erect  the  tanks.  We  finally  got  up  a 
set  of  drawings  of  tools,  and  had  them  criticized.  I  believe  it  would  be  a 
good  thing  for  this  Committee  to  collect  such  information  and  recommend 
the  best  class  of  tools  for  the  erection  of  such  tanks,  so  that  the  mem- 
bers of  the  Association  will  have  the  benefit  of  that  information. 

Mr.  Ferriday : — I  move  that  the  specifications  for  steel  water  and  oil 
tanks,  as  amended,  be  adopted  and  included  in  the  Manual. 

(The  motion  was  put  to  vote  and  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  CONSERVATION  OF  NATURAL 
RESOURCES. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.   429-45S.) 

list  of  speakers  taking  part  in  discussion  on  conservation  of  natural 

resources. 

William  McNab. 

The  President : — The  first  business  this  morning  will  be  the  report  of 
the  Committee  on  Conservation  of  Natural  Resources,  Mr.  E.  O.  Faulk- 
ner, Chairman.  In  the  absence  of  Mr.  Faulkner,  the  report  will  be  pre- 
sented by  Mr.  McNab,  the  Vice-Chairman. 

Mr.  William  McNab  (Grand  Trunk)  : — I  regret  very  much  the  ab- 
sence of  the  Chairman  of  this  Committee,  Mr.  Faulkner.  As  his  imme- 
diate deputy,  however,  I  will  say  that  the  compilation  of  this  report  has 
given  the  Committee  a  great  deal  of  pleasure.  It  is  submitted  at  pres- 
ent merely  as  a  report  of  progress  and  for  information,  but  it  is  the  pur- 
pose of  the  Committee  to  continue  the  work  on  the  present  lines,  by  keep- 
ing in  touch  with  the  National  organization  in  the  United  States,  as  well 
as  with  a  similar  one  in  the  Dominion  of  Canada. 

The  President : — The  Committee  simply  reports  progress  and  the  Com- 
mittee is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the  Association.  They  have  given 
us  a  lot  of  splendid  information  in  their  report  and  we  feel  very  grateful 
to  them. 


989 


DISCUSSION  ON  MASONRY. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.   459-504.) 
LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART    IN    DISCUSSION    ON     MASONRY. 

A.  W.  Carpenter.  C.  E.  Lindsay.  E.   V.   Smith. 

R.  D.  Coombs.  Hunter  McDonald.         G.  H.  Tinker. 

L.  G.  Curtis.  P.  C.  Newbegin.  E.  E.  R.  Tratman. 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Masonry,  of  which  Mr.  G.  H.  Tinker  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Tinker  will  make 
the  opening  statement. 

Mr.  G.  H.  Tinker  (New  York,  Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  :— The  Com- 
mittee on  Masonry  held  four  meetings  during  the  year,  all  at  Chicago. 
The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  six  subjects  for  its  investigation  and 
also  directed  that  the  Committee  appoint  sub-committees  to  act  with  the 
Joint  Committee  on  Concrete  and  Reinforced  Concrete  and  the  Joint 
Committee  on  Uniform  Specifications  for   Portland   Cement. 

The  various  subjects  have  been  assigned  to  sub-committees  and  work 
has  proceeded  upon  all  subjects.  In  accordance  with  the  directions  of  the 
Board,  we  present  final  reports  upon  two  subjects  only;  upon  a  third 
subject,  the  waterproofing  of  masonry,  we  submit  abstracts  of  the  replies 
received  to  a  circular  sent  out  by  the  Committee.  This  is  presented  as 
information  at  the  present  time,  it  being  the  intention  of  the  Committee 
to  follow  the  matter  up  with  a  final  report  at  a  later  date.  This  subject 
the  Committee  has  had  under  consideration  for  several  years,  during 
which  time  it  has  been  engaged  in  collecting  data  upon  which  to  base  a 
final  report. 

Upon  the  subject  of  "Methods  of  Patching  and  Repairing  Plain  and 
Reinforced  Concrete,"  the  matter  presented  by  the  Committee  will  be  found 
on  page  474.  The  Committee  sent  out  a  circular  of  inquiry  upon  this 
subject  and  received  a  great  many  replies,  over  one  hundred,  in  fact. 
There  were  so  many  replies,  a  number  of  them  describing  practically  the 
same  method  of  work,  that  only  a  selection  has  been  presented  in  the 
form  of  abstracts  to  show  the  substance  of  the  information  received.  The 
conclusions  of  the  Committee  upon  this  subject  are  given  on  page  476. 
There  are  seven  conclusions.  The  Committee  asks  that  these  conclu- 
sions be  approved  under  Rule  16-g  for  publication  in  the  Manual. 

"Your  Committee  presents  the  following  conclusions  as  to  the  methods 
of  repairing  defective  or  worn  surfaces  of  concrete: 

"(1)  In  all  cases  the  surface  to  be  repaired  must  first  be  thoroughly 
cleaned  of  all  loose  material,  laitance  and  dust  and  the  clean,  rough,  sound 
concrete  exposed  to  receive  the  patch.  Probably  the  best  method  of 
cleaning  is  by  means  of  a  steam  jet. 

990 


DISCUSSION.  991 

"(2)  After  cleaning,  the  surface  to  be  repaired  must  be  thoroughly 
saturated  with  water,  not  simply  moistened,  but  so  thoroughly  drenched 
that  the  old  concrete  will  not  absorb  water  from  the  new  mortar  or 
concrete  used  in  patching.  If  possible,  the  surface  should  be  kept  covered 
with  water  for  several  hours. 

"(3)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  vertical  or  sloping 
surface  and  is  not  to  be  more  than  iT4  in.  thick,  the  surface  of  the  old 
concrete,  while  it  is  still  wet,  should  be  spattered  or  splashed  with  a 
cement  grout,  following  this  immediately  with  a  fairly  stiff  plaster  coat 
of  mortar  made  of  the  same  proportions  of  cement  and  sand  as  was  used 
in  the  original  concrete,  but  never  richer  than  1  cement  to  2^4  sand. 
This  plaster  coat  should  not  be  thicker  than  ^-in.  and  each  coat  should 
be  forced  into  the  surface,  but  not  dragged  with  a  trowel.  The  sur- 
face of  each  coat,  except  the  final  coat,  should  be  "scratched"  to  give  a 
bond  for  the  next  coat.  This  plastering  should  preferably  begin  at  the 
top  and  progress  downward,  and  only  enough  time  be  allowed  to  permit 
each  coat  to  receive  its  initial  set  before  the  next  coat  is  applied.  The 
final  coat  should  be  finished  with  a  wooden  float  and  only  enough  water 
used  to  properly  finish  the  surface.  This  patch  should  be  kept  damp  and 
protected  from  sun  or  frost  till  fully  set  up. 

"(4)  If  the  repair  or  patch  or  'finish  coat'  is  to  be  made  on  a 
horizontal  or  nearly  horizontal  surface,  the  surface  of  the  old  concrete 
should  be  slushed  and  broomed  with  a  thin  cement  grout,  following  this 
immediately  with  a  zvet  mortar  made  of  1  part  cement  and  2^2  parts  sand 
or  granite  screenings  and  of  the  full  thickness  required  (not  less  than 
*/2-in.  thick,  however).  When  this  mortar  begins  to  take  its  initial  set, 
it  should  be  floated  or  troweled  to  such  a  finish  as  may  be  desired." 

Mr.  P.  C.  Newbegin  (Bangor  &  Aroostook)  : — Referring  to  Con- 
clusion 4  as  to  the  methods  of  repairing  defective  or  worn  surfaces  of 
concrete,  I  ask  why  in  one  case  the  Committee  recommends  mortar  of 
the  same  standard  as  the  original  structure  and  not  in  the  other? 

Mr.  Tinker: — There  is  no  very  good  reason  for  the  difference,  except 
that  in  the  case  of  a  horizontal  surface  there  is  not  the  tendency  for  the 
mortar  to  fall  off  that  there  is  on  a  vertical  surface.  In  both  cases  a 
very  rich  mortar  is  not  successful.  It  cracks  too  much.  Therefore,  we 
limit  it  to  1  to  2T/2.  There  is  less  cracking  and  less  shrinkage  if  the 
two  mortars  are  of  the  same  consistency. 

(Conclusion  4  was  adopted  as  presented.) 

Mr.  Tinker: — "(5)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  vertical 
or  sloping  face  and  is  to  be  more  than  1^2  in.  thick,  it  will  be  advisable 
to  embed  dowels  into  the  old  concrete,  as  deeply  as  the  thickness  of  the 
proposed  patch,  and  spaced  sufficiently  close  together  to  firmly  anchor  the 
patch  to  the  old  concrete.  The  dowels  must  be  wedged  into  the  old 
concrete  and  it  will  be  advisable  to  fasten  wires,  metal  fabric  or  bars  to 
the  dowels,  in  the  case  of  extensive  patching,  as  an  additional  safeguard. 
The  patching  may  then  be  done  with  mortar  without  forms,  or  with  wet 


992  MASONRY. 

concrete  supported  by  forms,  depending  upon  the  thickness  and  the  ex- 
tent of  the  patch. 

"(6)  If  the  repair  or  patch  is  to  be  made  on  a  horizontal  or  nearly 
horizontal  face  and  of  considerable  thickness,  dowels  may  be  used,  or 
the  concrete  may  simply  be  reinforced  by  fabric  or  bars  without  using 
dowels — treating  the  patch  as  a  block  of  masonry." 

Mr.  A.  W.  Carpenter  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — Does 
paragraph  6  refer  to  patches  more  than  V/2  inches  thick?  The  preced- 
ing paragraph  refers  to  a  patch  more  than  il/2  inches  thick.  Paragraph 
6  does  not  give  any  definite  thickness. 

Mr.  Tinker : — This  refers  more  especially  to  a  rather  thick  block  of 
concrete,  in  the  nature  of  a  replaced  bridge  seat,  which  might  be  from  6 
inches  to  2  feet  thick.  In  that  case  it  goes  a  little  outside  of  the  designa- 
tion of  a  patch. 

Mr.  E.  V.  Smith  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  notice  that  in  paragraphs 
5  and  6  there  is  no  mention  of  the  size  of  the  dowel  or  the  number  of 
dowels  to  be  put  in.     I  ask  the  Committee  if  they  considered  that? 

Mr.  Tinker: — That  would  be  regulated  by  the  size  of  the  patch,  and 
the  method  to  determine  that  would  be  to  consider  the  cross-section  of 
the  patch  and  the  amount  of  shrinkage  stress  which  could  be  obtained, 
putting  in  dowels  enough  to  withstand  the  shrinkage  stress. 

(Conclusion  6  was  adopted  as  presented.) 

Mr.  Tinker: — "(7)  Care  must  be  taken  not  to  have  thin  edges  on 
patches.  To  avoid  this,  it  may  be  necessary  to  cut  out  sound  concrete 
around  a  place  to  be  patched,  so  as  to  give  deep  edges  to  the  patch.  If 
possible,  the  edges  should  be  undercut." 

(Conclusion  7  was  adopted  as  presented.) 

Mr.  Tinker: — The  second  subject  upon  which  we  present  conclu- 
sions is  upon   "Methods  of  Depositing  Concrete  Under  Water." 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis)  :— Mr. 
President,  pardon  me,  but  before  we  take  up  the  consideration  of  methods 
of  depositing  concrete  under  water,  I  wish  to  ask  the  Committee  a  few 
questions  relating  to  this  matter  of  patching  concrete.  I  want  to  know 
if  the  Committee  has  made  any  investigation  of  the  different  patented 
methods  that  are  being  so  extensively  advertised,  and  I  refer  especially 
to  one  which  seems  to  be  a  modification  of  what  is  known  as  the  old  rust 
joint,  a  mixture  of  emery  grindings,  Portland  cement  and  salamoniac. 
The  percentages,  I  believe,  are  about  49  of  iron  filings,  49  of  Portland 
cement  and  2  of  salamoniac.  The  mixture  has  been  patented,  and  the 
manufacturers  are  endeavoring  to  sell  it  at  the  rate  of  5  cents  a  pound. 
They  produce  samples  of  the  effects  and  efficiency  of  the  method,  and  I 
want  to  know  if  that  method,  or  any  other  of  the  various  mixtures,  have 
been  brought  to  the  attention  of  the  Committee,  and  whether  they  gave 
them  consideration  and  decided  to  turn  them  all  down. 

Mr.  Tinker:— This  Committee  has  not  considered  definitely  mixtures 
of  that  kind,  perhaps  for  the  reason  that  the  attention  of  the  Committee 


DISCUSSION.  993 

was  not  called  to  them,  at  least  until  after  the  report  had  been  formu- 
lated. 

I  may  say,  in  general,  that  the  Committee  is  inclined  to  frown  on 
patented  mixtures.  The  Committee  does  not  believe  in  them.  In  this  part 
of  our  report  we  refer  to  the  patching  of  concrete.  The  mixture  to  which 
Mr.  McDonald  has  referred  is  in  the  nature  of  a  foreign  substance  which 
is  placed  upon  the  concrete.  It  is  not,  strictly,  a  patch.  There  are  a  num- 
ber of  substances  which  can  be  made  to  adhere  to  the  surface  of  con- 
crete and  produce  a  different  finish.  For  instance,  on  a  concrete  floor, 
there  are  a  number  of  substances  which  will  make  a  more  or  less  orna- 
mental finish,  but  they  are  not  strictly  patches.  The  idea  of  a  patch  is 
that  a  concrete  surface  which  is  either  imperfect  or  broken,  must  have 
its  surface  restored,  by  putting  a  patch  of  concrete  upon  it. 

Referring  to  the  patent  mixtures,  this  particular  mixture,  as  has  been 
said,  is  about  one-half  Portland  cement,  about  one-half  iron  filings  and  a 
small  percentage  of  salamoniac,  all  comparatively  cheap  materials,  and 
it  is  being  sold  at  five  cents  a  pound.  If  the  cost  of  Portland  cement  by 
the  pound  is  computed  it  will  be  seen  that  the  cost  of  this  mixture  at  five 
cents  a  pound  figures  out  about  15  times  the  cost  of  Portland  cement. 
That  may  be  one  reason  why  we  did  not  consider  it.  Portland  cement 
is  plenty  good  enough. 

Mr.  McDonald : — I  did  not  know  that  the  Committee  expected  this 
section  to  be  confined  to  the  method  of  patching  concrete  with  concrete. 
If  they  are  convinced  that  they  have  arrived  at  the  best  method  of  patch- 
ing concrete  and  the  plan  they  propose  is  all  right  and  will  work  in 
all  cases,  then  I  think  the  Committee's  report  is  proper.  On  the  other 
hand,  if  there  are  patented  methods  of  patching  worn  places  in  concrete 
surfaces  that  are  superior  to  the  method  recommended  by  the  Commit- 
tee, I  think  we  ought  to  know  it  whether  they  are  patented  or  not. 

Mr.  L.  G.  Curtis  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  inquire  if  the  Committee 
has  made  any  use  of  what  is  known  as  Ransomite  for  the  preparation  of 
the  surface  of  concrete  before  the  application  of  the  new  surface  is  made. 
The  Baltimore  &  Ohio  has  used  a  great  deal  of  it,  with  good  success,  so 
far  as  my  information  and  experience  goes,  and  I  would  like  to  inquire 
as  to  that  point. 

Mr.  Tinker : — In  the  abstracts  of  the  replies  to  our  circular  which  we 
give  in  the  report,  there  will  be  found  a  number  of  methods  recommended 
for  preparing  the  surface  of  the  concrete,  one  of  which  is  the  acid  method, 
which  is  a  good  method.  I  understand  that  the  use  of  the  Ransomite 
mixture  is  an  acid  method  of  treating  the  surface  of  the  concrete.  The 
Committee  has  said  nothing  about  that  in  the  conclusions.  It  is  referred 
to  in  the  preliminary  discussion.  The  Committee  recommends,  as  the  best 
method,  the  use  of  a  steam  jet. 

The  President : — We  will  now  proceed  to  the  consideration  of  the 
methods   of  depositing  concrete   under  water. 

Mr.  Tinker :— Five  items  were  considered  under  this  head :  Methods 
used  for  depositing  concrete ;  depth  of  water ;  results ;  precautions  neces- 


994  MASONRY. 

sary  to  secure  desired  results  ;  statement  of  the  cost  of  plant  and  relative 
cost  of  depositing  concrete  per  cubic  yard. 

Upon  the  last  item  not  much  information  was  obtained,  for  the  rea- 
son that  many  railroads  do  not  have  these  costs.  The  -work  is  often 
done  by  contract  and  the  cost  is  not  available,  and  if  the  work  is  done 
by  the  company  forces,  the  cost  is  often  obscured,  so  that  it  is  not  easily 
obtained.  There  is  some  little  information  upon  this  point  which  will  be 
found  in  the  abstracts  of  the  replies. 

"(i)  Concrete  may  be  deposited  successfully  under  water,  if  so 
handled  as  to  prevent  the  washing  of  the  cement  from  the  mixture. 

"(2)  Cofferdams  should  be  sufficiently  tight  to  prevent  current 
through  the  pit,  and  the  water  in  the  pit  should  be  quiet. 

"(3)  The  concrete  should  be  deposited  in  place  either  by  means  of 
a  drop-bottom  bucket  or  a  tremie,  and  should  not  be  allowed  to  fall 
through  the  water." 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — 'Does  that 
section  exclude  all  the  other  methods,  confining  us  to  the  drop-bottom 
bucket  or  a  tremie? 

Mr.  Tinker : — It  does  not  exclude  the  other  methods.  There  are 
situations  where  the  other  methods  may  be  used,  but  we  do  recommend, 
from  the  information  received,  especially  for  a  work  of  magnitude,  that 
these  two  methods  are  preferable.  One  of  these  methods  may  be  pre- 
ferred in  one  case  and  the  other  method  in  another  case. 

Mr.  Lindsay  :<— I  had  in  mind  some  work  on  a  bridge,  where  we  had 
riprap  that  was  torn  loose,  and  we  put  the  concrete  down  dry,  in  sacks, 
in  sixteen  feet  of  water,  with  quite  a  strong  current  flowing,  and  got  very 
good  results. 

Mr.  Tinker: — "(4)  Where  a  bucket  is  used,  it  should  be  carefully  low- 
ered to  the  bottom  and  raised  to  the  surface,  so  as  to  cause  as  little  disturb- 
ance as  possible  of  the  water. 

"(5)  Where  a  tremie  is  used,  it  should  be  kept  filled  with  concrete 
up  to  the  top  of  the  water  level,  and  the  discharge  end  should  be  kept 
buried  in  the  freshly  deposited  mass  to  prevent  emptying,  and  raised  a 
few  inches  at  a  time  as  the  filling  progresses. 

"(6)  The  surface  of  the  concrete  must  be  kept  as  nearly  level  as 
possible  to  avoid  the  formation  of  pockets  which  will  retain  laitance  and 
sediment. 

"(7)  Where  concrete  is  not  deposited  continuously,  all  sediment 
should  be  removed  from  the  surface  of  the  concrete,  by  pumping  or  other- 
wise, before  depositing  fresh  concrete. 

"(8)  The  concrete  should  be  a  1:2:4  mixture  and  of  a  'quaking' 
consistency." 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs  (Consulting  Engineer)  : — If  conclusion  No.  1  is  re- 
tained, should  it  be  necessary  to  specify  the  exact  mixture  in  No.  8,  and. 
would  it  not  be  possible  in  some  cases  to  use  a  leaner  mixture? 

Mr.  Tinker : — It  is  undoubtedly  true  that  concrete  of  a  different  mix- 
ture, or  leaner  mixture,   might  be   successfully  used.     The  danger,  with 


DISCUSSION.  W5 

concrete  under  water  is  that  some  of  the  cement  will  be  washed  out,  and 
for  that  reason  the  mixture  should  be  fairly  rich.  The  Committee  thought 
i  :2 :4  is   fairly   rich,   and  perhaps   not  too   rich. 

"(9)     Freshly   deposited   concrete   should  not  be  disturbed. 

"(10)  Where  the  flow  of  water  through  the  pit  cannot  be  prevented, 
concrete  should  be  deposited  in  cloth  sacks." 

Mr.  E.  E.  R.  Tratman  (Engineering  News)  : — The  wording  of  con- 
clusion No.  10  does  not  seem  to  cover  work  which  is  done  in  open 
water.  The  use  of  the  words  "through  the  pit"  seems  to  imply  work  done 
in  a  cofferdam.  A  large  amount  of  work,  both  on  the  lakes  and  the  sea- 
coast,  is  done  in  open  water,  such  as  pier  and  harbor  work.  I  would 
suggest  the  words  "in  open  water  or''  be  prefixed  to  the  present  con- 
clusion, so  that  it  will  read,  "In  open  water  or  where  the  flow  of  water," 
etc. 

(On  motion,  duly  carried,  the  conclusions  were  adopted  as  a  whole.) 

Mr.  Tinker : — The  Joint  Committee  on  Reinforced  Concrete  expected 
to  have  a  final  report  in  print  at  this  time,  but  it  has  not  yet  been  pub- 
lished. The  Joint  Committee  on  Uniform  Specifications  for  Cement  had 
several  meetings  and  finally  failed  to  agree.  The  Departmental  Commit- 
tee of  the  Government  has  adopted  a  specification,  and  the  American 
Society  of  Civil   Engineers  has  adopted   its  own   specification. 

The  work  of  this  Committee  was  brought  to  a  close  too  late  to  do 
anything  more  than  make  a  statement  of  it  in  the  report.  It  would  be 
desirable  to  have  the  Committee  take  the  subject  up  for  further  considera- 
tion and  make  a  report  next  year. 

That  covers  the  work  of  the  Committee,  and  we  ask  that  the  con- 
clusions adopted  be  printed  in  the  Manual  under  Rule  16-g. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President : — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the 
Association  and  commended  for  their  excellent  work. 


DISCUSSION  ON  RECORDS  AND  ACCOUNTS. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  505-507.) 
LIST   OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART   IN    DISCUSSION    ON    RECORDS    AND    ACCOUNTS/ 

H.  J.   Pfeifer. 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Records  and  Accounts,  of  which  Mr.  H.  J.  Pfeifer  is  Chairman.  The 
Chairman  will  make  the  preliminary  statement. 

Mr.  H.  J.  Pfeifer  (Terminal  Railroad  Association  of  St.  Louis)  : — 
The  Committee  was  directed  to  make  comprehensive  studies  of  the 
forms  in  the  Manual,  and  of  the  economical  way  of  managing  a  store- 
house. We  recommend  no  changes  in  the  Manual.  The  Committee 
devoted  practically  all  of  its  time  to  the  study  of  the  storehouse  propo- 
sition. The  first  question  that  presented  itself  was :  Should  the  Com- 
mittee study  only  the  internal  economy  of  the  storehouse,  or  should  it 
also  take  into  consideration  its  relation  to  the  other  departments  of 
the  railroad?  From  the  standpoint  of  Maintenance  of  Way  Depart- 
ment, it  seemed  that  the  latter  view  was  the  correct  one.  The  Com- 
mittee offers  its  conclusions  shown  on  page  506,  and  I  move  their 
adoption. 

"It  is  recommended — 

"(1)  That  no  changes  be  made  in  the  forms  appearing  in  the 
Manual. 

"(2)  That  the  following  statement  embodies  the  general  principles 
governing  the   economical   management   of   a   railway   storehouse: 

"Reasons  for  Maintaining  a  Storehouse. — The  object  of  a  store- 
house is  to  provide  material  and  tools  when  required  so  that  the  cost 
of  work  may  be  a  minimum,  bearing  in  mind  the  factors  of  delay  to 
work  or  labor,  also  interest  on  investment  in  stock. 

"The   following  essential  elements   enter  into  the  problem: 

"(a)  Standardization. — The  standardization  of  materials  and  in- 
structions in  regard  to  their  use  will  reduce  to  a  minimum  the  number 
of  items  of  material  of  the  various  classes  which  should  be  carried  in 
stock.  The  amount  of  each  item  which  should  be  carried  in  stock  will 
depend  upon  the  rate  of  consumption,  time  required  for  the  purchase 
and  delivery  of  material,  and  also  upon  local  conditions. 

"(b)  Classification  of  Material. — This  is  necessary  so  as  to  re- 
duce to  a  minimum  the  cost  and  time  of  handling.  An  approved 
classification  should  be  followed  in  making  requisitions. 

"(c)  Stock  Account.— An  account  should  be  kept  of  stock  show- 
ing  at   all  times   a   record   of   receipts,    disbursements    and   amount   on 

996 


DISCUSSION.  997 

hand.  Stock  should  be  replenished  when  the  amount  of  any  item  has 
been  reduced  to  a  fixed  minimum.  Inventories  should  be  made  at 
stated  periods.  A  proper  stock  account  furnishes  a  check  on  excessive 
supply  and   obsolete   material. 

"(d)  Distribution. — When  material  is  shipped,  notice  should  be 
sent  to  consignee  showing  partial  or  complete  filling  of  requisition  and, 
if  partial,  when  final  shipment  may  be  expected. 

"(e)  Organization. — The  storekeeper's  place  in  the  general  or- 
ganization should  be  so  fixed  and  adjusted  that  the  measure  of  his 
efficiency  is,  primarily,  the  promptness  and  accuracy  with  which  he  fills 
requisitions,  and,  secondly,  his  ability  to  hold  down  the  stock  invest- 
ment to  the  lowest  amount  consistent  with  the  first  requirement." 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President : — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  ELECTRICITY. 

(For   Report,    see   pp.    509-558.) 
LIST  OF  SPEAKERS  TAKING  PART  IN  DISCUSSION  ON  ELECTRICITY. 

J.  R.  W.  Ambrose.  J.  B.  Jenkins.  G.  A.  Mountain. 

F.  J.  Bachelder.  E.  B.  Katte.  H.  J.  Pfeifer. 

W.  S.  Bouton.  George  W.  Kittredge.     A.  F.  Robinson. 

R.  D.  Coombs.  J.  H.  Milburn.  Earl  Stimson. 

L.  C.  Fritch. 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Elec- 
tricity, of  which  Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge  is  Chairman. 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — 
This  Committee,  following  out  the  instructions  of  the  Board  of  Direction, 
has  carried  to  a  conclusion  two  recommendations,  the  question  of  clear- 
ances, and  transmission  line  crossings. 

The  Committee  felt,  until  quite  late  in  the  year  last  past,  that  it  was 
going  to  have  difficulty  in  presenting  conclusions  on  these  two  subjects, 
which  would  be  satisfactory,  and  it  was  only  at  the  very  last  meeting 
that  the  matter  was  cleared  up  in  such  a  way  as  to  enable  us  to  unite  in 
making  reports  which  v/e  believe  will  be  acceptable  to  the  Association  and 
the  public  generally. 

Our  recommendations  are  contained  on  page  511.  I  move  the  defini- 
tion of  "Third  Rail  Gage,"  reading  as  follows,  be  adopted  and  inserted 
in  the  Manual : 

"(1)     Definition:     'Third  Rail  Gage.     Distance  measured  parallel  to 
plane  of  top  of  both  running  rails  between  gage  of  nearest  running  rail 
and  inside  gage  line  of  third  rail.' " 
(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Kittredge : — 'The  second  recommendation  is  the  adoption  of  the 
lines  shown  on  diagram  "A"  as  equipment  clearance  lines. 
I  move  the  adoption  of  recommendation  2. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Jenkins  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  :— I  understand  that  Mr.  Mil- 
burn,  of  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio,  has  something  to  say  on  that  recommenda- 
tion. 

Mr.  J.  H.  Milburn  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — In  taking  up  the  question 
of  clearance  for  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  System,  and  trying  to  establish  a 
standard  for  our  use,  I  considered  the  diagram  as  presented  by  this  Com- 
mittee, and  found  that  the  line  which  is  represented  on  this  diagram  as 
suggested  for  design  of  equipment  was  a  line  that,  if  adhered  to,  would 
put  out  of  business  some  of  the  rolling  stock  which  we  have  to  handle, 
not  only  of  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio,  but  of  other  companies.  Our  third 
rail  is  a  short  distance  above  the  running  rail  and  level  top  contact,  and 

998 


DISCUSSION.  999 

we  have  had  cases  where  rolling  stock  has  injured  the  corner  of  the 
covering  of  the  third  rail,  which  is  some  distance  outside  of  the  lines 
proposed  here  for  third  rail  construction.  I  had  no  intention  of  making 
any  remarks  on  this,  but  being  called  to  the  floor  I  have  said  what  I 
did  because  I  think  this  diagram  is  prett\  liberal  from  a  third  rail  point 
of  view  and  not  quite  as  liberal  as  it  should  be  from  a  motive-power 
point  of  view. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — The  Baltimore  &  Ohio 
is  represented  both  on  this  Committee  and  on  the  Committee  of  Clear- 
ances of  the  American  Railway  Association,  so  that  any  objections  which 
the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  had  were  taken  under  consideration.  I  do  not 
know  whether  the  Chairman  has  stated  that  this  diagram  will  also  be 
presented  to  the  American  Railway  Association,  by  its  Committee,  at  the 
next  meeting  of  that  Association,  so  that  if  this  Association  adopts  this 
clearance  diagram  it  will  be  in  harmony  with  the  American  Railway 
Association  report. 

Mr.  W.  S.  Bouton  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  ask  if  the  diagram  which 
goes  below  the  top  of  the  rail  conflicts  with  the  timber  guard  rail  on 
bridges  ? 

Mr.  Kittredge : — The  diagram  shows  that  the  clearance  for  equipment 
does  not  come  below  the  timber  guard  rail.  We  are  discussing  the  clear- 
ance line  for  the  design  of  equipment. 

(The  recommendation  was  adopted  as  printed.) 

Mr.  Kittredge: — "(3)  The  lines  shown  on  diagram  'A'  as  permanent 
way  structure  adjacent  to  third  rail  clearance  lines. 

"(4)  The  lines  shown  on  diagram  'A'  as  third  rail  structure  clear- 
ance lines. 

"(5)  The  adoption  of  the  specifications  for  overhead  crossings  of 
electric  light  and  power  lines." 

I  want  to  say  a  word  or  two  in  regard  to  this  report  and  to  lay 
before  the  Association  the  matter  as  it  stands  at  the  present  time.  Within 
the  last  four  months  the  four  Associations — the  National  Electric  Light 
Association,  the  American  Institute  of  Electrical  Engineers,  the  American 
Electric  Railway  Association  and  the  Association  of  Railway  Telegraph 
Superintendents — acting  jointly,  have  made  a  report  which  corresponds 
very  nearly  with  the  report  of  your  Committee.  There  are  differences 
between  the  report  of  the  Joint  Committee  of  these  four  Associations 
and  our  report  in  paragraphs  10,  13,  18,  24,  29,  31,  32,  34,  45,  49,  51,  55, 
60  and  61.  In  some  of  these  paragraphs  the  changes  are  simply  those  of 
words.  In  one  case  the  word  "practicable"  is  used  for  the  word  "pos- 
sible," and  in  another  place  where  it  says  "Treated  poles  are  recom- 
mended," it  really  means  that  where  wooden  poles  are  to  be  used,  they 
shall  be  treated.  In  all  cases  of  difference  the  phraseology  in  our 
report  is  the  better,  we  think. 

The  reason  it  pleases  me  to  dwell  so  much  on  this  subject  is  that  it 
is  a  very  great  advantage  to  have  a  report  which  will  be  accepted  and 


1000  ELECTRICITY. 

acknowledged  by  the  principal  societies,  associations  and  companies  inter- 
ested. As  it  is  now,  particularly  in  the  State  of  New  York,  the  railways 
can  control  the  crossings  over  their  rights-of-way,  but  they  have,  very 
little  to  say  about  crossings  which  occur  in  highways.  The  crossing  com- 
panies have  rights  which  apparently  are  co-extensive  with  those  of  the 
railways  and  almost  any  old  thing  does  for  a  crossing  in  a  highway.  It 
is,  of  course,  very  desirable,  in  the  first  place,  that  we  get  safety,  and  in 
the  second  place  good  construction  at  highways  as  well  as  at  private  cross- 
ings. 

We  believe  that  if  we  will  accept  their  report,  using  their  phraseology, 
we  will  be  in  a  very  much  better  condition  than  if  we  do  not.  Some  of  the 
members  of  the  Joint  Committee  were  brought  into  line  only  after  a 
great  deal  of  hard  work  and  they  have  shown  a  disposition  to  negative 
their  whole  joint  work  and  let  things  stand  as  they  are  at  the  present 
time,  if  this  Association  does  not  accept  specifications  which  are  the  same 
as  theirs.  How  much  truth  there  is  in  that  and  what  would  actually 
happen  is  only  a  matter  of  conjecture.  It  is  therefore  a  question  of 
policy  whether  or  not  in  matters  of  secondary  importance  we  shall  accept 
their  figures  and  specifications  rather  than  our  own. 

The  President : — We  will  now  take  up  the  "Specifications  for  Over- 
head Crossings  of  Electric  Light  and  Power  Lines,"  by  paragraphs.  If 
Mr.  Osgood  is  present,  we  will  be  glad  to  have  him  enter  into  the  dis- 
cussion. 

The  Secretary: — "i.  Scope.  These  specifications  shall  apply  to  over- 
head electric  light  and  power  line  crossings  (except  trolley  contact  wires), 
over  railroad  right-of-way,  tracks,  or  lines  of  wires;  and,  further,  these 
specifications  shall  apply  to  overhead  electric  light  and  power  wires  of 
over  5,000  volts  constant  potential,  crossing,  or  constructed  over  tele- 
phone, telegraph  or  other  similar  lines. 

"2.  Location.  The  poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span 
preferably  shall  be  outside  the  railroad  company's  right-of-way. 

"3.  Unusually  long  crossing  spans  shall  be  avoided  wherever  prac- 
ticable. 

"4.  The  poles,  or  towers,  shall  be  located  as  far  as  practicable  from 
inflammable  material  or  structures. 

"5.  The  poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span,  and  the  ad- 
joining span  on  each  side,  preferably  shall  be  in  a  straight  line. 

"6.  The  wires,  or  cables,  shall  cross  over  telegraph,  telephone  and 
similar  wires  wherever  practicable. 

"7.     Cradles,  or  overhead  bridges,  shall  not  be  used. 

"8.  Clearance.  The  side  clearance  shall  be  not  less  than  12  feet  from 
the  nearest  rail  of  main-line  track,  nor  less  than  6  feet  from  the  nearest 
rail  of  sidings.  At  loading  sidings  sufficient  space  shall  be  left  for  a 
driveway. 

"9.  The  clear  headroom  shall  be  not  less  than  30  feet  above  the  top 
of  rail  under  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  temperature  and  loading. 


DISCUSSION.  1001 

For  constant  potential,  direct-current  circuits,  not  exceeding  750  volts 
when  paralleled  by  trolley  contact  wires,  the  clear  headroom  need  not  ex- 
ceed 25  feet." 

Mr.  G.  A.  Mountain  (Canadian  Railway  Commission)  :— I  ask  the 
Committee  in  that  connection  what  they  do  with  trolley  wires.  I  see 
they  except  trolley  contacts  in  clause  1 ;  with  reference  to  the  clearance 
of  25  feet,  have  they  any  recommendation  to  make  on  that? 

Mr.  Kittredge: — We  have  no  recommendation  about  that. 

The  Secretary : — "10.  The  clearance  of  alternating-current  circuits 
above  any  existing  wires,  under  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  temper- 
ature and  loading,  shall  be  not  less  than  8  feet  wherever  practicable.  For 
constant  potential,  direct-current  circuits,  not  exceeding  750  volts,  the 
minimum  clearance  above  telegraph,  telephone  and  similar  wires  may  be 
2  feet  with  insulated  wires  and  4  feet  with  bare  wires. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — The  only  difference  in  this  paragraph  and  that  of 
the  joint  report  is  the  word  "practicable"  in  the  third  line.  The  joint 
report  uses  the  word  "possible." 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs  (Consulting  Engineer)  : — As  I  understand  it,  the 
request  of  the  Committee  is  that  the  Joint  Committee  report  be  adopted 
in  order  to  conform  to  what  has  already  been  done  by  the  other  asso- 
ciations and  by  the  Telephone  and  Telegraph  Companies. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — I  would  move,  for  the  sole  purpose  of  getting  a 
contract  which  is  similar  in  all  respects,  that  we  adopt  the  word  "pos- 
sible" instead  of  the  word  "practicable."  We  think  that  the  advantages 
to  be  derived  from  having  a  uniform  contract  in  this  particular  outweigh 
the  disadvantages  of  having  one  in  which  one  word  is  not  as  good  as  some 
other  word. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — '"11.  The  separation  of  conductors  carrying  alter- 
nating current,  supported  by  pin  insulators,  for  spans  not  exceeding  150 
feet,  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Separation. 

Not  exceeding  6,600  volts - 14^  in. 

Exceeding    6,600,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 24      in. 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000 30     in. 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35.000 36     in. 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 45      in. 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  70,000 60      in. 

"For  spans  exceeding  150  feet  the  pin  spacing  should  be  increased, 
depending  upon  the  length  of  the  span  and  the  sag  of  the  conductors. 

"Note. — (This  requirement  does  not  apply  to  wires  of  the  same  phase 
or  polarity  between  which  there  is  no  difference  of  potential. 

"With  constant  potential,  direct-current  circuits  not  exceeding  750 
volts,  the  minimum  spacing  shall  be  10  in." 

Mr.  H.  J.  Pfeifer  (Terminal  Railroad  Association  of  St.  Louis)  : — 
I  notice  that  the  maximum  line  voltage  is  70,000  volts.     The  Terminal 


1002  ELECTRICITY. 

Railroad  Association  now  has  an  application  for  a  crossing  over  its  right- 
of-way,  carrying  100,000  volts.  I  would  like  to  know  what  provision 
should  be  made  in  a  case  of  that  kind. 

Mr.  Kittredge :— The  Committee  has  not  discussed  that.  It  might 
come  up  for  discussion  next  year. 

Mr.  J.  R.  W.  Ambrose  (Grand  Trunk)  : — I  was  just  going  to  bring 
up  the  same  point.    We  have  several  crossings  to-day  of  110,000  volts. 

The  President: — That  seems  to  be  a  subject  for  further  considera- 
tion on  the  part  of  the  Committee. 

The  Secretary: — "12.  When  supported  by  insulators  of  the  disc  or 
suspension  type,  the  crossing  span  and  the  next  adjoining  spans  shall  be 
dead-ended  at  the  poles,  or  towers,  supporting  the  crossing  span,  so  that 
at  these  poles,  or  towers,  the  insulators  shall  be  used  as  strain  insulators. 

"13.  The  clearance  in  any  direction  between  the  conductors  nearest 
the  pole,  or  tower,  and  the  pole  or  tower  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Clearance. 

Not  exceeding  10,000  volts 9  in. 

Exceeding  10,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 12  in. 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000 15  in. 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  35,000 18  in. 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 21  in. 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  70,000 24  in. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — That  paragraph  varies  from  the  report  of  the  Joint 
Committee  as  shown  on  page  522  in  that  our  report  contains  one  more 
division.  The  Joint  Committee's  report,  first  line,  says,  "not  exceeding 
14,000  volts,  9  inches."  We  have  "not  exceeding  10,000  volts,  9  inches,-' 
"exceeding  10,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000,  12  inches."  After  discus- 
sion, and  for  the  reasons  indicated  in  discussing  paragraph  10,  your  Com- 
mittee recommends  the  adoption  of  paragraph  13,  as  shown  on  page  522, 
and  I  so  move. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "14.  Conductors.  The  normal  mechanical  tension 
in  the  conductors  generally  shall  be  the  same  in  the  crossing  span  and  in 
the  adjoining  span  on  each  side,  and  the  difference  in  length  of  the  cross- 
ing and  adjoining  spans  generally  shall  be  not  more  than  50  per  cent,  of 
the  length  of  the  crossing  span. 

"15.  The  conductors  shall  not  be  spliced  in  the  crossing  span  nor  in 
the  adjoining  span  on  either  side. 

"16.  The  method  of  supporting  the  conductors  at  the  poles,  or  towers, 
shall  be  such  as  to  hold  the  wires,  under  maximum  loading,  to  the  sup- 
porting structures,  in  case  of  shattered  insulators,  or  wires  broken  or 
burned  at  an  insulator,  without  allowing  an  amount  of  slip  which  would 
materially  reduce  the  clearance  specified  in  paragraphs  Nos.  9  and  10. 

"17.  Guys.  Wooden  poles  supporting  the  crossing  span  shall  be  side- 
fcuyed   in   both   directions   if  practicable,   and  be   head-guyed   away    from 


DISCUSSION.  1003 

the  crossing  span.  The  next  adjoining  poles  shall  be  head-guyed  in  both 
directions. 

"18.  Strain  insulators  shall  be  used  in  guys  from  wooden  poles  carry- 
ing any  power  wire  of  less  than  6,600  volts,  provided  the  guys  are  not 
through  grounded  to  permanently  damp  earth.  Strain  insulators  shall  not 
be  used  in  guying  steel  structures,  nor  required  on  wooden  poles  carrying 
wires,  all  of  which  are  6,600  volts  or  more,  provided  the  guys  are  through 
grounded  to  permanently  damp  earth." 

Mr.  Kittredge: — This  paragraph  varies  from  the  paragraph  of  the  Joint 
Committee  in  that  beginning  on  the  second  line  we  have  inserted  the 
words,  "Provided  the  guys  are  not  through  grounded  to  permanently 
damp  earth,"  and  at  the  end  of  the  paragraph  we  have  added  the  words 
"provided  the  guys  are  through  grounded  to  permanently  damp  earth." 

This  paragraph  is  so  important  that  we  could  not  change  it.  In  a 
conference  which  lasted  over  an  hour,  Mr.  Osgood,  the  Chairman  of  the 
Joint  Committee,  led  me  to  believe,  in  fact  he  finally  told  me,  that  he 
would  undertake  to  have  his  associates  adopt  No.  18  as  written  by  us 
provided  we  would  adopt  the  others  as  written  by  him.  I  move  the 
adoption  of  paragraph  18  as  written  here. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs : — I  assume  that  this  would  be  the  proper  time  to 
read  a  letter  to  the  Association  on  behalf  of  the  Joint  Committee.  The 
Joint  Committee  was  organized  by  placing  on  the  Committee  of  the 
National  Electric  Light  Association  the  Chairman  of  the  corresponding 
committee  of  each  of  the  associations  interested,  so  that  one  Committee 
could  do  the  work,  and  therefore,  when  we  speak  of  the  Committee  of  the 
National  Electric  Light  Association,  it  refers  to  the  Joint  Committee  and 
their  report. 

The  letter  which  I  shall  now  read  for  Mr.  Farley  Osgood  was  written 
before  the  action  of  the  Committee  to-day  was  known : 

"The  action  of  the  Committee  on  Electricity  of  the  American  Rail- 
way Engineering  and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association  in  not  unanimously 
approving  and  formally  recommending  for  adoption  the  Overhead  Cross- 
ing Specification,  as  drawn  by  the  Joint  Committee  appointed  for  that 
purpose,  leads  me,  as  Chairman  of  the  Joint  Committee,  to  call  to  your 
attention  some  important  facts  concerning  the  specification  and  action 
on  the  same  by  other  Associations  in  the  hope  that  the  matter  may  be 
reconsidered  by  your  Association,  with  a  view  of  establishing  this  year 
a  national  standard  specification  for  crossings  of  overhead  lines,  which 
will  become  a  fact  if  your  Association,  also  a  participant  in  the  formula- 
tion of  the  work,  and  the  last  one  to  act,  and  the  only  one  up-to-date  to 
disagree,  can  so  adjust  its  desires  concerning  changes  in  the  specification, 
as  to  make  it  possible  for  them  to  adopt  it  now,  as  written,  for  the  sake 
of  unanimity  of  action  just  at  this  time. 

"The  specification,  as  written,  has  been  formally  ratified  and  adopted 
by  the  National  Electric  Light  Association ;  American  Institute  of  Elec- 
trical Engineers;  Association  of  Railway  Telegraph  Superintendents; 
Engineering  and  Standards  Committee  of  the  American  Electric  Railway 
Engineering  Association,  the  matter  now  being  up  for  letter  ballot  by  that 
Association,  requiring  under  their  rules  a  delay  of  one  year;  American 


1004  ELECTRICITY. 

Telephone  and  Telegraph  Company ;  Western  Union  Telegraph  Company ; 
Postal  Telegraph-Cable  Company.  The  Sub-committee  on  Crossings 
of  the  Committee  on  Electricity  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering 
and  Maintenance  of  Way  Association  has  recommended  the  adoption  of 
the  specification  to  the  general  Committee  on  Electricity. 

"In  view  of  these  facts,  there  was  not  the  least  doubt  in  anybody's 
mind  as  to  the  formal  adoption  by  the  General  Committee  on  Electricity 
of  the  specification  as  recommended  by  their  own  sub-committee,  whose 
Chairman  was  a  member  of  the  Joint  Committee  which  formulated  the 
specification,  and  we  learn  with  much  regret  that  your  Sub-committee 
Chairman  is  obliged  to  report  that  your  Committee,  even  now,  feel  that 
a  few  changes  should  be  made  before  final  approval  for  adoption. 

"For  convenience  of  discussion  and  examination,  we  attach  hereto 
a  list  of  clauses  of  the  specification  which  were  recommended  by  your 
Committee  for  change,  and  for  convenience  sake,  we  have  listed  both 
the  specification,  as  written,  clauses  and  suggested  changes  in  two  ways ; 
one  of  the  lists  showing  the  changes  written  into  the  clauses  in  red  ink, 
and  the  other  list  showing  the  sections  side  by  side  in  parallel  columns. 

"A  study  of  the  changes  recommended  brings  out  the  rather  remark- 
able fact  that  alterations  are  recommended  in  only  thirteen  paragraphs 
out  of  a  specification  of  some  twenty-eight  printed  pages,  and  the  Joint 
Committee  which  formulated  this  specification  originally  honestly  believes 
that  the  differences  between  the  specification  as  written  and  as  suggested 
are  so  slight,  in  that  they  are  of  no  great  engineering  importance,  that 
on  a  careful  reconsideration  of  this  matter  by  the  Committee  on  Elec- 
tricity, they  may  find  it  possible  to  waive  their  objections  for  the  moment, 
and  recommend  for  formal  adoption  this  specification  as  written,  in  order 
that  all  the  Associations  represented  in  the  Joint  Committee  may  accept 
the  work  and  launch  it  as  a  national  standard. 

"The  Joint  Committee  does  not  feel  that  the  suggested  changes,  as 
indicated  in  the  attached  lists,  are  in  any  way  improper  or  undesirable,  and 
in  fact,  a  number  of  them,  we  believe,  may  improve  the  specification,  espe- 
cially in  clearness  of  expression,  but  do  not  feel  that  the  structural  re- 
sults are  materially  altered,  and  certainly  are  not  sufficiently  changed  to 
be  a  reason  for  preventing  the  universal  adoption  of  the  specification. 

"The  list  of  names  of  the  Joint  Committee  shows  that  the  men  form- 
ing the  same  are  of  very  wide  experience  in  the  field  of  work  under  dis- 
cussion, and  are  representative  of  all  conflicting  interests  in  overhead 
construction  work,  and  the  fact  that  so  many  engineers  have  agreed  upon 
a  specification  mutually  in  Committee,  and  the  fact  that  the  Associations 
and  large  companies  represented  by  these  men  have  approved  the  specifi- 
cation, is  a  very  strong  indication  that  the  specification  must  be  a  good 
one  and  sufficiently  safe  for  our  mutual  purposes,  and  it  is  such  a  great 
improvement  over  anything  which  has  ever  before  been  offered  that  we 
feel  it  our  real  duty  to  ask  you  to  reconsider  this  matter  in  the  broadest 
possible  way,  and  in  fairness  to  the  national  overhead  construction  situ- 
ation, as  a  whole,  which  represents  a  vast  number  of  conflicting  interests 
of  which  the  steam  railroads  are  one,  and  an  important  one,  although 
many  of  the  other  large  interests,  the  Committee  believes,  are  quite  as 
important,  both  from  an  engineering  and  financial  standpoint,  and,  there- 
fore, we  feel  that  their  judgment  in  formally  adopting  the  specification 
drawn  by  their  representatives  should  have  a  great  deal  of  weight  with 
your  Association,  our  last  member  of  the  General  Committee  to  join 
hands  with  us. 

"Our  plea  of  reconsideration  is  made  as  a  matter  of  engineering  pol- 
icy and  in  the  cause  of  a  mutually  broad  and  universal  specification,  which 
you,  of  course,  realize  has  been  the  desire  of  all  parties  interested  in  this 


DISCUSSION.  1005 

matter  for  a  number  of  years,  and  we  most  respectfully  urge  that  your 
Association  adopt  the  Overhead  Crossing  Specification  exactly  as  written. 

"We  would  further  suggest  that  after  your  Association  has  adopted 
this  specification  as  written,  that  it  at  once  make  a  recommendation  to 
the  Joint  Committee  covering  the  changes  it  desires,  in  order  that  the 
Joint  Committee  may  take  them  up  promptly,  having  them  discussed  and 
worked  out  by  the  various  representatives  of  the  interests  concerned,  and 
worked  into  the  specification  at  the  first  opportunity  for  revision  whicli 
presents  itself. 

"The  Joint  Committee  believes  that  this  action  on  the  part  of  your 
Association  will  be  a  healthy  one,  and  as  all  the  representative  parties 
formulating  the  specification  will  have  formally  adopted  the  same,  each 
Association,  or  each  individual  engineer,  will  then  be  in  a  position  to 
criticize  the  specification  in  detail,  and  the  Joint  Committee,  which  is  a 
standing  one,  will  be  in  a  position  to  take  care  of  such  criticisms  formally 
and  effectively,  and  the  results  of  the  use  of  the  specification  in  the  field 
will  thus  become  known  to  the  Joint  Committee,  and  all  desirable  changes 
can  be  made  from  time  to  time,  so  that  eventually  we  should  have  a 
specification  which  will  be  as  perfect  as  a  specification  can  be,  and  having 
started  with  this  one  as  a  sound  base,  each  year's  changes  can  be  worked 
out  from  the  needs  of  the  field  engineers  discovering  weaknesses  in  the 
work  as  it  stands  to-day,  which  method  we  believe  to  be  rational,  and 
quite  the  best  one  from  the  standpoint  of  all  construction  engineers  or 
Associations  affected  by  this  specification." 

The  Secretary : — "19.  Clearing.  The  space  around  the  poles,  or 
towers,  shall  be  kept  free  from  inflammable  material,  underbrush  and 
gras<. 

"20.  Signs.  In  the  case  of  railroad  crossings,  if  required  by  the  rail- 
road company,  warning  signs  of  an  approved  design  shall  be  placed  on  all 
poles  and  towers  located  on  the  railroad  company's  right-of-way. 

"21.  Grounding.  For  voltages  over  5,000  volts,  wooden  crossarms, 
if  used,  shall  be  provided  with  a  grounded  metallic  plate  on  top  of  the 
arm,  which  shall  be  not  less  than  %  inch  in  thickness  and  which  shall 
have  a  sectional  area  and  conductivity  not  less  than  that  of  the  line  con- 
ductor. Metal  pins  shall  be  electrically  connected  to  this  ground.  Metal 
poles  and  metal  arms  on  wooden  poles  shall  be  grounded. 

"22.  The  electrical  conductivity  of  the  ground  conductor  shall  be  ad- 
justed to  the  short-circuit  current  capacity  of  the  system  and  shall  be 
not  less  than  that  of  a  No.  4  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  wire. 

"23.  Temperature.  In  the  computation  of  stresses  and  clearances, 
and  in  erection,  provision  shall  be  made  for  a  variation  in  temperature 
from  — 20  degrees  Fahrenheit  to  +120  degrees  Fahrenheit.  A  suitable 
modification  in  the  temperature  requirements  shall  be  made  for  regions 
in  which  the  above  limits  would  not  fairly  represent  the  extreme  range 
of  temperature. 

"24.  Inspection.  If  required  by  contract,  all  material  and  workman- 
ship shall  be  subject  to  the  inspection  of  the  company  crossed;  provided, 
that  reasonable  notice  of  the  intention  to  make  shop  inspection  shall  be 
given  by  such  company;  if  such  notification  is  not  given,  the  company 
crossed  shall  be  furnished  with  certified  reports  of  shop  inspection  of 
material  and  workmanship  made  by  a  properly  qualified  inspector.     De- 


1006  ELECTRICITY. 

fcctivc  material  shall  be  rejected,  and  shall  be  removed  and  replaced  with 
suitable  material." 

Mr.  Kittredge: — This  is  one  of  the  paragraphs  in  question.  On  the 
fourth  line  it  says :  "If  such  notification  is  not  given,  the  company 
crossed  shall  be  furnished  with  certified  reports  of  shop  inspection  of 
material  and  workmanship  made  by  a  properly  qualified  inspector."  These 
words  do  not  appear  in  the  report  of  the  Joint  Committee,  and  for  the 
reasons  stated  I  move  the  adoption  of  paragraph  24  of  the  Joint  Com- 
mittee report. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "25.  On  the  completion  of  the  work,  all  falsework, 
plant  and  rubbish,  incident  to  the  construction,  shall  be  removed  promptly 
and  the  site  left  unobstructed  and  clean. 

"26.     Drawings.     If  required,  by  contract,   

( )    complete    sets    of    general    and    detail    drawings    shall  •  be    fur- 
nished for  approval,  before  any  construction  is  commenced. 

"27.  The  conductors  shall  be  considered  as  uniformly  loaded  through- 
cut  their  length,  with  a  load  equal  to  the  resultant  of  the  dead  load  plus 
the  weight  of  a  layer  of  ice  Yz  inch  in  thickness,  and  a  wind  pressure  of 
8  lbs.  per  square  foot  on  the  ice-covered  diameter,  at  a  temperature  of 
o  degrees  Fahrenheit." 

Mr.  A.  F.  Robinson  (Santa  Fe)  : — It  seems  to  me  the  provision  for 
load  is  hardly  sufficient ;  when  ice  gathers  on  wires  it  seldom  forms  in  a 
circle,  it  is  oblong  and  hangs  to  one  side  of  the  wire.  That  would  vitiate 
the  use  of  a  wind  pressure  of  8  lbs.  per  square  foot,  because  it  is  strik- 
ing more  nearly  on  a  plane  surface  than  it  would  if  blowing  against  the 
cylinder.  It  also  seems  to  me  it  would  be  better  if  we  could  arrive  at  a 
uniform  load  per  linear  foot,  without  respect  to  the  size  of  the  wire,  size 
of  the  supporting  cable  or  anything  of  that  sort.  It  is  a  matter  of  very 
small  moment  when  you  work  it  out.  If  you  take  a  1  ^4-inch  wire  it 
means  about  1.4  lbs.  per  linear  foot,  and  it  seems  to  me  we  could  cut  nearly 
all  of  that  out  and  put  a  provision  in  that  the  wires  shall  be  figured  for 
10,  15  or  20  lbs.  per  linear  foot,  and  not  say  anything  about  the  ice  or 
anything  of  that  sort. 

I  would  offer  that  as  a  suggestion  for  the  consideration  of  the  Com- 
mittee in  future  revisions  of  the  specification. 

The  Secretary : — "28.  The  weight  of  ice  shall  be  assumed  as  57  lbs. 
per  cubic  foot  (0.033  lbs.  per  cubic  inch). 

"29.  Insulators,  pins  and  conductor  attachments  shall  be  designed  to 
withstand,  with  the  designated  factor  of  safety,  the  tension  in  the  con- 
ductors under  the  maximum  loading,  assuming  the  conductor  to  be  broken 
on  one  side  of  the  structure." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  is  another  paragraph  that  differs  from  the  Joint 
Committee  report,  and  I  move  the  adoption  of  paragraph  29,  of  the  Joint 
Committee  report. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 


DISCUSSION.  1007 

The  Secretary: — "30.  The  pole,  or  towers,  shall  be  designed  to  with- 
stand, with  the  designated  factor  of  safety,  the  combined  stresses  from 
their  own  weight,  the  wind  pressure  on  the  pole,  or  tower,  and  the  above 
wire  loading  on  the  crossing  span  and  the  next  adjoining  span  on  each 
side.  The  wind  pressure  on  the  poles,  or  towers,  shall  be  assumed  at  13 
lbs.  per  square  foot  on  the  projected  area  of  solid  or  closed  structures,  and 
on  \l/2  times  the  projected  area  of  lattice  structures." 

Mr.  Ambrose : — In  designing  your  towers,  should  you  not  assume 
one  span  broken? 

The  President: — Section  31  takes  care  of  that. 

The  Secretary: — "31.  The  poles,  or  towers,  shall  also  be  designed  to 
withstand  the  most  unfavorable  condition  of  the  loads  specified  in  para- 
graph 30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  tension  of 

Two  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  5  wires  or  less. 

Three  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  6  to  10  wires. 

Four  broken  wires  for  poles,  or  towers,  carrying  11  or  more  wires." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — Mr.  Chairman,  this  paragraph  contains  the  words, 
"The  most  unfavorable  condition,"  which  the  paragraph  of  the  Joint  Com- 
mittee does  not  contain.  For  the  reasons  already  stated  I  move  the 
adoption  of  paragraph  31  of  the  Joint  Committee. 

Mr.  E.  B.  Katte  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  :— I  believe 
in  co-operation  and  in  standards,  but  not  in  the  adoption  of  a  standard 
unless  it  is  something  that  is  as  good  as  we  can  make  it.  This  Com- 
mittee has  had  a  little  longer  to  consider  the  specifications  than  the  so- 
called  Joint  Committee,  and  at  the  largest  meeting  that  your  Committee 
on  Electricity  ever  held,  it  was  agreed  to  make  the  modifications  as 
printed  in  the  report.  I  believe  that  it  has  been  generally  admitted  by  all 
of  the  other  committees  that  the  changes  are  good  and  that  they  should 
be  made.  I  have  been  told  that  the  other  committees  would  consider 
these  modifications  and  in  all  probability  would  accept  some,  if  not  all 
cf  them,  at  their  next  meetings.  During  the  months  following  these 
meetings,  if  you  do  not  adopt  the  revised  specifications  we  will  be 
lagging  behind  the  other  associations.  Our  specifications  will  contain 
thirteen  clauses  which  are  improper  or  at  least  ambiguous.  On  the  other 
hand,  if  we  adopt  to-day  the  specifications  as  modified  and  printed  in  your 
Bulletin,  we  will  be  six  months  in  advance.  Next  fall  the  other  asso- 
ciations will,  perhaps,  adopt  the  specifications  that  are  before  you  to-day : 
then  we  will  have  co-operated  in  obtaining  a  joint  standard  specification 
and  one  that  does  not  contain  thirteen  objectionable  clauses. 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs : — I  am  compelled  to  disagree  with  Mr.  Katte,  be- 
cause the  main  argument  for  warning  this  Association  not  to  make  changes 
is  to  obtain  a  uniform  national  standard,  and  the  engineering  differences 
are  so  slight  that  personally  I  do  not  believe  that  construction  will  be 
impaired  during  that  six  months. 

Mr.  Katte : — This  Association  has  already  adopted  one  change,  namely, 
clause  18.     The  specifications  will  not  be  uniform  now.     As  long  as  you 


1008  ELECTRICITY. 

have  made  one  change,  why  not  make  all  the  other  admittedly  desirable 
changes  ? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — There  is  something  to  be  said  on  both  sides  ot 
this  question.  If  we  were  independent  and  could  say,  "We  will  adopt 
our  own  specifications,"  the  chances  are  the  other  associations  would 
throw  them  out,  and  at  about  90  per  cent,  of  the  crossings  we  would 
have  to  take  whatever  they  would  give  us,  and  for  the  sake  of  uniformity, 
I  believe  that  half  a  loaf  is  better  than  none  at  all ;  so  I  think  we  ought 
to  adopt  these  specifications,  with  the  exception  of  clause  18. 

(The  question  was  called  for  and,  on  vote,  duly  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "32.  Crossarms  shall  be  designed  to  withstand  the 
loading  specified  in  paragraph  30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  tension  of 
the  wire,  which,  when  broken,  produces  the  highest  fiber  stress  in  the 
arm." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  paragraph  differs  from  the  Joint  Committee 
report,  in  that  it  uses  the  words,  "which,  when  broken,  produces  the  high- 
est fiber  stress  in  the  arm."  For  the  reasons  already  stated,  I  move  tht 
adoption  of  paragraph  32,  shown  on  page  522  of  the  joint  report. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "33.  The  poles,  or  towers,  may  be  permitted  a  rea- 
sonable deflection  under  the  specified  loading,  provided  that  such  deflection 
does  not  reduce  the  clearances  specified  in  paragraph  No.  10  more  than 
25  per  cent,  or  produce  stresses  in  excess  of  those  specified  in  paragraphs 
Nos.  65  to  69. 

"34.  The  ultimate  unit  stress  divided  by  the  allowable  stress  shall 
be  not  less  than  the  following : 

Wires  and  cables 2 

Pins 2 

Insulators,  conductor  attachments,  guys 3 

Wooden  poles   and  crossarms 6 

Structural  steel  3 

Reinforced  concrete  poles  and  crossarms 4 

Foundations    2 

"Note. — The  treating  of  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  is  recommended. 
The  treatment  of  wooden  poles  and  crossarms  should  be  by  thorough 
impregnation  with  preservative  by  either  closed  or  open-tank  process. 
For  poles,  except  in  the  case  of  yellow  pine,  the  treatment  need  not  ex- 
tend higher  than  a  point  2  feet  above  the  ground  line." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  last  paragraph  contains  a  difference  in  the  first 
sentence  of  the  note.  The  joint  paragraph  reads,  "The  ultimate  unit  stress 
divided  by  the  allowable  unit  stress  shall  be  not  less  than  the  following, 
etc."  For  the  reasons  already  stated,  I  move  the  adoption  of  the  para- 
graph shown  on  pages  522  and  523. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "35.  Insulators.  Insulators  for  line  voltages  of  less 
than  9,000  shall  not  flash  over  at  four  times  the  normal  working  voltage, 


DISCUSSION.  100!> 

under  a  precipitation  of  water  of   1/5  of  an  inch  per  minute,   at  an  in- 
clination of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of  the  insulator. 

"36.  Each  separate  part  of  a  built-up  insulator,  for  line  voltages  over 
9,000,  shall  be  subjected  to  the  dry  flash-over  test  of  that  part  for  five  eon-- 
secutive  minutes. 

"27.     Each    assembled   and   cemented  insulator  shall  be   subjected  to 
its  dry  flash-over  test  for  five  consecutive  minutes. 
"The  dry  flash-over  test  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Test  Voltage. 

Exceeding    9,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 65,000 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000 100,000 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  3S,coo 125,000 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 150,000 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  60,000 180,000 

Exceeding  60,000 3  times  line  voltage 

"Each  insulator  shall  further  be  so  designed  that,  with  excessive  po- 
tential, failure  will  first  occur  by  flash-over  and  not  by  puncture. 

"38.  Each  assembled  insulator  shall  be  subjected  to  a  wet  flash-over 
test,  under  a  precipitation  of  water  of  1/5  inch  per  minute,  at  an  inclina- 
tion of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of  the  insulator. 

"The  wet  flash-over  test  shall  be  not  less  than : 

Line  Voltage.  Test  Voltage. 

Exceeding    9,000,  but  not  exceeding  14,000 40,000 

Exceeding  14,000,  but  not  exceeding  27,000 60,000 

Exceeding  27,000,  but  not  exceeding  3S»ooo 80,000 

Exceeding  35,000,  but  not  exceeding  47,000 100,000 

Exceeding  47,000,  but  not  exceeding  60,000 120,000 

Exceeding  60,000 twice  the  line  voltage 

"39.  Test  voltages  above  35,000  volts  shall  be  determined  by  the 
A.  I.  E.  E.  Standard  Spark-Gap  Method. 

"40.  Test  voltages  below  35,000  volts  shall  be  determined  by  trans- 
former ratio. 

"41.  Conductors.  The  conductors  shall  be  of  copper,  aluminum,  or 
other  noncorrodible  material,  except  that  in  exceptionally  long  spans, 
where  the  required  mechanical  strength  cannot  be  obtained  with  the  above 
materials,  galvanized  or  copper-covered  steel  strand  may  be  used. 

"42.      For   voltages   not   exceeding   750   volts,   solid   or   stranded   con- 
ductors may  be  used  up  to  and  including  4/0  in  size ;   above  4/0  in  size, 
stranded  conductors  shall  be  used.     For  voltages  exceeding  750  volts,  and 
not  exceeding  5,000  volts,  solid  or  stranded  conductors  may  be  used  up  to 
and  including  2/0  in  size  ;  above  2/0  in  size,  conductors  shall  be  stranded. 
For    voltages    exceeding    5,000    volts,    all    conductors    shall    be    stranded-. 
Aluminum  conductors  for  all  voltages  and  sizes  shall  be  stranded. 
The  minimum  size  of  conductors  shall  be  as  follows: 
No.  6  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  for  voltages  not  exceeding  5,000  volts. 
No.  4  B.  &  S.  gage  copper  for  voltages  exceeding  5,000  volts. 


1010  ELECTRICITY. 

No.  i  B.  &  S.  gage  aluminum  for  all  voltages. 

"43.  Insulators.  Insulators  shall  be  of  porcelain  for  voltages  exceed- 
ing 5,000  volts. 

"44.  Strain  insulators  for  guys  shall  have  an  ultimate  strength  of 
not  less  than  twice  that  of  the  guy  in  which  placed.  Strain  insulators 
shall  be  so  constructed  that  the  guy  wires  holding  the  insulator  in  position 
will  interlock  in  case  of  the  failure  of  the  insulator. 

"Strain  insulators  for  guys  shall  not  flash  over  at  four  times  the 
maximum  line  voltage,  under  a  precipitation  of  water  of  1/5  inch  per 
minute,  at  an  inclination  of  45  degrees  to  the  axis  of  the  insulator. 

"45.  Pins.  For  voltages  of  5,000  and  over,  insulator  pins  shall  be 
steel,  wrought  iron,  malleable  iron,  or  other  approved  metal  or  alloy,  and 
shall  be  galvanized,  or  otherwise  protected  from  corrosion.  Pins  shall 
be  locked  with  cotter,  nut,  or  other  device,  to  prevent  raising  out  of  the 
socket  or  hole  in  the  crossarm." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  paragraph  varies  from  that  of  the  joint  report 
in  that  the  last  sentence  of  this  paragraph  does  not  appear  in  the  joint 
report,  "Pins  shall  be  locked  with  cotter,"  etc.  For  the  reasons  already 
stated,  I  move  that  paragraph  45,  on  page  523,  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "46.  Guys.  Guys  shall  be  galvanized  or  copper- 
covered  stranded  steel  cable,  not  less  than  5/16  inch  in  diameter,  or  gal- 
vanized rolled  rods  of  equivalent  tensile  strength. 

"47.  Guys  to  the  ground  shall  connect  to  a  galvanized  anchor  rod. 
extending  at  least  1  foot  above  the  ground  level. 

"48.  The  detail  of  the  anchorage  shall  be  definitely  shown  upon  the 
plans. 

"49.  Wooden  Poles.  Wooden  poles  shall  be  of  selected  timber  of  ap- 
proved species,  peeled,  free  from  defects  which  would  decrease  their 
strength  or  durability,  not  less  than  7  inches  minimum  diameter  at  the 
top,  and  meeting  the  requirements  as  specified  in  paragraphs  17,  30,  31 
and  34." 

Mr.  Kittredge: — Mr.  Chairman,  this  varies  from  the  joint  report  para- 
graph in  that  the  joint  report  paragraph  omits  the  words,  "of  approved 
species."  For  the  reasons  already  given,  I  move  the  adoption  of  para- 
graph 49,  on  page  523. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "50.  Concrete.  All  concrete  and  concrete  material 
shall  be  in  accordance  with  the  requirements  of  the  Report  of  the  Joint 
Committee  on  Concrete  and  Reinforced  Concrete. 

"51.  Structural  steel  shall  be  open-hearth,  in  accordance  with  the 
Manufacturers'  Standard  Specifications." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  paragraph  differs  from  the  Joint  Committee 
paragraph  in  that  the  word  "open-hearth"  is  omitted  in  the  joint  specifi- 
cation. For  the  reasons  already  stated,  I  move  the  adoption  of  paragraph 
51,  page  523. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson   (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  :— It  would  be  interesting  to 


DISCUSSION.  1011 

me  to  know  why  the  Committee  prepared  these  specifications,  knowing  the 
Joint  Committee  specifications  were  already  in  existence,  and  recommend- 
ing them  for  adoption,  and  even  going  so  far  as  to  state  that  their  own 
specifications  were  more  satisfactory,  and  now  be  willing  to  modify  them 
to  conform  to  the  joint  specifications  in  every  respect. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — When  these  specifications  were  adopted  by  your  Com- 
mittee and  sent  for  printing  in  the  Bulletin,  we  were  led  to  believe  by  the 
Joint  Committee  that  if  they  varied  in  any  particular  it  would  be  just  as  if 
we  had  thrown  over  their  whole  specifications.  Afterward,  when  we  met 
several  members  of  the  Joint  Committee  and  explained  to  them  our  im- 
movable position  in  regard  to  clause  18,  they  said  they  would  undertake  to 
modify  their  clause  18  to  meet  ours,  if  we  would  modify  the  others  to 
meet  theirs.  That  is  the  sole  and  only  reason  we  have  for  recommend- 
ing as  we  do. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary : — "52.  The  design  and  workmanship  shall  be  strictly 
in  accordance  with  first-class  practice. 

"53.  The  form  of  the  frame  shall  be  such  that  the  stresses  may  be 
computed  with  reasonable  accuracy,  or  the  strength  shall  be  determined 
by  actual  test. 

"54.  The  sections  used  shall  permit  inspection,  cleaning  and  painting, 
and  shall  be  free  from  pockets  in  which  water  or  dirt  can  collect 

"55.  The  length  of  a  main  compression  member  shall  not  exceed  150 
times  the  least  radius  of  gyration.  The  length  of  a  secondary  compression 
member  shall  not  exceed  180  times  its  least  radius  of  gyration." 

Mr.  Kittredge: — This  varies  in  that  the  "150"  of  our  report  is  "180" 
of  the  Joint  Committee  report  and  the  180  of  our  report,  on  the  last  line, 
is  220  in  the  joint  report.  For  the  reasons  already  stated,  I  move  the 
adoption  of  paragraph  55,  page  523. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary  : — "56.  The  minimum  thickness  of  metal  in  galvanized 
structures  shall  be  %  inch  for  main  members,  and  %  inch  for  secondary 
members.     The  minimum  thickness  of  painted  material  shall  be  %  inch. 

"57.  All  structural  steel  shall  be  thoroughly  cleaned  at  the  shop 
and  be  galvanized,  or  given  one  coat  of  approved  paint. 

"58.  Painted  Material.  All  contact  surfaces  shall  be  given  one  coat 
of  paint  before  assembling. 

"All  painted  structural  steel  shall  be  given  two  field  coats  of  an 
approved  paint. 

"The  surface  of  the  metal  shall  be  thoroughly  cleaned  of  all  dirt, 
grease,  scale,  etc.,  before  painting,  and  no  painting  shall  be  done  in  freez- 
ing or  rainy  weather. 

"59.  Galvanized  Material.  Galvanized  material  shall  be  in  accordance 
with  the  Specifications  for  Galvanizing  Iron  and  Steel   (Appendix). 

"Bolt  holes  in  galvanized  material  shall  be  made  before  galvanizing. 

"60.  The  foundations  for  steel  poles  and  towers  shall  be  designed  to 
prevent  overturning. 


1012  ELECTRICITY. 

"The  weight  of  concrete  shall  be  assumed  as  140  lbs.  per  cubic  foot. 
In  good  ground,  the  weight  of  'earth'  shall  be  assumed  as  100  lbs.  per 
cubic  foot.  In  swampy  ground,  special  measures  shall  be  taken  to  prevent 
uplift  or  depression." 

Mr.  Kittredge: — This  varies  from  the  Joint  Committee  report  in  that 
the  latter  has  a  bracketed  clause  which  says,  "Calculated  at  30  degrees 
from  the  vertical."  For  the  reasons  already  stated,  I  move  the  adoption 
of  paragraph  60,  page  523. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "61.  The  top  of  the  concrete  foundation,  or  casing, 
shall  be  not  less  than  12  inches  above  the  surface  of  the  ground  or  ex- 
treme high  water." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — This  varies  from  the  Joint  Committee  report  in 
that  the  Joint  Committee  report  says,  "The  top  of  the  concrete  founda- 
tion, or  casing,  shall  be  not  less  than  6  inches  above  surface  of  the  ground, 
nor  less  than  1  foot  above  extreme  high  water."  For  the  reasons  already 
stated,  I  move  the  adoption  of  paragraph  61,  on  page  523. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary :- — "62.  When  located  in  swampy  ground,  wooden  cross- 
ing and  next  adjoining  poles  shall  be  set  in  barrels  of  broken  stone  or 
gravel,  or  in  broken  stone  or  timber  footings. 

"63.  When  located  in  the  sides  of  banks,  or  when  subject  to  wash- 
outs, foundations  shall  be  given  additional  depth,  or  be  protected  by  crib- 
bing or  riprap. 

"64.  All  foundations  and  pole  settings  shall  be  tamped  in  6-inch 
layers,  while  back  filling. 

"Working  Unit  Stresses. — Obtained  by  dividing  the  ultimate  breaking 
strength  by  the  factors  of  safety  given  in  paragraph  34. 

Lbs.   per  sq.   in. 

"65.     Structural   Steel.     Tension   (net  section) 18,000 

Shear 14,000 

Compression    18,000-60- 

r 

"65.     Rivets,    Pins.      Shear 10,000 

Bearing  20,000 

Bending    20,000 

"67.     Bolts.     Shear    8,500 

Bearing 17,000 

Bending    17,000 

"68.     Wires   and    Cables.      Copper,    hard-drawn,    solid, 

B.  &  S.  gage,  4/0,  3/0,  2/0 25,000 

Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  1/0.  ..  .27,500 
Copper,  hard-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S.  gage,  No.  1.. 28,500 
Copper,   hard-drawn,   solid,   B.   &   S.   gage,   Nos. 

2,   4,   6 30,000 

Copper,  soft-drawn,  solid,  B.  &  S 17,000 

Cupper,  hard-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S 30,000 


DISCUSSION.  1013 

Copper,  soft-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S 17,000 

Aluminum,  hard-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S.  gage, 

under  4/0   12,000 

Aluminum,  hard-drawn,  stranded,  B.  &  S.  gage, 

4/0  and  over 11,500 

"69.     Untreated  Timber.    East-  Bending.  Compression. 

ern   white   cedar..   600  lbs.  per  sq.  in..   600(1  —  —-) 

Chestnut    850  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  850 

Washington  cedar 850  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  850 

Idaho  cedar 850  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  850 

Port  Orford  cedar 1150  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .1150 

Long-leaf  yellow  pine...  1 100  lbs.  per  sq.  in..  1 100 

Short-leaf  yellow  pine.  ..   950  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  950 

Douglas  fir 1000  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .1000 

White  oak 950  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  950        " 

Red  Cedar   700  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .   700 

Bald  cypress    (heartw'd)   800  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  800 

Redwood 850  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  850 

Catalpa    500  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .  500 

Juniper    550  lbs.  per  sq.  in.  .   550 

L  =  Length  in  inches. 

D  =  Least  side,  or  diameter,  in  inches. 

"SPECIFICATIONS  FOR  GALVANIZING  FOR  IRON  OR  STEEL. 

"These  specifications  give  in  detail  the  test  to  be  applied  to  galvanized 
material.     All  specimens  shall  be  capable  of  withstanding  these  tests. 

"(A)  Coating.  The  galvanizing  shall  consist  of  a  continuous  coating 
of  pure  zinc  of  uniform  thickness,  and  so  applied  that  it  adheres  firmly 
to  the  surface  of  the  iron  or  steel.     The  finished  product  shall  be  smooth. 

"(B)  Cleaning.  The  samples  shall  be  cleaned  before  testing,  first  with 
carbona,  benzine  or  turpentine  and  cotton  waste  (not  with  a  brush),  and 
then  thoroughly  rinsed  in  clean  water  and  wiped  dry  with  clean  cotton 
waste. 

"The  sample  shall  be  clean  and  dry  before  each  immersion  in  the 
solution. 

"(C)  Solution.  The  standard  solution  of  copper  sulphate  shall  con- 
sist of  commercial  copper  sulphate  crystals  dissolved  in  cold  water,  about 
in  the  proportion  of  36  parts,  by  weight,  of  crystals  to  100  parts,  by  weight, 
of  water.  The  solution  shall  be  neutralized  by  the  addition  of  an  excess 
of  chemically  pure  cupric  oxide  (Cu  O).  The  presence  of  an  excess  of 
cupric  oxide  will  be  shown  by  the  sediment  of  this  reagent  at  the  bottom  of 
the  containing  vessel. 

"The  neutralized  solution  shall  be  filtered  before  using  by  passing 
through  filter  paper.  The  filtered  solution  shall  have  a  specific  gravity  of 
1. 186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit  (reading  the  scale  at  the  level  of  the  sola- 


1014  ELECTRICITY. 

tion)  at  the  beginning  of  each  test.  In  case  the  filtered  solution  is  high 
in  specific  gravity,  clean  water  shall  be  added  to  reduce  the  specific 
gravity  at  1.186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit.  In  case  the  filtered  solution  is 
low  in  specific  gravity,  filtered  solution  of  a  higher  specific  gravity  shall 
be  added  to  make  the  specific  gravity  1.186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit. 

"As  soon  as  the  stronger  solution  is  taken  from  the  vessel  containing 
the  unfiltered  neutralized  stock  solution,  additional  crystals  and  water  must 
be  added  to  the  stock  solution.  An  excess  of  cupric  oxide  shall  always  be 
kept  in  the  unfiltered  stock  solution. 

"(D)  Quantity  of  Solution.  Wire  samples  shall  be  tested  in  a  glass 
jar  of  at  least  2  in.  inside  diameter.  The  jar  without  the  wire  samples 
shall  be  filled  with  standard  solution  to  a  depth  of  at  least  4  in.  Hard- 
ware samples  shall  be  tested  in  a  glass  or  earthenware  jar  containing  at 
least  l/z  pint  of  standard  solution  for  each  hardware  sample. 

"Solution  shall  not  be  used  for  more  than  one  series  of  four  im- 
mersions. 

"(E)  Samples.  Not  more  than  seven  wires  shall  be  simultaneously 
immersed,  and  not  more  than  one  sample  of  galvanized  material  other 
than  wire  shall  be  immersed  in  the  specified  quantity  of  solution. 

"The  samples  shall  not  be  grouped  or  twisted  together,  but  shall  be 
well  separated  so  as  to  permit  the  action  of  the  solution  to  be  uniform 
upon  all  immersed  portions  of  the  samples. 

"(F)  Test.  Clean  and  dry  samples  shall  be  immersed  in  the  required 
quantity  of  standard  solution  in  accordance  with  the  following  cycle  of 
immersions. 

"The  temperature  of  the  solution  shall  be  maintained  between  62 
degrees  and  68  degrees  Fahrenheit  at  all  times  during  the  following  test : 

"(1)     Immerse  for  one  minute,  wash  and  wipe  dry. 

"(2)     Immerse  for  one  minute,  wash  and  wipe  dry. 

"(3)     Immerse  for  one  minute,  wash  and  wipe  dry. 

"  (4)     Immerse  for  one  minute,  wash  and  wipe  dry. 

"After  each  immersion  the  samples  shall  be  immediately  washed  in 
clean  water  having  a  temperature  between  62  degrees  and  68  degrees 
Fahrenheit,  and  wiped  dry  with  cotton  waste. 

"In  the  case  of  No.  14  galvanized  iron  or  steel  wire,  the  time  of  the 
fourth  immersion  shall  be  reduced  to  Yi  minute. 

"(G)  Rejection.  If  after  the  test  described  in  section  (F)  there 
should  be  a  bright  metallic  copper  deposit  upon  the  samples,  the  lot  repre- 
sented by  the  sample  shall  be  rejected. 

"Copper  deposits  on  zinc  or  within  1  in.  of  the  cut  end  shall  not  be 
considered  causes  for  rejection. 

"In  the  case  of  a  failure  of  only  one  wire  in  a  group  of  seven  wires 
immersed  together,  or  if  there  is  a  reasonable  doubt  as  to  the  copper 
deposit,  two  check  tests  shall  be  made  on  these  seven  wires  and  the 
lot  reported  in  accordance  with  the  majority  of  the  sets  of  tests. 


DISCUSSION.  1015 

"Note. — The  equipment  necessary  for  the  tests  herein  outlined  is  as 
follows : 

"Filter  paper. 

"Commercial  copper  sulphate  crystals. 

"Chemically  pure  cupric  oxide   (Cu  O). 

"Running  water. 

"Warm  water  or  ice,  as  per  needs. 

"Carbona,  benzine   or  turpentine. 

"Glass  jars  at  least  2  in.  inside  diameter  by  at  least  4^  in.  high. 

"Glass  or  earthenware  jars  for  hardware  samples. 

"Vessel  for  washing  samples. 

"Tray  for  holding  jars  of  stock  solution. 

"Jars,  bottles  and  porcelain  basket  for  stock  solution. 

"Cotton  waste. 

"Hydrometer  cylinder  3  in.  diameter  by  15  in.  high. 

"Thermometer  with  large  Fahrenheit  scale  correct  at  62  and  68  de- 
grees. 

"Hydrometer  correct  at  1.186  at  65  degrees  Fahrenheit." 

Mr.  Kittredge : — I  move  the  adoption  of  specifications  for  overhead 
crossings,  as  amended. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Kittredge : — The  recommendation  of  the  Committee  is  the  con- 
tinuation of  work  already  outlined. 

Mr.  A.  F.  Robinson : — I  may  be  a  little  bit  late,  but  I  want  to  call 
attention  to  two  or  three  items  in  these  specifications  we  have  adopted 
that  are  not  consistent  with  our  specifications  for  structural  material,  and 
to  suggest  that  a  small  committee  of  one  or  two  persons  be  appointed  to 
confer  with  the  Committee  on  Electricity,  suggesting  these  minor  changes, 
which  they  wish  put  up  to  the  Joint  Committee  later  on  for  adoption. 
These  changes  will  make  the  specifications  consistent  with  our  printed 
specifications,  and  with  ordinary  working  conditions,  and  I  think  will 
be  a  decided  improvement.  I  am  not  offering  this  with  any  idea  of 
objecting  to  the  specifications  as  a  whole,  but  simply  to  make  them  con- 
sistent all  the  way  through.  I  think  it  could  be  handled  very  easily  in 
this  manner,  so  that  the  Committee  on  Electricity  can  get  the  matter 
into  shape  for  presentation  to  the  Joint  Committee. 

Mr.  F.  J.  Bachelder  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  :— I  would  'like  to  ask  if  the 
manufacturer's-  standard  specifications  mentioned  in  paragraph  51  are 
the  same  as  the  specifications  of  this  Association. 

Mr.  Robinson : — That  was  one  of  the  items  I  had  in  mind  in  speak- 
ing. 

The  President: — Mr.  Robinson,  will  you  write  a  letter  to  the  Chair- 
man of  the  Committee? 

Mr.  Robinson : — Yes,  I  will,  and  cover  all  the  features  I  have  in 
mind. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — The  Committee  would  not  only  gladly  accept  such 
a  letter,  but  would  gladly  accept  the  names  of  any  individuals  whom  Mr. 


1016  ELECTRICITY. 

Robinson  might  suggest,  who  would  prove  valuable  members  of  the  Com- 
mittee. We  would  be  glad  to  have  two  or  three  more  good  members  and 
would  welcome  more  such  men  as  Mr.  Robinson  refers  to. 

Mr.  Ambrose : — Is  it  understood  that  the  Committee  will  take  up  these 
higher  voltages  at  once?  We  have  several  crossings  now  in  existence 
carrying  110,000  volts  and  would  be  glad  to  have  some  recommendation. 

Mr.  Kittredge : — I  would  suggest  that  such  a  letter  be  addressed  to 
the  Board  of  Direction,  so  that  it  will  come  before  the  Committee  in  the 
regular  formal  way. 

The  President : — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of"  the 
Association.  There  has  been  an  immense  amount  of  work  done  in  this 
connection. 


DISCUSSION  ON  RAIL. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.   559-862.) 
LIST   OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART   IN    DISCUSSION    ON    RAIL. 

Chas.  S.  Churchill.  George  W.  Kittredge.  John  G.  Sullivan. 

R.  D.  Coombs.  C.   E.   Lindsay.  G.  H.  Tinker. 

W.  C.  Cushing.  W.  L.   Seddon.  Robert  Trimble. 

L.  C.  Fritch.  W.  F.  Steffens.  Walter  Loring  Webb. 
James  E.  Howard. 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on  Rail, 
Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill,  Chairman.  The  Chairman  is  requested  to  make 
the  preliminary  statement. 

Mr.  Chas.  S.  Churchill  (Norfolk  &  Western)  :— The  report  of  the 
Rail  Committee  begins  at  the  top  of  page  560.  We  have  there,  in  the 
first  place,  the  answer  to  our  instruction  No.  3,  "Continue  the  investiga- 
tion of  breakage  and  failure  of  rails."  This  being  a  study  of  failed  rails 
up  to  October  31,  1910,  with  conclusions. 

"(1)  Study  of  these  general  statistics  does  not  furnish  accurate  and 
specific  information  so  as  to  determine  the  value  of  different  sections  of 
rail,  because  (a)  The  conditions  of  traffic  are  different;  (b)  the  condi- 
tions of  roadbed  are  different;  (c)  the  conditions  of  ingot  making  and 
rolling  practice  are  so  different  that  the  quality  of  the  material  varies 
widely,  and,  at  the  present  time,  this  difference  in  quality  of  the  material 
eliminates  differences  in  section ;  nevertheless,  when  the  time  comes  that 
the  difference  in  quality  of  material  will  be  less,  the  influence  of  the  sec- 
tion will  be  more  apparent,  for  there  is  no  doubt  that  one  section  is 
stiffer  and  stronger  than  another  according  to  the  distribution  of  the 
material.  Inasmuch  as  we  are  endeavoring  to  eliminate  the  differences  in 
quality  of  material  and  bring  it  to  a  high  state  of  perfection,  we  should 
not,  in  the  meantime,  lose  sight  of  the  desirable  features  of  the  rail  sec- 
tion, but  keep  them  constantly  in  mind,  so  that  when  we  arrive  at  a  good 
quality  of  metal,  we  will  also  have  a  desirable  rail  section. 

"(2)  A  study  of  these  general  statistics  tends  to  disclose  unusual  re- 
sults, and  were  it  not  for  their  compilation,  we  would  not  have  much  in- 
formation relative  to  the  difference  between  Bessemer  and  Open-Hearth 
steel  and  concerning  the  various  alloys. 

"(3)  The  general  statistics  are  also  important,  in  showing  a  relation 
between  broken  rails  and  failure  of  head,  web  and  base. 

"(4)  Their  tabulation  discloses  the  difference  between  Steel  Com- 
panies when  the  sections  and  chemical  composition  are  practically  the 
same. 

1017 


1018  RAIL. 

"The  report  by  Mr.  Wickhorst  covers  an  investigation  made  at  the 
South  Works  of  the  Illinois  Steel  Company,  to  throw  light  on  the  rela- 
tionship of  the  size  of  ingots  of  Bessemer  Rail  steel  to  the  segregation  of 
the  metalloids,  locations  of  pipes  and  blow  holes,  and  the  properties  of 
the  rails.  This  investigation  showed  that  under  the  conditions  of  the  tests, 
the  carbon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  collected  or  segregated  toward  the  in- 
terior and  upper  part  of  the  ingot  and  that,  in  a  general  way,  such  segre- 
gation increased  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  increased.  The  manganese  also 
segregated  some,  but  to  a  much  smaller  extent,  while  the  silicon  showed 
little  or  no  tendency  to  segregate. 

"The  elements  which  segregated  as  described  also  showed  a  lowering 
in  the  top  part  of  the  ingot,  below  the  average  composition  of  the  steel 
and  this  lowering  extended  downward  along  the  sides  of  the  ;no;ot.  The 
'negative'  segregation  increased  in  general  as  the  size  of  the  ingot  in- 
creased and  also  extended  down  further  along  the  sides  of  the  ingot. 
There  was  also  a  region  of  negative  segregation  in  the  interior  and  lower 
part  of  the  ingot,  but  the  lowering  of  the  elements  was  not  as  great  in 
this  region. 

"This  investigation  also  indicated  that  the  material  was  distributed  in 
the  rail  bar  about  the  same,  relatively,  as  it  was  in  the  ingot  from  which 
the  rail  bar  had  been  rolled. 

"(D)  Tests  of  Rail  Steel  Ingots  and  Derivative  Shapes  Made  at  Wa- 
tertown  Arsenal,  being  a  Review  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst  of  the  Report  Pub- 
lished by  the  Watertown  Arsenal  (Bulletin  No.  139,  September,  191 1.) 

"This  report  covers  a  digest  and  analysis  of  the  Government  investi- 
gation at  the  Watertown  Arsenal  of  rail  steel  ingots  and  derivative  shapes 
as  embodied  in  the  Report  of  Tests  of  Metals,  etc.,  made  at  the  Water- 
town  Arsenal  for  the  year  1909. 

"The  work  indicated  that  the  interior  cavities  of  an  ingot  cooled  di- 
rectly after  pouring  are  about  the  same  or  slightly  less  than  in  a  similar 
ingot  placed  in  the  soaking  pit  and  then  cooled.  This  same  result  was 
also  indicated  as  true  of  blooms  made  from  such  ingots. 

"It  was  shown  that  almost  the  full  tensile  strength  and  ductility  of  the 
metal  of  the  lower  part  of  the  ingot  were  obtained  rolling  to  about  one- 
tenth  of  the  original  cross-section,  but  with  the  metal  of  the  upper  part 
of  the  ingot  it  was  necessary  to  reduce  the  cross-section  to  one-twenty- 
fifth  or  less  of  the  original  amount. 

"A  great  many  etchings  were  made  and  it  was  shown  that  the  structure 
of  the  cross-section  as  developed  by  etching  varies  from  the  top  to  the 
bottom  of  the  ingot  and  that  each  structure  finds  its  counterpart  in  suc- 
ceeding shapes  and  at  about  the  same  proportionate  distance  from  the 
top  end.  It  was  also  shown  that  the  structure  was  considerably  altered  by 
changing  the  position  in  which  the  ingot  was  allowed  to  cool,  as  for  in- 
stance allowing  it  to  cool  on  its  side  after  stripping. 

"(E)  Influence  of  Rolling  Temperature  on  the  Properties  of  Bes- 
semer Rails,  by  M.  H.  Wickhorst,  November,  191 1. 

"This  report  covers  an  investigation  made  at  the  works  of  the  Car- 


DISCUSSION.  1019 

negie  Steel  Company  to  determine  the  influence  of  the  temperature  of 
rolling  on  the  properties  of  Bessemer  Rails.  This  work  indicated  that  the 
ductility  and  deflection  in  the  drop  test  were  influenced  little,  if  any, 
by  the  rolling  temperature.  The  number  of  blows  that  it  took  to  break  the 
rails  in  the  drop  test  was  uninfluenced  by  the  temperature  of  rolling.  The 
yield  point  and  tensile  strength  in  the  tension  tests  were  influenced  little, 
if  any.  The  elongation  in  the  tension  test  decreased  some  as  the  temper- 
ature increased.  The  influence  of  temperature  showed  most  prominently 
in  the  tension  test,  in  the  reduction  of  area,  which  decreased  as  the  tem- 
perature of  rolling  increased.  The  size  of  the  grain,  as  shown  by  the 
microscope,  increased  as  the  temperature  increased. 

"In  this  report  it  is  also  pointed  out  that  the  ductility  in  the  drop  test 
with  the  head  of  the  rail  in  tension  more  nearly  indicates  the  ductility 
of  the  interior  metal  as  measured  in  the  tension  test,  than  does  the  ductil- 
ity in  the  drop  test  with  the  base  of  the  rail  in  tension,  which  is  usual  in 
inspection  work. 

"Each  report  mentioned  above  gives  a  short  summary  of  the  matter 
contained  in  it,  but  the  main  principles  that  seem  to  have  been  brought  out 
by  the  year's  work  are  set  forth  in  the  brief  reviews  above." 

That  shows  the  work  that  this  Committee  has  done  during  the  year. 

I  will  refer  now  to  the  requirement,  "Present  recommendations  on 
standard  rail  sections."  The  Committee  reports  progress  on  this.  We 
think  that  the  information  that  is  coming,  not  yet  tabulated,  on  rail  fail- 
ures for  the  period  ending  October  31,  191 1,  together  with  information  that 
has  come  in  since  that  date,  is  going  to  be  of  such  assistance  that  this 
Committee  can  make  very  rapid  progress  upon  this  question.  Therefore 
the  Committee  reports  progress  only  on  this  instruction. 

We  have  carried  investigation  of  the  failure  of  rails  up  to  October 
31,  1910.  Similar  statements  and  conclusions  will  be  prepared  and  pub- 
lished in  the  course  of  probably  two  months  on  the  tabulation  of  rail 
failures  for  the  period  ending  October  31,  191 1. 

The  Committee  was  further  instructed  to  report  on  the  results  ob- 
tained from  the  use  of  Open-Hearth  and  Special  Alloy  Steel  Rails, 
and   the   chemical   composition  of  such   rails. 

Bulletin  No.  137,  referred  to  above,  containing  the  report  of  the  rail 
failure  statistics,  also  gives  all  the  information  that  the  Committee  has  in 
regard  to  Open-Hearth  and  Special  Alloy  Steel  Rails. 

I  have  simply  referred  to  these  few  items  so  that  the  members  of  the 
Association   will  catch  quickly  the  salient  features  of  the  report. 

With  these  remarks  of  the  work  in  general,  I  wish  now  to  refer  to 
page  562  of  Bulletin  143,  and  take  up  the  matter  beginning  with  sec- 
tion 1 : 

"(1)  The  first  item  of  work  for  the  Rail  Committee  according  to  the 
instructions  for  191 1,  was  to  recommend  changes  in  the  specifications  for 
steel  rails. 

"Considerable  work  has  been  done  during  the  past  year  in  the  prepara- 
tion of  specifications,  and  the  specifications  submitted  herewith  are  rec- 


1020  RAIL. 

ommended  by  your  Committee.  Some  paragraphs,  such  as  Nos.  5,  6, 
14  and  15,  are  not  to  be  considered  as  final,  it  being  thought  that  the  Com- 
mittee did  not  have  sufficient  information  in  its  possession  to  make  these 
sections   in   the   specifications   mandatory. 

One  of  the  sections  in  question,  No.  14,  refers  to  the  ductility  test. 

The  requirements,  in  the  specifications,  for  ductility  are  somewhat 
lower  than  some  members  of  your  Committee  think  desirable,  and  it  is 
hoped  that  sufficient  information  will  be  obtained  during  the  coming  year 
to  enable  the  Committee  to  make  some  revision  in  these  respects. 

"Paragraph  No.  15,  referring  to  deflections  as  a  method  of  classifying 
rails,  is  also  tentative.  It  is  the  intention  when  sufficient  data  is  at  hand 
to  prescribe  maximum  and  minimum  limits  for  deflections  under  the  drop 
test." 

The  Committee,  therefore,  asks  that  the  specifications  we  recom- 
mend be  now  considered  and  that  they  be  adopted  as  good  practice,  and 
to  that  end  I  would  suggest  that  we  take  up  the  specifications  so  that  they 
may  be  discussed  and  passed  upon  by  paragraphs. 

The  President : — With  the  consent  of  the  Association,  the  Secretary 
will  read  the  specifications  paragraph  by  paragraph  and  will  pass  from 
one  to  the  other  without  formal  action,  unless  some  motion  is  made. 

The  Secretary: — "1.  Access  to  Works. — Inspectors  representing  the 
purchaser  shall  have  free  entry  to  the  works  of  the  manufacturer  at  all 
times  while  the  contract  is  being  executed,  and  shall  have  all  reasonable 
facilities  afforded  them  by  the  manufacturer  to  satisfy  them  that  the 
rails  have  been  made  in  accordance  with  the  terms  of  the  specifications. 

"2.  Place  for  Tests. — All  tests  and  inspections  shall  be  made  at  the 
place  of  manufacture,  prior  to  shipment,  and  shall  be  so  conducted  as  not 
to  interfere  unnecessarily  with  the  operation  of  the  mill. 

"3.  Material. — The  material  shall  be  steel  made  by  the  Bessemer  or 
Open-Hearth  process  provided  by  the  contract. 

"4.  Chemical  Composition. — The  chemical  composition  of  the  steel 
from  which  the  rails  are  rolled,  determined  as  prescribed  in  Section  7, 
shall  be  within  the  limits  set  forth  in  the  table.     (See  page  565.)" 

The  President: — We  have  with  us  to-day  at  our  invitation  Mr.  James 
E.  Howard,  of  the  Bureau  of  Standards,  and  if  he  is  present  in  the  room 
I  would  be  glad  to  have  him  make  some  remarks.  You  all  know  Mr. 
Howard ;  he  has  been  present  at  our  meetings  before. 

Mr.  James  E.  Howard  (Bureau  of  Standards)  : — Mr.  President  arid 
Gentlemen:  In  regard  to  the  general  subject  of  rail,  it  has  been  my  priv- 
ilege to  make  a  number  of  tests  on  different  occasions,  and  I  feel  very 
gratified  at  this  opportunity  of  making  a  few  remarks  before  you.  The 
work  your  Committee  has  in  hand  is  advancing  the  subject  very  mate- 
rially and  so  far  I  think  it  has  proceeded  in  a  highly  satisfactory  manner. 

It  seems,  however,  that  some  features  connected  with  the  rail  situa- 
tion ought  to  be  considered  which  are  perhaps  a  little  out  of  the  usual 
order,   in  addition  to  what  we  have  heretofore  directed  our  attention  to. 

In   regard   to   matters   of  test — specifications — I   never  feel   like  tying 


DISCUSSION.  1021 

myself  down  very  closely  to  specifications.  They  are  necessary,  but  not 
all  that  is  needed. 

I  will  refer  to  a  few  of  the  features  which  have  just  been  suggested 
by  reading  paragraphs  in  your  specifications.  As  to  this  question  of 
ductility  and  the  deflections  in  the  drop  tests,  when  we  come  to  analyze 
the  case,  it  seems  that  the  drop  test  means  simply  this — that  it  gives  us  an 
indication  of  well-worked  metal.  I  do  not  know  that  it  does  very  much 
more.  If  we  have  the  composition  of  the  steel  and  it  is  cast  in  an  ingot 
and  reduced  thirty  or  forty  times,  we  have  good  evidence  when  it  reaches 
the  form  of  a  rail  that  it  is  well-worked  steel.  I  do  not  know  that  we 
could  secure  better  evidence  that  it  has  been  well-worked  than  the  fact 
that  it  has  become  a  rail,  so  the  drop  test,  in  that  respect,  merely  shows 
we  have  secured  what  we  know  we  have. 

In  regard  to  the  deflection,  what  does  that  mean  further  than  that 
one  ordinate  of  a  stress-strain  curve  has  been  reached.  If  we  make  a 
tension  test  of  steel  we  get  its  elastic  limit,  and  as  it  is  stretched  at  dif- 
ferent intervals  beyond  also  the  total  extension,  and  the  contraction  area. 
Now,  we  are  not  content  usually  with  just  one  ordinate  of  that  charac- 
ter, and  I  would  request,  for  consideration,  whether  the  drop  test  car- 
ries with  it  quite  enough  information  in  this  respect.  We  wish  to  know 
something  about  the  elastic  limit  of  the  material,  and  we  do  not  know 
what  that  is  from  the  results  of  the  drop  test. 

Then  it  goes  back  to  the  question  of  what  elastic  limit  is  needed  in 
steel  rails.  It  comes  to  the  definition  or  recognition  of  what  fiber  stresses 
you  have  in  rails.  I  do  not  know  what  fiber  stresses  are  involved  in 
rails  in  the  track.  Some  of  the  gentlemen  present  may  be  in  possession 
of  definite  information,  but  it  is  doubtful.  Earlier  tests  which  I  had  the 
pleasure  of  conducting  showed  that  the  fiber  stress  per  ton  on  the  wheels 
varied  with  different  types  of  engines  and  different  wheels  of  the  same 
engine,  so  that  I  feel  that  in  general  the  specifications  and  tests  had  not  yet 
touched  upon  some  of  the  vital  points. 

Then,  again,  in  regard  to  the  extension  due  to  the  drop  test,  we  are 
stretching  the  metal  in  the  most  favorable  direction.  If  we  had  the  same 
ductility  in  the  crosswise  direction  that  we  have  longitudinally,  I  do  not 
think  there  would  be  so  many  base  fractures.  The  crescent-shaped  frac- 
tures are  due  to  a  want  of  structural  soundness,  which  is  very  evident 
when  the  bases  are  bent  in  a  crosswise  direction,  but  these  defects  are  not 
apparent  when  we  stretch  the  material  in  a  lengthwise  direction. 

I  hope  I  am  not  criticising  too  many  features  at  this  time,  but  it  seems 
that  these  are  the  things  which  we  ought  to  consider  in  addition  to  those 
features  which  now  are  covered  by  specifications. 

Concerning  the  question  of  chemical  analysis,  the  few  observations 
that  I  have  made  have  shown  that  the  composition  of  the  rail  in  its  cross- 
section  may  vary  considerably.  I  will  not  say  it  generally  varies  so  much 
as  witnessed  in  a  recent  case,  but  in  a  recent  case  the  carbon  at  the  outer 
portions  was  0.44  per  cent,  to  0.45  per  cent.,  while  at  the  center  of  the  head 
it  was  as  high  as  0.77  per  cent.   That  variation  in  composition  is  quite  wide, 


1022  RAIL. 

but  do  you  find  in  the  test  ingot  very  much  clew  to  what  actually  reaches 
you  in  the  rails?  Should  not  the  rails  themselves  now  and  then  be  care- 
fully analyzed  for  the  purpose  of  determining  whether  segregated  parts 
of  the  ingot  were  used  or  whether  the  outer  portions  of  the  rails  are  not  in 
a  measure  decarbonized?  There  are  reasons  for  thinking  there  is  need 
for  such  procedure. 

Doubtless  there  are  other  features  of  importance  which  do  not  at  this 
time  occur  to  me,  but  I  should  be  very  happy  to  answer  any  questions 
that  I  may  be  able  to  answer,  if  anyone  present  would  kindly  make  the 
inquiries ;  however,  these  are  the  salient  features  which  to  me  seem  de- 
sirable to  consider,  and  their  consideration  may  aid  in  securing  a  better 
material. 

The  President : — Have  you  any  criticism  to  make  on  this  particular 
paragraph  that  we  have  just  read  in  reference  to  the  chemical  composition 
proposed  for  these  specifications?  We  would  be  glad  to  know  what  you 
think  in  regard  to  that. 

Mr.  Howard : — The  chemical  composition  carries  with  it  the  idea 
of  certain  physical  properties.  First,  to  consider  what  the  physical  prop- 
erty should- be  and  then  work  back  from  that  to  the  chemical  composition. 
We  have  in  that  case  to  go  back  to  the  fiber  stresses  which  are  involved 
and  until  they  are  defined  we  cannot  reach  a  definite  conclusion ;  that  is, 
considering  the  rail  as  a  beam  subjected  to  bending  stresses.  As  to  the 
wheel  pressures,  cold-rolling  on  the  running  surface  of  the  head,  that  is 
still  another  question.  In  general,  low-carbon  steel  responds  quickly  to  the 
cold-rolling  of  the  wheel,  and  we  do  not  have  a  very  high  stress  before 
the  elastic  limit  is  reached.  Higher  carbon  steel  than  a  mild  one  is 
certainly  necessary.  But  there  is  danger  in  going  too  far,  getting  too  high 
a  carbon,  introducing  great  brittleness,  therefore,  I  am  inclined  to  favor 
a  medium  carbon ;  doubtless  the  zone  of  safety  lies  around  0.65  per  cent, 
to  0.70  per  cent.,  or  a  little  outside  of  those  limits. 

The  President: — For  open-hearth,  Mr.  Howard? 

Mr.  Howard : — I  am  not  prepared  to  make  a  distinction  between  the 
two  kinds  of  steel  at  the  present  time. 

This  feature  of  ductility  is  one  to  be  considered  and  we  do  know  this 
— that  when  a  material  is  subjected  to  repeated  alternate  stresses  it  may 
be  ruptured  without  the  display  of  any  ductility  whatever.  If  we  have 
a  very  low  carbon  steel,  although  one  of  great  ductility  at  the  outset, 
when  this  is  subjected  to  a  comparatively  low  fiber  stress,  in  alternate  di- 
rections, we  very  quickly  reach  a  brittle  fracture.  That  metal  will  fail 
without  any  display  of  ductility,  and  the  hardest  steel  can  hardly  do  less. 
It  is  necessary  to  start  with  considerable  stiffness  or  strength  in  the  ma- 
terial to  resist  bending  stresses.  The  ductility  which  you  find  in  the 
drop  test  is  inherent  to  the  new  material  and  not  to  that  which  has  been 
repeatedly  strained.  It  is  not  necessary  that  the  overstraining  force 
reaches  the  elastic  limit  of  the  material,  to  bring  about  that  final  state  of 
brittleness.  Too  soft  a  metal  is  undesirable  to  use.  If  the  metal  is  a  strong 
one,  a  higher  stress  can  be  endured  repeatedly  without  impairing  the  final 


DISCUSSION.  1023 

ductility  or  such  ductility  as  the  metal  may  incidentally  be  called  upon 
to  develop.  That  leads  to  the  use  of  rather  high  carbons  and  to  be  con- 
servative, I  think  around  0.55  to  0.70  is  a  fair  limit. 

The  dangers  of  higher  carbon,  as  I  see  them,  are  somewhat  along 
these  lines :  With  high  carbon  steel,  and  high  wheel  pressures,  we 
reach  an  unsatisfactory  internal  condition.  To  follow  the  action  of 
the  high  wheel  pressures,  they  move  the  metal  on  the  surface  of  the 
head  and  induce  internal  strains  of  compression.  These  internal  strains 
may  be  of  considerable  magnitude,  and  when  they  exist  there  must  be 
a  tensile  component  in  the  steel  below  it.  In  that  case  we  have  below 
the  running  surface  of  the  head,  metal  which  is  put  into  tension,  and 
if  structurally  unsound  there  is  an  opportunity  present  for  an  incipient 
fracture  to  develop.  To  show  that  the  stresses  from  a  disturbing 
cause  like  those  under  consideration  are  considerable,  I  would  mention 
an  example,  referring  to  a  steel  forging,  one  which  had  walls  zV* 
inches  in  thickness.  The  metal  of  that  cylinder  was  so  disturbed  by 
hammering  with  a  hand  hammer  that  the  bore  was  measurably  en- 
larged. The  dimensions  of  this  cylinder  were  8  inches;  bore,  15  inches 
outside  diameter.  Hammering  the  outside  surface  of  the  cylinder,  the 
bore  was  enlarged  nearly  one-thousandth  of  an  inch.  Turning  off  one- 
eighth  of  an  inch  of  metal,  on  a  side,  restored  the  diameter  of  the 
bore  to  its  primitive  dimension.  That  showed  that  the  internal  strains 
in  a  zone  only  ^-inch  thick  were  capable  of  stretching  the  balance 
of  3J/i  inches  and  making  its  effect  measurable.  It  meant  several  thou- 
sand pounds  stress  per  square  inch  to  do  that,  so  that  it  is  possible 
that  the  cold-rolled  surface  of  the  head  of  the  rail  may  have  in  it 
internal  strains  amounting  to  a  number  of  thousand  pounds  per  square 
inch,  and  that  coupled  with  that  fact  we  may  have  a  decarbonized  ex- 
terior, with  a  hard  center,  the  decarborized  exterior  responding  easily 
to  the  rolling  of  the  wheels,  the  hard  interior,  through  its  natural  lack 
of  ductility,  not  responding  so  well,  we  have  presented  ample  oppor- 
tunity,  it   would   seem,   for   starting   a    fracture  in   the   hard    steel. 

These  are  features  which  are  regarded  as  important  in  considering 
what  the  composition  of  the  steel  should  be  and  would  lead  to  limiting 
it  to  the  range  in  carbon  which  I  have  mentioned,  and  to  the  exercising 
of  care  to  see  that  the  steel  in  the  finished  rail  is  fairly  uniform  in  its 
composition  from  the  exterior  surface  to  the  center  of  the  head. 

Mr.  Churchill : — You  stated  that  you  did  not  wish  to  express  your- 
self as  to  the  chemical  analysis  as  between  open-hearth  and  Bessemer — 
do  you  not  think  that  the  lowering  of  the  phosphorus  we  get  in  the 
open-hearth  is  a  very  valuable  item  to  balance  the  large  amount  of 
carbon  in  the  Bessemer  steel?  I  believe  you  think  that  and  I  want  to 
bring   out   that   point. 

Mr.  Howard : — I  think  that  is  undoubtedly  true,  but  the  effect  of 
these  metalloids,  which  is  well  recognized,  and  which  I  quite  concur  in, 
justify   us    in   keeping  them   to   the   minimum. 

Mr.   G.  H.  Tinker    (New  York,   Chicago  &  St.  Louis)  : — The  speci- 


1024  RAIL. 

fication  states  that  silicon  is  not  to  exceed  0.20.  I  ask  if  it  would  not 
be  proper  to  have  also  a  low  limit  on  the  silicon;  say  that  it  should 
not  go  below  0.13? 

Mr.  Howard:— In  regard  to  the  general  chemical  problem,  I  would 
not  like  to  go  too  far  in  expressing  an  opinion.  I  would  prefer  to 
turn   that  over  to   the  steel   men. 

Mr.  Robert  Trimble  (Pennsylvania  Lines)  :— Mr.  Howard  has  talked 
about  the  large  internal  strains  which  are  set  up.  Take  a  steel  with 
an  ultimate  tensile  strength  of  about  150,000  pounds  per  square  inch; 
how  much  internal  stress  can  be  set  up  in  that  steel  necessary  to  cause 
a   fracture? 

Mr.  Howard : — The  internal  stresses  that  can  be  set  up  in  a  steel 
can  easily  reach  its  elastic  limit.  If  the  steel  had  an  elastic  limit  of 
say  from  35,000  to  45,000  pounds  per  square  inch,  we  could  closely 
approach   that   stress. 

Mr.  Trimble: — You   could  not  go  over  that? 

Mr.  Howard : — No ;  then  we  would  get  a  display  of  ductility. 

Mr.  Trimble : — I  understood  you  to  say  it  might  go  over  100,000 
pounds  per  square  inch? 

Mr.  Howard : — No ;  I  do  not  think  I  mentioned  that.  When  the 
steel  is  disturbed  (overloaded)  by  cold-working,  internal  strains  are 
certain  to  result.  When  a  beam  is  bent  transversely,  while  the  load  is 
sustained,  one  side  will  necessarily  be  in  tension,  the  other  in  com- 
pression, but  a  beam  which  is  given  a  permanent  bend,  so  as  not  to 
spring  back  straight  again  when  the  load  is  released,  will  have  internal 
strains  from  the  inside  to  the  outside,  described  as  follows :  First  ten- 
sion, then  compression,  then  the  neutral  axis,  then  tension  and  then 
compression  on  the  very  outside — that  is  what  you  will  find  in  a  bent 
beam,  one  which  has  been  bent  beyond  its  elastic  limit.  In  the  case  of 
straightening  rails,  and  it  is  impractical  to  straighten  them  except  when 
cold,  then  you  will  get  the  combination  of  internal  strains  just  de- 
scribed and  in  such  a  state  of  equilibrium  that  a  few  pounds  load  will 
be  sufficient  to  remove  some  of  the  initial  straightening.  Such  a  result 
cannot  be  avoided.  That  is  one  of  the  conditions  we  have  to  reckon 
with,  and  there  is  no  escape  from  it.  Observations  show  that  very 
little  additional  stress  on  a  cold  straightened  rail  will  put  back  some 
of  its  former  deflection,  that  we  cannot  escape  from,  and  the  intensity 
of  the  internal  strains  may  coincide  very  closely  with  elastic  limit  of 
the   material. 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay: — I  would  like  to  ask  Mr.  Howard  if  in  his  opinion 
the  process  of  annealing  would  permit  the  parts  to  adjust  themselves  and 
relieve  internal  strain? 

Mr.  Howard : — Annealing  certainly  does  restore  it.  Steel  responds 
very  readily  to  annealing  temperatures.  Internal  strains  introduced 
by  cold  working  can  also  be  put  in  with  great  facility  by  heating 
and  quenching.  Heat  a  cylinder  to  not  exceeding  1,000  degrees  Fahr- 
enheit, quench  with  cold  water  from  the  bore,  and  initial  compression 


DISCUSSION.  1025 

of  40,000  pounds  per  square  inch  may  easily  result.  These  internal 
strains  may  be  eliminated  by  annealing.  The  annealing,  to  be  effi- 
cient, has  to  be  carried  on  at  such  a  temperature  that  the  metal  does 
not  have  at  that  time  an  appreciable  elastic  limit.  Steel  appears  to 
have  some  strength  at  all  temperatures  up  to  fusion,  but  it  is  of 
a  viscous  nature  at  the  higher  temperatures.  When  those  softening 
viscous  temperatures  are  reached,  there  is  very  little  or  no  real  elastic 
limit,  and  if  the  steel  is  then  slowly  cooled  internal  strains  will  be 
eliminated. 

Mr.  Churchill : — So  far  as  Mr.  Howard's  statement  refers  to  No. 
4  alone,  in  behalf  of  the  Committee  I  would  state  that  the  chemistry 
is  the  chemistry  of  the  best  rails  that  we  have  in  service  to-day,  and 
have  had  for  years.  It  is  not  the  extreme,  one  way  or  the  other. 
In  carbon  it  is  the  limit  prescribed  in  a  number  of  both  manufacturers' 
and  other  specifications  that  have  been  used  recently,  and  the  limits 
are  those  within  which  the  manufacturers  say  they  can  work,  and 
therefore  we  want  to  make  especially  clear  the  fact  that  there  is  no 
departure  whatsoever  in  the  chemical  part  of  the  specifications  from 
what    has    been    regarded    for    years    as    good    practice. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — Some  manufacturers 
in  the  Bessemer  process  recommend  0.43  to  0.53  as  the  limit  of  carbon 
for  85  to  ioo-lb.  rail.  I  would  like  to  have  the  Committee  state  if 
they  think  that  lower  limit  would  not  be  more  satisfactory  than  the 
limit  of  0.45  to  0.55. 

Mr.  Churchill : — We  do  not  think  that  the  little  variation  of  the 
two  points — two-hundredths  in  carbon — has  any  bearing  in  a  lower 
limit.  This  is  a  workable  range,  0.45  to  0.55,  that  the  manufacturers 
have  been  endeavoring  to  adhere  to ;  and  they  are,  we  think,  keeping 
their  rails  more  within  those  limits  in  recent  years  than  they  were 
before.  The  long  series  of  tests  reported  last  year  in  the  second 
volume  of  Proceedings  shows  how  nearly  it  is  practicable  to  keep  a 
rail  within  the  specified  limits  as  to  chemistry.  We  think,  therefore, 
there  is  no  advantage  gained  in  slightly  modifying  either  the  lower 
limit  or  the  higher  limit.  If  there  was  anything  to  be  gained,  of 
course,  the  Committee  would  be  ready  to  consider  it.  I  would  say 
that  this  fourth  paragraph  has  been  passed  upon  by  the  Manufac- 
turers' Committee  as  well  as  the  Rail  Committee  and  agreed  to. 

The  President :— Any  further  discussion  on  No.  4?  If  not,  the 
Secretary    will    read    No.    5. 

The  Secretary  :• — "No.  5.  Modification  of  Carbon  for  Low  Phos- 
phorus. When  the  material  used  at  any  mill  is  such  that  the  average 
phosphorus  content  of  the  ingot  metal  used  in  the  Bessemer  process 
is  running  below  0.08  and  in  the  Open-Hearth  process  is  running 
below  0.03,  and  if  it  seems  mutually  desirable,  the  carbon  may  be 
increased  at  the  rate  of  0.035  f°r  eacn  °01  that  the  phosphorus  con- 
tent of  the  ingot  metal  used  averages  below  0.08  for  Bessemer  steel, 
or  0.03    for  Open-Hearth   steel." 


1026  v  RAIL 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — Before  we  pass  No.  5,  I  do  not  think  it  is 
quite  clear  enough.  It  says :  "When  the  material  used  at  any  mill 
is  such  that  the  average  phosphorus  content  of  the  ingot  metal  used 
in  the  Bessemer  process  is  runing  below  0.08  and  in  the  open-hearth 
process  is  running  below  0.03,  and  it  seems  mutually  desirable,  the 
carbon  may  be  increased  at  the  rate  of  0.035  for  each  0.01  that  the 
phosphorus  content  is  lower" — that  means  the  decrease  of  the  phos- 
phorus. If  you  want  the  lower  phosphorus,  you  want  the  higher 
carbon.  Therefore,  I  think  it  should  show  the  decrease  of  0.035. 
Phosphorus   content   would   be   clearer. 

Mr.    Churchill : — No ;    it   is   the   other   way. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — Where  you  have  decrease  in  the  phosphorus, 
you  can  raise  the  carbon.     It  does  not  seem  quite  clear  to  me. 

Mr.  Churchill : — I  think  if  you  will  reread  that  carefully  it  will 
be  clear — that  question  has  been  carefully  discussed — "for  each  decrease 
in  the  0.01  phosphorus."  It  is  desirable,  under  consent,  to  raise  the 
carbon  by  the  amount  stated.  The  point  is  that  some  mills,  in  their 
natural  process,  obtain  Bessemer  steel  below  0.08  in  phosphorus,  cer- 
tainly below  0.10.  The  result  would  be  if  we  had,  for  example,  0.06 
phosphorus  with  the  carbon  also  running  low,  an  abnormally  soft  rail. 
On  the  other  hand,  some  open-hearth  mills  naturally  run  their  phos- 
phorus down  to  the  neighborhood  of  0.01.  In  such  cases  as  that 
it  is  allowable  to  increase  the  carbon,  under  agreement,  by  0.03  to 
each  0.01  in  phosphorus  below  0.03.  However,  it  is  not  a  require- 
ment in  the  specification ;  it  is  a  matter  of  mutual  consent  or  agree- 
ment, after  the  contract  is  made  or  after  the  work  is  in  progress  of 
making  the   rails. 

The  President: — Any  additional  discussion  on  No.  5? 

Mr.  Tinker : — I  would  like  to  ask  why  the  Committee  changed 
this  specification  from  the  ordinary  practice  at  present.  The  manu- 
facturers furnish  manganese  determinations  on  every  fifth  heat.  This 
specification  requires  only  two  determinations  a  day.  I  think  it  is 
desirable  to  have  as  full  information  as  we  can  get  on  all  of  the 
elements. 

Mr.  Churchill: — We  find  this  to  be  the  general  practice,  and  it 
was  agreed  to  as  being  such.  There  may  be  some  exceptional  cases, 
where  the  determinations  are  made  more  often.  On  the  other  hand, 
I  want  to  call  to  the  attention  of  the  members  that  we  have  now 
specified  the  elements  the  average  of  which  are  to  be  furnished. 
In  some  other  specifications  this  was  not  called  for.  Now  we  have 
specifically  named  all  these  elements,  so  there  may  be  no  misunder- 
standing. This  paragraph  was  fully  discussed  between  our  Committee 
and    the    Manufacturers'    Committee    and    agreed   to  in    this    form. 

The  Secretary : — "6.  Average  Carbon.  It  is  desired  that  the  per- 
centage of  carbon  in  an  entire  order  of  rails  shall  average  as  high 
as   the   mean  percentage   between   the   upper   and   lower   limits    specified. 


DISCUSSION.  1027 

"7.  Analyses.  In  order  to  ascertain  whether  the  chemical  com- 
position is  in  accordance  with  the  requirements,  analyses  shall  be 
furnished  as  follows :  (a)  For  Bessemer  process  the  manufacturer 
shall  furnish  to  the  inspector,  daily,  carbon  determinations  for  each 
heat  before  the  rails  are  shipped,  and  two  chemical  analyses  every 
24  hours  representing  the  average  of  the  elements,  carbon,  manganese, 
silicon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur  contained  in  the  steel,  one  for  each 
day  and  night  turn,  respectively.  These  analyses  shall  be  made  on 
drillings  taken  from  the  ladle  test  ingot  not  less  than  one- eighth  inch 
beneath  the  surface,  fb)  For  Open-Hearth  process,  the  makers  shall 
furnish  the  inspectors  with  a  chemical  analysis  of  the  elements,  car- 
bon, manganese,  silicon,  phosphorus  and  sulphur,  for  each  heat.  (c) 
On  request  of  the  inspector,  the  manufacturer  shall  furnish  drillings 
from    the    test    ingot    for    check    analyses. 

"8.  Physical  Qualities.  Tests  shall  be  made  to  determine:  (a) 
Ductility   or   toughness   as  opposed   to   brittleness.     (b)   Soundness. 

"9.  Method  of  Testing.  The  physical  qualities  shall  be  deter- 
mined by   the   Drop   Test. 

"10.  Drop  Testing  Machine.  The  drop  testing  machine  used  shall 
be  the  standard  of  the  American  Railway  Engineering  Association, 
(a)  The  tup  shall  weigh  2,000  lbs.,  and  have  a  striking  face  with 
a  radius  of  5  inches.  (b)  The  anvil  block  shall  weigh  20,000  lbs., 
and  be  supported  on  springs,  (c)  The  supports  for  the  test  pieces 
shall  be  spaced  three  feet  between  centers  and  shall  be  a  part  of,  and 
firmly  secured  to,  the  anvil.  The  bearing  surfaces  of  the  supports 
shall  have   a    radius    of   five    inches. 

"11.  Pieces  for  Drop  Test.  Drop  tests  shall  be  made  on  pieces 
of  rail  not  less  than  four  feet  and  not  more  than  six  feet  long.  These 
test  pieces  shall  be  cut  from  the  top  end  of  the  top  rail  of  the  ingot, 
and  marked  on  the  base  or  head  with  gage  marks  one  inch  apart  for 
three  inches  each  side  of  the  center  of  the  test  piece,  for  measuring 
the    ductility    of    the    metal." 

Mr.  Churchill : — I  want  to  call  attention  to  the  fact  that  the  test 
pieces  are  to  be  marked  with  the  gage,  on  either  the  head  or  the  base, 
which  allows  it  to  be  tested  either  with  head  up  or  head  down.  I 
make  that  note  especially,  because  it  is  one  of  the  points  raised  by 
Mr.  Howard.  Undoubtedly  rails  break  oftener  in  track  from  top 
of  head  down.  Hence  a  drop  test  with  top  of  head  down  is  a  safe 
check.  This  was  made  the  subject  of  a  special  report  by  Mr.  Wick- 
horst,  and  you  are  all  familiar  with  it,  I  think,  as  it  is  given  in  a  recent 
Bulletin. 

The  Secretary: — "12.  Temperature  of  Test  Pieces.  The  tempera- 
ture of  the  test  pieces  shall  be  between  60  and  100  degrees  Fahrenheit." 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — That  was  changed  from  120  degrees  to  100 
degrees,   was   it  not,   Mr.    Chairman   of  the   Committee?     I    would   like 


1028  RAIL. 

to  know  the  purpose   of  that   change  from    120  degrees,   upper   limit,  to 
100  degrees. 

Mr.  Churchill: — It  was  felt  by  many  that  120  degrees  was  too 
high  a  limit,  and  would  result  in  not  giving  a  correct  gage  on  the 
results  of  the  test ;  100  degrees  is  easily  secured,  and  it  was  thought 
advisable  to  keep  the  test  piece  within  the  '  lower  range  at  the  time 
the  tests  were  being  made. 

The  Secretary : — "13.  Height  of  Drop.  The  test  piece  shall,  at 
the  option  of  the  inspector,  be  placed  head  or  base  upward  on  the 
supports,  and  be  subjected  to  impact  of  the  tup  falling  free  from 
the    following   heights : 

For  70-lb.   rail 16  feet 

For  80,  85  and  90- lb.  rail 17  feet 

For  100-lb.   rail 18  feet 

"14.  Elongation  or  Ductility.  Under  these  impacts  the  rail  under 
one  or  more  blows  shall  show  at  least  6  per  cent,  elongation  for  one 
inch,  or  5  per  cent,  each  for  two  consecutive  inches  of  the  six-inch 
scale,    marked   as   described   in    Section    11." 

Mr.  Churchill : — I  wish  to  call  the  attention  of  the  members  to 
the  fact  that  this  is  an  important  addition  to  general  specifications 
heretofore  issued.  Mr.  Howard  referred  to  this  matter.  If  you  will 
refer  to  page  818  and  page  830  of  this  Bulletin,  in  which  our  specifi- 
cations are  printed,  you  will  find  diagrams  showing  that  the  elonga- 
tion and  ductility  varies  with  the  other  tests.  We  all  know  that  one 
of  the  best  tests  of  steel  is  the  elongation  and  contraction  in  8  inches, 
or  2  inches,  as  the  case  may  be,  in  tests  of  structural  steel.  We 
want  to  use  a  test  for  rail  that  can  quickly  be  made,  and  at  the 
same  time  bring  out  this  same  comparative  information,  and  if  you 
will  refer  especially  to)  the  diagrams  on  page  830,  you  will  see  that 
the  ductility  test  shows  correspondence  to  a  very  fair  degree  with 
tensile  tests,  for  example,  and  on  the  preceding  page  you  will  see 
comparisons  between  reduction  of  area  and  elongation.  In  other  words, 
by  this  ductility  test  we  get  a  quick  means  of  finding  the  toughness 
or  ductility  of  the  material  in  rail  somewhat  similar  in  results  to 
those  secured  by  the  longer  method,  impracticable  of  use,  we  think,  in  rail 
manufacture — that  is,  the  turning  down  of  a  specimen,  and  subjecting 
it  to  a  test  for  tensile  strength,  reduction  of  area  and  elongation. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan  (Canadian  Pacific)  : — I  would  like  to  ask 
two  questions :  First,  I  see  there  is  only  one  limit — "must  show  at 
least  6  per  cent,  elongation."  Now,  is  it  not  a  fact  that  the  elongation 
bears  a  direct  ratio  to  the  middle  ordinate,  and  is  it  not  easier  to 
measure  the  middle  ordinate  in  a  chord  of  three  feet  than  it  is  to 
measure  the  elongation  by  measuring  the  distance  between  points 
and,  as  the  unit  will  be  greater,  will  you  not  get  more  accurate 
results?  This  on  the  assumption  that  there  is  a  direct  ratio  between 
the  two. 


DISCUSSION.  1029 

Mr.  Churchill : — We  do  not  agree  that  there  is  a  direct  ratio 
between  the  two.  We  started  out  a  few  years  ago  with  the  idea 
that  the  permanent  set  would  be  something  of  a  guide,  that  it  would 
give  an  idea  of  the  character  and  uniformity  of  the  material ;  but 
if  you  will  refer  to  Part  2  of  last  year's  Proceedings,  you  will  find 
that  there  were  very  great  variations  on  the  permanent  set  meas- 
urements. Mr.  Wickhorst  has  since  reported  upon  »this  same  matter, 
and  we  find,  in  brief,  that  the  permanent  set  is  not  a  uniform  gage; 
that  the  minimum  ductility  is  a  better  gage,  and  it  is  for  that  reason 
that  it  is  suggested.  The  permanent  set  is  given  in  the  next  para- 
graph, and  we  hope  we  can  fix  limits  in  the  course  of  time  to  deter- 
mine that  the  material  is  not  too   soft. 

The  President: — What  is  your  second  question,  Mr.   Sullivan? 

Mr.  John   G.   Sullivan : — That  answers   the   second   one. 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs  (Consulting  Engineer)  : — Is  there  any  difference 
in  the  result  of  the  test,  depending  on  whether  the  rail  is  tested  head 
up  or  head  down  ? 

Mr.  Churchill : — Mr.  Wickhorst  brings  that  out  very  plainly  in 
the  latter  part  of  this  Bulletin.  Head  down  for  the  upper  portion 
of  the  rail  bar  shows  a  little  less  elongation  than  with  head  up ;  in 
the  rest  of  the  bar  the  reverse  is  true.  The  safest  course  is,  therefore, 
to  take  head  down.  We  have  made  it  allowable  for  the  inspector 
to  make   the  test  either   way. 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb  (Consulting  Engineer)  : — I  would  like 
to  ask  if  there  should  not  be  some  specification  as  to  stiffness  of  the 
springs  which  support  the  anvil  block.  It  states  merely  that  they 
should  be  supported  on  springs.  I  think  it  would  make  quite  a  dif- 
ference whether  those  springs  were  abnormally   stiff  or  abnormally  easy. 

Mr.  Churchill : — That  is  all  given  in  the  specifications  for  the 
standard  drop  testing  machine  adopted  by  the  Association  a  few 
years  ago. 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs : — Based  upon  what  the  Chairman  of  the 
Committee  said  a  moment  ago,  would  it  not  be  desirable,  though  I 
do  not  make  this  as  a  motion,  to  add  to  that  paragraph  some  state- 
ment to  the  effect  that  it  is  desirable  to  test  in  one  way  rather  than 
the  other? 

The   President : — Not  at  the  present  time,  Mr.   Coombs. 

The  Secretary: — "15.  Permanent  Set.  It  is  desired  that  the  per- 
manent set  after  one  blow  under  the  drop  test  shall  not  exceed  that 
in  the  following  table,  and  a  record  shall  be  made  of  this  information." 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch : — The  Committee,  in  commenting  on  section  15, 
says  that  it  is  the  intention,  when  sufficient  data  are  at  hand,  to 
prescribe  maximum  and  minimum  limits  for  deflections  under  the 
drop  test,  and  that  this  method  of  classifying  rails  is  only  tentative. 
I  do  not  think  any  of  us  would  reject  any  rails  on  this  specification, 
and  it  occurs  to  me  that  that  paragraph  could  just  as  well  be  left  out 


1030  RAIL. 

of  these  specifications  until  we  have  reached  definite  conclusions  where 
the  maximum  and  minimum  could  be  fixed.  While,  of  course,  it  is 
a  question  of  getting  information  and  records,  I  believe  we  can 
spend  our  time  better  in  getting  physical  tests  of  rails  and  not  include 
this  at  the  present  time  until  we  have  reached  some  definite  data 
that  will  give  us  a  maximum  and  a  minimum  that  we  can  reject 
rails  upon  or  accept  rails. 

Mr.  Churchill: — I  will  state  that  it  is  easy  to  measure  the  per- 
manent set  at  the  time  the  elongation  is  measured,  and  with  the  elongation 
secured  the  permanent  set  becomes  the  check  on  too  soft  material.  We 
want  this  information  and  we  hope  it  will  be  taken.  It  is  not  an  item 
mandatory  or  as  a  basis  of  condemning  the  rail,  but  we  think  that  we  will 
soon  have  a  figure  for  the  maximum  set  to  determine  when  a  rail  is  too 
soft.  We  sometimes  receive  rail  that  is  too  soft.  Some  of  us  have,  I 
think,  within  the  last  two  years  set  aside  heats  of  steel  that  have  been 
found  to  be  too  soft. 

The  Secretary: — "16.  Test  to  Destruction.  The  test  pieces  which  do 
not  break  under  the  first  or  subsequent  blows  shall  be  nicked  and  broken,  to 
determine  whether  the  interior  metal  is  sound." 

Mr.  Churchill: — I  would  explain,  in  behalf  of  the  Committee,  that 
this  test  shows,  first,  whether  or  not  the  material  is  too  brittle,  and  the 
test  to  "destruction"  shows  whether  enough  discard  has  been  made  to 
secure  sound  material. 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs: — My  question  is  partly  answered,  I  think,  b}r 
what  Mr.  Churchill  has  just  said.  My  question  was  in  reference  to 
the  use  of  the  word  "sound."  If  the  metal  were  really  unsound, 
would  not  the  drop  test  show  it?  It  is  a  question  of  what  is  meant 
by  "sound." 

Mr.  Churchill: — No,  sir;  a  pipe  rail  is  not  discovered  by  a  simple 
drop  test  alone. 

The  Secretary: — "17.  Bessemer  Process  Drop  Tests.  One  piece 
shall  be  tested  from  each  heat  of  Bessemer  steel. 

"(a)  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  at  the  first  blow  and  shows 
the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall 
be  accepted,  provided  that  the  test  piece  when  nicked  and  broken  does 
not  show  interior  defect. 

"(b)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the 
required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  test  piece  shows  the  re- 
quired elongation  but  when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect, 
all  of  the  top  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

"(c)  A  second  test  shall  then  be  made  of  a  test  piece  selected 
by  the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  second  rail  of  the  same 
heat,  preferably  of  the  same  ingot.  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break 
at  the  first  blow,  and  shows  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all 
of  the  remainder  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided 
that  the  test  piece  when  nicked  and  broken  does  not  show  interior 
defect. 


DISCUSSION.  1031 

"(d)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the 
required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  piece  shows  the  required 
elongation  but  when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect,  all  of 
the  second  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

"(e)  A  third  test  shall  then  be  made  of  a  test  piece  selected  by 
the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  third  rail  of  the  same  heat, 
preferably  of  the  same  ingot.  If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  at  the 
first  blow  and  shows  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  all  of  the 
remainder  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided  that  the 
test  piece  when  nicked  and  broken  does  not  show  interior  defect. 

"(f)  If  the  piece  breaks  at  the  first  blow,  or  does  not  show  the 
required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  the  piece  shows  the  required 
elongation  but  when  nicked  and  broken  shows  interior  defect,  all  of 
the  remainder  of  the  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected." 

Mr.  Churchill: — In  behalf  of  the  Committee,  I  wish  to  explain 
that  this  method  of  testing,  or  rather  the  additional  number  of  tests, 
are  made  primarily  to  discover,  of  course,  anything  that  is  defective, 
and  secondly,  and  of  almost  equal  importance,  so  as  not  to  throw 
away  any  good  material.  We  have  proved,  in  the  last  two  years, 
that  the  making  of  tests  is  very  quickly  done  in  this  manner  and 
that  they  are  not  costly.  There  is  very  little  expense  connected  with 
it.  This  form  of  testing  can  be  quickly  made;  and  the  result  of  these 
three  trials,  if  necessary,  on  a  Bessemer  heat  of  steel,  will  reduce  to 
a  minimum  the  amount  of  material  that  is  thrown  away  and  will 
save  all  good  material. 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb: — I  do  not  see  the  necessity  of  the 
words  "or  subsequent"  at  the  end  of  the  first  line  of  No.  16,  because 
it  would  seem  as  if  all  those  tests  which  follow  depend  on  the  first 
blow.  As  far  as  I  can  see,  it  does  not  depend  on  any  subsequent 
blow. 

Mr.  Churchill: — That  brings  out  the  point  I  probably  should  have 
explained  before.  In  No.  13,  the  question  of  ductility  is  described — 
how  we  get  it.  Now  it  is  conceivable  and  it  often  does  happen  that 
the  full  ductility  of  the  metal  is  not  secured  under  one  blow,  in  an 
18-foot  drop,  therefore  we  make  a  second  blow.  In  case  we  have  not 
6  per  cent,  elongation,  for  example,  even  a  less  drop  than  18  feet 
may  be  used  for  the  second  blow.  We  want  to  find  what  is  the  total 
ductility  of  the  rail;  if  it  is  over  6  per  cent,  in  the  inch,  it  is  an  ac- 
ceptable rail  under  that  test.  Therefore,  there  may  be  more  than 
one  blow  necessary  before  the  ductility  is  determined  or  the  rail  is 
broken.  Next,  if  the  rail  does  not  break  in  developing  ductility,  we 
want  to  go  on  with  the  breaking  to  destruction,  to  find  out  the 
character  of  the  inner  metal  as  far  as  the  eye  can  determine,  that  is, 
to  find  out  whether  there  are  any  interior  flaws. 

Mr.  W.  L.  Seddon  (Seaboard  Air  Line): — I  would  like  to  ask  the 
Committee  whether  they  have  considered  at  all  the  breaking  of  a 
piece  from  the  top  of  each  ingot  for  soundness.     It  seems  to  me  that 


1032  RAIL. 

the  drop  test  and  the  breaking  of  the  rail  for  soundness  is  all  right 
so  far  as  that  ingot  goes,  but  it  does  not  seem  to  me  that  that  would 
necessarily  tell  us  anything  about  the  soundness  of  the  top  rails  of 
the  other  ingots. 

Mr.  Churchill: — The  method  is  the  carrying  out  of  the  general 
practice  in  all  steel  testing.  We  do  not  test  every  ingot  of  any  struc- 
tural steel.  From  our  present  information  we  think  it  would  not  be 
possible  to  keep  the  mills  running  and  test  every  individual  ingot. 
We  do  not  say  that  as  a  finality.  It  is  certainly  in  the  right  line  to 
test  more  ingots.  We  propose  to  test  a  good  deal  more  under  these 
specifications  than  we  have  tested  heretofore.  We  believe  that  under 
this  testing  method — or  the  expansion  of  this  method  later,  that  we 
may  be  able  to  reduce  the  chemistry  requirements. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — Mr.  Seddon  has  brought  up  a  point  which  I  was 
going  to  touch  on  after  the  drop  test  on  the  open-hearth  had  been 
read,  but  as  he  has  brought  up  the  point  I  would  like  to  discuss  it 
now.  It  seems  to  me  we  have  reached  a  point  where  we  ought  to 
quit  taking  a  chance  on  accepting  a  lot  of  rails  about  which  we  know 
nothing,  in  regard  to  the  soundness  of  the  material.  The  only  way 
we  can  arrive  at  that  is  to  take  a  test  piece  from  each  ingot  and  test 
it  to  destruction.  Now,  while  it  is  said  that  this  seems  to  be  imprac- 
ticable, and  at  the  present  time  will  delay  the  mills  in  their  operation, 
yet  by  providing  the  necessary  equipment,  it  should  not  take  much 
time.  It  need  not  be  a  test  piece  of  the  full  length,  as  specified  here. 
A  shorter  test  piece  can  be  taken,  and  if  it  does  involve  a  slightly 
additional  cost,  it  certainly  will  be  worth  the  expense.  The  specifica- 
tions are  a  great  advance  over  previous  specifications,  especially  in 
the  open-hearth  process,  where  a  test  piece  from  three  ingots  is  re- 
quired, but  if  there  are  sixteen  to  nineteen  or  more  ingots  we  have 
to  take  a  chance  on  the  balance.  We  know  nothing  positively  about 
them,  and  it  occurs  to  me,  if  we  have  a  test  of  this  kind,  including 
the  primary  tests  mentioned,  which  are  all  right  as  far  as  that  goes, 
and  then  require  some  secondary  test  made  for  soundness,  something 
on  the  following  order,  it  would  be  desirable: 

"In  addition  to  the  primary  tests  above  provided,  the  remaining 
ingots  not  tested  shall  be  subjected  to  the  following  tests,  to  insure 
sound  rails  from  each  individual  ingot. 

"A  test  piece  shall  be  taken  from  the  'A'  rail  and  if,  when  nicked 
and  broken,  shows  no  interior  defect,  all  the  rails  of  that  ingot  shall 
be  accepted.  If,  when  nicked  and  broken,  it  shows  interior  defects 
the  'A'  rail  of  that  ingot  shall  be  rejected,  and  a  test  piece  taken  from 
the  'B'  rail.  If  the  test  piece,  when  nicked  and  broken,  shows  no 
interior  defect,  all  the  remaining  rails  of  the  ingot  shall  be  accepted. 
If  the  test  piece,  when  nicked  and  broken,  shows  interior  defects  all 
the  rails  above  and  including  the  'B'  rails  of  the  ingot  shall  be  re- 
jected, and  a  test  piece  taken  from  the  'C  rail  and  tested  in  the  same 
manner,   and  this  process  shall  be  continued  until  the  remainder  of 


DISCUSSION.  1033 

the  rails  of  the  ingot  are  tested  wherever  the  presence  of  interior  de- 
fects is  developed." 

Mr.  Churchill: — I  presume  you  make  that  as  a  suggestion. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — Simply  as  a  suggestion. 

Mr.  Churchill: — We  would  prefer  that  you  turn  that  suggestion 
over  to  us  and  let  us  work  on  it.  We  think,  during  the  coming  year, 
we  can  go  on  with  the  work  along  this  line.  We  do  not  think  your 
suggestion  can  be  carried  out  at  present.  The  whole  intent  of  para- 
graphs 17  and  18  is  to  encourage  tests.  This  Association  was  respon- 
sible, a  few  years  ago,  for  increasing  the  number  of  tests  from  one 
in  five  heats  to  one  in  each  heat.  You  know  what  difficulty  we  had 
to  convince  not  only  members  but  the  manufacturers  as  well,  that 
that  could  be  done.  The  manufacturers  and  others  are  modifying 
their  views,  and  I  believe,  as  we  use  these  specifications,  all  will 
soon  be  in  hearty  accord  in  multiplying  tests.  The  same  labor  force 
is  constantly  at  the  drop  testing  machine,  and  I  see  no  reason  in  the 
world  why,  if  any  question  is  raised  about  any  ingot  or  any  test,  an 
inspector  should  not  say,  "We  will  go  and  test  the  next  ingot;"  and 
especially  is  that  true  in  open-hearth  steel,  where  the  heats  are  larger. 
But  you  notice  we  have  provided  for  three  tests  in  the  Bessemer 
heat,  which  is  far  ahead  of  anything  before.  The  principle  that  is 
laid  down  here,  as  far  as  the  tests  are  concerned,  is  a  well-defined 
principle  applied  in  testing  all  materials  used  by  railroads  and  every  other 
class  of  work.  Bridge  material  is  tested  in  this  method,  not  by 
every  ingot.  Wheels  are  tested  by  this  method,  not  by  every  ingot; 
axles,  everything  we  use,  are  tested  under  this  general  scheme.  If 
we  find  that  a  decided  improvement  can  be  gained  under  your  sug- 
gestion, we  are  in  for  it,  and  I  think  the  manufacturers  will  be  in 
for  it,  if  we  can  show  that. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — I  do  not  want  to  be  understood  as  criticising 
the  Committee  in  any  way. 

The  President: — They  are  here  for  criticism. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch- — I  think  we  have  made  a  great  improvement, 
especially  on  the  question  of  tests  on  open-hearth  steel.  I  believe  this 
will  work  both  ways.  I  think  we  are  rejecting  a  lot  of  rail  now  that 
will  be  accepted. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan: — For  information  of  the  Committee,  one 
of  our  Canadian  mills  proposed  voluntarily  that  they  would  sell  us 
rails  on  the  test  of  top  piece  at  every  ingot,  at  50  cents  per  ton 
extra.  Did  I  correctly  understand  Mr.  Churchill  to  state  that  he  was 
going  to  keep  hammering  a  rail  until  he  got  that  ductility? 

Mr.  Churchill: — If  the  test  piece  does  not  break  on  the  first  blow, 
and  at  the  same  time. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan: — I  think  we  would  be  getting  on  dangerous 
ground.     I  would  be  very  much  afraid  of  that. 

Mr.  Churchill: — Why  so?  It  is  the  same  process  that  we  adopted 
in  getting  the  ductility,  under  the  static  test;  we  carry  it  out  to  a 


1034  RAIL. 

failure.  I  think  it  would  be  a  mistake  to  say  that  a  rail  must  show  a 
given  ductility  as  a  minimum,  with  an  18-foot  drop.  I  speak  now  of 
ioo-lb.  rail.  If  that  rail  will  stand  the  18-foot  drop,  we  have  not 
at  that  time  gotten  a  measure  of  what  the  ductility  is.  Hence,  an- 
other drop  may  be  made,  though  it  may  be  of  less  height  than  18  feet. 
It  is  shown  by  withstanding  the  first  drop  that  it  is  not  brittle,  but 
we  have  not  the  full  measure  of  the  ductility. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan: — What  I  would  be  afraid  of  would  be  this: 
I  think  we  all  agree  that  the  drop  test  is  the  physical  check  '011 
chemical  composition,  and  if  the  material  is  at  all  uniform  we  should 
get  a  uniform  deflection  or  percentage  of  ductility  with  a  uniform 
weight  dropping  a  uniform  distance.  If,  however,  the  majority  of 
the  rails  gave  prescribed  results  on  receiving  one  blow,  it  would 
indicate  to  my  mind  that  the  rail  that  had  to  be  hit  two  or  three 
times  was  either  high  in  phosphorus  or  carbon,  and  that  while  that 
particular  piece  might  stand  this  treatment,  I  would  be  afraid  of 
some  of  the  other  rails  from  the  same  heat  of  ingot. 

Mr.  Churchill: — Remember  this  is  the  top  rail  of  the  ingot,  which 
is  in  all  probability  the  worst  piece  there  is. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan : — I  had  never  heard  of  that  second  dropping 
before,  and  I  should  like  to  ask  for  information,  have  any  rails  been 
accepted  under  that  specification? 

Mr.  Churchill: — Yes. 

Mr.  John  G.  Sullivan: — How  many  of  those  have  to  be  hit  half 
a  dozen  times  or  twice  to  get  ductility?  Is  it  the  general  thing  or  the 
exception?    If  it  is  the  exception,  I  would  be  afraid  of  it. 

Mr.  George  W.  Kittredge  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — 
For  the  information  of  the  Association,  the  specifications  of  the  New 
York  Central  Lines  have  required  subsequent  blows  if  the  ductility  is 
not  brought  out  on  the  first  blow.  All  the  rails  accepted  by  the  New 
York  Central  Lines  have  been  subjected  to  that  test  for  a  great 
many  years. 

Mr.  Seddon: — Do  I  understand,  if  one  of  these  three  rails  breaks 
and  the  other  two  stand  up,  that  the  whole  heat  is  accepted? 

Mr.  Churchill: — This  is  accepting  an  ingot  on  the  best  two  out  of 
three.     We  had  only  one  test  heretofore;  now  we  get  three. 

Mr.  Seddon: — You  are  accepting  something  where  one  shows  bad. 

Mr.  Churchill: — We  would  not  use  the  bad  one.  The  top  rail 
would  be  discarded. 

Mr.  Seddon: — The  top  rail  of  that  single  ingot? 

Mr.  Churchill: — Yes,  sir. 

The  Secretary: — "18.  Open-Hearth  Process  Drop  Tests.  Test 
pieces  shall  be  selected  from  the  second,  middle  and  last  full  ingot  of 
each  open-hearth  heat. 

"(a)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  do  not  break  at  the  first  blow 
and  show  the  required  elongation   (Section  14),  all  of  the  rails  of  the 


DISCUSSION.  1035 

heat  shall  be  accepted,  provided  that  these  test  pieces  when  nicked 
and  broken  do  not  show  interior  defect. 

"(b)  If  two  of  the  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow,  or  do  not 
show  the  required  elongation,  or  if  any  of  the  pieces  that  have  been 
tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show  interior  defect, 
all  of  the  top  rails  from  that  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

"(c)  Second  tests  shall  then  be  made  from  three  test  pieces  selected 
by  the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  second  rails  of  the  same 
heat,  preferably  of  the  same  ingots.  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  do 
not  break  at  the  first  blow  and  show  the  required  elongation  (Section 
14),  all  of  the  remainder  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  accepted, 
provided  that  the  pieces  that  have  been  tested  under  the  drop  when 
nicked  and  broken  do  not  show  interior  defect. 

"(d)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow  or  do  not 
show  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  any  of  the  pieces 
that  have  been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show 
interior  defect,  all  of  the  second  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be  rejected. 

"(e)  Third  tests  shall  then  be  made  from  three  test  pieces  se- 
lected by  the  inspector  from  the  top  end  of  any  third  rails  of  the 
same  heat,  preferably  of  the  same  ingots.  If  two  of  these  test  pieces 
do  not  break  at  the  first  blow,  and  show  the  required  elongation 
(Section  14),  all  of  the  remainder  of  the  rails  of  the  heat  shall  be 
accepted,  provided  that  the  pieces  that  have  been  tested  under  the 
drop  when  nicked  and  broken  do  not  show  interior  defect. 

"(f)  If  two  of  these  test  pieces  break  at  the  first  blow  or  do  not 
show  the  required  elongation  (Section  14),  or  if  any  of  the  pieces 
that  have  been  tested  under  the  drop  when  nicked  and  broken  show 
interior  defect,  all  of  the  remainder  of  the  rails  from  that  heat  shaM 
be  rejected. 

"19.  No.  1  Rails.  No.  1  classification  rails  shall  be  free  from 
injurious  defects  and  flaws  of  all  kinds. 

"20.  No.  2  Rails,  (a)  Rails,  which,  by  reason  of  surface  im- 
perfections, or  for  causes  mentioned  in  Section  30  hereof,  are  not 
classed  as  No.  1  rails,  will  be  accepted  as  No.  2  rails,  but  No.  2  rails 
which  contain  imperfections  in  such  number  or  of  such  character  as 
will,  in  the  judgment  of  the  inspector,  render  them  unfit  for  recog- 
nized No.  2  uses,  will  not  be  accepted  for  shipment. 

"(b)  No.  2  rails  to  the  extent  of  5  per  cent,  of  the  whole  order 
will  be  received.  All  rails  accepted  as  No.  2  rails  shall  have  the  ends 
painted  white  and  shall  have  two  prick  punch  marks  on  the  side  of 
the  web  near  the  heat  number  near  the  end  of  the  rail,  so  placed  as 
not  to  be  covered  by  the  splice  bars. 

"21.  Quality  of  Manufacture.  The  entire  process  of  manufacture 
shall  be  in  accordance  with  the  best  current  state  of  the  art. 

"22.     Bled  Ingots.    Bled  ingots  shall  not  be  used. 


1036  RAIL. 

"23.  Discard.  There  shall  be  sheared  from  the  end  of  the  bloom, 
formed  from  the  top  of  the  ingot,  sufficient  metal  to  secure  sound 
rails." 

Mr.  Seddon: — Is  there  not  some  possibility  of  going  to  the  39- 
foot  rail? 

The  President: — The  question  of  longer  rails  is  being  studied. 

Mr.  Seddon: — I  think  we  ought  to  try  to  get  a  longer  rail. 

The  President: — That  is  under  investigation. 

Mr.  W.  F.  Steffens  (Boston  &  Albany): — Is  it  necessary  to  jn- 
clude  any  statement  as  to  the  fact  that  this  10  per  cent,  of  short  rails 
shall  not  come  at  one  time?  In  a  case  with  which  the  Chairman  is 
acquainted  the  manufacturers  tried  to  ship  the  entire  order  of  shorts 
first. 

Mr.  Churchill: — I  do  not  see  how  we  can  control  that  matter.  It 
is  one  of  the  things  that  can  be  fixed  in  the  contract  between  the 
buyer  and  the  purchaser  under  mutual  agreement. 

The  Secretary: — "24.  Lengths.  The  standard  length  of  rails 
shall  be  33  feet,  at  a  temperature  of  60  degrees  Fahrenheit.  Ten  per 
cent,  of  the  entire  order  will  be  accepted  in  shorter  lengths  varying 
by  1  foot  from  32  feet  to  25  feet.  A  variation  of  %  inch  from  the 
specified  lengths  will  be  allowed.  No.  1  rails  less  than  33  feet  long 
shall  be  painted  green  on  both  ends. 

"25.  Shrinkage.  The  number  of  passes  and  speed  of  train  shall 
be  so  regulated  that  on  leaving  the  rolls  at  the  final  pass,  the  temper- 
ature of  the  rail  will  not  exceed  that  which  requires  a  shrinkage  al- 
lowance at  the  hot  saws,  for  a  rail  33  feet  in  length  and  of  100  lbs. 
section,  of  6-y\  inches  and  %  inch  less  for  each  10  lbs.  decrease  in 
section. 

"26.  Cooling.  The  bars  shall  not  be  held  for  the  purpose  of  re- 
ducing their  temperature,  nor  shall  any  artificial  means  of  cooling 
them  be  used  after  they  leave  the  finishing  pass.  Rails,  while  on  the 
cooling  beds,  shall  be  protected  from  snow  and  water. 

"27.  Section.  The  section  of  rails  shall  conform  as  accurately 
as  possible  to  the  template  furnished  by  the  Railroad  Company.  A 
variation  in  height  of  1/64  inch  less  or  1/32  inch  greater  than  the 
specified  height,  and  1/16  inch  in  width  of  flange,  will  be  permitted; 
but  no  variation  shall  be  allowed  in  the  dimensions  affecting  the  fit 
of  the  splice  bars." 

Mr.  Lindsay: — What  can  be  done  to  check  the  overfilling  or  the 
underfilling  of  the  head  of  the  rail?  Very  often  we  get  a  rail  with 
too  much  metal  in  the  center  of  the  head  or  too  little  metal  in  the 
center  of  the  head,  and  while  it  might  comply  with  the  specifications 
as  to  height,  it  would  be  objectionable. 

Mr.  Churchill : — I  think  the  careful  using  of  the  template  on  the 
part  of  the  inspectors  will  result  in  checking  that.  These  are  the 
usual  limits. 


DISCUSSION.  1037 

The  Secretary: — "28.  Weight.  The  weight  of  the  rails  specified 
in  the  order  shall  be  maintained  as  nearly  as  possible,  after  complying 
with  the  preceding  section.  A  variation  of  one-half  of  1  per  cent, 
from  the  calculated  weight  of  section,  as  applied  to  an  entire  order, 
will  be  allowed. 

"29.  Payment.  Rails  will  be  accepted  and  paid  for  according  to 
actual  weights." 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — It  occurred  to  me  that  Section  29  would  read 
a  little  better  if  it  were  changed  to  read,  "Rails  accepted  will  be  paid 
for  according  to  actual  weights." 

Mr.  Churchill: — We  accept  that. 

The  Secretary: — "30.  Straightening.  The  hot  straightening  shall 
be  carefully  done,  so  that  gagging  under  the  cold  presses  will  be  re- 
duced to  a  minimum.  Any  rail  coming  to  the  straightening  presses 
showing  sharp  kinks  or  greater  camber  than  that  indicated  by  a 
middle  ordinate  of  4  inches  in  33  feet,  for  A.  R.  A.  type  of  sections, 
or  5  inches  for  A.  S.  C.  E.  type  of  sections,  will  be  at  once  classed 
as  a  No.  2  rail.  The  distance  between  the  supports  of  rails  in  the 
straightening  presses  shall  not  be  less  than  42  inches.  The  supports 
shall  have  flat  surfaces  and  be  out  of  wind. 

"31.  Drilling.  Circular  holes  for  joint  bolts  shall  be  drilled  to 
conform  accurately  in  every  respect  to  the  drawing  and  dimensions 
furnished  by  the  Railroad  Company. 

"32.  Finishing,  (a)  All  rails  shall  be  smooth  on  the  heads, 
straight  in  line  and  surface,  and  without  any  twists,  waves  or  kinks. 
They  shall  be  sawed  square  at  the  ends,  a  variation  of  not  more  than 
1/32  inch  being  allowed;  and  burrs  shall  be  carefully  removed. 

"(b)  Rails  improperly  drilled  or  straightened,  or  from  which  the 
burrs  have  not  been  removed,  shall  be  rejected,  but  may  be  accepted 
after  being  properly  finished. 

"33.  Branding.  The  name  of  the  manufacturer,  the  weight  and 
type  of  rail,  and  the  month  and  year  of  manufacture  shall  be  rolled 
in  raised  letters  and  figures  on  the  side  of  the  web.  The  number  of 
the  heat  and  a  letter  indicating  the  portion  of  the  ingot  from  which 
the  rail  was  made  shall  be  plainly  stamped  on  the  web  of  each  rail, 
where  it  will  not  be  covered  by  the  splice  bars.  The  top  rails  shall 
be  lettered  'A,'  and  the  succeeding  ones  'B,'  'C,'  'D,'  etc.,  consecu- 
tively; but  in  case  of  a  top  discard  of  20  or  more  per  cent.,  the  letter 
'A'  will  be  omitted.  Open-hearth  rails  shall  be  branded  or  stamped 
'O.  H.'  All  markings  of  rails  shall  be  done  so  effectively  that  the 
marks  may  be  read  as  long  as  the  rails  are  in  service. 

"34.  Separate  Classes.  All  classes  of  rails  shall  be  kept  separate 
from  each  other. 

"35.  Loading.  All  rails  shall  be  loaded  in  the  presence  of  the 
inspector." 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb: — I  would  like  to  ask  why,  at  the  be- 
ginning of  Section  26,  the  word  "bars"  is  used  instead  of  "rails"? 


1038  RAIL. 

Mr.  Churchill : — Those  are  not  yet  rails.  They  are  in  the  process 
of  being  made  rails;  therefore,  they  are  bars. 

The  President: — Does  anyone  wish  to  make  any  remarks  on  these 
specifications  before  a  motion  is  put  for  their  adoption? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — Mr.  Chairman,  I  move  that  the  specifications, 
as  amended,  be  adopted. 

The  President: — For  printing  in  the  Manual? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — Yes,  sir. 

The  President: — Any  remarks  on  the  motion? 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  oj 
the  Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  WOOD  PRESERVATION. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.   863-S72.) 
LIST   OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING   PART   IN    DISCUSSION    ON    WOOD    PRESERVATION. 

S.  R.  Church.  L.  C.  Fritch.  C.   H.   Spencer. 

R.  D.  Coombs.  V.  K.  Hendricks.  Earl  Stimson. 

L.  G.  Curtis.  C.  E.  Lindsay.  Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk. 

S.   B.   Fisher.  Hunter  McDonald.  Walter  Loring  Webb. 

E.  A.  Frink.  W.   L.   Seddon.  S.    N.    Williams. 

The  President: — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Wood  Preservation,  Mr.  Earl  Stimson,  Chairman.  We  will  have  the 
opening  statement  by  Mr.  Stimson. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson  (Baltimore  &  Ohio): — Mr.  Chairman,  before 
taking  up  the  consideration  of  the  report,  I  want  to  call  attention  to 
a  few  typographical  errors.  On  page  863,  under  "Work  assigned  by 
Board  of  Direction,"  paragraph  3,  second  line,  the  sixth  word  should 
be  '"gas."  On  page  864,  from  the  top  of  the  page,  paragraph  3,  the 
second  line,  the  word  "beeches"  should  be  "beech."  In  the  same  line, 
next  to  the  last  word,  the  word  "hardwood,"  should  be  "heartwood." 
On  page  865,  under  "Revision  of  adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote 
Oil,"  the  clause  in  the  fourth  line,  under  "standard  specifications  for 
creosote  oil,"  namely,  "including  coal-gas  tar  or  coke-oven  tar," 
should  be  placed  after  the  word  "tar"  in  the  third  line,  making  that 
line  read,  "and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  including  coal-gas  tar  and 
coke-oven  tar,  or  oil  or  residue,"  etc.  The  same  correction  is  to  be 
made  under  Specifications  for  No.  2  Grade  Creosote  Oil,  the  changes 
occurring  in  the  same  .  lines,  and  also  the  same  correction  under 
Specifications  for  No.  3  Grade  Creosote  Oil.  With  these  corrections 
we  will  take  up  the  consideration  of  our  report. 

The  Board  of  Direction  assigned  eight  subjects  for  the  consider- 
ation of  the  Committee.  Following  the  instructions  with  reference  to 
making  up  reports,  we  selected  two  of  these  subjects  upon  which  to 
report  conclusions.  These  two  subjects  are:  "the  grouping  of  timbers 
for  antiseptic  treatment,"  and  "the  revision  of  the  adopted  Specifica- 
tions for  Creosote  Oil." 

Under  the  grouping  of  timbers  for  antiseptic  treatment,  I  will 
state  that  arrangements  were  made  last  year  for  a  series  of  co-opera- 
tive experiments  at  various  plants  to  determine  the  best  method  of 
grouping  different  species  in  different  regions.  These  tests  are  not 
completed,  but  progress  to  date  is  reported  in  Appendix  E  of  this  re- 
port.   "Past  experience  has  demonstrated  and  your  Committee  recom- 

1039 


1040  WOOD    PRESERVATION. 

mends  that  such  principles  as  have  received  recognition  in  standard 
practice  be  embodied  in  the  Manual."  These  principles  are  given 
in  this  paragraph,  there  being  four.  Another  subject  which  received 
consideration  of  the  Committee,  and  which,  to  my  mind,  is  of  great 
importance  and  interest  to  the  Association,  is  the  record  of  service 
tests.  Last  year  the  Committee  recommended,  and  the  recommenda- 
tion was  adopted,  that  certain  sections  of  track  be  selected  on  each 
railroad  for  the  purpose  of  making  accurate  tests,  covering  the  life 
of  treated  and  untreated  ties.  We  wrote  to  various  roads  making 
inquiries  as  to  whether  such  tests  had  been  inaugurated,  and,  if  so, 
to  obtain  data  and  information  bearing  on  such  tests.  In  Appendix 
R  you  will  find  this  information  tabulated.  It  is  the  intention  of  the 
Committee  that  this  form  a  nucleus  of  a  permanent  record  of  service 
tests,  to  be  added  to  from  year  to  year. 

Aside  from  the  tests  reported  in  this  tabulated  statement,  we 
received  too  late  to  include  in  it,  the  record  of  forty  service  tests 
from  the  Forest  Service.  These  will  be  added  to  this  record  and  pub- 
lished next  year.  The  Committee  is  going  to  make  a  very  strenuous 
effort  to  keep  up  this  record  and  make  it  as  complete  as  possible.  It 
is  hoped  it  will  form  a  source  of  very  valuable  information  to  the 
Association. 

Your  Committee  was  also  instructed  to  investigate  the  merits  of 
various  preservatives,  specifying  oil  from  water  gas  tar  and  the 
use  of  refined  coal-tar  in  creosote  oil.  While  the  Committee  instituted 
investigations  along  these  lines,  it  does  not  feel  in  a  position  this 
year  to  make  a  report.  If  so  ordered  by  the  Roard  of  Direction, 
our  investigations  will  be  continued  during  the  coming  year  and  a 
report  will  be  made  at  some  subsequent  meeting. 

The  second  subject  upon  which  the  Committee  reports  in  a  defi- 
nite manner  is  "the  revision  of  adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote 
Oil."     We  will  take  this  up  later. 

On  other  matters  which  were  assigned  to  the  Committee  for  con- 
sideration we  report  progress.  These  are  forms  for  reporting  in- 
spection, the  impregnation  of  crude  oil,  and  the  value  of  brush  coat- 
ing and  dipping.  There  was  not  very  much  information  to  be  found 
on  these  subjects,  and  we  will  continue  our  hunt  for  more  during 
the  coming  year. 

The  Committee  was  further  asked  to  prepare  specifications  for 
impregnation  with  creosote  oil.  A  specification  has  already  been 
adopted  by  the  Association  and  is  contained  in  the  Manual.  As  this 
specification  represents  good  practice,  the  Committee  does  not  recom- 
mend any  changes  in  it.  With  the  consent  of  the  Chair  and  the 
Association  we  will  now  consider  our  recommendations  for  this  year. 
These  will  be  found  on  page  864,  the  four  principles  recommended 
for  the  grouping  of  timbers  for  treatment.  These  we  present  for 
adoption  by  the  Association,  for  insertion  in  the  Manual. 


DISCUSSION.  1041 

"(i)  Ties  of  approximately  the  same  period  of  seasoning  should 
be  grouped  together  for  treatment;  green  ties  should  never  be  mixed 
with  seasoned  ones." 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis): — 
Mr.  Chairman,  I  understand  the  province  of  this  Committee  is  that 
of  wood  preservation.  There  seems  to  be  a  tendency  on  the  part  of 
the  Committee  to  confine  its  activities  entirely  to  ties.  Should  not 
that  first  clause  refer  to  something  else  besides  ties?  I  think  it  is 
just  as  important  to  group  dimension  timber  as  it  is  ties. 

The  President: — It  is  intended  to  cover  all  kinds  of  wood. 

Mr.  McDonald: — I  think  it  should  be  made  to  read  that  way  then. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — This  grouping  applies  more  particularly  to 
ties  rather  than  the  longer  timbers.  The  bulk  of  the  timber  treating 
for  railroads  is  confined  to  ties,  and  from  a  railroad  standpoint  the 
treatment  of  ties  at  the  present  time  is  the  one  of  greatest  interest. 

Mr.  McDonald: — There  is  no  doubt  about  that,  but  the  point  I 
make  is  if  this  Committee's  province  is  considered  tie  preservation 
only,  then  this  clause  is  right  and  proper,  but  if  it  is  timber  preserva- 
tion, it  should  be  made  inclusive  of  all  kinds  of  timber. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — We  can,  by  a  very  simple  process,  widen  the 
scope  of  our  recommendations  by  substituting  the  word  "timbers" 
for  "ties,"  if  that  is  what  the  Association  wants.  I  move  that  the 
first  recommendation,  as  presented,  be  adopted. 

The  President: — The  first  conclusion  is  on  page  867,  but  it  refers 
to  four  headings,  on  page  884.  I  will  ask  the  chairman  to  read  each 
one  separately,  as  the  motion  applies  to  each  one  separately. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — "(2)  Pine  ties  should  be  separated  on  the 
basis  of  hardwood  and  sapwood;  it  would  also  be  advisable  in  some 
cases  to  group  hardwood  on  the  same  basis,  but  it  is  not  generally 
practical  to  do  so. 

"(3)  Grouping  on  the  basis  of  species  and  families,  as,  for  ex- 
ample, red  oaks,  pines,  beech,  etc.,  if  a  further  division  into  heartwood 
classes  is  made  with  pine,  is  usually  a  satisfactory  practice.  From 
this  it  follows  that  red  oak,  beech,  long-leaf  pine,  loblolly  pine  and 
gum  should  be  treated  separately.  Birch  and  hard  maples  and  certain 
other  combinations,  depending  on  the  locality,  can  be  grouped  to- 
gether to  advantage. 

"(4)  The  separation  in  the  yard,  on  the  basis  the  ties  are  to  be 
grouped  for  treatment,  is  an  essential  and  economical  practice." 

Mr.  C.  E.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River): — Does 
paragraph  4  refer  to  the  storage  yard  only? 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — Yes,  sir.  I  move  the  adoption  of  para- 
graph 4. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President: — Next  is  page  867,  conclusion  No.  2.  Before  mak- 
ing any  motion  I  will  ask  the  chairman  to  read  each  one  of  them 
separately  and  make  a  separate  motion. 


1042  WOOD    PRESERVATION. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — The  only  change  in  the  standard  specification 
tor  creosote  oil  is  with  reference  to  specifically  excluding  coal-gas  tar 
and  coke-oven  tar.  I  will  read  the  present  specification  and  then  as 
it  is  revised: 

"The  oil  used  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of  coal-tar  creo- 
sote; that  is,  it  shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained  from  coal  gas  tar  or 
coke  oven  tar  and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  including  coal  gas  tar 
or  coke  oven  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from  petroleum  or  any  other 
source;  it  shall  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centi- 
grade and  shall  be  free  from  suspended  matter;  the  specific  gravity 
of  the  oil  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall  be  at  least 
1.03.  When  distilled  by  the  common  method — that  is,  using  an  eight 
(8)  ounce  retort,  asbestos  covered,  with  standard  thermometer,  bulb 
one-half  (^2)  inch  above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the  creosote,  calcu- 
lated on  the  basis  of  the  dry  oil,  shall  give  no  distillate  below  two 
hundred  (200)  degrees  centigrade,  nor  more  than  five  (5)  per  cent, 
below  two  hundred  and  ten  (210)  degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than 
twenty-five  (25)  per  cent,  below  two  hundred  and  thirty-five  (235) 
degrees  centigrade,  and  the  residue  above  three  hundred  and  fifty-five 
(355)  degrees  centigrade,  if  it  exceeds  five  (5)  per  cent,  in  quantity, 
shall  be  soft.  The  oil  shall  not  contain  more  than  three  (3)  per  cent, 
water." 

I  move  that  this  change  in  the  specificat'ons  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — There  seems  to  be  a  demand  for  a  specifica- 
tion for  creosote  oil  somewhat  less  stringent  than  our  standard  speci- 
fication. In  fact,  it  seems  necessary  to  have  such  a  specification  in 
order  to  meet  the  grade  of  oil  that  we  are  oftentimes  obliged  to 
purchase.  For  this  purpose  the  Committee  submits  specifications  for 
a  No.  2  grade  oil  and  for  a  No.  3  grade  oil.  The  specification  for 
the  No.  2  grade  creosote  oil  reads  as  follows: 

"The  oil  used  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of  coal-tar  creo- 
sote; that  is,  it  shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained  from  coal  gas  tar  or 
coke  oven  tar,  and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  including  coal  gas  tar 
or  coke  oven  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from  petroleum  or  any 
other  source;  it  shall  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38) 
degrees  centigrade  and  shall  be  free  from  suspended  matter;  the 
specific  gravity  of  the  oil  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall 
be  at  least  1.03.  When  distilled  by  the  common  method — that  is, 
using  an  eight  (8)  ounce  retort,  asbestos  covered,  with  standard  ther- 
mometer, bulb  one-half  (j4)  inch  above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the 
creosote,  calculated  on  the  basis  of  the  dry  oil,  shall  give  not  more 
than  eight  (8)  per  cent,  distillate  below  two  hundred  and  ten  (210) 
degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than  thirty-five  (35)  per  cent,  below 
two  hundred  and  thirty-five  (235)  degrees  centigrade,  and  the  residue 
above  three  hundred  and  fifty-five  (355)  degrees  centigrade,  if  it  ex- 


DISCUSSION.  1043 

ceeds  five  (5)  per  cent,  in  quantity,  shall  be  soft.  The  oil  shall  not 
contain  more  than  three  per  cent,  water." 

I  move  the  adoption  of  this  specification  for  a  No.  2  grade  creo- 
sote oil. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western): — I  would  like  to  have 
some  information  on  the  real  purpose  of  drawing  these  two  separate 
specifications  for  creosote  oil.  What  will  be  the  difference  in  the 
cost  between  the  specifications  No.  2  and  No.  3? 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — I  do  not  think  we  are  prepared  to  state  just 
what  will  be  the  cost.  That  is  a  matter  depending  on  market  price. 
As  I  understand  the  creosote  situation,  we  are  very  seldom  able  to 
get  a  creosote  oil  that  conforms  strictly  with  the  standard  specifica- 
tion. Still  the  inference  is  that  we  pay  the  same  for  it  as  for  the 
high-grade  oil.  Now  the  idea  is  that  we  place  the  modified  specifica- 
tions in  the  hands  of  our  Purchasing  Agent,  and  if  he  cannot  get  the 
oil  according  to  the  standard  specification,  he  will  be  able  to  accepl 
one  that  will  meet  one  or  the  other  of  the  modified  specifications, 
with  some  corresponding  modification  in  price. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — I  think  three  grades  are  too  many;  two  in 
most  cases  are  enough.  It  seems  to  me  we  should  insist  upon  the 
very  best  grade  of  creosote  oil.  That  is  the  very  life  of  our  timber 
treatment.  We  are  all  investing  a  lot  of  money  in  it,  and  we  should 
not  accept  inferior  oils.  I  think  we  should  consider  very  carefully 
the  adoption  of  three  grades.  I  realize  at  times  it  is  difficult  to  se- 
cure the  first  grade,  but  it  seems  to  me  the  third  grade  is  too  low 
for  us  to  accept.  A  slight  difference  in  the  grade  of  the  oil  will 
seriously  affect  the  treatment,  while  the  difference  in  the  cost  of  the 
oil  will  be  very  slight.  So  we  will  be  throwing  away  a  lot  of  the 
value  of  our  timber  treatment  by  accepting  an  inferior  grade  of  oil. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — As  a  matter  of  fact,  there  is  now  quite  a 
large  quantity  of  oil  that  comes  within  the  No.  3  grade  that  is  being 
purchased  at  the  standard  grade  price.  This  revision  of  the  specifi- 
cations was  given  very  careful  consideration  by  the  sub-committee, 
composed  of  some  of  the  leading  lights  in  the  timber  treating  world, 
men  who  are  specialists  in  that  line,  and  as  long  as  the  discussion  is 
started,  I  will  call  upon  the  chairman  of  the  sub-committee  that 
drafted  these  specifications  to  defend  any  attacks  made  upon  them. 
Mr.  Hendricks,  will  you  please  explain  to  the  Association  just  why 
we  recommend  these  three  grades? 

Mr.  V.  K.  Hendricks  (St.  Louis  &  San  Francisco): — Some  of  the 
roads  are  getting  a  grade  of  creosote  that  will  not  come  under  No. 
2  and  will  come  under  No.  3,  and  they  have  to  have  the  creosote, 
and  that  was  the  reason  the  third  grade  was  recommended  by  the 
Committee.  For  instance,  the  Chicago  &  Northwestern  is  forced  to 
take  creosote  that  does  not  come  within  No.  2.  That  was  the  reason 
for  adopting  the  third  specifications. 


1044  WOOD    PRESERVATION. 

Prof.  S.  N.  Williams  (Cornell  College) : — I  would  like  to  inquire 
if  the  Committee  would  please  give  us  an  approximate  idea  of  the 
difference  in  values  of  these  three  grades. 

Mr.  Hendricks: — The  Committee  is  not  able  to  do  that.  There 
is  too  much  that  is  unknown  about  the  value  of  creosote,  and  the 
valuable  constituents  of  it.  The  Committee  did  at  one  time  consider 
the  question  of  trying  to  assign  relative  merits  to  the  different  speci- 
fications, but  it  was  entirely  impracticable  to  do  so  with  the  present 
knowledge. 

Prof.  Williams: — Is  there  much  difference  in  the  cost? 

Mr.  Hendricks: — That  depends  upon  the  market  conditions  and 
the  location,  so  that  we  do  not  see  that  we  can  give  any  information 
on  that  question. 

Mr.  W.  L.  Seddon  (Seaboard  Air  Line) : — I  think  the  way  to  look 
at  this  is  not  so  much  the  question  of  the  difference  in  the  cost  of  the 
oil,  but  as  to  how  the  low-grade  oils  will  act  in  preserving  the  timber, 
whether  timber  treated  with  No.  2  oil  will  stand  as  much  as  timber 
treated  with  No.  1  oil,  and  whether  timber  treated  with  No.  2  will 
stand  as  much  as  with  No.  3.  Before  we  recommend  No.  2  and  No.  3 
oil  specifications,  we  ought  to  have  some  information  with  reference 
to  what  the  effect  on  the  timber  is  going  to  be. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson : — Most  of  us  are  now  using  oil  corresponding 
to  the  proposed  No.  2  or  No.  3  oil  and  have  gotten  very  good  results. 
Dr.  von  Schrenk  will  please  explain  this  question  more  fully. 

Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk  (Consulting  Timber  Engineer)  : — Per- 
sonally, I  have  always  advocated  the  use  of  strictly  No.  1  high-grade 
specification  oils,  on  account  of  the  desirability  of  getting  the  very 
best  that  we  can  possibly  find.  The  Committee  find,  however,  that 
for  several  years,  owing  to  the  tremendous  increase  in  the  creosoting 
industry  in  this  country,  and  owing  to  the  absence  of  a  sufficient 
supply  of  high-grade  standard  oil,  a  great  many  railroads  were  buying 
(using  the  present  standard  specification)  creosote  oil  which,  as  a 
matter  of  fact,  did  not  come  up  to  it.  In  other  words,  we  had  a 
state  of  affairs  of  having  the  Purchasing  Agent  sent  out  to  purchase 
a  material  under  a  specification,  and  as  one  Chief  Engineer  expressed 
it,  "When  we  asked  him  whether  the  oil  he  obtained  came  up  to  that 
specification,  he  said,  'Why,  we  buy  it  under  the  specification  but 
it  by  no  means  meets  it.'"  I  asked  him,  "What  do  you  do?"  He 
said,  "We  make  a  terrible  fuss  about  it  and  then  we  take  it."  The 
object  of  the  specifications  Nos.  2  and  3  was  largely  to  do  away  with 
that  rather  anomalous  situation.  I  think  the  Committee  pointed  out, 
in  the  middle  of  page  865,  answering  one  of  the  questions  put,  that 
in  using  specifications  Nos.  2  and  3,  it  should  be  understood  that  if 
they  have  to  be  used,  consideration  should  be  given  to  the  use  of 
greater  quantities  of  creosote  oil  per  cubic  foot  of  wood,  than  would 
be  used  if  specification  No.  1  is  used.  The  Committee  meant  to  give 
the  impression   that  wherever  possible  the  railroad  company  should 


DISCUSSION.  1045 

try  to  buy  under  the  specification  No.  I,  and  where  that  could  not  be 
obtained  they  should  try  No.  2,  and  where  they  could  not  get  No.  2, 
they  should  buy  No.  3,  with  the  understanding  that  they  would  use 
more  of  it  per  cubic  foot.  In  presenting  grades  2  and  3  we  wish  to 
have  it  clearly  understood  that  they  are  inferior  in  value  to  No.  1 
specification,  but  nevertheless  they  might  be  used,  and  we  would  get 
away  from  the  anomalous  position  of  depreciating  the  value  of  No.  1 
specification,  and  get  a  price  reduction. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — It  seems  to  me  we  ought  to  stick  to  our 
standard  specifications  for  one  grade  of  oil  until  we  have  had  some 
experience  as  to  the  effect  of  No.  2  and  No.  3  grade  oil.  If  any  one 
is  asking  for  bids  on  No.  1  and  getting  No.  2  or  No.  3,  he  should 
investigate  it.  The  proper  proceeding  might  be  to  refer  specifications 
No.  2  and  No.  3  back  to  the  Committee  for  a  report  next  year,  and 
so,  in  the  light  of  this  information,  the  Association  can  act  upon  the 
adoption  of  the  other  specification.  Also,  whether  it  would  not  be 
sufficient  to  have  a  standard  specification  on  No.  1  and  No.  2.  It 
seems  to  me  we  will  lower  our  standard  in  accepting  so  many  grades. 

Mr.  E.  A.  Frink  (Seaboard  Air  Line): — It  seems  to  me  the  one 
purpose  is  to  get  as  long  life  as  we  can  of  the  timber  treated.  We 
ought  to  find  out,  first,  whether  No.  2  grade  will  give  as  long  life  as 
No.  1.  If  not,  we  want  No.  1;  and  usually  it  is  the  case  where  a 
sustained  demand  is  made  for  one  product,  we  get  that  product.  I 
understand  the  known  sources  of  supply  are  not  utilized.  Enormous 
amounts  go  to  waste  every  year  in  this  country.  If  there  were  a  de- 
mand for  that  No.  1  grade,  I  think  the  supply  would  soon  fill  it. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  would  like  to  ask  Dr.  von  Schrenk,  is  it  practic- 
able to  refine  the  No.  2  and  No.  3  grades  up  to  the  standard  of  No.  1? 

Dr.  von  Schrenk: — No,  sir;  if  that  were  the  case  we  would  insist 
absolutely  on  No.  1.  I  think  I  voice  the  sentiment  of  the  Committee 
when  I  say  that  we  should  all  stand  absolutely  for  the  highest  grade 
standard.  In  other  words,  we  want  to  recommend  that  as  the  standard 
that  should  be  used  and  the  inclusion  of  grades  2  and  3  is  simply 
recognizing  the  natural  state  of  affairs.  The  natural  state  of  affairs 
is  that  these  oils  cannot  be  bought  under  No.  1  specifications,  be- 
cause they  are  not  there;  they  do  not  exist.  I  think  we  ought  to 
stand  by  our  high-grade  specifications,  but  the  grades  2  and  3  are 
simply  given  to  help  out  those  roads  which,  for  geographical  or  other 
reasons,  are  unable  to  get  No.  1  creosote  oil,  and  with  the  warning, 
if  they  buy  creosote  oil,  they  ought  to  approximate  No.  1  standard. 

Mr.  S.  B.  Fisher  (Missouri,  Kansas  &  Texas)  : — There  is  another 
reason  why  I  think  we  should  have  the  lower  grades  of  creosote. 
The  indications  with  us  are  that  soft  ties  will  wear  out  before  they 
decay,  and  we  may  wish  to  get  cheaper  grades  of  creosote  to  pre- 
serve those  ties  until  they  wear  out.  For  that  reason  I  am  in  favor 
of  lower  grades  of  creosote. 


1046  WOOD   PRESERVATION. 

Mr.  R.  D.  Coombs  (Consulting  Engineer): — It  seems  to  me  the 
question  is  largely  one  of  money.  It  may  be  perfectly  proper  to  use 
a  cheaper  grade  of  oil  for  a  cheaper  class  of  work,  and  I  would  sug- 
gest that  the  Committee  might  properly  advise  the  relative  ultimate 
cost  of  work  of  different  grades,  taking  into  account  the  larger 
quantity  of  the  cheaper  grades. 

(The  President  put  the  motion  for  the  adoption  of  specification 
No.  2,  and  a  vive  voce  vote  was  indecisive;  whereupon  a  rising  vote 
was  taken,  resulting  in  83  votes  in  the  affirmative  and  7  in  the  nega- 
tive.) 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — "The  oil  shall  be  the  best  obtainable  grade  of 
coal  tar  creosote;  that  is,  it  shall  be  a  pure  product  obtained  from 
coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar  and  shall  be  free  from  any  tar,  including 
coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar,  oil  or  residue  obtained  from  petroleum 
or  any  other  source;  it  shalS  be  completely  liquid  at  thirty-eight  (38) 
degrees  centigrade  and  shall  be  free  from  suspended  matter;  the 
specific  gracity  of  the  oil  at  thirty-eight  (38)  degrees  centigrade  shall 
be  at  least  1.025.  When  distilled  by  the  common  method — that  is, 
using  an  eight  (8)  ounce  retort,  asbestos  covered,  with  standard  ther- 
mometer, bulb  one-half  (J4)  inch  above  the  surface  of  the  oil — the 
creosote,  calculated  on  the  basis  of  the  dry  oil,  shall  give  not  more 
than  ten  (10)  per  cent,  distillate  below  two  hundred  and  ten  (210) 
degrees  centigrade,  not  more  than  forty  (40)  per  cent,  below  two 
hundred  and  thirty-five  (235)  degrees  centigrade,  and  the  residue 
above  three  hundred  and  fifty-five  (355)  degrees  centigrade,  if  it 
exceeds  five  (5)  per  cent,  in  quantity,  shall  be  soft.  The  oil  shall  not 
contain  more  than  three  (3)  per  cent,  water." 

I  move  the  adoption  of  the  specification  for  the  third  grade  creo- 
sote oil. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Spencer  (Washington  Terminal  Company) : — I  suppose 
what  I  have  to  say  will  do  no  good.  I  have  always  stood  for  good 
practice.  I  do  not  believe  the  adoption  of  these  low-grade  oils  con- 
stitutes good  practice.  Dr.  von  Schrenk  told  us  a  few  moments  ago, 
or  indicated  to  us,  that  the  difficulty  is  going  to  be  met  by  using 
more  oil  in  the  tie.  I  would  like  to  ask,  for  information,  if  it  is  a  fact 
that  those  in  charge  of  the  creosoting  plants  are  able  to,  or  if  they 
actually  will,  use  more  of  the  lower-grade  oil  to  meet  the  difficulties: 

I  feel  that  we  are  going  to  be  met,  when  we  specify  the  No.  1 
specification  for  our  ties,  by  the  question,  "Why  will  not  the  No.  2 
or  the  No.  3  do?"  The  Committee  in  making  this  report  does  not  give 
us  any  basis  on  which  we  can  make  a  reply  to  this  question.  What 
are  we  going  to  say  as  to  the  relative  values  of  this  oil?  What  reply 
are  we  going  to  make  when  we  are  asked  as  to  the  relative  life  of 
a  tie  that  is  creosoted  with  No.  2  oil  or  No.  3  oil,  as  compared  with 
No.  1?  Or  what  reply  will  we  make  to  a  question  as  to  the  cost, 
the  relative  values? 


DISCUSSION.  1047 

I  really  believe  that  the  suggestion  made  by  Mr.  Friteh  should  have 
been  carried  out,  that  this  matter  be  referred  back  to  the  Committee 
fcr  further  consideration  and  report,  that  we  might  have  a  clearer 
idea  of  what  we  are  doing  when  we  are  specifying  No.  I.  Therefore, 
Mr.  Chairman,  unless  sufficient  explanation  can  be  made,  I  wish  to 
amend  that  motion  that  has  just  been  made,  to  the  effect  that  speci- 
fication for  No.  3  oil  be  referred  back  to  the  Committee  for  further 
consideration  and  report  as  to  quality  and  values  of  the  creosote 
specified. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Friteh: — In  seconding  the  amendment  I  would  like  to 
say  that  many  of  us  are  treating  our  timber  with  all  the  oil  we  car. 
get  into  it.  How  are  you  going  to  get  more  oil  of  the  lower  grades 
into  the  timber  when  we  specify  the  use  of  all  the  oil  you  can  get 
into  it?  You  are  up  to  the  point  of  the  limit  of  penetrability.  I  do 
not  think  that  argument  will  stand. 

As  far  as  the  refinement  of  the  oil  is  concerned,  I  question 
whether  it  is  not  possible  to  refine  the  lower  grade  oil  into  higher 
grades;  it  is  a  matter  of  distillation. 

I  think  we  are  making  a  mistake  to  open  the  doors  to  an  inferior 
grade  of  oil,  and  I  hope  the  amendment,  for  No.  3  being  referred 
back  to  the   Committee,  will   carry. 

Mr.  Hendricks:— How  long  do  your  ties  last,  treated  with  all  the 
creosote  oil  that  can  be  put  in? 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — I  also  ask  Mr.  Friteh  whether  ke  knows  he  is 
getting  the  standard  grade  creosote? 

In  answer  to  Mr.  Spencer,  this  Committee  does  not  feel  as  though 
it  is  recommending  to  the  Association  any  poor  practice.  We  are 
merely  submitting  specifications  that  meet  the  conditions  that  are 
imposed  upon  the  users  of  creosote  oil. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Friteh:— In  answer  to  the  Chairman  of  the  Committee, 
I  wish  to  say  that  if  I  am  not  getting  first-grade  creosote  oil  it  is 
my  fault,  and  it  is  the  fault  of  every  other  railway  man  who  has  this 
matter  in  charge,  if  he  does  not  get  first-grade  creosote  oil  when  he 
buys  that  grade.  You  do  not  analyze  it  and  test  it  properly,  or  you 
would  know  whether  or  not  you  get  first-grade  oil. 

In  regard  to  the  suggestion  of  the  Committee,  I  think  it  is  very 
valuable,  but  there  is  a  commercial  condition  which  we  must  meet. 
and  I  do  not  think  we  are  prepared  to  meet  it  now.  We  have  not 
enough  light  on  the  subject  and  we  are  simply  asking  for  a  little  more 
time  so  that  the  subject  may  be  thoroughly  investigated  in  order  that 
we  do  not  make  a  mistake  when  we  take  action. 

Prof.  Williams: — It  seems  to  me  the  object  of  the  amendment  has 
been  provided  for  by  the  Committee  itself,  as  you  will  see  by  reference 
to  page  866,  where  it  says  that  samples  are  to  be  submitted  to  the 
various  railways  for  analysis  and  the  information  to  be  reported  to 
the  Association  next  year. 


1048  wood  preservation: 

M'r.  C.  H.  Spencer: — I  submit  that  this  Association  is  not  organ- 
ized for  the  purpose  of  meeting  all  of  the  conditions  that  obtain  on 
the  various  railways  of  the  country.  We  are  here  to  recommend 
good  practice  to  our  railways  and  not  to  meet  all  the  conditions, 
which,  for  various  reasons,  different  railways  have  to  contend  with. 

Prof.  Walter  Loring  Webb  (Consulting  Engineer): — I  think  the 
question  involved  here  is  like  the  question  of  buying  different  grades 
of  lumber.  It  would  be  very  nice  to  always  use  the  highest  grade  of 
lumber,  but  we  cannot.  It  is  a  matter  of  practical  business.  As  I 
understand,  from  what  these  experts  have  told  us  regarding  creosote 
oil,  some  creosote  oil  will  always  be  of  a  relatively  lower  grade,  as 
it  comes  out  of  the  still.  There  will  always  be  a  market  for  it,  and 
if  railways  want  to  use  that  lower  grade,  just  as  they  may  want  to 
use  the  lower  grades  of  lumber,  we  have  simply  to  provide  specifi- 
cations so  that  these  different  grades  can  be  used  properly.  We  do 
not  recommend  that  any  railway  shall  use  this  third  grade  of  creosote 
oil,  but  we  simply  define  what  the  third  grade  of  creosote  oil  shall  be, 
just  as  we  define  the  various  grades  of  lumber. 

Mr.  Seddon: — We  do  know  something  about  the  comparative  life 
and  usefulness  of  various  grades  of  lumber,  and  we  are  willing  to 
consider  various  grades  of  creosote  oil  if  we  know  something  about 
them,  but  at  the  present  time  the  Committee  is  not  prepared  to  tell 
us  either  their  value  or  the  effect  upon  the  timber,  and  I  do  not  think 
this  Association  should  recommend  creosote  specifications  unless  the 
Committee  can  put  us  in  the  possession  of  such  information  as  will 
enable  us  to  go  to  the  Chief  Engineer,  or  the  responsible  official  of 
the  railway,  and  say,  "Let  us  buy  No.  3  creosote  oil,  and  we  will  get 
such  and  such  results  from  its  use."  I  confess  there  is  nothing  here 
in  this  report  that  I  can  see  that  gives  us  that  information. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — I  wish,  in  answer  to  that  statement,  to  say 
that  we  feel  these  specifications  are  all  right,  and  meet  the  conditions 
that  confront  Purchasing  Agents  when  they  go  into  the  market  to 
buy  creosote  oil.  We  do  say  that  we  are  not  prepared  to  state  how 
many  cents  less  per  gallon  the  grades  of  oil  No.  2  and  3  will  cost 
as  compared  with  the  standard  grade,  or  how  many  years,  more  or 
less,  the  ties  which  are  treated  with  No.  2  and  No.  3  oil  will  last 
as  compared  with  the  standard  grade  oil.  This  must  be  deter- 
mined by  practical  experience.  No  doubt  many  of  the  good  results 
obtained  on  railways  in  creosoting  have  been  obtained  by  the  use  of 
an  oil  below  the  standard  grade,  but  conforming  to  the  proposed  No. 
2  and  No.  3  grade  of  creosote  oil. 

I  have  the  greatest  confidence  in  my  Committee.  (Applause). 
I  will  say  right  here  that  most  of  these  gentlemen  on  this  Com- 
mittee know  a  great  deal  more  about  the  creosote  business  than  I 
do,  and  than  most  of  those  present  do,  because  they  have  been  associ- 
ated with  the  scientific  study  and  practical  use  of  creosote  oil  for  many 
years,  therefore,  I  most  earnestly  recommend  to  the  Association  the 


DISCUSSION.  1049 

adoption  of  the  recommendations  of  this  Committee.  In  a  way,  I 
infer  that  possibly  some  of  the  speakers  have  not  had  quite  as  broad 
an  experience  with  this  subject  as  some  of  the  members  of  this  Com- 
mittee (Applause),  and,  for  this  reason  I  feel  all  the  more  justified  in 
urging  our  recommendations  for  adoption. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch: — We  appreciate  the  fact  many  of  us  are 
ignorant  on  this  subject,  but  the  confession  of  ignorance  is  often- 
times the  first  step  to  finding  out  something  about  a  thing.  The 
chairman  has  said  it  is  for  the  Purchasing  Agent  that  these  specifi- 
cations are  made.  How  about  the  Engineers?  The  Engineer  must 
use  the  creosote  oil.  The  Purchasing  Agent  will  say  to  the  Engineer: 
"Shall  we  buy  No.  i,  No.  2,  or  No.  3  oil?"  What  can  the  Engineer  say  in 
answer  to  that  question?  The  Engineer  does  not  know  the  values 
of  these  respective  grades  of  oil  for  treating  timber.  We  want  to 
know  what  we  are  doing  before  we  adopt  these  specifications. 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — In  answer  to  that  last  remark,  let  the  Pur- 
chasing Agent  get  bids.  That  is  really  the  only  way  we  can  tell 
regarding  the  respective  costs  of  these  different  grades  of  oil. 

Mr.  L.  G.  Curtis  (Baltimore  &  Ohio):— It  looks  to  me  that  the 
only  way  we  can  tell  as  to  what  the  No.  1  grade  is  worth,  what  the 
No.  2  grade  is  worth,  and  what  the  No.  3  grade  is  worth  is  to  adopt 
the  specifications  and  then  try  them  out.  It  is  just  as  certain  of  our 
members  have  said,  and  certain  members  of  the  Committee  have 
said,  that  there  have  been  a  great  many  ties  treated,  but  we  do  not 
know  what  has  gone  into  them.  Now,  let  us  put  these  specifications 
into  effect  and  find  out  what  the  result  really  is. 

Mr.  Lindsay : — As  I  understand  it,  the  difference  between  specifi- 
cation No.  2  and  specification  No.  3  is  only  a  small  percentage  in  spe- 
cific gravity;  one  is  1.03  and  the  other  1.025.  I  ask  Dr.  von  Schrenk 
what  percentage  of  the  total  output  of  creosote  oil  would  be  rejected 
if  he  did  not  have  No.  3  specification? 

Dr.  von  Schrenk: — That  is  almost  impossible  to  answer,  because 
the  volume  of  oils  differ  from  week  to  week  and  month  to  month, 
depending  on  the  fluctuation  of  the  production  of  the  output,  and  on 
peculiar  accidents  which  occur  in  the  distilling  operation.  The  only 
reason  why  a  very  small  difference  is  made  in  the  specifications  is 
simply  to  give  an  actual  specification  for  the  actual  oil  as  we  find  the 
railways  actually  buying  in  millions  of  gallons  every  week.  To 
further  justify  these  specifications — I  feel  that  really  we  are  getting 
very  finicky  on  these  specifications  of  creosote  oil — I  will  say  that  I 
made  a  trip  over  some  English  railways  not  very  long  ago  and  I 
find  specifications  in  use  in  England  that  run  all  the  way  from  away 
above  our  standard  specification  to  away  below  our  No.  3,  and  they 
have  been  using  some  of  that  oil  for  forty  years  and  the  ties  in  many 
cases  have  been  twenty-five  and  thirty  years  in  use  on  the  English 
railways. 


1050  WOOD    PRESERVATION. 

As  the  Chairman  has  stated,  we  are  not  recommending  anything 
that  will  be  at  all  dangerous  or  experimental,  but  oils  of  the  character 
of  grades  Nos.  2  and  3  have  been  used  for  from  75  to  100  years  or 
more  the  world  over  and  a  lot  of  them  have  been  worse  than  the 
No.  2  and  3  grade,  and  all  we  are  doing  is  to  endeavor  to  get  an  op- 
portunity for  some  of  the  oils  to  be  used  with  positive  recommenda- 
tions concerning  their  use. 

The  statement  has  been  made  by  one  of  the  speakers  that  some 
of  us  are  pumping  our  timber  full  of  oil.  If  the  timber  is  being 
pumped  full  of  standard  creosote  oil,  very  well;  but  if  they  are  pump- 
ing the  timber  full  of  No.  2  and  3,  the  answer  which  may  be  made  to 
that  is  if  they  pump  full  of  No.  1,  they  are  spending  more  money 
than  is  necessary,  and  the  maximum  amount  that  can  be  pumped  in 
of  No.  3  is  about  what  should  go  in.  I  do  not  think  we  are  recom- 
mending anything  experimental  or  doubtful. 

The  President: — Is  Mr.  S.  R.  Church,  Manager  of  the  Railroad 
Department  of  the  Barrett  Manufacturing  Company,  of  New  York, 
present? 

Mr.  S.  R.  Church: — I  thank  you,  Mr.  Chairman,  for  an  oppor- 
tunity to  speak  on  the  subject  in  which  I  am  very  much  interested 
indeed;  and  I  think  what  Dr.  von  Schrenk  has  just  said  has  probably 
done  more  to  enlighten  some  of  you  who  are  not  particularly  well 
posted  on  this  matter  than  anything  the  Committee  has  said  before. 
The  point  is  there  is  really  no  essential  difference  between  the  three 
grades  of  oil  which  your  Committee  has  recommended.  They  are  all 
pure  coal-tar  creosotes.  I  think  I  can  say  without  fear  of  contradic- 
tion that  the  reputation  of  coal-tar  creosote  as  a  preservative,  both 
abroad  and  in  this  country,  was  established  before  any  oil  of  as  high 
specific  gravity,  or  with  as  high  distillation  range  as  your  standard 
specification  requires,  was  produced  or  was  in  use,  that  is,  in  large 
quantities.  Therefore,  the  recommendation  for  these  three  grades 
does  not  involve  any  experiment.  It  is  simply,  as  your  Committee 
has  already  stated,  a  matter  of  recognizing  existing  conditions  and 
enabling  a  road  to  have  a  specification  which  can  be  met  by  the  oil 
producer. 

The  question  has  been  raised  as  to  whether  it  will  be  possible 
to  refine  any  of  these  oils  of  lower  distillation  range  to  make  them 
comply  with  specification  No.  1.  That  could  be  done,  but  only  at  the 
expense  of  a  large  loss  of  creosote  oil,  and  increasing,  therefore,  the 
cost  of  the  preservative. 

It  is  not  true,  as  someone  stated,  that  there  is  any  surplus  of  raw  ma- 
terial in  this  country  from  which  creosote  oil  can  be  obtained.  The 
amount  of  tar  going  to  waste  is  very  negligible.  The  manufacturers 
are  doing  everything  in  their  power  to  get  the  highest  possible 
percentage  of  creosote  and  the  best  possible  quality  of  creosote  from  the 
tar.    We  are  continually  endeavoring  to  obtain  enlarged  outlets  for  the  by- 


DISCUSSION.  1051 

product  which  results  in  the  manufacture  of  high-grade  creosote,  and  I  feel 
safe  in  saying  that  the  average  quality  of  the  creosote  will  improve  with 
time.  I  also  feel  safe  in  saying  that  the  average  quality  of  the  creosote 
produced  to-day  is  of  proven  value  and  that  timbers  treated  with  enough 
of  the  preservative,  using  any  of  these  three  oils,  need  cause  no  anxiety 
as  to  their  life. 

Mr.  Lindsay : — I  ask  if  there  is  any  difference  in  the  degree  of 
penetration  of  dense  woods  in  the  use  of  the  lighter  oils — will  the 
lighter  oil  penetrate  any  more  deeply  in  the  dense  wood  than  the  oil 
covered  by  the  No.  I  specification? 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — I  will  answer  that  by  saying  no. 

The  President: — The  motion  for  adoption  has  been  amended  to 
one  for  recommittal  with  instructions,  and  we  will  vote  on  the 
amendment  first,  if  the  discussion  is  finished. 

(The  question  was  put,  and  the  motion  was  lost.) 

The  President: — We  will  now  vote  on  the  motion  to  adopt  the 
recommendation  of  the  Committee  covering  No.  3  grade  creosote  oil. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Mr.  Earl  Stimson: — I  now  move  the  adoption  of  the  third  con- 
clusion of  the  Committee  which  reads:  "That  the  heading  'Specifi- 
cations for  Analysis  of  Creosote  Oil,'  as  it  now  stands  in  the  Manual,  be 
changed  to  read  as  follows :  'Specifications  for  the  Fractionation  of 
Creosote  Oil.'  " 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  has  no  further  conclusions  to 
offer,  and  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the  Association.  They 
have  furnished  us  with  some  excellent  work. 


DISCUSSION  ON  GRADING  OF  LUMBER. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.   873-884.) 
LIST   OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING   PART   IN    DISCUSSION    ON   GRADING   OF   LUMBER. 

L.  C.  Fritch.  Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk. 

The  President : — The  next  committee  is  the  Special  Committee  on 
Grading  of  Lumber,  Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk,  Chairman.  We  will  hear 
from   Dr.   von   Schrenk. 

Dr.  Hermann  von  Schrenk  (Consulting  Timber  Engineer)  : — Mr. 
President  and  Members,  the  Special  Committee  on  Grading  of  Lumber 
has  continued  the  work  this  year  which  was  begun  last  year,  reports  of 
which  were  published  in  Bulletin  133.  The  report  of  the  Committee  last 
year,  as  you  will  remember,  gave  a  list  of  grading  rules,  submitted  by 
various  national  organizations  for  various  classes  of  maintenance  of  way 
lumber,  it  being  thought  if  we  had  a  standard  specification  (with  defini- 
tions of  defects)  for  maintenance  of  way  lumber,  as  well  as  a  list  of  com- 
mercially obtainable  grades,  it  would  go  far  towards  unifying  standards 
for  the  purchase  of  maintenance  of  way  lumber.  During  the  present  year 
the  Committee  has  continued  its  efforts  with  various  organizations  and 
presents  in  its  report  this  year  specifications  for  the  grading  of  cypress. 
There  are  still  two  or  three  organizations  which  have  not  formulated  their 
reports,  and  it  is  hoped  that  the  work  of  the  Committee  will  be  brought 
to  a  conclusion  during  the  coming  year. 

In  the  recommendation  as  made  in  this  report,  the  Committee  wishes 
to  call  your  attention  to  the  fact  that  they  have  this  year  very  carefully 
gone  over  the  rules,  as  submitted  last  year,  and  have  endeavored  to  bring 
them,  as  far  as  they  could,  into  harmony  with  the  rules  and  specifica- 
tions already  adopted,  as  printed  in  the  Manual.  In  order  to  avoid  re- 
printing the  entire  report  of  last  year,  which  was  rather  bulky,  they  have 
simply  called  attention,  in  the  paragraphs  at  the  bottom  of  page  873,  to 
the  changes  in  the  Bulletin  as  submitted  last  year,  in  order  to  make  it 
conform  to  the  recommendations  already  in  the  Manual ;  and  we  wish  at 
this  time  to  recommend  the  adoption  of  the  rules  as  submitted  last  year, 
with  the  corrections  as  indicated  in  the  present  report,  with  this  change. 
At  the  time  the  report  for  1912  was  submitted,  it  was  thought  that  it 
would  probably  be  printed  sufficiently  far  in  advance  of  the  meeting  of 
the  convention  to  give  the  members  a  chance  to  criticise  the  rules  sub- 
mitted. 

Owing  to  the  fact  that  the  report  has  only  been  out  a  short  time,  I 
will  take  it  upon  myself,  as  Chairman  of  the  Committee,  trusting  that  the 
other  members  will  agree,  to  withdraw  recommendation  6,  and  move  that 
the  other  rules  as  submitted  last  year  be  adopted  at  this  time. 

1052 


DISCUSSION.  1053 

The  President: — The  Chair  will  suggest,  gentlemen,  that  these  previ- 
ous appendices,  beginning  with  A,  Classification  and  Grading  Rules 
for  Douglas  Fir,  be  acted  upon  by  the  Association  in  bulk ;  thai 
is,  each  appendix  by  itself,  as  there  has  been  ample  opportunity  for  the 
members  to  make  any  notes  of  criticisms  they  desire  to  bring  forward. 
Each  appendix  therefore  will  be  taken  up  as  a  whole,  and  the  Association 
members  are  asked  to  criticise  it.  If  no  criticisms  are  offered,  or  no 
amendments  are  made,  you  will  be  asked  to  pass  the  appendices  one  by 
one.     Is  the  Association  willing  to  have  that  action  taken? 

(On  vote,  the  suggestion  of  the  President  was  carried.) 

The  President: — Each  appendix  will,  therefore,  be  read  by  title  and 
a  vote  will  be  requested. 

The  Secretary:— "(Appendix  A)  Classification  and  Grading  Rules  for 
Douglas  Fir." 

Dr.  von  Schrenk : — I  move  that  the  Grading  Rules  for  Douglas  Fir, 
printed  in  Appendix  A  of  Bulletin  133,  with  the  corrections  submitted 
in  this  year's  report,  as  indicated  in  paragraph  1,  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "(Appendix  B)  Classification,  Grading  and  Dressing 
Rules  for  Northern  Pine,  including  White  and  Norway  Pine  and  Hem- 
lock." 

Dr.  von  Schrenk : — I  move  that  the  Classification  Rules  for  Northern 
Pine,  including  White  and  Norway  Pine  and  Hemlock,  as  given  in  Ap- 
pendix B,  of  Bulletin  133,  subject  to  corrections  as  given  in  paragraph 
3  of  this  year's  report,  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carrie.d.) 

The  Secretary: — "(Appendix  C)  Classification,  Grading  and  Dressing 
Rules  for  Southern  Yellow  Pine." 

Dr.  von  Schrenk  : — I  move  you  that  the  Classification  Rules  for  South- 
ern Pine,  as  given  in  Appendix  C,  Bulletin  133,  subject  to  the  correc- 
tions as  indicated  in  paragraph  4  of  this  year's   report,  be  adopted. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  Secretary: — "(Appendix  D)  Standard  Specifications  for  Con- 
struction  Oak  Timbers." 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — I  would  like  to  ask  the 
Committee  if  this  work  is  the  result  of  a  joint  conference  with  the  lum- 
ber associations. 

Dr.  von  Schrenk :— Yes,  sir;  it  is  the  result  of  about  four  years'  work. 
I  move  the  adoption  of  Appendix  D,  Standard  Specifications  for  Con- 
struction Oak  Timbers,  as  printed  in  Bulletin  133,  subject  to  corrections 
in  paragraph  5  of  this  year's  report. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

Dr.  von  Schrenk: — Appendix  E,  as  given  in  Bulletin  144,  is  submit- 
ted as  information  only,  and  no  action  is  necessary. 

The  President : — The  Committee  is  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the 
Association. 


DISCUSSION  ON  BUILDINGS. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  885-899.) 

list   of   speakers   taking    part    in    discussion    on    buildings. 
Maurice  Coburn. 

The  President : — The  next  report  is  that  of  the  Committee  on 
Buildings,  of  which  Mr.  Maurice  Coburn  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Coburn 
will  make  the  opening  statement. 

Mr.  Maurice  Coburn  (Vandalia)  : — The  Committee  has  not  pre- 
sented any  conclusions  this  year  and  our  report  is  presented  as  informa- 
tion. 

The  Committee  has  endeavored  to  add  to  the  work  of  the  previous 
year  in  connection  with  roofing.  We  have  found  a  few  errors  in  the 
technical  discussions,  which  we  have  endeavored  to  correct,  referring 
to  the  pages  in  the  report  as  published  last  year.  These  are  not  of 
any  great  importance.  Perhaps  the  one  about  water-gas  tar  is  as 
important  as  any. 

We  have  tried  to  get  some  further  information,  as  suggested  at 
the  convention  last  year,  about  the  asphalt-built-up  roofs,  but  did  not 
succeed  in  getting  anything  definite.  We  also  had  in  mind  an  endeavor 
to  get  a  specification  for  coal-tar  pitch  for  built-up  roofing,  but  we 
did  not  succeed  in  getting  that.  We  do  not  know  whether  we  are 
going  to  be  able  to  get  one  that  is  going  to  be  of  any  value. 

We  have  discussed  the  asphalt-asbestos  built-up  roof,  and  have 
also  added  some  information  about  gutters  and  flashings.  We  hope 
during  the  coming  year  to  fill  out  this  information  and  complete  the 
work  on  roofings,  presenting  particularly  the  principles  which  should 
govern  in  the  design  of  flashing.  The  Committee  has  also  done  a 
good  deal  of  work  in  connection  with  freight  house  floors,  but  we 
decided  that  it  was  not  yet  wise  to  present  what  we  have. 

We  also  wish  to  call  attention  to  the  death  of  Mr.  Metcalf,  who 
has  been  for  a  good  many  years  one  of  the  most  valuable  members 
of  the  Committee,  a  man  whom  we  all  learned  to  thoroughly  respect. 
We  feel  his  loss  very  much. 

The  President :— Do  any  members  wish  to  make  any  remarks  on 
the  report  of  this  Committee?  If  not,  they  are  dismissed  with  the 
thanks  of  the  Association. 


1054 


DISCUSSION  ON  SIGNS,  FENCES  AND  CROSSINGS. 

(For    Report,    see    pp.    900-904.) 

LIST  OF  SPEAKERS   TAKING   PART  IN   DISCUSSION   ON   SIGNS,   FENCES   AND   CRUSS- 
i  INGS. 

C.  H.  Stein. 

The  President: — We  will  call  on  the  Committee  on  Signs,  Fences 
and  Crossings,  Mr.  C.  H.  Stein,  Chairman. 

I  would  like  to  announce  that  we  are  very  desirous  of  having 
lots  or  good  discussion,  and  I  hope  the  members  will  feel  free  to 
get  up  and  criticize  the  report  as  much  as  they  wish.  Mr.  Stein  will 
make  the  opening  statement. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Stein  (Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey) : — Mr.  Chair- 
man, I  wish  to  state,  in  briefly  reviewing  the  report  of  the  Committee 
on  Signs,  Fences  and  Crossings,  that  it  is  distinctly  a  progress  report 
this  year.  The  first  subject  assigned  was  to  continue  the  investigation 
of  ways  and  means  for  securing  a  proper  quality  of  fence  wire  to 
resist  corrosion  and  secure  durability.  This  subject  has  been  under 
discussion  and  consideration  for  the  past  three  or  four  years  and  a 
great  amount  of  data  has  been  secured,  particularly  during  the  past 
year.  Practical  investigations  have  been  conducted  by  a  member  of 
the  Committee,  and  there  is  also  a  series  of  investigations  in  progress 
on  the  part  of  the  Committee  of  the  American  Society  for  Testing 
Materials.  We  do  not  feel  that  at  this  time  these  investigations  and 
experiments  have  reached  a  point  where  we  can  definitely  come  to  a 
conclusion;  hence  the  matter  should  be  continued  for  another  year 
at  least,  and  we  believe  that  at  its  expiration  we  will  be  in  a  position 
to  announce  something  to  the  Association  upon  which  it  can  take 
action.  We  have  received  the  co-operation  of  the  large  wire  manu- 
facturers, and  that  has  helped  us  very  much  in  the  investigations  that 
we  have  made.  At  the  present  time  there  are  four  processes  of  galva- 
nizing wire  under  investigation.  One  is  the  galvanizing  after  weaving, 
the  other  the  ordinary  dip  process,  the  third  the  special  galvanized, 
and  the  fourth  the  sherardized.  As  stated  in  the  Bulletin,  the  galva- 
nizing after  weaving  and  the  special  galvanized  appear,  at  this  writing, 
to  be  giving  the  best  results.  The  investigation  and  observation  of 
these  wires  are  still  in  progress  and  we  will  probably  learn  some- 
thing about  it  during  the  course  of  this  year. 

The  second  instruction  was  to  report  on  the  relative  advantages 
and  disadvantages  of  the  different  kinds  of  fence  posts.  Letters  of 
inquiry  were  submitted  to  the  various  railways  and  we  discovered 
that  very  few  experiments  have  been  made,  so  far  as  the  knowledge 
of  the  Committee  went,  from  information  received,  in  regard  to  the 
use  of  concrete  or  other  styles  of  posts  than  wood.     I  believe  there 

1055 


1056  SIGNS,   FENCES   AND   CROSSINGS. 

are  about  nine  roads  that  have  been  making  tests  of  concrete  posts, 
but  not  for  a  sufficiently  long  time  to  enable  them  to  give  us  suffi- 
cient information  on  the  subject.  We  propose  to  look  into  the  matter 
further,  and  we  think  with  the  groundwork  that  we  have  done  that 
we  will  be  enabled  to  develop  some  facts  during  this  year  that  will 
be  of  some  interest  to  the  Association. 

I  think  two  years  ago  the  Committee  was  directed  to  report  on 
the  best  form  of  track  construction  and  flangeways  at  street  cross- 
ings in  paved  streets.  The  Committee  made  certain  recommendations 
in  regard  to  this  subject,  but  it  was  found  after  these  recommenda- 
tions were  made  that  the  processes  they  had  recommended  had  not 
been  actually  tried  out  in  practice.  The  Committee  has  been  investi- 
gating along  these  lines,  but  because  of  the  fact  that  no  actual  ex- 
perimentation had  been  made  it  was  found  difficult  to  recommend  any- 
thing, or  to  prepare  plans,  as  the  Board  of  Direction  suggested,  to 
show  just  what  the  Committee  was  endeavoring  to  arrive  at.  Since 
that  time,  however,  the  Committee  has  speculated  upon  this  subject 
and  we  have  prepared  certain  tentative  plans,  and  we  are  negotiating 
with  the  steel  manufacturers  now,  and  it  is  thought  that  during  the 
course  of  this  year  the  Committee  will  be  able  to  arrange  with  the 
steel  manufacturers  to  roll  a  few  of  the  rolled  fillers  that  were  pro- 
posed for  flangeways  through  street  crossings  and  try  them  out  in 
actual  practice.  This,  it  is  thought,  will  be  a  distinct  move  in  the 
line  of  progress  on  this  subject. 

There  is  one  other  matter  that  forcibly  presented  itself  to  the 
Committee  during  this  year,  and  that  is  that  there  was  a  growing 
demand  for  uniformity  in  the  styles  of  signs  for  all  railway  purposes, 
not  only  for  the  information  of  the  public,  but  for  that  of  the  rail- 
way employe  as  well.  The  Committee  conducted  some  little  investi- 
gation along  these  lines  and  felt  that,  preliminary  to  actual  injunc- 
tions from  the  Board  of  Direction,  that  it  ought  to  do  something 
so  that  if  it  were  seen  fit  in  the  wisdom  of  the  Board  of  Direction 
to  assign  this  subject  to  them,  that  they  would  have  a  foundation 
to  work  upon  and  the  Committee  proposes  to  recommend  that  the 
Board  of  Direction  assign  this  subject  to  it  for  consideration  and 
discussion  and  possible  conclusions  during  the  next  year. 

I  want  to  state  in  connection  with  this  subject  that  during 
the  past  year,  more  particularly  than  ever  before,  the  public  utility 
commissions  of  the  various  States  are  taking  some  notice  of  this  sub- 
ject. A  few  months  ago  I  happened  to  be  summoned  before  the 
Board  of  Public  Utility  Commissioners  of  the  State  of  New  Jersey 
in  reference  to  it,  and  it  was  their  wish  at  that  meeting  to  direct  us 
to  adopt  a  certain  style  of  sign  for  railway  crossings.  I  believed  at 
the  time  that  perhaps  other  boards  of  public  utility  commissioners 
and  State  Commissions  of  various  kinds  would  perhaps  take  up 
the  suggestion,  if  they  have  not  already  done  so,  from  the  action  taken 
in   New  Jersey,  and   I   thought  this,  perhaps,  was  a  propitious  time 


DISCUSSION.  1057 

for  the  Association,   through   its   Committee,   to  discuss   this   subject 
and  I  told  the  Commissioners  of  the  State  of  New  Jersey  that  the  Com- 
mittee was  already  giving  some  consideration  to  this  matter  and  was 
going  to  suggest  it  to  the  Association  at  its  next  meeting,  which  is  the  . 
present  one. 

I  have  learned  only  recently  that  the  commissioners  of  several 
other  States  have  actually  taken  up  this  subject  and  in  one  instance, 
1  believe,  have  actually  directed  the  style  of  crossing  sign  that  the 
railroads  of  that  particular  State  should  adopt.  Now,  it  is  our  opinion 
that  it  is  highly  inexpedient  that  the  boards  of  public  utility  com- 
misioners  and  the  railway  commissions  of  the  various  States  should 
direct  any  special  design  of  sign  until  such  time  as  we  have  given 
some  thought  and  some  study  to  this  subject. 

Therefore,  the  Committee  wishes  to  present  the  matter  to  the 
Association  as  a  live  topic  for  consideration,  and  we  believe  that  it 
v/ould  be  well  for  us  in  this  respect,  as  much  as  in  other  of  our  oper- 
ations, to  have  uniformity,  so  that  individuals,  when  traveling  from 
the  Atlantic  to  the  Pacific  or  from  the  Northern  States  to  the  Gulf 
of  Mexico,  will  see  that  there  is  a  distinct  wording  of  signs,  distinct 
character  of  signs,  to  indicate  the  purposes  for  which  they  are  in- 
tended. Automobilists,  for  instance,  no  matter  through  what  States 
they  travel,  may  know  by  the  very  form  of  the  sign  that  it  represents 
on  all  railways  a  railway  crossing.  It  seems  as  if  these  standard 
signs  ought  to  be  adopted  from  the  standpoint  of  efficiency,  utility 
and  economy  for  the  railways,  and  the  Committee,  therefore,  pro- 
poses to  recommend  that  this  subject  be  given  it,  for  its  considera- 
tion and,  therefore,  we  present  the  following  recommendations: 

(i)  That  the  Board  of  Direction  instruct  our  Committee  to  en- 
deavor to  co-operate  with  a  similar  Committee  of  the  American  So- 
ciety for  Testing  Materials,  in  reaching  conclusion  on  the  subject  of 
a  proper  quality  of  fence  wire  to  resist  corrosion  and  secure  dura- 
bility. 

(2)  That  subjects  Nos.  2,  3  and  4  assigned  last  year  be  reas- 
signed for  study  and  report;  that  is,  the  relative  advantages  and 
disadvantages  of  the  different  kinds  of  fence  posts,  the  best  form  of 
track  construction  and  flangeways  at  street  crossings  and  paved 
streets,  and  the  relative  advantages  and  disadvantages  of  the  differ- 
ent kinds  of  telegraph  poles. 

(3)  That  the  Board  of  Direction  assign  the  subject  of  "uniform 
railway  signs  for  all  purposes  as  applicable  to  the  public  and  to 
railway  operation,  for  study  and  conclusions." 

The  President: — Do  any  of  the  members  wish  to  make  any  re- 
marks on  the  progress  report  of  this  Committee?  Do  any  of  the 
members  desire  to  say  anything  in  regard  to  concrete  posts? 

If  there  is  no  discussion,  the  report  of  the  Committee  will  be  re- 
ceived and  the  Committee  dismissed  with  the  thanks  of  the  Asso- 
ciation. 


DISCUSSION  ON  ECONOMICS  OF  RAILWAY  LOCATION. 

(For  Report,   see  pp.  905-906.) 

LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART    IN    DISCUSSION    ON    ECONOMICS    OF   RAILWAY 

LOCATION. 

L.  C.  Fritch.  A.  K.  Shurtleff. 

The  President — 'The  next  is  the  Committee  on  Economics  of  Rail- 
way Location,  of  which  Mr.  A.  K.  Shurtleff  is  Chairman.  Mr.  Shurtleff 
will  make  the  opening  statement. 

Mr.  A.  K.  Shurtleff  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific)  :— Mr.  Presi- 
dent and  Members,  the  report  of  this  Committee  is  found  in  Bulletin 
144.  The  Committee  has  received  one  compliment  on  their  report;  that 
was  from  the  Secretary,  and  he  complimented  us  because  of  the  brevity  of 
the  report.  There  was  one  most  excellent  reason  for  the  brevity — we 
had  nothing  to  say,  and  we  tried  not  to  say  it.  The  Committee  feels  a 
little  more  cheerful  than  it  did  last  year,  as  we  have  received  some  data 
from  railways  which  we  consider  extremely  valuable,  but  it  takes  time  to 
digest  this.  I  will  say  that  we  have  a  number  of  members  on  this  Com- 
mittee who  are  good  workers  and  willing  workers.  One  or  two  of  them 
have  told  me  that  they  were  ashamed  to  tell  me  how  much  work  they 
had  done  and  how  little  it  showed  in  the  final  results.  The  Chairman 
feels  the  same  way  about  the  work  that  he  has  done.  In  digesting  this 
information,  it  takes  an  enormous  amount  of  work  to  accomplish  a  little 
for  the  final  results.  We  trust  that  next  year  we  will  be  able  to  give 
you,  in  a  substantial  form,  something  in  the  line  of  conclusions. 

Mr.  Begien  informs  me  that  the  Baltimore  &  Ohio  Railroad  is  still 
tabulating  the  results  of  those  extensive  tests  they  have  been  making,  and 
this  will  eventually  be  given  to  the  Association.  I  know  of  nothing  further 
the  Committee  has  to  say.  We  have  no  apologies  because  we  have  not 
been  able  to  give  a  report.  We  have  been  working,  but  are  unable  as  yet 
to  give  anything  that  we  think  should  be  placed  before  the  Association. 

The  President: — Does  anyone  wish  to  make  any  remarks? 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  :— Mr.  Chairman,  I  would 
like  to  say,  on  behalf  of  the  Committee,  that  in  order  that  the  work  of 
this  Committee  be  effective,  the  membership  must  make  up  its  mind  to 
furnish  them  data.  The  Committtee  cannot  carry  on  its  work  unless  the 
Association  furnishes  it  good,  reliable  data  on  which  to  work. 

Mr.  Shurtleff : — I  want  to  say  in  reference  to  Mr.  Fritch's  remarks, 
that  after  the  last  annual  convention  a  number  of  the  roads  gave  us  most 
excellent  data  for  the  work,  and  the  Committee  feels  grateful  to  those 
who  have  furnished  that  information. 

The  President :— The  Committee  will  be  dismissed  with  the  thanks 
of  the  Association. 

1058 


DISCUSSION  ON  UNIFORM   GENERAL  CONTRACT 

FORMS. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  907-916.) 

LIST    OF    SPEAKERS    TAKING    PART    IN    DISCUSSION    ON     UNIFORM    GENERAL 
CONTRACT    FORMS. 

C.  Frank  Allen.  J.  E.  Greiner.  A.  R.  Raymer. 

W.  G.  Atwood.  J.  B.  Jenkins.  J.   P.  Snow. 

A.  S.  Baldwin.  R.  G.  Kenly.  W.  F.  Steffens. 

J.  B.  Berry.  E.  H.  Lee.  C.  H.  Stein. 

E.  C.  Brown.  C.  E.  Lindsay.  G.  D.  Swingly. 

C.  Dougherty.  Hunter  McDonald.         W.  I.  Trench. 

E.  A.  Frink.  C.  A.  Morse. 

The  President : — The  Committee  on  Uniform  General  Contract 
Forms  will  please  come  forward.  Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood,  the  Vice-Chairman, 
will  make  the  statement  of  the  work  of  this  Committee. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood  (Lake  Erie  &  Western)  : — This  Committee  has 
had  meetings,  as  shown,  and  in  addition  the  Chairman  of  the  Committee 
and  myself  met  with  the  Chairman  appointed  by  the  Bridge  Builders' 
Association,  who  were  also  working  on  a  general  contract  form.  The 
contract  which  they  had  drawn  differed  some  from  the  form  that  we 
proposed,  but  after  the  meeting  we  were  substantially  in  agreement.  The 
Committee  asks  the  approval  of  the  convention  to  the  general  idea  which 
we  have  set  out  of  having  a  short  agreement  which  can  be  used,  when 
desired,  in  place  of  letter  agreements,  which  are  very  common.  If 
we  desire  a  formal  contract  instead  of  the  acceptance  of  the  proposition 
by  letter,  we  can  use  the  agreement  which  we  have  shown  under  Form  A. 
In  cases  of  larger  work,  where  more  detail  is  desired,  we  propose  the 
general  condition  shown  under  Form  B,  the  idea  being  to  print  the 
Form  A  so  that  the  Form  B  can  be  bound  in  it,  together  with  such 
other  clauses  as  may  be  desired  by  the  person  using  the  contract.  We 
have,  in  addition  to  working  with  the  steel  manufacturers;  gone  over 
a  large  number  of  contract  forms  in  use  by  various  roads,  and  have  also 
considered  the  work  presented  by  the  Building  Committee  several  years 
ago.  The  form,  as  we  have  presented  it,  is  unfortunately  incomplete,  as 
the  Committee  has  not  finally  agreed  on  clauses  covering  annulment 
of  contract  on  account  of  the  contractor's  fault,  annulment  of  the  con- 
tract without  fault  of  the  contractor,  removal  of  equipment,  measure- 
ment and  approval  of  work,  and  final  estimate. 

The  Committee  recommends  that  the  work  be  continued  in  order 
that  those  clauses  may  be  completed.  With  these  clauses  we  considered 
that  we  had  covered  about  all  the  ground  that  it  is  practical  to  cover  in  a 

1059 


1060  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

general  contract  of  this  kind.  When  applied  to  specific  cases,  it  will 
probably  be  generally  necessary  to  add  certain  clauses,  covering  each 
case. 

The  President : — Will  you  read  the  construction  contract  as  pro- 
posed, by  paragraphs?     We  will  wait  after  each  paragraph  for  criticism. 

Mr.    W.    G.    Atwood  : — "Construction    Contract     (A — Agreement)  — 

This  agreement,  made  this  day  of  in  the 

year    by  and  between    

party  of  the  first  part,  hereinafter  called  the  Contractor,  and 

party  of  the  second  part,  hereinafter  called  the   Company. 

"Witnesseth,  That,  in  consideration  of  the  covenants  and  agreements 
hereinafter  mentioned,  to  be  performed  by  the  parties  hereto,  and  of  the 
payments  hereinafter  agreed  to  be  made,  it  is  mutually  agreed  as  follows: 

"The  Contractor  shall  furnish  all  the  necessary  transportation,  ma- 
terials, superintendence,  labor  and  equipment,  and  shall  execute,  construct 
and  finish  in  an  expeditious,  substantial  and  workmanlike  manner,  to 
the  satisfaction  and  acceptance  of  the   Chief  Engineer   of  the   Company 

in  accordance  with  the  plans  hereto  attached  or  as  herein 

described,  and  the  following  general  conditions,  requirements  and  speci- 
fications, forming  part  of  this  contract. 

"The  work  covered  by  the  contract  shall  be  commenced 

and  be  completed  on  or  before  the 

day  of   ,   191.  .,    

"This  agreement  shall  inure  to  the  benefit  of  and  be  binding  upon  the 
legal    representatives    and    successors    of    the    parties    respectively. 

"In  Witness  Whereof,  The  parties  hereto  have  executed  this  agree- 
ment in  the  day  and  year  first  above  written. 

"Witness :   " 

Mr.  E.  C.  Brown  (Carnegie  Steel  Company)  : — Is  it  not  unusual  to 
nominate  the  Contractor  as  party  of  the  first  part  in  agreements  with 
the  railroads. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — I  would  say  that  the  practice  is  not  at  all 
uniform.  We  had  under  consideration,  1  think,  probably  fifty  contract 
forms,  and  it  was  done  about  an  equal  number  of  times  in  each  way.  It 
is  really  a  matter  that  the  Committee  did  not  consider  of  any  very  great 
importance.  However,  the  Contractor's  signature  appears  first  on  the 
contract,  and  for  that  reason  it  seems  that  he  should  be  the  party  of 
the  first  part. 

Mr.  J.  P.  Snow  (Consulting  Engineer)  : — I  would  like  to  ask  the 
Committee  if  they  feel  it  is  worth  while  to  say  that  either  the  Con- 
tractor or  the  Company  is  the  party  of  the  first  part  or  the  party  of  the 
second  part?  Oftentimes  an  agreement  states  that  such  a  party  "will 
be  hereafter  called  the  contractor"  or  "the  railway,"  or  "the  company," 
or  some  characteristic  name.  Is  it  not  better  to  use  some  such  form 
than  to  speak  about  "party  of  the  first  part"  and  "party  of  the  second 
part?"     It  is  my  preference. 


DISCUSSION.  1061 

Another  thing  that  occurs  to  me  is  that  there  is  nothing  apparently 
in  this  form  that  tells  what  the  job  is.  It  seems  to  me  that  the  first  line 
or  the  first  sentence  of  an  agreement  should  state  what  the  job  is,  so  that 
in  running  over  your  files  you  can  easily  recognize  the  paper  that  you 
are  trying  to  find.  Again,  it  is  often  necessary  to  refer  to  the  job  in 
the  document,  especially  in  the  articles  of  agreement  under  B ;  and  my 
preference  is  to  name  the  work  which  is  to  be  done,  give  it  a  distinctive 
title,  and  say  that  it  will  hereafter  be  called  "the  work."  Then  you 
can  refer  to  it  without  stringing  out  the  full  name.  In  this  way  we 
have  "the  work,"  "the  contractor"  and  "the  purchaser,"  whoever  it  may 
be — the  railway,  the  company,  or  some  man's  name,  or  the  corporation. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — In  reply  to  Mr.  Snow's  first  criticism  I  would 
say  that  we  have  found  the  practice  of  naming  the  parties  to  the  contract 
as  the  first  and  second  party  is  very  largely  a  matter  of  preference.  In 
my  own  experience  I  have  found  one  or  two  attorneys  who  insisted  that 
it  should  be  in  this  way.  I  have  also  heard  of  other  attorneys  who  in- 
sisted it  should  be  in  the  way  Mr.  Snow  states.  I  think  that  is  largely  a 
matter  of  preference.  The  Committee  thought  this  was  the  better  way 
in  which  to  set  it  out. 

In  regard  to  the  naming  of  the  work  in  the  first  portion  of  an  agree- 
ment, that  could  readily  be  cared  for  by  a  heading.  Mr.  Snow  will 
find,  below  the  next  clause,  a  blank  provided  for  a  description  of  the 
work.  That  changes  the  order  which  he  suggests,  but  it  is  on  the  first 
page  of  the  contract. 

Prof.  C.  Frank  Allen  (Massachusetts  Institute  of  Technology)  : — 
Mr.  President,  in  relation  to  the  question  of  omitting  the  words  "party 
of  the  first  part"  and  "party  of  the  second  part,"  it  is,  of  course,  a  well- 
recognized  fact  that  in  contracts  there  must  be  definitely  at  least  two 
parties.  Sometimes  the  description  of  one  of  the  parties  is  somewhat 
elaborate,  and  if  there  is  a  clear  distinction  made  between  those  two 
parties,  the  contract  on  the  whole  is  somewhat  clearer,  and  apparently 
a  sharp  distinction  between  the  two  parties  does  more  clearly  establish 
who  the  two  parties  are,  if  there  is  an  opportunity  to  put  it  in  this 
form.  It  does  not  impress  me  as  unnecessarily  encumbering  the  con- 
tract, but  it  does,  from  my  standpoint,  add  somewhat  to  its  clearness. 

Mr.  Snow : — In  reference  to  the  definition  of  the  work,  my  idea 
is  to  have  the  first  sentence  simply  give  a  title  to  the  job  and  say  after- 
wards that  "hereafter  it  will  be  called  the  work."  The  reference,  lower 
down,  where  the  blank  is  provided  for  the  description  of  the  work,  is 
necessary  also,  because  the  work  must  be  defined  with  a  good  deal  of 
definition,  more  than  you  would  want  to  put  into  the  initial  sentence. 
My  idea  is  that  there  shall  be  three  distinct  terms  used  for  reference 
all  through  the  agreement,  "the  work,"  "the  contractor,"  and  the  party  for 
whom  the  work  is  to  be  done. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin  (Illinois  Central)  : — I  agree  with  Mr.  Snow  in  his 
suggestion  as  to  the  better  wording,  at  the  opening  clause  of  the  con- 
tract.    I   think,    as   arranged    here,    it    is    a    mixture    of   two    forms.      It 


1062  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

is  rather  the  older  form  in  which  the  parties  were  named  as  the  first  and 
second  parties  to  a  contract  to  take  the  place,  of  course,  of  repetition  of 
names.  At  the  same  time  undoubtedly  that  frequently  makes  one  have  to 
refer  back  to  the  first  part  of  the  contract  to  refresh  one's  mind  as 
to  who  was  the  first  and  second  party.  Subsequent  to  that  the  method 
has  become  very  common  of  naming  one  as  a  Contractor  and  one  as  the 
Railway  Company.  I  would  suggest  that  "party  of  the  first  part"  and 
"party  of  the  second  part"  be  removed. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — I  will  call  the  attention  of  both  of  the  former 
speakers  to  the  fact  that  this  clause  reads,  "party  of  the  first  part, 
hereinafter  called  'the  Contractor,'  and  blank,  party  of  the  second  part, 
hereinafter  called  'the  Company.'"  In  the  clauses  in  Form  B  the  two 
parties  to  the  contract  are  spoken  of  in  that  way. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin: — What  is  gained  by  naming  them  as  parties 
of  the  first  part  and  second  part  if  not  referred  to  thereafter  in  the 
contract  by  the  same  terms?  If  they  are  referred  to  as  "Contractor" 
and  "the  Railway  Company,"  the  terms  "party  of  the  first  part"  and 
"party   of   the    second    part"    are    probably    not    used    again. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — No ;  we  do  not  use  "party  of  the  first  part" 
and  "party  of  the  second  part."  That  is  a  legal  form  and  some  of  the 
lawyers  consider  it  necessary.  I  don't  know  personally  whether  there 
is  any  legal  objection  to  withdrawing  "party  of  the  first  part"  and  "party 
of  the  second  part"  from  this  one  clause  or  not,  but  it  doesn't  seem  to 
me  there  is  any  objection  to  leaving  it  there. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin : — I  move  that  in  the  third  line  "party  of  the 
first  part"  be  eliminated,  and  in  the  fourth  line  "party  of  the  second 
part"  be  eliminated. 

Mr.  A.  R.  Raymer  (Pittsburgh  &  Lake  Erie)  : — An  operating  com- 
pany when  making  contracts  quite  frequently  includes  the  name  or 
names  of  one  or  more  lessee  companies,  which  companies  together  are 
called  the  "first  party"  or  the  "second  party,"  etc.,  as  the  case  may  be 
For  this  reason  the  form  used  by  the  Committee  is  preferable 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin  : — I  have  seen  a  great  many  contracts  drawn  up 
in  which  several  parties  were  combined  in  one,  by  referring  to  such  and 
such  parties  "hereinafter  collectively  called  so  and  so,"  giving  them  a 
name  that  identifies  them  by  name  all  the  way  through  the  contract, 
which  of  course  answers  the  same  purpose. 

Mr.  C.  H.  Stein  (Central  Railroad  of  New  Jersey)  : — I  want  to  em- 
phasize the  view  which  is  taken  by  Mr.  Raymer.  I  do  not  believe  we 
could  afford  to  get  up  the  contracts  in  any  other  form.  I  think  there 
should  be  some  specific  designation  similar  to  the  one  outlined  by  the 
Committee.  I  believe  that  almost  from  time  immemorial  this  has  been 
substantially  the  form  in  which  the  contracts  have  been  gotten  up,  and 
it  frequently  happens  that  the  names  of  contracting  parties  are  so 
much  alike  that  even  we,  who  are  familiar  with  the  general  character 
of  the  contract  but  not  entirely  familiar  with  the  specifications  of 
it,  are  obliged  to  be  very  careful  in   reading  the  contract  in  order  to 


DISCUSSION.  1063 

fully  understand  what  obligations  rest  upon  the  respective  parties.  In 
my  own  experience  when  it  has  been  referred  to  as  "party  of  the  first 
part"  and  "party  of  the  second  part,"  I  would  be  obliged  to  refer  to 
the  indication  in  the  preamble  to  the  contract  to  distinctly  understand  what 
particular  person  was  obligated  by  that  particular  specification.  If  names 
so  nearly  alike  had  simply  been  mentioned  it  would  have  been  almost 
impossible  to  separate  them  in  our  minds,  and  would  have  made  us 
prone  to  error  in  a  proper  interpretation  of  the  contract.  For  that 
reason,  I  believe,  if  this  paper,  as  prepared  by  the  Committee,  was  sub- 
mitted to  the  legal  departments  of  the  railroads,  they  would  direct  that 
the  contract  be  prepared  just  in  the  form  that  has  been  arranged  for 
by  the  Committee.  For  that  reason  I  think  the  Committee's  report  should 
stand  and  that  the  Association  should  not  set  aside  all  the  edicts  of  the 
legal  fraternity  and  assume  to  itself  the  prerogative  of  how  a  contract 
of  this  kind  should  be  prepared.  If  the  Association  thinks  there  is  any 
question  as  to  the  propriety  of  this  character  of  contract,  it  had  better 
be  submitted  to  the  legal  department  of  some  of  the  railways  and  get 
their  advice  in  the  matter  before  the  Association  arbitrarily  says  'cut 
this  thing  out,"  or  "cut  that  thing  out."  This  question  is  of  too  much 
importance   to   be   put    aside   by   mere    resolutions. 

M'r.  J.  B.  Berry  (Chicago,  Rock  Island  &  Pacific): — I  suggest  the 
Committee  leave  a  blank  line  or  two  after  the  description  of  the  parties — 
there  are  frequently  three  or  more  parties   to  any  contract. 

Mr.  E.  A.  Frink  (Seaboard  Air  Line)  : — I  call  attention  to  the  last 
clause,  "In  witness  whereof  the  parties  hereto  have  executed  this  agree- 
ment   in    ,    the    day    and    year    first    above    written."      It 

seems  to  me  that  date  is  incorrect,  for  the  reason  that  a  contract  is  made 
and  completed  on  the  day  when  the  proposition  has  been  accepted,  but 
need  not  necessarily  be  signed  until  some  time  thereafter,  and,  therefore, 
instead  of  that  clause  referring  to  the  date  first  above  written,  which 
appears  at  the  head  of  the  contract,  it  seems  to  me  it  should  show  the 
date   when   the   contract   was   actually   signed. 

Mr.  Raymer : — I  make  one  suggestion.  The  contract  follows  the 
usual  form  in  saying,  "in  accordance  with  the  plans  hereto  attached." 
We  know  this  is  an  idle  term,  because  in  most  railway  contracts  it  is  im- 
possible to  attach  the  plans  to  the  contract,  and  I  think  a  different  form 
should  be  used ;  for  instance :  "In  accordance  with  the  plans  identified 
by  the  signatures  of  the  parties  hereto."  This  will  identify  the  plans 
and  render  unnecessary  the  words  "in  accordance  with  the  plans  hereto 
attached." 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — In  regard  to  the  criticism  of  the  last  clause  there 
is  a  misprint.  The  word  "in"  should  be  "on."  Jt  is  my  opinion  that 
the  contract  does  not  become  in  force  and  effective  until  it  is  signed. 
In  fact,  a  contract  supersedes  by  law  any  prior  agreement,  verbal  or 
written.  The  contract  is  supposed  to  embody  all  such  agreements,  and 
it  does  not  seem  to  me  the  last  clause   should  be  changed  as   suggested. 


1064  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

In  regard  to  Mr.  Raymer's  criticism,  it  is,  of  course,  a  fact  that  some- 
times the  complete  plans  are  not  attached  to  the  contract,  but  that  is 
covered  by  the  words  "or  as  herein  described."  If  the  plans  are  not 
attached  to  the  contract,  the  description  of  the  work  would  necessarily 
include  the  plans  that  woidd  be  required  to  cover  the   entire  work. 

Mr.  Raymer : — That  is  true,  but  there  is  another  point.  In  work 
of  any  magnitude,  the  detail  plans  are  usually  not  all  completed  at  the 
time  of  the  letting  of  the  contract.  It  may  be  necessary  to  make 
changes  in  the  plans  during  the  progress  of  the  work  by  agreement  with 
the  Contractor.  The  original  plans  referred  to  in  the  contract  should  be 
specifically  marked.  For  this  reason  it  is  desirable  to  have  the  plans 
identified   by   the   signatures   of   the   parties   to    the   contract 

To  bring  the  matter  before  the  meeting  in  proper  form,  I  move 
that  the  phraseology  now  contained  in  the  report  of  the  Committee,  "in 
accordance  with  the  plans  hereto  attached"  or  "as  herein  described,"  be 
changed  to  read  as  follows:  "In  accordance  with  plans  identified  by  the 
signatures  of  the  parties  hereto." 

(The  motion  was  lost.) 

M'r.  W.  F.  Steffens  (Boston  &  Albany)  : — Do  I  understand  that  there 
is  to  be  space  left  for  a  description  of  the  plans?  As  the  forms  now 
read,  the  blanks  left  for  necessary  or  extra  writing  apply  to  the  beginning 
and  date  of  completion  of  the  contract.  Should  there  not  be  a  space  pro- 
vided in  the  contract  to  identify  the  plans   "as  herein  described?" 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — It  hardly  seems  to  the  Committee  that  in 
general  it  is  necessary  to  definitely  describe  each  plan  attached.  We 
say,  "in  accordance  with  the  plans  hereto  attached."  They  become 
part  of  the  contract,  but  it  is  a  matter  of  detail  arrangement.  This 
contract  form  probably  will  not  be  used  very  extensively  exactly  as 
it  is  printed,  especially  as  to  the  spacing  of  blanks,  and  I  am  inclined 
to  think  the  suggestion  of  Mr.  Steffens  is  in  the  line  of  a  detail  which 
it  would  not  be  necessary  to  cover   in  this  general    form. 

Prof.  Allen : — The  Railway  Company  is  very  likely  to  have  several 
blank  forms  of  contract ;  one  a  short  form,  with  small  blanks ;  and 
another  with  larger  blanks,  and  the  Railway  Company  has  ample  oppor- 
tunity to  print  its  own  forms  with  such  additional  blanks  as  may  seem 
desirable. 

Mr.  J.  B.  Jenkins  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  suggest  that  the  blank 
space  immediately  above,  for  describing  the  work  to  be  done,  could 
also  be  used  to  describe  the  plans  to  be  used,  and  in  connection  with  the 
motion  just  lost  I  would  suggest  that  the  contract  reads:  "As  herein 
described,"  and  these  plans  could  be  very  readily  described  as  being 
identified   by   the    signatures    of   the    contracting   parties. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — I  would  move  that  the  fii  st  recommendation 
of  the  Committee  that  the  form  of  construction  contract  A,  as  presented 
by  the  Committee,  be  approved. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 


DISCUSSION.  1065 

The  President : — We  will  now  take  up  the  "Construction  Contract" 
B,  General  Conditions,  and  it  will  be  read  by  sections. 

(Mr.  Atwood   read   the   construction   contract   by   sections.) 

"i.  Bond.  The  Contractor  agrees,  at  the  time  of  the  execution  and 
delivery  of  this  contract  and  before  the  taking  effect  of  the  same,  to 
furnish  and  deliver  to  the  Company  a  good  and  sufficient  bond  of  in- 
demnity to  the  amount  of  dollars,  as  se- 
curity for  the  faithful  performance,  by  the  Contractor,  of  all  the  cove- 
nants and  agreements  on  the  part  of  the  Contractor  contained  in  this 
contract.  The  security  in  such  bond  of  indemnity  must  be  satisfactory 
and  acceptable  to  the  Company. 

"This  bond  shall  remain  in  force  and  effect  in  such  amount,  not 
greater  than  that  specified,  as  shall  be  determined  by  the  Chief  En- 
gineer,   until   the   final   completion   and    acceptance    of   the    work." 

Mr.  C.  A.  M'orse  (Santa  Fe)  : — What  is  intended  to  be  meant  by  the 
words  "to  furnish  and  deliver  to  the  Company  a  good  and  sufficient 
bond?"  Would  it  not  be  well  to  say  the  Treasurer  of  the  Company 
in  referring  to  the  Railway  Company? 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — That  practice  varies  with  different  companies. 
In  the  case  of  some  companies  the  Chief  Engineer  controls  it,  in  some 
cases  the  Treasury,  and  in  some  cases  the  Legal  Department,  and  in  some 
cases  all  three. 

"2.  Contractor's  Understanding.  It  is  understood  and  agreed  that 
the  Contractor  has,  by  careful  examination,  satisfied  himself  as  to  the 
nature  and  location  of  the  work,  the  conformation  of  the  ground,  the 
character,  quality  and  quantity  of  the  materials  to  be  encountered,  the 
character  of  equipment  and  facilities  needed  preliminary  to  and  during 
the  prosecution  of  the  work,  the  general  and  local  conditions,  and  all 
other  matters  which  can  in  any  way  affect  the  work  under  this  con- 
tract. No  verbal  agreement  or  conversation  with  any  officer,  agent  or 
employe  of  the  Company,  either  before  or  after  the  execution  of  this 
contract,  shall  affect  or  modify  any  of  the  terms  or  obligations  herein 
contained. 

"3.  Intent  of  Plans  and  Specifications.  All  work  that  may  be  called 
for  in  the  specifications  and  not  shown  on  the  plans,  or  shown  on  the  plans 
and  not  called  for  in  the  specifications,  shall  be  executed  and  furnished 
by  the  Contractor  as  if  described  in  both  these  ways ;  and  should  any 
work  or  material  be  required  which  is  not  denoted  in  the  specifications 
or  plans,  either  directly  or  indirectly,  but  which  is  nevertheless  necessary 
for  the  proper  carrying  out  of  the  obvious  intentions  thereof,  the  Con- 
tractor is  to  understand  the  same  to  be  implied  and  required,  and  shall 
perform  all  such  work  and  furnish  any  such  material  as  fully  as  if 
they  were  particularly  delineated  or  described. 

"4.  Permits.  Permits  of  a  temporary  nature  necessary  for  the 
prosecution  of  the  work  shall  be  secured  by  the  Contractor.  Permits 
for  permanent  structures  or  permanent  changes  in  existing  facilities  shall 
be  secured  by  the  Company. 


1066  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

"5.  Protection.  Whenever  the  local  conditions,  laws  or  ordinances 
require,  the  Contractor  shall  furnish  and  maintain,  at  his  own  cost 
and  expense,  necessary  passageways,  guard  fences  and  lights  and  such 
other  facilities  and  means  of  protection  as  may  be  required." 

Mr.  C.  A.  Lindsay  (New  York  Central  &  Hudson  River)  : — What  is 
the  object  of  making  the  distinction  between  "permits  of  a  temporary 
nature"  and  "permits  for  permanent  structures  ?"  It  seems  to  me  the 
line  is  hazy  and  might  lead  to  confusion,  unless  the  Committee  has  some 
special  object  in  making  the  distinction. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood: — The  Committee  has  already  boiled  down  sdme 
clauses  bearing  on  this  matter  which  were  much  longer.  It  is  intended 
that  the  Contractor  shall  obtain  permits,  for  instance,  such  as  the  open- 
ing of  a  street,  for  the  erection  of  false  work  or  similar  temporary 
work,  while  it  is  intended  that  it  shall  be  the  duty  of  the  Company  to 
secure  permits  in  such  cases  as  the  permanent  change  of  grade  or  the 
position  of  a  sewer  or  water  pipe.  Anything  that  is  of  a  permanent 
character  will  be  cared  for  by  the  Company,  and  if  it  is  a  temporary  ob- 
struction it  will  be  the  duty  of  the  Contractor  to  secure  the  permit. 

"6.  Rights  of  Various  Interests.  Wherever  work  being  done  by 
Company  forces  or  by  other  Contractors  is  contiguous  to  work  covered 
by  this  contract  the  respective  rights  of  the  various  interests  involved 
shall  be  determined  by  the  Engineer,  to  secure  the  completion  of  the 
various  portions  of  the  work  in  general  harmony. 

"7.  Consent  to  Transfer.  The  Contractor  shall  not  let  or  trans- 
fer this  contract  or  any  part  thereof  (except  for  the  delivery  of  ma- 
terial) without  consent  of  the  Chief  Engineer,  given  in  writing.  Such 
consent  does  not  release  or  relieve  the  Contractor  from  any  or  all  of  his 
obligations  and  liabilities  under  the   contract. 

"8.  Superintendence.  The  Contractor  shall  constantly  superintend 
all  the  work  embraced  in  this  contract  in  person  or  by  a  duly  authorized 
manager    acceptable    to    the    Company. 

"9.  Timely  Demand  for  Points  and  Instructions  The  Contractor 
shall  not  proceed  until  he  has  made  timely  demand  upon  the  Engineer 
for,  and  has  received  from  him,  such  points  and  instructions  as  may  be 
necessary  as  the  work  progresses.  The  work  shall  be  done  in  strict 
conformity  with   such  points  and  instructions. 

"10.  Report  Errors  and  Discrepancies.  If  the  Contractor,  in  the 
course  of  the  work,  finds  any  discrepancy  between  the  plans  and  the 
physical  conditions  of  the  locality,  or  any  errors  in  plans  or  in  the 
layout  as  given  by  said  points  and  instructions,  it  shall  be  his  duty  to  im- 
mediately inform  the  Engineer.  Any  work  done  after  such  discovery, 
until  verified,  will  be  done  at  the  Contractor's  risk. 

"11.  Preservation  of  Stakes.  The  Contractor  must  carefully  preserve 
bench  marks,  reference  points  and  stakes,  and  in  case  of  wilful  or  care- 
less destruction,  he  will  be  charged  with  the  resulting  expense  and  shall 
be  responsible  for  any  mistakes  that  may  be  caused  by  their  unnecessary 
loss  or  disturbance. 


DISCUSSION.  1067 

"12.  Inspection.  All  work  and  materials  shall  be  at  all  times  open 
to  the  inspection,  acceptance  or  rejection  of  the  Engineer  or  his  duly 
authorized  representative.  The  Contractor  shall  at  all  times  provide 
reasonable  and   necessary  facilities   for  such  inspection. 

"13.  Defective  Work  or  Material.  Any  omission  or  failure  on  the 
part  of  the  Engineer  to  disapprove  or  reject  any  work  or  material  shall 
not  be  construed  to  be  an  acceptance  of  any  defective  work  or  material. 
The  Contractor  shall  remove,  at  his  own  expense,  any  work  or  material 
condemned  by  the  Engineer,  and  shall  rebuild  and  replace  the  same  with- 
out extra  charge,  and  in  default  thereof  the  same  shall  be  done  by  the 
Company  at  the  Contractor's  expense — or,  in  case  the  Chief  Engineer 
should  not  consider  the  defect  of  sufficient  importance  to  require  the  Con- 
tractor to  rebuild  or  replace  any  imperfect  work  or  material,  he  shall 
have  power,  and  is  hereby  authorized,  to  make  any  deduction  from  the 
stipulated  price  that  he  may  deem  proper." 

Mr.  Steffens : — The  last  sentence  is  pretty  radical,  giving  the  Chief 
Engineer  authority  to  make  any  deduction  from  the  stipulated  price 
that  he  may  deem  proper  for  defective  work.  Unless  there  is  an  ar- 
bitration clause  that  is  pretty  dangerous  from  the  Contractor's  stand- 
point.   "As  agreed  upon  by  the  parties"  would  be  acceptable  reading. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood: — The  Committee  felt  that  perhaps  this  clause 
was  somewhat  radical,  not  quite  in  the  way  Mr.  Steffens  suggests.  It 
is  unusual,  I  think,  in  contracts  to  permit  the  Chief  Engineer  to  accept 
work  that  is  not  up  to  specifications.  I  think  all  of  us  have  had  ex- 
periences where  we  have  condemned  work  and  ordered  it  torn  out  when 
we  felt  that  it  was  not  up  to  specifications,  but  would  perhaps  have 
performed  its  service.  This  paragraph  leaves  an  opportunity  to  use 
the  defective  work  and  allows  the  Chief  Engineer  to  make  a  deduction. 
I  do  not  believe  it  is  practicable  to  make  that  a  matter  of  agreement. 

(There  was  no  change  in  the  section.) 

"14.  Insurance.  The  Contractor  shall  secure  in  the  name  of  the 
Company  and  for  its  benefit,  policies  of  fire  insurance  on  such  structures 
and  in  such  amounts  as  shall  be  specified  by  the  Chief  Engineer  not 
exceeding  

"15.  Indemnity.  The  Contractor  shall  indemnify  and  save  harmless 
the  Company  for  and  from  all  claims,  demands,  payments,  suits,  actions, 
recoveries  and  judgments  of  every  nature  and  description  brought  or  re- 
covered against  it,  by  reason  of  any  act  or  omission  of  the  said  Con- 
tractor, his  agents  or  employes,  in  the  execution  of  the  work  by  or  in 
consequence  of  any  negligence  or  carelessness  in  guarding  the  same. 

"16.  Settlement  for  Wages.  Whenever,  in  the  opinion  of  the  Chief 
Engineer,  it  may  be  necessary  for  the  progress  of  the  work  to  secure 
to  any  of  the  employes  of  the  Contractor  any  wages  which  may  then 
be  due  them,  the  Company  is  hereby  authorized  to  pay  said  employes  the 
amount  due  them  or  any  lesser  amount,  and  the  amount  so  paid  them,  as 
shown  by  their  receipts,  shall  be  deducted  from  any  moneys  that  may 
be  or  become  payable  to  said   Contractor." 


1068  CONTRACT    FORMS. 

Prof.  Allen: — A  question  occurs  as  to  this  section,  whether  it  is 
possible  that  the  amount  of  money  that  is  reserved  and  payable  will 
in  all  cases  be  sufficient  to  safeguard  the  Company.  A  Contractor  may 
do  a  certain  amount  of  work  that  proves  of  very  little  value  to  the  Com- 
pany and  the  workmen  who  did  the  work  may  have  a  mechanic's  lien 
against  the  Company;  this  clause  apparently  does  not  sufficiently  pro- 
tect the  Company ;  it  has  occurred  to  me  that  it  would  be  wise  to 
have  a  provision  in  the  bond  looking  to  matters  of  that  sort.  This 
form  of  contract  is  not  to  be  accepted  in  full  at  the  present:  time,  because 
it  is  incomplete  in  parts,and  I  make  this  suggestion  to  the  Committee 
so  that  there  may  be  opportunity  to  take  care  of  this  matter  if  they  see 
fit,   either  here,   or,  probably,  better,   in   the  bond. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood  : — I  think  the  bond  generally  does  take  care  of 
that. 

Mr.  Hunter  McDonald  (Nashville,  Chattanooga  &  St.  Louis)  : — I 
ask  the  Committee  if  they  intend,  in  the  second  line  of  the  clause,  the 
word  "employes"  to  mean  also  "sub-contractors?" 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood:— I  think  that  was  the  intention  of  the  Committee. 

"17.  Liens.  If  an  established  lien  be  filed  against  the  Contractor 
for  labor  or  material  furnished  in  the  performance  of  the  work,  the 
Company  is  hereby  authorized  to  pay  and  discharge  the  same,  if  it  shall 
deem  best  so  to  do,  and  to  deduct  the  amount  so  paid  from  any  moneys 
which  may  be  or  become  due  and  payable  to  the  Contractor." 

Mr.  Raymer : — The  no-liens  laws  are  different  in  different  States. 
In  Pennsylvania  it  is  customary  with  us  to  have  a  "no-lien"  clause.  The 
law  requires  a  copy  of  the  contract  and  some  additional  information 
to  be  filed  at  the  County  courthouse ;  after  complying  with  these  require- 
ments the  Company  is  not  responsible  for  liens.  These  liens  some- 
times develop  after  the  final  payment  has  been  made.  I  ask  the  Com- 
mittee if  there  is  any  objection  against  having  a  "no-lien"  clause  included 
in  this  contract? 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — It  seems  to  the  Committee  that  the  case  men- 
tioned by  Mr.  Raymer  and  other  cases  which  might  occur  under  various 
State  laws  would  be  special  cases  that  the  road  using  the  contract  would 
have  to  cover  in  a  special  clause  which  they  would  insert  in  the  con- 
tract to  meet  local  conditions.  The  lien  laws  do  vary  quite  generally 
in  different  States.  It  might  be  that  in  Pennsylvania  this  clause  would 
have  to  be  materially  changed. 

"18.  Work  Adjacent  to  Railroad.  Whenever  the  work  embraced  in 
this  contract  is  near  the  tracks,  structures  or  buildings  of  this  Company 
or  of  other  railroads,  the  Contractor  shall  use  proper  care  and  vigilance 
to  avoid  injury  to  persons  or  property.  The  work  must  be  so  conducted 
as  not  to  interfere  with  the  movement  of  trains  or  other  operations  of 
the  railroad;  or,  if  in  any  case  such  interference  be  necessary,  the  Con- 
tractor shall  not  proceed  until  he  has  first  obtained  specific  authority 
and  directions  therefor  from  the  proper  officer  of  the  Company  and 
has  the  approval  of  the  Engineer." 


DISCUSSION.  1069 

Mr.  J.  E.  Greiner  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — Suppose  there  is  some  other 
property  adjacent  to  the  railway  which  is  not  railway  property— how  arc 
you  going  to  take  care  of  that? 

In  a  highway  for  instance? 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — I  think  that  is  generally  covered  in  another 
clause — the  clause  on  protection. 

"19.  Risk.  The  work  in  every  respect  shall  be  at  the  risk  of  the 
Contractor  until  finished  and  accepted,  except  damage  or  injury  caused 
directly  by   Company's   agents   or   employes. 

"20.  Order  and  Discipline.  The  Contractor  shall  at  all  times  enforce 
strict  discipline  and  good  order  among  his  employes,  and  any  employe 
of  the  Contractor  who  shall  appear  to  be  incompetent,  disorderly  or  in- 
temperate, or  in  any  other  way  disqualified  for  or  unfaithful  to  the  work 
entrusted  to  him,  shall  be  discharged  immediately  on  the  request  of  the 
Engineer,  and  he  shall  not  again  be  employed  on  the  work  without  the 
Engineer's  written   consent." 

Prof.  Allen  : — Would  it  be  an  advantage  to  have  that  read  "any  em- 
ploye of  the  Contractor  who  shall  appear  to  the  Engineer  to  be  in- 
competent?" That  places  the  responsibility  a  little  more  clearly,  although 
che  inference   from   this   reading  would  be   to  the   same   effect. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — The  request  is  to  be  made  by  the  Engineer 
according  to  this  clause. 

Prof.  Allen  : — My  suggestion  would  make  it  a  little  more  definite 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood: — "21.  Contractor  Not  to  Hire  Company's  Em- 
ployes. The  Contractor  shall  not  employ  or  hire  any  of  the  Company's 
employes  without  the  permission  of  the  Engineer." 

A  Member: — What  does  that  mean? 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — This  perhaps  covers  two  things.  The  Con- 
tractor sometimes  steals  a  man  from  you,  very  much  to  your  detriment, 
and  I  have  heard  of  cases  where  masonry  inspectors,  for  instance,  have 
been  employed  as  "pumpers"  somewhat  to  the  loss  of  the  masonry. 

"22.  Intoxicating  Liquors  Prohibited.  The  Contractor,  in  so  far 
as  his  authority  extends,  shall  not  permit  the  sale,  distribution  or  use  of 
any  intoxicating  liquors  upon  or  adjacent  to  the  work,  or  allow  any  such 
to  be  brought  upon,  to  or  near  the  line  of  the  railway  of  the  Company. 

"23.  Cleaning  Up.  The  Contractor  shall,  as  directed  by  the  En- 
gineer, remove  from  the  Company's  property  and  from  all  public  and 
private  property,  at  his  own  expense,  all  temporary  structures,  rubbish 
and   waste   materials    resulting   from    his    operations. 

"24.  Engineer  and  Chief  Engineer  Defined.  Wherever  in  this  con- 
tract the  word  Engineer  is  used,  it  shall  be  understood  as  referring  to 
the  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Company,  acting  personally  or  through  an 
assistant  duly  authorized  in  writing  for  such  act  by  the  Chief  Engineer, 
and  wherever  the  words  Chief  Engineer  are  used  it  shall  be  understood 
as  referring  to  the  Chief  Engineer  in  person,  and  not  to  any  assistant 
engineer. 


1070  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

"25.  Power  of  Engineer.  The  Engineer  shall  have  full  power  to 
reject  or  condemn  all  work  or  material,  which,  in  his  opinion,  does  not 
conform  to  this  contract;  to  direct  the  application  of  forces  to  any  portion 
of  the  work  which,  in  his  judgment,  requires  it;  to  order  the  force  in- 
creased or  diminished,  and  to  decide  every  question  that  may  arise  be- 
tween the  parties   relative  to  the  execution  of  the  work. 

"26.  Adjustment  of  Dispute.  All  questions  or  controversies  which 
may  arise  between  the  Contractor  and  the  Company,  under  or  in  refer- 
ence to  this  contract,  shall  be  subject  to  the  decision  of  the  Chief  En- 
gineer,   and  his   decision   shall   be   final   and    conclusive    to   both   parties. 

"27.  Order  of  Completion;  Use  of  Completed  Portions.  The  Con- 
tractor shall  complete  any  portion  or  portions  of  the  work  in  such  order 
of  time  as  the  Engineer  may  require.  The  Company  shall  have  the 
right  to  take  possession  of  and  use  any  completed  or  partially  com- 
pleted portions  of  the  work,  notwithstanding  the  time  for  completing  the 
entire  work  or  such  portions  may  not  have  expired;  but  such  taking 
possession  and  use  shall  not  be  deemed  an  acceptance  cf  the  work  so 
taken  or  used  or  any  part  thereof.  If  such  prior  use  increases  the  cost 
of  or  delays  the  work,  the  Contractor  will  be  entitled  to  such  extra  com- 
pensation, or  extension  of  time,  as  the  Chief  Engineer  may  determine." 

Mr.  Steffens  : — Between  sections  26  and  27,  it  seems  that  there  should 
be  inserted  an  arbitration  clause.  This  clause  makes  the  Chief  Engineer 
the  sole  judge  of  all  disputes,  whereas  an  arbitration  clause  very  often 
saves  us  from  annoying  lawsuits. 

Mr.  W.  I.  Trench  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  : — I  have  prepared  an  addi- 
tion to  paragraph  27  to  meet  a  condition  I  have  lately  encountered,  the 
case  being  one  in  which  a  Contractor  failed  to  properly  locate  his  plant 
in  the  beginning  and  also  failed  to  remove  it.  in  time  to  avoid  delay 
to  the  work,  and  also  failed  to  remove  portions  of  his  plant  after  com- 
pletion of  parts  of  the  work,  which  seriously  delayed  a  portion  of  the 
work  to  be  done  by  the  Company,  and  to  remedy  this,  I  move  that  an 
addition   be   made   to   paragraph   27   as    follows : 

"The  Contractor  shall  locate  his  plant  only  after  careful  study  of 
the  plans  and  consultation  with  the  Engineer  in  charge,  so  as  not  to 
interfere  with  any  work  to  be  performed  by  the  Company  during  his 
occupation  of  the  premises ;  if  to  facilitate  the  work  temporary  location 
has  been  permitted,  the  Contractor  shall  immediately  upon  demand  of 
the  Engineer  remove  such  plant  or  portion  of  plant  at  his  own  expense. 
If  the  Contractor  fails  to  make  said  removal,  the  Company  may  do  it 
at  his  expense. 

"The  Contractor  shall  remove  the  plant  from  finished  portions  of  the 
work  immediately  on  demand  of  the  Engineer  in  charge.  If  he  shall 
fail  to  make  such  removal,  it  may  be  done  by  the  Company  at  his 
expense." 

(The  above  addition  was  put  to  vote,  but  was  not  adopted.) 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — "28.  Changes.  The  Company  shall  have  the 
right  to  make  any  changes   that  may  be  hereafter   determined  upon,  in 


DISCUSSION.  1071 

the  nature  or  dimensions  of  the  work,  either  before  or  after  its  com- 
mencement, and  such  changes  shall  in  no  way  affect  or  void  this  con- 
tract. If  such  changes  diminish  the  quantity  or  extent  of  the  work  to 
be  done,  they  shall  not,  under  any  circumstances,  be  construed  as  con- 
stituting, and  shall  not  constitute  a  claim  for  damages  or  for  anticipated 
profits  on  such  work. 

"In  case  quantities  in  the  completed  work  vary  from  the  quantities 
shown  on  the  original  plans,  and  provided  for  in  the  specifications,  then 
the  final  payment  shall  be  adjusted  on  the  basis  of  unit  rates  specified 
in  this  contract. 

"Note. — First  paragraph  of  section  28  to  be  used  in  unit  price  and 
force  account  contracts,  i.  e.,  in  all  contracts  not  on  lump-sum  prices. 
Should  be  omitted  in  lump-sum  contracts." 

The  first  paragraph  of  section  28  is  intended  to  be  used  in  unit 
price  contracts,  and  the  second  paragraph  in  lump-sum  contracts. 

Prof.  Allen : — Is  it  not  necessary  to  have  some  provision  that  changes 
shall  not  void  the  contract?  Is  it  not  necessary  that  such  a  provision 
shall  be  inserted,  in  the  case  of  the  lump-sum  contract?  Is  it  not  as 
necessary   in   one   case   as   the   other? 

M'r.  W.  G.  Atwood : — The  Committee  will  consider  the  suggestion 
made  by   Prof.   Allen  in   regard   to   that  clause  and  perhaps   change   it. 

Mr.  Lindsay : — Section  28  provides  for  changes  in  unit  price  and 
force  account  contracts,  and  provides  that  in  contracts  not  on  those 
terms — i.  e.,  lump-sum  contracts — that  the  first  paragraph  should  be 
omitted.  How  does  the  Committee  propose  to  take  care  of  changes  in 
lump-sum   contracts  ? 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — Prof.  Alien's  suggestion  was  in  the  same  line, 
and  the  Committee  said  they  would  revise  that  clause. 

"29.  Extra  Work.  No  bill  or  claim  for  extra  work  or  material  shall 
be  allowed  or  paid  unless  the  doing  of  such  extra  work  or  the  furnish- 
ing of  such  extra  material  shall  have  been  authorized  in  writing  by  the 
Engineer  before  any  part  of  such  work  was  done  or  material  furnished. 

"The  price  for  such  work  shall  be  determined  by  the  Chief  Engineer, 
who  may  either  fix  a  unit  price  or  a  lump-sum  price,  or  may,  if  he  so 
elects,  provide  that  the  price  shall  be  determined  by  the  actual  cost,   to 

which  shall  be  added   per  cent,  to  cover  general   expense 

and  superintendence,  profits,  contingencies,  use  of  tools,  Contractor's  risk 
and  liability.  If  the  Contractor  shall  perform  any  work  or  furnish  any 
material,  which  is  not  provided  for  in  this  contract,  or  which  was  not 
authorized  in  writing  by  the  Engineer  previous  to  the  doing  of  the  work 
or  the  furnishing  of  material,  said  Contractor  shall  receive  no  compensa- 
tion for  such  work  or  material  so  furnished,  and  does  hereby  release  and 
discharge  the  company  from  any  payment  therefor. 

"If  the  Contractor  shall  proceed  with  such  extra  work  or  the  fur- 
nishing of  such  extra  material  after  receiving  the  written  authority  there- 
for, as  hereinbefore  provided,  then  such  work  or  material,  stated  in  the 
written   authority  of  the   Engineer,   shall   be   covered,  governed  and   con- 


1072  CONTRACT    FORMS. 

trolled  by  all  the  terms  and  provisions  of  this  contract,  subject  to  such 
prices  as   may  be   agreed  upon  or  fixed   by  the   Chief   Engineer. 

''If  the  Contractor  shall  decline  or  fail  to  perforin  such  work  or 
furnish  such  extra  material  as  authorized  by  the  Engineer  in  writing, 
as  aforesaid,  the  Company  may  then  arrange  for  the  performance  of 
the  work  in  any  manner  it  may  see  fit,  the  same  as  if  this  contract  had 
not  been  executed,  and  the  Contractor  shall  not  interfere  with  such  per- 
formance of  the  work." 

Mr.  Greiner: — It  seems  to  me  that  the  last  part  of  the  second  para- 
graph of  section  29  is  rather  hard  on  the  Contractor.  Conditions  may 
arise  where  the  Contractor  is  compelled  to  do  some  work  not  covered 
in  the  contract,  in  order  to  protect  his  work,  or  something  that  has  not 
been  anticipated,  and  it  may  be  necessary  to  do  that  at  a  time  in  advance 
of  notice  from  the  Engineer,  and  as  this  paragraph  reads  he  would  get 
no  pay  for  it  at  all.  It  seems  to  me  that  this  part  of  the  paragraph 
should  be  worded  just  a  little  differently,  so  that  if  you  have  a  condi- 
tion like  that,   there  would  not  be  any  injustice  done. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — The  Committee  has  felt  that  it  is  necessary  to 
draw  this  contract  as  rigidly  as  it  is  drawn.  The  Engineer  is  an 
arbitrator  and  he  is  supposed  to  be  fair  to  both  parties.  The  final  de- 
termination in  any  case  would  go  to  the  courts  if  there  was  a  disagree- 
ment, and  we  feel  we  have  covered  this  matter  of  extra  work  as  fairly 
to  both  parties  as  it  is  possible  to  do  it  and  protect  both  parties.  An  unfair 
Engineer  can,  of  course,  by  the  enforcement  arbitrarily  of  certain  clauses 
of  a  contract  work  great  hardships,  but  I  do  not  believe  it  is  possible  to 
draw  a  contract,  if  there  is  unfairness  on  either  side  that  will  prevent 
an  appeal  to  the  courts. 

Mr.  Greiner : — The  Engineer  will  have  no  authority  at  all  on  this 
point.  If  the  Contractor  should  perform  any  work,  or  furnish  any  ma- 
terial, which  was  not  provided  for  in  the  contract,  or  authorized  in 
writing  by  the  Engineer,  previous  to  the  doing  of  the  work,  or  the 
furnishing  of  the  material,  the  Contractor  would  receive  no  compensation 
for  such  work  or  material. 

The  point  I  am  trying  to  make  is  that  if  the  Contractor  should  do 
work  not  called  for  in  the  contract,  that  he  be  paid  for  it,  provided  the 
Engineer  shall  see  fit  to  authorize  it  in  writing,  even  after  it  is  started. 
According  to  the  language  used  in  this  section,  the  Engineer  has  no 
right  to  authorize  it,  after  the  work  is  started,  even  if  it  is  absolutely 
necessary. 

Mr.  Jenkins : — I  think  the  clause  as  it  stands  deters  the  Contractor 
in  some  cases  from  doing  necessary  extra  work  in  the  absence  of  the 
Engineer,  because  he  might  be  afraid  he  would  not  get  the  proper  authori- 
zation, even  after  the  work  is  done,  and  might  be  afraid  that  authoriza- 
tion, if  issued,  would  not  enable  him  to  collect  any  money. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  (Chicago  Great  Western)  : — I  think  Mr.  Greiner's 
point  can  be  covered  if  we  leave  out  the  words  "previous  to  the  doing  of 
the  work  or  the  furnishing  of  material." 


DISCUSSION.  1073 

Mr.  Lindsay: — In  the  first  paragraph,  page  51,  in  line  with  the  sug- 
gestion of  Mr.  Fritch,  it  would  be  necessary  to  eliminate  the  words  "after 
receiving  the   written  authority  therefor." 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — The  Committee  will  accept  the  amendment. 

Mr.  G.  D.  Swingly  (Baltimore  &  Ohio)  :— The  article  reads,  "Will, 
however,  pay  the  Contractor  for  expense  of  men  and  teams  necessarily 
retained  during  the  interval  of  suspension."  I  would  like  to  know  when 
it  would  be  considered  that  they  were  necessarily  retained.  It  seems  to 
me  there  might  be  some  time  fixed  after  which  they  will  not  be  paid.  That 
might  go  on  for  a  long  time  and  might  amount  to  quite  an  item  of  ex- 
pense. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood: — I  think  that  is  covered  by  the  statement,  "pro- 
vided the  Contractor  can  show  that  it  was  not  reasonably  practicable  to 
move  these  men  and  teams  to  other  points  at  which  they  can  be  engaged.'' 
The  Committee  feels  that  if  the  Company  stops  the  work  temporarily  and 
forces  the  Contractor  to  hold  his  men  and  equipment  on  the  work,  that 
he  ought  to  be  paid  for  it.  In  cases  where  the  Contractor  cannot  use 
them  on  other  portions  of  the  work,  he  is  entitled  to  payment  until  such 
time  as  the  Company  either  annuls  the  contract,  or  allows  the  Contractor 
to  proceed  with  the  work. 

Mr.  Lindsay: — I  would  like  to  ask  if  it  is  necessary  to  put  in  the 
words  "in  sections,"  near  the  bottom  of  paragraph  32?  Would  it  not  be- 
better  to  read,   "as  provided  in  this  contract"  ? 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin: — This  clause,  as  drawn,  leaves  latitude  for  a  great 
deal  of  dispute  between  the  Contractor  and  the  Engineer  as  to  the  value 
or  amount  of  the  time  that  is  lost.  We  have  made  it  a  practice  to  name 
the  price  per  day  that  should  be  charged  for  teams  under  those  circum- 
stances, and  require  the  Contractor  to  make  it  part  of  his  contract,  and 
likewise  specify  that  payment  would  be  for  men  on  monthly  time  only. 
This  precludes  the  Contractor  from   bringing  in  an   excessive  claim. 

The  President :— Mr.   Swingly,  do  you  wish  to  say  anything  further? 

Mr.  Swingly : — It  is  also  my  idea  that  the  Contractor  should  be  paid 
for  teams  which  are  necessarily  idle  on  account  of  temporary  stoppage 
of  the  work;  but  it  seems  to  me  that  we  might  name  a  time  limit,  be- 
cause it  might  be  necessary  to  hold  up  the  work  for  a  considerable  period 
of  time  and  give  the  Contractor  a  very  good  chance  to  keep  his  men  and 
teams  there  at  our  expense,  and  if  he  did  not  have  other  contracts  it 
might  be  more  profitable  for  him  to  keep  his  men  and  teams  there  and 
not  try  to  get  them  away. 

Mr.  A.  S.  Baldwin :— We  cover  that  by  naming  a  price  that  barely 
more  than  lets  the  Contractor  out,  with  both  men  and  teams.  The  result 
is  he  is  after  the  Engineer  to  get  started  just  as  much  as  the  Engineer  is 
desirous  that  the  Contractor  get  started. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — "30.  Property  and  Right  of  Entry.  The  Com- 
pany shall  provide  the  lands  upon  which  the  work  under  this  contract 
is  to  be  done,  except  that  the  Contractor  shall  provide  land  required  for 
the  erection  of  temporary  construction  facilities  and  storage  of  his  ma- 
terial, together  with  right  of  access  to  the  same. 


1074  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

"The  Contractor  shall  not  enter  upon  said  lands,  nor  ship  any  ma- 
terial or  equipment,  until  he  has  received  written  notice  from  the  Engineer 
that  he  may  proceed  with  said  work  or  any  part  thereof. 

"31.  Unavoidable  Delays ;  Extension  of  Time  on  Parts  of  Work. 
If  the  Contractor  shall  be  delayed  in  the  performance  of  the  work  from 
any  cause,  for  which  the  Company  is  responsible,  he  shall,  upon  written 
application  to  the  Chief  Engineer  at  the  time  of  such  delay,  be  granted 
such  extension  of  time  as  the  Chief  Engineer  shall  deem  equitable  and 
just. 

"32.  Suspension  of  Work.  The  Company  may  at  any  time  stop  the 
work,  or  any  part  thereof,  by  giving  ten  (10)  days'  notice  to  the  Con- 
tractor in  writing.  The  work  shall  be  resumed  by  the  Contractor  in  ten 
(10)  days  after  the  date  fixed  in  the  written  notice  from  the  Company 
to  the  Contractor  so  to  do.  The  Company  shall  not  be  held  liable  for 
any  damages  or  anticipated  profits  on  account  of  the  work  being  stopped,  or 
for  any  work  done  during  the  interval  of  suspension.  It  will,  however,  pay 
the  Contractor  for  expense  of  men  and  teams  necessarily  retained  during 
the  interval  of  suspension,  provided  the  Contractor  can  show  that  it  was 
not  reasonably  practicable  to  move  these  men  and  teams  to  other  points 
at  which  they  can  be  engaged.  The  Company  will  further  pay  the  Con- 
tractor  for   time   necessarily   lost   during   such   suspension   at   the   rate   of 

per  cent,  per  annum  on  the  estimated  value  of  all  equipment 

and  fixtures  owned  by  the  Contractor  and  employed  on  the  work  which 

are  necessarily  idle  during  such  suspension,  said  rate  of   per 

cent,  per  annum  being  understood  to  include  depreciation,  interest  and 
insurance.  But  if  the  work,  or  any  part  thereof,  shall  be  stopped  by  the 
notice  in  writing  aforesaid,  and  if  the  Company  does  not  give  notice  in 

writing  to  the  Contractor  to  resume  work  at  a  date  within  

of  the  date  fixed  in  the  written  notice  to  suspend,  then  the 

Contractor  may  abandon  that  portion  of  the  work  to  suspend  and  he  will 
be  entitled  to  the  estimates  and  payments  for  such  work  so  abandoned, 
as  provided  in  Sections    of  this  contract. 

"33-  Annulment,  Contractor's  Fault.  Discussed,  but  not  acted  upon 
by  the  Committee. 

"34.  Annulment,  Without  Fault  of  Contractor.  Discussed,  but  not 
acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 

"35.  Removal  of  Equipment  in  Case  of  Annulment.  Discussed,  but 
not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee. 

"36.  Measurement  and  Approval  of  Work.  Discussed,  but  not  acted 
upon  by  the  Committee. 

"2,7-  Monthly  Estimate.  So  long  as  the  work  herein  contracted  for 
is  prosecuted  in  accordance  with  the  provisions  of  this  contract,  and  with 
such  progress  as  may  be  satisfactory  to  the  Chief  Engineer,  the  said  Chief 
Engineer  will,  on  or  about  the  first  day  of  each  month,  make  an  approxi- 
mate estimate  of  the  proportionate  value  of  the  work  done  and  of  ma- 
terial furnished  or  delivered  upon  the  Company's  property  at  the  site  of 
the  work,  up  to  and  including  the  last  day  of  the  previous  month.  The 
amount  of  said  estimate,  after  deducting   per  cent,  and  all 


DISCUSSION.  1075 

previous  payments,  shall  be  due  and  payable  to  the  Contractor  at  the  office 
of  the  Treasurer  of  the  Company  on  or  about  the  20th  day  of  the  current 
month. 

Mr.  E.  A.  Frink  (Seaboard  Air  Line)  :— In  our  work,  we  have  found 
it  saves  a  good  deal  of  trouble  if  we  require  the  Contractor,  before  the 
first  monthly  payment,  to  file  with  us  a  schedule  of  prices  for  material 
on  specified  price  contracts  and  labor  and  material  on  lump-sum  contracts. 
Then,  in  making  up  the  estimates  the  inspector  on  the  ground  makes  up 
an  estimate  of  the  work  done,  makes  up  a  regular  form  showing  his 
estimate.  That  is  examined  by  the  Contractor,  or  the  Contractor's  fore- 
man, and  if  it  is  satisfactory,  it  is  signed  by  both  parties  and  sent  to  the 
home  office  for  payment.  In  that  way  we  avoid  all  discussion  with  the 
Contractor  about  whether  he  has  or  has  not  been  allowed  as  much  as  he 
ought  to  be  allowed. 

Mr.  Berry : — I  would  like  to  ask  the  Committee  whether  the  mem- 
bers have  consulted  with  their  law  departments  in  regard  to  the  bond  and 
contracts. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — The  New  York  Central  Lines'  members  of  the 
Committee  have,  and  we  have  found  that  in  various  States  that  various 
roads'  law  departments  disagree  about  the  same  thing.  There  are  un- 
doubtedly things  in  this  contract  which  some  law  departments  will  not 
approve  and  will  change,  but  I  do  not  believe  it  possible  to  draw  a  gen- 
eral contract  of  this  kind  that  will  satisfy  all  law  departments.  We  think 
that  the  provisions  we  have  put  in  this  form  are  legal,  and  they  have  been 
gone  over  with  some  lawyers. 

Mr.  Berry : — 'The  membership  on  this  Committee  is  scattered  through- 
out the  country,  and  it  seems  to  me  that  the  law  departments  of  the  com- 
panies with  which  these  members  are  associated  should  be  consulted  in 
regard  to  the  matter.  It  is  'skating  on  pretty  thin  ice  nowadays  unless 
they  are  consulted  in  advance  and  know  all  about  it ;  they  are  a  party 
to  it  and  have  got  to  defend  it.  Our  department  always  consults  them 
in  matters  of  that  kind.  Not  only  that,  but  my  superior  officers  ask 
whether  I  have  asked  the  law  department.  I  would  not  like  to  vote,  and 
1  think  a  good  many  members  would  not  like  to  vote  until  they  knew 
the  law  department  had  approved  the  bond  and  contract. 

Mr.  E.  H.  Lee  (Chicago  &  Western  Indiana)  : — In  reference  to  Mr. 
Berry's  remarks,  it  was  the  aim  of  the  Committee,  in  preparing  this  form, 
to  cover  the  -general  conditions.  The  Committee  realizes  that  it  is  a 
matter  of  impossibility  to  prepare  any  general  form  which  will  receive 
the  approval  of  the  legal  departments  of  all  the  roads.  In  fact,  the  speaker 
knows  of  one  case  within  the  last  year  or  two,  where  the  legal  repre- 
sentatives of  four  or  five  separate  Chicago  roads  were  asked  for  an  opin- 
ion on  identically  the  same  proposition,  where  there  were  as  many  differ- 
ent opinions  rendered.  The  Committee,  therefore,  feels  that  the  form 
should  be  taken  as  subject  at  all  times  to  the  approval  of  the  legal  de- 
partment of  any  Company  that  uses  it. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  : — I  think  the  Committee  is  to  be  congratulated  on 
the  excellent  form  of  the  contracts  which  they  have  given  us,  especially 


1076  CONTRACT   FORMS. 

the  short  form,  and  for  more  extensive  work  the  long  form ;  but  I  be- 
lieve with  Mr.  Berry,  that  before  we  vote  on  the  adoption  of  this,  it 
ought  to  be  referred  back  for  a  legal  opinion.  There  are  five  clauses 
which  were  discussed,  but  not  acted  upon  by  the  Committee.  It  seems 
to  me  it  would  be  proper  to  receive  this  report  as  information  and  have 
the  Committee  report  finally  next  year.  In  the  meantime  many  of  us 
can  use  this  form,  but  we  should  get  a  final  report  on  it  for  next  year. 

Mr.  Berry : — In  the  absence  of  the  lawyers,  I  think  I  will  have  to 
defend  them.  One  of  the  members  of  the  Committee  and  I  have  been  on 
an  Engineers'  Committee.  I  found  that  no  two  Engineers  agreed.  How- 
ever, these  same  Engineers  got  together  and  agreed  upon  a  contract  and 
the  work  is  going  forward.  I  believe  the  lawyers  will  finally  agree  upon 
a  form. 

Mr.  R.  G.  Kenly  (Minneapolis  &  St.  Louis)  : — I  agree  with  the 
proposition  made  by  Mr.  Fritch,  that  these  contract  forms  be  referred 
back  to  the  Committee,  that  we  formulate  the  specifications,  have  them 
printed,  send  them  in  the  form  of  a  circular  letter  to  every  railroad  repre- 
sented in  this  Association,  and  ask  them  to  reply  with  an  opinion  of  their 
legal  department  as  to  the  phraseology  and  legal  terms  of  the  specifica- 
tions. Then  let  the  Committee  tabulate  them  and  report  to  the  Associa- 
tion with  at  least  a  statement  of  the  majority  of  the  opinions  of  the 
various  legal  departments. 

Mr.  Curtis  Dougherty  (Cincinnati,  New  Orleans  &  Texas  Pa- 
cific) : — If  not  out  of  order,  I  would  like  to  ask  the  Committee  if  they 
considered  any  provision  to  cover  the  case  where  the  Contractor  becomes 
insolvent  and  unable  to  carry  the  work  forward,  and  the  work  has  to  be 
undertaken  by  the  Company. 

Mr.  W.  G.  Atwood : — I  would  say  that  that  is  covered,  or  will  be 
covered  in  one  of  the  clauses  which  the  Committee  have  been  consider- 
ing for  annulment ;  this  is  one  of  the  clauses  which  we  are  considering 
but  are  not  ready  to  submit.  Among  the  reasons  given  for  annulment  of 
the  contract  by  the  Company  is  on  account  of  the  work  not  progressing 
with  reasonable  speed  and  the  inability  of  the  Contractor  to  meet  his 
financial  obligations. 

Mr.  L.  C.  Fritch  : — I  move  that  the  report  of  the  Committee  be  re- 
ceived as  information  and  be  referred  back  to  the  Committee  for  final 
report  next  year. 

(The  motion  was  seconded  and  carried.) 

Mr.  Jenkins: — I  move  that  the  Association  thank  the  Committee  for 
its  good  work. 

(The  motion  was  seconded.) 

Mr.  Kenly: — I  would  like  to  amend  that  to  cover  the  <  ctive  mem- 
bers of  the  Committee,  and  you  will  have  to  read  the  names  of  those  at- 
tending the  various  meetings  to  find  out  who  were  the  active  members. 

(The  motion  was  carried.) 

The  President: — The  Committee  will  be  dismissed  with  the  thanks 
of  the  Association. 


AMENDMENTS. 


AMENDMENTS   TO   COMMITTEE   REPORTS. 

REFERENCE  TO  AMENDMENTS   MADE  TO  COMMITTEE  REPORTS   AT  THE  THIRTEENTH 

ANNUAL    CONVENTION. 

RULES  AND  ORGANIZATION. 

(For  Report,  see  "p.   65-68;  discussion,  pp.  919-931.) 

Amend  clause    (6)    to   read  as   follows : 

"(6)  After  ballast  is  distributed  and  the  track  lifted,  the  track 
should  be  lined  and  surfaced  and  the  ballast  trimmed  to  conform  to 
standard  plans." 

Amend  clause   (7)   to  read  as  follows : 

"(7)  Where  track  is  electrically  bonded,  ballast  must  be  kept  at 
least  one  inch  below  the  base  of  rail.  At  road  crossings,  platforms,  etc., 
where  this  is  not  practicable,  only  clean  gravel  or  rock  ballast  shall  be 
used." 

Amend  clause   (10)   to  read  as  follows: 

"(10)     The   renewal   of  ties    shall   be   started   when   directed  by  the 

...\... When  ties  are  being  renewed,  the  line  and  surface 

shall  be  corrected,  unsuitable  material  removed   and  ballast  trimmed." 

Amend  clause  (12)   to  read  as  follows: 

"(12)     The shall  frequently  inspect  ties  removed 

from  track  to  see  if  any  of  them  have  been  removed  which  might  have 
remained   in   the  track  with   safety  until  the  next  inspection." 

Amend  clause   (14)   to  read  as  follows: 

"(14)  Ties  must  be  laid  so  as  to  obtain  the  best  bearing.  The 
largest  and  best  ties  shall  be  selected  for  use  at  joints.  Twisted  or 
badly  hewn  ties  must  not  be  notched,  but  the  bearing  must  be  made  true 
with  the  adze." 

Amend   clause    (17)    to   read   as   follows: 

"(17)  The  bottom  of  the  new  rail  and  the  bearing  surface  of  the 
tie  shall  be  cleaned  before  the  rail  is  laid." 

Amend  clause  (18)  by  adding  thereto,  at  the  end,  the  words,  "if 
necessary." 

Amend  clause  (20)  and  (22)  by  substituting  the  term  "compromise 
splices"  for  the  terms  "step  chairs"  and  "offset  splices." 

Amend  clause    (22)    further  by   striking  out  the  last   sentence. 

Amend  clause  (25)  to  read  as  follows : 

"(25)  Rails  for  curves  of  4  degrees  and  over  should  be  curved 
before  being  laid.  In  curving  or  straightening  rails,  a  rail  bender  must 
be  used." 

1079 


1080  AMENDMENTS  TO  COMMITTEE  REPORTS. 

Amend  clause    (26)    to  read  as   follows: 

"(26)  When  picking  up  joints  or  other  low  places,  the  general  level 
of  the  track  must  not  be  disturbed." 

IRON  AND  STEEL  STRUCTURES. 

CFcr  Report,   see   pp.    81-88;    discussion,    pp.    934-945.) 

Amend  the  "Specifications  for  Erection  of  .Steel  Railway  Bridges"  by 
emitting  clauses  20  and  21,  and  renumbering  clause  22  to  read  No.  20. 

BALLAST. 
(For  Report,   see  pp.  95-300;   discussion,   pp.   949.   950.) 

Add  to  conclusion  on  page  97,  regarding  depth  of  ballast,  the  words 
"gravel  or,"  at  the  end  of  the  fourth  line. 

TRACK. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.  37T-3S6;  discussion,   pp.   965-9S0.) 

Amend  conclusion  3  on  page  374  to  read  as  follows : 
"(3)     That    for    all    new    work,    the    Committee's    recommendations 
as  to  lengths  of  switches   and   numbers  of  frogs  be  adopted." 

Amend  clause  relating  to  "Stops  and  Hold-downs,"  at  top  of  page 
379,  to  read  "spring  rail,"  in  the  first  line,  instead  of  "wing  rail." 

Amend  Table  I,  page  381,  third  line,  under  A.  B.,  to  read  "7  ft."  in- 
stead of  "5  ft." 

WATER  SERVICE. 

(For  Report,  see  pp.   401-428;   discussion,  pp.   983-988.) 

Amend  by  changing  title  of  Specifications,  on  page  417.  to  read  as 
follows :     "General  Specifications  for  Steel  Water  and  Oil  Tanks." 

Amend  clauses  1  and  2  to  read  as  follows : 

"1.  Scope  of  Specifications.  These  specifications  are  intended  for 
steel  tanks   requiring  plates   not  more  than  -Hs   i"-  thick." 

Change  the  numbers  of  the  succeeding  clauses,  in  consequence  of 
consolidating  clauses  1  and  2. 

Amend  the  fourth  paragraph  of  clause  3,  page  418,  to  read  as  follows : 

"2.  Quality  of  Metal.  The  metal  in  these  tanks  shall  be  open-hearth 
steel.  The  steel  shall  conform  in  physical  and  chemical  properties  to  the 
specifications  of  this  Association  for  steel  bridges." 

Amend  clause  13,  page  419,  to  read  as  follows : 

"12.  Tank  Support.  If  the  tank  is  supported  on  a  steel  sub- 
structure, the  latter  shall  conform  to  the  specifications  of  this  Association 
for  the  manufacture  and  erection  of  steel  bridges,  except  that  allowance 
shall  be  made  for  wind  pressure,  but  not  for  impact." 

ELECTRICITY. 
(For   Report,    see   *y\    509-558;    discussion,    pp.    998-1016.) 

Amend  clause  10  of  the  Specifications  for  Overhead  Crossings  of 
Electric  Light  and  Power  Lines,  page  512,  to  read  as  follows : 


AMENDMENTS  TO  COMMITTEE  REPORTS.  1081 

Substitute  the  word  "possible,"  in  the  third  line,  for  the  word  "prac- 
ticable." 

Amend  clause  13,  page  513,  by  omitting  the  second  line  in  the  table, 
reading,  "Exceeding  10,000  volts,  etc." 

Amend  clause  24,  page  514,  by  omitting  the  words  "if  such  notifica- 
tion is  not  given,  the  company  crossed  shall  be  furnished  with  certified 
reports  of  shop  inspection  of  material  and  workmanship  made  by  a 
properly  qualified   inspector." 

Amend  clause  29,  pp.  514  and  515,  to  read  as  follows: 

"29.  Insulators,  pins  and  conductor  attachments  shall  be  designed 
to  withstand,  with  the  designated  factor  of  safety,  the  tension  in  the 
conductors   under  the  maximum   loading." 

Amend  clause  31,  by  omitting  the  words  "the  most  unfavorable 
condition,"  on  the  first  and  second  lines. 

Amend  clause  32,  page  515,  to  read  as  follows: 

"32.  Crossarms  shall  be  designed  to  withstand  the  loading  specified 
in  paragraph  30,  combined  with  the  unbalanced  tension  of  the  one  wire 
broken  at  the  pin  furthest  from  the  pole." 

Amend  clause  34,  page  515,  to   read  as   follows: 

"34.  The  ultimate  unit  stress  divided  by  the  allowable  unit  stress 
shall  be  not  less  than  the  following,  etc." 

Amend  the  "Note"  to  read :  "The  use  of  treated  wooden  poles  and 
crossarms   is   recommended,"   etc. 

Amend  clause  45,  page  517,  by  omitting  the  last  sentence,  beginning 
with  the  word  "Pins." 

Amend  clause  49,  page  517,  by  omitting  the  words,  "of  approved 
species,"  in  the  first  and  second  lines. 

Amend  clause  51,  page  517,  by  omitting  the  words,  "open-hearth," 
in  the  first  line. 

Amend  clause  55,  page  517,  by  changing  the  figures  "150,"  on  the 
first  line,  to  read  "180,"  and  the  figures  "180,"  on  the  last  line,  to  read 
"220." 

Amend  clause  60,  on  page  518,  by  adding  the  following  clause  in 
the  second  line,  after  the  word  "earth  (calculated  at  30  degrees  from  the 
vertical)." 

Amend  clause  61,  page  518,  to  read  as  follows: 

"61.  The  top  of  the  concrete  foundation,  or  casing,  shall  be  not 
less  than  6  in.  above  the  surface  of  the  ground,  nor  less  than  1  ft.  above 
extreme  high  water." 

RAIL. 
(For  Report,    see  pp.    559-862;    discussion,   pp.    1017-1038.) 

Amend  clause  29,  page  570,  to  read  as  follows : 

"29.  Payment.  Rails  accepted  will  be  paid  for  according  to  actual 
weights." 

WOOD  PRESERVATION. 
(For   Report,    see   pp.    863-872;  discussion,    pp.     1039-1051.) 

Amend  clause  (3),  page  864,  by  substituting  the  word  "beech"  for 
the  word  "beeches,"  in  the  second  line ;  also,  by  substituting  the  word 
"heartwood"  for  the  word   "hardwood." 


1082  AMENDMENTS  TO  COMMITTEE  REPORTS. 

Amend  the  "Specifications  for  Creosote  Oil,"  on  pp.  865-6,  as  fol- 
lows :  Transpose  the  words  "including  coal  gas  tar  or  coke  oven  tar,*' 
in  the  fourth  line  of  the  three  specifications  to  follow  the  word  "tar,"  in 
the  third  line  of  each  specification. 

BUILDINGS. 
(if or  Report,   see  pp.   885-899;   discussion,  p.  1054.) 

Amend  diagram  on  page  863,  Fig.  4,  top  line,  to  read  "Side  Flash- 
ing," instead  of  "Head  Flashing."  Also,  change  heading  on  Fig.  2-10 
to  read  "Continuous  Head  Flashing"  instead  of  "Continuous  Foot  Flashy 
'trig." 

UNIFORM  GENERAL  CONTRACT  FORMS. 

(For  Report,   see  po.   907-916;    discussion,    pp.    1059-1076.) 

Amend  clause  29,  pp.  914-5,  by  omitting  the  words  "previous  to  the 
doing  of  the  work  or  the  furnishing  of  material,"  in  the  eighth  line  of 
the  second  paragraph,  and  the  words  "after  receiving  the  written  authority 
therefor,"  in  the  second  line  of  the  third  paragraph. 


MONOGRAPHS. 


THE  DESIGN  OF  RAILWAY  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

(Bulletin   140.) 

By  J.    H.    Prior,   Assistant  Engineer,    Engineering   Department   Chicago, 
Milwaukee   &    St.    Paul    Railway. 

INTRODUCTORY. 

Approximations  from  available  statistics  show  that  some  $60,000,000 
are  at  present  invested  in  bridge  abutments,  and  as  this  figure  is  being 
increased  each  year  by  the  value  of  new  work,  these  structures  can  be 
said  to  have  an  importance  which  warrants  a  fairly  extended  examination 
of  the  present  art  of  their  design. 

The  following  paper  gives  the  result  of  an  investigation  ordered 
by  Mr.  C.  F.  Loweth,  Chief  Engineer  of  the  Chicago,  Milwaukee  &  St. 
Paul  Railway,  and  made  by  the  writer. 

A  railway  bridge  abutment  is  ordinarily  a  masonry  structure,  such 
as  is  shown  in  Fig.  1,  which  gives  vertical  support  to  one  end  of  a 
steel  span  and  gives  whatever  lateral  support  to  the  embankment  "A," 
adjoining,  is  necessary  to  prevent  the  embankment  from  slipping  into 
the  stream. 


IHSiHH^HH^HHi 

♦•.      -  -Iff    ^       ■ 

^^H  IMIIIl) 

^■■■B?  Z^tk 

'"^H.itfcrf  ^$1                           *W*~mW"19l**\WPl!*'~'  " 

*>'  ■■  "fc^  *  *' ' 

Fig.    1 — Plain   Concrete   Wing   Abutment,   Type   B:! 
1085 


1086 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


The  most  common  type,  Fig.  i,  has  a  cross-section  similar  to  that 
shown  in  Fig.  2,  in  which  "a"  is  the  bridge  seat,  consisting  of  a  horizontal 
surface  carrying  the  steel  span ;  "b"  is  the  back  wall  which  supports  the 
embankment  and  prevents  its  spilling  forward  on  the  bridge  seat;  the 
base  "e"  of  the  back  wall  "b"  being  made  of  such  width  as  will  make  the 
back  wall  stable  against  overturning  on  account  of  the  lateral  pressure 
"R-i"  of  the  earth;  "c"  is  the  main  body  of  the  neatwork,  and  must 
have  sufficient  base  "f"  so  that  it  will  also  be  stable  against  overturning 
from  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork  "R-2 ;"  "d"  is  the  footing, 
which  must  have  a  base  "g"  large  enough  to  carry  all  the  vertical  loads, 
and  offset  "h"  large  enough  to  keep  the  pressure  at  the  toe  of  the  footing 
"R-3"  within  the  allowable  limit. 


Fig.  2 


Plan 

Wincj  Abutment 

Fig.  5 


The  three  principal  types  of  abutments  are  the  wing  abutment,  Fig. 
3 ;  U  abutment,  Fig.  4 ;  and  T  abutment,  Fig.  5.  These  three  types,  which 
are  the  oldest  as  well  as  the  most  important,  were  developed  when  stone 
masonry  was  the  only  material  available  to  the  designer. 

In  the  wing  abutment,  Fig.  3  and  Fig.  1,  the  span  is  supported  on 
the  bridge  seat  '"a,"  and  the  wings  "b"  keep  the  embankment  from  slip- 
ping into  the  stream.  In  the  U  abutment,  Fig.  4  and  Fig.  6,  the  span  is 
supported  on  the  bridge  seat  "a,"  and  the  wings  "b"  are  made  parallel 
to  the  track,  thus  giving  the  lateral  support  to  the  embankment  which  is 
required  to  extend  the  embankment  to  the  bridge  seat.  In  the  T  abut- 
ment, Fig.  5,  the  span  is  carried  on  the  bridge  seat  "a"  and  the  floor  is 
supported  directly  back  of  the  bridge  seat  by  the  stem  "b"  of  the  abut- 
ment, which  carries  the  track  back  to  a  point  where  the  embankment  is 
of  sufficient  height  to  support  it. 

Some  of  these  older  types,  which  were  best  adapted  to  stone,  masonry, 
have  exerted  considerable  influence  in  later  designs  executed  in  the  newer 
materials  of  plain  concrete  and  reinforced  concrete,  often  in  situations 
where  the  old  design  was  poorly  adapted  to  the  newer  material. 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1087 


ABUTMENTS    BUILT    OF    STONE    MASONRY. 

The  wing  abutment,  Fig.  3;  U  abutment,  Fig.  4;  and  T  abutment, 
Fig.  5,  are  referred  to  as  type  Ai,  type  A2,  and  type  A3,  respectively, 
when  constructed  of  stone  masonry.  As  railway  structures,  some  of  these 
t)pes  are  rapidly  becoming  obsolete,  but  as  they  are  the  prototypes  of  all 
present  designs  and  exerted  considerable  influence  on  later  designs  exe- 
cuted in  different  material,  they  are  given  some  mention. 


E  le  vat/ on 


Plan 
U-A  butment 


Fis- 


4- 


p — n 


Fa 


£  le  vat  ion 


3- 


Plan 

T-  Abutment 

Fig.  5 


The  wing  abutment  of  stone  masonry,  type  Ai,  is  often  found  to  be 
of  such  a  design  that  the  section  of  the  abutment  along  the  center  line 
of  track  is  about  as  shown  in  Fig.  8.  This  might  have  been  a  creditable 
design  in  the  day  in  which  it  was  made,  but  at  present  it  is  not  much 
of  an  exaggeration  to  say  that  this  cross-section  represents  everything 
that  an  abutment  should  not  be.  The  batter  on  the  front  of  this  abutment 
is  slight,  and  the  bridge  seat  is  thus  set  so  far  forward  over  the  footings 
that  the  resultant  of  the  vertical  loads  and  lateral  pressure  of  the  earth- 
work is  located  so  near  the  front  edge  of  the  footings  that  the  pressure 
on  toe  is  excessive  for  ordinary  foundations.  Without  any  increase  of 
material  in  the  cross-section,  this  cross-section  can  be  revised  to  that 
shown  in  Fig.  9,  with  reduction  in  the  toe  pressure,  as  shown  in  the  figures, 
from  7l/2  tons  to  4.07  tons  per  square  foot,  or  about  45  per  cent  reduction. 
While  the  cross-section  is  not  increased  in  area,  the  change  from  Fig. 
8  to  Fig.  9  is  accompanied  by  a  greater  cost,  on  account  of  the  increase 
in  the  length  of  the  span,  due  to  moving  bearing  from  the  point  P, 
in  Fig.  8,  to  the  point  P-2  in  Fig.  9.  This  would  amount  to  an  increase 
in  the  length  of  the  span  of  5  ft.  and  an  additional  cost  of  $250.00,  which 
is  only  5  per  cent,  additional  cost  for  one  abutment.  Although  this 
increase   in  the  cost   of  the   steelwork   incident  to   changing  the  outline 


1088 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


of  the  cross-section  is  a  small  percentage,  it  probably  accounts  for  the 
nearly  vertical  front  faces  of  the  abutments,  and  the  bridge  seats  located 
near  the  front  of  the  footings  in  the  design  of  many  old  abutments,  which 
can  be  found  in  every  railway  office.  The  cross-section,  Fig.  8,  is  taken 
from  the  details  of  an  abutment  dated  1887. 


Fig.  6 — Stone  Masonry  U  Abutment,  Type  A2. 


The  U  abutments  of  stone  masonry,  type  A2,  Fig.  4  and  Fig.  6,  have 
a  section  as  shown  in  Fig.  10,  which  is  a  cross-section  at  right  angles  to 
track  along  the  line  "dd"  of  Fig.  4.  In  this  abutment  the  side  walls  "a," 
which  retain  the  fill  "f,"  are  usually  built  with  a  base  thickness  "e"  equal 
to  0.4  of  the  height  "h."  For  an  abutment  14  ft.  in  width,  the  backs 
of  the  two  side  walls  "a"  would  intersect  at  the  point  "b"  when  "h" 
was  equal  or  greater  than  17.5  ft.  Thus  an  abutment  built  of  this  design 
would  be  a  solid  mass  of  masonry  below  the  point  "b,"  as  shown  in 
Fig.  10.  For  this  reason  they  show  only  small  economy  over  the  wing  and 
T  abutments  for  heights  from  12  ft.  to  24  ft.,  as  illustrated  in  Fig.  11. 

In  Fig.   11  the  cubic  yards  of  masonry  in  abutments,   exclusive  of 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1089 


footings  and  copings  for  various  heights,  are  platted  as  ordinafes   with 
the  height  from  the  top  of  footing  to  bottom  of  coping  as  abscissas.* 


yggse  of  Pail  ^ 


Fig.O 

Defective  Cross-Section 
Abutment. 


Fig.  9 

Improved  Cross-Section 
Abutment. 


The  small  economy  of  the  neatwork  of  U  abutments,  shown  in  Fig. 
ii,  is  lost  if  the  same  slope  of  embankment  of  ilA  to  i,  which  was  used 
in  determining  the  length  of  the  wing  walls  of  the  wing  abutments,  is 
used  to  determine  the  length  of  the  side  wall  of  the  U  abutment. 

The  T  abutment  of  stone  masonry,  type  A3,  Fig.  5,  has  a  cross-section 
at  right  angles  to  the  track,  as  shown  in  Fig.  12.  It  can  be  seen  from 
Fig.  12  that  the  cross-section  of  the  T  abutment  would  resemble  very 
closely  the  cross-section  of  a  U  abutment  if  the  height  of  the  U  abut- 
ment was  much  greater  than  17.5  ft.,  and  an  examination  of  Fig.  11  will 
show  that  there  is  no  great  difference  in  volumes  or  cost  between  the 
T  abutment  and  the  other  two  types. 

There  was  not  much  uniformity  in  the  design  of  the  stone  abutments, 
and  data  concerning  them  are  scarce  and  meager ;  therefore,  the  curves 
showing  the  volumes  of  these  abutments  in  Fig.  11  can  only  be  considered 
approximate. 


•Volumes    taken    from    old    standards    of    a    western    railway 
shown  in  Baker's  Masonry,  pp.  357-363,  Wiley  &  Sons.     1905. 


company. 


1090 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


e=.4-h 


77777777777777777>, 


\ffl 


Cnos>s    sect/or?  et-ct  at- 
ria h  1~- cznc?  I  e.  s    to  track. 


r/3. 


10 


Fig.li 


3'      IO'      15'    £0'    B5'   50'    35'    40'  45'    50' 
Height  -  top  of 'foot/no  to  bottom  of  coo/r>c7 

F/3  // 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE   ABUTMENTS.  1091 

ABUTMENTS    OF   CONCRETE,    PLAIN    AND    REINFORCED. 

In  addition  to  conforming  to  the  ordinary  laws  of  structural  design, 
there  are  a  number  of  properties  which  have  an  unusual  importance  in  the 
design  of  bridge  abutments. 

Properly  designed  abutments  should  have  the  following  properties, 
which  may  be  called  major  requirements,  because  they  affect  the  integrity 
of  the  structure : 

mi.  The  neatwork  should  be  stable  against  overturning  by  revolving 
on  the  line  k,  Fig.  2,  at  the  intersection  of  the  front  face  of  the  neatwork 
and  footing,  and  should  also  be  safe  against  crushing  on  the  same  line. 

m:.  The  abutments  should  be  stable  against  sliding,  either  by  the 
neatwork  sliding  on  the  footing  or  the  footing  sliding  upon  the  founda- 
tion bed. 

m3.  The  pressure  of  the  toe  of  the  footing  upon  the  foundation 
should  not  be  excessive. 

They  should  have  the  following  properties,  among  others,  which  may 
be  called  minor  requirements : 

ni.     The  abutments  should  protect  the  bank  against  scour. 

n2.  The  abutments  should  prevent  the  embankment  drainage  from 
washing  away  the  shoulder  of  the  bank  adjacent  to  the  back  wall. 

n3.  The  abutments  should  provide  a  joint  which  will  support  the 
track  in  an  easy  and  continuous  manner  from  embankment  to  super- 
structure. 

n4.     The  abutment  should  be  easily  drained. 

As  by  far  the  greater  number  of  abutments  being  built  are  either 
of  plain  or  reinforced  concrete,  the  term  "Design  of  Bridge  Abutments" 
at  present  means  the  design  of  bridge  abutments  in  concrete  masonry. 

All  the  abutments  mentioned  in  the  following,  together  with  the 
three  abutments  mentioned  in  the  foregoing  paragraphs,  have  been  tabu- 
lated in  Appendix  A  for  ease     in  reference. 

In  order  to  compare  the  properties  and  economy  of  the  various  types, 
it  was  necessary  to  assume  the  same  conditions  in  the  design  of  all  types. 
The  more  important  assumptions  which  were  made  for  this  purpose  are 
as  follows : 

(1)  The  height  of  the  abutment  is  the  distance  "H"  of  Fig.  25 
from  the  base  of  rail  to  the  natural  ground. 

(2)  Slope  of  fill  1V2  to  1. 

(3)  Slope  of  the  natural  ground  away  from  stream  or  bridge  opening 
4  to  1. 

Type  Bi. 

The  plain  concrete  masonry  abutment  without  reinforcement  in  the 
back  wall,  type  Bi,  is  shown  in  Fig.  13. 

As  this  abutment  is  designed  without  steel  reinforcement  of  any 
kind,  its  design  is  made  in  a  similar  manner  to  the  wing  abutment  of 
stone  masonry,  type  Ai,  previously  described.     The  cross-section   of  the 


1092 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


Plan 


-Base,  of  Rail 


L.L+EP.  4(>1,000 
E  P.  only  556,00dfo4._ 


Max.  load  pe 
i    pile  <f6  tons 


C~  B  a  se  of  Rail 

r^/qy 4^560  Total 
Inaction 


Section  "A  "on  5ection"B"on  5ection"C" 

S  of  Track.  <£  of  Track. 

Type  3/  Plain    Concrete    Wing   Abutment 
with  Plain     Concrete    Backwcr/I 


Fia.  15 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1093 


abutment,  marked  "section  B  on  center  line  of  track  in  Fig.  13,"  is 
determined  about  as  follows : 

The  distance  "h2,"  from  the  base  of  rail  to  the  top  of  the  bridge 
seat  "a,"'  is  determined  by  the  depth  required  by  the  floor,  girders  and 
bearings  of  the  superstructure ;  and  in  new  work  the  abutment  must 
conform  to  these  dimensions.  The  dimension  "e,"  which  is  the  width 
of  the  back  wall  at  its  base,  is  taken  as  4/10  "h:"  if  the  lateral  pressure  of 
the  earthwork  tending  to  overturn  the  back  wall  is  alone  considered,  or 
it  is  taken  at  5/10  "hi"  if  a  slight  further  provision  is  made  for  the 
overturning  action  of  frost  in  the  bank.  The  width  of  the  bridge  seat 
"m"  is  determined  by  the  width  required  for  the  superstructure  bearings 
plus  whatever  distance  "j"  is  required  to  keep  the  bearings  back  far 
enough  from  the  outer  edge  of  the  bridge  seat  to  prevent  the  outside 
corner  of  the  bridge  seat  from  being  sheared  off  in  a  diagonal  direction. 

The  position  of  the  ground  line  and  the  character  of  the  foundation 
determine  the  distance  "hi"  from  the  base  of  rail  to  top  of  footing.  If 
the  base  of  the  neatwork  "f"  is  made  4/10  of  the  distance  "hi,"  the  neat- 
work  is  stable  against  overturning  or  crushing  on  the  line  "k,"  at  the 
lower  front  edge  of  the  neatwork.  The  dimension  "f"  together  with  the 
width  of  bridge  seat  "m"  and  thickness  of  back  wall  "e"  having  been 
determined,  we  have  the  choice  of  setting  the  bridge  seat  and  back  wall 
vertically  over  the  rear  edge  of  the  footing,  as  shown  in  Fig.  13  and  by  the 
full  lines  in  Fig.  14,  or  we  can  locate  the  bridge  seat  and  back  wall  nearer 
the  front  of  the  footing,  as  shown  by  the  dotted  lines  in  Fig.  14,  and 
thus  decrease  the  length  of  our  superstructure  at  the  expense  of  an 
increased  bearing  on  the  toe  of  the  foundation. 


~, — j- -    -Po5it/or?  (a) 
l     1 


Position    (7) 


Fig.  14 


The  design  of  the  cross-section  entirely  without  reinforcement  leaves 
this  type  with  two  important  defects.  If  the  outline  of  the  neatwork, 
marked  position  1,  and  shown  by  dotted  lines  in  Fig.  14,  gives  excessive 
toe  pressure,  it  is  desirable  to  alter  the  outline  of  the  cross-section  to 
about  that  of  position  2,  shown  by  full  lines  in  Fig.   14.     The  object  in 


1094  DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

changing  the  outline  from  position  i  to  position  2  is  to  move  the  point 
of  application  of  the  forces  "pi"  and  "p2,"  Fig.  13,  toward  the  back  of 
the  footing,  thus  moving  the  resultant  "p5"  also  toward  the  back  of  the 
footing,  and  consequently  decreasing  the  pressure  on  the  front  edge  of 
the  neatwork  and  the  toe  of  the  foundation.  But  in  an  abutment,  in  which 
the  back  wall  contains  no  reinforcement,  these  forces  cannot  be  moved 
toward  the  back  of  the  footing  by  any  great  amount  on  account  of  the 
large  width  "e"  of  the  base  of  the  back  wall,  which  is  made  from  .4 
to  .5  of  "h2." 

Fig.  15  shows  an  abutment,  type  B2,  of  the  same  height  as  the  abut- 
ment, type  Bi,  Fig.  13,  except  that  the  back  wall  "lb"  is  reinforced  against 
overturning  by  some  }i  in.  by  14  ft.  bars.  The  addition  of  these  bars 
permits  the  base  "e"  of  the  back  wall  "b"  to  be  made  2  ft.  5  in.  in  width 
instead  of  4  ft.  10  in.  in  width  in  type  Bi.  This  decreased  width  of 
back  wall  base  permits  the  point  of  application  of  the  resultant  of  the  loads 
"pi"  and  "p2"  to  be  moved  an  average  distance  of  6  in.  toward  the  back  of 
the  footings,  by  this  means  decreasing  the  pressure  on  the  toe  of  the 
footings  from  3.7  tons  to  3.2  tons  pressure  on  natural  foundation,  at  no 
additional  cost  in  the  abutment,  and  at  an  additional  cost  of  only  $100 
in  the  superstructure. 

The  other  defect  is  due  to  the  absence  of  bars  in  the  foundation  of 
type  Bi  and  is  shown  by  a  comparison  of  the  cross-section  of  the  abut- 
ment marked  "Section  B  on  center  line  of  track"  in  Fig.  13,  with  the 
section  "C"  in  the  same  figure. 

In  Section  "B"  the  maximum  load  comes  on  the  piles  located  nearest 
to  the  toe  of  the  footing.  The  load  on  each  pile  is  determined  by  the 
total  number  of  piles  and  by  their  location  with  reference  to  the  resultant 
of  all  the  loads  on  the  abutment,  marked  "p5"  in  Fig.  13.  If  foundation 
conditions  were  encountered  which  made  it  desirable  to  decrease  the 
maximum  bearing  on  piles  of  26  tons  in  Section  "B,"  or  to  decrease  the 
total  number  of  piles  without  increasing  their  loading,  it  could  be  ac- 
complished by  moving  some  of  the  piles,  marked  "q"  m  Section  "B," 
forward  to  about  the  position  shown  on  Section  "C,"  thus  increasing 
the  projection  of  the  footing  beyond  the  neatwork  from  1  foot  in  Section 
"B"  to  2  feet  in  Section  "C."  To  reinforce  the  cantilever  beam  "s-t" 
against  bending,  some  bars  must  be  placed  at  the  bottom  of  the  footing, 
crossing  the  section  of  maximum  moment  "r-s ;"  but  if  it  is  required 
to  build  the  entire  abutment  without  reinforcement,  these  bars  cannot  be 
used,  and  instead  the  neatwork  must  be  increased  by  changing  the  face 
of  the  neatwork  from  the  line  "s-u''  to  the  line  "v-w,"  thereby  increasing 
the  volume  of  the  neatwork  by  16  yards  and  that  of  the  footing  by  5 
yards. 

Type  B». 

Abutment  type  B2,  Figs.  15  and  I5a  ,  is  similar  to  abutment  type  Bi, 
Fig.  13,  except  that  the  two  defects  just  described  are  remedied.  The 
defect  first  mentioned,  which  is  the  absence  of  bars  in  the  back  wall,  is 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE   ABUTMENTS. 


1095 


\  f Base  of  Rail 


Plan 

/-Base  of  Rail 


£5,560  Total 
fe"  Traction 


Max.  load  per 
pile,  £5  tons 


Sec tion  "A "on 
<£  of  Track. 


Section"B"on 
<£  of  Track. 
Type  Be   Plain    Concrete    Wing    Abutment 
with  R.ein  forced   Concrete    B  a  ckwa/l 
Fig.  15 


1096 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


eliminated  in  Fig.  15  and  the  second  defect,  which  is  the  absence  of  rein- 
forcement in  the  footing,  is  eliminated  in  Fig.  i5a  .  The  saving  in  abut- 
ment type  B;,  due  to  altering  the  cross-section  from  that  shown  in  Fig. 
15  to  the  one  shown  in  Fig.  i5a  ,  is  approximately  $90.00. 

The  two  abutments  are  similar  in  other  respects  so  that  all  of  the 
following  descriptions  of  the  properties  of  abutment  type  B2  apply  equally 
to  abutment  type  Bi. 


/Base  of  Rail 


Abutment  Type  E>z 
Fig  15a 


The  abutment  type  B2,  shown  in  Fig.  15,  is  a  wing  abutment  built 
practically  of  plain  concrete  masonry.  This  type  is  by  far  the  most 
widely  used,  and  is  an  economical  abutment  for  certain  heights.  The 
position  of  the  resultant  of  all  the  loads  on  the  abutment  "ps,"  and  the 
loading  per  pile,  also  entered  in  Fig.  15,  show  that  this  abutment  has 
the  major  requirements  "mi"  mentioned  on  page  9. 

An  examination  of  Section  B  also  shows  that  the  abutment  satis- 
fies the  requirement  called  "m2,"  which  states  that  the  neatwork  should 
be  stable  against  sliding  on  the  footing,  and  the  footing  stable  against 
sliding  on  the  foundation  bed. 

The  angle  of  inclination  of  the  resultant  "ps"  in  Section  B  shows 
that  the  horizontal  component  of  the  force  which  the  abutment  exerts 
upon  its  foundation  is  31  per  cent,  of  the  vertical  component.  This  is 
less  than  coefficient  of  friction  of  nearly  all  foundation  beds,  except,  per- 
haps, wet  clay.  The  stability  against  sliding  is  assisted  by  the  back  fill 
in  front  of  the  abutment  and  the  pressure  against  the  wing  wails  of  that 
portion  of  the  bank  which  extends  in  front  of  the  wing  walls.  This 
abutment  conforms  to  the  minor  requirement  "m"  to  "n"  page  9  in  as 
large  a  measure  as  any  other  type. 

It  is  sometimes  stated  that  a  wing  abutment  affords  greater  pro- 
tection to  the  bank  against  scour  than  any  other  type,  but  it  can  hardly 
be  said  that  the  protection  afforded  by  the  abutment  is  complete.  If 
only  the  end  of  the  bank  be  considered,  as  shown  in  the  elevation  of  the 
abutment  in  Fig.  15,  the  protection  is  complete,  especially  if  the  wing  walls 
are  of  such  a  length  as  to  bring  the  top  of  the  wing  wall  close  to  the 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

4£'-0" 


109T 


5/c/e.    El  evert  Ion 


<5'-5"    2 

'-O"   3' 

5" 

1 

1 

1 

h 

*) 

j 

41 

A 

•T) 

4 

if 

ii 

^^ 

V 

y 

\J 

1 

\ 

W 

[_ 

At. 

?i   ' 

i"  S'-3i" 

3'-  5i"  /"- 

\'-f 

Plan 


7'- 6 


7-6" 


Ha  IF  5ecf/'on 
"Ft  -  F)  " 


Ha  IF    Front 
E I  e  v  a  f/on 


Type.   B5-  Plain    Concrete.  "U  "  A  butm  en  t- Fi  lied 

Fig.  II 


1098 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


ground.  But,  if  the  side  of  the  bank  be  considered,  as  shown  in  Fig.  18, 
it  will  often  be  found  necessary  to  protect  the  toe  of  the  bank  by 
rip-rap  similar  to  that  shown  in  the  figure,  and  without  this  rip-rap 
the  protection  afforded  by  the  heavy  wing  walls  at  the  end  of  the 
bank  is  not  far  enough  extended.  Fig.  19  shows  the  situation  where  a 
bank  which  has  been  washed  away  from  behind  a  wing  abutment  has 
been  replaced  and  protected  with  rip-rap. 


Fig.   18 — Toe  of  Embankment  Protected  by  Rip-rap. 


Abutments  of  this  type  do  not  cause  the  drainage  water  to  wash 
away  the  corner  of  the  bank  adjacent  to  the  back  wall  at  "x"  on  Fig. 
15,  but  at  the  lower  point  "y"  on  the  bank,  Fig.  15,  where  the  amount 
of  the  drainage  water  is  greater,  there  seems  to  be  a  tendency  to  wash 
the  portion  of  the  bank  adjacent  to  the  end  of  the  wing  wall,  and,  therefore, 
this  point  is  often  found  protected  by  loose  rip-rap,  as  shown  in  Fig.  20. 

It  is  possible  with  this  abutment  to  provide  a  joint  between  the  bank 
and  superstructure  which  will  support  the  track  in  as  easy  and  continuous 
a  manner  as  any  other  abutment,  especially  if  a  ballasted  floor  is  useds 
as  shown  in  Fig.  21. 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1099 


Fig.  19— Embankment  Protected  by  Rip-rap  After  Washout. 


Fig.  21— Track  Rails  and  Ties  Continued  Over  Ballast  Floor  Bridge. 


1100 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


Fig.  20— Portion  of  Bank  Adjacent  to  the  End  of  Wingwall  Protected 

by  Rip-rap. 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS.  1101 

Type  B3. 

The  U  abutment  of  plain  concrete  masonry,  type  B3,  is  shown  in 
Fig.  17.  This  abutment  is  designed  substantially  in  the  same  manner 
as  the  U  abutment  of  stone  masonry,  type  A2,  page  6,  except  that  the 
side  walls,  C4,  are  made  long  enough  to  provide  for  an  embankment  slope 
of  1  J/2  to  I,  as  experience  shows  that  the  slopes  at  the  end  of  the  embank- 
ment cannot  be  made  much  steeper  than  the  side  slopes  of  the  same 
embankment. 

This  lengthening  of  the  side  walls  d  of  abutment  B3  to  take  care  of 
the  1%  to  1  embankment  slopes,  results  in  making  the  neatwork  yardage 
for  abutment  B3  greater  than  for  abutment  B2.  This  difference  in  yard- 
age in  the  neatwork  is  overcome  by  the  lower  foundation  costs  of  abut- 
ment B3  so  that  the  total  cost  of  abutment  B3  is  somewhat  less  than 
abutment  B2  for  heights  over  23  feet,  as  shown  in  Fig.  45. 

Type  Be. 

An  examination  of  Section  B,  Fig.  15,  shows  that  it  is  more  difficult 
to  make  provision  in  an  abutment  to  resist  the  lateral  forces  "p3"  and  "P4" 
tending  to  overturn  the  abutment  than  it  is  to  take  care  of  the  vertical 
loads  "px"  and  "p2." 

The  lateral  forces  are  exceeded  in  magnitude  by  the  vertical  forces, 
but  the  vertical  forces  are  directly  opposed  by  the  equal  and  opposite 
reaction  on  the  foundation,  whereas  no  such  equal  and  opposite  reaction 
can  be  placed  on  the  line  "p3"  continued,  which  shows  the  direction  and 
location  of  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork.  As  a  consequence  it 
would  seem  that  a  considerable  economy  could  be  effected  in  a  design 
in  which  the  lateral  forces  "p3"  and  "p*"  were  eliminated  or  greatly  dimin- 
ished. In  abutments  B5,  Fig.  22 ;  B0,  Fig.  23 ;  B7,  Fig.  24 ;  and  B«,  Fig. 
25,  little  provision  is  made  for  resisting  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earth- 
work. Instead,  provision  is  made  for  diminishing  the  lateral  pressure 
by  omitting  the  wings  and  allowing  the  bank  to  spill  around  in  front  of 
the  abutments. 

Abutment  type  B5,  Fig.  22,  consists,  as  shown  in  the  elevation  and 
Section  B,  of  two  short  piers,  which  carry  a  beam  "c-i,"  the  top  of  which 
forms  the  bridge  seat  "a."  The  earthwork  is  kept  off  the  bridge  seat 
by  the  back  wall  "bi"  and  the  side  walls  "b2."  The  bank  is  permitted  to 
run  around  in  front  of  the  abutment  to  the  point  "z"  where  the  natural 
slope  of  the  fill  intersects  the  ground  line. 

If  an  abutment  type  B5  and  an  abutment  type  Bi  were  so  located 
as  to  have  their  bridge  seats  in  the  same  position,  the  abutment  B5  would 
give  a  smaller  waterway  than  the  abutment  type  Bi  by  the  distance 
from  "z"  to  "zi"  in  Fig.  22,  to  which  the  fill  extends  in  front  of  the 
abutment.  In  order  to  get  the  abutment  B5  on  the  same  basis  for  com- 
parison as  the  other  abutments,  it  is  necessary  to  add  to  the  cost  of  abut- 
ment Bs  the  cost  of  extending  the  superstructure  so  as  to  permit  the 
location  of  the  abutment  to  be  moved   from  "z"  to  "zi."     As  shown  in 


1102 


9'-0" 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

5'-0"       9-0" 


<H>-<H£- 


"  e'-o"/'-t " 


zxx>-<> 


-SKHMB- 


<p  cp  <p  cp 


/■Bcfse  of  Rail- 

Level 

CO 

oy^k  / 

<^i>     ^*0ȴ\        i 

mwhjimia. 

^r*°-      z, 

l& 


-Natural  Grounc/ 


Pile,  Plan 


Location  Diaaram  of  Abutments 


"'  I5-0"-  6"ctrs. 


L.L,  Thru5t 
b£,000  Lbs. 
Ecrrth  Thrust 
5L>,  500  Lb  &. 


Without  Earth 
n   Front 


Without  Tract/on  \ 
967,000  Lbs. 


Section  "B"on  <£  o-f  7~rack. 
Type.    B$-  Plain    Concrete.     Pier    Abutment 

Fig.  £2 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1103 


t'-j',        9®  £'- & '* SS '- 6 " 


yBase  of  Rail-  Level -Tanc?ent 


\   L  l   Thru  5 r 
^7G.500  Lbs 


£44  000  Lbs 


Plan 


Without  Tr£3ctior>\ 
/  105  OOO  L  bs 


1077  950  Lbs 


Section  "B" on  <£  o-f  Trcrck. 
Type-    Bfr-Plain    Concrete     Pier    Abutment 


FlQ.  2  5 


1104 


t- 


:\ 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

15-0" 


6'-<?" 


<>  <±>  c>  <±>  <t>  ct> 


6'-0" 


0990999 


^!6 


fBase  of  Rail-  Level  -  Tangent 


^Natural    C  round 
Location    Diagram  of  A  butments 


Half  Elevation 

Rein  force ment 

not  Shown 


Z  *  5-0" Dowels 
I'O"  Cfrs. 


Half  Section 
thru   Backwa// 


Section  "A  "<at 
4l  of  Tracks 


E&  o" 


Tract/on 
4  5.560Lbs 


<£  Bearlna 


Plan 


£arth  Thrust 
I  &.OOO  Lbs. 


Without  Earth 
in  Fron  t 


Without  Traction 
3  75,000  Lbs 


Earth  thrust 
on  stale,  ex- 
tension s  or 
back  wall 
30,400  lbs. 

L.L.  Thru  st 
73,  OOO  Lbs 

E_arth  Thru  si 
1 4c.  OOO  Lbs. 


355,000  Lbs 


Section  "B"  Thru     Co unterfort 
Type.    37  -  Con  crete.     Pier    Abutment 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

/5'-0" 


1105 


6"  6'-0' 


o  6  6  o  cb  cb  o 


6'-0"/'-h 


<M)~0  6  0  (H> 


(p  9  $  ()  Q  Q  tfr 


/Base   of  /?ail-  Level  -  Tangent 


1  Natural    Ground 

Location    Dicfaram  of  A  butmen 


All  bars 
footings 

Batter  £i' "to  1-0" 


Half  Elevation  He* if  Section 
Reinforcement  thru   Backwcr// 
not  Sho/vn 

o" 


Sect/ on  "A" art 
<t    of   Tr&  c  k^ 


SI  VI 

3>    - 

frcfct/on    at 
4  5,  560  Lbs 


f<£  B  ear  ma 


Earth   thrust 

on   s/de.    e.x- 

ten  s/ons  of 

back,  rva // 

5  0,  &00  Lbs 

L.L.  Thrust 
45,000  Lbs. 

Earth  Thrust 
47,  SOO  Lbs. 


With  Traction 
595,000  Lbs 
Without  Traction 
5&IOOO  Lbs 


Plan 


Sec tion  " B  "at  <£  of  Track. 
Type    B  &  -  Cone  r&te.    Pocket   A  hutment 
Fin.  £0 


1106  DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

Fig.  43b,  this  element  of  cost  is  an  important  item,  amounting  to  59  per 
cent,  of  the  total. 

Type  B8. 
Abutment  type  B6,  Fig.  23,  is  similar  to  abutment  type  Bs,  Fig.  22, 
except  that  the  beam  "ci"  in  abutment  B5  is  replaced  by  a  pier  "c"  in 
abutment  B0.  The  side  walls  "b"  of  abutment  B5  are  revolved  900  and 
form  a  continuation  of  the  back  wall  "hi"  in  abutment  B8.  The  abutment 
possesses  no  special  features  not  shown  on  the  drawing. 

Type  B7. 
Abutment    B7,    Fig.    24.    is    similar    to    abutment    B6,    Fig.    23,    except 
that  reinforced  concrete  has  been  substituted  for  plain  concrete  at  ever} 
point  where  the  change  seemed  to  promise  a  saving. 

Type  B8. 

Abutment  Bs,  Fig.  25,  is  in  turn  similar  to  abutment  B-,  Fig.  24,  ex- 
cept that  instead  of  carrying  the  neatwork  down  to  the  natural  ground, 
the  neatwork  has  been  made  only  deep  enough  to  distribute  the  loads 
from  the  superstructure  and  to  provide  a  bearing  on  the  tops  of  the  piles. 

The  concrete  of  abutment  Bs  consists  of  a  shallow  concrete  beam, 
the  upper  side  of  which  forms  the  bridge  seat  "a"  (shown  in  Section 
B),  the  lower  side  resting  on  a  pile  foundation. 

On  account  of  the  natural  slope  which  was  assumed  in  these  com- 
parisons, the  piles  do  not  extend  out  of  the  ground  and  into  the  bank 
for  as  great  a  distance  as  they  would  if  the  ground  were  level  along  the 
line  "z"-"zi,"  Fig.  25,  and  therefore  give  a  more  stable  support  than 
if  the  ground  line  had  been  assumed  level.  On  the  whole  the  conditions 
assumed  were  rather  favorable  to  this  type  of  abutment.  As  the  piles 
in  this  abutment  are  above  the  ground  water  line,  they  must  be  creosoted, 
and  concrete  or  creosoted  piles  have  been  figured  in  the  estimate.  The 
piles  have  been  shown  battered  longitudinally  to  add  to  the  width  of 
the  base  of  the  foundation  and  its  stability,  and  it  is  thought  that  this 
batter  is  not  a  difficult  thing  to  secure  from  a  construction  standpoint. 

Experience  with  abutments  similar  to  type  Bs,  but  with  vertical  piles, 
shows  that  there  is  sometimes  a  tendency  for  the  bank  to  crowd  the 
abutment  forward  against  the  steel  spans.  The  battered  piles,  shown  in 
Fig.  25,  will  partly  remedy  this  defect.  After  having  made  this  pro- 
vision there  is  still,  however,  a  tendency  to  crowd  and  two  additional 
precautions  must  be  taken.  First,  the  abutment  must  receive  somewhat 
more  than  the  usual  attention  from  inspectors.  Second,  it  should  be 
made  to  support  only  the  expansion  bearing  for  the  girder  in  order 
to  prevent  any  movement  in  the  abutment  producing  undue  stresses  in  the 
adjacent  girder  span. 

It  was  originally  intended  that  the  abutments  Bi  to  Bs  should  only 
include  abutments  built  throughout  of  plain  concrete,  except  for  a  small 
amount  of  reinforcement  in  the  back  wall,  footings,  or  other  places  where 
tension  stresses  were  high.  All  of  the  foregoing  abutments,  except  B7 
and  B8)  conform  to  this  classification.     Abutments  B7  and  Be,  however, 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1107 


resemble  abutments  BB  and  B8  in  the  feature  of  having  the  fill  extend 
forward  from  the  abutment  at  its  natural  slope  without  restraint.  They 
were,  therefore,  included  in  what  were  termed  the  group  of  plain  con- 
crete abutments,  although  structurally  they  should  be  classed  with  the 
reinforced  concrete  abutments,  of  which  a  description  follows. 

Type  Ci. 

The  reinforced  concrete  wing  abutment  type  d,  shown  in  Fig.  26, 
is  similar  to  the  abutment  type  B2  of  Fig.  15,  except  that  it  is  constructed 
of  reinforced  concrete  instead  of  plain  concrete.  Commencing  at  the 
bottom,  abutment  G  consists :  first,  of  a  pile  foundation ;  second,  of  a 
deep  footing  slab  "d,"  which  distributes  the  vertical  loads  and  furnishes 
a  means  of  anchorage.  Resting  on  slab  "d,"  as  shown  in  Section  A-A, 
is  a  curtain  wall  "c2"  which  gives  lateral  support  to  the  earth.  The  cur- 
tain wall  is  prevented  from  being  tipped  outward  by  the  buttresses  "c3," 
which  are  anchored  to  the  slab  "d."  If  the  abutment  is  properly  pro- 
portioned, the  curtain  wall  "c2"  could  not  be  pushed  outward  by  the 
lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork  without  carrying  with  it  the  buttresses 
"c3"  and  without  lifting  the  slab  "d"  from  the  pile  foundations  and  also 
lifting  the  entire  weight  of  the  earth  which  rests  vertically  on  the 
slab  "d." 

At  the  front  of  the  abutment,  the  curtain  wall  "c2"  is  given  a  hori- 
zontal offset  "ci"  as  shown  in  Section  E-E  to  provide  for  the  bridge  seat 
"a."  The  curtain  wall  is  carried  up  vertically  from  the  bridge  seat  "a, ' 
forming  the  back  wall  "b"  shown  in  the  same  section. 


figse  of  Rail-^,   y 


Fi3- lG 


a 


The  abutment  shown  in  Fig.  26  has  many  of  the  properties  of  abut- 
ment type  B2  but  has  no  particular  advantage  over  it;  the  introduction 
of  buttresses  not  decreasing  the  cost  of  neatwork  and  the  provisions  for 
anchoring  buttresses  to  the  footings  greatly  increasing  the  cost  of  foot- 
ings for  fills  above  20  ft.  Fig.  26  does  not,  however,  show  the  best 
design  that  can  be  made  of  reinforced  concrete  wing  abutment.  It 
contains  the  two  defects  of  the  bridge  seat  set  too  far  forward  and 
footings  with  insufficient  projection  in  front  of  the  neatwork,  referred 
to  in  pp.  11  and  12,  in  discussion  of  type  Bi. 


1108  DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

31'-  9"  7>.  7-9",  7'-  9V7"  3/  -9" 


Half  P  Ian  of  Footing  5 

Il'-O"  l'-9"/-3'-0" 


Half  Plan 


Re  sultan 
£.100,000 

I  "3\ars 


'540,500  Lt>5   Total  Span  Load 


^4-5,560  Lbs  Total       ii"Bars 
Tractive   Force  c3 

All  vert  and  nor  bars 
in  counter  fort s  C3 
and  curtain  wa/ls  Cz 
j'un/ess  otherwise  noted 

d-0"Ctrs  5-l£"Bar3 


d/4-6'\  <i"Bars  91'Ctrs 

/3'-0"  Max    ioaa  per 

pile  cl  tons 


d-^ 4lGl'   [z"Bars  9"Ctrs. 


5e  Ction  "A-  A" 


"5ection"E- E"near  <£of  Track 

Type    C,  -  Rem  forced    Concrete    Counterfort  Abutment 

Fiac6 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1109 


If  these  defects  are  corrected  we  have  an  improved  abutment,  such 
as  shown  in  the  cross-section,  Fig.  26a .  This  abutment,  called  type 
Cia  ,  is  cheaper  than  that  shown  in  Fig.  26  and  costs  considerably  less 
than  type  B2  for  heights  above  28  ft. ;  estimates  showing  that  it  costs 
about  10  per  cent,  less  than  type  B2  for  the  36  ft.  height  and  25  per 
cent,  less  for  the  50  ft.  height  which  is  outside  the  limits  of  our  diagram. 

If,  in  addition  to  the  economies  shown  in  Fig.  26a ,  the  sections  of 
all  walls  and  buttresses  are  reduced  to  the  minimum  which  can  be  placed 
by  experienced  workers  under  proper  supervision,  the  economy  of  type 
Cia    over  B2  is  still  further  increased. 

Type  C2. 

Abutment  type  C2,  Fig.  27,  is  a  U  abutment  of  reinforced  concrete. 
It  resembles  the  U  abutment  of  plain  concrete  in  external  appearance. 
Structurally,  however,  it  is  quite  different. 

It  consists  in  plan  of  a  rectangular  box  open  at  the  top  and  at  the 
embankment  end,  which  is  filled  with  earth.  The  track  is  directly  sup- 
ported on  the  earth  filling.  The  sides  of  the  box  "c*"  are  prevented 
from  being  forced  outward  by  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earth  by  ties 
"c3"  which  connect  the  two  opposite  sides  "c*."  The  front  of  the  box 
is  the  curtain  wall  "c2,"  which  is  a  beam  between  the  two  side  walls  "C4," 
and  restrains  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork  in  longitudinal 
direction. 

Commencing  at  the  bottom,  then,  this  abutment  consists  of  foundation 
"d,"  which  supports  the  front  curtain  wall  "c2"  and  the  two  side  walls 
"cu"  The  front  curtain  wall  <lCj"  and  the  two  side  walls  "c4"  form 
three  sides  of  a  rectangle,  the  fourth  side  toward  the  enbankment  re- 
maining open.  The  front  curtain  wall  "c2"  is  carried  upward  to  the 
point  "a,"  where  it  is  offset  in  horizontal  direction,  forming  the  beam 
"ci,"  the  upward  surface  of  which  is  the  bridge  seat  "a."  From  "ci" 
the  wall  is  carried  upward  forming  the  back  wall  "b."  The  ends  of 
beam  "ci"  rest  on  the  side  walls  "o,"  or  on  an  enlargement  thereof  "c5," 
and  the  front  edge  of  the  beam  "ci"  rests  upon  the  front  curtain  wall  "c2." 
It  is  apparent  that  this  type  should  result  in  considerable  saving  in  con- 
crete over  the  same  type  constructed  in  plain  concrete,  which  is  called  "B3." 

If  the  design  C2,  Fig.  27,  were  to  be  constructed  of  plain  concrete, 
the  side  walls  "c"  would  have  to  be  made  about  as  shown  by  the  dotted 
lines  "e— e"  in  order  to  make  them  stable  against  overturning. 

Considering  only  the  upper  portion  of  the  side  walls  "C4,"  where 
the  economy  of  introducing  the  tie  is  least  apparent,  a  comparison  of 
restraining  the  side  wall  against  overturning  by  means  of  a  tie  or  by 
means  of  its  own  weight  is  shown  in  Fig.  28.  One  square  inch  of  metal 
is  imbedded  in  the  rectangular  concrete  tie  "h  i  f  g/'  and  carries  a  load 
of  13,500  pounds  at  the  assumed  unit  stresses,  and  if  this  tie  is  5  ft.  above 
the  corner  "k"  on  which  the  side  wall  tends  to  rotate,  the  effective  moment 
against  overturning  furnished  by  the  tie  is  67,500  ft.  lbs. 

Let  "pi"  represent  the  weight  of  the  concrete  in  the  triangle  "b  a  c." 


1110 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

4-Z-O"  B~~- 


Pomfx- 


45,5601 1  to 


I  Un i  -form   Bear-mc 
B  ~~~      I  75  Tons  per  5c?.  Ft 

"beef ion   erf  <£_  of  Trcrctc 


'' 6 \\i,f°i, '  5'~6 ",|, 5 'g "  ^;°iffJ''6 " 


H^  Point 


9'0" 


9--0" 


\5">  IZ" 
^Affeep-  ho 


Half  Section  i  Half  Elevation 
"B  -  B  "         I 
Half  5ect/on\Hcfi  f   Plan 
"A- A"  I 

Type    Cg-  Rein  forced    Con  crete  "U '"  a  burment 
filled-    Long    Side     War II $ 

F,3.  21 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1111 


Let  "m"  be  the  center  of  gravity  of  the  triangle  "b  a  c."  Assume  the 
lever  arm  of  the  force  "px"  to  be  equal  to  the  lever  arm  of  the  force  "p2," 
which  represents  the  stress  in  the  tie  bar.  If  the  sketch  is  representative, 
it  will  take  3.38  yds.  of  concrete  at  4,000  lbs.  per  cu.  yd.  to  produce  the 
same  resisting  moment  by  means  of  the  force  of  gravity  as  is  produced 
by  the  tie  rod  "p2,"  which  ties  the  two  walls  together. 

Comparing  the  quantities  in  the  foregoing  paragraphs,  we  have : 

(1)  Gravity  retaining  wall: 

3.38  yds.  of  concrete  for  one  side  wall. 

6.76  yds.  of  concrete  for  two  side  walls. 

6.76  yds.  at  $5.00  per  cu.  yd.  (material,  mixing  and  placing 

same)     $33.80 

(2)  For  the  thin  wall  with  steel  tie : 

15  linear  ft.  of  one  inch  square  steel  bar,  at  3.4  lbs.  per  linear 
ft  =51.1  lbs. 

51. 1  lbs.  at  zl/2  cents  per  lb $  1.78 

15  cu.  ft.  of  concrete  =  .56  yards. 

.56  cu.  yds.  at  $10.00  per  cu.  yd 5-6°' 

$7-38 

The  above  approximate  comparison  of  a  small  part  of  the  C2  abut- 
ment with  the  corresponding  part  of  Br.  abutment  gives  a  ratio  between 
the  parts  compared,  of  21  per  cent. 


Fig. 


£& 


As  shown  in  Fig.  44  the  actual  cost  of  the  type  C2  abutment  is 
about  75  per  cent,  of  the  B3  abutment.  The  foregoing  comparison  is. 
therefore,  only  a  rough  analogy.  It  illustrates,  however,  in  a  general 
way  the  source  of  economy  of  abutment  type  C2. 

This  abutment  type  C2  easily  satisfies  the  requirements  of  "nil"  and 
"m?."  against  overturning,  of  page  9.  The  width  of  footings,  measured 
along  the  center  line  of  track,  which  is  effective  against  overturning  of 
type  B2,  is  13  ft.  9  in.  That  of  type  Ci  is  18  ft.  The  corresponding 
dimension  on  abutment  C2  is  the  distance  from  the  front  to  back  of 
abutment,  or  45  ft. 

It  is  true  that  the  wing  walls  of  abutments  B2  and  Ci  protect,  perhaps, 
five  times  as  much  of  the  embankment  against  scour  as  does  abutment  C-, 


1112  DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

but  if  we  compare  the  protection  afforded  by  either  type  B2  or  C2  with 
the  total  amount  of  bank  protection  required,  the  difference  between  the 
two  abutments  in  this  respect  is  not  much.  One  of  the  defects  of  this 
abutment  is  that  practically  all  of  the  surface  water  from  the  track  for 
the  entire  length  of  abutment  must  drain  past  the  point  "x,"  Figs.  27 
and  29.  As  the  amount  of  water  is  considerable  it  tends  to  wash  away 
the  embankment  at  the  end  of  the  wing  wall,  as  shown  in  Fig.  29.  The 
washing  of  the  bank  at  this  point  is,  of  course,  an  important  matter,  as 
the  material  is  washed  away  at  a  point  not  far  from  the  end  of  the 
track  ties  and  requires  much  more  attention  than  if  the  material  was 
washed  away  at  the  end  of  the  wing  wall,  as  shown  in  Fig.  20. 

In  Fig.  30  is  shown  an  abutment  of  an  entirely  different  structure, 
but  which  is  exactly  the  same  as  abutment  C2,  as  far  as  drainage  is  con- 
cerned. Fig.  30  shows  the  loose  rock  and  boards  necessary  to  maintain 
the  shoulder  of  the  bank  on  account  of  drainage.  Drainage  openings 
are  provided  in  the.  front  and  side  walls  of  abutments  C- ;  but  even  with 
this  provision  it  is  not  as  easy  to  drain  as  type  B2  or  G,  unless  it  is 
rilled  with  porous  material. 

Type    C3. 

In  Fig.  31  abutment  type  C2  is  shown  in  dotted  lines  and  is  shown 
to  be  42  ft.  in  length.  If  the  approach  span  is  lengthened,  the  face  of 
the  abutment  can  be  moved  from  "a"  to  "b,"  thus  shortening  the  abut- 
ment by  16  ft.  This  shortened  abutment,  which  is  shown  in  full  lines, 
is  called  type  G,  and  is  similar  in  every  way  to  type  C2  except  that  it 
requires  a  longer  approach  span  and  that  it  permits  the  fill  to  spill  around 
the  front  of  the  abutment. 

Type  G. 

Abutment  type  G,  Fig.  32,  and  all  of  the  abutments  which  follow 
have  one  feature  differing  from  any  of  the  abutments  previously  mentioned. 
Abutments  G,  C5,  Co  and  C7  have  the  common  feature  of  carrying  the 
track  directly  on  the  body  of  the  abutment  over  the  entire  length  of  the 
abutment  instead  of  on  the  bank.  Commencing  at  the  top,  abutment  type 
G,  Fig.  32,  consists  of  a  slab  "a;"  resting  on  the  side  walls  "c4,"  the 
side  walls  in  turn  resting  on  the  footings  "d."  The  side  walls  "d"  are 
tied  together  in  front  by  the  curtain  wall  "c2;"  this  curtain  wall  being 
offset  to  form  the  bridge  seat  "a"  and  the  back  Avail  "b"  in  a  manner 
similar  to  that  used  in  abutment  type  C2.  The  curtain  wall  "c2"  of 
abutment  G  is  not  required  to  carry  any  of  the  lateral  pressure  of  the 
earthwork,  however,  as  in  this  abutment  the  earth  is  allowed  to  spill 
into  the  interior  of  the  abutment  and  around  on  the  outside,  assuming- 
its  natural  slope  from  "x"  to  "z,"  here  assumed  at  ilA  to  1.  The  side 
walls  "a"  are  tied  together  by  the  ties  "c;." 

To  save  material  and  to  equalize  the  pressure  of  the  earthwork  on 
both  sides  of  the  side  walls  "cj,"  two  large  openings  "cc"  are  made 
in  the  walls.  The  portion  of  the  side  wall  remaining  between  the  open- 
ings "c,/'  forms  a  column ;  and  the  portion  of  the  side  walls  above  the 
openings   forms  a  beam  between  columns.     A    portion   of  the   completed 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1113 


1114 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


abutment  type  d  having  one  panel  only,  is  shown  in  Fig.  33.  The  open- 
ings are  shown  circular  on  top,  although  structurally  they  could  have  been 
as  easily  made  square. 

Abutment  €<  has  an  advantage  over  abutment  C>  in  that  its  founda- 
tion loads  are  less,  due  to  the  fact  that  the  interior  of  the  abutment  is 


kl 

ig'wv.."  .qgifr-gH"  ' r-r. — 

&  £ :*jjj$ 

SflHilMmf'- v 

V    ■ 

Ak  ]*>  ^tea1- a  ^A 

Fig.  30 — Loose  Rock  and  Boards  Required  to  Maintain  the  Shoulder 
of  the  Bank  Against  Drainage  Water. 


4-e-o" 


^Abutment      ^ 

C5     ! 
*- ,   \  f  Abutment 


A  butment  Type  C5  shown  in  fu/l  //res. 
Abutment  Type  C>  shown  in  dotted  //nes. 
Type  C3  Re  in  Forced  Concrete.  "U" 
Abutment- Filled-  Short _  3idewafl5 

F/tj.5/ 

only  partially  filled  with  earth.  The  side  walls  of  C«  are  subjected  to 
practically  no  unbalanced  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork.  It  has 
the  disadvantage  that  it  requires  a  considerable  amount  of  material  for 
the  construction  of  the  floor  slab  "a2,"  and  as  a  consequence  it  does 
not  show  much  economy  for  low  fills. 

In  Fig.  34  a  completed  abutment  of  this  type  with  the  fill  in  place  is 
shown.  The  embankment  in  Fig.  34  has  an  average  slope  along  the  face 
of  the  side  wall  of  about  1  to   1   instead  of  the  slope  1V2  to   1   which 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1115 


Poinf'X'l 


Base  of /?ail 


v leep-ho'e 


B- >      Uniform    Bearing 

1 4  Ton  5  per    3a.  Ft 

Section    at    <£   o-f  Track. 

C\f  a?r5v   (f Stirrups/?) 


j  Bars) 


f- 


5'£' 


Br 


£c>f5 


5^ 


?y 


H 


5'i 


S5V\5 


5'-0 


y-o 


9'-0" 


13 


Bars 


9'-0" 


•-O" 


e  Bars- 


Section  of  Slab 
9 '-  O  "     ,       9'-0" 


Alpfe 
All  vertical  bars 
shown  except  m 
the    walls,  are 


Half  Section  .Half  Elevation 
"B  -  B " 


Half  Section\Ha/f  Plan 
"ft  -  A  " 

Type  C^-  Rein  forced  Concrete  "U"  Abutment-  Co  ve  recY 

Fiq.  3£ 


1116 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


u 

w 


[2h 


'^            ;'"'"^-     r 

IP^^HH^BHJjffiHBHHi 

DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1117 


was  used  in  the  design  in  Fig.  32.  The  quantities  for  abutment  type  d 
were  all  figured  on  a  1/2  to  1  slope,  so  that  at  a  later  point  when  we 
compare  the  costs  of  various  types  it  is  not  necessary  to  make  allowance 
for  rip-rap  used  with  type  Ci,  Fig.  34.  Fig.  35  is  a  general  view  of  the 
bridge  in  which  a  type  C4  abutment  was  used  at  each  end.  The  abutment 
on  the  left-hand  side  is  the  same  abutment  which  is  shown  in  Fig.  34. 

As  there  are  practically  no  unbalanced  lateral  earthwork  pressures 
in  action  against  abutment  G,  no  provision  need  be  made  to  make  it 
conform  to  the  requirements  "mi,"  "m2"  and  "m3"  on  page  9.  This  abut- 
ment gives,   perhaps,   slightly   less  protection   to   the   embankment   against 


Fig.  34 — Completed  Abutment,  Type  d,  Fill  in  Place. 

scour  than  abutment  C2,  but  it  will  probably  not  wash  away  at  the 
shoulder  of  the  embankment  at  "x,"  as  drainage  for  the  top  of  the 
abutment  is  provided  through  holes  in  the  sides  of  the  floor  slabs.  It 
is,  of  course,  easily  drained,  and  if  a  ballasted  deck  is  used  on  the  girder, 
as  shown  in  Fig.  35,  it  provides  a  continuous  support  of  the  same  char- 
acter for  the  track  on  the  abutment  and  on  the  superstructure,  as  shown 
in  Fig.  36.  The  ties  in  the  foreground,  Fig.  36,  are  the  ties  of  the  pile 
trestle  which  have  not  yet  been  removed,  the  trestle  having  just  been 
replaced  by  an  earth  embankment. 

Type  Ca. 
Abutment  type  G,  Fig.  37  and  Fig.  38,  consists  in  general  of  six  verti- 
cal posts  "ci"  and  "c5)"  which  support  the  slab  "a2."     At  the  bottom  they 


1118 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


are  tied  together  by  the  footings  "di"  and  "d2."  The  footings  "d,"  and 
"d2"  act  partly  as  foundation  beams  and  partly  as  ties,  which  hold  the 
bottoms  of  columns  in  their  true  relative  position  and  afford  them  sup- 
port against  any  unbalanced  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork. 


pIG.  35_Span  Supported  on  Type  C<  Abutments. 


pIG   36 — Track  Supported  on  Slabs  of  Type  d  Abutment. 

Ties  in  the  Foreground  are  the  Ties  of  the  Pile  Trestle  Which  Have 

Not  Been  Removed,  the  Trestle  Having  Just  Been 

Replaced  by  an  Embankment. 


A/ote.   "A" 

Dotted  line.  incJ. /crates 
position  of  foot/ng  for 
which  cfuan  titi e s  were 
frjurec/. 


5  lab  and  beam 
same  a5   in 
first    bay 


4b,560  Lbs    To  tat 
Tractive.    Force 

l4'-\&" 


] 


-5'%0,000  Lbs.  Total    Span   Load 

l-§"*?d'-0"{St/rrups  /5-e"  {Bav<e  of  Rail 


Part   5ec  f/on"/Q-  A 

53-6" 


r-~B 


U   u.-l   U(j/  It   U1  U 

Front  Ele vcff/on 


uuu u  # 


Column  reinforcement  not  shown  in  efevat/on 
5  ide,    E  fe,va  fion 


/4'-0" 


Footing  P/an 

Sec  fion  "B-B" 
Showing  Bent  "A" 
Type,    C  5  -  Rein-Tor  cect    Cone  rete    Arch   Abutment 

Fig.  57 


1120 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


At  the  top  the  cross  beam  c8  spans  transversely  between  the  posts  a. 
Two  posts  and  the  cross  beam  c3  form  a  single  bent,  such  as  the  one 
called  "A"  in  Fig.  23. 

At  the  top,  also,  longitudinal  beam  c6  spans  longitudinally  between  the 
bents  "A."  By  this  arrangement  the  slab  a2  is  supported  on  four  sides,  the 
two  ends  of  the  slab  resting  on  cross  beams  c3,  and  the  two  sides  of  the 
slab  are  supported  by  longitudinal  beam  Ce. 

At  the  front  of  the  abutment  the  posts  "c5"  are  made  much  heavier, 
as  the  beam  "c3"  which  connects  them  together  at  the  top  carries  the 
weight  of  the  adjacent  span  of  the  superstructure,  and  also  carries  one 
end  of  a  slab  "a2."     The  divisions  mentioned  are  only  those  which  have 


Fig.  38 — Completed  Type  C5  Abutment. 


to  be  made  in  order  to  execute  the  design ;  the  structure  itself  being 
tied  together  by  steel  in  all  directions  so  as  to  resemble  a  monolith. 
In  service  this  abutment  has  all  the  advantages  and  disadvantages  of 
type  d,  which  it  resembles  structurally  in  many  respects.  As  it  is 
somewhat  more  open  than  type  d,  it  drains  itself  a  little  better.  A  com- 
pleted abutment  of  this  type  is  shown  in  Fig.  38.  The  opposite  side  of 
the  same  abutment  after  filling  is  shown  in  Fig.  39,  and  a  general  view 
of  a  bridge  having  an  abutment  of  this  kind  at  each  end  is  shown  in 
Fig.  40.  The  abutment  at  the  right  end  of  Fig.  40  is  the  same  abutment 
of  which  a  nearer  view  is  shown  in  Fig.  39.  The  rip-rap  shown  in  Fig. 
39  was  due  to  the  special  requirement  of  the  situation  where  this  abut- 
ment is  built  and  would  not  ordinarily  be  required. 


DESIGN    OF    BRIDGE    A  HUTMENTS. 


1121 


Abutment  shown  in  Fig.  37  is  the  design  of  W.  S.  Lacher.* 
The  first  abutment  of  this  character  of  which  the  writer  had  knowl- 
edge was  built  by  the  Illinois   Central   Railroad   and  photographed,   but 
never  published. 

Type  C8. 

A  T  abutment  of  reinforced  concrete  type  Ca  is  shown  in  Fig.  41. 
The  stem  of  this  abutment  consists  of  a  slab  "a2,"  which  is  supported 
longitudinally  along  its  center  line  by  the  central  wall  of  the  stem  "d." 
The  wall  is  carried  vertically  down  to  the  spread  footings  "d." 


Fig.  39 — Completed  Abutment,  Type  C5,  Fill  in  Place. 

The  floor  "a2"  with  the  wall  "c*"  are  given  lateral  stability  against 
overturning  by  the  front  curtain  wall  "c2"  and  by  the  reinforcement  on 
both  faces  of  the  wall  "c4,"  which  extends  directly  into  the  footings. 
The  curtain  wall  "c2"  is  carried  up  to  form  the  bridge  seat  "0"  and  the 
back  wall  "b"  is  in  the  same  manner  as  in  the  G  abutments. 

This  abutment  has  the  defect  that  it  is  not  safe  under  a  derailed 
locomotive.  The  derailed  locomotive  produces  in  this  structure  much 
greater  stresses  than  in  the  other  types. 

If  we  increase  the  reinforcement  to  take  care  of  the  exceptional  case 
of  a  derailment,  we  need  a  quantity  of  steel  nearly  double  that  shown  in 


*A  similar  abutment,  called  Fig.  6,  is  described  in  the  article  by  Wm. 
M.  Torrence  in  the  "Engineering  News,"  January  11,  1906.  Also  in  the 
"Engineering  News,"  August  18,  1910,  pp.  180 — "Abutments  for  the  New 
York  State  Barge  Canal." 


1122 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


the  table,  increasing  the  cost  of  reinforcing  steel  practically  $400  and 
filling  the  structure  so  full  of  bars  that  the  cost  of  laying  the  concrete 
would  be  largely  increased. 

Provision  for  derailment  in  this  structure  is,  therefore,  out  of  the 
question,  and  its  weakness  under  a  derailment  must  stand  a  grave  defect. 

We  can  offer  little  additional  information  concerning  type  C6  and  the 
following  type  C-,  other  than  that  shown  on  the  drawings.  The  ad- 
vantages and  defects  of  the  several  features  of  these  abutments  are  the 
same  as  the  advantages  and  defects  of  the  same  features  in  the  fore- 
going abutments,  which  were  described  more  fully. 

Type  Ct. 
The  trestle  abutment  type   Cr,   Fig.  42,  in  a  general   way  is  a  con- 
crete trestle  of  sufficient   length   to   carry   the   track   from  the   point   "z," 
or  from  the  end  of  the  superstructure,  to  the  point  "x,"  where  the  bank 


Fig.  40 — Bridge  Terminated  at  Each   End  With   Type  Co  Abutments. 

has  attained  its  full  height.  Commencing  at  the  top,  this  abutment  con- 
sists of  two  standard  U-shaped  trestle  slabs  "a2"  which  contain  the 
ballast,  which  in  turn  supports  the  ties  and  rails:  These  slabs  rest  on 
the  neatwork  of  the  bents  "c"  and  "ct,"  which  are  ordinarily  reinforced 
concrete  trestle  bents  with  spread  footings  "d."  To  resist  unbalanced 
longitudinal  pressure  of  the  earthwork  and  also  to  add  longitudinal 
stability  to  the  abutment,  the  struts  "c3"  are  introduced  between  the 
tops  of  the  bents  "c2"  and  "C4,"  and  the  struts  "di"  introduced  between 
the  bottoms  of  the  same  bents.  In  addition  to  acting  as  struts  these 
members  "c3"  and  "di"  combine  the  three  bents  and  the  two  spans  into 
two  rigid  quadrilaterals.  The  trestle  bent  "c2"  at  the  front  end  of  the 
abutment  is  made  considerably  thicker  than  the  bents  "<u"  in  the  bank 
in  order  to  leave  room  for  the  bridge  seat  "ai."  In  service  this  abut- 
ment is  much  like  C<  and  C5.  Structurally  it  resembles  C*  more  closely 
in  that  the  floor  "a"  is  a  separate  member  and  can  be  placed  after  the 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

<£ '-  O  " 


1123 


/O'-O" 


47-6" 


Uniform    Be.  arm  a    I  ^_    Tons  per  Sq  Ft 

E ' I e.  vor  t  ion 


14 -  6  " 


y- 


tz 


15'-  e" 


9'-0" 


5'-6"/'- 


Bars    IP" Ctry.s  /'■(?" 5'-6"t    ^    P 
"^-    ■   '       1      T    ■ 


Bar 5    6"  Ctrs 
fill  bars  -;" 5a 


Half   5ect/on\Haif    Front 
"  fit  -  A"  |    £  I e  v a  t /  on 


Foot i  na    Plan 

Type.    C  h~  Rem  forced    C  on  c  re  t  e  "T"'A  b  u  trnen  + 

F,3  4-, 


1124 


Point' 'Xl 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

4d'-0" 


Lbs- 


Uni-form    Bearmcr    /^  Tons    per    Sa    f~f 

E  I  e  vcff  i  on 


9'- 6 


9  '-6' 


5-6" 


6'-0" 


5-9"  4-6' 


1-6' 


4-6"  4'- 6" 


9-6" 


A//  bars   in  piers 
ornai  I ' onqifudinal 
struts^  ^"square. 


9'- 6" 


i"8ars  l'-0"Ctrs 


Half  Section 
"E>  -  A  " 


Ha  IE  E leva f ion 


Her  if 

"B 


Section 
-  B" 


Ha/E  Plan 
Slabs  Re  moved 


Type.    C-[-Reinforceaf    Concre-te. 
Trestle    Abutment 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1125 


abutment  has  been  built.  The  remaining  portion  of  the  abutment  forms 
a  complete  structure  without  the  slab.  The  slab  is  only  used  to  afford 
direct  vertical  support  to  the  track.. 

MEMORANDUM  ON  TOTAL  COSTS  OF  VARIOUS  TYPES. 

Figs.  43a  to  43g,  on  inserts,  pp.  44-45,  are  tables  which  show  the  man- 
ner in  which  the  total  estimated  costs  of  the  foregoing  abutments  were 
made  up. 


Ficj.45 

These  tables  should  give  dependable  estimated  costs,  as  the  division 
of  the  total  costs  into  their  elements  has  been  carried  as  far  as  could 
be  conveniently  done. 

The  tables  show  the  quantities  as  well  as  the  unit  costs  and  make  it 
possible  for  the  reader  to  substitute  different  unit  costs  for  those  shown, 
where  the  conditions  are  such  that  the  unit  costs  given  in  the  table  would 
not  apply.  It  is  not  believed,  however,  that  any  ordinary  changes  will 
affect  the  relations  between  the  totals. 

Figs.  44  to  64  contain  curves  which  compare  the  cost  of  the  several 
abutments  for  different  heights  and  for  different  types.  On  Fig.  44  the 
total  cost  of  abutments  are  platted  as  ordinates  to  the  heights  platted 
as  abscissas.  Each  of  the  Figs.  46  to  5S,  inclusive,  shows  the  total  cost 
of  one  type  and  shows  also  the  manner  in  which  the  cost  of  that  type  is 
divided  between  neatwork,  foundation,  embankment,  etc.  In  each  figure 
from  59  to  64  are  platted  curves  showing  a  single  element  of  cost  in 
all  the  abutments,  Fig.  59  containing  curves  which  compare  the  total 
cost  of  neatwork  of  any  type  with  the  total  cost  of  neatwork  in  any 
other  type,  and  Figs.  60  to  64,  inclusive,  contain  similar  curves  for  the 
foundation,  floor,  embankment,  additional  length  of  superstructure  and 
falsework. 

The  total  cost  of  the  various  types  of  concrete  abutments  are  platted, 
Fig.  44,  the  following  being  omitted : 

Type  Bi  is  omitted,  except  for  the  28  ft.  height,  the  design  having 
so  many  defects  that  it  did  not  seem  worth  while  to  estimate  its  cost  for 
other  heights. 

Type  B4,  T  abutment,  is  omitted  because  most  of  its  properties  can 
be  obtained  from  an  examination  of  the  figures  and  curves  illustrating 
Type  B3. 

Curves  showing  the  cost  of  all  the  other  types  are  platted. 


1126  DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

The  objection  most  frequently  made  to  abutments  types  C2  to  Ct  is 
their  high  cost,  especially,  it  is  said,  if  constructed  by  men  experienced 
mostly  in  the  construction  of  plain  concrete  work. 

On  account  of  this  objection  the  principal  unit  costs  for  this  type 
were  taken  rather  high,  as  it  was  believed  that  there  was  enough  economy 
in  the  design  of  some  of  these  types  to  more  than  offset  the  highest  unit 
cost  which  could  be  reasonably  selected.  Examination  of  Fig.  44  will 
show  that  this  prediction  was  substantially  correct. 

In  order  to  furnish  information  as  to  the  cost  of  these  abutments 
if  lower  unit  prices  were  selected,  the  curves  shown  in  Fig.  44  have  been 
reproduced  in  Fig.  45.  The  total  costs  have  been  reduced,  however, 
so  that  Fig.  45  shows  average  low  costs  under  ordinary  circumstances, 
which  are  about  37.5  per  cent,  less  than  those  shown  in  Fig.  44. 

In  examining  these  cost  curves  the  following  should  be  noted : 

Types  Ce  and  Ct  are  untried,  and  unexpected  weaknesses  may  develop 
in  their  use. 

C»  does  not  take  care  of  derailment. 

B5,  B8,  B7,  B3  or  C-  cannot  be  used  where  much  scour  is  anticipated 
or  where  the  highwater  is  near  the  bridge  seat,  without  the  use  of  rip-rap, 
whose  cost  has  not  been  included. 

It  should  be  observed  that  the  necessity  of  carrying  the  footings 
further  below  the  ground  will  make  a  proportionately  greater  increased  cost 
in  types  Bi  to  B7  than  in  types  C»  to  C7. 

The  use  of  any  type  of  superstructure  which  gives  a  less  depth  of 
bridge  seat  below  base  of  rail  will  mean  a  greater  proportionate  increase 
in  cost  in  types  Bi  to  B7  and  Ce  than  in  types  Ci  to  C5  and  C7. 

With  these  points  in  mind  the  cost  curves  permit  the  reader  to  draw 
his  own  conclusions  as  to  the  relative  economy  of  the  various  types  in 
different  situations. 

Type  Ci  is  highest  in  cost  of  any  abutment  for  heights  over  21  ft. 
As  previously  mentioned,  this  type  is  created  by  the  substitution  of  rein- 
forced concrete  in  a  mediocre  design  intended  for  plain  concrete,  making 
the  least  number  of  changes  in  the  design  which  would  permit  the  use 
of  the  new  material. 

If  this  design  is  improved,  as  shown  in  Fig.  26a  ,  its  cost  can  be  re- 
duced by  an  amount  which  will  make  it  of  less  cost  than  type  B2,  for 
heights  above  28  ft.  If,  as  mentioned  on  page  27,  advantage  is  taken  of 
other  known  refinements  in  design  of  abutments  of  this  character,  its 
cost  can  be  still  further  reduced. 

The  equality  of  cost  shown  for  types  B5,  B8  and  B7  is  not  accidental 
but  is  due  to  the  similarity  of  these  types,  and  is  explained  by  an  examina- 
tion of  Figs.  59,  60,  62,  63  and  64,  which  show  that  not  only  the  total 
cost  of  these  abutments  is  alike,  but  that  the  cost  is  proportioned  in  a 
similar  manner,  in  all  abutments  between  neatwork,  foundation,  fill,  addi- 
tional length  of  superstructure  and  falsework. 

For  nearly  all  heights  types  C3,  C8  and  C7  are  the  lowest  in  cost  of 
those  types  in  which  the  neatwork  is  carried  to  a  sufficient  depth  to  place 
footings  on  the  natural  ground. 


1127 


Estimate  of  Quantities  and  Coats 

Height 
In  Ft. 

Item 

Itatiotl 

F    o    o    t ;     1     n     .    n 

Cu.    Yds. 
of  Exca- 
vation 

Piles 

Cu.Yds. 
of  Fill 

False- 
work 

Change    in 
Length  of 
Bridge  One 
Abutment 

FirBt 
Total 

Engng.A 

Inold-         Grand 

entals         Total 

Cu.   Yda. 
of  Cone. 

Lbs.    of 

Ste*! 

Sq.    Yds. 
of   Forma 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forms 

h 

13 

Quant  - 
ities 
Unit 

Coet 

60 
$5.00 
8300 

2  70 
39 

121 
$1.30 
$145 

31 
85.00 
$105 

0 

33 
81.30 

538 

65 

$1.50 

$98 

0 

170 

$0.35 

$43 

0 

.71    ft. 

$61.00 

543 

$771 

.5* 
838 

$809 

20 

Quant  - 
ltles 
Unit 
Cost 

160 
$5.00 

5800 

370 

it 

220 
81.20 
8264 

56 

$5.00 
$380 

0 

49 

$1.30 

$59 

120 
81.50 
$180 

34 
$8.00 
$373 

600 
$0.35 
8150 

0 

3.79   ft. 

$61.00 
$170 

$3134 

Si 
$109 

$3393 

Bl 

28 

Quanti- 
ties 
Unit 

Cost 

406 
{5.00 
82030 

0 

435 
81.20 
$510 

103 
$5.00 
8515 

0 

63 

81.20 

$76 

260 
81.50 
$390 

71 

88.00 
$568 

1500 
$0.35 
$375 

$50 

4.43   ft. 

$61.00 
$370 

$47f>3 

5* 
5339 

$5023 

B3 

28 

Quant- 
it  les 
Unit 
Cost 

387 
85.00 
81935 

370 
11 

430 
$1.30 
$504 

103 
85.00 
$510 

0 

60 

$1.30 

873 

260 
81.50 
$390 

64 
$8.00 
$513 

1500 
$0.25 
$375 

$50 

6.04   ft. 

$61.00 

$368 

$4735 

5fi 
$336 

$4961 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

696 
85.00 
53480 

370 
11 

638 
$1.30 
8754 

143 

85.00 
$710 

0 

75 

81.20 

$90 

400 
$1.50 
$600 

108 
$8.00 
$864 

3100 
$0.25 
$775 

$50 

8.38   ft. 

$61.00 

$511 

$7843 

.   5* 
$393 

$8335 

B3 

13 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

74 
85.00 
8370 

0 

135 
81-30 
8150 

31 
85.00 
8155 

0 

0 

60 

$1.50 

890 

0 

60 

$0.25 

815 

$100 

0 

0 
0 

$880 

si 

844 

$934 

30 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

229 
$5.00 
$1145 

0 

285 
81.20 
$343 

59 
85.00 
$395 

0 

0 

115 
$1.50 
$173 

0 

250 

80.25 
863 

$300 

.85   ft. 

$61.00 

853 

$3370 

.   5* 
$113 

$3383 

38 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

496" 
$5.00 
$3480 

0 

450 
$1.20 
$540 

103 
$5.00 
8515 

0 

0 

310 
$1.50 
$315 

0 

525 
$0.25 
$131 

$300 

1.53  ft. 

$61.00 
$93 

$4374 

Bit 
$319 

84593 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Coat 

880 
$5.00 
$4400 

0 

780 
$1.30 
$936 

137 
$5.00 
$685 

0 

0 

290 
$1.50 
8435 

0 

1075 
$0.25 
$269 

$400 

2.27   ft. 

$61.00 
$139 

87364 

si 

$363 

$7637 

1127 


Estimate  of  Quantities  and  Costs 

Height 
In  Ft. 

Item 

Haatwork 

F  o  o   t    i   n   e   n 

Cu.   Yds. 
of  Exoa- 
vat  ion 

Piles 

Cu.Yds. 
of   Fill 

Engng.4 
Incid- 
entals 

Grand 
Total 

of  Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.   Yde. 
of    Forms 

Cu.   Yda'. 
of   Cone. 

Lbs.   of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forme 

False- 
work 

Length  of 
Bridge  One 
Abutment 

B5 

13 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

36 
35.00 
8130 

540 
$19 

64 
$1.30 

$77 

36 
$5.00 
$130 

0 

0 

45 

$1.50 

$68 

0 

76 

$0.25 

$19 

0 

10    ft. 

$61.00 

$610 

5$ 
$53 

$1106 

30 

Quant- 
it  iee 
Unit 
Cost 

52 

$5.00 
$360 

540 
$19 

96 
$1.30 
$115 

35 
$5.00 
$135 

0 

0 

48 

$1.50 

$73 

37 
$8.00 
$316 

400 
$0.35 
$100 

0 

33   ft. 
$61.00 

$1340 

$112 

$2359 

38 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

80 
$5.00 
$400 

945 
3i* 
$33 

134 
$1.20 
$161 

35 
$5.00 
$135 

0 

0 

46 

$1.50 

$69 

32 
$8.00 
$356 

960 
$0.35 
$340 

$45 

34    ft  . 
$61.00 
$3075 

$170 

$3574 

36 

Quant - 
itiee 
Unit 
Cost 

103 
$5.00 
$515 

945 
$33 

172 

$1.30 
$206 

36 
$5.00 
$180 

550 

zy 

$19 

0 

68 
$1.50 

$103 

45 
$8.00 
$360 

1860 
$0.35 
$465 

$60 

46   ft. 
$61.00 
$3800 

5$ 
$237 

$4977 

h 

13 

Quant- 
lties 
Unit 
Cost 

33 

$5.00 
$160 

435 
$15 

74 

$1.30 

$89 

30 
$5.00 
$150 

275 

$10 

0 

50 

$1.50 

$75 

0 

70 

$0.25 

$18 

0 

7.6  ft. 

$61.00 

$460 

5% 
$49 

$1036 

30 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

58 

$5.00 
$290 

480 

zh 

$17 

103 
$1.30 
$124 

24 
$5.00 
$130 

0 

0 

45 

$1.50 

$68 

28 
$8.00 
$224 

400 
$0.35 
$100 

0 

19.6   ft. 

$61.00 
$1300 

si 

$107 

$3350 

38 

Quant  - 
lties 
Unit 
Cost 

97 

$5.00 
$485 

480 
$17 

154 
$1.20 
$185 

39 
$5.00 
$145 

0 

0 

53 

$1.50 
$80 

35 

$8.00 

$280 

935 
$0.35 
$334 

$45 

31.6  ft. 
$61.00 
$1930 

5% 
$170 

$3571 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Coat 

148 
$5.00 
$740 

385 
3** 
813 

200 

51.20 
$240 

49 
$5.00 
$345 

1090 

z\t 

$38 

0 

70 
$1.50 
$105 

54 
$8.00 
$432 

1800 
$0.25 
$450 

$60 

43.6  ft. 

$61.00 
$3660 

5$ 
$349 

$5333 

1127 


Estimate  of  Quantities  and   Costs 

Height 
in  Ft . 

Item 

Neatwork 

Foot    1  n  e  s 

Cu.   Yds. 
of  Exca- 
vation 

Piles 

Cu.Yds. 
of  Fill 

False- 
work 

Change  in 
Length  of 
Bridge  One 
Abutment 

Engng.A 
Incid- 
entals 

Grand 
Total 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cone. 

Lb s  •    of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of    Forms 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cono. 

the.   of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forms 

B7 

12 

Quant- 
ities 

Unit 
Cost 

27 
85.50 
$149 

745 
$36 

71 

$1.30 

$85 

15 
$6.50 

$98 

73& 
3if 
$36 

0 

35 

$1.50 

$38 

19 

$8.00 
$153 

76 

$0.25 

$19 

0 

8.2  ft. 

$61.00 

$500 

5f. 
$55 

$1148 

20 

Quant - 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

45 
85.50 
$248 

781 
lit 
$37 

97 
$1.20 
$116 

19 
$6.50 
$133 

985 
$34 

0 

32 

$1.50 

$48 

37 

$8.00 
$316 

420 
$0.25 
$105 

0 

30.2  ft. 
$81.00 
$1330 

5$ 
$107 

$2354 

38 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

67 

$5.50 

$369 

1050 

$37 

137 
$1.30 

$164 

34 
$6.50 
$156 

1040 

$36 

0 

46 

$1.50 

$69 

33 

$8.00 
$364 

970 
$0.25 
$243 

$45 

33.3  ft. 
$61.00 
$1960 

.   5* 
$167 

$3510 

36 

Quant - 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

88 
$5.50 
$484 

1310 
lit 
$43 

174 
$1.30 
$309 

$6.50 
$189 

1350 
lit 
$44 

0 

58 

$1.50 

$87 

43 
$8.00 
$344 

1900 
$0.25 
$475 

$60 

44.2  ft. 
$61.00 
$2700 

5$ 
$333 

$4866 

B8 

13 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

25 

$6.50 

$163 

480 

!*' 

$17 

65 

$1.30 

$78 

15 

$6.50 
$98 

610 
lit 
$31 

0 

37 

$1.50 
$41 

19 
$8.00 
$153 

76 

$0.35 

$19 

0 

8.2  ft. 

$61.00 
$500 

555 

$54 

$1143 

30 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

35 

$6.50 
$163 

480 
lit 
$17 

65 

$1.20 
$78 

15 

$6.50 

$98 

610 

lit 

$21 

30 

$1.30 
$34 

3 

$1.50 
$4 

19 

$8.00 

$153 

425 

$0.25 

$106 

0 

30.3  ft. 

$61.00 
$1330 

5f» 
$95 

$1988 

38 

Quant  - 
Ities 
Unit 
Cost 

25 

$6.50 

$163 

480 
$17 

65 

$1.30 

$78 

15 

$6.50 

$98 

610 
$31 

31 

$1.30 

$36 

0 

31 

$13.50 

$363 

1010 

$0.25 
$253 

S45 

33.2  ft. 

$61.00 
$1960 

.   5* 
$147 

$3083 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

35 

$6.50 

5163 

480 
lit 
$17 

65 

li.ao 

$78 

18 

$6.50 

$117 

610 
lit 
$31 

35 

$1.30 

$43 

0 

31 

$15.00 
$315 

1975 
$0.25 
$494 

$60 

44.3  ft. 
$61.00 
$3700 

5$ 
$300 

$4307 

Flo.  43c. 

■ 


1127 


Estimate 

of  Quant 

ities  and 

Costs 

Height 

in  Ft. 

Item 

N   e 

a   t  w  o 

r   k 

F  o   o    t    i    n    p 

Cu.Yds. 
of   Exc. 

Piles 

Cu.Yds. 
of  Fill 

Falne- 
«ork 

Engng. 
and 
Inoi- 

Grand 
Total 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

8q.    Yds. 
of   Forms 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cone. 

Lbs.   of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forms 

cl 

13 

Quant  - 
itiee 
Unit 
Cost 

38 

$6.50 
$247 

680 
$34 

130 

$1.20 

$144 

34 
$6.50 
$156 

700 
3i# 
$25 

32 
$1.20 

$38 

79 

$1.50 

$119 

0 

171 

$0.25 

$43 

0 

$96 

$893 

30 

Quant  - 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

100 

$6.50 

8650 

5050 

$177 

316 
$1.30 
$379 

45 

$6.50 
$393 

2380 

$83 

48 

$1.30 
<>58 

183 

$1.50 
273 

0 

630 
$0.25 
$158 

0 

i3<r 

$349 

$2330 

38 

Quant  - 
ities 
Unit 

Cost 

183 
$6.50 
$1190 

9950 

$348 

608 

$1.30 

$730 

113 

$6.50 

$735 

7754 

zy. 

$271 

80 

$1.30 

$96 

358 

$1.50 
$537 

85 

$8.00 

$680 

1703 

$0.25 

$436 

0 

13$ 

$603 

$5615 

36 

Quant  - 
it  ies 
Unit 
Coat 

306 
$6.50 
$1989 

16600 
$581 

1007 
$1.30 
$1208 

176 

$6.50 
$1144 

13070 

3i# 

$422 

86 

$1.30 

$103 

603 

$1.50 

$903 

141 
$8.00 
$1138 

3450 
$0.35 

$963 

0 

13$ 
$1001 

$9341 

C3 

13 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

37 

$6.50 
$341 

3440 
$85 

134 

$1.30 

$161 

10 

$5.00 

$50 

200 

14 

$1.20 
$17 

30 

$1.50 

$45 

0 

80 

$0.35 

$20 

$10 

$51 

$  687 

30 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

103 

$6.50 

$663 

6730 

$336 

349 

$1.30 

$419 

20 
$6.50 
$130 

900 

zU 

$33 

34 
$1.20 

$41 

65 

$1.50 

$98 

0 

300 

$0.35 

$75 

$30 

8f, 
$137 

$1851 

38 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

189 
$6.50 
$1339 

13130 
3i# 

$435 

60S 

$1.20 

$733 

37 

$6.50 

$241 

1180 
3*# 

$41 

41 

$1.30 

$49 

130 

$1.50 

$195 

0 

630 

$0.35 

$158 

$30 

8* 
$347 

$3337 

36 

Quant  - 
it  ies 
Unit 
Cost 

304 
$6.50 
$1976 

30000 

zU 

|700 

1015 
$1.30 
$1318 

43 

*5,00 

$310 

840 
$39 

74 

$1.30 

69 

140 

$1.50 
«310 

54 

$8.00 
$433 

1300 

$0.35 
$300 

$30 

si 

$416 

»5610 

Fig.  i 

13d. 

1127 


Estimate  of  Quantities  and  Coete 

Hoi»ht 

in  Ft  . 

Item 

Floor 

llltllrt 

Cu.   Yds. 
of  Fxca- 
vatlon 

Piles 

Cu.Yds. 
of  Fill 

False- 
work 

Change    in 
Length  of 
Bridge  One 

Engn». 
Incl- 

Crand 
Total 

of  Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.    tin. 

of  Forme 

Cu.    Yds. 
of  Cone. 

Lob.    of 
Stc?l 

Sq.   Yds. 
of  Forms 

Cu.    Yds. 
of  Cono. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forms 

13 

Unit 

Cost 

0 

0 

0 

29 
36.50 
3189 

1875 
tit 

166 

103 
31.20 
3124 

11.5 

36.50 

375 

405 
514 

0 

35 

51.50 

838 

0 

80 

80.35 

320 

310 

40   ft. 

861.00 

8244 

.8* 
863 

8943 

20 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

0 

0 

0 

68 
"6.50 
3   442 

4400 
3154 

198 
81.20 
3239 

18 
36.50 
8117 

630 
tit 
522 

0 

36 

31.50 
854 

0 

350 

80.25 

S63 

330 

10.0  ft. 

361.00 

8610 

9', 
8138 

31958 

-"' 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

0 

0 

0 

104 
36.50 
3   676 

67.20 

Jit 

5235 

345 
31.20 
3414 

29 
56.50 
5189 

1020 
536 

0 

63 

81.50 

895 

0 

690 
80.25 
8173 

330 

16.0   ft. 

861.00 

8976 

8* 
8336 

'3050 

36 

Quant- 
ities 

Cost 

0 

0 

0 

160 
36.50 
11040 

10350 
tit 

8363 

535 
81.20 
3642 

39 
f.6.50 

Sie9 

1000 
335 

0 

55 

81.50 

383 

43 
58.00 
3336 

1300 
80.35 
8335 

330 

32.0  ft. 
861.00 
81340 

5351 

84733 

13 

Unit 

8 

56.50 
"52 

2180 
tit 
5  76 

48 
32.50 
3120 

31 
»6.50 
3202 

1950 
tit 

568 

25  |99 
£  50fl  SO 

$65  f#"9 

16 

55.00 

380 

400 
514 

81.20 

529 

60 

81.50 

590 

0 

70 

80.35 

819 

330 

10JS 
895 

81046 

30 

Unit 

C0  3t 

15 

36.50 

398 

4100 

tit 

5144 

81 
52.50 
3203 

69 
36.50 
3449 

4340 
tit 
5152 

A  5    l£24. 

2  5ofi  20 

31 
36.50 
3203 

2110 
tit 
574 

47 

51.20 

556 

100 
31.50 
3150 

0 

300 

50.35 
550 

840 

10* 
3300 

83300 

28 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

21 

55.50 
3137 

5370 
tit 
S201 

lis 

32.50 
(268 

114 
56.50 
3741 

7180 
tit 
3251 

too 
zso 

J250 

2  98 
1.20 
|35S 

41 
86.50 
3267 

2790 

398 

65 
31.20 

578 

130 
31.50 
5195 

0 

550 
80.35 
S138 

(60 

10* 
8306 

33368 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 

27 
46.50 
0176 

7360 
A* 

f25e 

148 
32.50 
3370 

175 
86.50 
31138 

11000 
tit 
3385 

g  50 
|  51" 

55* 
'1.20 

i,    I 

68 
35.00 
3340 

1500 
34 1 
353 

94 
51.20 
5113 

320 
81.50 
8330 

63 
38.00 
3496 

1050 
80.35 
8263 

360 

10* 
8493 

85428 

Fig.  43c 


1127 


Estimate  of  Quantities  and    Coats 

Height 
in  Ft  . 

Item 

Floor 

Ou.   Yds. 
of  Exca- 
vation 

Piles 

Ou.Ydn. 
of  Fill 

Falso- 
nork 

Change    In 
Length  of 
Dridgo  One 
Abutment 

F.njns.4 
Incid- 
entals 

Grind 
Total 

Cu.    Vdo. 

of    Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.    Vde. 
of   Forma 

Cu.    Ydo. 
of   Conr. 

Lbs. of 
fit  eel 

Sq.    Yde. 
of  Forms, 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Conn. 

bba.    of 
Gteel 

Sq.    Ydn. 
of  Forms 

C5 

20 

Quant- 

Unit 

Coat 

30 
86.50 
S195 

2740 
3$* 
596 

80 
51.20 
S96 

49 
{6.50 
3319 

3S68 
593 

130 
$1.20 

3156 

48 
36.50 
8312 

2373 
(83 

0 

67 
{1.50 

5101 

26 

58.00 
8208 

239 

30.35 

560 

3 100 

2.2   ft. 

861.00 

8140 

10)1 
3196 

33155 

28 

Quant- 
Cost 

48 
{6.50 
3312 

5250 
Jit 
$184 

135 
51.20 
3163 

90 
56.50 
{585 

6873 
3i(t 
3241 

250 
81.20 
$300 

84 
36.50 
3546 

7198 
3852 

0 

130 
31.50 
{195 

44 

5a. oo 

3352 

550 
30.35 
8138 

3300 

0.5   ft. 

$61.00 
330 

10* 
$350 

8384  7 

36 

Quant- 
ities 

Unit 
Coat 

51 
06.  50 

{332 

5296 
3j* 
{185 

140 
51.20 
5168 

125 
fG.,50 
8813 

8923 
3312 

345 
31.20 
3414 

113 

36.50 
3735 

9853 
5345 

0 

145 
81.50 
{318 

53 
38.00 
3416 

1050 
30.35 
8363 

$300 

8.0  ft. 

Sfil.00 

8490 

10* 

8489 

55379 

41 

Unit 
Cost 

81 
86.50 
8527 

7781 
(272 

200 
31.30 
5240 

234 
36.50 
31521 

15165 
3i* 

5531 

570 
31.30 
5684 

153 
56.50 
3995 

13354 
3439 

0 

244 
Si. 50 
3366 

80 
88.00 
$640 

1913 
SO. 35 
5478 

$300 

5.3  ft. 

861.00 
8320 

10* 

$730 

38033 

C6 

12 

Quant- 
ities 

Coat 

13 

56.50 

585 

1038 
336 

33 
52.50 

583 

33 
36.50 
$315 

1084 
338 

80 

31.20 

396 

20 
36.50 
{130 

890 

;£# 

331 

31 

31.20 

525 

50 
81.50 

375 

0 

63 

30.35 

316 

8io 

10* 
384 

}  934 

20 

it  loo 
Unit 

23 
16.50 
$150 

1835 
3j(( 
564 

58 

?2.50 
5145 

72 
56.50 
3468 

3365 

w 

383 

177 
81.30 
3313 

33 
86.50 
{215 

3000 

W 

370 

37 

31.20 

844 

83 

31.50 
8135 

0 

334 

80.35 
$56 

320 

10* 
J165 

81817 

se 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Coat 

33 
{6.50 
$215 

2633 
3i# 

592 

84 
«3.50 
8310 

133 
36.50 
8865 

4371 
3iK 
3153 

301 
31.20 
5361 

50 
86.50 
3335 

5066 
Sl77 

53 

81.30 
362 

130 
*1.50 
3195 

0 

467 
80.25 
8117 

830 

10* 
8280 

{3082 

30 

quant- 
ities 

Unit 

43 

JO. 50 

f2eo 

3430 
$120 

108 
52.50 
5270 

208 
56.50 
51352 

6840 

A* 

3339 

471 
31.20 
5565 

82 
36.50 
8533 

8330 

Mt 

3391 

82 
Si. 20 
{98 

200 
51.50 
3300 

0 

1100 
80.35 
8350 

$30 

10* 
$433 

$4761 

1127 


3a  to  43g. 

ESTIMATE    OF   QUANTITIES   AND    COSTS. 


Est  imate   of  Quantities   and   Costa 

Height 

Item 

Floor 

II   e   a  t    *  o    r   * 

F  o    0    t    i    n    e    s 

Cu.   Yds. 
of  Exc. 

Files 

Cu.Yds. 
of  Fill 

False- 
work 

Enene,   & 
incid- 
entals 

Grand 
Total 

Cu.    Yds. 
of  Cone. 

Lbs.   of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of   Forn.s 

Cu.    Yds. 
of   Cone. 

Lbs.    of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of    Forms 

Cu.    Yds. 
of  Cone. 

Lbs. of 
Steel 

Sq.    Yds. 
of  Forms 

c7 

13 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

12 
$6.50 
$78 

2960 
5104 

54 
$3.50 
$135 

34 
$£.50 
$156 

910 
$32 

76 
$1.20 

$91 

14 

$5.00 

870 

250 
11 

18 

$1.30 

$33 

40 

$1.50 

$60 

0 

60 
80.35 

♦is 

0 

6* 

♦63 

$834 

30 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

31 
16.50 
#137 

5170 
1161 

91 

$2.50 
$328 

58 
$6.50 
$377 

2190 
3±# 
$77 

186 
$1.30 
$223 

36 
$6.50 
$169 

1380 
$40 

31 

$1.30 
$37 

70 
$1.50 
$105 

0 

190 

$0.35 

$48 

0 

B<f, 
$130 

$1760 

38 

qruant- 

Unit 
Cost 

41 
$G.50 
8267 

10100 

Ht 

$354 

129 
43.50 
$333 

87 
$6.50 

3390 
3j# 
$115 

383 
$1.30 
$340 

36 
$6.50 
$234 

1910 
3i* 
$67 

37 

fl.20 

$44 

100 
$1.50 
$150 

0 

500 
$0.35 
$125 

0 

8'" 
8307 

$2793 

36 

Quant- 
ities 
Unit 
Cost 

45 

86.50 
3293 

11100 
3^ 
$309 

16G 

$3.50 
$415 

145 
$6.50 
$943 

5480 
3itf 

$193 

451 

$1.20 
$541 

61 
$6.50 
$397 

3340 

$113 

53 

$1.20 
$64 

150 
$1.50 
$235 

0 

950 
$0.25 
$238 

0 

Bf. 
$305 

84115 

1127 


(44-                           J                  J        1  |  1  1  1  ITTTT 

-'tt^I 

•- 

Nlv                         ^v.,           ''-vv 

'^ 

""-^              ^v^       ~  *- 

V^oo^ 

\ 

\ 

r 

Vv*            ^  4 

4,. :<;^C 

"-^4: 

«  - 

^\           v--- 

<N 

« 

4_     _                                     ^-^ 

V.                           S     "N^v 

ii 

-V. 

\ 

«7 

£|              15    „>> 

S. 

•n. 

-. 

- 

M          §  X\ 

^         V^ft       ^                  ^ 

%* 

\ 

s 

"S"'** 

^. 

'. 

§  5                     ^  ■*-     -SJ 

^^s      ^  N^ 

*&•**_. 

„ 

^ 

tl 

^  ti                   £  ?  -  «> 

^v*     ^ v"  s^. 

"SS^is 

_ 

^ 

i 

^"v^     ^~_ 

^ks.1*. 

"- 

4-"% 

X 

>J               ^  ? |  * 

^ 

rs> 

4^ 

*o 

■*» 

k4  .  ^ 

^ 

H 

!■**        ^°*      - 

^4 

•s 

"•i^ 

^N 

1*1      ^h'^o,   £ 

'o 

^> 

^N 

V^*H*f$fi5  1 

^ 

^s~ 

, 

?cr  •*?■*;  ft<"cV^^                   -     - 

=^4 

^4 

■ 

|<ii:«{^«  ^iPt^^ai^ 

'^ 

J> 

-X 

, 

1  Hi 

U'l^^^H^h 

~" 

^ 

_\ 

S 

Ny 

i 
t: 

8^^S§c^«^ 

-^CNi 

v 

| 

^.M^^M!^         — -             

~v 

V 

^ 

-, 

s 

J, 

» 

O^i^U   uJoi^^R 

;J 

ftj    "^   1*1    «0    S-    qj    ^    s   Hi    "1    t    K)  O    K 

s 

1^ 

& 

. 

0^ 

N 

' 

?  £&f&&£  1  MIR^ 

^4  " 

N., 

■,i 

oo 

j  as 

y« 

Ll 

ll" 

u  - 

<-_e/,c,£'    'ji  '  s>  <;>/  7f<j<?^  -t 

L4 

■- 

:n<ja 

3„0 

>■= 

:o-i 

- 

c\           9            ^            o           o            9 

0                Q                0                0                § 

as           a           a           a 

;i 

0 

r 

0 

:: 

( 

. 

ST      *           o            *           °            "S 

os    ]          to          |    o              i-              r-              -0 

o            «            a            5            § 

MS                   ">                   «)                   *                   * 

* 

m 

" 

i 

c 

5 

■Cs 

q;  ^ 
V  * 

in   k. 

v. 

o 

I 

C3 


'' 

t 

"' 

■ 

I- 

l; 

; 

CS 

j 

1 

.* 

a 

- 

• 

■*• 

t 

t 

1] 

i 

! 

4~ 

I 

(1 

«1 

• 

\ 

S 

■3"; 

1 

.' 

■ 

c 

..v* 

T 

m 

si 

0 

tv 

§ 

<k 

0 

10 

r 

v^ 

1. 

r^ 

P 

>0 

5 

* 

■u 

ni 

v 

l> 

<k 

^ 

0 

ft 

■k 

0) 

0 

0 

IV 

0 

^ 

\ 

+- 

% 

m 

V 

0 
u 

tr, 

k- 

•: 

0 

- 

U) 

i 

<•, 

k 

6 

'-. 

St 


In.     h  and  45 

COSTS    OF    ABUTMENTS    OF   VARIOUS    HEIGHTS. 


<c 

( 

G  ly 

IJ 

(j 

" 

- 

0 

"if 

- 

'  — 

p*- 

^ 

\ 

\ 

M 

r 

\ 

. 

" 

- 

N 

' 

\ 

\ 

. 

\ 

+t- 

1* 

>, 

s 

\ 

\ 

w 

V 

■\ 

*-- 
■I 

" 

^ 

^ 

S 

\ 

s 

1 

,\ 

V— 

- 

\ 

\ 

\ 

*v 

V 

\ 

tl 

El      ^  ^ 

0  ^  5  £  Q.  Q.  Q.   Nu^i^Ks 
U  '    '   i    i   i   i    gl  i   i   I   I    i  1   I 
^  co  iQ  oq  cffOQ  >Q    (J  u  0  U  U  0  U  U 

0.  ^^^|b^  $  ^^^^(b 

^~ 

k- 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\ 

« 

*r\ 

*  ^» 

^ 

\ 

&* 

:\ 

kx 

\^ 

' 

~~~. 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\ 

v 

>' 

f- 

^ 

■^ 

Sj 

\ 

\l 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\ 

\l 

^. 

^ 

^5 

\ 

0 

V 

o\ 

\s 

>\ 

r 
5 

\ 

\ 

">s 

\ 

V 

V 

V 

.,\ 

\ 

P*1 

r«-'^ 

\ 

\ 

\\ 

-n 

rt 

V. 

V> 

\ 

\ 

-v 

\ 

\ 

V 

\ 

O 

"^ 

s, 

*., 

\\ 

\ 

\\ 

f~ 

^  v- 

-s 

.\ 

s 

^_ 

1 

\ 

\ 

\ 

0 

v^_ 

»o 

\ 

\ 

\\ 

\\ 

K 

x 

v*x 

sN 

0 

.    \ 

v 

\ 

N 

v 

\ 

s.s 

^ 

\ 

A 

V 

N, 

\ 

\\ 

s 

\ 

i 

lj— 

\\ 

\\ 

\ 

>i- 

s 

*o 

\  \ 

^^5 

Vi 

iw 

\ 

1 
111 

m 

0, 

(71 

;? 

^ 

* 

"m 

//. 

p 

4 

—  4. 

=     i 

u 

-*-> 

40 

=  ^ 

j><>  4:. 011 

0" 

>'*;', 

i'!< 

u'lj 

'■•" 

-.1' 

0 

8 

0 

?; 

l 

8 

\ 

•1 
-1 

0 

ft 

i. 

1" 

M 

8 

CVi 

$ 

Cs 

I 

'j 

is  § 
Q 


1127 


-~ 

II 

j 

fl[ 

Of 

1? 

' 

r  ■-.. 

HQ4? 

j 

J 

i 

' 

\ 

\ 

N\ 

V- 

-V- 

\-l 

1 

^ 

I 

V 

\ 

\ 

\ 

V 

\ 

.  v. 

\ 

V 

a 

^ 

0 

^ 

\ 

* 

G\\\ 

\ 

1 

\ 

\ 

\ 

T 

\ 

« 

\ 

\ 

\ 

,  i\ 

\ 

k  o                        k       ns 
k  «i                    k  c  J> .  Q 

0     ^        c  S-|  ^  os-     y 

U  ^  «   i  «   H     ^2  *  '  '   "  '   ? 

s  £  i  a  C  $  c  ^<3iii<c^k 
n  i  i  i  i  i  i  u  i  i  i  i  i  i  i 

^  «o  m  id  m  to  tr  {js  (j  u  0  u  JCfJ 
~  *  v  v  v  v  u   ^"""tiwSS 

\ 

V 

V 

11 

s 

^ 

>. 

ii 

\ 

5  - 

\ 

\ 

,3 

i 

!\ 

\ 

Q 

v" 

\ 

-1 

T- 

tf 

j 

v 

\ 

\N 

J_ 

-' 

<»' 

i 

\ 

\ 

& 
M 

1 

1' 

1 

\  - 

K 

\ 

' 

\ 

\ 

0 

* 

\ 

'\ 

^ 

A 

<\ 

\ 

V 

I 

\\ 

\ 

\y 

J, 

ii 

\ 

V1:! 

^ 

■  'ij 

\:i' 

\ 

{ 

1 

a 

V 

i\ 

\\ 

1 

\ 

\ 

\\ 

A 

\ 

1 

. 

V 

K 

'1 

I 

\ 

N 

Y 

\ 

i\\f 

% 

y> 

" 

$* 

s. 

a 

■r:  ' 

■f  -> 

,^ 

tn 

?e> 

"3 

.a 

uc 

J- 

,.=» 

&u> 

->=>_, 

j/ 

0  4 

3 

it 

u"0 

ft 

L"    T! 

UC, 

3 

0 

Q 

0 

'■ 

0 

f. 

1 

15 

HI 

»< 

h 

, 

"'. 

0 

0 

1127 


Ij 

iff 

$  0 

«?  tf 

u 

(j      U 

iJ_IOjj    U 

U 

~~ 

^ 

.Sin 

5*fcs 

\ 

%      "*> 

v"\ 

ri") 

v.- 

%b. 

\    \ 

\>N\ 

•0 

•^ 

\ 

\\\^ 

^ 

^ 

■S^ 

^ 

\ 'w; 

('V'^1 

a 

El        k  ,< 

*!■■-•  n°?^^^t 

o  §  s  a  a  a  a.  ^u^ii^KP 

0  '  '  '  '  '- '„  ^  L '  '  '  L, '*  s 

;>  to1  «? «? oo  io  <o  §  Cu^u  i?u  u  u 

k»h«»!   J  »  •»»«  «n 

^ 

. 

\\^\ 

?Q 

'«.' 

v<.. 

\ 

\\\ 

\ 

?*> 

N^ 

\\ 

*^\ 

-V 

\\ 

v\ 

8 

'o 

~*k 

o\ 

X 

0 

^ 

\^N 

*k, 

v  >\ 

^ 

\\  N 

N 

\ 

%. 

I    ^ 

0 

\\ 

"1 

\.  ^ 

>l 

N\ 

^ 

^ 

^x 

So 

.       "vTl'V             CHl 

\\ 

A  i 

w 

\ 

ft 

\s 

\v 

\\ 

Ab 

\ 

Vr 

\\ 

\V\ 

X 

*l  \ 

L) 

iff   h 

C-IO//0, 

cu+nqt3 

auo    t* 

■>qz>   ^s-c 

a  +u*<. 

uyu&Q 

■U3 

0 

0 

Ci 

0 

0 

0 

0 

0 

0 

0 

0 

«1 

0) 

5 

01 

«0 

r- 

to 

m 

^ 

Kl 

cu 

0 

1127 


Figs.  59,  60,  62. 

COST    OF    NEATWORK    OF   ABUTMENT. 

COST   OF    FOUNDATION    OF   ABUTMENT. 

COST    OF   EMBANKMENT. 


IOCI  I   I    UIUUUI 


rer  -  Mease  Insert  Foldout  here 
rage  Warier 
iisert  Foldout 

er  -  Please  Insert  Foldout  here 
3age  Marker 
lsert  Foldout 

^aae.  Marker 

:er  -  Please  Insert  Foldout  here 
'age  Marker 
isert  Foldout 

.  -  PL6XSE  INSERT  FOLDOUT  H€W 
6  KAXKKtK 
PJ  FOLDOUT 

lease  Insert  roldoiit  In 
Mar* 
roldoiil 

let  -  J^fea^e  Jngeff  ^iJ&uf  here 
aye  J$$af^er 

$erf  f^fcW 


-  Please  Insert  Foldoul  here 


ffi 


rker 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1127 


1 

.t  r  - 

a 

t- 

>6 

- 

1 

7 

I 

i    i 

>  / 

-h^ 

- 

zs 

V 

,i 

/ 

/, 

& 

^ 

4A 

& 

f* 

H 

>— 

1 

t 

* 

IN 

{) 

'.- 

■U 

1 

C 

/ 

01 

f 

i 

k 

/ 

+> 

3 

P<A 

'JC 

1 

/ 

< 

j 

' 

j) 

/ 

li 

/ 

0) 

1 

/ 

C 

2 

5C 

>d 

1 

0 

1 

i 

1 

i 

/ 

,Q 

1 

i 

/ 

'i 

1 

Vi 

/ 

■k 

e 

CC 

■>o 

i 

~t 

' 

r' 

in 

/ 

IJ/ 

f 

0 

/ 

< 

/ 

U 

/ 

r 

/ 

/ 

/ 

/ 

i 

/. 

>C 

0 

/ 

^ 

/ 

' 

<■ 

f 

\ 

t 

, 

■ 

o 

/ 

/ 

/ 

y 

\ 

f 

■ 

r 

K 

7" 

A 

y 

/£ 

~>G 

0 

• 

n 

/, 

• 

{ 

/ 

V 

/ 

K 

y 

/ 

| 

^ 

5 

0 

') 

„ 

/' 

f 

!, 

r 

s 

' 

_ 

_- 

- 

-f 

■/  e 

k' 

**" 

f 

r 

e 

vy 

S 

^ 

Ji5 

r 

! 

n 

« 

si 

'" 

ir 

' 

( 

•^ 

hi 

s 

z 

■VL 

t>/ 

■X: 

C 

— 

" 

'. 

n- 

ii 

3 

— 

-- 

-- 

"- 

fi- 

- 

— (- 

-" 

1 

10'  15'  £0'  25'  50'  35' 

Heiqht  of  crbufme.nt,-  bar  se    of  re?  if 
to  qrounaf    I  eve  f  art   toe.    of   5/ope^ 

Type.    B& 
Fig.  46 


1128 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


i 

— h 

ii 

3= 

7 

H 

Hi 

L 

*== 

■,  ; 

6 

5< 

76 

>- 

— 

-( 

/ 

X, 

i 

i 

X 

A 

/ 

/ 

5 

5 

SX 

?" 

11 

-4 

p 

■3/* 

3 

- 

/ 

r- 

t 

.' 

./ 

•5 

t 

-- 

— 

-4 

€> 

£?- 

S^ 

' 

■v 

/ 

0 

/ 

ti 

r 

i 

3 

5. 

3( 

3 

i 

c 

/ 

' 

1 

r 

1 

1 

Q) 

1 

I 

E 
*» 

3 

Pi 

^C 

3 

/ 

/ 

i 

5 

' 

/ 

-Cs 

1 

-r< 

/ 

f 

C5 

1 

/ 

Il- 

s 

5 

0 

0 

' 

/ 

ls 

r 

\ 

0 

0 

% 

' 

^s 

I, 

|5 

;C  _ 

\  A 

-\l 

'/ 

ja. 

'+- 

2 

£3 

?« 

1 

'- 

V 

k 

-k 

-,  - 

r\ 

<u 

0 

{ 1 

A 

V 

V 

/ 

/ 

50- 

/ 

/ 

/ 

5( 

?< 

7 

/ 

/ 

*c 

/ 

i 

/ 

/ 

t 

> 

-fck 

/ 

' 

/( 

2r 

>£ 

> 

/ 

/ 

W 

/ 

- 

\< 

-- 

- 

+ 

\\ 

.c 

U- 

./ 

\< 

0) 

' 

il 

)' 

> 

45* 

G 

0 

/ 

Y 

_£_ 

.. 

^ 

"C^r 

.. 

,- 

/h 

? 

V 

pi 

•f 

-'- 

<! 

;=>^ 

; 

-r 

... 

-- 

1 

^ 

/ 

ri 

r" 

_  £!, 

C 

=^-U4==-- 

-- 

-T 

/<?'  15'  ao'  25'  30'  35' 

Height  of  abutment,-  ba^e-    of  rail 
to  ground   leve.1  art   toe*   o-f  s/opo^ 

Type,    B3 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1129 


5 

5 

3 

> 

5 

0 

3 

) 

) 

/ 

/ 

/ 

4 

5 

P 

3 

r 

/ 

? 

' 

/' 

V 

m 

t 

/ 

t. 

/ 

*os 

s 

O 

P 

3 

/ 

■*- 

/ 

^3 

/ 

/ 

Q 

*■ 

3 

5 

?i 

' 

•k 

■ 

F: 

/ 

/ 

5 

5 

O 

r< 

1 

/ 

/ 

,■ 

_> 

■ 

/ 

_c 

&, 

/ 

j! 

t» 

/ 

< 

- 

£ 

,? 

5 

? 

i 

/ 

>, 

0 

/ 

i 

'. 

t- 

« 

i 

( 

% 

/ 

J 

■  / 

' 

\ 

?• 

•k 

f 

0 

p. 

3 

/ 

<h 

U) 

^ 

/ 

(■ 

■ 

•0 

o 

)/ 

o 

y 

0 

/ 

(i 

/ 

/ 

/. 

X 

^c 

r 

■' 

e- 

/ 

£ 

$ 

& 

/ 

'C 

~>a 

c 

0 

>' 

> 

< 

<\ 

/ 

-f- 

f\ 

Vl 

)j_ 

-~ 

"■ 

' 

hj 

" 

.-■ 

5 

Ot 

p 

. 

-.' 

r7 

a 

f 

- 

-- 

r< 

,  J 

"-i 

c^ 

<  i 

i 

^ 

~ 

-/ 

O 

- 

~- 

- 

- 

/<?'  /5'  <?<?'  <?5'  JO'  35 

/-/eight  of  abutment,  -  b  ase.   of  rail 
to  grounaf   /eve/  at  toe-    of  s/op&^ 

Type.    B5 
Fiq.  4& 


1130 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


5 

5( 

7C 

1 

/ 

5 

(9 

-J( 

? 

/ 

/ 

0 

/ 

'■' 

/< 

/ 

4 

5< 

It 

? 

' 

/ 

/ 

10 

/ 

^ 

fc 

/ 

4 

<?< 

?C 

p 

/ 

/ 

0 

/ 

/ 

i; 

3 

5< 

?C 

b 

c 

5 

5 

■0 

3 

PC 

1C 

i 

/ 

/ 

/ 

Ci 

1 

,' 

<tf 

/' 

* 

C 

a 

5C 

K 

i 

f' 

0 

j 

\J 

/ 

l 

6 

/ 

o 

.V 

• 

^ 

\ 

A 

' 

■k 

a 

9C 

>C 

y 

}/ 

<" 

r 

U) 

0.i 

1 

>«* 

-- 

0 

A 

y>, 

/ 

u 

/ 

V 

' 

/ 

c 

i 

/. 

56 

o 

/ 

/ 

\\ 

— 

/ 

( 

p. 

/ 

\ 

/ 

/ 

/(1 

■>c 

c 

/ 

\\ 

' 

n 

£, 

«-- 

.< 

9 

\o 

,, 

*- 

,sr1 

i& 

2 

■  r 

'1 

./,/ 

o 

,f 

4 

' 

I 

fl 

ija 

r 

0, 

l^ 

5 

0( 

? 

/ 

-_ 

i 

'- 

__ 

i" 

£■ 

// 

i 

.-.< 

0 



[-- 

— 

f 

•a 

3 

>£ 

e. 

n 

o 

" 

L 

/£>'  /5"'  ao'  S5'  30'  35' 

Height  of  abutment,  -  ba^e.   of  rail 
to  q  round    level  at   toe.    of  slopes 

Type.    S6 


Fig. 


4-9 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1131 


" 

5 

5 

?c 

? 

5 

0( 

>c 

J       - 

/ 

7     - 

4 

5< 

j  a 

1 

.  / 

-0? 

s 

^ 

££- 

Is 

J 

IS 

4- 

c?< 

'X 

) 

T 

■s. 

7 

u 

0 

-V 

z 

c 

.5 

5( 

~'C 

1 

a) 

/ 

5 

<5 

5 

9< 

-JC 

/ 

J 

1 

/ 

01 

~7 

^' 

e 

? 

5C 

~>c 

_f~ 

Jf.^' 

0 

/ 

-»<£' 

( 

~? 

/■^^ 

1° 

_)< 

*£- 

V 

t 

■k 

?. 

?( 

->c 

j> 

7-                & 

• 

»i 

y                  S- 

u 

\ 

r                 £^ 

U 

.' 

V 

c/ 

A 

1/ 

$4 

1 

5C 

•)C 

\, 

/ 

-,^S 

V 

22 

/ 

l^i 

/ 

&z 

t 

*v 

It 

>C 

o 

x( 

t 

V 

— ,~-i^- 

c 

/ 

^£^7^ 

' 

r- 

^  -""  —  —  -"'So.'? 

5 

0 

Q 

/ 

r 

sri-'S 

^UCL^^      - 

_■-  — 'S^^5" 

— 

m~ 

—  ~~ 

,.  —  ^ 

^i//     -=-- 

-""          T 

,-F'a/  t'Qwo'"^ 

o 

- 

'- 

■" 

±          -^    --      . 

/<?'  /5'  fO'  £5V  30'  35' 

Height  of  abutment,-  bcrse.    of  rcri/ 

to  qrounc/    /eve/  crt   toe,    of   slopo- 

Type,    B  7 


Fig 


.50 


1132 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


5 

5 

?< 

' 

5 

■9 

?l 

■) 

•7 

5 

■)(. 

' 

"1 

(. 

/ 

J3 

4 

£?< 

K 

-> 

/ 

V 

/ 

/ 

') 

^ 

/ 

<0 

*> 

c- 

3 

^ 

:Z 

<< 

)/ 

*" 

) 

'\ 

■k 

c 

/ 

E 

/ 

i. 

5 

3, 

'JC 

1 

J 

& 

) 

< 

UA 

/ 

(I) 

x, 

\>, 

e 

2 

5i 

'>c 

> 

o] 

o 

,<• 

Y, 

t 

r^ 

r 

\>, 

k 

i 

•k 

2 

?< 

bc 

t 

■  \ 

V; 

6 

' 

U 

( 

/ 

v 

>> 

n 

K, 

/ 

;. 

VI 

/- 

A 

fo 

c 

<ri 

'/ 

/ 

f 

V 

w! 

v- 

n 

i 

/ 

»:d 

>d 

>o 

r 

V 

<" 

~.r 

* 

1  / 

0 

/ 

f 

5 

0 

■} 

< 

n 

fi 

a 

J 

-' 

u 

ir- 

~r 

f 

7 

r 

,- 1 

/ 

^ 

^, 

-f- 

a 

It 

'  £ 

r 

'C 

I/1 

fc 

C 

-- 

- 

-- 

»• 

-- 

" 

""" 

IO'  15'  SO'  ?5'  30'  35' 

Hei  cjht  o-f  abutment,-  base,   o-Trcr// 
to  ground  level  at  toe    of  slopes- 
Type-    Be 


Fig.  51 


3 

5*5 

/ 

* 

* 

— 

/ 

/ 

■=i 

!ff 

\r. 

/ 

4j> 

/- 

'  / 

W 

(•- 

7 

£_ 

i 

/ 

/ 

/ 

/ 

«) 

k 

St? 

<s 

/ 

/ 

i 

u 

/ 

(1 

/ 

> 

/ 

r' 

r 

1 

/ 

t 

/ 

/ 

■k 

/ 

k 

0 

// 

f 

3 

OC 

>c 

/ 

/U/ 

/ 

1 

\ 

,7 

i 

*] 

h/ 

A 

^ 

' 

// 

'J 

CN 

r 

7 

/ 

3 

PC 

"vC 

K 

g 

w 

/ 

/( 

i 

c. 

/ 

I 

r 

/ 

/ 

1. 

(/ 

s 

e 

JC 

)C 

i 

. 

-k 

/ 

C 

<0 

r 

/ 

0 

j 

,- 

u 

/ 

<! 

<? 

7£ 

>c 

i 

' 

i 

1 

■1 

1 

/ 

/ 

/ 

/ 

N 

/ 

•V 

/ 

A 

rc 

o> 

/ 

/ 

/ 

' 

/ 

,( 

i  / 

/ 

c 

/ 

K 

; 

,- 

,0 

/ 

z1 

/ 

( 

/ 

fd 

)/ 

/<: 

?c 

'C 

*» 

{/ 

v 

/ 

r> 

/ 

/ 

/ 

tv 

/, 

/ 

ii 

y 

lx 

/ 

fj 

!> 

^ 

/ 

5 

0 

3 

• 

/ 

t 

-' 

'' 

F 

;"/ 

1 

d 

10'  15'  ao'  ?5'  30'  55 

Hei  ghf  oT  abutment,-  base,  o -Trail 
to  ground  leve.1  at  toe.    oT  slopo- 

Type,    C/ 
Fiqz5t 


1134 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


6 

?c 

K 

5 

5C 

'<C 

/ 

/ 

/ 

1 

/ 

5 

Ot 

>a 

/ 

1 

/ 

v 

i 

/ 

K! 

/ 

4 

5C 

o 

1 

1 

i 

<0 

j 

k 

1 

/ 

is 

4 

Ot 

It 

i 

i 

s 

1 

I 

-J, 

/ 

1 

if 

c 

1 

** 

3 

K 

o 

/ 

*' 

/ 

Q 

1 

V 

i 

i 

AC 

/ 

5 

1 

/ 

t 

"3 

3 

DC 

•c 

1 

/ 

•0 

i 

/ 

ft 

/ 

/ 

/ 

, 

a) 

/ 

/ 

n 

? 

?C 

•o 

/ 

/ 

/ 

/ 

Pi 

/ 

/ 

c 

/ 

/ 

•k 

/ 

/ 

in 

E 

C'C 

><3 

/ 

/ 

0 

/ 

/ 

0 

. 

i 

* 

/ 

/ 

/ 

y 

i 

>C 

0 

/ 

: 

/ 

■' 

/ 

V 

/ 

,■' 

'/ 

/ 

, 

I 

n 

vc 

o 

* 

\ 

' 

I 

< 

/ 

P 

'' 

V 

K 

- 

0 

5 

0 

3 

< 

-/ 

a 

1 ' 

c 

r; 

0 

!  j 

(,7 

/ 

- 

F 

!i 

f 

"^ 

c 

" 

" 

"" 

IO'  15'  SO'  £5'  30'  55' 

Heicjhfo-fabufrr>en-f-,-bc?5e.   o-Frcti/ 
to  ground   I  eve./  at   toe.    of  s  /ope^ 

Type,    C2 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1135 


10' 


15'  SO'  25'  30' 

Heiqht  of  abutment,-  base    of  nail 

to  ground    level  at   toe-    of  s/ope>- 

Type,    C3 
Fig.  54 


1136 


DESIGN 

c 

F 

1 

BI 

a 

D 

G 

E 

y 

VI 

$t 

IT 

A' 

t* 

S» 

fT 

s 

6 

->■ 

•>c 

> 

5 

5C 

rC 

1 

/ 

\ 

/ 

5 

Ot 

ic 

> 

W 

X 

y 

^ 

1 

1 

4 

5c 

■>c 

1 

1 

/ 

/ 

c 

O 

/ 

/ 

fc 

/ 

\ 

4 

OC 

~>C 

/ 

n 

/ 

13 

/ 

/ 

k 

/ 

+ 

3 

5( 

JC 

T~ 

/ 

r- 

/ 

ti) 

; 

1 

5 
+, 

/ 

S 

3 

V< 

:<c 

ii 

15 

r 

/ 

0 

e 

5t 

>c 

* 

o\ 

/ 

^ 

|ij 

^ 

a 

V 

-k 

/ 

,\< 

v 

m 

e 

OC 

'>0 

e 

V 

J 

/ 

\( 

V 

/ 

/ 

r, 

' 

A 

( 

1. 

5C 

0 

/ 

/ 

/ 

.-- 

/ 

/ 

• 

j 

/ 

/ 

\\ 

/ 

• 

Al] 

it 

>C 

0 

/ 

/< 

/■ 

)j: 

/ 

1 

,j 

/ 

4! 

/ 

X 

fi 

i 

rt 

$• 

^. 

f 

li 

ny 

rJ 

S 

_- 

3; 

b 

V 

1 

' 

pi 

aj 

— 

ir 

rj 

-f 

t 

> 

v 

> 

u 

ii> 

£ 

> 

/=v 

// 

O 

__ 

- 

— ' 

- 

— 

v 

-/ 

~<s? 

?5 

ei 

V< 

?r\ 

$ 

/<?'  IB'  £0'  25'  30'  35' 

Height  of  abutment,  -  base,   of  rail 
to  groan c/   /eve/  at  toe,    of  s/ope^- 

Typo-    C4. 
F/cj.  55 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1137 


V- 

-7i 

St 

>t 

)~ 

■A 

/ 

/ 

/ 

- 

/ 

- 

/ 

,1 

i.i 

1 

•i 

tf) 

r. 

i  / 

1  - 

{. 

^ 

/ 

/ 

v. 

-> 

/ 

0 

* 

/ 

l 

I 

Q 

/ 

"* 

> 

3 

5l 

oc 

? 

•k 

j 

3 

O 

OC 

? 

£ 

jj 

/ 

]( 

l- 

is 

/ 

V 

'.. 

<ii 

l 

rl 

V 

rt 

-i 

r 

/ 

r.t. 

' 

0 

z 

i% 

> 

o 

2 

5c 

pc 

p 

> 

^ 

/ 

CV 

t> 

/ 

V 

/ 

■k 

i 

10 

e 

■?(. 

>c 

> 

y 

n 

«»* 

u 

f 

i<2 

i> 

.f, 

\c; 

> 

, 

' 

r>L 

'i- 

> 

-K 

/  - 

h 

5C 

PC 

r. 

'.- 

- 

0, 

S 

i} 

{-■■' 

N 

- 

,' 

r 

' 

:.' 

h 

?c 

yj 

rn 

, 

' 

?< 

iy 

1^ 

, 

.' 

-- 

— 

-- 

-1 

~v 

'\$ 

-1 

/ 

z 

r 

t 

5 

a,. 

? 

r* 

flri 

M 

fl« 

.f 

p 

// 

t 

/ 

\i 

f 

£ 

9u 

1 

t 

y 

£ 

^ 

"' 

-j 

1 

\A 

F 

a 

1 1 

■id 

n 

u 

n 

<. 

<* 

■k 

U 

~/ 

o 

s 

i?(3'  25'  JC  35'  40'  45 

He/ g'ht  of  abutment,-  base-   of  ra/  I 
to  ground    level  at  toe.   of  slopes 

Type,     Cs 


Fig. 


56 


1138 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


eo 

oo 

55 

?t 

^C 

or 

1 

J  - 

+                A    - 

4' 

-j>, 

0 

f 

Jsl     If 

_J>"          , 

t 

V 

Us 

£/ 

\ 

4C 

>oc 

J 

I 

0 

(_ 

fc 

4 

t 

_      L 

k    ^ 

+. 

V 

-oc 

? 

Z_ 

c 

OJ 

/_ 

K 

■k 

3 

5£ 

~)0' 

7 

o 

IS 

(1) 

c 

/ 

0 

p . 

jD 

P 

,0 

>• 

V 

< 

• 

ID 

c< 

11 

? 

/ 

0 

' 

_/ 

u 

/ 

/ 

> 

// 

/ 

ti 

>0( 

? 

< 

P/ 

z 

\ 

-WJ-' 

r^v 

0 

/ 

£ 

,J[ 

i 

.'' 

IC 

><?£ 

?       / 

a 

/ 

t 

^ 

rJ 

/■ 

^-^ 

C 

,  +  '> 

p 

/ 

^ 

#->^ 

_.-<' 

/ 

X 

[J 

r+ 

/-     --"■=1" 

A 

OO 

y 

f; 

' 

r 

--' 

■— 

" 

_.-  — 

t-  — 

--'" 

^,~  —  -^' 

F 

/'/ 

/ 

o 

=  =.■:  — 

—  _ 

~r~ 

" 

.. 

— 



IO'  15'  £0'  25'  50'  35' 

Heiaht  of  abutment,  -  base,    of  rcri! 
to  ground    level  at   toe,    of  s/opo^ 

Type.    Oe 


Fi<j. 


51 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1139 


6 

•x 

->c 

5 

5 1 

7C 

5 

O 

9t 

-1 

4 

5: 

?c 

) 

U) 

4T 

J' 

?t 

) 

y 

0 

5 

/ 

(J 

V 

^ 

/ 

c 

4 

/ 

■k 

Q 

3 

5 

?( 

7 

/ 

/ 

/ 

5 

/ 

/ 

/ 

"3 

3 

O 

-?<: 

J 

/ 

-CI 

/ 

fi 

2 

5> 

7C 

? 

C 

o 

K 

■k 

10 

2 

0 

?( 

? 

0 

u 

/ 

• 

1 

pc 

)C 

! 

/ 

c: 

J 

/ 

■< 

' 

/ 

/ 

— 

- 

/< 

?*: 

■>c 

■ 

/ 

^ 

ir 

-- 

■ 

/ 

V 

r  V 

<■ 

/ 

,rl 

e. 

|f 

^ 

x 

-> 

/- 

-' 

•" 

w 

i< 

{.'. 

5 

o 

■J 

,- 

^_ 

r 

p 

r?L 

A 

<. 

\„ 

■" 

— 

■?> 

-- 

-- 

F 

// 

1 

r~ 

, 

- 

O 

_ 

t* 

r/ 

/<?'  15'  SO'  25'  50'  35' 

Hei  cjht  of  abutment,-  base-    of  rail 
to  ground    lava!  art   toe.    of  slopes- 
Type.     C  7 

Fig.  5<5 


1140 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


£ 


5 


P 

CO   \> 


!5  Q-c  5 


CD  +* 


O  i    i    *•  i    i    S  r   i    i    »    ■ 

L)        1     "1      'O      S^l     (V    ,W      It      ^r*      S 

^cqcqcqCOOq  ^OJoUO 


■VA 


-n 


V 


P5\ 


^ 


-\ 


£ 


^v 


X 


I 


S; 


5 


x-^ 


^ 


1^1 

C 


5  "K 


5  « 
'§   S  0 


*3 


Cost  of floor  for  one   abutment 
in  dollars 


Cost  ofadct/tional  length  of  superstructure  charged  to  each  abutment^-  Q  lO 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1141 


F-L-MIIV      LC^/Vl..<C    /£     /YliH  OLS/VS<  r     f-i  CSU  /  /fl£/V  1  J 

Type.   Bz~  Wing    Abutment,  Reinforced  Backwa/1 

Type  B3-  U-  A  butmen t,    Filled. 

Type  Bs  -  Pier    Abu  tmen  t. 

Type  B&  -Pier   Abutment. 

Type  By-Pier    Abutment. 

Type  B8-  Pocket    A  butmen  t. 

REINFORCED   CONCRETE  MASONRY  ABUTMENTS 
Type  Cs-  U- Abutment,  Filled,  Long    Side  walls. 
Type- C*,-  U- Abutment,  Fit/eat,  short  Side  w& /Is. 
Type  C4-  U-A butment,    Covered 
"Type.  C5-  Arch    Abutment. 
Type  Cb-~T-  A  butm en  t. 

4f< 

jp 

^(j 

■?o 

<hi 

_3J 

-O 

11 ) 

5C 

IO 

g 

0 

u 

,c 

-k 

£t 

>d 

k 

V 

£ 

■i- 

-0 

r 

c5 

ia 

ZC 

?c 

Q) 

1 

0 

t. 

& 

y 

/5 

0 

0 

k 

0 

10 

» 

s 

< 

-5 

/O 

0 

0 

t- 

fi 

u 

/ 

~* 

_ 

-~J 

I  i— 

5C 

5 

.- 

— 

-■ 

'■*"' 

r 

'A 

C 

;•* 

^i 

^ 

ffS 

S« 

By 

% 

-* 

,-- 

~-A 

— 

... 

-- 

Ce, 

r- 

"^ 

Cs 

r= 

=^= 

"^ 

^ 

Q 

Ci 

__-_ 

rfi 

5*= 

-K 

JJc 

O 

,/,s 

-1 

»* 

&« 

37 

^a 

O 

/ 

0' 

/ 

5' 

?0 

y/' 

<? 

5' 

3 

0' 

5 

5' 

Height  oF a butment ,  -   base   oF rail  to  ground  level  at  toe  oF slope 

Diagram     Showing    Cost   of  Fa  / se  won  fie 
fop  A  butmen  f 5  of  Various    Heights 

Fig. 64 


1142  DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

CONCLUSION. 

The  writer  finds  that  a  general  statement  about  the  foregoing  abut- 
ments has  to  be  qualified  in  so  many  directions  that  it  becomes  merely 
a  group  of  more  or  less  disconnected  facts. 

Inspection,  however,  will  show  that  the  cheapest  abutments  for  the 
higher  fills,  Cs,  Ce,  Ct  and  Bs,  are  those  in  which  no  provision  is  made  to 
restrain  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork,  but  where  instead  the 
earthwork  is  allowed  to  spill  forward  to  its  own  natural  slope. 

Fig.  43  shows  the  principal  elements  in  the  design  of  an  abutment 
which  resists  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork  instead  of  avoiding^ 
it  and  in  which  the  resistance  to  the  lateral  pressure  of  the  earthwork 
tending  to  overturn  the  abutment  is  provided  by  the  weight  o+  the  abut- 
ment neatwork.  In  this  type  the  designer  has  little  freedom  and  is  in 
danger  of  producing  a  design  which  tends  to  be  unstable  on  account  of 
high  foundation  pressure  at  the  toe  of  the  abutment. 

Looking  at  Fig.  43,  we  can  see  that  the  overturning  moment  around 
the  point  "k"  at  the  intersection  of  the  face  of  the  neatwork  and  footings, 
is  P3.I3,  in  which  "p3"  is  the  lateral  piessure  of  the  earthwork,  and  "13" 
its  lever  arm,  measured  from  the  point  "k." 

In  a  similar  manner  the  resisting  moment  is  P2.I2  in  which  "p2"  is 
the  resultant  of  the  vertical  loads  and  '%"  the  lever  arm  around  "k." 

With  so  many  elements  fixed,  the  ways  in  which  the  required  sta- 
bility can  be  obtained  are  few  and  not  subject  to  much  variation. 

First,  the  resisting  moment  "P2.I2"  can  be  increased  by  altering  the 
outline  of  the  abutment  from  that  shown  in  full  lines  to  that  shown  in 
dotted  lines,  thereby  inceasing  the  lever  arm  from  "L"  to  "b."  It  is  plain 
that  the  length  of  the  lever  arm  can  only  be  slightly  increased  by  this 
means. 

Second,  the  moment  of  resistance  "p>.h"  can  also  be  increased  by 
increasing  the  force  "p^"  and  thus,  of  course,  the  moment  of  stability 
of  the  neatwork  around  the  point  "k."  But  in  abutments  of  ordinary 
proportions  any  increase  in  "p2"  results  in  an  increase  in  the  pressure 
"pr"  on  the  toe  of  the  footing.  If  no  provision  were  made  for  this 
increased  pressure  on  the  toe  of  the  footing,  the  increased  stability  of 
the  neatwork  on  the  footing  would  have  been  obtained  at  the  expense 
of  decreased  stability  of  the  abutment  as  a  whole,  due  to  excessive  toe 
pressure. 

On  the  other  hand,  as  soon  as  departure  is  made  from  the  gravity 
abutment,  the  greatest  latitude  is  obtained  for  the  ingenuity  and  skill 
of  the  designer.  The  types  mentioned  in  this  paper  are  only  a  few  of 
the  large  number  of  abutment  types  which  promise  considerable  economy. 

A  number  of  such  abutments,  designed  under  the  direction  of  H.  C. 
Lothholz,  but  which  are  outside  the  limits  of  this  paper  on  account  of 
their  character  or  size,  are  shown  in  Figs.  65,  66,  68,  69,  70  and  71. 

As  the  minimum  sections  adopted  are  more  liberal  in  the  reinforced 
concrete  abutments  than  in  the  plain  abutments,  it  is  probable  that  there 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS.  1143 

is  a  wider  margin  for  new  economies  in  the  reinforced  than  there  is  in 
the  plain  abutments.  In  the  reinforced  abutments  a  minimum  section  of 
i  ft.  3  in.  was  used  in  a  few  places,  but  at  the  greater  number  of  points 
the  minimum  thickness  of  concrete  adopted  was  I  ft.  9  in.  to  2  ft.  without 
regard  to  the  load  which  it  was  to  carry.  If  we  compare  the  above  thick- 
ness of  reinforced  concrete  section  with  the  thicknesses  shown  in  Fig. 
72,  which  is  a  drawing  from  a  foreign  textbook,*  it  would  seem  that  the 
possible  economies  have  not  been  exhausted. 


*Der  Eisenbeton  in  Theorie  und  Konstruktion,   Rudolph  Saliger,   Leipzig, 
1911.     Alfred  Kroner  Verlag. 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


114f 


Section  at  <£  of  Track- 


Half]  Ha /f 

Sec  t.  !  Etc  v 


Plan 

Fiq.  6& 
Line  Diagram   Abutment   Spokane  River  Bridge. 


=».*■-• r " '•■ 

' 

r 

^ 

-■  -^  ■'  '■"■'  ■    •" 

?  £„'  + 

la"    ^UU9:-H 

m  - 

''&ds 

L    '           ' 

■I      ; 

SfifiBj 

*^~ 

* 

A  •• '  i»'*i 

f*£  * 

S$  ••' 

^^^^^H 

fc^^^"i 

Fig.  69 — Abutment  Spokane  River  Bridge.    Abutment  Contains  Open- 
ings for  Under  Crossings. 


114fi 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


3-m 


Sect/on   at  <£  of Track. 


Half 
Sect."A-A" 


4zzz? 


LAiz 


A/6?//"  A/C7/f 


Half 


Plan       Secf'B-  B"\E  leva  f  Ion 
Fig.  lO 


Fig.   70 — Line   Diagram    Abutment   Sixteen   Mile   Bridge. 


Fig.  71— Abutments  Sixteen  Mile  Creek  Bridge  on  C.  M.  &  P.  S.  Ry. 
Near  Lombard,  Mont. 


DESIGN   OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 


1147 


r-ii"(o.5m) 

\Ground  Level} 


Fig.  1<L 


1148  DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

WRITTEN    DISCUSSION    ON    "DESIGN    OF   RAILWAY    BRIDGE 

ABUTMENTS." 

Mr.  J.  L.  Campbell  (EI  Paso  &  Southwestern)  :— Referring  to  "The 
Design  of  Railway  Bridge  Abutments,"  by  J.  H.  Prior,  Assistant  Engineer, 
Chicago,  .Milwaukee  &  St.  Paul  Railway,  in  the  November,  1911,  Bulle- 
tin. 1  enclose  herewith  Fig.  73,  showing  a  type  of  buried  abutment 
which  we  have  found  more  economical  than  wing  abutments  for  high 
tikments.  Referring  to  this  figure,  the  buried  abutment  involves  the 
use  of  a  concrete  pier  and  a  deck  plate  girder,  both  of  which  are  in- 
cluded in  the  comparative  estimates  that  follow.  The  pier  is  assumed 
to  replace  a  wing  abutment  in  position. 

Buried   Abutment   22   Ft.    High. 

Excavation,  44  cu.  yds.  at  $1.00 $44.00 

Concrete,  177  cu.  yds.  at  $7.00 1,239.00 

Riprap,  150  cu.  yds.  at  $1.50 225.00 

Steel,  18,000  lbs.  at  354c 675.00 

$2,183.00 
Wing   Abutment   22   Ft.    High. 

Excavation,  90  cu.  yds.  at  $1.00 $90.00 

Concrete,  290  cu.  yds.  at  $7.00 2,030.00 

Excess  embankment,  445  cu.  yds.  at  20c 89.00 

Riprap,  50  cu.  yds.  at  $1.50 75.00 

$2,284.00 
Buried   Abutment  30   Ft.    High. 

Excavation,  50  cu.  yds.  at  $1.00 $50.00 

Concrete,  238  cu.  yds.  at  $7.00 1,666.00 

Riprap,  240  cu.  yds.  at  $1.50 360.00 

Steel,  37,000  lbs.   at  354c 1,388.00 

$3,464.00 
Wing  Abutment   30  Ft.    High. 

Excavation,  140  cu.  yds.  at  $1.00 $140.00 

Concrete,   540  cu.  yds.   at  $7.00 3,780.00 

Excess  embankment,  1,350  cu.  yds.  at  20c 270.00 

Riprap,  80  cu.  yds.  at  $1.50 120.00 


$4,310.00 

The  comparative  estimates  assume  the  ground  to  be  level.  Ordi- 
narily the  foundation  of  the  abutment  is  higher  than  that  of  the  pier. 
in  which   case  the  cost  of  the  abutment  is   reduced.     In  some  cases  no 

riprap    is   required. 


DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS.  1149 

Referring  again  to  Fig.  73:  The  embankment  is  assumed  to  be 
30  ft.  high.  The  pier  and  the  embankment  span,  40  ft.  long,  are  a  more 
economical  arrangement  than  the  elimination  of  the  pier  and  extension 
of  the  adjacent  span  to  the  buried  abutment.  For  example,  assume  the 
adjacent  span  to  be  a  60-ft.  deck  plate  girder,  and  that  it  extends  to  the 
abutment,  making  a  girder  span  100  ft.  long.  The  comparative  esti- 
mate is  then  as  follows : 

For  Single  Span. 
1     100    ft.    girder,    160,000    lbs.     at   &/4C $6,000.00 

For    Pier    and    Embankment    Span. 

Excavation,  30  cu.   yds.  at  $1.00 $30.00 

Concrete,   140  cu.  yds.  at  $7.00 840.00 

1     40  ft.  girder,  37,000  lbs.    at  3^4c 1,387.50 

1     60  ft.  girder,  67,000  lbs.    at  3^4  c 2,512.50 


$4,770.00 

The  difference  in  favor  of  the  arrangement  shown  in  Fig.  73  wi!i 
increase  rapidly  as  the  height  of  the  embankment  increases.  Modern 
railway    construction    involves    many    bridges     connecting    embankments 

IQ'-O" 


Reinforcement  in  backwaf/  not  shown 

-UTTTTST 


\t_J 


Fig.  7  5 


too  high  for  wing  abutments.  The  buried  abutment  is  an  economical 
substitute  when  designed  with  due  regard  to  the  character  of  its  founda- 
tion and  of  the  embankment  surrounding  it.  For  embankments  in  which 
the    material    is    stable    even    when    wet,    the    type    of    buried    abutment 


i i5o  DESIGN  OF  BRIDGE  ABUTMENTS. 

shown  will  generally  be  found  to  have  the  necessary  stability.  However, 
numerous  high  embankments  in  many  parts  of  the  country  do  not  be- 
come stable  for  several  years  after  being  built,  in  which  case  it  is  often 
difficult  to  determine  the  proportions  and  minimum  dimensions  required 
in  a  high  abutment  buried  in  such  an  embankment.  When  high  em- 
bankments start  to  run  off  the  right-of-way,  as  they  sometimes  do,  it 
is  not  always  the  case  that  that  portion  of  the  embankment  in  front  of 
the  buried   abutment  gives   very   much   support   to   the  latter. 

Mr.  J.  H.  Prior :— Mr.  Campbell's  estimates  on  his  buried  abutment 
as  a  substitute  for  a  wing  abutment  would  seem  to  bear  out  the  find- 
ings of  this  paper;  that  an  abutment  of  this  general  character  is  more 
economical  for  moderate  and  high  fills  than  a  wing  abutment. 

The  buried  abutment  and  wing  abutment  which  he  mentions  cor- 
respond in  a  general  way,  as  far  as  design  is  concerned,  to  our  abut- 
ments B-6  and  B-2,  and  if  his  estimated  costs  are  platted  on  figures  44 
and  45,  it  will  be  seen  that  the  total  costs  bear  a  similar  relation. 

We  agree  with  his  figures  which  show  that  it  is  cheaper  to  obtain 
the  increased  length  of  bridge  required  by  the  buried  abutment  by 
means  of  an  additional  approach  span  than  it  is  to  obtain  this  increased 
length  by  increasing  the  length  of  the  end  span. 


isqql 


Appendix   A. 

SUMMARY  OF  THE  VARIOUS  TYPES  OF  ABUTMENTS 
DESCRIBED  IN  THIS   PAPER. 


SUMMARY  OF  THE  VARIOUS  TYPES  OF  ABUTMENTS 
DESCRIBED   IN   THIS   PAPER 

I.     Stone   Masonry  Abutments : 
Type  Ai,  Wing  Abutments; 
Type  A;,  U  Abutments; 
Type  A3,  T  Abutments; 

II.     Plain  Concrete  Masonry  Abutments: 

Type  Bi,  Wing  Abutments,  plain  concrete  back  wall; 

Type  B..,  Wing  Abutments,  reinforced  concrete  back  wall; 

Type  B5,  U  Abutments,  filled ; 

Type  B,,  T  Abutments; 

Type  Bs,  Pier  Abutment,  transverse  beam  on  concrete  columns 

Type  B8l  Pier  Abutment,  plain  concrete  buttress; 

Type  Bi,  Pier  Abutment,  reinforced  concrete  buttress, 

Type  B»,  Pocket  Abutment ; 

II.     Reinforced  Concrete  Masonry  Abutments: 
Type  Ci,  Counterfort  Wing  Abutments; 
Type  G,  U  Abutments,  filled,  long  side  walls; 
Type  Ci,  U  Abutments,  filled,  short  side  walls ; 
Type  C,  U  Abutments,  covered ; 
Type  Ci,  Arch  Abutments ; 
Type  CB,  T  Abutments; 
Type  G,  Trestle  Abutments. 


EQUATED   TONNAGE  RATING  FOR  LOCOMOTIVES. 

•  (Bulletin    138.) 

By  M.  H.  Wickhorst. 

The  method  of  locomotive  tonnage  rating  and  the  train  resistance 
tables  described  in  this  paper  were  first  worked  up  by  the  Laboratory 
of  the  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy  Railroad  about  the  year  1902,  and 
were  presented  by  the  author  in  a  paper  before  the  Western  Railway 
Club,  March  17,  1903.  The  paper  was  later  revised  and  the  tables  con- 
siderably extended,  under  the  direction  of  the  author,  under  date  of 
September  3,  1908,  and  it  is  these  that  now  constitute  the  present  paper. 
Credit  for  such  merit  as  this  work  may  possess  is  due  to  a  number  of 
persons,  and  the  work  of  revision  in  particular  was  done  mostly  by 
Mr.  W.  A.  Pownail,  of  the  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy  Railroad 
Laboratory  at  Aurora,  111.  Permission  to  publish  this  material  was  kindly 
given  by  Mr.  H.  E.  Byram,  Vice-President,  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy 
Railroad.  This  revision  was  used  as  a  code  of  instructions  for  those 
doing  tonnage  rating  work  on  the  road  mentioned. 


1151 


TONNAGE  RATING  OF  LOCOMOTIVES. 

CHICAGO,  BURLINGTON  &  QUINCY  RAILROAD  COMPANY. 

In   establishing   a   tonnage   rate   for  an   engine   we   aim    to   load   the 
engine  up  to  near  its  maximum  pulling  capacity  and  yet  not  load  it  so" 
heavily  that  it  will  stall  on  any  of  the  hills,  or  be  on  the  road  an  excessive 
length  of  time. 

The  work  of  engine  rating  consists  of:  (i)  Determining  the  maximum 
working  tractive  force  the  engine  can  maintain  under  average  conditions 
over  the  ruling  grade;  and  (2)  to  balance  this  with  an  equal  amount 
of  total  train  resistance  on  the  ruling  grade.  We  have  tractive  force 
formulae  and  curves  of  train  resistance  from  actual  tests  which  are 
worked  up  into  tables  convenient  for  use  in  this  work.  These  are  given 
later  on  in  this  article. 

The  tonnage  rater,  in  rating  a  division,  must  first  get  an  alinement 
and  grade  profile  of  the  division  and  make  a  careful  study  of  the  grades, 
curves,  etc.,  for  the  purpose  of  determining  the  ruling  grade  and  esti- 
mating about  what  percentage  of  the  maximum  tractive  force  an  engine 
can  consistently  maintain  and  get  over  the  road  with  in  good  time  and 
without  stalling.  There  is  also  the  question  of  momentum  grade  as 
affecting  the  ruling  grade.     This  will  be  explained  later. 

He  should  also,  if  consistent  with  operating  conditions,  divide  the 
main  runs  of  the  division  into  rating  divisions  whenever  there  is  a 
sufficient  change  in  ruling  grade  to  warrant  two  different  rates.  For 
instance,  one  run  on  the  Galesburg  Division  of  the  Chicago,  Burlington 
&  Quincy  Railroad  is  from  Quincy  to  Galesburg;  from  Quincy  to  Bush- 
nell  is  70  miles,  with  a  ruling  grade  of  0.7  per  cent. ;  from  Bushnell  to 
Galesburg  is  30  miles,  with  a  ruling  grade  of  0.3  per  cent.  As  Bushnell 
is  a  point  where  there  is  a  great  deal  of  freight  to  fill  up  with,  there 
should  be  two  rates  for  the  Quincy-to-Galesburg  run.  If  there  were  no 
important  points  where  freight  originated  between  Quincy  and  Galesburg, 
we  would  probably  make  a  straight  through  rate  from  Quincy  to 
Galesburg. 

Having  settled  on  these,  the  rater  will  consult  the  equated  tonnage 
tables  for  the  grade  in  question,  and  using  the  predetermined  tractive  force 
as  the  train  resistance,  he  will  get  a  trial  rate. 

The  next  step  is  to  ride  engines  hauling  this  trial  rate  and  see  how 
the  estimate  works  out  in  practice.  There  are  many  local  influencing 
conditions  which  cannot  be  seen  on  the  profile  chart,  such  as  differences 
in  roadbed,  speed  limits,  some  grades  being  protected  from  winds  by 
trees  or  cuts,  overworking  of  firemen,  etc.     Very  often   sidings   or  the 

1X52 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING.  1153 

approach  to  them  will  be  on  a  heavy  grade,  so  that  if  an  engine  had  to 
stop  to  head  in  at  one  of  them,  it  would  be  unable  to  start  the  train 
again.  The  approach  to  crossovers,  home  semaphores,  or  any  place 
where  trains  have  to  be  stopped  under  ordinary  operating  conditions,  are 
similar  instances  that  have  to  be  considered  in  making  the  rate.  If, 
however,  to  consider  such  a  point  would  lower  the  rate  very  materially 
and  if  the  point  in  question  were  one  where  wise  despatching  would 
eliminate  most  of  the  stops  at  the  place,  it  should  be  ignored  in  making 
the  rate.  These  will  show  up  on  the  trial  trips,  and  the  rater  can,  in 
a  few  trips,  check  up  his  rates  and  readjust,  if  necessary,  for  the  final 
rating. 

If  a  train  averages  less  than  ten  miles  an  hour  between  terminals 
(except  on  runs  of  less  than  ioo  miles),  the  engine  and  train  crew  are 
on  the  road  an  excessive  length  of  time.  In  practice  we  find  that  ordi- 
narily if  an  engine  be  loaded  so  that  her  average  speed  in  motion  is  twenty 
miles  an  hour,  the  average  speed  between  terminals  will  not  fall  under 
ten  miles  per  hour. 

Outside  the  ability  of  the  engine  to  handle  her  train,  density  of  traffic 
and  efficiency  of  despatching  are  factors  to  be  considered.  The  ques- 
tion of  speed  is  an  important  one,  and  the  engine  rater  should  keep 
accurate  record  of  stops  and  time  on  road  on  his  trial  trips,  and  rate 
accordingly. 

The  length  of  the  division  is  another  influencing  factor.  On  a  short 
division,  of  say,  60  miles  in  length,  it  is  economy,  traffic  permitting,  to 
load  the  engines  a  little  more  heavily;  whereas,  on  a  160-mile  division  the 
rate  should  be  lowered  on  account  of  excessive  time  on  the  road,  the 
possibility  of  heavy  or  clinkered  fires,  etc. 

Following  is  the  method  of  arriving  at  the  equated  tonnage  rates: 

TRACTIVE  FORCE. 

(1)     Tractive  Force  at  Tender  Drazvbar. 

For  figuring  the  maximum  tractive  force  that  an  engine  may  develop 
at  the  tender  drawbar  on  level  track  for  simple  engines,  we  use  the 
following  formula : 

TF=  — 

D 

Where  P  =  maximum  boiler  pressure  in  lbs.  per  sq.  in. 

d  ==  diameter  of  cylinder  in  inches 

j  =  stroke  in  inches 

D  =  diameter  of  drivers  in  inches 

T  F  =  tractive  force  in  pounds. 

This  formula  assumes  that  the  mean  effective  pressure  in  the  cylinders 
at  full  stroke  is  92  per  cent,  of  the  maximum  boiler  pressure,  and  that  92 
per  cent,  of  the  work  done  by  the  cylinders  is  transmitted  back  to  the 
drawbar  behind  the  tender. 


1154  EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 

For  compound  engines  we  use  the  following  formula,  working  com- 
pound : 

.85  P  d\s 

Two  cylinder  compounds,  1  F  =  — — r 

D  (r  +  1) 

,     ^V       1.7  P  d\s 

Four  cylinder  compounds,  TP  =  ~~~ 7 

£>(r+i) 

.85  Pdfc 
Two  cylinder  compounds  working  simple,  T F  =  •- 

Where  di   =  diameter  of  low  pressure  cylinder  in  inches 
r    =  ratio  of  cylinder  volumes    (LP^-PTP) 
d.  =  diameter  of  high  pressure  cylinder. 

(2)  Tractive  Force  on  Grade. 

On  a  grade  the  tractive  force  of  an  engine  is  less,  due  to  the  fact 
that  she  must  lift  her  own  weight  up  the  hill,  which  absorbs  some  of 
the  work  performed  by  the  cylinders  and  leaves  less  to  develop  at  the 
drawbar. 

The  amount  to  be  deducted  for  this  engine  grade  resistance  is  found 
by  the  following  formula : 

Engine  Grade  Resistance  =  20  W  G; 

Where  W  =  weight  of  engine  and  tender  in  tons 
G  =  grade  in  per  cent. 

(3)  Net  Working  Tractive  Force. 

Having  obtained  the  maximum  effective  tractive  force  at  tender  draw- 
bar, a  certain  allowance  must  be  made  for  small  drops  in  steam  pressure 
as  affecting  the  tractive  force,  and  for  an  occasional  stuck  brake,  excess 
of  billed  over  actual  tonnage,  etc.,  as  affecting  train  resistance.  A 
variable  and  sometimes  very  considerable  allowance  has  to  be  made  de- 
pending on  the  profile  of  the  road ;  i.  e.,  where  the  run  as  a  whole  is  hard 
and  the  grades  long,  we  take  from  80  per  cent,  of  the  tractive  force 
down  to  as  low  as  65  per  cent,  on  the  lower  grade  divisions.  An  ex- 
ample of  this  would  be  a  division  of  perhaps  120  miles  with  a  large 
amount  of  0.3  per  cent,  grade ;  this  would  probably  be  rated  as  a  0.3  per 
cent,  grade  using  65  or  70  per  cent,  of  the  tractive  force  as  the  total 
train  resistance  over  this  grade.  If  sufficient  allowance  were  not  made 
we  would  find  that  while  the  engine  would  probably  take  the  train  over 
without  stalling,  the  time  would  be  very  slow,  the  fire  would  get  in  bad 
shape,  and  on  the  low-grade  divisions  with  our  heavy  power  the  fireman 
would  be  unable  to  stand  the  work. 

To  find,  therefore,  the  net  working  tractive  force,  we  take  a  certain 
predetermined  percentage  of  the  drawbar  tractive  force  (afterwards 
checked  by  road  test),  and  subtract  from  this  the  engine  grade  resistance. 
The  resulting  net  tractive  force  is  the  same  as  the  total  train  resistance 
over  the  ruling  grade,  and  is  the  figure  that  determines  the  rate. 

For  convenience  in  working  rate  schedules  and  calculating,  tables 
are  given,  showing  tractive  forces,  weights  and  amount  of  heating  sur- 
face for  the  different  classes  of  engines  of  the  Chicago,  Burlington  & 
Quincy  Railroad.     (See  Fig.  1.) 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


1155 


TRAIN   RESISTANCE. 

Train  resistance  consists  of  three  primary  resistances,  as  follows : 
(i)     Acceleration   resistance. 

(2)  Grade  resistance. 

(3)  Friction. 

Acceleration  and  grade  resistances  are  elementary  resistances,  de- 
pendent only  upon  the  amount  of  tonnage,  and  not  upon  the  form  of  the 
tonnage,  such  as  in  empty  or  loaded  cars,  etc.  Friction  is  a  compound 
resistance  dependent  upon  a  good  many  conditions,  such  as  kind  of  cars, 
load  in  cars,  condition  of  track,  condition  of  trucks,  wind,  temperature 
of  air,  curves,  etc.  The  composition  of  train  resistance  is  shown  be- 
low : 

f  Acceleration  Resistance,  depends  on  ton 
nage  only. 


Train 
Resistance 


Grade    Resistance,  depends   on   tonnage' 
only. 


'  Journal.     Depends    on    design  ' 
and  lubrication. 

Rolling.      Depends  on   solidity 
of  roadbed. 


'20  lbs.  per  ton 
for  1  per  cent, 
grade,  or  about 
.4  lb.  for  each 
foot  per  mile  of 
grade. 


Friction 


Flange. 


Curve 


'  Sliding  of  one  tread, 
in  each  pair,  on  the 
rail. 

Flange  Friction. 


Varies  trom  2^ 
to  12  lbs.  per 
ton. 


Side  bearings  and  center  plates 
cause  flange  friction. 

!Wind  against  body  of 
car. 
Flange  Friction. 

Note — Flange  friction  consists  of  that  due  to  curves,  side  bearings 
and  center  plates,  winds,  etc. 

(1)  Acceleration  Resistance. 

In  rating  slow  freight  trains  acceleration  resistance  need  very  seldom 
be  considered,  except  on  momentum  grades.  Here  it  comes  as  negative 
resistance,  and  will  be  considered  later  under  the  head  of  momentum 
grades. 

(2)  Grade  Resistance. 

This,  generally,  is  the  largest  component  of  the  freight  train  resist- 
ance, and  is  dependent  only  on  the  tonnage  on  any  given  grade.     The 
grade  resistance  per  ton  may  be  figured  by  the  following  formula : 
Where  rs  =  20  G 

re  =  grade  resistance  in  lbs.  per  ton 
G  =  grade  in  per  cent. 


1156  EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 

(3)     Friction. 

As  stated  above,  the  frictional  resistance  varies  considerably.  The 
friction  expressed  in  pounds  per  ton  drawbar  pull  increases  as  the  speed 
increases,  decreases  as  the  gross  weight  of  a  car  and  its  freight  increases, 
and  increases,  in  a  general  way,  as  the  temperature  of  the  air  decreases. 
It  varies  for  freight  cars  at  freight  speeds  between  limits  of  about  2 
lbs.  per  ton  and  12  or  more  lbs.  per  ton.  Fig.  2  shows  some  curves  of 
friction  resistance  of  freight  cars  at  speeds  of  20  miles  per  hour.  These 
curves  show  the  relation  between  the  gross  weight  per  car  in  tons  plotted 
horizontally,  and  the  resistance  per  ton  in  pounds  plotted  vertically  for 
four  different  weather  conditions,  as  follows : 

(1)  Temperature  above  30  degrees  Fahrenheit,  and  not  much  wind. 

(2)  Temperature  between  zero  and  30  degrees  Fahrenheit,  or  strong 
head  or  side  wind,  or  frosty  rail. 

(3)  Temperature  between  zero  and  30  degrees  Fahrenheit  and  strong 
head  or  side  wind,  or  temperature  below  zero  and  not  much  wind. 

(4)  Temperature  below  zero  with  strong  head  or  side  wind. 

The  curve  showing  resistance  of  freight  cars  in  summer  weather 
(above  30  degrees  Fahrenheit)  is  the  result  of  dynamometer  tests  by 
the  Pennsylvania  Railroad,  and  various  results  obtained  by  us  fall  in 
well  with  this  curve. 

The  curve  showing  friction  of  freight  cars  for  the  third  weather 
condition  is  one  obtained  by  the  Burlington  from  dynamometer  tests  dur- 
ing the  winter  of  1900-1901.  This  curve  was  formerly  used  for  the  re- 
sistance of  cars  in  10  degrees  Fahienheit  to  30  degrees  Fahrenheit 
weather,  but  we  found  that  there  was  too  wide  a  gap  between  the  winter 
rates  derived  from  this  curve  and  the  summer  rate ;  i.  e.,  for  calm  winter 
days  an  engine  could  easily  take  considerably  more  than  the  old  winter 
weather  rate,  especially  on  the  low-grade  division.  Accordingly,  between 
these  two  curves  was  placed  another  curve  for  calm  winter  weather,  or 
windy  summer  weather,  and  road  tests  indicated  that  rates  derived  from 
this  curve  were  about  right. 

The  curve  for  very  severe  winter  weather  was  obtained  by  arbitrarily 
adding  2  lbs.  per  ton  to  the  No.  3  curve.  This  seems  to  give  the  right 
result  for  grades  0.6  per  cent,  or  over ;  for  grades  of  0.5  per  cent,  or 
lower,  we  deduct  10  per  cent,  from  our  No.  3  or  "C"  rate  to  get  the 
"D"  rate.  This  diagram  also  gives  a  curve  of  grade  resistance  based  on 
the  above  formula. 

Knowing  the  grade,  the  gross  weight  of  a  car,  and  the  general  weather 
condition,  the  total  resistance  per  ton  is  found  by  adding  together  the  grade 
and  friction  resistances  per  ton  as  found  from  these  curves. 

MOMENTUM  GRADES. 

Where  the  grade  is  not  too  long,  the  momentum,  or  the  work  stored 
in  the  train  as  motion,  can  often  be  used  to  help  get  the  train  over  the 
grade.     A  body  in  motion  has  an  amount  of  work  stored  in  it  dependent 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING.  1157 

upon  its  speed,  and  this  stored  work  can  be  used  to  overcome  the  force 
of  gravity,  or  in  other  words,  take  a  train  a  certain  distance  up  a  hill. 
The  amount  of  work  so  stored  increases  as  the  square  of  the  speed.  A 
body  moving  30  miles  per  hour  has  sufficient  work  stored  in  it  to  carry 
it  vertically  upward  about  30  ft. ;  one  moving  60  miles  per  hour  sufficient 
for  120  ft.,  etc.  Therefore,  a  train  approaching  a  hill  at  30  miles  per  hour 
could  be  taken  a  vertical  distance  of  30  ft.,  due  to  the  momentum,  pro- 
vided the  friction  were  otherwise  taken  care  of.  On  a  grade  30  ft.  to  the 
mile  this  distance  along  the  track  would  be  one  mile ;  on  a  60-ft.  grade, 
one-half  mile,  etc.  Where  this  momentum  is  to  be  expended,  or  to  run 
out,  in  a  given  distance,  the  propelling  force  can  be  expressed  as  a  pull 
of  so  many  pounds  per  ton,  or  as  a  certain  total  drawbar  pull  at  the 
head  end  of  the  train,  or  as  so  much  negative  grade,  thus  cutting  down 
the  actual  grade  and  producing  a  lower  virtual  grade.  For  our  pur- 
pose the  simplest  method  is  to  express  momentum  as  so  much  negative 
grade  and  its  value  may  be  figured  by  the  following  formula : 

x 
Where  Gm  =  equivalent  grade  in  per  cent. 
V  —  speed  in  miles  per  hour 
x    =  distance  traversed  during  retardation,  in  feet. 

Where  a  minimum  speed  of  five  miles  per  hour  at  top  of  grade  is 
assumed,   the   equivalent  grade   would   be  determined   as  follows: 

V*— '25 

Gn>  =  3-5   r 

X 

For  convenience  we  show  Fig.  3,  from  which  can  readily  be  obtained 
the  equivalent  grade  in  per  cent.,  having  the  speed  of  approach  and 
length  of  grade,  based  on  this  formula.  Having  the  actual  grade  and 
the  momentum  expressed  as  equivalent  grade,  the  virtual  grade  is  equal 
to  the  actual  grade  minus  the  momentum  grade.  The  actual  resistance 
of  the  train  is,  then,  that  due  to  the  virtual  grade  plus  the  friction. 

TRACTIVE   FORCE   AT  SPEED. 

Where  the  speed  is  above  8  or  10  miles  per  hour,  the  maximum 
tractive  force  cannot  be  sustained  on  account  of  the  inability  of  the  boiler 
to  furnish  sufficient  steam,  and  when  calculating  tonnage  rates  on  mo- 
mentum grades,  it  is  necessary  to  determine  the  average  tractive  force 
from  the  bottom  to  the  top  of  the  hill.  It  might  be  well  to  mention  here 
that  some  engines  are  a  bit  over-cylindered ;  i.  e.,  their  tractive  force 
figured  from  the  cylinders  is  higher  than  the  boiler  can  maintain,  even 
at  lower  speeds.  On  the  low-grade  lines,  where  the  train  has  to  run  at 
a  considerable  speed  over  the  ruling  grade,  such  engines  should  really 
be  rated  on  their  boiler  capacities.  This  falling  off  of  tractive  force  due 
to  limit  of  boiler  is  shown  for  our  various  engines  at  speeds  up  to  40 
miles  per  hour  in  Fig.  4. 


1158  EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 

The  tractive   force   shown  on  these   curves   as  limited  by  the  boiler 
is  obtained   by  the   following  formula : 

_      ..     '  375  X -43^       e 

Tractive  t  orce  = —  R 

S 

Where  H  =  heating  surface  in  sq.   ft. 
S  =  speed  in  miles  per  hour 

R  =  the  total  resistance  in  pounds  of  the  engine  and  tender. 
The  expression  .43  H  gives  the  maximum  cylinder  horsepower  of 
the  locomotive  assuming  an  evaporation  of  12  lbs.  of  water  per  square 
foot  of  heating  surface  per  hour,  and  a  cylinder  water  rate  of  28  lbs. 
of  water  per  horsepower  hour.  This  is  a  formula  given  by  Professor 
Goss  and  the  results  of  our  locomotive  tests  agree  well  with  it,  so  we  have 

375  X  -43  H 
adopted  the  same.    The  expression  converts  horsepower  into 

cylinder  tractive  force.  Now  to  convert  this  cylinder  tractive  force 
into  drawbar  tractive  force  we  must  subtract  R,  the  total  resistance  of 
the  engine  and  tender.  R  is  gotten  by  multiplying  the  weight  in  tons  of 
the  engine  and  tender  with  half  load  of  coal  and  water  by  the  resistance 
per  ton  at  given  speed  as  obtained  from  curve  in  Fig.  5.  This  curve 
is  the  average  of  the  engine  resistance  curves  of  engines  C,  B.  &  Q. 
1967,  1989,  3156,  C.  &  A.  340,  and  Erie  1776,  all  of  which  engines  were 
pulling  full  tonnage  on  the  tests  from  which  these  curves  were  taken. 

The  tractive  force  shown  on  the  above-mentioned  sheets  of  curves, 
at  the  average  speed,  will  generally  be  found  satisfactory.  In  figuring 
on  a  momentum  grade  it  is  necessary  to  know  the  speed  limit  of  the 
division  for  freight  trains,  and  whether  there  are  any  permanent  slow 
orders  at  foot  of  hills  due  to  bad  curves,  crossover,  etc.  It  is  hardly 
safe  to  regard  as  a  momentum  grade  any  grade  over  ilA  miles  long  or 
one  that  has  several  reverse  curves  on  it. 

EQUATED  TONNAGE  TABLES. 

Having  the  total  resistance  per  ton  of  any  given  train  and  the  maxi- 
mum working  tractive  force  of  the  engine,  the  thing  is  now  to  get  sufficient 
tonnage  to  just  make  total  train  resistance  to  balance  this  tractive  force. 
The  number  of  tons  that  will  give  this  total  resistance  will,  of  course, 
vary  with  the  load  per  car  and  the  weather  conditions,  increasing  as 
the  load  per  car  increases,  and  decreasing  as  the  weather  conditions 
become  more  severe.  For  operating  use  we  get  up  a  rate  table,  showing 
the  number  of  tons  for  various  number  of  cars  in  the  train  and  for 
four  weather  conditions,  namely : 

Rate  "A" — Temperature  above  30  degrees  Fahrenheit  and  not  much 
wind. 

Rate  "B" — Temperature  between  zero  and  30  degrees  Fahrenheit,  or 
strong  head  or  side  wind,  or  frosty  rail. 

Rate   "C" — Temperature   between    zero   and    30   degrees    Fahrenheit, 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING.  1159 

and  strong  head  or  side  wind,  or  temperature  below  zero  and  not  much 
wind. 

Rate  "D" — Temperature  below  zero,  with  strong  head  or  side  wind. 

The  method  in  detail  of  obtaining  these  tables  is  shown  in  Fig.  6. 

EXPLANATION   OF  METHOD. 

The  tables  in  Fig.  6  show  method  used  in  calculating  equated  tonnage 
tables.  The  various  tonnages  shown  all  have  the  same  drawbar  resist- 
ance of  20,ooo  lbs.,  and  are  calculated  for  a  0.5  per  cent,  grade  at  freight 
speeds  of  20  miles  per  hour.  The  method  is  to  make  a  column  of  gross 
car  weights  from  10  tons  to  60  tons,  column  1.  In  column  2  is  shown 
the  resistance  per  ton  of  cars  of  the  various  gross  weights.  This  includes 
the  grade  and  the  friction  resistances  per  ton.  Next  we  divide  20,000 
by  the  resistance  per  ton,  and  get  column  3,  showing  the  various  tonnages 
having  the  total  train  resistance  of  20,000  lbs.  Then  by  dividing  the  num- 
ber of  tons  by  the  gross  weight  per  car  we  get  column  4,  showing  the 
number  of  cars  in  the  train  corresponding  to  the  various  tonnages.  The 
columns  of  tons  are  then  interpolated  to  the  nearest  even  figure  divisible 
by  5  and  corresponding  to  an  even  number  of  cars  divisible  by  5  and 
placed  in  column  12,  which  is  the  column  as  finally  used  in  rate  schedules. 
Having  column  12,  the  columns  5  to  10,  inclusive,  are  obtained  from 
columns  11  and  12  by  multiplying  by  a  suitable  factor.  For  example, 
columns  5  and  6  are  the  intermediate  steps  in  getting  the  "B"  rate,  and 
are  gotten  by  use  of  the  factor  .83,  the  ratio  of  resistance  per  ton  of 
a  40-ton  car  on  a  0.5  per  cent,  grade  in  warm  weather  (curve  1),  to 
the  resistance  per  ton  of  a  40-ton  car  on  a  0.5  per  cent,  grade  in  zero 
to  30  degrees  Fahrenheit  weather  (curve  2).  This  ratio  or  factor  would 
vary  slightly  between  the  10-ton  car  and  the  60-ton  car ;  the  factors  shown 
are  gotten  by  taking  an  average  of  the  ratios  for  the  cars  of  following 
weights:  10,  11,  12,  14,  16,  18,  20,  25,  30,  40,  50  and  60  tons.  The 
tons  and  cars  thus  obtained  are  interpolated  to  even  figures  and  the 
tonnage  placed  in  column  13,  opposite  the  proper  number  of  cars.  The 
other  columns  are  obtained  similarly  by  using  the  suitable  factor  selected 
from  table  shown  on  the  print. 

Tables  have  been  made  showing  the  tonnages  for  grades  from  0.3 
per  cent,  to  1.6  per  cent.,  and  for  total  train  resistances  from  10,000  to 
35,000  lbs.  When,  therefore,  we  have  decided  on  the  maximum  working 
tractive  force  on  a  given  grade,  we  simply  select  from  the  set  of  tables 
the  suitable  schedule  and  give  this  as  the  tonnage  rate  schedule  for  the 
engine.  For  practical  use  the  rates  thus  decided  upon  are  gotten  out  on 
tonnage  rating  sheets  for  each  division,  which  show  the  number  of  cars 
and  tons  for  the  different  rating  divisions  and  for  all  classes  of  engines 
on  that  division.  A  page  from  the  time-card  of  the  Aurora  Division  of 
the  Chicago,  Burlington  &  Quincy  Railroad,  showing  engine  rates  on 
that  division,   is   given   with   this  article  as   Fig.   7. 


1160 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


•J 

r 

0 

i 

d 
M 

■ 

a 
• 

• 
i 

u 

u 

i 

cC 

D 

o 

z 

u 

I 

:  Q 

M 

u       ! 

j 
<n        3 

&        \ 
2        j 

i  i 

<   ! 

j 

I 

h 
I 
« 

y 
T 

M 

2 

N 

5 

91 

3 

0 

0 

o 
o 

5 

cm 

9, 

CO" 

3 

] 

r 

0 

o 

o 

CM 

o 
o 
o 

r; 

uo 
o 

CO 

2tf 

«1 

0 

0 

8 

a 

o 

LA 

O 

if 

o 
a 
u 

j 
ft." 

1 
■a 

0 

fM 

o 

! 

o 

i 

0 
in 
(l 

isl 

¥ 

5 

<0 
ID 

0 
V9 

o 
e 
CO 
o 

ID 

| 

<M 

3 

<> 

q:' 

ip 

* 

0 

CD 

r 

0 

13 

0 

o 

<0 
fO 
N 

<5 
O 

r. 

o 

o 
n 
n 

N 

2 

i 

0 
0 

0 

o 
p 
*■ 

o 
o 

CM 

iO 
cm 

c 
r- 

s 

N 

oT 

o 
r* 

0 

o 
o 

r 

p 

o 

10 

t 
en" 
r- 
M 

IP 

IP 

'J 

10 

■>j> 

N 

x 

0 

o 

0 

,0 

o 
o 
m 

O 

P> 

in 

F 

J 

3 

N 

0 

0 

0 
0 

rO 

O 

in 
it 

rJ' 

s 

(J 

in 

CJ 

h 

Ifl 

o 
o 

M 

0 
0 

* 
ill 

isl 

I 

t 

< 
<n 

i 

0 

a 

o 
o 

s 

3 

o 
o 

r- 

5 

ID 

o 
II 

^ 
^ 

5 

IS 

U) 

O 

O 

0 

d 

2 

^ 

CM 

X 
'ol 

CM 

* 

O 

N 

o 
a 

c0 

o 
o 

CM 
Itf 

CO 

r 
to 

I 

X 

E 

Q 

r 

o 
o 

o 
o 
p 

* 

'£! 

a 
< 

It 

o 

r 

0 

o 

i 

o 

r 
m 

CM 

r- 

in 

«5 
* 

0 

rJ 

o 
o 
o 

ro 

s 

CM 

i 

P- 

r- 
>n 

I 

'4 

0 

r 

o 
o 

5 

o 
o 
r- 
£ 

iM 

in 

ip 

CM 

X 

E 

0 

0 

0 

5 

o 
o 

s 

o 
o 

n 

s 

CO 

oS 
O 

C-J 

or 

CM 

0 

N 

O 
O 
O 

m 

CO 

o 
o 

M 

«6 

m 
co 

* 
(0 
0 
vn 
in 

I 

• 
■a 

X 

'2 

0 

£ 

o 
o 

5 

5 

O 
O 
P 
f 

+ 
^ 

* 

2 

5 

8 

CM 

§ 

N 

O 
O 

CO 

Lf) 
CM 

O 

CM 

c0 

a: 

M 
> 

0 
IP 

0 

o 

N 

8 

(M 
« 

CM 

<5 

o 
en 
o' 
o 

CO 

t* 
m 

o 

r 

ip. 

X 

o 

ip 

o 

0 

CM 

0 

e 
<i 

P 

'g 

M 

r- 

0 

o 

C>J 

0 

o 

M 

rj 
M 

o 

o 
to 

in 

CM 

O 

* 

cJ 

o 

0 
O 
N 

o 
o 

Ul 

Ul 
N 

i 
i 

CM 

i 

<M 

rf 

»< 

'-4 
CM 

IS 

a 

8 

Id 

<M 

t 

a 

s 

in 

r 

n 

< 

0 

0 
ID 

o 
o 

F 

o 
o 

M 

lO 

s 

r 

DC 

X 

in 

0 

0 

O 

U3 
OS 

N 

0 

CM 

n 

to 
r 

m 

to 
P 

N 
K 
'oJ 

N 

P4 
U) 

0 

o 
o 
M 

en 
r) 

o 
o 

10 

s 

,1 

to 

a 

(31 
N 

■A 

Si 

I 

0 
10 

o 
o 
* 

5 

8 

o 

CM 

E 

a+ 

v5 

CJ 

X 

2 

r 

o 
o 

CM 

O 

J) 

s 

CM 

o 

o 

<t 

r 

CM 

$ 

u> 

CM 

•1 

P 

3 

o 

cm 
Ul 

o 

ID 

O 

8 
3 

o 

0' 

o 

2 

o 

o 
o 

© 

cm- 
is! 

o 

i 

t 
s 
or 

CM 

in 

> 

0 

N 

0 

o 

in 

M 
CM 

o 
o 
o 
p 

cO 

IP 
o 
•J 
to 

vn 
< 

J 

£ 

Id 

Q 
Z 
J 
> 
J 

< 
P 

i0 

at 

u 
> 
a: 
Q 

ft 
U 

or: 
P- 

r 
5 

u 

J 

cC 
o 

U. 

> 

Of 

r 

a 
Hi 

i 
o 
u 

U 

< 
u. 

DC 

3? 

o 
z 

E 

u 

I 

in 
in 
< 

j 

0 

in 
qC 

u 

o 

z 
J 
)- 
0 

< 

5 

>n 
or 

Ui 

> 

m 
io 

u 
a: 

Z 
<c 

u 

h 

u 
u 

0 

u. 

Ul 

> 

J 
< 

2 

K 
I 
O 

u 

u 
J 
<£ 

£ 

3i 

o 

z 

E 

uJ 

X 

in 
J 

/I 

a: 

Ui 
Q 

z 
> 

0 

I 
< 

5 

in 

> 

a 

/) 

U 

a: 

a. 

I 
< 

UJ 

u 
J 

a: 
o 

u. 

U 

> 
P 

o 

<t 

H 

m4 

I 

u 
O 

IT 
3 
in 

0 

z 

1 

ul 

1 

EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


1161 


;::::u»9:::i:::::::::::::::: 


::..'■  ;::■;:::  .:.•: 


Fig.   2 — Curves   of   Train    Resistance,    Frictional  and    Grade. 


1162 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


1163 


speed  >h  miles  per.  hour.  — *» 
Fig.  4 — Curves  of  Tractive  Force  of  Engines  of  C.  B.  &  Q.  R.  R. 


1164 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


1165 


^8.1 

P 

'-0 

If) 

o 

p 

(33 

0 
(TV 
33 

0 

51 

c 

Ul 

m 
i?> 

o 
in 

0 

6 

Ul 

t 
o 

Ul 

p 
0 

Ul 

0 

0 
* 

0 
<0 

lit 

HlH 

p 

CO 

00 

05 

IT) 
CO 

0 
ffi 

0 
ffl 

ul    via   * 
0    ov   o 

^    a  j>    < 
tt     VO    tf 

0   <i«  J 

in 

h 
< 

J 

in 
in 
ff> 

0 

if) 

0 
p 

ff> 

o 

SI 

0 
0 

m 
i" 
0 

0 
Ul 
0 

0 

ti 

0 

0 

0 

Ul 
«1 

0 

in 

N 

0 

p 

si 

0 

0 

Ul 

i 

d 

0 

(0 

i 

z 
I.I 

r-V° 

? 

si 

si 

ir> 

in 

Ifl 
SJ 

O"   0 

[1 

0    1- 

D3 

0 
4- 

0 

(i) 
0 

0 

0 

0 
0 

in 
si 

0 

in 

0 

10 

0 

M 

0 

m 

M 

Ul 

a 

0 

rJ 

in 

0 

0 
0 

♦ 

0 

* 

O 

in 
* 

rO 

r*!^ 

0 

o 

o 

SI 

? 

p 

ffi 

< 

0 

o 

O 
0 

si 

0 

N 
N 

Ul 
4- 
id 

0 

r 

0 
0 
i« 

0 

I" 

0 

10 

0 

U) 
IC 

0 
0 

in 

m 
in 

in 

Ul 

r 

Ul 

in 

5 

sJ 

< 

t- 

7 

S    3 

<  s 

Ul 

8 

p 

© 

ffl 

O 

IM 

m 

u  O 

£ 

n 

0 

m 

o 

Ul 

0 

in 

0 

Ul 

O 

in 

0 

in 

O 

Ul 

o 

0 

si 

+ 

in 

10 

;** 

< 
U 

0 

<T> 

P 

tf 

<3 

r 

p 

I!) 

ii* 

in 

♦ 

* 

i« 

H 

a 
z 

tfl 

CO 

CO 

to 

op 

03 

00 

03 

iO 

*  ■ 

u 
h 

P 

< 

0 

0 

J 

p?|hJ 

(S 

p 
(0 

00 

U3 

0 

ill 

O 

01 

o 
ffl 

ffl 

4 

fi 

u 

<j 

i 
i- 

? 

m 

ui 

r? 

a: 

2 

P 

n 

h'ih" 

ffl 

rn 

IT. 

* 

CI 

in 

Ifl 

in 
in 

ffi 

« 

0   JJ 

■n 

z 

z 

p 

3* 

J 

tfl 

iq 

m 

<0 
(0 

a 
j 

HI 

a 

* 
(9 

SI 

oO 

(0 
in 

in 

in 

r 

M 
r*l 

in 

r 
o 

a 

a: 

«J 

0 

Z 
(f 

U       z 

<D 

ffl 

o 

- 

si 

Ul 

si 

io 

* 

X   r 

5* 

•;  2 

u 

<n 

cO 

r 

r 

r 

IP 

It 

« 

* 

+ 

ro 

0    i 

CL 

in 

0 

o 

n 

id 

0 

fl 

n 

O 

Ul 

0 

a 

LI 

Ul 

in 

0 

'J 

r  I 

£ 

z 

ill 

» 

m 

m 

in 

iO 

0 

A 

it 

Hi 

* 

r 

(1 

s 

r-V" 

ip 

EC 

Ul 

5  * 

h  J 

o 

«■- 

ffi 

iii 

ff> 

0 

o 

o 

(j 

N 

N 

n 

ui 
z 

0 
p 

17 

r- 

P 

Ji 

lO 

3 

a 

u 

* 

0 

ffl 

< 
J 

0 

0 

5 

ID 

r 

r 

ID 

»1 
* 

Ul 

0 
* 

|<1 

a 

P 
Si 

si 
N 

a> 

II 

0 

0 

r 

4 

htf|i-J 

V3 

3D 
if 

T 

p 

p; 

CO 

10 

cO 

s 

l/l 

CO 

i/ 

u 

h 

tC 

"J    ■""    u 

•  I 
r  II 

SO 

r 
P 

si 

+ 

0 

Ifl 
0 

0 

(0 

a 

0 
0 

o 

it 

0 

r 

0 
0 

rvl 

rJ 

Ifl 

Ul 

rJ 

Ul 

•i 

M 

0 

0 

In 
|fl 

o 

09 
|0 

Ul 

m 

Ul 

Ul 

r-V 

It 

to 

$ 

* 

ffi 

a 

ffl 

sJ 

ffl 

in 
< 

« 

* 

vj> 

It 

r 

M 

vO 

O 

0> 

P 

U       X 

i;1 

o     ,  o  8 

Z     l<     T 

vi  5S  i 

VI    i        w 

T       J     Vl      U 

1,1  J  2  t- 

<  5  <  o 

< 

ei 

r 

it 

<0 

u> 

J) 

it) 

ID 

* 

0 

si 

tO 

* 

m 

U> 

p 

u 

- 

0 

0 

09 

p 

p 

4 

in 

<T 

(^ 

p 

PI 

d 

*           i 

< 

z 
P 

p 

iO 

0 

p 

(J 

(J 

r 

0 

ffi 

N 
(0 

ffl 

J 

'Ul 

Ul 

m 

0 
0 
IS 

Cl 

i 
z 

0 

F 

i 

u 
i 

i 

r 

§          e        £ 

1          I                P    «        P     J 
r        <    «i        So       5    5 

k                   0            u    t                 v 
t          u     r          Jo        vi     - 

l      <   i      '8 

uZ<  <> 

fi 

* 

Is 

10 

it 

ffi 

in 

in 
in 

in 

+ 
4 

n 

0 

m 

cvl 

O   fc  £    r 

:<*#< 

< 

u^r 

£  ^8 

! 

r 

0 
u 
< 

r  «  i 
o   JJ   < 

a 

- 

M 

«• 

It 

(0 

0 

0 

n 

0 

0 

II) 

0 

IB 

- 

u 

'1 

M         1- 

.d  5'    .'»  J 

r 

■PC 

F 

r    * 

h 

1- 

Fig.  6 — Sample  Data  Sheet  Showing  Method  of  Calculating  Equated 
Train  Resistances  In  Tons  of  Train. 


*On  grades  of  0.5  per  cent,  and  under  the  D  rate  is  90  per  cent,  of  the 
C  rate. 


1166 


EQUATED  TONNAGE  RATING. 


1 

[ON 

" 

o 

0 

265 
285 
310 
330 
350 
375 
395 
415 
435 
465 
600 
530 
560 
505 
630 

llslsssslsslip?  : 

I       J                1 

o 

||  |  §  |  S  S  §  i  §  |  3  S  3  | 

ISIlslil'gllil8  ! 

:       j 

n 

2S|SS|SS2SS|||    ; 

gSSsslillslsiS  1 

1    1  * 

ssslllsslssssi  1 

1    -8 

w     s 

>     5 

3   s 

t 

c 

3 

53 

omouioiooiooiooiootno 

oiooiootoowowowow 

ooio)oto(-sioii)inioi^r) 

I       111 

si  | 

o-anasa-ivo  ox  vxoaMam 

vioaNaw  ox  ouaasaivo 

i"e 

O 
P 

<       » 

1      A 
VI      „ 

W     g 

H 
Ph 

S 

o 

a 

8SSSS825S5SS8S    j 

S  S  g  ?  2  8  3  8  8  8  S  S  S  8  f-  g 

H-^H 

o 
n 

2  |  |  S  S  S  8  |  |  S  3  §  §  §    | 

'58S8S5S8888388S 

i          W 

h"h 

s  s  3  s  §  i  i  1  §  1 1  a !  i  : 

s^s^gsssssn^ 

I    w  a 

< 

II1IIIII  lllll  1  1 

S££g;2SS£g2SS£SS 

6 

o     . 

►H         V. 

3 

K 

O 

a 
3 

a 

£j 

oiootooinowowotoowo 

otooiooinotoomotnoioou] 

OOOlCQCDt-NCDtDlfltO^^CJOCN 

s    1 

vxoaNaw  ox  vaosnv 
aaAio  ox  vioaNaw 
aaiao  ox  vnoihvhs 

VNoaavHs  ox  vsnvatb 

1 

B     A 

o    a 

8 

o 

0 

o8o55SSS8883°88 

»2  111  Is  1  all  a  II 

I         llri 

a 

1  slsss  35  1  Is  1 II? 

28 

SgggSSPSSSSPSS 

m 

I: 

la  la  1  III  1  lllll 

£  1 

< 

I 1  §  g  g  g  i  g  1 1 1 § 1  i  1 

s  s 

8S2S  SS8SS8S8S8 

!       a  a 

* 

c 

E 

5 

5 

I 
a 

5° 

oifloiooinowowoinoioo 
oo>o>(DooNN(0(otou>^^nn 

O    a 

omo   io    omotoo   io   omoin 

JJ1 

* 

FHOHOT     OX    3QA70 

O-IOa   OX   NO33B0   HajI3H 
VJJMVAV8    01    VHOHOV 

«« 

|S| 

C! 


&  W 


s  t> 


0 

a 

w 

< 

Pi 

^ 

o 

p 

C4 

K 

LJ 

< 

<  o 

pt. 

W 

o 

8 

en 
W 

H 

H 

< 

& 

p2 

i — i 

w 

£ 

< 

'A 

to 

/, 

qn 

H 


fe 


EQUATED     TOim  AGE     for      .3$     GRADE 
Resistances   10,000  -   12,500 


Ho. 
Of 

000 

10 

,500 

11 

,000 

Bars 

A 

B 

c 

D 

A 

B 

G 

D 

A 

B 

c 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

760 

810 

70 

730 

785 

840 

65 

755 

815 

870 

70G 

60 

785 

620 

845 

680 

905 

730 

610 

55 

820 

650 

555 

880 

710 

595 

945 

760 

640 

575 

50 

855 

685 

580 

520 

920 

750 

625 

565 

985 

795 

670 

600 

46 

900 

725 

610 

550 

965 

795 

655 

590 

1030 

840 

705 

635 

40 

945 

765 

650 

585 

1015 

845 

695 

625 

1G80 

885 

745 

670 

35 

995 

805 

690 

620 

1065 

895 

740 

665 

1135 

930 

790 

710 

30 

1050 

855 

735 

660 

1120 

950 

790 

710 

1190 

980 

840 

755 

25 

1105 

905 

790 

710 

1175 

1000 

840 

755 

1245 

1040 

895 

805 

20 

1170 

960 

845 

760 

1235 

1050 

895 

805 

1305 

1100 

955 

860 

15 

905 

815 

950 

855 

1015 

915 

10 
5 

So. 

of 

Sara 

11, 

500 

12 1 

OGO 

12, 

500 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

870 

925 

80 

835 

895 

950 

75 

865 

925 

980 

70 

895 

710 

955 

760 

1015 

820 

65 

930 

740 

990 

790 

675 

1050 

860 

715 

60 

965 

770 

655 

1030 

830 

700 

630 

1090 

900 

745 

670 

55 

1005 

810 

685 

615 

1070 

870 

730 

655 

1130 

940 

775 

700 

50 

1050 

850 

720 

650 

1115 

910 

765 

69G 

1180 

980 

810 

730 

45 

1G95 

890 

755 

680 

1165 

960 

805 

725 

1230 

1030 

850 

765 

40 

1150 

940 

796 

715 

1220 

1C00 

845 

760 

1285 

1080 

895 

805 

35 

1205 

990 

840 

755 

1275 

1050 

895 

805 

1340 

1120 

945 

850 

30 

1260 

1040 

890 

800 

1330 

1100 

950 

855 

1400 

1160 

1000 

9G0 

25 

1320 

1090 

950 

855 

1390 

1160 

1010 

910 

1460 

1210 

1060 

95E 

20 

1380 

1140 

1010 

910 

1070 

960 

1120 

1010 

15 

1070 

960 

1130 

1015 

10 

* 

Note. — Tables    showing 
jiven   in  Bulletin   138. 


train    resistance    from    12,500    to    35,000    lbs.    are 
1167 


EQUATED     T  0  B  H  A  G  E      for      .4$     GRADE 
Resistances  10,000  -   IS, 500 


no. 

of 

: 

10,5C( 

Hi 

oco 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D. 

A 

B 

c 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

615 

665 

710 

60 

640 

690 

735 

625 

55 

665 

565 

710 

610 

760 

650 

555 

60 

690 

590 

505 

740 

635 

540 

790 

675 

680 

520 

45 

720 

615 

530 

475 

770 

660 

670 

510 

820 

700 

605 

540 

40 

750 

640 

560 

505 

800 

685 

600 

540 

860 

730 

636 

570 

35 

785 

670 

590 

530 

835 

715 

630 

570 

885 

760 

670 

600 

30 

820 

710 

625 

550 

870 

750 

665 

600 

920 

790 

706 

630 

25 

850 

750 

660 

595 

910 

790 

700 

630 

960 

830 

740 

665 

20 

900 

790 

695 

625 

955 

830 

740 

665 

1015 

870 

780 

700 

15 

960 

830 

740 

666 

1016 

880 

795 

715 

1075 

920 

830 

745 

10 
5 

795 

715 

Bo. 
of 

Cara 

11,500 

12,000 

12, 

600 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

750 

795 

70 

730 

775 

820 

65 

755 

800 

670 

846 

60 

780 

660 

826 

700 

606 

876 

640 

55 

806 

690 

590 

855 

730 

630 

660 

905 

770 

665 

600 

60 

836 

715 

615 

550 

886 

760 

655 

590 

935 

800 

695 

625 

45 

870 

746 

845 

580 

920 

790 

685 

620 

970 

830 

726 

660 

40 

905 

775 

675 

610 

956 

820 

720 

650 

1006 

865 

760 

685 

35 

940 

810 

710 

640 

990 

860 

755 

680 

1040 

905 

796 

716 

30 

976 

850 

745 

670 

1026 

900 

790 

710 

1080 

960 

830 

745 

26 

1015 

890 

780 

700 

1070 

940 

826 

740 

1125 

990 

870 

780 

20 

1070 

930 

825 

740 

1130 

990 

870 

780 

1185 

1040 

915 

825 

15 

875 

785 

925 

830 

970 

870 

10 

6* 

IK 


E  Q   0   A   T   E  D      T  0   H  H   A   G   E      for      .5ff      GRADE 
Resistances     10,000  -   1£,500 


Ho. 
of 

lq^ooo 

lO.BOG 

11, 

000 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

G 

•  D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

615 

55 

560 

600 

635 

50 

580 

620 

535 

655 

560 

515 

45 

600 

520 

470 

640 

560 

500 

450 

680 

590 

530 

475 

40 

625 

545 

485 

435 

665 

585 

520 

470 

705 

620 

560 

495 

35 

650 

575 

505 

455 

695 

615 

540 

490 

735 

650 

575 

615 

30 

680 

605 

530 

480 

725 

645 

565 

510 

770 

680 

600 

540 

25 

715 

635 

565 

510 

760 

675 

600 

540 

805 

710 

635 

570 

20 

750 

665 

600 

540 

795 

705 

635 

570 

840 

745 

670 

600 

15 

790 

700 

635 

570 

835 

740 

675 

610 

880 

780 

710 

640 

10 
5 

830 

740 

670 

600 

875 

780 

715 

645 

745 

670 

No. 

of 

Cars 

11,500 

-  r-  ^ 

12, 

500 

12, 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

c 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

675 

700 

60 

655 

695 

725 

630 

55 

675 

575 

715 

610 

560 

750 

650 

585 

50 

695 

600 

545 

735 

630 

575 

515 

775 

675 

605 

545 

45 

720 

625 

565 

510 

760 

660 

595 

535 

805 

700 

625 

560 

40 

750 

655 

585 

525 

790 

690 

615 

555 

835 

730 

650 

585 

35 

780 

685 

610 

550 

825 

720 

645 

580 

870 

760 

680 

610 

30 

815 

720 

640 

575 

860 

750 

675 

605 

905 

790 

715 

646 

25 

850 

605 

895 

790 

710 

640 

940 

830 

750 

675 

750 

675 

20 

885 

785 

710 

640 

930 

830 

746 

670 

975 

870 

785 

706 

15 

925 

825 

745 

670 

970 

870 

785 

705 

1015 

910 

820 

740 

10 
5 

785 

705 

825 

740 

855 

770 

1169 


EQUATED     HIIAGE      for      .6j6     G  R  A  D  B 
Beeietances   10,000  -   12,500 


lo. 
of 

lO.ooo 

10, 

BOO 

11, 

000 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

c 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

650 

50 

500 

635 

570 

500 

45 

520 

465, 

555 

490 

590 

520 

466 

40 

540 

475 

430 

675 

510 

445 

610 

540 

485 

426 

25 

560 

495 

445 

390 

596 

630 

475 

630 

560 

505 

445 

30 

580 

520 

460 

410 

615 

560 

495 

436 

666 

585 

625 

465 

£6 

605 

545 

485 

430 

640 

575 

520 

460 

660 

610 

560 

490 

20 

635 

570 

510 

450 

670 

600 

545 

485 

T10 

635 

580 

516 

15 

665 

600 

545 

485 

705 

630 

575 

516 

746 

665 

610 

545 

10 
5 

700 

630 

575 

520 

740 

660 

606 

650 

780 

700 

640 

585 

Ho. 
Of 

11,500 

12, 

000 

12, 

600 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 

96 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

600 

635 

65 

585 

620 

665 

676 

60 

605 

535 

640 

566 

510 

676 

595 

535 

46 

625 

555 

490 

660 

686 

520 

460 

695 

616 

560 

486 

40 

645 

576 

510 

450 

680 

605 

640 

475 

716 

636 

570 

505 

66 

665 

596 

630 

470 

700 

630 

660 

496 

740 

660 

690 

525 

60 

690 

6S0 

555 

490 

725 

656 

685 

615 

766 

690 

615 

545 

25 

720 

645 

580 

516 

766 

680 

610 

640 

795 

715 

640 

570 

20 

750 

670 

610 

640 

786 

705 

635 

565 

825 

740 

670 

695 

15 

785 

700 

640 

670 

815 

735 

670 

595 

855 

770 

706 

625 

10 
6 

820 

730 

670 

610 

850 

766 

706 

635 

740 

660 

1170 


EQUATED     T  0  H  B  A  G  E      for      .7$     GRADE 
Resistances  10,000  -   12,500 


So. 

of 

Cars 

10.000 

10,500 

11,600" 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

606 

45 

460 

490 

520 

480 

40 

470 

430 

500 

460 

416 

535 

490 

435 

35 

485 

445 

400 

355 

515 

475 

425 

360 

650 

606 

460 

405 

30 

506 

460 

410 

370 

535 

490 

435 

395 

570 

520 

465 

420 

25 

525 

475 

430 

385 

555 

505 

455 

410 

595 

540 

486 

440 

20 

550 

495 

455 

410 

580 

525 

480 

436 

620 

560 

610 

460 

15 

575 

520 

480 

435 

605 

545 

505 

460 

645 

585 

535 

485 

10 

605 

550 

505 

460 

640 

580 

636 

485 

670 

610 

560 

510 

5 

530 

485 

515 

"Bo. 
of 

Cars 

lit 

500 

IS, 

000 

12 , 

500 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

i 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

675 

50 

535 

560 

500 

590 

626 

45 

550 

500 

575 

520 

470 

605 

545 

495 

40 

565 

515 

460 

416 

690 

540 

485 

435 

620 

565 

516 

460 

35 

585 

530 

476 

430 

610 

560 

500 

450 

640 

585 

525 

476 

30 

605 

550 

490 

445 

635 

580 

520 

466 

665 

605 

645 

490 

25 

630 

570 

510 

465 

660 

600 

540 

485 

690 

625 

565 

510 

20 

655 

590 

535 

485 

685 

620 

565 

510 

716 

650 

590 

635 

15 

680 

620 

560 

510 

710 

645 

590 

635 

740 

680 

615 

560 

10 

705 

650 

585 

535 

740 

670 

615 

660 

765 

700 

640 

585 

5 

560 

586 

1171 


EQUATED      TONNAGE      for      .8$      GRADE 
Resistances   10,000   -    12,500 


No. 
of 

10, 

000 

10, 

500 

11,000 

Dars 

A 

B 

G 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

96 

90 

85 

*i 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

465 

40 

425 

450 

405 

480 

435 

35 

440 

400 

360 

465 

420 

385 

350 

495 

450 

410 

375 

30 

455 

415 

375 

345 

480 

435 

400 

365 

510 

465 

425 

390 

25 

470 

430 

390 

360 

495 

450 

415 

380 

525 

480 

440 

405 

20 

490 

450 

410 

375 

515 

470 

435 

395 

545 

500 

460 

420 

15 

510 

470 

430 

395 

540 

490 

455 

415 

570 

520 

480 

440 

10 

535 

490 

455 

415 

565 

510 

480 

440 

595 

540 

505 

466 

6 

480 

440 

505 

465 

530 

490 

No. 

of 

Cars 

a, 

12, 

000 

12,500 

A 

B 

C 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

D 

A 

B 

ioo 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

- 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

500 

525 

45 

490 

515 

470 

540 

495 

450 

40 

505 

455 

415 

530 

485 

440 

400 

555 

505 

465 

420 

35 

520 

470 

430 

375 

545 

500 

455 

415 

570 

520 

480 

435 

30 

535 

485 

445 

410 

560 

515 

470 

430 

585 

535 

495 

450 

25 

550 

500 

460 

425 

580 

530 

490 

445 

605 

550 

510 

465 

20 

570 

520 

480 

440 

600 

550 

510 

465 

625 

670 

530 

485 

15 

595 

545 

500 

460 

625 

575 

530 

485 

650 

595 

550 

505 

10 
5 

625 

570 

525 

485 

650 

600 

555 

510 

675 

680 

575 

550 

1172 


EQUATED      T  0  H   II   A   G   E      for      .9#      GRADE 
Resistances  10,000  -   12,500 


No. 

of 

Cars 

10,000 

10, 

500 

11,000 

A 

B 

C 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

D 

A 

B 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

405 

430 

35 

395 

355 

415 

375 

350 

440 

400 

375 

30 

410 

370 

345 

320 

430 

390 

365 

335 

455 

415 

390 

360 

8S 

425 

385 

360 

335 

445 

405 

380 

345 

470 

430 

405 

375 

20 

440 

400 

375 

350 

465 

425 

395 

360 

485 

450 

420 

390 

15 

460 

420 

395 

365 

485 

445 

415 

375 

505 

470 

440 

405 

10 

480 

440 

415 

385 

505 

465 

435 

395 

530 

490 

460 

425 

5 

435 

410 

Mo. 
of 

11,. 

12,500 

500 

lc» 

JOU 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

loo 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

460 

485 

40 

450 

410 

475 

430 

400 

500 

455 

420 

35 

465 

420 

395 

365 

490 

445 

415 

385 

515 

470 

435 

405 

30 

480 

435 

410 

380 

505 

460 

430 

400 

530 

485 

450 

420 

25 

495 

450 

425 

395 

525 

480 

445 

415 

550 

500 

465 

435 

20 

515 

470 

440 

410 

545 

500 

465 

430 

570 

520 

485 

450 

15 

535 

490 

460 

425 

565 

520 

485 

450 

590 

540 

5C5 

470 

10 

555 

510 

480 

445 

585 

540 

505 

470 

610 

560 

525 

490 

5 

1173 


^^"B  T   0  B  H  A  G  E  f  o  r  l.Og  Q  R  A  p  S 
Resistanoes  10,000  -  12,600 


Ho, 

Of 

Cars 

10 

OGO 

10. 

500 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

.  ..  _  _ 

C 

s 

A 

B 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

360 

380 

355 

400 

375 

30 

370 

340 

320 

300 

390 

365 

335 

315 

415 

385 

366 

335 

25 

380 

350 

330 

310 

405 

375 

345 

325 

430 

395 

366 

345 

20 

395 

365 

340 

320 

415 

385 

360 

340 

445 

410 

380 

360 

15 

410 

380 

355 

335 

435 

405 

375 

355 

460 

425 

395 

370 

10 

430 

400 

375 

350 

455 

425 

395 

370 

480 

445 

415 

390 

5  ' 

396 

370 

390 

Ho. 

of 

Oars 

11,500 

12, 

000 

12,500 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

A 

B 

C 

D 

C 

D 

LOO 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

405 

435 

400 

455 

420 

35 

420 

390 

365 

445 

410 

386 

360 

465 

430 

400 

375 

30 

435 

400 

376 

350 

460 

425 

395 

370 

450 

445 

410 

385 

25 

450 

415 

385 

360 

476 

440 

410 

380 

496 

460 

425 

395 

20 

465 

430 

400 

375 

490 

455 

425 

395 

510 

475 

440 

410 

15 

485 

450 

416 

390 

510 

475 

440 

410 

530 

495 

460 

435 

10 
5 

505 

470 

435 

410 

530 

495 

460 

430 

550 

515 

480 

450 

1174 


EQUATED     T  0  B  H  A  G  E     for     1.156     GRADE 
assistances  10,000  -  18,600 


So. 
of 

Care 

'  16.000 

10.600 

11.000 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 
95 

90 

66 

80 

75 

TO 

6B 

60 

55 

60 

45 

40 

56 

350 

370 

50 

540 

315 

360 

336 

380 

355 

330 

305 

£5 

350 

326 

306 

280 

370 

345 

326 

300 

396 

370 

345 

320 

20 

565 

340 

320 

295 

385 

360 

340 

315 

410 

386 

360 

335 

15 

380 

355 

325 

310 

400 

576 

365 

350 

425 

400 

375 

350 

10 
5 

395 

370 

360 

326 

415 

390 

370 

345 

440 

415 

390 

365 

5o. 
of 

11,500 

lE^OOO 

12,600 

Jars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

LOO 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

66 

60 

55 

£0 

46 

40 

400 

420 

55 

390 

360 

410 

380 

430 

400 

380 

355 

50 

400 

370 

350 

326 

420 

390 

370 

345 

440 

410 

390 

365 

56 

415 

386 

366 

340 

435 

405 

380 

366 

465 

426 

400 

375 

SO 

450 

400 

380 

355 

450 

420 

395 

570 

470 

440 

4].5 

390 

16 

446 

416 

396 

370 

465 

436 

410 

386 

485 

455 

430 

406 

10 

460 

430 

410 

385 

480 

450 

425 

400 

500 

470 

446 

420 

5 

1175 


EQUATED     TONNAGE      for     1.2ft     GRADE 
RaBiatanoea     10,000  -  12,500 


No. 

10,000 

10.500 

n. 

000 

of  " 

Care 

A 

B 

C 

n 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

^ 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

feO 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

30 

315 

330 

310 

350 

330 

310 

25 

325 

305 

285 

270 

340 

320 

300 

285 

360 

340 

320 

300 

20 

335 

315 

295 

280 

355 

330 

310 

295 

375 

355 

330 

310 

15 

350 

330 

310 

290 

370 

345 

325 

305 

390 

370 

345 

320 

10 

365 

345 

325 

305 

385 

360 

340 

320 

405 

385 

360 

335 

5 

380 

360 

340 

320 

400 

375 

355 

335 

420 

400 

375 

350 

No. 
of 

11,500 

12,000 

12 

.500 

Cara 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

* 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

360 

380 

355 

395 

370 

30 

370 

350 

325 

305 

390 

365 

345 

325 

405 

380 

360 

340 

25 

380 

365 

335 

315 

400 

375 

355 

335 

420 

395 

370 

350 

20 

395 

370 

345 

325 

415 

390 

365 

345 

435 

410 

380 

360 

15 

410 

385 

360 

335 

430 

405 

380 

355 

450 

425 

395 

370 

10 

425 

400 

375 

350 

445 

420 

395 

370 

465 

440 

410 

385 

5 

440 

1 

395 

370 

1 

415 
. .  .  . 

390 

| 

425 

400 

1176 


B  Q  0  A  T  E  D  T  0  H  H  A  G  E   for  1.8 
Resistances  10,000  -  12,500 


G  R  A  DE 


»0.~ 

10 

000 

"10" 

of 
Cars 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

_..-U 
B 

,000 
C 

B 

10Q 
95 
90 
66 
80 

76 

70 
66 
60 
56 

50 
46 
40 
66 
20 

205 

326 

305 

330 
340 

320 

200 

£80 

£6 
£0 
15 
10 
6 

215 
226 
325 
250 
270 

£96 
205 

215 
230 
350 

i 

£80 
290 
300 
215 
220 
— 

260 

270 
280 
290 
306 

336 
346 
366 
370 

386 

315 
225 
325 
260 
265 

296 
305 
315 
330 
345 

275 
285 
296 
306 
320 

350 
360 
370 
386 
400 

330 
340 
350 
365 
280 

210 

220 
230 
245 
260 

290 
300 
210 
220 
225 

5o. 

of 

2ara 

11,600 

1£, 

000 

500 

A 

B 

0 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

LOO 
95 
90 
66 
80 

76 

70 
66 
60 
65 

60 
45 
40 
36 
20 

250 
260 

340 

2£0 

365 
376 

350 
360 

335 

310 

385 
396 

265 
275 

256 

226 

£6 

£0 

15 

10 

6 

270 

280 
390 
405 
420 

360 
360 
370 
386 
400 

220 
240 
260 
266 
280 

305 
316 
326 
335 
350 

385 
396 
410 
425 

370 

380 
290 
405 

345 
355 
365 
380 
400 

220 
330 
340 
355 
270 

405 
416 
430 
445 

285 
395 
410 
425 

265 
376 
386 
400 

226 
345 
365 
370 
385 

1177 


B  Q  U  A  T  B  D     T  0  H  S  A  G  B     for     l.H     GHAH 

Eesistano68  10,000  -   12.R00 


do. 

of 
Cars 

10.000 

10.500' 

11.000 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 
95 
90 
65 
60 

- 

75 
70 
65 
60 
55 

50 
45 
40 
35 
30 

305 

325 

305 

£5 
£0 
15 
10 
5 

300 
310 
3£0 
335 

£85 
£95 
305 
320 

£66 
275 
285 
300 

£50 
260 
270 
£65 

315 
325 

335 
350 

300 
310 
320 
335 

280 

290 
300 
315 

265 
276 
285 
300 

335 
345 
355 
370 
385 

315 
326 
335 
350 
370 

295 
305 
315 
330 
345 

£80 
290 
300 
315 
330 

Ho. 

of 

Cars 

11,500 

12,000 

12,500 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 
95 
90 
86 
80 

76 
70 
66 
60 
55 

50 
45 
40 
35 
30 

345 

325 

355 
365 

345 

320 

306 

370 

380 

360 
360 

336 

320 

£5 
£0 
16 
10 
5 

355 
365 
376 
390 
405 

335 
346 
355 
370 
385 

310 
320 
330 
345 
360 

295 
305 
315 
330 
345 

376 
385 
395 
410 

366 
366 
375 
390 

330 
340 
350 
365 
380 

315 
325 
335 
350 
365 

390 
400 
410 
425 

370 
380 
390 
405 

345 
355 

365 
380 
395 

330 
340 
360 
366 
380 

1178 


Q  0  A  T  E  J  T  0  H  H  A  S  E  for  1.4#  0  R  A  D  B 
Resistances  10,000  -  12.500 


Ho. 

10^000 

10. BOO 

11.000 

of 

Cars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

S 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 
95 

90 

85 

80 

76 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

80 

305 

£6 

286 

270 

256 

300 

285 

270 

315 

300 

280 

£65 

20 

295 

280 

266 

260 

310 

£96 

£80 

266 

325 

310 

290 

£75 

15 

306 

290 

278 

£60 

320 

505 

290 

276 

335 

820 

300 

285 

10 

316 

300  285 

270 

330 

515 

300 

285 

350 

330 

316 

800 

5 

525 

310  295 

£80 

346 

330 

310 

296 

366 

346 

330 

315 

Ho. 
of 

11,500 

12.000 

12,500 

Cars 

A 

B 

0 

D 

A 

B    C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

B 

100 

■ 

95 

90 

86 

60 

76 

70 

65 

60 

56 

60 

46 

40 

35 

30 

320 

306 

340 

320 

305 

366 

386 

320 

25 

330 

316 

295 

280 

360 

330 

315 

300 

365 

345 

330 

315 

20 

340 

325 

305 

290 

360 

340 

325 

310 

375 

8bb 

340 

325 

15 

350 

335 

315 

300 

370 

360 

355 

320 

385 

365 

350 

335 

10 

365 

345 

330 

316 

385 

365 

360 

335 

400 

380 

365 

350 

5 

380 

360 

346 

330 

400 

380 

365 

350 

415 

395 

380 

365 

1179 


EQUATED     TOHHAGE     for     1.5$     GRADE 
Resistances  10,000  -  12,500 


Bo. 
of 

io.Ooo 

16,500 

11,000 

3ars 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

30 

25 

265 

255 

280 

265 

250 

295 

280 

265 

250 

20 

275 

265 

250 

245 

290 

275 

260 

255 

305 

290 

275 

260 

15 

285 

275 

260 

250 

300 

285 

270 

260 

315 

300 

285 

270 

10 

295 

285 

270 

260 

310 

295 

280 

270 

325 

310 

295 

280 

5 

310 

295 

280 

270 

325 

310 

295 

____ _ 

280 

— _ 

340 

325 

310 

295 

Ho. 
of 

11,500 

12,000 

12,500 

Sara 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

A 

B 

C 

D 

100 

95 

90 

85 

80 

75 

70 

65 

60 

55 

50 

45 

40 

35 

30 

305 

320 

305 

330 

315 

25 

310 

295 

280 

260 

325 

310 

285 

275 

340 

325 

310 

290 

20 

320 

305 

290 

270 

335 

320 

305 

285 

366 

335 

320 

300 

15 

330 

315 

300 

280 

345 

330 

315 

295 

360 

345 

330 

310 

10 

340 

325 

310 

290 

355 

340 

325 

305 

375 

355 

340 

320 

5 

355 

340 

320 

305 

370 

355 

335 

320 

390 

370 

355 

336 
r 

1180 


THE   STORAGE  BATTERY  IN  RAILWAY  SERVICE. 

(Bulletin    X45.) 
By  L.  C.  Fritch,  Chief  Engineer,  Chicago  Great  Western   Railroad. 


INTRODUCTORY. 

The  Storage  Battery  is  rapidly  coming  into  prominent  use  in  various 
operations  in  railway  service,  such  as  Train  Lighting,  Station  Light- 
ing, Signaling  and  Interlocking,  Operation  of  Drawbridges,  Motor  Truck 
and  Motor  Car  Propulsion,  Telephone  and  Telegraph  work,  Supplement- 
ing the  Load  on  Current  Supply  Systems,  and  numerous  other  uses  to 
which  it  is  readily  adapted. 

A  brief  outline  of  the  theory  and  principal  characteristics  of  the  stor- 
age battery  is  herein  submitted  with  the  thought  that  it  will  prove  of  some 
service  to  the  Engineer  in  solving  the  problems  that  daily  confront  him  in 
his  work.  An  effort  has  been  made  to  present  the  subject  in  an  elementary 
form  and  as  briefly  as  consistent,  and  although  the  entire  subject  is  not 
fully  treated,  it  embodies  the  essential  features  of  a  branch  of  the  electrical 
field  which  is  daily  becoming  more  and  more  important  in  railway  opera- 
tion. 

HISTORY. 

The  principle  of  the  Storage  Battery  has  been  known  for  over  one 
hundred  years.  Gautherot  in  1801  discovered  that  a  secondary  current 
could  be  obtained  from  a  cell  which  consisted  of  two  silver  or  plati- 
num electrodes  immersed  in  a  common  salt  solution. 

The  cell  was  first  charged  by  passing  a  current  through  it,  then 
breaking  the  charging  current ;  he  connected  the  two  electrodes  to  the 
terminals  of  a  galvanometer  and  obtained  a  momentary  deflection,  in- 
dicating a  flow  of  current  in  a  direction  opposite  to  the  charging  cur- 
rent. 

While  the  discovery  of  the  principle  of  the  storage,  or  secondary, 
battery  may  be  said  to  date  from  1801,  no  further  development  of  note 
was  made  in  its  application  to  practical  use  until  1842,  when  Sir  William 
Grove  constructed  a  gas  battery,  which  established  the  first  progress  to- 
ward a  commercial  accumulator. 

Grove's  battery  consisted  of  a  pair  of  platinum  strips  immersed  in 
dilute  sulphuric  acid,  each  strip  being  surrounded  on  top  and  sides  by 
a  closed  glass  tube,  which  collected  the  gas  developed  in  charge,  and  kept 

1181 


1182    THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

each  gas  in  contact  with  its  respective  electrode  and  some  of  the  adjoin- 
ing acid  surface.  After  a  charge  was  passed  through  this  battery  and 
its  terminals,  then  connected  with  a  galvanometer,  a  small  current  in 
reverse  direction  was  perceived  for  some  time,  until  the  oxygen  and 
hydrogen  developed  by  the  charge  gradually  became  absorbed  by  the 
platinum  and  recombined  to  form  water.  While  this  was  an  important 
advance  over  the  discovery  of  Gautherot,  it  resulted  in  no  practical  value, 
and  with  all  the  development  since  Grove's  time  it  has  failed  of  com- 
mercial value. 

In  i860  Plante,  a  Frenchman,  developed  the  next  important  step  in 
storage  battery  development,  which  was  destined  to  prove  of  great  com^ 
mercial  value.  His  experiments  consisted  in  making  a  cell  using  lead 
strips  instead  of  platinum,  immersed  in  dilute  sulphuric  acid.  This 
cell  on  being  charged  yielded  a  considerable  reverse,  or  "secondary," 
current.  Plante's  important  discovery  was  that  each  time  such  a  cell 
was  charged  and  discharged  the  quantity  of  "secondary"  current  in- 
creased, and  further  experiments  developed  that,  not  merely  discharging, 
but  charging  in  the  reverse  direction  each  time,  the  capacity  was  brought 
up  rapidly.  By  these  discoveries  batteries  of  sufficient  capacity  to  render 
them  commercially  valuable  were  produced.  The  subsequent  develop- 
ments and  changes  made  in  the  Plante  type  of  battery  have  been  along 
the  same  fundamental  lines,  so  that  to  Plante  must  be  accorded  the  honor 
of  first  having  developed  a  commercially  practicable  storage,  or  sec- 
ondary, battery. 

Plante  found  that  the  lead  plate  which  was  connected  to  the  nega- 
tive pole  of  the  primary  source  of  power  became  coated  with  a  film  of 
dark  brown  peroxide  of  lead,  and  the  lead  plate  connected  with  the  posi- 
tive pole  was  coated  with  spongy,  metallic  lead.  Each  time  the  charging 
current  was  reversed,  more  of  the  metallic  lead  became  peroxidized  and 
the  gradual  accumulation  of  this  film  of  "active  material"  on  both  plates 
caused  the  increased  capacity  of  the  cell. 

Plante  arranged  a  large  series  of  cells,  through  which  he  continually 
passed  a  current,  first  in  one  direction  and  then  in  the  reverse,  the  dura- 
tion of  charge  gradually  increasing,  and  by  this  process  the  plates  accu- 
mulated considerable  thickness,  respectively,  of  active  porous  lead  and 
lead  peroxide  on  their  surfaces.  After  one  to  two  months  of  this  forma- 
tive process,  the  plates  were  ready  for  use. 

The  "forming"  process  for  converting  solid  lead  into  active  material 
was  tedious  and  expensive,  and  the  next  progress  made  consisted  in  over- 
coming this  difficulty.  Plante's  experiments  were  made  during  a  time 
when  electricity  had  limited  uses,  and  not  until  the  dynamo  was  per- 
fected was  the  urgent  necessity  of  storage  batteries  imminent. 

In  1881  Faure,  another  Frenchman,  discovered  a  process  of  forming 
the  plates  of  batteries  without  the  tedious  and  expensive  process  used  by 
Plante.  Instead  of  electro-chemically  treating  the  surface  of  the  metal- 
lic lead  plate,  Faure  covered  the  surface  with  lead  oxide  in  the  first  in- 
stance.    A   single   charge   was   then   sufficient   to   convert   this   into   lead 


THE   STORAGE    BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1183 

peroxide  on  the  one  plate  and  metallic  lead  upon  the  other.  This  in- 
vention marked  the  last  stride  toward  the  perfection  of  the  storage  bat- 
tery for  practical  use. 

At  the  same  time  and  working  entirely  independently  of  Faure, 
Brush,  in  America,  arrived  at  the  same  results  as  did  Faure,  so  that  in 
this  country  we  give  to  Brush  the  honor  of  producing  the  battery  known 
as  the  "pasted  plate"  battery. 

All  lead  battery  plates  made  at  the  present  time  are  either  after  the 
Plante  type,  where  part  of  the  metallic  lead  plate  is  chemically  acted  upon 
to  produce  the  active  material,  or  else  after  the  Brush-Faure,  or  pasted 
type,  where  the  active  material,  usually  in  the  form  of  an  oxide  of  lead, 
forms  an  integral  part  of  the  original  plate. 

Great  improvement,  however,  has  been  made  in  details  of  design, 
construction  and  process  of  manufacture,  which  have  collectively  brought 
the  lead  battery  up  to  a  high  state  of  perfection  and  of  great  commercial 
importance  and  value. 

About  ten  years  ago  Thomas  A.  Edison  assigned  himself  the  task  of 
perfecting  a  new  type  of  storage  battery,  one  that  would  be  light,  dur- 
able and  compact  and  free  from  the  difficulties  inherent  in  the  lead- 
sulphuric  acid  battery.  After  nearly  ten  years  of  unremitting  toil,  re- 
peated failures  and  triumphs  and  at  the  expenditure  of  vast  sums  of 
money,  he  has  succeeded  in  perfecting  a  type  of  battery  which  is  a  dis- 
tinct departure  from  the  old  battery  practice. 

The  principle  of  electro-chemical  action  in  the  active  materials  is  the 
same  as  in  any  other  type  of  "secondary"  battery,  but  instead  of  using 
lead  plates  and  sulphuric  acid  as  an  electrolyte,  Edison  uses  steel  plates, 
nickel  plated,  with  steel  tubes  and  pockets,  respectively,  to  contain  the 
active  material  in  the  positive  and  negative  plates,  the  active  material 
consisting  of  nickel  hydrate  for  the  positive  plate,  and  iron  oxide  for 
the  negative  plate,  and  the  electrolyte  being  a  solution  of  about  21  per 
cent,  of  potassium  hydrate  and  a  small  percentage  of  lithia. 

The  use  of  these  elements  provides  a  combination  that  is  practically 
free  from  the  corrosive  effects  of  the  lead-sulphuric  acid  batteries. 

The  Edison  battery  has  now  been  in  commercial  use  about  three  and 
one-half  years,  and  sufficient  length  of  time  has  hardly  elapsed  to  deter- 
mine its  life  and  efficiency,  as  far  as  economy  of  cost  is  concerned, 
compared  with  the  lead  battery,  which  latter  has  been  in  practical  use 
for  upwards  of  thirty  years. 

THE  LEAD-SULPHURIC  ACID  STORAGE  BATTERY. 

THE   PRINCIPLES   OF   THE    STORAGE   BATTERY. 

The  function  of  a  storage  battery  in  transforming  the  energy  of 
chemical  combination  into  electrical  energy  is  practically  the  same  as 
that  of  a  primary  battery.  The  storage  battery  has  the  additional  prop- 
erty of  being  able  to  be   recharged  by  the  passage  of  a  current  in  the 


1184    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

reverse  direction  through  the  cell.  This  reversal  of  current  reverses 
the  chemical  reactions  which  had  taken  place  during  the  discharge,  and 
restores  the  cell  to  its  original  condition. 

THE   LEAD   CELL. 

Until  quite  recently  the  only  type  of  cell  that  has  been  exten- 
sively adopted  in  commercial  service  of  all  kinds  is  the  lead  cell.  This 
cell  consists  of  two  lead  plates  or  two  groups  of  such  plates  which  con- 
stitute, respectively,  the  positive  and  negative  electrodes,  immersed  in  a 
solution  of  dilute  sulphuric  acid.  Each  plate  consists  of  a  metallic  sup^ 
port,  or  grid,  which  acts  as  a  support  for  the  active  material,  and 
at  the  same  time  serves  to  conduct  the  electric  current  to  the  point 
where  connection  is  made  to  the  external  circuit.  The  active  ma- 
terial of  the  positive  plate,  when  fully  charged,  consists  of  lead 
peroxide  represented  by  the  symbol  PbO?.  This  lead  peroxide  in  a 
healthy  cell  has  a  dark  chocolate  brown  color.  The  active  material 
of  the  negative  plate  in  a  fully  charged  cell  is  spongy  metallic 
lead,  and  is  slate  gray  in  color.  During  discharge  the  peroxide  is  re- 
duced to  a  lower  state  of  oxidization  and  combines  with  a  portion  of 
the  sulphuric  acid  in  the  electrolyte  forming  lead  sulphate  (PbSOO, 
which  being  insoluble  remains  on  the  plate.  At  the  same  time  the  spongy 
metallic  lead  of  the  negative  plate  becomes  oxidized,  and  also  combines 
with  a  portion  of  the  sulphuric  acid  of  the  electrolyte,  forming  sulphate 
of  lead  on  the  negative  plate.  During  discharge,  therefore,  it  will  be 
seen  that  the  electrolyte  loses  some  of  its  sulphuric  acid,  and  becomes 
weaker.  When  the  cell  is  recharged  the  lead  sulphate  on  the  two  plates 
is  decomposed,  the  sulphuric  acid  is  restored  to  the  electrolyte,  while 
the  active  material  on  the  positive  plate  again  becomes  lead  peroxide, 
and  on  the  negative  plate  spongy  metallic  lead. 

The  chemical  action  above  described  may  be  expressed  in  the  form 
of  the  following  equations  : 

PbO*  +  HaSO«  =  PbSO,  +  H,0  +  O  (i ) 

Pb  +  H..SO4  =  PbSO  +  H,    (2) 

(1)  +  (2)  =  Pb02  +  Pb+2H.S04  =  2PbS04  +  2HaO    (3) 

Equation  (1)  represents  the  reactions  which  take  place  at  the  posi- 
tive plate,  and  equation  (2)  at  the  negative  plate  during  charge,  and 
equation  (3)  the  combined  effect  or  fundamental  equation  of  the  stor- 
age battery  and  is  the  reaction  which  takes  place  on  discharge. 

CHARACTERISTICS     OF     THE     LEAD     CELL. 

The  open  circuit  voltage  of  the  lead  storage  cell  is  from  2.05  to  2.1 
volts.  This  applies  to  a  cell  which  has  been  allowed  to  stand  for  a 
sufficient  length  of  time  on  open  circuit  to  acquire  its  true  voltage  read- 
ing. Immediately  after  charging  a  cell,  its  open  circuit  voltage  will  be 
somewhat  higher,  due  to  bubbles  of  hydrogen  and  oxygen  gas  retained 
in  the  plates,  as  well  as  to  concentration  of  acid  in  the  pores  of  the 
plates.     Immediately  after   discharge,   especially   at   high   rates,   the  open 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1185 

circuit  voltage  will  be  somewhat  low,  owing  to  the  exhaustion  of  acid  in 
the  pores  of  the  plates.  After  standing  for  some  time,  the  open  circuit 
voltage  is  gradually  restored  to  the  normal  value,  and  this  occurs 
whether  the  cell  is  fully  charged  or  is  considerably  discharged.  The 
open  circuit  voltage  of  a  cell  cannot,  therefore,  be  used  as  an  indication 
of  the  state  of  charge  of  the  cell. 

During  discharge  the  voltage  of  a  cell  will  drop  below  its  open  cir- 
cuit value,  t^is  drop  being  clue  to  two  different  causes,  namely,  the  in- 
ternal resistance  of  the  eel.',  whose  effect  is  instantaneous,  and  the  so 
called  polarization,  which  appears  more  gradually.  This  drop  in  voltage 
increases  as  the  cell  becomes  more  nearly  discharged.  It  varies  with 
the  rate  of  discharge,  and  with  the  temperature.  The  final  voltage  at 
the  end  of  a  discharge  at  the  normal  or  eight-hour  rate  will  be  ap- 
proximately 1.75.     At  higher  rates  it  will  be  somewhat  lower. 

During  charge,  the  voltage  of  the  cell  will  rise  above  the  open  cir- 
cuit voltage  by  an  amount  dependent  also  upon  the  rate  of  charge,  and 
the  temperature.  During  charge  at  normal  rate  the  voltage  of  the  cell 
gradually  rises,  varying  from  about  2.15  to  2.3  volts,  and  toward  the  end 
of  the  charge  this  voltage  rises  rapidly  until  it  reaches  a  maximum, 
which  may  be  anywhere  from  2.5  to  2.8  volts,  depending  upon  the  rate, 
temperature,  acid  density,  and  age  of  the  cell.  On  account  of  these 
variations,  the  actual  cell  voltage  is  not  a  satisfactory  indication  of  the 
completion  of  the  charge.  The  most  reliable  way  of  determining  when 
a  cell  is  fully  charged  is  to  continue  the  charging  current  at  constant 
rate  until  the  cell  voltage  and  the  specific  gravity  of  the  electrolyte  cease 
to  increase  and  become  constant.     (Fig.   1.) 

The  capacity  of  a  storage  battery  cell  is  usually  stated  in  ampere 
hours,  based  upon  a  rate  of  discharge  which  will  exhaust  the  cell  in  a 
period  of  eight  hours.  This  rate  is  called  the  normal  rate,  and  the 
capacity  which  the  cell  will  give  at  this  rate  in  ampere  hours  is  called 
the  normal  capacity.  The  capacity  of  a  cell  in  ampere  hours  is  decreased 
by  increasing  the  rate  of  discharge,  so  that  a  cell  which  will  give  20 
amperes  for  eight  hours,  or  160  ampere  hours,  will  give  40  amperes  for 
about  three  hours,  or  120  ampere  hours,  and  will  give  80  amperes  for 
one  hour,  or  80  ampere  hours.  The  relations  between  the  discharge 
rate  and  the  capacity  given  above  are  approximate,  and  vary  some- 
what with  the  design  of  the  cell  and  the  type  of  plate.  A  rating  of 
seven  hours  at  the  normal  rate  and  one  hour  at  four  times  the  normal 
rate  is  quite,  usual.     (Fig.  2.) 

The  capacity  of  a  cell  in  ampere  hours  is  also  affected  by  the  tem- 
perature, and  in  the  vicinity  of  70  degrees  F.  the  normal  capacity  is  re- 
duced about  6/10  of  1  per  cent,  for  a  reduction  of  one  Fahrenheit  de- 
gree, but  the  capacity  also  increases  with  rise  in  temperature  at  about 
same  rate. 

During  discharge,  as  noted  above,  the  acid  density  becomes  reduced 
owing  to  the    combination   of  the  sulphuric   acid   with   the   active   mate- 


118C    THE    STORAGE    BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


^ 

«*>            CM            V.            <S* 

0> 

00 

K 

N 

N        N        N        N 

*< 

"< 

v: 

THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN   RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1187 


^.  (V^  rv,  \ 


1188    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

rial  of  the  plates.  The  variation  in  the  density  of  the  electrolyte  is, 
therefore,  a  very  accurate  measure  of  the  state  of  charge  of  a  cell,  pro- 
vided proper  correction  is  made  for  temperature,  and  for  the  loss  of 
water  due  to  evaporation,  provided  also  that  a  sufficiently  free  circula- 
tion of  electrolyte  is  secured  to  insure  uniform  density.  The  specific 
gravity  of  the  electrolyte  in  a  cell  when  fully  charged  varies  from  1.200 
to  1.300,  depending  on  the  type  of  cell.  The  higher  gravity  is  employed 
in  cells  where  the  quantity  of  electrolyte  is  small  compared  with  the 
bulk  of  the  plates.  In  common  practice  electrolyte  having  a  specific 
gravity  of  1.200  is  referred  to  as  twelve  hundred  acid,  or  sometimes, 
though  erroneously,  as  twelve  hundred  degree  acid. 

LEAD    BATTERY    CHARACTERISTICS. 

The  more  important  characteristics  inherent  in  the  operation  of  lead 
batteries  are  due  to  the  following  causes : 

(a)  Loss  of  capacity. 

(b)  Loss   of   active   material. 

(c)  Sulphation. 

(d)  Loss  of  voltage. 

(e)  Buckling  of  plates. 

These  will  be  briefly  treated  in  their  order. 

(a)  Loss  of  capacity  may  be  caused  by  the  filling  of  the  pores  in  the 
plate  with  sulphate,  thus  preventing  the  taking  place  of  the  proper  reaction 
in  the  active  material  in  the  interior  of  the  plates.  This  condition  can 
be  remedied  by  a  prolonged  overcharge  at  low  current  rates,  or  at  from 
one-fourth  to  one-half  the  normal  eight-hour  rate. 

(b)  Loss  of  active  material  occurs  to  a  greater  or  less  extent  in 
lead  storage  batteries,  but  is  greatly  increased  by  frequent  over-discharge, 
and  the  amount  of  sulphate  deposited  in  the  plates  will  cause  undue  ex- 
pansion of  the  active  material,  resulting  in  cracking  and  shedding  of 
same  and  depositing  at  the  bottom  of  the  plates. 

When  the  negative  active  material  contracts  to  such  an  extent  as  to 
reduce  the  capacity  perceptibly,  the  positive  plates  may  be  removed  and 
"dummy"  plates  (lead  sheets)  substituted.  The  connections  with 
terminals  should  then  be  reversed.  The  negative  plate  then  becomes  the 
positive  plate  and  the  "dummy"  the  negative  The  charging  current  is 
then  reversed  and  the  negative  plate  changed  back  to  sponge  lead.  This 
process  has  the  effect  of  opening  the  pores  and  bringing  the  negative 
plate  back  to  its  normal  condition.  The  current  when  reversed  should  be 
about  double  the  normal  rate. 

(c)  Sulphation  results  from  over-discharge  and  can  be  prevented 
by  not  permitting  the  discharge  to  fall  below  a  voltage  of  1.8  volts  per 
cell.  Sulphation  takes  place  very  rapidly  when  a  battery  has  been  over- 
discharged  and  is  permitted  to  stand  idle  in  this  condition  before  charg- 
ing. 

The  treatment  for  sulphation  consists  in  charging  a  battery  as  rapidly 
as  possible  without  overheating.     As  the  resistance  of  the  cell  is  greatly 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1189 

increased  by  the  sulphate  deposited  on  the  plates,  it  will  become  hot.  The 
temperature  should  not  exceed  no  degrees  Fahrenheit.  When  the  plates 
begin  to  gas  freely  reduce  the  rate  of  charge  to  normal  and  continue 
until  gassing  again  takes  place.  The  rate  of  charge  should  then  be  re- 
duced to  about  one-half  the  normal  rate  and  continued  until  further 
gassing  occurs.  The  cells  should  then  be  partly  discharged  and  the 
process  repeated.  Several  cycles  of  this  treatment  may  be  required  until 
the  capacity  of  the  cells  is  restored. 

(d)  Loss  of  voltage  is  due  directly  to  loss  in  capacity  of  one  or 
more  cells.  The  cells  having  the  lower  capacity,  being  in  series  with  the 
main  battery,  will  discharge  at  the  same  rate  as  the  cells  of  higher 
capacity,  causing  the  voltage  of  the  former  to  drop  more  rapidly,  bring- 
ing them  below  those  of  higher  capacity.  The  remedy  lies  in  bringing 
up  the  capacity  of  the  lower  cells  by  treatment  for  the  causes  which  in- 
duced the  loss  of  capacity,  by  treating  the  lower  cells  specifically. 

(e)  Buckling  of  plates  is  due  to  the  over-expansion  of  the  plates  on  dis- 
charge, and  is  caused  by  sulphation  to  such  an  extent  as  to  cause  expan- 
sion of  the  plates  beyond  their  safe  limit.  This  difficulty  results  from 
over-discharge  and  consequent  excess  deposit  of  sulphate  on  the  plates, 
and  is  intended  to  be  provided  against  in  the  construction  of  the  plates, 
but  when  this  expansion  exceeds  a  safe  limit,  buckling  of  plates  result?. 
Buckling  may  also  result  from  rapid  charging  or  discharging,  causing 
unequal  distribution  of  electro-chemical  action  on  two  surfaces  of  the 
plate  and  thereby  setting  up  stresses,  which,  if  not  resisted  by  the  plate, 
result  in  distorting  them. 

The  remedy  against  buckling  of  plates  lies  in  well  constructed  plates, 
and  care  in  not  over-discharging,  or  too  rapidly  charging  or  discharging 
batteries. 

(f)  Loss  of  electrolyte  is  a  frequent  cause  of  loss  of  capacity  in  bat- 
teries. If  through  evaporation  or  other  causes  the  level  of  the  electrolyte 
falls  below  the  top  of  the  plates,  the  portion  exposed  performs  no  func- 
tion, and  the  surface  of  the  active  material  for  the  electro-chemical 
action  is  reduced,  cutting  down  the  capacity  of  the  cells.  The  remedy 
lies  in  keeping  the  level  of  the  electrolyte  above  the  top  of  the  plates. 
When  adding  electrolyte,  care  must  be  taken  not  to  increase  its  specific 
gravity.  The  added  portion  should  be  either  pure  water  or  a  very  dilute 
solution  of  about  5  per  cent,  of  acid  and  95  per  cent,  of  pure  water. 

TYPES    OF    PLATES. 

The  lead  storage  battery  plates  are  divided  broadly  into  two  classes 
in  accordance  with  the  process  of  manufacture,  namely,  the  Plante  or 
formed  plates,  and  the  Faure  or  pasted  plates. 

In  the  Plante  type  of  plate  the  active  material  is  formed  electro- 
chemically  out  of  the  metal  of  the  grid  itself.  In  order  to  obtain  a  sat- 
isfactory formation,  it  is  necessary  that  the  grid  should  be  practically  of 
pure  lead.  In  order  to  obtain  a  sufficient  extent  of  surface  on  which  to 
produce  this   formation  of  active  material,   the    lead    grid   is   sometimes 


1190    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

provided  with  leaves  or  ribs  extending  across  its  face,  which  may  be 
produced  either  by  rolling,  spinning  or  cutting  the  original  lead  blank ; 
or  a  cast  grid  may  be  produced  consisting  of  vertical  and  horizontal 
ribs  with  openings  extending  entirely  through  the  plate.  The  latter  type 
of  grid,  having  no  central  web,  has  the  advantage,  when  used  as  a  posi- 
tive, of  permitting  the  active  material  to  be  worked  uniformly  through- 
out, even  though  the  amount  of  work  on  opposite  sides  of  the  plate  is 
unequal,  whereas  with  a  positive  plate  having  a  central  web,  unequal  work 
on  opposite  sides  (a  condition  which  is  almost  sure  to  occur,  due  to  dif- 
ference in  separation,  or  in  the  capacity  of  adjacent  plates)  will  dis- 
charge one  side  of  the  plate  before  the  other,  producing  unequal  expan- 
sion and  contraction  of  the  active  material,  and  a  tendency  to  distortion 
called  "buckling."  This  does  not  apply  to  the  negative  plate,  as  its  active 
material  does  not  expand  and  contract  appreciably  in  normal  service. 
(Figs.  3  and  4.) 


Fig.  3.     Tudor  Positive  Plate,  Fig.  4.     Rolled  Negative  Plate, 

Type  "EP."  Type  "EP." 

In  addition  to  these  pure  lead  grids,  composite  Plante  plates  have 
been  extensively  used  for  the  positive  plate,  consisting  of  a  grid  or 
frame  of  hard  antimony  lead  alloy,  supporting  sections  or  buttons  of 
soft  lead  on  which  the  active  material  is  formed.  The  best  known  plate 
of  this  type  is  the  Manchester  plate  in  which  the  buttons  are  made  of 
pure  lead  ribbon  corrugated  crosswise,  and  rolled  up  into  rosettes  which 
are  forced  into  circular  openings  in  the  alloy  grid.     The  active  material 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1191 

is  then  formed  on  the  surface  of  the  corrugations  of  the  ribbon.  This 
latter  type  of  composite  Plante  plate  has  been  used  only  for  the  posi- 
tive plate,  while  the  pure  lead  Plante  plates  are  used  for  both  positive 
and  negative  plates.     (Fig.  5.) 


Fig.  5.     Manchester  Positive  Plate. 

Rigid  Grid,  impervious  to  the  action  of  the  electrolyte,  thus  insuring 
original  conductivity  and  mechanical  support  for  the  active  material  through- 
out the  life  of  the  plate. 

Growth  of  the  active  material  does  not  distort  the  plate,  but  increases 
the  contact  pressure  between  the  buttons  and  the  grid. 

Absence  of  a  central  web  prevents  buckling  or  other  injury  due  to  any 
unequal  work  on  opposite  sides  of  the  plate. 

The  Faure  or  pasted  plate  consists  of  an  antimony  lead  alloy  grid, 
to  which  is  mechanically  applied,  by  a  process  called  "pasting,"  the 
active  material  consisting  principally  of  oxide  of  lead  with  small  quan- 


1192    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

titics  of  other  ingredients,  applied  in  the  form  of  a  paste.  After  drying, 
the  active  material  is  either  reduced,  or  formed  to  the  higher  oxide,  to 
produce  the  negative  or  positive  plate,  respectively.  Many  designs  of 
grids  have  been  brought  out  for  such  pasted  plates,  the  principal  object 


£.  a .a.'  'tb'.'iif 

Fig.  6.     Box  Negative  Plate. 

Rigid  Grid,  impervious  to  the  action  of  the  electrolyte,  thus  insuring 
original  conductivity  and  mechanical  support  for  the  active  material  through- 
out the  life  of  the  plate. 

Active  material  enclosed  in  compartments  by  perforated  sheet  lead. 
Thus,  the  active  material  need  not  be  mechanically  self-supporting,  but  is  of 
a  permanent  porous  composition  best  adapted  to  the  electro-chemical  re- 
quirements of  the  negative  plate. 


usually  being  to  arrange  ribs  or  pockets  that  will  retain  the  active  mate- 
rial in  position,  and  at  the  same  time  maintain  good  contact  between  the 
active  material  and  the  metal  support.     (Figs.  6  and  7.) 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1193 

CONTAINING    VESSELS. 

Three  kinds  of  containing  vessels  are  used  for  storage  battery  cells, 
namely,  glass  jars,  lead-lined  wooden  tanks  and  hard  rubber  jars.  Glass 
jars  are  used  for  stationary  batteries  of  smaller  capacity  up  to  capacities 
of  about  800  ampere  hours  at  the  normal  rate.  It  has  been  found  im- 
possible to  obtain  glass  jars  on  a  commercial  scale  for  batteries  of  larger 
sizes  owing  to  the  excessive  breakage,  due  to  the  weight  of  plates 
and  electrolyte  and  to  expansion  and  contraction  with  changes  of  tem- 
perature. For  stationary  batteries  of  larger  capacity,  therefore,  lead- 
lined  wooden  tanks  are  used.  It  has  been  found  that  selected  long  leaf 
yellow  pine  is  a  very  durable  wood  for  these  tanks  on  account  of  its  acid- 
resisting  qualities.     Special  precautions  are  also  taken  in  the  design  of 


ESBC0209 

Fig.  7.     Shelf  Negative  Plate. 

these  tanks  to  keep  the  acid  away  from  the  wood.  These  precautions 
consist  in  carrying  the  lead  lining  up  over  the  upper  edges  of  the  tank, 
and  down  a  short  distance  on  the  outside  clear  from  the  tank;  these 
overhanging  edges  being  provided  with  drip  points  to  concentrate  any 
dripping  due  to  the  creeping  of  the  acid,  where  it  will  do  no  harm.  Rub- 
ber jars  are  used  for  portable  cells  on  account  of  their  lightness. 
(Figs.  8,  9  and  10.) 

The  plates  in  stationary  batteries  are  supported  by  plate  lugs  pro- 
jecting from  the  plates  near  the  top,  which  rest  upon  the  edges  of  glass 
jars  or  upon   vertical   sheets   of  glass  in   lead-lined   tanks.     This   leaves 


1194    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

a  free  space  beneath  the  plates  for  sediment  to  collect  without  the  pos- 
sibility of  short-circuiting  the  plates;  this  space  being  free  from  obstruc- 
tions which  would  interfere  with  the  removal  of  this  sediment,  and  this 
must  be  done  at  intervals  of  several  years  in  most  stationary  batteries. 
In  rubber  jars  the  plates  are  supported  on  ribs  moulded  into  the  bottom 
of  the  jar.  These  ribs  must  be  made  of  sufficient  height  to  provide 
ample  sediment  space. 

In  stationary  batteries,  where  there  is  ample  separation  between  the 
plates  in  a  cell,  wood  diaphragm  separators  supported  by  vertical  slotted 
dowels  are  installed  between  adjacent  plates.     (Fig.   n.)     In  the  larger 


Fig.  8.     Multiple-Plate  Type  "Chloride  Accumulator"   Installed  on 
Two  Tier  Racks  in  an   Outbuilding. 


cells  hard  rubber  pins  through  the  dowels  near  the  top  serve  to  support 
them  from  the  tops  of  the  plates.  In  smaller  cells  the  dowels  extend  to 
the  bottom  of  the  jar.  The  dowels  prevent  the  plates  from  coming  in 
contact  with  the  separator,  and  the  separator  prevents  the  growth  of 
so-called  lead  trees  between  adjacent  plates  which  might  produce  short- 
circuits.  In  portable  cells  where  the  plate  separation  is  reduced  to  a 
minimum  no  dowels  are  used,  but  a  perforated  sheet  of  hard  rubber  is 
usually  inserted  between  the  positive  plate  and  the  wood  separator  on 
either  side  to  avoid  the  destructive  action  of  the  lead  peroxide  on  the 
wood  separator. 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


1195 


1196    THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

In  stationary  batteries,  cells  in  glass  jars  are,  in  some  cases,  sup- 
ported on  wooden  trays  filled  with  sand  to  produce  a  uniform  distribution 
of  pressure  on  the  bottom  of  the  jar ;  these  sand  trays  being  mounted  on 
glass    insulators.     In   other   cases,   glass    sand   trays   provided   with    suit- 


Fig.  10.     Rubber  Jar  Container. 


Fig.    ii.     Type   "F"   Wood  Separator. 


able  feet  are  used  in  place  of  the  wooden  sand  trays  with  their  insulators. 
Cells  in  lead-lined  tanks  are  usually  mounted  on  oil  insulators.  These 
consist    of    a    glass    insulator   provided    with   an    inverted   petticoat,   pro- 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.   1197 

ducing  a  circular  trough  which  is  partly  filled  with  oil,  this  insulator 
being  covered  with  a  lead  cap  extending  down  over  the  sides.  In  some 
cases,  where  the  voltage  is  low  and  the  circuit  is  not  grounded  at  any 
point,  a  double  tier  of  petticoat  glass  insulators  may  be  used  instead  of 
the  oil  insulators.     (Figs.  12  and  13.) 


Fig.  12.     Oil  Insulator,  Unassembled. 


Fig.  13.    Assembled  Oil  Insulator  Mounted  on 
Earthenware  Pedestal. 


The  insulation  of  lead-lined  tanks,  especially  in  batteries  connected 
to  high  voltage  systems  (greater  than  150  volts)  or  in  systems  where  one 
side  of  the  circuit  is  grounded,  is  of  very  great  importance.  A  slight 
leakage  of  current  which  may  take  place  over  the  surface  of  insulators 
coated  with  dirt  or  acid-laden  moisture  is  liable  to  produce  electrolytic 
corrosion  of  the  tank  linings.  The  oil  insulator  described  above  has  been 
found  to  practically  eliminate  these  difficulties. 


1198   THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

METHOD   OF   CONTROL    AND    CONTROLLING    APPARATUS. 

Several  methods  have  been  adopted  for  controlling  the  charge  and 
discharge  of  stationary  batteries.  One  of  the  most  important  pieces  of 
apparatus  for  this  purpose  is  the  booster.  This  is  a  dynamo  (which 
may  be  driven  by  belt  or  a  motor)  connected  in  series  with  the  battery, 
and  used  to  compensate  for  the  difference  in  voltage  between  the  electric 
circuit  and  the  battery  during  charge  or  during  discharge,  or  both.  This 
booster  may  be  controlled  by  manual  operation  of  its  field  rheostat,  or  by 
automatic  apparatus.  Wherever  automatic  control  is  employed  the 
booster  usually  controls  both  the  charge  and  the  discharge  of  the  bat- 
tery. Where  control  is  effected  by  hand,  the  booster  is  generally  used- 
only  for  charging,  and  the  discharge  voltage  is  controlled  by  end  cells, 
or  counter  electro-motive-force  cells.  End  cells  are  a  series  of  cells  at 
one  end  of  the  battery  connected  to  a  multiple  point  end  cell  switch  by 
which  the  number  of  cells  included  in  the  circuit  may  be  controlled. 
Counter  electro-motive-force  cells  are  electrolytic  cells,  in  which  the 
plates  are  plain  lead  grids  or  dummies  having  no  active  material,  and 
no  appreciable  capacity.  They  are  connected  to  a  multiple  point  switch, 
and  are  operated  in  the  same  way  as  a  rheostat  to  reduce  the  voltage 
during  charge,  or  at  the  beginning  of  discharge  when  the  battery-  vol- 
tage is  above  that  of  the  circuit.  In  some  cases  an  ordinary  rheostat  is 
used  for  this  purpose,  but  the  counter  cells  have  the  advantage  of  cut- 
ting down  the  voltage  by  a  fixed  amount  per  cell  (2.3  to  2.5  volts)  ;  this 
amount  being  but  little  affected  by  changes  in  the  amount  of  current, 
whereas  the  voltage  absorbed  by  a  rheostat  varies  directly  with  the 
amount  of  current  transmitted.     (Fig.  14.) 

Where  a  booster  is  not  employed,  the  high  voltage  necessary  for 
charging  is  sometimes  obtained  by  raising  the  voltage  of  the  generator, 
(Fig.  15.)  This  may  be  done  when  no  current  is  required  for  lights,  or 
if  lights  are  burning,  the  lower  voltage  necessary  may  be  obtained  by 
introducing  counter  cells,  or  by  an  end  cell  switch.  In  other  cases  small 
stationary  batteries  are  charged  by  dividing  the  series  of  cells  into  two 
equal  groups  which  are  connected  across  the  circuit  in  parallel  through 
suitable  resistance,  so  that  the  voltage  of  the  circuit  need  not  be  al- 
tered. In  many  small  battery  installations  no  voltage  control  during 
discharge  is  required.     (Figs.  16,  17  and  18.) 

DEFINITIONS  OF  COMPONENT  PARTS. 

Positive  Plate. — Brown  in  color,  active  material  lead  peroxide.  Figs. 
3  and  5.) 

Negative  Plate. — Gray  in  color,  active  material  spongy  metallic 
lead.     (Figs.  6  and  7.) 

Positive  Group. — The  set  of  positive  plates  of  a  single  cell  lead 
burned  to  a  connecting  strap.     (Fig.  19.) 

Negative  Group. — The  set  of  negative  plates  for  a  single  cell  lead 
burned  to  a  connecting  strap.     (Fig.  20.) 

Wood  Separator. — A  thin  wood  sheet,  specially  treated,  placed  be- 
tween adjacent  plates  in  a  cell.     (Fig.  11.) 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.   1199 


/£/<V/^^  £///?/</ 


1200    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


t 


1 


o 
O 


w 


u 


k 


inc    o  x  v^xvrvvjn.    Drt.  1  x  r^i\.  i     xin     i\.n.xx_,  vv /\  i     oxlxs.  v  xv^il.     iwi 


1202   THE   STORAGE   BATTERY   IN   RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


Fig.   17.     Switchboard  Front  with   Round   Pattern  Cell  Switch. 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1203 


Fig.   18.     Remote  Control  Cell  Switch.     Two  of  the  Four  End  Cell 

Switches  Installed  in  the  Sixteenth  Street  Substation  of  the 

New    York    Edison    Company.     Maximum    Capacity, 

20,000  Amperes  Each. 


1204 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


Q 


I   I   II" 

mm 

si 


ESB  CO.  206. 


Fig.   19.     Manchester  Positive 
Group 


Fig.  20.     Box  Negative  Group. 


Fig.  21.    Two  Plate  Type.     "ET"  Elements  in  Glass  Jars. 

Rubber  Separator. — A  thin  sheet  of  perforated  hard  rubber  used  be- 
tween adjacent  plates,  either  alone  or  with  a  wood  separator.  (Rubber 
separators  are  not  used  in  stationary  batteries.) 

Hold-down. — A  glass  weight  used  in  stationary  batteries  to  prevent 
wood  separators  from  floating. 

Element. — A  positive  group  and  a  negative  group  with  separators 
and  hold-downs  assembled  for  a  single  cell.     (Fig.  21.) 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.  1205 

Electrolyte. — The  fluid  or  solution  in  the  cells  consisting  of  dilute 
sulphuric  acid. 

Cell. — A  single  jar  or  container  equipped  with  element  and  elec- 
trolyte.    (Fig.  21.) 

Two-Plate  or  Couple-Type  Cell. — A  cell  containing  only  one  posi- 
tive and  one  negative  plate.  In  a  series  of  such  cells  the  positive  plate 
in  one  is  permanently  connected  to  the  negative  plate  in  the  next  by  a 
"U"-shaped  lead  strap  which  supports  the  two  plates  on  the  edges  of 
the  jars.     (Fig.  21.) 

Multiple  Plate  Cell. — A  cell  having  more  than  two  plates.  In  such  a 
cell  there  is  always  one  more  negative  plate  than  positive,  the  outside 
plates  being  always  negatives. 

Pilot  Cell. — One  cell  of  a  series  selected  for  taking  readings  of  vol- 
tage and  specific  gravity  to  indicate  the  condition  of  the  entire  series. 

SPECIAL   INSTRUCTIONS   REGARDING   LEAD    STORAGE   BATTERIES. 

Complete  instructions  for  the  care  and  operation  of  lead  storage  bat- 
teries are  issued  by  the  Manufacturing  Companies.  A  few  of  the  most 
important  points,  however,  are  given  below: 

Keep  the  level  of  the  electrolyte  above  the  plates.  For  this  purpose 
add  only  pure  water;  never  add  electrolyte  or  acid,  except  to  replace  loss 
by  spilling.  Weakness  of  the  acid  in  the  cells  is  an  indication  of  a  dis- 
charged condition  of  the  plates  and  the  acid  density  should  be  restored 
by  charging,  and  not  by  the  addition  of  acid.  Such  low  specific  gravity 
in  a  single  cell  of  a  series  may  be  the  result  of  a  short-circuit  between 
the  plates.  After  removing  this  short  circuit  the  cell  may  be  separately 
charged  or  the  entire  series  may  have  to  be  overcharged  in  order  to 
bring  this  cell  up  to  equality  with  the  rest. 

Do  not  over-discharge  a  battery.  High  rates  of  discharge  in  am- 
peres are  not  injurious,  but  excessive  discharge  in  ampere  hours  will 
shorten  the  life  of  the  plates. 

Do  not  overcharge.  Charging  should  preferably  be  done  at  the 
normal  or  eight-hour  rate  of  the  cells,  and  should  not  be  continued  after 
the  cells  are  fully  charged.  Higher  rates  than  the  normal  are  permis- 
sible at  the  beginning  of  the  charge,  but  the  rate  should  be  reduced  to 
normal  toward  the  end  when  gassing  begins. 

Do  not  allow  cells  to  stand  for  a  considerable  length  of  time  in  the 
discharged  condition.  After  a  battery  is  discharged  it  should  be  re- 
charged within  a  few  hours.  This  is  particularly  important  if  the  full 
capacity  of  the  battery  has  been  taken  out. 

Do  not  allow  any  foreign  material  whatever  to  get  into  the  cells. 

Ventilate  the  battery  compartment.  This  is  especially  necessary  when 
charging,  as  the  gases  given  off  form  a  mixture  when  confined,  which 
may  explode  in  the  presence  of  an  exposed  flame. 

Never  allow  the  sediment  which  accumulates  in  the  bottom  of  the 
jars    to  reach  the  plates. 


1206   THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


THE  EDISON  STORAGE  BATTERY. 

There  are  many  combinations  which  can  be  utilized  as  secondary 
storage  batteries,  wherein  when  charged  with  a  current  of  electricity,  by 
virtue  of  the  electro-chemical  action,  a  portion  of  the  electric  current  is 
returned  in  the  reverse  direction  of  the  charge.  Of  the  various  com- 
binations, however,  none  excepting  the  lead  sulphuric  acid  battery  has 
proven  commercially  practicable,  until  within  the  past  few  years,  when 
through  the  genius  of  Thomas  A.  Edison  a  combination  has  been  suc- 
cessfully developed  which  has  for  one  of  its  electrodes  nickel  oxide  and 
for  the  other  finely  divided  iron  or  iron  sponge,  these  being  immersed  in 
a  solution  of  potassium  hydrate. 

THEORY    OF    CHEMICAL   REACTION. 

Starting  with  oxide  of  iron  in  the  negative  electrode,  green  nickel 
hydrate  in  the  positive  electrode  and  potassium  hydrate  in  the  electrolyte, 
the  first  charging  of  a  cell  reduces  the  iron  oxide  to  metallic  iron  while 
converting  the  nickel  hydrate  to  a  very  high  nickel  oxide,  black  in 
color. 

On  discharge,  the  metallic  iron  is  converted  back  to  iron  oxide  and 
the  high  nickel  oxide  to  a  lower  oxide,  but  not  to  its  original  form  of 
green  hydrate. 

In  every  cycle  thereafter  the  negative  active  material  charges  to 
metallic  iron  and  discharges  to  iron  oxide,  while  the  positive  active  ma- 
terial charges  to  a  high  nickel  oxide  and  discharges  to  a  lower  oxide. 

Current  passing  in  the  direction  of  charge  or  discharge  decomposes 
the  potassium  hydrate  of  the  electrolyte,  and  the  oxidation  and  reductions 
at  the  electrodes  are  brought  about  by  the  action  of  its  elements.  An 
amount  of  potassium  hydrate  equal  to  that  decomposed  is  always  re- 
formed at  one  of  the  electrodes'  by  a  secondary  chemical  reaction,  and 
as  a  result  none  of  it  is  lost  and  its  density  remains  constant. 

The  result  of  charging,  therefore,  is  the  transference  of  oxygen 
from  the  negative  to  the  positive  electrode  and  a  discharging  of  a  trans- 
ference back  again  of  oxygen  from  the  positive  to  the  negative  elec- 
trode. 

A  comparison  of  the  two  types  of  batteries  may  be  made  as  follows : 


Element. 

Lead  Battery. 

Edison  Battery. 

(I) 

Positive  Plate, 

Lead  Peroxide 

Nickel  Hydrate 

(2) 

Negative  Plate, 

Sponge  Lead 

Iron  Oxide 

(3) 

Electrolyte, 

Dilute  Sulphuric  Acid 

Potassium  Hydrate 

(4) 

Insulation, 

Wood,  Rubber  or 
Porcelain 

Hard  Rubber 

(5) 

Container, 

Glass,  Rubber  or  Lead 

Nickeled  Steel  Cans 

Lined  Tank 

Wood  with  Steel 

(6) 

Trays, 

Wood 

Cradles 

(7) 

Connectors, 

Lead     Straps     Burned 

Copper  Wire  Steel 

on 

Lugs 

A  description  of  the  component  parts  of  the  Edison  Batteries  follows : 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1207 

POSITIVE    PLATE. 

The  positive  plate  consists  of  one  or  more  perforated  steel  tubes, 
nickel  plated,  filled  with  alternate  layers  of  nickel  hydroxide,  and  pure 
metallic  in  thin  flakes  which  form  the  active  material. 

The  tube  is  drawn  from  a  perforated  steel  ribbon,  and  has  a  spiral 
lapped  seam.  After  being  tilled  with  the  active  material,  the  tube  is  re- 
inforced with  eight  steel  bands  equally  spaced  to  prevent  expansion  and 
breaking  of  contact  of  tube  with  its  contents.     (Fig.  22.) 

NEGATIVE    PLATE. 

The  negative  plate  consists  of  a  grid  of  cold-rolled  steel,  nickel 
plated,  holding  a  number  of  rectangular  pockets  of  perforated  steel,  also 
nickel  plated,  which  contains  powdered  iron  oxide,  the  active  material. 
After  the  pockets  are  filled  they  are  inserted  in  the  grid  and  compressed 


Fig.  22.     Positive  and  Negative 
Plate. 


Fig.  23.    Insulation. 


between  dies,  corrugating  the  surface  of  the  pockets,  and  forcing  them 
into  integral  contact  with  the  grid.     (Fig.  22.) 


electrolyte. 


The  electrolyte  consists  of  a  21  per  cent,  solution  of  potash  in  dis- 
tilled water,  added  to  which  is  a  small  per  cent,  lithia. 


1208    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


INSULATION. 

After  the  plates  are  assembled  narrow  strips  of  hard  rubber  are  in- 
serted between  the  plates,  separating  and  insulating  them  from  each 
other.  The  side  insulators  have  grooves  to  fit  the  edge  of  the  plates, 
separating  the  plates  from  the  steel  container.  At  the  ends  the  negative 
plates  are  separated  and  insulated  from  the  steel  container  by  means  of 
smooth  hard  rubber  sheets.  At  the  bottom  the  plates  rest  upon  a  hard 
rubber  rack  or  bridge,  insulating  the  plates  from  the  bottom.  Very 
little  space  is  required  at  the  bottom,  as  no  active  material  is  precipi- 
tated.    (Fig.  23.) 

CONTAINER  OR  JAR. 

The  container  or  jar  is  made  of  rolled  sheet  steel,  nickel  plated, 
with  welded  seams.  The  sides  of  the  jar  are  corrugated  to  increase  the 
strength.     (Figs.  24  and  25.) 


Fig.  24.     Container  or  Jar. 


Fig.  25.     Cell. 


trays  or  boxes. 

The  assembled  cells  are  enclosed  in  wooden  trays  of  special  con- 
struction, using  light  wood.  The  cells  rest  directly  upon  a  steel  cradle, 
which  is  supported  on  the  lower  side  slats  of  the  tray.  The  cells  are 
held  in  place  by  steel  hold-downs,  attached  to  the  upper  side  slats.  The 
trays  have  no  bottoms,  the  cells  being  supported  by  the  cradles.     (Fig.  26.) 

connectors. 
The  plates   of   a   cell   are   assembled    on   steel   connector   rods;    with 
steel   spacing  washers,  all  attached  to   a   steel   terminal   post,   the   outer 


THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.   1209 

end  of  which  is  tapered  to  fit  a  terminal  lug.  The  tip  of  the  terminal 
is  threaded  to  receive  a  nut  to  hold  down  the  lugs.  The  terminal  post 
is  insulated  from  the  cover  of  cell  by  means  of  hard  rubber  washers  and 
bushings.     (Fig.  27.) 

The  terminal  lug  is  of  drop  forged  steel  made  to  fit  the  terminal 
post.  The  connecting  link  between  two  terminal  lugs  is  copper,  swedged 
into  the  lugs. 

VOLTAGE. 

To  charge  an  Edison  Battery  to  full  capacity  a  D.  C.  voltage  of  1.85 
volts  per  cell  should  be  provided.  A  60-cell  battery  requires,  therefore, 
a  D.  C.  voltage  of  60x1.85,  or  in  volts. 

The   normal   discharge   rate   of  the   Edison    Battery  is    1.2  volts   per 


Fig.   26.    Trays   or   Boxes. 


Fig.  27.     Connectors. 


cell.     The  terminal  voltage  divided  by  the  average  voltage  per  cell  will 
give  the  required  number  of  cells. 


efficiency. 


The  efficiency  of  any  battery  is  the  ratio  of  the  discharge  to  the 
charge,  of  the  electric  energy  derived  from  the  discharge,  or  use  of  the 
battery,  divided  by  the  electric  energy  expended  in  charging  the  battery. 


1210    THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

The  watt  hour  efficiency  of  the  Edison  battery,  at  the  normal  dis- 
charge rate,  is  approximately  58  per  cent.  The  watt  hour  efficiency  of  the 
lead  storage  battery  at  the  normal  discharge  rate  is  approximately  75 
per  cent. 

While  this  is  the  efficiency  of  the  two  types  of  batteries,  as  far  as  the 
relation  between  input  and  output  of  energy  is  concerned,  it  does  not  take 
into  account  other  considerations  which  affect  the  life  and  maintenance  of 
the  various  types  of  batteries. 

Some  of  the  advantages  claimed  for  the  Edison  type  of  battery  are 
as  follows : 

Longer  life  due  to  the  use  of  nickel  steel  in  the  elements  and  an 
alkaline  solution  as  an  electrolyte  eliminating  corrosion  of  parts. 

Lighter  weight  per  unit  of  energy  output  due  to  the  use  of  lighter 
material  in  plates  and  parts  of  battery.  No  injury  is  done  to  cells  if 
battery  is  overdischarged  and  if  left  discharged. 

Absence  of  such  difficulties  as  sulphation,  buckling  of  plates,  loss  of 
active  materials,  sedimentation,  breaking  of  jars  from  vibration,  corro- 
sion of  plates  and  grids. 

The  first  cost,  however,  of  the  Edison  type  of  battery  is  about 
twice  that  of  a  lead  battery  of  equivalent  capacity.  The  Edison  Battery 
has  not  been  in  general  commercial  use  long  enough,  in  competition  with 
the  lead  battery  and  under  equal  conditions  of  service,  to  demonstrate 
whether  its  life  is  twice  that  of  the  lead  battery  and  whether  or  not, 
therefore,  it  is  more  economical  as  far  as  first  cost  is  concerned. 


APPLICATIONS  IN  RAILWAY  SERVICE. 

The  applications  of  the  storage  battery  in  railway  service  may  be 
enumerated  as   follows : 

Train  Lighting. 

Signaling. 

Draw-bridge  Operation. 

Lighting  of  Stations   and  Terminals. 

Storage    Battery   Traction. 

TRAIN    LIGHTING. 

The  principal  systems  of  train  lighting  are :  Straight  storage,  axle 
lighting  and  the  head-end  system. 

In  the  straight-storage  system  the  batteries  are  used  to  carry  the 
entire  lighting  load  during  the  trip,  and  sometimes  during  a  complete 
round  trip,  the  charging  being  done  at  the  terminals.  Where  the  run 
is  not  so  long  as  to  require  excessive  battery  capacity  or  to  endanger 
over-discharge,  and  where  the  service  is  sufficiently  regular  to  insure  that 
the  batteries  receive  proper  care  and  systematic  inspection,  the  straight- 
storage  system  is   eminently  satisfactory. 

The  head-end  system  has  been  adopted  where  the  run  is  too  long  to 
permit  straight  storage,  but  the  train  makes  the  entire  run  as  a  unit,  and 
is  not  sub-divided  for  service  on  branch  lines.  In  this  system  a  battery 
may  be  installed  on  each  car,  or  several  batteries  may  be  distributed 
throughout  the  train  and  a  dynamo  is  installed  either  on  the  engine  or 
baggage  car  at  the  head  of  the  train,  driven  by  steam  from  the  locomo- 
tive boiler.  The  dynamo  is  run  at  a  voltage  sufficiently  high  to  take 
the  lighting  load  when  the  steam  supply  is  available,  the  batteries  float- 
ing across  the  circuit  under  these  conditions  without  any  considerable 
amount  of  charge  or  discharge.  When  the  engine  is  disconnected,  the 
batteries  supply  current  for  the  lights.  Under  normal  conditions  of  serv- 
ice the  amount  of  discharge  taken  from  the  batteries  is  comparatively 
small,  and  it  may  be  restored  by  raising  the  voltage  of  the  dynamo  dur- 
ing a  daylight  run  when  the  lamps  are  disconnected,  or  the  batteries 
may  be  recharged  at  the  terminals. 

Whenever  the  conditions  are  not  suitable  for  straight  storage,  or 
the  head-end  system,  as,  for  example,  where  cars  are  liable  to  be  operated 
on  branch  lines,  without  facilities  for  recharging,  or  where  the  service  is 
intermittent   and   irregular,   the   axle   lighting   system   is   very   generally 

1211 


1212    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

adopted.  In  this  system  a  dynamo  is  mounted  on  one.  of  the  trucks,  and 
driven  by  belt  or  chain  from  one  of  the  axles.  In  order  to  control  the 
voltage  of  the  dynamo  to  compensate  for  the  variable  speed  at  which  it  is 
driven,  many  automatic  regulating  devices  have  been  introduced.  In 
general  these  devices  are  designed  to  maintain  a  constant  current  output 
from  the  dynamo,  regardless  of  speed,  and  are  controlled  by  this  current 
output  in  such  a  manner  that  variations  within  certain  limits  will  vary 
the  field  excitation  of  the  dynamo  to  produce  the  desired  regulation. 
The  output  of  the  dynamo  being  maintained  practically  constant,  it  is 
obvious  that  when  there  is  no  lamp  load,  the  entire  output  will  be  utilized 
for  charging  the  battery.  As  the  lamps  are  turned  on  1he  amount  of  cur- 
rent delivered  to  the  battery  is  reduced,  and  if  the  demand  under  maxi- 
mum load  conditions  is  greater  than  the  output  of  the  dynamo,  the 
battery  will  discharge  to  assist  the  dynamo  in  carrying  the  load.  When 
the  car  speed  is  below  a  certain  limit,  the  voltage  of  the  dynamo  cannot  be 
maintained,  and  an  automatic  switch  disconnects  the  dynamo,  leaving 
the  battery  to  carry  the  entire  load.  This  switch  again  closes  auto- 
matically when  the  voltage  of  the  dynamo  has  reached  a  proper  value. 

The  varying  charging  current  into  the  battery,  and  the  varying  state 
of  its  charge,  produces  a  considerable  variation  of  voltage  at  the  bat- 
tery terminals.  In  order  to  prevent  this  variation  from  affecting  the 
brilliancy  and  life  of  the  lamps,  a  lamp  regulator  is  ordinarily  intro- 
duced to  control  the  lamp  voltage  by  varying  a  resistance  in  series  with 
the  lamp  circuit.  In  the  earlier  axle  lighting  systems  the  constant  out- 
put of  the  generator  was  adjusted  to  keep  the  battery  fully  charged  un- 
der maximum  load  conditions,  and  whenever  the  load  conditions  were 
less  severe  the  excess  output  produced  serious  overcharging  of  the  bat- 
teries, and  a  marked  reduction  in  their  normal  life.  Recently,  auto- 
matic devices  have  been  introduced  to  reduce  the  output  of  the  gener- 
ator, and  avoid  some  of  this  overcharge  when  the  battery  voltage  rises 
to  a  certain  point.  This  does  not  entirely  eliminate  overcharging,  but 
reduces  it  appreciably. 

One  modification  of  the  head-end  system  has  been  tried  with  some 
success,  under  special  conditions,  in  which  a  battery  is  located  at  each 
end  of  the  train  instead  of  on  each  car.  with  a  dynamo  at  the  locomotive 
end.  This  system  provides  for  keeping  the  lights  burning  when  the 
train  is  parted  in  the  middle,  but  does  not,  of  course,  provide  for  cutting 
out  an  individual  car. 

Train  lighting  batteries  are  mounted  in  compartments  supported 
under  the  car-bodies,  and  generally  consist  of  separate  units,  each  con- 
taining two  cells  mounted  in  a  wooden  crate.  (Fig.  29.)  In  most  cases 
two-compartment  lead-lined  wooden  tanks  are  adopted,  the  plates  being 
supported  by  porcelain  wedges  on  the  bottom  of  the  tank.  In  some 
cases  hard  rubber  jars  are  used,  embedded  in  insulating  compound,  which 
fills  the  entire  space  between  the  jars  and  the  wooden   crate,   the  jars 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1213 


Fig.  29.     Two-Cell  Unit  of  Type  13  "EP,"  in  Lead  Lined  Tank 
with  Special  Connectors. 


Fig.  30.    Two-Cell  Unit  of  Type  ii  "EP"  in  Rubber  Jars,  Wood  Crate. 


being  floated  in  while  the  compound  is  hot.  (Fig.  30.)  Hard  rubber 
covers  are  used  which  fit  the  jars  and  the  terminals,  and  are  sealed  in 
with  compounds,  so  as  to  prevent  the  slopping  of  acid,  a  vent  being  pro- 
vided to  allow  the  escape  of  gases  while  charging. 

Two  different  voltages  are  being  extensively  used  in  train  lighting, 
namely,  64  and  32  volts,  calling  for  32  and  16  cells  respectively.  Owing 
to  the  introduction  of  the  Tungsten  lamp,  and  its  greater  ruggedness  at 


1214    THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

lower  voltages,  the  32-volt  systems  are  becoming  more  generally  stand- 
ardized, especially  for  axle  lighting  systems.  The  higher  voltage  is  still 
used  for  head-end  systems  on  account  of  the  drop  in  train  line  conduc- 
tors, and  for  straight  storage  on  account  of  the  additional  capacity  ob- 
tained by  the  increased  number  of  cells,  which  would  involve  excessive 
size  and  weight  of  individual  cells  at  the  lower  voltage. 

SIGNALING. 

In  signal  service  the  storage  battery  has,  in  many  situations,  sup- 
planted the  primary  battery.  It  is  generally  found  less  expensive  to 
maintain,  and  it  also  offers  other  advantages  over  the  primary  cell,  suchu 
as  low  internal  resistance,  uniform  voltage  and  large  output  for  inter- 
mittent service,  such  as  the  operation  of  motor-driven  signals.  In  some 
cases  portable  batteries  are  employed  for  this  purpose,  which  are  col- 
lected at  regular  intervals  for  charging  at  some  convenient  charging 
point,  a  certain  number  of  spare  batteries  being  provided  for  service 
while  the  discharged  cells  are  being  charged.     (Fig.  31.)     In  other  sys- 


Fig.  31.    Four  SS  9  Signal  Cells  Assembled  in  Case. 


tems  the  batteries  are  charged  without  removal  by  a  charging  circuit 
which  extends  along  the  right-of-way,  into  which  the  cells  may  be  con- 
nected in  series.  Duplicate  batteries  are  installed,  one  of  which  is  con- 
nected to  the  charging  circuit,  while  the  other  is  supplying  the  current 
to  the  signals.  In  some  cases  the  storage  cells  are  connected  in  parallel 
with  a  sufficient  number  of  primary  cells  of  the  "gravity"  or  "bluestone" 
type.  These  primary  cells  supply  a  small  amount  of  current  continuously, 
sufficient  to  keep  the  storage  cells  fully  charged,  while  the  storage  cells, 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN   RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1215 

on  account  of  their  low  internal  resistance,  furnish  the  high  momentary 
current  demands  for  operating  the  signals.  The  choice  between  primary 
batteries  and  storage  batteries  for  signal  service,  as  well  as  the  best 
method  of  charging  the  cells,  will  depend  upon  local  conditions,  particu- 
larly on  the  space  between  the  signals  and  the  facilities  available  for 
charging. 

DRAWBRIDGE    OPERATION. 

The  introduction  of  storage  batteries  for  supplying  current  for 
operating  motor-driven  drawbridges  has  been  quite  general  of  recent 
years.  The  battery  in  this  service  has  two  important  functions.  The 
first  is  to  provide  an  absolutely  reliable  source  of  current  which  is  not 
subject  to  interruption.  Accidents  which  have  occurred,  due  to  failure 
of  power  while  a  large  vessel,  under  considerable  headway,  is  approach- 
ing a  partially  opened  drawbridge,  have  shown  the  necessity  for  such  an 
auxiliary  supply  of  current.  The  second  function  is  to  provide,  by  means 
of  a  small  continuous  current  supply,  for  the  heavy  intermittent  serv- 
ice required.  The  24-hour  average  demand  of  the  drawbridge  is  usually 
very  small  as  compared  with  the  momentary  maximum  demand.  By 
the  installation  of  a  storage  battery,  the  primary  source  of  current,  which 
may  be  a  dynamo  driven  by  a  gasoline  engine,  or  a  motor  generator  set 
operated  by  alternating  current  supplied  from  a  distance,  may  be  only 
sufficient  for  the  average  requirements,  and  for  charging  the  battery  at 
its  normal  rate.  On  discharge,  the  battery  may  be  called  upon  for  an 
output  up  to  eight  times  its  normal  rate,  or  under  certain  conditions  for 
even  greater  discharge  rates,  for  furnishing  the  heavy  momentary  cur- 
rents required  for  operating  the  bridge.  This  function  of  the  battery,  by 
reducing  the  maximum  demand  on  the  primary  source  of  power,  not 
only  reduces  the  amount  of  investment  for  generating  machinery,  but 
where  power  is  purchased  it  will  often  make  a  marked  reduction  in  the 
power  bills.  Another  advantage  of  the  battery  in  this  service  is  to  per- 
mit a  24-hour  supply  of  current  with  only  a  few  hours'  operation  of  the 
generating  machinery;  the  battery  having  no  moving  parts  does  not  re- 
quire constant  attendance,  and  the  cost  of  labor  may  thus  be  reduced. 
(Figs.  32  and  33.) 

STATION   LIGHTING. 

For  the  lighting  of  stations  and  terminals  the  storage  battery  is  a 
valuable  adjunct  to  the  power  plant,  permitting  the  latter  to  be  shut 
down  entirely  during  the  hours  of  lighter  load  when  the  battery  sup- 
plies the  entire  demand,  and  also  assisting  the  generating  machinery 
during  the  few  hours  of  excessive  or  peak  load.  Such  a  battery  is 
usually  charged  from  the  station  bus  by  means  of  a  booster,  which  is  a 
motor-driven  dynamo  connected  in  series  between  the  bus  and  the  bat- 
tery, and  supplies  the  additional  voltage  required  for  charging.  The 
discharge  of  such  a  battery  is  controlled  by  end  cells  connected  to  a 
multiple  point  end  cell  switch  which  may  be  operated  by  hand,  or  by 
remote  control  apparatus  to  cut  cells  into  or  out  of  circuit,  for  con- 
trolling the  battery  voltage,  and  the  amount  of  discharge  current  when 
the  battery  is  operating  in  parallel  with  the  main  generator. 


1216    THE    STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 


THE    STORAGE    BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1217 


1218   THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

STORAGE   BATTERY   TRACTION. 

In  the  early  history  of  storage  battery  development  considerable  at- 
tention was  paid  to  storage  battery  traction,  and  a  number  of  storage 
battery  cars  were  put  into  commercial  service  on  different  roads.  For 
one  cause  or  another,  however,  these  were  finally  abandoned.  Within 
the  last  two  years  this  application  of  the  storage  battery  has  been  revived, 
largely  owing  to  improvements  in  the  storage  battery  itself,  as  well  as 
to  a  better  knowledge  of  the  conditions  under  which  storage  battery 
traction  will  prove  successful. 

The  Third  Avenue  Railroad  Company,  in  New  York  City,  is  oper- 
ating about  eighty  storage  battery  cars,  in  which  lead  storage  battery 
cells  carried  on  the  cars  furnish  the  current  for  the  motors ;  58  cells, 
each  having  a  capacity  of  about  400  ampere  hours,  are  installed  on 
each  car  under  the  longitudinal  seats,  these  cells  being  charged  during 
the  night  without  removal  from  the  cars.  Some  experiments  are  also 
being  made  with  storage  battery  cars  on  branch  lines  of  steam  rail- 
roads', where  the  traffic  is  light,  and  only  infrequent  service  is  main- 
tained. It  is  probable  that  in  many  such  situations  the  storage  battery 
car  will  prove  to  be  the  most  economical  method  of  providing  for  the 
passenger  service  from  a  commercial  standpoint.  The  cost  of  labor  and 
power  will  be  less  than  for  locomotive  operation,  and  the  initial  invest- 
ment will,  in  many  cases,  be  considerably  less  than  that  required  for 
equipment  with  the  overhead  trolley,  particularly  where  power  can  be 
purchased  from  a  local  lighting  company,  at  a  low  rate,  during  the 
hours  when  the  lighting  load  is  a  minimum,  and,  therefore,  no  invest- 
ment for  additional  machinery  is  called   for. 

STORAGE  BATTERY  CHARGING  APPARATUS. 

The  means  employed  to  supply  a  charging  current  for  storage  bat- 
teries vary  with  the  circumstances  surrounding  each  individual  case.  The 
most  desirable  condition  is  that  in  which  current  can  be  secured  from 
some  outside  source,  available  without  the  installation  of  a  prime  mover. 
Such  conditions  are  provided  in  cases  where  there  already  exists  a  gen- 
erating plant,  either  operated  by  the  railway  company  or  by  commercial 
concerns  where  current  can  be  secured  at  reasonable  rates. 

There  may,  however,  be  no  outside  sources  of  power  available,  in 
which  case  it  becomes  necessary  to  install  a  plant  for  the  purpose  of 
generating  the  charging  current;  or  the  condition  may  arise  where  cur- 
rent is  available,  but  it  is  of  such  a  character  as  to  require  conversion  as 
may  be  necessary,  for  charging  the  batteries. 

The  character  of  equipment  required  to  provide  the  necessary  charg- 
ing current  will  usually  consist  of  one  or  more  of  the  following  types  of 
apparatus : 

(1)  Motor  Generator   Sets. 

(2)  Mercury  Arc  Rectifier. 

(3)  Rotary  Converters. 

(4)  Steam  Turbine  Unit. 

(5)  Steam  Engine  Unit. 

(6)  Internal  Combustion  Engine  Unit. 


THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE.    1219 

The  first  three  types  named  are  simply  converters  of  electrical 
energy,  and  presuppose  that  current  of  some  character  is  available  from 
an  outside  source,  which  only  requires  a  change  in  its  character  to  con- 
form to  the  required  charging  current. 

Types  (4)  and  (5)  are  usually  used  where  steam  supplies  are  avail- 
able, but  where  separate  steam  supply  is  necessary  for  the  installation 
of  this  type  of  generator  it  may  become  prohibitive. 

Type  (6),  the  internal  combustion  engine  with  its  various  available 
types  using  low  grade  of  oil  products  for  fuel,  is  the  most  practical  and 
economical  type  of  installation,  where  no  external  source  of  power  or 
energy  is  available. 

The  various  types  are  more  fully  described  as  follows : 

(1)  Motor  Generator  Sets. — Motor  Generator  sets  are  in  common 
use  for  battery  charging  installations.  They  should  be  preferably  direct 
connected.  They  are  adaptable  to  the  various  voltage  and  current  re- 
quirements. While  constant  voltage  is  desirable  for  driving  the  motor, 
even  such  fluctuating  current  as  trolley  current  may  be  used,  with  proper 
automatic  voltage  regulator. 

Motor  Generator  sets  are  either  of  the  D.C.-D.C.  or  A.C.-D.C.  type, 
the  former  known  as  the  direct  current  generator  set.  The  generator 
should  be  shunt  wound  with  considerable  range  of  voltage,  through  reg- 
ulation of  field  by  suitable  rheostats.  Moderate  speeds  are  recommended 
for  mechanical  reasons.  The  generator's  are  shunt  wound  for  125  volts 
with  variation  of  from  70  to  140  volts.  Motors  are  furnished  for  115, 
230  or  550  volts  D.C.     Capacities  range  from  125  watts  to  12.5  k.w. 

In  many  localities  it  is  possible  to  secure  at  fair  rates  supplies  of 
alternating  current,  usually  at  60  cycles,  single  or  three  phase  at  suitable 
voltages.  The  A.C.-D.C.  motor  generator  sets  are  frequently  used  in 
such  cases  to  convert  the  current  for  charging  purposes.  The  genera- 
tors are  shunt  wound  for  125  volts  normal  operation  and  range  from 
70  to  140  volts.  Motors  may  be  no,  220,  440  or  550  volts  for  two  or 
three  phase  current.     Capacities  range  from  200  watts  to  10  k.w. 

(2)  Mercury  Arc  Rectifiers. — Mercury  Arc  Rectifiers,  with  the  im- 
provements made  in  recent  years,  are  proving  one  of  th<»  most  prac- 
ticable and  economical  devices  used  in  battery  charging.  They  are  com- 
plete in  themselves,  requiring  no  auxiliary  apparatus  not  available  in 
small  floor  space.  They  are  furnished  in  standard  sizes  from  o  to  175 
volts  D.C,  and  in  capacity  from  10  to  50  amperes.  Where  battery  charg- 
ing is  done  at  a  terminal  for  car  lighting  service  it  is  possible  to  use  a 
number  of  rectifier  panels  side  by  side  to  obtain  the  necessary  amount 
of  current  required. 

Ordinarily  Rectifiers  are  designed  for  operation  where  the  Alter- 
nating Current  furnished  has  a  frequency  of  60  cycles  and  at  from  no  to 
220  volts,  single  phase.  They  are,  however,  readily  adapted  to  other 
voltages  and  frequencies  down  to  25  cycles.  Rectifiers  are  simple  in  de- 
sign and  very  satisfactory  in  operation  within  the  limits  to  which  they 
are  adapted. 


1220   THE   STORAGE   BATTERY    IN    RAILWAY    SERVICE. 

(3)  Rotary  Converters. — The  Rotary  Converter  in  small  sizes  for 
use  in  battery  charging  is  not  in  great  demand  on  account  of  its  cost 
and  characteristics.  The  impressed  alternating  current  voltage  bears  a 
constant  ratio  to  the  direct  current  voltage  current  generated  by  the 
rotary  converter,  so  that  the  direct  current  voltage  can  only  be  changed 
by  regulating  the  alternating  current  voltage.  The  ratio  of  A.C.-  to  D.C. 
current  is  6/10  in  three-phase  circuits  and  7/10  in  single  and  two-phase 
circuits.  On  account  of  these  limits  of  voltage  regulation  the  rotary 
converter  has  not  been  used  in  small  capacities  such  as  apply  to  battery 
charging. 

(4)  Steam  Turbine  Units. — Small  Steam  Turbine  driven  units  for^ 
direct  current  generation  have  not  been  generally  installed  for  battery 
charging  purposes.  Such  units  can,  however,  be  secured  and  may  prove 
economical  where  a  source  of  steam  supply  is  available  without 
special  steam  supply  installation.  There  are  numerous  types  of  steam 
turbines  available,  the  smaller  units  ranging  from  7  to  15  k.w.,  speeds  4,500 
to  5,000  R.P.M.,  with  shunt-wound  generators  125  volts  normal  opera- 
tion and  a  range  with  field  regulation  to  give  voltages  ranging  from  65 
to  140  volts. 

(5)  Steam  Engine  Units. — Where  a  steam  supply  is  available,  a 
direct  or  belt  connected  steam-engine-driven  generator  unit  is  one  of 
the  most  practicable  outfits  for  battery  charging.  These  are  adapted  to 
steam  pressures  as  low  as  80  lbs.  They  occupy  little  floor  space  and, 
when  supplied  with  fly-wheel  and  closely  regulating  governor  for  speed 
regulation,  result  in  practically  constant  voltage,  eliminating  automatic 
regulators  for  voltage.  The  direct-connected  steam  units  range  from  25  to 
50  k.  w. 

(6)  Internal  Combustion  Engine  Units. — The  devlopment  of  the 
internal  combustion  engine,  especially  the  types  using  low  grades  of  oil 
for  fuel,  opens  up  a  wide  field  for  the  application  of  such  prime  movers. 
They  are  built  with  various  numbers  of  cylinders  and  either  two  or  four 
cycle  operation.  When  reliably  built  and  of  good  design,  they  provide 
the  most  economical  prime  movers  adaptable  for  charging  service  at  iso- 
lated locations.    They  can  be  secured  in  sizes  varying  from  1  to  25  k.  w. 

This  type  has  the  advantage  of  being  capable  of  mounting  on  a  car 
and  thereby  providing  a  portable  charging  plant  which  can  be  utilized 
wherever  desired. 

In  general,  the  selection  of  types  of  apparatus  for  proposed  charging 
plants  should  be  made  only  after  special  investigation  into  the  power 
supply  conditions  at  each  particular  point. 

In  the  limited  quantities  of  current  required  for  charging  stations, 
current  can  ordinarily  be  purchased  more  cheaply,  or  as  cheaply,  as  it 
can  be  generated  independently,  and  where  this  can  be  done  much  an- 
noyance and  expense  may  be  saved  by  utilizing  such  sources  of  supply. 


THE  STORAGE   BATTERY   IN   RAILWAY   SERVICE.    1221 


LIST  OF  ILLUSTRATIONS. 

Fig.  No.  Title.  Page, 

i.  Approximate    Charge    and    Discharge    Curves 6 

2.  Capacity    Curve.      Rate    Time    Relation 7 

3.  Tudor   Positive    Plate,   Type   "EP" io 

4.  Rolled   Negative    Plate,   Type   "EP" io 

5.  Manchester    Positive    Plate 1 1 

6.  Box  Negative  Plate  •  • 12 

7.  Shelf  Negative   Plate 13 

8.  Multiple-Plate    Type    "Chloride    Accumulator" 14 

9.  "Exide"    Battery    at    Sixteenth    Street    Substation,    New    York 

Edison  Company 15 

10.  Rubber  Jar  Container 16 

11.  Type  "F"  Wood  Separator 16 

12.  Oil  Insulator,  Unassembled 17 

13.  Assembled  Oil  Insulator  Mounted  on  Earthenware  Pedestal 17 

14.  Booster  and  End  Cell.     Diagram  of  Connection 19 

15.  Counter  E.  M.  F.  Cells.     Diagram  of  Connections 20 

16.  Parallel  Charging.     Diagram  of  Connections 21 

17.  Switchboard  Front,  with  Round  Pattern  Cell  Switch 22 

18.  Remote  Control  Cell  Switch 23 

19.  Manchester  Positive  Group 24 

20.  Box  Negative  Group 24 

21.  Two  Plate  Type.     "ET"  Elements  in  Glass  Jars 2. 

22.  Positive  and   Negative    Plate 2; 

23.  Insulation 2] 

24.  Container  or  Jar 2« 

25.  Cell 28 

26.  Trays  or  Boxes 29 

27.  Connectors    29 

29.  Two-Cell  Unit  of  Type  13  "EP,"  in  Lead-Lined  Tank  with  Special 

Connectors    33 

30.  Two-Cell  Unit  of  Type  11  "EP"  in  Rubber  Jars,  Wood  Crate...  33 

31.  Four  SS  9  Signal  Cells  Assembled  in  Case 34 

32.  Northern  Pacific  Railway  Bridges  at  Duluth,  Minn.,  and  Superior, 

Wis.,  Equipped  with  "Chloride  Accumulators" 36 

33.  Chicago  &  Northwestern  Railway  Draw  Span  at  Clinton,  Iowa, 

Operated  by  "Chloride  Accumulators" 27 


INDEX. 


INDEX. 


A 

PAGF. 

Abutments,  design  of  bridge ,. 1085-1150 

Address,  President's 40-48 

Advantages  of  Oil  as  Fuel  Compared  to  Coal 437, 43S 

Alfred,  F.  H.,  election  of  as  Member  of  Nominating  Committee.  61 

Amendments   to    Committee    Reports 1079- 1082 

Arrangements,  Committee  on,   resolution  of  thanks  to 60 

Association   Affairs    40-44 

B 

Ballast,    report   on    95-300 

Conclusions   .  . .  . 97,  98,  99,  102 

Discussion    945~950 

Experiment    to    Determine    tbe    Necessary    Depth    of    Stone 

Ballast    1 13-265 

Conclusions  126,  127 

Description  of  Test  Track 114-121 

Gravel  as  Ballast 266-289 

Gravel  Ballast,  grading  of 99-102 

Gravel  Washing  Plant,  R.  F.  &  P.  R.  R 103- 1 10 

Methods  of  Test    122-127 

Physical  Tests  of  Stone  for  Ballast 97-99 

Proper  depth  of,  to  insure  uniform  distribution  of  loads....  95-97 
Report  of  Maintenance  of  Way  Committee  on  Ballast,   New 

York  Central  Lines 290-300 

Definitions    , 29  r 

Description    291, 292 

Photographs   and   Description   of   Ballast 295-300 

Recommended    Practice    294 

Specifications    292, 294 

Use  of  Oil  to  Secure  a  Dustless  Roadbed 295 

Ballasting,  rules  governing 66 

Boiler  Corrosion  and  Treated  Water 420-428 

Bremner,  Geo.  H.,  re-election  of  as  Treasurer 61 

Bridges,   Specifications  for  Erection 83-87 

Brush  Coating  and   Dipping,  value  of 867 


1226  INDEX. 

PAGE. 

Buildings,  report  on 885-899 

American  Method  of  Laying  Asbestos  Shingles 897,898 

Details    of    Flashing    and    Counter    Flashing    for    Roof    and 

Walls    891-896 

Diagonal  Method  of  Laying  Asbestos  Shingles 899 

Discussion   1054 

Flashings  889-890 

Roof  Coverings  885-889 

Business  Session 39-62 

C 

Carbon  Steel  Rails,  specifications  for 565-571 

Churchill,  Chas.  S.,  election  of  as  President 61 

Installation  of  as  President 62 

Clearance  Lines   for  Equipment 525 

Clearances   510, 511 

Coal  and  Fuel  Oil  Resources 437,  456,  457 

Coal  Fields  of  the  United  States 449"452 

Coal   Supply,   duration   of 453, 454 

Coating  and  Dipping,  value  of 867 

Committee  Reports 65-916 

Committees,  appointment  of,  rules  governing 32 

Concrete  Fence  Posts 902 

Concrete,  methods  of  depositing  under  water 487-502 

Concrete  Ties,  report  on 343~3"o 

Conservation  of  Natural  Resources,  report  on 429-457 

Advantages  of  Oil  as  Fuel  Compared  to  Coal 437,  438 

Annual  Fire  Loss 456 

Coal  Fields  of  the  United  States 449-452 

Coal  and  Fuel  Oil  Resources 437.  456,  457 

Crude   Petroleum    457 

Discussion    989 

Duration  of  Coal   Supply 453, 454 

Evaporative  Tests — Oil  as  Fuel 439-441 

Government  Fuel  Oil   Specifications 443,  444 

Inspection  and  Tests  of  Fuel  Oil 441-443 

Methods  of  Preventing  or  Lessening  Waste  in  the  Petroleum 

Industry  444-449 

Natural  Gas  in  Canada 457 

Peat   Deposits   in   Canada 4 457 

Petroleum  as  a  Locomotive  Fuel 438,  430 

Tree   Planting  and  General  Reforestation 430-437,455,456 

Bibliography 435-437 

Constitution    23-31 

Construction  Contract  Form 909-916 


INDEX.  1227 

PAGE. 

Creosote   Oil,   specifications    for 865,  866 

Crossings  of  Electric  Light  and   Power  Lines,  specifications  for 

overhead    512-521 

Crude    Petroleum   in    Canada 457 

Cypress  Lumber,  classification  and  grading  rules  for 875-884 

Gushing,  W.  C.   (see  also  under  "The  President")  : 

.    Address   of 40-48 

Resolution  of  thanks  to 62 

D 

Darling,  W.  L.,  election  of  as  Director 61 

Delano,  F.  A.,  election  of  as  Director 61 

Design  of  Railway  Bridge  Abutments 1085-1150 

Discussions    of    Committee    Reports 919-1076 

Division  Engine  Terminal,  typical  situation  plans 91,92 

Drainage,  agricultural,  as  it  affects  railways 396,  397 

Drainage,  rules  governing 66 

E 

Economics  of  Railway  Location,  report  on 905,  906 

Discussion    1058 

Electricity,  report  on 509-558 

Clearances    510 

Discussion   998-1016 

Foundations    518 

General   Requirements    512-514 

Loads    514-516 

Material 516-518 

Protective  Coatings 518 

Recommendations    511 

Specifications  for  Overhead  Crossings  of  Electric  Light  and 

Power    Lines 512-521 

Transmission   Lines   and   Crossings 511 

Engineer,   defined    87 

Ejigine  Service,   furnishing  of 84 

Equipment  Diagrams  of  Various  Railways 526-534 

Evaporative  Tests — Oil  as  Fuel 439-441 

F 

Felt,  C.  F.  W.,  election  of  as  Member  of  Nominating  Committee  6r 

Fence  Posts,  concrete 902 

Fence  Wire    900-902 

Fire  Loss,  annual,  in  Canada 456 

Flashing,  for  roofs  and  walls 891-896 


1228  INDEX. 

PAGE. 

Forests  of  the  United  States 430 

Freight,  handling  of  by  mechanical  means 90, 91 

Fritch,  E.  H.,  re-election  of  as  Secretary 61 

Fritch,    L.    C,   paper   by   on    "The    Storage    Battery   in   Railway 

Service"   1 181-1221 

Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches,  general  specifications  for 375-386 

Frogs,   general   specifications   for 377~38o 

G 

a 

Gas,  Natural,  in  Canada 457 

General  Information   32-36 

General  Plan  for  a  Reinforced  Concrete  Sub-Structure  and  a  Re- 
inforced Concrete  Water  Tank 407-409 

Government   Fuel    Oil    Specifications 443, 444 

Grading  of  Lumber,   report  on 873-884 

Classification  and  Grading  Rules   for  Cypress   Lumber  and 

Shingles  875-884 

Barn  or  Dimension 880,  881 

Cull  or   Peck 881 

Finishing    ^81, 882 

General    Instructions 875 

Pickets,   Battens,    Car   Roofing  and   Siding,   Car  Lining, 

Shingles    883, 884 

Selects    880 

Siding,  Flooring  and  Ceiling  Partition 882 

Standard    Defects    875, 878 

Standard  Finished  Sizes  of  Cypress 878,  870 

Standard   Lengths    878 

Tank    Stock    879, 880 

Discussion 1052,  1053 

Recommendations 873, 874 

Guard   Rails,   progress    report 79 

I 

Indiana  Railroad   Commission,  hearing  before 841-862 

Ingots  and  Derivative  Shapes,  tests  made  at  Watertown  Arsenal  ~$3 

Inspection  and  Tests  of  Fuel  Oil 441-443 

Insulation  Resistances,  table  of ' 70 

Iron  and  Steel  Structures,  report  on .  81-88 

Conclusions ,  82 

Discussion     934, 935 

Secondary  Stresses 88 

Specifications  for  the  Erection  of  Railroad  Bridges 83-87 


INDEX.  1229 

L 

PAGE. 

Lead    Battery    Characteristics 1 188.  1 189 

Locomotive    Boiler   Corrosion 420-428 

Locomotive  Tonnage  Rating 1151-1180 

M 

Manual,  general  rules  for  the  publication  of 36 

Masonry,  report  on 459-504 

Conclusions  , 476,  477,  488,  504 

Discussion     990-995 

Methods  of  Depositing  Concrete  Under  Water 487-502 

Methods   of   Patching  and   Repairing  Plain  and   Reinforced 

Concrete  474-487 

Report  on  Work  of  Joint  Committee  on  Concrete  and  Re- 
inforced   Concrete    502 

Unification  of  Portland  Cement  Specifications 502-504 

Waterproofing   of   Masonry 459-474 

Materials,  handling  and  storing  of 84 

Monographs  : 

Design  of  Railway  Bridge  Abutments .1085-1150 

Equated  Tonnage  Rating  for  Locomotives 1151-1180 

Storage  Battery  in  Railway  Service .1181-1221 

N 

National  Railway  Appliances  Association,  resolution  of  thanks  to        59,  60 

Natural  Gas  in   Canada 457 

Nominating  Committee,  election  of 61 


O 

Officers,  election  of 60,  61 

Oil,  advantages  of  as  fuel,  as  compared  to  coal 437-449 

Oil  Tanks,  general  specifications  for 417-419 

Osgood,  Jos.  O.,  election  of  as  Member  of  Nominating  Committee  61 


P 

Painting  86 

Paragraphs  in   Specifications   for  Overhead   Crossing  of  Electric 

Light  and  Power  Lines  as  Adopted  by  Other  Associations..  522,523 

Passenger   Stations,  typical   situation  plans 90 

Peat   Deposits  in   Canada 457 

Petroleum  as  a  Locomotive  Fuel 438,  439 

Petroleum  Industry,  methods  of  preventing  or  lessening  waste.  .  444-449 


1230  INDEX. 

PAGE. 

Piling,   sheet,  progress   report 78,  79 

Portland  Cement  Specifications,  unification  of 502-504 

President,  address  of 40-48 

R 

Rail,  report  on 559-862 

Comparative   Wear   of    Bessemer,    Open-Hearth   and   Nickel 

Steel  Rail  on  Pennsylvania  Railroad 635-654 

Discussion  1017-1038 

Hearing  before  Indiana  Railroad  Commission 841-862 

History,  Development  and  Use  of  Rails  by  Railroad  Com- 
panies of  the  United  States  from  1830  to  date 843-850 

Influence  of  Rolling  Temperature  on  the  Properties  of  Bes- 
semer Rails    797-839 

Rail    Failure    Statistics    for    One    Year    Ending    October   31, 

1910 613-633 

Thoughts  Resulting  from  the  Study 633 

Segregation  and  Other  Rail  Properties  as  Influenced  by  Size 

of   Ingot    655-752 

Specifications   for   Carbon   Steel  Rails 565-571 

Chemical    Requirements 565,  566 

Details  of  Manufacture 569-571 

Inspection    565 

Material     565 

Physical  Requirements   566-569 

Steel  Rails,  Investigation  by  the  American  Society  of  Civil 

Engineers 851,  852 

Study  of  Seventeen  Good  Service  Rails 573-6n 

Summary  of  Work  of  the  Committee 559-564 

The  Question  of  the  Improvement  of  Rail  Design  and  Specifi- 
cations, from  1893  to  the  Present  Time 853-862 

Rail,  rules  governing  laying 67 

Ray,  G.  J.,  election  of  as  Member  of  Nominating  Committee...  6i 

Records  and  Accounts,  report  on 505-507 

Conclusions    506, 507 

Discussion   996, 997 

Reasons    for   Maintaining    a    Storehouse 506,507 

Reinforced  Concrete,  methods  of  patching  and  repairing 474-487 

Reinforced  Concrete,  use  of  for  railway  water  tanks  and  supports  402-417 

Roadway,   report  on 387-400 

Agricultural  Drainage  as  it  Affects  Railways 396,  397 

Discussion    981, 982 

Tunnel  Construction  and  Ventilation 396,  398-400 

Unit  Pressures  Allowable  on  Roadbeds  of  Different  Materials  388-396 

Waterway  Formulas 387,  388 


INDEX.  1231 

PACE. 

Rules  and  Organization,  report  on 65-68 

•    Discussion  919-931 

Instructions .• 66-68 

S 

Secretary,  report  of 49-52 

Scott,  W.  B.,  election  of  as  Director 61 

Sheet   Piling,   progress   report 78,  79 

Shingles,  asbestos,  method  of  laying 897-899 

Signals  and  Interlocking,   report  on 69-74 

Conclusions     69, 70 

Discussion    932, 933 

Minority  report   75,  76 

Recommendations    71-74 

Signal  Fundamentals   71 

Supplementary   Indications  to  be  used  where  required 71 

Uniform  Signaling  70-74 

Signs,  Fences  and  Crossings,  report  on 900-904 

Concrete  Fence  Posts 902 

Discussion   1055-1057 

Fence  Wire 900-902 

Signs    for   Railroad    Purposes 903, 904 

Track  Construction  and  Flangeways  at  Street  Crossings  in 

Paved   Streets    902, 903 

Specifications : 

Carbon   Steel   Rails 565-571 

Creosote    Oil    865, 866 

Cypress  Lumber   573-612 

Erection  of  Railroad  Bridges 83-87 

Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches 371-374 

Galvanizing  Iron   or   Steel 521-529 

Government   Fuel   Oil   Specifications 443,  444 

Ordinary  Steel  Water  and  Oil  Tanks 417-419 

Overhead  Crossings  of  Electric  Light  and  Power  Lines....  512-521 

Reinforced  Concrete  Standpipe  Water  Tank  for  Railways.  .  413-417 

Standpipe,  design  for  reinforced  concrete 410-412 

Storey,  W.  B.,  Jr.,  election  of  as  Vice-President 61 

Stresses,    Secondary,   progress    report 88 

Storage  Battery  in  Railway  Service 1181-1221 

Storehouse,  reasons  for  maintaining 506,  507 

Stuart.  Francis  Lee,  election  of  as  Member  of  Nominating  Com- 
mittee      61 

Surfacing,   rules   governing 68 

Switches,  general  specifications  for 381-386 


1232  INDEX. 

T 

PAGE. 

Tellers,  report  of 60, 61 

Resolution  of  thanks  to (&> 

Third  Rail  Clearances,  data  regarding 524 

Third  Rail  Structure  Diagrams  of  Various  Railways 535-558 

Ties,  report  on 30i-37<> 

Conclusions    33*-  342,  370 

Discussion  951-964 

Metal,  Composite  and  Concrete  Ties 343.  370 

Stresses  to  Which  Cross-ties  are  subjected 301-331 

Arrangement  of  Ties  Under  Joints 330 

Bibliography  on  Size  of  Cross-ties 307-311 

Bearing  Strength  of  Ties  Under  the  Rail  Tests 303 

Cross-Ties,  size  of  in  current  use ..  307 

Tie    Renewals   in    Continuous    Stretches    Versus    Single    Tic- 
Renewals   332-342 

Ties,  rides  governing 66,67 

Timber,   Standing,  in  the  United  States 431 

Timbers,  grouping  of  for  antiseptic  treatment 868-872 

Tonnage  Rating  for  Locomotives 1151-1180 

Track,  report  on  37^-3^6 

Conclusions  374 

Discussion  965-080 

Frogs,  Crossings  and  Switches 371-3/4 

General  Specifications  for  Frogs,   Crossings  and  Switches.  .  375-3B6 

Frogs    377-tfo 

General   Instructions    375 

Inspection  375, 376 

Material    376, 377 

Switches    381-386 

Workmanship    377 

Track  Work,  Instructions  as  to 66-68 

Ballasting 66 

Cross-Sections    66 

Drainage    • 66 

Rail    67 

Surfacing   68 

Ties    66,  57 

... 

I  transportation,   furnishing  of 84 

Treasurer,   report  of 53 

Tree  Planting  and  General  Reforestation 430-437,  455,  456 

Trestles,   fire  protection,   progress  report 79,  80 

Tunnel   Construction   and   Ventilation 396,  398-400 


INDEX.  1233 
U 

PAGE. 

Uniform  General  Contract  Forms,  report  on 907-916 

Construction   Contract,   Agreement   Form 909,910 

Construction    Contract,    General    Conditions 911-916 

Discussion  1059-1076 

V 

Ventilation   of   Tunnels 396.  398-400 

W 

Waterproofing   of   Masonry 459-474 

Water  Service,  report  on 401-42S 

Conclusion     4J9 

Discussion    983-998 

General   Specifications   for  a   Reinforced   Concrete   Standpipe 

Water  Tank  for  Railways 4T3-4T7 

General    Specifications    for    Ordinary    Steel    Water   and    Oil 

Tanks  417-419 

Locomotive  Boiler  Corrosion  and  Treated  Water 420-428 

Reinforced    Concrete,    use    of    for    railway   water   tanks    and 

supports   402-41 7 

Water  Tanks,  general  specifications   for 417-419 

Conclusions    419 

Waterway  Formulas    387. 388 

Wickhorst,  M.  H.,  paper  by  on  "Equated  Tonnage  Rating" 1151-1180 

Wooden  Bridges  and  Trestles,  report  on 77-So 

Discussion     946 

Fire  Protection 79,  80 

Guard  Rails    79 

Pile  Formulas    79 

Sheet  Piling   78,  79 

Wood   Preservation,   report  on 863-872 

Conclusions     867 

Discussion  1039-1051 

Forms  for  Reporting  Inspection 866 

Grouping  of  Timbers    for  Antiseptic  Treatment 863,864,868-872 

Merits  of  Various   Preservatives 864 

Records   from   Service  Tests 864 

Revision  of  the  Adopted  Specifications  for  Creosote  Oil....  865,866 

Specifications  for  Impregnation  with  Creosote  Oil 866 

Value  of  Brush  Coating  and  Dipping 867 

Value  of  Impregnation  with  Crude  Oil 867 

Working   Unit    Stresses 518,  510 


1234  INDEX. 

Y 

PAGli. 

Yards  and  Terminals,  report  .on. . ,,. .3 8q-q* 

Conclusions .          Q7 

Discussion    -  0.^  ^.o 

Division  Engine  Terminal,  typical  situation  plans 91,  9,. 

Freight,  Handling  of  by  Mechanical  Means 90,  01 

Hump  Yards,  design  and  operation  of oi 

Passenger   Stations,   typical   situation   plans 00